Latest / Deep Dive / Australia's Property Tax Shake-Up: Will Negative Gearing and CGT Survive?
Transcript
- 0:00You know, I want you to imagine sitting down to play a game of
- 0:04Monopoly with your friends, but there's like this huge catch,
- 0:08OK? One thing.
- 0:09So half the players, they started three hours ago, they
- 0:12already own all the orange and red properties and every time
- 0:15they land on a space they can't afford, the bank just steps in
- 0:18and pays for it out of your starting.
- 0:19Money. Wow.
- 0:21I mean that is a completely rigged board.
- 0:23Like you're rolling the dice, but the math is just
- 0:26fundamentally working against you from turn 1, right?
- 0:28Exactly. But then right in the middle of
- 0:30the game, the banker stands up and says, hey, we are changing
- 0:33the rules to make it fair. And suddenly the players who are
- 0:36winning are furious. But strangely, some of the
- 0:40players who are losing feel like they're being punished too.
- 0:42Yeah, which makes no sense at first glance.
- 0:44Exactly. Welcome to the Deep dive.
- 0:47Today we are exploring a massive, highly contentious
- 0:51shift in Australia's economic landscape.
- 0:54We're talking about the sweeping 2026 tax reforms targeting
- 0:58capital gains tax or CGT, and negative gearing.
- 1:01And the fallout from this is just a fascinating collision of,
- 1:04you know, economics, politics and, honestly, human aspiration.
- 1:08It really is. So to figure out exactly how we
- 1:11got here and where this is going, we're combining over a
- 1:15decade of economic modeling from the Gratton Institute and a HURI
- 1:19that's the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute.
- 1:22Right, the heavy hitters. Yeah, Plus we're going to
- 1:25analyze the mechanics of the official government proposal
- 1:27from the Office of Impact Analysis.
- 1:29That's the one announced on May 12, 2026.
- 1:32But we aren't just looking at the spreadsheets today.
- 1:35No, we're balancing those sterile economic models with the
- 1:38very real, very angry voices captured during a recent boots
- 1:43on the ground investigation by 60 Minutes Australia.
- 1:46Because blunding the data with the human impact is, well, it's
- 1:50crucial. I mean, the economic models tell
- 1:52us what the numbers are programmed to do.
- 1:53But the 60 Minutes piece shows us how those changing numbers
- 1:56actually dictate people's lives. Yeah, they're real decisions.
- 2:01So our mission today is to just cut through all the intense
- 2:04political noise and figure out the actual machinery of these
- 2:07tax mechanisms. Like, why is the Australian
- 2:10government risking immense political backlash to dismantle
- 2:13them? It's a huge risk, right?
- 2:15And what does this clash between intergenerational fairness and
- 2:19frankly, crushing ambition mean for you and your own financial
- 2:23future? Because, listen, even if you
- 2:25don't live in Australia or you don't own property, this entire
- 2:27situation is a master class. It really is.
- 2:30It's a master class and how a countries tax code secretly
- 2:34engineers who gets wealthy, who gets left behind, and how
- 2:37incredibly hard it is to change the rules once an entire economy
- 2:40has been built. Around them, you know, tax codes
- 2:42are so often viewed as these boring mathematical documents
- 2:45that, like, just accountants deal.
- 2:47Yeah, totally. Just numbers on a page, yeah.
- 2:50But the reality is they are the invisible scaffolding of a
- 2:53society's values. I mean, they actively dictate
- 2:56human behavior by rewarding certain actions and penalizing
- 2:59others. Let's actually get into the nuts
- 3:01and bolts of that Australian tax shelter that created this
- 3:04current reality, because before we can understand the absolute
- 3:07uproar over the 2026 changes, we have to understand the specific
- 3:11loopholes being closed. Right, the foundation.
- 3:13So I want to test an analogy with you.
- 3:15Let's say I run a lemonade stand on the weekend and I
- 3:18intentionally lose money on it. Can I I use those lemon scented
- 3:23losses to payless tax on my Monday to Friday salary as an
- 3:26accountant? Is that essentially the
- 3:29superpower of negative gearing? Honestly, that analogy hits the
- 3:32nail on the head when we apply it to investments like property
- 3:36and shares in Australia. The AURI in Graton reports
- 3:39outline mechanics of this beautifully.
- 3:41OK, break it down for me. Well, normally in most tax
- 3:44jurisdictions, if a business loses money, it can only offset
- 3:48those losses against future profits of that same business.
- 3:51Right. So your lemonade stand losses
- 3:52stay quarantined to your lemonade stand.
- 3:54Exactly. But under the traditional
- 3:57Australian negative gearing rules, if you buy an investment
- 4:01property and the rental income you receive isn't enough to
- 4:04cover your expenses, things like mortgage interest, maintenance,
- 4:07council rates, you're operating at a net financial loss.
- 4:10So your property is actively bleeding cash.
- 4:13Yes, but the specific magic trick of negative gearing is
- 4:17that you can take that cash loss from your passive property
- 4:20investment and deduct it directly from your unrelated
- 4:23active wage income. Wow, yeah.
- 4:26So you're highly taxed Monday to Friday.
- 4:29Salary as an accountant is suddenly reduced on paper.
- 4:32You pay significantly less income tax today, effectively
- 4:35subsidized by the public purse, simply because your investment
- 4:38property failed to turn a profit.
- 4:39Which? I mean, it feels entirely
- 4:41counterintuitive when you say it out loud.
- 4:42You're being financially rewarded by the tax office for
- 4:44making a lot. It sounds crazy, but yes.
- 4:46But it doesn't stop there, does it?
- 4:48There's a second piece to this puzzle that turns a tax
- 4:51deduction into a wealth building machine.
- 4:53Oh absolutely. The multiplier effect.
- 4:55Negative gearing on its own is really only half the engine.
- 4:58The real fuel comes from the 50% capital gains tax discount,
- 5:02which was introduced back in September 1999.
- 5:06OK, so this is where the arbitrage happens.
- 5:08Walk us through the timeline of how an investor utilizes both of
- 5:11these at the same time. Sure, So consider the lifespan
- 5:15of an investment property, right?
- 5:16Every single year you own the house, you're utilizing negative
- 5:19gearing to take a tax deduction against your salary.
- 5:22So you're saving cash in real time, buffering your day-to-day
- 5:25living expenses. Right.
- 5:27And meanwhile, the physical property itself is sitting
- 5:29there, ideally growing in market value, but the payoff happens
- 5:33when you finally go to sell that property years later.
- 5:36Because of that 1999 legislation, the CGT discount
- 5:39means the government only requires you to declare and pay
- 5:42tax on half of the profit you made.
- 5:44Wait, so an investor gets to deduct 100% of their holding
- 5:48costs against their highly taxed salary along the way, but when
- 5:51they finally cash out, the government only taxes 50% of the
- 5:55financial gain? That is the arbitrage.
- 5:57You're systematically converting your highly taxed wage income
- 6:01into lightly taxed capital gains.
- 6:03That is wild. And the Graton Institute data
- 6:06demonstrates just how entrenched this behavior has become.
- 6:09Like this isn't a minor loophole utilized by a few savvy
- 6:13financial planners. No, I imagine it's huge.
- 6:15It costs the public purse roughly $11 billion annually,
- 6:19and the distribution of that benefit is incredibly skewed.
- 6:23The top 20% of income earners reap nearly 90% of the capital
- 6:27gains tax discount benefits. Because it aggressively
- 6:30incentivizes leveraged property speculation.
- 6:33I mean, if the tax code guarantees those terms, of
- 6:35course investors are going to borrow heavily and intentionally
- 6:38run at a loss and outbid regular homebuyers for existing houses.
- 6:42They're. Just trying to capture that
- 6:43lightly taxed capital growth down the line.
- 6:45The system practically demands it if you want to optimize your
- 6:48wealth. Right.
- 6:49So that brings us to the government's unprecedented
- 6:51attempt to pull the plug on this exact mechanism.
- 6:55If I'm reading the May 12, 2026 proposal from the Office of
- 6:58Impact Analysis correctly, the government is essentially trying
- 7:02to perform a controlled demolition of this tax shelter.
- 7:05Yes, but without collapsing the broader housing market itself.
- 7:08How exactly are they attempting that tightrope walk?
- 7:11Well, they're deploying A2 pronged strategy that
- 7:14fundamentally rewrites the rules.
- 7:16Let's look at the capital gains tax reform first.
- 7:18Starting July 1st, 2027, that generous 50% discount is
- 7:23completely abolished for individuals and trusts.
- 7:26Just wiped off the board. But they aren't just taxing the
- 7:29whole profit at the highest rate are they?
- 7:30Like what replaces the discount? They're introducing a system
- 7:33called Cost Based Indexation. Cost based indexation.
- 7:37OK, what does that mean? It means the tax office will
- 7:39only tax you on the real gains above the rate of inflation.
- 7:42So for instance, if inflation over 5 year period was 15% and
- 7:46your property value also went up exactly 15%, you wouldn't pay
- 7:50any capital gains tax on that specific portion.
- 7:52Oh, because your asset didn't actually gain any real
- 7:55purchasing power in the broader economy.
- 7:57Exactly. OK.
- 7:58So the inflation portion is protected, but what happens to
- 8:02the profit above that? Any actual profit above that
- 8:05inflation threshold will be subject to a new 30% minimum tax
- 8:09rate. The structural goal here is to
- 8:12align the tax rate on capital gains more closely with the
- 8:15marginal tax rate faced by the average full time working
- 8:18person. So they're trying to level the
- 8:20playing field between the person physically earning a wage and
- 8:24the person earning passive asset growth.
- 8:26Right. The government's philosophy is
- 8:28that a dollar earned through labor shouldn't be taxed at a
- 8:31punitively higher rate than a dollar earned simply by holding
- 8:35a title deed. OK, let's talk about the second
- 8:37prong, because that targets negative gearing directly.
- 8:40The proposal states that for any existing residential properties
- 8:42purchased after May 12th, 2026, those financial losses are now
- 8:47quarantined. Yes, quarantined.
- 8:48So if we go back to our earlier analogy, the government isn't
- 8:52shutting down the lemonade stand.
- 8:53They're just saying you can only use your lemonade losses against
- 8:56future lemonade profits. You cannot touch your accounting
- 9:00salary anymore. That captures the mechanics
- 9:02perfectly. You can no longer offset those
- 9:05property losses against your day job salary.
- 9:07The losses are locked in a box, right?
- 9:10You can only offset them against other property income, or you
- 9:14carry them forward year after year waiting to offset them
- 9:17against future capital gains when you eventually sell the
- 9:20asset. But, and this is huge, there's a
- 9:22massive exemption build into this new rule, isn't there?
- 9:25The supply exemption. Yes, and this exemption is
- 9:28arguably the most crucial part of their entire macroeconomic
- 9:32strategy. Newly built homes are entirely
- 9:35exempt from these negative gearing changes.
- 9:37We really So if you build a new house, the old rules still
- 9:40apply. Exactly.
- 9:41If you fund the construction of a brand new house, you can still
- 9:44deduct those losses against your salary.
- 9:46It's a deliberate, highly targeted behavioral much, OK.
- 9:48I see what they're doing. Right, by removing the tax
- 9:51shield for buying an existing home, but preserving it for a
- 9:55new home, the government is trying to force investor capital
- 9:58out of the business of simply trading old houses back and
- 10:01forth and redirect it into actually building new housing
- 10:05stock. They're trying to take the
- 10:06firehose of investor money and point it toward creating new
- 10:09supply. You only get the tax break if
- 10:12you add a new roof to the market.
- 10:13The objective is to increase the physical number of dwellings
- 10:16rather than just inflating the price of the ones that already
- 10:18stand. Now, logically, you would think
- 10:20a policy explicitly designed to lower the barrier to entry and
- 10:24level the playing field for young people would be
- 10:26universally cheered by. Them.
- 10:27You would think so. But as we pivot to the 60
- 10:30Minutes investigation, we see a massive paradox in who is
- 10:34actually outraged by this reform.
- 10:36The human element completely complicates the mathematical
- 10:39theory. We are seeing a textbook example
- 10:42of how macroeconomic policy collides with microeconomic
- 10:45reality. Yeah, I really want to focus on
- 10:48Emily and Simon Jeffrey. They're the young parents
- 10:50featured in the 60 Minutes piece.
- 10:52The budget is theoretically supposed to help people exactly
- 10:55like them buy their first home, but they feel incredibly
- 10:58punished by this. Yeah, their story is really
- 11:01striking. Why?
- 11:02Because they realized early on that they couldn't save a house
- 11:05deposit purely from their wages. House prices were rising way
- 11:09faster than they could save, so they figured out how to play the
- 11:12game. Right, they adapted.
- 11:13Exactly. They started aggressively
- 11:16investing in shares utilizing the old tax rules to outpace
- 11:19housing inflation, and now under these new 2026 rules, when they
- 11:23eventually sell those shares to buy a house, the government is
- 11:26going to take a much larger cut through that new 30% minimum CG2
- 11:31rule. It's rough.
- 11:32Are these reforms actually catching the wrong people in the
- 11:35crossfire? Well, this raises a critical
- 11:37question about aspiration and the danger of unintended
- 11:40consequences. The 60 Minutes piece captures a
- 11:43visceral sense of demoralization from people who feel they
- 11:45adapted to a specific set of rules only to have the goal
- 11:49posts moved mid game. Yeah, Emily and Simon expressed
- 11:52this deep structural frustration.
- 11:55Because they played by the rules they were given, took the risk,
- 11:58and now the ladder is being pulled up.
- 12:00I mean, they explicitly mentioned considering a move to
- 12:03the United States just to have a shot at building the kind of
- 12:06financial security their parents took for granted.
- 12:08And the outrage isn't contained just to young home buyers trying
- 12:11to get a deposit. There's a whole segment of the
- 12:14business community calling this the ambition tax.
- 12:17The small business impact is profound.
- 12:20Take the story of Elaine, the founder of Melvie Skin Care,
- 12:24highlighted in the investigation.
- 12:26Story was intense. Very She spent six years
- 12:29hustling, taking immense personal risk to grow a business
- 12:32from local weekend markets to a $4 million turnover company
- 12:36employing up to 20 people. Amazing.
- 12:37But then the rules change. Right.
- 12:39Under the new rules, if she decides to sell the business she
- 12:42built from scratch, she loses that 50% discount.
- 12:46Suddenly, she faces up to a 47% tax on her capital gains,
- 12:49depending on how it pushes her into the top marginal bracket.
- 12:52A 47% tax on the ultimate reward for six years of grinding.
- 12:57That's almost half. Exactly.
- 12:59She explicitly told 60 Minutes that she has halted plans to
- 13:02expand the business overseas. Her calculation is simple.
- 13:07If the government is going to take nearly half the value of
- 13:09the enterprise when she sells, the immense stress and risk of
- 13:13expansion is no longer worth the potential reward.
- 13:16Which is terrible for the broader economy, yeah.
- 13:19You also see prominent corporate figures like Janine Allis, the
- 13:21founder of Boost Juice, publicly labeling this a direct
- 13:25punishment on job creators that will systematically crush
- 13:28innovation across the country. So it's the ultimate tension for
- 13:31a government. How do you fix systemic
- 13:33inequality without accidentally stifling the engine of economic
- 13:37growth? How is the government,
- 13:38specifically Treasurer Jim Chalmers, defending this?
- 13:42Because they are taking an absolute beating in the court of
- 13:45public opinion. Treasurer Chalmers is holding a
- 13:47remarkably firm line. He presents the argument
- 13:50impartially. There is no point having a
- 13:52ladder of opportunity if the first few runs are completely
- 13:55missing for an entire generation.
- 13:57He acknowledges the intense backlash from business owners
- 14:00and investors. He even openly admits that
- 14:03breaking the explicit pre election promise not to touch
- 14:06these taxes is going to cost him, in his words, political
- 14:10skin. Because the Prime Minister had
- 14:12gone on the record multiple times promising not to touch
- 14:15negative gearing or CGT. Breaking that trust is a massive
- 14:18political gamble. It is, but the Treasurer insists
- 14:22that the status quo was fundamentally broken beyond
- 14:24repair. The core of his defense is an
- 14:27appeal to societal fairness. How so?
- 14:30He argues that it is structurally unjust for the
- 14:32everyday wage earning taxpayer to subsidize an investor buying
- 14:36their 10th or 12th investment property while young families
- 14:38with steady jobs are completely locked out of buying their first
- 14:41home due to the inflated prices the tax code created.
- 14:45So the political and emotional backlash is incredibly severe.
- 14:48And that brings us to the ultimate question.
- 14:50Does the economic modeling actually show that going through
- 14:53all this pain, breaking election promises and risking the
- 14:55absolute wrath of voters will actually cure the housing
- 14:59crisis? Well, when we look closely at
- 15:01the data from the Gratton Institute, we get a very
- 15:03sobering reality check regarding the actual impact on housing
- 15:06affordability. I want to bring in a quote from
- 15:09the sources to frame this, Tom Panos, the veteran auctioneer,
- 15:12interviewed on 60 Minutes. He said this policy is just
- 15:16reshuffling things on the monopoly board when what we
- 15:19really need is more monopoly boards, right?
- 15:21Does the data backup his claim that changing the tax code is
- 15:24ultimately A distraction from a lack of physical housing supply?
- 15:29Honestly, the economic modeling heavily validates his skepticism
- 15:33regarding a drop in house prices.
- 15:34Really. Yeah.
- 15:36The Gratton Institute's 2025 modeling estimates that even
- 15:39with these sweeping, dramatic changes to negative gearing and
- 15:42CGT, overall property prices would probably fall by less than
- 15:461%. Hold on, let me pause you there
- 15:48because the math on this feels totally disconnected from the
- 15:51intended outcome. If you suddenly remove a massive
- 15:54multibillion dollar tax shield that specifically encourages
- 15:57investors to hoard existing existing properties, wouldn't we
- 16:00see a massive sell off? You'd think so.
- 16:02Right. Like why wouldn't investors just
- 16:04dump their portfolios tomorrow, flooding the market and crashing
- 16:07prices? It comes down to the underlying
- 16:10mechanics of supply and demand. First, remember that selling an
- 16:14asset triggers the very capital gains tax event these investors
- 16:18want to minimize. Oh, right, so they're trapped.
- 16:21Many will simply hold on to their properties, absorbing the
- 16:23new rules rather than take the immediate tax hit.
- 16:27And second, the fundamental drivers of the housing market,
- 16:30interest rates, physical supply bottlenecks and population
- 16:33growth. They're simply much larger
- 16:35forces than the tax code. That makes sense.
- 16:38Removing the investor tax shield removes a layer of speculative
- 16:42froth, but it doesn't change the fact that more people need
- 16:45housing than there are physical roofs available.
- 16:48Consequently, Gratton projects that rents would barely move
- 16:50either, dropping by less than a dollar a week.
- 16:53Less than a dollar a week. So if it doesn't actually fix
- 16:56housing affordability in a meaningful, immediate way for
- 16:59people like Emily and Simon, what is the actual point?
- 17:02Why endure all this political bloodshed?
- 17:05The real benefit and grant and highlights this very clearly is
- 17:08a massive revenue boost and a structural repair of the
- 17:11government's budget. Ah.
- 17:13Follow the money. Always.
- 17:14We're talking about $6.5 billion a year recovered from the CGT
- 17:19reforms alone, and billions more over the long term from curbing
- 17:24negative gearing. The Economist argue that this
- 17:27revenue could be strategically deployed to fund massive social
- 17:30housing projects or to lower income taxes for younger
- 17:33workers. I see.
- 17:34It's about shifting the national tax burden away from daily wages
- 17:38and onto accumulated wealth. Exactly.
- 17:40So it's less about crashing house prices and more about
- 17:42fixing the structural deficits. The government has the capital
- 17:45to build the supply themselves, but I have to wonder, haven't
- 17:48they tried this before? I saw something in the 2012
- 17:51feature article source about the ghost of 1985.
- 17:54Yes, the historical parallel here is absolutely vital for
- 17:57understanding the current political risk.
- 17:59Australia actually did abolish negative gearing for real estate
- 18:02once before, in July 1985. No way they did.
- 18:06The government of the day quarantined property losses very
- 18:10similar to the system used in the United Kingdom and
- 18:12remarkably similar to what is proposed now in 2026.
- 18:15OK. And what happened?
- 18:17Did the Skyfall? Well, the property industry
- 18:19unleashed one of the most intense and effective lobbying
- 18:22campaigns in Australian political history.
- 18:25They claimed that the abolition of negative gearing immediately
- 18:28caused residential investment to dry up, leading to skyrocketing
- 18:32rents across the country. But wait, if the rent drops by
- 18:35less than a dollar under the new models, how could rents have
- 18:38skyrocketed in 1985? Because the lobbying groups
- 18:41weaponized local data to create a national panic.
- 18:44Oh wow. Yeah, independent studies later
- 18:47showed that rents only really rose in two specific cities,
- 18:50Perth and Sydney. And crucially, in those two
- 18:53cities, rental vacancy rates were already virtually 0 before
- 18:56the tax change was even implemented.
- 18:58So the rent spikes were caused by a physical pre-existing lack
- 19:02of houses, an unrelated supply bottleneck.
- 19:04Exactly had nothing to do with the lack of negative gearing.
- 19:07But I'm guessing the narrative had already taken hold in the
- 19:10press and the public consciousness.
- 19:12The narrative was overwhelming, the political pressure became
- 19:15insurmountable. And in 1987, less than two years
- 19:18later, the government caved. They completely reversed the
- 19:21policy and restored negative gearing to its full power.
- 19:24That is wild. And what was the long term
- 19:27result of that reversal? Well, since that reversal in
- 19:301987, average house prices in Australia have soared by 433%,
- 19:36vastly outpacing the growth of average wages.
- 19:39It serves as a stark historical warning for the current
- 19:42government about how difficult it is to remove an entrenched
- 19:45financial advantage once an entire industry and a large,
- 19:49vocal segment of the voting public relies on it.
- 19:51Which perfectly sums up the sheer scale of what we're
- 19:54looking at in this deep dive. The Australian government is
- 19:56currently attempting to dismantle a deeply entrenched
- 19:59wealth building machine that cost the public billions of
- 20:02dollars every year. But in attempting to level the
- 20:05playing field, they're colliding head on with the very
- 20:09aspirations. Of the citizens they're trying
- 20:10to help, the young investors and small business owners who feel
- 20:14the latter is being pulled up just as they finally reach for
- 20:17it. It's a massive societal shift.
- 20:19It is. And understanding these
- 20:21invisible tax structures is so vital for you, the listener,
- 20:25because they dictate the economic headwinds and tailwinds
- 20:28of your own life, regardless of where you live or what you do
- 20:31for a living. They determine whether your hard
- 20:33work is rewarded, or if the game was largely decided before you
- 20:36even rolled the dice. You know, it really makes you
- 20:39wonder if our economic systems are perfectly designed to
- 20:42achieve the results we are currently getting.
- 20:45What does it say about our societal values that we spent
- 20:48decades heavily subsidizing the ownership of a tenth home while
- 20:52fully taxing the daily wages of the person physically building
- 20:55it? And as a society tries to course
- 20:57correct, what happens to a generation's ambition when the
- 21:01primary vehicle for wealth has shifted from building something
- 21:04entirely new to simply waiting for a tax advantage asset to
- 21:07appreciate? A completely rigged monopoly
- 21:10board indeed. Thanks for joining us on The
- 21:13Dive and we'll catch you next time.