Latest / The El Paso Matters Podcast / Execution of El Paso serial killer halted
Transcript
- 0:00In 1987, between Valentine's Day and August of
- 0:03that year, nine women from northeast El Paso
- 0:05went missing. Over the following months, the
- 0:08remains of six of the missing young women and
- 0:10girls were found in shallow graves in the northeast
- 0:12desert where Painted Dunes Golf Course is now
- 0:14located. No sign of the three other women was
- 0:16ever found. It was the worst killing spree El
- 0:19Paso had ever seen until decades later when 23
- 0:21people were murdered in the Walmart mass shooting
- 0:23on August 3rd, 2019. For 32 years, David Leonard
- 0:27Wood has lived on death row after he was convicted
- 0:29by a jury in late 1992 of murdering 23 -year
- 0:33-old Ivy Susanna Williams and at least one of
- 0:35the other five victims whose remains were discovered
- 0:37in the desert. On Thursday of last week, Wood
- 0:40was scheduled to be put to death by lethal injection
- 0:42at the state prison in Huntsville, Texas. But
- 0:45the state's court of criminal appeals on Tuesday
- 0:47stepped in to block the execution. To help us
- 0:49understand Wood's case and the implication for
- 0:51criminal justice in El Paso, we welcome El Paso
- 0:53Matters founder and CEO Bob Moore to the show.
- 0:56Bob, thanks for joining me. Thanks for having
- 0:58me, Diego. So Bob, can you walk us through the
- 1:00latest update in Wood's case and why Texas's
- 1:02highest criminal court halted his execution last
- 1:04week? And I think it's worth noting it's an unusual
- 1:06step for the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals
- 1:09in particular to step in at kind of the last
- 1:12moment like this. It's obviously a very conservative
- 1:14court that has not historically been open to
- 1:18a lot of arguments around the death penalty.
- 1:21This court also has rejected most of David Wood's
- 1:25appeals over the years too. Last August that
- 1:31an execution date was set for March 13th 2025
- 1:34for David Leonard would Starting toward the end
- 1:39of last year and then really accelerating over
- 1:41the last few weeks His defense attorneys have
- 1:44filed a number of appeals both with the Texas
- 1:47Court of Criminal Appeals and with a couple of
- 1:50federal courts up until two days before the scheduled
- 1:56execution date appeals courts had not been particularly
- 2:00open to any of the arguments coming from Wood's
- 2:04lawyers. As a matter of fact, a couple of hours
- 2:07before the Court of Criminal Appeals weighed
- 2:09in, a federal court had rejected another one
- 2:12of his appeals. But then on Tuesday, March 11th,
- 2:18probably around 1 o 'clock our time, I was checking
- 2:21the Court of Criminal Appeals website, and I
- 2:23noticed that they had entered a stay of execution,
- 2:26which I think surprised a lot of people. It took
- 2:31about 15, 20 minutes for the document to come
- 2:33up on the website, which is always unnerving
- 2:35for a journalist. That's like, I want to see
- 2:37what the ruling is. And when the ruling came
- 2:41out, the Court of Criminal Appeals really did
- 2:44not. outline why they stopped the execution.
- 2:47All they did was note the issues that the defense
- 2:51had raised in its latest appeal and basically
- 2:54said, no further action on this case until we
- 2:57have some time to think about it. So we don't
- 3:00know. how long the stay will remain in place.
- 3:05But my understanding of Texas law is that a new
- 3:09execution date can't be set any sooner than 60
- 3:12days after a final ruling from an appeals court.
- 3:16So my guess is we're probably looking at months,
- 3:20possibly years before another execution date
- 3:23might be set. And this wasn't the first time
- 3:25that a court stepped in to block Woods execution.
- 3:28Is that right? Yeah, so, you know, and I mentioned
- 3:30at the outset that this is a very conservative
- 3:33court that doesn't tend to block executions,
- 3:36but it also happened in 2009, in that case, a
- 3:40day before Wood was scheduled to be executed
- 3:43when the Court of Criminal Appeals granted a
- 3:45stay so that the courts could review a claim
- 3:48that Wood was making that he had intellectual
- 3:51development disabilities that would preclude
- 3:54him from execution under some fairly recent Supreme
- 3:57Court rulings. that those claims were then looked
- 4:01at over the years and eventually rejected in
- 4:042014 at every level. At that point, Wood's lawyers
- 4:10had also begun to make a number of requests for
- 4:13DNA testing of evidence. Obviously, back in 1987,
- 4:17DNA testing was in its infancy, really. And so
- 4:21Wood's argument was, let's test a lot of this
- 4:24evidence to make sure he's the guy. And initially,
- 4:27in 2010, the trial judge did grant a request
- 4:32to test three bits of evidence that were found
- 4:35from three different victims. and they were all
- 4:39blood droplets. Two of the blood tests came back
- 4:43inconclusive. The third excluded wood as a contributor
- 4:47of the sample. His defense lawyers have long
- 4:51maintained that that's exculpatory evidence,
- 4:53meaning evidence that points to his innocence.
- 4:56Prosecutors and courts have disagreed with that,
- 4:59saying it would not have changed a jury verdict.
- 5:02And so the Texas Attorney General's Office, which
- 5:05has been handling these appeals for... complicated
- 5:09reasons that we can get into has resisted at
- 5:12every turn any further DNA tests and the Court
- 5:16of Criminal Appeals and the federal courts have
- 5:18upheld those decisions. The latest appeal really
- 5:21doesn't necessarily ask for more DNA tests, but
- 5:25in claiming actual innocence, I think is trying
- 5:28to set the grounds for getting the courts to
- 5:32eventually be more amenable to maybe future requests
- 5:34for DNA testing. Yeah. And so I guess going forward
- 5:37from here, what do you expect to happen with
- 5:39this case? And curious if you can talk about
- 5:41the attorney general's involvement at all. Yeah.
- 5:44So not having a roadmap of an opinion from the
- 5:48Court of Criminal Appeals is very difficult to
- 5:50kind of see what's going to go on. My best guess
- 5:54is the court said, hey, there are some issues
- 5:57here that we probably should check out before.
- 6:00allowing somebody to be executed. And so they
- 6:04may have oral arguments in that. I don't know.
- 6:08So we'll have to see. But as I said, I think
- 6:11we're probably months or years, again, away from
- 6:14an execution date. The attorney general is involved
- 6:17because in 1992, Jaime Esparza was elected the
- 6:23district attorney in in Texas. He took office
- 6:27Essentially a month and a half after the trial
- 6:30ended and wood was sentenced to death He had
- 6:33beaten the incumbent DA a guy named Steve Simmons
- 6:36in the Democratic primary earlier that year for
- 6:40a day or two in 1990 Jaime Esparza was appointed
- 6:45to represent David Leonard Wood as a defense
- 6:47lawyer. Wood, by the way, quickly said, hey,
- 6:49that guy used to work for the DA's office. I
- 6:51don't want him anywhere near me. And so Esparza's
- 6:55appointment was then rescinded. But because he
- 6:57had represented Wood for less than 48 hours in
- 7:031990, his office disqualified itself from handling
- 7:07any of the appeals. as far as a left office in
- 7:112020, but the attorney general was appointed
- 7:14essentially the acting district attorney for
- 7:19this case and has remained so. Wood's lawyer,
- 7:24a guy named Gregory Wiershock, sort of asked
- 7:28James Montoya, the current DA, if he would take
- 7:31the case back and make his own decisions about
- 7:34whether to allow DNA tests. Take the legalese
- 7:38out of it James Montoya said now we good and
- 7:42he didn't want anything to do with this case
- 7:44So it's remained with the Attorney General's
- 7:47office the we're shocked accused Montoya of cowardice
- 7:51essentially for not taking it back, but I you
- 7:54know that We can talk about this more to that
- 7:57as you know The DA's office has a lot of challenges
- 8:00that they're dealing with now including the Walmart
- 8:02case and for a variety of reasons I think Montoya
- 8:05is not interested in taking on a case that the
- 8:09office hasn't touched for 30 years it would Delay
- 8:12the CA, you know the wood case for another five
- 8:14or ten years for sure if they did that Yeah,
- 8:17and one thing I should have touched on before
- 8:20Despite Wood maintaining his innocence and lawyers
- 8:23making various arguments about that, Wood did
- 8:25have a criminal history prior to the conviction
- 8:27for these murders, is that right? Yeah, that's
- 8:29an important point too. He grew up in Northeast
- 8:32El Paso, dropped out of Parkland High School
- 8:35when he was 16 or 17. He never really got out
- 8:40of his freshman year of high school, which is
- 8:44kind of part of the argument around his intellectual
- 8:46development disability. But he was. Did some
- 8:51kind of petty crimes to begin with and then was
- 8:54found guilty of a couple of sexual assault charges.
- 8:57Got a five year sentence out of that in 1980.
- 9:02He served two years and and was released and
- 9:07then kind of almost immediately again arrested
- 9:09on rape charges or upside down. Those sexual
- 9:13assault charges are 78 in 1980. He gets arrested
- 9:16on these two rape charges, gets a 20 year sentence
- 9:19and is released. a little over six years into
- 9:21that sentence. comes back to El Paso in January
- 9:26of 1987. And on February 14th, Valentine's Day
- 9:30of 1987, the first young girl, Marjorie Knox,
- 9:33who lived in Chaparral, New Mexico, right next
- 9:36to Northeast El Paso, disappeared. So these disappearances
- 9:40at least coincide with Wood's return to El Paso.
- 9:44And one of the things that cops have always insisted
- 9:47on this is these things didn't start until Wood
- 9:50was here, and they ended. after he got arrested,
- 9:53which is not proof that he did it, but to investigators,
- 9:58it was kind of a strong indicator that they had
- 10:00gotten the right guy. Yeah, and Bob, you've been
- 10:03a journalist in El Paso since the mid -1980s
- 10:05and followed the story intimately for decades.
- 10:07Can you talk about your personal experience with
- 10:09this really grisly story? Yeah, and there's a
- 10:12really important journalism lesson in all of
- 10:15this that I've carried with me ever since. So
- 10:19these disappearances started in February of 1987
- 10:24by the summer. I think six or seven girls and
- 10:29young women had disappeared. Over a couple of
- 10:33days in June of 1987, two girls disappeared back
- 10:37to back, Desiree Wheatley and Karen Baker. Desiree
- 10:41was 15, Karen Baker was 20. In July, their mothers,
- 10:47Marsha Wheatley at the time, she's now known
- 10:48as Marsha Fulton, and Mary Baker started going
- 10:52to the media and saying, hey, these... There's
- 10:55something going on here There are girls who are
- 10:57missing and the police aren't paying any attention
- 11:00and I was not directly involved in the reporting
- 11:02But I was supervising the reporters doing that
- 11:05and when we would check with the police on Like
- 11:08hey, these moms say their kids are in danger
- 11:11The police would tell us, you know, there are
- 11:14runaways and yes a couple of prostitutes have
- 11:18disappeared But hey that happens they go from
- 11:21from city to city so The media, including the
- 11:25El Paso Times, where I was working at the time,
- 11:28basically just went with the police story and
- 11:30didn't report that a number of young girls were
- 11:34missing, or girls and young women were missing
- 11:37from Northeast El Paso. did not change. There
- 11:41was, I think in July of 1987, Mary Baker and
- 11:47Marsha Wheatley went down to the Stanton Street
- 11:50Bridge and staged a protest to try to draw some
- 11:53attention. I went back and looked at the El Paso
- 11:57Times coverage. The El Paso Times ran three paragraphs
- 11:59and a photograph about that. The Herald Post,
- 12:03the other paper at the time, wrote a little bit
- 12:06longer story. And my recollection is the TV station.
- 12:09This was a Saturday, so they kind of covered
- 12:11it with some video on the Saturday newscast.
- 12:14And that was it. Nobody followed up on it or
- 12:17anything like, hey, is there something to what
- 12:18these moms are saying? That all changed in September
- 12:22when the first two bodies were found. Karen Baker
- 12:25was one of the first two bodies that was found.
- 12:28And then in October, Desiree Wheatley's body
- 12:32was found. And so over the years, I have the
- 12:37pleasure of getting to know Marcia, her mom.
- 12:41I've gotten to be really friendly with her over
- 12:42the years. She married a wonderful guy named
- 12:45Robert Fulton, who used to be the head of the
- 12:47El Paso Zoo. And so I had conversations with
- 12:51her over the years about what had happened and
- 12:55kind of expressing my regrets that we didn't
- 12:57listen to her. And I don't think forgiving is
- 13:00the right word, but she was understanding. And
- 13:02she would say, You're just listening to what
- 13:04the police told you. And then and then I would
- 13:07ask her about, you know, her frustrations with
- 13:10the initial police investigation. And she acknowledged
- 13:13she's very frustrated and and didn't and didn't
- 13:18think they took it seriously enough. But she
- 13:20also said, you know, to be fair to them, they'd
- 13:24never had to investigate a serial killing before.
- 13:26So I understand why they may have been very slow
- 13:31to do this. So Marsha is a person of great grace.
- 13:35So I think she has more understanding than I
- 13:37might have in those situations. So I've stayed
- 13:40in touch with her over the years. She has become
- 13:44one of only two certified wildlife rehabilitators
- 13:48in El Paso. And so she takes care of mammals,
- 13:53baby squirrels and raccoons and things like that.
- 13:57So, you know, talked with her over that. About
- 14:00that a lot over the years and then when the execution
- 14:04date was set I called her up and I said If it's
- 14:09okay with you, I will volunteer to be a media
- 14:12witness to the execution But I'm only going to
- 14:14do it if it's okay with you and she said that
- 14:17that's fine I'd love to have you there and so
- 14:20we've kind of stayed in in contact and then In
- 14:24February as the date got nearer. She and I sat
- 14:27down and she really Walked me through in great
- 14:31detail. What happened? The day Desi disappeared
- 14:35also talked about who she was as a child, but
- 14:38she disappeared on the last day of school Which
- 14:41played a role in why the police didn't? respond
- 14:44as quickly as possible because they were thinking
- 14:47all kids are just goofy on the last day of school
- 14:49and So she talked about the last time she saw
- 14:53Desi Marsha was a night shift worker. And so
- 14:56the last time she saw Desi was that morning,
- 15:00June 2nd, she had taken her to a couple stores
- 15:03to try to find some film for her camera. And
- 15:07Desi had also asked if she could wear a white
- 15:08t -shirt to school that day so she could get
- 15:11her friends to sign it. And so Marcia was driving
- 15:14them back home. Desi had her t -shirt on. And
- 15:18they only lived a block or two from H .E. Charles
- 15:21School where Desi was going to middle school.
- 15:23She was an eighth grader. And Desi and kind of
- 15:27girls will do this with their mom, said, you
- 15:29can just drop me off here and I'll just walk
- 15:31the rest of the way. And so Marsha said, OK.
- 15:34So kind of dropped her off about half a block
- 15:37from the school. And Desi started to walk away
- 15:40and turned around back to Marsha and said, love
- 15:43you, mom. And Marsha said she just loved Desi.
- 15:49And that was the last time. They saw each other
- 15:53she came home from work that night at two in
- 15:57the morning and she was living with with her
- 16:00parents Marsha was She recently divorced and
- 16:04trying to get back on her feet and her mother
- 16:06said something's wrong as he didn't come home
- 16:08And so that was kind of the the beginning of
- 16:11the nightmare So stayed in touch with with Marsha
- 16:15over the years and she told me this really powerful
- 16:17story, which we published at El Paso matters.
- 16:22But a couple of days after I interviewed her,
- 16:24she got really sick and eventually developed
- 16:26pneumonia. And I wasn't sure whether she was
- 16:31going to be able to continue with her plans to
- 16:33go to the execution, which is really important
- 16:36for her because she, when they found Desi's body
- 16:44in October, And the medical examiner finally
- 16:47released it, and they were able to bury her at
- 16:49Reslon Cemetery in early November of 1987. And
- 16:54she made a pledge to Desi at her grave that she
- 16:58would make sure that whoever did this got caught.
- 17:01And Marcia, just to be clear, was a major reason
- 17:05that David was eventually arrested. She put a
- 17:08lot of pressure on the police to solve this case.
- 17:15she believed that she would be able to fulfill
- 17:17that promise by witnessing Wood's execution.
- 17:21It became really uncertain for a while that she
- 17:24was going to be able to go. She was in the hospital
- 17:27for a little bit. And then I think about a week
- 17:30before the execution, she finally got out of
- 17:32the hospital, was able to come home. She got
- 17:36off of oxygen. And so by Monday of that week,
- 17:41were pretty clear that she was going to be able
- 17:43to go. And then on Tuesday, she got a call from
- 17:46the Texas Department of Criminal Justice letting
- 17:47her know that the stay had been issued. And she
- 17:52was very, very mad. And she tells me that she
- 17:56doesn't want to be angry because she doesn't
- 17:59see that as a helpful emotion. It just hurts
- 18:01her. And so she has come to terms with it. But
- 18:06she thinks that the criminal justice system views
- 18:10this as a game that's a term she's used over
- 18:13and over again with me and So but she's she says
- 18:17she remains Committed to fulfilling that promise
- 18:21and I think she's 72 years old now wood is almost
- 18:2568 the one thing she says she won't let happen
- 18:30is she's Not going to die before he does and
- 18:33so she wants to be able to continue to do that
- 18:37It's obviously a lot of emotion with all the
- 18:39years of following this The murders and disappearances
- 18:43in the late 1980s was the worst killing spree
- 18:45El Paso had seen for decades Until a man murdered
- 18:4823 people at a Walmart here on August 3rd 2019
- 18:50So I wonder Bob what implications if any do you
- 18:53think woods case has on the prosecution of the
- 18:55alleged Walmart shooter? For whom the state of
- 18:57Texas is still pursuing the death penalty It's
- 18:59a very important and timely question in some
- 19:02ways. I mentioned earlier that James Montoya
- 19:05is the new DA in El Paso. The three previous
- 19:11DAs who've handled this case have all said they
- 19:14want to pursue the death penalty. You covered
- 19:17the DA's election. So you talked to Montoya a
- 19:19lot about this. And your coverage really documented
- 19:23sort of a. an evolving position that he had throughout
- 19:28the campaign. I think initially he was like,
- 19:30yes, we want to pursue the death penalty. That
- 19:33decision should be made by a jury. I think by
- 19:35the end of the campaign he was telling you there's
- 19:38some things we need to look at. And so I think
- 19:41sometime. Soon probably within days no more than
- 19:47a couple weeks He's probably going to have to
- 19:48make a decision on whether he's going to pursue
- 19:51the death penalty And I think the wood case it
- 19:55could be instructive in some ways Your wood has
- 20:00been on at death row as you mentioned for more
- 20:02than 32 years There actually are a couple of
- 20:06people who've been on death row a little bit
- 20:07longer wood would have served longer on death
- 20:10row than any other executed inmate if the sentence
- 20:13had been carried out. And there's another person
- 20:17on death row from El Paso, a guy named Tony Ford,
- 20:22who was sent to death row about a year after
- 20:24what he's still there too. So El Paso has this
- 20:26history of people being on death row for a long
- 20:31time, which is prosecuting death penalty cases.
- 20:36keeping people on death row is a very expensive
- 20:40process. So that's one thing I think the DA is
- 20:44going to have to weigh, is in some ways the Walmart
- 20:50case is a little bit more sort of clear cut in
- 20:53terms of evidence than the Wood case was, but
- 20:58in other ways. Because of what happened when
- 21:01Yvonne Rosales was the district attorney and
- 21:04and some of the disastrous decisions that she
- 21:07and her people made especially around the Walmart
- 21:10case You're going after one of the families of
- 21:14one of the victims who would not participate
- 21:17in this scheme They wanted to pull off to sort
- 21:20of target the judge in the case and get him recused
- 21:23that has created a real mess and has allowed
- 21:27the defense to make allegations of prosecutorial
- 21:30misconduct that will, if Patrick Crucius is found
- 21:35guilty and sentenced to death, those prosecutorial
- 21:39misconduct claims will probably tie up the appeals
- 21:43courts for years and years and years. So that's
- 21:46one thing that. The lesson of the David Wood
- 21:51case, I think, is going to be weighing in Montoya's
- 21:54decision. And to be clear, I don't know what
- 21:57decision he's going to make. He also has to decide,
- 22:01you know, it's a political decision, too. What
- 22:04do El Paso voters want? And the Walmart case,
- 22:09obviously... in your coverage was a big issue
- 22:13in the DA's race. Bill Hicks, the appointed incumbent
- 22:17that he ran against, who replaced Ivan Rosales,
- 22:20was very adamant that he wanted to pursue the
- 22:22death penalty. And as I mentioned, Montoya was
- 22:26adamant initially, but then he never said he
- 22:29wasn't going to do it, but he began to introduce
- 22:31these questions. So it's going to be an interesting
- 22:35decision. The other thing that Montoya will have
- 22:38to weigh one of the Things that you have to prove
- 22:41in Texas in order to get a death sentence is
- 22:45that the defendant represents a future danger,
- 22:48not just that he did horrible things in the past,
- 22:51but he would be a danger in the future. As I
- 22:54think most people know, Patrick Crucius also
- 22:56faced federal charges. hate crimes and weapons
- 22:59charges, the federal government decided not to
- 23:02pursue the death penalty. He quickly pleaded
- 23:04guilty and was sentenced to 90 consecutive life
- 23:08terms. And the judge's recommendation, which
- 23:10is not binding on the Bureau of Prisons, but
- 23:13they'll have to take it into account, the judge's
- 23:15recommendation was that he be sent to the Supermax
- 23:18prison in Florence, Colorado, which is the nation's
- 23:22most secure prison. So. Can already hear the
- 23:26defense team making these arguments in the penalty
- 23:28phase of a state trial Like our client is going
- 23:31to be locked up in a hole essentially for the
- 23:34rest of his life He does not represent a danger
- 23:37to anybody That will present a challenge before
- 23:41before jurors and so this is Definitely an emotional
- 23:47case. It means a lot to El Pasoans The median
- 23:53age of people in El Paso, I think, is 34, which
- 23:56means that half of all of our population wasn't
- 23:59born in 1987 when David Wood was convicted of
- 24:04doing these crimes. So a lot of people have no
- 24:07memory of the emotions around that. But at the
- 24:11time, for those of us who were there, and especially
- 24:14girls and young women of that era, that was a
- 24:18deeply emotional case, much like the Walmart
- 24:21case is now, that sort of reshaped people's views
- 24:26of the world that they lived in. All of a sudden,
- 24:30girls had to worry about going to the Circle
- 24:33K at night and would they disappear. So that
- 24:36was a deeply emotional case just as this was.
- 24:40There was no question in the 1990s when the case
- 24:44finally went to trial that the state was going
- 24:46to seek the death penalty. It's also interesting
- 24:49to note that David Wood's trial had to be moved
- 24:53out of El Paso. It was held in Dallas because
- 24:56of pretrial publicity, which added to the delay
- 24:59in the expense of the trial. In the Walmart case,
- 25:04both the defense and prosecution have said that
- 25:07they want the trial to be held in El Paso, but
- 25:10that may prove. not to be possible once they
- 25:14start talking to potential jurors. They may say,
- 25:17oh, David Wood can't, or I'm sorry, Patrick Cruz
- 25:19just can't get a fair trial in El Paso, so we
- 25:22have to move it somewhere else. That will then
- 25:24add years of delay to the case. So all of these
- 25:28factors are something that James Montoya is gonna
- 25:30have to take into account in deciding whether
- 25:32to pursue the death penalty. And the Wood case,
- 25:35I think, offers some illustrations for him. Yeah,
- 25:39you've done powerful reporting on this Bob and
- 25:41listeners can continue to read our coverage of
- 25:42David Leonard Woods case as well as updates on
- 25:44the case against the Walmart mass shooter at
- 25:46El Paso matters org Thanks for joining me. Thanks
- 25:50for having me