Latest / James O'Brien Daily / The tide has changed in Trump's America
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:06Hello and welcome to another installment of my daily podcast, full of the best bits of news, discussion and discoveries from my LBC show.
- 0:18I, I thought yesterday's show was one for the ages, actually.
- 0:21I, I'm not tooting my own trumpet.
- 0:22It was entirely due to contributions because I, I, I felt my oil tanker turning round.
- 0:28I think one of the best things about, or rather one of the most worrying things about getting older is the worry that you will atrophy.
- 0:37Do you know what I mean?
- 0:38The worry that you will stagnate, that you will sort of reach a place and just stick there for the duration, for whatever's left.
- 0:45The ability to move, the ability to change, the ability to absorb and inquire, the power of curiosity.
- 0:52All of these things are what keep us honest and get me out of bed in the morning.
- 0:57And two things have happened in the last week that have made me reflect upon the dangers of stagnating, upon the dangers of standing still.
- 1:08The first, oddly, was going to see the magnificent tour that Jonathan Pye is currently on and being reminded of the importance of getting angry about things.
- 1:19I think we may have reached the point in recent years where the anger began to feel redundant.
- 1:24It doesn't change anything.
- 1:25The bad guys keep winning.
- 1:27We've got racism and genocide and misogyny and sex offending being celebrated by huge swathes of the English speaking democratic world.
- 1:36Our media is dominated by liars and freaks who've been wrong about everything forever and yet continue to get feted and rewarded and treated like messiahs.
- 1:46Their every utterance like a kind of Etch A Sketch.
- 1:49Trump is brilliant.
- 1:50Johnson is amazing.
- 1:51Brexit will be great.
- 1:52Truss is a genius.
- 1:53You just give the old Etch A Sketch a shake, tap, tap the screen a few times, chuck it over your shoulder and then come back and pretend that you'd never done any of that.
- 2:01Of course, we should be a little bit angrier, but purposeful anger.
- 2:06Purposeful, focused anger, not sort of incoherent anger.
- 2:10And then of course, the second thing to happen that has made me wonder about the dangers of standing still is the result of the American midterms, the relatively simple equation of massively good news.
- 2:27People who don't celebrate sex offending or racism, bigotry, misogyny, transphobia, homophobia, xenophobia, all the phobias, all the phobias.
- 2:36People who don't celebrate it.
- 2:38Finally getting a bit of a win, it would seem.
- 2:40And yes, it's complicated.
- 2:42And yes, the reasons why Republicans lost so badly don't necessarily admit the things we want to admit.
- 2:49At the very top of the list, you're looking at the cost of living.
- 2:52You're looking at the war in Iran, which even JD Vance has now cited as the main cause.
- 3:00You're looking at a surprisingly disciplined Democratic Party.
- 3:03And wonderful to hear the former teacher James Tallarico, the former public health official Abdel Al Said, and the former, or rather the already serving Democratic Senator John Ossoff, reminding us what decent politics and progressive politics can sound like.
- 3:20Then you've got Trump's remarkable unpopularity.
- 3:22But that isn't necessarily linked to the racism or the lies or the corruption.
- 3:27It could be a combination of all three, or none of the above.
- 3:31And then the thing that has always confused me the most, given that back backdrop of racism, is that Hispanic and black voters have shifted again, moving in some Hispanic counties, majority Hispanic counties, more than 22 percentage points against
- 3:44the bloke who said before the last election that Haitians were eating cats and dogs.
- 3:50Big lies.
- 3:51Important, I think, to be a bit emotional sometimes, actually.
- 3:54And we've almost been bullied out of it.
- 3:56And it occurred to me this morning that's what woke was.
- 4:00It was just a.
- 4:00It was just an act of bullying.
- 4:02Racism's really bad, you know, lads.
- 4:04Oh, he's so woke.
- 4:06He's so.
- 4:07Maybe we could, like, not be.
- 4:09Not be racist.
- 4:10Yeah.
- 4:10Woke.
- 4:11Woke.
- 4:11Woke.
- 4:12Police.
- 4:13Woke.
- 4:13Police.
- 4:14Yeah.
- 4:14You know, like equal marriage is probably quite a good thing.
- 4:19It'd be quite nice, wouldn't it, if people could get married to each other, even if they'd sort of fallen in love with someone of the same.
- 4:24Woke.
- 4:25Woke.
- 4:26What?
- 4:26Genocide's bad, right?
- 4:28We hate genocide.
- 4:28We don't want to be involved in genocide or allied with a regime that's committed.
- 4:31Committing genocide in, I don't know, Gaza.
- 4:33Woke.
- 4:34Woke.
- 4:35Woke.
- 4:37Do you think violence against women is.
- 4:39I think it's pretty bad.
- 4:40Me.
- 4:40You know, I mean, I've never done it.
- 4:42It's not something I'm an expert on.
- 4:43But if I saw a woman getting beaten up on the.
- 4:46On the floor of a party conference next to me, I'd probably intervene with the person doing the beating up, not the person being woke.
- 4:53I so.
- 4:54Woke.
- 4:54Woke.
- 4:55I wish Vladimir Putin hadn't invaded Ukraine.
- 4:58He's such a.
- 4:58He's such a.
- 4:59I mean, evil war criminal.
- 5:00Woke.
- 5:00He was perfectly justified to do so.
- 5:02You shouldn't poke the Russ.
- 5:04I mean, it's bonkers, right?
- 5:05What you get bullied out of.
- 5:07Not saying sometimes by this extraordinary.
- 5:11What would it be this Extraordinary tsunami of bullying, trying to.
- 5:17And then they do this magnificent thing when they say, oh, they're trying to silence us, trying to cancel us.
- 5:21We've got all the newspapers, all the TV shows, we've got all the platforms.
- 5:26Our boys bought Twitter now, so we haven't even.
- 5:28We don't even have to worry about Twitter.
- 5:30We dominate social media.
- 5:31We got Facebook, we've got all the platforms except the one, the Chinese.
- 5:35And they're probably not going to be coming down on the side of liberalism and progressiveness.
- 5:39So we've got all the platforms, we've got all the.
- 5:41All the.
- 5:41Yeah, but we're the ones, we're the real victims here.
- 5:43We're going to set up a free speech union because we're the ones that haven't got free speech.
- 5:48Says a bloke put in the House of Lords by Kemi Baden.
- 5:52Nothing says cancelled like getting a seat in the House of Lords.
- 5:56So you just have these moments where you catch yourself being the victim or the recipient of bullying and you notice that you haven't noticed.
- 6:10This is what the Overton Window is.
- 6:12It took me a while to work this out.
- 6:13Partly, I'll say it again, as a consequence of Jonathan Pye's brilliant stage show, which is still touring at the moment.
- 6:19If you get the chance to see it, I'd go so far as to say, if you ever enjoy this show, you'll enjoy that show.
- 6:24All right.
- 6:26He's not real, by the way.
- 6:27I am.
- 6:28I wanna make that absolutely clear and obviously.
- 6:30But the fact that I feel a bit of kinship with a parody is something that you can probably have a little bit of fun with yourself.
- 6:35But the Overton Window, it doesn't happen organically.
- 6:40You know the parameters of acceptable conversation within a society.
- 6:44The things that you just can't say that the window is not moving randomly.
- 6:50It's not like it's not on wheels that sway according to the way the world turns.
- 6:56Oh, it's gone to the left.
- 6:57Oh, it's gone to the right.
- 6:58I want you to picture the Overton Window and then I want you to picture the mass ranks of right wing media, right wing politics and client journalism.
- 7:06And they are all pushing it.
- 7:08So here's the Overton Window, right?
- 7:09This is the things it's acceptable to say and do in a civilized society.
- 7:14Here's the Overton Window.
- 7:16What can't you say in this country at the moment or in the United States?
- 7:19Well, you can't say that you don't want to see black faces on the telly.
- 7:23Push.
- 7:24Come on.
- 7:24Heave, everybody.
- 7:25Come on.
- 7:25Get behind me, lads.
- 7:26So we're giving it a push.
- 7:27Nigel's at the front, Sarah Poachin's next to him.
- 7:30We got the Daily Mail columnist, we got the right wing broadcast.
- 7:33Push it.
- 7:33Push it.
- 7:33Yeah, you can say that now.
- 7:34Don't have to resign.
- 7:35That's absolutely fine.
- 7:36Who's pushing back the other way?
- 7:39Who's pushing back the other way?
- 7:41Who's on the other side of the kind of Overton Window rails?
- 7:47Who's pushing back?
- 7:48So I'll tell you who's on the other side.
- 7:50People who are described as woke or politically correct because they are sticking up for things like decency.
- 7:55Oh, not decency.
- 7:56Wokeness.
- 7:58Wokeness.
- 7:58And you lose sight of this because that's what the shifts in the Overton Window do.
- 8:02The Overton Window moves.
- 8:04You can only see through that window.
- 8:05So suddenly you're living in a country where it's okay to complain about the colour of your neighbor's skin or an actor on the telly's skin, or someone walking out of their own front door in Birmingham.
- 8:17Skin.
- 8:17It's okay to do all that.
- 8:18You beat up a woman.
- 8:19You want to beat up a woman.
- 8:20Go to the Reform UK conference.
- 8:22You'll get cheered for doing so.
- 8:24The Overton Window has moved.
- 8:25Oh, sorry.
- 8:26ProtectOurWomen.
- 8:27ProtectOurGirls.
- 8:28Don't mention the bloke who was charged with a litany of hideous crimes yesterday, shortly after becoming the go to spokesperson for Nigel Farage's political party.
- 8:39Hashtag Protect Our Women.
- 8:40Hashtag ProtectOurGirls.
- 8:41So you just get.
- 8:43What's the word that you could use to describe it?
- 8:45Gaslit.
- 8:47Even when you're on the right side of these arguments, and that's not an opinion, that's counting.
- 8:52It is the right side to be in favor of humanity and humanitarianism.
- 8:56You want to get an absolute distillation of how bonkers the other side is.
- 9:00They are human beings who are against human rights.
- 9:03I don't think that point gets made enough.
- 9:05What are you?
- 9:05I'm a human being.
- 9:06What's your position on human rights?
- 9:07Damn with them.
- 9:08Absolutely woke.
- 9:10They're woke.
- 9:10Actually, human rights, they're woke.
- 9:12And I hate woke.
- 9:13Do you know what that means?
- 9:14No.
- 9:15Don't ask me what things mean.
- 9:17Gordon Brown sold the gold.
- 9:18We need us.
- 9:19They need us more than we need them.
- 9:21They don't ask me what things actually mean.
- 9:23Brexit means Brexit.
- 9:24Everyone knows that.
- 9:25Quiche.
- 9:26So, yeah, I'm a human being who hates human rights.
- 9:29And these moments, like the midterms, really matter.
- 9:37Actually, I came on air yesterday, I got it all wrong.
- 9:40I came on air yesterday, I didn't get it all wrong because I was completely honest with you.
- 9:44But you set me straight over the course of two hours.
- 9:46I came on air yesterday, and I had allowed the despair to eclipse the hope.
- 9:51I'd allowed myself to think, well, this is a temporary or this is a welcome moment.
- 9:57But never forget the fact that they were putting up with the depravity right up until this week.
- 10:04But that doesn't matter, does it?
- 10:06That doesn't matter because it's always going to be like this.
- 10:13You never win the war.
- 10:15You only ever win battles.
- 10:18I think when Roe vs.
- 10:19Wade got repealed in the United States of America, in this term of Donald Trump, when one of the greatest victories of equal rights or feminism or humanity or whatever you want to call it, bodily autonomy for women, which
- 10:34I think an awful lot of us thought was a victory that was chiseled in stone, that was a victory forever, right?
- 10:41When Roe vs Wade got repealed, you realized America could bring back racial segregation.
- 10:46If the cards fell differently, you could go back to a life before Selma.
- 10:52You could go back to the world that Martin Luther King was describing.
- 10:56All of those victories are temporary because the powers of bigotry and ignorance, hatred and oppression are always bubbling away under the surface.
- 11:05And they bubbled right to the surface with Donald Trump winning things.
- 11:13Winning things.
- 11:14And, of course, when he didn't win, he lied.
- 11:16He lied through his teeth.
- 11:18And he watched as his own supporters, his absolute base, his victims, his mugs, his marks, embarked upon a rampage of murderous violence against the very democracy that had previously and subsequently delivered him power, power that he abused heinously,
- 11:34egregiously, constantly.
- 11:36And those of us who are on the other side, the side of human beings, the side of humanity, the side of fairness, decency, equality, not grabbing women by the genitals, not high office to enrich yourself on a medieval
- 11:53scale, not trying to shut down criticism, not trying to shut down media commentary, not trying to do any of those things.
- 12:04We forget sometimes that you never stop fighting.
- 12:07You never stop battling.
- 12:09You always, always keep your fists up.
- 12:15And so today, I'm kind of asking you the same question that I asked you yesterday, but from a completely different perspective, from a perspective of stop.
- 12:24I think the kids call it deeping it.
- 12:26Stop deeping it.
- 12:27Stop deeping it.
- 12:29Just feel the burn, feel the wind.
- 12:31This is extraordinary.
- 12:32Some of the examples of what has happened feel as if they've almost happened.
- 12:40In a foreign country.
- 12:42I don't mean by.
- 12:43I mean the United States of America is a foreign country.
- 12:45But they feel as if they've happened in a country that didn't exist.
- 12:49The first black female governor in US history.
- 12:52The first Muslim in the Senate.
- 12:54The first Latino governor elected in California.
- 12:57Texas gets its first Latina governor.
- 13:00First female Native American governor.
- 13:02Florida's first black governor.
- 13:03The first openly gay man elected to the U.S.
- 13:05senate.
- 13:06There's been a couple of hundred closeted gay men, of course, first.
- 13:10I mean, and that is a tragedy.
- 13:11Let me be absolutely clear.
- 13:13We can all see the consequences of men who feel compelled to hide their sexuality or feel such shame at it that they can never admit it, even to themselves.
- 13:22First Native American woman elected to Senate.
- 13:24First black governor of Wisconsin, Nevada's first elected black governor.
- 13:28First female governor of Ohio.
- 13:29First black female governor of a U.S.
- 13:31territory in the Virgin Islands.
- 13:33First female senator elected in South Carolina.
- 13:35First all female gubernatorial ticket in New York.
- 13:37And the first female governor in Minnesota.
- 13:40And okay, you're sitting there thinking, well, I'm a white man, I'm a white straight man.
- 13:44Why should I be celebrating?
- 13:46I am a white straight man.
- 13:48What on earth should I be celebrating for?
- 13:50Well, you're also a human being.
- 13:52You are a human being.
- 13:54And don't worry, white straight man like me, you've still got almost all the power, you've still got almost all the big jobs, you've still got almost all the plum positions in the most prestigious professions.
- 14:07You've still got way more hands on the steering wheels of society than anybody else.
- 14:13But if you really want to move towards a place where hatred is in retreat, where freedom is prioritized, where decency is normal, then you have to have equality, you have to have diversity, and you have to have inclusion.
- 14:30Because another thing that I think we'd lost sight of as a consequence of that Overton Window moving.
- 14:37And again, I appreciate not everybody knows what it means.
- 14:43It simply is that the acceptable parameters of conversation.
- 14:47So when Enoch Powell gave his Rivers of Blood speech, he got fired by Ted Heath.
- 14:52Enoch Powell was outside the Overton Window.
- 14:54What he said was beyond acceptance.
- 14:57If he gave it now, he'd get promoted by Cami Badenough, quite possibly.
- 15:02And if he didn't, he'd defect immediately to reform and be made Home affairs spokesman.
- 15:06So that is what the Overton Window does.
- 15:08Racism is more acceptable in public discourse today than it was when Enoch Powell gave his Rivers of Blood speech.
- 15:14Which is an incredible thing to reflect on, but probably the best illustration I can give you of what the Overton Window is.
- 15:21And it's not just race, of course.
- 15:22It's also transgender human beings.
- 15:25It's also gay human beings.
- 15:27It's also Muslim human beings, Jewish human beings, black human beings, brown human.
- 15:32It's about what you can say about people who have done absolutely nothing to offend you, what you can say with impunity.
- 15:40Somebody with brown skin commits a crime.
- 15:42You can make hideous comments about everybody who was not born in this country and has brown skin.
- 15:48The Overton Window has moved beyond recognition, beyond recognition.
- 15:52And I think that this moves it back.
- 15:55And if you don't want to live in a world where you are distracted from the reality of your own existence, your own experience, if you don't want to live in a world where the people responsible for the things
- 16:06that you're unhappy about are constantly trying to persuade you to blame someone else.
- 16:12What's that?
- 16:12Mixed toilets.
- 16:14Flipping heck.
- 16:15Don't look at how much money Thames Water has made in the last few years.
- 16:19Get angry about toilets that men and women can use.
- 16:22That's the point.
- 16:23If you want to live in a world where actually grievances are directed at the people responsible for them, then you need to celebrate diversity.
- 16:32You need to celebrate equality, you need to celebrate inclusion.
- 16:37And it took me a while, in fact, I'm not even sure it happened before this introduction to this program to realize why they hated it so much.
- 16:45It's not exactly rocket science.
- 16:47Why do they keep going on about diversity, equality, and inclusion?
- 16:50Because that is the absolute enemy of politics that allows people to blame minorities and allows people to blame utterly innocent individuals.
- 17:01That allows people to lie about Haitians, about Muslims, about Jews, about people of color, about gay men, about gay women, about trans men, about trans women.
- 17:11As long as you can lie about them, as long as you can whip up hatred about them, you can get on with ripping your own country off.
- 17:18You can get away with filling your own pockets with filthy luca.
- 17:23That's what did for Trump, knit all of those things together.
- 17:26That's what finally did for it.
- 17:28I'm still skin, and he's made $2 billion.
- 17:31I'm beginning to think that it's not actually the fault of immigrants, it's not actually the fault of Haitians.
- 17:38You know, I'm beginning to wonder whether they even eat cats and dogs at all.
- 17:41So it doesn't matter that it wasn't a rejection of the racism.
- 17:45It wasn't an outright and explicit rejection of the lies and the corruption.
- 17:48It was a calculation that includes all of those things I couldn't do this introduction yesterday because I hadn't had time to think about things.
- 17:55I hadn't had time for it to settle.
- 17:57I only saw the result when I got out of bed and looked at my phone.
- 18:00That's why I came on air yesterday.
- 18:01A bit deflated, a bit downbeat, because I'm thinking, well, it's still a country that put a fascist in the White House.
- 18:08It's still a country that has a man in charge who has chosen Vladimir Putin over Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
- 18:15It's still a country that elected a man who boasts about sexually assaulting women.
- 18:19It's still that country, but it's also the other country.
- 18:22It's also the country that has rejected all of that for a whole heap of reasons which I think are probably a lot more linked than you might otherwise acknowledge.
- 18:31So how big a deal is this for you?
- 18:36Lisa's in Locksheath in Southampton.
- 18:37Lisa, what would you like to say?
- 18:39Yeah, yeah, I've been on before.
- 18:42I feel proud again.
- 18:44I haven't been able to.
- 18:45I've been embarrassed to be an American in the last few years.
- 18:48And I voted in California and I voted in what was a very red area.
- 18:53It's been red all my life.
- 18:55And I was always the kid in school that was a Democrat.
- 18:59For the benefit of British listeners, I just need to remind people that red is.
- 19:03Yes, red is.
- 19:04No, no, red is.
- 19:05Red is.
- 19:06Right, sorry, Red.
- 19:07Yeah, there we go.
- 19:08For the benefit.
- 19:09Of.
- 19:09I grew up in a very Republican area.
- 19:11There we go.
- 19:11For the first time, my vote counted and it went blue.
- 19:15And it was really.
- 19:17I was proud that my city actually just woke up and said, enough is enough.
- 19:23And it is blue because.
- 19:25Because we're a very agricultural area.
- 19:27We're the richest agricultural valley in the country, the San Joaquin Valley.
- 19:32And the farmers were hurt and they were tired of their ICE picking up their workers.
- 19:39They were tired of the prices for diesel and fertilizer.
- 19:43And they said, enough is enough.
- 19:45I think the immigration thing is a surprising one, isn't it?
- 19:48Because, I mean, it doesn't make you racist to want criminal gangsters who are in the country illegally to be rounded up and deported and not even in a million years.
- 19:59And that was the promise that was made.
- 20:00But that is not because that problem was so negligible in the great scheme of things.
- 20:04That was not what they sought to deliver.
- 20:06But my brother and sister in law just had to go to an immigration hearing in behalf of their gardener.
- 20:12He's been there 35 years.
- 20:14He has four American children.
- 20:16His wife is American, and they want to deport him.
- 20:19And he pays tax.
- 20:20He's a registered taxpayer.
- 20:21This is what Brits don't understand about the American immigration system.
- 20:24Compared to us, it's not a black economy.
- 20:26He's a taxpayer.
- 20:29Tried several, five routes to try to come in.
- 20:34Every time they keep changing the system, and so he reapplies.
- 20:38So he's been trying for 35 years to apply.
- 20:40And that's the thing.
- 20:42Don't realize people talk about immigrants.
- 20:44But for the first time in America, our country is represented by our diversity.
- 20:52And what you just said, you know, there are 15 women governors now out of 50.
- 20:57That's a huge amount.
- 20:58That's almost.
- 20:59That's a huge amount.
- 21:01That's almost one third of our governors are women.
- 21:04And I think that's amazing.
- 21:05And when you look at Georgia, the diversity in the Senate and now as a governor is just amazing.
- 21:12I don't want to be.
- 21:13I don't want to be that guy.
- 21:14But they are progressive women.
- 21:16So, you know, it is often popular among.
- 21:19No, no, no.
- 21:19But they're not all progressive women.
- 21:23The Virginia governor is very, very moderate.
- 21:26No, forgive me.
- 21:27I just meant that they're not, they're not.
- 21:29You're talking about.
- 21:30You're not talking about social.
- 21:31Yeah,.
- 21:32Because we could say, well, we had the first female prime minister in this country, but she was slightly to the right of Genghis Khan.
- 21:37So it's not really a cause for.
- 21:38So that's all.
- 21:39They're all Democrats.
- 21:40Yeah,.
- 21:40Yeah, yeah, you're right.
- 21:41That's what I mean.
- 21:42Yeah.
- 21:42I was going to say.
- 21:42Oh, my gosh.
- 21:43No.
- 21:43But.
- 21:43Yeah, but I also think that I.
- 21:46And the hope that fills me is because I've taught politics and I know the American system.
- 21:50Trump is not going to be able to veto everything because there's no hold he has over these congressmen and women because he can't primary them.
- 22:00He's done.
- 22:01So they will start.
- 22:02Think they will start coming over little by little, and you can actually overturn a veto with two thirds of the Congress.
- 22:09So you're going to watch a lot of people jumping ships.
- 22:12And this is my hope that we're going to get more done because people are looking already at 2028.
- 22:19They're already talking about the presidential election and they're already talking about running again.
- 22:23So this is all.
- 22:24We're on election Mode now for 2028.
- 22:26And just a quick word, if you would, on my personal realization this morning.
- 22:31It's always tension.
- 22:33There's always battles to be fought.
- 22:35And just because the other lot have been winning for what feels like forever doesn't mean you don't stay true to the things that you know are right.
- 22:42Yeah.
- 22:43And also corruption.
- 22:44Corruption was a huge thing.
- 22:46And I think people are really upset that Elon Musk and people like this have so much power and they don't want to have data centers in their back gardens and this is what's happened.
- 22:56And they feel like I'm the little guy and I want to be something.
- 23:01And I was really proud of the students coming out in droves.
- 23:05I mean, in droves.
- 23:06Yes.
- 23:07And the, you know, the size of Elon Musk's wealth breached the 1 trillion dollar mark according to some reports.
- 23:15And you sit here as a Brit thinking, can these people not see what's going on?
- 23:19They can't afford to fill their trucks with gas and he's worth a trillion dollars and he's trying to tell them what to do or he's trying to pretend he's got their interests at heart.
- 23:28And also I think the president making it all about the reflecting pool the day before, that.
- 23:34Was extraordinary.
- 23:35Well, the thing is.
- 23:37But it's showing you how there are no guardrails with this president and nobody thought to tell him or ignored, don't do that.
- 23:45That's a stupid thing to do.
- 23:46See Obama, Obama faced the headwinds in 2010 after his midterms, but he still worked over the across the aisle.
- 23:56And that's what Trump.
- 23:57He will not be able to do that.
- 23:59I think he might check out, actually.
- 24:01I think he might be president in name, but not in actuality.
- 24:04Of course, the alternative is that he goes completely bonkers and starts doing terrible things, particularly on the world stage.
- 24:10And you know, once again, good for business, bad for the soul.
- 24:13But we'll keep a close eye on things and try to keep these little flames quite big and growing flames of optimism and hope burning.
- 24:21Because I think it's time perhaps to jettison that old adage about despair being the thing you can bear and hope being the thing that you can't.
- 24:28Because if you let your hope get extinguished, then corruption wins, evil wins, racism wins, fascism wins.
- 24:36That's the point, isn't it?
- 24:37And yesterday's conversation about the 20% that swing it one way or the other is still pertinent, it's still accurate, but it's, it's not the most important element of this discussion because of course, everybody benefits from decency, even the
- 24:52people who think that it's their enemy.
- 24:55Time For a short break now.
- 24:56Afterwards, the best callers in the business.
- 25:06Chris is in Brighton.
- 25:07Chris, what would you like to say?
- 25:10Hi, James.
- 25:11I suppose I'm feeling just a lot more hopeful.
- 25:15Despite best impressions.
- 25:16I was born in the United States of America and Virginia.
- 25:19Most of my family are American and we've kind of, it's just been, I think your previous caller nailed it.
- 25:24Basically just been an incredibly embarrassing kind of disgrace the last kind of 10 years, really.
- 25:31And I think one of the reasons that it's been allowed to happen is I think the Democrat Party has kind of been at war with itself for the whole of that 10 year period.
- 25:38Basically where you've got the Bernie Sanders wing of the party and the Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama wings.
- 25:43I think they just kind of haven't really been able to kind of grapple with how they're going to kind of offer any kind of meaningful change to the American people that can then.
- 25:52Down to the kind of.
- 25:53Yeah, I mean, these are two conversations in a way, aren't they?
- 25:56They're kind of like the principles and then the details.
- 26:00So for me, yesterday I got a bit bogged down in the details and I lost sight of the principles.
- 26:05This is a rejection, at the very least of corruption, of self enrichment on an industrial scale.
- 26:12And I have spent five, two years sitting here thinking, how can the Americans be comfortable with that?
- 26:16How can they all be so dumb?
- 26:18How can they be?
- 26:18And some of them still are.
- 26:20Of course, you know, Republicans won some seats, but there's a rejection on principle here and there's a danger, I think, of getting distracted by the detail.
- 26:30Everything you say is true, but the speeches that I loved the most yesterday, overnight are the speeches that actually addressed principles, not, not details or promises.
- 26:43Principles, decency, humanity, fairness, equality and, and the rejection of hatred and that we can enjoy.
- 26:50We can bask in that until.
- 26:52No, no.
- 26:52I mean, some of the speeches yesterday were incredible.
- 26:55Al Said speech, Talarico speech in particular was absolutely incredible.
- 27:01Ossoff is, in my opinion, going to be the next President of the United States of America.
- 27:05And that is an incredible arrangement.
- 27:07I don't dispute any of those things.
- 27:09I would just say that I think what they've been able to do is they've been able to link those kind of lack of principles and the corruption within the Republican movement to direct impacts on people's lives.
- 27:21But I think previously they weren't able to do that.
- 27:23It's kind of, well, this corruption.
- 27:26It's not just that Donald Trump is getting rich because he's been Getting rich before he started his next, his latest term, it's that.
- 27:34That he's getting rich off the back of building data centers in your backyard.
- 27:38And this is going to cause noise, water pollution, and all sorts of things that are going to change your life in a tangible way.
- 27:44Have we underpriced that in this country's coverage, do you think?
- 27:47You obviously have a foot on both sides of the Atlantic, but people yesterday and now you today are citing this as a really significant swing.
- 27:57Data centers is an absolutely massive issue in America.
- 28:00And if you look at some of the sort of most viral sort of videos in the political sphere within America over the last year, they're all sort of like, you know, campaigners trying to stop data centers within their
- 28:13communities.
- 28:14And the reason that they've gone viral is because they've been able to directly prove that their local officials are just not listening to them because they've been paid off by the tech industry.
- 28:23So I think you're.
- 28:24Making me think of fracking, actually.
- 28:26Yeah, it's exactly that, but on a much bigger scale.
- 28:29And.
- 28:29Of course, it's woke to object to fracking, and indeed, it's woke to object to the continuing exploitation of fossil fuels.
- 28:35But for some reason, the accusation that it's woke to object to data centers hasn't quite landed.
- 28:40Yeah.
- 28:41And then you've also got the fact that the tariffs have directly impacted rural communities.
- 28:46So there is a reason why places like Ohio, Texas have kind of switched, because these communities and also Maine and Place, Michigan and places like that, because they've been directly impacted by these policies.
- 28:58And they can see directly why these policies have been impacted, enacted, and it isn't for the good of American people.
- 29:04And I also stand by the part of what I was saying at the beginning, which is that the Democrat Party, I think, was at war with itself when Trump first was elected.
- 29:15And there was a sort of epochal moment, I think, in the early part of his administration, which was Mamdani becoming the mayor of New York.
- 29:23I think it just.
- 29:24I think it sort of was sent shockwaves to the establishment Democrats was, this is how we're going to have to do things.
- 29:30We may still have differences on ideals and policies that we will argue with, but that has to be done behind closed doors.
- 29:38But this is the kind of campaign that we need to be running,.
- 29:41A tight campaign, disciplined campaign, and.
- 29:44Disciplined with a good orator.
- 29:46It has to be that.
- 29:47And.
- 29:48That ain't Hakeem Jeffries, even though he's likely to be the majority leader in the House.
- 29:51I mean, it was almost ironic to see him and the other fella coming out as the.
- 29:55As the kind of de facto leaders of this movement when they've had absolutely nothing to do with the success,.
- 30:01Nothing to do with this whatsoever.
- 30:03You know, and you can see Ossoff probably, if you, if you sort of cut him to see what he bled.
- 30:09Yeah.
- 30:09You know, he probably would be more, you know, in that element of the party.
- 30:13But he's read the room and he's just.
- 30:15His campaign is very disciplined where if he does get establishment Democrat figures into his campaign, it's people like Barack Obama.
- 30:22It's.
- 30:23It's the ones that you would want.
- 30:25They.
- 30:25Very noticeably during the midterms, I noticed that Hillary Clinton did a bit of a media round, but she wasn't on any of the stunts tickets or anything like that at all.
- 30:33Whereas Obama was.
- 30:35Whereas Obama was.
- 30:36Interesting.
- 30:37Really interesting.
- 30:38Actually.
- 30:38That's two different part.
- 30:39Two very different wings of the same party in a way.
- 30:42Exactly.
- 30:43In 2024, you couldn't have a campaign without Bill Clinton or Hillary Clinton being rolled out, but they were noticeably absent from the campaign this time.
- 30:51So I think for me, I just feel like they've got the message that if they're going to go to the American people and ask them to reject Trump, you know, you have to accept that one of the big
- 31:03mistakes with Trump, I think, that people who don't necessarily follow American politics makes, is that Trump isn't the reason that all of this happens.
- 31:11You know, when Barack Obama won the election in 2028 or the nomination for the Tea Party basically emerged out of nowhere as a rejection of the fact that an African American was going to be potentially the President of
- 31:25the United States of America.
- 31:26And that existed for a full eight years before Donald Trump sort of came down that escalator.
- 31:32So that's his candidacy.
- 31:33And all he's done is kind of like what he does in his business career, which is a kind of leveraged buyout of a political movement and then just rebranded it Margaret and made it about him.
- 31:43That's a brilliant.
- 31:44Going to steal that.
- 31:45So he's a political asset stripper.
- 31:47Exactly.
- 31:47He's just stolen a movement that existed years before he came along.
- 31:52Sarah.
- 31:52Palin, I suppose John McCain tried to co opt it when he appointed Sarah Palin as and as his running mate.
- 31:57But.
- 31:57But McCain wasn't really corrupt enough to ride that.
- 32:00And I think the Tea Party movement could see that he was kind of having a kind of existential fit whenever he shared a kind of stage with her.
- 32:07He's not a proper racist.
- 32:09He doesn't really mean it.
- 32:10You know, I disagree with John McCain on almost everything, but, you know, you could tell that he was at the very least a decent man that operated within a moral framework.
- 32:20You know, I don't think anyone could say that about Palin or Trump, but the problem is that those people are gone.
- 32:25So if you're trying to convince the sort of passive Republican voters, many of whom are in my family, to kind of like reject Trump, then you have to kind of offer them something.
- 32:34And they've got the Democrats have that real opportunity with data centers, the removal of corruption from political, you know, more checks and balances around the president.
- 32:44Not make the next two years about trying to impeach Trump.
- 32:47You know, don't interfere with your enemy while he's, you know, you know, basically destroying himself.
- 32:52Just let him destroy himself and then try and just build a message to the American people and coalesce around the leader that offers real change, which I think they are doing.
- 33:03I.
- 33:03Think you're right.
- 33:04I think this is one of the best analyses I've heard.
- 33:06You obviously spend more time following American politics than I do or can, but this is really, really strong and it hinges ultimately on the question of whether or not we believe what these characters we have mentioned have said
- 33:21in the last 48 hours.
- 33:23And at the moment there's no reason not to.
- 33:26Yeah, yeah.
- 33:29I think it's impossible to come out of the last 10 years and not feel a level of cynicism about American politics.
- 33:35That was yesterday's show, Chris.
- 33:38It's impossible.
- 33:39If you are, if you've been watching even half heartedly or even just, you know, once a year, American politics over the last 10 years.
- 33:47And you're not cynical about it, you're completely unhinged.
- 33:50In my opinion.
- 33:51It's been deeply troubling and unsettling for not just Americans, but for the whole world.
- 33:57Yeah.
- 33:57And the closer you are to America, the more unsettling it has been because we have watched friends and neighbors, colleagues and commentators who we used to have at least a modicum of respect for the John McCain Principle.
- 34:08People who you knew were fundamentally different.
- 34:10Even if you had a different view on economics or upon military spending or upon foreign policy, you knew that they weren't going to end up cheering for a self confessed sex offender or someone who revels in racism.
- 34:25And yet here we are.
- 34:26I don't know why Richard Littlejohn just popped into my mind at that point in the conversation, but he did Chris, thank you very much.
- 34:32Time for a short break now, but when we get back, we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 34:47Ivar's in Crystal Palace.
- 34:48Ivar, what would you like to say?
- 34:50Hi, James?
- 34:52Yeah, I think what, what's really interested me about this whole, this, this whole race in, in the, in the U.S.
- 34:56i, I, I lived in Dallas, Texas, when I was a kid, so I've, I've always been fascinated by particularly Texan, Texan politics.
- 35:04And, you know, the, the, the whole campaign that James Talarico ran was just absolutely fascinating to watch because, you know, he ran as an unapologetic, you know, open, openly Christian guy.
- 35:18I mean, the guy's the guy studying to be, to become a pastor.
- 35:21Yeah.
- 35:21And it's really interesting from, from a British perspective to look at this because we, we are much more reticent when it comes to talking about faith in politics.
- 35:30We don't, you know, our politicians, you know, Alistair Campbell famously said, we don't do God.
- 35:35I.
- 35:36Think we'd be suspicious of a candidate who was training to be a vicar or a priest or a rabbi or an imam or whatever it may be.
- 35:44I think that the general default British response, probably post Reformation, would be of skepticism or suspicion,.
- 35:51And I'm broadly comfortable with that because I'm British.
- 35:55But at the same time, when you look at it from the perspective of an American, particularly in a conservative state like Texas, I think it's so important to see just how powerful that campaign has been in really putting
- 36:11the tanks on the MAGA lawn and saying, okay, you guys talk about Christianity all the time.
- 36:17You guys talk about Christian identity.
- 36:19You talk about America losing its Christian identity.
- 36:22You talk about, you use language that is marinated in Christian identity.
- 36:30But what does your Christian ethic look like?
- 36:33And I think what's been really interesting is that people like Talarico starting to flip the conversation and say, okay, if we're going to have a conversation about faith in the public square, then it's meaningless unless you're talking about
- 36:48what that means in terms of a public ethic.
- 36:50You can talk about your identity of faith until the cows come home.
- 36:55But, I mean, Jesus himself said, you know, we will.
- 36:57You will be known by your fruits.
- 36:59Right?
- 36:59It's like, what kind of, what kind of policies are you talking about?
- 37:03What do you want do to, to be to other people?
- 37:05What, I mean, this is a guy that gave his victory speech standing behind a podium saying, love thy neighbor, you know, in Texas.
- 37:13And so.
- 37:14We should Have a listen to that, shouldn't we?
- 37:15The Talo Eco victory speech.
- 37:17Because you're right, and it does land differently on this side of the Atlantic.
- 37:22We forget how.
- 37:23I mean, genuinely religious a lot of America is.
- 37:26And of course, these people are not religious at all.
- 37:29These people are not living a Christian life.
- 37:32They're not abiding by Christian values.
- 37:34I mean, I always remember Donald Trump being asked, well, what his favorite bit of the Bible was.
- 37:37Yeah.
- 37:38And he.
- 37:38Said, he said, he said all back when we thought these things would matter.
- 37:42But, you know, you're claiming some sort of Christian affiliation, some sort of Christian allegiance, while doing profoundly unchristian things.
- 37:49It tempts you to forget that some people might be the real deal.
- 37:52Talarico might genuinely believe.
- 37:55I think he does.
- 37:56I've got no reason not to.
- 37:57But his Christian ministry is authentic.
- 37:59Yeah.
- 38:00And I think it's.
- 38:01I think it's an important lesson to reflect on here in the UK because even though we do talk about things very, very differently, we do have a hard right that is increasingly using the language of Christian identity to
- 38:13talk about, you know, what they're.
- 38:15What they're.
- 38:17Well, mostly.
- 38:18Mostly to attack people who are not white and people which, of course, Jesus probably wasn't, and people who are.
- 38:26Well, and to rob women of bodily autonomy.
- 38:29It usually boils down to down.
- 38:31Down with Muslims and down with abortion.
- 38:35That's what they claim is Christian.
- 38:36And Talarico's gone there.
- 38:37He went there last year.
- 38:38You probably know this, but many people listening won't.
- 38:40He's pointed out that abortion isn't in the Bible.
- 38:42There's no set Christian orthodoxy on abortion.
- 38:44And someone else who got elected made exactly the same point about transgender people.
- 38:49I think I'm gonna try and dig that clip out as well.
- 38:52Yeah.
- 38:53I mean, I find the guy incredibly interesting to listen to and quite challenging, and it's welcome.
- 39:02And I'.
- 39:03I think rhetorically, there are definitely lessons to be learned here in the UK about.
- 39:09As that sort of rampant Christian identity rhetoric ratchets up over here, what is the ethical response to that?
- 39:20And how do you flip it and say, okay, you talk about Christian faith.
- 39:27What does that actually mean, you know, within the context of the public square and what it means.
- 39:33To.
- 39:34Really interesting to me.
- 39:35Are you.
- 39:35Are you a man of faith?
- 39:36Do you mind me asking?
- 39:37I have.
- 39:38I have a very complicated relationship.
- 39:40Okay.
- 39:40I mean, I grew up a Christian, but I wouldn't.
- 39:43I wouldn't.
- 39:43I.
- 39:44I wouldn't identify.
- 39:45You feel.
- 39:46Protective of it?
- 39:47I think, in a way, I Do I do too?
- 39:48Which is weird because.
- 39:50Well, it isn't weird at all.
- 39:51I feel protective of the beauty that's contained within the Gospels and I hate to see it being abused and co opted by people who are the opposite of what Jesus was trying to encourage people to be.
- 40:01And it doesn't mean you think, think that any of the other stuff is definitely true or that you've got very strong views on an afterlife just as a work of philosophy or even as a self help guide, that
- 40:14the Gospels are pretty clear and these people who claim to be doing Christian work are living the opposite.
- 40:20Right up to and including the characters turning up with crosses.
- 40:23Yaxley, Lennon marches.
- 40:25Absolutely.
- 40:26And I sometimes joke with friends.
- 40:27I sometimes describe myself as a.
- 40:30Of Christian.
- 40:31Probably.
- 40:31I sometimes say I'm.
- 40:32I'm probably the most Christian agnostic I know.
- 40:36Yes.
- 40:37But it's, it is a powerful story and it's, it's a story that on a, on a personal level I struggle with in terms of my own identity.
- 40:47Do I really believe, et cetera, et cetera.
- 40:48But in the public square, that's where I experience it most powerfully.
- 40:53And I think particularly in American politics, you just have to read the speeches of someone like Martin Luther King.
- 40:58Yeah.
- 40:59And it's like this is a powerful redemptive story that can be used in a very religious society like America to bring about incredible change.
- 41:09And I just, I think the Democrat Party and progressive politics in general is sitting on a goldmine of potential in terms of flipping that narrative into something that is.
- 41:21It's been a dirty word on the left for a long, long time.
- 41:26And I don't say that as someone who is wanting to push a faith onto somebody else.
- 41:30I'm saying rhetorically, it's a powerful story.
- 41:34It's a powerful message that I think someone like Talarico is showing.
- 41:39And Adam Hamilton in Kansas as well.
- 41:42I don't know how much I think that this is like that Bernard Shaw line about two countries divided.
- 41:48In this case not by a common language but by a common religion.
- 41:51But you're absolutely right that to see Christianity weaponized by far right fig and borderline fascists while we're too busy wringing our hands about whether heaven actually exists to stand up and fight for the beauty of what Christian teachings
- 42:08can bestow other religions as well.
- 42:09Of course.
- 42:10But we're talking about Christianity because it's so intrinsic to American politics.
- 42:14And thank you for not only reminding us of that, but for absolutely explaining what's in play at the moment.
- 42:20And the pastor, I Met.
- 42:22Well, the Democrat I mentioned, Adam Hamilton, is also a church pastor and like Talarico, he has gone to places that American politicians haven't really gone to before.
- 42:31And if they have, they haven't won.
- 42:33And it matters.
- 42:35I'm going to share a little more of this with you in a moment and then we'll take a view on whether to continue this conversation or to send it off in a slightly different direction or to do something
- 42:43completely different.
- 42:44I'm leaning at the moment towards doing a little bit more for one, one rather obvious reason that I'm sure you've noticed.
- 42:51Every single caller today has a much better grasp of American politics than I do.
- 42:56And I've got an A level.
- 43:05Religiousness in the United States of America is absolute.
- 43:10It's a huge political issue.
- 43:12Funny, in this country, the kind of Donald Trump sympathizing fascists who had done so well recently would tell someone like the Archbishop of Canterbury to stay out of politics.
- 43:22They're so dishonest, aren't they?
- 43:23I mean, it is extraordinary.
- 43:25I really, really revel in the clarity that comes with a little bit of victory and a little bit of success.
- 43:31Telling the Archbishop of Canterbury to stay out of politics while fetishizing a country in which religion is so intrinsically tied to politics is just an act.
- 43:43Usually it's ignorance.
- 43:44They're just too thick and ill informed to know what they're banging on about.
- 43:47They're just attacking whoever it is.
- 43:48That said, don't be racist, even if it's the Archbishop and Canterbury.
- 43:52But it is extraordinary when you step back and clock the full scale of this utter grift.
- 43:58So usually they're just ignorant and ill informed.
- 44:01But sometimes, of course, they'll be deeply aware of how intrinsic religion is to American politics, but they'll just turn off their brain and shout, get out of politics.
- 44:10Religion's got no place in religion is politics.
- 44:12Politics in some ways is religion.
- 44:15You don't think Jesus was a religious figure?
- 44:17They're not.
- 44:17And I've got a bridge that you might be interested in buying.
- 44:20So this is really interesting what Ivar just said and really missing from most British political coverage is that Talarico most obviously, and this chap as well, Adam Hamilton, are trying to reclaim Christianity from the fascists.
- 44:38By the way, there's a deep relationship between fascism and Catholicism.
- 44:43You don't need me to tell you that.
- 44:45But it works because religion can be authoritarian.
- 44:49Religion, and I was raised as a Catholic, saw the good and a lot of the bad tells you what to do.
- 44:57So Some people who love the idea of telling you what to do or indeed using the cloak of authority to abuse you in any imaginable way will be drawn towards religion.
- 45:07Politicians that are dishonest and exploited would love to use religion to pretend that they have some sort of divine right to abuse you.
- 45:16Donald Trump posting pictures of himself redrawn as Jesus is not a coincidence.
- 45:20It's part of a phenomenon that I'm describing to you now, an absolutely undeniable and crystal clear part of that phenomenon.
- 45:27Because America is so religious.
- 45:29You saw the stuff, right, of them putting their hands on him, a self confessed sex offender, a mattress who wants nothing more than to be best friends with a war criminal.
- 45:40You saw all the footage of him with pastors and religious leaders putting their hands on Donald Trump, a man who boasts about where he likes to put his hands on women, whether they have consented to it or not.
- 45:53And it is an utter corruption.
- 45:55And Ivor's really set me thinking because I feel protective towards Christianity, even though my relationship with it is very complex and probably too intellectual.
- 46:05When my dad died, I was so desperate to believe in heaven that for a long time I did.
- 46:10Now I don't really think about it as much, but if I did, I probably wouldn't.
- 46:16But religion as a thing of beauty, Christianity as a religion of peace and love being co opted by agents of violence and hatred is huge in the context of American politics and probably the biggest thing we miss when
- 46:34we look at it from Britain.
- 46:35So this guy, Adam Hamilton, this is a brilliant headline.
- 46:39I love these sort of things.
- 46:40It's like, how do you measure things in Journalese if you're not using double decker buses?
- 46:46Do you know what I mean?
- 46:48It's the size of 54 Olympic swimming pools.
- 46:50This is the equivalent of that.
- 46:51The last time Kansas, the state of Kansas, elected a Democrat to the Senate, Judy Garland was filming the wizard of Oz.
- 47:02That's how long ago?
- 47:03Not quite 100 years.
- 47:05I think it was 1932.
- 47:06But anyway, the last time that the state of Kansas sent a Democrat to Washington in the senate was in 1932.
- 47:18And this time they've sent the leader of the United States largest United Methodist Congregation, 24,000 congregants campaigning on a promise of civility, moderation and open ears.
- 47:34Have a little listen to what he had to say.
- 47:36I think it was last year.
- 47:38Where do you come down on transgender rights?
- 47:40Well, first of all, I don't understand everything there is to know about transgender people.
- 47:43What I can say is this.
- 47:45I don't think we should take a small group of people and bully them, pick on them, and hurt the.
- 47:51I think, you know, I look at people and I understand one thing really clearly when it comes to transgender, and that is Jesus told me I was to love my neighbors, but I love myself.
- 47:58And so I'm going to love the trans person as well as the straight person, as well as the, you know, male or female.
- 48:05I just think we have to do better than picking on small groups.
- 48:08And what's happened is we've turned a group of people into a campaign issue because it polls well.
- 48:13I just don't think that's okay.
- 48:15And I think we have to treat people decently and humanely, and that's all people.
- 48:19And so that's what I'd say.
- 48:21I'm governed by what Jesus said was the second great commandment, love your neighbor as you love yourself.
- 48:26We dealt quite well with that.
- 48:27Of course, if the journalist had chosen to shout, can a woman have a penis?
- 48:30At him, then he may have stumbled and struggled because it's, I mean, you know, a really tricky issue.
- 48:37But that basic humanity there, basic kind of human, have a penis.
- 48:42A basic humanity there is really inspiring.
- 48:44And it's been completely missing an awful lot of people who see themselves as anti trans campaigners or whatever they prefer to identify as.
- 48:53I don't know that they deserve all the responsibility for unleashing these tidal waves of hatred and victimization, but it was visible from space.
- 49:01Two things visible from space that people were determined not to see in the last 10 years of international politics.
- 49:08Number one was that if you give permission to a society to talk about transgender people as if they are subhuman women, then that permission will extend to other categories as well.
- 49:21Just watch.
- 49:22Just sit back and watch.
- 49:23Why would Donald Trump jump on the anti trans bandwagon if he didn't think it was going to drive him to a place where he could be even more explicitly racist or misogynistic.
- 49:33I'm not saying you knew that was going to happen, but I'm saying you were warned.
- 49:37And the second thing actually is that Benjamin Netanyahu was going to render Israel an international pariah state.
- 49:42And this week we've seen that it has become too toxic, even for J.D.
- 49:46Vance.
- 49:47And again, everybody who warned that that was going to happen and that the safety and security of Israel moving forward would be much better served by not backing the far right genocidal regime of Benjamin Netanyahu.
- 49:59That got you called anti Semitic.
- 50:01Funny, isn't it?
- 50:02So you pointed out that the anti trans movement was going to make life much harder for pretty much everybody body.
- 50:08And you got called a woman hater, I think, or a misogynist, or you pointed out that Benjamin Netanyahu was going to lead Israel to a place where even Republicans would turn their back on it.
- 50:19And I don't know where you go for support when they've turned their back on you.
- 50:23You got called anti Semitic.
- 50:24Two little lessons.
- 50:26And what is really interesting about these midterm results is that they offer up a reset of things that some of us had perhaps began to think couldn't be reset, couldn't be reversed, couldn't be changed.
- 50:39That is, you know, a 62 year old Christian preacher sounding sensible and humane on the issue of transgender people who thought that was going to happen.
- 50:50Simon is in act.
- 50:51And Simon, what made you pick up the phone?
- 50:53Good morning, James.
- 50:55First time caller, should I say,.
- 50:57You're very welcome, say, not nervous at all.
- 51:00First time caller, not nervous at all.
- 51:02It's only you.
- 51:04Friends and I were on a Central Line Tube train yesterday chatting gleefully about Trump getting a pasting.
- 51:11Yeah.
- 51:11And we were interrupted on three separate occasions by three complete strangers, or women, as it happens, who just joined in and just said things like, yes, isn't it brilliant?
- 51:23Oh, just amazing that.
- 51:25What did one of them say?
- 51:26He's a hateful man.
- 51:28I was so pleased to read the news today and you know what it's like on tube trains.
- 51:32You know, people tend to keep their, their own space and.
- 51:34Yes,.
- 51:35They don't chat and interact with other people.
- 51:37Well, it happened three times to us on the Tube yesterday.
- 51:40Why?
- 51:41And.
- 51:41I thought that was.
- 51:42Oh, so it's like a weight has been lifted somehow,.
- 51:46Because you don't know it's there sometimes, do you?
- 51:49You're just, you're repressed, oppressed by it, I think.
- 51:52And that.
- 51:52And I know for me it's taken 24 hours or more for that weight to lift.
- 51:57And that sense of this is the world.
- 51:59Actually, it's not a world that I thought I lived in.
- 52:02It's a world.
- 52:03World that they run and that they dominate, where hatred is normal and where being vile is rewarded.
- 52:11And of course, we live in both worlds.
- 52:13That's all we need reminding of.
- 52:14We live in both worlds and oceans rise, empires fall.
- 52:19Yeah.
- 52:20Were.
- 52:20You talking very loudly?
- 52:22Were you being quite.
- 52:23Tell me the truth, had you had an ale?
- 52:26No, but I was talking a little bit loudly because I like to spread the good word, you know.
- 52:30No,.
- 52:30No, it's an invitation to others.
- 52:32It's an invitation to others.
- 52:33And the Central Line, because the Piccadilly line in the Elizabeth Library is such dire straits yesterday that the Central Library is probably picking up new custom at every stop.
- 52:41And yeah, I mean it should be.
- 52:43That's what I opened yesterday by comparing this to Obama's election and feeling less about this.
- 52:49In some ways you should feel more because Obama marked the end of the Bush era.
- 52:54It didn't necessarily.
- 52:55What happened in the midterms suggests that the end of a much, much, much worse period in world history may be coming to an end.
- 53:03Although of course those, those chickens are yet to hatch.
- 53:07Thank you, Simon.
- 53:07Andrew is in.
- 53:08I'm not playing the kicked in the head by a horse clip, for God's sake.
- 53:12Look, it might be the finest clip in the history of LBC radio and yes, it pains me to say that as the self appointed king of clips, but I'm not.
- 53:19I'm playing clips that are relevant to the US midterm results.
- 53:22Results.
- 53:23If you don't know what the kick to the head of the horse clip is, then look it up and, and thank me later.
- 53:28Andrew's in Stockton on seas.
- 53:30Andrew, what would you like to say?
- 53:32James, I'm really sorry to be the Marv and the miserable.
- 53:36Here.
- 53:36He is, here he is, here he is.
- 53:39Enter stage left misery guts from Stockton Aunties.
- 53:43Go on then.
- 53:48I feel like the guy on the film Pressure telling you you can't invade France.
- 53:53Dodgy.
- 53:54But that's where we are.
- 53:57You are on day one of Thermopylae.
- 54:00You've just beaten however many persons and everyone's singing and dancing and going, it's all over.
- 54:05Great.
- 54:06They've gone back and then you find there's another 300 ships were turned up.
- 54:12Tell me why, tell me why you're not feeling sure.
- 54:14Yeah,.
- 54:15Here we go.
- 54:15Here go we, we go.
- 54:16You were dealing with a one off incident in 2026.
- 54:21The folks who are arranging all of this have been doing this for 50 years.
- 54:26This is an over to a permanent Overton window switch from democracy and the ideas of freedom into basically a group of very, very wealthy people deciding what the hell happens.
- 54:40And it started with John Birch and the PTA in the 60s.
- 54:44It's gone through all these bizarre things, think tanks.
- 54:48And let me tell you one thing because I just worked it out before, you know, everyone's going, where are you Beating the trillionaires.
- 54:55In Elon Musk's wealth terms, if you related it to the average UK earnings, he spent £14 80.
- 55:08God, you really are a miserable get.
- 55:10On you.
- 55:11I know, but.
- 55:14What's that in dollars?
- 55:16About 11, isn't it?
- 55:18The pound's gone up, so it might be 10.50.
- 55:22Yeah.
- 55:23So.
- 55:23You know when we're going this great victory, he literally said, here, Donald, I've got a tenner in my wallet.
- 55:29Will that do?
- 55:30Take this.
- 55:31I mean, that's technically correct, but you're not.
- 55:35It's technically correct, but it doesn't mean he won't be feeling epic humiliation.
- 55:39And you can tell it is.
- 55:40No, that is true, but remember, this is an ongoing project.
- 55:43And Jeanette, what really, really changed after Obama?
- 55:47Go on.
- 55:48Because Obama was their low point.
- 55:50It was everyone else's high point.
- 55:51Yes, of course.
- 55:52So we had Obama, we had the 2012 Olympics.
- 55:56Wasn't life going rather well?
- 55:58No one wanted to leave the EU, etc.
- 56:00Etc.
- 56:01Etc.
- 56:03And then our billionaire friends went, oh, we reproached the other way.
- 56:09Who else has lots and lots of money and wants to keep it?
- 56:13Autocratic dictators.
- 56:15They're quite good, aren't they?
- 56:17So for the first time in your life, you've got these anti communist billionaires going, why don't we have a word with Vlad?
- 56:25And effectively you've now got the billionaires working with the dictators to bugger everything up for everyone else.
- 56:33Well, I mean, it's an analysis I've shared in the past, but I think that you, you suffer from undue pessimism in that nothing is ever permanent, which it did.
- 56:42Well, if you learn anything from history, go back to the classics.
- 56:45Even, even, even the Roman Empire can fall.
- 56:47So there is never any permanence to any of this.
- 56:50No, no, no.
- 56:52This is potentially the beginning of a reversal.
- 56:56It's certainly the beginning of a fight back.
- 56:57Whether, I mean, you'd have been no good at all in Star wars, would you, mate?
- 57:01You'd have been bending the knee for Darth Vader in the.
- 57:03Before the opening credits had finished.
- 57:06Before that great.
- 57:07Obi wan.
- 57:08I'm OB.
- 57:09OB1, pal.
- 57:10I'm.
- 57:10I'm OB1.
- 57:13But that, but that is the point.
- 57:15You.
- 57:15Can beat them in the end if you know what you're facing.
- 57:18Well,.
- 57:18Exactly.
- 57:18And I think, I think these.
- 57:20No, we're not.
- 57:20Facing.
- 57:21No, we do know what we're facing.
- 57:22Because I mean, a, the speeches that were delivered by these people speak directly to some of the things that you describe and B, the conspiracy of right wing politics, client journalists and lobby groups masquerading as think tanks is
- 57:37probably better understood than it, than it has been at any point.
- 57:41Since that chicken farmer set up the so called Institute of Economic affairs or indeed since the fellow you mentioned took on the John Birch, took on the pta.
- 57:52I genuinely believe that that actually, I mean, this might even be a high watermark.
- 57:57But I'm just meeting your pessimism with my optimism and suggesting that if nothing is ever permanent, then the beginning of the end of the bad state stuff has to happen at some point and it could, and I think
- 58:11it probably is happening now.
- 58:13But as I said just before you came on, I think, as I said, those chickens ain't hatched yet.
- 58:20It is 11:42.
- 58:21You are listening to James O' Brien on LBC.
- 58:24Let me just take a moment because today's show has been spectacular and yesterday's was brilliant as well.
- 58:29And I think we've kept up the standard that we had from 10 o' clock today where pretty much every caller has not known more about American politics than I have.
- 58:38But this, of course is, is one of the reasons why we've launched a subscription service for this program.
- 58:43Well, not for this program, for me, for this presenter, which contains lots of exclusive content as well.
- 58:50It's called James o'.
- 58:51Brien.
- 58:52Plus you can find it right now on the Global Player app, the official lbc app, or lbccatchupplus.com you can also sign up via YouTube.
- 59:01YouTube.
- 59:02What you get is everything I do on the radio with all the adverts removed.
- 59:06You get the podcasts, all the podcasts I do with all the adverts removed.
- 59:10And crucially, you get exclusive content which we're now recording on a regular basis.
- 59:15The best bit so far is you having the opportunity to ask me anything you want.
- 59:19And there's two ways of approaching that.
- 59:21You can either be curious about something regarding me and people are, you know, don't snigger, or you can be the phone in host and I'll be the caller.
- 59:31So you can just ask me a question, a bit like the questions that I ask on the radio but haven't got around to asking.
- 59:35Because if I have got around to asking it, I've almost certainly got around to answering it.
- 59:39So there's anything.
- 59:40That's why it's called Ask James Anything.
- 59:41There's a clue in the title, right?
- 59:43And then there's James Reacts.
- 59:44We could do the Kicked in the Head by a Horse clip on James Reacts.
- 59:48But I don't.
- 59:49There'd be no.
- 59:49Well, I could tell you I could do that actually, because I could talk you through exactly what was going through his head.
- 59:55Head as that call unfolded given that I am also a radio presenter who occasionally gets taken by surprise on the or maybe not, but anyway, that's another little bit of exclusive content.
- 1:00:05But the bit I think I'm most excited about is the newsletter, which I'm only going to write for you.
- 1:00:11Still doing my newspaper column, but at least twice a month and probably more if the appetite is there.
- 1:00:17I'm going to be just, just writing straight from the the hip about whatever seems to me to be most important or most interesting.
- 1:00:25So sometimes it'll be cultural, other times it'll be political.
- 1:00:29Today, because I'm writing it after the show today, it will be about this and it will involve, of course, Andrew's pessimism, my optimism and all of the calls that we've taken and what it's done to me in the
- 1:00:39course of being a listener to this program as well as, would you believe it, being the person that sometimes seems to do almost all of the talking.
- 1:00:46So I'll be writing that later today and that is exclusive only to subscribers to James o' Brien Plus.
- 1:00:51So if you want to sign up for that, it is a MIA 4.99amonth and you can do so.
- 1:00:59You got to be over 18.
- 1:01:01Be a nice Christmas present actually, wouldn't it, Keith?
- 1:01:03You could buy a year's subscription for someone.
- 1:01:0549.99 have you got your mum anything yet?
- 1:01:0849.99 I probably do you a deal, mate.
- 1:01:11Of course I can't 49.99 for a whole year or 4.99amonth.
- 1:01:16And you can get on board via global Player app, the official lbc app, or lbccatchupplus.com and we're done for another day.
- 1:01:24Huge thank you to all my contributors for some truly special conversations.
- 1:01:28I'll be back on lbc tomorrow from 10 or right here shortly afterwards.
- 1:01:33This has been a global production.