Latest / Interfaiths / Interfaiths: Public Scholarship, Shi’ism, and the Middle East with Dr. Juan Cole
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome again to our Interfaiths podcast for
- 0:04our FIU online course. My name is Professor Iqbal
- 0:07Akhtar in the Department of Religious Studies
- 0:09and Politics and International Relations, and
- 0:11we're very honored today to have Professor Juan
- 0:14Cole at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor,
- 0:18who is one of the top scholars of the Islamic
- 0:21world, Middle East, with us here today. He's
- 0:24here for a conference. We were very lucky to
- 0:26grab him for a few minutes. So I think let's
- 0:31get started. Maybe talk to us a little bit about
- 0:33your background and kind of how you got, maybe
- 0:36a little bit about kind of where you grew up
- 0:40and how you, you know, what took you on this
- 0:43path. I know you went on a Fulbright to India
- 0:46eventually, but kind of. What was kind of your
- 0:49early experiences that might have geared you
- 0:52towards kind of this type of intellectual journey?
- 0:55Sure. My father was in the U .S. military. And
- 0:59I grew up traveling. I went to 12 schools in
- 1:0312 years. And we had two long tours in Europe,
- 1:08in France. And when I was a teenager, we had
- 1:15a posting. a year and a half in Eritrea. It was
- 1:21then part of Ethiopia. Eritrea is a multicultural
- 1:26place. It's probably a third Muslim. It's a multicultural
- 1:38place, Eritrea. About one -third Muslim, two
- 1:41-thirds Christian. There were mosques and you
- 1:45heard the call to prayer and we had Eritrean
- 1:50Muslim friends. So that was my first serious
- 1:55contact with the Muslim world there in the Horn
- 2:00of Africa. And then when I got back to the States,
- 2:07it was the late 60s. But still the 60s. Right.
- 2:13So, you know, my generation was interested in
- 2:16spirituality, alternative states of consciousness.
- 2:20I read a lot about Sufism, for instance. And
- 2:25so when I went to college at Northwestern, I
- 2:33majored in history of religions. I was very interested
- 2:38in all the world religions, but especially, I
- 2:42would say, in Asian ones. So Islam and Hinduism
- 2:48and Buddhism were special interests of mine.
- 2:52And I began actually taking Arabic when I was
- 2:58an undergraduate. I was only 19 when I started.
- 3:01This is early for most Americans. Of course.
- 3:04Often they don't get to Arabic until they're
- 3:06already graduate students. I think that was something
- 3:09that helped me as I had early exposure to it.
- 3:13So we had a wonderful program at Northwestern
- 3:20called the Traveling Scholars. It had been endowed
- 3:23by an alumnus. I was able to, all of us, it was
- 3:29a competition. So you designed a research project.
- 3:31I had a friend who designed a project on Dickens'
- 3:35London. So he would go around to the places that
- 3:37were described in the novels and set it into
- 3:41context. So I put together a project on Christian
- 3:44-Muslim dialogue in Lebanon. After the Second
- 3:52Vatican Council, there was an encouragement by
- 3:57the Catholic Church of dialogue with the other
- 4:00religions. And the Second Vatican Council's documents
- 4:05about Islam are actually quite positive and talks
- 4:10about, from a Catholic point of view, it talks
- 4:15about the light of Christ being present in Islam,
- 4:19praises Muslims for honoring Jesus and Mary.
- 4:22It was a document you couldn't have imagined
- 4:26it a century before. And so the church was encouraging
- 4:31Catholic intellectuals to engage with their Muslim
- 4:35counterparts. And of course, Lebanon was a perfect
- 4:37place for this. So there were a series of dialogue
- 4:41meetings and some publications came out of it.
- 4:45Some high -powered Lebanese... intellectuals
- 4:49were involved. So I had read about it and I wanted
- 4:53to go and interview the principals, the participants,
- 4:56and I was able to get this grant from Northwestern
- 4:59to go. I had already started Modern Standard
- 5:04Arabic, but I didn't speak Arabic. I was doing
- 5:09it as a book language, but when I was in Beirut
- 5:13I was able to take a class in colloquial Lebanese
- 5:18Arabic so that I could actually learn to speak
- 5:20the language. When I first arrived in Lebanon,
- 5:23I would say things from my modern standard Arabic.
- 5:27People would fall down laughing. It's like speaking
- 5:29Shakespearean English to someone. Well, so I
- 5:36didn't know this at the time, but I was already
- 5:38set on a path because I had a friend in Cairo
- 5:42who was kind of a slacker, and I met him a few
- 5:47years later, and he was wearing a business suit
- 5:49and had a Belize. And I said, dude, what happened
- 5:52to you? It was like a pothead originally. So
- 5:56he said, well, you know, we studied Arabic. I
- 6:00said, yes. He said, you don't realize it at the
- 6:03time, but after a while, when you study something
- 6:06like Arabic, it's what you've got going for you.
- 6:09And so he had ended up being hired to teach Arabic
- 6:12as a second language. And this is what happened
- 6:19to me, is that scholarship runs along language
- 6:22lines. And if you're going to be a scholar of
- 6:26Buddhism, then you would want to know Sanskrit
- 6:29and Chinese and Japanese and so forth. So since
- 6:32I had decided to learn Arabic, it's what I had
- 6:36going for me. Interesting. Okay. I mean, just
- 6:41kind of a tangent, that period where in the 60s,
- 6:44where people were experimenting with different
- 6:46types of spirituality. I mean, it seems that
- 6:50there was a point in American history where Sufism
- 6:54actually was quite viable as kind of one of these
- 6:57sort of alternative pathways. I mean, I think
- 6:59what ends up happening, like Sufism, Hinduism,
- 7:02and Buddhism. It seems like they were some of
- 7:06the three biggest ones, I think, that were kind
- 7:08of like competing for the spirituality. And it
- 7:10seems like Buddhism eventually ends up winning
- 7:12as kind of like the main one, I think. But Sufism,
- 7:15do you feel that, did it not really resonate
- 7:19with Americans because of the inherent qualities
- 7:25of Sufism? Or do you think it was the geopolitics
- 7:28of like Iran and things like that that kind of
- 7:30made it less? appealing to Americans. Well, it's
- 7:37true that I think there's a lot more awareness
- 7:40of and interest in Buddhism among that community
- 7:44of Americans who are interested in Eastern religions.
- 7:48I don't think the Sufism ever really went away,
- 7:51though. There's a small minority of people who...
- 7:58I mean, of course, there are many immigrant Sufis,
- 8:01like the Senegalese are all Sufis and so forth.
- 8:04But among native -born Americans, there's a certain
- 8:09interest in it, even to this day. There are directories
- 8:13of Sufi organizations in all the major cities
- 8:15and so forth. But it's a relatively small phenomenon.
- 8:18You're right, compared to Buddhism. And I couldn't
- 8:22tell you why. You know, this is one of the problems
- 8:25in the history of religions is that we know things
- 8:28change, but people don't typically write in their
- 8:33diary the reasons for which they have made these
- 8:35changes. So I think that would be a big research
- 8:38project to do the interviews. And of course,
- 8:41we're trying to answer a negative. Right, exactly.
- 8:43Why it didn't happen, exactly. So you spent this
- 8:48time in... In Lebanon, looking at Christian -Muslim
- 8:52relations, what were some takeaways from that
- 8:56experience? What did you notice or understand?
- 8:59What were the challenges that Vatican II presented
- 9:02to the relationship between Christians and Muslims?
- 9:06Christians and Muslims in Lebanon. Well, in Lebanon,
- 9:12religion was very siloed. And even I found, to
- 9:17my amazement, That I knew much more about Islam
- 9:20than most Christian Lebanese did. They don't
- 9:23talk to their Muslim neighbors about religion.
- 9:26So then they're ignorant. And like the Lebanese
- 9:30Muslims often didn't know very much about Christianity.
- 9:34That was why the dialogue movement was useful.
- 9:39That was one of the takeaways, was how siloed
- 9:42people can be and how ignorant they can be even
- 9:45of a reality that lives across the hall from
- 9:49them. That's what I've learned generally, I think,
- 9:51in terms of my own research in Africa and other
- 9:53places, is that you have very multi -ethnic,
- 10:00multi -religious societies, but people simply
- 10:03do not... talk about religion or really engage
- 10:06theologically at all and i think that's a very
- 10:08modern phenomenon i think that really comes out
- 10:10of kind of the modern interfaith movement this
- 10:12idea that you can actually talk about your religion
- 10:14to other people in a way that is also um not
- 10:17proselytizing because i think that's another
- 10:19way that muslims have kind of dealt with christianity
- 10:21is they're like okay well they're just trying
- 10:23to convert me or you know but actually just being
- 10:25able to understand just being able to understand
- 10:27so that you have a more harmonious sort of uh
- 10:30world right and a better understanding rather
- 10:32than just prejudice you know That's right. Another
- 10:36takeaway was that as I did my research on this
- 10:40dialogue movement, I found I was hobbled by not
- 10:43knowing enough history. I needed to know more
- 10:47about the history of the Maronite Church, for
- 10:49instance, and the history of Islam. And so I
- 10:53spent a lot of time reading history. I was a
- 10:58religion major, so it hadn't originally occurred
- 11:01to me. Focusing more on the theology. Yeah. And
- 11:03then I liked reading the history. So it was one
- 11:10of my transitions to being a historian. Talk
- 11:12a little bit about that transition. Well, I think
- 11:17the nail in the coffin was the Lebanese Civil
- 11:19War. Of course. After being graduated from Northwestern
- 11:24in 1975, I went back to Lebanon. to try to do
- 11:29an MA in religion at the American University
- 11:32in Beirut. They were the only institution in
- 11:37the Middle East that offered a religion degree.
- 11:41Not a seminary kind of degree, but the history
- 11:45of religions as an academic discipline was actually
- 11:48practiced in Lebanon. It really wasn't allowed
- 11:51in Egypt. There was opposition from some of the
- 11:54more hidebound clerics to the whole idea. And
- 11:59so, but when I got to the campus, the war had
- 12:04broken out. And there was a big battle for control
- 12:09of the hotels downtown. You know how in the old
- 12:14World War II movies, they talk about the need
- 12:17to take the hill? Right. So it's because it's
- 12:20high and you can dominate. the surrounding area
- 12:23from it, set up mortars and stuff. The same thing
- 12:26is true of tall buildings in modern urban warfare.
- 12:29So they were fighting for control of these tall
- 12:31buildings. You know, nice tourist hotels, and
- 12:35they gradually looked like Swiss cheese. You
- 12:38could see this happening from the campus of the
- 12:41American University of Beirut. It's up high.
- 12:43You could look down on this. You could see the
- 12:48trails of the rockets and so forth. So they called
- 12:52us all together and said, go away. The university
- 12:57is not going to open this year. And we might
- 13:00see you next fall if things settle down. So I
- 13:04went to Jordan for a while and then applied to
- 13:09the American University in Cairo. I saw the writing
- 13:11on the wall. It's not going to end any time soon.
- 13:14Yeah, Beirut was not going to settle down. And
- 13:17so I went to the American University in Cairo
- 13:19for my MA. And I was determined to do an MA in
- 13:22the area because I wanted to get my Arabic near
- 13:25native fluent. And you can't do that very easily
- 13:28in the United States. And in addition to which,
- 13:31I was reacting against the American. academic
- 13:38tradition. People would go and do a nine -month
- 13:41Fulbright semester and come back, and then they
- 13:43would be an expert in that for the rest of their
- 13:45lives, and they would mostly live in the United
- 13:46States. I wanted to know the ins and outs. I
- 13:49wanted to get deep. So I ended up living almost
- 13:52five years from the time I went to Beirut at
- 13:58first until I finally came back to the United
- 14:00States in the region. So I did an MA in Cairo.
- 14:06They didn't have a religion program. They did
- 14:09have a history program. So I moved to history.
- 14:16I worked on Muslim reformers of the 19th century,
- 14:21but from a historical point of view rather than
- 14:24a theological one. Then when I ultimately went
- 14:29to UCLA, I'd already gotten some training as
- 14:31a historian. I started to think of that as my
- 14:34discipline. I also have to tell you that I reacted
- 14:38a little bit against the disciplinary underlying
- 14:41ideas of the history of religions as I was taught
- 14:45it as an undergraduate. We were under the shadow
- 14:48of the University of Chicago. And philosophically
- 14:52speaking, It was phenomenology of religion that
- 14:56was ascendant, which is a little bit ahistorical.
- 15:00It was all about myth cycles and things like
- 15:04that. First of all, it wasn't very relevant to
- 15:06Islamic studies. Mostly it developed out of Hinduism
- 15:11and Christianity and Buddhism. And I don't know
- 15:16what myth cycles are there in Islam. I mean,
- 15:19that's silly. But then also phenomenology seemed
- 15:24to be kind of detached from concrete reality.
- 15:28And I became interested in the way that history
- 15:34is researched and the use of archives and personal
- 15:38papers and getting deep into the details of a
- 15:43person's mind and thought at a level that I think
- 15:46phenomenology doesn't allow. I think also just
- 15:52personally and philosophically, I moved to being
- 15:55a historian. Okay. That's very interesting. So
- 15:59you ended up going on a Fulbright? Well, I went
- 16:05to UCLA for my PhD work, and I initially had
- 16:10gone back to Lebanon, by the way, in the meantime,
- 16:13and I worked for a newspaper there. Because we
- 16:18thought the Lebanese Civil War might be over
- 16:20in 78, and then it wasn't. So I was working for
- 16:25this newspaper. Sometimes we couldn't put the
- 16:30paper to bed because Syrian artillery had knocked
- 16:34out the electricity or things like that happened.
- 16:37And so I could see there wasn't a future for
- 16:42me as a newspaperman in Beirut. And I went to
- 16:44UCLA to do a PhD. But when I was in Beirut, it
- 16:49was during the Iranian Revolution. And the Iranian
- 16:53Revolution was a local story in Beirut because
- 16:55it has a large Shiite population and the Shiites
- 16:58mobilized. And so our newspaper covered these
- 17:02kinds of things. I was working mainly as a translator
- 17:05for the newspaper. I would take the Arabic wire
- 17:06services and put them into English. And so I
- 17:12followed the Iranian Revolution very closely.
- 17:15and its local reverberations in Lebanon. So I
- 17:23initially went to UCLA because it had the best
- 17:25Iranian studies program in the country. And I
- 17:28was going to do my dissertation on Iran. And
- 17:32that was perfectly plausible. Even after the
- 17:34revolution in the summer of 1979, a lot of American
- 17:37academics went to Iran for research and relations
- 17:40between the two countries weren't at a nadir.
- 17:45Then the hostage crisis happened. And these guerrilla
- 17:50groups took American diplomats hostage. And it
- 17:56was a crisis for the next year and a half. Well,
- 18:01no embassy, no visas, no diplomatic relations.
- 18:05I couldn't do research in Iran. But I had done
- 18:08a lot of background research. towards a dissertation
- 18:13on what I was interested in was the rise of the
- 18:17Shiite clergy as a ruling class. Where does that
- 18:22come from? Because there isn't any other modern
- 18:24country where the clerics came to power. There
- 18:28have been places like Franco's Spain where they
- 18:30were very influential. Seize power. Seize power
- 18:34as a group in the same way that the military
- 18:36seizes power. That seems strange and I wondered
- 18:40if there's something about Shiite traditions
- 18:42that helped to explain how it could happen. So
- 18:46I was reluctant to let go of the subject. I thought,
- 18:50well, maybe I can do it as a manuscript library
- 18:52project. So I went to the manuscript library
- 18:55catalogs. As I got over into the India catalogs,
- 19:00I was ignorant about this at first. I discovered
- 19:04that there had been Shiite kingdoms in India,
- 19:10Shiite ruled kingdoms in India between the fall
- 19:14of the Mughals and the rise of the British. And
- 19:18the manuscript catalogs demonstrated that these
- 19:21Shiite ruled kingdoms had generated a lot of
- 19:25writing. They gave patronage to clergy to write
- 19:28things and so forth. And the manuscripts were
- 19:31sitting there. And I went to the secondary literature.
- 19:35I didn't find anything about it. It was not in
- 19:37the literature. There was an unknown subject.
- 19:39Well, that's what you want as an PhD student.
- 19:42This is a place you can make your mark. So, yeah,
- 19:46I applied for a Fulbright and a Social Science
- 19:50Research Council grants, and they accepted my
- 19:54application and sent me off to South Asia. So
- 19:57that was actually... Unexpected but also a pleasant
- 20:02idea because remember I was interested in Eastern
- 20:06religions and India and Gandhi as a teenager
- 20:10in the late 60s. So there was a mystique of India
- 20:14and I hadn't thought about being able to combine
- 20:19my interest in the Middle East and Islam with
- 20:22an interest in India. But here was the perfect
- 20:24opportunity. So I went off to Lucknow in Uttar
- 20:28Pradesh and made contact with the local Shiites.
- 20:34Some of them were at the university as professors,
- 20:37and so they could understand what I was doing
- 20:40and was interested in. opened their hearts to
- 20:44me, and more importantly, their libraries, including
- 20:47manuscripts. Now, I was from a generation of
- 20:52scholars of Islamics and the Middle East who
- 20:56were impatient with depending mainly on French
- 21:02and British archives for the modern period as
- 21:06your sources. And it hadn't really been known,
- 21:11I think, in the 60s, to the degree to which a
- 21:15very rich manuscript tradition survives. Only
- 21:19a small proportion of it ever was printed. But
- 21:22you could find these handwritten books produced
- 21:27in 1750 and 1790 and 1830. And since they're
- 21:34often unique, there was... no copy of them made,
- 21:38you had to go to where they were held in order
- 21:41to use them. And so I was not alone in this.
- 21:47There were Peter Grant and others were beginning
- 21:49to use these kinds of materials and to make it
- 21:52known that they existed. And so I was able to
- 21:55write my dissertation primarily out of these
- 21:58primary sources written by Indians, often in
- 22:02Arabic and Persian, which Mostly Indians don't
- 22:05read Arabic anymore. They know to recite the
- 22:09Quran, but they wouldn't read a book in it. And
- 22:13so I was doing things that even local scholars
- 22:16maybe wouldn't have done. And I was able to write
- 22:20a history of Shiite religion and religious practices
- 22:26in North India in the 18th and 19th century.
- 22:32historians had treated this period in this place,
- 22:35they'd mostly treated it as a chess piece in
- 22:40the British conquest of India, and it was all
- 22:44about diplomacy and economics sometimes and so
- 22:48forth, but an intercultural history of the Shiite
- 22:51practices in India, some of which were in dialogue
- 22:55with Hindu practices and so forth. had not been
- 22:59done. So that was my dissertation. It turned
- 23:02into my first book. And it got me the job at
- 23:05Michigan and laid a foundation for my career.
- 23:08Wow. Yeah, I mean, your work is like, at least
- 23:12in English, is groundbreaking in terms of being
- 23:15able to show that. Because I think people in
- 23:16South Asia knew that not only were these Shia
- 23:20kingdoms important, but they were also, in a
- 23:23way, kind of... part of the creators of the high
- 23:25culture of Muslim society, right? And the Shias
- 23:30especially, like, having an important part to
- 23:32play in that. It's very, very interesting. So
- 23:36then I'm interested in kind of, like, in terms
- 23:42of how you go from your kind of your more teaching
- 23:48kind of historical work to... the more public
- 23:51-facing work that you kind of shifted to eventually.
- 23:55What took you in that direction? Well, because
- 23:58I had done this MA in Cairo, and I had lived
- 24:01in Cairo in the 70s, and then I did the PhD work
- 24:04in India and Pakistan, I lived on the terrain
- 24:09on which the components of al -Qaeda grew up.
- 24:16So when I was in Egypt, You read the newspapers,
- 24:19and 88 members of Islamic Jihad had been arrested
- 24:22that day. It was impossible not to be aware of
- 24:25it. And being specialized in Islamic movements,
- 24:30I wanted to do some reading in it. And then when
- 24:33I was in the shower in 1982, the Afghan refugees
- 24:39had come, and I didn't know it. I was in the
- 24:42same city with bin Laden and Zawahiri and the
- 24:45later leaders of al -Qaeda. who were at that
- 24:50time running something called the Office of Services
- 24:52for the Afghan Jihadin or fighters against the
- 24:57Soviet invasion. So I came back to the United
- 25:02States. I got this job at Michigan. I was teaching
- 25:04my courses on the modern Middle East, or I taught
- 25:06some South Asia. I taught the Mughal Empire.
- 25:09But when 9 -11 hit, The whole of America was
- 25:16seized with curiosity and fear and anxiety about
- 25:20what had happened. Who were these people and
- 25:23why had they done what they had done? Well, I
- 25:26knew exactly who they were. I didn't have to
- 25:29look it up. I'd lived with it. And, you know,
- 25:33you can follow these movements. At that time,
- 25:36they had Internet bulletin boards and so forth.
- 25:39So knowing Arabic and Persian and Urdu. And having
- 25:45lived out there, I could easily answer people's
- 25:49questions about Al -Qaeda and 9 -11. At the time,
- 25:54the major vehicle for intellectual exchange of
- 26:03a specialized sort was the email round robin.
- 26:06So you would just have a CC list of all the people
- 26:09who might be interested in this discussion. And
- 26:12you would send out a message. Somebody else would
- 26:14reply. So you would have these internet discussions
- 26:17and dialogues. So I was on such a list. It was
- 26:22called Gulf 2000, which had been founded by Gary
- 26:26Sick, who had been on the National Security Council
- 26:32for the Gulf. And, of course, that was a place
- 26:39where a lot of these kinds of questions were
- 26:41asked by academics and policymakers. So I could
- 26:46answer their questions. And the Internet is really
- 26:49useful because it's a very fast medium. It's
- 26:55a hot medium. It's useful if you don't have to
- 26:58go off for a week to do reading in order to come
- 27:01back and answer a question, because people will
- 27:03have forgotten the question was ever asked by
- 27:05a week later. I could just answer their questions
- 27:08immediately. And so my answers about Al -Qaeda
- 27:12were very well thought of by my colleagues, and
- 27:15they told me so. And although that list was supposed
- 27:18to be internal to the group, In fact, I would
- 27:23start to get fan mail from Denmark. I liked your
- 27:27posting of October 7th and so forth. So then
- 27:32people would start writing me for back issues.
- 27:39And at the time, we used Microsoft Outlook, most
- 27:44of us, for emails. It didn't have a search engine.
- 27:47It was a little bit of a hassle to go back and
- 27:50find an old email and send it out again. So that
- 27:55was 2001, the winter of 2001 was when blogging
- 27:59started to become a well -known phenomenon. It
- 28:02had existed since 1999, but it was only then
- 28:08gaining a reputation. Andrew Sullivan was a prominent
- 28:14journalist who had started a blog. And there
- 28:19wasn't very much serious content still in the
- 28:22web blogs. A lot of cats. And so I thought, well,
- 28:30I'll start a blog. And I can just archive my
- 28:34email messages there because I consider them
- 28:36public. And when somebody comes looking for a
- 28:39back issue, I can just give them the URL. It
- 28:42would save me a lot of trouble. So that's in
- 28:45the spring of 2002. Okay. I started putting things
- 28:48up at this web log. And, you know, in the old
- 28:54days when the Internet first emerged in the early
- 28:5990s, you know, the Internet is different from
- 29:03the World Wide Web, I mean, when the World Wide
- 29:06Web first emerged. The web is different from
- 29:10the Internet. Email can be the Internet, but
- 29:12the World Wide Web has pages. Initially, they
- 29:16were just index cards. You couldn't scroll, and
- 29:21you couldn't really do anything but to write
- 29:23on the index card and display it. The only movement
- 29:26you could have was a hyperlink, so you could
- 29:28link that index card to other index cards. Every
- 29:32time you put up an index card, you had to do
- 29:36this. called file transfer protocol you had to
- 29:39design it and and put it up manually upload it
- 29:43manually and then it would be a standalone document
- 29:47only linked to other documents by the hyperlink
- 29:50so you could go sideways but you couldn't go
- 29:53up and down so in 1999 this young software engineers
- 29:59invented blogger .com which was had a window
- 30:03And you could put text in and press publish and
- 30:06it would FTP it for you. You didn't have to do
- 30:09it manually. And also, it would push down whatever
- 30:14text was there before and put this on top of
- 30:16it. So that just became much more convenient.
- 30:21And that was the software that we used initially,
- 30:26most bloggers, to put up their web pages. But
- 30:30then after a while, it would be summer, and we
- 30:34professors don't teach in the summer, and I would
- 30:37have some time to do research, and I would be
- 30:39tooling around the web. And again, I knew Arabic,
- 30:42so I could find out things that other people
- 30:44couldn't. And if I found an interesting article
- 30:46about al -Qaeda and its history, I would translate
- 30:49it and put it at the website. So I started making
- 30:52original entries. And the website, you know,
- 30:5650 people would come a day or 75 or what. Initially,
- 31:00it was a small thing. And then Bush decided to
- 31:04invade Iraq. And those Shiites that I studied
- 31:09in India went on pilgrimage to Iraq. And there
- 31:13was a lot of back and forth between Iran, Iraq
- 31:15and North India at that time, because India,
- 31:17the Indian Shiite kingdom of Awad that I studied
- 31:20was rich. And so there was patronage and pilgrimage
- 31:24and so forth. So two chapters of my dissertation
- 31:28were actually set in Iraq. I knew who the Iraqi
- 31:30Shiites were. I knew who the grandparents were.
- 31:32And when Bush decided to go to Iraq, I was able
- 31:39to talk knowledgeably about Iraqi history and
- 31:42society. And then once Saddam fell, the Iraqis
- 31:47put up like 200 websites. And some of them were
- 31:51city. So you could read local news, what was
- 31:55happening in a particular neighborhood. There
- 31:56was no censorship. So I could find out almost
- 32:00anything. A high -ranking U .S. general once
- 32:05wrote me in that period and said, how do you
- 32:07know these things? So apparently I was doing
- 32:10a better job than this and tell people. And I
- 32:17blogged Iraq. And once Bush decided to go to
- 32:20war there and send U .S. troops there, you figure
- 32:22he sent 100 ,000, 120 ,000 troops. Each of those
- 32:28has family. They have friends. That's a big constituents
- 32:31of people who really want to know what's going
- 32:32on over there because they're interested in the
- 32:35fate of their loved one. In addition to which,
- 32:38it was a national project. Bush promised the
- 32:41Americans he was going to turn Iraq into a beacon
- 32:43on the hill. They became emotionally invested
- 32:46in Iraq. It's so funny now if you think about
- 32:49it. We just had elections in Iraq last October,
- 32:52and I don't think the American public even knew
- 32:55that it happened. But in the early zeros, that's
- 32:58the kind of thing they were focused like a laser
- 33:01on. So at the time, the blog technology was such
- 33:06that you would have... a side panel in which
- 33:11it was called a blog roll, in which you would
- 33:14recommend other sites to your readers. And so
- 33:18people who had a weblog that was in any way related
- 33:24to foreign affairs would suddenly put my weblog
- 33:27in their list as a hyperlink. And so when people
- 33:31finished reading an article on that site, they
- 33:33would go to the blog roll and click and come
- 33:36to me. And then there were some mega bloggers,
- 33:41people who had a big following who linked to
- 33:44me. I woke up one morning and I had 60 ,000 hits.
- 33:50And, you know, in April of 2004. at the height
- 33:57of the struggles between the Marines and the
- 34:00Mahdi Army, I had a million hits that month.
- 34:02I'd never had a million of anything. And then
- 34:06they called me on public television, the NewsHour,
- 34:10and even on cable news more generally, CNN. I
- 34:15even once went on Fox. And people were interested
- 34:19in what I knew, the Senate Select Foreign Relations
- 34:21Committee, then headed by Joe Biden and Dick
- 34:23Lugar. called me to testify because they couldn't
- 34:27get the Bush administration to tell them what
- 34:28the world was going on over there. So I gained
- 34:32a certain odd sort of celebrity. I actually was
- 34:37recognized in restaurants in D .C. That's interesting.
- 34:41I can remember I was in Minnesota giving a talk,
- 34:43and I paid the taxi by credit card, and the young
- 34:46man looked at it, and he said, oh, are you the
- 34:47Juan Cole? So it wasn't... It wasn't the frivolous
- 34:53kind of Hollywood celebrity. I didn't have the
- 34:55pink limousine or anything like that. But I was
- 34:57very well known. C .P. Snow said that the celebrity
- 35:02is someone who's very well known for being very
- 35:03well known. In a very minor way. I don't want
- 35:07to make too much of it. I entered those ranks.
- 35:10But it was because the country wanted the knowledge
- 35:13that I had. They wanted the analysis that I had.
- 35:16And I consulted with the government. You know,
- 35:21I've been against the Vietnam War and marched
- 35:23against it. But with Al Qaeda in Iraq, I thought
- 35:28the Iraq war was a bad idea. But I also wanted
- 35:33a soft landing for everybody. And then I really,
- 35:37really wanted to help do whatever I could to
- 35:40destroy Al Qaeda. So the government called me
- 35:43to consult. I came and told them what I knew.
- 35:45I thought, well, I'm a public intellectual. I'm
- 35:47the people of Michigan for... whatever reason
- 35:50to pay me to tell the public these things. The
- 35:53government is part of that public. So I was willing
- 35:58to talk to other experts in D .C. and share that
- 36:05knowledge. I kept expecting this to be a one
- 36:09-year adventure and to be over, but it lasted
- 36:12really until COVID. The people were interested
- 36:15in Iraq, and then ISIL arose. So there was 20
- 36:22years there where a big chunk of my career was
- 36:25telling people about Islam in the Middle East.
- 36:30And then I found that... It was so much Islamophobia
- 36:34in my comments. As hard as I tried to inform
- 36:40people, I couldn't always get through. And then
- 36:44it occurred to me that maybe trying to explain
- 36:48radical groups like Al -Qaeda and ISIL to people
- 36:52is not the best way to inform them about Islam
- 36:54more generally. Because the Americans didn't
- 36:57realize it, but those are very tiny little sects.
- 36:59I mean, almost nobody... paid attention to them
- 37:02in their home countries, except to the extent
- 37:04that they're violent. And so I had been trained
- 37:09at the American University in Cairo and UCLA
- 37:12in early Islamics as well. So I decided to write
- 37:15a book about the idea of peace in the Quran.
- 37:19As far as I could tell, there had not been such
- 37:22a book. But I find concepts of reconciliation,
- 37:28peace, moderation, and dialogue are throughout
- 37:34the Quran. Of course, Muslims know this. The
- 37:38Western public, including the Western academic
- 37:40public, I think mostly didn't know it. And so
- 37:43that became my project from the middle of the
- 37:46last decade was I wrote a book about Muhammad
- 37:51and peace. I wrote a book about, I edited a book
- 37:56about peace movements in Islam in which we looked
- 37:58at all range of them. There's a lot of peace
- 37:59movements in Muslim societies, but people don't
- 38:03think about them that way. They know about them.
- 38:05You know, they had that horrible. genocide in
- 38:07Bosnia, but after it was over and you had the
- 38:10Dayton Accords, there were Muslim women who formed
- 38:14organizations to work for conciliation with their
- 38:18Serbian neighbors and so forth. And there is
- 38:21a literature on this, but it's just, it's not
- 38:23in people's consciousness. Yeah. We're ending,
- 38:28we're nearing our time to end, but I am interested
- 38:32in kind of what is your I mean, you've had such
- 38:39a varied career in terms of the work that you've
- 38:41done. I mean, what are kind of the main takeaways
- 38:48that you would want, say, students who are interested
- 38:50in kind of learning more about either interfaith
- 38:54dialogue or kind of the Middle East more generally
- 38:57to, what are some of the key learnings that you
- 39:01think that... people just should know about the
- 39:04world, especially as we see it kind of things
- 39:07unfolding today. With regard to the first part
- 39:11of your question about studying Islam, its history,
- 39:15its thought, you know, the Victorians in the
- 39:1919th century developed this notion of what they
- 39:22called the enlargement of the self. It was very
- 39:26common for people to go on vacation to Italy,
- 39:28for instance. And we now... do this routinely,
- 39:32but in the mid -19th century that was a boat
- 39:36ride and a pretty big deal. Mostly rich people
- 39:39did it. But also, we don't think about this,
- 39:42but they were pretty hardline Protestants and
- 39:45they were going into a Catholic environment and
- 39:47the churches were gaudy from their point of view
- 39:51and so forth. But then they would be exposed
- 39:53to this wonderful Renaissance art. And George
- 39:56Eliot, the novelist, who was a woman that she
- 40:01wrote under a man's name, she talked about her
- 40:05trip to Italy and the way in which it was an
- 40:07enlargement of herself, of ordinary life, she
- 40:11called it. And so this was the whole concept
- 40:14in that period. And of course, it was a time
- 40:18when the Victorian world was... sticking its
- 40:20fingers all over the world, but also the intellectuals
- 40:23and the cultural figures found beauty in these
- 40:27other cultures in a way that maybe the administrators
- 40:30did not. The district commissioner of such and
- 40:33such place in India may not have fully appreciated
- 40:36the richness of the culture of the people that
- 40:38he was ruling over. So that enlargement of the
- 40:43self, of the ways in which you can become that
- 40:49you can widen your horizons and deepen your understanding.
- 40:53That's something that's worth gold. And learning
- 40:57another language, another way of expressing yourself,
- 41:00understanding the concepts, because the world
- 41:03looks different when you know another language.
- 41:05There's even an Arabic proverb, every language
- 41:11is a person. It's like when you learn a new language,
- 41:14it's like you have a new personality incorporated
- 41:16into yourself. And although, as you say, there
- 41:21may be a lot more public interest in the history
- 41:25of Zen Buddhism or something like that, those
- 41:29Sufis in Islam are really interesting people
- 41:32and they have fascinating stories to tell. We
- 41:37think about religion as sermons and homilies,
- 41:40but they like to tell tales, folk tales kind
- 41:43of thing, but with a spiritual import. And they
- 41:47have very large books full of these stories,
- 41:49and they're more spiritual kinds of stories.
- 41:54They're not like the Thousand and One Nights,
- 41:55which are also very interesting. But anyway,
- 41:58I think that study of that kind of literature
- 42:02is very rewarding in its own right, and it gives
- 42:05you spiritual insights that are useful in facing
- 42:08life. With regard to geopolitics, I mean, I don't
- 42:11think I have to really make a strong pitch for
- 42:14that. We don't understand the Middle East, but
- 42:18we rampage around it like an elephant in a china
- 42:22shop. I have been both pleasantly surprised and
- 42:29deeply disappointed by my interactions with officials
- 42:33in Washington because some of them were really
- 42:34on the ball and knew their stuff, but a very
- 42:36large number of them were completely ignorant
- 42:38of the places that they were trying to run. And
- 42:43I think that's unadvisable. I think the U .S.
- 42:47public is going to go on having things to do
- 42:49with the Middle East. the public needs to get
- 42:53up to speed and do the reading and investigate.
- 42:58Well, thank you so much, Professor Paul. It's
- 43:00been an honor and a pleasure. Thank you.