Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / 5 Reasons to Finally Heal Your Attachment
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It is Thursday, September 12th, 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time,
- 0:30and I thought that I would talk about why you would consider
- 0:35doing attachment repair work at this point in your life.
- 0:42My, we're always trying to do these.
- 0:48The top five things of this, the top five things of that.
- 0:51What are the top five reasons that you would consider
- 0:54undertaking attachment repair? But I it all boils down really
- 1:00just to one reason and that is old age, sickness and death.
- 1:11This is a short life that we have and why not take care of
- 1:17this stuff now so that it doesn't interfere with with the
- 1:20opening of your life so that you really can get into a a process
- 1:24of exploring. And really, what do you one way
- 1:31to look at the the way that it attachment disturbances impact
- 1:36you is that it interferes with that natural process of
- 1:41exploring the things that are meaningful because it creates
- 1:45these barriers of fear which actually prevent the attachment
- 1:50system itself from shutting down and allowing the exploration
- 1:56system to turn on. We probably don't notice it or
- 2:00think of it in that way because we don't really, without some
- 2:05kind of psychoeducation, understand the state of the
- 2:10attachment system being activated or the the state of it
- 2:13being deactivated and the exploration system being
- 2:16activated. And a lot of us who didn't
- 2:19really learn to explore very well when we were kids don't
- 2:23really have a, a tangible sense between pursuing the tokens of
- 2:30of our culture's evaluations of what's important, the gathering
- 2:36of time, energy, and resources from the things that really are
- 2:39moving to us that are that provide for us an essential
- 2:43meaning. You know, secure people even in
- 2:50somewhat challenging environments, let's say secure
- 2:53people with a feature with features.
- 2:55At least they had the experience of the caregivers being attuned
- 3:00to them and interested in the things that they found
- 3:04interesting and also some support and encouragement to
- 3:07pursue those things. And in those of us who have
- 3:11insecure, disorganized attachment, that really wasn't
- 3:14so much what happened. What really happened was us as
- 3:18children having to attend to the needs of our caregivers so that
- 3:23we could survive in those rather harsh environments.
- 3:28And if you haven't gone through a normalizing process where you
- 3:31actually understand how difficult those environments
- 3:34were, you might just think that that's normal life.
- 3:40As it turns out, we talk about security and and attachment as
- 3:47being an astonishingly low bar. And and I think that insecure
- 3:53and disorganized people so wildly overestimate what that
- 3:57means that, you know, you ask a disorganized person how ordinary
- 4:04security is and they'll often express somewhere along the
- 4:10lines of a Unicorn. It's just not something that you
- 4:13actually ever encountered. And and for disorganized people,
- 4:17that's actually true because the disorganized people are so
- 4:20unreliable. Secure people won't really be in
- 4:23relationship to the so the secure people self exclude from
- 4:28entering into relationships with disorganized people, but and
- 4:32they probably don't do so well with insecure organized people
- 4:36either. Do you know enough about
- 4:38attachment that when I say these kinds of categorizations, you
- 4:42have an understanding, but I'm talking about or I need to a
- 4:46little bit more granular on that more granular.
- 4:52OK, when we talk about the spectrum attachment, we we're,
- 4:59we're talking about an organized group and a disorganized group.
- 5:03The organized group has a reliable attachment response to
- 5:08attachment stressors. So secure people respond in a
- 5:12secure way, Dismissing people respond in a different
- 5:17dismissing way, and preoccupied people respond in a preoccupied
- 5:23way. So a secure person seeks
- 5:29proximity and comfort for somebody when they're
- 5:32emotionally dysregulated and can't regulate themselves.
- 5:36A dismissing person deactivates their attachment system,
- 5:39deactivates their emotional system, and regulates through
- 5:43external sources. There's a high level of
- 5:46addiction in dismissing people. Preoccupied people become
- 5:53chaotic and distressed and seek physical proximity to somebody
- 5:58who they find regulating. But when you get into
- 6:02disorganization, what really is characteristic of the fearfully
- 6:06preoccupied, fearfully avoided, and then the complexly
- 6:09disorganized person is this tremendous fearfulness that they
- 6:15go into, which really shuts down any capacity to explore and
- 6:21almost really any capacity to regulate with other people.
- 6:25It's the most isolating strategies, so that you would
- 6:29really withdraw from other people to attempt to regulate.
- 6:33And complexly disorganized people can react all over the
- 6:38spectrum, some a secure response, a dismissing response
- 6:42to preoccupied risk. But really what I want to talk
- 6:48about more is the exploration piece around how it presents
- 6:53with the different detachment strategies.
- 6:55Secure people are able to keep in balance the sense of
- 6:59secondary exploration. I like to call it the gathering
- 7:02of tokens from our culture and what it values.
- 7:06The gathering of time, energy and resources that you need to
- 7:11survive and also support primary explorations, which is this
- 7:16pursuit of something meaningful. We often talk about it in our
- 7:21culture because of the the thing, the way that our culture
- 7:24values thing is a creative expression or an artistic
- 7:28expression. But if you were in societies
- 7:33where, for instance, this is a meditation community where
- 7:37enlightenment was something that was highly valued, then
- 7:39enlightenment would actually be considered one of the things
- 7:43that you you creatively explore. It isn't so much in the past
- 7:50that we think of that. So how does that happen?
- 7:59How do we learn to explore as children and how does the
- 8:03different ways in which people experience interference with the
- 8:07development of that exploration, those exploration systems
- 8:12happen. You're a child, you're attuned
- 8:17to by your caregiver. You're empathetically connected
- 8:21so sensitively enough the the caregivers that actually
- 8:26interested in your point of view and the things that you're good
- 8:28at, the things that you're drawn to and they encourage you to
- 8:32explore them. And so you begin this process of
- 8:36examining the things that initially are attractive to you,
- 8:40evaluating whether they're meaningful or not, and then
- 8:45continuing down this line of discovery more and more oriented
- 8:51around the things that really matter to you.
- 8:57This requires, of course, the activation in in some sense of a
- 9:02self experience. Have you ever been so
- 9:06concentrated on a task that the the limited identity or that
- 9:12sense of, of self consciousness is absent and absent for a long
- 9:18period of time? I mean, it can be absent for
- 9:20hours, but then you come back into that self consciousness and
- 9:25you recognize that you've been engaged in this creative
- 9:29activity for a long period of time, highly concentrated.
- 9:35That would be this activation of that sense of creative self and
- 9:42exploring in a child who grows up to be a dismissing adult.
- 9:49We call that an attachment theory, an anxious avoidant
- 9:54child. The way that their development
- 9:59of exploration is affected is that they don't have sensitively
- 10:03attuned caregivers. The caregivers really are not so
- 10:07interested in what matters to the child and the child's
- 10:10expression of that. They want the child to
- 10:13participate in in a family system that's based on
- 10:18idealization. So the child's needs, all of
- 10:22those aspects of the child that would be important for the child
- 10:26to have developed through the interest and attention of the
- 10:30caregiver doesn't really happen. What happens is that they learn
- 10:34a system of idealization in the home where they need to present
- 10:38to the caregiver a version of the experience of the child that
- 10:42the caregiver is interested in having and typically causes the
- 10:47child to strip out all of the negative experiences, all of the
- 10:51frustrations that not actually being encouraged to pursue the
- 10:55things that matter to them and over and over again present this
- 10:59idealized version of reality that the caregivers want.
- 11:04What that produces in the child is a very transactional
- 11:07relationship to the nature of the world.
- 11:10I do this performance and I get this reward quite transactional.
- 11:16It's also lacking and really a subsidence quality to it because
- 11:22the child is actually just performing the idealization for
- 11:26the caregiver. It isn't based on the actual
- 11:31experience of the child so much. And so it doesn't have that that
- 11:37quality of realness to it. So if you engage and dismissing
- 11:41adult and they give you what you want in the conversation, they
- 11:45promise you the sun and the stars and the moon and you're
- 11:50not and you're a secure person, for instance, you're expecting
- 11:54them to deliver on their promises.
- 11:56But for them, there was never any delivery in childhood.
- 12:01They never had to do any of that.
- 12:04That isn't what happened. And they don't have that
- 12:06expectation that that's what they should be doing.
- 12:10They're providing you with an ideal experience, which is the
- 12:14thing in itself, and then you provide for them what they want
- 12:20and they think that the transaction is complete.
- 12:25Now that tends to preclude them from being in relationship to
- 12:29secure people, because secure people are actually expecting
- 12:33you to do what you say. But this is some people don't
- 12:38but what that but but when you turn the the focus back on to
- 12:43exploration, what that really means for the dismissing person
- 12:47is that that authentic creative self is never valued.
- 12:57And so it's not really developed.
- 12:59And so all of the information that would come from the pursuit
- 13:03of exploring things that that that creative sense of self
- 13:07would have found out is not found out.
- 13:12So how do you know? And because the transactional
- 13:16nature of the appearance of the world to dismissing person means
- 13:21they get very involved in the secondary exploration, gathering
- 13:26the time, energy and resources that they need so that they can
- 13:30transact. Here.
- 13:35Especially, we will give up on any hope that somebody will be
- 13:41interested in them. Somebody will take care of them
- 13:44without the transactional nature.
- 13:48So they just learn how to do that so that their exploration
- 13:52is really limited to the gathering of these tokens of
- 13:59value that our culture tends to put out.
- 14:02And if you were lucky and what was actually meaningful to you
- 14:06align with that, that it would be a rich experience.
- 14:09But often you'd find dismissing people, or at least in the work
- 14:13that I do, the complaint is that they're very good at getting all
- 14:17of these tokens, that they don't mean anything.
- 14:20And so there's a kind of despair that comes in.
- 14:24I'm doing all of these things, I'm doing them well, and I'm
- 14:26getting the rewards, but the rewards aren't meaningful.
- 14:30And then what do you do? And then there's a little pivot
- 14:34where you spend more of your of your time actually trying to
- 14:39activate that creative sense of self that is then able to pursue
- 14:43things that are more meaningful. Does that making sense?
- 14:49One of the things about the general unfairness of all things
- 14:53is, I'd like to call it, is that dismissing people have all of
- 14:59the skills that are necessary to really pursue primary
- 15:03exploration. Really what they need to do is
- 15:05change their mind about the value of it and then begin the
- 15:08process of pursuing it. But this the ability to explore
- 15:13is there. The the ability to navigate the
- 15:16world is there, and often the resources that they need to do
- 15:20the exploration are there because they're good at
- 15:23secondary exploration. George, can you talk about the
- 15:30value again? Why do they think that there is
- 15:35no value in exploring? Well, when you're just gathering
- 15:44a resources to transact care it, it's easy to get into this
- 15:50understanding that if I wasn't giving you something, you
- 15:53wouldn't give it to me. So it is, it's really not about
- 15:55me. You don't care about me.
- 15:57You care about the resources that I can direct to you and so
- 16:03on in the interpersonal relationship.
- 16:06There isn't the belief that you would do this for me if I wasn't
- 16:09giving you something. And, and really, when you look
- 16:16at the the experience of the child who over and over again
- 16:20tries to get the caregiver to be responsive to them and never
- 16:25succeeds in achieving that. At the core of that is this
- 16:29terrible sadness that there's something fundamentally wrong
- 16:33with me that nobody is interested in me or is willing
- 16:37to take care of me if I don't provide something for them.
- 16:41And so that at the core of the that of the dismissing mind is
- 16:46this terrible sadness that I'm not worth anything without the
- 16:51stuff that I can that I'm good at gathering.
- 16:58And then in response to that terrible sadness, there's this
- 17:02this activity of trying to inflate the sense of self by
- 17:06gathering these tokens so that you, you can present yourself as
- 17:11valuable to draw people to you. But at the same time, you're not
- 17:17thinking that they're coming to this authentic experience of me,
- 17:20which is this terrible sadness. They're coming to this, this
- 17:25sort of facade that I'm able to create about myself.
- 17:32And if they discovered the core, the core sadness of the child
- 17:40that was was not really valued, that they would react in a
- 17:47rejecting way. Because the experience of
- 17:50dismissing people in childhood is one of constant rejection.
- 17:55That really becomes the expectation of the of the adult
- 18:00that I'm constantly under threat of rejection and I have to
- 18:05fortify against that because if I don't, I'll be knocked into
- 18:10the terrible sadness, which is unbearable.
- 18:16That making sense? So the value is moved from the
- 18:19resource itself to him or herself.
- 18:25The value. All all that's needed is to
- 18:31change the mindset, and the change of that is actually the
- 18:35change of focus from the resource itself to the.
- 18:41To the pursuit of meaning. But what happens a lot of times
- 18:46to people who grow up to be dismissing is that that the
- 18:50kernel of that exploration, that kernel of what's meaningful,
- 18:55that the the primary drive for the arising of that creative
- 19:01self is rejected. So it becomes this secret that's
- 19:08held very closely that you don't actually ever reveal to anyone
- 19:12because the experience of humiliation around it in
- 19:16childhood was so awful. And so you have to change your
- 19:19mind about being willing to express that to other people
- 19:25that you can, you can actually bring out the that very
- 19:31sensitive, very vulnerable primary explorations.
- 19:38The experience. Now have to be careful about
- 19:43that because you have to be sure that the person who you're going
- 19:48to express that to is not just going to reject you so that you
- 19:54then lock it up again. And one of the things about
- 19:59dismissing people is they often couple with preoccupied people
- 20:03and preoccupied people. While they may claim that they
- 20:07really want intimacy, they don't really.
- 20:11And so when they're faced with their partner suddenly turning
- 20:16around and actually opening up to allow a moment of intimacy,
- 20:22they're just as likely to poke you to get you to shut it down
- 20:25again as they are to be receptive to the experience of
- 20:30it. So there has to be some care in
- 20:33terms of that process of, of bringing it out into the world.
- 20:38But once you have the experience of that small group of people
- 20:43around you that really value it and are really interested in it,
- 20:47then you can take off with it because you have all of the
- 20:52skills that you need in terms of how to explore.
- 20:57Is that making more sense? But I've, I've had that actually
- 21:08in some sense thrown back at me where I encourage somebody to do
- 21:12it and then they do it in the first person they pick just
- 21:14pokes them really hard and they just want to shut it all back
- 21:19down. So I, I try to recommend a lot
- 21:22of care with that, you know, when you don't normalize this
- 21:28stuff, that is to say, when you don't actually express this
- 21:31stuff to anybody and it's just something that you preserve for
- 21:34yourself, you don't really, you don't really have a way of
- 21:39understanding its value in the world, right?
- 21:42We don't as human beings have much of A way of understanding
- 21:46ourselves without the help of people reflecting back to us
- 21:51their experience of what we're expressing.
- 21:54So when we keep that essential core of meaning private and
- 21:59unexpressed, we really don't have a sense of it.
- 22:03Really. We have our experience of it,
- 22:06but it but it isn't something that's been balanced and
- 22:12normalized. I'd like to say, you know, you
- 22:15grow up in a family system as a child and that's the world.
- 22:20That's normal. That's how and we don't really
- 22:23have the cognitive capacity to understand that the way it is in
- 22:27our household is not the way it is in all households.
- 22:30We just think that that's how the world is.
- 22:33And then in adolescence, when you move into the the wider
- 22:37world, you begin to understand that not all households run the
- 22:43same way, that your household has a distinct character to it.
- 22:49But I also, I think because of the way that organized and
- 22:56disorganized sort of separate from each other and secure and
- 23:00insecure attachment strategies tend to separate from each
- 23:04other's. Would not be unusual to be in a
- 23:07secure world where there wasn't much alternative to that.
- 23:11So that the whole world looks like that and people function
- 23:15well and people are carrying all the rest of it.
- 23:17Whereas if you're in the, the insecure and disorganized side
- 23:21of the world, the world is really chaotic and unpredictable
- 23:25and fearful and everybody's like that and everybody's having that
- 23:29experience. It's, it's even hard to imagine
- 23:34an alternative to that. And it's also really hard to
- 23:37understand how severe the circumstances are when
- 23:41everybody's circumstances are like that.
- 23:45You know, we talk about secure attachment as this astonishingly
- 23:50low bar, which is that 30% of the time people have to respond
- 23:57to your needs well enough, but that you, you have an
- 24:00expectation that actually your needs will be met.
- 24:03And if you grow up in an insecure, disorganized
- 24:07attachment system, understand that less than 30% of the time
- 24:12your needs are actually being and how severe, how harsh that
- 24:18is for a child to have to endure, you know, 7 attempts to
- 24:25get care before anything happened.
- 24:29But because that is the world, it's hard to to normalize that
- 24:37preoccupied people in terms of exploration.
- 24:39The the the problem is that there whole process of
- 24:46exploration is interfered with. This either is through
- 24:50overprotection or the the caregiver themselves is so
- 24:55chaotic that the child becomes enmeshed in the mind states of
- 25:00the caregiver and and is not free then to pursue their own
- 25:07interests in the world. They're in a state of having to
- 25:11attend to the needs of the caregiver at such a constant
- 25:16rate that that individuation that they they would need in
- 25:22order to be able to pursue their own exploration.
- 25:25The emotional regulation that they would need in order to
- 25:29pursue their own exploration just is never available to them.
- 25:36Often the the either the caregiver presents is so
- 25:40helpless that they take on a controlling role, or the
- 25:45caregiver insists that they are helpless so that in order to get
- 25:49any attention really that would be useful to them, they have to
- 25:55pretend to be helpless in order to get attention.
- 26:01But because this interferes with the capacity to explore so early
- 26:06in that development of, or even much experience of that creative
- 26:15sense of self arising to be the, the, the, the doer of the
- 26:20exploration is not present so much on the controlling side.
- 26:24Of course, you can have people that get very good at secondary
- 26:30exploration really well, do really well at school, really
- 26:34see this their way out of that chaotic household, but it
- 26:40doesn't actually translate too much into the the activation of
- 26:44that creative sense of self that is then the motivator for
- 26:49exploration. And what you see in the adult
- 26:52lives of organized preoccupied people is they're very good at
- 26:56supporting other people's exploration, but they don't do
- 26:59much of their own. So in a professional
- 27:02environment, they support the higher ups in a in a way that's
- 27:05consuming for them. But if they were put in a
- 27:09position of having to come up with what it is that the the
- 27:13company was supposed to be doing, they would they wouldn't
- 27:16really be able to do it so well. Is that making sense?
- 27:23Disorganized people have the experience of that natural,
- 27:28creative sense of self often being activated and exploited so
- 27:33that the perpetrators who harm them use that as a way of
- 27:38getting to them. In disorganization, the main
- 27:45qualifier is that the caregiver themselves is the source of
- 27:52fearfulness. So remember that the attachment
- 27:56system activates, which causes you to seek proximity to
- 28:00somebody who will protect you. But when the caregiver is the
- 28:04cause of the fearfulness that activates the attachment system,
- 28:10which would cause you to seek proximity to them, and they're
- 28:14the ones who are frightening, it activates the fight or flight
- 28:18system, which then cancels out the attachment system and leaves
- 28:25the child in a position where they don't seek comfort from
- 28:29anyone. That's one of the reasons why
- 28:32disorganized people self isolate to emotionally regulate most of
- 28:41the time, the the hapless nature of the caregiver, the, the, the,
- 28:48the low functioning of the caregiver is what causes them to
- 28:52cross the, the boundaries of the child and violate them
- 28:56emotionally or psychologically or physically.
- 29:01So there there's the, the absence of the intention and
- 29:04often the expression of love and they're doing it.
- 29:08But for the child, the experiences that this natural
- 29:11desire for closeness is the thing that opened me up, the
- 29:16harm that I experienced. And so they distrust themselves
- 29:21and they distrust the, the, the desire for colosis and really
- 29:29become unwilling to seek comfort from someone else because
- 29:35they're afraid that that that is going to draw them into the
- 29:39situation where they will, where they'll be harmed.
- 29:43And because their ability to trust themselves to determine
- 29:47whether somebody would harm them or not is, is so badly damaged
- 29:52that they don't trust it, they really do tend to, to withdraw
- 30:01from, withdraw from the Society of other people and self
- 30:06isolate. Now there is also a, a, a
- 30:09trajectory on that a childhood really, let's say that's zero to
- 30:1510. You don't remember your early
- 30:20childhood really. You don't have the physical
- 30:23capacity for the brain to to remembered it.
- 30:28We're very procedural, very wrote as children.
- 30:32And then somewhere in the middle of that 456, you have a sense of
- 30:38when that happened for you, the 1st autobiographical memories,
- 30:42unless you're strongly dismissing and then you won't
- 30:45really remember anything before adolescence.
- 30:49And then puberty hits sort of toward the end of that period
- 30:56because of all of the the additives to the different kinds
- 30:59of foods we eat. It's quite earlier, 9:10, 11-12,
- 31:03something like that for girls, maybe a little bit later for
- 31:07boys. And then there's this dramatic
- 31:11change in your thinking process, right?
- 31:13You have this child's brain, which is just all of these axons
- 31:17waiting to connect to information.
- 31:20And then in adolescence, the brain is radically pruned down
- 31:24to the ones that are just connected and all of the the
- 31:27ones that aren't are pruned out, which really increases your
- 31:31cognitive ability to understand things.
- 31:33And so you can begin to reflect on your childhood experiences
- 31:37and you can begin to evaluate meaning in a much higher level.
- 31:46And we have epistemic trust is that you believe somebody is
- 31:50telling you the truth, that they have evidence to back it up.
- 31:54You believe that the reason they tell you it is because they want
- 31:57to be helpful to you. And if you recognize actually
- 32:01the the kind of childhoods that lead to insecure and
- 32:04disorganized attachment, it can be shattering of the epistemic
- 32:08trust. And then it becomes difficult to
- 32:11learn from other people and you have to do it all yourself.
- 32:16Disorganized people generally, their epistemic trust is quite
- 32:22damaged. One of the things about
- 32:28exploration is it's often A-Team sport.
- 32:31So you have to be able to activate these relationships in
- 32:37order to really dive deep into the things that you want to
- 32:40know. So another reason to really
- 32:44repair your attachment system as soon as you can is because being
- 32:49able to build these relationships and inform these
- 32:54groups of people that can support you in your exploration
- 32:57is absolutely vital to you being able to take big enough risks to
- 33:02really have a rich, meaningful experience of being loved.
- 33:07And if you can't do that, then you often end up in, in a kind
- 33:12of despair at being like, and that progresses as you age.
- 33:17Most of us are in school in, you know, our adolescents through
- 33:22our 20s. And we meet hundreds of people
- 33:29usually in that process. Or at least if you're more urban
- 33:33on the, the rural environment, maybe the, maybe it's the same
- 33:3710 people, you know, that whole period of time, you have these
- 33:43opportunities to engage in all sorts of different things.
- 33:47And that that whole expanse begins to narrow with age.
- 33:52And you have the attachment system that you have, which is
- 33:56allowing you to engage in relationships the way that you
- 33:59can. And if your attachment system is
- 34:03so adversely affected that you can't actually form attachment
- 34:08bonds, then what you really end up with is the succession of
- 34:12relationships that fail. And there's an accumulation of
- 34:16disappointment in that. And as soon as the
- 34:21disappointment gets so great that it's greater than the hope
- 34:27of forming a relationship, you begin to withdraw from
- 34:30attempting to. And that, for most people, is
- 34:34sort of in the middle of the 30s where you just aren't willing to
- 34:38try again. It's too disruptive to things.
- 34:41And you begin this idea that you can have a more solitary life,
- 34:48but that's also going to grossly impact your ability to explore.
- 34:54And one of the things that you may remember in my constant
- 35:01jabbering on about it is that we all, we all start as auto
- 35:05regulators. And if somebody comes well
- 35:07enough, we reorient as an external regulator.
- 35:10And if somebody comes reliably enough, we learn this a way of
- 35:14collaborative, collaboratively, emotionally regulating each
- 35:19other, dismissing people stay in this auto regulating state.
- 35:24And one of the things that happens to 20 and 30 somethings
- 35:29and then later on in life is that we mistake the engagement
- 35:35in in in meaningful activities as an expression of the pursuit
- 35:41of meaning when it actually morphs into a kind of auto
- 35:45regulating. And so we're simply able to
- 35:48distract and be with ourselves in an activity that's engaging,
- 35:53but that actually further isolates us and further
- 35:56restricts us from actually being in the world.
- 36:01Not that you have to be at the at the the top of the heap, but
- 36:06that cycle of of gathering meaning and exploring is really
- 36:11to go out and find the things that matter to you and then come
- 36:15back to that social network that you put around yourself and
- 36:19expressing it and having that effect, the people that that are
- 36:24in that social circle. And if you don't develop that
- 36:27social circle and you never really express it, it becomes
- 36:30that that auto regulating self enclosing experience that isn't
- 36:40but you might tell yourself is exploration who did?
- 36:47So that made me think, even though it's against social
- 36:49media, but people who are on social media who are sharing
- 36:56their work is actually much more valuable.
- 36:59If this holds true for everybody, not just for people
- 37:04close to you simply sharing, let's say your creative
- 37:08expression on Instagram and getting likes.
- 37:11I guess what you were saying is those interaction with people
- 37:14those likes has what a meaning. I'm not saying that an intimate,
- 37:25authentic expression needs to be given to a person and you need
- 37:30to be able to track their response to it, which one of the
- 37:34things that makes social media so successful, I think is it
- 37:38removes the intimacy from and it actually removes the the
- 37:43response really alike is not like somebody seeing you and
- 37:53understanding you and delighting in you.
- 37:56It's so insufficient in that way.
- 38:02And then of course, you know, do we think that life is the way
- 38:10that it's presented on social media?
- 38:12Is this an authentic expression that people are making or is it
- 38:15a completely pretend experience? So.
- 38:23That's on the creator. That's on the creator.
- 38:27Yes, indeed, but. What's you're saying, not a
- 38:33negative impact, but let's say very less influence.
- 38:36So let's say 20% with the race 80 has to be in person.
- 38:42I don't know. I don't really see much in the
- 38:47way of reports on what the actual impact of social media
- 38:52is. I do hear every now and then
- 38:53these complaints that it, that it is detrimental.
- 39:02The one, the only one that I've actually looked at, and it's
- 39:04quite old now, is that for 80% of people, there's a higher
- 39:09social engagement with social media because you know more of
- 39:12what's going on and you can show up to it in person or you can
- 39:15get invites or so, event promotion and that sort of
- 39:19thing. That leads to an actual live
- 39:22experience with other people. For 80% of people is better.
- 39:27But for 20% of people, it completely replaces any kind of
- 39:32interaction with other people. They don't.
- 39:35They use it as a way of not needing to go and that creates
- 39:41social isolation. Remember that we are not meant
- 39:45to be socially isolated. We're meant to be in physical
- 39:49proximity to other people. The way that the brain is, the
- 39:53way that the nervous system is, it actually requires a constant
- 39:58interaction with other people in some intimate way, not
- 40:04necessarily completely, but in some way where you at least have
- 40:08the registration that that they see you and they they know you
- 40:14in order for the body mind to settle.
- 40:16And if the body mind doesn't have that it, it experiences.
- 40:20That as painful and the longer that you socialize socially
- 40:26isolate, the greater the level of pain is that you experience.
- 40:33I was reading something in the paper the other day that
- 40:36loneliness is the cause of the rise of fascism.
- 40:41Because the the inability to connect, the inability to feel
- 40:46connected then creates the need for these overarching
- 40:51identities, which you could then identify with without having to
- 40:56have the the intimate functionality to it.
- 41:00But it's also the thing that makes it so cruel and so, so
- 41:06unlimited in terms of that because there isn't that
- 41:10empathetic connection to other people, that there isn't that
- 41:13compassionate identification with other people.
- 41:18So if you were using it as a resource to gather the
- 41:22information of where to go and what to do that, that could be
- 41:25enhancing. But if you were using it as a
- 41:29replacement for that, it would not be.
- 41:35Is that making sense? If you have difficulty in
- 41:41forming relationships that are based on attachment
- 41:44conditioning, then doing the work of uprooting that and
- 41:48moving into more secure, functioning relationships is
- 41:52going to create that foundation that then will allow you to
- 41:56develop exploration that provides a sense of richness and
- 42:00being. And then that richness, as you
- 42:04express it to the people that are close to you, enhances not
- 42:08only your experience of richness, but also their
- 42:11experience of richness. And then if, if they, I trust
- 42:15you and are willing to express the experiences of their
- 42:19intimate explorations, their discoveries, their sources of
- 42:23meaning in life, and their life is enriched in the expression of
- 42:27it, but also your life is enriched because you are Privy
- 42:33to the experience of that. It may also help you with you,
- 42:37with your own exploration. You do better in all things.
- 42:45I think that the one thing I might not have touched on in
- 42:48terms of a reason why to do your attachment work sooner than
- 42:52later is that there's a capacity in securely attached people to
- 42:59connect and settle so that that normal fearfulness, that normal
- 43:07level of anxiety that we have living in in these complex
- 43:13social communities that we live in actually can settle.
- 43:18And people that don't have that capacity are are in an
- 43:23experience of constant fearfulness, constant anxiety.
- 43:28And for a lot of people, it's always been there and it's so
- 43:33ordinary. You don't really understand the
- 43:36level of distress that that it can be until you have the
- 43:40contrast of the absence of it. And then suddenly it's, Oh my
- 43:43God, how did I get through life with this level of anxiety for
- 43:47so long? It's so unbearable.
- 43:50But what that anxiety can also do is activate the attachment
- 43:54system and shut down the exploration system.
- 43:57And so you can go for these these stretches of time where
- 44:01there really isn't an opportunity in the way that your
- 44:04nervous system is operating to explore anything because you're
- 44:08in that anxious seeking safety state the whole time.
- 44:15Is that all making sense? I think also one of the things
- 44:21about the time that we live in that's so wonderful is that
- 44:27effective means of attachment repair haven't really been
- 44:29available before. This is a very new thing, maybe
- 44:39not even a decade really. I think five or six years really
- 44:45since the ideal parent figure was pushed out in a book.
- 44:54So I think that's quite a quite extraordinary to consider
- 45:00because before that, of course, we were just simply asked to
- 45:05adapt to the attachment system that we have and get along the
- 45:08best we could, which, you know, you were like me, complexly
- 45:15disorganized it, it everything was hard.
- 45:19It was always hard, never got not hard.
- 45:23Even when things went well, it was hard.
- 45:25There was no relief from it. We did.
- 45:32George, is there any correlation between intelligence and
- 45:36insecurity? What do you consider, like, I
- 45:39don't know, CEOs or managers and successful positions to to be
- 45:47secure because there's this, there's a sense that this
- 45:51organization comes with also poor cognition, poor
- 45:54intelligence, just. No, I don't think so, no.
- 46:03And that's probably like something else would be ADHD is
- 46:06would be separate or dyslexia would be just separate.
- 46:10A DHDI think is is caused by a hyper vigilance in childhood
- 46:20because of a chaotic environment.
- 46:23The child has to focus on multiple things all the time, so
- 46:26it is in some sense of skill, and there's even a group of
- 46:29people who think that it's a natural evolutionary
- 46:32development. When we were in tribal group,
- 46:36that somebody was constantly focusing on everything around,
- 46:40which ensured the safety of the group.
- 46:43Dyslexia is a kind of ordinary natural diversity in the way
- 46:48that the brain is structured. The reason I think that it's
- 46:53considered such a problem is because our educational system
- 46:58isn't adapted for people who are dyslexic and so they can't learn
- 47:02in that environment. So it becomes a learning
- 47:04disability because the the dominant brain structure is the
- 47:12dominant system for instruction. And, and when you move into a
- 47:17system that's adapted for dyslexia, people learn this
- 47:22isn't so much the issue, it's really the, the, the, the sort
- 47:28of funneling into what is considered a productive citizen
- 47:35doesn't adapt well to people that are outside of that
- 47:40spectrum that this is is built for.
- 47:42But I'm profoundly dyslexic and I think the way that I think is
- 47:47awesome. And I think this whole
- 47:49instruction comes from that, where I can consider the
- 47:52attachment and the the spiritual stuff and I can link them
- 47:56together because that's the way that my brain works.
- 47:59And that people who are much more linear thinkers don't have
- 48:04a hard time making sense of the, these leaps that my mind just
- 48:09makes as a, a matter of its daily process of thinking.
- 48:15And the thing that I've learned in terms of communicating is to
- 48:18put the steps in so that people can follow the jumps.
- 48:22But I don't need the steps. My mind just jumps.
- 48:25Whereas people who are much more concrete thinkers and linear
- 48:29thinkers don't, they don't do that.
- 48:32They don't think that. But I love the way that my mind
- 48:37thinks. And I don't think it's a, it's
- 48:41a, it's, it's limiting. So I think that I didn't do well
- 48:46in the educational system, but my mind and people who have
- 48:49minds like mine don't do well in the educational system because
- 48:52it's, it's not a, it's not the way that we, we think that
- 48:58making sense. The if you, you know, and I
- 49:09think as a child, if you had a sensitively attuned caregiver
- 49:12who realized that you didn't think literally and then helped
- 49:16you find the resources that you need, you wouldn't have had like
- 49:19me to go through years of not being able to function in school
- 49:24and being called stupid. 'Cause we talked about like lack
- 49:32of imagination or visualization skills in in preoccupation or in
- 49:38this organization. So I cannot expect them to be
- 49:41like big time CE OS or like in good corporate positions or any.
- 49:47Well, I, I work a lot in the tech and what I notice is the
- 49:50very upper strategy of tech is dismissing.
- 49:56They're really organized around the thing.
- 49:59They don't have a lot of compassion.
- 50:01They don't have a lot of empathy.
- 50:02It doesn't interfere with them sort of bulldozing their way
- 50:06ahead, but everybody below them is preoccupied.
- 50:12There is. They're very good at supporting
- 50:14the vision, but they don't really have much in the way
- 50:17vision of their own. And business of people do.
- 50:23Yeah, they're dismissing people see the they're very good at
- 50:27secondary exploration, which is often why the way that the
- 50:32corporate world works is a devastating the environment.
- 50:36For instance, they don't give a shit about the environment.
- 50:38They give a shit about getting the stuff that they want and,
- 50:42and, and, and they don't understand the nature of the
- 50:45cruelty of that because they don't feel empathy.
- 50:48And that actually makes the corporate structure work better.
- 50:54They externalize every all of the costs they can.
- 50:57They do, they wreck the environment and leave, and then
- 51:00the taxpayer has to pay for it. They don't see that as a
- 51:05difficulty because it's good business.
- 51:09So only just only distance of not disorganized or preoccupied
- 51:13will not be capable of doing intellectually high jobs or.
- 51:20Well, you're associating that with an intellect of of a kind,
- 51:28maybe. You know, if we talk about AI,
- 51:35which is being pieced out everywhere, right?
- 51:43Give it a choice of being responsible about it and going
- 51:45at a pace that maybe as a society we could absorb with
- 51:49enough protections and losing the race.
- 51:53Forget that. So off we go, right?
- 52:01The consolidation of power and resources into a smaller and
- 52:05smaller and smaller group of people.
- 52:08I read in the paper a couple of days ago that we're going to
- 52:11have trillionaires, but if we have trillionaires, we're going
- 52:16to have just masses of poor people.
- 52:20Does it mean that the poor people are less intelligent
- 52:28automatically? No, I wouldn't say that.
- 52:34In fact, I, I think it's such a lack of intelligence not to
- 52:38really discover and, and develop the talent of so many people
- 52:44that are talented and in favor of this in this shrinking
- 52:49segment of resource people, that that seems a complete absence of
- 52:55intelligence to me. You know what it was, I'm
- 53:06paraphrasing this. It was one of my favorites.
- 53:09You can't expect a woman to have an intelligent conversation if
- 53:13you won't allow her to be educated, right?
- 53:20Does that mean that they're inherently less intelligent?
- 53:24It does not. Fact.
- 53:29I definitely feel more intelligent as I've worked on
- 53:31myself for some reason. It's almost like there's a
- 53:34medical ignition that becomes extremely sharp.
- 53:37Right. So which I thought it was very
- 53:40neat. Yeah, so we blabbed on.
- 53:50Why don't we do a little meditation, some hard practices
- 54:05to combat the cruelty of the world.
- 54:13So go ahead and settle in, OK? Let go of the meditation.
- 54:21You're expecting us to bold the mine state all day, right?
- 54:28It's a lot of effort. It is in the beginning.
- 54:31So it's a John of practice, right?
- 54:33So high concentration state practice in the beginning.
- 54:37You effort, you place and sustain awareness and then PT
- 54:41arises or this energy arises and then you the.
- 54:49The difference between say a vipassinageana or a metagana is
- 54:54you don't shift to the focus on PT which you would in a
- 54:58vipassinageana. You stay holding the mindset and
- 55:03then a blissfulness arises which actually helps going and then
- 55:07the mind settles. But it's efforting.
- 55:11But you do eventually drop down a notch and then you're in
- 55:17second shot. And so you don't need to effort
- 55:20so much. The mind just stabilizes there.
- 55:23We have a lot of energy in the body, a lot of bliss in the body
- 55:26and then stable. But at a certain point you'll
- 55:30drop into the third shot of where the the energy is just too
- 55:33coarse. And so you go deeper in and then
- 55:36it's just bliss at one pointedness.
- 55:39But Shinzen used to call the most pernicious trap in all of
- 55:43meditation because it feels so good, but you don't really get
- 55:47any insight out of that. You just feel good.
- 55:51But what we like about it is you can use it as a launching pad to
- 55:55go into the Vipassana practice and really explore deeply.
- 56:00But if you get it heats up too much, you can jump back and go
- 56:05into that blissful state and hold yourself there until you
- 56:09settle and then go back into the vipassana.
- 56:14At a certain point though, the the blissfulness will become too
- 56:17coarse and the mind will slip out of methane to vipassana and
- 56:21you'll be in the 4th Jana, which is the equanimity in one point.
- 56:26Just that balance. Yeah, that's my effort is to
- 56:31move out of this. My effort is moving out of the
- 56:34equanimity. Right.
- 56:37Well, yeah, it's it's very easy to overshoot and end up in in
- 56:42that equanimity. And then you need to incline the
- 56:44mind back into the the loving kindness mind.
- 56:48Which is a lot of effort. Yes, I realize this.
- 56:53On the other hand, the the the economist mind, the world is
- 56:59pretty ordinary. In the metamind, the world is
- 57:01just beautiful. Exactly.
- 57:06It's only it's only worth having the skill to do it but not get
- 57:11stuck there. So we started a level 2 class on
- 57:19Fridays and it's we had the first class last week and the
- 57:23the second class is on the 20th and we tend to close the
- 57:28registration for that after the 20th.
- 57:30So if you're interested in maybe jumping into it, it's on Friday
- 57:33mornings from 10:30 to 12:30, the 1st and 3rd Fridays of the
- 57:39month. I have a workshop on exploration
- 57:43coming up, I think on the 21st, which is a Saturday.
- 57:47That right? I'm doing two of these
- 57:51exploration workshops. 1 is on primary and secondary
- 57:56exploration and then I thought that I would talk about my own
- 58:00interest in photography, which is what I really one of my
- 58:06primary exploration. So the the first half day long
- 58:10is on the 21st of September, which is from 9:00 until 1:00
- 58:17and then the second one is on October 26th.
- 58:26So that's what's coming up. Once that class starts, pretty
- 58:31much all of the beginnings for the rest of the year are are are
- 58:36finished and that will begin again in January.
- 58:43So anyway, it's on the website. Take a look.
- 58:46Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope that if you're
- 58:49resourced and are able to, you can support us.
- 58:52There's a donation link on the website that helps support me
- 58:56and also the work that Medigroup is doing and any amount is
- 58:59appreciated. Thank you for your practice.
- 59:02Good to see you. I hope to see you again soon.
- 59:06Bye. Thank you, enjoyed it.
- 59:10Good. Glad you're here.
- 59:12Yeah, me too. Bye.