Latest / Comeback Journey: Resilience, recovery & starting over / How to Hold Space for Pain Without Trying to Fix It | Comeback Journey
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from loving someone who is breaking, and wanting so badly to hand them the glue. But what if the most loving thing you could offer wasn’t a solution, but just your presence? I want you to think about the last time someone you love sat across from you, tears in their eyes, or maybe just that hollow look in their face when the world feels too heavy to carry. What was your first instinct? For me, it’s always been the same. My heart starts hammering against my ribs like a trapped bird. I feel this physical tightening in my chest, this desperate need to reach out, to grab their hands, and say, 'Here. Let me fix this.' It’s not arrogance. It’s terror. We are wired to protect. And when we see someone we care about in pain, our brains interpret it as a threat to our own sense of safety and competence. If they are hurting, and I can’t make it stop, then I am useless. Or worse, I am failing them. So we rush in. We offer advice before they’ve even finished speaking. We minimize the pain by saying, 'At least it’s not worse.' We distract them with humor or plans for the future. We try to pull them out of the dark hole they’re sitting in because the darkness makes us uncomfortable. We treat their grief like a problem to be solved, a knot to be untied quickly so we can both get back to normal life. But here is the truth that took me years to learn, after burning myself out trying to manage crises in corporate offices and then in my own relationships: You cannot fix another person’s soul. You cannot logic someone out of feeling broken. And every time you try to 'fix' them, you are accidentally telling them that their pain is something wrong that needs to be corrected, rather than an experience that needs to be witnessed. Let’s just sit with that for a second. Think about how it feels when someone tries to fix you. Imagine you’ve had a terrible day. Maybe you lost your job, or a relationship ended, or you’re just exhausted by the sheer weight of existing in a world that demands so much from women who never seem to do enough. You go to a friend, hoping for a safe harbor. And instead of listening, they immediately start listing three steps to get a new job, or five reasons why that ex-partner wasn’t right for you anyway, or suggesting you try meditation apps. Does that feel like comfort? Or does it feel like pressure? When we offer unsolicited solutions, we are often more concerned with relieving our own discomfort than honoring their experience. We want the crying to stop. We want the silence to end. We want to feel useful again. So we fill the air with words, with strategies, with optimism. But in doing so, we skip over the most important part: the validation of their reality. It doesn’t have to be fixed today. In fact, it probably won’t be fixed today. And that is okay. When we rush to fix, we rob the other person of the dignity of their own process. We imply that their pain is an inconvenience to us, rather than a shared human experience. We turn connection into a transaction where we give advice in exchange for relief from our anxiety. But real connection isn’t transactional. It’s relational. It’s about being there, even when it’s messy, even when it’s slow, even when there is no clear path forward. So, if we aren’t fixing, what are we doing? How do we hold space without disappearing into passivity? Holding space is active. It is one of the hardest, most disciplined acts of love there is. It requires you to suppress the urge to speak, to advise, to redirect. It asks you to stay present in the discomfort alongside someone else, without flinching away. It looks like sitting on the floor next to them while they cry, not because you know what to say, but because you refuse to leave them alone in the dark. It looks like asking, 'Do you want to be heard, or do you want help solving this?' Most of the time, people just want to be heard. They want to know that their feelings are valid, that their grief has weight, that their anger has reason. It means letting the silence breathe. I know silence can feel awkward. It can feel like failure. But in those quiet moments, something sacred happens. The other person begins to trust that you are strong enough to handle their pain. They begin to trust that you won’t abandon them when things get ugly or raw or confusing. Your steady presence becomes a container for their chaos. You don’t need to have the answers. You don’t need to be the wise guide with all the tools. You just need to be the witness. Say, 'I see you.' Say, 'This is really hard.' Say, 'I’m here.' That’s it. Those three sentences can do more healing than a thousand pieces of advice ever could. Now, I want to ask you a gentle question, and I invite you to answer it honestly in your own heart. What did that cost you? When you choose to hold space instead of fixing, what is the price you pay? For many of us, especially women who have been socialized to be caretakers, the cost is high. It costs us our need to be needed. It costs us our illusion of control. It forces us to sit with our own helplessness. And that is terrifying. We worry that if we don’t offer a solution, we aren’t being good friends, or good partners, or good daughters. We fear that our silence will be interpreted as indifference. We worry that we are failing in our role as the emotional manager of our community. But let me tell you something I learned during my own reset, after leaving the high-stakes world of crisis management. The most resilient people in my garden were not the ones who fought every pest and weed with chemicals and force. They were the ones who understood the ecosystem. Who waited. Who observed. Who trusted that life would find its way, provided the soil was tended and the roots were protected. Your presence is the soil. Your attention is the water. Your patience is the sun. You are not neglecting them by holding space; you are nurturing them in the only way that truly matters. You are giving them the gift of being seen, exactly as they are, without condition or agenda. So how do we practice this? Because it’s easy to say 'just listen,' but hard to do when your brain is screaming for action. Start small. Next time someone shares a struggle, count to three in your head before you respond. Just three seconds. Use that time to check in with yourself. Are you feeling anxious? Do you want to jump in? Notice that urge. Acknowledge it. And then let it pass. Ask open-ended questions. Instead of saying, 'Have you tried talking to HR?', ask, 'What feels most overwhelming about this situation?' Instead of saying, 'You’ll get over it,' ask, 'What does this feel like for you right now?' Validate their emotions, even if you don’t agree with their perspective. You can say, 'It makes sense that you’re angry,' even if you think their reaction is disproportionate. Validation doesn’t mean agreement. It means recognition. It means, 'I hear you. Your feelings are real.' And if you don’t know what to say? Say that. 'I don’t know what to say, but I am so glad you told me.' 'I wish I could take this pain away, but I can’t. So I’ll just sit here with you.' Honesty is powerful. It breaks down the barrier between performer and human. It reminds us that we are all just doing our best, navigating the messy, beautiful, painful journey of being alive together. Before we close, I want to address one important boundary. Holding space does not mean carrying the burden. You are not responsible for their healing. You are not responsible for their happiness. You are not responsible for fixing their past or securing their future. It is easy to slip into codependency, where we tie our worth to their recovery. But remember, you are a companion on the journey, not the destination. Your job is to walk beside them, not to pull them along. If you find yourself becoming depleted, resentful, or overwhelmed, it is okay to step back. To say, 'I care about you, but I don’t have the capacity to talk about this right now.' Self-care is not selfish. It is necessary. You cannot pour from an empty cup. And you cannot hold space for others if you are drowning in your own unprocessed pain. So tend to your own garden. Tend to your own wounds. Be gentle with yourself as you learn this new rhythm of relating. It takes time. It takes practice. There will be days when you fail. You will interrupt. You will offer bad advice. You will run away. That’s okay. Resilience isn’t about perfection. It’s about returning. Returning to the moment. Returning to the presence. Returning to the simple, radical act of showing up, again and again, with an open heart and a quiet mind. Thank you for staying here with me. Thank you for the courage it takes to simply be present, in your own life and in the lives of those you love. I’ll be right here, waiting for you next time. Until then, be gentle with yourself.