Latest / Wisdom of the Ages Library / 43 - Appendix - The Great Controversy
Transcript
- Appendix General Notes, Page fifty titles. In a passage which forms a part of the Roman canon Law, Pope Innocent the third declares that the Roman pontiff is the vice gerrant upon earth, not of a mere man, but of very God, and in a gloss on the passage, it is explained that this is because he is the vice gerrant of Christ, who is very God and very man. See De cretel Domini Grigory Pape the ninth liber I de translation Episcoporum, Title seven, chapter three, Corpus Juris Canonici, edition, Paris, sixteen twelve, Tom two de cretle, column two O five. For the title Lord God the Pope, see a gloss on the Extravagantes of Pope John the twenty second title fourteen, chapter four Decloromus. In an Antwerp edition of the Extravagantes dated fifteen eighty four, the words dominum, deum nostrum papam Our, Lord God the Pope occur in column one fifty three in a Paris edition dated sixteen twelve. They occur in column one forty in several editions published since sixteen twelve. The word deum God has been omitted, page fifty two. Image worship. The worship of images was one of those corruptions of Christianity which crept into the church stealthily and almost without notice or observation. This corruption did not, like other heresies, develop itself at once, for in that case it would have met with decided censure and rebuke. But making its commencement under a fair disguise, so gradually was one practice after another introduced in connection with it, that the Church had become deeply steeped in practical idolatry, not only without any efficient opposition, but almost without any decided remonstrance. And when at length an endeavour was made to root it out, the evil was found too deeply fixed to admit of removal. It must be traced to the idolatrous tendency of the human heart and its propensity to serve the creature more than the creator. Images and pictures were first introduced into churches not to be worshiped, but either in the place of books, to give instruction to those who could not read, or to excite devotion in the minds of others. How far they ever answered such a purpose is doubtful, But even granting that this was the case for a time, it soon ceased to be so, and it was found that pictures and images brought into churches darkened rather than enlightened, the minds of the ignorant, degraded rather than exalted the devotion of the worshiper, so that, however they might have been intended to direct men's minds to God, they ended in turning them from Him to the worship of creative things. J meant him. The Seventh General Council, The Second of Nicea Introduction, pages three through six for a record of the proceedings and decisions of the Second Council of Nice eighty seven eighty seven, Called to establish the Worship of Images. C. Baronius, Ecclesiastical Annals, Volume nine, pages three hundred ninety one through four hundred seven, sixteen twelve, Antwerp edition. J. Menthem The Seventh General Council, The Second of Nicea ed. Stillingfleet, Defense of the Discourse concerning the Idolatry practiced in the Church of Rome, London, sixteen eighty six. A Select Library of Nicene and post Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Volume fourteen, pages five hundred twenty one through five hundred eighty seven, New York, nineteen hundred. C. J. Heffel. History of the Councils of the Church from the original Documents, Book eighteen, Chapter one, section three thirty two, three thirty three, Chapter two, Section three forty five through three fifty two. T. And T. Clark Edition eighteen ninety six, Volume five, pages two hundred sixty to three hundred four, three hundred forty two to three hundred seventy two, page fifty three. Edict of Constantine. The law issued by Constantine on the seventh of March eighty three, twenty one, regarding a day of rest, reads, thus, let all judges, and all city people, and all tradesmen rest upon the venerable day of the sun. But let those dwelling in the country freely and with full liberty, attend to the culture of their fields. Since it frequently happens that no other day is so fit for the sowing of grain or the planting of vines. Hence the favorable time should not be allowed to pass, lest the provisions of Heaven be lost. A. H. Lewis History of the Sabbath and the Sunday, pages one twenty three and one twenty four, Second edition, revised nineteen o three. The original in the Codex of Justinian Libre three, Title twelve, Leg three is quoted by doctor J. A. Hessey in his Bampton Lectures on Sunday Lecture three, paragraph one, and by doctor Philip Schaff in his History of the Christian Church, Volume three, section seventy five, paragraph five, note one. See also Mosheim Ecclesiastical History, sent four, Part two, Chapter four, Section five, Chambers Encyclopedia, Article Sabbath. Encyclopedia Britannica, ninth edition, Article Sunday. Peter Haylen History of the Sabbath, Part two, Chapter three, second edition, revised, London, sixteen thirty six, pages sixty six, sixty seven, page fifty four. Prophetic dates c note for page three, twenty nine, page fifty six forged writings. Among the documents that at the present time are generally admitted to be forgeries, the donation of Constantine and the pseudo Isidorean decretals are of primary importance in citing facts concerning the question when and by whom was Constantine's donation forged. Monsieur Goslain, director of the Seminary of Saint Sulpice, Paris, says, though this document is unquestionably spurious. It would be difficult to determine with precision the date of its fabrication. Monsieur de Marca Moratory and other learned critics are of the opinion that it was composed in the eighth century, before the reign of Charlemagne. Moratory moreover thinks it probable that it may have induced that monarch and papin to be so generous to the Holy See. Gosslain the power of the Pope during the Middle Ages, Volume one, page three twenty one, translated by the Reverend Matthew Kelly, Saint Patrick's College, Mayneth, Baltimore, J. Murphy and Company, eighteen fifty three. On the date of the Pseudo is Abelian decretles see Mosheim Ecclesiastical History, Book three cent nine, Part two, Chapter two, Section eight. As Doctor Murdoch the translator points out in a footnote, the learned Catholic historian Monsieur Labee Fleuri, in his Ecclesiastical History Dissertation four, section one, says of these decretles that they crept to light near the close of the eighth century. Fleury, writing near the close of the seventeenth century, says further that these false decretals were looked upon as authentic for the space of eight hundred years, and it was with much difficulty that they were given up in the last century. It is true that at present there are hardly any, though meanly instructed in these matters, who do not acknowledge that these decretils are false. Florie Ecclesiastical History Book forty four, paragraph fifty four, g Adams Translation, London, seventeen thirty two, Volume five, page one ninety six. See also Gibbon Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Chapter forty nine, paragraph sixteen, page fifty seven. Dictates of Hildebrand Gregory the seventh c. Baronius Ecclesiastical Annals and ten seventy six Antwerp edition sixteen oh eight, Volume eleven, page four seventy nine. A copy of the dictates in the original may also be found in Giesler Ecclesiastical History, Period three, section forty seven, Note four, Edition eighteen thirty six, translated by F. Cunningham. An English translation is given in Mosheim Ecclesiastical History Book three cent eleven, Part two, Chapter two, section nine, note eight. Solme's edition translated by Murdoch, Page fifty nine. Purgatory doctor Joseph Fau de Bruno thus defines purgatory. Purgatory is the state of suffering after this life, in which those souls are for a time detained, who depart the life after their deadly sins have been remitted as to the stain and guilt, and as to the everlasting pain that was due to them, but who have, on account of those sins, still some debt of temporal punishment to pay, as also those souls which leave this world guilty only of venial sins. Catholic Belief, Page one, ninety six, edition eighteen eighty four. In primature Archbishop of New York. See also K. R. Hagenbach Compendium of the History of Doctrines, Volume one, pages two three four to two thirty seven, four hundred five, four hundred eight, Volume two, pages one hundred, thirty five to one hundred fifty, three hundred eight, three hundred nine TNT Clark Edition, Charles Elliott, Delineation of Roman Catholicism, Book two, Chapter twelve, Catholic Encyclopedia, Article Purgatory, page fifty nine. Indulgences. For a detailed history of the doctrine of indulgences, see the Catholic Encyclopedia article Indulgences contributed by W. H. Kent O, S C. Of Bayswater, London, Carl Ullman Reformers Before the Reformation, Volume one, Book two, Part one, Chapter two. M. Creighton History of the Papacy, Volume five, pages fifty six through sixty four seventy one. Alvon Ranca History of the Reformation in Germany. Book two, Chapter one, paragraph one, thirty one, one thirty two, one thirty nine through one forty two, one fifty three through one fifty five. Second London edition, eighteen forty five, translated by S. Austin. Volume one, pages three thirty one, three thirty five through three thirty seven, three forty three through three forty six. Charles Elliot, Delineation of Roman Catholicism. Book two, Chapter thirteen. H. C. Lee. A History of Oracular Confession and Indulgence. G. P. Fisher The Reformation, Chapter four, paragraph seven on the practical outworkings of the doctrine of indulgences during the period of the Reformation. See a paper by doctor H. C. Lee entitled Indulgences in Spain published in Papers of the American Society of Church History. Volume one, pages one twenty nine through one seventy one. Of the value of this historical sidelight, Doctor Lee says in his opening paragraph, unvexed by the controversy which raged between Luther and Doctor Eck and Sylvester Priirius, Spain continued tranquility to follow in the old and beaten path, and furnishes us with the incontestable official documents which enable us to examine the matter in the pure light of history, page fifty nine. The Mass on the doctrine of the Mass see Cardinal Wiseman's work The Real Presence of the Body and Blood of Our Lord Jesus Christ in the Blessed Youthist. Also Catholic Encyclopedia, Article Eucharist contributed by J. Pohl, St. D. Breslau. Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent, Session thirteen, chapters one through eight, London Edition, eighteen fifty one, translated by T. A. Buckley, Pages seventy through seventy nine. K. R. Hagenbach Compendium of the History of Doctrines, Volume one, pages two fourteen to two twenty three, three ninety three through three ninety eight and Volume two, pages eighty eight through one fourteen. J. Calvin Institutes, Book four, chapter seventeen and eighteen. R. Hooker, Ecclesiastical Polity, Book five, chapter sixty seven. Charles Elliot Delineation of Roman Catholicism, Book two, chapters four and five, page sixty five. While Densian versions of the Bible on early wall Dacian translations of portions of the Bible into the language of the common people see Townley Illustrations of Biblical Literature, Volume one, chapter ten, paragraphs one through thirteen. E. Pettival The Bible in France, Chapter two, paragraph three, four, eight ten, thirteen twenty one, Paris edition eighteen sixty four. G. H. Putnam, The Censorship of the Church of Rome, Volume two, chapter two, page seventy seven, Edict against the Walden seas. A considerable portion of the text of the papal bull issued by Innocent the Eighth in fourteen eighty seven against the Waldencis, the original of which is in the library of the University of Cambridge, is given in an English translation in Dowling's History of Romanism, Book six, chapter five, section sixty two, edition eighteen seventy one, page eighty four. Indulgences c. Note for page fifty nine, page eighty five Wickliffe. For the original text of the papal bulls issued against Wickliffe with an English translation, see J. Fox Acts and Monuments, Volume three, pages four through thirteen, Pratt Townshend Edition, London, eighteen seventy. See also J. Lewis Life of Wickliffe, pages forty nine through fifty one, three O five to three fourteen edition eighteen twenty. Leckler John Wickliffe and his English precursors. Chapter five, section two, pages one sixty two through one sixty four, London edition, eighteen eighty four, translated by laurmer Amander. General History of the Christian Church, Period six, section two, Part one, paragraph eight, page eighty six. Infallibility on the doctrine of infallibility see Catholic Encyclopedia article Infallibility contributed by P. J. Turner, std. George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, Charles Elliot, Delineation of Roman Catholicism, Book one, Chapter four, Cardinal Gibbons, The Faith of Our Father's Chapter seven, forty nine, edition eighteen ninety seven, Page one O three indulgences ce note for page fifty nine, page one O four. Council of Constance on the calling of the Council of Constance by Pope John the twenty three at the instance of the Emperor Sigismund C. Moshem. Ecclesiastical History, Book three, fifteen, Part two, Chapter two, Section three. J. Dowling History of Romanism, Book six, Chapter two, paragraph thirteen. A. Bauer History of the Popes, Volume seven, pages one forty one through one forty three, London edition, seventeen sixty six. Neander History of the Christian Religion and Church, Period six, Section one, eighteen fifty four, five volume edition, translated by Tory, Volume five, pages ninety four through one oh one, Page one twenty eight indulgences. See note for page fifty nine, page two thirty four. Jesuitism. For a statement concerning the origin, the principles, and the purposes of the Society of Jesus, as outlined by members of this order, see a work entitled concerning Jesuits, edited by the Reverend John Gerrard s J and published in London nineteen o two by the Catholic Truth Society. In this work it is said that the mainspring of the whole organization of the society is a spirit of entire obedience. Let each one write, Saint Ignatius persuade himself that those who live under obedience ought to allow themselves to be moved and directed by Divine providence through their sas superiors, just as though they were a dead body, which allows itself to be carried anywhere and to be treated in any manner whatever, or as an old man's staff, which serves him who holds it in his hand, in whatsoever way he will. This absolute submission is ennobled by its motive, and should be continues the founder prompt, joyous and persevering. The obedient religious accomplishes joyfully that which his superiors have confided to him for the general good, assured that thereby he corresponds truly with the divine will. The comtesse Aire de Coisson in concerning Jesuits, page six. See also L. E. Du pint A Compendious History of the Church, sent sixteen, Chapter thirty three, London edition, seventeen thirteen, Volume four, pages one thirty two through one thirty five. Mosheim Ecclesiastical History, sent sixteen, Section three, Part one, Chapter one, paragraph ten, including notes five and six. Encyclopedia Britannica, ninth edition, article Jesuits C. Paroisien. The Principles of the Jesuits Developed in a collection of extracts from their own authors, London, eighteen sixty An earlier edition appeared in eighteen thirty nine. W. C. Cartwright The Jesuits Their Constitution and Teaching, London, eighteen seventy six. E. L. Taunton, The History of the Jesuits in England fifteen eighty through seventeen seventy three, London, nineteen o one, page two thirty five. The Inquisition c. Catholic Encyclopedia Article Inquisition contributed by J. Blutzer, S. J. Munich, H. C. Lee. History of the Inquisition in the Middle Ages, Limbourg History of the Inquisition, Volume one, Book one, chapter twenty five, twenty seven through thirty one, London edition, seventeen thirty one, translated by S. Chandler, Volume one, pages one thirty one through one forty two, one forty four through one sixty one. Alvon Ranca History of the Popes, Book two, Chapter six, page two sixty five. Causes of the French Revolution on the far reaching consequences of the rejection of the Bible and of Bible religion by the people of France. See H. Von Sybyl, History of the French Revolution, Book five, Chapter one, paragraphs three through seven. HT. Buckle, History of Civilization in England, Chapters eight and twelve, New York Edition, eighteen ninety five, Volume one, pages three sixty four through three, sixty six, three sixty nine through three, seventy one, four, thirty seven, five fifty five, forty five, forty one. Blackwood's Magazine, Volume thirty four, Number two, fifteen November eighteen thirty three, Page seven thirty nine. J. G Lorimer and Hi. The Historical Sketch of the Protestant Church in France, Chapter eight, paragraphs six and seven, Page two sixty six. Prophetic dates see note for page three twenty nine, page two sixty seven. Efforts to suppress and destroy the Bible. Referring to the long continued efforts in France to suppress the Bible, particularly versions in the language of the common people, Gossin says the Decree of Toulouse twelve twenty nine, which established the Tribunal of the Inquisition against all the readers of the Bible in the vulgar tongue, was an edict of fire, bloodshed and devastation. In its third fourth fifth and sixth chapters. It ordained the entire destruction of the houses, the humblest places of concealment, and even the subterranean retreats of men convicted of possessing the scriptures, that they should be pursued to the forests and caves of the earth, and that even those who harboured them should be severely punished. As a result, the Bible was everywhere prohibited. It vanished as it were underground it descended into the tomb. These decrees were followed for five hundred years by innumerable punishments in which the blood of the saints flowed like water al Gassan The Canon of the Holy Scriptures, Part two, Book two, Chapter seven, Section five, prop. Five sixty one, and Chapter thirteen, Section two, Prop. Six forty one, Paragraph two, on the special efforts made to destroy Bibles during the Reign of Terror, late in seventeen ninety three, doctor Lorimer says, wherever a Bible could be found, it might be said to be persecuted to death, so much so that several respectable commentators interpret the slaying of the two witnesses in the eleventh chapter of the Apocalypse of the General Suppression nay destruction of the Old and New Testaments in France at this period. J. G. Lorimer An historical sketch of the Protestant Church in France Chapter eight, paragraph four and five. See also G. P. Fisher The Reformation Chapter five, fifteen, paragraphs sixteen. E. Pettaval The Bible in France Chapter two, paragraph three, eight through ten, thirteen and twenty one, Paris edition eighteen sixty four. G. H. Putnam, The Censorship of the Church of Rome, Volume one, Chapter four, nineteen O six edition, pages ninety seven, ninety nine, one oh one and one O two. Volume two, Chapter two, pages fifteen through nineteen. S. Smiles, The Huguenots, their settlements, churches and industries, et cetera. Chapter one, paragraphs thirty, two thirty four, Chapter two, paragraph six, Chapter three, paragraph fourteen, Chapter eighteen, paragraph five, with note S. Smiles. The Huguenots in France after the Revocation Chapter two, paragraph eight, Chapter ten, paragraph thirty, Chapter twelve, paragraphs two through four. J. A. Wiley History of Protestant is his Wath Book, twenty two, Chapter six, paragraph three, page two seventy six. The Reign of Terror, on the responsibility of misguided leaders in both church and state, and particularly in the church. For the scenes of the French Revolution, see W. M. Sloane, The French Revolution and Religious Reform, preface and chapter two, paragraphs one, two, ten through fourteen, nineteen o one edition, pages seven through nine, nineteen twenty twenty six through thirty one. Forty P. Chaff In Papers of the American Society of Church History, Volume one, pages thirty eight, forty four. S. Smiles The Hugenots after the Revocation, Chapter eighteen, paragraphs four, six, nine, ten, twelve through sixteen twenty seven. J. G. Lorimer and Historical Sketch of the Protestant Church of France, Chapter eight, paragraphs six and seven. A. Galton Church and State in France, thirteen hundred through nineteen o seven, Chapter three, Section two, London edition, nineteen o seven. Sir J. Stephen, Lectures on the History of France, Lecture sixteen, paragraph sixty, page two eighty. The Masses and the Privileged Classes on social conditions prevailing in France prior to the period of the Revolution. See H. Von holst Lowell Lectures on the French Revolution, Lecture one. Also Tame Ancient Regime and A Young Travels in France, Page two eighty three retribution. For further details concerning the retributive character of the French Revolution, see Thomas H. Gill The Papal Drama Book ten E de Pressensei. The Church and the French Revolution, Book three, chapter one, page two eighty four. The Atroce of the Reign of Terror See ma A. Thiers History of the French Revolution, Volume three, pages forty two through forty four, sixty two through seventy four, one oh six, New York edition, eighteen ninety translated by F. Schobril. F. A. Migner History of the French Revolution, Chapter nine, paragraph one, Vaughn edition, eighteen ninety four. A. Allison History of Europe, seventeen eighty nine through eighteen fifteen, Volume one, chapter fourteen, New York edition, eighteen seventy two. Volume one, pages two ninety three through three, twelve, page two eighty seven. The circulation of the Scriptures In eighteen o four, according to mister William Canton of the British and Foreign Bible Society, all the Bibles extant in the world, in manuscript or in print, counting every version in every land, were computed at not many more than four millions. The various languages in which the Thus those four millions were written, including such bygone speech as the Meso Gothic of Ulphilas and the Anglo Saxon of Bede, are set down as numbering about fifty What is the Bible Society, Page twenty three, Revised edition, nineteen o four. A hundred years later, at the close of its first centenary, the British and Foreign Bible Society was able to report a total distribution of Bibles testaments or portions thereof by that society alone to the number of one hundred eighty six million, six hundred eighty thousand, one hundred one, a total that in nineteen ten had grown to upwards of two hundred twenty million copies in nearly four hundred distinct tongues. To these totals must be added the millions of copies of the scriptures or portions thereof in many languages, distributed by other Bible Societies and by various commercial agencies. The American Bible Society, the greatest of the daughters of the British Parent Society, during the first nineth ty four years of its work, reported a total distribution of eighty seven million, two hundred ninety six thousand, one hundred eighty two copies see Bible Society Record, June nineteen ten. According to conservative estimates, about six million copies of the Bible are printed annually by commercial houses, which, added to the combined output of the Bible societies, gives a total yearly circulation of more than fifteen million copies. The scriptures, in whole or in part, have been printed in more than five hundred distinct tongues, and the work of translation into new languages and dialects is still carried forward with unflagging zeal page two eighty eight. Foreign Missions. Doctor G. P. Fisher, in a chapter on Christian missions in his History of the Christian Church, outlines the beginnings of the missionary movement, which in the later years of the eighteenth century ushered in a brilliant era of missionary activity, an era which in the history of missions, is only less remarkable than the first of the Christian ages. In seventeen ninety two, the Baptist Society was founded, with Kerry as one of its first missionaries. Kerry sailed for India, and there, with the help of other members of the same society, founded the Mission of Serampoort. In seventeen ninety five, the London Missionary Society was founded. In seventeen ninety nine there was formed the organization which in eighteen twelve became the Church Missionary Society. Soon afterward, the Wesleyan Missionary Society was founded. While the missionary activity was growing up in Great Britain, the Christians of America were becoming animated with a like zeal. In eighteen twelve they founded the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, and in eighteen fourteen the American Baptist Missionary Union at an Iram Judson, one of the first missionaries to go out from America, sailed for Calcutta in eighteen twelve and reached Burma in July eighteen thirteen. In eighteen thirty seven, the Presbyterian Board was formed. Sea Fisher History of the Christian Church Period nine, Chapter seven, paragraphs three through twenty five. Doctor A. T. Pearson, in an article published in the Missionary Review of the World for January nineteen ten, declares a half century ago, China and Manchuria, Japan and Korea, Turkey and Arabia, and even the vast continent of Africa were sleeping hermit nations locked in the cell of long seclusion and exclusion. Central Asia was comparatively unexplored, as was Central Africa. In many lands, Satan's long occupation was undisputed and his empire unmolested. Papal countries were as intolerant as pagan Italy, and Spain imprisoned a man for daring to sell a bible or preach the Gospel. France was practically infidel, and Germany permeated with rationalism, and over a large part of the mission field the doors were shut and locked by a more or less rigid exclusion and caste system. Now the changes on every side are so remarkable and so radical, that to one who should suddenly come out of this middle period of the last century, the world would be unrecognizable. He who holds the keys of the two leaved gates has been unlocking them, opening up all lands to the messenger of the Cross. Even in the Eternal City, where a half century ago a visitor had to leave his Bible outside the walls, there are Protestant chapels by the score, and a free circulation of the scriptures. Page three, twenty seven Prophetic dates CEE note for page three twenty nine, Page three twenty nine. Prophetic dates. The historical and chronological facts connected with the prophetic periods of Daniel eight and nine, including many evidences pointing unmistakably to the year four fifty seven BC as the proper time from which to begin reckoning. These periods have been clearly outlined by many students of prophecy. See Stanley Leed's Old Testament Prophecy Lectures ten and eleven. Warburton Lectures for eighteen seventy six through eighteen eighty W. Good Fulfilled Prophecy Sermon ten including no Day Warburton Lectures for eighteen fifty four through eighteen fifty eight. A tom Chronology of Prophecy, pages twenty six through one hundred six, London edition, eighteen forty eight. Sir Isaac Newton Observations upon the Prophecies of Daniel on the Apocalypse of Saint John, Chapter ten, London edition, seventeen thirty three, pages one twenty eight through one forty three. Euriah Smith thoughts on Daniel in the Revelation, Part one, chapters eight to nine. On the date of the Crucifixion, see William Hale's Analysis of chronology Volume one, pages ninety four through one hundred one, Volume three, pages one sixty four through two fifty eight. Second London edition, eighteen thirty, page three thirty five. Fall of the Ottoman Empire. For further details as to the predicted fall of the Ottoman Empire during the month of August eighteen forty, see J. Lych. The Probability of the Second Coming of Christ about eighty eighteen forty three, published in June eighteen thirty eight. J. Lych. An Address to the Clergy, published in the spring of eighteen forty. A second edition with historical data in support of the accuracy of former calculations of the prophetic period extending to the fall of the Ottoman Empire was published in eighteen forty one. The Advent Shield and Review, Volume one, eighteen forty four, Number one, Article two, pages fifty six, fifty seven, fifty nine through sixty one. J in Loughborough, The Great Advent Movement, pages one twenty nine through one thirty two. Nineteen o five edition. J. Lych. Article and Signs of the Times and Expositor of Prophecy August one, eighteen forty See also article in Signs of the Times and Expositor of Prophecy, February one, eighteen forty one, page three forty withholding the Bible from the people. On the attitude of the Roman Catholic Church towards the circulation of the Holy Scriptures in vernacular versions among the laity. See Catholic Encyclopedia article Bible. Also G. P. Fischer, The Reformation, Chapter fifteen, paragraph sixteen, eighteen seventy three edition, pages five thirty through five thirty two. J. Cardinal Gibbons, The Faith of Our Fathers Chapter eight, forty ninth edition, eighteen ninety seven, pages ninety eight through one seventeen. J. Dowling, History of Romanism, Book seven, Chapter two, section fourteen and Book nine, Chapter three, sections twenty four through twenty seven, eighteen seventy one edition, pages four ninety one through four ninety six, six twenty one through six twenty five. F. Bungener History of the Council of Trent, pages one o one through one ten, second Edinburgh edition, eighteen fifty three, translated by D. D. Scott. G. H. Putnam. Books and Their Makers during the Middle Ages, Volume one, Part two, Chapter two, paragraphs forty nine, fifty four through fifty six, Page three seventy three. Ascension robes. The story that the Adventists made robes with which to ascend to meet the Lord in the air was invented by those who wished to reproach the cause. It was circulated so industriously that many believed it, but careful inquiry proved its falsity. For many years, a large reward has been offered for proof that one such instance ever occurred, but the proof has not been produced. None who loved the appearing of the Savior were so ignorant of the teachings of the scriptures as to suppose that robes which they could make would be necessary for that occasion. The only robe which the Saints will need to meet the Lord is the righteousness of Christ. See Revelation nineteen eight, page three, seventy four. The Chronology of Prophecy. Doctor George Bush, professor of Hebrew and Oriental Literature in the New York City University, in a letter addressed to mister Miller and published in The advent Harold and Signs of the Times Reporter, Boston, March six and thirteen, eighteen forty four, made some important admissions relative to his calculation of the prophetic times mister Bush wrote, neither is it to be objected as I conceive to yourself or your friends, that you have devoted much time and attention to the study of the chronology of Prophecy, and have labored much to determine the commencing and closing dates of its great periods. If these periods are actually given by the Holy Ghost in the prophetic books, it was doubtless with the design that they should be studied and probably in the end fully understood. And no man is to be charged with presumptuous folly who reverently makes the attempt to do this. In taking a day as the prophetical term for a year, I believe you are sustained by the soundest exegesis, as well as fortified by the high names of Mead, Sir Isaac Newton, Kirby, Scott, Keith, and a host of others who have long since come to substantially your conclusions on this head. They all do agree that the leading periods mentioned by Daniel and John do actually expire about this age of the world, and it would be a strange logic that would convict you of heresy for holding an effect the same views which stand forth So prominently in the notices of these eminent divines. Your results in this field of inquiry do not strike me as so far out of the way as to affect any of the great interests of truth and duty. Your error, as I apprehend, lies in another direction than your chronology. You have entirely mistaken the nature of the events which are to occur when those periods have expired. This is the head and front of your expository, offending page three ninety nine prophetic dates. See note for page three twenty nine, Page four ordive A threefold message. Revelation fourteen six and seven foretells the proclamation of the first angel's message. Then the prophet continues, there followed another angel, saying Babylon has fallen is fallen, and the third angel followed them. The word here rendered followed means in constructions like that in this text to go with little and Scott render the word thus to follow one, go after or with him, Robinson says, to follow, to go with, to accompany any one. It is the same word that is used in Mark five twenty four Jesus went with him, and much people followed him and thronged him. It is also used of the Redeemed one hundred forty four thousand, where it is said, these are they which follow the Lamb whithersoever he goeth Revelation fourteen four. In both these places it is evident that the idea intended to be conveyed is that of going together in company with so in Firs. Corinthians ten four, where we read of the children of Israel, that they drank of that spiritual rock that followed them, the word followed, as translated from the same Greek word, and the margin has it went with them. From this we learn that the idea in Revelation fourteen eight and nine is not simply that the second and third angels followed the first in point of time, but that they went with him. The three messages are but one threefold message. They are three only in the order of their rise, but having risen, they go on together and are inseparable. Page four forty seven. Supremacy of the Bishops of Rome. Some of the leading circumstances connected with the assumption of supremacy by the Bishops of Rome are outlined in Mosheim's Ecclesiastical History, sent two, Part two, Chapter four, sections nine through eleven. See also G. P. Fisher History of the Christian Church, Period two, chapter two, paragraphs eleven through seventeen eighteen ninety edition, pages fifty six through fifty eight. Geisler Ecclesiastical History, Period one, Division three, Chapter four, section sixty six, paragraph three, including note eight, New York edition, eighteen thirty six, translated by F. Cunningham. J. And Andrews History of the Sabbath, pages two seventy six through two seventy nine, Third edition, revised, page five seventy four. Edict of Constantine c Note for page fifty three, page five seventy eight. The Abyssinian Church on the Observance of the Bible, Sabbath and Abyssinia. C. Dan A. P. Stanley Lectures on the History of the Eastern Church Lecture one, paragraph fifteen, New York edition, eighteen sixty two, pages ninety six, ninety seven. Michael Getty's Church History of Ethiopia, pages eighty seven, eighty eight, three eleven three twelve. Gibbon Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Chapter forty seven, paragraphs thirty seven through thirty nine. Emanuel Gobett Journal of Three Years Residence in Abyssinia, pages fifty five through fifty eight, eighty three, ninety three, ninety seven, ninety eight, New York Edition, eighteen fifty A. H. Lewis a critical history of the Sabbath and the Sunday in the Christian Church, pages two o eight through two fifteen, Second Edition, revised, page five eighty one. Dictates of Hildebrand c Note for page fifty seven, end of appendix. End of the Great Controversy by Ellen G. White