Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 7 Episode 16: The Myth of Perpetrator Accountability
Transcript
- 0:16David Mandel: And we're back.
- 0:17Ruth Reymundo: And we're back.
- 0:19David Mandel: Hello.
- 0:19Ruth Reymundo: Hello there, Mandel.
- 0:22David Mandel: We have uh not done one of these in a while.
- 0:24David Mandel: Just you and I chit-chatting.
- 0:26Ruth Reymundo: You always say that.
- 0:27David Mandel: I do.
- 0:28Ruth Reymundo: We actually did one last month.
- 0:29David Mandel: We did?
- 0:30David Mandel: Yeah.
- 0:30David Mandel: Okay.
- 0:31Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, we took a little summer slowdown, which was good because we're doing a lot of things.
- 0:36Ruth Reymundo: But let's begin with our little routine.
- 0:40David Mandel: I am David Mandel, CEO and founder of the Safety Desert Institute, and co-founder with you of Safety Nexus.
- 0:47Ruth Reymundo: That's right.
- 0:47Ruth Reymundo: You're my co-founder at Safety Nexus.
- 0:49David Mandel: That's right.
- 0:50Ruth Reymundo: And I'm Ruth Raimundo, and I am your partner and co-owner at the Institute and co-founder at Safety Nexus.
- 0:56David Mandel: That's right.
- 0:57David Mandel: And we are on Tungus Masako Land.
- 1:00David Mandel: It is a gorgeous day, sunny fall here in the northeast part of the United States.
- 1:07David Mandel: For many people, this is the best part of the year.
- 1:10David Mandel: It's sunny, it's still warm, but night times are cool and leaves will be starting to change any minute now.
- 1:18Ruth Reymundo: And we just want to send our regards to the traditional custodians of the land, past, present, and emerging.
- 1:28David Mandel: So we wanted to kind of do a kind of an old school, just back to basics conversation, really, about the myth of perpetrator accountability, which is one of the chapters in my book, Stop Blaming Mothers and Ignoring Fathers, How to Transform the Way We Keep Children Safe from Domestic Violence.
- 1:50Ruth Reymundo: And this is really coming on the heels of the interview with Rodney Villet that was just dropped around men and behavior change, which was a very robust conversation about men, violence, and change, and our responsibilities in the industry to support and to facilitate that change.
- 2:19David Mandel: That's right.
- 2:20David Mandel: So you know, I there's so many angles we can come at this, and we're gonna touch on the book chapter.
- 2:28David Mandel: We're gonna go beyond it.
- 2:29David Mandel: You know, the book chapter is a real good place for you to go if you want more about this.
- 2:33David Mandel: But I'm gonna go back to one of my more kind of basic maneuvers, which is I think anybody who hears the phrase perpetrator accountability should assume they don't know what is being referenced or meant by that, or what that gets operationalized as until you ask some really specific questions.
- 2:57David Mandel: Like if that's the one thing you take away from this episode, you can stop listening now.
- 3:02Ruth Reymundo: Ask more questions.
- 3:04David Mandel: Is is understand that perpetrator accountability, and Donna Chung from Western Australia is a researcher, did a policy paper for Androse in 2020 that said basically that there was no standard definition of the term perpetrator accountability, but you see it everywhere used all the time as a placeholder for something.
- 3:25Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 3:28David Mandel: So that's my my kind of opening salvo in the in the episode is is we use this term all the time.
- 3:35David Mandel: We don't have a shared understanding of it.
- 3:38R: Well, there's two terms and I want to break them apart.
- 3:41David Mandel: Okay.
- 3:42Ruth Reymundo: Because there's the term perpetrator accountability, which is used as a broad term for many different actions and many different philosophies and many different system level structures and processes that we have created in order to facilitate whatever that accountability means.
- 4:06Ruth Reymundo: But then there's men's behavior change, and those are two separate things.
- 4:10Ruth Reymundo: And I would really challenge people to separate out those concepts because accountability is not behavior change.
- 4:19David Mandel: Right.
- 4:19Ruth Reymundo: They are two separate actions.
- 4:21Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 4:21Ruth Reymundo: And a lot of times in these industries, domestic violence industries, child protection industries, child and family services industries, domestic violence services, there's a lot of conflating of accountability with behavior change.
- 4:40Ruth Reymundo: And that is a false claim that actually cannot be backed up by the evidence that the forms of accountability that we have widely systematized bring about any type of long-term behavior change and improvements in men's behavioral functioning, mental health functioning, and relational functioning.
- 5:08David Mandel: Well, can I can I take that even further, you know, which is that we have this question about what does accountability mean and look like and what do you how are you defining it?
- 5:19David Mandel: We have this question about is this person really changing?
- 5:25Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 5:26David Mandel: Which starts putting some space between monitoring, compliance, systems actions.
- 5:33Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 5:34David Mandel: You know, because a lot of times people will say, oh, was the order enforced?
- 5:38David Mandel: That's accountability.
- 5:40David Mandel: Were they punished for the order?
- 5:42David Mandel: Were they incarcerated because it committed a crime?
- 5:44David Mandel: A lot of people will, that's their working definition of accountability.
- 5:48David Mandel: None of that, while that is important, and we need to have systems that work, are dependable, that are fair, that are victim-centered, right?
- 5:57David Mandel: And incarceration, we know, doesn't guarantee behavior change.
- 6:03R: I don't really want victim-centered systems.
- 6:05R: I got to be honest with you.
- 6:07R: When you say that, that makes me anxious.
- 6:09David Mandel: But what does that mean?
- 6:10David Mandel: Go ahead.
- 6:10Ruth Reymundo: Why should systems focus on victims rather than focusing on the person who's causing the problems?
- 6:16Ruth Reymundo: They should be considerate of, they should be respectful of our rights, they should be inclusive of our experience, and they should have an ongoing consultative stance towards survivors and victims.
- 6:29Ruth Reymundo: But I do not want either professional, advocates, domestic violence, nor personal systems to be focused on victims.
- 6:38David Mandel: I love it.
- 6:39David Mandel: So you're getting in real time us teasing out another piece of jargon, which is a lot of times people will talk about centering the voices or centering lived experience or centering survivors.
- 6:51David Mandel: And what I would say is a lot of systems, particularly when it comes to domestic abuse in children, have negatively centered survivors.
- 7:01David Mandel: That's right.
- 7:02David Mandel: Scrutinize them, put them under the microscope, punish them, pressurize them.
- 7:06David Mandel: And that's a that is another kind of centering, which is sort of making the perpetrator's parent invisible, and then centering that, you know, and and so, oh, we go and meet with the survivor and we offer her services.
- 7:17David Mandel: And people will equate that with being survivor-centered, but but oftentimes that's done without any intervention with him as a parent, particularly, or any kind of looking at is this behavior changing and what is he still doing?
- 7:29David Mandel: So you just had in real-time audience us teasing out those terms, because when I say victim center, I mean that it that we because you can have change even, right?
- 7:42David Mandel: You have accountability, you have change, but then the real question is, does our interventions, and I'm going to say that with the the user of violence perpetrator, does do those things make things better for the adult and child survivor?
- 8:00David Mandel: That's what I mean by victim-centered.
- 8:03David Mandel: Right.
- 8:03Ruth Reymundo: The measure of success is victim-centered that this this institution, this particular system has a focus on intervening with that survivor, has a focus on mandating to them and providing providing in air quotes them services.
- 8:26Ruth Reymundo: And you know what?
- 8:27Ruth Reymundo: I want the systems out of our freaking business.
- 8:31Ruth Reymundo: Go focus on the perpetrator and their choices and patterns, leave us alone, give us support, give us resources, give us options and choices because we are not the problem.
- 8:45Ruth Reymundo: And so all of these different services in their in their quote-unquote victim-centered processes often simply pressurize survivors, offer them inadequate and partial services that often mean that we have to trade off our liberties and our self-determination and our rights in order to acquire those.
- 9:11Ruth Reymundo: It is a trap.
- 9:12Ruth Reymundo: And I don't like it.
- 9:14Ruth Reymundo: And I'm a cranky survivor about it.
- 9:16Ruth Reymundo: And really, what I want is I want systems to respect our autonomy, to respect our self-determination, our liberties and our rights, and our right to leave and move and breathe and be well resourced and not be mandated to and not be the central focus of their interventions because it is the perpetrator who is causing the problem, not us.
- 9:44David Mandel: Mic drop.
- 9:45Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 9:46David Mandel: That's a mic drop moment.
- 9:47David Mandel: That is I'm steroids, right?
- 9:50Ruth Reymundo: So you're just gonna get you're gonna get volcanic root.
- 9:53Ruth Reymundo: I but all those hundreds of years of volcanic soil in my blood is just gonna boil out totally.
- 9:59David Mandel: I love it.
- 10:00David Mandel: I love it.
- 10:00David Mandel: It's it's it's it's really to me, it's so clear and powerful.
- 10:05David Mandel: And it and and it really opens the doorway to this idea that we really need to be to slow down when we use the words perpetrator accountability, when we use the words, you know, we look at change, whether it's a men's behavior change program or change, what's the definition?
- 10:26David Mandel: And then we need to look at are we really I I I Dr.
- 10:30David Mandel: Eloise Cepeda is an amazing advocate for restorative justice.
- 10:35David Mandel: She does work around women in trafficking, and she's a safety other certified trainer.
- 10:41David Mandel: And she said to me, you know, one of the questions she asks over and over again is, did this intervention make things better for that adult and child survivor?
- 10:50David Mandel: Right.
- 10:51David Mandel: She says, I don't ask safer because I want a more the way I interpret it is better is a more holistic, survivor-defined, culturally responsive, like sort of what is better, what does better look like?
- 11:05David Mandel: Because better it because the complexity of trading off, you know, needs of kids and employment and safety and all these things, survivors are whole people.
- 11:15David Mandel: Our work with perpetrators should be defined by have we helped the whole person, the adult and child survivor?
- 11:24David Mandel: Not just did we put physical distance between them.
- 11:29David Mandel: Did our intervention with the perpetrator make things better, or how did it make things better for those adult and child survivors?
- 11:37Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 11:38Ruth Reymundo: And I think that it's worth noting that one of the reasons why we have done such a colossally and globally horrible job at the words perpetrator accountability or men's behavior change is because we have been set up in a system where the system does focus on victims and interventions and mandates to victims.
- 12:06Ruth Reymundo: It does mandate to victims, it demands that survivors and victims leave their homes, abandon their assets, dislocate themselves from their day-to-day resources and their life and their families and their communities and their support networks.
- 12:23Ruth Reymundo: And if they don't do that, they charge those women with failure to protect.
- 12:28Ruth Reymundo: And we have not really diven down, dove down into the to the philosophical and and other motivations for that, which is a fundamental and implicit belief that exists globally around the world.
- 12:48Ruth Reymundo: It's a pattern that women are responsible for male violence, that women are responsible to be the buffer between men's violence and children, that women are supposed to be the peacemaker makers in the home, the ones that regulate that man's behavior, that takes his sexual violence so that he's not sexually violent to strangers or physically violent to strangers, and absorbs that and then takes all of the responsibility for the fact of those behaviors and is charged with failure to protect.
- 13:26Ruth Reymundo: So we have an upside-down world and lots of interlocking systems and processes and institutions that have been created around that one fundamental view that men are not capable of being responsible for their behavioral reality, that they're not capable of not being sexually violent, that they're not capable of not abusing and brutalizing their own family or raping their own children.
- 13:57Ruth Reymundo: I don't know how any person of goodwill could justify such a stance, such a horrible, negative, violent view of men.
- 14:11Ruth Reymundo: I find it incredibly dehumanizing and degrading towards men, and I'm not even a man.
- 14:36David Mandel: I don't think it's the only thing.
- 14:36David Mandel: Oh, it's way before.
- 14:38David Mandel: But you but the most recent thing is it's sort of what you put the Victorian English that really migrated into the U.S.
- 14:44David Mandel: And I think throughout the sort of the empire, which is that women are the civilizing force, right?
- 14:50David Mandel: If people are not familiar with that kind of Victorian idea, because it's behind temperance, you know, anti-drinking, it's it's it's it's behind all these things about social movements in the late 1800s into the early 1900s, yeah, and really shaped modern-day feminism in a lot of ways still, which is that women are the civilizers, quote unquote, and men are the barbarians.
- 15:13David Mandel: And that's genetic.
- 15:15David Mandel: And I don't I don't almost say I don't agree with genetic hormonal hormonal, whatever you want to say.
- 15:19David Mandel: So you you know, you often often take us to this this next level, which is that how do you to really question, I'm gonna ask people a question saying, do you operate from a unexamined bias that men's violence is inevitable?
- 15:39Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 15:39David Mandel: Natural inevitable and natural.
- 15:41David Mandel: And and therefore, one, there's two corollaries.
- 15:44David Mandel: One is one you're pointing out, which is therefore, when it comes to kids, particularly, you expect women to act in a certain way because it's inevitable or natural, unavoidable.
- 15:54David Mandel: It's gonna rain, so you better take an umbrella.
- 15:56David Mandel: And if you get wet, it's not because the rain's the problem, it's because you didn't take an umbrella.
- 16:01David Mandel: Right.
- 16:01David Mandel: That's that failure to protect thinking in a nutshell, basically.
- 16:05David Mandel: And the other part of it is that how do we or why bother holding men accountable and to what standard if this is their natural state?
- 16:13David Mandel: And I think, sadly, I agree with you that I think there's a lot of that unspoken, and I'll tell you that my my active process, it continues to be unwinding some of these biases.
- 16:29David Mandel: I'd like to give a couple examples.
- 16:31David Mandel: I think people need to see that this is that we're all in process with this.
- 16:36Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 16:37David Mandel: And we're all that like this isn't a given.
- 16:39David Mandel: And and and I I have I have two examples.
- 16:41David Mandel: One from a few years ago, where, and this is just about expectations of men as parents, but also about accountability.
- 16:49David Mandel: One was was how people were talking about, well, they're being, you know, father informed in their work because they offer groups for men after hours in the evenings and then on weekends, so men could work.
- 17:01David Mandel: And it's like, first I was like, yay, that's great.
- 17:04David Mandel: And I was like, we don't do the same thing for women, you know, so we create this space for men.
- 17:08David Mandel: Well, you're working is important.
- 17:10David Mandel: And women, we just expect them to leave work to go to parent teacher conference, right?
- 17:14David Mandel: But the but that was one kind of moment where I realized I was treating men differently.
- 17:18David Mandel: But the accountability one was realizing that I had not taken even my own thinking about accountability for men as parents to the next level, which is fathers who use violence need to be held accountable for healing the harm that they caused.
- 17:47David Mandel: That's only what I've been saying within the last couple of years, which is shocking to me, because basically, before that, I was like, well, I joined with everybody, which is our standard of like, what does change look like?
- 17:59David Mandel: What is better look like, didn't include that for me.
- 18:03David Mandel: And I was like, wait a second, if I give my kid a cold, or they get sick from me, or they get sick from a stranger, it doesn't matter.
- 18:10David Mandel: I'm still responsible for taking them to the doctor.
- 18:12Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 18:14David Mandel: If we don't have a clear view of expectations of what change looks like, if we don't expect it, if we don't envision it, if we don't paint a picture of it, what does it mean to be a father who's chosen violence, who now is changing in a way that is meaningful for their children and their ex-partner or partner, that creates real freedom, real safety, absence of threat, but nurturance and thriving.
- 18:42David Mandel: Because it's not enough to be a parent who just doesn't do harm.
- 18:46Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 18:49David Mandel: We would consider that neglectful.
- 18:50David Mandel: We have to nurture kids.
- 18:52David Mandel: We have to, if a kid has an injury, emotional, psychological, it's our job to be part of the healing of that.
- 19:00Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 19:02David Mandel: So I I ha keep really unlearning this these low expectations of men and men as parents in this uh this sort of really wrestling with what you're talking about, which is what what are our genuine beliefs about men's capacity to be nurturing, connected, caring, admit mistakes, be somebody who can hear somebody else's anger, a loved one's anger, or judgment can accept that prior behavior came at cost that they have to accept and work with.
- 19:42David Mandel: I believe men in general have that capacity, and I believe a lot of men live from that capacity day in and day out.
- 19:55David Mandel: I like I really want to be clear.
- 19:56David Mandel: This is I don't share that view, but you've got to ask yourself do I suck jump over that question and go, well, but she's gotta like she's just it sucks, but she's gotta kind of step up.
- 20:12Ruth Reymundo: You know, I think a lot about the different cultural realities and traditions and linguistic differences that we exist in as a model because we operate globally a lot of across a lot of different contexts that are very different than the English language American perspective.
- 20:37Ruth Reymundo: I think about Japan and its deep sense of collective duty to behave in a way that creates social health, social wealth, social stability, and social cohesion.
- 20:58Ruth Reymundo: And that men are really expected socially to contribute to that reality in those contexts.
- 21:04Ruth Reymundo: Now in America, hyper-independence, right?
- 21:08Ruth Reymundo: Hyper abdication of collective duty to care for each other.
- 21:12Ruth Reymundo: It's it's a mess.
- 21:13Ruth Reymundo: Like we can totally admit hyper-individualism.
- 21:17Ruth Reymundo: But I am fascinated by the fact that even with those deep traditions, many cultures have failed to carry that expectation over to men in their personal relationships, in their familial relationships, and in their family duties.
- 21:40Ruth Reymundo: Not that those men need to do the exact same tasks, day to day tasks.
- 21:45Ruth Reymundo: We can all agree that in relationship, we especially if they're respectful relationships that are grounded in consent, that we each agree upon the ways we're going to contribute.
- 21:59Ruth Reymundo: To our domestic and family life, and it may cross gender expectations and norms.
- 22:05Ruth Reymundo: You love to cook, for example, you love to make and create beautiful food.
- 22:11Ruth Reymundo: I'm kind of tired of doing that after you know 30 years of being a parent.
- 22:16Ruth Reymundo: And so, you know, we agree upon the way that we divide the labor, but it's very interesting to me that reflexively, even professionals in the field cannot wrap their head around and continue to focus on men's behavioral patterns as being not only destructive and disruptive to their intimate relationships and their family bonds and the health and the stability and the resources and the well-being and the future of their children, but also fail to translate how men have a duty and responsibility to our communities, to our societies to reduce their violence, to contribute to society in a positive and nurturing way that is actually protective, right?
- 23:19Ruth Reymundo: Not this fake violence that is called protection, but what is actually long-term protective of our connections, of our relationships, of our bonds, and of the nurturance, the stability, the resources of their own families and children.
- 23:38Ruth Reymundo: And it is such a global phenomenon.
- 23:44Ruth Reymundo: It's such a pattern that it's so deeply embedded in our psyche that we are failing men.
- 23:56David Mandel: You know, it's I I love what you're saying.
- 23:59David Mandel: And um what I would add to it is that what is implicit, I think, in what you're saying is that we have a commitment to men and to kids and to families.
- 24:14David Mandel: And we're talking about whatever constellation of families we're talking about, you know, same-sex couples, you know, different sex couples.
- 24:22David Mandel: Which is that I think there's a way.
- 24:27David Mandel: So when I think about the myth of perpetrator accountability, it's this idea that all of it can be dropped in this bucket of did we arrest him?
- 24:34David Mandel: Did we put a DVO against him?
- 24:35David Mandel: Did we send him a mental behavior change?
- 24:37David Mandel: Is he compliant?
- 24:38David Mandel: You know, is is he is he incarcerated?
- 24:41David Mandel: That that's a lot of what people think when they use the word accountability.
- 24:46David Mandel: I I think that deeper question is can we look at those behaviors and what an intervention with this person is and what are we basing it on?
- 24:55David Mandel: What are we focused on?
- 24:55David Mandel: If we're focusing on just on physical violence, we're missing so much, for instance.
- 24:58David Mandel: Right.
- 24:59David Mandel: But we also need this idea that this person is important to the community.
- 25:06David Mandel: Yeah.
- 25:07David Mandel: This is important to their kids.
- 25:09David Mandel: Yeah.
- 25:09David Mandel: And and what I would say in the vast majority of cases, their partner or ex-partner would say this is an important person to me.
- 25:16David Mandel: Majority, not all of them.
- 25:18David Mandel: I really want to make clear that some people are like, no, he is dead to me.
- 25:22David Mandel: I don't want anything to do with him.
- 25:23David Mandel: He's so dangerous, he's hurt me so much.
- 25:25David Mandel: But I don't think actually the majority of folks, even survivors, have complex feelings about this person, especially the kids with them.
- 25:33David Mandel: And we have to honor those things and say, this person's an important community member.
- 25:37David Mandel: They may be a trauma survivor themselves.
- 25:40David Mandel: They may be struggling with suicidality.
- 25:43David Mandel: We can treat them as a whole person.
- 25:44David Mandel: They're important, but we don't subsume or sort of say, oh, they're important, but there's no sort of focus on responsible behavior or changing in a way that means something.
- 25:58David Mandel: Because you can't be a good member of your community and regularly cause harm or danger to that family or to that community.
- 26:04David Mandel: That you can't be in good standing.
- 26:06David Mandel: Right.
- 26:06David Mandel: But it's a cop out to say, jail is the answer, or that's that sort of fixes something.
- 26:12David Mandel: Right.
- 26:12David Mandel: And it's convenient for systems that treat offenders as one-dimensional that have a history of being racist or colonizing, right?
- 26:25David Mandel: That treat black, brown, indigenous men, men of different backgrounds differently or less than.
- 26:33David Mandel: So it's really convenient to say, oh, here's a criminal versus a community member that we are gonna make a real effort to support them and change in a way that means something for the community and their family.
- 26:53David Mandel: And if they're not willing or able to make that change to do the containment that needs to be done so that people, other people can live free and safe.
- 27:02Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 27:04David Mandel: But it's not a quick, like, oh, well, we we just need to count how many arrests we've done or or or we passed a new law.
- 27:11David Mandel: Look at us, we've done this.
- 27:12David Mandel: That's look what we call course of control, is now in our statutes.
- 27:17David Mandel: Okay.
- 27:19David Mandel: What does that mean for change?
- 27:24Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 27:25Ruth Reymundo: What does that mean for accountability?
- 27:27Ruth Reymundo: Because just because you have a law and it's it's on the books, or just because you have a policy, doesn't actually mean that people are following it to the spirit of how it was written, or I mean this is being it is being used in a way that brings about a better situation.
- 27:45David Mandel: Or or how is it being operationalized inside a child protection system where or a family law system where if somebody really, and this is where we talk about in the the model and the and the the chapter of the book, microaccountability.
- 27:58David Mandel: Microaccountability is this idea.
- 27:59David Mandel: Can you describe what he did?
- 28:01David Mandel: Can you have a holistic look at his parent, of course, control and actions taking harm the kids?
- 28:07David Mandel: Can you now tell the story?
- 28:09David Mandel: And you talk a lot about telling the importance of storytelling, not in a mythic way, but in a like communicative way, which is can you tell the story of how those behaviors have impacted child, partner, and family functioning?
- 28:22David Mandel: If you cannot create that building block of accountability, that microaccountable practice, then you're lost because you don't know the danger, you don't know the risk, you don't know what you're measuring that should be different at the end of an intervention.
- 28:36Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 28:37David Mandel: You don't know how to talk to the survivor about her experience and what he's done and put it into context.
- 28:41David Mandel: It without those micro-accountable accountability practices of documentation assessment, interviewing, you can't build these larger structures of accountability or at least make them successful.
- 28:54David Mandel: You could say we passed a law, right?
- 28:56David Mandel: But does your average child protection worker know how to assess for coerce control and its impact on children and the victim's parenting?
- 29:02R: Right.
- 29:02R: And and just to point out that accountability is not behavior change, yet again.
- 29:07R: Right.
- 29:07R: And that incarceration is not a behavior change strategy.
- 29:11R: It doesn't change people's behaviors.
- 29:14R: In fact, it has been shown to often exacerbate violence, to exacerbate poverty, to exacerbate instability and unhousedness, which are primary factors in the risk of violence by men.
- 29:28R: So, you know, while we have invested trillions and billions of dollars into these carceral systems and to online men's behavior change programs and in-person 12-week, 24-week men's behavior change programs, we have very little evidence that the way that we are going about it is actually making things better, that it is creating behavioral change and giving those men the skills that they need in order to live healthily and safely and without violence and without criminality inside their own relationships.
- 30:13R: And then that expands out from their familial reality into society and into our costs.
- 30:20R: But I guess my question to you would be considering that there really is a myth of accountability, it really is.
- 30:27R: There is there is a myth of male accountability in this world.
- 30:31R: There is a myth of men's behavior change programs being golden bullets to change the reality for men when there's very little evidence that that's actually occurring.
- 30:44R: How do we actually measure if we're system professionals, if we're involved in systems, that change?
- 30:58David Mandel: You know, I there's there's a multi-level answer.
- 31:02David Mandel: One is I look to see if there's good quality information sharing about the perpetrator's behavior and clarity around how it's impacting the functioning and lives and well-being and safety of their immediate family and even extended family.
- 31:22David Mandel: And I again the language we use, and it should be no surprise to anybody, so important, because I really take the language of how does this person's behavior impact the functioning?
- 31:34David Mandel: Not just safety, functioning, going to work, employment, education, social connections, parenting connections, housing, that that we should be able to ask that question, what's different in the lives of of of the this this mom or these kids because this person engaged in this pattern of behavior?
- 31:55David Mandel: It's that simple.
- 31:56David Mandel: So I'm looking for first, is this shared understanding?
- 32:00Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 32:01David Mandel: Is there a plan to address that person's behavior in a way that ideally is collaboratively developed with the survivor?
- 32:10David Mandel: I remember a case I worked on where the social workers' plan was dad had to stop drinking, and the mother and the kid said, that will never work.
- 32:19David Mandel: What will work is we make an agreement as a family that that we will signal to him when he he he he can drink, to say he can't drink, but to that when it becomes a concern that we'll say it, that he'll listen, and he'll take certain steps in the moment.
- 32:38David Mandel: And I know that flies in the face of what systems often want, which is that absolute clear, bright line.
- 32:44David Mandel: What the family says is let us try to manage this together.
- 32:48David Mandel: And so you want those interventions that are collaboratively built, ideally, that and that survivors report back to us to say, this is what's better and this is what's not better, because usually that's the case.
- 33:03David Mandel: And that better is really like, are you free to say things you couldn't say before?
- 33:09David Mandel: Are you free to talk to people you you couldn't talk to before?
- 33:13David Mandel: Are you do you feel like the the danger of retribution for parenting the way you parent is gone?
- 33:19David Mandel: Are you worried that he's not gonna take you to court?
- 33:23Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 33:23David Mandel: And I think that results from a system that is in alignment, family court and child protection sending the same message.
- 33:30David Mandel: We've seen that.
- 33:31David Mandel: When those two systems align, people are more likely to respond in a constructive way, talking about perpetrators, not guaranteed, but we're creating the conditions that produce more success.
- 33:44R: Right.
- 33:45David Mandel: So these are some of the things I look for, but it has to include that understanding that showing up to a meeting, even saying I'm getting a lot from a meeting, these are things I would hear guys say or report back to their probation officer.
- 34:04David Mandel: Well, I love going to group, or he's going to group, or or I've learned a lot from sitting with the other guys that my problems aren't as bad.
- 34:11David Mandel: No, that's not what real change looks like.
- 34:13David Mandel: Real change looks like really what we know, common sense.
- 34:19David Mandel: I did bad things.
- 34:21David Mandel: I was wrong for doing that.
- 34:23David Mandel: People have a right to be angry.
- 34:25David Mandel: I heard you.
- 34:26Ruth Reymundo: I hurt you.
- 34:27David Mandel: I hurt you, and I heard you when you told me when the kids say, I can't go over to dad's today, it's too much for a visit.
- 34:34David Mandel: Can he accept that that's a natural consequence of his behavior and to give the kids the time and space to approach when and if they're ready themselves?
- 34:46Ruth Reymundo: Or can or can the person who was violent accept the financial responsibility for the medical costs of the survivor?
- 34:59Ruth Reymundo: Can they accept that the survivor gets to openly disclose that they are injured and harmed because of somebody else's physical behaviors?
- 35:08Ruth Reymundo: Do they accept that not only from a familial standpoint, I damaged my family, I took from them.
- 35:19Ruth Reymundo: The impact that I had can never be erased.
- 35:24Ruth Reymundo: This person has disabilities, physical disabilities, because of my actions.
- 35:30Ruth Reymundo: Now, there's a place in us that's highly calibrated by carceral systems to say that person must pay in a very specific way.
- 35:40Ruth Reymundo: But that is absolutely against the the rights of survivors.
- 35:46Ruth Reymundo: Survivors, as imperfect as their solutions may appear to professionals in carceral systems, actually should be the people saying what would be meaningful for them.
- 35:58Ruth Reymundo: What is a meaningful compensation?
- 36:01Ruth Reymundo: Is the meaningful compensation financial?
- 36:05Ruth Reymundo: Is it emotional support?
- 36:08Ruth Reymundo: Is it ongoing caretaking because of the disabilities that that person has caused?
- 36:14David Mandel: Right.
- 36:15Ruth Reymundo: Is it what is the form that that takes?
- 36:18Ruth Reymundo: And this is where children and women are just simply not respected and believed by professionals and systems.
- 36:27Ruth Reymundo: And their their measure of what accountability would look like, what meaningful behavior change would look like, is usurped by a system level measure that is often not even measured in an ongoing way, that has no capacity to be linked to their long-term stability and well-being and healing and connections and relationship health.
- 36:57Ruth Reymundo: And so we are living in this systematized institutional world where the institution really takes priority in defining what accountability means, what behavior change means, which is completely dislocated from the reality of the people who are experiencing the violence on the ground.
- 37:19Ruth Reymundo: And I do believe that that has come about from a philosophy of men and their behavior, where the state determines it a benefit for men to be violent and traumatized and impoverished because they use those men as cannon fodder in their wars and in their legal systems, their law enforcement systems.
- 37:48Ruth Reymundo: And they believe that men's violence is a primary and fundamental benefit to them, and so they protect it.
- 37:54Ruth Reymundo: I really do believe that.
- 38:35David Mandel: Yeah.
- 38:35David Mandel: By men, and then a smaller actually number of men and men's violence against women, men's violence being the bigger number of what's happening to women.
- 38:44David Mandel: But I don't when I share that, I don't share it out of this idea that it's an indictment of men as a as a group, but as a doorway to step through that we need to face and say this can be different.
- 39:02David Mandel: Yeah.
- 39:02David Mandel: And this is this is systemic, not biological.
- 39:05David Mandel: Because those are our two choices, basically.
- 39:08Ruth Reymundo: And they're just inherently violent and always will be.
- 39:10Ruth Reymundo: And women will always have to bear the responsibility to have violence in children and the earth and animals.
- 39:17David Mandel: And I and I believe that, and and I agree with you, I think, in this sense, and this may be where we start moving to wrap it up, that we that that I believe that men and women can be violent and can be of abusive, that people human beings are a human issue, that and that really that we have to believe that's possible, and I do, right?
- 39:40David Mandel: That we've created conditions to support men's greater maneuvering room to be violent in bigger ways, more violent, more and that that this is this is changeable.
- 39:50David Mandel: We can change social structures.
- 39:51David Mandel: So I guess I'm a I guess I'm coming down on, and you are too, I'm gonna check this out on the side of optimism.
- 39:58David Mandel: Are you coming down on the side of optimism?
- 40:01Ruth Reymundo: I I really believe that if you cannot envision a world where men are fully capable of relational health and fully capable of being accountable for the behaviors that injure and harm and create distrust and create injury and ill health, then as a species, we're kind of lost.
- 40:36Ruth Reymundo: I don't believe that men are inherently violent.
- 40:40Ruth Reymundo: I believe humans have violence in them, and and that violence that lives in us is actually a part of nature.
- 40:49Ruth Reymundo: It is our self-defense mechanism, it is our way to protect ourselves from threat and from boundary crosses that overtake our being, our rights, our ability to be autonomous and to live in this world and create as individuals and together collectively.
- 41:08Ruth Reymundo: But if we cannot envision a reality where men are fully capable of self-regulation, behavioral, emotional, sexual, then we're never going to bring it about.
- 41:26Ruth Reymundo: So being able to see that world, to see the places where men are fully embodying themselves as adult humans, contributing, nurturing, providing real protection, which real protection is protection of trust, protection of bonds, protection of connection, protection of our togetherness, protection of our resources, protection of our nurturance.
- 41:53Ruth Reymundo: I I do believe that we are totally capable of that, both male and female and beyond of those behaviors.
- 42:04Ruth Reymundo: So I I am definitely a vote for men can men can be fully human.
- 42:14David Mandel: Well, this was as always, this these conversations take amazing turns, and and I hope that people enjoyed this exploration of perpetrator, the myth of perpetrator accountability with a heavy dose of philosophy and deep thinking.
- 42:32David Mandel: Phenomenology led by led by Ruth.
- 42:34David Mandel: So you've been listening to this conversation about the myth of perpetrator accountability.
- 42:39David Mandel: Check out the book, you know, Stop Laying Mothers and Ignoring Fathers, How to Transform the Way We Keep Children Safe from Domestic Violence, because there's tremendous amount more information in there than on the chapter on perpetrator accountability.
- 42:51David Mandel: Check out our conference coming up.
- 42:54David Mandel: Check out our digital coach and insight engine, yeah, which is uh in flight, and we'll be talking more about this on future episodes.
- 43:01David Mandel: And website is safety of the institute dot com.
- 43:05David Mandel: Our virtual site is academy.com.
- 43:09David Mandel: And with that, we out.