Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Secret Societies, Resistance and Political Intrigue in Istanbul Under Allied Occupation
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to EyeSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kimberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspect of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:33Dr Evren Altinkas, an adjunct professor in the Department of History at the University
- 0:38of Guelph, brings an extensive background in Turkish and Middle Eastern studies.
- 0:42With a PhD in comparative history from Dokuz Eylul University, Dr El-Tinkash focuses his
- 0:49research on the historiography of the Turkish war of independence, examining the significant
- 0:53role of the Committee of Union and Progress and its connections to Mustafa Kemal at the
- 0:58Turk's leadership.
- 0:59His work challenges mainstream narratives by analyzing the political networks and strategies
- 1:04that shaped the transition from the Ottoman Empire to the Republic of Turkey.
- 1:08Hello, it's such an honour to have you here today.
- 1:12Thank you for joining us on iSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 1:17Welcome.
- 1:18In your article, Istanbul Under Allied Occupation, Venues of Resistance, you mention how Istanbul
- 1:25has been a city of secret meetings and intrigue ever since the ideals of nationalism, democracy
- 1:32and freedom spread from Europe.
- 1:35And I was wondering, can you expand on this?
- 1:38Sure.
- 1:39Thank you very much.
- 1:40First of all, thanks for having me.
- 1:43Well, the Ottoman Empire has been a part of the European political arena since the capture
- 1:53of Istanbul in 1453.
- 1:55And because of this, Ottomans were always playing an important part, or let's say they
- 2:00were always involved or interested in the European politics and developments.
- 2:05However, the Ottoman Sultan always considered himself as superior than the European kings
- 2:11or monarchs.
- 2:13Until the second half of 17th century, when Ottomans were no longer able to expand, when
- 2:19they lost their campaign at the gates of Vienna in 1683.
- 2:27And after that, Ottoman Empire started to focus on its domestic affairs.
- 2:35And also Ottoman sultans started to send emissaries or other kind of diplomatic missions into
- 2:41the European countries in order to find out what's happening in those lands.
- 2:47And especially after the French Revolution, the Ottoman Sultan has decided to deploy the
- 2:53diplomatic missions permanently in certain capitals of European countries like Paris,
- 3:00like London, et cetera.
- 3:02And those emissaries, those diplomatic missions, when they returned from their task for a couple
- 3:11of weeks or a couple of months back to Istanbul, they always reported to the Sultan about the
- 3:16reforms in their country.
- 3:18So Sultan decided to establish a translation office within the Ottoman government structure.
- 3:25So the developments and the ideas like, not ideas like nationalism, democracy per se,
- 3:33but the developments, how the Europeans keep themselves updated and what are the means
- 3:39they use in order to be superior than the Ottomans regarding their military or other
- 3:44technologies, the Ottoman Sultan decided to establish this translation office.
- 3:49So this translation office, which was established in the heart of the Ottoman state, has employed
- 3:54Ottomans, Ottoman Turks, or Ottoman Arabs, including the other nations that were a part
- 4:02of the Ottoman Empire.
- 4:04And these people, once they started to translate the books, once they started to read the books
- 4:09have suggested the Sultan to establish some military schools.
- 4:13And these military schools were predominantly established in Istanbul since it was the capital
- 4:17of empire.
- 4:18In these military schools, new teachers were hired to teach about the technology or the
- 4:24developments in Europe.
- 4:26And they used those books that the translation office had translated as textbooks for the
- 4:32students.
- 4:33So simply put, the military officers who were now trained in these military schools with
- 4:37a modernized curriculum were able to read and understand the concepts of democracy,
- 4:45nationalism, and freedoms.
- 4:49So these people, these students, and their commanders that the students were interacting
- 4:59with decided to criticize, not criticize, but decided to question the authority of Ottoman
- 5:06Sultan over its subjects, which had been like a godly power, which means that the Ottoman
- 5:12Sultan owned everything and they were all subjects of him.
- 5:15But now they say, but this is not the case in Europe.
- 5:18That's one of the reasons why Europe is getting developed or progress.
- 5:23But the Ottomans remain a little bit behind the development.
- 5:28And since, as I said, the headquarters of these military schools or these military officers
- 5:33were mainly in Istanbul, they decided to overthrow the Sultan, to replace the Sultan in the middle
- 5:40of the 19th century.
- 5:42This is a mostly neglected event in Ottoman history.
- 5:46But in 1859, a group of Ottoman bureaucrats and soldiers started to gather, come together
- 5:56in secret meeting at mosques within the city or at some coffee houses within the city.
- 6:03And they established a secret organization called in Turkish called Fedailer Cemiyeti,
- 6:08which means the Association of Devotees.
- 6:11And their goal was to replace the Sultan with a more conservative one because in 1839, the
- 6:17Ottoman Sultan had declared a decree in which the Ottoman Sultan granted some rights to
- 6:24the minorities.
- 6:25And they believed these rights that were granted to these minorities were shaking the grounds
- 6:31of the Ottoman institutions.
- 6:34So they wanted to replace the Sultan with a more conservative one who would apply the
- 6:39rules of Sharia or Islam.
- 6:41So these people tried to disseminate their ideas and also expand their network.
- 6:50But one of the people they reached out was a Pasha, was a very important soldier within
- 6:55the Ottoman system.
- 6:57His name was Mirli Vahasan Pasha.
- 7:01And he learned about the secret meetings and he just informed them to the Ottoman Sultan
- 7:06and all the members of this committee were caught or and the committee was dissolved.
- 7:12They were imprisoned or sent to exile.
- 7:15Some of them were executed.
- 7:16But this did not stop this movement of changing the Sultan that there is a chance to overthrow
- 7:23the ruler, the monarch.
- 7:25This idea spread exponentially and continuously.
- 7:29So in 1868, a group of other military officers have organized an assassination attempt against
- 7:36the Sultan which was informed again and they were captured.
- 7:40In 1869, another group of intellectuals who were mainly occupied by the translation office
- 7:48and also who were teachers at these military schools have organized another group called
- 7:53the Mission Organization.
- 7:56And they were inspired from the French word mission.
- 7:59Like they said, our mission is to improve the government, improve and change the institutions
- 8:06in order to cope with the realities of modernity, of the modern life.
- 8:10And this was another venue of secret organizations in the Ottoman Empire until the first constitutional
- 8:16period.
- 8:17But of course, the most famous among these groups have always been known as the New Ottomans.
- 8:22They were just a group of intellectuals who were writing in newspapers or publishing some
- 8:27literacy books.
- 8:29And these people have become the origin of all these ideas, but they followed another
- 8:35route instead of organizing secret meetings.
- 8:38They decided to convince the Sultan and his entourage to carry out these reforms within
- 8:44the Ottoman Empire.
- 8:45And as I said, this ended up with the 1876 first constitutional period in the Ottoman
- 8:50state.
- 8:52Yeah, very interesting.
- 8:54And did Abdurah the second suspension of parliament and the establishment of a surveillance system
- 9:02drive the formation of these secret societies, such as you mentioned the Committee of Union
- 9:08and Progress?
- 9:10And how did the formation of secret societies among the Ottoman intellectual class reflect
- 9:15broader social and political shifts within the Empire?
- 9:19Yes, thank you for this question.
- 9:21So as I said, when in 1876 Abdulhamid with the promise of declaring the constitutional
- 9:29monarchy came to power as the new Sultan, soon after the outbreak of war between Ottomans
- 9:37and Russia, he just suspended the constitution.
- 9:40So there was a constitution, there was an elected parliament, but now it was suspended.
- 9:46And the people who were just having these ideas of, you know, crumbs of freedom or democracy
- 9:52have, were in a shock, were in a panic, especially those who sought to replace the government
- 9:58with a modern approach.
- 10:00But Abdulhamid was so clever because he knew about the events or developments that I mentioned
- 10:07while answering your first question, that there were secret organizations that even
- 10:12the highly high level bureaucrats could organize against the Sultan.
- 10:17So he established a surveillance system, a spy system, as we can call it.
- 10:22In Ottoman language, it is called hafiye.
- 10:24Hafiye means, you know, the secret guy, you know, the person who is invisible, like, you
- 10:31know, they were always among the people, they were on the streets, they were in the coffee
- 10:36houses, they were in bureaucracies, but they never were identified as the spy connection,
- 10:43spies of Abdulhamid.
- 10:44So anyone could be a spy.
- 10:47And according to the records, after Abdulhamid fell in 1909, according to the records, because
- 10:54Abdulhamid was personally reading all those reports provided to him.
- 10:58So according to the records found, the archives found, even the most prominent members of
- 11:03intellectual movement who claimed to want a change were among those who reported their
- 11:08friends to Abdulhamid's palace during this period, which is between 1876 and 1908.
- 11:17So then Abdulhamid established this secret surveillance system and suspended the parliament.
- 11:22Obviously, the military schools, which continue to exist, and also the military medical schools
- 11:31wanted to change this attitude, they wanted, they started to think about how to overthrow
- 11:36Abdulhamid again.
- 11:37However, another dimension stepped into the Ottoman Empire, another group of people that
- 11:44the Ottomans never thought this would happen.
- 11:46The religious minorities, like the Armenians, the Greeks, or other groups started to, you
- 11:52know, organize their own nationalistic movements, especially the Armenians within the Ottoman
- 11:57Empire were very active.
- 11:59They wanted to establish their own nation state and they said, in order to do that,
- 12:04first we need to have a real constitutional democracy or let's say constitutional monarchy,
- 12:09and then we will be able to convert the Ottoman Empire into a multi-ethnic and, you know,
- 12:16with independent sovereign states to be declared out of it.
- 12:20And they also wanted to assassinate Abdulhamid, but this created a reaction among the Muslim
- 12:25groups within the Ottoman Empire because they said, we have been living with Armenians for
- 12:29centuries.
- 12:30Why are they the ones to go and kill Abdulhamid?
- 12:34There were some assassination attempts on Abdulhamid.
- 12:38And then the military schools and the military medicine schools in the Ottoman Empire in
- 12:43Istanbul said, maybe we should replace Abdulhamid so we could control the Armenians or other
- 12:49ethnic groups to, you know, to stand against the Ottoman regime because after all they
- 12:56wanted to protect the Ottoman regime, the Ottoman state, regardless of who ruled the
- 13:02country.
- 13:03So they said, maybe it's Abdulhamid, maybe we should replace Abdulhamid.
- 13:05When we do that, we may be able to keep the empire together as a unified institution.
- 13:13So in 1889, a group of students from the military medical school have established another secret
- 13:21organization which is called in Turkish, İttihadi Osmani Cemiyeti, which means the Ottoman
- 13:26Union Association.
- 13:28And for the first time, ittiha, or, you know, in English we call it, you know, Union and
- 13:34Progress.
- 13:35Progress means ittiha.
- 13:37For the first time, the word progress was used in a secret organization's title.
- 13:42And they met at the fields, at the vineyards, not within the military schools in Istanbul,
- 13:52in distant areas where the Sultan's spies could not hear or understand what's going
- 13:58on.
- 13:59So they met for a couple of times, then they organized their other military school students
- 14:07or military medicine school students through an internal training which lasted for six
- 14:12years.
- 14:13So between 1889 and 1895, they kept on meeting regularly in a secret way and to organize
- 14:20the students.
- 14:21Like, they even distributed the tasks.
- 14:23When the day will come, this person will go to the barracks, this person will go and capture
- 14:30the guards of Abdulhamid, this person will capture his family.
- 14:34They even distributed all these tasks.
- 14:36So, in 1896, when they decided to finally implement their plan to overthrow Abdulhamid
- 14:47with this military coup attempt, they failed.
- 14:50They couldn't achieve it because most of the people who promised to support or help them
- 14:55literally stepped away.
- 14:56They just did not keep their promises.
- 15:00So most of them were captured and again sent to exile.
- 15:03But during Abdulhamid's reign, there were some intellectuals, again, some newspaper
- 15:09authors, thinkers who started to learn about the developments in Europe.
- 15:17And they were already in exile in different cities of Europe.
- 15:20Most of them were self-exiled.
- 15:22They just wanted to leave the country.
- 15:24They said, I don't want to remain under Abdulhamid's regime because I don't know what will happen
- 15:28to me.
- 15:29So, most intellectuals, some of them were coming from rich families.
- 15:34And even one of them was a member of the royal family.
- 15:37So he was the cousin of Abdulhamid with his father and brother.
- 15:41They escaped to Paris, not escaped, they traveled to Paris and then they joined the intellectuals
- 15:48in exile in that part.
- 15:50So these groups have established another organization called the Osmanlı İttihat ve Terakki Cemiyet.
- 15:59Which means the Ottoman Committee of Union and Progress.
- 16:03And they started to organize meetings.
- 16:06They called themselves the Young Turks from abroad.
- 16:10But they also had branches within the Ottoman state, within the Ottoman Empire.
- 16:14They had branches in Istanbul.
- 16:16They had branches in Tisselaniko, in modern Greece today.
- 16:22And in Tisselaniko, for instance, a group of army officers who were highly trained and
- 16:27very well skilled about military techniques have formed another committee which is called
- 16:36Osmanlı Hürriyet Cemiyeti, which means the Ottoman Freedom Committee.
- 16:40And then they joined their forces with the Osmanlı İttihat ve Terakki Cemiyeti in Paris,
- 16:46in Europe.
- 16:47So, and this group altogether have established the Committee of Union and Progress as we
- 16:53know in modern Turkish history today.
- 16:58And in 1908, they were able to carry out a bloodless revolution, which led to the declaration
- 17:08of the second constitutional period.
- 17:10And Abdulhamid had to declare it because he could no longer control the army in Tisselaniko.
- 17:17And the officers who were members of Committee of Union and Progress have literally threatened
- 17:21Abdulhamid, if you do not declare the constitutional period again, we will come and overthrow you.
- 17:28And they had a very strong military power.
- 17:29So, and this is how Committee of Union and Progress was formed based on these historical
- 17:36origins.
- 17:40And what challenges specifically did the Committee of Union and Progress face, especially considering
- 17:50its more covert activities and border nationalists and revolutionary objectives during the second
- 17:57constitutional era?
- 17:59Perfect question.
- 18:00Thank you.
- 18:01So first of all, the Committee of Union and Progress, when they were established, I forgot
- 18:06to mention that, had followed the rules of Italian carbonari group.
- 18:13Italian carbonari were very famous in terms of their secret organizations, their membership
- 18:18system, their system of cells, etc.
- 18:21And the Committee of Union and Progress founders were aware of this.
- 18:26They learned it from the actual carbonari members and they used the same technique.
- 18:30So their system was based on a secrecy.
- 18:33So most of the members did not know each other as long as they were not the part of the same
- 18:37cell, which means that when the revolution happened in 1908 and when Committee of Union
- 18:43and Progress started to have a say in political system within the Ottoman Empire, most of
- 18:48the members of Committee of Union and Progress were not aware of each other.
- 18:51They didn't know.
- 18:52It was a very covert system and it continued during the constitutional period when Committee
- 19:01of Union and Progress was at least technically in power between 1908 and 1918.
- 19:06But the interesting part here is that within the Committee of Union and Progress, there
- 19:10was still mistrust towards each other.
- 19:13So because they didn't know whether that person was really a member of their committee, they
- 19:18had their numbers, their numbering system.
- 19:21Each cell had a number and each cell had a unique number and within each cell, there
- 19:27were different numbers.
- 19:28But sometimes some people claimed to be the members of Committee of Union and Progress.
- 19:33There were no official documentation.
- 19:37And this caused a kind of conflict within the Committee of Union and Progress.
- 19:41They started to believe that some people who claimed to be their members are actually spies
- 19:46of the Sultan.
- 19:48They are actually spies of the traditional or conventional rulers of the Ottoman state.
- 19:54In 1909, a year after the second constitutional period, a religious riot happened in Istanbul.
- 20:04And some soldiers within Istanbul, within the barracks, who were not trained or educated
- 20:10as their officers, have revolted against the Committee of Union and Progress simply by
- 20:15blaming them as being infidels, Christians, masons, etc.
- 20:21And they wanted Abdulhamid to take the power under his hands.
- 20:25Again, Abdulhamid was still the Sultan, but he was under the control of or under the surveillance
- 20:30of the Committee of Union and Progress.
- 20:33So when this event happened in 1909, the Committee of Union and Progress officers in Balkans
- 20:39have sent an army in order to suppress it without the permission of the Sultan.
- 20:44And they murdered most of the people who stood against them.
- 20:50And that's the time when they replaced Abdulhamid with another Sultan who was more, let's say,
- 21:00legit in their eyes because they believed that Sultan would obey them.
- 21:03And he did actually until he died in 1918.
- 21:07So during that period, within the Committee of Union and Progress, because of its covert
- 21:12activities, because of this secrecy, some groups have emerged in order to overthrow
- 21:17the ruling elite of the Committee of Union and Progress because they believed the Committee
- 21:23of Union and Progress was under the effect of Germans.
- 21:26And they say Germany, because of the connections of the rulers of the Committee of Union and
- 21:32Progress, such as Enver Talat and Cemal, the three famous Pasha's of the Trump rate
- 21:37of the CUP, they believed that German infiltration into the Ottoman state was going to be destructive.
- 21:46And they also believed that the Ottomans were no longer in an Islamic state because the
- 21:53rulers, the CUP leaders were mostly secular.
- 21:57And they started a movement within the Committee of Union and Progress.
- 22:01And then they separated themselves, calling themselves as the Association of Freedom.
- 22:09And they gave themselves a name called Halaskar Zahabitan, which means the soldiers for freedom.
- 22:15And they wanted to overthrow the time rate of CUP.
- 22:21And they achieved three elections in the parliament and they came to power in 1912.
- 22:26During this time, the Balkan War started.
- 22:28So the Balkan states have fought against the Ottomans and Ottomans lost the substantial
- 22:33territory in the Balkan region.
- 22:35And as a result of the CUP members said, okay, now you see they are not able to rule the
- 22:42country.
- 22:43So let's take it back from them.
- 22:44And in 1913, the CUP, which is a secret organization, has finally showed its face.
- 22:51And hundreds of CUP members gathered in front of the ministerial meeting when the ministers
- 22:56of the Ottoman government were at meeting.
- 22:58And they walked inside under a very organized secret meetings instructions.
- 23:05They murdered some of the ministers and they took the power in 1913.
- 23:09And that's the time when CUP was finally able to dismiss all the remaining secret cells
- 23:17or organizations within it, which were against the principles of CUP leaders.
- 23:22And this lasted until 1918 when the Ottomans lost or let's say when the Ottomans were in
- 23:28the losing side of the First World War.
- 23:30So stemming from that, in what ways did Istanbul become a center of political intrigue and
- 23:38resistance under allied occupation following World War One?
- 23:42Thank you very much.
- 23:43So when the Ottomans were finally in the losing side of the war, the leaders of CUP, these
- 23:52three names I mentioned, Enver Talat and Cemal, who were responsible for so many atrocities
- 23:57and crimes and violence throughout World War One, have decided to escape the Ottoman capital
- 24:05because the Ottoman sultan, the new Ottoman sultan, Vahdetin, who is the last sultan of
- 24:12the Ottomans, was not a CUP fan.
- 24:17He has said a couple of times in his statements that CUP had made very wrong decisions with
- 24:22the World War One and taking sides with the Germans.
- 24:26So they were afraid of their future, afraid of their lives.
- 24:30So they escaped Istanbul in a German ship.
- 24:35However, before they escaped, before their departure, they met with some loyal members
- 24:44of CUP who were like their watchdogs during the Ottoman, during the rule of Ottoman Empire
- 24:56between 1913 and 1918, the actual rule.
- 25:00They had also established an organization during World War One, which is called Special
- 25:05Organization.
- 25:06In Turkish, it means Teşkilatı Mahsusa, which is the origin of the modern Turkish intelligence
- 25:12agencies today.
- 25:14So and in this special organization, they had very devoted members who were ready to
- 25:20kill anyone they just pointed.
- 25:22So and some of them were left in Istanbul because they were not able to escape because
- 25:26Germany did not allow everyone to come and live in its territories.
- 25:31So before leaving, before departing the Istanbul, these three leaders have gathered with their
- 25:38devotees or other members of CUP, second rank or third rank members, and commanded them,
- 25:44instructed them to establish a secret society, an underground society to fight against the
- 25:50Allied occupation in Istanbul.
- 25:52And they called it Karakol.
- 25:54Karakol has different meanings in Turkish, one of them today Karakol is used as a word
- 25:59to describe the police stations or, you know, the branches of police stations.
- 26:05But the name they gave to it was because of its two members who were the leaders of Karakol,
- 26:14namely Kara Kemal and Kara Vasuf.
- 26:16Kara Kemal was a very effective member of CUP.
- 26:20He organized during the, during 1913 and 1918, he organized the working classes in Istanbul,
- 26:27you know, all the occupations in Istanbul.
- 26:30You can't think about anything, bakers, horse carrier, carriage riders, anyone who would
- 26:38participate in the Ottoman economy with their physical contribution.
- 26:43And he organized them because he wanted to create a purely Turkish economic system within
- 26:50Istanbul.
- 26:51So Kara Kemal was the first leader that they instructed to establish this underground organization.
- 26:56And the second person's name was Kara Vasuf.
- 27:00He was a very devoted, devoted military officer.
- 27:03So since their name started with Kara, Kara means black, or let's say dark in terms of
- 27:08color, because their skin colors were a little bit darker than the traditional Turkish skin
- 27:15color.
- 27:16So both of them, because both of them had Kara in front of their names, the organization
- 27:21was named as Karakol.
- 27:22The Karakol was organized in almost all branches of Ottoman government, because most of them
- 27:29were placed there by the CUP during the rule, like small petty officers, or even the high
- 27:36rank officers.
- 27:38And the goal of Karakol was a three stage plan.
- 27:41First one, we should fight against the allied occupation in Istanbul.
- 27:45We should do our best guerrilla tactics, hit and run tactics in order to give them some
- 27:54kind of disturbance during the rule.
- 27:57The second stage or second phase of the plan was to smuggle weapons or any kind of logistical
- 28:06support to Anatolia, because during World War I, when there was the Gallipoli War, when
- 28:12Britain and France were at the shores of Istanbul in 1915, the CUP government had an alternative
- 28:21plan to move the capital of Ottoman state into Anatolia.
- 28:26That's why since 1915, they had already organized a kind of potential resistance against an
- 28:33occupation of the territories in case the Ottomans had lost the war.
- 28:38And this organization had already placed some weapons in distant lands in Anatolia under
- 28:45the farms, they buried it underground.
- 28:48And they also gave some codes for some CUP members in Anatolia that in case something
- 28:55happens, this is the code you will use.
- 28:57And this is how you will know that you are assigned to carry out a kind of resistance
- 29:02against the occupation.
- 29:04And because most of the military officers and headquarters and barracks were in Istanbul,
- 29:09Karakol said, you know, let's send these arms, these weapons, these ammunition into Anatolia
- 29:16to support these resistance groups.
- 29:19This was the second goal.
- 29:21And the third goal was to send some military officers or some soldiers who had to come
- 29:27to Istanbul after the war and resign or take their discharge papers and, you know, send
- 29:34them to Anatolia under disguise like maybe as like religious dervishes or, you know,
- 29:40claiming that they have family members in Anatolia and they are going to the villages.
- 29:44These were the three goals of Karakol.
- 29:46In addition to Karakol, some local resistance groups were formed as well.
- 29:50They were all underground.
- 29:53And they provided intelligence simply by placing their members into the headquarters of British,
- 30:00French or Italian occupation forces as translators, as servants, as gardeners, as drivers.
- 30:11And these people were able to retrieve all kinds of information simply by listening to
- 30:16them or simply by copying the documents with their hands.
- 30:22They didn't know English, they didn't know French, but they were just simply copying
- 30:25what they saw and provided it to local resistance groups.
- 30:29So they were able to formulate a kind of stance against the occupying powers.
- 30:38And in addition to that, they also identified the collaborators within Istanbul, the Turks,
- 30:43Muslims or other ethnic groups who were all Ottoman citizens, the ones who collaborated
- 30:48with the occupying forces during their rule.
- 30:51And sometimes they assassinated them, sometimes they intimidated them.
- 30:55And these were the aims of these groups as well, in addition to Karakol.
- 31:00That's absolutely fascinating.
- 31:03And how did the Karakol organization, I guess, facilitate the smuggling of weapons and what
- 31:10impact did they have, like what larger impact on the Turkish war of independence?
- 31:16Thank you.
- 31:17That's a great question.
- 31:18I think this is one of the most challenging claims or let's say arguments I'm making in
- 31:27my project, actually.
- 31:29I'm working on three different manuscript projects and still the data is coming, so
- 31:34I couldn't publish the books yet.
- 31:37But this is the challenge, this is the most challenging one.
- 31:40What I say simply is that CUP and Karakol were the organizations behind the Turkish
- 31:45war of independence.
- 31:46It was not only Mustafa Kemal Atatürk who led the Turkish war of independence starting
- 31:52from 1919, which lasted until 1922, but it was the Karakol members who sent different
- 31:59commanders into Anatolia to start this kind of resistance against the occupying forces
- 32:06after Istanbul was occupied by the allied powers.
- 32:09And as I said before, they already had sent their weapons, ammunition, or even some officers
- 32:17into Anatolia and there were some specific locations where most of them were accumulated
- 32:22at.
- 32:23And when we look at the trajectory of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, when he landed in Anatolia
- 32:28in 1919, he visited all these places one by one, simply acquiring, gathering all the ammunition
- 32:36and support and soldiers and then letting them know that the headquarters will be Ankara,
- 32:41the modern capital of Turkey.
- 32:42So when we look at his trajectory, those are the steps he took, those are the cities he
- 32:46visited.
- 32:47I'm talking about all the important milestones of Turkish war of independence, you know,
- 32:52when the resistance started.
- 32:54He landed in Samsun.
- 32:55Samsun was a port city.
- 32:58They had all the ammunition and weapons waiting for him there.
- 33:02He took them, then he went to Sivas.
- 33:04Sivas was in the center of Anatolia where another congress was held in order to declare
- 33:10the word that Turks were now going to resist against the occupation.
- 33:14That was the second location of the ammunition and weapons and the men that were gathering
- 33:21for a resistance by the orders of CUP and Karakol.
- 33:24Then he went to Erzurum in the eastern part of Anatolia, in the eastern part of Turkey.
- 33:29Again, the same pattern continent.
- 33:32And finally he ended up in Ankara, the modern capital of Turkey, which was his headquarters
- 33:36during the Turkish war of independence.
- 33:39Everything in there was already organized by CUP and Karakol in case of an occupation,
- 33:44in case an occupation would occur.
- 33:46So what Karakol did, you know, until Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, until Mustafa Kemal landed
- 33:54into Anatolia, was to send ammunition and weapons by use of these sailors, you know,
- 34:05who had very small boats and they were members of the organization that Karak Kemal had established
- 34:10during World War I.
- 34:11I told you he wanted to create a Turkish group of economic groups, so Turkish group of economic
- 34:20occupations.
- 34:24And the boatmen were among these groups.
- 34:27So he simply used his connections.
- 34:30So these boatmen were just, you know, saying, I'm just going to go fish, I'm just going
- 34:35to go carry some stuff to Anatolia, you know, usual trade.
- 34:38But in fact, they were smuggling weapons.
- 34:42You may think that these were small amounts of it, but the number of boatmen who visited
- 34:47Istanbul, who visited Anatolia from Istanbul was among 800 or a thousand people per day.
- 34:54So they continued smuggling those weapons.
- 34:57Another tactic they used was because the occupying powers were very sensitive about the religious
- 35:02affairs of the Ottoman Empire, they just did not want to instigate or let's say trigger
- 35:10any kind of religious problems.
- 35:13They were so respectful to religious people, like people who had a kind of religious occupation
- 35:18or a title.
- 35:19So what they did was to use some religious institutions within Istanbul as their secret
- 35:25headquarters.
- 35:26And there were always some passwords.
- 35:29For instance, they used passwords like they use names like Jesus, Moses, Noah, in order
- 35:38to identify themselves as the leaders of Karakola organization, and they gave the title Noah
- 35:44to Mustafa Kemal because remember the story of Noah, the Ark of Noah, Mustafa Kemal is
- 35:50the one who goes with the ship to start the war again, like the Noah carried all the animals
- 35:56and survived the flood.
- 35:58So they gave these titles in a very smart way.
- 36:01And when they entered these religious institutions, which was, you know, like a mosque like institution,
- 36:08they were just praying, they were just doing their religious duties.
- 36:12But then when the occupying forces came to visit or, you know, to supervise or look after
- 36:17them, but as soon as they left, they were just sending them under the disguise of dervish
- 36:22or religious Molda costumes into Anatolia through some secret passages between the mountains.
- 36:31And then officers were being sent.
- 36:34And as soon as they stepped into Anatolia, they took their rifles, ammunition, waiting
- 36:39for them, and they joined the local resistance groups.
- 36:42According to this was the tactic of Karakola and CUP to initiate a kind of resistance,
- 36:47which then led to Turkish War of Independence in 1990.
- 36:52And focusing more on Mustafa Kemal at the Turk, how did he leverage these existing networks
- 36:58in Istanbul to aid in the organization of the Turkish War of Independence and the foundation
- 37:04of the Republic of Turkey?
- 37:06So Mustafa Kemal was in Istanbul between November 1918 and May 1919 until he left for Anatolia
- 37:14inmates.
- 37:15During his visit, during his presence in the city, he met with all the remaining members
- 37:23of CUP and Karakola because he was a member of the CUP as well, which is a fact.
- 37:29All the military officers during that time had to be the members of the CUP in order
- 37:34to have a good position or title within the Ottoman system, not only the military officers,
- 37:41but also the bureaucrats or any other person who had occupied the position in the government.
- 37:45So Mustafa Kemal arrived in Istanbul.
- 37:49He learned about the existence of Karakol.
- 37:51He was aware of it.
- 37:52He met with the leaders of Karakol multiple times, Kara Kemal, Kara Vasif.
- 37:58And then he learned about their organization.
- 38:00He took the maps, the locations and all the information needed in order to start a kind
- 38:07of resistance.
- 38:09But they offered him the leadership of Karakol.
- 38:12They said, they told him, you can be our leader, but Mustafa Kemal said, no, I prefer to remain
- 38:18an officer of the Ottoman government because this will make it easier for me to go and
- 38:23do whatever I want to do.
- 38:25But I promise I will do what Karakol's three goals are.
- 38:30I will complete them.
- 38:33But it was impossible for him to be sent to Anatolia because the Ottoman Sultan, the occupying
- 38:39powers were highly suspicious of him because he was a successful military commander during
- 38:44the Gallipoli War.
- 38:45He was also successful in the Middle East against the war to Britain.
- 38:51So the British occupying forces did not arrest him, but they also wanted to keep him in Istanbul.
- 38:56So he had to find a way to leave Istanbul, but he couldn't do that because he was always
- 39:04under supervision.
- 39:05He was always under surveillance.
- 39:07And so he approached the Karakol members and said, look, okay, I'm going to do this.
- 39:12I am going to initiate this resistance, but you need to find a way to convince the Ottoman
- 39:17Sultan or the authorities to send me to Anatolia with an official position, with an official
- 39:22title.
- 39:23So the Karakol members, as I said, who were highly involved in Ottoman bureaucracy because
- 39:30the occupying powers were not able to replace the officers since they were very limited,
- 39:38they started a kind of gossiping, like saying, did you know that Mustafa Kemal Pasha is against
- 39:45the CUP?
- 39:46He doesn't like the leaders of CUP.
- 39:49Did you know that he is loyal to the Sultan?
- 39:52That's why he was always, he never had a high rank position within the CUP during CUP's
- 39:59reign.
- 40:00So all these kinds of gossiping somehow worked to convince the ministers of the Ottoman government,
- 40:08Damat Ferit Pasha and his ministers who were in good terms with the occupying powers to
- 40:13consider Mustafa Kemal as a leader, sorry, as a military commander to be sent to Anatolia
- 40:19in order to control or suppress the resistance movement by the Turks.
- 40:25So it was like a very smart and intelligent move as far as I can say, simply by providing
- 40:34misinformation about him, telling them that he is going to control or suppress the Turkish
- 40:40resistance, local resistance in Anatolia.
- 40:42So the Ottoman Sultan was finally convinced and that's how they sent him.
- 40:47Once he went to Anatolia and once he declared the beginning, the start of Turkish war of
- 40:53independence, Karakol members obviously reached out to him and said, now it is time to declare
- 41:00that this is all organized and planned by the CUP and Karakol.
- 41:03And that's the moment he was able to convince his followers that the Karakol and CUP had
- 41:09nothing to do with this because of the reputation, bad reputation of the CUP and their members.
- 41:15It should be a wise idea not to call themselves as members of committee of union and progress
- 41:20or in Turkish terminology unionists.
- 41:22So instead of him, he decided to use the term nationalists, which then turned or converted
- 41:28into Kemalists after his name.
- 41:31And then he was able to take control of all the underground organizations within Istanbul
- 41:38simply by sending some of his men into Istanbul under disguise and tell the members of these
- 41:45underground organizations that he was the commander of all the resistance and intelligence
- 41:49groups.
- 41:50And that's how he was able to facilitate the Turkish war of independence simply by eliminating
- 41:57or let's say, I mean, yes, eliminating the original leaders of the CUP and Karakol within
- 42:05this event, within this Turkish war of independence or resistance, we can say.
- 42:13So my final question is what are you currently working on and how is the history of intelligence
- 42:20in particular part of your research and perhaps how it also all of this work can contribute
- 42:28to understanding of the intelligence sphere in Turkey today?
- 42:34I can say that it is not only limited to Turkey when we look at the activities of Karakol
- 42:41members and other underground organizations during the occupation of Istanbul or Turkey
- 42:48between 1918 and 1922.
- 42:51But we can also say that British, French, Italians, and after the declaration of Republic
- 42:58of Turkey, the Americans and Russians were able to learn from the members of Karakol
- 43:04or the underground organizations about some intelligence tactics.
- 43:08So my current research is about their interactions after the declaration of Republic.
- 43:14The Soviet government, Bolshevik government had sent some of their emissaries, some of
- 43:20their members in order to learn from the Karakol members or intelligence underground groups.
- 43:26Americans did the same starting from 1920s.
- 43:28British, French, and Italians were highly inspired.
- 43:31So they had very good connections with them.
- 43:32They became friends.
- 43:34They invited some of the former underground organization or Karakol members into their
- 43:38countries to learn about their tactics, you know, simple spy or intelligence tactics like,
- 43:44you know, how to write with a chemical so no one will be able to read it is just one
- 43:49of them.
- 43:50They learned from some Karakol members or how to disguise some very famous members of
- 43:55Karakol who were actively involved during the underground organization have become
- 44:01diplomats simply sent by Mustafa Kemal or Ataturk now the leader of the Republic of
- 44:06Turkey both to learn and also to teach these activities to them.
- 44:11And there are of course some connections about the American intelligence after the beginning
- 44:20of Cold War coming to Turkey, creating this de facto headquarters within Ankara and then
- 44:28creating a Turkish military intelligence group and how they have learned from Karakol and
- 44:34their members and how they interacted is my current research.
- 44:37So I'm not claiming that it's going to be groundbreaking or I'm not claiming that everything
- 44:41the Western intelligence organizations do or did are have been learned by the from the
- 44:48from the Turks or from the Karakol but I can say that they were highly inspired and that's
- 44:52the connection I'm working on right now.
- 44:55That's absolutely fascinating.
- 44:56Yeah, really, really interesting work.
- 45:00Thank you so much for sharing.
- 45:02Thanks for having me.