Latest / The Line Podcast / On The Line: Fixing Canada's refugee system in the Trump era
Transcript
- 0:00Hello,
- 0:00ladies and gentlemen,
- 0:01I am Jen Gerson,
- 0:02and this is this week's episode of On The Line.
- 0:05SPEAKER_02: Today,
- 0:06SPEAKER_02: I have with me Adam Sedinsky,
- 0:07who is an immigration and refugee lawyer and also a member of
- 0:10the Canadian
- 0:11SPEAKER_02: Association of Refugee Lawyers.
- 0:12SPEAKER_02: Why am I speaking to Mr. Sedinsky?
- 0:14SPEAKER_02: Why?
- 0:15SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 0:15because immigration and refugee lawyers are now arguing that we
- 0:17need to change our
- 0:18approach to the Safe Third Country Agreement in light of the
- 0:21changes to immigration
- 0:22and refugee status that have been put into effect in the United
- 0:26States under the
- 0:26SPEAKER_02: administration of Donald Trump.
- 0:28SPEAKER_02: I'm going to be speaking at length with Mr.
- 0:30SPEAKER_02: Sidinski to talk about what the Safe Third Country Agreement is,
- 0:33SPEAKER_02: why it matters,
- 0:34SPEAKER_02: and why he thinks it needs to be altered.
- 0:36SPEAKER_02: That's on this week's edition of On the Line with Jen Gerson.
- 0:54This message is brought to you by the Forest Products
- 0:57Association of Canada.
- 0:59SPEAKER_00: Canadian forestry supports 200,000 workers,
- 1:02SPEAKER_00: generates $87 billion in annual revenue,
- 1:05and provides the products we need to build homes and drive
- 1:08economic growth.
- 1:10SPEAKER_00: While trade barriers from the U.S.
- 1:11SPEAKER_00: threaten jobs and investment,
- 1:13Canada's own approval processes and regulations are blocking
- 1:16critical projects that
- 1:18SPEAKER_00: increase our self-reliance.
- 1:20SPEAKER_00: We can and should have programs that expand domestic wood use,
- 1:24SPEAKER_00: advance biomass and pulp market opportunities,
- 1:27SPEAKER_00: and cut red tape and regulatory barriers.
- 1:29The Government of Canada has a clear opportunity to stand up
- 1:32for Canadian forestry
- 1:34SPEAKER_00: at a time of growing global uncertainty.
- 1:36SPEAKER_00: We need real action that puts Canadians first,
- 1:39SPEAKER_00: supporting employees and their families,
- 1:41SPEAKER_00: securing stability for our businesses,
- 1:43SPEAKER_00: and protecting the long-term potential of our sector and its people.
- 1:47SPEAKER_00: To learn more, visit forestryforthefuture.ca.
- 1:51SPEAKER_02: Well, hello, Adam Sedinsky.
- 1:53SPEAKER_02: Very nice to have you on On The Line.
- 1:54And thank you so much for taking some time out of your day to
- 1:57explain to us what is
- 1:58going on with refugees in Canada and how we need to be
- 2:03responding to the Trump administration.
- 2:05So I decided that I wanted to talk to you today because your organization,
- 2:09SPEAKER_02: the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers,
- 2:11SPEAKER_02: put out a really interesting press release on
- 2:13about the way that Canada needs to be approaching something
- 2:16called the Safe Third
- 2:17SPEAKER_02: Country Agreement in response to what's happening in the United States.
- 2:20SPEAKER_02: So assume that I'm real dumb and explain to me in simple terms,
- 2:25SPEAKER_02: just for any audience members who don't know,
- 2:28SPEAKER_02: what is the Safe Third Country Agreement and how does it work?
- 2:33SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 2:33So the Safe Third Country Agreement at its very core is a
- 2:37treaty between Canada and
- 2:39SPEAKER_01: the United States.
- 2:40Whose objective is to share the responsibility of refugee
- 2:45protection and refugee
- 2:46SPEAKER_01: determination between Canada and the U.S.
- 2:50SPEAKER_01: It's not the only agreement of this type in the world.
- 2:53SPEAKER_01: There are other countries who have agreements like this.
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: And at the basic level,
- 3:00SPEAKER_01: what the Save Third Country Agreement does is it says,
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: you are expected to make a refugee claim or claim asylum.
- 3:08SPEAKER_01: We use different terms for this in Canada and the US.
- 3:11So when I say make a refugee claim,
- 3:13that's the same thing as claiming asylum.
- 3:17SPEAKER_01: You're supposed to do that in the first country that you arrive.
- 3:20SPEAKER_01: So you arrive in the United States, you're expected to claim there.
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: You arrive in Canada, you're expected to claim here.
- 3:27SPEAKER_01: How
- 3:28And just to go into the history a little bit,
- 3:32this Save Their Country Agreement
- 3:35SPEAKER_01: Canada and the U.S.
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: started talking about this in the 90s,
- 3:40and what Canada was seeing at that time was about a third of
- 3:44people who were making
- 3:45refugee claims in Canada were doing so after having previously
- 3:49arrived in the U.S.
- 3:51SPEAKER_02: And presumably being rejected from the U.S., is that right?
- 3:53SPEAKER_01: Not necessarily.
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 3:55SPEAKER_01: A lot of people make claims under the, I'm going to call it the STCA,
- 4:02SPEAKER_01: not having made a claim already in the US,
- 4:06SPEAKER_01: or they may have just started making a claim,
- 4:08SPEAKER_01: but their goal is ultimately to arrive in Canada.
- 4:12And so there were negotiations,
- 4:14but the rubber really hit the road after 9-11.
- 4:18SPEAKER_01: And after 9-11,
- 4:20SPEAKER_01: the US was pressuring Canada to,
- 4:23SPEAKER_01: or asking Canada to implement tougher anti-terrorism laws.
- 4:30And Canada said to the U.S.,
- 4:31okay,
- 4:31we'll do that,
- 4:32but you have to do something for us.
- 4:34SPEAKER_01: Let's sign this agreement to share responsibility for refugee claims.
- 4:38Because the reality has been that there is always more traffic
- 4:43going north from the U.S.
- 4:44to Canada of people who want to make refugee claims than south
- 4:48from Canada to the United States.
- 4:51SPEAKER_02: And why has that been the case historically?
- 4:54SPEAKER_02: So just because we have an easier refugee system?
- 4:57SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 4:58the way that our refugee system works and the way that we
- 5:00process refugees and the
- 5:02way that Canada interprets the refugee definition is a little
- 5:05bit different than in
- 5:07SPEAKER_01: the United States.
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: So on average,
- 5:09SPEAKER_01: and this is not for all cases,
- 5:11a person might have a better chance of receiving protection in
- 5:14Canada than they
- 5:16SPEAKER_01: might in the US.
- 5:17SPEAKER_01: There are also whole categories of people.
- 5:20SPEAKER_01: who are effectively shut out from refugee protection in the US,
- 5:23SPEAKER_01: who get it on a regular basis in Canada.
- 5:26And I'm thinking in particular here about women fleeing
- 5:29gender-based violence.
- 5:31In Canada,
- 5:32we have a task force within the refugee board that deals with
- 5:35claims of that type.
- 5:37SPEAKER_01: But in the United States,
- 5:39SPEAKER_01: people in that position making claims on those grounds,
- 5:42SPEAKER_01: they face huge hurdles to ultimately receiving protection.
- 5:46SPEAKER_01: Generally, our system also works faster than the US system.
- 5:50SPEAKER_02: So with this claim,
- 5:50SPEAKER_02: with this gender based violence,
- 5:53SPEAKER_02: are we talking about,
- 5:53SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:54SPEAKER_02: women fleeing their abusive husbands,
- 5:56SPEAKER_02: that kind of scenario?
- 5:57OK,
- 5:57so those women could come to Canada under under and claim
- 6:00refugee status.
- 6:02SPEAKER_01: Yes, and they do regular.
- 6:04SPEAKER_02: Interesting.
- 6:04SPEAKER_02: OK, I actually didn't see it here.
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: I didn't actually know that.
- 6:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 6:08SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 6:08SPEAKER_01: it really depends on the country that a person comes from,
- 6:11because at the core of refugee protection is a question of
- 6:15whether you can receive
- 6:16SPEAKER_01: protection from your home state.
- 6:18So an American woman in California fleeing her abusive husband
- 6:24in Sacramento or
- 6:25SPEAKER_02: whatever is probably not going to be able to...
- 6:27SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 6:27SPEAKER_01: The expectation is she goes to the police,
- 6:30SPEAKER_01: gets a restraining order,
- 6:31SPEAKER_01: or gets her husband charged,
- 6:35SPEAKER_01: and then she's safe.
- 6:36SPEAKER_01: There's no need to travel internationally.
- 6:40SPEAKER_01: On the other hand...
- 6:40SPEAKER_02: But if you're coming from Saudi Arabia or someplace like that...
- 6:42SPEAKER_01: Many countries in the world where...
- 6:45SPEAKER_01: A woman may not be taken seriously by the police,
- 6:48SPEAKER_01: or there's lots of countries who say,
- 6:49SPEAKER_01: well,
- 6:50SPEAKER_01: this is an internal family matter.
- 6:52SPEAKER_01: Go deal with that at home.
- 6:53SPEAKER_01: We're not going to provide you protection.
- 6:55And in that case,
- 6:56that person is in danger,
- 6:58cannot rely on their home country.
- 7:00And so they're only left with the option of traveling abroad to
- 7:03get protection
- 7:05SPEAKER_01: under international refugee law.
- 7:06SPEAKER_02: So I take it prior to the Safe Third Country Agreement,
- 7:09what was happening is there was a lot of duplication between
- 7:11the American and the
- 7:12SPEAKER_02: Canadian system.
- 7:12So people would potentially be applying for both countries and
- 7:15seeing what worked out?
- 7:17Not so much of applying for both,
- 7:18but choosing which country they wanted to apply in.
- 7:24SPEAKER_01: Shopping a little bit.
- 7:25SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 7:26SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 7:26the term that people use is asylum shopping usually carries a
- 7:30bit of a negative connotation.
- 7:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 7:34SPEAKER_01: But what I often say when this comes up in refugee hearings,
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: when a refugee board member asks my client or me,
- 7:40SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 7:40SPEAKER_01: well,
- 7:40SPEAKER_01: why didn't you claim in that other country?
- 7:44SPEAKER_01: I always like to bring people back to,
- 7:46SPEAKER_01: well,
- 7:46if you're in danger for your life and you want to do the best
- 7:52thing for yourself to
- 7:53SPEAKER_01: make sure that you get protection,
- 7:55it's natural that you're going to want to go to the place where
- 7:58you're most likely
- 7:59SPEAKER_01: to receive protection.
- 8:01SPEAKER_01: And so if a person does that analysis and they say,
- 8:04SPEAKER_01: well,
- 8:04SPEAKER_01: it's more likely that I'm going to get protection in Canada,
- 8:08SPEAKER_01: they will do that.
- 8:10SPEAKER_01: Undergirding the third country agreement,
- 8:12SPEAKER_01: though,
- 8:12SPEAKER_01: is an understanding or an acknowledgement that Canada and the U.S.
- 8:17SPEAKER_01: have relatively similar asylum systems.
- 8:22And so the assumption is that you shouldn't need to shop
- 8:26between the countries,
- 8:28and each country should do its part in terms of making those
- 8:31refugee determinations,
- 8:32SPEAKER_01: accepting those claims,
- 8:34SPEAKER_01: and rather than all of the brunt of the volume going into one country.
- 8:41SPEAKER_01: And so that's how the agreement works.
- 8:45SPEAKER_01: You arrive in the United States, come to Canada,
- 8:49SPEAKER_01: There have been changes in recent years that we can get into.
- 8:52But the basic idea is you cannot then come to Canada and make
- 8:57your claim here.
- 8:58You're sent back to the United States and you have to go
- 9:02through the asylum process there.
- 9:03SPEAKER_02: And is there a big discrepancy in terms of the number of asylum seekers,
- 9:06SPEAKER_02: refugee claimants who get approved in Canada versus the United States?
- 9:10SPEAKER_01: It is significant.
- 9:11SPEAKER_02: It is significant.
- 9:12So people are much better off coming to Canada first than they
- 9:15are going to America.
- 9:16SPEAKER_02: Okay, interesting.
- 9:18So it's safe to say that the safe third country agreement
- 9:21hugely benefited Canada.
- 9:23SPEAKER_02: Is that right?
- 9:24SPEAKER_02: Because it meant because just just by virtue of our geography,
- 9:27it was much more likely that a refugee would land in America
- 9:29first than than in Canada.
- 9:33I mean,
- 9:34it definitely shifts a lot of the responsibility to the United States.
- 9:41SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 9:41And the United States did this as a concession to us in
- 9:44exchange for us passing
- 9:45SPEAKER_02: stronger anti-terrorism legislation.
- 9:47SPEAKER_01: As politics tend to work.
- 9:50SPEAKER_02: That's horse trading, baby.
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: So this has been a law that's benefited us.
- 9:56SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 9:56we've seen in recent years America has really struggled with
- 10:00migrants and refugees,
- 10:02SPEAKER_02: particularly south of the border.
- 10:03SPEAKER_02: There's been significant cultural and I think political backlash.
- 10:08to immigration generally,
- 10:09but also specifically to illegal immigration in the United States.
- 10:12And Canada has been unduly smug about its pro-immigration
- 10:18policies until fairly recently.
- 10:20And I say unduly because we've benefited from things like the
- 10:23Safe Third Country Agreement.
- 10:24SPEAKER_02: We've benefited from being surrounded on three sides by an ocean.
- 10:27And we've benefited from the fact that America really absorbs
- 10:30these flows so that
- 10:31SPEAKER_02: we don't have to.
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: We also benefit from a relatively restrictive visa policy.
- 10:36SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: You come from a country where that produces lots of refugees,
- 10:43SPEAKER_01: it's much more difficult to get a visa to fly to Canada.
- 10:47SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 10:47So we like to imagine ourselves as being more welcoming to
- 10:50refugees and immigrants.
- 10:51SPEAKER_02: But in reality,
- 10:52we're just more welcoming to refugees and immigrants once they
- 10:55actually get here.
- 10:56SPEAKER_02: But we make it much more difficult for them to get here.
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: Is that safe to say?
- 10:59SPEAKER_02: It is.
- 11:00SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 11:00SPEAKER_02: So our smugness is undue.
- 11:02SPEAKER_02: This is what I'm saying.
- 11:03SPEAKER_02: We're not necessarily better.
- 11:06SPEAKER_02: But I don't know.
- 11:06SPEAKER_02: Maybe you disagree with that.
- 11:08SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 11:10SPEAKER_01: it's the usual compared to...
- 11:15SPEAKER_01: Our refugee system,
- 11:16SPEAKER_01: I will say,
- 11:17SPEAKER_01: is one that has been modeled in many countries.
- 11:21SPEAKER_01: And Canada has won awards internationally for its refugee system.
- 11:27SPEAKER_01: We have a good one.
- 11:28SPEAKER_01: As you say, once people are here, we do what we can...
- 11:32SPEAKER_01: to keep people out.
- 11:34SPEAKER_01: And the Safe Third Country Agreement is an example of that.
- 11:37SPEAKER_01: But once people are here,
- 11:38SPEAKER_01: we have a system that works,
- 11:41SPEAKER_01: that gets people protection who need it,
- 11:43SPEAKER_01: and gets them through the system relatively quickly.
- 11:46SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 11:46SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 11:46we're going to get into that because first I want to talk about
- 11:49what you guys are saying,
- 11:50because I think that was really important set up so that people
- 11:52really understand
- 11:53SPEAKER_02: what the safe third country agreement is and why we benefit from it.
- 11:56So it seems kind of counterproductive for a Canadian to be
- 11:59calling for effectively
- 12:00SPEAKER_02: the end of the safe third country agreement,
- 12:02SPEAKER_02: because this benefits us,
- 12:04SPEAKER_02: doesn't it?
- 12:05SPEAKER_01: Well, it depends.
- 12:08SPEAKER_01: It depends what you mean, first of all, by it benefits us.
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 12:14SPEAKER_01: you can say it benefits us in that we receive fewer claimants.
- 12:18SPEAKER_01: The question is,
- 12:21Legally,
- 12:21ethically,
- 12:24what should we be doing vis-a-vis people who need protection?
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: And we know or we suspect are not going to get it in the United States.
- 12:35As I said,
- 12:35the agreement...
- 12:36Maybe we should get really specific about this.
- 12:39What's changed to the United States that changes Canada's moral
- 12:43responsibilities to
- 12:44SPEAKER_02: refugees coming to North America?
- 12:46SPEAKER_01: So I'll take a step back and say that as an organization...
- 12:51We and others have been calling for an end to the Safe Third
- 12:54Country Agreement
- 12:55SPEAKER_01: since long before Donald Trump became president the first time.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 13:00It's an agreement that is problematic because its very basis is
- 13:05not one that as
- 13:06SPEAKER_01: refugee advocates,
- 13:08SPEAKER_01: we believe...
- 13:10is necessarily accurate in that we have these substantially
- 13:15similar refugee systems
- 13:18where a person can expect to have the same level of protection
- 13:21in both countries,
- 13:22SPEAKER_01: and so it doesn't matter where you are.
- 13:24SPEAKER_01: In reality,
- 13:25SPEAKER_01: it really does matter where you are,
- 13:27SPEAKER_01: as I mentioned,
- 13:28because of the way that Canada interprets the Refugee
- 13:31Convention and also in the
- 13:33SPEAKER_01: way that we treat people once they're in Canada.
- 13:35SPEAKER_01: For example,
- 13:37SPEAKER_01: In the US, detention is regularly used against asylum claimants.
- 13:43SPEAKER_01: They're regularly detained.
- 13:45SPEAKER_01: Whereas in Canada,
- 13:47SPEAKER_01: in line with UN guidance,
- 13:50SPEAKER_01: detention of immigrants,
- 13:52SPEAKER_01: refugees,
- 13:53SPEAKER_01: is a last resort.
- 13:56SPEAKER_01: And so recently,
- 13:58SPEAKER_01: in the past few years,
- 13:59SPEAKER_01: for the second time,
- 14:01a number of organizations challenged the safe third country
- 14:04before the Supreme
- 14:05SPEAKER_01: Court of Canada.
- 14:06arguing in part that the detention regime in the United States
- 14:10and the way that
- 14:12SPEAKER_01: refugees are treated in the United States,
- 14:15SPEAKER_01: both in terms of the actual conditions that they face,
- 14:18SPEAKER_01: as well as...
- 14:20The matrix of laws that they face puts Canada in a position
- 14:25where we could be in
- 14:28SPEAKER_01: violation of our obligations under the Refugee Convention,
- 14:32which is not to send people back to a country where they would
- 14:36face persecution.
- 14:37SPEAKER_02: Can we sort of get into the details?
- 14:40SPEAKER_02: What do you mean by detention?
- 14:41SPEAKER_02: What does America do to detain refugees?
- 14:44SPEAKER_02: What does that look like?
- 14:46SPEAKER_01: It means you make an asylum claim, you approach the border.
- 14:51SPEAKER_01: The first instinct is that you will be detained.
- 14:54SPEAKER_01: Now, it's not automatic for everyone.
- 14:55SPEAKER_01: It's dealt with on a case-by-case basis.
- 14:58SPEAKER_02: And what does detained look like?
- 14:59Does that mean they're being put up in hotels and can't leave
- 15:02for weeks at a time?
- 15:03SPEAKER_02: It means you're in jails.
- 15:04SPEAKER_02: They're in jails.
- 15:05SPEAKER_02: They're in jails.
- 15:06SPEAKER_02: They're in jails.
- 15:07SPEAKER_02: And for what length of time?
- 15:09SPEAKER_02: Are they being detained while their paperwork's being processed,
- 15:12SPEAKER_02: or are they being languishing in jails for years at a time?
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: It really depends on the case.
- 15:17What we've heard recently in the United States is that many
- 15:20more people are being
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: detained for longer and longer periods of time.
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: This is since Trump's inauguration.
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: But
- 15:31It has always been an essential tool of the United States
- 15:37immigration system that
- 15:39SPEAKER_01: asylum claimants,
- 15:41SPEAKER_01: irregular migrants are detained.
- 15:44SPEAKER_01: Whereas in Canada, they are for a number of reasons.
- 15:48If you can't establish your identity,
- 15:50if you're found to be a danger to the public.
- 15:53SPEAKER_01: But in general, it's not used in regular course.
- 15:59SPEAKER_02: So when someone comes to Canada and makes a refugee claim,
- 16:02SPEAKER_02: they're presumably,
- 16:03SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 16:04SPEAKER_02: processed in some kind of,
- 16:06SPEAKER_02: um,
- 16:06SPEAKER_02: government bureaucratic room,
- 16:08SPEAKER_02: they sign out all their paperwork,
- 16:09SPEAKER_02: whatever.
- 16:10SPEAKER_02: And then after the end of that,
- 16:11SPEAKER_02: it's okay,
- 16:12SPEAKER_02: off you go,
- 16:13SPEAKER_02: like come back in three weeks and we'll tell you where your paperwork is.
- 16:16SPEAKER_02: Like what's, what, what happens to them at that point?
- 16:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 16:18SPEAKER_01: So the,
- 16:19SPEAKER_01: so the first thing that happens when someone makes a refugee claim,
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: let's say at the border or at the airport,
- 16:25SPEAKER_01: um,
- 16:27SPEAKER_01: is they fill out paperwork,
- 16:29they meet with an immigration officer who determines whether or
- 16:33CBSA officer who
- 16:34SPEAKER_01: determines whether they're eligible to make their refugee claim.
- 16:38And what they all receive immediately upon making the refugee
- 16:43claim is what's
- 16:44SPEAKER_01: called a conditional departure order.
- 16:46SPEAKER_01: So once you make a refugee claim in Canada,
- 16:48SPEAKER_01: you are on a path that goes to one of two final destinations.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: One is to being accepted as a refugee,
- 16:56SPEAKER_01: which allows you to apply for permanent residence,
- 16:58SPEAKER_01: or you're on a path to deportation.
- 17:01And that departure order becomes a deportation order the moment
- 17:05your refugee claim is refused.
- 17:07SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 17:08SPEAKER_01: people can appeal,
- 17:10but it becomes effective and in force once you're found to be
- 17:14not a refugee.
- 17:16So once you have that condition order,
- 17:17you're basically free to leave the airport.
- 17:19SPEAKER_02: You've got to go find a hotel.
- 17:20SPEAKER_02: You find your own place to live.
- 17:21SPEAKER_02: You stay with family.
- 17:23SPEAKER_02: What happens to people once they leave the airport with that order?
- 17:26SPEAKER_01: Yeah, you named it.
- 17:28SPEAKER_01: Depending on the situation, they may have family.
- 17:31SPEAKER_01: They may go to a shelter.
- 17:34SPEAKER_01: In the past, the government was housing people in hotels.
- 17:36SPEAKER_01: That's happening still, but to a lesser extent.
- 17:40SPEAKER_01: But they're not jailed.
- 17:42SPEAKER_02: They're not jailed.
- 17:43SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 17:43SPEAKER_02: And they're free to come and go.
- 17:44SPEAKER_02: And then what's the timeline that it takes a typical refugee?
- 17:49Let's take our hypothetical Saudi Arabian woman fleeing an
- 17:51abusive husband at home
- 17:53SPEAKER_02: kind of situation.
- 17:55How long would it take her to from the point where she lands at
- 17:57the airport to the
- 17:58point where the government would then say you're a legitimate
- 18:00refugee or you're not
- 18:01SPEAKER_02: a legitimate refugee and you should be sent home?
- 18:04SPEAKER_01: What's the timeline?
- 18:05SPEAKER_01: The timelines have really fluctuated over the past few years,
- 18:10SPEAKER_01: both because of the pandemic and backlogs that have been experienced.
- 18:17It's been on average about two years from the time that people
- 18:20make their claim
- 18:21SPEAKER_01: until they get a determination by the Refugee Board.
- 18:25But with greater numbers of claims in recent years,
- 18:28the Refugee Board has...
- 18:30advise us that they forecast that those times are going to
- 18:33increase potentially up
- 18:35SPEAKER_01: to four years.
- 18:36SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 18:36SPEAKER_02: so we're going to come back to internal capacity issues in a minute,
- 18:39but I want to get back to this because I think it's important
- 18:41to compare and
- 18:42SPEAKER_02: contrast the Canadian situation to the American situation.
- 18:44What you just described to me is a relatively humane procedural
- 18:51system for dealing
- 18:52SPEAKER_02: with refugee claimants,
- 18:53and we can describe about whether or not there's problems in
- 18:56terms of getting
- 18:57SPEAKER_02: people processed at an appropriate time frame or not.
- 19:01SPEAKER_02: But in America,
- 19:02SPEAKER_02: it seems like they land in America,
- 19:04SPEAKER_02: you make your refugee claim and off to jail you go for two years.
- 19:08SPEAKER_01: Not not not necessarily.
- 19:11SPEAKER_02: OK.
- 19:11SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 19:14SPEAKER_01: I'm not I'm not an expert on the US asylum system,
- 19:18so it's hard for me to to speak in great detail about what
- 19:22their timelines are,
- 19:23SPEAKER_01: how long people remain.
- 19:25SPEAKER_02: And I'm sure it depends radically from case to case.
- 19:27SPEAKER_01: Of course.
- 19:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah, of course.
- 19:30SPEAKER_02: But they are looking at significant periods of detention in a jail.
- 19:36SPEAKER_01: They're looking at periods.
- 19:37SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 19:38SPEAKER_02: And on that basis,
- 19:39SPEAKER_02: the argument has been even before Trump that because that's the case,
- 19:43SPEAKER_02: because there is not comparable treatment between the two countries,
- 19:46it's not really ethical for Canada to be sloughing off refugee
- 19:50claimants back to America.
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: Well, that's one part of the argument.
- 19:55SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 19:55SPEAKER_01: The second one is the heart of refugee law.
- 20:00is a duty that comes out of the 1951 Refugee Convention of non-refoulement,
- 20:07which simply means the obligation not to return people to a
- 20:11country where they
- 20:13SPEAKER_01: would face persecution.
- 20:15SPEAKER_01: And so all countries who are signatories,
- 20:18SPEAKER_01: parties to that agreement,
- 20:20SPEAKER_01: the Refugee Convention,
- 20:21SPEAKER_01: which Canada is,
- 20:23have an obligation to ensure that people are not returned to
- 20:26countries where they
- 20:27SPEAKER_01: would face persecution.
- 20:29SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 20:30So in Canada,
- 20:32we have an idea of what kinds of people would face persecution.
- 20:37And we have an interpretation of the Refugee Convention that
- 20:43identifies certain groups,
- 20:44SPEAKER_01: certain types of cases,
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: always on a case-by-case basis,
- 20:49that they would meet the definition of a refugee and receive
- 20:53refugee protection in Canada.
- 20:56That interpretation in Canada is very different than in the
- 20:59United States.
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: And as I said,
- 21:01SPEAKER_01: women fleeing gender-based violence,
- 21:03our broader interpretation of that definition allows those
- 21:08people to apply for and
- 21:09SPEAKER_01: receive protection that they would not in the United States.
- 21:13SPEAKER_01: So from the Canadian perspective,
- 21:15SPEAKER_01: those are people who are deserving of protection,
- 21:18SPEAKER_01: that if we allow them to
- 21:21or if we force them back to the United States to a system where
- 21:25they are unlikely
- 21:27SPEAKER_01: to receive protection,
- 21:29are we now in violation of our international human rights
- 21:33obligations not to send
- 21:35SPEAKER_01: people back to a place where they fear persecution?
- 21:38SPEAKER_01: Now, it's not us doing it.
- 21:39SPEAKER_01: We're not sending them directly,
- 21:40but we're sending them to a place where we know that the likely
- 21:43outcome is going to
- 21:44SPEAKER_01: be that they are sent.
- 21:45SPEAKER_02: So let's put a dot on the I and a cross and the T on that one.
- 21:49SPEAKER_02: Let's give an example.
- 21:50SPEAKER_02: Let's say,
- 21:51SPEAKER_02: would the Saudi Arabian woman who's fleeing her husband back home,
- 21:55SPEAKER_02: let's say she stops in America,
- 21:58SPEAKER_02: realizes she has no case in America,
- 22:01SPEAKER_02: goes back to Canada...
- 22:03SPEAKER_02: Canada says,
- 22:03SPEAKER_02: well,
- 22:04SPEAKER_02: because you have violated the safe third country agreement,
- 22:07SPEAKER_02: we're not going to hear your case in Canada.
- 22:09SPEAKER_02: You've got to make your claim back in America.
- 22:11SPEAKER_02: America looks at this and says,
- 22:13SPEAKER_02: that's cute,
- 22:14SPEAKER_02: but you don't meet our standard for a refugee back off to Saudi Arabia.
- 22:18SPEAKER_02: Would that be a sort of a real example?
- 22:21SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 22:21SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 22:22SPEAKER_01: it's not,
- 22:22SPEAKER_01: look,
- 22:24SPEAKER_01: I will concede,
- 22:25it's not automatic that that person's claim is going to be
- 22:27refused in the United States,
- 22:29SPEAKER_01: but that's effectively how it works.
- 22:31SPEAKER_01: Now, there are exceptions to the Save Third Country Agreement.
- 22:36SPEAKER_01: If that woman has family in Canada, she's allowed to enter Canada.
- 22:42SPEAKER_01: If she flies to Canada, the agreement does not apply at the airport.
- 22:47So this is,
- 22:48say she had a connecting flight through New York and then
- 22:51landed in Montreal.
- 22:55That's a bit more complicated as she wouldn't have entered the
- 22:57United States.
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: But either way, the agreement doesn't apply to her.
- 23:01SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 23:02if she went to LaGuardia and flew to Montreal and arrives in
- 23:05Montreal and makes a claim,
- 23:07SPEAKER_01: the safe third country doesn't apply.
- 23:10SPEAKER_02: Why not?
- 23:10SPEAKER_02: Why wouldn't it apply if you're flying?
- 23:11SPEAKER_01: It only applies at the land board.
- 23:14SPEAKER_02: Well, then that seems weird.
- 23:16SPEAKER_02: Why wouldn't it apply at an airport?
- 23:19SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 23:24SPEAKER_01: It's a good question.
- 23:26SPEAKER_02: Because,
- 23:26SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 23:27SPEAKER_02: the number of people applying or,
- 23:28SPEAKER_02: like,
- 23:29SPEAKER_02: literally tromping across the border,
- 23:31SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 23:31SPEAKER_02: we know there were some,
- 23:32SPEAKER_02: but it's not,
- 23:34SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 23:35SPEAKER_02: tens of thousands at the Roxham Road crossing a couple years ago,
- 23:38SPEAKER_02: but,
- 23:38SPEAKER_02: like,
- 23:39SPEAKER_02: the vast majority of refugees are coming into Canada through the airport.
- 23:43SPEAKER_02: Are they not?
- 23:44SPEAKER_01: Now, yes.
- 23:45SPEAKER_01: In 2023, the Safe Third Country Agreement was expanded.
- 23:51SPEAKER_01: You mentioned Roxham Road.
- 23:53Prior to 2023,
- 23:53the Safe Third Country Agreement only applied at official ports
- 23:59of entry.
- 24:00SPEAKER_01: So your Thousand Island Bridge, your Peace Bridge...
- 24:05SPEAKER_02: So someone could hypothetically,
- 24:08SPEAKER_02: our Saudi Arabian wife,
- 24:10SPEAKER_02: we're just going to use her as an example here,
- 24:12SPEAKER_02: this very hypothetical figure.
- 24:14SPEAKER_02: She flies from Saudi Arabia to New York,
- 24:17SPEAKER_02: doesn't make an application in New York,
- 24:19SPEAKER_02: instead makes flies from New York to Toronto.
- 24:24SPEAKER_02: Safe third country wouldn't apply.
- 24:25SPEAKER_02: She makes a refugee claim in Toronto.
- 24:27SPEAKER_02: Am I right?
- 24:28SPEAKER_01: Correct.
- 24:29SPEAKER_01: Also, she crosses irregularly into Canada.
- 24:33So she would only be deported back into the United States if
- 24:39she were to rent a car
- 24:41SPEAKER_02: and drive across the border.
- 24:43SPEAKER_01: Or now,
- 24:44SPEAKER_01: so since 2023 and an expansion of the Safe Third Country Agreement,
- 24:49SPEAKER_01: to apply across the entire land border,
- 24:52SPEAKER_01: including both regular ports of entry and irregular ports of entry.
- 24:56SPEAKER_01: If she were to cross through the forest in Quebec,
- 25:00She would be sent back to the United States if she is
- 25:04apprehended by the RCMP
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: within 14 days of arrival in Canada.
- 25:08SPEAKER_01: And then she's again sent back.
- 25:10So why would anybody walk across the border if all they had to
- 25:12do was fly?
- 25:13SPEAKER_02: They just go to Buffalo and grab like a cheap flight.
- 25:17SPEAKER_01: Because they need a visa.
- 25:21SPEAKER_02: Oh, right.
- 25:22SPEAKER_02: Okay, I get it.
- 25:23Once you're at the land border,
- 25:25you make your refugee claim,
- 25:27you don't need a visa.
- 25:28SPEAKER_01: But to get into Canada by plane, to get onto the plane, you need a visa.
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: And if you have done any international travel,
- 25:35you know that they're now very diligent about checking
- 25:38everybody's visa before you
- 25:39SPEAKER_02: even get on the plane.
- 25:40SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 25:41SPEAKER_02: Like you cannot get on the plane now.
- 25:42And in fact,
- 25:43there have even been crazy stories of people like making breaks
- 25:45for it from the
- 25:47SPEAKER_02: from airplanes onto tarmacks and things like that, right?
- 25:50SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 25:50SPEAKER_02: Okay, so, okay, now I'm getting it.
- 25:52SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 25:53SPEAKER_02: So that makes sense to me.
- 25:55SPEAKER_02: So what's changed with Donald Trump that you're,
- 25:58SPEAKER_02: like,
- 25:58you guys have always had issues with the safe third country
- 26:01agreement because there
- 26:02are some ethical conventions you think that we meet or ethical
- 26:05requirements and
- 26:05SPEAKER_02: legal requirements that they might contravene.
- 26:08But what's changed with Donald Trump that makes the safe third
- 26:12country agreement
- 26:13SPEAKER_02: less tenable from your perspective?
- 26:15SPEAKER_01: Well, there's a few things.
- 26:18First is Trump has continued policies that were started by the
- 26:24Biden administration
- 26:26to suspend asylum claims by people who have crossed into the
- 26:31United States without
- 26:32documents and turning those people away from the United States
- 26:36without having an asylum.
- 26:39SPEAKER_01: So these people,
- 26:40SPEAKER_01: doesn't matter what their reason is,
- 26:42SPEAKER_01: they've come to the United States undocumented,
- 26:45SPEAKER_01: they're apprehended by ICE,
- 26:48SPEAKER_01: Number two,
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: Trump has spoken about removing temporary protected status,
- 26:55SPEAKER_01: TPS status,
- 26:57SPEAKER_01: from a whole host of nationalities.
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: So Canada has moratoriums on removals of people from certain countries.
- 27:08SPEAKER_01: The U S has also had it through this TPS,
- 27:11SPEAKER_01: but Trump wants to remove TPS from many countries of nationality.
- 27:16SPEAKER_01: And I saw yesterday that he announced this also for Ukrainians.
- 27:19SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 27:20SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 27:20SPEAKER_02: So in order to screw Zelensky in particular,
- 27:23because he wasn't sufficiently grateful and respectful at the
- 27:26Oval Office.
- 27:27SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 27:28SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 27:29SPEAKER_02: Awesome.
- 27:29SPEAKER_01: Um,
- 27:30SPEAKER_02: Very defensible.
- 27:31SPEAKER_02: However,
- 27:32SPEAKER_01: and also,
- 27:33SPEAKER_01: Trump has also signaled his intentions by saying,
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: well,
- 27:37SPEAKER_01: we're also going to shut off our overseas refugee program,
- 27:41SPEAKER_01: except for Afrikaners from South Africa.
- 27:43SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 27:44SPEAKER_02: No virtue signaling.
- 27:46SPEAKER_01: Really showing what the objective is here.
- 27:48SPEAKER_02: I really love this new movement away from virtue signaling.
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: That's great.
- 27:53SPEAKER_01: I think it's virtue signaling in a different direction, really.
- 27:56SPEAKER_02: Well, advice signaling, one might even call it.
- 27:58SPEAKER_02: I like that.
- 28:00SPEAKER_02: Great.
- 28:01SPEAKER_02: I stole it from someone, but you can take it.
- 28:03SPEAKER_02: It's not virtue signaling, it's advice signaling.
- 28:05So Trump is removing these protections from people that Canada
- 28:10has decided,
- 28:11these countries are so dangerous that we don't deport anyone to
- 28:15these countries
- 28:16SPEAKER_01: unless they have committed crimes or been involved in serious...
- 28:20SPEAKER_02: Can you give me some examples of some of these countries?
- 28:24SPEAKER_02: What would be some of these...
- 28:25Afghanistan,
- 28:27Venezuela,
- 28:29Gaza,
- 28:32parts of Somalia,
- 28:34Eritrea,
- 28:35and the list goes on.
- 28:36I mean,
- 28:37if you are from those countries,
- 28:40you cannot be removed from Canada.
- 28:42And so there are people in the United States that Trump wants
- 28:44to remove them from
- 28:45SPEAKER_01: the US who are from these specific countries.
- 28:52SPEAKER_01: And these people might ask themselves, well,
- 28:55SPEAKER_01: I'm about to be deported from the U S to,
- 28:58SPEAKER_02: to,
- 28:58SPEAKER_02: to probably certain death or something or persecution.
- 29:03SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 29:04SPEAKER_01: There's an option for it.
- 29:07SPEAKER_01: I might be able to go to Canada.
- 29:10SPEAKER_01: They treat people from my country fairly in that country.
- 29:16SPEAKER_01: The issue is because of the safe third country agreement,
- 29:19those people cannot just approach the Canadian border and say,
- 29:23look,
- 29:23I'm from Sudan.
- 29:25SPEAKER_01: Um, Trump is going to remove my status.
- 29:28SPEAKER_01: Uh,
- 29:29I want to make a refugee claim in Canada because they're still
- 29:32barred from making a
- 29:33SPEAKER_01: claim in Canada because of the safe third country.
- 29:36SPEAKER_01: So as their status,
- 29:37SPEAKER_02: they couldn't get,
- 29:38SPEAKER_02: they couldn't get a visa into the,
- 29:39SPEAKER_02: into Canada then either.
- 29:41SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 29:41SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 29:42So as an organization,
- 29:43we've said,
- 29:45and we're not the first to have said this.
- 29:47SPEAKER_01: In fact, uh,
- 29:48House of Commons Standing Committee on Citizenship and
- 29:50Immigration in 2023 released
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: a report about asylum seekers at the border,
- 29:55and they made two recommendations about exemptions to the Save
- 29:59Third Country Agreement.
- 30:01SPEAKER_01: One is for women fleeing gender-based violence,
- 30:03and one is for people from countries where Canada has a
- 30:06moratorium of criminals.
- 30:07SPEAKER_01: I should take a step back for a second.
- 30:10SPEAKER_01: So there are exceptions.
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: There are exceptions built into the agreement.
- 30:14SPEAKER_01: So if you have a family member in Canada,
- 30:18SPEAKER_01: unaccompanied minors,
- 30:22SPEAKER_01: if you have a family member in Canada and you can prove it,
- 30:25SPEAKER_01: or if you're an unaccompanied minor,
- 30:26it doesn't matter that you were already in the U S you can
- 30:29claim under an exception
- 30:31SPEAKER_01: to the agreement.
- 30:31SPEAKER_01: The same thing as people who face the death penalty in the United States,
- 30:35Canada created an exemption for those people that if you face
- 30:38the death penalty in
- 30:39SPEAKER_01: the United States,
- 30:40SPEAKER_01: you're not barred from claiming refugee protection in Canada.
- 30:43SPEAKER_02: But I mean, that's got to be a nearly impossible exemption.
- 30:47SPEAKER_01: It's very rare.
- 30:48You'd be talking about people who were like convicted to death
- 30:52and like escaping
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: prison and crossing the border or something in that kind of a scenario.
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: So all right,
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: guys,
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: just so you know,
- 30:58if you're ever convicted to death for a crime committed in the
- 31:02United States...
- 31:04SPEAKER_02: Head north.
- 31:06SPEAKER_02: You'll probably be arrested at the border, but you won't be sent back.
- 31:09SPEAKER_02: Is that the deal?
- 31:10SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 31:10SPEAKER_01: not necessarily,
- 31:12SPEAKER_01: because if you've been convicted to death,
- 31:18SPEAKER_01: you're probably going to be ineligible to make a refugee claim in Canada.
- 31:23SPEAKER_01: You'll probably be excluded from protection under the Refugee Convention.
- 31:27SPEAKER_02: So that exemption can't practically be used.
- 31:32SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 31:32SPEAKER_02: it can,
- 31:33but the ultimate result could be that you're returned to your
- 31:36country of origin.
- 31:38SPEAKER_02: But I can't think of a scenario where it has been used.
- 31:42SPEAKER_02: Has there ever been a scenario where that exemption has been used?
- 31:45SPEAKER_01: It may have, but I'm not aware.
- 31:48I think you have to get into Donald Trump death squads level in
- 31:51order to have that
- 31:52SPEAKER_02: particular exemption come into effect.
- 31:54SPEAKER_01: But if I can say the agreement has another section,
- 32:02SPEAKER_01: which allows either country to,
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: on its own accord...
- 32:08SPEAKER_01: decide to create an exemption.
- 32:10In fact,
- 32:10this death penalty one,
- 32:13it's a Canadian use of discretion to exempt those individuals.
- 32:19There's a use of discretion clause that allows you to make
- 32:21exemptions to the safe
- 32:22SPEAKER_01: third country clause.
- 32:24SPEAKER_01: So this is what the House committee recommended,
- 32:26SPEAKER_01: and this is what we're advocating for,
- 32:28SPEAKER_01: which is that,
- 32:30SPEAKER_01: look,
- 32:30SPEAKER_01: there are people in the U.S.
- 32:32SPEAKER_01: who need our protection.
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: who are in danger in the U.S.
- 32:35SPEAKER_01: and in danger in the U.S.
- 32:36SPEAKER_01: of being sent back to their home countries.
- 32:39And so Canada has the power to create exemptions in the safe
- 32:44third country
- 32:44SPEAKER_01: agreement so that they can come to Canada through the front door.
- 32:50SPEAKER_01: Rather than crossing irregularly,
- 32:52than taking dangerous routes through Manitoba in the middle of
- 32:57the winter,
- 32:58SPEAKER_01: we can say we recognize that these people need protection.
- 33:03And we are going to allow them to access our refugee system in
- 33:07an orderly way by
- 33:08SPEAKER_01: approaching the border and saying,
- 33:10SPEAKER_01: I meet an exemption under the Save Third Country Agreement.
- 33:15SPEAKER_01: And this is what we are advocating as well.
- 33:19SPEAKER_01: So in that kind of scenario,
- 33:21SPEAKER_02: it would be like,
- 33:22SPEAKER_02: say,
- 33:22SPEAKER_02: so someone would apply for a visa to come to Canada and they would say,
- 33:27SPEAKER_02: yes,
- 33:27SPEAKER_02: I'm a refugee,
- 33:29but I'm a refugee who qualifies to come to Canada under this
- 33:32exemption of the safe
- 33:33SPEAKER_02: third country agreement.
- 33:34And then you would get your visa and then you could fly in or
- 33:36fly in or drive into Canada.
- 33:38SPEAKER_01: Well, we're talking really about people...
- 33:41SPEAKER_01: In the U.S.
- 33:42SPEAKER_01: And we're talking about the land border.
- 33:44SPEAKER_01: So that they would be allowed to drive to Niagara Falls.
- 33:49SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 33:50Present themselves to a CBSA officer and say,
- 33:54I want to make a refugee claim in Canada.
- 33:56Look,
- 33:57I'm from such and such place,
- 34:00or I'm a woman fleeing gender-based violence.
- 34:03SPEAKER_01: I fall under this exemption.
- 34:06SPEAKER_01: Please let me in.
- 34:07SPEAKER_01: Let me go through the refugee system in Canada.
- 34:10SPEAKER_00: This message is brought to you by the Métis Nation of Ontario.
- 34:14SPEAKER_00: Agawa Bay, Ontario, 1967.
- 34:18SPEAKER_00: Without warning, government officials arrive in float planes.
- 34:21SPEAKER_00: You have to leave, they announce.
- 34:23SPEAKER_00: This land is needed for Lake Superior Provincial Park.
- 34:27SPEAKER_00: For generations, Métis families lived along the shores of Lake Superior.
- 34:31SPEAKER_00: They hunted, fished, harvested maple syrup, and guided visitors.
- 34:34SPEAKER_00: But the government ignored their rights and branded them squatters.
- 34:38SPEAKER_00: Suddenly,
- 34:39Métis families were forced to pack their belongings by
- 34:42government employees who then,
- 34:43SPEAKER_00: under orders,
- 34:44SPEAKER_00: set fire to their homes.
- 34:47The Métis who grew up in the village watched as their family's
- 34:50homes were reduced to ashes.
- 34:52SPEAKER_00: These Métis families, already pushed off their river lots in Sault Ste.
- 34:55SPEAKER_00: Marie generations earlier, had no choice but to leave.
- 35:00SPEAKER_00: But they did not disappear.
- 35:02SPEAKER_00: The Métis of Agawa Bay lost their homes, but never their identity.
- 35:07SPEAKER_00: For more,
- 35:08go to OntarioMétisFacts.com and check out the brand new song
- 35:12about this story by
- 35:13SPEAKER_00: Métis singer-songwriter Amanda Rayum.
- 35:16The song is called One of These Days,
- 35:19and you can hear some of it right now.
- 35:48SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 36:11SPEAKER_02: So I think there's an interesting moral argument to this.
- 36:14SPEAKER_02: There's also a practical conversation.
- 36:16SPEAKER_02: And that is one of the things that,
- 36:17SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 36:17has been on and off in the news in recent years is that the
- 36:20refugee system is overlogged,
- 36:23SPEAKER_02: completely overloaded.
- 36:24SPEAKER_02: There's not enough people to hear these claims.
- 36:28SPEAKER_02: It's really time consuming.
- 36:29And then what happens to these refugees in the years that
- 36:31they're waiting to know
- 36:32SPEAKER_02: whether or not they get approved?
- 36:35SPEAKER_02: Can you even deport them once they don't get approved?
- 36:37SPEAKER_02: I mean, can you find them again?
- 36:39SPEAKER_02: Are we actually keeping track of these people accordingly?
- 36:43SPEAKER_02: I don't know if you can speak to that.
- 36:44What actually is the capacity of our refugee system to allow
- 36:48for these kinds of exemptions?
- 36:50SPEAKER_02: How many more people can we tolerate or take on?
- 36:53And what would need to be done to our system to make it capable
- 36:57of dealing with that?
- 36:59So I think one thing,
- 37:00just to answer one of the questions that you had asked,
- 37:04SPEAKER_01: Is what are these people doing while they're waiting for their hearings?
- 37:07And the answer is,
- 37:10by making a refugee claim in Canada,
- 37:11people are entitled to work permits.
- 37:14And so when I speak to my clients who have recently made
- 37:17refugee claims in Canada,
- 37:19SPEAKER_01: the first question that I get is,
- 37:22SPEAKER_01: when am I going to get my work permit?
- 37:25SPEAKER_01: people want to start working.
- 37:26SPEAKER_01: They want to be able to support themselves.
- 37:28The social assistance,
- 37:29the refugee claimants are entitled to the same as any other Canadian.
- 37:34SPEAKER_01: It's not sufficient,
- 37:35SPEAKER_01: particularly when you're living in major urban centers like Toronto,
- 37:39SPEAKER_01: Vancouver,
- 37:39SPEAKER_01: Montreal.
- 37:40And so people want to start working so that they can support
- 37:43themselves and their families.
- 37:44SPEAKER_01: That's what's happening to them.
- 37:46SPEAKER_01: That's what they're doing in that.
- 37:50SPEAKER_01: We're
- 37:53It would be disingenuous to say that our system has such a
- 37:58great capacity to
- 38:02efficiently process an indeterminate and an infinite number of
- 38:08refugee claims.
- 38:11SPEAKER_01: What we've tried to advocate for,
- 38:13SPEAKER_01: though,
- 38:13SPEAKER_01: is within the Immigration and Refugee Board,
- 38:17the most straightforward claims can be determined without a
- 38:22refugee hearing.
- 38:23SPEAKER_01: And they are determined without a refugee hearing.
- 38:25SPEAKER_01: And the board has that capacity.
- 38:29SPEAKER_01: They have that power.
- 38:30SPEAKER_01: And we've advocated for expanding that.
- 38:33SPEAKER_01: There are countries of origin that have 95-plus percent acceptance rates.
- 38:40And so what happens with this expedited process is you'll
- 38:44receive a letter from the
- 38:44SPEAKER_01: Immigration and Refugee Board.
- 38:45They'll say,
- 38:46you know,
- 38:48we might be considering your claim for an expedited paper decision.
- 38:53SPEAKER_01: Please send us all of your evidence.
- 38:55And then a member of the board reviews all of that evidence to
- 38:58see if you've
- 38:59SPEAKER_01: established what you need to establish.
- 39:01And if they don't actually have to ask you any questions based
- 39:04on what you've proven,
- 39:05SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 39:05SPEAKER_01: maybe you're a political dissident,
- 39:07SPEAKER_01: you
- 39:08in a country where that's illegal and you have photos of
- 39:10yourself speaking to a
- 39:13SPEAKER_01: crowd or media clips of yourself or whatever,
- 39:16SPEAKER_01: whatever evidence it is that you have,
- 39:20the resources of the system don't need to be used in order to
- 39:24determine whether
- 39:25SPEAKER_01: you're a refugee or not in a hearing.
- 39:27SPEAKER_01: You can just be processed on paper.
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: And the more of these simple claims that can be processed on paper,
- 39:35The more the board is able to spend its time and resources
- 39:38focusing on the claims
- 39:39SPEAKER_01: that don't have the merit on their face,
- 39:43SPEAKER_01: that are more complicated,
- 39:44SPEAKER_01: and get those people the decisions that they need,
- 39:47SPEAKER_01: positive or negative,
- 39:49SPEAKER_01: in a speedy way.
- 39:51another was gonna say just i mean aside there what about
- 39:54concerns about abuse of
- 39:55the system i mean to what extent or is the system abused by
- 39:59people who really
- 40:00shouldn't be using it but are looking for a quicker way to
- 40:02immigrate to a wealthier
- 40:04country um are looking for uh you know ways out of their
- 40:08current situation is abuse
- 40:11SPEAKER_01: a major problem in canada so everyone has a right to claim asylum um
- 40:18SPEAKER_01: So everyone has a right to claim asylum,
- 40:20SPEAKER_01: to get into the system,
- 40:22SPEAKER_01: but not everyone ultimately receives asylum.
- 40:27SPEAKER_01: The system is robust.
- 40:29SPEAKER_01: The system works.
- 40:31The government feels that there are problems with integrity of
- 40:35the system,
- 40:35credibility.
- 40:37The Minister of Immigration or the Minister of Public Safety
- 40:40can intervene in a
- 40:41SPEAKER_01: refugee claim,
- 40:42SPEAKER_01: basically to advocate why a person should not
- 40:45receive refugee protection,
- 40:47and they pursue many of those claims in a vigorous way.
- 40:52SPEAKER_01: So where there are claims that seem like they are an abuse of the system,
- 40:57SPEAKER_01: it's not easy to succeed.
- 40:59SPEAKER_01: It's not easy to get through the full process,
- 41:02SPEAKER_01: the robust process before an independent decision maker who will say,
- 41:05SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 41:05SPEAKER_01: yeah,
- 41:06SPEAKER_01: actually,
- 41:06SPEAKER_01: I am going to grant you refugee protection.
- 41:09SPEAKER_01: And that's why we want the focus at the board to be on these more complex
- 41:14SPEAKER_01: potentially less meritorious claims.
- 41:17You can spend a three-hour hearing for an LGBT person from
- 41:22Uganda who faces near
- 41:24SPEAKER_01: certain death if they return to their country.
- 41:26SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I'm pretty comfortable with that person.
- 41:28SPEAKER_02: That person in, you're good.
- 41:30SPEAKER_01: Right?
- 41:30SPEAKER_01: But the question is,
- 41:31how much time and effort is the board going to put into delving
- 41:35into that person's
- 41:36SPEAKER_01: case and determining...
- 41:39SPEAKER_01: determining whether they're entitled to protection.
- 41:41SPEAKER_01: Women from Afghanistan.
- 41:45SPEAKER_01: There's many of these profiles that spring immediately to mind.
- 41:48SPEAKER_01: Yes, yes, yes.
- 41:49SPEAKER_01: Right?
- 41:49SPEAKER_01: Yes, yes, yes.
- 41:51SPEAKER_01: And as I said, how long are we taking to give those yeses?
- 41:55SPEAKER_01: And how much effort are we putting into the system?
- 41:57SPEAKER_01: Because in many of these cases, those people go through full hearings.
- 42:02SPEAKER_01: And I sit there in the hearing wondering, what are we doing here?
- 42:05SPEAKER_01: Why is this person being put through the ringer?
- 42:08SPEAKER_01: It's obvious on the face of these documents.
- 42:12SPEAKER_01: You speak to this person for 15 minutes.
- 42:14SPEAKER_01: You know that they're terrified.
- 42:16SPEAKER_01: What are we spending our time?
- 42:19SPEAKER_01: Now, this is not the only solution necessarily.
- 42:23There is a huge backlog in the system and there are ways to
- 42:28clear that backlog.
- 42:31And we can look to previous times that Canada has faced
- 42:36immigration backlogs and
- 42:38SPEAKER_01: some examples of how to do this.
- 42:40And I think the Mulroney government did this in a couple of
- 42:43different ways to clear
- 42:45SPEAKER_01: out backlogs from the system.
- 42:48One is the minister to determine certain profiles like the ones
- 42:53that we've talked
- 42:54SPEAKER_01: about and say,
- 42:57SPEAKER_01: if you fit into that profile,
- 42:59SPEAKER_01: I'm giving you a permit.
- 43:00We're taking you out of the queue for the refugee board and
- 43:03you're going to be on a
- 43:04SPEAKER_01: path to permanent residence.
- 43:06SPEAKER_01: The board doesn't have to determine that.
- 43:07SPEAKER_01: An immigration officer can determine that in their office.
- 43:10SPEAKER_02: Women and children from these 10 countries, auto, yes.
- 43:14SPEAKER_02: You don't need to mess around.
- 43:16SPEAKER_01: Another example is,
- 43:17SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 43:18SPEAKER_01: we have labor sectors and industries in Canada that are short of workers.
- 43:25SPEAKER_01: And there are refugee claimants.
- 43:27SPEAKER_02: But here's where we get into real dangerous territory,
- 43:29because then are we talking about refugee claimants or are we
- 43:32talking about
- 43:32SPEAKER_02: economic migrants?
- 43:33And shouldn't someone who's coming here for purely economic
- 43:36reasons be going
- 43:37SPEAKER_02: through a standardized immigration system?
- 43:39Well,
- 43:40I'm not saying that this is a person who's coming for economic reasons.
- 43:44SPEAKER_01: I'm saying this is a person who's a refugee,
- 43:46who's in the refugee system and is already contributing to the
- 43:52economy and they're
- 43:53SPEAKER_01: working in an industry.
- 43:54For example,
- 43:56during the pandemic,
- 43:57the government brought in a program for healthcare workers.
- 44:02SPEAKER_01: They called it the guardian angels,
- 44:03people who were working on the front lines of the pandemic that
- 44:06had come to Canada
- 44:08SPEAKER_01: prior to a certain date
- 44:09SPEAKER_01: So that's not a pull factor to Canada,
- 44:12SPEAKER_01: that anyone who fits this profile,
- 44:13they're going to come and make their claim and get through in
- 44:16that economic stream.
- 44:17SPEAKER_01: These are people who are in the refugee stream already.
- 44:20SPEAKER_01: They're working as a doctor, a nurse, a PSW.
- 44:27SPEAKER_01: They're already contributing to...
- 44:29SPEAKER_01: Canada, we need them in the industry that they're working in.
- 44:34SPEAKER_01: And the government said, okay.
- 44:35Are there a lot of refugees who would qualify to work as nurses
- 44:39or doctors?
- 44:39SPEAKER_02: Because,
- 44:40SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 44:40I know that the process for getting qualified to operate as a
- 44:43nurse or a doctor in
- 44:44SPEAKER_01: this country can already be pretty honest.
- 44:46SPEAKER_01: Doctors is not the best example, but...
- 44:49SPEAKER_01: That was one of the criteria.
- 44:51SPEAKER_01: But nurses, PSWs, orderlies, people working in these roles.
- 44:58And there are many refugee claimants who are working in those roles,
- 45:03which are in need.
- 45:05SPEAKER_01: And so what happened was those people were pulled out of the queue.
- 45:10and were allowed to apply for permanent residence by showing
- 45:13that they had certain education,
- 45:16SPEAKER_01: certain number of hours worked with verification from their employers,
- 45:23SPEAKER_01: and they were on a path to permanent residence.
- 45:25SPEAKER_01: You stay, and those are people who are out of the queue.
- 45:29SPEAKER_01: And there are many industries.
- 45:30SPEAKER_01: It doesn't need to just be healthcare workers.
- 45:33SPEAKER_03: House building.
- 45:35SPEAKER_01: Right, construction.
- 45:372023,
- 45:39RBC said that we're short 64,000 jobs in the construction industry.
- 45:46There's a lot of refugee claimants I know because I speak to my
- 45:48clients and I know
- 45:49SPEAKER_01: what they do who work in the construction industry.
- 45:52SPEAKER_02: It just seems like the risk here is that you're creating a pull factor,
- 45:56SPEAKER_02: as you were saying earlier,
- 45:57SPEAKER_02: a pull factor if you're not careful,
- 45:59where anybody who works in construction and who wants to get
- 46:03out of their current
- 46:04SPEAKER_02: situation for whatever reason would come to Canada,
- 46:07SPEAKER_02: claim refugee status and say,
- 46:08SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 46:08SPEAKER_02: I'm a construction worker,
- 46:09as opposed to trying to do the more appropriate route of doing
- 46:13permanent residency
- 46:14SPEAKER_02: and immigration.
- 46:14SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 46:15this is why you set a date for when the person is working at a
- 46:19time prior to when
- 46:20SPEAKER_01: the program comes into effect.
- 46:23You already have to be in the refugee system and working as a
- 46:28construction worker to qualify.
- 46:29SPEAKER_01: It's not
- 46:31SPEAKER_01: for subsequent applications, someone who comes later on.
- 46:34And this is being done consciously in order to reduce backlogs of...
- 46:38Exactly.
- 46:39SPEAKER_01: A one-time thing,
- 46:41SPEAKER_01: pull this chunk of people out,
- 46:44SPEAKER_01: make these ministers' exemptions of the very obvious case,
- 46:48SPEAKER_01: pull that chunk of people out,
- 46:50SPEAKER_01: and now the backlog is more manageable and the board can get through it.
- 46:54SPEAKER_01: And all of these things can work together.
- 46:56SPEAKER_02: So here's the other side of the capacity issue.
- 47:00SPEAKER_02: What happens to refugee claims that fail?
- 47:03SPEAKER_02: Once these people go through this process,
- 47:05SPEAKER_02: you've been in the country for two years,
- 47:06SPEAKER_02: maybe up to four years even,
- 47:08SPEAKER_02: waiting for a board to decide on your claim.
- 47:11The board looks at the evidence and says,
- 47:12yeah,
- 47:13sorry,
- 47:13no,
- 47:14this doesn't qualify.
- 47:16SPEAKER_02: What happens to these people?
- 47:17SPEAKER_02: Are they instantly deported?
- 47:18SPEAKER_02: Are they forcibly deported?
- 47:20SPEAKER_02: How do we know they're deported?
- 47:21SPEAKER_02: Or do they just become sort of undocumented residents in Canada?
- 47:26SPEAKER_01: It really depends on the case.
- 47:30SPEAKER_01: Once people's claims are refused, they are eligible to be deported.
- 47:35SPEAKER_01: They're supposed to leave Canada.
- 47:39Many of them get called in by Canada Border Service and say,
- 47:42okay,
- 47:43you got to go.
- 47:44SPEAKER_01: Uh,
- 47:45SPEAKER_01: but there is,
- 47:45SPEAKER_01: there has been a capacity issue for CBSA in terms of how many people,
- 47:50SPEAKER_01: um,
- 47:51SPEAKER_01: they can remove.
- 47:53SPEAKER_01: And there has been reporting that they have lost track of, uh,
- 47:58SPEAKER_01: of individuals who are out of status.
- 48:02SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 48:02SPEAKER_02: doesn't this doesn't this suggest that part of the problem is that,
- 48:05SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 48:05SPEAKER_02: we can't keep track of people,
- 48:07SPEAKER_02: we can't reasonably deport people after they've their dirt,
- 48:10SPEAKER_02: their immigration application has been sorry,
- 48:13SPEAKER_02: the refugee application has been denied.
- 48:15Does that not point to an argument against opening the doors
- 48:19wider for more refugees?
- 48:22Well,
- 48:23I think to take a step back,
- 48:25we should look at how many refugees are accepted in Canada.
- 48:29SPEAKER_01: And last year,
- 48:31SPEAKER_01: just on the basis of stats at the Immigration and Refugee Board,
- 48:36SPEAKER_01: just focusing on cases that are accepted or rejected,
- 48:39SPEAKER_01: leaving aside ones that are withdrawn or abandoned for various reasons,
- 48:42SPEAKER_01: 80% of cases that were decided on the merits were accepted.
- 48:48SPEAKER_01: And so when we're talking about...
- 48:51SPEAKER_01: refugees coming and making claims in Canada,
- 48:54SPEAKER_01: we're talking about a system where the cases that are being decided are
- 48:58SPEAKER_01: overwhelmingly well-founded and meritorious.
- 49:03SPEAKER_01: These are people who need protection.
- 49:05SPEAKER_01: This is who the system is for,
- 49:07and these are the people who are getting the protection that
- 49:09the system provides.
- 49:11SPEAKER_02: So,
- 49:12SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 49:12we know right now we're going through a bit of a moment with
- 49:14immigration policy in Canada.
- 49:16SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 49:17we for a long time had a very strong bipartisan consensus on
- 49:23the general good that
- 49:24SPEAKER_02: immigration had for Canada and a general support for immigration.
- 49:28SPEAKER_02: Of course,
- 49:29what we saw in recent years was that the number of people
- 49:31coming into the country
- 49:32went up dramatically year over year to the extent that we
- 49:36struggled to cope with
- 49:37basic and keeping up with basic infrastructure for these people
- 49:40in terms of the
- 49:40SPEAKER_02: healthcare system,
- 49:41SPEAKER_02: but also more noticeably things like housing.
- 49:44SPEAKER_02: Just infrastructure.
- 49:47SPEAKER_02: And this has led to,
- 49:48SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 49:49SPEAKER_02: not a shattering of the bipartisan consensus,
- 49:51SPEAKER_02: but if anything,
- 49:52a bipartisan softening of support for having more people in
- 49:57this country generally.
- 49:58And I actually fully expect that regardless of who gets
- 50:01reelected in the next election,
- 50:02SPEAKER_02: liberal or conservative,
- 50:03SPEAKER_02: we're going to start to see a...
- 50:06SPEAKER_02: Moving the numbers down,
- 50:07SPEAKER_02: a reduction to more normalized immigration levels,
- 50:11SPEAKER_02: perhaps something closer to what we saw in 2015 or thereabouts.
- 50:17How does that political conversation jive with what you're
- 50:22trying to accomplish in
- 50:23terms of easing refugee backlogs by moving certain profiles of
- 50:30people through the
- 50:31system faster or opening up the safe third country exemptions
- 50:35to people from
- 50:36SPEAKER_02: certain countries fleeing here from the United States?
- 50:41SPEAKER_01: So first of all, on
- 50:44reducing the backlogs and granting people status who are
- 50:48already in the system.
- 50:51SPEAKER_01: What we need to understand is these are people who are already in Kent.
- 50:54SPEAKER_01: These are not new people adding to the system.
- 50:57SPEAKER_01: These are people conceivably already have housing.
- 51:01SPEAKER_01: They already have jobs.
- 51:02SPEAKER_01: They're already here.
- 51:03SPEAKER_01: We're not talking about bringing new people.
- 51:07SPEAKER_01: And really the focus should be on...
- 51:10SPEAKER_01: the levels of permanent residence that the government is approving,
- 51:16there's really no issue with the focus being on people who are
- 51:18already in Canada
- 51:20and making sure that there's a path to permanent residence for
- 51:25people who are
- 51:26SPEAKER_01: already here.
- 51:28SPEAKER_01: There's a real difference between how we treat refugees and our
- 51:34legal and ethical obligations to refugees versus how we treat
- 51:40sort of anyone who
- 51:41SPEAKER_01: applies for a visa.
- 51:43SPEAKER_01: It's very different.
- 51:45SPEAKER_02: Do you know what percent,
- 51:45SPEAKER_02: like of all the new people coming into Canada every year,
- 51:48SPEAKER_02: what percentage are refugees versus immigrants?
- 51:51SPEAKER_02: Do we have a general divide between that?
- 51:54SPEAKER_01: Well, generally people don't come to Canada as refugees.
- 52:00So the majority of new people coming into Canada,
- 52:02that's what I'm saying here.
- 52:04SPEAKER_02: I'm not talking about tourists or visitors.
- 52:06SPEAKER_02: I'm talking of our population growth year over year.
- 52:12SPEAKER_02: Do we have a sense of what percentage of that population growth is being
- 52:15SPEAKER_02: contributed to from refugees versus immigration?
- 52:18SPEAKER_02: My understanding is it's small.
- 52:20SPEAKER_02: It's a small number.
- 52:21SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 52:22SPEAKER_02: Um, what's your sense?
- 52:24SPEAKER_02: Have you had this conversation with conservatives?
- 52:26SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 52:27there's a pretty good chance that we're looking at a
- 52:28conservative government,
- 52:29SPEAKER_02: maybe in a few short weeks.
- 52:31SPEAKER_02: Uh,
- 52:31have you had an opportunity to speak to conservatives about
- 52:33some of these issues
- 52:34SPEAKER_02: and what's your sense of,
- 52:35SPEAKER_02: of,
- 52:36SPEAKER_02: of the vibe on refugees on the conservative side?
- 52:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 52:40I mean,
- 52:40we have,
- 52:41we have spoken with,
- 52:43uh,
- 52:44folks in the conservative party,
- 52:45um,
- 52:47And the vibe that I get is we share an interest in a system
- 52:52that is efficient and
- 52:54SPEAKER_01: works for those who need protection.
- 52:59SPEAKER_01: How we reach that,
- 53:01SPEAKER_01: I don't think that,
- 53:04SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 53:05reducing a backlog at the Refugee Protection Division or taking
- 53:12people out of the
- 53:13SPEAKER_01: refugee queue to address...
- 53:18SPEAKER_01: labor shortages in critical industries.
- 53:20SPEAKER_01: It's not a liberal or conservative issue.
- 53:24It's just an issue of our country working efficiently in a way
- 53:31that we also uphold
- 53:32SPEAKER_01: our international human rights obligations.
- 53:36My understanding is that conservatives,
- 53:38from speaking with them,
- 53:40they're not against refugees.
- 53:42SPEAKER_01: They're for a system that works.
- 53:44SPEAKER_01: They're for a system that cracks down
- 53:47on abuse um you know there's a question i think there's an
- 53:52outstanding question about um
- 53:55How do you do that in a way that respects rights and
- 54:00fundamental freedoms and
- 54:02SPEAKER_01: procedural fairness?
- 54:05SPEAKER_01: And in the Harper government,
- 54:09SPEAKER_01: particularly leading up to 2015,
- 54:11there were many measures that the government tried to implement
- 54:14that ultimately
- 54:15were shot down by the courts because they violated the charter
- 54:20and procedural fairness.
- 54:22SPEAKER_01: And so they weren't able to stand.
- 54:24SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 54:24SPEAKER_02: I kind of wonder whether or not that history,
- 54:27SPEAKER_02: some of the issues of that,
- 54:29SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 54:29I'm going to be pulling from the depth of my memory and soul
- 54:32now to remember the specifics.
- 54:34SPEAKER_02: But if I do recall, it had to do with like certain types of refugee...
- 54:41Entitlements is the wrong word,
- 54:43but they were trying to pull certain types of what?
- 54:47SPEAKER_02: Health care and social services?
- 54:48SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 54:49SPEAKER_01: So that was one.
- 54:49SPEAKER_01: That was health care for refugees.
- 54:54SPEAKER_01: And the federal court shot that down,
- 54:56that they could not distinguish and refuse to provide health
- 55:00care for refugees.
- 55:01SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 55:02There were also rules around specific countries of origin and
- 55:08how people from
- 55:09certain countries would be treated with fewer procedural
- 55:12protections that were also
- 55:13SPEAKER_01: shot down.
- 55:14SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 55:14so I'm just saying because of that history of these proposals
- 55:17being shot down by
- 55:18SPEAKER_02: the court,
- 55:18has that poisoned the chalice a little bit between the
- 55:20conservatives and any kind
- 55:22SPEAKER_02: of refugee reform or refugee changes to the refugee system?
- 55:26SPEAKER_01: I'm not sure where the,
- 55:27where the conservative party sits in terms of the exact
- 55:31policies that they,
- 55:32SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 55:32SPEAKER_01: that they want to implement.
- 55:34SPEAKER_01: I mean, Mr. Polyev has not been, uh, you know, hugely out, uh, uh,
- 55:41SPEAKER_01: detailed about any policy proposals,
- 55:43SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 55:44SPEAKER_01: that he has,
- 55:45SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 55:45SPEAKER_01: particularly not on,
- 55:47SPEAKER_01: sorry,
- 55:47SPEAKER_02: we're going to,
- 55:47SPEAKER_02: we're going to ask the tax and build the homes.
- 55:49SPEAKER_02: What are you talking about?
- 55:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 55:50SPEAKER_01: And,
- 55:50SPEAKER_01: and,
- 55:51SPEAKER_01: and,
- 55:51SPEAKER_01: and,
- 55:51SPEAKER_01: and on the refugee side of things,
- 55:53SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 55:53SPEAKER_01: I,
- 55:54SPEAKER_01: I know that there's a,
- 55:55SPEAKER_01: there's a commercial featuring his wife,
- 55:57SPEAKER_01: uh,
- 55:58SPEAKER_01: Where she said,
- 55:58SPEAKER_01: back when I came,
- 56:00SPEAKER_01: we were treated in a different way,
- 56:02SPEAKER_01: but now the system is broken.
- 56:04SPEAKER_01: I hear a lot of the system is broken, but how are we going to fix it?
- 56:08SPEAKER_01: And so what we are trying to do is the kinds of proposals that I've made,
- 56:12SPEAKER_01: that I've talked about today,
- 56:15SPEAKER_01: we're trying to get them to buy into that and say,
- 56:18SPEAKER_01: this works for everyone.
- 56:19SPEAKER_01: This is a way to fix a quote unquote broken system.
- 56:23SPEAKER_02: Awesome.
- 56:23SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 56:24SPEAKER_02: Those are all my questions.
- 56:25Is there anything else that I'm forgetting to ask about or that
- 56:27we didn't talk about?
- 56:28SPEAKER_02: We've gone on for a good hour, which is really impressive.
- 56:30SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 56:31I personally find little intricacies of policies like this to
- 56:34be really interesting,
- 56:35SPEAKER_02: and I hope that our audience does as well.
- 56:37SPEAKER_02: But is there anything else that I forgot to discuss?
- 56:40SPEAKER_01: I think there's one other point to zero in on,
- 56:45SPEAKER_01: which is the STCA,
- 56:47SPEAKER_01: the Safe Third Country Agreement,
- 56:49SPEAKER_01: was challenged in the Supreme Court.
- 56:53The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal of the various
- 57:01organizations that had
- 57:02SPEAKER_01: challenged the agreement.
- 57:03SPEAKER_01: But there are two interesting things that came out of that decision.
- 57:07SPEAKER_01: Number one is part of the decision was sent back to the federal court.
- 57:12They found that the federal court had initially not considered
- 57:16gender aspect of the
- 57:18STCA and the disproportionate impact that it can have on women
- 57:22under Section 15 of
- 57:23SPEAKER_01: the Charter.
- 57:24And so that case has gone back to the federal court and will
- 57:27probably work its way up.
- 57:29And there is a possibility in the end that this agreement will
- 57:32be found in the end
- 57:33SPEAKER_01: to be unconstitutional.
- 57:35SPEAKER_02: Interesting.
- 57:36SPEAKER_02: So that's still pending.
- 57:37SPEAKER_02: And do we have any kind of timeline?
- 57:39And there is new litigation from other angles trying to attack
- 57:43this agreement,
- 57:44SPEAKER_01: which would now be for the third time.
- 57:46SPEAKER_02: Interesting.
- 57:47Do we have a timeline on how long the Supreme Court might take
- 57:51or not take to decide on that?
- 57:53SPEAKER_01: Well, these cases are not even at the Supreme Court.
- 57:55SPEAKER_01: Well, fair enough.
- 57:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah, they've disappeared back to the federal courts.
- 57:57SPEAKER_01: Years, years.
- 57:58SPEAKER_01: Years, years.
- 57:59SPEAKER_01: Okay.
- 57:59The other piece of this is the Supreme Court found that on
- 58:03Section 7 of the chart,
- 58:05SPEAKER_01: which is the right to life,
- 58:08SPEAKER_01: liberty,
- 58:09SPEAKER_01: and security,
- 58:10SPEAKER_01: that...
- 58:13sending people back to the United States potentially violated
- 58:17individuals' rights
- 58:19SPEAKER_01: because of the possibility of reform,
- 58:21because of the possibility of detention and the conditions that
- 58:24they faced there.
- 58:25But what the court said was this agreement and the legal
- 58:33mechanisms that Canada has
- 58:34in place don't violate the Constitution because there are
- 58:39so-called safety valves
- 58:41SPEAKER_01: that
- 58:42That if a person is going to face a particularly impactful
- 58:47negative outcome as a
- 58:48SPEAKER_01: result of this agreement,
- 58:50there are things that they can do to not be sent back to the
- 58:55United States.
- 58:56There are things that they can access so that those impacts on
- 59:00them that would
- 59:01SPEAKER_01: otherwise violate their rights are avoided.
- 59:04SPEAKER_01: Which is basically, just to paint the picture, is...
- 59:10SPEAKER_01: Our Saudi woman fleeing domestic violence.
- 59:15SPEAKER_02: Bring back our friend from Saudi Arabia.
- 59:17She approaches the border and she says,
- 59:20look,
- 59:23I'm not going to get protection in the U.S.
- 59:25SPEAKER_01: If you send me back to the U.S.,
- 59:28I'm going to be sent back to Saudi Arabia and my husband is
- 59:31going to kill me.
- 59:34There is a limited discretion that the CBSA officer who speaks
- 59:40to her at the border
- 59:41SPEAKER_01: has to allow her to enter Canada.
- 59:46SPEAKER_01: And so the Supreme Court said,
- 59:47SPEAKER_01: because that small discretion exists,
- 59:51SPEAKER_01: this system is allowed to stand.
- 59:56SPEAKER_01: However, in practice, it's very difficult to access that discretion.
- 1:00:03Well,
- 1:00:03yeah,
- 1:00:04and also,
- 1:00:04I mean,
- 1:00:05it's like trying to trust which Canadian border guard you get.
- 1:00:09You know,
- 1:00:10Jill goes out for lunch that day or borked kind of thing,
- 1:00:13right?
- 1:00:14SPEAKER_01: And you probably don't have a lawyer.
- 1:00:17SPEAKER_01: You have to get this right the first time around.
- 1:00:21SPEAKER_01: You know, anyone who's traveled abroad and spoken to a foreign lawyer
- 1:00:28SPEAKER_01: you know, immigration or border guard.
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_02: Have fun.
- 1:00:30I have,
- 1:00:31I have,
- 1:00:31I have nothing to hide,
- 1:00:32but I'm always a little nervous when I speak to them.
- 1:00:34SPEAKER_01: Who knows what's going to happen, but.
- 1:00:36SPEAKER_01: to then go to that person and ask for this exceptional remedy from them,
- 1:00:42SPEAKER_01: that there isn't really a set...
- 1:00:45That the border guard themselves might not know that they have
- 1:00:47the power to grant.
- 1:00:49SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 1:00:50SPEAKER_01: And that there isn't a standard procedure of how to ask for this.
- 1:00:55SPEAKER_01: And what evidence do you need to do?
- 1:00:57SPEAKER_01: And how are you going to convince them?
- 1:00:59It's really your refugee hearing is about to happen in this
- 1:01:03little cubicle.
- 1:01:06That is what the Supreme Court said is sufficient to allow this agreement,
- 1:01:13which potentially exposes people to violations of their most
- 1:01:18essential human rights,
- 1:01:20that it all hangs on the decision of that border officer to use
- 1:01:27their goodwill to
- 1:01:28SPEAKER_01: help that person.
- 1:01:28SPEAKER_01: And
- 1:01:30There's a question of the evidence that was before the court in
- 1:01:33that case,
- 1:01:34and I understand that there are going to be further challenges
- 1:01:37of this system to
- 1:01:38SPEAKER_01: really show these are not the kinds of,
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_01: quote-unquote,
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_01: safety valves that the court believed that they were.
- 1:01:48SPEAKER_02: Fascinating.
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_02: Okay, well, anyway, thank you so much for your time, Madam Sedensky.
- 1:01:51SPEAKER_02: I really appreciate it.
- 1:01:52SPEAKER_02: That was a really excellent conversation, and I feel like...
- 1:01:55I found out all kinds of things about how our refugee system
- 1:01:58actually works that I
- 1:01:59SPEAKER_02: thought were very grounded and very helpful.
- 1:02:01SPEAKER_02: So once again, I really appreciate your time.
- 1:02:03SPEAKER_02: And again,
- 1:02:04thank you to the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers for
- 1:02:07putting forward that
- 1:02:08SPEAKER_02: request because it opened up a whole can of curious worms for me.
- 1:02:12SPEAKER_02: So I appreciate the opportunity to ask these questions.
- 1:02:15I appreciate the opportunity to be able to share this with your listeners.
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: Thanks again.
- 1:02:21SPEAKER_01: Thank you.