Latest / Show, don't Tell Writing with Suzy Vadori / 105. How Brains of Different Ages Read (And How You Can Write for Them!)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to the Show Don't Tell Writing Podcast with me, Suzy Vadori, where I peel back the layers of how to wow your readers with your fiction, your nonfiction.
- 0:13Anybody can bang out a first draft, but it takes a little more work to make your book as amazing as it can be.
- 0:20Join me as I share the step-by-step writing techniques you could apply to your writing right away, as I host successful writers who share a behind-the-scenes look at their own writing lives, and as I live coach writers on their pages, giving practical writing examples that will make your own writing stronger.
- 0:38Nobody is born knowing how to write an engaging book.
- 0:42There are real and important skills that you need to learn.
- 0:45On this show, I cut through the noise and get you all the info you need.
- 0:49I can't wait to see how this information is going to transform your writing Today on the Show Don't Tell Writing Podcast, we have a special reappearance of a guest, Samantha Cameron, who has been on the show before.
- 1:07But when we were talking before, we started to get into this discussion on brain chemistry, and as you know, I'm absolutely obsessed with how reading works in the brain and how your words can play out in readers' brains and how that can all work and how you can affect them.
- 1:23And Sam has a unique perspective because she was a former high school English teacher and has a lot of information on how teen brains work, and so we started talking about how the young adult books need to be different in order to appeal to teen brains.
- 1:40But conversely, in this episode that w- when we decided to ha- do an episode, of course, because you need this information as well, and we wanted to geek out and have this conversation.
- 1:50But more than that, knowing what needs to be different about teen brains can also help you with what is different about adult brains.
- 1:57So regardless of your genre, we'll talk about this a lot in this episode today, regardless of your genre, take a listen.
- 2:03This is gonna be super interesting.
- 2:06Welcome back to the podcast, Sam Cameron, who is a book coach and developmental editor helping frustrated authors find clarity and fall in love with their stories again.
- 2:15She specializes in helping writers revise complete manuscripts so that they can turn rejections into requests.
- 2:22She's the creator of the weekly Substack Truant Pen, where she shares actionable advice for stuck writers.
- 2:28Okay.
- 2:29Welcome back to the podcast, Sam Cam.
- 2:32I'm so excited to talk about this topic today I'm so excited to be back.
- 2:36I had so much fun last time.
- 2:38Yeah, and it, this topic came about, as I said in the introduction, it kind of came about after we recorded the last one.
- 2:45We, we kind of touched on this, and I think it's a really important one for you to hear.
- 2:49So before you tune out if you are not a young adult writer, I wanna say we're gonna talk about brain chemistry in young people and also how it's different.
- 2:59So even if you write for adults or whatever age category you write for, listen to this because it's important.
- 3:05And as well, we're gonna talk about crossover, we're gonna talk about all kinds of things.
- 3:08So don't miss this one.
- 3:10Okay.
- 3:11I just wanna start off by saying to our listeners, first, when we say writing for young people, really, which is what it's about, what do we mean?
- 3:21What are the ages?
- 3:22Like, what, what, what is this young people?
- 3:23What are we talking about?
- 3:25I'm glad we're starting this way because if you just say teen or young people, I think folks have lots of different ideas about what that means because I've had people come to me and say they're writing for young adults, and what they mean by that is someone who's in their 20s.
- 3:41Yeah.
- 3:41But that's not actually what the industry means when they say young adult.
- 3:45And it's also kind of different from the psychological definition of adolescent and teen.
- 3:51So to clarify what I'm talking about, when I talk about teens or adolescents, I'm referring to roughly to people who are between the ages of 10 and 20, which is a pretty large age group.
- 4:03Within that age group, folks who are in these ages are undergoing an enormous amount of development, physical and cognitive development.
- 4:14It is the largest period of development that we undergo any time except for when we're toddlers.
- 4:20It's just that people don't think it's as cute when you're a teenager as when you're a toddler.
- 4:26Um- No, my teenagers are pretty cute.
- 4:28They push back- I think teenagers are pretty- But I, I think it's kind of cute too, and sometimes I laugh.
- 4:32They don't really appreciate that, but you know.
- 4:35You gotta, you gotta think some of this is cute.
- 4:38But yeah, so- I think there's, there's a lot of amazing things about, about teen brains.
- 4:41And, and that's a huge range, like 10 to 20.
- 4:44So we're gonna talk about the brain development and what it means for your writing and how to appeal to these people.
- 4:48But actually, that spans a ton of different categories- Yeah, it does ... in terms of, in terms of what publishing says are the categories.
- 4:58I can, I can run through them or you can run through them, but let's just state this, 'cause it's a hard thing to find.
- 5:02Yeah.
- 5:03That publishing actually states the category based on the age of the protagonist, which is weird, and sort of the age of the reader as well.
- 5:11Do you wanna elaborate on that?
- 5:13Yeah.
- 5:13Yeah.
- 5:13Yeah, I'll elaborate on that.
- 5:14So that age range that I gave, that 10 to 20 age range, there's three, maybe four different publishing categories that span that.
- 5:23So the first one we're gonna hit is middle grade, or sometimes abbreviated as MG, and that's broadly speaking for characters or readers who are ages 8 to 13.
- 5:34So mostly these days you're not gonna see something marketed as middle grade- That has a protagonist that's older than 13.
- 5:42Really older- Yeah.
- 5:42Can you talk about that?
- 5:43Because there's a reason for that.
- 5:45Yeah.
- 5:45Because readers won't read about younger kids.
- 5:48They don't want to.
- 5:49Yeah.
- 5:50They're not interested.
- 5:51They're too cool, right?
- 5:52Yeah, for the most part.
- 5:53Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:54So what's interesting though is when I was a kid, you could find middle grade novels where the main characters were older teenagers or where the main characters were adults.
- 6:03So I'm thinking, for example, of like Ella Enchanted was my favorite middle grade novel when I was a kid.
- 6:08Once Upon a Marigold.
- 6:10These are all books that are middle grade by definition.
- 6:14That's clearly who they're written for, but the protagonists in all those books are older teenagers or adults, and that you don't see anymore.
- 6:23It is incredibly rare, if not unheard of, to find a middle grade novel with a, an older teen or an adult main character.
- 6:32Yeah.
- 6:32Um, does that- Okay...
- 6:33match what you see, Suzy?
- 6:34Yeah, it definitely does, and I love that you said eight to 13 because typically we see it listed as 9 to 12.
- 6:41And then when we- Mm-hmm talk about the next, but it isn't because there's sort of this 9 to 12 and then I'm gonna steal a bit of thunder 'cause I wanna move on, but the, the young adult category is sort of 14 plus, and the issue is, listen to that for a second.
- 6:54We have 9 to 12 and then we have 14 plus.
- 6:56Well, who's writing that gap?
- 6:58I write that gap for that reader, and it's hard because there's no shelf, and so I have this huge marketing lift to do to reach that category of readers that I think is so important.
- 7:08Those on the cusp tween-teenagers who actually want to read higher content or they have a higher reading level, avid readers, but so middle grade doesn't work for them from a reading level perspective, but they're not quite ready to read some of the racy stuff in YA that's for 17s, you know?
- 7:28So, okay.
- 7:28So then there's YA, right?
- 7:30Which I say 14 plus, but there's lower YA, which is sort of for 13, 14, and then there's upper YA, which is like 16 plus, which can- Right ... include lots of other content.
- 7:40And then you said, because we're saying 10 to 20, there is this other, and I love that you say kind of half category.
- 7:47Do you wanna talk a little bit about that for the 18- Yeah ... plus-year-olds?
- 7:51So there is a ca- an, a publishing category that appears and disappears periodically.
- 7:57It's in and out of favor.
- 7:58At the moment, it seems to be having a little bit of a return to popularity.
- 8:02Very cool.
- 8:03Very cool.
- 8:03Which is the new adult category.
- 8:05And so that is very, very similar to YA, but it is a little bit longer.
- 8:10It can be a little more explicit sexually and, and violently speaking.
- 8:16Yeah.
- 8:16And it is for people in that sort of 18, 19, 20 category of you've left high school, you've graduated high school, you're going to college, you're starting your first job.
- 8:27Yeah.
- 8:28So for those of you who write for adults, this category for 10 to 20 is still important because...
- 8:34Well, teenagers read all Just like- Yeah ... adults read all sorts of things.
- 8:39So if you are writing f- for adults, you may still capture the interest and attention of teen readers.
- 8:48And I saw this as a high school teacher, that there's lots of teens who like both YA and adult.
- 8:54There's teens who only wanna read adult.
- 8:56There's adult books that are regularly popular with teens, like Dune and Game of Thrones, are wildly popular with teenagers even though they were not written with that audience in mind.
- 9:06Yeah.
- 9:06And so that's the dream, right?
- 9:08So this is why you need to keep listening to this podcast, because the dream- Mm-hmm is that everybody everywhere will find your book.
- 9:14And I, you hear this a lot from writers, that, "Oh, I want my book to appeal to everybody." And I mean, there's the old marketing adage, if you're speaking to everybody, you're speaking to no one.
- 9:22Mm-hmm.
- 9:22Right?
- 9:23So the thing is, the trick is, how do you write in your category with the genre expectations in your category, yet still leave the door open to appeal to a broader audience?
- 9:34And so that's what we're gonna talk about some things today.
- 9:37Some of these tips and tricks might be the key to getting that big crossover.
- 9:41Okay, I just love that you're on the podcast, and this is how it started.
- 9:45I'm a parent of three teenagers, one soon to, to pass over that 20-year-old mark in a couple of months.
- 9:51But still a teenager, I'm gonna take it for now.
- 9:54And there's this whole concept of generations, right?
- 9:57So I'm Gen X. Mm-hmm.
- 9:59And when I say Gen X, so a lot of my listeners are Generation X. I don't know the specific names.
- 10:04I don't have the dates in front of me, but you probably know if you are.
- 10:07And that means I was a latchkey kid who, you know, was home alone a lot, did my own thing, and I read a lot because I didn't have a lot of technology.
- 10:15And so when we're writing as adults for other categories, sometimes we're a little bit blind to the differences, um, which is why this is really important.
- 10:26Do you wanna talk a little bit about, because now these categories of generations are getting much smaller.
- 10:32They don't span 20 or 30 years anymore because of technology and changes.
- 10:37Mm-hmm.
- 10:37What do you see, like as a former high school teacher, how does that change?
- 10:41Like Millennials, and Gen Z, and I don't even know.
- 10:44I think my daughter's right on the cusp of whatever the next one is.
- 10:48Yeah.
- 10:48So I think you're right that technology plays a very big role in how teens come to reading and experience reading in a different way.
- 10:58So for example, I'm a Millennial.
- 11:00W- I'm what would be called peak Millennial, in that I was like the largest couple of years of when Millennials were born.
- 11:07And we were born in a time when basically we, we spanned an enormous amount of change, right?
- 11:12We were born into an analog world, and then by the time we graduated high school, people had smartphones.
- 11:17And so- But did you have a smartphone?
- 11:20Probably not.
- 11:21I did not.
- 11:21Smartphones were different.
- 11:23Some people did.
- 11:23Yeah.
- 11:23But now it's really like- But now it's ubiquitous ... very, right.
- 11:27Yeah.
- 11:27So that's one thing, right, is that the, the type of technology that's available, you know, changes how kids interact with books, and how much time they'll spend- Or don't because like education, like the expectations of what kids are supposed to do, like I think kids today are way busier than either of us probably were as teenagers, right?
- 11:45So as teens, teens used to have a lot more time, I think, for leisure reading than they do now.
- 11:50They're much busier.
- 11:51There's like higher expectations.
- 11:53Yeah, my kids travel and play sports, and like do all kinds of things, and are busy all the time.
- 11:59And if they're not busy, then they're making plans, right?
- 12:01And they can make- Yeah ... quick plans.
- 12:04And so there's, so there's, there's elements that change, and then there's also things like culturally what's going on, you know, and that will impact, like when So millennials really liked a lot of very dark, you know, dystopian fiction.
- 12:16I don't think the current generation is as interested in that because their world is pretty dark.
- 12:20They've lived it.
- 12:21They've lived it.
- 12:22So there's things like that that change.
- 12:23And then what's interesting is that there's some, like, brain chemistry things that are just, you know, standard brain chemistry things, but because the technology has changed, the way those brain chemistry things are activated kind of differs.
- 12:38So an example- Okay, let's talk about that.
- 12:40Yeah.
- 12:40Yeah.
- 12:41So an example I can think of is teenagers have a lower baseline level of dopamine in their brains than adults and younger children.
- 12:49Do you wanna ... Okay, do you wanna back up and explain that whole thing?
- 12:51Oh, yeah.
- 12:51'Cause I know what you're talking about.
- 12:53I'm, you know, dopamine chaser here.
- 12:55Um, but- Yeah ... but our list- that might be new to our listeners, so let's talk about it.
- 12:59Yeah.
- 13:00So dopamine is a neurotransmitter.
- 13:02It's one of those chemicals in your brain, and it basically floods you with good feelings to reward you for doing things that are gonna help you survive.
- 13:12Um, so it's part of our survival mechanism.
- 13:14So you get flooded with dopamine when you eat carbohydrates,'cause we need them to survive.
- 13:19Yum.
- 13:19Um, you get flooded with dopamine when you socialize, because we're social animals.
- 13:24And you also get flooded with dopamine when you are reading something really good, because reading is also a survival thing, right?
- 13:34Storytelling's a survival thing.
- 13:35It's how we learn.
- 13:37Um, it's how we, by kind of getting the chance to see what it's like in somebody else's experience, and this is where show, don't tell becomes so important, right?
- 13:47Yes.
- 13:48'Cause you're- You're on the show-... bringing them into that- ... don't tell podcast ... into your experience.
- 13:52Um, w- we want that, and we get dopamine for that because, again, we're social animals.
- 13:57So we need to know how to interact in society, and books help us to, to do that.
- 14:05So teenagers have this, like, lower baseline level of dopamine in their brains, um, and what that means is that they're very easily bored because they're not getting as much of that good feeling.
- 14:18So I don't know if you notice this with a- with your kids, Suzy, but it can happen that- Oh, yeah...
- 14:23w- you know, kids who, like, maybe they it was, like, now it's really boring or they're just, like, bored all the time.
- 14:30Yeah.
- 14:31Now, yeah, and, and I see this, you know, they kinda turn into somebody different for a few All of a sudden- Yeah...
- 14:38but one, one coming out of it and one So, uh- Yeah ... it, yeah, it's, it's totally true.
- 14:44Like, things that they used to love doing, you know, skipping down the sidewalk with me is no longer cool or whatever.
- 14:51There- Yeah ... there's other things.
- 14:52But also, to get them to engage is difficult during that stage because they're okay just laying on their bed looking at their phone.
- 15:01Yeah.
- 15:02And they really don't need you to interact.
- 15:03Well, that's ... And I think so it's like, so here's- Yeah, so for younger, right?
- 15:06Here's where the technology comes in, right?
- 15:09Yeah.
- 15:11We know that our devices give us a hit of dopamine, right?
- 15:15That's, that's, and that's what all the social media apps are designed to do.
- 15:19So that makes social media, for a lot of reasons, but one of them is the dopamine, the lower level of dopamine.
- 15:25That's what makes it so appealing to teenagers.
- 15:28But also, the low dopamine makes teens more susceptible to anxiety and depression.
- 15:34And so all of the problems that, you know, we've been talking about within our societies about should teens be allowed on social media, what should we do about access to these technologies, are because in anyone, we know that these technologies can cause depression and anxiety, right?
- 15:50Or exacerbate depression, anxiety.
- 15:53And because of their natural brain chemistry, teens are more susceptible to those things.
- 15:58So- And I think, yeah, and I, and I just wanna add to that because I think at late stages of, you know, social media, I mean, I'm on social media.
- 16:07I met many of my listeners on social media.
- 16:09But it's changing rapidly because of AI and other factors, and because those companies are struggling to remain relevant, remain profitable, all these things, where you're the product on social media right now.
- 16:21And actually, I'm, I'm really proud.
- 16:23I live in Canada, and Canada just passed something.
- 16:25Who knows?
- 16:26By the time this airs, it may already be struck down or it may already be in place.
- 16:30I don't know.
- 16:31But they just passed something this week saying that they are going to outlaw social media under 16.
- 16:38Now, I don't know how they're going to do that, because my kids would just change their birthdate.
- 16:41There's ways around it.
- 16:43I mean, we, we've been... We're pretty strict in our household, I gotta say.
- 16:45Like, 'cause before I get all this hate mail or advice on parenting, we, we are very strict, and we have very open communication about social media in our, in our household, and my kids were old when they got it, and we're kind of like, my youngest still doesn't have data.
- 17:00Like, we're just kinda stingy about it.
- 17:02Yeah.
- 17:03And, and we do monitor it, and when they were younger especially, they weren't allowed phones in their rooms, and they weren't allowed this and that.
- 17:08And in elementary school, we had, they had one phone between the three of them because they needed a phone.
- 17:16They were walking from the bus stop by themselves, and they were home with a, a young babysitter, like a teenage babysitter- Mm-hmm for that time.
- 17:24So we wanted them to have a phone when I was working in corporate and I wasn't home when they got home from school.
- 17:28And so, yeah, they had this one phone, and anyways, it's not, I mean, it's a work in progress.
- 17:34I'm sure we're not doing things perfectly, but in general, kids these days have a lot of and a lot of competition.
- 17:40They're not reading as often, right?
- 17:42Yeah.
- 17:43Okay.
- 17:43So what is about, so lower dopamine, that's actually really interesting.
- 17:47I didn't know that.
- 17:48What else about teen brain chemistry is interesting as it relates to reading?
- 17:52Um, okay, so we talked about the lower dopamine.
- 17:55The other thing that's really fascinating paired with the lower dopamine is that teen brains are what neuroscientists would call highly plastic.
- 18:05So plasticity in neuroscience means, like, how adaptable your brain is, like how able you are to learn new things.
- 18:13And teen brains are highly plastic.
- 18:15Um, and so this makes sense if you think about it, right?
- 18:18Like what your teen is up to on a daily basis.
- 18:20They're like learning calculus and Spanish and how to drive and world history and like all these things at once.
- 18:25And it would be way too much for an adult brain to actually take all of that in and absorb it.
- 18:32It would take us a lot longer, for sure.
- 18:34And so that combination of the fact that you have the low dopamine, right?
- 18:40And so teens are bored because of that, but also their brains are highly plastic.
- 18:45They have this natural, intense curiosity that makes them really want new things, right?
- 18:53To, to have new experiences and to find new things.
- 18:56So that actually Makes reading appealing to teenagers, right?
- 19:02To, to those who enjoy reading, right?
- 19:04It makes watching television, it makes socializing, it makes all of these things more appealing to them.
- 19:09It actually makes school appealing, right?
- 19:11If they are lucky enough to be in a school environment where they have teachers and courses that pique their curiosity, they are naturally primed to want to learn new things because it, it fills that gap, that natural gap.
- 19:27And when I look at my middle schooler, they have seven or eight periods in one day.
- 19:32Mm-hmm.
- 19:32Seven or eight different subjects.
- 19:34I'm like, and then my high school, they got four, right?
- 19:36'Cause it kind of changes, I think, their ability to context in that way or what they, like how deep they need to go on a given day.
- 19:45So what else?
- 19:46So the low dopamine, the other thing that it does is it makes their emotions very powerful.
- 19:51Teen emotions very powerful.
- 19:52So folks probably remember this from their own adolescence that especially new emotions like a first crush are like very, very intense compared to like other times of life.
- 20:04And so teens are really looking for an outlet for those very intense emotions, and so books again can kind of provide that for them.
- 20:13So again, the value of show, don't tell- Like, like repeat their experience, right?
- 20:17Or- Yeah ... reflect their experience or help them process their feelings about something in their lives.
- 20:22Yeah.
- 20:23Yeah.
- 20:23Yeah, exactly.
- 20:24So like a teen who is having very intense, like a very intense crush, they may not be able to actually do anything about that very intense crush in real life, but they can read like a love story or like a very intense romance and like have an outlet for those feelings, right?
- 20:40Or a teen could be extremely angry about just everything, right, and how unfair everything feels, and they maybe can't do anything about that in their real life, but they could read something like Red Rising or one of those like big angry rebellion books and have an outlet for that anger, right?
- 20:59And something like that.
- 20:59Right, because as they're reading and getting the dopamine, getting all the other things, they're also processing, right?
- 21:04Right.
- 21:04Where like processing their own feelings and putting themselves in that situation and kind of working through so that it doesn't feel so big and scary.
- 21:12I mean, when you read something that's way bigger than what your own experience has been, or way more traumatic or way, you know, deeper or whatever it is- I know, you know, I don't know if it's, I, I assume it's a brain chemistry thing.
- 21:25I don't know.
- 21:26I've thought about it.
- 21:26But sometimes reactions in teenagers over small things can be really big, right?
- 21:32Mm-hmm.
- 21:32Um, they lose control or blow things out of proportion, as it were.
- 21:36Okay, so what's this mean in terms of from a reading standpoint?
- 21:40What does this mean in terms of their focus, in terms of what topics they're interested in or the feelings or big questions that they might be exploring?
- 21:50What does that, what can we learn as writers about this particular moment in time and what they might be looking for?
- 21:58You mentioned a couple, that they're looking to explore feelings about crushes or anger or these things, but anything else that you wanna add?
- 22:06What can we learn about?
- 22:08Yeah, so I have, I have three ideas that I wanna talk about, and the first two appeal will be useful for writers of any age group, right?
- 22:18So if you're writing adult, these first two tips will still be useful to you.
- 22:21And then the third one is more specifically about if you are wanting to write for the YA or middle grade markets.
- 22:28So the first thing is to be as, I, I'm-- What's the word I'm looking for?
- 22:35Um, concise.
- 22:36You wanna be concise, right, and tight with your writing in terms of making sure that you don't have, like, meandering plots.
- 22:44Yeah, that you don't have all these tangents that don't go anywhere.
- 22:47And this is something that will appeal to a lot of adult readers as well, um, because a lot of adults' attention pan- spans have also shortened as a result of- Yeah, I was gonna say, I think that's changed over time, and that's something that a lot of writers, especially if you're, you know, with many from the boomer generation and from my gener- you know, from Gen X generation, and we grew up reading much slower books where the pacing is different, and you just can't get away with that now.
- 23:15It doesn't, doesn't stand up in the marketplace, right?
- 23:18It's not what people are wanting.
- 23:20Yeah.
- 23:21Like, I mean, if you go to the, the bookstore and you see "Priory of the Orange Tree," don't think you can get away with writing a fantasy novel that long.
- 23:27That's rare, right?
- 23:28That, one, that someone's gonna buy that.
- 23:31And, and the author whose name I'm forgetting, it's Samantha something.
- 23:35She is an established author before she wrote that book.
- 23:37Like, that was not her debut.
- 23:39Yeah, so shorter, shorter books, or at the very least, like, very tight pacing of, you know, moving from one thing to the next very quickly, especially at the beginning.
- 23:50The second is lots of interiority on the page.
- 23:54Now, this might seem contradictory to what I've, I just said, because interiority, that, that place where you show how the character is feeling and how they're processing and making meaning.
- 24:06Yeah, so those inner thoughts, like they can, on the one hand, they seem like they might slow down the story, right?
- 24:12And so if you're like, "Wait, Sam, you just told me to cut my word count," and, you know, everything like that, I wouldn't do it at the expense of the interiority, because the interiority is where the emotion is coming from, and it's what makes it, it's what makes the book appealing not just to teen readers, but to- readers of all ages Um, honestly, when I talk with readers and when I look at the way that books have changed in the last 30 years, I mean, or 40 years if I'm being honest, how long I've been reading, 45 years, that switch to interiority or deep perspective is one of the biggest shifts.
- 24:50And if you're coming to this having read a lot of books that are 25 or 30 years old as your inspiration, you know, mention Game of Thrones or Lord of the Rings or, you know, you're, you're comparing yourselves to these epic big books that are, would probably never get published today, unfortunately.
- 25:06It's because of this switch or this ability to immerse in that deep way, several with interiority, which is one of the only things, advantages that we have over film or television or, um, other mediums even, even live acting, because they don't have that ability to be inside somebody's head.
- 25:27And you'll see that shift technically in more recent books in that something like omniscience where you're, um, or a third person that is close third person is rare today.
- 25:42And you have to do it so well, and it has to be, you know, there has to be a reason for it.
- 25:46You have to be over the top well to be accepted in publishing.
- 25:50Third person close and/or first person is by far more popular in most genres because we can do this interiority thing, which is really difficult to do well in those other formats.
- 26:02So I just wanted to point out, like technically there's been a shift because of this, because of what people are demanding, and because we have access to, I mean, I can go and do virtual reality or like many, many immersive technologies that allow me or raise my expectations.
- 26:19Yeah.
- 26:20Yeah, and I think it's telling that the, to me, the novels that I see continue to be popular with teen audiences.
- 26:28So I brought up that like Dune and Game of Thrones continue to be popular.
- 26:32Yeah.
- 26:32And partly that's because kids were drawn to them from the movies and the television show.
- 26:37But then they actually read the books and they like the books.
- 26:39And I think both of those series do have, you know, pretty deep interiority, you know- Mm-hmm ... even for the time that they came out.
- 26:48And that's part of why they're still, still appealing.
- 26:50So anyway, so those are my two, like if you want to write for something that will appeal to anyone and that would also get you the teen readers is the deep interiority and the kind of tighter plots.
- 27:02And then the other question you asked about was like what appeals, like what types of stories appeal to teen readers.
- 27:09Um, so this is more of a thing to consider if you are aiming specifically for like middle grade or YA and those kinds of sweet spots.
- 27:18So middle grade, so that's that again, that kind of 8 to 12 You know, 9 to 12 age group.
- 27:25Those books, though the sort of phase of life that kids are in there, these are kids who are starting to get like a little bit of independence, um, and they're starting to figure out like what, who they wanna be in the world.
- 27:38So they're thinking about their interactions with their friends, doing the right thing, you know, when they're faced with like- And, and but they're still part of a family unit too- Yeah in this topic, um, and they see themselves as part of a family unit.
- 27:52They're gonna try to break out of that, right?
- 27:54Yes.
- 27:54And so that was like the family unit.
- 27:57But then we get to the next category, and then there's other sets of topics, right?
- 28:02Yeah, so then with, at the YA side, there is, that's the age at which kids are really thinking about autonomy and independence, right?
- 28:09Like you said, kind of breaking free of the family unit.
- 28:12This is where, you know- Kill the parents ... the age at which-- Yeah.
- 28:16Well, this is why like, you don't have to kill them.
- 28:18That's the joke of some of these.
- 28:20Yeah.
- 28:20If you look at every Disney princess, her mother is dead.
- 28:23Um, sorry to be crass, but this is true, and we don't really think about it.
- 28:26We just accept it.
- 28:27So find a way to get rid of the parental figures or at least make them so useless that they can't-- They're not going to spring in the way that I might and save my kids.
- 28:36Yes.
- 28:37Like, "Hey, yeah, you know what? That person's lying to you. That's not true." Or- Yeah...
- 28:43not have those parental figures or are that they can actually rely on.
- 28:49Like- Yes.
- 28:50Because it's- Yeah, you need to give the, the kids agency, whether it's middle grade or YA, right?
- 28:56Your k- your child protagonists need to have agency.
- 28:59You can't give the agency to an adult, even if it feels, quote-unquote,"more realistic," because the point is that these are kids.
- 29:06The kids who are reading this want to see themselves in the driver's seat.
- 29:10So Suzie, you know, did say like, "Kill off the parents," and like that's why.
- 29:14That's why so many YA books are about orphans, right, or middle grade books are about orphans.
- 29:19Um, but there are some examples of books I can think of where the parents are present and they're supportive even, but they're, the plot is structured in such a way that- That they can't intervene for some reason the teen-- They can't intervene.
- 29:32So the two examples that pop to the top of my head are Date Me, Bryson Keller by Kevin Van Whye, and in this book, the main character is closeted, and he's not sure how his parents are gonna react when they find out that he's gay.
- 29:46And the plot kind of revolves around him sort of secretly dating this other boy who's also closeted.
- 29:52So he can't talk to his parents or any of the adults about what's going on in the plot because he's worried about how they're gonna respond when they find out.
- 30:00Well, right.
- 30:01So when I say kill the parents, you don't have to literally kill them, but you have to create a barrier so that whatever the real or imagined, right?
- 30:08Yeah.
- 30:09In that case.
- 30:11Okay, so that's sort of the topic.
- 30:13That is amazing.
- 30:14So okay, but what can we do technically to attract these younger readers in terms of what emotional depth can they handle?
- 30:23Or we kind of touched on this, what about dark?
- 30:26Like what can middle grade YA readers or that age group reader, what can they handle?
- 30:33Because that question comes up a lot, or sexual explicitness, or politics, or religion, or death.
- 30:38I mean, I'm throwing a lot of these things out there, but this is a big question when people want to write a book that appeals to young teenagers, whether they're writing for adults and they want it to be a crossover or not.
- 30:50What does that look like?
- 30:52How do you make those decisions, and what are the rules if any?
- 30:55Okay, that's a really good question.
- 30:57So there's a huge amount of diversity among kids, just like there is among adults.
- 31:02And kids, for the most part, will kind of know what they are interested and what they can handle in terms of, you know, what they want to be reading about.
- 31:11So you're gonna have some kids who are really craving the dark topics and who can handle them and want to read about them.
- 31:21And then you're gonna have some kids who really don't want that and, and really can't handle it.
- 31:26So I think that it's important to provide, as creators, a variety of, of topics.
- 31:34And so if there is a kind of dark topic that you feel like is important and you have a story that you wanna share about it for young readers, then go for it.
- 31:46Um, we'll talk about some of the, the quote, unquote, boundaries in a second.
- 31:49But if that's not some- if you're not someone who wants to write that, you don't have to because there is a, a market for, and readers who aren't looking for the darker stuff.
- 32:00I think as long as you're clear on this and, and like every genre, I mean, why can't middle reader not technically genres?
- 32:05They're age categories, right?
- 32:07Within that, there are lots of different genres, and they all kind of get lumped together on the same shelf.
- 32:11But there are thrillers and mysteries and romance.
- 32:14You know, all of the things.
- 32:15And so the darkness level and the whatever, it, it really does depend on what type of book.
- 32:21And as long as you're clear on and it's obvious from the get-go, you don't wanna surprise the reader with- Right...
- 32:27a really dark twist three-quarters discombobulating, especially for a younger reader, it can be very triggering.
- 32:34I know when I was trying to help my kids, I mean, choose books, you know, Hunger Games was a huge series, and the movies had just come out when my daughter, my, who's now turning 20, was probably 10 or 11.
- 32:48And so she came to me and said, "I wanna read The Hunger Games." And I mean, I'm, I'm not one for, and we can talk about this too, I don't try to censor books by any means.
- 32:57Mm-hmm.
- 32:58But I wanted her to understand what the book was about because I know my kids.
- 33:01And I said, "Hey, yeah, it's a really awesome book. I loved it." I said, "But it's about kills- kids kind of being forced to kill other children." And I said, "When I took your dad to the movie, he looked at me and said, 'I understand why you like it and why this is a really important movie.
- 33:15But please don't make me watch anymore.
- 33:16I'm gonna, I'm gonna throw up.'" Like it was just way too, way too hard for him.
- 33:22And I told that to my then 10 or 11-year-old, and she said, "Okay, well I'm not ready to read that yet. Like, that feels sad." Right.
- 33:29And I was like, "Okay, yeah." You know, a year or two later she's,"Yeah, I think I got this." And then she read it and she was like, "Whoa." Like crazy emotional, but like, "I'm ready." And that was sort of, I didn't tell her, "Don't read the book." I own the book.
- 33:41It's on the shelf.
- 33:42Go ahead.
- 33:43But just so you know, like do it- Yeah ... in a space where you're gonna be okay, and I'm here to talk about it if it becomes not okay.
- 33:50Right?
- 33:50Like- Yeah...
- 33:52helping them through that choice.
- 33:54Yeah.
- 33:54Which is I think a service that we all owe to any reader of any age, right?
- 33:58Is to be very clear upfront what the emotional experience of the book is so that people can choose whether they're on board for that experience or not.
- 34:09Like, I think there is a temptation for s- like, 'cause I've talked to some writers who are like, "Okay, well, if I include this, then I have to put a content warning, and is that gonna turn people away?" It's like, yes, it is gonna turn people away, but it's gonna turn people away who would not enjoy reading this book, and so that's good.
- 34:25You don't want to trick someone into reading a book that they're not actually going to like.
- 34:30Yeah, and I think that's true no matter what you're writing.
- 34:33It's often writers always wanna have the surprise twist, and if you're writing thriller or suspense, I mean, go listen to my other great colleague, Samantha Skal.
- 34:42We do an episode on that about twists and things.
- 34:44But if you're not writing something that needs to hide it, it's often not the right answer because you could, you could really surprise your reader, and that's true with fantasy books where the first half of the book there's no magic, and then all of a sudden there's magic in the second half of the book.
- 34:58We're breaking a contract here, right?
- 34:59They, we're gonna attract the wrong reader.
- 35:01So the same thing is true with any of these deep topics, which, like you said, I mean, there's a place for these, and it's also the reason why a lot of readers read up or read adult- Mm-hmm ... topics, but don't be afraid to explore them in, in YA or in middle grade.
- 35:18And you were talking, okay, so you kinda mentioned boundaries.
- 35:21You threw out there that you wanted to talk about boundaries.
- 35:23What do you mean by that?
- 35:25Okay, so in terms of boundaries, these are things that are not hard and fast rules, but they are the things that traditional publishers typically will stay away from just because it, they're sort of the social mores and, and- Or controversial or controversies or whatever.
- 35:42So- Mm ... the biggest one, the biggest, clearest one is that there's a pretty hard line around anything sexually explicit for characters that are under the age of 18.
- 35:54Um, now this does not mean that you can't have characters under the age of 18 having sex in your book.
- 36:00It just means that it's probably gonna be fade to black or closed doors.
- 36:03It's gonna be not explicit if you're doing traditional publishing.
- 36:07So that's the, I would say, the biggest one.
- 36:08Yes, not erotica for teens.
- 36:10Correct.
- 36:11Yes.
- 36:12Um, teens read that stuff, but they read it in adult books, and I think it's very notable that A Court of Thorns and Roses, the main character's 19 years old, right?
- 36:21So we can get away with some very explicit sex scenes.
- 36:23I was thinking of that, and that's a, that's a really, you know, that's a really controversial series, or it isn't but maybe should be.
- 36:31And you know, when I, when I used to do a lot of school visits, I would see that book on, you know, grade five kids' desks because they're reading up.
- 36:39And I think- Yeah ... because it's in the young adult section, their parents don't realize what's in the book.
- 36:45Yes.
- 36:45As, and again, I mean, I'm not for censoring or anything else, but I know, like, i- in the case of some of my colleagues or friends, they're like, "Oh, my kid is reading this, and she's 11," right?
- 36:57And I'm saying, "Oh, cool.
- 36:58It's actually an amazing series, but just so you know, there is fairly explicit sex in it." And so, like in, you know, not erotica pieces, I said, "So they're gonna learn some new things, but just be aware, not don't let them read it." And they're like,"Whoa, should I not let her read it?" And I'm like, "They're all reading it." Yeah.
- 37:14So just, just- Just like know ... be prepared to have the conversation and open the door to the conversation.
- 37:20And that's one where, again- Not exactly a censor, but those, those books are also in my home.
- 37:26And when my daughter was, you know, 14 and said, "Can I read these books?" I said, "They have this in it." And she's like, "Ew, I don't wanna read that." And so I was like, "Okay, well, when you're ready," you know.
- 37:35And I'm sure she did read them eventually.
- 37:37Now she's 20.
- 37:38But she didn't ask me, so, so I'm sure they got read.
- 37:42Um, during the pandemic she, she ate books.
- 37:44I had ... I'm fortunate to have some really amazing colleagues who have, uh, worked with some huge publishers, and they brought over boxes of, like, ARCs and, like, cool stuff.
- 37:54And I remember, this is, sorry, just one quick aside, 'cause this is such a good story.
- 37:58It was during the pandemic, and she was in grade, ninth grade, I think, and we had, like, this online Zoom meeting with her teacher who requested it, which is unusual.
- 38:06And we're sitting there, and she's kind of wagging her finger and saying she's a good reader, and the things that she's bringing to school to read during reading period are not high-level books.
- 38:18They're kind of middle grade or whatever, and, or really young, like y- lower YA, and she could be reading much more.
- 38:26And we, we were doing, we were doing this Zoom meeting in this office, like, right, I was sitting right in this chair.
- 38:32Mm-hmm.
- 38:33And I said, "Oh," and I looked at my daughter and I said, "What, what gives?" And she said, "We only read 10 minutes a day, and I don't wanna leave that," like, they were back in school- Mm-hmm ... um, masked and all the things, and distanced, but they were back in school, and she said, "I don't wanna leave my book there.
- 38:48And so I just bring a book that I can re-read." She goes, "But that's not what I'm actually reading." And I reached for this stack of books that was on my desk, I'm like, "This is her actual reading list." And I was, like, showing the teacher these things, and she's like, "That book isn't out yet." I'm like, "No, it isn't." She's like, "Oh my God, now I wanna read what she's reading." But, like, yeah, it was this thing where she was actually hiding what she was reading because it wasn't, you know, she didn't wanna talk about it with other kids.
- 39:15She didn't wanna show people that she had signed books- Right...
- 39:19from pretty big authors.
- 39:21They weren't mine.
- 39:22They were from colleagues that had dropped them off to keep her entertained, but yeah.
- 39:26It's amazing, right?
- 39:27Like, what they end up reaching to read.
- 39:30Okay, so we're talking about the content and all of the things, and the boundaries.
- 39:35Were there any other boundaries, or are we good?
- 39:37So that's, that's the really the only Absolute, like clear boundaries Well, and I will say, yeah, and I will say if you are writing, um, YA and/or middle grade, and you want to be in the school system, then you have a different standard, um, because you may not be- Yes, that's true allowed to present in schools if you have certain content in your books.
- 39:58And it's just something to be aware of.
- 40:00It doesn't mean that you can't write them.
- 40:01It does mean that you may get banned, which might, might be a great thing because you can feature that or you can rail against it, um, maybe do something right.
- 40:10Yeah.
- 40:10I mean, so for example, like I write LGBTQ fiction- Yeah...
- 40:13um, and you were saying about how like A shelves at, you know, in the YA section in the school library- Yeah ... or whatever, and nobody thinks twice about it.
- 40:23Totally has.
- 40:24Nope.
- 40:24And a way less explicit same sex romance- Ugh, so frustrating would absolutely be challenged.
- 40:30Yeah.
- 40:30Yeah.
- 40:31So frustrating in terms of what- Yeah... people's biases are, and, and you know the whole point of literature at that age is to expose people to different things.
- 40:39Yes.
- 40:39And actually, this is a topic I'm gonna stumble through right here.
- 40:43But you know, there's this idea, and it's something that I coach a lot of writers on, and I'm sure you come across as well, when we are from a different generation and we don't have the language or things, you know, bullying was different in terms of what was acceptable and things like that in our day, and it does still happen, but we try to model different things in books and not, not unintentionally reinforce negative stereotypes.
- 41:08We try to not sugarcoat the world, but we try not to give voice to some of those negative opinions.
- 41:16What's your experience been on that?
- 41:17Like w- whatever the topic, right?
- 41:20There's things that are just-- I had to tell a writer, you know, writing middle grade this week when she's using the word stupid.
- 41:27Mm-hmm.
- 41:27And I'm like, "Kids don't use that word anymore," right?
- 41:30Like we don't to, not in the way that we did growing up, and you've gotta adjust it'cause a publisher won't like it, right?
- 41:36Like how do you- Yeah...
- 41:38how do you talk to your Okay, so that's a really good question.
- 41:43So one of the things that I'm always on the lookout for is tropes, like problematic tropes that are now kind of- Stereotypes, right?
- 41:50Yeah, or stereotypes and things like that.
- 41:52Yeah.
- 41:52So like the gay best friend stereotype, for example.
- 41:55Like, I was just working on a manuscript that had it, and I was like, "Okay." And I said, "You can do this, but there's a lot of people who aren't gonna like it," right?
- 42:02There's a, a lot of people who are gonna find it to be kind of like stereotypical.
- 42:05So if it's important to you that your straight female character has a gay best friend, because like some straight women have gay male best friends, you just wanna make sure this guy is like really well-developed as a character and that, you know, you do something to subvert the trope.
- 42:20Like, you know, what if he's married?
- 42:23Whereas like normally that stereotype is, you know, if I'm working on- The single one that's always available to- He's single all the time.
- 42:28Right.
- 42:28Yeah.
- 42:29Yeah.
- 42:29Yeah.
- 42:30So I would say that that's the main way in which that comes up in my work, is kind of identifying tropes that are now like, you know, used to be really common or like things that we now would say are stereotypical that we, we wanna edit out.
- 42:46The other place I would s- you were talking about how we wanna like model things that are like maybe not reality, but would be like a better version of reality.
- 42:55So like consent in relationships, you see this in romance novels both, you know, as well as in YA novels.
- 43:02So I thought, I was just thinking about is, I, I always forget the, if it's Dark and Deepest Red or Deep and Darkest Red.
- 43:09I think it's Dark and Deepest Red.
- 43:10Okay.
- 43:10By, uh- Oh ... Anna-Marie McLemore.
- 43:13It's a retelling of The Red Shoes, the fairytale.
- 43:16Yeah.
- 43:16And there's a sex scene in the book.
- 43:18It's very not explicit, like very implied, but it's between two teenagers, and the author very specifically models healthy consent between these two teenagers, right?
- 43:28In a way that probably real teenagers don't yet know how to do.
- 43:33But it is no fun for those teenagers- I hope my kids never listen to this episode- Who are reading it ... because I'm sharing a lot.
- 43:39But my youngest came home this week and said, "Mom, we learned all about consent today in sex ed." And I was like, she, and I said, "Oh yeah?
- 43:46How was that?" She's like, "I mean, how many times have we had this conversation?" Because it's something that we talk about, um, very openly in terms of writing, and she's my one hope for, I have one hope for a reader and one hope for a writer.
- 44:00That's my, and then I have a child who's interested in neither.
- 44:03But yeah, so, so she's actually quite interested in that topic, and so I don't think she offered any advice or anything, I'll say, during that class- Yeah but she said, "Yeah, like, all the things that you and I have talked about and things we learned today," so yeah.
- 44:18It's something that they're learning, but, but it's difficult to model, for sure.
- 44:21Or for many of those teens in that classroom, it was probably the first time that they'd ever heard that topic talked about.
- 44:27Right.
- 44:28So modeling it in books- Well, and like, if their parents- Mm-hmm ... you know, don't wanna talk to them about it or don't know how to talk to them about it, you know, a book is a place where they can find it.
- 44:36Yes.
- 44:37And for me, because I'm so aware of it because of the industry, it's definitely something I talk about with my girls, it's something I talk about even more with my son.
- 44:45Um, it's really, really important for, to have that conversation, and to model that in books is amazing.
- 44:50Okay, so the bottom line is we do want to have, we talked about tropes or, or whatnot, we wanna have diversity in our books, but we don't wanna be modeling or inadvertently reinforcing negative stereotypes.
- 45:02But give them a role, right?
- 45:04We don't wanna just stick something in there that, you know, a diverse character that is unlike ourselves just to have them there or to check a box.
- 45:13Right.
- 45:13We need to make sure that they are, you know, that it's not just that they're a gay character, but that they actually make sense in terms of, yes, there are many, many gay people in the world, so they belong in your book.
- 45:24Uh, it doesn't need to- Yeah ... write it, right?
- 45:27Yeah.
- 45:27There's, um, so there's a, a little test that, it's called the Vito Russo test.
- 45:31It's kind of like the Bechdel test, and it's specifically for, for gay characters, but I think you can modify it in general for, like, approaching writing about marginalization.
- 45:42So the, the Vito Russo test is do you have, like, identifiably, explicitly gay characters?
- 45:49Yeah.
- 45:49So, like, Dumbledore doesn't count because he's not explicitly gay in the book.
- 45:53J.K. Rowling- Exactly ... just said he was later.
- 45:55Yeah.
- 45:55Um, is the character important to the plot such that their removal alters the story?
- 46:03And the last one is, are they identifiable by features, differentiable from other characters by features other than their marginalization?
- 46:11Yeah.
- 46:11So those are three good questions to ask yourself, and just like replace gay with, you know, whatever type of marginalization you're working on, or representation- Yeah ... you're working on.
- 46:20Right?
- 46:20So make sure that your characters are three-dimensional, right?
- 46:23That they're not just identifiable by, well, this character's gay, and that's how they're different from the main character.
- 46:27Yeah.
- 46:28They're not a stock character, right?
- 46:29Yeah.
- 46:30And that they actually matter to the story.
- 46:32Okay.
- 46:33Well, this has been absolutely amazing.
- 46:35I, I'm sure we're gonna talk about teen brains for many, many years to come- Yeah ... you and I. But yeah, we're to the quick-fire portion.
- 46:43You only get one quick-fire question, because I've asked you these questions before.
- 46:47But what is your best advice for writers listening today that wanna pull in young people to their books?
- 46:54Do some journaling about what it was like for you at that age, and what mattered to you, and what you cared- Mm-hmm... about and what you wanted to see.
- 47:03Yeah.
- 47:04Good advice.
- 47:05But then I, yeah, and i- it's excellent advice, but if you are of my generation, you're gonna need to temper that, right?
- 47:11Um- Yeah...
- 47:12to, to modernize it a little But- Some of the deep stuff will resonate still.
- 47:18Yeah, absolutely.
- 47:19I mean, universal truths are universal truths, whether or not you had a landline that you, a pink phone that you pulled down the hall and in your bedroom with a really long cord, or whether you Snapchat your friends 80 times an hour, right?
- 47:35Like, technology- Yeah ... may have changed, but the resonance or the emotional resonance- The feelings ... probably hasn't.
- 47:40Yeah.
- 47:41Amazing.
- 47:41Thank you so much, Sam, for coming on the podcast again today.
- 47:45This was amazing.
- 47:46Thank you, Suzy.
- 47:47It was great to be here.
- 47:54Thanks for tuning in to the Show, Don't Tell writing podcast with me, Suzy Fiedorowy.
- 47:59It is my absolute honor to bring you the straight goods for that book you're writing or the book that you're planning to write.
- 48:05Please help me keep the podcast going by helping people find us.
- 48:09You can subscribe to the podcast and leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever else you're listening to show how much you enjoy the show.
- 48:18That's how other listeners will find us.
- 48:21Also, visit Suzyfiedorowy.com/newsletter to hop on my weekly inspired writing newsletter list, where you'll stay inspired and be the first to know about all the upcoming training events and writing courses that happen in my community.
- 48:35Want my eyes on your writing?
- 48:37Submit a page of your current draft for a chance to come on the podcast at the link in the show notes.
- 48:42I'd love to chat with you about your writing in my always positive, incredibly supportive way so that you can make great strides towards your writing goals.
- 48:52I'm here to cheer you on.
- 48:54Remember, that book you're writing is gonna open doors that you haven't even thought of yet, and I can't wait to help you make that it the absolute best it can be.
- 49:04See you again right here next week