Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Sues for $95 Million — and Names How the Money Vanished - Jackson Area FCU Revisited
Transcript
- 0:05Speaker: Hey, everyone.
- 0:05This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:08On May 6th, NCUA conserved Jackson Area Federal Credit Union.
- 0:14On May 11th, I did a podcast saying I think there might be a huge problem
- 0:18here perhaps a huge l- deficit that was gonna cost the insurance
- 0:22fund, perhaps a embezzlement o- of a larger variety because they had
- 0:28borrowed money, yet had no loans.
- 0:30It just didn't make sense, and there were some other red flags, and when you
- 0:33conserve a credit union, you do it for safety and soundness reasons, but this
- 0:38one kinda had a smoking gun effect.
- 0:40I was traveling a little bit over the last week, and I got a message from
- 0:44a listener, a nice message saying, "Hey, have you looked at the new 5300?
- 0:48It shows that the credit union had a $95 million write-off, and that
- 0:53they were upside down in reserves to the tune of about 71 to 73 million."
- 0:58And I told them that I would take a look at it and do a follow-up
- 1:01podcast, and that's what this is.
- 1:03So in prepping for the podcast two days ago, I stumbled across this morning an
- 1:09article by Frank Diekmann of cutoday.info,
- 1:13I believe is what his website is, and NCUA has filed a suit against the CEO.
- 1:19So- That is now included here in my update, and I'm gonna
- 1:23walk through what's going on.
- 1:25But as you can see here I'm calling this podcast NCUA sues for $95 million
- 1:30and names how the money vanished.
- 1:33Poof, like that.
- 1:35So there is a new federal complaint, which is a- alleges that the CEO, and I'm not
- 1:39gonna go into names here, and allegesâ¦
- 1:41Everything I say here is alleges, okay?
- 1:44Alleges that former CEO diverted at least ninety-five million, confirming
- 1:48that my phantom cash thesis was correct and putting a face on the
- 1:54seventy-seven million dollar deficit the insurance fund now stands to absorb.
- 1:59I do happen to know that they are shopping Jackson Area
- 2:02already for a quick resolution.
- 2:04And so next up on the slideâ¦
- 2:06By the way, on the bottom I say allegations unproven because,
- 2:08again, these are allegations.
- 2:10Although, we'll find out that she actually appears to have admitted to it.
- 2:14All right.
- 2:15So who is Jackson Area Federal Credit Union?
- 2:18Jackson Area Federal Credit Union was chartered in 1953.
- 2:22It's a MDI, self-designated, and a limited income, serving the city of
- 2:26Jackson and Hinds County employees.
- 2:29The reported profile, it was reported that they had one pointâ¦
- 2:33a hundred and sixty-two million in assets, 92 perâ¦
- 2:369.2%
- 2:37net worth, but this was the thing that stood out to me, only 28% loan-to-asset,
- 2:44which was unusual since they had forty-one million dollars in non-member deposits.
- 2:48Why did they need that cash?
- 2:50The intervention happened, as I mentioned, May 6th, a conservatorship,
- 2:53and when you see somebody conserved with a net worth of 9.2%,
- 2:58you immediately conclude that 9.2%
- 3:01might not be there, which is what I concluded
- 3:07So the previous episode I talked about the possibility of phantom cash.
- 3:1166% of assets were in cash deposits, which was implausible, and the fact
- 3:17that they were borrowing money, as I mentioned when they didn't really need to.
- 3:20And they must have needed that cash for something, and it
- 3:23turns out indeed it was fraud.
- 3:25There was fabricated net equity that was also in play that went on the
- 3:30books and then went off the books.
- 3:31And then what also triggered my analysis was that NCUA said that this
- 3:36was an estimated finding, which to me meant there were write-offs coming.
- 3:39They knew they were coming.
- 3:40They had to file to get the debt- to get the data into the system, because
- 3:44they never want to say, "We didn't get data into system for one credit union."
- 3:48Because that happened once and Congress wasn't happy when
- 3:50they asked some questions.
- 3:52So NCUA doesn't do that anymore.
- 3:54All right, so why is my slide not moving down?
- 3:57Here we go.
- 3:58Why we're back today.
- 3:59So two things have happened.
- 4:00First, NCUA filed a restated call report, the regulator's own number.
- 4:05And again, when you conserve a credit union, you act as the agency, the
- 4:09regulator, you act as the insurer, and you act as the board in the best
- 4:12interests of the members as well.
- 4:14So NCUA went in there, did their reviews and I think quickly found
- 4:19out that the cash was not what it had been reported to for years and years.
- 4:24Second, on June 11 and tipped off, a hat tip to Frank Diekmann NCUA files
- 4:29a federal lawsuit alleging the former CEO diverted at least $95 million, and
- 4:34named the mechanism and the numbers on how they allegedly did that.
- 4:38So they restated the books.
- 4:40Then in a sworn federal complaint, they landed on exactly the mechanism
- 4:44that I said they did it by.
- 4:46So sometimes it's better to be lucky than good
- 4:51All right, so
- 4:54What we now have is that the fraud landed a-a-and was taken from where it would
- 4:59normally be taken from, the cash account.
- 5:01First quarter, they recognized a $91.7
- 5:04million loss, and there was a reduction in cash of $93.6
- 5:10million.
- 5:11And their net worth ratio went from a positive 9% to a negative 107%.
- 5:16That's just not a number thatâ¦
- 5:17that, that's a laughable number, a number that doesn't make any sense at all.
- 5:21They are materially insolvent, which means NCUA has to shut them down and
- 5:26will have to pay probably at least 70, $80 million to make this go away.
- 5:33Ironically, that will wipe out most, some, all of the savings that Kyle
- 5:38Hauptman's reorganization made.
- 5:40And longer term, when NCUA is doing less exams, which in the short term is
- 5:46good for credit unions, and when NCUA is doing re- contemplating and FFIEC
- 5:51is comp- contemplating changing the CAMELS rating system, which a net-net
- 5:55I think is a good thing, but curtails some of NCUA's and banking regulators'
- 5:59flexibilities to downgrade management.
- 6:01Again, short term, that's a good thing.
- 6:03Long term, occasionally it's going to lead to some losses.
- 6:05And again, of course, NCUA is not a fraud auditor.
- 6:08There's a lot of, "Where was NCUA?"
- 6:10And we l- tend to lose sight of the fact that a criminal stole
- 6:12a lot of money here, right?
- 6:13But it's easy to look at, what happened in a postmortem, and it was easy for
- 6:18me to look when they conserved to say, "Hey, what might be wrong here?"
- 6:20But the inspector general will have to do a postmortem on that,
- 6:23and I'll walk through that.
- 6:24So this is a chart I put together looking at what was reported in December
- 6:29and then what was restated in March.
- 6:31We had total assets going down $91 million, cash going down $93 million,
- 6:36net worth going down $92 million.
- 6:38Net worth going from the best category to the worst category, and they're
- 6:42well beyond the worst category.
- 6:43They're, This was, this is a f- a fatal adjustment to net worth
- 6:47because nobody can survive that.
- 6:49And so loans, no changes, member shares, no changes and
- 6:52non-member deposits no changes.
- 6:54So the asset side imploded.
- 6:55The liabilities are there because they stole the money, and they
- 6:57still owe the money to the members and/or to the organizations that
- 7:02that put in non-member deposits.
- 7:04What's new?
- 7:04The loss relative to the lawsuit
- 7:08I'm trying to move where my, where this is popping up on my screen here.
- 7:12Okay.
- 7:12So they filed June 11th in US District Court as conservator.
- 7:15They allege that the former CEO diverted at least $95 million for personal
- 7:20use $51 million in false deposits.
- 7:23Entries into the CEO's and her husband's own share accounts alle- allegedly
- 7:28showed funds arriving from outside institutions when they actually came
- 7:32from Jackson Area's general ledger.
- 7:35And allegedly, this goes back to 2015.
- 7:39Now, I think I saw somewhere that the CEO hasn't even been CEO s-
- 7:43that long my guess is there might be somebody else at the credit union
- 7:46who's aware of what's going on here.
- 7:47But NCUA will suss all of that out.
- 7:49And so the signer.
- 7:51What happens if you don't have separation of church and state, if
- 7:53you don't have separation of duties?
- 7:56The signer had the keys.
- 7:57The former CFO, who becameâ¦
- 7:59Okay, so here we go.
- 7:59I did have that here.
- 8:00The CFO, who became the CEO around 2021, allegedly prepared and signed
- 8:05the regulatory filings and held wire transfer authority, the same filings
- 8:10our episodes our previous episode analyzed and questioned, right?
- 8:14And they overstated the corporate cash.
- 8:16Accounting entries allegedly overstated funds held at a corporate credit union.
- 8:20The phantom cash mechanism now describes in a sworn filing rather
- 8:25than inferred from the 5300.
- 8:26And I've heard chatter which may or may not be true, that that the
- 8:32corporate credit union tipped off NCUA.
- 8:35That could be true.
- 8:36That could be just chatter, or that could be somebody trying to
- 8:39control a narrative of some sort.
- 8:41But NCUA, when there's a big loss like this, always gets criticized.
- 8:45And again, there is a rumor, and I will call it nothing more than a rumor,
- 8:49that the corporate did tip off NCUA.
- 8:52I don't know if that's true or not.
- 8:53I don't know who they tipped off whether it was looked at what the reality is
- 8:57there, but I just thought I'd mention it because I did hear that All right.
- 9:02And next slide is not wanting to come up.
- 9:04All right so this is when you when you have these losses when you're at NCUA
- 9:08or when you're sitting at home looking at the web or looking at a newspaper
- 9:11if you if you're one of those folks who still gets a hard copy of a newspaper.
- 9:15When you read the story and you see somebody stole money, it's
- 9:17fun to it's it's interesting.
- 9:19I don't wanna say fun.
- 9:20Interesting to see where the money went.
- 9:22So there was alleged personal use of $14.4
- 9:25million in alleged payments to a single card issue- issuer, American
- 9:29Express, which was one line among many.
- 9:31The, their credit card payments, Amex, Apple, Chase, $15 million.
- 9:36Luxury jewelry and handbags at local area Jackson retailers, $3.3
- 9:41million.
- 9:41Jewel- jeweler- jewelers in New York, Illinois, and California, $1 million.
- 9:46A wire connected to Tiffany's & Company, $378,000.
- 9:50Construction and interior design, $1.16
- 9:53million.
- 9:53A Steinway grand piano, 'cause when you're stealing all this jewelry and
- 9:58you're building fancy houses, of course you need a Steinway grand piano at the,
- 10:02to the tune pun intended, of $129,000.
- 10:06Vehicles, Mercedes, Porsche, Tesla, $193,000.
- 10:10And of course, they need more than one house, right?
- 10:14Properties in Mississippi and Orange Beach, Alabama.
- 10:20So there is a co-defendant.
- 10:22The husband is named.
- 10:23His account was allegedly received $13.8
- 10:26million from the general ledger between May 2019 and May 2026,
- 10:31far exceeding his payroll income.
- 10:32So the money in doesn't make sense when you look at what he did.
- 10:35That's basically what NCUA put in the complaint.
- 10:38And the complaint alleges the CEO controlled the
- 10:40account to conceal activity.
- 10:43And there is, was an alleged admission.
- 10:46So somebody figured something out, and they confronted, allegedly
- 10:51confronted the CEO on April 17th, meeting with the board and NCUA.
- 10:55The CEO admitted misappropriating funds and using false entries to
- 10:59conceal it, was placed on leave, and then NCUA conserved the credit union
- 11:04about two and a half weeks later.
- 11:08What NCUA is seeking.
- 11:10Claims include fraud, conversion, breach of fiduciary duty,
- 11:14and D&O liability violations.
- 11:16Seeking money, judgment- judgments, assets, recovery, disgorgement, a
- 11:20constructive trust, and injunctive relief.
- 11:24A constructive trust, I'm curious what that might mean.
- 11:27I think I might mean, but I'm not gonna guess.
- 11:29But that, that's kinda interesting.
- 11:30And you know what happens when there's these fraud cases and
- 11:33you ⦠the people confess and they say, "How much did you take?"
- 11:35They think the number is this much, and it's actually this much
- 11:38because they had to pay dividends on the stolen money, right?
- 11:42And that kind of money can't be recovered from a bond claim.
- 11:45And so of course, the bond claims, whatever it is, whatever their bond
- 11:48cover- coverage is not gonna cover the $70, $80 million, maybe $5 million.
- 11:53But NCUA will net that against the loss of whoever the successful bidder is to take
- 11:59over the remnants of the credit union.
- 12:02So again, I confirm the phantom assets, it was validated.
- 12:05It's no longer a hypothesis.
- 12:06It's now corroborated twice.
- 12:08The restated books book the loss on the cash account, and the complaint
- 12:12alleges the matching mechanism, false deposits, and overstated corporate cash.
- 12:16The asset side of my story my thoughts on the theory hold true.
- 12:21And then the liabilities were the liabilities.
- 12:23I had mentioned the possibility of fake deposits on the other side, but
- 12:27that does not appe- be based on the filing of the lawsuit, and based on
- 12:31the filing of the 5300, that, that does not appear to be the case.
- 12:35So let resolution, there's a clean clean books left, right?
- 12:40Theoretically, NCUA has only, is only offering for sale what they know exists.
- 12:45And they'll be selling that.
- 12:46NCUA NCUSIF taking a hit is unavoidable, probably $77 million or more.
- 12:51O- of course, if you had less than $250,000, you were covered.
- 12:54If you had more than $250,000, you may be covered depending on
- 12:58how NCUA writes up this deal.
- 13:01There is a way that you can allow those deposi- depositors to be made
- 13:07whole if the net effect of everything is the least cost in the insurance
- 13:12fund, but I won't go down that rabbit hole other than what I just said.
- 13:16And then of course, the IG materal- materialal- materiality, they're
- 13:20gonna have to do a material loss review 'cause it's 3.7
- 13:23times the limit.
- 13:24They have to do one over $25 million or 10% of assets.
- 13:27This hits both those It's probably gonna take them a while.
- 13:31They're gonna look at when NCUA first became aware.
- 13:33They're probably gonna look into these rumors of whether or not
- 13:35the corporates indeed did tip off NCUA, and if so, who they did and
- 13:39what NCUA did in response to that.
- 13:41There may end up being some changes to how NCUA does some exam steps.
- 13:45There may not.
- 13:47But it's gonna be a black eye or a red eye on the insurance fund and if you
- 13:51have one, two, three, four, five of these things happen eventually and then
- 13:55the credit union industry grows, the way the math works on the insurance fund,
- 13:58you could end up having to pay a premium into the insurance fund, but this in
- 14:02and of itself won't cause that, so I wouldn't worry about that too much yet.
- 14:06So what we know and what we look for still ahead again the
- 14:09theory that I had was right.
- 14:11These are still allegations, not verdicts, although U- NCUA wouldn't say that she
- 14:15confessed if they didn't, so clearly this is going to play out, in my opinion.
- 14:18There will be subsidization of the insurance fund.
- 14:21I'll report more on the material loss review when that comes out,
- 14:25but that's gonna probably be a year.
- 14:27I do have some other podcasts coming up on IG reports.
- 14:30I had a previous one on IG reports.
- 14:32But, NCUA's not a fraud auditor.
- 14:34CPA opinions are not a fraud auditor.
- 14:36I've fraud audit the, this credit union's asset size, did not require a CPA opinion.
- 14:40They probably had a agreed-upon procedures.
- 14:43And it's a sad state of affairs that these folks decided to use their
- 14:48local credit union as a piggy bank.
- 14:50But I'm guessing they will be be doing substantial time for
- 14:54their crime and/or crimes.
- 14:56And I'm gonna leave it at that, all right?
- 14:58I got a couple other podcasts I'm gonna be rolling out here that
- 15:01I've got the PowerPoints ready for.
- 15:03And this week was, I think, only the second week in two years that I missed
- 15:07a current version of the podcast.
- 15:09Again, I had some travel going on.
- 15:11And I'm back in my rhythm, and you'll see a new episode
- 15:14every Mon- Monday or Tuesday.
- 15:16You will see on the podcast version only, the old g- evergreen topics
- 15:21that that I reissue on Thursdays.
- 15:23And on Wednesdays, don't forget, we've got our other podcast Credit Union
- 15:27Regulatory Guidance with an AI voice, Samantha Shares, and that talks about
- 15:33audiobook style of NCUA releases, FDIC releases, et cetera, et cetera.
- 15:37All right.
- 15:38That's it.
- 15:38I wanna thank you for listening.
- 15:40Thank you for watching.
- 15:41I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 15:43This is Mark Trakel signing off with flying colors.