Latest / Deep Dive / Why Great Counselors Refuse to Give Advice (And What They Do Instead)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission today is to crack
- 0:04open this well. It's a profoundly insightful
- 0:08training manual. Yeah, it really is a
- 0:10fascinating. Read right So it's the 8th
- 0:12edition of a book called Basic Personal Counseling.
- 0:15By David Geldard, Catherine Geldard, and Rebecca Yinfu.
- 0:18Exactly. And we are going to basically
- 0:21demystify what actually happens, you know, behind the closed
- 0:25doors of a counseling room. Because it's not always what
- 0:27people think. Not at all.
- 0:28We're going to explore the literal mechanics of human
- 0:31vulnerability and discover why the absolute worst thing you can
- 0:35do for someone in a crisis is to actually give them advice.
- 0:38Which sounds completely backward, I know.
- 0:39It totally does. So OK, let's unpack this because
- 0:42for you listening, I mean, whether you're a manager, a
- 0:44parent, a partner, or just someone who wants to be a better
- 0:47friend, you can kind of think of this as your master class and
- 0:50understanding the psychology of, you know, truly helping others.
- 0:53It's such a vital framework to wrap your head around,
- 0:56especially because we need to completely redefine what the
- 1:00word helping actually means in this specific context.
- 1:03Right, because we all think we know what helping looks like.
- 1:06Exactly. We have this deeply ingrained
- 1:08societal idea of helping that usually involves, well, highly
- 1:13practical, visible assistance. Like fixing something that's
- 1:17broken. Right.
- 1:17If someone breaks a collarbone, you take them to a doctor, they
- 1:20look at an X-ray, they set the bone and they put into a sling.
- 1:24It's very transactional. And it's comforting, too, having
- 1:26a clear fix. It is a nurse bandaging A wound
- 1:30or, you know, an occupational therapist organizing a home
- 1:32layout. Those are vital practical fixes,
- 1:35but counseling operates on an entirely different plane.
- 1:38Because it's internal. Exactly.
- 1:39It doesn't rely on those practical external fixes
- 1:42because, well, you cannot put a plaster cast on a midlife
- 1:45crisis. Yeah, that is so true.
- 1:47When you step into the world of emotional distress, that X-ray
- 1:50machine is just utterly useless. Completely useless.
- 1:54We're looking at a landscape that is incredibly murky.
- 1:57Murky is the perfect word for it.
- 1:59Counseling uses highly specific relationship skills, like
- 2:03carefully calibrated verbal and nonverbal communication, to
- 2:07facilitate this really profound internal change.
- 2:10So it's not about just handing them a solution.
- 2:13No, not at all. It's about engineering a highly
- 2:16specialized environment, one where the person being helped
- 2:20can actually discover new ways of thinking and behaving for
- 2:23themselves. Rather than having some expert
- 2:25just impose a solution on them. Exactly.
- 2:27Well, let's start with the people who are actually tasked
- 2:30with creating that environment, like who is sitting in the
- 2:33counselor's chair. That's a great place to start.
- 2:35Because I, I think we have this tendency to view therapists as
- 2:39he's perfectly balanced, enlightened beings.
- 2:43You know, like they were just born with a notepad in hand,
- 2:46ready to absorb the world's pain.
- 2:48Oh. Absolutely the blank slate myth.
- 2:50Right, but their paths to that chair are surprisingly human and
- 2:55honestly quite messy sometimes. Very messy.
- 2:58Take the authors of this manual, for instance.
- 3:01Katherine Geldar didn't start out as a psychotherapist.
- 3:04She was an occupational therapist working in a
- 3:06psychiatric ward before her focus, you know, gradually
- 3:09shifted toward the mind. And the other two authors
- 3:12experienced even more dramatic career pivots.
- 3:15I mean, David Geldard was originally trained as a
- 3:18mechanical engineer. Which he readily admits in the
- 3:21book was a terrible mistake for him.
- 3:23Yeah, he's very upfront about it.
- 3:25He writes that as a young person, he actually wanted to be
- 3:27a counselor, but his parents and teachers steered him away.
- 3:30They told him he was better suited to working with
- 3:32predictable machines than with unpredictable people.
- 3:36Yeah, so he just believed them. But he notes that the only
- 3:39reason he wasn't sacked for sheer incompetence as an
- 3:42engineer was because of his interpersonal skills.
- 3:45It's hilarious, really. Is he got along with the other
- 3:48much more competent engineers, so his ability to relate to
- 3:52people literally saved his job while he was just, you know,
- 3:54marooned in the completely wrong field.
- 3:57Which requires a brilliant level of self-awareness to admit in a
- 3:59textbook, by the way. Totally.
- 4:01And then there's Rebecca Yinfu, who was quite literally in the
- 4:05middle of a PhD thesis on artificial joint lubrication
- 4:08before realizing she needed to change course.
- 4:11Artificial joint lubrication. I mean, you cannot get further
- 4:14from the messy subjective reality of human emotions than
- 4:19measuring friction on inanimate metal joints, right?
- 4:23She realized she felt incredibly isolated working with objects,
- 4:27so she eventually found her way to psychology, where she now
- 4:30works with children and families.
- 4:32But what's fascinating here is that the manual doesn't just
- 4:35share these quirky backstories for light entertainment.
- 4:38Right, there's a point to it. Exactly.
- 4:40It's establishing a really foundational point about human
- 4:42motivation. Counselors are not purely
- 4:45selfless beings who descend from the heavens to serve others,
- 4:48right? The book explicitly states that
- 4:51anyone entering this profession has to look in the mirror and
- 4:54recognize that they are motivated by their own internal
- 4:56needs too. Wait, OK, so you're telling me
- 4:59the person I'm going to for supposedly selfless help is
- 5:01actually doing it for their own ego?
- 5:03Well, yes and no. Because that sounds, I don't
- 5:05know, borderline narcissistic or at least a bit selfish.
- 5:08I see why it sounds that way, definitely, but it is actually
- 5:11the ultimate safeguard against narcissism, well beyond the
- 5:15practicalities of earning a paycheck.
- 5:18There are deep psychological needs at play here, things like
- 5:21the desire for status or a sense of power in the dynamic.
- 5:25OK, I could see that. Or simply the immense,
- 5:28undeniable personal satisfaction that comes from caring for
- 5:31someone else. I mean, helping feels good.
- 5:33Yeah, it does it. Strokes the ego.
- 5:35The authors argue that by openly acknowledging that, you get a
- 5:39psychological payoff from helping you actually protect the
- 5:42vulnerable person sitting across from you.
- 5:45Oh, I think I see where you're going with this.
- 5:47It's like it's the airplane oxygen mask rule but applied to
- 5:50the ego. That is exactly it.
- 5:52If you don't rigorously examine your own motivations first, your
- 5:56help might secretly become about you feeling like a savior rather
- 6:00than genuinely assisting the other person.
- 6:02Right, you end up using their crisis to validate your own
- 6:05worth. Wow, that's a huge pitfall.
- 6:08It is the core danger because if a counselor walks in completely
- 6:12unaware that they're chasing a hero high, they will
- 6:14subconsciously steer the session toward their own brilliance.
- 6:17Which doesn't help the client at all.
- 6:19No, and it's incredibly dangerous because of the
- 6:21delicate state the person seeking help is in, which kind
- 6:25of brings us to the clients themselves.
- 6:27Yeah, let's talk about. Them because making an
- 6:29appointment and sitting down to expose your deepest flaws to a
- 6:32stranger, That is a highly unnatural act for most of us.
- 6:37It really is, like the book points out, that people who are
- 6:39living, satisfying, fulfilling lives without major disruptions,
- 6:43they generally don't wake up and decide to seek counseling.
- 6:46Right, they're not just popping in for fun.
- 6:48No, it's triggered by a crisis, and usually these crises fall
- 6:52into two camps. Severe relationship issues like
- 6:55a brutal divorce or being trapped in a toxic dynamic or
- 6:59massive developmental life changes.
- 7:01Like what kind of changes? Well, we're talking about things
- 7:03like getting married, having a first child, a sudden promotion
- 7:06to a really high pressure role, or, you know, hitting a midlife
- 7:09wall. These are moments where the
- 7:11ground just completely falls out from under you.
- 7:14We also cannot underestimate the massive barrier of stigma and
- 7:19pride that someone wrestles with before they even pick up the
- 7:21phone. That's a huge factor.
- 7:23It is the manual highlights, that for many people,
- 7:26particularly those with significant work or leadership
- 7:29responsibilities, there's this profound, paralyzing fear of
- 7:34looking weak. Yeah, nobody wants to look like
- 7:36they can't handle things. Right.
- 7:38They're terrified that if their colleagues or employees knew
- 7:41they were in counseling, they'd be viewed as inadequate or
- 7:45incapable of handling their duties.
- 7:47So they hide the distress, they grit their teeth and just push
- 7:50through until their ability to carry out normal daily tasks is
- 7:54significantly impaired. Which?
- 7:56Is such a heavy burden to carry. They really only show up to the
- 7:59clinic when the pain is simply too loud to ignore anymore.
- 8:01Precisely. And this means they arrive in a
- 8:04state of high anxiety. They're tightly wound, heavily
- 8:08guarded, and usually highly skeptical of the whole process.
- 8:11Which brings us to one of the most powerful concepts in the
- 8:14manual this metaphor of peeling the onion.
- 8:16I love this metaphor. It's so vivid.
- 8:19If you're going to help someone who is that heavily guarded,
- 8:22they have to open up. So the book visualizes this
- 8:25dynamic as an onion. The outer layers are the safe,
- 8:29socially polite information. You know the kind of surface
- 8:32level venting you might do at a water cooler?
- 8:34Like oh work is really stressful right now or I just haven't been
- 8:38sleeping. Well, But as you move toward the
- 8:40core of the onion, the layers represent increasingly personal,
- 8:44risky and highly private information.
- 8:47The stuff they don't want anyone to see.
- 8:49Exactly. This is the raw material that is
- 8:52never shared with others. The deep insecurities, the
- 8:56hidden traumas, the shame. This heavy stuff.
- 8:58And this connects to a much bigger picture regarding how
- 9:01humans process adversity. Those outer layers aren't just a
- 9:05sign of someone being stubborn or difficult or resistant to
- 9:08therapy. That is protective armor for
- 9:11many people, especially those who have experienced severe
- 9:14abuse or trauma. Those layers were built for
- 9:16sheer survival. They aren't just walls, I mean
- 9:19they're load bearing walls holding the person's daily life
- 9:21together. That's a great way to put it.
- 9:23But OK, if I'm a manager trying to help a distressed employee or
- 9:27a friend dealing with someone in crisis, my instinct is to dig.
- 9:31Right, you want to help? Yeah, I want to ask probing
- 9:34questions to get to the root of the problem quickly, so we can
- 9:37just deal with that. Well, that is the interrogation
- 9:39trap, and it is catastrophic, Absolutely.
- 9:42If a counselor or or a friend for that matter, tries to RIP
- 9:46those layers off too quickly through aggressive questioning,
- 9:50they are essentially violating the person's psychological
- 9:53safety. Oh.
- 9:54Wow, it feels like an attack to them.
- 9:57The pace of peeling that onion must be entirely dictated by the
- 10:00person seeking help. They have to decide when the
- 10:03environment is secure enough to expose the next vulnerable
- 10:07layer. So how does a professional
- 10:09create an environment safe enough to peel those layers
- 10:13without making it feel like a clinical interrogation?
- 10:15It's a delicate balance. Because if someone is sitting
- 10:18there terrified of looking weak and you just sit there and wait
- 10:20in silence, they might never open up.
- 10:23Well, this raises a really important question, and it leads
- 10:26directly to the great paradox of the counseling profession.
- 10:29OK, I'm listening. When the client finally does
- 10:31peel back those layers, you know when they take a breath and
- 10:34expose the raw, painful core of their failing marriage or their
- 10:38crippling anxiety, their immediate expectation is that
- 10:41the counselor will now just fix. It right, They've done the hard
- 10:43part. Now give me the cure.
- 10:45Exactly. They want a tangible solution.
- 10:47They are essentially demanding direct advice, but giving advice
- 10:52is the exact opposite of the counselor's goal.
- 10:55OK, let's pause here because I really struggled with this when
- 10:58reading the sources. It's tough to accept it first.
- 11:00It is because if I'm paying a professional 150 bucks an hour
- 11:04and my life is imploding, I want answers.
- 11:07Of course you do. I want a road map, not just a
- 11:09sympathetic nod. Why on earth wouldn't an expert
- 11:12just tell me what to do? And he feels incredibly
- 11:15counterintuitive, I know. But the book outlines several
- 11:19glaring dangers in giving advice.
- 11:22First, humans are remarkably resistant to it.
- 11:25We really are. Even if we explicitly ask for
- 11:27advice, the moment someone actually tells us what to do,
- 11:31our defenses automatically flare up.
- 11:33It's just human nature to fiercely protect our autonomy.
- 11:36OK, fair enough. We don't like being bossed
- 11:38around. Right, but the dangers go much
- 11:41deeper than mere resistance. Consider the actual outcomes of
- 11:46giving direct advice. OK let's say the client says
- 11:50should I leave my husband and the counselor says yes you
- 11:53should. OK, the client follows the
- 11:55instructions. The divorce is an absolute
- 11:58nightmare and they end up financially ruined and
- 12:00miserable. Oh.
- 12:02Geez, the counselor has just done a massive disservice.
- 12:04The client's trust is totally shattered, they feel betrayed,
- 12:08and they are significantly worse off than before.
- 12:11Right, that makes sense. But the book also argues that if
- 12:14the advice actually succeeds, it might be even worse for the
- 12:17client in the long run. It is entirely worse.
- 12:20Think about what the client actually learns.
- 12:22If the counselor gives great advice and it fixes the
- 12:25immediate problem, have they learned how to navigate a crisis
- 12:28on their own? No.
- 12:29No, they have learned that the counselor is a superior expert
- 12:33who holds the magic answers to their life.
- 12:36So what does this all mean? I was trying to conceptualize
- 12:38this and it's a bit like using AGPS system.
- 12:42OK, I like where this is. Going if you want to drive to a
- 12:44new city and you just blindly follow the turn by turn audio
- 12:48directions. The advice you get to your
- 12:50destination Right, but your brain hasn't built a mental map
- 12:54of the route. You didn't pay any attention to
- 12:56the landmarks or the highway signs.
- 12:58So if the GPS breaks down on your way back, you are
- 13:02completely stranded. You're entirely dependent on the
- 13:05machine. That is a brilliant way to
- 13:07conceptualize it. If the counselor hands you the
- 13:10solution, you never build your own mental map.
- 13:12You just rely on them. Exactly.
- 13:15The next time you face a major life decision, you won't trust
- 13:18your own judgment. You'll just run back to the
- 13:20clinic. The counselor has effectively
- 13:23ruined your ability to be self reliant.
- 13:25Which is the opposite of helping.
- 13:27Right. They've created a dynamic where
- 13:29you are permanently subordinate to their wisdom, stripping you
- 13:32of your own adaptive decision making muscles.
- 13:35The only exceptions the book makes for giving direct advice
- 13:37are, well, acute medical emergencies or situations where
- 13:40someone's physical safety is actively compromised.
- 13:43Yes, safety is paramount. In those moments of life or
- 13:46death, obviously the counselor has to step in and be directive,
- 13:50but otherwise the advice trap is to be avoided at all costs.
- 13:54Because the goal of counseling is never short term problem
- 13:57solving just to make the person feel temporarily relieved.
- 14:00It's not a quick fix, no. If they feel better today but
- 14:04completely fall apart at the next hurdle tomorrow, the
- 14:07intervention failed. The true goal is enduring long
- 14:10term change. It's an empowering process where
- 14:13the counselor wants the person to test out their own decisions,
- 14:17even if those decisions are a little messy, and learn from
- 14:20their own experiences. But this naturally forces us to
- 14:22ask a big question. If the counselor isn't giving
- 14:25advice and they aren't directly solving the problem, what on
- 14:28earth are they actually doing in that room for an hour?
- 14:31Well, they are doing something exponentially more difficult
- 14:34than dispensing advice, which is they are leveraging the profound
- 14:37catalytic power of the relationship itself.
- 14:40OK, this brings us to the historical shift and how this
- 14:42all works, specifically the pioneering work of Carl Rogers
- 14:46in the 50s and 60s. Yes, Rogers is huge here.
- 14:49He he champions this massive tivot toward what he called
- 14:52person centered counseling because before this therapy
- 14:56could be quite clinical and detached, like treating clients
- 14:59as impersonal puzzles to be diagnosed and fixed by the
- 15:03expert doctor. Almost like a mechanic fixing a
- 15:05car. Exactly.
- 15:07But Rodgers said no, you have to treat them as human beings, and
- 15:10he identified 3 necessary and sufficient qualities that a
- 15:14counselor must bring to the relationship.
- 15:16And those 3 qualities remain the absolute bedrock of the
- 15:19profession today. What's the first one?
- 15:21The first is congruence, which means the counselor is genuine
- 15:25and authentic, not just hiding behind a stiff, authoritative
- 15:28professional mask. So they act like a real person.
- 15:31Yes, if they're feeling a disconnect in the room, they
- 15:34don't fake a smile, they gently name it.
- 15:37And the second. The second is empathy, which is
- 15:40not merely sympathy or feeling bad for someone.
- 15:43It is the ability to deeply understand and cognitively share
- 15:47the feelings of the person in front of them.
- 15:49It's like cling down into the dark hole with them.
- 15:51Not just shouting down from the top.
- 15:53Exactly, and the 3rd and perhaps the most famous is unconditional
- 15:57positive regard. OK, here's where it gets really
- 16:00interesting for me. Right?
- 16:01Because think about the sheer mechanics of doing that.
- 16:04This means accepting and respecting the person exactly as
- 16:08they are, without judgment, regardless of what they have
- 16:11done. It's very demanding.
- 16:12How does a normal human being maintain unconditional positive
- 16:16guard for an hour? I mean, if a client sits there
- 16:20detailing how they're actively sabotaging their family or
- 16:23making deeply destructive moral choices, you're supposed to just
- 16:27project warmth. It sounds impossible.
- 16:29It feels almost impossible, or at least completely unnatural.
- 16:32You have to withhold the burning urge to judge them while
- 16:35simultaneously refusing to hand them the life raft of your own
- 16:38advice that requires A staggering amount of emotional
- 16:42discipline. It requires immense discipline,
- 16:44but it works because of the psychological mechanism
- 16:47underneath it. How so?
- 16:49Unconditional positive regard is not about endorsing destructive
- 16:52behavior, it is about separating the human beings inherent worth
- 16:56from their flawed actions. OK, I see.
- 16:58When someone who expects to be judged suddenly realizes they
- 17:02are fully accepted, the armor drops.
- 17:06If we connect this to the bigger picture of Roger's philosophy,
- 17:09he held the fundamental belief that people already possess the
- 17:12ability within themselves to find their own solutions.
- 17:15So they aren't just empty vessels waiting to be filled
- 17:18with the experts wisdom. Correct, They have the answers.
- 17:21Those answers are just buried under trauma or fear or a
- 17:24crushing lack of confidence, right?
- 17:26The relationship itself, the empathy, the positive regard,
- 17:30doesn't fix the person. It acts as the safe catalyst
- 17:34that lowers their anxiety enough so they can finally examine
- 17:37their own ugly behavior and fix themselves.
- 17:39I love that distinction, it's so empowering.
- 17:42But the authors, Geldard, Geldard and Yinfu, do note that
- 17:45just being a warm, empathetic person isn't quite enough to get
- 17:48the job done. No, you need more than just good
- 17:50vibes. Right.
- 17:52They referenced David Howe, who added that counselors also need
- 17:55to be attentive, clarificatory and collaborative.
- 17:58And they also bring in Gerard Egan, who delivers a necessary
- 18:01reality check. Egan is very pragmatic.
- 18:03He is, He says that good human relations alone will not cut it.
- 18:08You also need a highly methodical, pragmatic approach,
- 18:12an actual practiced skill. Yes, because empathy without a
- 18:16framework can just evolve into a mutual pity party.
- 18:19Nobody wants that. Egans methodical approach is all
- 18:23about movement. It involves helping the client
- 18:25map out their current picture, vividly imagining their
- 18:29preferred picture, and then reversely developing the way
- 18:32forward to actually bridge that gap.
- 18:34And so it's active. It is highly active work.
- 18:37It involves gently challenging blind spots and setting
- 18:40concrete, measurable goals. And part of that methodical work
- 18:43is established right at the beginning through what the
- 18:46manual calls the counseling contract.
- 18:48A very crucial step. I initially thought this was
- 18:50just, you know, signing a waiver about billing and cancellation
- 18:53fees, but it's actually a vital psychological tool.
- 18:56It really is the foundation of safety in the room.
- 18:59The contract is an explicit, usually verbal, agreement on
- 19:02confidentiality, on the general grease of the process, and,
- 19:06crucially, an agreement on what will not be discussed.
- 19:08Setting those firm boundaries upfront.
- 19:10Exactly that, by explicitly telling the client hey we will
- 19:15only go where you want to go and your wishes will be strictly
- 19:17respected regarding what traumatic issues are off limits,
- 19:21you dramatically lower their anxiety.
- 19:23Because they know they're in control.
- 19:25Right. They don't have to fear being
- 19:26tricked or pressured into revealing a layer of the onion
- 19:29they just aren't ready to share. That contract builds the very
- 19:33trust needed for unconditional positive regard to actually take
- 19:37root. It's entirely about engineering
- 19:40and environment of total safety and autonomy.
- 19:42Exactly. So to bring this all together
- 19:44for you listening, we've covered some incredible ground today
- 19:47from the 8th edition of the Basic Personal Counseling
- 19:50Manual. You really have.
- 19:51I started by looking at the surprising, wonderfully messy
- 19:54motivations of the people who become counselors, remembering
- 19:58that even helpers have their own psychological needs that must be
- 20:01heavily scrutinized so they don't hijack the process.
- 20:04So important. We explored the delicate, client
- 20:08dictated pacing of peeling the emotional onion, respecting the
- 20:12trauma armor people wear. We uncovered the massive danger
- 20:16of the advice trap, learning why handing someone the answers is
- 20:20like making them dependent on Agps, ultimately destroying
- 20:23their self-reliance. And finally, we looked at the
- 20:26transformative catalytic power of empathy and unconditional
- 20:31positive regard to help people find their own way forward.
- 20:35It is a profound, beautifully complex framework, and I think
- 20:39the most practical take away is that while these are highly
- 20:41trained professional skills, the underlying philosophy, you know,
- 20:45practicing deep listening, actively withholding judgment,
- 20:47and resisting the urge to instantly fix people with your
- 20:50own advice is something that can radically improve our own
- 20:53personal relationships, whether you're dealing with a frustrated
- 20:56spouse, a struggling child, or just a colleague in crisis.
- 21:00It really changes how you view every conversation.
- 21:03But before we wrap up this deep dive, there is one compelling
- 21:06detail from the introduction of this 8th edition that we haven't
- 21:09touched on yet, and it's something I want to leave you to
- 21:11Mull over. Oh, the new chapters, yes.
- 21:13The authors note that for this specific new edition, they had
- 21:16to add chapters on 2 very modern realities, a bird out inventory
- 21:21for the practitioners themselves, and a brand new
- 21:23chapter on Internet counseling. Which is so relevant right now.
- 21:27It is as world moves increasingly online and as
- 21:31receiving therapy through a digital screen becomes the norm
- 21:34rather than the exception, it forces us to ask a really
- 21:38difficult question. It fundamentally challenges the
- 21:41very mechanics of the relationship we just spent all
- 21:43this time dissecting. Yes, think about everything we
- 21:46just discussed. The silent pauses, the subtle
- 21:50shifts in body language, the heavy atmosphere of A room.
- 21:54How does a digital screen change your ability to paste The
- 21:56peeling of that emotional onion? It's a great question.
- 21:59Can a professional truly project unconditional positive regard,
- 22:03read the microscopic non verbal cues of distress and build a
- 22:07profound person centered relationship through a webcam?
- 22:10Or is there a vital, necessary layer of human connection, a
- 22:14biological resonance that simply gets lost in the pixels?
- 22:17It's definitely something we all need to consider.
- 22:19Something to think about the next time you log on.