Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fingey Mini: Fission Vision
Transcript
- 0:00OK, Charles, I feel like it's been a while since we've touched base
- 0:03on this whole AI phenomenon.
- 0:05So Fringe Mini this week, I decided to kind of look at some things going on with AI,
- 0:11not necessarily AI itself, if that makes any sense.
- 0:14But some of the things going on around it and not necessarily in a bad way,
- 0:18just so everybody knows that ahead of time.
- 0:21Well, perhaps. Let's see.
- 0:23Perhaps. Yes.
- 0:24In the end. That's fair enough. OK.
- 0:26This article comes from CBC posted on October 29, 2024, written by Mehek Mazar.
- 0:32And it is titled Microsoft, Google and Amazon turn to nuclear energy to fuel the AI boom.
- 0:38Big tech companies are scrambling to secure nuclear energy deals
- 0:41worth billions of dollars in order to meet the growing demands of generative
- 0:44artificial intelligence. But critics say they need to rethink that and slow down.
- 0:49Well, tech companies have gotten away with the lot just because it's a new area.
- 0:53The approach tends to be move fast and break things and start ups and Silicon Valley.
- 0:58And so what worries me is that approach transposed to nuclear energy
- 1:01because nuclear energy is something that has to involve a lot of care, says Sasha Luchoni,
- 1:07AI researcher and climate lead at New York based AI developers, hugging face.
- 1:12In September, Microsoft announced their plans to purchase power from the Three Mile Island
- 1:17plant in Pennsylvania, where the worst nuclear incident in US history took place in 1979.
- 1:21The site shut down its remaining operating unit in 2019, but plans to reopen for this project.
- 1:27Last week, Google announced a deal with nuclear startup Kyro's Power buying 500
- 1:32megawatts of electricity from seven small modular reactors, SMRs, that have yet to be built.
- 1:38And just a few days ago, Amazon struck a similar deal with startup X Energy.
- 1:42Small modular reactors are considered safer than traditional nuclear plants due to their
- 1:46smaller size and power output. According to the proponents of the technology,
- 1:50they're also touted as cheaper and faster to build, which will ideally provide the tech
- 1:54companies with a source of renewable energy.
- 1:56In Google's case, as early as 2030, companies are racing towards nuclear
- 2:00because they are using exponentially more power now due to the upsurge of generative AI use.
- 2:06Both Google and Microsoft missed their net zero emissions goals for 2024, a first because
- 2:12these companies tend to set goals they can meet according to Luchoni.
- 2:15Quote, this year, they're like, Oh, oops, AI caught us by surprise.
- 2:20And quote, she said, some see the Microsoft, Google and Amazon investments in nuclear energy
- 2:26as a positive step towards reducing big tech emissions.
- 2:28Quote, I think all of that is great for the environment.
- 2:31And quote, said, Jacopo beyond Giorno, a nuclear science and engineering
- 2:36professor and director of MIT's Center for Advanced Nuclear Energy Systems.
- 2:41The AI systems are trained on large data sets and program with specific
- 2:45rules and algorithms so that each request the identify patterns in order to provide an answer.
- 2:50Quote, they're trying to stick that into anything that moves, anything that a customer
- 2:54can interact with, and quote, Luchoni said, of the big tech companies.
- 2:58Generative AI takes more power to perform than, for example, streaming shows and scrolling
- 3:03through your social media feed, says Luchoni, who has research AI's environmental
- 3:08costs and is currently developing a rating system for the technology.
- 3:11Put another way, one chat GPT query uses as much electricity as a light bulb needs to be on
- 3:17for 20 minutes, according to a research cited by NPR.
- 3:20Luchoni says companies should be mandated to release how much energy its AI tech uses
- 3:25and to allow users to opt out of using it.
- 3:28Once there is more information about Generative AI's energy usage, she says the
- 3:32government will be able to develop regulations around its use.
- 3:36Quote, we should be curbing the demand.
- 3:38And quote, she said, instead, as demand rises, tech companies are investing in nuclear energy
- 3:44and building more AI data centers, which are the mega warehouses full of servers,
- 3:48routers and cooling systems that power AI.
- 3:50Quote, there's going to be a couple of years when the demand is going to be
- 3:54outstripping any kind of renewable energy supply.
- 3:56And quote, Luchoni said, tech companies have been actively looking for renewable energy
- 4:01sources to sustain the rapid growth of Generative AI.
- 4:03In 2023, Google built a geothermal power project in Nevada to power its nearby data centers.
- 4:10And Amazon recently became the world's top corporate buyer of solar and wind energy,
- 4:14which I did not know.
- 4:15Good for them, I guess.
- 4:18There's some random knowledge for you.
- 4:20Yeah.
- 4:21Part of random people.
- 4:24Which is at the end of the day, the whole one of the main reasons we do this podcast.
- 4:28Is it really is mostly forest and near the is near the order of cable where you need
- 4:32to accost people with your random knowledge and questions.
- 4:37That's where you need all the knowledge.
- 4:38Obviously we've shot.
- 4:40We've fallen short in the past and really need to make up for it.
- 4:44Yeah, it's obvious.
- 4:45But we're making up one small step at a time, apparently.
- 4:49Quote, the use of nuclear reactors is almost like an ideal energy source.
- 4:52And that's because nuclear reactors produce electricity 24 seven.
- 4:56And quote, beyond Giorno said beyond Giorno believes that it is quite
- 4:59realistic for nuclear power to run constantly without carbon emissions.
- 5:03He says that the small modular reactors that the companies will be using produce
- 5:06less energy than the larger reactors currently on the grid, but are reliable
- 5:10enough to power the data centers that perform AI calculations.
- 5:14Wind and solar energy comparatively need to be backed up with energy storage
- 5:17batteries and that will add to the cost of land usage associated with the power generation.
- 5:22Quote, building a new nuclear plant is expensive.
- 5:25The good news is that once you have built it and authorized it, then the
- 5:28marginal cost of operating and maintenance plus fuel are actually pretty low
- 5:32and predictable over decades.
- 5:34And quote, as for concerns, I guess I can say beyond Giorno because they didn't
- 5:38put it there, but two days, I'm pretty sure.
- 5:41As for certain as for concerns about radiation from the SMR as beyond Giorno
- 5:46says he has virtually none due to the smaller size and energy output
- 5:50that conventional nuclear power plants.
- 5:52They also have passive safety systems, according to one proponent of Canada's
- 5:56investments into SMRs. Quote, if things go wrong, there's no need for human
- 6:01intervention. Things just shut down.
- 6:02And so that's probably one of the biggest differences.
- 6:05And quote, Romina Velshi, former president and CEO of the Canadian
- 6:08Nuclear Safety Commission told CBC's Edmonton AM earlier this month.
- 6:13The reactor at Thromel Island is expected to be back up and running by 2028,
- 6:17pending approval from the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
- 6:20Google's deal with Cairo's power projects this first SMR to be ready by 2030,
- 6:25whereas Amazon and X Energy are planning for 2039.
- 6:28However, the first SMR project in North America is under construction right now,
- 6:32operated by Ontario Power Generation at the Darlington plant in Clarington,
- 6:37Ontario. It's expected to be the first in North America to go online.
- 6:40It is scheduled to become operational by 2029.
- 6:43Quote, if the investment is there and the need is there, the demand is there.
- 6:47It's absolutely feasible.
- 6:48And quote, Bon Giorno said. So that's the article.
- 6:51I do have one more thing to add just before we move on and talk about this,
- 6:56Chelsea, just because there's another article that's super short and I wanted
- 6:58to include it, just because it's somewhat on the same page.
- 7:01This one comes from iPhoneincanada.ca,
- 7:04which I'm not going to say is a reputable source.
- 7:07iPhone in Canada.
- 7:09Yes.
- 7:10OK.
- 7:12Just wanted to make sure.
- 7:13This may make it the whole, this may be its only appearance on this podcast.
- 7:19And in fact, I'm now realizing.
- 7:20Now, I'm realizing now that they also just
- 7:24include that this is coming from the Financial Times, but you're regardless.
- 7:28We're moving forward.
- 7:30This article was written six days ago by
- 7:34Uisman Koreshi.
- 7:35One article from iPhone.
- 7:38It was stolen six days ago.
- 7:40Maybe I don't know.
- 7:43By Uisman Koreshi, Rare Bees stole Meta's nuclear-powered AI data center plans.
- 7:48So Meta's on the same page, ambitious to establish a nuclear-powered AI data center
- 7:53in the US, has encountered a significant obstacle due to the discovery of a Rare
- 7:57Bees species on the proposed site.
- 7:59The Financial Times is reporting and also iPhoneincanada.ca or whatever it is.
- 8:04The initiative aimed to partner with an existing nuclear power plant to supply
- 8:08emissions-free electricity for a new data center dedicated to artificial
- 8:11intelligence operations.
- 8:12However, the identification of a Rare Bees species on the land designated for
- 8:16construction has introduced environmental complications.
- 8:19This setback occurs as other tech giants, including Amazon, Google, and Microsoft,
- 8:22have secured agreements with nuclear power operators to meet the escalating
- 8:26energy demands of their data centers.
- 8:27Despite this challenge, Meta remains committed to exploring carbon-free
- 8:31energy solutions, including potential future collaborations evolving nuclear power.
- 8:36I think that's far enough for that one.
- 8:37I just wanted to include them because that's a good part of the story.
- 8:40Maybe the bees get to survive.
- 8:42They probably don't because a billionaire is behind this getting built.
- 8:45So he probably gets to last day.
- 8:47Yes.
- 8:48Now we know about iPhoneincanada.com.
- 8:51I'm sorry.
- 8:52I'm going to have to listen to the last part.
- 8:54And sorry, Chelsea.
- 8:55What?
- 8:56.ca.
- 8:57I don't want you going to that other website.
- 8:59I don't know what trash is there.
- 9:00To finish my thought, I did not listen to that last part because I was too busy
- 9:07looking at the news articles on iPhoneincanada.ca.
- 9:11I'll have to listen to what I wanted to.
- 9:13It does not have different news categories.
- 9:17It has Amazon, deals and shop apple.ca.
- 9:19Yeah.
- 9:20And the category for Tesla.
- 9:22Anyhow, it's no good.
- 9:23So I'm sad that I missed that.
- 9:25All I know is he said something about bees at the end.
- 9:28Well, I mean, if we take nothing else from this, Meta may be responsible for nuclear
- 9:34bees or radioactive bees in the near future.
- 9:37That's probably a good one to see.
- 9:38Does that make them stronger?
- 9:40Well, usually it makes them cancer riddled.
- 9:42So.
- 9:43Well, that's not good.
- 9:44We need those bees.
- 9:46If it made them stronger, perhaps I'd be on board, but it's seemingly, that summary,
- 9:51I don't think I like it.
- 9:53Does this have anything to do with our chain emails that we're getting and can't delete
- 10:00and as well as our old photographs that we can't delete from the cloud?
- 10:05Well, I don't think so.
- 10:07And I know we talked about that.
- 10:09We talked about that a while back in one of the fringee minis that a lot of our just like
- 10:13mundane uses of the usage of the interwebs ends up contributing to global warming in
- 10:18ways we didn't realize that pales in comparison to the actual power needed for AI, despite
- 10:23the fact that nobody really needs AI.
- 10:25So why?
- 10:27Like is it because AI is thinking?
- 10:30Why does it take so much power for AI?
- 10:33Because it's a language model and it takes a lot of power to be able to actually come
- 10:37up with those sentences.
- 10:39Based on all the information that's been fed.
- 10:41So it's like thinking and it's like, it's not thinking.
- 10:44I cannot stress enough that it is not thinking.
- 10:47It's like it needs calories to be able to generate output.
- 10:51Sure.
- 10:52It's blood for the blood God.
- 10:54Okay.
- 10:55Okay.
- 10:56So definitely not alive anymore than a light bulb is alive.
- 11:00Yeah.
- 11:01And that makes it great that they explained that it uses as much electricity as a light
- 11:05bulb.
- 11:06I wish they would have specified it for talking about like incandescent bulbs or like the newer
- 11:10light bulbs that are pretty energy efficient or I don't know, maybe we're talking about
- 11:14a kerosene light bulb for some reason.
- 11:16Maybe.
- 11:17I don't think they exist, but maybe that's what we're talking about.
- 11:20I mean, they could if you really wanted it to, but who wants it to unless you're a ghost
- 11:25on a lake.
- 11:26Yeah, that's fair.
- 11:27Anyhow, the reason I really wanted to like bring this to our attention is because it
- 11:31is in the AI realm and it is interesting that we're going back into nuclear power and I
- 11:35don't have a problem with nuclear power per se.
- 11:39Like in itself, there's no real issues with it that can't be offset.
- 11:44However, the problem I always have and it comes back to our entire capitalistic model
- 11:49that everything needs to be run for a profit.
- 11:51And I just don't trust nuclear power being run for profit.
- 11:55Yes.
- 11:56Because that can be a reason.
- 11:59Yeah.
- 12:00We all know.
- 12:01And I find it particularly apt that they're in fact going to be using Three Mile Island
- 12:06for Google Energy.
- 12:07Yeah, that's the whole sentence in itself seems wrong.
- 12:12Yeah.
- 12:13Yeah, I guess of all the energies, that one's one of the, I don't want to say the wrong thing,
- 12:18greenest.
- 12:19Compared to...
- 12:20Kind of.
- 12:21It's quasi-green in that it isn't renewable exactly, but it's sustainable over an extremely
- 12:28long time period.
- 12:30And who knows how long we're going to be here for that because as covered in the article,
- 12:34we are slowly destroying the environment.
- 12:37Yeah, but we'll have nuclear bees.
- 12:39So it could be...
- 12:41That could be good.
- 12:42It could be cancer riddled.
- 12:43We don't know.
- 12:44It sounds like they're weaponizing bees.
- 12:47It's only a matter of time.
- 12:49It really was a matter of time.
- 12:51And frankly, we don't even have a Beeman comic book as far as I know.
- 12:54Beeman.
- 12:55And now I'm kind of stuck on what the superpowers would be and what the Archangel is.
- 13:00What the Nemesis would be, but you guys got 48 hours to think this stuff up.
- 13:03Send it to us.
- 13:04We got an email.
- 13:05You guys don't use it, but we got it.
- 13:06Anyhow, bye.