Latest / The Team House / KGB Spies in Silicon Valley | Zach Dorfman | Ep. 247
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, folks, I just want to take a minute to ask you to
- 0:03go in rate this podcast. Let the Team House know how you think we're
- 0:07doing. Go and rate us on whatever platform you're listening to this on,
- 0:11whether it's iTunes or Spotify or whatever else. Those ratings really help us out
- 0:16and we really appreciate the feedback to let us know what you like and what
- 0:19you don't like. And if you do like the Team House and you'd like
- 0:23to support us, go check out our Patreon page and you can actually support
- 0:27the stream and well as get access to our bonus segments and bonus episodes.
- 0:32Yeah, if you're going to give us a great review, please do.
- 0:35And if you're going to give us ant secret view, why don't you just
- 0:37send us an email and we'll talk about special operations. Obert ask me an
- 0:50the Team House with your hopes. Jack Murphy and David bark Hi, Everyone,
- 1:03Welcome to episode two hundred and forty seven of The Team House. I'm
- 1:07Jack Murphy here with tonight's guest, Zach Dorfman. Zach is a national security
- 1:11journalist, author of many great articles in the national security and espionage field,
- 1:17and he also recently did the podcast series Valley of Spies with Project Brazen,
- 1:23reporting on previously unknown to the public Trader in our midst somebody who worked for
- 1:30the US National Security Complex in Silicon Valley and sold secrets to the enemy during
- 1:36the Cold War. So we're very happy to have Zach here tonight on the
- 1:40show. Thanks for coming on. Man, appreciated your patience with us tonight.
- 1:44Of course, Man, great to be back. Absolutely, So,
- 1:48you know, just to kick it off, I mean, talk to us
- 1:51a little bit about about your podcast series, Valley of Spies. I mean,
- 1:57before we get into the production of it. I'd really like the your
- 2:00how this story like even came on your radar because I recently read, for
- 2:05instance, there was a journalist who wrote the book from Warsaw with Love whole
- 2:10history about the Polish American intelligence relationship, and I don't recall your story being
- 2:15in there. I mean, this is something that I had never heard of
- 2:19before. Yeah, I mean that's a great book, by the way,
- 2:22John Ponferen's book, and I read that before I started. Yeah, it
- 2:28was about the same time I embarked on the podcast. So basically, Spy
- 2:32Valley, the genesis of Spy Valley was one of those great kind of kismet
- 2:38things that you have with your sources, and I know that you know you've
- 2:43had this too. I was sitting with a longtime FBI counter intelligence official from
- 2:50San Francisco named Bill Canane, and Bill was an awesome guy. He got
- 2:55out to San Francisco in the early seventies and were worked Kundter intelligence in San
- 3:02Francisco until the mid nineties. He was one of the capsin in his career.
- 3:07Was he was one of the first FBI attas ches in Moscow after the
- 3:13fall of the Soviet unions, so he was kind of renowned in the bureau.
- 3:16I mean that was like his low was the last thing he did.
- 3:19But he spent basically his entire career working on the Soviet Squad, then the
- 3:23Russia Squad, and then in between what was known was like the East Block
- 3:25Squad and the East Block Squad during the Cold War was you know, every
- 3:30communist country in Eastern Europe that wasn't Russia basically, but it was all the
- 3:35satellite states, so the Polls, the East Germans, the Czechs, the
- 3:39Hungarians, the Romanians, the Bulgarians, and you know they weren't as you
- 3:46know, big of a deal, but they're pretty big deal. They're they're
- 3:49very, very active in the Valley, mostly for economic espionage. And Bill
- 3:54Bill was awesome. He was He was an Irish guy from Park Slope who
- 4:00grew up in Park Slope. Was a Marine, and then after he got
- 4:03out, he ended up in the FBI. He worked in New York for
- 4:06a while and then he moved out to San Francisco in the early seventies.
- 4:13And Bill and I would have coffee from time to time and we would like,
- 4:15we'd hang out, we would chat. He would kind of shoot the
- 4:18shoot shit about about like all the spy you know stuff that he did.
- 4:24They kind of you know, spy hunting he did in the Valley. And
- 4:27one day he said to me, oh, have you ever looked into the
- 4:29James Harper case? And I was like, not really. I heard a
- 4:31little bit about it. And he goes, oh, that should be a
- 4:33book. And he said, well, by the way, I was the
- 4:36squad supervisor on that case. And of course, you know, as a
- 4:41reporter, you're like, wait, huh, You're a squad supervisor. You
- 4:45oversaw the whole case from the investigative side. And he said, yeah,
- 4:49I'm going to start talking about it, and and I was like, well,
- 4:54if Bill says this is a book, there might be a book.
- 4:56And so I started reading everything I could about the case. It was a
- 5:00big deal at the time, but it had been completely memory hold. You
- 5:02know. It was one of those great Cold War stories that, for various
- 5:05reasons, had just been completely forgotten, and much of the story had never
- 5:11been told because, you know, the FBI guys weren't talking at the time.
- 5:15Obviously, when the case broke in nineteen eighty three, the prosecutors wouldn't
- 5:19have talked. The documents I gotten wouldn't have been able to get, and
- 5:23of course I wouldn't have been able to talk to James Harper himself. So
- 5:26that was the real genesis of the story. And then that was a twenty
- 5:30That was twenty nineteen, and the story came out in twenty twenty three.
- 5:33So it was on and off reporting the story for half a decade, and
- 5:36a book proposal ended up becoming a narrative podcast. And Bill also has like
- 5:42the most FBI voice ever in the podcast We Arrived, Yeah, we had.
- 5:48Yeah, he had just very and he was funny because he had this
- 5:51you know, I think it's this old I think it was this old school
- 5:54Brooklyn Irish had gone on, and he was so disarming because he was he
- 5:59was he was, you know. But then but then you'd be like,
- 6:00oh, Bill, can we meet for coffee tomorrow? And he'd be like,
- 6:03oh, I can't. I got to go to James Joyce day,
- 6:05you know, down at the you know, he was like a really literary
- 6:08guy. He was famous in the bureau in San Francisco because every morning he
- 6:15would get to the office and then he would go across the street and read
- 6:18the New York Times cover and cover for like three hours. Like he would
- 6:21read the New York Times every day. And some of his colleagues were like,
- 6:27what's this guy doing. This isn't his job. But Bill's thinking was
- 6:30that, like, to do his job well, he had to understand what
- 6:32the world, how the world worked, you know, in a kind of
- 6:35like geopolitical way, not you know, because it's very easy when you're working
- 6:39cases just to think about it in the narrow context. But Bill, to
- 6:43his great credit, I think, understood that you couldn't separate counter intelligence work
- 6:46from the larger political and geopolitical situation that was going on at the time,
- 6:51and so yeah, I mean, once I knew I had the squad leader
- 6:57ready to talk, I was like, that's one big piece. Little did
- 7:00I know there was going to be a podcast and bill of the time,
- 7:03it was a hardcore like can't record me, you know, can't record me
- 7:10even on background, even to take notes. Can't record me ever, And
- 7:15of course I thought that there was going to be big problem with this.
- 7:17But you know, years went by, and when I came back to him
- 7:19and said, hey, this isn't going to be a book anymore. It's
- 7:21going to be a podcast. Would you lend would you be willing to have
- 7:25a microphone in front of you and talk about this case? He was kind
- 7:28of like, okay, maybe it was COVID, Maybe it was like he
- 7:31realized that this was the one this was the one best shot to have this
- 7:34story told. And I was like, look, it's not going to be
- 7:36a book and I need it. It's not as powerful, you know,
- 7:42right, you know how this is right? Obviously it's not as powerful for
- 7:45you to narrate somebody else's story. You want them to be able to narrate
- 7:46a little bit. So it was really special and I think wonderful having people
- 7:49like Bill and a lot of his colleagues in the Bureau who you know,
- 7:54were they were long retired at that point and they were willing to talk about
- 7:58the work they did. So, Yeah, that was really cool. And
- 8:01as we kind of like get into this story itself, can you tell us
- 8:05a little bit about the history of Silicon Valley and why that part of America
- 8:09is such a huge target for foreign intelligence services. Yeah, I mean,
- 8:13going back to the post war period, basically the valley always had a take
- 8:20connections to the US military industrial complex. You know, got of missile technology
- 8:24was being developed both in Silicon Valley and then down in the South Los Angeles
- 8:28area, if you know, there's a lot of a lot of military,
- 8:33very very large military contractors are still based out there, and then of course
- 8:37the valley. By the nineteen seventies, the micro trip revolution entered the picture,
- 8:43and computing power became important for everything from missile guidance systems to tanks,
- 8:50to satellite systems to big data analysis what we call today big data analysis,
- 8:58you know power. The idea of like networked computing was something that obviously had
- 9:05civilian importance but was primarily as you know, like you know, DARPA was
- 9:09the Internet was a military project. You know, it's about military connectivity.
- 9:15So as soon as the micro trip revolution, the semiconductor revolution kicked off by
- 9:20the seventies, sixties and seventies, you know, it became the valley became
- 9:26and it still is, but it really became a central front in the kind
- 9:31of Cold War espionage war. Back then it was primarily the US versus the
- 9:37Soviet Union and allies. Now it's a more complex picture where you have the
- 9:41Russians obviously, but you also even more so probably have the Chinese. The
- 9:46Iranians are there. I mean, everybody's playing around in the valley. And
- 9:48I think there's a way in which people don't necessarily associate it with with being
- 9:54rich terrain for espionage, because they think of espionage as something that happens in
- 10:00government buildings, you know, or at the un you know, places that
- 10:03you think of as like seats of power. There's a lot of power in
- 10:05the valley, and there's a lot of technology that foreign states want to steal
- 10:11in order to replicate, to understand better. And that's always been the primary
- 10:18kind of espionage you get in the valley is that is like tech focused economic
- 10:24espionage. You also get political stuff, right because it's California. So you
- 10:26can't discount the fact that like foreign governments want to know what's going on in
- 10:31California, I mean, particularly the Chinese, So that's a part of the
- 10:35picture too, But it's really tech focused here. You're probably the only person
- 10:41I know of offhand who's really kind of pointed out the importance of California and
- 10:46specifically Miami as like hubs for intelligence because of the way the United States projects
- 10:52itself out into the world from those particular parts of America. Yeah, I
- 10:58mean the Miami scene, and I wish there was some if there's somebody out
- 11:01there, and I apologize if I don't know them, but I'm not aware
- 11:05of any dedicated full time intelligence reporter down in Miami. And the Miami Herald
- 11:11did amazing stuff back in the day. They did, I mean, they
- 11:15used to have. I mean it's just kind of like how the Yeah,
- 11:16it's a longer conversation about the loss of national security reporting as a as a
- 11:22national enterprise as opposed to like nine percent of people being based in d C.
- 11:28I mean, you're even you're in New York, right, and that's
- 11:31that should be the most obvious place in the world for national security reporters to
- 11:35be playing around in. But it's so DC focused. I mean, Miami
- 11:39obviously you have I mean, not only do you have you have so calm
- 11:43in Florida, but you also have you know, the Cuban and Venezuela and
- 11:48Russians and the Russians down in Miami. There's a there's always ton going on
- 11:54down there, Ton going on down there. I mean what I'm more familiar
- 11:58with, of course, is that is the the Bay Area scene. And
- 12:01look, you know, there's always a data point that I was told by
- 12:05a former senior intelligence official that always stuck out to me, which is that
- 12:11the MSS. The MSS had a unit, a political intelligence unit, uh
- 12:18for two American entities. One was Washington, d C. And the other
- 12:22one was California. You know, like they literally set up like a team
- 12:26or like a unit to understand politics in DC. And then they're like,
- 12:30what's the only other place that we carried out? But I mean's not like
- 12:31they don't care about what's going on in other states, but they literally set
- 12:35up a unit you know for that, I mean, is it is a
- 12:39is a top priority for them, and it's long been a priority for the
- 12:41Russians too. I mean, the Russians have been mucking around in California for
- 12:46a long long time for all sorts of reasons, and it just never got
- 12:50you know. I think that's why. Also, this, this case Despy,
- 12:52this the case in Spy Valley, uh, kind of got forgotten because
- 12:56it was a California case, right, And it wasn't It wasn't a it
- 13:01wasn't a guy who was It's not handsOn or Aims, right. It's not
- 13:03a guy who was an FBI agent, CIA officer. It's a dude who
- 13:07worked in high tech whose girlfriend worked for a missile contractor you know. So
- 13:13it's it. And in a way though, it's actually more representative of where
- 13:18espionage is going or has gone right where It's like, it may not always
- 13:22be that guy in Langley, right, It's probably going to be somebody with
- 13:28access to classified information of like a narrowly tailored type but nonetheless has a crazy
- 13:37value you know, for for states. Right. I mean that's that's that's
- 13:41the irony, right, is that you have all these nameless building, these
- 13:43nameless companies, these tech firms that have classified contracts, and they're doing stuff
- 13:48that is like wild that nobody really understands and is kind of a softer target.
- 13:54Right. It's much harder to walk into the Pentagon or to Foggy Bottom
- 13:58and like get what you want, whereas like in the Valley, nobody really
- 14:03even like nobody really understands the kind of geography of the classified world in the
- 14:09valley. Right, It's not like you can point to five buildings and say
- 14:11they have these contracts. They I mean, probably there's a couple of big
- 14:13firms, right, but like they're small firms all over the valley that have
- 14:18some overlapping relationship to the Pentagon or the IC, and it's just nobody really
- 14:24understands it. So it's not being guarded the same way. So tell us
- 14:28about John Harper, who was this guy who's kind of the focal point of
- 14:35your story. So James Harper was a guy who was a native Californian.
- 14:45He he went through he was a he he was trained in electronics by the
- 14:52military. He entered the he entered the military to try to avoid being drafted
- 14:58into Korea. So that that places him in time, right, I mean,
- 15:01so he graduated in high school in the early nineteen fifties. He wanted
- 15:05to basically choose where he would get routed so he didn't end up like on
- 15:09the front lines, I guess. And he had a facility of electronics,
- 15:13and he was like a kind of like first generation archetype of a Silicon Valley
- 15:18entrepreneur. A dude who's like really really good at math and science, really
- 15:24ambitious, really greedy, wants to strike it big. Sees that like there's
- 15:28this kind of gold rush going on in San Francisco by the sixties and seventies,
- 15:33that first generation of like high tech gold rush guys who were just like,
- 15:35I can make millions in a few years, I can like hit it
- 15:39big, right, This guy thinks he's going to like make it, and
- 15:41the process he ends up, you know, working at these kind of storied
- 15:46valley firms. At some point he has a clearance, he's working on missiles,
- 15:48he's working on missile related technology. But then he's like he does other
- 15:52stuff that's not classified. Ends up in Alaska for a bit working on something
- 15:56called the White Alice Project, which was like setting up telecommunityations relays in case
- 16:02the Soviets shot a you know, ICBM or something it was this at the
- 16:07time, the technology required, like actual physical relay systems from very very rural
- 16:11parts of Alaska. So he went up to Alaska for a few years and
- 16:15did that, and his whole life was kind of defined by the Cold War
- 16:18that way, like the intersection between high tech and the Cold War. So
- 16:22he does that, and he does like non classified contracts, but still in
- 16:26the high tech space. One day he decides, I want to strike out
- 16:32on my own. I want to do something. Apparently he told me he
- 16:36he had four daughters, and he told me one day he was watching one
- 16:41of his daughters at a swim practice and they saw he had someone had a
- 16:45stopwatch, and he was like, why isn't there an electric stopwatch? Oh,
- 16:51I should invent the electric stockwatch. So he does. Like the main
- 16:56spy in this story in Spy Valley, James Harper is like the he is
- 16:59the ventor of the electric stopwatch, like the digital stopwatch US. Yeah,
- 17:04digital, Like it's literally called Acus, but it's a company that still exists,
- 17:08Digital Stopwatch, I mean, and he he starts the company up,
- 17:18starts doing really well. But like Harper is a man of appetites, right,
- 17:22he's a cheat. You know, he was a compulsive gambler. He
- 17:27he like partied really really, really hard, and he bezzled funds from his
- 17:33company, and so he got kicked out of his company. He got kicked
- 17:34out of his own company. And this is by like the early nineteen seventies.
- 17:41And when he gets kicked out of his company, he's like, shit,
- 17:44I gotta find a way to make more money, and so he starts.
- 17:48He starts. Basically he hooks up with the other Silicon Valley entrepreneur named
- 17:52Bill Hugle. And Bill Hugel was a you know, a kind of pioneer
- 17:57of the semiconductor industry in the Valley. And Bill Hugle at the same time,
- 18:02I had a secret. Bill Hugle's secret was a basically was an agent
- 18:07of the Polish intelligence Services, right, like which were then a core ally
- 18:11of Moscow is literally the Warsaw packed, right, I mean Warsaw. So
- 18:15like he Bill Hugle was this kind of proto Valley libertarian guy who was like
- 18:21free love, like legalized pot out of Vietnam, but also like free trade
- 18:27and free trade for Bill Hugle also meant free trade with the Soviet block because
- 18:30he just believed like there shouldn't be any prohibition impediments, Yeah, impediments on
- 18:37him making money, right, and just you know, for the you know
- 18:40your listeners, I mean, given who they are, they probably know all
- 18:44this. But like, there's there's a lot of technology that is that is
- 18:48export prohibited, right. There's there's stuff that has dual use, dual use
- 18:52technology, which means that it has civilian purposes but also potential military or intelligence
- 18:59purposes. Things like micro things like computer systems that would allow American adversaries to
- 19:07build better and faster supercomputers or missile systems. I mean, this is going
- 19:11on today, right, There's like there's been a real squeeze both on the
- 19:14Chinese in terms of certain kinds of like computer technology, but then also the
- 19:17Russians now, particularly after the Ukraine War. That's why the Russians are ripping
- 19:21microchips out of washing machines and refrigerators, you know, because they can't they
- 19:26can't get this technology other ways. It's like it's kind of incredible. Well,
- 19:30those are the same case in the seventies, right. So Bill Hugle
- 19:33was not a traditional spy in the way we think about spies, but he
- 19:36was an agent of the Polish Intelligence Services, and the Polls would get lists
- 19:41of high tech that they wanted from the KGB. The KGB would pass them
- 19:45a list. The list would be like, we want this kind of chip,
- 19:48this kind of chip, this kind of thing, this kind of thing's
- 19:49kind of processing technology, are replicator of some sort? You know, all
- 19:52this stuff. In the seventies they handed to the polls. The Polish Intelligence
- 19:56Services would then hand those lists out to their agents. Can you get me
- 20:00x can you get me wine? And Bill Hugle was one of those guys,
- 20:03right, he was like a principal agent for the Polls. Now,
- 20:07as a good principal agent, he subcontract he contracted out to sub agents.
- 20:12Right. And James Harper enters Bill Hugle's world and becomes a sub agent.
- 20:18So he becomes a guy who works for Bill Hugle finding technology that is technically
- 20:26illegal to export to the Soviet block. That's how he begins to get in
- 20:32to Spine again. It's it's interesting, right because it's not how we think
- 20:36of spies, right, it's adjacent to Spine. It's certainly it was illegal.
- 20:41I mean, Hugle knew he was working for like an adversary intelligence service.
- 20:45He knew that basically the computer chips and the material that he was providing
- 20:48was eventually going to make its way to Moscow. But it was like different,
- 20:52right, they looked at these guys looked at it. It's just another
- 20:55play, right. It was like the Silicon Valley idea of like this is
- 20:57just another way way to make money, to make money, and we're just
- 21:03we're just we're free traders. We're just advancing free trade, like we don't
- 21:06really care, you know, beyond that. So that's how Hardbery got in
- 21:10to that world. But of course it didn't end there. Okay, Zach,
- 21:12I'm gonna do this ad read real quick before we move on to the
- 21:15next point. Thank you to our sponsor for tonight's show. It's a Factor.
- 21:22So this holiday season, you might be looking for nutritious, convenient meals
- 21:26to keep you energized on jam packed days. Factor America's number one ready to
- 21:30eat meal delivery service, can help fuel up your breakfast, lunch, or
- 21:34dinner and chef prepared, dietician approved ready to eat meals delivered straight to your
- 21:38door. You'll save time, eat well, and stay on track with your
- 21:41healthy lifestyle while tracking all your holiday to dos. Too busy with holiday plans
- 21:48to cook, but you want to make sure you're eating well. With Factor,
- 21:49skip the extra trip to the grocery store and the chopping, prepping and
- 21:53cleaning up too, while still getting the flavor in nutritional quality you need.
- 21:59Factors Fresh never frozen meals are ready in just two minutes, so all you
- 22:03have to do is heat and enjoy. Skip the stress of meal prepping over
- 22:07the holidays. With Factor, choose from thirty five weekly flavored, flavor packed,
- 22:11fresh, never frozen meals that support healthy lifestyles and meet your meal preferences,
- 22:15all delivered right to your door, ready to eat in two minutes,
- 22:19so you know you'll enjoy the any With Factor, you can rest assured you're
- 22:26making a sustainable choice. We offset one hundred percent of our delivery emissions and
- 22:32source one percent renewable electricity for our production sites and offices. And this November,
- 22:38get Factor and enjoy eating well without the hassle. Simply choose your meals
- 22:42and enjoy fresh, flavor packed meals delivered to your door, ready in just
- 22:45two minutes, no prep, no mess, So head to Factor meals dot
- 22:48com slash Teamhouse fifty and use the code Teamhouse fifty to get fifty percent off.
- 22:55That's Teamhouse fifty at Factor Meals dot com slash Teamhouse fifty to get fifty
- 23:00percent off of your meals. So thank you to the Factor for sponsoring the
- 23:04show I and Zach. So that's a little intro into who James Harper was
- 23:12and sort of his entry into the world of espionage. I'm I guess you
- 23:18know, you know, his his erstwhile handler had identified him as someone who
- 23:23would be useful to him. Did he did he have to pitch him?
- 23:27Like? How did that work? Honestly, the way that Harper told it
- 23:32to me was just that, you know, Bill Hugle, like, these
- 23:34these guy you got to step back to These guys are all just drinking buddies,
- 23:38right, I mean at the time, at the time the Valley scene,
- 23:41there was like a couple of bars down the peninsula from San Francisco in
- 23:45the heart of the valley that was where all the entrepreneurs are just hanging out.
- 23:51And it was like a really boozy scene. Right. It was the
- 23:53seventies and eighties, Like everyone was drinking a lot all the time, right,
- 23:59and so there was a lot of like there was just a lot of
- 24:03like wheeling and dealing that would go on at these a couple of these bars,
- 24:07and everybody knew that, like basically every night of the week, there'd
- 24:10be people in the scene there, right, it was a small enough scene
- 24:11and then for that to happen. So at some point Bill Hugle, you
- 24:18know, the semiconductor Pioneer, you know, the primary agent of the Polish
- 24:21intelligence Services, the friends Harper at one of these bars and they just start
- 24:26talking, they just start shooting the ship. And that's how it ended up
- 24:30happening. I don't think it took a lot of convincing, let's put it
- 24:33that way. Right, Like he was not he was knocking on an open
- 24:37door, you know, he was like, hey, money, and he
- 24:40was like and Harbor was like, yeah, I'd love to make somebody how
- 24:41and he's like, well, you got to get some stuff from me.
- 24:44Oh who is it for? You know, well it's for some friends of
- 24:45mine in the Eastern block, all right, whatever, Like they did,
- 24:48like they didn't. You know. It's funny because in the world in the
- 24:52in the world of the usg right, there's this kind of like there's this
- 24:59attitude, well you know, these are they are adversaries. These are you
- 25:03know, how could you betray your country like that? And it's a valid
- 25:07perspective, but it's not the way culture that these guys came up. They
- 25:15wanted money, they wanted global they wanted global networks. They were not thinking
- 25:21like their value hierarchy was not like the idea of like this this competition between
- 25:29these two global behemoths being the thing that they woke up every day thinking about
- 25:32and worrying about. Was like that was just not there. Well, I
- 25:36mean I think what really gives away the banality of it is just how little
- 25:40money he sold his country out for. It's like this wasn't like a retirement
- 25:42fund. It's just like chump change. Really at the end of the day.
- 25:45Oh yeah, I mean the stuff he was doing for you go finding
- 25:48the microchips and stuff that was like a couple thousand dollars each time. I
- 25:52mean he really was what that was it? I mean, that was it?
- 25:56Right? So that's the thing was that he was just he was making
- 25:59a he was he was making like pocket change, you know, rent money
- 26:03basically, right, low level spine, you know, And in a way
- 26:07he realized that that wasn't enough. I mean it's like almost odd like he
- 26:11did that for enough. He did that for I don't know, on and
- 26:14off from roughly nineteen seventy five until nineteen seventy nine, which is when Harper's
- 26:21like big scheme begins. And that was that was like when he discovered that
- 26:26his girlfriend at the time, whose name was Ruby Louis Schuler, was working
- 26:30for a company that was a specialist in ballistic missile defense. Right, and
- 26:37you know again, I know your listenership is like pretty up on this stuff.
- 26:41But like in the late seventies and early eighties, was a huge topic
- 26:45of discussion because it was all about mutually a sure destruction. It was all.
- 26:48It was all about, like the idea of like can we can we
- 26:52survive a second strike like mister aeb first strike, and the idea that like
- 26:57American, like if thisbe it's attacked first, America might be basically destroyed before
- 27:03we could you know, we could counterattack or could we could we actually stop
- 27:07many Soviet missiles from coming in. So there was a huge amount of money
- 27:11and energy and DoD projects put into trying to somehow destroy Soviet intercontinental ballistic missiles
- 27:23before they reached the US mainland and Harper's girl friend. Harper didn't even know
- 27:29this. I mean, Harper was just like, oh, yeah, cool,
- 27:30Yeah, you're an executive assistant to the president of this like this company
- 27:33down the valley. And she was like yeah. And he's like, oh,
- 27:36what do they work on? Well, this isn't this? Oh and
- 27:37also ballistic missile defense. And it was kind of like his ears perked up,
- 27:41you know, and he was like, wait, what you're working on?
- 27:42What it's like, Oh, like a classified contract? Oh yeah,
- 27:45this classified contracts. Well, where are the classified documents? Started? Oh,
- 27:48they're in the safe. Oh well who's access to the safe? Oh?
- 27:51I do you know? Like that was literally it. He was like,
- 27:55I mean it was, it was. It was And most people,
- 27:59right hear that, You're like, oh, that's good for you, Like,
- 28:02you know, that must be interesting work, right, But his thinking
- 28:06went right to, oh, I could steal those cash money, I could
- 28:12sell them for a lot of money because the nuclear weapons with documents, right,
- 28:17this is literally US ballistic missile information, right, I mean that is
- 28:19like and it's stuff that was like. And Harper was an engineer, so
- 28:25he was a mathematics. He understood this. You know, these documents were
- 28:30These aren't like analytic product products, right, They're not things that have narratives,
- 28:36you know. It's literally documents of like mathematical formulas, right and stuff
- 28:42about, you know, because missiles have to go into the atmosphere and come
- 28:45back down again. It's like they're highly technical, mathematically oriented. It's a
- 28:52mathematically oriented field that requires PhDs and engineers. And so it's like funny because
- 28:59for most of us it's gobbledygook, right, I mean for me, it's
- 29:00certainly it's like I don't you couldn't hand me a document be like is this
- 29:03interesting or valuable to you? I'd be like, I have no idea,
- 29:07Like why would I know anything about that? Right? But he knew,
- 29:11so he started going After the after hours, he and his girlfriend would go
- 29:18to their her office, unlock the safe, look through the documents, take
- 29:23them back to their apartment, and photo copy them, and then bring them
- 29:27back before the end of the night. And that's how they amassed like literally
- 29:33hundreds of pounds, hundreds of pounds of missile related documents. Now he was
- 29:41like, I got to sell these now, right, I got to find
- 29:44a buyer. So he went back to his you know, principal handler,
- 29:48this guy Bill Hugole, also you know, a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, and
- 29:52was like, can you broker an introduction to the Soviets or the polls?
- 29:56And that's how he started. Like he was fully self actualizing, right.
- 30:02He didn't have somebody to come up to him and be like I heard you're
- 30:03having some money troubles, you know, like or you know what I mean,
- 30:07or like I heard your boss is a dick, you know, and
- 30:08like, wouldn't you like to show him by giving me some documents? Like
- 30:11he literally he initiated the entire process. You know, he was a He
- 30:17was a volunteer if there ever was when he was a greedy guy who looked
- 30:22at Spine the way he would look at any other kind of entrepreneurial Silicon Valley
- 30:26play. And that's what's what's one thing that's super interesting about him, Right,
- 30:30It's like it doesn't mean there aren't greedy people in DC or New York
- 30:34or Brussels or wherever, but like there's something about the culture out here that
- 30:38he is exemplary of. Right, Like a guy who was like just viewed
- 30:42Spine as like basically another kind of small business or startup. Yeah, he's
- 30:48not ideological. He's just a tech bro. Let's make some cash here,
- 30:51let's do business. Yeah, he's a hundred percent of tech bro. I
- 30:52mean he was like he literally was like a he was a football juck in
- 30:56high school and he loved like sports cars, and he was good at math
- 31:00and science, you know, and kind of like hands on way as an
- 31:03engineer, like not a nerd at all, like big brawny dude. And
- 31:08it was just a tech bro who decided again to spine I mean, and
- 31:11he brought that attitude like kind of like tech bro, like you know,
- 31:18like fat frat bro tech bro vibe to spying. Yeah, and so did
- 31:23he did he make those introductions for him to you know, actual intelligence officers
- 31:30in the Eastern Bloc? Yeah? So see so yeah, no Eastern Bloc.
- 31:36I mean Hugle is Hugle. Hugle new real Jugle, new real players.
- 31:40I mean, Hugle's main contact was a very senior Polish intelligence officer under
- 31:45he worked for the UH. It was like totally Soviet. He worked for
- 31:49the Polish UH Ministry of like machine industry and tools. Extremely extremely like you
- 31:56know Eastern Bloc ministry title. But he was a real player. I mean,
- 32:00this guy was a very senior intelligence officer who was under undercover as a
- 32:06as a Polish government official and different in a different institution. And Hugo was
- 32:12like basically told Harper, hey cool, I will I'll outbroke the introu but
- 32:15I want to cut because everyone wants a cut, right. All these guys
- 32:19are viewing this again as as a money making opportunities. So they go to
- 32:22Europe and they talk it all out and they you know, Harper brings a
- 32:30couple of classified documents with him or like he actually he brings up he brings
- 32:34like a a like a couple of documents, but he kind of makes almost
- 32:39like a skeleton key of like all the documents that he has and with the
- 32:43description of them to be like it's literally like a would you like this serve?
- 32:46Would you like this sor would you like this? Like it's like he's
- 32:49like, I have all this to offer you, you know what are you
- 32:51going to pay for it? And they make an agreement that Harper is going
- 32:55to come back with more documents. So the first the first meetings are happening
- 32:59in Vienna and in uh and in Warsaw and that's how he starts. I
- 33:07mean, that's how I mean. Literally, you know this, this Polish,
- 33:10this senior Polish intelligence officer whose name was Siho Jin says, let me
- 33:14talk to my people. I got to talk to my tech, my science
- 33:16guys, my SNT intel officers, because I don't know enough about this to
- 33:21tell you what the value is. And I'll get back to get back to
- 33:22them. And they're like, they said, great, I want you to
- 33:25bring you know, I want you to bring all all all of these documents
- 33:29back. And Harper wanted a one time payout of a million dollars. This
- 33:35is nineteen seventy nine, right, so that's worth about four million dollars today.
- 33:37So that's a significant sum of cash. I mean it's I mean,
- 33:43it's not a great, great fortune, you know, but it's a fortune,
- 33:46especially a guy who was edging it on being broke. He looked at
- 33:50it as like this is going to be my This is like it for me.
- 33:52I'm gonna move down to Mexico or do whatever, like I'm gonna I'm
- 33:54be done, right, I'm gonna spy one something to be done. But
- 33:58of course, if you know anything about intelligence officers. They don't ever want
- 34:01that, right, They want to keep you on the hook, you know.
- 34:04They want to give you a little bit and a little bit and a
- 34:06little bit, and then keep tasking you for more and more and more.
- 34:07Right, Harper didn't want to do that, but he was desperate and he
- 34:13was willing to go along with it for a little while. Right where you
- 34:15know, guy says, well, I'll give you, I'll give you fifty
- 34:17thousand dollars, and then you come back again, I give you another fifty
- 34:20thousand dollars. And that's how the uh, the polls kind of kept them
- 34:23on. The kept them on. They even if I recall, right,
- 34:27they even kind of like dick them over on the bill the first time around,
- 34:29right, Yeah, they did. Actually they were fake, so they
- 34:34they they specifically. And I know this because when I was researching Despy a
- 34:42Valley podcast, I actually worked with a Polish researcher. And what's really amazing
- 34:47is that Poland and some of the other former Soviet block countries allow researchers to
- 34:53get access to unredacted intelligence documents. And I managed to find all the files
- 35:00from this case. I mean, there was no blackouts, no reactions like
- 35:04literally the unexpurgated documents, including the like strategic reports of the Polish intelligence officers
- 35:15writing about their thinking the case and like how they were going to try to
- 35:17play this guy right, And part of that was them saying, basically,
- 35:23when we want to go hot and cold with him, we wanted to,
- 35:25we want to say we're incredibly interested. And then when he gives us something,
- 35:30we want to basically say, you know what, this isn't what you
- 35:32promised us, this isn't the go we want, you know what, you
- 35:36kind of over promised and underdlivered, and to keep him basically wanting, you
- 35:40know, in a in a position of dependency. I mean, it was
- 35:44like some pretty you know, subtle psychological games at the polar Planers, good
- 35:46intelligence work on their part, and that like made Harper I rate, and
- 35:52it made him willing. It made him but it also like made him willing
- 35:54to like give them more for less, right, because he became so needy
- 35:59and like did he needed he needed the money? He was fine, you
- 36:00know, but then eventually there's like there's like one major payday that happens where
- 36:10Harper, Harper leaves right, he goes he goes back to Warsaw. He
- 36:15has this blowout argument basically where the polls are like, We're not going to
- 36:21pay you. This is garbage. Harper like goes back to California and he's
- 36:25like, what am I going to do with all these documents again? He's
- 36:28got hundreds of pounds of documents in his apartment. These are physical documents.
- 36:32This isn't like stuff on a on a thumb drive, like it's like stacking
- 36:36up. He is like, you know, and so he goes out to
- 36:39the San Joaquin Delta, which is just east of San Francisco. He gets
- 36:44on a sailboat with his best friend and bury all documents in like a muddy
- 36:49island in the middle of the delta to be like, I can't keep this
- 36:52stuff on me. It's like too hot, it's too hot. And then
- 36:55he tries to like get he tries to get contact again at some point with
- 37:01the poles because he's desperate. So he used to go back and dig it
- 37:05all up again. And there are are water logs, so he used to
- 37:08dry out these documents and then literally and there's stinking water log documents that he's
- 37:14like basically like hanging up, you know, all over his clothes pins,
- 37:17clothes pins, like exactly. He's like like classified documents, like they're like
- 37:21they're Christmas ornaments or something. And he literally stuffs these dried, like moldering
- 37:30documents in giant suitcases and just walks into SFO and gets on a plane to
- 37:37Europe to then go back and resell them. We you know, like it
- 37:42was very basic, like there was no trade craft. You know, there
- 37:45was really very little trade craft in this story. It gets back to Warsaw.
- 37:50He gets spirited out of Warsaw to this country estate and he provides these
- 37:57documents to the Poles, who are like ecstatic because they actually, all of
- 38:01a sudden we are like, oh, yeah, this is the good stuff.
- 38:04You know, this is like really valuable ballistic missile stuff. The Holes
- 38:07immediately contact their overlords in Moscow. The KGB flies in twenty science and technology
- 38:16officers to pour over the documents overnight. They literally spend like an entire day
- 38:22just laying the documents out, like one page by the time, and I'm
- 38:27looking through them and like as as valuable, as as valuable, as valuable,
- 38:30And so he gets his big payday. They pay him like like a
- 38:36couple hundred thousand dollars. You know, this is like his big, big
- 38:38payday. And then they're like we want more. But so that's you get
- 38:45these kind of false starts and stops, but that's the big one. That's
- 38:49like, that was like the big one. And so when I was going
- 38:54through the Polish intelligence files, I knew Harper's handwriting looked like from other US
- 39:01cork documents, So I knew what I was looking at. So I'm going
- 39:05through it and I'm seeing everything's in Polish, obviously, right, you're seeing
- 39:07everything in Polish. It's get it translated. All of a sudden, I
- 39:10come across a bunch of stuff and it's dated. It's dating lines up perfectly
- 39:19with when I knew Harper was at this estate, you know, basically under
- 39:24watched under the watch of the KGB. And it's limericks, like drunken limericks
- 39:32that that guy that he wrote about spine and he and he left it there,
- 39:38he left it there and they put it in his file, and I
- 39:40was like, this is the dumbest man ever. Like literally, the limericks
- 39:46were like, you know, I'm sitting here by the fire thinking about spine.
- 39:50Like it's like I don't remember them by heart anymore. But like if
- 39:53you're if people are watching or listening, like listen to Spy Valley of the
- 39:57podcast, and it's incredible, you know. He made up limericks about spine
- 40:01and he left it there, and I was like, this is the best
- 40:04blackmail material it's like ever been made. You know. He again he viewed
- 40:07it as like a lark, right, I mean, he was drunk and
- 40:09just partying, and like for him, it was just like an adventure almost,
- 40:13you know, which is incredible how greedy he was and how incautious he
- 40:20was about being a spy. And on the return trip, similarly, it
- 40:25was like just so half assed, as I recall, I mean, didn't
- 40:29he tape some of the money to his ankles and the rest of it was
- 40:30just in a suitcase and just whies back to the United States? Percent he
- 40:36literally he taped he taped half of it to his ankles and then he put
- 40:42the rest of it underneath his shoes. Right, this was way before you
- 40:44had to take off his shoes at the airport, right, many many decades
- 40:46before. He literally was like, well he tried to put it in a
- 40:51bank account in France, and they were like where'd you get this money from?
- 40:54Like you have like a you have a paper trail here, because we
- 40:57can't just take this money without some kind of receipt, you know. And
- 41:00and he was like, I can't, I can't provide you with that.
- 41:04So he just thought, ah, you know, like whatever, I'll literally
- 41:06just he literally got duct tape and just taped it to his to his ankles
- 41:09and just walked walked onto the airplane in Geneva and then walked out at JFK,
- 41:17you know, with one hundreds of like a hundred and fifty two hundred
- 41:21ffty thousand dollars taped to his like his ankles and his feet. So yeah,
- 41:24I mean again no tradecraft. Like I know, it's harder today with
- 41:29like the digital you know, there's like a more ubiqu with digital trail.
- 41:34But it just goes to show you that like if you have the drive,
- 41:37you have the access, you can get a lot if people aren't watching.
- 41:43Yeah, and I mean it could it could easily happen today. They can't
- 41:45search everybody that goes through Godstoms, No, of course not. And you
- 41:50know, the the thing about him too is that he didn't have a he
- 41:52didn't have a clearance at the time, right, he didn't work for a
- 41:53company that that was there's good plausible deniability all all around. It was his
- 42:00girl. It was his girlfriend and then his wife and he married her over
- 42:02the course at this scheme from which lasted from seventy nine to eighty one.
- 42:07So he you know, that was part of the issue. When the Bureau
- 42:09finally started investigating this case, they were looking for people who had access to
- 42:15classified documents to their job and he didn't, you know, and so that
- 42:20that took effect to that that that was a stumbling blog for them. So
- 42:23how did that come about? Because I mean, what did the Bureau have
- 42:27some inkling that there was a spy out there? Did they have some idea
- 42:31of who they were looking for? Did they have a defected KGB agent who
- 42:37gave gave up that there's a spy somewhere in the United States? I mean,
- 42:39how did that investigation come about? So this is actually one of my
- 42:43favorite parts of the story. And it's kind of this whole story is kind
- 42:46of larger than life, and you know, I can't do it's it's to
- 42:52hear the people who lived it telling their own world words. Is I think
- 42:57gives a lot more vividly than I can, but I was say this,
- 43:00like two things happened. The first thing that happened was that the CIA had
- 43:07a mole in the Polish Intelligence Service whose code name was Cariboo. And Cariboo
- 43:13was one of the most important Eastern Bloc recruitments in place that the IC had
- 43:22in the seventies and eighties. Kind of an unsung guy even to this day,
- 43:25I mean very little. He's you know, he comes up in that
- 43:30book you mentioned from Warsaw would Love because he was actually critical in busting Marian
- 43:35Sikarski, who was a Polish intelligence officer who was an illegal who was operating
- 43:38down Los Angeles at this time. I remember that one the offense almost lost
- 43:44that case, like buy that there. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that
- 43:46dead case came very close too, I mean, and that was a big,
- 43:50big, big deal. And so this guy Cariboo, who he was
- 43:58a Polish intelligence officer under diplomatic cover in Chicago in the mid nineteen seventies.
- 44:04Obviously Poland has a big interest in Chicago because it has a huge Polish population
- 44:10there. And at some point probably he was either fully recruited or his recruitment
- 44:19began in Chicago in the early to mid nineteen seventies. He rotates back out
- 44:27to warsaw because you know, people, that's the whole thing. You rotated,
- 44:30you rotate out. And he was also an engineer. He was an
- 44:35S and T focused spy, science and technology. And at some point he
- 44:40gets in touch with his CIA handlers and he says, this is probably nineteen
- 44:45eighty or so, maybe nineteen eighty one, and he says, look,
- 44:51I don't know the name of this guy, but you've got a serious spy
- 44:55in Silicon Valley. I was at my work. We were having a hollow
- 45:00a party, I think, and I was told that we were we were
- 45:06to come hang out because one of my coworkers, this intelligence officer named Cihojen,
- 45:12was getting an award from the head of the KGB from the head of
- 45:16the KGB because he had recruited an incredibly valuable nuclear spot, right yeah,
- 45:27like right, And he was like, oh, you know, like so
- 45:30he's there, he's watching this award being given out, you know, and
- 45:34you know how compartmentation is intelligence, So he doesn't he doesn't know the name
- 45:37of the guy, you know, the recruitment. He just knows that the
- 45:40senior intelligence officer named Cihojen has A has some kind of has some guy in
- 45:46Silicon Valley who's providing incredibly sensitive nuclear documents to the Polls, which are of
- 45:52course going directly to the KGB. I mean, actually it was very interesting
- 45:55reading those documents, the Polish Intelligent intelligence documents. There's a lot of discussion
- 46:00about who's going to pay, because they're like, well, this is all
- 46:02just like the Poles don't care, like the Poles don't have a ballistic missile
- 46:05program. This is all going to the Soviets, right, So it's like
- 46:07so there's a lot of like back and forth between them and the KGB about
- 46:10like, hey, you can't afford to pay this guy, Like you're going
- 46:13to pay this guy right and and and the KGB was like yeah, sure,
- 46:16we'll do it. Basically, so, I mean, Harper was working
- 46:21directly for the Polls, but his payment was coming from the KGB. So
- 46:29this secret CIA penetration of the Polish Intelligence Service gets in touch and it is
- 46:36like that's all I got for you, engineer Silicon Valley nuclear secrets. Oh
- 46:43and this guy, this this eight this this this secret source that that we
- 46:49have somehow is connected to Bill Hugle. Okay, so then the it gets
- 46:55Bill Hugle's name, see I gets the basic parameters of what's going on.
- 47:01They pass it on to the FBI. That's where like Bill Kane and the
- 47:07rest of that, like they're you know, like they're like reading. You
- 47:09get you get this highly classified memoranda that comes in, right, and it's
- 47:13like here's what we know, like you know, uh, it's like a
- 47:17you know, trusted source. Whatever says x y and z. You don't
- 47:20get the name of it. You don't even get the name of the source
- 47:22necessarily at the beginning. You just get information that says x y and z
- 47:25from somebody that's like considered a like a very very highly trusted source. That's
- 47:30the first thing. So the Bureau of course goes, oh, man,
- 47:34like we have a real problem, right, we got Hugele. Okay,
- 47:36that's a good lead, right, we know that, like that's been going
- 47:38on. We've got our eye on Hugle for a while in fact. But
- 47:44so they start investigating Hugle, including like wire taps and stuff like that.
- 47:47But there's not at this point Harper and Hulet are falling out. So they're
- 47:52not they're not they're not getting much from it, right, they're not getting
- 47:54much from them. At the same time this is happening, Harper gets cold
- 48:01feet about spawning, Like he decides he doesn't want to be a spy for
- 48:07the Eastern Block anymore, and he decides to get in touch with the lawyer
- 48:13to serve as a go between so he can offer his services to become a
- 48:16double agent for the CIA, and he wants to get paid for it,
- 48:20right, So like his dude, they just spent the last three years passing
- 48:24nuclear secrets to Moscow is now basically trying to negotiate a get out of jail
- 48:30free card for himself where he works for the CIA now against the Soviet Block
- 48:36and wants to be paid handsomely for it. To do that, he starts
- 48:40providing information on himself and his scheme and what he knows and who he knows,
- 48:46and of course DOJ and the Bureau are like, yeah, we're interested,
- 48:52Yeah, okay, we're interested. To keep telling us more, keep
- 48:53telling us, know us more, right, Like they're like, keep telling
- 48:57us more. And of course they never had any England whatsoever that they were
- 49:00ever going to deal with this guy. They just wanted him to give them
- 49:05more investigative leads so they could find him. So these two streams are coming
- 49:08together simultaneously, right. You have Harper anonymously through a lawyer diming himself out,
- 49:15himing himself out, and then you have the secret source within the Polish
- 49:20intelligence services. So these two intelligence streams come together, and that is eventually
- 49:23how the bureau identifies him. I mean, it's an interesting question, right,
- 49:28like if Harper had not if he hadn't come forward and tried to negotiate
- 49:32a sweet deal for himself, I don't know if they would have caught him.
- 49:36I mean, yeah, I guess. I mean engineer Silicon Valley,
- 49:38Like that's a pretty wide net. It's wide, and it's wide. And
- 49:43again, at that point, Harper and Hugel were not talking anymore, so
- 49:46there was no like nothing on an open line, no mention of it.
- 49:51I mean, obviously every time Hugle was like talking about somebody they wheeling and
- 49:54dealing with, they were like, we got to check up on that guy,
- 49:58you know, But Hugo wasn't talking about Harper at that point. You
- 50:01know, he will had moved on, he had the other schemes going on.
- 50:04So yeah, I mean in the end, it was probably Harper that
- 50:08that that. I mean, he never The Bureau definitely had to had to
- 50:13do some really good, solid investigative work to make those final leaps. I
- 50:16mean, Harper was never like, and my real name is James Harper.
- 50:19Like they had to figure out who he was, and they did, because
- 50:22he started naming all these people that he knew in the round, right,
- 50:27and at some point somebody he names is going like the Bureau would very gently
- 50:32start interviewing people in a way that didn't reveal what they actually wanted, right,
- 50:39because they were afraid of spooking right the spy. They were like,
- 50:45we don't know who he is, and if we make it seem like we're
- 50:47asking questions about a potential spy, that guy might you know, take off
- 50:52and had to head to Moscow and we'll never hear from him again. So
- 50:57they very skillfully managed to get the name Harper out of one of his contacts
- 51:01in the valley with that, without that guy in the valley knowing that they
- 51:05wanted to get in touch with him because of his spine right there, that
- 51:07they were identifying him as a potential lead in that And that's how they id
- 51:12Harper, and then and then of course they got to open up an investigation
- 51:15on him. They got a FAISA, they tapped his phone lines, they
- 51:19followed him around everywhere. And that was also hard because they didn't have like,
- 51:24he wasn't necessarily talking about spying at that point either, so they had
- 51:28to build that case against him, and that was not easy to do.
- 51:31Actually, And you said that in the you know, in the interim while
- 51:35they're listening in on mister Harper's life, that he had a very spicy lifestyle
- 51:40that he pursued. He had a very spicy lifestyle. He was he was
- 51:45a man of I don't know, he was a libertine, right, I
- 51:51mean he he he was a total cheat. I mean he he liked he
- 51:57liked to like booze it up. He he would like get into hot tub
- 52:01parties with like Hugh Gold back when they were still talking, and they'd have
- 52:05girls like you know it got it got. I think that the like there's
- 52:10a character in this story, and that character is basically booze, and like
- 52:16a lot of the story could be explained or understood the perspective of like dudes
- 52:23who were just drunk all the time and like just were like didn't care about
- 52:29They were just like caution to the breeze, don't care, Like I'm gonna
- 52:34go out and find some girls, I'm gonna go spy for the Soviet block,
- 52:36like I'm gonna do whatever, you know, Like they just didn't care.
- 52:38You know. That was kind of his attitude. And so that's that
- 52:43really drove a lot of what he did, you know, and Hu Will
- 52:45too. Honestly, I feel like he's almost like j Edgar Hoover's you know,
- 52:50caricature of a communist spy, like just a total genera, even though
- 52:53he wasn't ideological, I mean, in fact, yeah, I mean communists,
- 52:59he was like a he he would probably think of himself as a as
- 53:01a as a para, you know, the paradigm of a of a cap
- 53:06nor. Right. He was like, I'm a I'm here. I'm like
- 53:08that's what I do. Like I'm I'm trying to find new angle, I'm
- 53:10trying to find new new revenue streams, you know, like I'm thinking outside
- 53:15the box. I'm like I'm you know, I'm breaking things right, Like
- 53:17it's that Silicon Valley ethos of just like yeah, wheeling and dealing, right,
- 53:22he's got it far from communist. I mean, that's the irony,
- 53:25right, These guys, these were like these were really aggressive capitalists, small
- 53:32businessman who just viewed spine as another play, you know. So he was
- 53:37very much that. I mean, he's an extreme example of that, right,
- 53:42Like there are, of course, the vast majority of people in that
- 53:45world don't would not end up in that place, but he's a symptom of
- 53:49that culture out here. M hm. And so as this investigation is ongoing,
- 53:59how did they actually start to like zero in on him to the point
- 54:01that they're able to, you know, make an arrest. I mean it
- 54:05was just literally interviewing a guy very you know, very obliquely, and then
- 54:14they they tap his stuff, like I said, and they try to they
- 54:20try to like they try to get a smoking gun, and that's like really
- 54:29really hard, you know, smoking gun. But they eventually decide that they
- 54:37have enough evidence to bring it to trial. You know, they have.
- 54:40There's a great story that's a near mists that that Bill Canane told me,
- 54:45where they're tapping his line and they get a call. Harper gets a call
- 54:51from Europe and it's like it's like at you know, seven eight pm,
- 54:53at night, gets a call from Europe and it's a cutout for the Polish
- 54:57intelligence Service, right. It's this a woman who's a cutout, who's like,
- 55:00we miss you, we haven't heard from you in a while, like
- 55:01trying to be oblique, but it's like obviously they're talking spy talk, right,
- 55:07And Harper's like sloshed, like he has just drunk off his face.
- 55:12And so the cut out for the Polish intelligence services like, here, let
- 55:16me give you my number, call me back tomorrow and we'll talk about getting
- 55:21you back out to Europe, you know. And Harper says, okay,
- 55:23he writes down the number. Well, he writes down the wrong number.
- 55:28Oh, here writes down the wrong number. So so the bureau is listening
- 55:34to him write down the wrong number. And the next day he gets up
- 55:37and he calls the wrong number. He calls the wrong number, and the
- 55:40bureau is losing their mind. They're like, this is it, this is
- 55:44it, this is the call. This is him going to be talking about
- 55:46spine on the phone tapped line, and he literally does not, And so
- 55:53he never calls the woman back because and this so the bureau is like,
- 55:58how do we get him the number? Get do we enter his apartment and
- 56:01somehow like put the number on the table so he'll call back. Like like,
- 56:06that's I mean, that's the level that this case was at. What
- 56:08really led them to decide to arrest him was that Caribou, the CIA mole
- 56:17within the Polish Intelligence Service, decides to defect, like defect for good.
- 56:23And that is in the summer of nineteen eighty three. Because the the DOJ
- 56:30folks are getting a ton of pressure from the Bureau and the CIA to prosecute,
- 56:34prosecute, prosecute. The DJ people are like, we don't have the
- 56:37evidence, and we don't want to risk arresting this guy and then losing this
- 56:43case. That would be a disaster for us, right, I mean,
- 56:45it's all where you sit in the government. Right. If you're a prosecutor,
- 56:47you want to prosecute. If you're the FBI, you want to investigate
- 56:51and make an arrest. If you're a CIA you're playing the world. You
- 56:55know, cloak and Daggers, fibers, vibrus the spy. You want to
- 56:59get an American spy off the streets. It's part of this larger game.
- 57:02But you have no you know what I mean, Like everyone was playing their
- 57:06role right right right. So at that time, Caribou is out of warsaw.
- 57:13He is now under diplomatic cover of the Spine or diplomatic cover in Stockholm,
- 57:17Sweden, that he escapes with his family gets exfiltrated out to the US,
- 57:22and the prosecutors think that, okay, great, Like our star witness
- 57:27is here. You know, he's he's gonna se he's gonna appear a trial,
- 57:30and we're gonna we're gonna you know where we got this, We got
- 57:36this unlock, this is this is now. And Harper gets arrested in October
- 57:39nineteen eighty three. So now that this star, this star witness is here,
- 57:45this star CIA agent is now out of danger. He's now going to
- 57:47be resetled in the US with his family, and we're gonna we're gonna put
- 57:52Harper on trial. That's that's how the case all came together was around this
- 57:55one key witness. Yeah. I mean, I've read cases and I'm sure
- 58:01you have as well, where it seems like a pretty cut and dry,
- 58:06slam dunk case of espionage that you think, you know, someone would get
- 58:09thrown in prison for quite easily. You know, there's a handoff of money,
- 58:14there's an exchange of intelligence with a foreign intelligence officer, but that the
- 58:20bar to convict somebody of espionage is quite quite high in the United States,
- 58:22and you know, the FEDS lose a lot of these cases, as we've
- 58:25seen more recently with Chinese espionage. I mean, how how did this one
- 58:30play out in a court of law? I mean, what was it?
- 58:34Was it a slam dunk case or was it you know kind of uh,
- 58:37you know h or could it have gone either way? Well, I mean
- 58:39it never Well, this is what is amazing about it is they didn't have
- 58:43all the information that I'm you know, I've just I've described they didn't have
- 58:45at the time. They they had the sketches of it, right, they
- 58:52knew that Harper was the guy, I mean, but there was nothing there
- 58:57was There really wasn't a lot of hard, tangible evidence that they had.
- 59:02That was the whole problem is that they needed this Polish intelligence officer who was
- 59:10broadly a part of this operation, or at least was aware of it as
- 59:15an intelligence officer, to carry it out to to to bring the case home.
- 59:22But the problem was was that as soon as he got to the States
- 59:27and he started being debriefed by the prosecutors on the case who I spoke with,
- 59:32who are great guys who are incredibly hard working and really wanted to do
- 59:36this right, The CIA started walking back their promise to allow him to testify
- 59:43immediately, like CI was like, we'll bring him to the country, we'll
- 59:47get him out, he will testify, We'll put Harper away. They're like
- 59:51great. DJ was like, great, then we will arrest him on the
- 59:54condition that this happens. The moment he got to the States to see I
- 1:00:00was like, actually, we're not really sure we want him to testify anymore,
- 1:00:04right, And so that caused a huge blow up between DJ and CIA.
- 1:00:09And if you think about it, how many times have you heard of
- 1:00:16a of a defector from a foreign intelligence service testifying in a criminal trial for
- 1:00:22espionage in the US as a witness. I can't think of any I can't
- 1:00:28think of a single time, right, because they don't want they don't want
- 1:00:32those folks having any heat or light on them for some reasons that are good,
- 1:00:37right, but they just generally don't like you know. The way it
- 1:00:40was put to me was in the NDCIA just wanted to stay in the shadows.
- 1:00:45That's it like that's their imperative. That's the way they view the world.
- 1:00:47They don't want their agents showing up in courtrooms pointing to somebody and saying,
- 1:00:54yes, that is the man who passed me the documentary, like they
- 1:00:58don't want it. So the prosecutors felt like they had been lied to,
- 1:01:05basically, and there was a big blow up in Langley where they they walked
- 1:01:08into the you know, they walked into the room the senior CIA operations officer
- 1:01:14who offers them a drink at like eleven o'clock in the morning, and it's
- 1:01:16like, please sit down, you know, and then basically proceeds to tell
- 1:01:19them that like, you know, ain't happening, you know, after the
- 1:01:22promise. So the prosecutors are irate, and they're also really scared because they're
- 1:01:28like, we were this entire trial was predicated on this witness, and if
- 1:01:32we don't have that, we may not be able to get Harper, you
- 1:01:36know, we might not have enough. So they did they very smartly did
- 1:01:43probably they probably pursued their best path forward, which was leaning on him really
- 1:01:47hard to flee, to make it seem like they had an harp to get
- 1:01:52him. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's what they did. You know,
- 1:01:57they started walking in there like all all you know, pisson vinegar and
- 1:02:01telling him like, you're gonna get the needle for this. We're gonna like
- 1:02:06where you're gonna put you away forever and that's guilty, So you better sign
- 1:02:10on the dotted line right now or like you know you like literally, prosecutors
- 1:02:16me like your ass is grass, You're a dead man. That's it.
- 1:02:19It's done, you no, that's it had. It worked. It worked.
- 1:02:23It worked, and it worked because the prosecutors who worked, you know,
- 1:02:27worked the case were very very smart, convincing people. And he's the
- 1:02:30kind of guy who saves his own skin every time exactly. And also he
- 1:02:34got it. He got he got a judge who was a notorious hard ass
- 1:02:39who whose name was hanging Sam Conti. He was for basically asking for the
- 1:02:46death penalty for everything. He was like. He was like a truly crazy
- 1:02:52old school law and order judge. It was like Harper could not have gotten
- 1:02:57a worst judge. So, you know, he get he gets is the
- 1:03:00courtroom and Sam County's like, what are you accused of? It's like espionage
- 1:03:02and he's like, are you pursuing the death penalty, you know, the
- 1:03:06like no, you know, so this is this is not the bleeding heart
- 1:03:08liberal California legislature we hear about nowadays. This was a This was a wild
- 1:03:16West. He was a Nixon appointee. Yeah, Like I mean his nickname
- 1:03:22was literally Hanging Sam, like that was you know, he was a he
- 1:03:27was like dude. So when the prosecutors get this guy, they realize,
- 1:03:31like, you know, the judge is gonna scare Harper as bad as they
- 1:03:36could, and Harper, Harper, please because at that point you can't you
- 1:03:43can't get the death penalty for espionage anymore. Right. But literally, the
- 1:03:49judge is arguing with the prosecution about why he can't for Harper. He's like,
- 1:03:54why can't I have that? And they're like listen, sir, I'm
- 1:03:57sorry the Supreme Court and he was like make sure you know. So,
- 1:03:59Like so Harper's just standing there and it's like, oh god, why you
- 1:04:02know, like you're a dead man walking ex Literally, He's like, I'm
- 1:04:06gonna die. So so he decides to flee out and he pleas out and
- 1:04:11he thinks, all right, you know, I'm gonna avoid the electric chair
- 1:04:14and I'm gonna hopefully get a relatively leaning sentence, but he doesn't. Kanti
- 1:04:21gives him the max, of course, which is a life sentence, and
- 1:04:26Harper spends thirty three years in prison. He gets out in the mid twenty
- 1:04:29tens, and I managed to reach out to him and get him to talk
- 1:04:35to me and tell me his life story. And for folks interested in listening
- 1:04:41to the podcast by Valley, I mean, that really is the heart of
- 1:04:45a lot of the story is hearing about hearing about an American trader in their
- 1:04:50own words. As difficult as that can be sometimes, it's also a really
- 1:04:56valuable and I think fascinating character study because Harper he didn't lie to me as
- 1:05:02far I mean, and I tried to check every little detail I could about
- 1:05:05his case, and everything I could find was seemed like highly credible based on
- 1:05:12other sources, corroborating sources out there. And so he told me his whole
- 1:05:15story from the time he was a kid to his time as a spy.
- 1:05:19There's there's a real aspect of like sociopathy and narcissism, and that he's like
- 1:05:27even after all of this, he's almost like bragging to you about what he
- 1:05:30did. I think that's a lot of it. Yeah, I mean I
- 1:05:31think sociopathy is the right word for it. Extreme narcissism. Also, there
- 1:05:38were points Ahart asking questions and you're right, he he was kind of like,
- 1:05:42well I did this, and I did that, and I got away
- 1:05:44with this, and like I couldn't believe it, and all of a sudden,
- 1:05:45I had all this money burning a hole in my pocket, like he
- 1:05:47was. I think crowd of like cheating the system, right, And I
- 1:05:53think that was something that really made him. I think that made him I
- 1:05:59don't know it, even after having spent thirty plus years in prison. I
- 1:06:02think it made him feel good in a way that he had been able to
- 1:06:05cheat the system the way he had. I mean, it's incredible, and
- 1:06:09it's he's not a normal person, right, Like you hear him sometimes you're
- 1:06:13like, oh this is like a good time, good time boy. Really
- 1:06:15you can just tell like, oh, he's he's a dude you could like
- 1:06:16drink some beers with and he would like tell dirty jokes and it'd be fun.
- 1:06:20And then like it it goes from that to like much much darker,
- 1:06:25you know, like real quick with him, you know where it's clear like
- 1:06:28oh I could see how you could be kind of like a charming sociopath.
- 1:06:30He told me like he was pimping out his wife at one point or something
- 1:06:33like that. Uh, that wasn't him, that was that was you.
- 1:06:36I mean, yeah, he he wasn't doing that. What Harper did was
- 1:06:42I mean when his when his wife, Ruby Leui Schuler was his his co
- 1:06:45conspirator and wife, the woman who who worked for the company with the classified
- 1:06:51contracts. She was an extreme alcoholic. She was like basically dying of alcoholism
- 1:06:58by her like late thirties, like bedridden. And he would tell his his
- 1:07:03like bedridden co con spirit or wife that he's going out for a jog.
- 1:07:08He'd be like, I'm going up for a jog, sweetie. And he
- 1:07:10had another girl like five blocks away, and he would just jog to her
- 1:07:14place and like do his thing, and then he would like come back all
- 1:07:19sweaty and be like, man, what a great job. You know,
- 1:07:24Like that's the kind of level this guy was like operating at. Yeah.
- 1:07:27Yeah, that kind of guy. That kind of guy. And so what
- 1:07:30was his life like after prison? Uh? Sad? I mean, I
- 1:07:39don't know how else to put it. Sad. His life was so uh
- 1:07:42he got out of prison. He was in his mid eighties. He was
- 1:07:45a sad He was a sick old man. Most of his family had long
- 1:07:50since dis owned him because he was not a good He's not a good meat.
- 1:07:54He betrayed everybody who was around him, everybody who meant anything to him,
- 1:07:58everybody who was close to him. He betrayed his family, he betrayed
- 1:08:00lovers, he betrayed his business partners, he betrayed his country. He was
- 1:08:04left with very little. He spent most of his years in federal prison in
- 1:08:12up in Oregon. And he got out and he ended up chasing some old
- 1:08:16flame of his who had since long moved to Arkansas, and he moved out
- 1:08:20there with the idea that maybe he was going, like, I don't know,
- 1:08:24live with her much off or I'm not sure, but that did not
- 1:08:26work out, and he ended up kind of marooned in northwest Arkansas, California
- 1:08:32boy, and was just trying to get better and trying to kind of live
- 1:08:38and eke out a living something. He wasn't working, but just you know,
- 1:08:41living on probably disability at that point, and he wasn't doing much,
- 1:08:45you know, And so I think I found him in the right time.
- 1:08:48But he was in a sad state. You know, he was like really
- 1:08:50ill, and he was lonely. You know, he was ill, he
- 1:08:53was lonely. It was sad, it was you know, it was interesting
- 1:08:59talking to him then. I mean he he looked back on his life,
- 1:09:00but he never really seemed to exhibit much regret for what he would go.
- 1:09:05And then as as you were, you know, producing this podcast. I
- 1:09:10mean, he passed away, didn't he He did, Yeah, he actually
- 1:09:14well before he passed away, he stopped responding to me. It was actually
- 1:09:16very interesting. He excuse interesting, sure, uh. He we would talk
- 1:09:27a lot and intensively, and he we have these long conversations. He was
- 1:09:33like very very exuberant, and then he would like just drop a face of
- 1:09:42the earth, you know, like he would talk. I talked to him
- 1:09:44like twice twice a week for hours, and then all of a sudden he
- 1:09:46was just like stop paying on the phone. He was a very difficult interview
- 1:09:51that way. One day he just doesn't take up the phone and I don't
- 1:09:57hear from him for like a year and a half, and I'll I was
- 1:10:00like, okay, look, he was in and out of the hospital.
- 1:10:01He's in his like late eighties. At this point, you just kind of
- 1:10:04assume, right, like all right, he probably passed, And then out
- 1:10:10of nowhere, I got a call from him and he was like, hey,
- 1:10:13just wonder how you're doing, Like I'm not going to come to California.
- 1:10:15Do you want to like have coffee and keep talking? And I was
- 1:10:16like okay, and that's it. And then I tried to get in touch
- 1:10:24with them again and I couldn't and I couldn't and I couldn't, and I
- 1:10:27found out that he passed after some pretty gruesome health stuff. He never made
- 1:10:32it back to California. He died at age eighty nine, I believe,
- 1:10:36And because he had served in the military, he is buried in a US
- 1:10:43military cemetery in Northwest Arkansas, which is amazing, right, But the guy
- 1:10:49who like was a Soviet block spy just got like because he he used to
- 1:10:54be like, I gotta go to the VA, like do my PT And
- 1:10:56I was like what He's like, He's like, I get VA servis And
- 1:11:00I was like, oh yeah, all right, Like so what a world?
- 1:11:04Yeah, what a world? Right? That's like a little irony at
- 1:11:06the end of that. So that's where he's barried that's that's what happened to
- 1:11:10James Harper. I and I so the podcast Spy Valley. I mean,
- 1:11:15it's really incredible because you were able to get the FBI side, You're able
- 1:11:19to get these through the archival research, some of the documents from the Polish
- 1:11:24Intelligence Service pre uh, you know Wall coming down, and then you know
- 1:11:29the man himself, James Harper. What was the response when this podcast came
- 1:11:34out? I mean, was was there any interesting feedback you got from it
- 1:11:39or any other sources. I kind of popped out of the woodwork. I
- 1:11:42didn't have any sources that popped out of the woodwork. And that's always what
- 1:11:45you want, right as a journalist, is like somebody is like, I
- 1:11:46have another amazing story from the right right, and I will say, like
- 1:11:50the the most common response I got was kind of something you alluded to at
- 1:11:57the beginning of the interview, which is like I have no idea that this
- 1:12:00happened, which is always as a journalist, is like kind of great,
- 1:12:03like good, you know, like yeah, nah, like I've I've opened
- 1:12:08up a different world, like I've I've I've peeled back like this crazy thing
- 1:12:12and something you talked about, Uh, maybe before we started the stream,
- 1:12:15which was almost the the kind of like almost comedic like Coen Brothers burn after
- 1:12:25the thing, because that's that there is a real sense of the story that
- 1:12:29it's like it's just it's very very serious, but it's at the same time
- 1:12:33like undoubtedly a funny and bizarre story of like a guy, like kind of
- 1:12:39a crazy dude that did it crazy. It was a terrible thing what he
- 1:12:42did. But it's also like a cast of characters that you can't believe are
- 1:12:45real, you know, but it's like it's a very much a real story
- 1:12:50about real wild people doing some wild stuff and they you know, they most
- 1:12:56of them face the consequences for it. But that's that was the primary reaction
- 1:13:00was like I didn't know the respine in Silicon Valley. I didn't know about
- 1:13:03this story, and like I didn't know that like spic real life spy stories
- 1:13:06could be this funny. Yeah, well I think it was great. I'm
- 1:13:13glad it worked out, and I hope people will go and check it out.
- 1:13:16So the podcast is Valley of Spies. You can find wherever Spy Valley,
- 1:13:24wherever podcasts are available. I actually just listened to it on YouTube.
- 1:13:28Found it on there. Yeah, yeah, YouTube, Spotify, Apple podcasts,
- 1:13:34Stitcher, yeah, wherever you get your podcasts. It's uh, it's
- 1:13:39it's six episodes. Each episode I think it's like thirty minutes long. So
- 1:13:43I mean you can listen to it over, you know, in afternoon if
- 1:13:45you want to. It's not like like like some podcasts like this one sometimes
- 1:13:49where it's like three hour long shows. It's it's very listenable, and I
- 1:13:54hope you guys will check it out. And uh so, I mean,
- 1:13:59while we have you here is I have to I have to probe the wire
- 1:14:01and see like what's next on the horizon for you. Oh man, I
- 1:14:05got some stuff, but I can't talk about a lot of it yet because
- 1:14:10it's not out. But I have some long form investigative reporting that I've been
- 1:14:15working on for a long, long time years that is nearing completion, some
- 1:14:21very deep dives into stuff that goes back a lot of years, kind of
- 1:14:30US intelligence community stories, kind of back back to the core reporting that you
- 1:14:35know that you and I do. So I'm really really excited about that.
- 1:14:40I don't want to give too much away for a whole bunch of reasons,
- 1:14:44but like definitely some revelatory stories from the world of the post nine to eleven
- 1:14:54post nine eleven intelligence world. That's great, and I hope you know,
- 1:14:59we will have you on the show again, you know, a year down
- 1:15:01the line, and we'll have some more topics to talk about for sure.
- 1:15:05Happy to happy to be here anytime. Is there anything else that you want
- 1:15:10to plug or anything you want to tease out there? Tell people about where
- 1:15:16can people find you? Where can people find you online? This point,
- 1:15:20I don't know. I mean, Zach Astorfman a Twitter, I'm not calling
- 1:15:24it X and Blue Sky standing at Blue Sky and uh yeah, I mean
- 1:15:34unfortunately, I can't even talk about where some of these stories are going to
- 1:15:36be appearing yet. But but I would say Twitter first and foremost and and
- 1:15:45yeah, and we'll all come back on and we'll talk about some of these
- 1:15:49investigative pieces. Awesome. And so next week, next Friday, we're going
- 1:15:55to have our first interview. It's the first of two parts. So on
- 1:16:00December first, we're gonna have Mike Vickers on the show to talk about his
- 1:16:03career, cot me on before Mike Vickers. Yeah, hey, man,
- 1:16:10scheduling, you know, we let them mix it up. So Mike Mike
- 1:16:14Vickers is Next week we're going to talk about his time in the military and
- 1:16:17his uh stint in c i A, his career there working on the COVID
- 1:16:21action program in Afghanistan, and then we'll have him back for a second episode
- 1:16:26on December eighth, and we'll talk about his time at ust I and ASD
- 1:16:30Solick and some of those more like high level appointments that he had. So
- 1:16:33we're looking forward to doing that. That's going to be incredible. I mean
- 1:16:39that, I mean, Vickers is a is a living legend. I mean
- 1:16:42and wow, that sounds amazing. You're doing a two party with him.
- 1:16:45I'm going to yeah, yeah, two Fridays, two fridays in a row.
- 1:16:47He's he's been quite generous with his time, you know, we really
- 1:16:50appreciate that. And uh, he has a he has a book out.
- 1:16:54I think it's called By All Means Available I read a couple of months ago,
- 1:16:58worth worth checking out for anyone who has it yet. So yeah,
- 1:17:01I guess, Zach, barring any final thoughts, man, I guess that
- 1:17:05wraps it up. Anything else you want people to know about, or any
- 1:17:09final thoughts about this wild story that you told or the Coen Brothers working on
- 1:17:13the screen adaptation. No, well, I wish that would be great.
- 1:17:17No, I'm gonna plug you and I'm gonna plug you and Shawn's work on
- 1:17:19the high Side. Man. Oh yeah, thank you. Yeah, that's
- 1:17:23stuff. You're that stuff's incredible. That the story that you did, you
- 1:17:26beat all the major publications on the the US Special Operations Forces getting ready to
- 1:17:33potentially deploy to NASA and the kind of back and forth on that. I
- 1:17:39mean, that was that was a great story and you beat all the big,
- 1:17:42the big papers on that one. So yeah, thank you. And
- 1:17:45the next story we're working on, I don't I don't, I don't want
- 1:17:49to. I don't want to get Sean angry with me, but I'll just
- 1:17:53say it's it's a biographical piece about someone who's essentially a c I, a
- 1:17:57legend, a legend of the CIA and this Special Forces community, and we're
- 1:18:01working on a pretty extensive piece about him. So we're excited to get that
- 1:18:05out, hopefully, you know, in the next month or so. I've
- 1:18:09heard a little bit about that from Sean, and without going into any detail,
- 1:18:12obviously, I can vouch that that is going to be an amazing story.
- 1:18:15Yeah, yeah, it's it's it's a slice of of of an amazing
- 1:18:21person, but also through his own experiences, it's a slice of history as
- 1:18:26well. It's it's pretty incredible. So yeah, hopefully I'll be able to
- 1:18:30we'll be able to have that discussion on another episode. So until next Friday,
- 1:18:36We'll see all you guys then, Zach again, thank you for you
- 1:18:40know, taking some of your Friday evening with us, and we will see
- 1:18:44you then. Bye now, thanks again,