Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP316: Decoding Shopify's Strategy - What Shopify's Product Direction Means for Your Ecommerce Business
Transcript
- 0:00Lovables getting loads of traction and Shopify of the
- 0:04option of watching someone like Stripe take payments income and
- 0:09Lovable build more capability for commerce.
- 0:12Or they can take that payment income and build brand awareness
- 0:16as part of it. So for me, I feel like that's
- 0:20the goal behind that. This could give them the
- 0:23infrastructure to collect more signals and data, which could be
- 0:27super valuable from an advertising perspective.
- 0:31You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:34and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:37and re platform specialist James Get to Paul Rogers.
- 0:40Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:42industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:45practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:50This episode is sponsored by Shopify and we're actually going
- 0:53to focus in on the Shopify ecosystem today for one very
- 0:57good reason. We there's been a lot of
- 1:02activity in the Shopify space this year and Shopify is
- 1:07consolidating itself as a market leader.
- 1:11Latest consultancy reports have come out showing they're, you
- 1:14know, they're rated higher for execution and vision this year.
- 1:18Take consultancy reports with a slight pinch assault.
- 1:22However, what's clear is that there is a general strategic
- 1:26direction in the industry and Shopify is shaping an influence
- 1:29and that quite strongly. And what we want to look at is
- 1:31what are the, what are the key developments in Shopify's
- 1:33strategy and product and what does that mean?
- 1:37What are the indications where do we think the direction of
- 1:39travel generally is? And this will link into a wider
- 1:42state of the industry pod that will run pre Christmas and will
- 1:46release in a in a few weeks time.
- 1:49That's my rambling intro, Paul. Anything to add in terms of what
- 1:52we're going to jabber all about today?
- 1:55No, I don't think so. The only thing that I think, and
- 1:57when you said about it, at some point maybe we should do an
- 1:59episode more focused on our opinion on the Magic Quadrant,
- 2:02because I feel like, yeah, it's probably a good episode just
- 2:06looking like the movements and kind of, yeah, discussing some
- 2:09of the vendors. All that'll be a big discussion.
- 2:13Yes, we could potentially do one.
- 2:16Let's park at 1:00 because that involves lots of different sub
- 2:19threads. So yeah, again, this is quite
- 2:22good. We do these, we do these like
- 2:23head to heads and we end up coming up with loads more ideas
- 2:25for episodes. So anyway, let's let's go
- 2:28through some of the key key strategic drops and then let's
- 2:32do the what the So what basically and not just, oh, it's
- 2:35a new feature, isn't that great, we can use it, but it's more
- 2:37about what it indicates and and what merchants can expect coming
- 2:40forward. So I think the big one and it's
- 2:42the theme of the year is big tech companies bet it going big
- 2:46on AI and re architecting products around AI capabilities
- 2:52to increase auto automation, to increase self-serve and what
- 2:57this means to merchants and where they can evolve with the
- 3:00platform. And also what it means to the
- 3:02wider ecosystem in terms of other tech vendors, third
- 3:05parties, the tools that people are used to using, what they
- 3:08need to use, don't need to use go forward.
- 3:10And the big one was the Atlas AI store builder and the the
- 3:15lovable announcement. So, you know, big suite of tools
- 3:18for not just about, I guess, generative AI for like building
- 3:22out content capabilities within stores, but wider into the
- 3:26ability to to like void code and to build stores without
- 3:31developer support or without so much of other support.
- 3:34Big caveat on that because if you're not a technical person,
- 3:37building code and not being Lt. do any due diligence on it is
- 3:40not necessarily a smart way to go forward.
- 3:43So that's the big change. What in in the where your heads
- 3:47are in terms of what this means and and the conversations you're
- 3:50having with people and how others are seeing it.
- 3:53I think. I think I've got 3 separate
- 3:55views around this. I think lovable piece is a smart
- 4:00move. I think yeah, people set alive
- 4:03in in the industry on LinkedIn, there's been some really big
- 4:05views around kind of where this could go and could just kill
- 4:08agencies and everything else. I personally see it as like
- 4:13Lovables getting shed loads of traction and Shopify have got
- 4:18the option of watching someone like Stripe take all of that
- 4:23payments income and Lovable build more capability for
- 4:26commerce or they can go and agree something can take that
- 4:30payment income and build a lot of brand awareness as part of
- 4:34it. So for me, I feel like that's
- 4:36kind of the goal behind that. I don't think that will be the
- 4:41thing that changes the industry personally.
- 4:44I think it would just be a route to market for a certain type of
- 4:48user. And I think it's probably a bit
- 4:50of a competitive move as well personally and obviously a
- 4:55marketing move as well. So that's kind of how I see the
- 4:57Lovable 1. I think the more interesting one
- 5:00is the Atlas AI piece. So I think I again, personally
- 5:06feel like one of the big strands to Shopify will be the first
- 5:11party data strategy and the ad network strategy.
- 5:16And I feel like at the minute, if you look at the front end of
- 5:20sites, a lot of what's happening are within third party client
- 5:25side JavaScript like search experience, the product
- 5:30recommendations and the product grid.
- 5:33And actually, you know, Shopify is not providing the
- 5:36infrastructure for that. They're essentially just passing
- 5:39in catalog data and I think this could give them the
- 5:44infrastructure to collect a shit load more signals and data,
- 5:49which could be super valuable from an advertising perspective.
- 5:53Also will help them from an AI perspective in terms of
- 5:57understanding more around the customer and then also help them
- 6:01with kind of automating things. So again, just having a lot more
- 6:04kind of signals to drive the value of the AI stuff because
- 6:09realistically, yeah, where we're kind of heading is that a lot of
- 6:13the agentic stuff will be like kind of delivered all that.
- 6:18A lot of those kind of manual merchandising tasks will be
- 6:22automated. And I think shop find need to
- 6:25earn more of that data in order to drive that.
- 6:29And then I think the final thing is, I feel like a lot of people
- 6:35are predicting that there'll be like almost 2 types of
- 6:40experience for like owned website navigation.
- 6:45And 1:00 will be the existing kind of catalog experience and
- 6:481:00 will be more of a guided experience.
- 6:51And I feel like, again, in order to have the infrastructure for
- 6:55the second one, yeah, they need to own more of that.
- 6:59So yeah, for me, that feels like more of a data move than kind of
- 7:05just trying to improve capability.
- 7:08And I feel like we'll start to see a lot more from Shopify
- 7:13around kind of, yeah, optimizing storefronts in different ways,
- 7:18being able to automate more within the admin.
- 7:24And then also at at some point, I'll really push the advertising
- 7:28side. So I'm intrigued by the point
- 7:29you made about the payments bit and Stripe, because obviously
- 7:33Shopify's own payment things bit of Stripe, Stripe is a
- 7:36competitor, but equally payment engine like PayPal, the big
- 7:41competitors, you know, PayPal offer and it's like, you know,
- 7:45payment capabilities on ads etcetera, all these ways of
- 7:49speeding up the payment outside of websites.
- 7:52So I'm intrigued to expand on that, how you think this move is
- 7:57going to benefit them Then in terms of that consolidation of
- 8:00the OR protection against people going, is it you see this is
- 8:04well actually for make it easier for people to embed shoppable
- 8:07and payable experiences without the effort of building out sites
- 8:11in a traditional way. You think that's going to help
- 8:14them attract additional sites or users rather than people then go
- 8:19down through other? Routes, well, I think I mean the
- 8:21way that I look at it is if people are and like I've watched
- 8:24Joe Ho from RTM like build some pretty significant like web
- 8:29applications in lovable. And I guess as people kind of
- 8:34build out different types of applications and put more
- 8:36traffic and fit through them, you know, a lot of those will be
- 8:42commerce experience of like have a commerce component to it.
- 8:47And if Shopify are providing that experience and essentially
- 8:51you're going through the Shopify checkout or Shop pay experience,
- 8:54that's obviously revenue to them and you're not kind of, I guess
- 9:00giving that market share to someone like Stripe who are
- 9:04getting more prominent at the checkout based solution.
- 9:08I think the open AI Stripe partnership is, is pretty big.
- 9:13And I feel like the narrative around Shopify Payments is
- 9:17changing a little bit. So to me, it feels like, yeah,
- 9:22there's potentially an element of that to it as well as just,
- 9:26you know, combining 2 very powerful tools and Shopify
- 9:31helping them to get a foot into commerce and, you know, them
- 9:34giving Shopify some net new demand.
- 9:39What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 9:44all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 9:47Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 9:52and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 9:55It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 9:58planet Shopify, Powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 10:04Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 10:08And where do you, where do you see Sidekick Fitness because
- 10:11obviously you've talked about this, you're talking about this
- 10:13element of AI that pay for them for strategic gain, less so
- 10:18about features. Obviously there it brings
- 10:20feature and functionality benefits for the merchants as
- 10:23well. The psychic feels to me more of
- 10:28a merchant centric play rather than the shop price strategy.
- 10:31It yes, yes, it obviously they can see and track what people
- 10:36are inquiring which, which data objects are they most trying to
- 10:39execute commands and and automations are.
- 10:43But fundamentally, it's a utility thing, because if you
- 10:46make the storefronts easier to manage and maintain and execute
- 10:49day-to-day tasks on, you increase satisfaction and you
- 10:52keep people built into that ecosystem.
- 10:56Yeah, I mean, I think sidekicks got pretty interest in all of a
- 10:59sudden. I think one thing more recently
- 11:03that I've noticed is the, I mean, basically I think Sidekick
- 11:08will end up being a really useful resource for users.
- 11:12And I mean, you can already, you know, get it building kind of
- 11:16pretty decent levels of insights into like what's happening from
- 11:19like a day-to-day trade perspective.
- 11:21And obviously it's got quite a lot of like automation within
- 11:24it. I think as they collect more
- 11:27data and use more data, I think because I mean, it's quite
- 11:31interesting. So I've seen what demo are
- 11:33building and you know, a lot of the BI tools out there are
- 11:36building an equivalent. So like Demo use Claude, so do
- 11:41Polar. But I kind of watched, you know,
- 11:45Demo's agent kind of go through a process of analysing a period
- 11:51of that kind of performance on a website, determine a load of
- 11:57insights and then then essentially go deeper and say,
- 12:00right, my Netherlands market is 50% down year and year.
- 12:04What's causing it? And then it's like inventory
- 12:06issue and emails not performing as well and pay.
- 12:11And then it's giving all of this rationale around here's what you
- 12:14should do to reverse the trend. And I'm not saying it's got the
- 12:16same brain as like you do or you know, a really experienced econ
- 12:21person does. But the over time as that
- 12:25develops more context and as it's trained like realistically
- 12:29the future, especially with the level of data that demo have
- 12:32got, because they go pretty granular around like profit, but
- 12:35in on there and everything cut off.
- 12:37There's nothing stopping demo from, you know, starting to
- 12:42automate certain recommendations or fixes.
- 12:46And I feel like that's just one example of a very powerful kind
- 12:49of data and reporting tool. If you think about any kind of
- 12:52tool like that, that houses that level of data and has loads of
- 12:57different brands, suddenly you're going to have this
- 13:01capability where, you know, you've actually got a really
- 13:04good kind of, you can almost implement kind of a managed
- 13:09service. Well, you know, you can start to
- 13:11implement their changes. And I feel like that's where
- 13:13Sidekick will go because Shopify is sitting on so much data.
- 13:18And I think it'll probably, as Shopify tend to do with a lot of
- 13:20the stuff that they roll out, I think it'll probably start quite
- 13:23SMB. And you know, Sidekick of that
- 13:25same stuff, like 10 people have clicked this product, but it's,
- 13:29you know, not particularly prominent in this prominent and
- 13:31this high traffic collection. Do you want to increase the
- 13:34visibility? Do you want to test, you know,
- 13:37doing this with a product? Do you want to?
- 13:39Yeah. And I think, I feel like
- 13:41Sidekick could probably go quite predictive and then it'll start
- 13:43to get to a point where as an interface to drive change.
- 13:47Yeah, the the other opportunity where they haven't gone yet is
- 13:51preset commands like you get in AI chat bots, where you can like
- 13:54add macros for a customer to like, you know, what's my order
- 13:58status or whatever. How do I, you know, those things
- 14:00where they take you through a predefined journey?
- 14:03For me, the, the, the massive utility gain here would be
- 14:06having lots of standard ones that are commonly done by
- 14:09everybody. And there are ones like, for
- 14:11example, you know, whether it's like look up a specific product
- 14:14or I want to add a value to a meta object.
- 14:17There are lots of different bits where people do them all the
- 14:19time in a in a store, but you have to come on it through a
- 14:24prompt rather than clicking on a, a probe macro.
- 14:27The the, the other bit that for me is the the better
- 14:30connectivity with some of the data objects because it's, it's
- 14:33still pretty, it's very impressive, but it's still
- 14:35pretty surface level that you can't, you can't integrate fully
- 14:40with things like meta object to, if you want to like build out a
- 14:43meta object and add loads of different values into one that's
- 14:46existing to avoid having to do it manually or through an API,
- 14:48you can't yet do things like that.
- 14:50So for me, the the, the direction of travel, I, I take
- 14:55your point about the intelligence and helping people
- 14:59make smart decisions, but I think that utility of speeding
- 15:02up day-to-day tasks, which is almost like a what used to be
- 15:05true web OPS capabilities of people are managing stores.
- 15:09I don't feel it's quite there yet, although it's far better
- 15:12than it was 12 months ago. Yeah, I think, I mean, I
- 15:15completely agree. I think it will have, I think
- 15:16there'll be a lot of functionality sitting, but
- 15:19whether it's sidekick or just built into core areas of the
- 15:23platform, but I think Shopify's probably already sitting on a
- 15:27lot. And I can, they've probably with
- 15:29the Atlas AI piece, I feel like maybe they're, they've realized
- 15:32there's, you know, certain data points missing that would be
- 15:36really valuable to some of that stuff.
- 15:38And also they're not able to then implement fixes where a
- 15:43third party is, is managing that.
- 15:46So that's kind of where I see that going.
- 15:49But I think, yeah, I think with Shopify and the level of yeah,
- 15:55data they've got across the board, like when you start to
- 15:58then build in things like the customer segments and like all
- 16:01of that stuff that they've kind of been optimizing over the last
- 16:03couple of years, yeah, it feels like there's probably quite a
- 16:06lot that they're going to be able to build into the agentic
- 16:10capability. Yeah.
- 16:11And the, I mean they've, they've basically said they're going to,
- 16:14they're opening up more to like third party tools as well so
- 16:17that you can create like connectivity between different
- 16:20systems to create automations. And I think one of the obvious
- 16:24ones is in flow, the ability for to the ability to through
- 16:30commands rather than through a more developer focused
- 16:32interface, create flows to achieve outcomes.
- 16:36Flows, flows, an incredibly powerful tool.
- 16:39Blade will come to that in a bit actually.
- 16:42But you've got to have a more technical mindset in order to
- 16:45use the flow capability and understand the different
- 16:48triggers and conditions. Whereas doing that through
- 16:51prompting and being able to then connect it through different
- 16:53third parties to execute, I think that will be so powerful.
- 16:57Yeah, it's going to, it's all of this is going to be so
- 16:59interesting because like I obviously ran a bit of a rag
- 17:02rabbit hole on my on those bits, but you factor flow into that as
- 17:05well. Yeah.
- 17:07And I agree like some of our more technical clients are doing
- 17:10some amazing things with flow that a lot of people are just
- 17:15going by an out-of-the-box for the party for.
- 17:17Yeah, it's terribly. Hot.
- 17:19Powerful. Well, yeah, one of the projects
- 17:21I worked on recently, it was used as a basically a custom
- 17:25middleware to execute code for products that were in bundles
- 17:32that had discounts. When when the bundle was
- 17:34unpacked to its components was creating discrepancies in
- 17:38rounding rules. It was causing an issue from a
- 17:41older file and finance point of view and the flow was created to
- 17:46basically in an order before the order was sent through in the
- 17:50integration to ERP, Unpack. Do the calculations, work out
- 17:54the difference between the order total, the customer paid and
- 17:57what the rounded values are and create a rounded line difference
- 18:01to balance the order. The stuff you can do.
- 18:04I mean, it blew my mind. That and the stuff you can do,
- 18:07it's not perfect. There were lots of challenges
- 18:09with it. And I know there's probably
- 18:10education, which still doesn't work, but I guess the, the the
- 18:13capability is there. I think when it's connected to
- 18:17flows, that will be if it's ever connected to flows, but I would
- 18:20be surprised if that's not a future direction travel on it.
- 18:24I feel like it would just be kind of like a part of it,
- 18:27doesn't it? Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 18:30The, the bit that I always struggle with the flows is, is
- 18:32not the, the capability. It's more knowing how to build
- 18:36it because there are so many different permutations for how
- 18:39you build the conditions and the logic.
- 18:40And a lot of it requires you having to put specific code into
- 18:44it in order to execute commands. Next one is check out
- 18:51extensibility. It's not new new, but obviously
- 18:54they've increased capabilities this year.
- 18:57Shopify functions keeps extending.
- 19:01So what you can do and execute in the track out on top of
- 19:03Shopify's core. Check out where do you, what do
- 19:06you see the direction of travel? What do you see?
- 19:08The the the, I guess the the potential going forwards on
- 19:12this. So, yeah, I mean, I feel like it
- 19:14would just continue to get more open.
- 19:15It's got a lot better. I recently failed an exam on
- 19:19this actually. So it's part of our partnership
- 19:23with Shopify. We have to do a certain number
- 19:26of certifications. I was doing one on our retreat
- 19:30in Spain and I felt like I knew a lot about this actually, but
- 19:34I'm not as close to as I was. And then I did it without
- 19:37practicing and failed it by like 1 foot.
- 19:39And it's very annoying. But it that I think reminded me
- 19:43of, you know, how much has changed and how, you know,
- 19:47there's so many new little like classifications of things and
- 19:50also just like how much work they're doing or have done in
- 19:55this area. But yeah, it feels like, you
- 19:57know, particularly now they're trying to do more like check out
- 19:59as a service type things or. Kind of facilitate the demand
- 20:04outside of just normal like web browsers.
- 20:08It feels like they'll continue to push this harder.
- 20:12And I also think, you know, Shopify things like the lovable
- 20:15example, like I could see a world where there's a lot more
- 20:18kind of integrations that are direct to check up.
- 20:21Yeah, I think the for me the the, the, the future where where
- 20:25merchants need to be is a standardized check out so that
- 20:28you're not constantly building custom.
- 20:31You've got the core functionality, performance,
- 20:33scalability, security, compliance, all that locked down
- 20:36and you cannot break it by hack by changing the code and screwed
- 20:40up core features. That's a critical bit, which is
- 20:42where SAS self hosted checkouts are absolute no brainers, but
- 20:49they are the, the old view of that was really prescriptive and
- 20:52narrow and it limited businesses where they needed to do custom
- 20:56things and it could be custom payment flow.
- 20:59I mean, if you look at the advent of open banking, that's
- 21:01becoming more important to certain businesses who want to
- 21:04have open banking as a payment flow through the checkout.
- 21:08Can't do that in a lockdown 1 can do that through
- 21:11extensibility. And that to me is where the,
- 21:13where I guess where merchants need to see these, which check
- 21:17outs is going is you want to do something different for a
- 21:20particular use case. So there's a customer group or
- 21:24in a particular country or whatever it might be.
- 21:27And that means you don't show a particular payment method to
- 21:30these people. That can be achieved without
- 21:34tinkering with the core check out.
- 21:36And that's the, that's the critical thing.
- 21:37But the, the biggest challenge is for merchants to be really,
- 21:42really smart about what they do change and why, rather than
- 21:46trying to over complicate checkouts, because I often find
- 21:49in, in conversation people about what they want to achieve.
- 21:51There's lots of desires are we, we want to be able to like
- 21:53tailor this and show all the different messages.
- 21:55And actually, when you, when you strip it back down, don't really
- 21:58need it, it's a lot of noise. But yeah, I'm definitely
- 22:02impressed with the the Checkout Blocks app and functions.
- 22:07Already use that in a couple of projects, mainly around shipping
- 22:11logic and shipping rates and post code exclusions.
- 22:15It was a bit of fun playing around with it, but I've
- 22:17definitely seen first hand the benefits of that approach.
- 22:22Yeah. Let's go on to product data.
- 22:28I mean, this is more functional than the strategic, but I think
- 22:341 of, I think I know one of the limitations that has always been
- 22:38levied at Shopify has been around things like a variant
- 22:42limits. There's still a lot of
- 22:44restrictions in my opinion, because you can only have three
- 22:46variants per product. And for some businesses, there
- 22:49are configurable products that have maybe four or five or more
- 22:54variant options that impact price and skew.
- 22:57And that's needed for many knock on reasons for processing
- 23:02orders, for product data feeds, you name it.
- 23:04Even even recent project for 3D visualisation using a third
- 23:08party tool of having that granular, but they've increased
- 23:11varying limits at least now so that you can create more
- 23:14variants. Where do you, where do you see
- 23:16them going on this? Because it feels like it's they,
- 23:19they take it. This is 1 area where they're
- 23:21taking a lot of time to catch up with what I'd argue a product
- 23:25data leaders. I'm not saying the UI is
- 23:28perfect, but in terms of flexibility, the lights of
- 23:30Adobe, Magento where you really have great control over it, so
- 23:35better. But I feel like there's still a
- 23:37long way to go here to to take off most merchant use cases.
- 23:41Yeah. I mean, I feel like, I mean,
- 23:43there's there's workarounds in this area.
- 23:45And like we've had, as you say, like kind of build your own
- 23:48style product builders or like, yeah, products with just a kind
- 23:54of variation options as part of a configuration process.
- 23:58And you can obviously do it and just cool kind of yeah,
- 24:01different products as part of that use a catalog API.
- 24:05But I just think it'll just continue to get more flexible.
- 24:08I think they have, I mean, the bigger thing, we obviously
- 24:11haven't talked about what's going on from an internal
- 24:14perspective with Shopify. And it's yet to be seen kind of
- 24:17how things potentially change since after kind of Bobby Emmani
- 24:22left. And like, yeah, kind of what the
- 24:24biggest focuses are from a revenue perspective, but they
- 24:28have obviously been very, very focused on the enterprise.
- 24:31And I think there's probably a big correlation between kind of
- 24:35larger, more, yeah, larger businesses that have more
- 24:39complexity around catalog. So it feels like they are kind
- 24:44of focusing in on this. I think they've, this is the
- 24:46area that I've been most impressed with actually.
- 24:48Like I felt like over the last few years, markets would have
- 24:51moved faster and obviously that's now in a better place.
- 24:55But Catalog, I've been really impressed with how they've kind
- 24:59of improved kind of the handling of data and how they've improved
- 25:04kind of, yeah, the structure having, you know, worked with
- 25:08fairly big retailers 5-6 years ago where they're just
- 25:12workarounds on workarounds on workarounds.
- 25:16So, yeah, and I just think it would get more and more open.
- 25:18That's kind of my view. I think, yeah, they'll start to
- 25:21get to a point where, yeah, they can allow for kind of more
- 25:27variation options. I think I'll start to kind of,
- 25:29yeah, push more stuff into the API, etcetera.
- 25:32So yeah, I just feel like it'll just get more and more flexible
- 25:34in my opinion. I think the big, I think the big
- 25:37shift that I've seen the last few years is there are far fewer
- 25:41projects where a PIM is needed generally.
- 25:44And often when a PIM is in, it's, it's in because people
- 25:49historically think that's what you need when you have some
- 25:52complexities in like complex products, configurations, parent
- 25:56child variants, when you have like translations, etcetera.
- 26:02But actually the core data model now, and I've had this
- 26:04conversation a lot of people in the last couple of years about
- 26:06how you can use meta objects alongside meta fields to create
- 26:10structured data views and to house that data in a manageable
- 26:13way so that you don't need developers to keep maintaining
- 26:15it. But actually the business can
- 26:17update it and extend the meta object to add other values as
- 26:20the product data changes, as opposed to being locked into a
- 26:24data model in a PIM where you probably need developer support.
- 26:28If the product data model evolves in ECON to match it,
- 26:31that's the big shift I think that I've seen as a result of
- 26:34them building out this capability, yeah.
- 26:37Absolutely, Yeah. I feel like, I mean,
- 26:40particularly for the international brands, it was
- 26:42probably the separate stores, all the expansion stores drove a
- 26:48lot of people buying a lot of like brands buying Pimms over
- 26:52the last few years and then now that's getting better.
- 26:55They feel like Pimms, as much as there's still value in a lot of
- 26:58areas, it's just that people just don't want a separate
- 27:01system to pay for or maintain. So that wouldn't like forego
- 27:05certain functional for certain bits of functionality.
- 27:08But yeah, I'd say we've definitely seen that same trend.
- 27:12And actually it's quite funny because I've been working with a
- 27:14couple of clients recently and they've said we want to buy a
- 27:16PIM as part of this project. And my immediate thinking was
- 27:19like, why? But then you kind of remember
- 27:21that, you know, all of these, a lot of these businesses have
- 27:23like other channels and like, you know, a lot of misalignment
- 27:27amongst teams and a lot of issues with like PLM data
- 27:31getting lost and whatever else. So yeah, I still feel, I feel
- 27:35like maybe I'd kind of almost written them off a little bit.
- 27:37But I think again, that's how I start to get tunnel visioned in
- 27:40the fashion brand world, kind of more online orientated etcetera.
- 27:47Yeah. But it's inevitable that we all
- 27:49get biased by the types of projects we work on.
- 27:52I think that is a slight inevitability in any platform
- 27:55ecosystem. I think for me the, the bit
- 27:58where I really want to see the change is not being limited to
- 28:01three variant options per product because that does
- 28:04create, yes, you can build workarounds and you can build
- 28:07configurators, but often the product date, the products are
- 28:11simple enough that you don't need a configuration.
- 28:13You just need additional levels of variant tiers so that you can
- 28:18achieve your product set up and you can achieve your pricing and
- 28:21your SKU structure and not have to create other customisations
- 28:26that I would definitely, definitely want.
- 28:28And the other one that I think they massively benefit in here,
- 28:33although it's probably low level for a lot of retailers is just
- 28:38that control of when you, when you've set up a product with
- 28:40variants in some collections, PLPS, you just want the parents
- 28:45shown, whereas in others you want all your options showing.
- 28:48And the ability to do that without having to create
- 28:51customizations in, in code would be really, really useful just as
- 28:54a configurable setting. So I think they've done really,
- 28:57really, I agree with you. I think it's, it's shifted on
- 28:59really well. It's a really deep data model.
- 29:01There's a few things where if they could do that in the next
- 29:036-12 months it would help merchants massively.
- 29:07That's a good point. What you raised, that you
- 29:09raised, I think that's probably an area where because like we
- 29:12would still very often want to separate our products for the
- 29:17colour, for colour. So just because I mean there's
- 29:21so many areas of merchandising where you benefit from having
- 29:25those split out. And I agree, I think it's
- 29:28probably just needs to go a little bit further before that's
- 29:32kind of fully manageable as you say it like collection level or
- 29:36you know, being able to manage it for search or wreck
- 29:38specifically or something. Yeah, but I think they're
- 29:43improving massively and quickly. Next one is Omni channel and I
- 29:49guess what, what short, how serious do you think they are
- 29:52about creating a true enterprise Omni channel experience given
- 29:58the fact that you've got Shopify, you've got Shopify POS,
- 30:01lot of enterprise retailers historically have their own POS
- 30:04hardware systems and those can be quite complex and quite
- 30:08customized. POS is evolved significantly.
- 30:13You know, the, the, the ability to have custom views and
- 30:16different apps on different locations to suit different
- 30:19stores, different users when they logged in to have different
- 30:23views to suit their role within the store.
- 30:24I think that's fantastic and the UI is really easy, but it's it's
- 30:30still probably a little bit behind the true dedicated poses
- 30:34and just how much flexibility and how custom you can go in
- 30:37terms of capability. Where are you, where are you
- 30:39seeing them at the moment and where do you see that direction
- 30:42of travel? Yeah.
- 30:43So I mean, I've always felt that this is one of their biggest
- 30:46opportunities. They've got like so much low
- 30:49hanging fruit from a revenue perspective because any of their
- 30:53like kind of mid market brands or a lot of them will have yeah,
- 30:5820 plus stores and they won't want to use pause.
- 31:01And it's usually just because there's certain limitations and
- 31:05historic because there's been a lot of issues around things like
- 31:07stock. I will say we're working on a
- 31:10pause budget at the moment and we're not experts around point
- 31:14of sale. We've done quite a lot with Shop
- 31:155 for very simple brands, but we're not experts and we've been
- 31:18working with Cubic. So I think we have them on the
- 31:20podcast at one point. Who's that story?
- 31:24Cubix, the agency, so they work really closely.
- 31:27So we've got a client, they've been doing really complex
- 31:32positive implementation project and everyone said they've been
- 31:35amazing. So we should definitely get them
- 31:36on to do a podcast specifically on Shopify Pause, because this
- 31:41project has a lot of customisation and they are
- 31:46essentially moving from something, yeah, very heavily
- 31:48customized to Shopify. But overall, I think some people
- 31:53are now willing to compromise because of the value of having
- 31:57all your data in one place and being able to quickly roll out,
- 32:00you know, on the loyalty programs and do push
- 32:04notifications based on, you know, retail date and whatever
- 32:08else. But I think that I'm just
- 32:12surprised that they've not prioritized it more because the
- 32:15next point is B to B, which I don't really know much about,
- 32:18but it feels like they put a lot of work into B to B.
- 32:21And I'm sure like the big picture opportunity is massive.
- 32:26But to me retail it just feels like they've not, they've never
- 32:29really put that much behind it both from like a product and
- 32:34kind of sales and marketing perspective.
- 32:36And we've got and the other thing I'd say is also can be
- 32:38pretty expensive. And I think if they got that
- 32:42whole thing right, and they've definitely improved the
- 32:45underlying architecture with like the apps now and they're
- 32:48doing more to try and make the order management side better.
- 32:52But I feel like that could be just such AI mean it already is
- 32:56amazing for like so many small businesses.
- 32:59And I'm the I'm a massive fan of doing it and having everything
- 33:02in one place. But I think they can just put a
- 33:04bit more behind it and very quickly go and like clean up,
- 33:08like shed loads of revenue from the brands they've got that have
- 33:11got, you know, well over 100 stores.
- 33:15Yeah, if they just kind of put a little bit more behind it.
- 33:18Yeah, I think if I'm looking at it from a strategic point of
- 33:21view, the the times when people have gone for pauses when they
- 33:25were, I know this is just my experience and it you know,
- 33:27there's wider industry will have different use cases, but it's
- 33:30been where they don't have many stores and therefore they don't
- 33:34have a huge legacy estate of hardware to replace.
- 33:39And the cost model is easier to sign off on for the Omni channel
- 33:43benefits of having unified customer accounts, ability to
- 33:46push draft orders to store vice versa without having to create
- 33:49any integrations because the payments and also happen in the
- 33:52different systems, which is challenging as hell.
- 33:55And especially for things like refunds.
- 33:57If you want to refund online orders in store, but you've got
- 33:59different poles to different ecom, how the hell you do that
- 34:03because of payments and tokenization.
- 34:05That's complex. But when you get to bigger store
- 34:08estates, 50 stores, 100 stores, the cost of hardware there there
- 34:14feels like there's a missing trick in terms of the the cost
- 34:16proposition of understanding that the the rates on Shopify
- 34:20pods can be higher than other pods systems, but there's no
- 34:23offset for people, there's no incentive.
- 34:25Yes, there are some benefits of alignment, but if from ACF OS
- 34:29point of view, if you're adding, yeah, 100 grams worth of cost
- 34:34suddenly to a business that often changes the dynamic in
- 34:37considering it and getting a sign off internally.
- 34:40So I think definitely the cost model bit is something where
- 34:43some some, I guess evolution of thinking might be useful.
- 34:47Yeah. Let's do let's do a final quick
- 34:50one on B to B before we cut, cut this short.
- 34:53I guess where my head's at is, yeah, I've, I've read lots of
- 34:57different posts out there about shopifying B to B and where it
- 35:01sits and where it's a market leader or where it's not.
- 35:05And my view has always been it's, it's a good solid
- 35:07wholesale, but it's never been a market leader.
- 35:10I think those what I would have considered my objections to be a
- 35:12market leader in terms of functionality, flexibility and
- 35:16customization at for different customer accounts inside the
- 35:21account structures. They're gradually pulling the
- 35:23barriers away. They're still not 100% there
- 35:26against pure enterprise B to B or dedicated B to B platforms,
- 35:30but they've definitely, I mean, the bits, I guess the what I've
- 35:34seen and like you alluded to earlier, they've been genuinely
- 35:37focused here last couple of years.
- 35:39In each edition, we see meaningful functionality, which
- 35:43and that's why my rambling head, the strategic perspective on
- 35:46this is, whereas a couple of years ago I would have said to
- 35:49people, if B to B is your driving point for decision and
- 35:52platform, Shopify is significantly behind.
- 35:54And I couldn't tell you that's the right one to back yet
- 35:57because I don't know how quickly they going to accelerate for
- 36:00Fast forward two years. And I'd say that I'm seeing the
- 36:03direction of travel being really positive.
- 36:05And therefore that gives greater confidence that, you know, in
- 36:09another 12 to 24 months those gaps are going to be eroded even
- 36:14further. Yeah, Yeah.
- 36:17I think, I mean, to be honest, you've got more experience than
- 36:19I have a Boo to be. I think I've used it with some
- 36:22clients that have more of a kind of fairly basic trade kind of
- 36:27portal or as you say kind of some level of wholesale.
- 36:30And I've found it really nice and easy to use.
- 36:32But I feel like every time I've been exposed to people trying to
- 36:37push it really hard for B to B, there's always been compromise.
- 36:41And I think you would know more than I would around kind of
- 36:44where it's but not particularly strong.
- 36:47I think the really interesting thing that we kind of tucked
- 36:49down a little bit around in this episode that will will probably
- 36:54become clearer soon as like there's been so many leadership
- 36:58changes. It's shop fire all like some
- 36:59pretty significant leadership changes.
- 37:01Shopify recently at a time where you know, they're performing
- 37:05really well. It'll just be interesting to see
- 37:08what some of that change the new COOCRO leaving means to their
- 37:16overall direction. And because I think enterprise
- 37:20and B to B are probably 2 segments that have had so much
- 37:23attention. And obviously, like, yeah, we
- 37:25don't really know to what extent that's worked compared to how
- 37:31they thought it might work or yeah, returned the right level
- 37:35of return, etcetera. But yeah, it'll be interesting
- 37:38to see with everything that's happening in the world, yeah,
- 37:41kind of what the strategy looks like now around B to B and
- 37:46enterprise and product in general.
- 37:49Yeah. I think, I think my summary is
- 37:50that I've got greater confidence that they will close the gap or
- 37:54enough to satisfy a lot of core use cases for B to B where it is
- 37:58a predominantly a retail DTC business but with a strong B to
- 38:02B capability rather than the D I'm not talking about like pure
- 38:06complex B to B like manufacturing etcetera.
- 38:09I wouldn't be speaking about those now, but but anyway,
- 38:12that's, so that's our, I guess that's our kind of summary
- 38:15strategic view state of Shopify, what it means, where it's
- 38:18headed. I'd, you know, there are lots of
- 38:21different discussion points we could add.
- 38:24If you disagree of anything or your different viewpoints or
- 38:26you've got anything to add, please do reach out, comment on
- 38:29the post on LinkedIn, let us know.
- 38:30We'd love to hear because there's always different
- 38:32interpretations of what people are doing.
- 38:34But thanks as always for listening.
- 38:37You're listening to the Inside Comments podcast, hosted by
- 38:40experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 38:43Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 38:45featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 38:48industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 38:51explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 38:53and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 38:56really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 38:59to help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and tech
- 39:01stack. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 39:04out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an e-commerce
- 39:06project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 39:08episode.