Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Companies Use Employee Stock Purchase Plans
Transcript
- Lucas: So we'we talked a lot on this show about how post ipo companies use stock options, restricted stock, and even buybacks to reward employees and signal confidence. But there's one equity tool that often flies under the radar, and it's actually one of the most popular benefits at public tech companies: the employee stock purchase plan, or ESPP. Luna: Right, and I think a lot of listeners might have one sitting in their HR portal and not think twice about it. What makes it different from, say, stock options or RSUs? Lucas: Great question. An ESPP is essentially a payroll-deduction plan that lets employees buy company stock at a discount, usually up to fifteen percent below the market price, and often with a lookback provision that lets you buy at the lower of the price at the start or end of the offering period. It's a voluntary program, and unlike options, there's no real downside if the stock drops — you're just buying stock at a discount, and you can sell it immediately if you want. Luna: And that discount is usually the hook, right? I mean, who wouldn't want a guaranteed return on day one, even if it's just the discount? Lucas: Exactly. And that's why a lot of tech companies love them. They're a retention tool, but they also align employees with shareholders in a pretty direct way. Employees become owners, and they feel the ups and downs of the stock just like any other investor. When the stock is volatile, that can be a double-edged sword, though. Look at the last five days — Apple's down three point two percent, Alphabet's down four, but Tesla and NVIDIA are up over two percent. If you're an employee with an ESPP, you're watching that daily move. Luna: True. And I imagine most employees don't think about the tax implications. But there's a real difference between a qualified and a non-qualified ESPP. Lucas: Right, and that's where the IRS gets involved. A qualified ESPP, under section 423, offers tax advantages if you hold the shares for a certain period — at least one year after the purchase date and two years after the offering date. The discount is taxed at capital gains rates, and you avoid ordinary income tax on it. Non-qualified plans don't have those holding requirements, but the discount is taxed as ordinary income. For a lot of employees, that tax deferral is a big deal. Luna: So the plan design really matters. Some companies set the purchase price at fifteen percent below the fair market value on the purchase date, and others use the lookback, which can be even more generous. Which companies are known for having particularly good plans? Lucas: Atlassian is a great example. They offer a fifteen percent discount with a lookback, and it's available to all employees, not just executives. Salesforce too — they've had a plan for years that lets employees buy shares at a discount, and it's been a big part of their culture. What's interesting is that these plans are often set up right after the IPO, because the company wants to convert employees who are used to private stock options into long-term shareholders. Luna: And for a post ipo company, that's a huge deal. You're coming out of the gate with all these employees who just watched their options vest, and you want them to feel invested in the public company. An ESPP is a low-friction way to do that, because they're contributing from their paycheck, not making a big lump-sum decision. Lucas: Yeah, and the enrollment process is usually automatic, so participation rates are high. Some studies show that in tech, participation can be over seventy percent, which is huge compared to other industries. That's a lot of employees with skin in the game. Luna: But there's a catch, right? There's always a catch. What happens when the stock is in a downturn and employees are watching their ESPP contributions buy shares that are falling? Lucas: That's the tricky part. If the stock is sliding, the discount doesn't help as much, and employees might feel like they're catching a falling knife. Some companies have even suspended their ESPPs during severe downturns, though that's rare. More often, they'll just let the plan run, and employees with a longer time horizon see it as a buying opportunity. The research actually shows that employees who participate in ESPPs tend to hold their shares longer than those who get RSUs, which is interesting. Luna: So they're less likely to sell immediately. That kind of stability can be valuable for the company, especially right after the IPO when there's a lot of volatility. And speaking of volatility, I saw that Airbnb is up almost nineteen percent in the last five days. If you're an Airbnb employee, that's a nice boost to your ESPP balance. Lucas: For sure. But it can also create a tax headache if you sell too soon. That's why a lot of financial advisors tell employees to hold for the qualifying period. It's a patient person's game, but the payoff can be significant. Luna: Let's talk about the actual mechanics for a minute. There's usually an offering period, which can be six months or a year, and then a purchase date. Employees contribute a percentage of their salary, up to the IRS limit — that's twenty-five thousand dollars a year — and then the company buys shares at the discount. So there's a lag between when you contribute and when you get the shares. That lag matters. Lucas: It does, because the stock price can move a lot in that window. And companies have to be careful about insider trading rules. Employees with access to material non-public information have to be in a blackout period during the offering, just like with options. The SEC is pretty strict about that. Luna: So even though it's a payroll-deduction plan, it's not a free pass to trade your company stock whenever you feel like it. There are rules. Lucas: Right, and that's something a lot of employees don't realize until they try to make a change mid-cycle. The plan has set dates, and you can't just opt in and out whenever you want. When you enroll, you're committing to that contribution for the offering period. Luna: That kind of commitment is actually a behavioral nudge, isn't it? You're automatically saving and investing, which is a good habit for most people. Lucas: It's one of the few ways that employees get a truly automatic investment into their own company. And that's why a lot of financial wellness programs encourage ESPP participation as a first step toward building wealth. It's a forced savings plan, but with a company match — well, not a match, but a discount, which is even better. Luna: Before we get into some of the more advanced strategy, I want to touch on something you mentioned earlier — the fact that some companies have suspended ESPPs during downturns. How common is that, and what does it signal to employees? Lucas: It's not common, and when it happens, it's almost always framed as a cost-saving measure. But it can send a negative signal, like the company is struggling. I can recall a few cases during the 2008 crisis where companies paused their plans, and employees were pretty upset. It's one of those benefits that employees value more than it costs the company, so cutting it is a big deal. Luna: And today, with companies like Palantir up nearly ten percent in a week, and Cathie Wood's ARK funds bouncing back — ARKG is up over ten percent — the mood is a bit more risk-on. So ESPPs are probably looking pretty attractive to employees at growth-oriented companies. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's the thing — ESPPs are a long-term alignment tool, but they also respond to market cycles. In a bull market, employees love them. In a bear market, they're a bit of a waiting game. But the companies that keep them through the cycle are the ones that build the most loyalty. Luna: Speaking of loyalty, I've noticed that some companies have started to offer ESPPs to part-time employees or even contractors. Is that a trend? Lucas: It's definitely growing. The IRS allows part-time employees to participate if they meet certain hours thresholds, and a lot of tech companies are expanding eligibility to include them, partly for retention and partly for fairness. It's a low-cost way to make everyone feel like an owner, and that can be a big culture win. Luna: So, to bring it back to the post ipo context — what's the one thing a newly public company should think about when designing its ESPP? Lucas: I'd say the lookback provision is the single most powerful feature. It can substantially increase the discount, especially in a rising market. But it also creates a potential cost for the company in terms of dilution and accounting expenses. So it's a trade-off. Companies need to balance generosity with shareholder interests. Luna: And that's a great segue into something I've been thinking about — the cost to existing shareholders. When a company issues new shares for an ESPP, it dilutes existing holders. How do companies manage that? Lucas: That's a real concern. Most companies will buy back shares on the open market to offset the dilution. In fact, we've talked about buybacks on this show, and a lot of the time, the stated reason is to offset dilution from equity compensation programs, including ESPPs. So there's a direct link between the two. If you see a company with a robust ESPP and a regular buyback, they're probably managing dilution carefully. Luna: So shareholders shouldn't panic about ESPPs if the company is disciplined about offsetting dilution. But it does add to the overall share count, which can affect earnings per share. That's something investors should watch. Lucas: Yeah, and it's one of those things that's in the proxy statement, but not always in the headlines. The bottom line is that ESPPs are a win-win when structured well. Employees get a discount and a forced savings plan, and companies get more engaged employees without a huge cash outlay. Luna: And if you're an employee listening, you might want to check if your company offers one and whether you're taking full advantage. It's one of the few benefits that can literally put money in your pocket on day one. Lucas: Right. And speaking of putting money in your pocket — this is a good moment to mention something that keeps this show going. We keep these episodes ad-free, and that's only possible because of listeners who support the show. If you find these conversations useful, and especially if you're building or running a business, consider supporting us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to help us keep doing what we do. Luna: And every bit helps. We appreciate the listeners who've already chipped in. Lucas: Now, back to ESPPs. Let's talk about the mechanics of what happens when you actually sell those shares. There are tax reporting requirements, and it can get a bit technical. Luna: Right, the W-2 and the 1040. But I think for most employees, the key takeaway is to understand the holding period and the tax consequences before they sell. Lucas: Exactly. And the worst thing you can do is sell shares within a year of purchase — that disqualifies you from the favorable capital gains treatment. So it's really about planning. Luna: What about the company side? How do they account for ESPPs on their financial statements? Lucas: Under accounting rules, the discount granted to employees is considered compensation expense, so it hits the income statement. And the company has to estimate the fair value of the options embedded in the ESPP, which can be complex. But it's not usually a huge expense compared to other equity programs. Luna: So it's a manageable cost for the benefit it brings. I think that's why we see so many post ipo tech companies adopt ESPPs within their first year or two. Lucas: For sure. And if you look at the data, the adoption rate among recent tech IPOs is over ninety percent. It's become table stakes. A company that doesn't offer an ESPP is at a competitive disadvantage when it comes to hiring. Luna: That's a strong point. In today's market, where companies are competing for top engineering talent, even a simple benefit like this can make a difference. Lucas: And it also sends a signal to investors that the company is thinking about long-term ownership culture. It's not just a perk; it's a statement about how they want to run the business. Luna: So, next time you see a proxy statement with an ESPP, you'll know it's more than just a footnote. It's a key part of the post ipo playbook. Lucas: That's right. And as always, we'll leave you with a question to think about: if you were designing an ESPP for your company, what would you do differently from the standard fifteen percent discount? That's it for today's episode.