Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D NewsFlash-Upper Deck-Ravensburger
Transcript
- 0:07From the kitchen of the cabin. It's the Five Games for Doomsday news with
- 0:11Ben and Steve. So this is a newsflash rather than a full news show.
- 0:19The full new show will happen at the end of the month. But
- 0:22I got hold of a lawyer, CD Hunter to talk about the Upper Deck
- 0:28Disney Lorcana thing, and I thought this would be interesting as a news flash
- 0:33and I should put it out now because well maybe everything will change in a
- 0:38couple of days. So I hope you enjoy. So welcome. I'm entering
- 0:44the world of investigative journalism here, and I have a very special guest all
- 0:48the way from the Five Games for Doomsday Discord, also New Zealand, a
- 0:54proper lawyer, someone who's far cleverer than I will ever be, Colin David
- 0:58Hunter. Welcome, a pleasure to be here. Ben, I'm not really
- 1:02convinced I'm the smart one here. I am a person with lawyer as a
- 1:07profession, so that equives me a little bit of qualification. Yeah, So
- 1:14we're here to discuss the Upper Deck Ravensburger lawsuit regarding the Disney game law Karna,
- 1:21And before we get into that, can you give the viewers and listeners
- 1:25a precie of who you are, what your qualifications are to speak on this.
- 1:30So I'm a lawyer for a firm in Auckland, New Zealand called Hesket
- 1:36Henry. I'm an associate there. My specialty is in largely actually insurance litigation
- 1:44and in particular maritime laws, but also includes trade law and ideal a lot
- 1:51with cross border disputes. So that may be slightly out of the realm here
- 1:57where it's a Californian law issue, but there are some really interesting contractual issues,
- 2:04and obviously I should premise everything I say by the fact that it may
- 2:09well be that a Californian lawyer will say the sky doesn't know anything. But
- 2:14hopefully the kind of general conceptual issues are the same. And I'm willing to
- 2:20at least say things here and look like a fool, so hopefully I won't
- 2:24be. But but I'm always open to correction from people more knowledgeable, And
- 2:31so as a bit of context for us all who know nothing about the law,
- 2:36really I mean, how I mean, how specific, how NEU want?
- 2:42How arcane is this area of law that's being prosecuted in this case,
- 2:50it's it is actually more general than you might expect it. It's been kind
- 2:57of pitched in the board game media as a kind of intellectual property dispute,
- 3:01which is a which is probably strictly true, but most of this is actually
- 3:08just a general contractual dispute and with some what we would call equitable causes of
- 3:15action, so basically kind of allegations of people acting in bad faith and breaching
- 3:23various duties associated with that, and there's also some negligence thrown in there for
- 3:29good measure. So if you get into the theory of what's going on here,
- 3:35it can be quite arcane because we're going to be dealing with intangible property
- 3:39and what that means and whether we can possess such things and are they real
- 3:45and do they affect third parties and things like that. But Quins essentially the
- 3:50main thing here is really a breach of contract claim and then a claim against
- 3:55the designers subsequent employer Vansburger, to try and shoehorn them in as well.
- 4:03So and that's probably where the money is. That's the solvent party will be
- 4:08the will be the Ravensburger obviously, So reading the filing, I was I
- 4:15was interested to see that the case is being prosecuted in Nevada, not California,
- 4:20where both of the companies are based. Would you have any idea why
- 4:26they're filing in Nevada as opposed to California. So so I'm going to correct
- 4:30you there a little bit um alea. Please do at anytime. So it
- 4:36is before the Californian Court in San Diego. But you have picked up on
- 4:41a really important point, which is that upper Deck is a Nevada company.
- 4:47So what you've what you've got here is you've got upper Deck based in Nevada.
- 4:53You have um, sorry I say that upper Deck I made notes of
- 5:00this. Upper Deck is I believe based Sorry, yeah, in Nevada.
- 5:10But they operate mainly in California. Sorry about that. Then in California.
- 5:19But they entered into an agreement with Ryan Miller that has what's called a jurisdiction
- 5:26clause, and that's a clause in a contract where you promise to resolve disputes
- 5:30in a particular jurisdiction. And in this case, that was in San Diego,
- 5:33California. So there's a and also the contract was governed by Californian law.
- 5:43The interesting thing here from this that point of view is why Ravensburger has
- 5:48to be in a Californian suit, but we will The answer is going to
- 5:57be because the other parties have to be in California, so it's probably easiest
- 6:00to shoehorn them in as well, but we will avoid the niceties of conflict
- 6:04of laws too much, even though that's a particular area of interest for me.
- 6:11But yeah, that's why you have this weird thing where nobody's living in
- 6:15California, but that's where it's being heard. So can you give us then,
- 6:21before we sort of d into the meat of it, an overview,
- 6:26a sort of bird's eye view of the case, the upper deck of bringing
- 6:30against Robbins, Bigram, Ryan Miller. Yeah, So from a kind of
- 6:34high level point of view, what they're doing is they're basically saying, we
- 6:40had a contract. It all kind of stems out of this. We had
- 6:44a contract with Ryan Miller, we hired him, and in that contract we're
- 6:49basically two general obligations. One was this idea that he wouldn't steal our property.
- 6:58Query what that means and what sort of property? And the second thing
- 7:03is that he signed a non disclosure agreement or agreed not to tell other people
- 7:10confidential things and that Ryan Miller basically breached those obligations when he went over to
- 7:17Ravensburger, and by doing that, they then get entangled with this bad faith
- 7:27or this equitable issue where they knew that he was doing bad stuff and therefore
- 7:33they are also tainted and therefore they're asking the court to take steps. Now
- 7:41that is a gross simplification. There are a bunch of other causes of action,
- 7:45but I think at a high level that's the center of the dispute.
- 7:49So it's one party breaching a contract and another party being alleged to have known
- 7:55or to have participated in this bad thing, and therefore they should be affected
- 8:00as well. So the center of this seems. The center of this case
- 8:03seems to center around a meeting that was had a summit, a game design
- 8:07summit that was happened that was had between Upper Deck and Ryan Miller in which
- 8:13they discussed this game and they banded around ideas, and Ryan Miller signed a
- 8:18contract saying that he would not disclose anything that was discussed at this meeting.
- 8:24Can you can you expand on that for me? Yeah, that's right.
- 8:28So there's there's a meeting in um I think it's the end of twenty m
- 8:33Sorry, it's in the end of twenty eighteen where they have a summit.
- 8:37They invite a bunch of game designers and they're basically looking for feedback on ideas
- 8:43and new ideas. And as part of that summit, the Ryan Miller and
- 8:50other game designers basically signed a contract. And what they're alleging as is that
- 8:54in that contract there were clauses that said the Upper Deck owned all property that
- 9:01comes out of that intellectual property but also intangible property or anything that comes out
- 9:07of that, and also that it was any material there was confidential, so
- 9:15they couldn't disclose that to third parties. And then out of that meeting,
- 9:22I guess they were impressed with Ryan Miller. They then entered into a work
- 9:26for higher agreement, and that agreement, evidently, according to the complaint,
- 9:31has the same has the same sorts of terms in it. And so then
- 9:37when he worked there for another year and a half, all the property and
- 9:45all the material was confidential and therefore couldn't be disclosed and couldn't be passed on.
- 9:52So that's the kind of factual basis We should say at this point that
- 9:56what we're reading and it is want to look at it. It's freely available
- 10:01online. The complaint. This is one side of the story. They're saying,
- 10:07this is all the things that we are going to prove, but they
- 10:09don't have any evidence that this is true currently. But that's why they will
- 10:13go to trial, or that's why they'll present evidence, and whether they can
- 10:16is going to be the substance of the legal part of the legal battle.
- 10:22And so let's let's go through these these causes of complaint then from from the
- 10:26top. So there are there are some that target Ryan Miller specifically, some
- 10:33that target Ravensburger specifically, and let's go through. They're called causes of action.
- 10:39You can see I'm absolutely massively knowledgeable about the law here, and so
- 10:43the first one is is breach of contract. Can you give us an overview
- 10:46of what the first I think when I hadn't read any of this, it
- 10:52struck me that this must be the core of what it was going to be.
- 10:56And basically, the allegation is that Ryan Miller breached his contract again by
- 11:05doing one of two things, either disclosing confidential information or giving away property that
- 11:16Raven's that sorry that Upper Deck owned and it's that question there that is the
- 11:22real nub and kind of complexity here, because the issue is what constitutes property
- 11:31Here. We aren't talking about a car, a game box, we aren't
- 11:37even talking about a piece of art. What is really being alleged here and
- 11:41you can read it here It says products, works, concepts, trade secrets
- 11:46and intellectual property developed by Upper Deck. So what this means is this means
- 11:54the concepts and game and it includes these kind of game mechanics. So in
- 12:00terms of understanding this, there's a concept that's really helpful to understand about the
- 12:05nature of what property is. So at law, what separates kind of property
- 12:11in some ways is the fact that property can affect third parties. So Ben
- 12:18and I can have a contract and we can agree to pretty much anything.
- 12:20I can't sell myself into slavery. Maybe there are a few things that we
- 12:24can't promise to do illegal things, but in general we can promise to do
- 12:30pretty much anything as between us. But the central element here is whether that
- 12:35affects someone else, and in that case it's Ravensburger. And that's why this
- 12:41property issue is so big. So when we talk about it's kind of commonly
- 12:46known you can't copyright a game mechanic, and that's because a copyright affects a
- 12:54publication or something like that, whereas a game mechanic is a concept and copyright
- 13:01your rules. You can copyright the wording, but you can't copyright the concept
- 13:05of a thing, right, And I think that stands to reason. Otherwise
- 13:07we couldn't even think about things, right. It's patents that actually do that,
- 13:13And it's very difficult to get patents on game mechanics because they have to
- 13:18be truly novel and you have to meet a lot of stringent requirements that intellectual
- 13:24property lawyers will be far more qualified than I am to talk about specifically,
- 13:26But the gist of it is it's difficult to get a patent. So one
- 13:33of the things in understanding this is that what we're dealing with here are property
- 13:41rights that are intangible that we can't grab hold of, that may or may
- 13:48not really exist. So they can exist in a contractual sense between parties,
- 13:54But the question is whether they are the sorts of things that attract the potential
- 14:00for liability from a third party. So whether Ravensburger can be liable as a
- 14:07third party for kind of dealing with these concepts. And again I'm not a
- 14:13Californian lawyer and I'm not an expert, but that is a very naughty and
- 14:16difficult legal question from a conceptual point of view. And actually, if you
- 14:22look internationally, with the rise of electronic trading and things like that, different
- 14:28courts have come to different conclusions about the sorts of properties that can exist in
- 14:33these kind of nebulous sorts of rights. And if you really go back,
- 14:39there is a great history of this. There's a thing called choses an action,
- 14:43which is a ancient term but refers basically to something that you can enforce
- 14:48by suing in court, a contractual right. Those can be bought and sold,
- 14:52like property and things like that. So there is precedent for this,
- 14:56but I think the question's going to be about the nature of these rights and
- 15:01whether Ravensburger really can be liable for dealing in a concept right. So the
- 15:09second cause of action then is, and I'm reading this from my phone for
- 15:13the listeners and viewers, a breach of fiduciary duty. And I guess is
- 15:22this the one that's saying Because according to upper Deck, Key gave away the
- 15:30mechanisms for their game rise of icorps that he is harming them financially. Yeah,
- 15:37so breach of fiduciary duty. It's a funny word, this fiduciary word.
- 15:43What it really means is that you had a special obligation that arose from
- 15:50a relationship of trust. Is the best way to think about it. So
- 15:56for example, when you are does you know, on behalf of somebody else,
- 16:03they give you some money to go purchase something from the shop, you
- 16:07owe a duty with respect to that money to purchase it for the reasons that
- 16:12they gave it to you. For example, you can't use it to buy
- 16:17your own stuff. I don't know if that's the best fiduciary example, but
- 16:22the point is is that they have to do with obligations that do that do
- 16:26with trust. So when you are employed by someone as an employee as opposed
- 16:33to a contractor, you owe a fiduciary duty. So the whole thing behind
- 16:38employment law historically and in the US it's a little different, but in other
- 16:44common law countries, in other places, an employee owes fiduciary duties that a
- 16:53that a contractor does not. Ie they have to look after the best interests
- 16:59of the Pole that employed them. And so what this cause of action is
- 17:03saying is that Ryan Miller, as an employee, owed duties to tell them
- 17:10about his plans to steal to quote unquote on their words, steal stuff,
- 17:17negotiate with Ravensburger, go over to them, and all that sort of stuff.
- 17:22The issue with this, of course, is whether he was an employee
- 17:26at the time that they negotiated, whether really that caused any loss, whether
- 17:32there really was any stealing, whether these are things that are capable of even
- 17:36really being stolen. I mean, trade secrets definitely can be so if it
- 17:41was a particularly secret special thing, then potentially again that can come through.
- 17:48But really this is just another way to try and allege dishonesty or bad faith
- 17:55on behalf of Miller and therefore potentially to try and chet at home to Ravensburger.
- 18:04And there are a couple of things in this that seemed to me as
- 18:08the lay person. You know, a bit he said, she said.
- 18:12And this third cause of action where they accused Ryan Miller of fraud seems to
- 18:18be that in which they assert that two years before he stopped working with Upadeck,
- 18:25he was working with Ravensburger. Now, now, how would you prove
- 18:29that? I mean, if Ryan Miller just simply says no, I wasn't,
- 18:33how can you can you bring that before a court and make it compelling
- 18:37for the jury trial that they've demanded. Well, in my own jurisdiction in
- 18:42New Zealand, you would struggle because you can't plead things like fraud without a
- 18:48reasonable basis to do so already, and probably you'd struggle. I'm not sure
- 18:53about California, but it looks like maybe the rules aren't as stringent. So
- 18:59the reason and you'd do that is there's a process called discovery, and discovery
- 19:03is basically where both sides go through all their documents, including emails, everything
- 19:08else, and they search for things that help them but also that can hurt
- 19:14them, and they're legally obligated to turn those over. And because lawyers go
- 19:18through them, they have a professional obligation to the court, so they would
- 19:22have to if they came across something that was that hurt their client's case,
- 19:27they're basically legally obligated to provide it, and if they don't do that,
- 19:32they can suffer disciplinary action, be struck. All of it's pretty serious So
- 19:37what you'll find is that they'll go through their emails and they'll find a bunch
- 19:41of old emails potentially between Ravensburger and Miller that has them discussed this and I
- 19:48and maybe those emails show that they intended to defraud Upper Deck. I mean,
- 19:56my guess is probably not, but you never know. I think it's
- 20:00a bit of a fishing expedition. But by putting this cause of action in
- 20:04there, you are forcing them to disclose that when discovery comes if there's anything
- 20:11there. That's why, like I said, in our jurisdiction, you're not
- 20:14allowed to put it in unless you have some proof. But if it's a
- 20:18little looser, then you may well be able to do it. It's also
- 20:23the case that there's a Civil Code provision here that I did actually take a
- 20:30look at that they're relying on that has to do with that has to do
- 20:40with has to do with the remedies that they can get, and one of
- 20:45the remedies they're looking for here is an injunction. So one of the reasons
- 20:48they're pleading this or they're talking about fraud is that one of the remedies under
- 20:52the Californian Statute is that the court's entitled to give an order, and that
- 21:00order could be almost anything, including preventing Orcana from being distributed and sold,
- 21:06which would obviously be a king hit, right because it would destroy you know,
- 21:10their competitor's product. Now, whether they're likely to get that is another
- 21:15matter, but you know, this gives them a route to doing it,
- 21:19so you know, and so the fourth course of action then is essentially the
- 21:26same, but the other way around. It's asserting that Ravensburger induced Ryan Miller
- 21:34to to break his contracts with up a Deck and to take what he'd researched
- 21:41to them. Again, I guess this is a similar thing, right,
- 21:45I mean, it's it seems very he said, he said. She said
- 21:48to me again, it'd have to come out and discovery and what you'd get.
- 21:52And look, I can say, is somebody that's undertaken discovery and gotten
- 21:57things. And things come up, and you do get things that give you
- 22:00a bit of a king hit. Sometimes it's not that common, but it
- 22:03does happen. And because they have to be disclosed, you might be able
- 22:10to prove that they had emails, or that they had you know, or
- 22:14there was a record of a phone conversation and someone took a note of it,
- 22:17or there's all kinds of things that could that could be out there that
- 22:22they might be able to prove that this particular cause of action is what we
- 22:26call a tortious cause of action. So again, this is all about trying
- 22:32to make a third party to a contract liable. And one of the things
- 22:34you're not allowed to do generally is encourage somebody to break their contract in order
- 22:41to cause harm to that other party. But normally you have to do it
- 22:48in bad faith, so you have to have intentionally done it and encouraged it
- 22:52in order to cause the other person harm, and it's not always very easy
- 22:57to establish. It may be in California that it's easier, because I note
- 23:02that in their pleadings it doesn't It appears to have a negligent standard, which
- 23:08is a little lower than a kind of bad faith standard, and again a
- 23:12Californian lawyer would know much more about the specifics of that. But that's effectively
- 23:18what they're doing. And again it's about bringing in the solvent third party,
- 23:22Ravensburger, into the proceeding so that they can recover I suspect against them because
- 23:26probably Ryan Miller, as a game designer, is not sitting on millions of
- 23:30dollars of cash. So and so the fifth coal section and is entitled negligent
- 23:37interference with prospective economic relations. And again, from my very very lay person
- 23:44point of view, it seems to me that what they're trying to say here
- 23:47is that Ravensburger should have known Ryan Miller had a contract and therefore their approach
- 23:52to him was legally negligent. Is that it? That is? It is?
- 23:59This is a weird one for me from a New Zealand England kind of
- 24:03ordinary common law point of view, because ordinarily one is allowed to negligently affect
- 24:12a third party in terms of the economic loss they suffer. So normally I'm
- 24:19not allowed to destroy your car, but I can cause you loss in the
- 24:23market what lawyers would call pure economic loss. So this maybe again I don't
- 24:32know a ton about it, but it is a sort of negligent. It's
- 24:37looks to be a negligent cause of action. So they're basically saying you negligently
- 24:41did something that made us lose money. And the key question here I suspect
- 24:45and again not a Californian lawyer, but will be whether Ravensburger really owed Upper
- 24:52Deck a duty of care here, which means do they have a legal reason
- 24:56that they're supposed to look after their competitor, And maybe they do in particular
- 25:03situations, such as that they know particular things. Maybe that's how this works.
- 25:07I don't know the specifics on this one, but it is from reading
- 25:11the pleadings. Basically, a negligence a negligence allegation, but normally the negligence
- 25:21suits turn on whether that particular person owes a duty to prevent that loss,
- 25:26especially when it's basically an economic loss and not damage the physical property. And
- 25:33the sixth course of action then is constructive trust, and this is both against
- 25:37Miller and Raven's booker, can you give us some view of what that is?
- 25:41Yeah, So a constructive trust is what people describe as a remedy,
- 25:48but it's often pleaded as a cause of action. Basically, what a constructive
- 25:55trust is in situations where you have knowledge of acting badly. So think think
- 26:02a kind of old school idea about morality that you're only doing a bad thing
- 26:07if you know that it's bad, right, your conscience is tainted. So
- 26:11in certain situations where your conscience is tainted. The law says, you have
- 26:18this thing, but you were holding it on trust from the person that you
- 26:22took it from. Right. So imagine, Ben, you stole a painting
- 26:26from me and then you gave it to Stephen. Right. I could say
- 26:33to you, give me my painting back, and you say, look,
- 26:34I gave it away. I don't have it, I don't have any assets.
- 26:37It's a tough luck. But the law would say, well, you
- 26:41were holding it on trust for me because you had no legal reason to take
- 26:47it from me. And Stephen, because he got given it and didn't pay
- 26:52money for it, is also holding it on trust because because the courts will
- 26:57prefer my laim over Steven's claim to have been given a thing that was stolen
- 27:03basically, So that's that's the essence of constructive trust. So here again we
- 27:10have to deal with these kind of nebulous concepts. And the question is again
- 27:15whether these concepts are capable of in a proprietary sense of being transferred. Because
- 27:25one of the things about concepts is you're not denying the existence of them to
- 27:29the person you took them from. Right. I mean, upper deck still
- 27:33has the concept, it still has that. So the question is whether there
- 27:37could be a constructive trust of this sort of thing. And again that goes
- 27:42back to our initial question, what are the sorts of things where intangible property
- 27:48can affect the rights of third parties? And the third party here being Ravensburger,
- 27:55And so the seventh course of action then it really sounds, it really
- 27:57sounds. These illegal document kind of sound to me like a sort of biblical
- 28:03biblical chapter the seventh course of action, and this is conversion. And it
- 28:10seems to me that this is the one that says that Ravensburger and Ryan Miller
- 28:14consciously took the property of Upper Deck and converted it into a game for Ravensburger.
- 28:21Is there? Am I right there? That's right. Conversion is a
- 28:26tortious cause of action that normally comes out of taking possession of someone's property.
- 28:33Normally, this is not really available to the sorts of proprietary claims that are
- 28:41being made here, because normally what it means is that I take possession of
- 28:47something so that you don't have it. And so normally it only applies to
- 28:49kind of physical things, or when they're intangible, they have to kind of
- 28:53be unique in the sense of I can take it from you. So maybe
- 28:56like a bitcoin or you know, I could that, maybe I could convert,
- 29:00maybe I could possess that. But there's this hard concept and law about
- 29:06what is capable of possession. And to give you an idea, the UK
- 29:11Supreme Court in the last few years found that electronic versions of things, as
- 29:18an example, were not capable of possession and therefore could probably not be converted.
- 29:23Different courts have gone different ways on that. There's a lot of legal
- 29:26theory around around that. But for example, it's meant that the UK is
- 29:33now passing an Electronic Transactions Act in order to basically solve this problem. But
- 29:40the point is there's a hard conceptual issue. Again, a Californian lawyer,
- 29:44maybe they've sorted out the law there. In New Zealand, it looks to
- 29:48be sorted out, but it can go either way, and it's it's it's
- 29:52not an easy issue. The eighth course of action then is unsaid competition,
- 29:57and this is the one that is that Ravensburger took their game and then unfairly
- 30:06marketed their game under a different banner and so didn't give Upper Deck the equal
- 30:12opportunity in the market to market their product because Ravensburger zumped the money, right,
- 30:18Yeah, is that is that correct? That's right? I mean,
- 30:22this is one Again it's hard for me to have a lot of understanding exactly
- 30:27what the sorts of legal tests are. This arises specifically out of a California
- 30:33California statute which I have looked at. But the definition of unfair trade practices
- 30:41and things like that we have kind of equivalence in New Zealand, but I
- 30:45don't really know the extent to which those are the same, and what constitutes
- 30:52kind of unfair or misleading or or something that would give rise to that particular
- 31:00cause of action. So it's a little bit hard to tell what is actually
- 31:07being alleged there other than general unfairness. Presumably there's more than that, but
- 31:14but again I think I think that would be interesting to see where it is.
- 31:21And again, when you make these things, you often throw absolutely everything
- 31:25in that you can think of, because it's better to have everything there than
- 31:29forget something and then try to amend your stuff later. So it's kind of
- 31:34a tactic to put in everything. And and you know, this feels a
- 31:37little bit like a kitchen sink. And again it's to deal with Ravensburger.
- 31:42That's that must be their kind of main aim in this thing, because they're
- 31:48the deep pockets, and so at the bottom, now this is just a
- 31:53question for my curiosity. I often notice the dramatic at the bottom of the
- 32:00document. It says demand for a jury trial. Upper Deck demands a trial
- 32:05by jury on all issues so triable. It's not just something that always goes
- 32:09on the bottom of a legal document. Well, because it seems to me.
- 32:14It seems to me like they're going we demand a day in court.
- 32:19Yes, I mean the use of demand there is a little overly dramatic.
- 32:23But I think the reason the issue here is that the US allows jury trials
- 32:32for a broad number of causes of action. Most jurisdictions would not allow a
- 32:40jury trial on a civil action that wasn't for definite defamation. So normally a
- 32:46judge would decide this, And I suspect that one of the advantages of having
- 32:51a jury is that you probably have more a little more uncertainty on the outcome
- 32:57because as lawyers, you kind of get a sense of how judges would react.
- 33:02And so if you're a plaintiff that has a lot of speculative causes of
- 33:07action. A jury trial is probably a good idea. I guess again,
- 33:13American lawyers will be able to tell you better, but that that would be
- 33:15my guess. If I'm a plaintiff, it's probably a little bit better in
- 33:21just in terms of making the other side a bit scared. And again it
- 33:24maybe that there's a want to settle this behind the scenes, get a bit
- 33:28of a payout. You know, it's hard to know the strategies at this
- 33:32stage, but that's always in in in, that's always a question, yeah,
- 33:40with these sorts of things. So the reason we're talking is because I'm
- 33:49not the kind of person who hangs around with lawyers particularly, but I do
- 33:52hang around with gamer. Isn't you're a gamer? And what's fascinating reading the
- 33:55reading the filing to the called is they have a description of both games in
- 34:01there, and I was, I was struck by how similar Lorcana is.
- 34:09To remind me the name of their their game something of yeah, yeah,
- 34:20I was. I was struck by how similar those two games were. But
- 34:22I was also struck and how similar the Upper Deck game is to every other
- 34:27collectible card game there right and on the market. You build up manner you
- 34:30attack, and the only fundamental difference is instead of whittling, I mean it
- 34:36even uses twenty life points, right, but instead of whittling your opponent down
- 34:44to zero, you buff yourself up to zero. So so as a gamer,
- 34:51I mean surely you must be thinking that Upper Deck are taking the piss
- 34:55right um to some degree. Yes, I think that's right. I mean
- 35:04the game is so similar to a million other CCGs or and TCGs, right,
- 35:08it isn't that different. You know, it uses resources to summon cards,
- 35:14you put the cards, you can the cards are kind of multi use.
- 35:19Yes, I mean this is this is part of what I think revolts
- 35:22a lot of gamers seeing this and they're like, well, this is just
- 35:25the same as every game lots of game steel concepts, etc. Etc.
- 35:31And I think that's right. I mean, I think that's a weakness in
- 35:34their case from a legal perspective as well. But I think it's worth noting
- 35:38that the people that are going to be making findings about facts, so one
- 35:45of the things is going to be a jury, They're not going to be
- 35:47experts and gaming in fact, so that's an issue. It's going to be.
- 35:53So the question is whether those plaintiff lawyers can convince lay people. And
- 35:58you'll see this issue arise a lot in copyright cases with regard to music and
- 36:02musicians. I was a musician before I was a lawyer, and you know,
- 36:08my musician friends go spare when they're like, you know, this sounds
- 36:14like that because it's got the same chords or whatever it happens to be.
- 36:16But you see that. But again, it's about what a kind of reasonable
- 36:22person in this case, a jury member would think, not really what experts
- 36:27are people that are involved in the hobby would think. But I do think
- 36:30there is an element here that they may struggle with. So I think the
- 36:36claim for breach of contract is going to be the strongest when it involves a
- 36:40trade secret or involves information that is definitely confidential. And I guess one of
- 36:46the questions here is whether any of these concepts are really that confidential. There
- 36:52is an allegation that Ryan Miller copied the text from the cards that might be
- 37:00a breach of copyright, although they don't allege it, but you'll you'll you'll
- 37:04see here that none of the causes of his action are breach of our,
- 37:07breach of copyright or breach of or breach of anything else of a patent.
- 37:15And and you can actually see in the pleadings that it looks to me reading
- 37:19between the lines, that Upper Deck filed for a patent, but only after
- 37:23it read the publicly available rule book for Lorcana. It doesn't say that exactly,
- 37:29but they filed in April, and that's when the the rule book for
- 37:34Lorcana was publicly released. So it looks to me they saw the rule book
- 37:38for Lorcana and then decided to issue a patent. A patent attorney a bit,
- 37:43I'll tell you whether they might be able to get it or not.
- 37:45I think the general consensus is it's unlikely. But you can see that that
- 37:52there's this kind of issue with the originality of any of this. You know,
- 37:59is this really a trade secret because every CCG, you know, is
- 38:04this confidential information? You know, So if he's not copying the words in
- 38:07the rule book or the art or something like that, you know, what
- 38:12what is the loss here? And again, it's about much more than just
- 38:19Ryan and Upper Deck. I think it's really about how can they get to
- 38:23Ravensburger, their competitor probably don't care that much about raven about Ryan directly,
- 38:30I'm guessing he's not living it up in Beverly Hills. Yeah, and so
- 38:38so looking at the filing then, and again we stress you're not a California
- 38:44lawyer. This is not your specific area of expertise. But how strong do
- 38:49you see their case as being? Well, it depends if this is the
- 38:53lawyer answer. It depends if they can prove everything that's in their filing.
- 38:58I mean, if they can prove that they're bad faith and things like that,
- 39:01I mean a court will take a dim view. You know. If
- 39:05what happens is Ravensburger conspired with Ryan Miller to defraud Upper Deck, then the
- 39:15court is going to look It's going to look pretty bad, right. But
- 39:19I think the thing that's in the back of my mind is when you read
- 39:22this stuff, is like, are they really going to be able to prove
- 39:24that is the most likely explanation that they kind of conspired and acted in bad
- 39:30faith? Or is it that he kind of got bored of Rush of I
- 39:35Corps. You know, the Disney tie in for Ravensburger was interesting, and
- 39:40he was like, let's go over there, and probably didn't think about it
- 39:43too much. And Ravensburger probably didn't think that much about it maybe, and
- 39:49how much they have to look at whether there's particular clauses, you know,
- 39:53is a good question. I mean, ultimately, for me, if if
- 39:58if upper Deck really wanted to protect them themselves, you think they would have
- 40:04included a restraint of trade I used something to prevent I guess Ryan probably wouldn't
- 40:08have agreed to that, but that's the sort of clause that would have provided
- 40:13a lot more protection I would have thought then, you know, than trying
- 40:17to shoehorn other things in. But you know, I guess we'll see,
- 40:23and it'll be interesting to read the defense once that comes out, because we
- 40:28don't have the other side of the story from either party. And so say
- 40:32upper Deck win or upper Deck loose, what are the potential ramifications than in
- 40:37the future. I mean, if upper Deck win, is that a sort
- 40:40of thin end of the wedge when it comes to being able to copyright gay
- 40:45mechanisms? And could that affect people's ability to create games in the future.
- 40:52Honestly, I actually don't think so. I think what it will do is
- 40:55it might mean that people are more careful with their contracts. I mean,
- 41:00if they win. The reason that they're going to win is because there's been
- 41:04a breach of contract, and Ravensburger did something to kind of inflame the situation
- 41:10such that they became liable. Whether that was through acting in bad faith,
- 41:16or that was through kind of encouraging a breach of contract, or that was
- 41:20through some other mechanism, it's going to be a situation I think where that's
- 41:24happened. You know, these things aren't copyrightable. There are patents, but
- 41:30they're rarely given for games. So my general feeling is that probably this is
- 41:36very specific to this breach of contract charge. And yes, it means if
- 41:40you're a game designer and you sign up to these sorts of things, you
- 41:46know, hopefully a lawyer can look at it or something like that. But
- 41:52I think it's more much more about that than about the intellectual property issue to
- 41:57do with copyrights or anything else. I think I think that's actually largely unchanged.
- 42:02It's just that between Ryan Miller and Upper Deck you can agree to pretty
- 42:07much anything. So theoretically you can agree to never you know, never say
- 42:14a word, right Like you know, Ben and I could have a convert
- 42:19could have a contract where Ben's not allowed to say bell end. For example,
- 42:24I break I break that. You know, I'm not sure what damages
- 42:30you would have to pay. But the point the point is is that you
- 42:34know, we can agree to anything between us. The question is really about
- 42:37whether it affects other people. And normal intellectual property like rights like copyright and
- 42:44patents, do they can affect anybody in the world, well, in a
- 42:47jurisdiction, whereas an agreement between you and I won't necessarily have enough special effect
- 42:55against anyone else unless there's a special thing than makes it happen, and usually
- 43:00that's bad faith or interference in a contract. That's what they're pleading, right,
- 43:06And that's what it's really about. Those breaches of contract, you know,
- 43:09about whether it was confidential information, or whether it was you know,
- 43:14a property that could be passed, or whether it was a trade secret.
- 43:19Those are things that might be able to be protected. And if if Ravensburger
- 43:24was kind of incompetent enough slash acted in bad faith or turned to blind eye,
- 43:30maybe they can get caught. But again, proving that is difficult,
- 43:36you know, but if there's a smoking gun email, you never know.
- 43:40Yeah, brilliant, Well, Colin David Hunter, hot shot lawyer, all
- 43:45the way from Auckland. Thank you very much for italime pleasure. Thanks so
- 43:49much, Ben,