Latest / Film And Whiskey / Season 10 Bracket Challenge (Part 2): Chaos & Coin Flips
Transcript
- 0:02Today on the Film and Whiskey podcast, we are continuing the
- 0:05season 10 bracket and apparently we're drinking some surprise
- 0:10whiskeys as well. That's all ahead on Film and
- 0:13Whiskey. Well, hey there everybody.
- 0:34Welcome into the Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 0:37I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad.
- 0:38Gee. And Brad, we are coming at Film
- 0:41and Whiskey Nation with another special bonus episode.
- 0:45Bonus episode. I love it, man.
- 0:50Because this is Part 2 of the Season 10 Bracket challenge.
- 0:54Folks, if this is your first time joining us, why?
- 0:57Why is this the one you chose? Part 2 of the Season 10 bracket.
- 1:01I have to give so much context to catch you up.
- 1:03I'd recommend just just press stop, go back one episode and
- 1:07let past Bob give you that context.
- 1:10Because folks, we want to dive right in.
- 1:11Today. We started with 32 movies.
- 1:13We only got down to 16 last time around, and today we're trying
- 1:17to go from 16 through the round of eight and get down to just
- 1:22our final four films. So we have a lot of picks to do.
- 1:25Brad suggested drinking some whiskey.
- 1:27Folks, I'll be honest with you, nobody has sent us any new
- 1:30whiskeys to review in a while. So he said we should just grab
- 1:33something off our shelves and and try it out.
- 1:35So Brad, what did you pick to sip on tonight as we get into
- 1:38this bracket? As a true whiskey drinker in
- 1:42America ought to do. I'm drinking Scotch, Bob.
- 1:47I'm drinking Tam. Do 12 comes in this fancy box.
- 1:52I want to see you like just open the lid of the box and take the
- 1:55cork out, but not take it out-of-the-box and just pour it
- 2:00still in taste. In the box, it's just like that
- 2:04is that is how I pour my whiskey when it when it comes in a box.
- 2:09I believe I am also drinking Scotch bread, though I can't say
- 2:12for sure. So a year or two ago, our friend
- 2:16Zach Johnston gave us a whole bunch of whiskeys to try.
- 2:19We were very eager about trying a lot of them on the show.
- 2:22I have now accepted that we will simply never, I might not never
- 2:25drink these whiskeys as long as I live, Brad.
- 2:27But yeah, I spent a long time cataloging these whiskeys, and
- 2:32there were these tiny little vials amongst the whiskeys that
- 2:36look like this. If you're on the Patreon, you
- 2:38can see how small these things are.
- 2:40They're very tiny and they are, they're kind of Scotch colored.
- 2:44Like they're pretty clear. There's not much color to them
- 2:46and there is no label on them except on the very bottom.
- 2:50Some of them have tiny, tiny letters.
- 2:52One says GC1 says FB1 says PC, and one just says B.
- 3:00And I've believe me dude, I've tried Googling it.
- 3:02I don't. I have no idea what this is.
- 3:04So I'm trying 4 mystery liquids tonight Brad.
- 3:08And that's all I know at this point.
- 3:11OK, we're going to ask ChatGPT about this.
- 3:13Bob, What? What are the labels again?
- 3:17FBTC one just says. BB.
- 3:21And. GCGC.
- 3:26All right, let's see what. ChatGPT says it's going to be
- 3:28wrong. It's going to pull a whole bunch
- 3:30of stuff out of its butt here. No, ChatGPT can never be wrong,
- 3:34Bob. All right, Short answer, those
- 3:38letter codes alone aren't enough to confidently identify a Scotch
- 3:42brand, but we can make some educated guesses.
- 3:44Nope, PC could be port. Charlotte.
- 3:49I do like Port Charlotte, yeah. If it's a heavily peded line, it
- 3:52might be the bruclotic B could. Be so that might be.
- 3:56More Oh yeah. Or B could, yeah.
- 4:02GC. Yeah.
- 4:03Probably wouldn't be Glenn Morgan.
- 4:05Glenn something. Yeah, Glenn.
- 4:07Yeah, it's gotta be Glenn. Something it.
- 4:09Has to be like one big Scotch producer that owns a lot of
- 4:12brands and it's like all their brands but.
- 4:14Yeah, I don't know, probably. It's probably $1000 whiskey and
- 4:17I have no idea. In any case, Brad, we're not
- 4:20here to really talk about the whiskey much tonight at all.
- 4:22We're here to talk about our bracket.
- 4:24And folks, if you are watching on the Patreon, I'm gonna share
- 4:27my screen for a second so you can see where we're at in the
- 4:30film and whiskey bracket. And here we are, man.
- 4:33We are entering the round of 16 here.
- 4:35Brad. I think we should just go ahead
- 4:37and dive right in. We've got our number one overall
- 4:43seed, Vertigo, going up against Brad's favorite movie of all
- 4:47time, the number 16 seed Star Wars.
- 4:50Over to you, Brad. Break this one down for me.
- 4:54Man O man, Vertigo all time classic Bob.
- 4:58I mean it is just I would say the epitome of like Hitchcockian
- 5:06mystery and colors and the blocking in the movie is beyond
- 5:13spectacular. I like, I remember watching
- 5:16Vertigo as a teenager for the first time and like having
- 5:19nightmares being terrified. It was like a a truly horrifying
- 5:23movie. Great great film.
- 5:25Star Wars, maybe the most impactful movie ever released on
- 5:30the history of cinema. Tell me I'm wrong, Bob.
- 5:34I mean, it's close, definitely close, man.
- 5:37Yeah. Listen, this was easy for me.
- 5:39Vertigo's moving on in the Bob book bracket.
- 5:41Now I, I will say I'm looking at your vibes based list, your
- 5:45heart rankings, and Star Wars is your #2 film Vertigo's number 3.
- 5:50So this really is as easy as you might make it sound to move Star
- 5:54Wars on here, and this is a pretty close call for you, I
- 5:58would think. Dude Vertigo's is one of my
- 6:00favorite movies of all time. Definitely on my it's probably
- 6:04in my like 5th to 10th favorite movie of all time.
- 6:08I don't know if Star Wars Episode 4 is quite that high.
- 6:14So like vibes for Star Wars is higher.
- 6:17I think overall though, if I had to rank my top 10 movies of all
- 6:21time, I think Vertigo might be higher on that list.
- 6:25I am going to move Vertigo on I, I.
- 6:28Think it's. I think it's.
- 6:29The right decision. Do you feel pressured to do this
- 6:34like I? Don't feel pressured.
- 6:37Honestly, if I feel anything, Bob, I feel pressured to choose
- 6:41Star Wars just for the chaos, because I just for the point of
- 6:45view. I feel like, you know the one,
- 6:47the number one seed getting defeated by the 16 would never
- 6:51happen in any other bracket. I'm picking Star Wars.
- 6:53Star Wars is moving on, Bob. Dude, and just just for that, I
- 6:57have poured out a whole vial of PC for you my friend.
- 7:01And I got to say this smells fantastic.
- 7:03Brad. It's it's Granny Smith apple for
- 7:05days. I wish you were here to
- 7:06experience. Is it is it Scotch or is it
- 7:09something else? I want to say Scotch, Brad.
- 7:11OK. You drank a lot.
- 7:13I was. Going to say Scotch I trust a
- 7:15little smoky. It's.
- 7:16I'm going to say Scotch. Watch it be like a mescal or
- 7:20something. I have no idea, you know.
- 7:22Here I will say Film Whiskey Nation, here's an update for
- 7:26you. I did flip the Coin of Destiny
- 7:28about 50 times after our first bracket episode and I would say
- 7:36there is a slight lean towards heads.
- 7:41Now I, I don't know if that means that it's actually towards
- 7:43tails 'cause I always flip, flip the coin in the air and then do
- 7:47the flip onto my hand. So I don't know that, you know,
- 7:51I don't know if that technically means that it is weighted
- 7:54towards tails. Either way, start with the coin
- 7:59with the same orientation before flipping.
- 8:01No, OK, I, I don't now I will say I, I tried doing different
- 8:06things like flipping it a little higher than normal or a little
- 8:08less and that like helped with the variability.
- 8:12So I, I think we're working with an OK coin.
- 8:14I I don't think it is weighted. I don't know that we'll need a
- 8:18coin flip for this one, but you never know because Brad has
- 8:21established that he is an enemy of the movie musical.
- 8:25And that's my Segway into the. Hold on what?
- 8:29I picked Star Wars. We have to flip the coin of
- 8:31destiny. No, you didn't.
- 8:33You said you're moving Vertigo. Yeah.
- 8:34And then I thought about it and I was like, there's no chance
- 8:38that a #16 seed ever again will have the opportunity to beat the
- 8:42number one seed. And I picked Star Wars.
- 8:45You did not 100%. You know what?
- 8:49I'm picking Star Wars. I thought we were going to skate
- 8:52by here, you bastard. All right, we're going to flip
- 8:55the coin of destiny, which has a slight lean as we all do.
- 9:01A slight lean in One Direction. Vertigo's going to be heads.
- 9:05Vertigo wins my bracket and I'm voting against.
- 9:09Him. Why are you doing this?
- 9:10Why you? This is just for chaos.
- 9:13Chaos, baby. Vertigo's heads, Star Wars is
- 9:17tails Brad to ruin both of our brackets.
- 9:20Flip that coin. Is it really?
- 9:34Is it Tales? It is the first tales that we've
- 9:39had for the whole brackets. I think you've established what
- 9:43you're going to do for the rest of the bracket.
- 9:44Now you're just going to flip Star Wars against every movie
- 9:47just to see like Harvest. To see what happens, like, yeah.
- 9:51Yeah, exactly. God, I hate you man.
- 9:54Why did you do that? There's no reason for you to do
- 9:57that because Bob. Our brackets are boring at the
- 10:00end of the day. It ends up being like 1/2, 3:00
- 10:02and 5:00. Every season.
- 10:05We need, we need a Cinderella. Cinderella we we need somebody
- 10:09from the Mac to get into the Final four.
- 10:11Here it's it's funny that I say we need a Cinderella Man.
- 10:14We literally have a Cinderella Man.
- 10:16We do, we do. All right, let me get to the
- 10:18next match up here. It's the number 9 overall seed.
- 10:21West Side Story up against #8 The Tree of Life.
- 10:26Now that would mean that if there is a coin flip, the Tree
- 10:28of life will be heads as the eight seed.
- 10:31Brad, this was not that difficult for me.
- 10:33But as we established, you are a hater of the movie musical and
- 10:36all things good. And so the Tree of Life, I think
- 10:40I said in the last episode, it's like it's a movie that I can
- 10:43kind of sit on a shelf and acknowledge as a 10.
- 10:46I don't get like a ton of enjoyment watching that movie.
- 10:49And there are there are moments of true beauty and awe in that
- 10:53movie, but I think beginning to end, West Side Story is just a
- 10:56much more impactful experience for me.
- 10:59Yeah, I and I totally understand that.
- 11:01I, I think West Side Story is one of the best musicals ever
- 11:05made. I just, I don't know, man.
- 11:08I think the older I get, the more I feel intrigued by weird,
- 11:13artsy like stories that have a meaningful thing to say about
- 11:18the human experience. I think that Tree of Life has
- 11:21that in absolute spades and I am going to move Tree of Life
- 11:25forward. Of course you are.
- 11:28So we're going to have back-to-back coin flips on a day
- 11:31where we are already going to run long on this episode.
- 11:33You're like, let's, let's grind this baby to a halt.
- 11:35Why not? Tree of Life is heads, West Side
- 11:39Story is tails. You are going to really screw up
- 11:41my bracket my friend. Flip that coin.
- 11:55Bob, we have two tails in a row. I'll take it.
- 11:59I I I can't get her to go back, but I can move West Side Story
- 12:02on into the round of eight. That takes us to the bottom left
- 12:07quadrant. This one might not need much
- 12:10debate, Brad, as much as we love the number 13 seed, Amadeus,
- 12:15it's going up against the number four overall seed.
- 12:17And I believe your number one overall seed, Pulp Fiction.
- 12:21Yeah, dude. Pulp Pulp Fiction.
- 12:24Just I don't know what it was this time around.
- 12:26It checked all the boxes for me. I it still isn't once again
- 12:31similar to Vertigo. It probably would be in like my
- 12:355 to 10, fifth to 10th best overall movie range.
- 12:39So it's it's not like I have the passion for it, but it could
- 12:42easily win any individual season of our show.
- 12:46So I for me, this is an easy pick.
- 12:48Pulp Fiction. Yeah, for me too.
- 12:50And I love Amadeus. But like, again, if we're
- 12:53talking about movies that changed the course of movie
- 12:55history, yeah, Pulp Fiction's kind of a no brainer here.
- 12:58So after 2 long debates, we have one very quick one, getting the
- 13:02number four seed Pulp Fiction into the round of eight.
- 13:06And this will finalize the left side of the bracket here, Brad,
- 13:09the number 12 overall seed, the Treasure of the Sierra Madre,
- 13:14going up against the number 5 seed, Rear Window.
- 13:17Now I will. I'm just telling you now, I will
- 13:20be a ride or die for Rear Window, I think, on this side of
- 13:22the bracket from here on out because I think that is just
- 13:25frankly, a perfect movie. Yeah.
- 13:28And even even in the next round when I would like to think it
- 13:32will go up against Pulp Fiction, I think I'm going to pick it
- 13:34there too because I think Pulp Fiction is a great, slightly
- 13:38unwieldy movie. And Rear Windows, just like a
- 13:41freaking well oiled machine that just extracts suspense from you.
- 13:45So we don't even have to talk about that now, because it's up
- 13:47against The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, a movie that I
- 13:50love dearly, but that it just doesn't hold the candle to Rear
- 13:54Window in my mind. Dude, not at all.
- 13:57Rear window is like, once again, we're we're we're kind of
- 14:01whittling away the chaff and we are getting towards the cream of
- 14:05the crop. What, what would you say is your
- 14:08favorite Walter Houston quote from Treasure of the Sierra
- 14:12Madre? Because he's he has some
- 14:14incredible ones. All I keep coming back to is
- 14:17when he's doing his little like hop skip and he's like you're
- 14:21Dumber than the dumbest Jackass. Like it's just a great like of
- 14:26all the you're dumb quotes, you're Dumber than the dumbest
- 14:29Jackass is top tier. You're dumb.
- 14:31It's so. Freaking good dude.
- 14:35I love when he's talking to the guys and he's like, hey you
- 14:38fellas, now how about some beans?
- 14:39You want some beans going through some mighty rough
- 14:42country tomorrow? You better.
- 14:43Have he's trying to break up a fight by like, dangling beans in
- 14:46front of people, yes. It's.
- 14:49Incredible, dude. I freaking love that movie,
- 14:51dude. I'm sorry to see it go into the
- 14:53fiery abyss, but Rear Window must move on here.
- 14:56And so we've got our first half of the round of eight locked in
- 14:59Star Wars, West Side Story, Pulp Fiction and Rear Window.
- 15:04I like that. I've been talking a lot this
- 15:06episode. I know that you have the bracket
- 15:08on your end. I would like for you to intro
- 15:11the right side of our bracket so that I can sit back and enjoy my
- 15:14pour of BBB. You got the.
- 15:18You got the B, Bob, just B. On the right side of the
- 15:22bracket, we have our number two overall seed 12 angry Men going
- 15:28up against the number 18 seed and a real, you know, underdog
- 15:33story, if you will, Cinderella Man Bob I, I feel like once
- 15:39again, this this is where the bracket just kind of, you know,
- 15:44the, the one through 4 seed kind of has an easy row the first two
- 15:47rounds, as it should be. Cinderella Man is a great movie.
- 15:52It is a stirring film. It ought to it deserves more
- 15:55recognition than it gets. It's not 12 Angry Men.
- 16:00It's I don't. I don't have Ron Howard's book
- 16:04up here on my ledge. I have Sidney Lumetz.
- 16:07You do have Sidney Lumetz. Have you read it yet?
- 16:10I haven't I I really want to. I bought myself a copy of it
- 16:14about a year ago and I also haven't read it.
- 16:16I think we should have Film and Whiskey book club next season
- 16:18dude, and that could be our bonus episodes is just going
- 16:21through Sidney Lumetz book. Dude, we'll do a Patreon book
- 16:25club. Patreon Book Club.
- 16:27We'll do a giveaway, will buy a new Patreon, member a copy of
- 16:33the book, and you can join the book club.
- 16:37But I love it dude. We're moving into books and
- 16:39whiskey for season 11. I freaking love it man.
- 16:42Wine my only. Remaining question, right.
- 16:45My only remaining question about this matchup is do you think
- 16:49that James J Braddock could could take all 12 men in the
- 16:56jury room if you just put him in there?
- 16:58Like the old man's dead immediately and the little share
- 17:03of glasses is dead immediately, but there's like 10 able bodied
- 17:06men in there that I think might be able to gang up and and
- 17:10defeat Jim Braddock. That's a good question man.
- 17:13Are we talking about like pre broken hand got real strong
- 17:19working on the docks? Braddock, are we talking?
- 17:21We're talking about the same one that faces Max Baer at the end
- 17:25of the movie, Dings and all. I I think overcoming 10 men
- 17:30would be hard. I think if you put Max, I think
- 17:33if you put Max, Baer and Brad in the room.
- 17:35Just like 1 uppercut to each guy and they're all dead.
- 17:39And it's, it's like a bad like action movie where they're
- 17:44coming one at a time and he's just boom, boom, boom.
- 17:48Like Popeye? Yeah, dude.
- 17:49Yes, dude. Max Baer would have been a great
- 17:53if there's ever a live action Popeye, who's the actor who was?
- 17:58There was a live action Popeye, but we don't need to talk about
- 18:00that right now, Brad. That's another bonus episode.
- 18:02Why did we ever think that that was a good idea?
- 18:05All right, we're moving down into the next match up, the
- 18:08number 10 overall seed, The Great Escape up against #7
- 18:13Inglourious Basterds. This is a really hard match up
- 18:15for me, Brad, because I've really gone back and forth on
- 18:19Inglourious Basterds in our time on the show here.
- 18:21I think I was at like a six out of 10 the first time we watched
- 18:24it, and this time I was at like a nine out of 10.
- 18:26I, I do think that it's one of Tarantino's best.
- 18:30I also think it's one of Tarantino's most indulgent,
- 18:34along with Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.
- 18:37It's not one of my favorite Tarantino's.
- 18:39It's just one that I kind of like, appreciate and respect a
- 18:42little more than I love. And I think that opens the door
- 18:46for me for The Great Escape, a movie that is very solidly a
- 18:50nine out of 10 and nothing more than that, but like one of the
- 18:53best. I'm going to fall asleep with a
- 18:56window open on a Saturday afternoon and this movie's
- 18:59playing in the background and I wake up and it's still on and
- 19:01I'm like, dope, let's watch these guys try to escape.
- 19:03Steve's jumping over a barbed wire fence.
- 19:05It's crazy. Yeah, dude, I don't know what to
- 19:08do here, Brad. I'd like to hear your opinion,
- 19:10Bob. You're silly.
- 19:13Inglourious Basterds has one of the absolute greatest opening
- 19:18scenes of all time. Like True Bar None has one of
- 19:23the most incredibly dark and intimidating villains of all
- 19:29time who also pulls a little bit of a comedic edge.
- 19:33Right. The lows of Inglorious Basterds
- 19:36are like the midpoints of The Great Escape.
- 19:41And there's not many lows in Inglorious Basterds.
- 19:45Like for me this is an easy easy pick.
- 19:48I think Shoshanna out acts any human being who's in the Great
- 19:53Escape like this is an easy easy pic of inglorious Basterds.
- 19:59Man, my head says you're right. My heart says the great escape.
- 20:04And your heart is not saying anything, it is singing.
- 20:14Real quick, one more point. Against Inglorious Basterds?
- 20:16Not really. Against, Obviously.
- 20:18Tarantino is hugely influenced by The Good, The Bad and the
- 20:22Ugly. It's his favorite movie of all
- 20:23time. That movie was on TV the other
- 20:25night and I watched the opening couple scenes and I forgot about
- 20:29that first scene with the villain Lee Van Cleef, where he
- 20:32goes to that family's farmhouse and there's hardly any dialogue
- 20:36spoken. So it is different than
- 20:37Tarantino, but over the course of like 15 minutes, you watch
- 20:42this terrified family come to understand that this guy's going
- 20:45to kill everybody in the house. And he does that.
- 20:47And I was like, oh, it's the beginning of Inglourious
- 20:50Basterds. Tarantino just took his his
- 20:53favorite scene from his favorite movie and redid it with
- 20:55Christoph Waltz and a giant tobacco.
- 20:57If if Coogler can steal the entirety of well, what movie is
- 21:04it If. He can steal the entire movie of
- 21:06From Dusk Till Dawn. I think we can forgive 1 scene
- 21:10for Tarantino. Brad, I I'm sorry.
- 21:13I'm gonna make you do a coin flip.
- 21:14I'll get the great Escape more. Yeah, I just.
- 21:17I think you're right. But I also like you.
- 21:18You'd screwed me on Star Wars, so I.
- 21:20Knew this was coming. Flip this.
- 21:22Coin Yeah, let's see, the Great Escape is gonna be tails.
- 21:28So Inglorious Basterds heads and Great Escape tails, Brad, just
- 21:33for the hell of it, flip that coin.
- 21:43All right, we have another heads.
- 21:47There you go, it all worked out at the end.
- 21:49I went to bat for my movie. You did.
- 21:52I'm proud of you, Bob. All right, so 12 Angry Men and
- 21:56Inglourious Basterds will be facing off against each other in
- 21:58the round of eight. And that takes us to our last
- 22:01two matchups in this round, the number three overall seed
- 22:04Casablanca up against the 14 seed The Lion King, a film which
- 22:10once again, I, I think that's the first movie I remember going
- 22:14to see in the movie theater. I was like 4 years old, not even
- 22:17four years old. Yeah, I, I know that I saw
- 22:21movies in my zero to 10 years old.
- 22:23The first movie I really remember going to see in the
- 22:26theaters was Monsters, Inc when I would have been 10 or 11.
- 22:30So it came out 2001. And that like that's a great,
- 22:33what a great memory. Great movie, dude.
- 22:36And yet I think this is pretty obvious, man.
- 22:38I'm I'm riding Casablanca here. Sorry Lion King, we will dangle
- 22:42you over the edge like Mufasa and drop you into the herd of
- 22:47wildebeests. Now here's the real question.
- 22:48Am I going to be scar and hurl Casablanca into the wildebeests?
- 22:56No you're not, because you had Casablanca going really far in
- 22:59your your bracket as well. And you don't.
- 23:02Like The Lion King that much? I had Vertigo going real far,
- 23:04Bob. I don't like Lion King that
- 23:06much. That's true.
- 23:07That's true. I don't Casablanca.
- 23:10Is safe for this round. I would.
- 23:11It is. Yeah, it is.
- 23:12All right. That takes us to our last match
- 23:14up here, which I think may be another coin flip, Brad, because
- 23:18we're talking about a movie that you apparently loathe the number
- 23:2111 seed singing in the rain up against the number six seed.
- 23:24Some like it hot. A movie that we did have
- 23:27conversation about last episode and both said it's it's a
- 23:30perfect movie. The problem here is that I kind
- 23:33of also think that Singing in the Rain is a perfect movie and
- 23:36just a vessel for God to impart the divine gift of joy unto
- 23:42mankind. Except for you.
- 23:45Bob, this is this is a classic Goodfellas experience where I I
- 23:50gave this movie at 8.5. Like I I like singing in the
- 23:54rain. I'm just not like, captivated by
- 23:57its spell. There are certain films where
- 24:00it's like almost more insulting that you found it to be an 8
- 24:02point, but I'd rather you'd be like, it didn't work for me 5
- 24:05out of 10 then like it's pretty good.
- 24:08Yeah, it's that's like how who lands on?
- 24:11It's pretty good. I mean, it's a pretty good.
- 24:14Movie. I like it it.
- 24:15It entertained me. OK, so fair to say you moved
- 24:19some like it hot on here. Oh, obviously some like it hot,
- 24:22OK. I'm gonna, I'm gonna force a
- 24:23coin flip. The thing is that I don't care
- 24:27if some like a hot wins here 'cause I I do love that movie.
- 24:29I just like genuinely, truly think Singing in the Rain
- 24:33deserves is on like a Mount Rushmore of all time movies and
- 24:37not for Brad. So whoa, A.
- 24:40Top four movie all time. Not necessarily for me, but if
- 24:47you look through the history of like the sight and sound pools
- 24:50and like the French auteurs and movie critics down through the
- 24:54years, it is like, I'm telling you, it's like Citizen Kane one
- 24:58or two out, like Tokyo Story, maybe Singing in the Rain is in
- 25:01there. It is just considered like an
- 25:03auteurist masterpiece that deserves to be studied until the
- 25:07Earth explodes someday like it is.
- 25:09I'm sorry, I don't understand that.
- 25:11That's wild. I think we should flip the coin.
- 25:14All right, I think some might get hot as heads here, as the
- 25:16sixth seed singing in the rain will be tails for perhaps the
- 25:19most consequential 1 yet. Brad, flip that coin.
- 25:32See, now we're getting a little variety.
- 25:33We have tails again. Singing in the Rain pulls out
- 25:40the upset. Brad clearly pissed on his end
- 25:43over there, and I love it, folks.
- 25:45So that completes our round of eights.
- 25:48Now, I'll go back to the beginning to read these.
- 25:49We've got Star Wars against West Side Story, Pulp Fiction versus
- 25:54Rear Window 12, Angry Men against Inglourious Basterds,
- 25:59and Casablanca versus Singing in the Rain.
- 26:02Brad, I think that is a perfect time for us to press pause.
- 26:05Let's take a quick break here and then we'll come back and do
- 26:08our round of eight. What do you say?
- 26:10I'm ready man. Let's do it.
- 26:16All right, we're jumping back into the bracket in the round of
- 26:19eight. I, you know, honestly, Brad, for
- 26:22having three coin flips in the round of 16, we moved through
- 26:24that pretty briskly. And I look through, you know,
- 26:28obviously season 1 is full of old movies, but it is, it's
- 26:32pretty funny how quickly the movies are getting older and
- 26:35older by round. And I think that speaks to, you
- 26:39know, not just that we like old movies, but that the ones in
- 26:42this season are kind of unimpeachable classic old
- 26:46movies. Brad.
- 26:47Yeah, absolutely. I like if not for Vertigo being
- 26:51against Star Wars and me enjoying chaos like sure Vertigo
- 26:56is in here. I almost the average age of
- 27:00these movies As I look through is the only two movies made in
- 27:07the 2000s are Quentin not even from like 1995 on.
- 27:11The only two movies are Quentin Tarantino films, and even then
- 27:16our our youngest movie is 19 years old.
- 27:20Like, these are some old films, Bob, and they're pretty much
- 27:24some of the greatest. Yeah, man.
- 27:26And you know, not to dive too quickly into this first match up
- 27:30here, but your boy's going to flip the coin again because
- 27:33we're talking about Star Wars versus West Side Story now.
- 27:37I don't think we need to state our cases too much.
- 27:40I do have one question that I'm curious about, Brad.
- 27:43You know, we've, we've talked through auteur theory a little
- 27:46bit on the podcast and at least what we think it means.
- 27:50And you know, I look at a movie like West Side Story versus Star
- 27:54Wars, and I think it would be very easy to say if you're kind
- 27:57of an authorist, West Side Story is the clear winner here because
- 28:00it has such a clear kind of direction, visual theme,
- 28:06understanding of Miss Anson and all these things.
- 28:10Sure. I do think there's an arcturist,
- 28:13obviously an arcturist argument to make for Star Wars.
- 28:15Like it's George Lucas creating this world that he would come to
- 28:18spend his entire career on after the fact.
- 28:21Yep. But I guess what I'm asking is
- 28:23if you put your sort of like analytical film guy hat on and
- 28:28you only could pick this match up based on that, do do you
- 28:33think that even for you, West Side Story would win that match
- 28:37up? Like as in like.
- 28:39Which one represents Otur theory more?
- 28:43Which one encapsulates like, yeah, cinema, whatever that
- 28:48means that that ephemeral term of cinema.
- 28:50Oh my gosh, think I would still. That's a tough one, man.
- 28:55I think I would still say Star Wars because it feels like such
- 29:01a singular vision like that. Like, yes, West Side Story is
- 29:06unique. I wouldn't say it's like
- 29:08completely separate from all of their musicals.
- 29:11I can't think of many movies that capture the hero's story,
- 29:18the incredible miniature work that Lucas and his team did with
- 29:25a driving story and action like that.
- 29:28He combines all those things. Like, sure, you have 2001 a
- 29:31Space Odyssey. That's not an action movie, you
- 29:34know what I mean? It's not a popcorn movie.
- 29:37So I, I think that Lucas captures a lot of different
- 29:41elements in a very unique way. And for me, I think that's kind
- 29:46of the hallmark of auteur theory is that it's a director who can
- 29:53take all the different elements of filmmaking and create
- 29:57something unique to them. Like Wes Anderson is an auteur
- 30:01because he has all the same equipment everybody else is
- 30:04using, and yet he creates movies in such a way that you know it's
- 30:08him when he makes it. I think the same could be said
- 30:11true for Lucas in the films that he makes.
- 30:14I'll be honest with you, Bob. I don't remember who directed
- 30:17West Side Story. So.
- 30:19It's 'cause you're a casual, 'cause you are not a ball
- 30:22knower, Brad, it's Robert Wise. Yeah, but there's another guy
- 30:26directing it, right? And he got like fired.
- 30:29Jerome Robbins, Yeah, he got booted.
- 30:31They said get out of here. You can't call it an author
- 30:33movie if two different people directed the film.
- 30:36Get out of here. And on that note, it is time to
- 30:40flip that coin. I do wish that West Side Stories
- 30:44extended cast of characters got their own movie The way that
- 30:48Star Wars extended cast of characters do.
- 30:50I would like to see Baby John and Grogu like that.
- 30:54I would. I would go watch that movie in a
- 30:55heartbeat. If Disney made it though.
- 30:59Yeah, no, it wouldn't be any good.
- 31:00Flip the coin. All righty, we have another
- 31:14Tales victory, which means my boy, my boy, Georgie Luke is
- 31:21heading on dude. Why did you do this dude?
- 31:25This could have been Vertigo. I'm happy as a clam right now.
- 31:30You did. You knew you were going to do
- 31:32this. You came in this night knowing
- 31:33you were going to do this. I I feel it in my bones.
- 31:36I am. I am as happy as Walter Houston
- 31:39when he stares dead into the camera.
- 31:43You you my friend, are Dumber than the dumbest Jackass.
- 31:48And that takes us to our next match up, the four seed Pulp
- 31:51Fiction up against the five seed rear window.
- 31:55This might be the I mean, it's not as hard for me 'cause I
- 32:00think Rear Window's perfect, but just in general, this might be
- 32:03the toughest match up of the entire bracket, Brad.
- 32:06I I would agree. With you 4 versus.
- 32:07Five Yeah, I, I would agree with you.
- 32:10I think Rear Window I, I here's the problem.
- 32:13I think both of them are perfect films in their own way.
- 32:18I think I, I think I lean towards Pulp Fiction because of
- 32:23Samuel's speech at the end of the movie.
- 32:27Like there's some, oh dude, there's something about the end
- 32:30of a movie that has a good resonant ending and the idea of
- 32:36a man who has come face to face with God and just wants to be
- 32:42better. He's just trying Bob.
- 32:45That just that hit me. Dude, I've seen that scene.
- 32:50I was obsessed with this movie when I was in high school.
- 32:53Dude obsessed with this movie and I have watched this scene so
- 32:57many times that I can play it in my mind like a DVD now.
- 33:01And the moment when he he shifts his weight and he kind of
- 33:05squints his eyes like he's focusing extra hard on on Ringo
- 33:10when he says the truth is and he leans in and points the gun at
- 33:14him and says you're the weak. It's just it's the best line
- 33:19reading of all time. Brad.
- 33:22It's it's so good. He should have won an Oscar.
- 33:25Yeah, it's AB. It's stunningly good.
- 33:28It is Samuel L Jackson at his absolute peak.
- 33:31And I like, I love Rear Window Man.
- 33:34I would watch it 9 times out of 10 if you put it up against ten
- 33:38other movies. I think I'm taking Pulp Fiction
- 33:40on this one. I don't mind that dude and like
- 33:44I I think I am going to take Rear Window here.
- 33:46Not just because I want to force a coin flip, but because these
- 33:50movies are so close in my mind that on any given day, I think I
- 33:53would pick either one of them. And so a coin flip is kind of
- 33:57the only way for me to to hash this out.
- 34:00I'm happy with whichever one wins.
- 34:02Pulp Fiction will be heads in this scenario, and Rear Window
- 34:06will be tails. So Brad for a spot.
- 34:10Oh, you look like you're gonna make a joke about the rear.
- 34:12What I'll I'll give you, I'll give you an option.
- 34:16I'm gonna give you an out. Robert, Are you ready?
- 34:21You're going to. Let me have rear window as long
- 34:23as I agree to a coin flip against Star Wars and no.
- 34:27I will let you have both of them if one of them replaces
- 34:32Casablanca on the other side of the bracket.
- 34:35Oh interesting. Well, I guess that depends on
- 34:38how hard are you going to ride for 12 Angry Men or Inglorious
- 34:41Basterds. That's that's a that is a
- 34:44something that I know and you don't.
- 34:47Yeah, I don't care. We're going to flip this coin,
- 34:49dude. This is, we have to do this the
- 34:50way nature and God intended us to do it, and that is via chaos.
- 34:54So Pulp Fiction, Heads, Rear Window Tails, Brad, Flip that
- 34:58coin. Dude, see this?
- 35:10I told you, man, we got a few tails in here.
- 35:13Look at that, that that coin got pissed.
- 35:17Off at you for criticizing it publicly so much.
- 35:20It did. Rear Window is into the Final
- 35:23Four, so I think surprisingly to both of us, Brad, our our two
- 35:28entrants on this side of the bracket, Star Wars in Rear
- 35:30Window, I don't think either of us had that in our bracket.
- 35:33No what? What did you have for the bottom
- 35:36bracket? I I don't have my bracket pulled
- 35:39up, I either had Vertigo or West Side Story coming out of the top
- 35:42and I had Rear window coming out of the bottom here.
- 35:44Oh OK, alright, yeah, no, I had Vertigo and Pulp Fiction, so my
- 35:50western half of the bracket. Shot dude is.
- 35:52Done for. Well, why don't you take us over
- 35:56to the right side of the bracket here Brad, as we look at our
- 35:59first match up in the top right quadrant.
- 36:02Yeah, We are looking at the number two overall seed 12 angry
- 36:07men versus Inglourious Basterds. Now I will I will say if we're
- 36:13continuing on with our theme of who could fight 12 angry men, I
- 36:18think the Bear Jew would have a good chance.
- 36:21You give him that baseball bat. Yeah, that that doesn't seem
- 36:24like it'd actually be very hard at all, Brad.
- 36:26But but here's the thing, Henry Fonda gets the knife that he
- 36:31stabs into the. Table switchblade.
- 36:32That's it. That's true, man.
- 36:36We're just creating better sequels for both of these
- 36:39movies. All right, look, I I picked the
- 36:41great escape in the last round against this.
- 36:44I like Inglorious Basterds a lot.
- 36:45I think the great escape very narrowly edged it out for me.
- 36:49I don't think it holds a candle to 12 angry men 12 angry men's
- 36:52another perfect movie. And so for me, this is like this
- 36:55is a no brainer. I I moved 12 angry men on pretty
- 36:57easily. Man, I so I gave 12 Angry Men
- 37:03and Inglourious Basterds a 10 out of 10.
- 37:08I like I love both of these. Movies for Inglorious?
- 37:11I didn't know that. And I gave I in my vibe
- 37:14rankings, I put 12 Angry men at 4:00 and I put Inglourious
- 37:18Basterds AT5I. I love both of these movies, Bob
- 37:22I I think they both I will say, unlike last round and talking
- 37:27about great escape, 12 angry men is consistently A9 or 9 1/2.
- 37:35Like the lowest point of that movie might be a nine out of 10.
- 37:40And it's probably when the judge is like, telling them to go back
- 37:44into the room, and then they're in the room and it's at least a
- 37:479 1/2 out of 10. The rest of the movie, like,
- 37:50right. Like, it is a perfect movie
- 37:53through and through. Inglourious Basterds has some
- 37:56slow moments. We talked about it.
- 37:57It dips a little bit. It dips a little bit and it's
- 38:00whenever the Inglourious Basterds are like doing things.
- 38:03On the screen, yeah. Yeah, anytime anybody else is on
- 38:06the screen, it's great. Now, the one exception to that
- 38:08is the bar scene. But even that, it's like, not
- 38:11all the bastards, it's just a few of them.
- 38:13And who's the actress? Kruger.
- 38:18Diane Kruger. Diane Kruger.
- 38:20Yeah, yeah, it's like them and her and the German guy and it's
- 38:23great. Anyways, I, I want to see, I'm
- 38:30going to once again, Bob, I'm going to go against what I
- 38:36picked and I'm going to choose 12 Angry Men to move on.
- 38:41Yeah, you are. I I just, oh, I know I can't.
- 38:45I can't put in glorious over it. At the other listen, at the end
- 38:49of the day, you're being consistent because Star Wars was
- 38:52your number 2, Vertigo was your three and you picked Star Wars.
- 38:55That's true. Angry Men was your four and
- 38:57Glorious is your 5. Like, that's just, that's how
- 38:59the ranking shook out my friend. Dude, I, I mean, I've screwed
- 39:03myself out of two of my four final four.
- 39:09I might just have to do the same thing once we get down to our
- 39:12bottom right bracket, which is the number three seed Casablanca
- 39:17versus the number 11 seed Singing in the Rain.
- 39:21This, I can't, I can't do that. Bob Casablanca's moving on.
- 39:25I love Casablanca. It's an incredible film.
- 39:28If some Like It Hot was here, I might want to play a little
- 39:33chaos and choose it. But Singing in the Rain is a
- 39:37garbage movie for garbage people, so.
- 39:40I have a couple confessions to make.
- 39:42Brad, this is our confession. I'm, I'm 3.
- 39:45Is it a, is it a Dashboard Confessional?
- 39:50Yeah, it's a Dashboard Confessional.
- 39:51It sure is. Now I've watched Casablanca 2
- 39:55times in the last year. My perhaps my favorite movie of
- 39:58all time after having not watched it in about 5 years.
- 40:02And there is a section in the middle and I can, I can pinpoint
- 40:06the exact moment. It's when it's it's the daytime
- 40:09after. The eventful first night and he
- 40:12runs into Ilsa out in the bazaar when she's looking at things.
- 40:15And then they go visit Sydney Green Street at the Blue Parrot
- 40:18and talk to him for a while. And I thought to myself, this is
- 40:22boring. This section of this movie is
- 40:24boring. And I've never felt this way
- 40:26before. And I stuffed that down because
- 40:28I said, you can't say that about Casablanca.
- 40:30It's your favorite movie. You're not allowed to.
- 40:32Then I watched it a second time and I was like, Oh my God, is
- 40:37Casablanca closer to a nine and a half than a 10 for you now,
- 40:41Bob? And I stuffed that down within
- 40:44me. And then when I did my bracket,
- 40:47I had this match up and I remembered my son, who was three
- 40:54years old at the time, wanting to watch Singing in the Rain
- 40:58because he loved the dancing and he wanted to watch the Singing
- 41:01in the Rain number. He wanted to watch, Moses
- 41:03supposes, and he wanted to watch Make Him Laugh.
- 41:06And when he watched Donald O'Connor doing Make Him Laugh, I
- 41:09was like, this is what movies are about, dude.
- 41:13I'm watching my kid fall in love with one of my favorite movies,
- 41:18not because of something I did, but because it just freaking
- 41:21works, man. And hopefully someday he'll fall
- 41:25in love with Casablanca the way I did.
- 41:26But at this moment of my life, Brad, if I had to pick one movie
- 41:32to save from the fiery furnace for my children's sake, I think
- 41:38it's singing in the rain, Brad. I I like that you've placed this
- 41:42now that I am the destroyer of your children's no.
- 41:46I'm just telling you, like, for me to to willingly let
- 41:50Casablanca go into the fiery furnace there, there had to be
- 41:53some monumental shift. And I think what I'm telling you
- 41:55is I'm experiencing that now in fatherhood.
- 41:59Yeah. And I think singing in the rain
- 42:01at this moment is more near and dear to my heart, even though if
- 42:05I'm making a list of like, best movies ever, it's behind
- 42:08Casablanca. Yeah.
- 42:10I don't know, it's like it's like second hand Lions for You
- 42:12is behind a lot of movies on the best movies ever list, but like
- 42:16it's going to be in your final four movies.
- 42:19Second Hand Lions, a movie that was quoted of Robert Duvall's
- 42:26movies. That is the movie they chose.
- 42:28The quote from Bob that's going to come up every time Second
- 42:31Hand Lions comes up on this podcast from here on out.
- 42:34If this. Ends very anticlimactically here
- 42:37with an easy Casablanca coin flip victory.
- 42:40Like that's fine. I just had to say I I should
- 42:43have known when I offered you to get rid of Casablanca and keep
- 42:48Rear Window OR Pulp Fiction and you didn't even say anything.
- 42:52You're like, yeah, maybe I could do that.
- 42:54I should have known you. You're traitor.
- 42:57You don't. You don't.
- 42:58Actually, I would still pick Singing in the Rain over both
- 43:01those movies 'cause if Casablanca's my favorite movie
- 43:03and those other two aren't, and I'm still picking Singing in the
- 43:06Rain here, what does that tell you, man?
- 43:08I I love my children that I'm gonna I'm think I'm gonna call
- 43:12Wellness check on you, but let's let's get this coin for.
- 43:15My children. All right.
- 43:17Casablanca is heads. Singing in the rain is tails.
- 43:20Brad, flip that coin. Robert Casablanca will be moving
- 43:35on. We have finally.
- 43:37Casablanca moves on. As I said, it ended anti
- 43:40climactically, but it did not go down without a fight.
- 43:42So thank you to Singing in the Rain.
- 43:45But we have our final four films, Brad, 1977's Star Wars,
- 43:51the most recent film, our final 41954's Rear Window, 1957's 12
- 43:59Angry Men and 1942's Casablanca. Looking at this list of four, I
- 44:07very easily can identify my championship match up.
- 44:10Brad does. Do you have one in mind?
- 44:12Does one stick out to you pretty quickly here too?
- 44:15Oh man, I I would say it feels pretty obvious to me who the
- 44:23winner's who the winner's gonna be.
- 44:26I could tell that there's a coin flip coming pretty quickly in
- 44:29our next episode, Brad. But folks, that will do it for
- 44:34us today. Now, if you've been following
- 44:35along with your own film and whiskey bracket, especially if
- 44:38you're following us on social media, you will know that we are
- 44:41giving out some prizes to people who are completing their film
- 44:45and whiskey bracket and letting us know their winner.
- 44:48So we will be tagging winners in our social media posts.
- 44:51If you have not yet downloaded your film and whiskey bracket,
- 44:55it is not too late to do so. You see how we're shaking out.
- 44:57But we want to know what your final four movies would be and
- 45:01especially what your Film and Whiskey Season 10 champion would
- 45:04be. So go to filmwhiskey.com.
- 45:06That is film whiskey with an E dot com.
- 45:09You'll see the bracket challenge button right up in the
- 45:12navigation bar. You can download and fill out
- 45:14your own bracket there. Brad, where else should we send
- 45:17to the folks as we sign off for the day?
- 45:19Man, head over to our Discord. We're talking about movies,
- 45:22We're talking about brackets, We're talking about book clubs.
- 45:25Apparently you can find a link to our Discord server at the end
- 45:29of every single one of our show notes.
- 45:32Don't forget about the Patreon page, folks.
- 45:34For just $3 a month, you get access to everything we offer.
- 45:38And if you want to give us a little more, we won't say no to
- 45:40that either, but there are special video episodes.
- 45:43There's going to be a book club now if you'd like to join the
- 45:45Film and Whiskey Book Club, $3 a month, baby, come talk about
- 45:48Sidney Lumet with us. You can find us on
- 45:50patreon.com/filmwhiskey. That will do it for us today.
- 45:56We'll be back next week to finish out the season 10
- 45:59bracket, to talk about our favorite whiskeys of the season
- 46:02as well, and to give out the filmies the best Movie Awards
- 46:06there are. Brad.
- 46:07That's right, and it won't be a four hour telecast.
- 46:11It will not, Not this time. All right, so until next week,
- 46:15I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad.
- 46:16Gee. And we'll see you next time.