Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E026: Mining for Talent in Bitcoin with Andy Thompson
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop and we're going to be left holding the
- 1:31biggest bag of odorous extremism ever assembled in the history of
- 1:37darkness, 1974198792972000. And whatever we want to call
- 1:44this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:46over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:49I say when we sell, hey, I say when we sell.
- 1:56We're making fun of my fat face. Welcome back to the last trade.
- 2:02It's a good way to start any episode.
- 2:05This is the the Life of a Road Dog Cam and I were Rd. dogging
- 2:08it this week up to Fort Worth for the North American
- 2:12Blockchain Summit despite. How was it?
- 2:16How was it guys? Yeah.
- 2:19It was good. It's productive.
- 2:21It was productive 2 days. Cam, you might be on mute there.
- 2:27I'm not. Can you hear me?
- 2:28Yeah, you're good. Yeah, great production quality
- 2:31by Lee and team, but it also is very indicative of two years
- 2:36almost into a bear market where it's not a whole lot of new
- 2:39market participants yet. You know, it's mostly all the
- 2:42friends, the, the industry operators that that we know.
- 2:46It's a bunch of familiar faces, and everybody's been heads down
- 2:49building the infrastructure for the next bull market, huh?
- 2:53That's right. I think that's been the entire
- 2:55conference in the past year at least, right?
- 2:58Which is, I'm not complaining, you know, kind of kind of
- 3:00solidifying those ties with some close friends, you know, getting
- 3:02ready for the next run here. Yeah.
- 3:05No, I mean, Jesse, to your point, I don't know if you were
- 3:07saying that facetiously, but it is interesting to catch up with
- 3:12people who have been building in the bear market, particularly in
- 3:15the mining industry. I think there's a lot of really
- 3:19strong building going on right now.
- 3:21Mining. Obviously this is probably the
- 3:22worst. Bear market cycle in the mining
- 3:25industry historically I don't know if we've ever touched on
- 3:29this on the last trade, but I think it is important for people
- 3:34to learn the lessons that the mining industry learned over the
- 3:38last two years. So last cycle 2021 bull market,
- 3:42a lot of miners aped into ASIC collateralized debt around the
- 3:48all time high of of basic pricing.
- 3:52Not only that they engaged in. Futures orders on machines that
- 3:58that weren't delivered for more than a year and so they put a
- 4:01lot of capital down for for goods that would not be
- 4:04delivered for a year. When they were delivered they
- 4:06were worth significantly less than when they the the order was
- 4:11originally put in. So a lot of miners got wrecked
- 4:15when the the price of Bitcoin fell over the course of 2022.
- 4:21And we've had a lot of consolidation, a lot of, a lot
- 4:24of sort of overgrowth washed out of the industry.
- 4:30We've hit this bottom hash. Price bottomed out around five
- 4:33and a half cents, six cents. And people learned a lot of
- 4:37lessons and are building what I would deem to be more
- 4:42structural, more fundamental base layer with structural
- 4:49integrity. At the industry base, people
- 4:51really wise about how they approach debt, how they lock
- 4:55down their energy, where they do that.
- 4:58It's a long line, but I talked a lot of miners last few days.
- 5:00There's a lot of good stuff going on.
- 5:01Cam. I don't know if you saw that as
- 5:02well. Yeah, I I sure have and that's
- 5:06for me we've been one of the most enjoyable parts about being
- 5:09in Texas is so much of the mining industry is here and that
- 5:13you know really had the opportunity to talk with so many
- 5:15miners learn about. So many different types of
- 5:18business models at all scales but 2022 is probably the the
- 5:22toughest year for minors would you say?
- 5:23My I know the the 20/18/19 bear market was difficult as well,
- 5:27but you had converging dynamics of not only a a price drawdown
- 5:32of about 80% which is typical for Bitcoin after the four year
- 5:36having cycle, but then you had energy costs rising and then you
- 5:40had hash rate which continued to scream up and to the right and
- 5:43continue to hit new all time highs.
- 5:46And I think we've got some pretty good suppositions as to
- 5:49why that might happen. But that is truly a worst case
- 5:52scenario that is hard to model and plan for.
- 5:56And then on top of that, some of the, did you mention some of the
- 5:59loans and I also get the sense to talking with firms like
- 6:04EDDEDG and Luxor that the market is still nascent in some
- 6:10respects towards treasury management and considering
- 6:13options and hedging. And just thinking, planning for
- 6:18and having the tools to plan for some of those worst case
- 6:21environments that you have to operate in for an extended
- 6:23period of time. Yeah, this is a good
- 6:27opportunity. We're gonna start reminding on
- 6:28this episode. Yeah, we've got Andy Thompson
- 6:31with us from Bitcoin Talent Co Cam Shromy from On Ramp.
- 6:37If you're if you're hearing the intro to this podcast, that's
- 6:41Cam's beautiful voice. I'm sure you recognize it.
- 6:45We are going to talk about a lot, a lot about business
- 6:48formation because of what Andy's seeing at Bitcoin Talent Co at
- 6:52the intersection of all the companies looking to hire the
- 6:56best talent in the world, which I think is really insightful for
- 6:59this particular point of the cycle.
- 7:02But zooming into mining just because it's fresh on our mind,
- 7:05because we were just with a bunch of miners in Fort Worth, I
- 7:08don't think we've ever really done a deep dive into the.
- 7:11The mining landscape particularly the economics
- 7:13around it on the last trade, it's a good opportunity to do
- 7:15that. So Logan if you want to pull up
- 7:17insights.brains.com, this is a great resource for anybody out
- 7:21there trying to understand what's going on in the mining
- 7:25world looking go out to the three-year view, let's just look
- 7:27at the last three years. So we're looking at now is a a
- 7:34chart that has price overlaid with hash rate and difficulty
- 7:38and as you can see in. Late 2021 we peaked at price and
- 7:43started going down. But Despite that hash rate has
- 7:47where we at now. Where are we gonna pull it up on
- 7:51my screen so I can see hash rate is more more than doubled.
- 7:59It's gone from 100 and 87164 XA hash at the all time high.
- 8:07And now it's sitting at 455 XA hash a second, which is pretty
- 8:11insane growth throughout the bear market.
- 8:14Does this does this go back to can we see like the prior bear
- 8:17market 'cause I vaguely recall the hash rate quadrupling during
- 8:24like from the bottom in 2019 until the halving it is.
- 8:31That's my vague recollection. So is this just something that
- 8:34happens where the hash rate catches up?
- 8:37When you know catches up to where it you know it it couldn't
- 8:40get get to quick enough during the bull market and then the
- 8:45growth continues, you know in the lulls post from the bottom
- 8:49until the next having. Yes.
- 8:53So like in the middle of the bull market economics are really
- 8:56good and people are really bullish.
- 8:58They have a lot of cash on their balance sheets.
- 8:59Like I mentioned, in 2021 a bunch of people engaged in
- 9:02futures orders for the Bit main S 19 series.
- 9:06And the the micro BTM 30M50 series and so they they put
- 9:13these orders in at the height of the bull market and then they
- 9:17eventually do get those ASICS delivered or the the ASICS do
- 9:20come to market in some capacity and if you buy them you gotta
- 9:24plug them in, you can't just have them sitting on the
- 9:26sidelines. And so that is probably what's
- 9:30driving this growth is just that lag of inventory being delivered
- 9:34to market and then eventually being plugged in.
- 9:37And then on top of that, I don't think it's well known but it
- 9:42outside of the industry. But what bit main particularly
- 9:46does micro BT might engage in this as well as if they have a
- 9:49bunch of inventory that they're sitting on and they can't move
- 9:53it, they want to make revenue. So they'll often plug those
- 9:56machines in, they'll find, they'll find somewhere to host
- 9:59the machines and they'll plug them in.
- 10:01They can make revenue on them before they find a buyer to
- 10:04offload those ASICS on so that they can monetize the that
- 10:06inventory while it's sitting there.
- 10:10I'm I've also been curious before of the what, what's the
- 10:14minor mentality right now? We've got five months until the
- 10:19halving is the mentality. Like, plug everything you can in
- 10:22right now and and get it while the getting's good because you
- 10:27know. Block subsidy drops in half in
- 10:29five months. So right now is actually kind of
- 10:31like a a golden time to be mining relative to the entire
- 10:36future of of Bitcoin mining. Certainly it's that.
- 10:40It's also like how we locking in the lowest price possible to to
- 10:47ensure that we can survive after the halving, particularly if
- 10:49you're running a fleet of older generation miners.
- 10:53So once that, that halving comes and that subsidy gets cut in
- 10:56half. And if the price doesn't
- 11:00appreciate materially between now and then your your your
- 11:03revenue is gonna be significantly hindered in that
- 11:05hash price is is going to to fall significantly.
- 11:09And I think we can pull that chart up too on Insights, just
- 11:13to understand what miners are looking at, what their, what
- 11:17metrics they're following to determine, yeah, hash price, you
- 11:22can go to the three-year view 'cause this is little.
- 11:25Expanded, but like over the last three years, you can see hash
- 11:29price, which is the blue line on the screen if you're watching
- 11:31it, which essentially just looks at the dollar per Tara hash per
- 11:38day that's produced by the miner that bottomed out around five
- 11:44and a half cents in November of last year when we had that big
- 11:51price fall. Now it's currently sitting at
- 11:53$0.09. It's almost double where it was
- 11:55this time last year and that's partly being driven due the
- 11:58price appreciating. But if you could do transaction
- 12:01fees, Logan, one thing that's also happening, it's interesting
- 12:06in the mining world that's really driving significant
- 12:10revenue is the fees of the Bitcoin network have gone up as
- 12:15this ordinals craze has gone off, people are issuing.
- 12:20Essentially digital assets on top of Bitcoin using ordinals or
- 12:24the BRC 20 protocol, which is computationally expensive.
- 12:29It takes a lot of data and the way the block space works, the
- 12:33more data you have in a transaction, the more expensive
- 12:35it's gonna be. And so this this ordinals craze
- 12:38has really driven transaction fees.
- 12:41Right now, they're making up 20% of the overall block reward,
- 12:44which is pretty significant. And there were a few blocks in
- 12:48in May where. Fees were more than the block
- 12:53subsidy, which which I guess had actually happened a few times
- 12:59before in Bitcoin's history. But those were kind of flukes.
- 13:02And this was, yeah, I mean, it's an unusual reason ordinals
- 13:07driving high fees. But Marty, I had a question on
- 13:12the on the hash price chart. So you know at what point does
- 13:17the S 9 just? Not make any sense ever.
- 13:21And obviously it's based on what energy price you're you're
- 13:24getting, but for most miners. So we can actually pull up
- 13:29Insights again Logan, then Scroll down a little bit and
- 13:32they actually have a good calculator here.
- 13:35So right now if we see this, the bit main.
- 13:39S9, which is considered the AK47 of the mining industry, it
- 13:43launched in 2015. The first batch of them did and
- 13:47they really hit the scene in 2016.
- 13:49So they've been around for almost 8 years now, 7-8 years
- 13:54about and right now. So if you can see this
- 13:57profitability of the different ASIC models right now if your
- 14:00electricity cost is $0.06 you are unprofitable, but if you
- 14:05change that. Let's drop it down to two cents
- 14:10the the S 9 becomes somewhat profitable.
- 14:13So right now if you're running S nines you're all in electricity
- 14:16costs probably has to be below 4 cents I would imagine.
- 14:20And then after the halving if the price doesn't appreciate
- 14:24materially you're you're probably going to be
- 14:28unprofitable. Difficulty is obviously going to
- 14:31go up bit main. And Micro BT have both announced
- 14:35that they're gonna have very efficient and high hashing
- 14:38machines hitting the market in the beginning of next year.
- 14:40So that should add a material bump to hash rate.
- 14:44And another interesting thing there, as well as that bit main
- 14:47with their S 21 series, they really shocked the market a few
- 14:51months ago when they announced the pricing for those ASICS at
- 14:55$14.00, a Tera hash which is actually below the market rate
- 14:58of the S 19 XPS which are the highest hashing machines on.
- 15:04The the market right now so bit main has come in with a very
- 15:08aggressive pricing strategy for their for their top of the line
- 15:13models which can be way more efficient than the S 19 XPS
- 15:17which is leading people to believe that bit Main's
- 15:19attempting to use their economies of scale and the
- 15:22production side's really begin to muscle out micro BT muscle
- 15:26out the competition. So that's one theory or another
- 15:30theory is that. We're reaching.
- 15:33We're getting close to the point of ASIC commodification, where
- 15:37there's gonna be bountiful and relatively cheap.
- 15:41What a, what a brutal industry it it's unreal.
- 15:44It's also just so deep like like you know, I I've, I've been full
- 15:49time on Bitcoin for years and and at no point have I like
- 15:53really dug in to try to like learn the mining industry
- 15:56because my job depends on it. So, you know, I haven't really
- 16:01sunk my teeth into it that much, but like, but I've been around
- 16:04paying attention and learning about Bitcoin for years and I
- 16:07feel like I barely know. You know, it's a it's a whole
- 16:11deep industry that that is that's incredibly brutal from an
- 16:17economics point of view because it it's the it's there's not
- 16:21many industries that disincentivize being, you know a
- 16:25long standing player. In mining, there's actually an
- 16:30advantage to being brand new because you get the most
- 16:33efficient machines and you can, you can choose your machines
- 16:36based on what makes the most sense for the market at that
- 16:38point in time. But if you've been around for
- 16:41even even a year, you're using machines that may become dated
- 16:45versus the market conditions and what you need to compete
- 16:47against. Absolutely brutal.
- 16:51I was joking with some miners last night and saying you guys
- 16:53are masochists it's like why why would you enter this market.
- 16:56And the the nicer way to say that which I did was that you
- 17:01you know have sought out one of the most difficult problems to
- 17:04solve in in one of the most difficult markets to compete in
- 17:07period. But I think also in Bitcoin that
- 17:09the the execution risk and then you talk to some miners that are
- 17:13are taking that to the extreme and to them I talked to last
- 17:16night are. Have set up a A1 MW operation in
- 17:20Costa Rica and our our mining off hydro and there are others
- 17:24and so now you're dealing with the operational and execution
- 17:28risk but then you're working through the completely foreign
- 17:31regulatory landscape just to set up the operations.
- 17:36So, so this is what I've always thought too.
- 17:37We curious to hear you guys thoughts like miners are
- 17:39possibly are probably the most bullish market participants.
- 17:44And because they have, they're taking a look at again like this
- 17:47industry where the the halving is every four years definition
- 17:50like the nominal amount of Bitcoin they're earning is going
- 17:52to be cut in half in a predictable basis and they're
- 17:56deploying millions of dollars of CapEx in advance.
- 18:00Knowing that is the dynamic you'd almost think like from if
- 18:05you're coming into this industry that.
- 18:07Looking at the supply curve that the hash rate would decline
- 18:11either remain flat or actually decline over time because the
- 18:14opportunity decreases, but we we've seen quite the opposite.
- 18:18You're you're diving head first into the unknown every cycle.
- 18:22You know once every four years on average, right.
- 18:24And I mean, as far as I know, I'm I'm with you, Jesse.
- 18:26Definitely not an expert by any means.
- 18:27But as I understand it, there's there's no realistic way of
- 18:31thinking. What's worked for you over the
- 18:32past cycle will continue to work moving forwards.
- 18:34You have to always be rethinking your strategy.
- 18:36Both in terms of your capital expenditures, your physical
- 18:39setup, your Geo arbitrage if you will, I mean there's just,
- 18:44there's so many things that go into it, right?
- 18:46Yeah. And I'm curious, Andy, have you
- 18:50converse with a lot of miners looking to hire this cycle?
- 18:53We are starting to have conversations with miners, which
- 18:56yeah, my my limited view here, my lens is that obviously that's
- 18:59a positive. You know miners are kicking the
- 19:01tires, they are hiring, they're hiring everything from on site
- 19:04technicians up to you know, senior level corporate roles.
- 19:07So that alone is a bullish indicator in my in my view,
- 19:10right? But I know there's well actually
- 19:13there's an interesting interesting point to couple that
- 19:15where yes miners are starting to hire that there's an interesting
- 19:18perception from the candidate viewpoint where it's like oh, is
- 19:21mining a safe place to be in, right.
- 19:22And so these are these are kind of conversations we're trying to
- 19:25have and convincing people to come off the ledge so to speak
- 19:29to move forward with a mining client where actually my
- 19:31argument is if they are still around today, right and if they
- 19:35are profitable such that they're hiring again, then that's
- 19:38actually all you really need to know.
- 19:39We've we've kind of seen, for the most part, at least most of
- 19:41the. Inefficient mining businesses
- 19:44kind of clear out over the past year or two.
- 19:46So yeah, from my view, just as as a, you know, as a recruiter
- 19:49helping to build mining businesses, I think they are,
- 19:52they're all very bullish right now.
- 19:54Andy when those miners are coming to you, are there
- 19:57specific industries that they're looking to outside of mining or
- 20:01outside of Bitcoin to say we would love to have a candidate
- 20:03from XYZ industry and and of course you have.
- 20:08You know, you have operational aspects of mining operation.
- 20:11You have the executive level or the finance.
- 20:13I mean, there's obviously so many different components, but.
- 20:17Yeah it it differs across the size of the mining organization
- 20:20itself as well as the discipline for which they're hiring, right.
- 20:22So on on the more like on site you know technician site manager
- 20:27type roles you you're seeing increasingly people move within
- 20:31Bitcoin mining which is interesting.
- 20:32So you actually already have. Experience with one minor, you
- 20:34know just taking that to another, maybe your other
- 20:35business went out of business, right, or you're just continuing
- 20:38to move forward for a number of reasons, right.
- 20:40So that kind of like circular movement is starting to happen
- 20:42in this cycle. Beyond that, we're still of
- 20:44course looking at like let's bucket this broadly as like IT
- 20:48technician type things. You've come from Amazon data
- 20:51centers or some other large data farm like that where you know,
- 20:54generally speaking there's there's a lot of translatable
- 20:58skill sets. Of course, you're not like.
- 21:00Super well versed on ASICS themselves, maybe there's some
- 21:01ramp up period there, but in terms of like network, you know
- 21:04infrastructure and engineering things like that, we do see a
- 21:06lot of people coming from that space too.
- 21:08And then on the corporate side, that's where it is pretty
- 21:10interesting as well because I mean an early stage mining
- 21:13startup may want a tech type person who's operated in that in
- 21:17that early stage environment, whereas some of the more public
- 21:19miners, they actually want public company experience,
- 21:21right. Let's say you're hiring a
- 21:22finance role for one of the largest miners in this space.
- 21:25You probably want that person coming from a a Fortune 50,
- 21:27Fortune 100 and maybe having traditional finance experience
- 21:30as well as bringing that operation and that rigor into
- 21:32the mining industry as well. The short answer, there's no one
- 21:36bucket I mean and the good thing for us is that we we are then
- 21:39able to position that and as such for for all these
- 21:42candidates as well. You know there's not one type of
- 21:44background that's relevant for mining.
- 21:46If mining is something that's of interest to you, there's
- 21:48increasingly going to be an opportunity for you no matter
- 21:50what your background or skill set is, I would say.
- 21:53Yeah. Go ahead, Go ahead, Marty.
- 21:57I was gonna say yeah, the mining industry, I mean Ken you you
- 22:01alluded to, it's extremely masochistic.
- 22:03It's the most hyper competitive industry I've ever been a part
- 22:06of in my life. For those who are unaware, I was
- 22:10one of the first team members, Great American Mining, which
- 22:13spun up back in 2018. We focused heavily on.
- 22:17Off grid mining, particularly on upstream oil and gas wells to do
- 22:21flare mitigation. We were one of the first out
- 22:23there after upstream and Crusoe up in the Bakken helping oil and
- 22:29gas companies to mitigate their flare.
- 22:31And that was an extremely fun time in my life.
- 22:34Learned a lot about the dynamics and really got thrown head first
- 22:38into this hyper competitive market.
- 22:40And really the name of the game is it's Capital Management,
- 22:44treasury management, finance. Financing your operation the
- 22:48correct way, having good mixture of debt and equity financing and
- 22:52then really timing the market, timing the the ASIC purchases is
- 22:56probably one of the most important things.
- 22:57And then obviously the other most important thing is your
- 23:00energy cost, your own energy cost and that is a sort of
- 23:04moving target at any given point in time.
- 23:07My favorite description of miners comes from John Seth.
- 23:10He describes miners as energy pirates.
- 23:13And so miners are just engaged in this massive game of energy
- 23:17price arbitrage, always looking for the lowest cost energy
- 23:21possible. And again, that's a moving
- 23:24target, a Great American mining. There was a period of time,
- 23:28particularly in 2020, when the oil.
- 23:30The price went negative temporarily.
- 23:31That was a great time to lock in genset prices for for your
- 23:36leases, which generators for off grid miners is what produces the
- 23:39electricity and if you can lock in a low cost lease for many
- 23:44many years that was a great time to get in.
- 23:46And also that was post having 2020.
- 23:49At that time ASICS were really cheap so that was probably one
- 23:51of the most opportune times to get into the industry in the
- 23:54last decade. But that changes quickly.
- 23:56You had the war. And Ukraine breakout which led
- 23:59to an energy crisis and then off grid mining if you were getting
- 24:03into it in late 2021 throughout 2022 the the economics simply
- 24:10didn't make sense. The demand for Gen. sets in the
- 24:12oil field went up significantly as the price of oil and gas
- 24:16began to climb back up. And so you're you just have all
- 24:20these moving variables and timing and capital deployment.
- 24:25Doing capital deployment very strategically is, is how you're
- 24:29going to win and and actually survive in the mining industry.
- 24:35That's a great point. Have you ever seen that triangle
- 24:38that Bob Burnett has put together to try to really
- 24:42illustrate that dynamic? So it's kind of three.
- 24:45I can't remember if he calls it a three legged stool idea.
- 24:47But there are different times in the market you're going to be
- 24:50without one of these legs of the stool.
- 24:52You're either going to have you're balancing the cost of the
- 24:56energy, the infrastructure, the cost of the infrastructure and
- 24:59then the availability of capital.
- 25:01So you can see how you when you you know you're in the bull
- 25:04market, the capital's there but then the infrastructure is
- 25:06expensive and then you have to see what the energy, your energy
- 25:10costs are. Right now like you said the the
- 25:13cost per Tera hash for the miners couldn't be lower but
- 25:15then the the capital unless you're a public miner is is
- 25:18really hard to obtain. So to to find the right place to
- 25:22enter the market where all three of those aspects of that
- 25:28business formation are are favourable and will get you
- 25:31through the next four years very difficult to find that entry.
- 25:37It it it's a good point too that one of the the things I remember
- 25:42from from the peak of the last bull market was having a
- 25:47conversation with with a. A mining technology company, a
- 25:56guy from this company and and he said that right now this was at
- 26:01the top, right now it's six times more cost effective to
- 26:07invest in mining than it is to just buy Bitcoin.
- 26:11And it you know that in hindsight, that's the reason I
- 26:15always think about that is because in hindsight that was a
- 26:17top indicator that was. A a frothy market where it it
- 26:25actually, at that point in time looked extremely attractive to
- 26:29invest in mining and that ended up being the worst possible time
- 26:33to be investing in mining because from that point forward
- 26:37miners were over investing and a lot of them got washed out
- 26:40because their their balance sheets weren't healthy enough to
- 26:43survive. A a major bear market.
- 26:46The the long the drawdown plus the amount of time that you have
- 26:49to survive. Through those conditions and
- 26:53it's so you know it is a good watch out that I guess one of
- 26:57the lessons for the one of the few mining lessons that I've
- 27:00internalized is that investing in mining is usually best when
- 27:05it looks the worst and and almost certainly a bad idea when
- 27:09it looks the best. Yeah, that's I think going back
- 27:14to that, that three legged stool problem that you're describing
- 27:18Cam, I think the best. Lesson that miners have learned
- 27:21over the last few years is it's really being patient on the
- 27:23capital side of things like Jesse was just describing at the
- 27:27pico top of the last bull market, everybody was deploying
- 27:30their capital and holding on to their Bitcoin and and it's
- 27:33really interesting for the publicly traded miners
- 27:35specifically because they're essentially used as high beta
- 27:39Bitcoin exposure plays and and when the bull market's ripping
- 27:44historically that's been the case, who knows that that'll
- 27:45change. If the ETF comes to the market
- 27:48and you really don't need to get exposure to Bitcoin via mining
- 27:51stocks and you're able to do that via an ETF, it'll be
- 27:53interesting to see how those dynamics play out going forward.
- 27:56But historically mining stocks have been sort of high beta
- 27:59plays, high beta Bitcoin exposure plays for equity
- 28:03investors. But with that being said, I
- 28:06think these publicly traded miners are specifically in a
- 28:10predicament and thinking about being patient for capital with
- 28:12capital and being smart with capital like there was a lot of
- 28:14companies core scientific. Specifically, I mean they they
- 28:17just got out of bankruptcy and they wound up selling a a large
- 28:22portion of their Bitcoin treasury at I believe at $20,000
- 28:25when it would have been much more advantageous for them to to
- 28:29scrape some off their balance sheet when Bitcoin's trading at
- 28:3260,065 thousand, whatever it may have been.
- 28:35But at that point in time when the bull market's ripping, you
- 28:38can see how equity investors could really see that as a
- 28:43negative selling part of your Bitcoin treasury.
- 28:45When the price is ripping, you're not getting.
- 28:47As much high beta on that, but if you're thinking in the long
- 28:49term, it probably is the best strategy to deploy to lock in
- 28:56some cash so that you can then redeploy once the bull market
- 28:59settles down and we we go back into a bear cycle.
- 29:04I do wonder. There's obviously a huge
- 29:06difference between the individual investor and the
- 29:08mining, certainly public mining company, right?
- 29:11But what's the adage for all of us as Bitcoin holders, right?
- 29:15Don't trade, don't try to get queued, don't try to time things
- 29:18right. Just stay humble.
- 29:20Stacks. That's right.
- 29:21I mean, that's what we're told. Stay humble, right.
- 29:24That part means stay solvent you know do what you have to do
- 29:27manage your cash flow situation the right way.
- 29:29So is that does that strategy or that philosophy have a place in
- 29:33mining companies where it's like you're you're earning Bitcoin,
- 29:35you keep Bitcoin balance sheet. You know it's going to go up and
- 29:37down but it's it's almost out of sight, out of mind.
- 29:39Now where you have to be laser focused is your your Fiat
- 29:42management if you will. So again you're if you're public
- 29:45managing you know that whole side of the market, if you are a
- 29:48private company, your debt financing versus your equity
- 29:51financing and again thinking. If like Fiat strategy versus
- 29:54just Bitcoin hodling strategy, is that does that make sense for
- 29:57miners even? Well, if they want to survive in
- 30:00the long term, I think they had like over the long term, yes, it
- 30:03makes sense that you should be building your Bitcoin treasury
- 30:06bigger and bigger each cycle. But with that being said, you do
- 30:10have to be smart with it to lock in that cash so that you can
- 30:13redeploy and not have to dilute your company whether you're
- 30:16private or public, dilute your shareholders or.
- 30:21Get into some pretty that's what I'm looking for.
- 30:26Like predatory financing because mining's high risk and that's
- 30:30gonna be a high cost of capital to to actually finance anything
- 30:33on the debt side of things. That's fair, yeah.
- 30:37It's it's interesting too to like.
- 30:39You know, in the way that I think about and talk about
- 30:43mining, it's sort of, I fall into the trap of talking about
- 30:46the glory days of 2021 and how hot mining was then as if it is
- 30:52over, as if it is like past its peak in the high watermark won't
- 30:56be regained. But you know, this is this is
- 31:01emblematic of how Bitcoin grows in general, with higher higher
- 31:06highs and higher lows and higher lows being the key part.
- 31:09And mining is in the mining industry is is subject to that
- 31:13as well. And so it will be very exciting
- 31:16to see how in this next bull market the the global Bitcoin
- 31:20mining industry will be much bigger than it, than it was in
- 31:242021. And it will probably feel much
- 31:26more present in our lives too, as hot as hot as all those IPO
- 31:34ING. Bitcoin mining companies were in
- 31:372021. There were only a handful of
- 31:39them and there may be quite a few more in in this next bull
- 31:43market in the next 1824 months. And you know, like I have a a
- 31:50salient personal anecdote on this of of I just drove through
- 31:55West TX and I was stunned at how many gas flares I saw driving on
- 32:02the 10. Because in my in my mind, all
- 32:06these opportunities for for for taking unused energy and
- 32:11channeling it into Bitcoin mining have have been explored
- 32:15for years now by Bitcoin miners. But it's it's it's indicative of
- 32:22how many. Of the land owners, the the
- 32:28mineral rights owners have yet to accept that Bitcoin is a
- 32:33legitimate addition to their existing business models.
- 32:37And you know every single grass flare that you see when whenever
- 32:41you fly in a plane at night over West TX or the South China Sea
- 32:46for that matter, Or anywhere where there's a bunch of.
- 32:50Gas flares and you see all those pinpricks of orange light and
- 32:54every single one of those is a a small scale mining, Bitcoin
- 32:57mining operation that is yet to come into existence.
- 32:59But Will, that's how early we still are for Bitcoin mining.
- 33:04Yeah, I'm actually happy that we just settled on talking about
- 33:07mining cause again it's so fascinating there's and there's,
- 33:10there's such a deep rabbit hole and there's so many lessons that
- 33:12have been learned again in this cycle and the industry certainly
- 33:16matured over the last. Three years, particularly post
- 33:21China mining ban, a lot of that trade has moved to America.
- 33:24We've talked about that in previous episodes and the
- 33:28industry here in the United States has really matured.
- 33:30But with that being said, there are still a lot of things that
- 33:35can come to market that, that can help this market mature.
- 33:38More hedging products specifically, that's a lot of
- 33:42the risks that we're talking about on the capital side of
- 33:43thing is as high as it is because there's not really
- 33:47sufficient. Hedging strategies.
- 33:50Some miners have employed energy cost hedging strategies which
- 33:55has helped them out significantly.
- 33:56I know Riot does that and others here in Texas.
- 33:59That's certainly gonna allow them to manage their balance
- 34:02sheets more wisely. Moving forward the the whole
- 34:06conversation around hash rate derivatives and forwards
- 34:10contracts and being able to to hedge your your hash rate
- 34:13exposure there's. And people talking about that
- 34:16and trying to make products in market for years.
- 34:19If we're being honest that market hasn't really matured to
- 34:21the point where it's material yet.
- 34:24But there's companies like Luxor, Bedouda and others that
- 34:28are trying to to really jump start that that hedging of hash
- 34:31rate market that that should allow miners to hedge risk more
- 34:36appropriately moving forward which will certainly help the
- 34:39robustness of the industry and the companies within it.
- 34:43And then on top of that, just operationally?
- 34:45I think the market is learning on the go and I think a big
- 34:50trend that we're going to see during this next cycle is a lot
- 34:54of miners moving behind the meter.
- 34:55So getting their electricity like at the power plant before
- 34:59it even hits the grid which which dictates lower pricing and
- 35:02more control over that power by the mining industry.
- 35:06But I think for the context of this show and the audience that
- 35:10we're speaking to which is institutional investors, I I
- 35:12think that's one thing that. Anybody listening should really
- 35:16internalize. Is that really mining, I
- 35:19wholeheartedly believe, is an energy play at the end of the
- 35:22day. And what we're witnessing is the
- 35:24beginning of the sort of merging of the Bitcoin mining industry
- 35:28and the energy sector. And Bitcoin mining is going to
- 35:30be a very pivotal tool for for energy producers or utilities or
- 35:35power plants. I also think of it simply from
- 35:38the technological advancements that are sure to happen.
- 35:40So all we've talked about now is operational efficiencies.
- 35:42Miners, yes, they're continuing to learn through each cycle how
- 35:45to be more efficient, that this is great and that will continue.
- 35:49But just the the process of you know turning energy energy
- 35:53playoffs. But the process of turning
- 35:54energy into hash rate like more efficient machines, more
- 35:56efficient chips if you will, increase competition from you
- 36:00know more hiring that happens in the Bitcoin landscape but also
- 36:02the Intel's, the AMD's of the world right.
- 36:04So I think of this like maybe the techno optimist lens if you
- 36:07will. It's like.
- 36:08Of course the, the devices themselves will continue to
- 36:11increase in efficiency to to a place that we don't even
- 36:14understand yet, right. And then the whole energy
- 36:17abundance conversation, I mean we're, yeah, we're looking at A
- 36:19at a future that could be very different, right, from from
- 36:22access to energy and energy abundance standpoint, right.
- 36:25And so all of this will affect mining in ways that we just
- 36:27can't even comprehend yet. Yeah, it it's it's cool too how
- 36:32we stumbled into talking about mining, but I'm it keeps hitting
- 36:36me. How?
- 36:37Mining is like this, this very tangible example of how Bitcoin
- 36:41infrastructure is still in this very early days.
- 36:44And then Andy, what we're going to get into talking about here
- 36:47is how you are helping companies build out their, their, their
- 36:53hiring, solving that problem they're you're building out some
- 36:57of the infrastructure for how businesses operate and and the
- 37:01functions that they need to fulfil hiring.
- 37:05In order to grow an industry. And so it's it's kind of a funny
- 37:09parallel how mining is this very tangible infrastructure
- 37:12development process. But all these other behind the
- 37:16scenes businesses that need to exist in order for an industry
- 37:23to operate are are also developing and that's what you
- 37:26guys are at the forefront of doing.
- 37:31That's true. I mean I say this for all
- 37:32companies in all roles where you know the best of the best.
- 37:35We have a great community here in Bitcoin.
- 37:37It's gotten us to where we are, it's fantastic.
- 37:39But we're still just scratching the surface.
- 37:40You know there are so many people still stuck on these
- 37:42islands if you will, in traditional finance, traditional
- 37:45tech startup landscape. They just haven't haven't opened
- 37:47their eyes yet. Don't understand that Bitcoin is
- 37:49where they should be spending their time and effort, right.
- 37:52And so that certainly applies to the mining space too.
- 37:55I mean when you think of. The computational power required
- 37:59for AI or for self driving, like some of these amazing
- 38:01engineering minds working on those problems, they should also
- 38:04see Bitcoin mining as part of that.
- 38:06I don't. I don't think that's a crazy
- 38:07thing to say. Like why would you?
- 38:08Why is it so beyond obvious that AI is the most interesting place
- 38:13to work? It's going to be an amazing part
- 38:14of our future, yes, but I think I'd throw Bitcoin mining and and
- 38:17creating more efficient technology there.
- 38:19I'd throw that into the arena as something that's equally as
- 38:21important for humankind. Yeah, and.
- 38:27Just beating the drum of all the efficiencies that are being made
- 38:31operationally too, like again, this this industry, so nation.
- 38:36It's almost been like a bunch of Cavemen just plugging in
- 38:39computers and trying to get the most hash rate as possible so
- 38:41they can accumulate as much Bitcoin.
- 38:43That's what the mining industry has essentially been at.
- 38:46War was for the first, let's say 10 years since ASICS were
- 38:50released around 2013. But now?
- 38:56With the competitive nature and the competitive landscape of the
- 38:59industry, it's becoming more hyper competitive like the edge
- 39:02that an individual individual miner can get is really
- 39:06beginning to to surface and this is particularly being very
- 39:13calculated with how you manage your hash rate.
- 39:15And so Cathedra which I'm on the Board of Directors of publicly
- 39:19traded miner out of Canada with all of our operations our.
- 39:25In the US though, but one thing that they did this last cycle
- 39:28was really hone in on their under clocking strategy.
- 39:31So Bitcoin miners run firmware that allow you to essentially
- 39:35draw less power and if you can draw less power but have the
- 39:40ratio of hash rate produced for that power remain relatively
- 39:43high, you can increase your profit margins.
- 39:46And so that's one example of an operational efficiency really
- 39:48managing. How much hash rate each
- 39:51individual machine is, is producing by manipulating the
- 39:54firmware to either under clock when conditions are are very bad
- 39:59and then over clock when they're really good is something that is
- 40:02I think going to become more professionalized moving to this
- 40:06cycle too, you're going to see a lot of sort of hash board level.
- 40:12Efficiencies that are that are dictated by software that react
- 40:16to where the price of Bitcoin is in any given point in time,
- 40:19where your electricity cost is in any given point in time,
- 40:21where the hash price is at any given point in time.
- 40:24And so the room to create operational efficiencies that
- 40:28really Dr. optimal margin for these businesses is something
- 40:33that that's going to develop as well.
- 40:35I have a related question that you're the guy to ask this to
- 40:39Marty is. So now we're seeing the
- 40:42development of like heat, waste utilization for various
- 40:48applications and that makes me wonder going forward is are
- 40:54there dis economies of scale this?
- 40:56Are there dis economies of scale for Bitcoin mining when those
- 41:00large scale Bitcoin miners are competing with like home
- 41:06deployments of a couple miners heating?
- 41:09Your house in the winter and and obviously the the advantage that
- 41:13that small scale Bitcoin mine has is that it is getting two
- 41:19birds for one stone. You know you're paying your
- 41:21heating bill and you're mining Bitcoin with the same energy and
- 41:27and so does that. Move the needle towards it
- 41:31becomes more efficient, more cost effective to to mine.
- 41:38When there's a heat use application for that wasted,
- 41:42that otherwise wasted heat that the miners are generating and
- 41:46yeah, so it it do. Are we going to see a shift from
- 41:49large scale mines to this two birds, one stone sort of
- 41:54requirement of like you have to be heating Olympics, swimming
- 41:58pool with your Bitcoin mine for it to make sense and be
- 42:02competitive enough? I think it's gonna work at both
- 42:04ends of the market, right, 'cause that this economy is a
- 42:06scale on our smaller end, Yeah. It's like you're gonna have an
- 42:09advantage if you can use the waste heat to drive down your
- 42:12cost of heat. So you said it's paying your
- 42:15electricity bill for your your heating bill, but really you're
- 42:18not. It's like actually reducing your
- 42:19heating bill because you don't have to to run your your heater.
- 42:22You can just run your ASIC and that Asic's gonna produce
- 42:25Bitcoin. And so you don't have to turn
- 42:27your your heat on, you just turn your miner on your miner's
- 42:30producing revenue. So your your energy bill or your
- 42:34heating bill gets reduced. Your energy bill may stay
- 42:37static, but you're making Bitcoin in that mining from that
- 42:41mining operation. It's gonna work there.
- 42:44But then on the other end of the spectrum with the large miners,
- 42:46they have economies of scale which allow them to dictate
- 42:49pricing the electricity and so they're able to get very low
- 42:51cost electricity. And then on top of that,
- 42:53particularly here in Texas, they're able to participate and
- 42:56demand response programs that allow them to get extra revenue
- 42:59for selling their electricity back to the grid when prices are
- 43:03high. And so they're able to lock in
- 43:05higher revenues from selling that electricity instead of
- 43:07mining with it. So I think it's going to work on
- 43:09both ends of the spectrum which is actually a pretty beautiful
- 43:12thing. The the this economy is the
- 43:14scale that are afforded to the smaller miners actually helps
- 43:18distribute hash rate more granularly geographically and
- 43:22from an ownership perspective which is very important for the
- 43:25the the strength and overall security of the network in the
- 43:28long term. And it seems like we could head
- 43:31towards a world, maybe it's 510 years from now where you have
- 43:38these sort of turnkey Bitcoin miners at home that take care of
- 43:44your your heating and mine Bitcoin, or take care of your,
- 43:50you know, heating your Jacuzzi or a pool or whatever, and mine
- 43:54Bitcoin. And that could become like, so
- 43:57that barbell sort of thing that you're talking about there,
- 43:59Marty, of like we could have a a really sustainable consumer side
- 44:05of the Bitcoin mining industry because of the the use case of
- 44:09of putting that otherwise wasted heat to work.
- 44:14Pretty cool. Yeah, it's really cool.
- 44:17It's the energy currency of the world, the Bitcoin, it's it's
- 44:22insane. And then that's the, I mean we
- 44:24discussed this last week when we were talking about the Ethereum
- 44:27ETF, but that's like one thing when it comes to like proof of
- 44:30work first, proof of stake. That's why it's almost poetic
- 44:33and somewhat cosmic and beautiful.
- 44:37Is like Bitcoin particularly via proof of work in the mining
- 44:40industry is you're creating this digital money with a direct
- 44:44connection to the physical world.
- 44:45So it's like a building of the physical and the digital via
- 44:48energy, electricity and enables miners to produce the hashes
- 44:52that allow them to add blocks to the network that reward them.
- 44:55In this digital currency called Bitcoin, we're really melding
- 44:58the physical and the digital world together pretty directly
- 45:02via Bitcoin. So Satoshi was a fan of Henry
- 45:05Ford, right? Henry Ford?
- 45:08Buckminster Fuller, Nikola Tesla, all these guys.
- 45:12This idea's been out there for a while.
- 45:14Henry Ford wrote an op-ed I believe in the New York Inquirer
- 45:19when it was still around more than 100 years ago.
- 45:21He said. If we're gonna have peace on
- 45:24earth, we're gonna need an energy backed currency.
- 45:28Was Satoshi aware of of that, that line of thinking?
- 45:32Was he deliberately thinking that Bitcoin would be energy?
- 45:34Money? I don't know.
- 45:37I'm not sure, because if you read the white paper, Satoshi
- 45:42talks a lot about one CPU, one vote.
- 45:45No, I don't think he foresaw the competitive landscape that would
- 45:50evolve to to attain Bitcoin. I can't say for sure, but many
- 45:56people think he was running with the assumption that you'd just
- 45:57be able to mine Bitcoin on your CPU into perpetuity.
- 46:01And it's funny, Laszlo, the guy who's most famous for spending
- 46:0710,000 Bitcoin on pizza, he was actually the first person to
- 46:10build a GPU miner in Satoshi at the time, asked him to to hold
- 46:16off from from releasing his GPU miner because he didn't think
- 46:19the network was was sort of robust enough at that point.
- 46:23And if a bunch of GPUs came on, it could really consolidate the
- 46:27the the supply of Bitcoin in very few hands.
- 46:32So I think the progression of the computing power dedicated to
- 46:36Bitcoin mining was something that was a bit of a unforeseen
- 46:40consequence that that's Toshi didn't.
- 46:44There and again is the beauty of proof of work, right.
- 46:46So I would, I would wager that situation probably looked at
- 46:49proof of work as like the the mechanism for security, right.
- 46:51I mean that that's kind of his his view at the time, right.
- 46:54Making yeah no double spending things like that, right.
- 46:57So that that was probably the lens that she was viewing early
- 46:59on with no anticipation I expect of like the entire mining
- 47:02industry that would set up to the, you know, adjacent to
- 47:05Bitcoin, right? And so again, the proof of work
- 47:07is beautiful because I think that will continue.
- 47:09We'll continue to see examples of that, right.
- 47:11Mining will come out, other devices will come out.
- 47:13Like the ways that proof of work kind of manifests itself across,
- 47:18the industry will continue to evolve and change too.
- 47:20Yeah, it it's so beautiful. It's the right word because you
- 47:25know when you, when you address a problem, when you create an
- 47:28innovation that's so high level, it's really impossible to to
- 47:32imagine all of the downstream effects of that.
- 47:36And you know, it's like inventing the transistor, or
- 47:38inventing, you know, a CPU or inventing electricity like you,
- 47:43you have no ability. To the Internet, right?
- 47:47Yeah, anything that's high level like that, it's it's beautiful
- 47:53because you can you can attack that problem at a high level,
- 47:58abstract, conceptual way, and if you have a breakthrough then it
- 48:03unlocks. Untold levels of innovation
- 48:07downstream of that that you that you as the inventor cannot
- 48:10possibly imagine you're not even you're not thinking that this
- 48:13could happen it it's you know it this happens in math to where
- 48:18you know E equals MC squared like leads to the a bomb and you
- 48:23know our nuclear world world we that that wasn't really
- 48:27envisioned I think by by Einstein or you know Nash
- 48:32equilibriums with game theory like.
- 48:34The applications of those in all of finance have been way beyond
- 48:39what John Nash envisioned. So it it's such a beautiful
- 48:43thing when that happens and there's nothing more high level
- 48:47and that leads to more downstream effects than changing
- 48:51the money for a society. And you know the proof of work
- 48:55innovation, of that Bringing Bringing proof of work back to
- 48:59money then changes every industry that touches money.
- 49:04And the manufacturer of money being the most immediate of
- 49:11those. I think again of your main
- 49:15audience here, right, the investor, the institutional
- 49:17investor, right. Is this perhaps why it's been?
- 49:21Harder to grasp up until just recently, you know, investing in
- 49:23Bitcoin. Why does it make sense?
- 49:24Because you use this analogy again of, OK, well, inventing
- 49:27Bitcoin or the Bitcoin invention was like the invention of the
- 49:29Internet, right? But you can never invest in the
- 49:32Internet singularly, right? Like maybe early on you're
- 49:34investing in Alta Vista or AOL and that actually turned out to
- 49:38be not so great for your long term.
- 49:39Or you invested in Webvan or all these kinds of things right over
- 49:42time. There were companies, you know,
- 49:43built on the Internet that some were successful, some are not.
- 49:45But you were never investing in the Internet in the same way
- 49:48that you're investing in Bitcoin right now.
- 49:50So again. Investors who have gone through
- 49:51these cycles in the past, has that been a hard thing to grok
- 49:54and like, well, shit, I should just be buying Bitcoin.
- 49:56Because no matter, no matter what happens, like Bitcoin is
- 49:58going to rise in value. Other things will come and go
- 50:00built on top of it, but Bitcoin will always be the central point
- 50:03of that. Yeah, yeah.
- 50:06It's a topic I've been wrestling with how to articulate that, how
- 50:09to translate that simply into educational content and over the
- 50:15over the years and I have a graphic that sort of shows how.
- 50:19The Internet of information is this thriving city built on
- 50:23TCPIP, the protocol underneath and how.
- 50:27Now we have the early stages of the Internet of value developing
- 50:32and and it's built on a protocol, A protocol for storing
- 50:39and exchanging value that people are going to.
- 50:44Gravitate towards because the network effect ends up winning.
- 50:47And you know this is, this is the story of open protocols.
- 50:50It's why we use TCPIP for everything on the Internet.
- 50:53You don't have to you could build your Internet application
- 50:57on a different version of the Internet, but literally nobody's
- 51:01there. So why would you do that?
- 51:03This is how protocol standards emerge and and I think it's
- 51:09there's a big misconception that remains today.
- 51:12When we when people take a look at the cryptocurrency landscape
- 51:16and they see 30,000 different cryptocurrencies and they all
- 51:21look like startups, they all feel like Internet startups.
- 51:25And in the Internet you couldn't invest in the protocol layer.
- 51:28You could only invest in the Internet startups which are
- 51:32building on the application layer, building on top of the
- 51:34protocol layer using the TCPIP and the the rules set there in
- 51:40order to build their business. On top of that, and that's all,
- 51:45that's all that we know because we've never seen a digital
- 51:50protocol war where it was possible to invest in the
- 51:53protocol layer. And so we mistake when we come
- 51:57into cryptocurrencies. We all mistake the the
- 52:02cryptocurrencies for Internet start-ups when really they are
- 52:07competing protocols. And so that that's a that's a
- 52:11winner takes all war that plays out when and eventually a
- 52:16protocol standard emerges that if you're not if you're not on
- 52:21that protocol if you're not in that ecosystem your investment
- 52:26goes to zero and obviously we having reached the the Bitcoin.
- 52:33The level of understanding necessary to under to recognize
- 52:36that Bitcoin is is winning that battle, has already won that
- 52:39battle. But most of the world still is
- 52:42coming in fresh and and projecting what we learned from
- 52:46the Internet to what we see in the cryptocurrency landscape
- 52:51with all of these 30,000 start up looking things, competing and
- 52:54we assume it's just like the Internet.
- 52:56But no, it's it's a protocol war.
- 52:58And there will only be one There is no second best, Laura.
- 53:07Jesse, you say you've struggled to to articulate that simply.
- 53:10I I think that was just it. I think that that actually makes
- 53:13a ton of sense, right? It's the idea of competing
- 53:16startups or well, if Bitcoin is great, then what about this new
- 53:18one that's faster? Like that startup will obviously
- 53:20do well, right? Or this one that can work.
- 53:21Transactions per SE, Whatever, you know, whatever kinds of
- 53:23things you would pitch to say why.
- 53:25This random protocol or token is better than Bitcoin, obviously.
- 53:27We know it's not true, right? But that's like the marketing
- 53:30strategy up to this point, you know?
- 53:31Think of it, however, as competing protocols and if it is
- 53:34going to be winner take all, how is Bitcoin not going to win at
- 53:37this point, right. That and for the is in this
- 53:42conversation. Go ahead, Ken.
- 53:44Oh, sure. So given your your experience at
- 53:48Uber and there's some interesting analogies that I
- 53:50think where. Uber is this downstream business
- 53:54that maybe or may may not was foreseen by some of the early
- 53:57Internet pioneers, but pretty revolutionary.
- 53:59You can step outside on the sidewalk, press a button, and
- 54:02the car flies up to the curb and you get in with a total
- 54:06stranger. And then they take you to
- 54:08wherever you will need to go for a reasonable price.
- 54:12There's a lot of trust that goes into the some of those first
- 54:14rides. You know, when when you get into
- 54:16maybe an Uber for the first time with someone from an older
- 54:19generation or maybe our parents age.
- 54:21That's a pretty scary concept. Even though in some ways it's
- 54:24it's it's also kind of, you know, scary to you.
- 54:27You flag your hand up in New York and a Yellow Cab comes
- 54:31over. I mean, that's someone you don't
- 54:32know either, but. There's there's so much trust
- 54:35and reliance in the technology and the vetting of the drivers
- 54:38and those things. So I think there's some decent
- 54:40corollaries to Bitcoin where we're also shepherding people
- 54:44into a new technology that has profound implications.
- 54:49Are you seeing, you know, how How are companies thinking about
- 54:51finding some of those people to help build their businesses that
- 54:55can translate what this technology means and how it can
- 54:59be used by by everyday people? Well, I think the biggest
- 55:03learning upfront is this. We had this phenomenon, if you
- 55:06will, early on in Uber where there ended up being this whole
- 55:09crop of Uber for X, right? Uber for dog walking, Uber for
- 55:13haircuts, Uber, whatever, right? I mean, there were so many
- 55:15businesses, some, some ended up being somewhat successful,
- 55:18gaining enough, you know, economies of scale or enough
- 55:20like network effect, right. But for the most part, it's like
- 55:23at Uber we would always say like.
- 55:25We are that right. We we've already built the
- 55:27largest network effect like why can't we offer all kinds of
- 55:29other services on this marketplace, right?
- 55:32And so I'm not getting to your core question yet but I think
- 55:35companies should should realize that again or or investors even
- 55:38should realize that like there's not going to be the the Solana
- 55:42is the Bitcoin for speed or Ethereum is the Bitcoin whatever
- 55:45you want to say, right? Like that doesn't exist.
- 55:47Like Bitcoin is the one that's already built that that network
- 55:49effect and is the most secure. Kind of related to what we had
- 55:53with Uber early on, right now you know you are increasingly
- 55:56seeing across the landscape. I mean whatever it's an exchange
- 55:59or consumer product this or that like people are starting to open
- 56:02their eyes to the fact that there is a lot of talent in
- 56:05traditional tech that has already tackled some of these
- 56:07problems like how do you, how do you get viral growth, how do you
- 56:10have the best user experience right from a from an actual
- 56:13product design or you know UI UX kind of thing.
- 56:15So those. And those, you know,
- 56:18realizations are starting to happen across Bitcoin companies
- 56:20now. And that excites me because
- 56:21we're finally getting to a point where Bitcoin is mature enough
- 56:24to have our pitch to potential candidates be better received,
- 56:27right Orange Pilling along the way to getting people a role in
- 56:29Bitcoin. But the companies are actually
- 56:31demanding this talent too. You know, we we're not just,
- 56:34we're not just looking for talent on Bitcoin Twitter
- 56:36anymore. We're actually looking broadly
- 56:37and trying to bring the best of the best into the space.
- 56:42We need it. Bitcoin needs better UX, better
- 56:45UIII. Teed that up for Marty.
- 56:47It's his. It's his message.
- 56:49I love it. I I've said it before and I
- 56:53truly believe this. Like if you want to leave your
- 56:55mark on the world, we have a relatively blank canvas over
- 57:01here in the Bitcoin industry. So if you're a UXUI designer,
- 57:05Bitcoin, the way in which it works, how you receive, send
- 57:08transactions at the protocol level via Lightning with other
- 57:11solutions like Liquid and fediments that are coming to
- 57:15market like these are brand new experiences and brand new ways
- 57:18of interacting with money like just a private public key pair.
- 57:22How do you manage new addresses? How do you articulate that a
- 57:26user is interacting with the new address?
- 57:28How do you articulate that? If you're gonna send a
- 57:30transaction, maybe you should make it a a replace by fee
- 57:34transaction so that if it gets stuck stuck in the men pool you
- 57:37can increase your fee to make sure that it gets gets into a
- 57:41block in a timely manner. Like these are all user
- 57:44experience problems that have been solved up to this point,
- 57:48mainly by protocol engineers who don't really have the best
- 57:51design minds in the world. So if you're a designer looking
- 57:55to leave your mark on your industry, like this is a blank
- 57:59canvas to come. Build new experiences and UIS
- 58:02that help articulate to end users how to actually interact
- 58:04with Bitcoin The right way. To make sure that you're not gun
- 58:07footing yourself or spending too much money on fees or your coin
- 58:14selection is done in a way that that makes it as efficient and
- 58:17optimal as possible. Like there's so many different
- 58:20variables to interacting with Bitcoin that literally need user
- 58:24experience design around it to to really make sure this is as
- 58:29easy and efficient as possible for end users.
- 58:33Yeah, technology often falls flat, not because of the
- 58:35technology itself, but because of the the friction or the poor
- 58:38user experience. I mean, there's so many examples
- 58:40of this, right? So yeah, the the talent needs to
- 58:43be here. We need when we think of Bitcoin
- 58:45for the masses. That means we have to accept
- 58:48this may be controversial, right?
- 58:49But that means a world where it's Bitcoin for people who are
- 58:51not running nodes, who are not super savvy on self custody,
- 58:54even though we need to keep beating the self custody drum
- 58:56like we need between now and then to be building products
- 58:58that just make it so stupidly simple to interact with the
- 59:01protocol. Thanks for tuning in to The last
- 59:04trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 59:07want to dive deeper, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com where
- 59:11you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 59:15analytics. Including our recently published
- 59:18white paper, Bitcoin's full potential valuation and our new
- 59:22tool, the On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 59:27I I was just recalling how I had a class at Stanford from a
- 59:33venture capitalist there called Andy Ratcliffe who Co founded
- 59:38Wealthfront and his main like. A message to my class and every
- 59:48everybody you talks to is that the opportunities, the best
- 59:52opportunities for your career are with companies that are
- 59:57going through high growth and sustained high growth.
- 1:00:01In particular, you want to join a a company that that is clearly
- 1:00:06on a trajectory of of high growth and because it will
- 1:00:10accelerate your career the most and.
- 1:00:14Obviously the connections to Bitcoin here are pretty evident
- 1:00:19because, you know, Wealthfront puts out a list of 150 or 200 of
- 1:00:25these companies every year that they're traditional tech
- 1:00:27startups that are, I guess, seeing.
- 1:00:30I don't know if it's 50% annualized or 100% annualized
- 1:00:33growth for several years, but that's what Bitcoin is doing and
- 1:00:37Bitcoin companies are doing. I don't think Bitcoin companies
- 1:00:40are on his radar at all because you have to to to take that
- 1:00:45leap. You have to understand like the
- 1:00:47the Bitcoin is a rising tide that is going to to lift all
- 1:00:51boats and it has been and will continue doing so because of its
- 1:00:56inherent properties and internal mechanics and obviously the
- 1:01:02value proposition to the world of what Bitcoin represents for
- 1:01:04for your portfolio. And so that you know there's
- 1:01:09there's sort of a a connection there of of Bitcoin.
- 1:01:13Any Bitcoin company really could be on that list or should be on
- 1:01:18that list even though you know they're not going to give the
- 1:01:21time of day to Bitcoin companies.
- 1:01:23But you know, if you get deep enough down the rabbit hole to
- 1:01:27understand that the Bitcoin industry is going to keep
- 1:01:31growing a ton, then perhaps the best thing you can do for your
- 1:01:35career is be a part of that by joining a Bitcoin company that
- 1:01:39is has seen some growth and is, you know, on a trajectory to
- 1:01:43grow a lot more as Bitcoin, as the Bitcoin tide lifts all the
- 1:01:46boats with it and accelerates that growth.
- 1:01:49So you know, a random bit from my past that I realized is is a
- 1:01:53part of what you're doing, Andy. That's a great point.
- 1:01:57Just as a fall on to that Andy, are you what type of reasons are
- 1:02:01you seeing are you hearing from candidates in terms of why
- 1:02:04they're interested in working on Bitcoin because there's there's
- 1:02:06a few different aspects that could come to mind.
- 1:02:09One would be them seeing Jesse's thesis that this is one of the
- 1:02:13largest growth industries and will continue to be and change
- 1:02:16the world and as profound a way or possibly more so than the
- 1:02:19Internet itself, and that the chance to be at a early Google
- 1:02:23or Yahoo or or Uber. Is is one of the savviest moves
- 1:02:28you can make for your career or is it more ideological and
- 1:02:32wanting to kind of put your mark on the world and and look at
- 1:02:36this as a very, you know, high leverage way to make positive
- 1:02:40change in the world as as you see it.
- 1:02:43What are what are some of the reasons you're hearing from
- 1:02:44folks? Yeah, I mean that that last
- 1:02:46piece is definitely a huge part, just ideologically people lining
- 1:02:49with Bitcoin. But that's that's almost like
- 1:02:51the people who are already here, I would say.
- 1:02:53And So what I'm seeing is. 3 broad buckets of folks coming
- 1:02:57into coming into our pipelines or just the with whom we're
- 1:02:59having conversations. So first is again that that
- 1:03:02bucket of folks who are here, they they get it.
- 1:03:03They may not be working in Bitcoin yet, but they're
- 1:03:05definitely bitcoiners, right? They've taken their journey,
- 1:03:07they've gone through the learnings, whatever detours
- 1:03:09along the way. They know that Bitcoin is is
- 1:03:11what they want to focus on. And so very actively trying to
- 1:03:14transition their careers from wherever they may be today to
- 1:03:16Bitcoin. That's bucket one.
- 1:03:18Bucket 2, which I think is this is one that also makes a lot of
- 1:03:21sense, is. The refugees, if you will, from
- 1:03:25Crypto Web 3, broadly, right? Where there's a lot of
- 1:03:29discussion around this in the Bitcoin landscape, Yeah, every
- 1:03:31company has their own particular viewpoint and philosophy.
- 1:03:35I never want to touch someone who spent time at a crypto
- 1:03:37company or those who are more welcoming.
- 1:03:38I personally am of that latter viewpoint, where we've got to be
- 1:03:42a little more pragmatic around this.
- 1:03:43I'm not going to fault someone who.
- 1:03:45Went into crypto, let's say 3-4 years ago.
- 1:03:48Perhaps it was an insanely high salary offer, right?
- 1:03:50I mean, we know there's a lot of of capital in that space and so
- 1:03:53there's all these reasons why folks chose to to pursue a
- 1:03:56career there. The one that I like to, you
- 1:03:59know, references maybe just, you know, taking chances.
- 1:04:01You know, I like people who take chances jump into the unknown
- 1:04:04who are a little, you know, risk averse in that sense, right?
- 1:04:07But again, those people who after having spent time in a
- 1:04:10crypto environment. Have woken up, it's like OK,
- 1:04:12well actually Bitcoin is pretty different and I I'm stating
- 1:04:15today I want to work in a Bitcoin only company.
- 1:04:17So we see a ton of that. Not surprising.
- 1:04:19That's also very encouraging that we're seeing that, right.
- 1:04:21The third bucket is which I think is still the largest one,
- 1:04:25it will be a huge part of where our future talent comes from
- 1:04:28through this next cycle is folks who are curious, right they're
- 1:04:32they're they're not dying to get into Bitcoin.
- 1:04:34They're not. You know you're bleeding hard
- 1:04:37carnivore you know whatever all the the culture warrior type
- 1:04:41Bitcoin stuff you think about like it's it's not it's not that
- 1:04:44crowd right. But they're starting to get
- 1:04:45curious to start to understand there's something to it right.
- 1:04:48And I also encouraged by this last demographic because I think
- 1:04:51there's now a direct entry point into Bitcoin that.
- 1:04:54That does not require you to take your detours through
- 1:04:57crypto. I I hope I just maybe the chip
- 1:04:59on my shoulder having gone through my own pain.
- 1:05:02Just I know you have the story too of spending time on the
- 1:05:04other side of the fence and and learning mistakes, you know,
- 1:05:06learning the hard way, right? I I do believe that more and
- 1:05:09more people will come into Bitcoin in this next cycle, you
- 1:05:11know, directly into Bitcoin, because they've already
- 1:05:13understood the difference. They've seen the blow UPS of the
- 1:05:15last cycle. They see the legitimacy and the
- 1:05:17narrative ship that's happening. With the ETFs and things like
- 1:05:20that, accounting rules that are changing, more Bitcoin held on
- 1:05:23corporate treasuries outside of the Bitcoin landscape, right.
- 1:05:25So long winded answer for you Cam, but but yeah, there's
- 1:05:28there's like those 3 buckets of people and oddly enough I think
- 1:05:31that that last bucket, the one that is not yet in Bitcoin or
- 1:05:34not even yet bitcoiners, they will constitute a large part of
- 1:05:38our of our talent full moving forward.
- 1:05:42Yeah. And to sort of tie this back to
- 1:05:46the the first part of the conversation around mining,
- 1:05:48that's. Something that really gave me
- 1:05:51Peace of Mind, like in 2018-2019 as I was getting into the mining
- 1:05:57industry. Like you, you'll hear a bunch of
- 1:05:59buzzwords and a bunch of hype in altcoins.
- 1:06:02But at the end of the day, if you look at simply the energy
- 1:06:05expended to secure the Bitcoin network, it is orders and orders
- 1:06:09of magnitude larger than any of Bitcoin's quote UN quote
- 1:06:13competitors in the altcoin space.
- 1:06:15And that is something that despite.
- 1:06:18Any narrative that may pop up, come and go moving forward, Any
- 1:06:22narrative that has popped up and come and went in the past.
- 1:06:25If you just were to look at a pure spreadsheet that had the
- 1:06:30data of the energy expended and it would be very obvious to you
- 1:06:34that that Bitcoin is really the only only player in the room.
- 1:06:40Yeah. It's it's certainly the only
- 1:06:41energy money. And you know if you if you
- 1:06:44understand that that there needs to be some sort of link to real
- 1:06:48costs in the real world for a digital money to have value.
- 1:06:54And that energy is like the thing that makes sense because
- 1:06:58it it's a way to have cost for for creating and for creating
- 1:07:05the currency. You have to have some kind of
- 1:07:07cost and energy is like the foundational cost of any real
- 1:07:14world activity. And so that can be the cost and
- 1:07:18that works well with the digital landscape because you know
- 1:07:24energy is this ephemeral thing this this real world thing that
- 1:07:30is you know doesn't have like a materiality to it in in the
- 1:07:34traditional sense. But it it requires physical
- 1:07:38CapEx to to create but then you know it obviously powers the
- 1:07:42digital world. So that's the that's the the
- 1:07:45link and you need to have some link to real world cost.
- 1:07:49It can't just be you know proof of stake where well I bought
- 1:07:53this asset. So I get that's my investment
- 1:07:56and therefore I should get a right to vote in how more
- 1:08:01currency units are created in the future.
- 1:08:03That doesn't work because because that's how you get, you
- 1:08:07know the centralizing forces of of a few people with the ability
- 1:08:12to control the currencies destiny which is what's
- 1:08:16happening with Ethereum in slow motion and any proof of stake
- 1:08:20coin as well. But you know that, So there has
- 1:08:25to be some link and energy is the best link and no other coin
- 1:08:31has any measurable energy footprint relative to Bitcoin.
- 1:08:35I mean, Marty, like you probably have a better sense for these
- 1:08:38numbers, but I would imagine that the energy expenditure of
- 1:08:43the next greatest, next biggest coin, that's a proof of work
- 1:08:47coin. You know, I don't even know what
- 1:08:49that is. Is that like Litecoin?
- 1:08:50What's the number two in terms on the proof of work list in
- 1:08:53terms of energy expenditure and and I'm sure that that energy
- 1:08:58expended is is .001% of what Bitcoin does.
- 1:09:04Yeah, I think Litecoin is probably #2, maybe Monero.
- 1:09:09I'm looking. I'm looking at some charts here
- 1:09:14right now on coinwars.com. Asheray charts.
- 1:09:17Yeah, top ten because Bitcoin, Litecoin, Monero, Z Cash, Beam,
- 1:09:21which I've never heard of. Dash Zen and Ravencoin.
- 1:09:25I've never heard of the the bottom half of that list and and
- 1:09:29and and we can evaluate how we know that Litecoin's you know
- 1:09:33Litecoin came around. I don't actually even remember
- 1:09:36was it 2013, 2014 something like that maybe it was 2012 with the
- 1:09:41the hypothesis of well Bitcoin can be gold and will be silver
- 1:09:45right. And and that'll work like you
- 1:09:47need a you need a transactional currency to go with your gold
- 1:09:51because you're not going to. You transact with your gold.
- 1:09:55That was the whole point of Litecoin.
- 1:09:57And then the Lightning Network completely renders that useless.
- 1:10:04And yet it's still hanging around as the second biggest
- 1:10:09proof of work coin out there. Just because there's nothing,
- 1:10:12there's no other competitor. There's no other network effect.
- 1:10:15You you can't start a proof of work coin today and expect to
- 1:10:19get it off the ground because the cost of 51% attacking it is
- 1:10:23nothing for any anyone who has any hardware who's doing any
- 1:10:27kind of either Bitcoin mining or or Ethereum mining or Litecoin
- 1:10:34mining. If anybody could attack that
- 1:10:36that new coin and keep it from having a a sterling track record
- 1:10:42that's necessary for it to develop any kind of you know
- 1:10:46adoption and and network effect. So the game is already over and
- 1:10:51in terms of proof of work coins and because there's 30,000 coins
- 1:10:56out there, people don't realize that because it's you, you see
- 1:11:0030,000 coins and you think that the the competition is all even
- 1:11:04still it's it's still in still happening.
- 1:11:06But you don't realize that almost all of those 30,000 are
- 1:11:10proof of stake of of some kind and proof of stake is by
- 1:11:15definition not a competitor and you need to have some real world
- 1:11:19cost link. Yeah.
- 1:11:22Here's Logan. Thanks for pulling that up
- 1:11:24though. Here's here's the full set of of
- 1:11:26possible contenders in the proof of work landscape.
- 1:11:29Like coins only proof of work coins too.
- 1:11:32I know it's top ten. Are these the only whereas?
- 1:11:33We have no, these aren't the only.
- 1:11:35But there's there's thousand, or hundreds at least.
- 1:11:40But go up, Logan, I just like, I pulled this up 'cause I really
- 1:11:44just wanna conceptualize, help the listener really internalize
- 1:11:48just how much of an advantage Bitcoin has from an energy
- 1:11:52perspective. So Logan, click on the Litecoin
- 1:11:55chart and we'll see here that Litecoin's overall network hash
- 1:11:58rate is 879.36 Tera hash per second.
- 1:12:02So it's not even one XA hash. And so.
- 1:12:05It's 879.36. Then go back, then go to
- 1:12:10Bitcoin. Bitcoin is 482.7 exa hash, so
- 1:12:14you need 1000 Tera hash for exa hash.
- 1:12:17The bitcoins, about one 500th. Litecoin is about one 500th.
- 1:12:22Yeah, yeah. It's insane.
- 1:12:26That's great. And and that's only because
- 1:12:29Litecoin just still has some vestigial market value.
- 1:12:33Because people still kind of believe that it it has a place
- 1:12:38in a portfolio and so that's the only reason why it has any value
- 1:12:42worth mining that would that would cause miners to to point
- 1:12:47some hash rate to it in order to mine Litecoin and sell it on the
- 1:12:51market and move that into Bitcoin or dollars.
- 1:12:54Yeah, it's it's again, there's nobody else.
- 1:12:58There's no other player on the field, really.
- 1:13:00It comes close to Bitcoin. And the and the another thing
- 1:13:03too. Logan, pull up the the
- 1:13:06screenshots I included above that link 'cause I think there's
- 1:13:09a a big misconception you hear that Bitcoin mining waste
- 1:13:13energy. And it's literally the exact
- 1:13:16opposite. Over time, Bitcoin mining has
- 1:13:19become extremely efficient. So this is a chart here.
- 1:13:23The Bitcoin hash rate, heat rate, so the amount of
- 1:13:25electricity needed to produce a Tara hash.
- 1:13:30Via Bitcoin miner. And so in 2009 you can't even
- 1:13:33see the charts around like 20,000 joules per Tera hash in
- 1:13:372009 and in 2021, which is the the the last date that this
- 1:13:43chart goes to is 31 joules per Tera hash.
- 1:13:46But we've had miners come to market since then.
- 1:13:49The S 19 XP was 21 1/2 joules per Tera hash, so you had a 33%
- 1:13:57efficiency gain. Between the S 17 and the S 19
- 1:14:02and here are the specs for the S 21 which is coming out which is
- 1:14:07at 17 1/2 joules per Tera ash. So that's a 25% efficiency gain.
- 1:14:12And this S 21 is gonna produce 200 Tera ash per second when the
- 1:14:18S 19 produced, I believe 100 and 4040 Tera ash per second.
- 1:14:21So you have 25% increase in energy efficiency and you get a
- 1:14:2643%. Hash rate gain on that.
- 1:14:29So Bitcoin mining as an industry, the ASICS have become
- 1:14:32extremely energy efficient. They can efficiently take a
- 1:14:37Joule of energy and convert it into hashes at more efficient,
- 1:14:41more efficient rates over time. So Bitcoin mining is actually
- 1:14:45becoming one of the most energy efficient industries in the
- 1:14:49world in terms of taking electricity and turning it into
- 1:14:52digital gold and Bitcoin. Which is the beautiful of
- 1:14:58beautiful aspect of capitalism, right?
- 1:14:59We're just relentlessly forcing all market participants to
- 1:15:02continue to improve and be more efficient.
- 1:15:05The other thing I was thinking about too is that if you're a
- 1:15:07potential investor and you're looking at all the options you
- 1:15:10have and cryptocurrencies to invest in and where the the this
- 1:15:14dynamic of the amount of hash, rate and energy being expended
- 1:15:18to secure Bitcoin versus all others, you know 500X versus the
- 1:15:22second competitor. It it's such a crucial signal
- 1:15:25because there there's a such a there's a real opportunity cost
- 1:15:29to either choose to mine be a miner in mine Bitcoin or to
- 1:15:32choose one of the other protocols because you can't be
- 1:15:35mining to current cryptocurrency simultaneously in the same way
- 1:15:38that you can't invest your capital in both Bitcoin and
- 1:15:42smaller cryptocurrency and have them.
- 1:15:44Be in two places at once like you and.
- 1:15:46But this is sometimes the harder concept to wrap the head around
- 1:15:50because with the Internet you could do that.
- 1:15:52So often times we hear the comparisons well, isn't Bitcoin
- 1:15:56the Myspace of the industry? Surely it'll be out competed,
- 1:16:00But part of the difference there in my view is that you can be as
- 1:16:03a user of those social platforms, you can be in
- 1:16:06multiple networks at once with very little switching costs,
- 1:16:10whereas. When it's your own capital and
- 1:16:13you can only put it one place at a time, you spend more time with
- 1:16:17that decision and you learn and respond faster to the market
- 1:16:21feedback. So, and and this is one that
- 1:16:24clearly miners are forming consensus around, Bitcoin is the
- 1:16:28one that they're going to continue to invest millions of
- 1:16:30dollars of capital and you know, months and years building out
- 1:16:35their operations around. Yeah, it's a it's a good it's a
- 1:16:41good reminder you can only ride one horse at a time and.
- 1:16:45Pick one's the fastest horse, baby.
- 1:16:47Yeah, it's. Probably because Texas now
- 1:16:50coming out with the the cowboy metaphors.
- 1:16:53I'll get a I'll get a cowboy hat and boot soon enough.
- 1:16:59There we go. And I I guess to tie out this
- 1:17:02conversation to talking heavily about mining, and I'm very
- 1:17:06pumped that we went down this rabbit hole 'cause I think it's
- 1:17:08important. I don't think we've done a
- 1:17:09mining deep dive. On this show yet with the
- 1:17:15describe the dynamics of the mining industry up to this
- 1:17:17point, what may be on the horizon moving forward.
- 1:17:22But I think it's important to you know mention some headwinds
- 1:17:25too, which is the emergence of artificial intelligence and
- 1:17:28that's a very energy intensive industry as well.
- 1:17:32And after the China mining ban and the migration to the United
- 1:17:37States and other parts of the world became abundantly clear
- 1:17:39that Rackspace. And energy capacity is somewhat
- 1:17:42constrained. And now moving forward with the
- 1:17:45emergence of AI and its energy intensity, there's going to be a
- 1:17:48lot more competition for this electricity in this rack space
- 1:17:51moving forward. So that's another thing to pay
- 1:17:54attention to moving forward. I think in the long run what
- 1:18:00you'll see is a IHPC sort of data centers being Co located
- 1:18:06with Bitcoin miners and that is because.
- 1:18:08They want the lowest cost electricity possible too, to
- 1:18:11have the highest margins. It's very similar dynamics in
- 1:18:14that regard. However, with AI with training
- 1:18:18models and running inference, you need 100% up time, which
- 1:18:23means you can't really participate in demand response
- 1:18:26programs and be as profitable as you would like to.
- 1:18:29You want to train your models and get to the market so that
- 1:18:31you can beat your competitors and you need 100% up time and so
- 1:18:34I think. I think my thesis is that in the
- 1:18:37future what we'll see is Co located GPU farms doing AI
- 1:18:42computation with Bitcoin ASICS. And this is because you you have
- 1:18:48a facility that's Co locating these two operations.
- 1:18:50You can get a lower cost of electricity because you can
- 1:18:53participate in demand response because the ASIC part of your
- 1:18:56operation can respond to that demand in seconds and send that
- 1:19:01electricity back to the grid while you keep your.
- 1:19:03Your GP us on to do your AI computation.
- 1:19:06So I think you know in the early days there'll be like very high
- 1:19:11competition like AI operations and mining operations competing
- 1:19:16for scarce energy resources and infrastructure.
- 1:19:19But I think over time the the market will begin to recognize
- 1:19:23that they're actually somewhat symbiotic and help help each
- 1:19:27other out in creating diverse revenue streams and.
- 1:19:31Lower pricing because of the demand response that Bitcoin
- 1:19:33enables. I agree with that Marty, because
- 1:19:37with the brand that we've seen in mining of of miners in a
- 1:19:40sense diversifying their operations where maybe they
- 1:19:44started exclusively self mining, but then expanded those services
- 1:19:48to also hosting A complimentary service to help provide another
- 1:19:53and differentiated revenue stream, which it makes sense to
- 1:19:56have again AI. As part of your operation to
- 1:19:59help you get through those long and more unpredictable in a
- 1:20:03sense. I have heard from some minors
- 1:20:06though that there is a potential for demand response programs for
- 1:20:13AI data centers that so I guess it depends on the use case of
- 1:20:17the AI itself. It is longer term.
- 1:20:20Projects or use cases that don't that then also don't necessarily
- 1:20:25require 100% uptime. There might actually be the
- 1:20:28potential there to participate in that demand response and
- 1:20:31provide even more favourable economics.
- 1:20:35That miners slash AI data centre.
- 1:20:39Yeah. It depends again, if you're
- 1:20:42doing like model training versus inference, maybe on the
- 1:20:45inference side, yeah, we can have more disruptible load.
- 1:20:50And maybe people training particular models that think
- 1:20:53they have an edge in terms of the idea of the model they're
- 1:20:55training and don't think anybody else is is building it.
- 1:20:59Maybe they'll be more patient and be like yeah, we can disrupt
- 1:21:02this model temporarily just to send electricity back to the
- 1:21:05grid. But there's also I I talked to
- 1:21:08somebody recently, we're certainly nowhere near that
- 1:21:12point yet due to the like they the data isn't packed up like
- 1:21:17you can run. A model, a model training
- 1:21:21process and the data doesn't get backed up to RAM or anything.
- 1:21:24Like you run the model and you have to finish the model and
- 1:21:26then you get the data and so that I think the way I
- 1:21:30understand it. Again, I'm not an expert on this
- 1:21:32at all, but after this conversation with somebody who
- 1:21:34really knows what's going on, there really needs to be a a
- 1:21:38solution to backing up the data on the go as you're training
- 1:21:41these models before you can have something like a disruptible.
- 1:21:47Load added to your to your data center functionality.
- 1:21:55I'm sorry. Ran out of water in the throat
- 1:21:57stride. Holding it together over there,
- 1:22:01Marty, Huh? Yeah.
- 1:22:03But I think beyond all this AI Bitcoin very interesting, very
- 1:22:11energy intensive. I think we're at a critical
- 1:22:15crossroads in humanity too, where energy infrastructure has
- 1:22:19experienced a massive misallocation of capital.
- 1:22:22If you have a time coming out in the Bitcoin piece, the Bitcoin
- 1:22:25Times, next month, it really dives into this and dives into
- 1:22:30the way Germany really destroyed its energy infrastructure over
- 1:22:34the first two decades of this century.
- 1:22:37And that's one sort of headwind to worry about moving forward
- 1:22:40too of. The economies of the world don't
- 1:22:43get smart on energy capital allocation and infrastructure
- 1:22:47build out. Moving forward, there could be
- 1:22:49like material disruptions to the energy sector that make it
- 1:22:53harder to mine and do this AI computation.
- 1:22:58Yeah, it we are certainly a crossroads for all these things.
- 1:23:02And it's it's funny how we sort of walked through the
- 1:23:06second-half of the last century. Fooling ourselves into into
- 1:23:13believing that energy was was solved and you know not a
- 1:23:17problem and and that tech was everything that was exciting and
- 1:23:22new and and important And we've you know we've gone from a world
- 1:23:28where the the rapid development of new energy sources like like
- 1:23:34nuclear was you know. Had us on a track of of pretty
- 1:23:41linear increasing energy abundance and prosperity.
- 1:23:46You know, lifting people out of poverty, going from that to the
- 1:23:51last several decades of kind of stagnating energy production and
- 1:23:56you know, on decommissioning nuclear power and not investing
- 1:24:01in that stuff and instead investing in in much less energy
- 1:24:05efficient renewable energy. And thinking that that, you know
- 1:24:10that link between energy abundance and and prosperity
- 1:24:15didn't matter when when for all of human history it has
- 1:24:19mattered. So it's sort of a interesting
- 1:24:22parallel to Beyond Money and how having a unbacked money that you
- 1:24:28can print more of has has snuck into our reality in in a way
- 1:24:34that. As if it was as if there's no
- 1:24:36cost to it. As if there's no downside to
- 1:24:40being able to print as much money as you want.
- 1:24:43And we're collectively going to learn some hard lessons about
- 1:24:49both of these things and and hopefully, hopefully the
- 1:24:54incentives in place for Bitcoin help mitigate and even entirely
- 1:25:01offset some of the. Painful lessons that are coming
- 1:25:06for people who do not adopt Bitcoin or or want to stymie
- 1:25:10Bitcoins. The The tailwind that Bitcoin
- 1:25:13provides to the energy industry for developing more energy
- 1:25:18production. Yeah, and we'll get the last
- 1:25:21trade audience some alpha here, so he here's, said Logan.
- 1:25:26Pull up the third chart 1st and then the first chart.
- 1:25:30This is just diving in. When I dove into these numbers
- 1:25:33on Germany over the first two decades of the century, it was
- 1:25:35actually pretty scary looking at what they did.
- 1:25:38So here's a chart of their energy generation capacity for
- 1:25:43nuclear, coal and Nat gas in fossil oil since 2002.
- 1:25:49So in 2002 the German grid had generation capacity for these
- 1:25:55sources at 97.7 gigawatts over the 1st 2 decades.
- 1:26:00Over the last 20 years that's fallen from 97.7 to 77
- 1:26:04gigawatts. It's AI think a 21% decrease in
- 1:26:09generation capacity for these fuels fuel sources over that
- 1:26:16same period of time. You can go to the first chart
- 1:26:18Logan. Overall capacity within the
- 1:26:21German grid has grown I think by 108% and that has been.
- 1:26:26Led by solar and wind predominantly.
- 1:26:29So they've more than doubled the energy capacity on their grid,
- 1:26:32the generation capacity on their grid over the 1st 20 years.
- 1:26:37But that capacity has really been driven by wind and solar
- 1:26:41and nuclear and that gas particularly have been have been
- 1:26:45decommissioned and wound down. The result of all this is that
- 1:26:51prices for your average German household have gone up by 187%.
- 1:26:56Over that time period. So you've doubled the generation
- 1:26:59capacity over the last 20 years, but prices have doubled.
- 1:27:03And I I don't have this chart here right now, actually, let me
- 1:27:07see if I can find it real quick. But over that same period,
- 1:27:10overall generation has fallen by 2%.
- 1:27:14So you've doubled the generation capacity essentially like the
- 1:27:17amount of grid infrastructure that could take on electricity
- 1:27:19that's produced, that's generated, but you've actually
- 1:27:22generated less energy because you're relying.
- 1:27:24On unreliable sources like wind and solar, prices have more than
- 1:27:28doubled, and over that same period the German population has
- 1:27:31only grown by 2.7%. So there's a a clear
- 1:27:35disconnection from reality. There's a lot of virtue
- 1:27:37signalling about net zero and climate change and ESG.
- 1:27:42That's simply like you can build all the generation capacity that
- 1:27:46you want, but it's the equivalent to what the Chinese
- 1:27:48are doing. With these ghost cities you can
- 1:27:50build this capacity. But if nobody comes to live in
- 1:27:53it, and if there's no electricity that comes to
- 1:27:57actually live within that grid, it's all for naughty.
- 1:28:04And so in the beginning of the OR the beginning of the century,
- 1:28:07nuclear, Nat gas, coal and fossil oil made-up 84% of the
- 1:28:12overall generation capacity. Today it's 34%.
- 1:28:17Yeah, wow, that is a problem. It's a big problem.
- 1:28:22And I'm, I'm curious Marty, as you've dug into that, I mean are
- 1:28:24you, are you already seeing or translating that perhaps to
- 1:28:28directions we are heading here at home?
- 1:28:30Oh yeah, I mean, certainly tech that's I've wrote about in the
- 1:28:32piece too. It's like this is a microcosm of
- 1:28:35a larger trend, like it's happening here in Texas in West
- 1:28:39TX, massive wind and solar farms being spun up and.
- 1:28:44And it can make a strong argument that's led to the
- 1:28:47relative instability of the grid toward peak demand seasons in
- 1:28:50the middle of summer and winter over the last few years.
- 1:28:54Apparently when it gets cold out, the clouds cover the sky
- 1:29:00and the conditions are such that the windmills can can freeze up,
- 1:29:05not produce wind. So you can have all that wind
- 1:29:08and solar capacity that actually can't produce, so you're forced
- 1:29:11to make up. For that with like natural gas,
- 1:29:14peaker plants, and other forms of energy.
- 1:29:17Thank you, Logan, my savior. the IT took.
- 1:29:21A while. So yeah, no kind of happened
- 1:29:25here. Did you get that?
- 1:29:26From Did you did you have to go all the way to CVS or something?
- 1:29:29We have a kitchen here at the Phoenix.
- 1:29:32So I guess what we're and is that Bitcoin is the the nuclear,
- 1:29:36the net gas, the oil. It's the the true high dense
- 1:29:41energy source and Etherium is the wind and solar where we
- 1:29:46think we I would engineer reality and we can create our
- 1:29:50own new better ways of energy. But really what we're seeing is
- 1:29:54a reversion to the mean and we need to get back to basics and
- 1:29:58go back to. Funnily, verses that have gotten
- 1:30:01this here right. Funnily enough, Bitcoin fixes
- 1:30:03this. It actually does.
- 1:30:07All that was driven by the ability of the governments to
- 1:30:09print debt ad nauseam, print money ad nauseam, and then ESG
- 1:30:12mandates which are driven by the can tell in effect as well.
- 1:30:17Bitcoin reimposes economic reality, which fixes a lot of
- 1:30:21the malinvestment that has happened.
- 1:30:23So yeah, that's how Bitcoin fixes things, yeah.
- 1:30:26Yeah. You're not gonna be able to,
- 1:30:28you're not gonna be able to print money.
- 1:30:29You're not gonna be able to issue a lot of debt if the
- 1:30:33opportunity cost of parting ways with Bitcoin is not gonna be met
- 1:30:36by future production of the government that's taking on that
- 1:30:39debt. Like this is what Germany did.
- 1:30:42What we're doing here in Texas is all fueled by subsidies in
- 1:30:45ESG virtue signaling. And Bitcoin really ends that if
- 1:30:49if it gets widely adopted and then you have like.
- 1:30:52The 2nd order effect, which is the mining industry like just
- 1:30:55driving the economic incentive to actually create more reliable
- 1:30:58infrastructure so that miners can have 100% up time and make
- 1:31:03as much profit as possible. Yeah, I'm sure that's not part
- 1:31:09of your pitch to to to people. You're talking to Andy about
- 1:31:14Bitcoin fixes, fixes things. I say how how much time do you
- 1:31:18have in our our pretty night screen here?
- 1:31:20I'm actually just going to link to to this pod for every call
- 1:31:23moving forward. Yeah, you thought you were.
- 1:31:26You thought you were talking about job opportunities in the
- 1:31:29Bitcoin industry, but you're about to learn about energy.
- 1:31:33I mean that that's kind of the truth for all of us, right?
- 1:31:35Like we all had our own entry point into Bitcoin.
- 1:31:36And I mean, what myriad of corners within Bitcoin have we
- 1:31:41now become, if not proficient, at least knowledgeable and
- 1:31:44right? Yeah, and and there's a there's
- 1:31:46an irony there too of like, we're not supposed to be experts
- 1:31:49on stuff and we're not. And yet we seem to know more
- 1:31:54than the quote UN quote experts out there on so many of these
- 1:31:57topics at this point. Because.
- 1:31:59Because we live in a world where Bitcoin has reimposed economic
- 1:32:03reality and we've had to learn about reality, whereas so many
- 1:32:07experts are still living in unreality.
- 1:32:11Yeah. Absolutely.
- 1:32:14We gotta get back to that. I mean, that's another thing in
- 1:32:16the piece too, like we are very far away from humans gathering
- 1:32:22logs to stay warm. The population of the world,
- 1:32:26particularly in the western developed world, does not
- 1:32:30understand reality without reliable electricity and if we
- 1:32:35have a material enough disruption to.
- 1:32:39Our electrical infrastructure and the ability of people to
- 1:32:41simply turn on their lights, turn on their laptops, charge
- 1:32:44their phones, it's not going to be good.
- 1:32:47We are coddled and very far away from first principles, cutting
- 1:32:53down trees and starting fires to to warm ourselves and produce.
- 1:32:58A forgot in the world charge their cars too.
- 1:33:00Yeah, charge the cars. I'm guilt.
- 1:33:05I'm one of those people who thinks about the Roman Empire
- 1:33:07rather frequently, on a weekly basis at least.
- 1:33:11And you know, I can't help but think about how I'm sure that.
- 1:33:17So the Rome, The Rome, Rome was really 1000 years.
- 1:33:22You know, its peak was like 600 years really.
- 1:33:25And then late Rome, late stage Rome was 300 years of slow
- 1:33:29gradual decay. But you know at that point in
- 1:33:32time the psychology of of a Roman citizen was that Rome had
- 1:33:36created civilization and that civilization had lasted for so
- 1:33:39long already that it would last, that it would last forever.
- 1:33:42So I'm sure that the mentality of the of the Roman citizen as
- 1:33:46they continued to squabble amongst themselves and.
- 1:33:49Erode their currency and and erode.
- 1:33:51The strength of Rome was that the aqueducts will always keep,
- 1:33:55continue to bring water to Rome and Rome will always remain
- 1:33:58strong and we don't need to worry about those things.
- 1:34:00They've been solved. Yeah.
- 1:34:03No, I think this energy problem right now is existential.
- 1:34:06We really need to stop Larping and stop building unreliable
- 1:34:10energy infrastructure when we have on the most reliable energy
- 1:34:15we could ever want. We just don't have the political
- 1:34:17will. To allow us to leverage it,
- 1:34:20which is very sad. And that's the thing.
- 1:34:23What do you do a great job with? Marty is helping to change that
- 1:34:26the narrative and educate people about not like Bitcoin, but
- 1:34:31energy as well because there's been a Mal investment in human
- 1:34:34capital as well. Where there's more, there's you
- 1:34:41know when you have, when you have the ESG narrative, there's
- 1:34:43not as many people who want to be a roughneck in West TX or to
- 1:34:48become a petroleum engineer when those are critical roles that
- 1:34:51are high paying and afford a great life for folks.
- 1:34:57Similarly that that's one of the things I get most satisfaction
- 1:35:00seeing in Bitcoin mining is that you're able to revitalize rural
- 1:35:03communities and provide high paying jobs and skilled labor
- 1:35:08for the local workforce. So we're you know so, so much of
- 1:35:14the kind of folks we we think about when we associate with
- 1:35:18Bitcoin are the developers or the the most technical people
- 1:35:21possible on the planet. So it it's also refreshing to
- 1:35:23see some of these more blue collar working class communities
- 1:35:28also have an opportunity to participate in Bitcoin and and
- 1:35:31be in this high growth industry. Yeah.
- 1:35:36It's actually an exceptionally fulfilling part of of my job and
- 1:35:39what we're doing as a team right now too.
- 1:35:40I mean, yeah, I come from a world where, you know, venture
- 1:35:43backed startups, you're hiring engineers, you're hiring from
- 1:35:45maybe 5 to 10 universities, They're all getting the same
- 1:35:47obscene compensation packages, right.
- 1:35:49And it's not, it's not obscene. It is what it is, right.
- 1:35:52Because of the level of competition, right.
- 1:35:53But it's just so very focused on that type of talent pool, if you
- 1:35:56will, where where Bitcoin. Those roles are important, yes.
- 1:35:59But everything else under the sun is as well and and my
- 1:36:03ability to not like touch. On different parts of that
- 1:36:05instead of just hiring the same type of person over and over
- 1:36:07again. I mean it's it's so satisfying.
- 1:36:10It is, gentlemen. I was not expecting to dive deep
- 1:36:14down the the mining and energy rabbit hole, but I'm very happy
- 1:36:16that we did. Yeah, I'm happy as well, Andy.
- 1:36:20I hope. I hope that that works for you.
- 1:36:25No I mean it it's kind of echo what you said earlier Jesse you
- 1:36:28know mining is something that I've I've.
- 1:36:30Started to become more aware of just because we have clients
- 1:36:32coming to us who want to hireright mining, mining
- 1:36:34clients, right? And I am woefully
- 1:36:38unknowledgeable around that as it relates to other parts of the
- 1:36:41Bitcoin ecosystem. That said, I'm as as
- 1:36:44unknowledgeable as I am. I'm actually that excited and
- 1:36:46interested to learn more. So it's just been fascinating to
- 1:36:48dive deeper and deeper. Thankfully having folks like
- 1:36:50Marty we can lean on to learn more.
- 1:36:51It's just been, yeah, so much more to dive into, yeah.
- 1:36:57Andy, do you want to? Leaving this to the to the tail
- 1:37:01end here, but do you want to provide like just a little
- 1:37:04overview of of what Of what what you guys do and you know for our
- 1:37:10audience, if they want to find out more, where should they go?
- 1:37:15You know you take the floor for a while here because we we
- 1:37:19talked about mining most of the time.
- 1:37:21Well, for those of you that are still here, we appreciate you
- 1:37:23listening and staying tuned. So we we launched Bitcoin Talent
- 1:37:28Co myself and our team towards the beginning of this year in
- 1:37:31early spring really stood out to be the first Bitcoin only
- 1:37:35recruiting service. So again, my my background is in
- 1:37:37recruiting and tech businesses as we mentioned earlier, I was
- 1:37:40employed Uber coming from that type of world, right?
- 1:37:43Bringing that knowledge, that discipline, that rigor around
- 1:37:45recruiting into Bitcoin in a way that hasn't existed yet.
- 1:37:47So ourselves personally, being bitcoiners, we saw the
- 1:37:50opportunity to really draw the line in the sand.
- 1:37:52We don't touch crypto, We don't touch Web 3.
- 1:37:54It's really supporting the Bitcoin ecosystem, bringing the
- 1:37:56right talent here to the space. This is all levels of
- 1:37:59experience, all disciplines, as long as it's for the mission of
- 1:38:02pushing Bitcoin forward, right? And even though it's been the
- 1:38:05depths of the bear market and really less than a full year of
- 1:38:08operation, we've actually been able to accomplish that.
- 1:38:10It's been incredibly fulfilling hiring a number of key roles
- 1:38:13across, again, all levels of experience, all disciplines for
- 1:38:16clients like Unchained, like Fetty that could go on and on.
- 1:38:19A number of really, you know, really exciting businesses that
- 1:38:22we've been able to partner with up to this point.
- 1:38:24And so if you are there, listening, excited about
- 1:38:28Bitcoin, wanting to learn more, wanting to eventually work in
- 1:38:30Bitcoin, absolutely visit us Bitcoin talent.co.
- 1:38:34You can always reach out to our team, myself personally, happy
- 1:38:38to kind of walk you through the job hunt process.
- 1:38:39And then of course any companies that are looking, any Bitcoin
- 1:38:42companies that are looking to hire, but also any companies
- 1:38:44broadly that are looking to hire bitcoiners, which I think is an
- 1:38:46important distinction. We're here to kind of help you
- 1:38:49through that process as well. Yeah, you you guys, it's a good
- 1:38:53point that you've you've only been operating in the bear
- 1:38:56market or or or sort of crab market of going sideways the
- 1:39:02last year. You guys are going to be really
- 1:39:03busy a year from now. Yes, short answer, we're we're
- 1:39:09starting to see that already already ticking up and and we're
- 1:39:13excited about, I mean a lot of what we've been doing over the
- 1:39:14past few months too is, is preparing for that that wave of
- 1:39:18of you know new interests, new candidates, more companies with
- 1:39:21capital trying to hireright, it's going to be crazy right and
- 1:39:23so spending a lot of time. Making our own services and and
- 1:39:27products more robust to real to to respond to that demand.
- 1:39:30So whether it's retained search for full time executive roles,
- 1:39:33whether it's connecting you with contractors on our flex platform
- 1:39:36or even providing more like self-serve type tools throughout
- 1:39:39through another platform that we're building right now.
- 1:39:41You know, we're excited to to really offer services at all
- 1:39:45into the spectrum of price points for companies who need
- 1:39:47the help. It one of those one of those
- 1:39:53parts of an industry that is behind the scenes and people
- 1:39:56don't think about but you are building that this type of
- 1:39:58infrastructure and we spent all that we we talked about Bitcoin
- 1:40:02mining infrastructure and you know I but this is this is the
- 1:40:06the reality of business infrastructure like human
- 1:40:10capital yeah human capital is is needs to be served in order for
- 1:40:15an industry to function and you guys are are helping to.
- 1:40:19Apply the grease to the cogs that make a whole industry run.
- 1:40:23It's already been so valuable to me personally too.
- 1:40:25I'll put a personal plug in handy that I I talk, you know,
- 1:40:29we get to, because of the nature of our jobs, get to talk to a
- 1:40:31lot of people who are already in Bitcoin or are are seeking to
- 1:40:35break in. And I can provide my own
- 1:40:37recommendations for them as what parts of the industry might be
- 1:40:41interesting or specific companies that might be
- 1:40:42interesting to look at it and make some introductions myself.
- 1:40:44But it's so nice having you guys as a resource to say like OK.
- 1:40:48Definitely one of the first places you start with is Andy
- 1:40:51Eric team at the Bitcoin Town Code, because they have a even a
- 1:40:54broader purview of the potential opportunities and they're
- 1:40:57skilled at helping to understand taking your skill set, what
- 1:41:01you're interested in and then what's the most fulfilling way
- 1:41:03you can apply that in this industry.
- 1:41:05Think about from, you know, the individual candidate
- 1:41:08perspective. But.
- 1:41:09Yeah, and we appreciate that. Yeah.
- 1:41:11Again, for anyone listening, if you have friends, anyone who's
- 1:41:13interested, yeah, send them our way too.
- 1:41:15Yeah, we're happy to have those conversations.
- 1:41:17I know there are many of you that listen to the show out
- 1:41:19there that are sitting in a cubicle right now doing some
- 1:41:23Excel functions for some terrible part of the industry
- 1:41:27that you really don't feel passionate about.
- 1:41:29And you're you're here because you're passionate about Bitcoin.
- 1:41:31You should reach out to Andy. You have a Bitcoin standard to
- 1:41:34build and Andy knows all the all the teams out there that need
- 1:41:39help building. Get out of your cubicle.
- 1:41:41Get into the Bitcoin industry. Save yourself.
- 1:41:44Save the world. Look at Marty not only
- 1:41:47delivering orange pills, but also quarter life crisis
- 1:41:51existential pills. I had it myself.
- 1:41:55I had it myself. I was in the cubicle, running
- 1:41:59Excel functions, pulling data from Bloomberg, putting it into
- 1:42:02performance reports. One day it was my birthday.
- 1:42:07Nobody said happy birthday to me and I had.
- 1:42:09I had enough. Oh, wow.
- 1:42:11I quit and got into Bitcoin. You can do it too.
- 1:42:15Very risky. Wife's not going to be happy,
- 1:42:18but it's worth it. On the other side, yeah it's
- 1:42:23especially especially if this is the rising tide and you know
- 1:42:30bringing it back to that Andy Radcliffe thing from Wealthfront
- 1:42:34puts out this 150 companies a year that they term by their
- 1:42:39metrics are high growth and a great place to grow your career
- 1:42:43because of all the opportunities that happen when company's
- 1:42:47growing and needs people to step up into bigger roles and you
- 1:42:51move up the ladder more rapidly as the company itself grows.
- 1:42:55But that's happening at an industry level for for us And so
- 1:42:58it makes me crazy today to jump into Bitcoin, to quit your your
- 1:43:03cubicle job where you have stability and and more security.
- 1:43:08But if this industry grows into a fraction of what we think it
- 1:43:11will be, then people who build their career as early entrance
- 1:43:16into that industry will become the senior executives 10 years
- 1:43:21down the road. And and you know, that is the
- 1:43:24fork in the road for a lot of people right now.
- 1:43:27Do you want to be an Excel jockey or an executive?
- 1:43:31Choices. Really quickly I'd counter the
- 1:43:33the risk. I mean sure at risk overall
- 1:43:35industry wise we we have to we have to temper our expectations
- 1:43:39and our excitement that we all have here and and just say that
- 1:43:42even though we know where this is heading.
- 1:43:43But the point to make is that you don't have to work for a
- 1:43:46three person you know pre revenue Bitcoin startup.
- 1:43:50There are already larger organizations today, whether
- 1:43:52it's the public, miners or even the the rivers, the the big goes
- 1:43:56of the world, companies that are Bitcoin focused but obviously
- 1:43:58have more robust operations, right?
- 1:44:00There are companies of all shapes and sizes at which you
- 1:44:02can you can find a home and still, you know, still
- 1:44:05accomplish that mission of contributing to Bitcoin.
- 1:44:06Broadly, we're. Going to win.
- 1:44:12We're going to win. Gentlemen, I'm 15 minutes late
- 1:44:18to a call. I got a jump.
- 1:44:20This has been great. Thank you guys.
- 1:44:23We. Didn't even mention.
- 1:44:24I feel like, well, Andy, thank you for coming, but I it'd be
- 1:44:27remiss of us to say like obviously Michael's not here.
- 1:44:30He's traveling for his Thanksgiving holiday.
- 1:44:34He was missed. This is a great, this is a great
- 1:44:36model crew we got. Here How long do you think it
- 1:44:38took people to realize that I wasn't Michael I?
- 1:44:41Don't think he can grow a mustache like that, so it'll
- 1:44:43probably happen immediately. There's no replacing Michael.
- 1:44:48We we've missed him. Thanks for coming on, Andy.
- 1:44:52Thank you guys. That was great.
- 1:44:55Thank you all for putting up with my Rd. dog voice.
- 1:44:58Cam and I Rd. dogged it this week.
- 1:44:59Didn't get back into my bed until till like 12:30 last
- 1:45:03night. The kids jumped to bed at 5:30,
- 1:45:05so that's what. I'm doing.
- 1:45:08You gotta Rd. dog it. You gotta Rd. dog it.
- 1:45:12It's the morning part that that'll kill ya 12:30.
- 1:45:15That's OK. If you can sleep in but you
- 1:45:17can't sleep in, that's tough. Things we do for Bitcoin for our
- 1:45:22children. A better world.
- 1:45:25That's why we're here. This is the last trade.
- 1:45:28We'll be back next week.