Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The End of 280E? IRS Enforcement, Transition Rules, and What Attorneys Must Know
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the end of 280 Cap E. I .S. Enforcement
- 0:08Transition Rules and What Attorneys Must Know.
- 0:11My name is Philipp Behren, Chair of the BHPA
- 0:13Taxation Law Section. The tax section is sponsored
- 0:17by Hochmann, Zorc and Torscher Perez. The Hochmann,
- 0:19Zorc and Torscher Perez advantageous experience,
- 0:22an eye for innovation and a genuine dedication
- 0:24for clients, their families and their business.
- 0:27In addition to their national practice in civil
- 0:29and tax, civil tax and criminal tax controversy
- 0:33and related litigation in federal and state courts.
- 0:36The firm is also active and successful in handling
- 0:39other non -tax white collar investigations and
- 0:42prosecutions. If you want to join our tax section
- 0:46every Thursday of the month at 4 p .m. we are
- 0:53happily inviting you to meet us. And I'm delighted
- 0:59to introduce our speakers today, Annie Galian
- 1:01and Jonathan Kalinsky. Annie is the founder of
- 1:06Galan Law. She is an attorney and certified tax
- 1:09specialist with the State Bar of California.
- 1:12In addition, Annie is a certified public accountant
- 1:14admitted to practice in California. She also
- 1:17holds the LLM. She was recognized as Southern
- 1:21California Super Lawyers Rising Stars in 2016
- 1:24through 2022. Annie has a knack for recognizing
- 1:28emerging industries and becoming a well -informed
- 1:30tax advisor to her clients within the specialty
- 1:33area. She focuses her practice in the area of
- 1:37tax law for federal, state and local tax compliance,
- 1:40tax disputes and tax crimes. She routinely represents
- 1:44US taxpayers in civil tax examinations with sensitive
- 1:47tax issues. She has been in the forefront of
- 1:51representing cannabis operators in the state
- 1:53of California and all aspects of federal, state,
- 1:57and local tax compliance matters. Jonathan Kalinske
- 2:00is principal at Hochmann Solke Torscher Press
- 2:02and specializes in both civil and criminal tax
- 2:06controversies as well as sensitive tax matters
- 2:09including disclosures of previously undeclared
- 2:11interests in foreign financial accounts and assets
- 2:15and provides tax advice to taxpayers and their
- 2:18advisors throughout the world. He handles both
- 2:20federal and state tax matters involving individuals,
- 2:23corporations, partnerships, limited liability
- 2:26companies, and trust at the states. Annie, Jonathan,
- 2:29please take it away. Thank you for the introduction
- 2:33and welcome everyone. With the focus on changes
- 2:39in the cannabis space, we thought this would
- 2:41be a good presentation to talk about. Um, on
- 2:44the federal level, what is going on and is really
- 2:47to rescheduling going to end. So, the focus of
- 2:52the presentation will be mostly on federal. We
- 2:55won't touch on state issues and. Maybe in the
- 2:58future, we'll have a state program on cannabis.
- 3:01But moving forward, just a disclaimer. Um. You
- 3:05know, whatever we say here is not to be taken
- 3:08as tax advice and you should seek your own counsel
- 3:12with regards to your clients. You know, going
- 3:15to the next slide. Where are we now in cannabis?
- 3:20Cannabis was legalized going back to the origins
- 3:24in 1973 just to give some background when Oregon
- 3:28as the first state reduced penalties for small
- 3:31amounts of cannabis. Fast forward to the next
- 3:36level of legalization was California in 1996
- 3:39when we saw a medical cannabis being allowed
- 3:44in the state of California. And then the next
- 3:47wave started the adult abuse legalization, which
- 3:49was 2012 with Washington and Colorado and then
- 3:53California soon following in 2016. Since then,
- 3:58we've seen, if you can see on the map, legalization
- 4:00across various states on different levels, with
- 4:04only currently four states disallowing cannabis
- 4:07at all levels. But we see anywhere from adult
- 4:10legalization to medical legalization, as well
- 4:14as THC and CBD legalization for states such as
- 4:18Texas. Why this is significant is because we're
- 4:22starting to see a shift in public's approach
- 4:26to cannabis and also state's approach to cannabis,
- 4:30where individuals and citizens are not viewing
- 4:33this as a legal activity, as well as states are
- 4:37looking for new sources of revenue in the form
- 4:40of excise tax and sales tax and other cannabis
- 4:43-related taxes. With the wave of shift towards
- 4:48the public opinion towards legalization, we are
- 4:52moving forward to rescheduling of cannabis. Next
- 4:56slide, please. Just a little history, cannabis
- 4:59is a schedule one narcotic or schedule one product
- 5:05under the Control Substances Act, which says
- 5:07that there's no medical use for cannabis. Since
- 5:12that, 50 years has passed since scheduling of
- 5:16cannabis as a Schedule 1 substance. Now, with
- 5:21research and recommendations, cannabis has found
- 5:25to have medical use. And so we're starting to
- 5:30see a shift in pushing for rescheduling from
- 5:33Schedule 1 to Schedule 3 under the Controlled
- 5:36Substances Act. In 2023, the Department of Health
- 5:41and Human Services made the recommendation that
- 5:44cannabis should be rescheduled from schedule
- 5:47one to schedule three because there is a currently
- 5:51accepted medical use in the United States. We
- 5:55haven't seen any movement towards this rescheduling
- 5:58since that recommendation. There has been some
- 6:03movement with the Department of DEA with comments
- 6:10and whatnot, but nothing really has happened.
- 6:12And the industry is impatiently waiting to see
- 6:16the next steps. Next slide, please. And then
- 6:22we got great news in December of 2025. President
- 6:26Trump issued the executive order, which says
- 6:29that cannabis should be rescheduled from schedule
- 6:33one to schedule three, and this process should
- 6:35be expedited to move forward. However, this does
- 6:39not mean that cannabis has been rescheduled,
- 6:43does not mean that it is now. control substances
- 6:48category three, this is still a category one.
- 6:52The industry has taken this as a shift in the
- 6:57industry. However, this does not elevate some
- 7:00of the issues that the industry still has with
- 7:03banking and section 280E, which we will talk
- 7:07about momentarily. The next steps would be that
- 7:12the necessary steps have to be taken to make
- 7:16the rescheduling happen. This will move things
- 7:21along in the needle, but when it will happen,
- 7:24we don't know, and there's no current pathway
- 7:27of when that will happen. Next up. I want to
- 7:32add over here just a quick comment is that I
- 7:37think anecdotally, at least listening to people
- 7:41in the industry, got very excited when this came
- 7:46out. But here we are three, four months later
- 7:50and it really has been much ado about nothing
- 7:55to this point. And in terms of tax law, we're
- 8:03in the same space. essentially nothing has changed.
- 8:08This may or may not be an indication of things
- 8:11to come, but right now it's essentially fluff.
- 8:19And for those who are unwise and decide to take
- 8:25this as a direction to change the tax position
- 8:30on your return, I would just caution that and
- 8:35say you're asking for trouble. And the executive
- 8:40order is not just tax related. There are other
- 8:43implications with regards to research and banking.
- 8:48And this does not mean that these issues have
- 8:51been elevated or changed. We are still in the
- 8:55land that we were in before. And there are. lawmakers
- 8:59who are against scheduling or rescheduling. So
- 9:03where this will go, we don't know. It is just
- 9:06that this has been issued and we are watching
- 9:08this closely and it can't have implications to
- 9:13how individuals or companies are doing their
- 9:16financials, modeling their financials, and also
- 9:20looking forward to the next steps in the industry.
- 9:23However, we're going to focus on how this will
- 9:26impact tax matters for our operators here in
- 9:29California and how they move forward in filing
- 9:31their income tax returns and classifying their
- 9:35activities under IRC Section 280E. So moving
- 9:39to the next slide. If you work in this space,
- 9:44you know that IRC 280. Oh, can we go back to
- 9:47the slide? Sorry. Thank you. IRC section 280e
- 9:50is the law of the land right now, and it applies
- 9:53to schedule well control substances, which cannabis
- 9:57is still classified under. What this section
- 10:01means is that operators can no longer take a
- 10:04deduction for their business expenses or credits.
- 10:08We just saw a recent case. him California out
- 10:11of San Diego ruling that cannabis operators are
- 10:14ineligible for The employment retention credit
- 10:17which comes also comes under section 280e So
- 10:20it's important to keep in mind its deductions
- 10:23as well as credits and incurred in the trade
- 10:27or business This does not include cost of goods
- 10:30So and the definition of cost of goods sold varies
- 10:33whether an operator is a retailer licensed under
- 10:38the state as a retailer or even certain distributors
- 10:42who are not adding any value and are deemed as
- 10:45a retail companies. And those operators who are
- 10:50holding cultivation licenses, manufacturing licenses,
- 10:54to some degree some distributors who are adding
- 10:56value. to the product. So you're either a retailer
- 11:01or you are a manufacturer distributor. And the
- 11:04way you compute your cost of goods sold will
- 11:07fall under those categories. So it's important
- 11:10to know what type of operator you are dealing
- 11:12with, what type of a license they hold, how they
- 11:16operate, how their expenses are spread out across
- 11:19the various departments. If you have an operator
- 11:22who holds a microbusiness license, which means
- 11:25an operator who can do all levels of activity
- 11:28here in the state, it's very important to know
- 11:31how to classify these expenses for Section 280E
- 11:35purposes because it will come down in how the
- 11:38operators are computing their cost of goods sold
- 11:41if they're adhering to the 280E rules. I will
- 11:45say that some operators have put 280E aside and
- 11:49are taking the risk with operating and computing
- 11:54and filing their income tax returns without any
- 11:57regards to Section 280E. And I don't know if
- 11:59Jonathan wants to add any comment to that before
- 12:01we move on. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I've had conversations
- 12:05with folks who take that position. I don't advise
- 12:13that position. I think it's problematic for a
- 12:16practitioner to advise. that position. Even if
- 12:21your plan is to subsequently then challenge that
- 12:25position in court, I think advising on that position
- 12:32on a return that's being filed, whether you're
- 12:36signing the return or not, presents a problem.
- 12:42Several courts of different jurisdictions have
- 12:45addressed the legality of 280e. And to this point,
- 12:49it's the law of the land. It's been upheld. Certainly
- 12:54in tax court, it's been upheld several times.
- 12:57That's not to say tomorrow and the new challenges
- 13:00that are currently pending before several courts
- 13:03may not change things. But filing a return with
- 13:11the plan of ignoring 280e, I think is asking
- 13:17for litigation. And I think those folks may say,
- 13:23yes, we know we're asking for litigation. Bring
- 13:25it on. That's sort of the intention of some of
- 13:30these. But be that as it may, I think you are
- 13:36risking having your client face big tax liability
- 13:41penalties. And potentially, depending on where
- 13:46you are positioned, you could face prepare penalties
- 13:51or different types of sanctions in endorsing
- 13:57a position that may be considered at some points
- 14:01frivolous unless the rules change. Again, that
- 14:07doesn't mean we have to agree with the position
- 14:09and think it's right and just. But my view is
- 14:14that's the rule of the land. And until that changes,
- 14:20that's the way taxpayers should be filing their
- 14:24returns. That doesn't mean, and we'll get into
- 14:29this later, that if it creates a tax liability
- 14:31that your business can't pay, that there are
- 14:34no alternatives, okay? That you can't, knowing
- 14:39280 exists, structure your business in such a
- 14:43way to minimize those effects. Just one example,
- 14:48you will almost always see cannabis companies
- 14:51operate as a C corporation because if there's
- 14:54going to be a tax liability because of the effects
- 14:58of 280, that liability sits at the corporate
- 15:00level. instead of an S corporation where liability
- 15:06would sit at the 1040 level and may put the assets
- 15:09of the individual owners at risk in a way that
- 15:14a C corporation doesn't. So there are other ways
- 15:17to address those issues. And just simply saying,
- 15:23yeah, we're going to take the position that 280E
- 15:26doesn't exist, I don't think is the right strategy,
- 15:32but to each their own. And I want to add that
- 15:35Section 280 does not just hit those licensed
- 15:38operators. It hits also unlicensed operators,
- 15:41but it also hits management companies who have
- 15:44been organized by operators, whether it's to
- 15:47get around 280E, banking, or just tax planning.
- 15:52purposes. And we've seen courts take a strict
- 15:54rule that 280e does apply to management companies.
- 15:59So it's really important to consider what type
- 16:02of business your operators are in, how their
- 16:05choice of entity and how their business structure
- 16:08will be impacted by 280e. And we see in management
- 16:12companies that 280e, because they don't have
- 16:14cost of goods sold, pretty much taxes the operators
- 16:17at gross receipts level. There's no deductions
- 16:20allowed for those level of those companies. So
- 16:25moving on, what scheduling does change? Rescheduling
- 16:29is important for the industry because it will.
- 16:31Get rid of 28080. 28080 will no longer be applicable.
- 16:35So there's burden that cannabis operators being
- 16:38treated differently, being hit with is essentially
- 16:41a harsh penalty for being in this industry will
- 16:44no longer be applicable. However, this does not
- 16:48mean that this also applies for past years. And
- 16:52we'll get a little bit into that when we speak
- 16:53about IRS collection. But 280E is moving forward
- 16:57as long as far as we know at the moment. We don't
- 17:00have any indication that it's going to be applied
- 17:03retractively to prior years. It will let cannabis
- 17:07operators function just like any other business
- 17:10when they're doing, whether it's tax spending,
- 17:13financial planning, hopefully applying for banking,
- 17:16which we'll talk about in a little bit later.
- 17:18But it normalizes the industry without having
- 17:21this 280E burden imposed on them. Okay, moving
- 17:28on to the next slide here. What it does not change
- 17:32is cannabis is still a regulated industry. It
- 17:37is still regulated by the state. It is still
- 17:40regulated by the federal government. It does
- 17:43not make cannabis legal for adult use across
- 17:4650 states. It also does not eliminate 280e for
- 17:52past matters, right? So if you have past matters
- 17:55that you need to deal with, whether it's filing
- 17:58returns for past years or dealing with IRS collection
- 18:02for returns that have been filed, it does not
- 18:06await those issues, okay? IRS can continue to
- 18:10apply 280e in IRS audits. It can also apply,
- 18:14as far as we know right now, 280e in collection
- 18:17issues unless that rule is changed in the Internal
- 18:21Revenue Manual. For states that do not have consistent
- 18:26compliance or consistent 2ADE application, this
- 18:33will also have implications for them. Here in
- 18:37California, the state of California, the conformity
- 18:41is no longer an issue with the federal government,
- 18:44so 2ADE is not an issue for Cannabis operators
- 18:47here in this state, whether you're in corporation,
- 18:50an LLC, or an individual filing these returns.
- 18:54So it's important to keep in mind that rescheduling
- 18:57does not mean that now cannabis is legal and
- 19:00you can walk into any store and buy cannabis
- 19:03within your jurisdiction. Okay. So with the change,
- 19:10I'm going to shift it over to Jonathan to speak
- 19:13on IRS examinations and how that's going to be
- 19:17impacted. Thank you, Ani. So IRS examinations
- 19:25of cannabis companies have been around for many
- 19:29years. I would say that they've waxed and waned
- 19:33a little bit over those years. And I think we're
- 19:37currently in a period that if you look at IRS
- 19:44enforcement in general is down. Staffing is down.
- 19:50And that's had an impact across the board. But
- 19:54we're still seeing cannabis companies at various
- 20:00levels of the industry being audited. I would
- 20:06expect that to continue. I wouldn't say that
- 20:11there is an increase in cannabis audits at the
- 20:16moment. I think it's sort of been at a fairly
- 20:21steady level as audits go up, those go up, as
- 20:25audits go down, those would go down. And we'll
- 20:30just have to wait and see. with current staffing
- 20:33levels and enforcement at the IRS, how things
- 20:37change into the future. And broadly speaking,
- 20:43enforcement, I think, is at a crossroads. And
- 20:49again, we'll just wait and see how things develop.
- 20:51So if you are unlucky enough, to have a client
- 20:56be examined, you're going to have an initial
- 21:00audit letter. And usually that audit letter is
- 21:03going to be accompanied by an information document
- 21:07request. That information document request number
- 21:11one is generally a very broad request that is
- 21:17going to ask for books and records, copy of the
- 21:21return, copy of any returns for related entities,
- 21:29W -2s, 1099s, sort of all third party information
- 21:34reporting that has taken place. It's going to
- 21:39want... general ledger, it may want various,
- 21:43you know, a P &L, it may want an income statement,
- 21:46sort of your basic documents, bank statements
- 21:51for one or all accounts that are there. It may
- 21:56ask for credit card statements, if there is a
- 21:59credit card involved, just depends. That IDR
- 22:06may seem very burdensome, but it's often a very
- 22:11typical IDR that you're going to see in any case.
- 22:15It's not generally an IDR that says you're in
- 22:19extra trouble because you're in the cannabis
- 22:22business. There very much can be specifics that
- 22:27we'll get into because of cannabis, but that
- 22:31sort of initial broad -based IDR at the outset
- 22:34is what you see in almost every case. Some of
- 22:39the differences that you're going to see in a
- 22:42cannabis audit will be the agent's insistence
- 22:47early on that there be tour of the facilities.
- 22:53And taking, for example, a retail shop, they're
- 22:57going to want to see the operation because if
- 23:00you are claiming cost of goods sold in putting
- 23:04labor as a component to that cost of goods sold,
- 23:08but your shop is really just a retail floor selling
- 23:13product, that may be an issue. If you have a
- 23:18separate part of your facility that maybe only
- 23:22deals with the product and it's not your retail
- 23:27floor, that may be in your favor. But these are
- 23:32the things that the IRS wants to see and coming
- 23:36out initially and saying, no, no, no, you can't
- 23:39come to my facility is not the way to start an
- 23:43audit out on the right foot in a very combative
- 23:47way. The other thing you will see both in cannabis
- 23:53and in other businesses is the IRS is going to
- 23:57want that initial interview. Several years ago,
- 24:02through a FOIA request, the IRS released their
- 24:08training guide for cannabis audits and highlighted
- 24:12the importance of this initial interview and
- 24:16the importance of it being done early because
- 24:19it said later on in the audit people tend to
- 24:23get hire a representative and you'll get better
- 24:27information if you can get the interview done
- 24:29earlier before they hire. That obviously didn't
- 24:32sit well with the practitioner community as well
- 24:36it shouldn't have and that's a tactic. that the
- 24:39IRS is using to try to trip up a taxpayer and
- 24:43get them to say things that a representative
- 24:46would advise them not to say, whether that's
- 24:49to invoke their Fifth Amendment rights or just
- 24:51to answer questions differently. That's not a
- 24:55practitioner trying to be difficult, but the
- 25:00take home here is if you have a client or you
- 25:03are the client, and you get this audit letter,
- 25:08immediately talk to somebody like Ani or myself
- 25:11who handles these type of cases. Don't start
- 25:15going down the audit path and having an interview
- 25:18and only later saying, oh geez, I wish I should
- 25:21have hired a representative. I kind of want to
- 25:23rewind and say things differently because often
- 25:28it'll be too late. And if there are some real
- 25:31problems with the books and records, okay, that
- 25:35case may already be down a path for a fraud referral
- 25:38or if things really go bad, a criminal referral.
- 25:43So at the very outset, once that audit letter
- 25:46is received, it's time to, I think, get a representative
- 25:51involved and plan the strategy. My preference
- 25:58is that the client is not going to be interviewed
- 26:01if I can help it. Okay. Sometimes you have no
- 26:04choice, but I'd like to postpone that interview
- 26:07for as long as possible. Okay. I can provide
- 26:11the information as far as documents go and have
- 26:15a discussion with the revenue agent. But oftentimes
- 26:19I don't want the client interviewed. I don't
- 26:21want the client put in the proverbial hot seat.
- 26:25But that's a case by case. analysis that you're
- 26:29going to make with your client to have them understand
- 26:33the pros and cons of talking to the government.
- 26:37So all this, again, is going to happen fairly
- 26:41early in the audit. Once the audit gets rolling,
- 26:48you know, I think, what the IRS is going to look
- 26:51at in a cannabis audit. Number one is cost of
- 26:55goods sold. Have you shoved everything into cost
- 26:59of goods sold such that you're zeroing out the
- 27:01effects of 280. I've seen it and it becomes a
- 27:06problem, obviously. They're going to look at
- 27:09deductions. If you are a cannabis touching entity
- 27:12and you should be abiding by 280, do you have
- 27:17deductions on your return that you should not
- 27:20have? One of the issues that I see increasingly,
- 27:25and this is a trickier one, is does 280E apply
- 27:29to this business? Oftentimes in the structures,
- 27:36there are several different entities involved,
- 27:39some of which are sufficiently isolated that
- 27:43they really don't touch cannabis. I think the
- 27:47position can be taken that 280 does not apply
- 27:50to that business. This is a little different
- 27:53than what Ani was talking about earlier in terms
- 27:56of a management company. Often what you see in
- 27:59the management company is let's just set up an
- 28:02S corporation, shove all the wages that we couldn't
- 28:06deduct, shove all the other expenses and call
- 28:09it management Inc and then take deductions. tax
- 28:14court has heard that case, that case doesn't
- 28:17work. But when you have a separate entities that
- 28:24handle different aspects of a business, and some
- 28:28have nothing to do with cannabis, one may be,
- 28:31for example, a real estate related entity. I
- 28:34would argue 280 does not apply to that. So those
- 28:39issues I think are very much at the forefront.
- 28:43It's not always 280e, does it apply? Did you
- 28:47deduct this? Not that. It's looking at, does
- 28:51280e even apply to this entity at the outset?
- 28:55And if it doesn't, you're just like any other
- 28:58business and you should be entitled to your deductions.
- 29:03One of the other things that is important here
- 29:07but no different from a regular audit to cannabis,
- 29:11is the IRS is going to issue a third party contact
- 29:15letter. This is required. This has nothing to
- 29:17do with cannabis. It's required notice that if
- 29:21the IRS intends to contact third parties, they
- 29:24will issue taxpayer notice. And then you can
- 29:29follow up with the agent and ask who in fact
- 29:33has been contacted, if anybody. But again, these
- 29:38may be typically banks in cannabis. Again, that
- 29:42could be Bank of America, Wells Fargo, the big
- 29:44banks, but very well could be some of the credit
- 29:48unions and the sort of cannabis specialty banks
- 29:53that you see very much contacted. They could
- 29:57contact your vendors. If you're retail, they
- 30:00could contact the people who supply to you. do
- 30:05all kinds of third party contacts. They could
- 30:08contact your employees and figure out what's
- 30:13going on. Again, the aim is, are your cost of
- 30:17goods sold accurately reported? Is your income
- 30:20accurately reported? But there's nothing that
- 30:24you are going to be able to do to stop the IRS
- 30:26from contacting third parties. You can know about
- 30:29it, but again, you're not going to have that
- 30:33ability to cut it off. Next slide, please. I
- 30:38just want to add, so the examining agents who
- 30:43are coming out to cannabis operators for these
- 30:46exams, they're not just agents who deal with
- 30:49other industries and this is just a one -off
- 30:51case for them. These are agents who work within
- 30:54the cannabis unit. They have a technical advisor
- 30:57involved in These audits, so they know the reports
- 31:01that they're looking at. They know here in California,
- 31:04you know, the metric report, the state reports,
- 31:06they want the sales tax returns. They want the
- 31:08excise tax returns. They want the business license
- 31:11renewal forms. They are coming in, they know
- 31:14what credit unions you may be banking with because
- 31:17they've been through this more than once or they
- 31:19have technical advisor pointing to the right
- 31:21direction. So it's important to understand that
- 31:24you're not just dealing with an agent who is
- 31:27coming in and wants to tour the facility. And
- 31:29it's the first time they're seeing a cannabis
- 31:31operator. Secondly, they're going to. Coming
- 31:36to sometimes doing the interview, the technical
- 31:40advisor will also be on the call when they're
- 31:42interviewing your clients. So it's important
- 31:44to understand that you're not dealing with someone
- 31:46who doesn't know cannabis on the flip side. If
- 31:50I payroll audits where the. Examining agent does
- 31:54not understand cannabis and you know will make
- 31:56comment. For example, why don't you use your
- 31:59personal banking to pay your payroll taxes, right?
- 32:01And it's like you don't understand how the industry
- 32:05is working. So just be advised of that in that
- 32:08they're going to, for example, ask back statements,
- 32:11but they're going to ask for not just for the
- 32:13entities back statements, but any back statements
- 32:15that the company has control over or the individuals
- 32:19with the company have control over who may have
- 32:21commingled the funds so that and they can potentially
- 32:24expand their audit to related entities. So it's
- 32:28important to keep those informations in mind
- 32:30and also important to understand how state reporting
- 32:34differs from federal reporting so that you are
- 32:36better to explain to your examining agent why
- 32:40the sales tax returns, why the excise tax return
- 32:44gross receipts are different than what's being
- 32:46reported on the federal return. Thank you, Ani.
- 32:53Those are all fantastic points to keep in mind.
- 33:00And I think one of the other things to remember
- 33:05here is that the IRS, as Ani mentioned, they've
- 33:14been doing this for a long time on cannabis audits,
- 33:16and they've trained specialists to work here.
- 33:23I think initially at times, but I think it's
- 33:28gone away. At least for me, it has is there to
- 33:33be this tension like, oh, I'm in cannabis, I'm
- 33:36inherently in trouble. That's not true. If you're
- 33:42doing things the right way and your records match
- 33:45up, you'll get through the audit and you should
- 33:49be fine. It's when You have sloppy books and
- 33:54records. Your POS system is a mess. Your sales
- 33:57tax returns are a mess. And things don't reconcile.
- 34:03They are going to have problems. But they're
- 34:08not after you simply because you're in cannabis.
- 34:11They are not going to refer you criminally because
- 34:15you're in cannabis. That really never was the
- 34:18case with the IRS. and still is not the case.
- 34:24And so I think you need to have that level of
- 34:28cooperation with the agent to get through the
- 34:32audit, as opposed to a combative relationship.
- 34:36They know that this is a cannabis audit. Whether
- 34:41280E applies or not, This is a business who is
- 34:45in and around the cannabis space. It is not random.
- 34:50They're not asking the questions that they're
- 34:52going to ask because they just so happen to stumble
- 34:56on it. It's very much a targeted inquiry and
- 35:02the things that they're asking. With that said,
- 35:07the other thing to note is if there are issues
- 35:11with the licensing, okay, again, I don't know
- 35:18that the IRS is all that interested in, whether
- 35:21you're black market, gray market, perfectly legal,
- 35:25okay, you got to pay income tax, you've got a
- 35:29duty to report accurately, okay, so that doesn't
- 35:34necessarily, there are other implications for
- 35:37that. That may change how you deal with it, but
- 35:40at a very basic level, you've got to file your
- 35:47return. It's got to be accurate. One of the other
- 35:50things that I see very frequently in cannabis
- 35:54is oftentimes these are closely held businesses.
- 35:59There may be one owner, two, three, four, five
- 36:01owners. And there is a lot of use of personal
- 36:08funds going in and out, or business funds being
- 36:12used for personal purposes. And that's where
- 36:16you can start to get into another layer of trouble
- 36:20where maybe you don't pay yourself an appropriate
- 36:25salary and you're driving fancy cars and buying
- 36:31fancy houses and taking fancy vacations. introduces
- 36:36another potential issue of a constructive dividend
- 36:43or payroll tax issues, various things like that
- 36:49that you see when you're commingling and sort
- 36:52of abusing the corporate form. But it is something
- 36:56you see all the time in closely held businesses,
- 36:59whether it's cannabis or not. I think cannabis
- 37:02adds the layer oftentimes of dealing with large
- 37:06amounts of cash that in one sense becomes a lot
- 37:10easier for the taxpayer to just simply use for
- 37:15personal purposes because it's not hitting a
- 37:18bank. Next slide, please. Some other items that
- 37:31may come up, we've already mentioned record keeping,
- 37:36ownership, can be a contentious issue. You'll
- 37:41often see, for example, sometimes somebody's
- 37:44name is on the license, but they're sort of figurehead.
- 37:49Maybe they were just the person who was able
- 37:52to get that license easier or already had a license,
- 37:56but the business is actually being operated by
- 37:59other folks or another entity. That's one issue
- 38:04that can come up. I don't know, Ani, do you want
- 38:08to say anything about 471C? Yeah, so 471C, some
- 38:13operators have taken the position that 471C is
- 38:17applicable and that they're going to start using
- 38:20this section to be able to allocate their expenses
- 38:24how it fits the business model, right? What is
- 38:28best suitable to represent the financials of
- 38:30the company as an accounting method? However,
- 38:34if the company did not... elect to change their
- 38:37accounting method that's an issue right if you're
- 38:40applying 471 c there are challenges to 471 c
- 38:45whether it's applicable whether cannabis operators
- 38:48can use that to move cost of goods sold. For
- 38:52example, some operators will take the position
- 38:55that the ability to sell requires that you have
- 38:58a license. A license will cost anywhere, you
- 39:01know, it can be $120 ,000, for example, for an
- 39:04annual renewal for the state of California on
- 39:07average, right? And so they'll take the position
- 39:09that that is a cost of goods sold of the 471C
- 39:12because it's indirect expenses for the ability
- 39:15to be able to sell. And so I'm going to put this
- 39:19as cost of goods sold. However, they did not
- 39:22make the proper accounting collection or they
- 39:24don't have the proper accounting method in place.
- 39:26And so that becomes an issue. These are being
- 39:29challenged in tax court right now. And so when
- 39:33we've spoken to the government or we've had conversations
- 39:36with the government, they do not comment on anything
- 39:38relating to 471C. Whereas we've seen clear application
- 39:43of Section 280E to cannabis operators by the
- 39:47courts. The other thing I want to add is, having
- 39:50been in the industry for quite some time, it's
- 39:54a misnomer that these operators are not banking.
- 39:56They are banking for the most part if they can
- 39:59afford it and they have the ability to obtain
- 40:01a bank account. But cash still remains king in
- 40:04the industry. And it's important to understand
- 40:07that cash accounting, making sure your records
- 40:10reconcile, you have accurate records, because
- 40:13at the end of the day, that's what's going to
- 40:15carry you through the audit. And so if your operators
- 40:18are paying for expenses and they're not documenting
- 40:21that properly and they're just estimating, you
- 40:24cannot rely on estimates. They need to have cash
- 40:26logs, they need to have receipt books, and they
- 40:30need to operate like any other cash business
- 40:32would have. back in the day when cash was kicked.
- 40:35The other issue that we see is the ownership
- 40:37issue come up, particularly if you have an operator
- 40:40who is a social equity applicant. In the city
- 40:43of Los Angeles, social equity applicants are
- 40:45required to hold 51 % ownership. So you have
- 40:49an individual holding 51 % ownership, but then
- 40:52you have some sophisticated owner who's holding
- 40:5549 % through various entities and structures.
- 40:58And so when the IRS comes in, it's not very clear
- 41:02who the owner is and the first person they go
- 41:05to is the individual whose name is on maybe the
- 41:08operating agreement or who's listed on the licensing.
- 41:13So that also becomes an issue is because this
- 41:16social equity applicants for the most part are
- 41:19not sophisticated enough to get proper advice
- 41:22and probably protect themselves when it comes
- 41:25to these audits. Next slide. So outside of rescheduling,
- 41:36rescheduling is just one front of how we see
- 41:41changes in the industry and how we look to eliminate
- 41:44the application of Section 280E to cannabis operators.
- 41:48But there are cases that are also important to
- 41:51keep an eye on as they are challenging the application
- 41:54of 280E. to cannabis operators outside of rescheduling
- 41:59and the pending rescheduling that is potentially
- 42:02going to happen or not happen, who knows, right?
- 42:05The most important case that if you're in this
- 42:07industry, you're watching is the New Mexico Top
- 42:10Organics, which is testing whether 280E applies
- 42:15to cannabis operators. So just like any other
- 42:19cannabis audit, cannabis business audit, the
- 42:22IRS went in and disallowed expenses outside of
- 42:26cost of goods sold, right? I mean, at this level
- 42:29of the case in tax court, they have agreed that
- 42:32cost of goods sold are deductible. The parties
- 42:35have stipulated to the amounts. So the only question
- 42:37is whether ordinary operating expenses are subject
- 42:41to 280. And so the case takes the position that
- 42:48section 280 is no longer the Petitioners in this
- 42:52case take a position that section 280 is no longer
- 42:55applicable to cannabis operators because cannabis
- 43:00is Should no longer be scheduled one substance
- 43:04and they go back to the history of when schedule
- 43:07one was Determined there was no medical use accepted
- 43:12medical use and high abuse rate for cannabis
- 43:15that has changed that The criteria used to put
- 43:20cannabis into a category one substance is no
- 43:23longer applicable. And therefore, based on the
- 43:26current recommendation and based on the current
- 43:29shift in the focus of how cannabis should be
- 43:33scheduled, the case takes the position that or
- 43:37the petitioners take the position that this cannabis
- 43:39no longer falls within a scheduled one substance
- 43:42and therefore should not be. subject to 280 E,
- 43:48and that's a new position. It's a unique position
- 43:51because we haven't seen that before. We've seen
- 43:54the arguments for various reasons why section
- 43:56280 is not applicable, but we have not seen the
- 44:00basis of that based on the current recommendation
- 44:03or the recommendation that cannabis be rescheduled.
- 44:07Schedule one no longer applies. I think it's
- 44:11important to keep an eye out on this. If you're
- 44:14interested, there's a few amicus briefs filed
- 44:16on this case and it's an interesting read, goes
- 44:19through the history of cannabis and how it's
- 44:22been regulated. The other argument is that because
- 44:27it's no longer a schedule one or it should no
- 44:30longer be category schedule one, these are state
- 44:34operators subject to intrastate distribution,
- 44:38possession, and cultivation. and are no longer
- 44:41coming within the commerce clause based on the
- 44:45necessity that control substances overall scheme
- 44:47when Congress is going to apply this, right?
- 44:50And so this is the way that the case is shaking
- 44:53out. We'll see how it goes. It's in briefing
- 44:57right now, and we're keeping an eye out for it.
- 45:01If the case does move forward or. You know, we've
- 45:06seen the tax code be very strict on how section
- 45:09280 applies, so it'll be an interesting decision
- 45:12to read. But in the event that you have operators
- 45:15who did not take a position that section 280
- 45:19or took the position that section 280 fully applies,
- 45:22there may be opportunities to file some protective
- 45:24claims or. and so refund, you know, if there
- 45:28was tax paid. So we'll see how that goes. There's
- 45:32two other cases that are making its way through
- 45:34court that are maybe important to watch. Both
- 45:38of these cases are filed by the same attorney.
- 45:41So they have similar positions in that 280 is
- 45:46no longer applicable because of the rescheduling
- 45:50that is on the horizon. The edible management
- 45:54versus Commissioner, that's also challenging
- 45:57the operations of management companies and whether
- 46:00management companies should be subject to Section
- 46:03280E. The task force has already ruled on this.
- 46:07There's cases on management companies that you
- 46:10can look up. And it's really important to keep
- 46:14in mind they're looking at control, they're looking
- 46:16at ownership, they're looking at whether... The
- 46:19management company has other clients, right?
- 46:21Other operators that they're working with outside
- 46:24of cannabis. I'll give me an example if. if you're
- 46:28a packaging company, for example, and you provide
- 46:30packaging to both cannabis operator and a non
- 46:34-cannabis operator, where do you draw the line
- 46:36of where 280E applies or not? And so a similar
- 46:40would be to management companies if you are truly
- 46:42a management company. But in cannabis space,
- 46:46when we look at management companies, it's generally
- 46:48the same owners. It's generally one entity that
- 46:51they're managing or a group of entities, related
- 46:54entities that they're managing. And so This challenge,
- 46:57we don't see it going anywhere. And the tax court
- 47:00has been very strict on how 280EU has been applied
- 47:04previously. Jonathan, you want to add anything
- 47:08on this case? No. So next slide. So we talked
- 47:19a little bit about protective claims. I don't
- 47:21know if you want to add anything on protective
- 47:22claims. Only to say that the IRS came out and
- 47:31basically said these protective claims based
- 47:33on rescheduling are not valid claims. They have
- 47:40strongly discouraged taxpayers from filing them.
- 47:45What I would say is have that discussion with
- 47:49your client, whether it's beneficial to file
- 47:53these or not. Note that your claim has to be
- 48:00perfected at some point for it to be a full -fledged
- 48:05claim for refund. And you need to make all the
- 48:09requirements in terms of the year, the amount
- 48:12that you're seeking, so on and so forth. But
- 48:17I mean, this is a very real issue that There
- 48:23has been nothing in terms of retroactivity been
- 48:26mentioned. That doesn't mean it may not be something
- 48:32that gets put on the table at a later point,
- 48:35but the statute of limitations is going to be
- 48:38what it is going to be. One of the things, and
- 48:44this sort of gets into an issue. on the next
- 48:50slide or two is a lot of these companies really
- 48:54don't have money to pay tax and aren't paying
- 48:58any tax. And so there really wouldn't be anything
- 49:02to refund anyway. You can file an amended return
- 49:07that would eliminate a tax balance owed, okay,
- 49:12but as long and not seek an actual refund. To
- 49:16get a refund, you know, presupposes that you
- 49:20have paid some tax that you would now like refund.
- 49:24So, a lot of these businesses are paying very
- 49:28little in tax. Not all of them, that doesn't
- 49:31mean. that these aren't very applicable to certain
- 49:35businesses where they aren't paying a little
- 49:38amount of tax because they just don't have the
- 49:41cash to full pay liability. Then they file a
- 49:44return showing a very large balance owed having
- 49:48paid some tax that they may want back in a future
- 49:51year. So this is an important discussion to have
- 49:56with a client. You would not want to represent
- 49:59your client, never have this discussion And now
- 50:03two years later, they're saying, well, can I
- 50:05file a refund claim because 280 was ruled unconstitutional,
- 50:10something like that. So have that discussion,
- 50:13but know that the IRS is not going to act on
- 50:17these and does not encourage these claims, quite
- 50:22the opposite. Next slide, please. The one thing
- 50:26I would add is I agree with Jonathan that a lot
- 50:28of clients are not paying their tax. They're
- 50:30either taking the strong cost of goods sold deduction,
- 50:34which eliminates a lot of the tax that returns
- 50:37that I've seen through audits show significant
- 50:40cost of goods sold when in just view you can
- 50:43see that it's unrealistic, right? 99 % of your
- 50:46expenses go to cost of goods sold. So they're
- 50:49not paying pretty much any tax that would allow
- 50:53them to have any claims but also when you're
- 50:58filing an amended return you know some operators
- 51:01are taking the position well 280 is no longer
- 51:03applicable so I'm going to file an amended return
- 51:06know that the amended returns will become will
- 51:09come under scrutiny and they will be reviewed
- 51:11before their process and that can sometimes lead
- 51:14to an examination as well so you know if your
- 51:18client is saying I'm going to file an amended
- 51:19return to eliminate my the taxes owed, they can
- 51:23potentially be under an examination at some point.
- 51:28So, okay, next slide. Yeah, there's also filing
- 51:33frivolous, you know, frivolous refund claims.
- 51:37So, if you work the IRS, know that there could
- 51:43be consequences for your client. So shifting
- 51:53to, go ahead Ani. I was just going to say the
- 51:56government has a lot of information and a lot
- 51:59of data that they can pull from, and they know
- 52:02what percentage of the business generally is
- 52:04cash, what percentage of the business is credit
- 52:07cards or banking, how quickly these accounts
- 52:09get terminated. So don't doubt that the government's
- 52:12coming in blind -eyed and does not have the statistics
- 52:15for your industry, because they clearly at this
- 52:18point do. It's been, TANOS has been legal since
- 52:212012. in Colorado and Washington. So there's
- 52:24a lot of data for them to pull from. Okay. Moving
- 52:29to IRS collection, you know, it's great. Client
- 52:32file, compliant returns applied to ADE correctly.
- 52:36Now they're facing a huge liability and the IRS
- 52:40is coming into collection. With collections,
- 52:43I'm going to just focus on income tax collection
- 52:46because payroll taxes have their own issues you
- 52:48know clients will sometimes use the IRS as their
- 52:52bank because they can't get banking and then
- 52:54you have payroll tax collection issues and that
- 52:56has its own nuances and issues and that's outside
- 52:59of 280e and outside of this presentation but
- 53:02here we're talking about income tax collection
- 53:04for tax returns filed so that you start getting
- 53:07your notices for collection issues that are coming
- 53:10a collection for self -reported taxes What's
- 53:14happening? There's two avenues that operators
- 53:18can take when it comes to collection, right?
- 53:22It's hard for the government in this industry
- 53:25to do collection because banking is limited.
- 53:29They need to find the banks you're banking with.
- 53:33that it becomes kind of cumbersome, especially
- 53:35if your accounts keep getting terminated for
- 53:38levies and then your operator can get a bank
- 53:41account and now they're forced into a cash function.
- 53:45We see the state of California coming in to do
- 53:48cash collection from the saves through a tab
- 53:50tail, but we do not see the IRS doing that. So
- 53:54assets are hard to seize. Cash is hard to seize.
- 53:57And so collection becomes an issue. But let's
- 54:00say your client is cooperating and wants to get
- 54:03into compliance and stop the notices from coming,
- 54:06there's two avenues to go through when it comes
- 54:09to collection, either an installment agreement
- 54:12or an offering compromise. With regards to an
- 54:16installment agreement, the IRS does not take
- 54:20into account 280E in determining the ability
- 54:23of the taxpayer to pay and the monthly income
- 54:25or monthly payment they can afford to pay so
- 54:29they will take the financials just like any other
- 54:32installment agreement review the financials see
- 54:35what is available and determine what can the
- 54:38client afford to pay on a monthly basis or quarterly
- 54:42basis whatever you work it out with the government
- 54:44right whereas on an offering compromise, the
- 54:51Internal Revenue Manual is very clear that when
- 54:54you're a cannabis operator who makes an offering
- 54:56compromise to compromise your liabilities, 280E
- 55:00is to be applied in determining your reasonable
- 55:04collection potential. And so that becomes an
- 55:07issue because when you apply 280E to the income,
- 55:11you have phantom income. You have phantom amount
- 55:14of available assets or future income that the
- 55:18government can collect from. So generally, offering
- 55:21compromises do not work out for cannabis operators,
- 55:25particularly for retailers and distributors who
- 55:28are facing large liabilities. And I'll let Jonathan
- 55:31talk about the Mission Organics case. Yeah, so
- 55:37Mission Organics Center was a tax court case
- 55:41that challenged this up or in compromise aspect
- 55:49that Ani mentioned. I'm going to discuss this
- 55:52case because Ani is involved in this case. It's
- 55:56currently pending before the Ninth Circuit and
- 56:00the tax court in a divided opinion. And this
- 56:08is, you know, what we call a court reviewed opinion
- 56:10where you have the majority opinion, then you
- 56:15have dissenting opinions, but essentially challenged
- 56:19this offer and compromise. And the court said,
- 56:23no, that's okay. It's not an abuse of discretion.
- 56:27And also the court leaned on sort of policy.
- 56:32that the IRS is within its right for public policy
- 56:35grounds to reject certain offers and compromise.
- 56:39And so we'll have to wait and see what the Ninth
- 56:42Circuit does with this case. But when it comes
- 56:47to the actual collection, and at the end of the
- 56:49day, the IRS should want to collect the taxes
- 56:52that it assesses, its rigidity in the offer and
- 56:57compromise I think does not necessarily aid in
- 57:03its ability to collect some tax. The offer and
- 57:09compromise is designed to say, hey, we'll give
- 57:13some amount and the IRS forgives the rest. Oftentimes
- 57:18the alternative is the IRS has to spend significant
- 57:22time and resources trying to collect an amount
- 57:27that may or may not be less than it would get
- 57:33having approved an offer and compromised. But
- 57:38the IRS to this point is going to stick by its
- 57:41position, which to this point has won. to seriously
- 57:50keep in mind on these liabilities from a taxpayer
- 57:55perspective is when you're looking at collection
- 57:58alternatives, specifically an offer and compromise,
- 58:02or you get into collection due process, you're
- 58:04tolling the statute of limitations on collection
- 58:08while that offer is pending, while you're in
- 58:11CDP, if you take that CDP to court. So oftentimes
- 58:14you're adding two, three, four, five years to
- 58:18a collection statute, where otherwise these taxes
- 58:23will roll off. Now, the negative to this is that
- 58:31as long as 280E is on the books, you're just
- 58:35going to start accruing new tax liabilities each
- 58:38and every year. And so if one falls off, the
- 58:41next year a new liability comes on, you're just
- 58:44in this pattern of always going to have some
- 58:46tax liability. But still, I think it's worth
- 58:50considering before you start doing collection
- 58:54alternatives or going to collection due process,
- 58:58what the benefit is. What is that doing to the
- 59:00statute of limitations? What are the possibilities
- 59:03that the government might go after the individual's
- 59:06assets personally? So on and so forth. So this
- 59:09is an area that is still developing. We will
- 59:13see how it turns out in the Ninth Circuit and
- 59:16any other future challenges. Next slide. We're
- 59:25running out of time here. If you have any questions,
- 59:28please get them in. And I think the last thing
- 59:31we're going to have time to get to is 8 ,300s.
- 59:35And this is an area that I think is often forgotten,
- 59:37but it is very important in cannabis. All your
- 59:42cannabis clients should know very much the ins
- 59:44and outs of the 8 ,300. They're dealing in cash.
- 59:48almost undoubtedly, no matter where on the cannabis
- 59:52business they are, they're coming into contact
- 59:55with cash. They're either paying cash, they're
- 59:58receiving cash or both. And if it's over 10 ,000,
- 1:00:02they need to file an 8 ,300. The 8300 form can
- 1:00:08be, you can find a copy online. You should know
- 1:00:11it. Your clients should know it in and out. And
- 1:00:13each transaction should be triggering a separate
- 1:00:178300 for this. Okay. And the other few things
- 1:00:22to note, if somebody comes in one day with 7
- 1:00:25,500, it says, well, I'll come back with another
- 1:00:287 ,500 the next day. No, no, no, no. That's not.
- 1:00:32a way to get around the $8 ,300. That's still
- 1:00:35the same transaction, most likely, in an $8 ,300
- 1:00:40would need to be filed. Clients will say, well,
- 1:00:45what do I do if I ask the client, I asked my
- 1:00:48vendor, to give me the information so I can file
- 1:00:52an 8300 and they would not give it to me. They
- 1:00:55didn't want to give their social security number.
- 1:00:58Can I still accept it and do business? The answer
- 1:01:00is there is a process to notify the government
- 1:01:05that an attempt was made to collect the information.
- 1:01:10for the 8300 and you would submit it to the government
- 1:01:14with essentially a statement as to what efforts
- 1:01:18you have made to collect the information. So
- 1:01:21simply saying, oh, well, I asked and that's it.
- 1:01:24They didn't want to give it to me and go about
- 1:01:26your business. Not the right answer. That's a
- 1:01:28way to get in trouble. And I think you do have
- 1:01:32to have the discussion with your client. If they
- 1:01:35have a vendor who absolutely refuses to give
- 1:01:38information, whether they should be doing business
- 1:01:41with that vendor. That's a consideration. And
- 1:01:46just to sort of put more dire consequences on
- 1:01:49this, not in the cannabis space, but a few months
- 1:01:52ago in the central district, there was a a case
- 1:01:56called Wynn involving a husband and wife and
- 1:01:59their precious metals business where there was
- 1:02:02a conspiracy to avoid 8300s were alleged. They
- 1:02:07were knowingly not filing 8300s receiving large
- 1:02:11amounts of cash and they ultimately pled guilty.
- 1:02:16to filing a false tax return and a conspiracy
- 1:02:21charge that included the 8300 conduct. So this
- 1:02:27could turn criminal if you are taking large sums
- 1:02:30of cash and willfully failing to file 8300s.
- 1:02:36And the penalties for this, even if they're just
- 1:02:39civil, really add up if you're doing high volume
- 1:02:42business. With that, I'll turn it back to Ani
- 1:02:47for any final comments. I thank everyone for
- 1:02:51listening to the presentation. And if you have
- 1:02:55any questions, please feel free to submit them,
- 1:02:57Ani. So I just want to add that. You know, rescheduling
- 1:03:01does not change these requirements for the 8300
- 1:03:04days I've been here before cannabis and are going
- 1:03:07to be here after cannabis sale. And if you're
- 1:03:09even an attorney operating in this industry,
- 1:03:12you are required to comply with these rules,
- 1:03:14right? So it's something you have to keep in
- 1:03:17mind. Just a few takeaways, you know, it's an
- 1:03:20industry to keep an eye out for if you are operating
- 1:03:23in this industry, you're advising in this industry.
- 1:03:26Even though things are moving slow, things also
- 1:03:28can move fast. So know your customers, know your
- 1:03:32clients, know what they're doing, and be on the
- 1:03:36lookout to see how rescheduling will impact your
- 1:03:39operators moving forward. We don't have any open
- 1:03:45questions, so we want to thank everyone for attending
- 1:03:48and turn it back over to the Beverly Hills Bar.
- 1:03:52This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:03:54so much, Ani and Jonathan for an excellent presentation
- 1:03:57and thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 1:03:59great day, everybody.