Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Buffer Pools Lock Up 40% of Credits, Insurance Costs 1% a Year | CWN EP11
Transcript
- speaker-0: Bepper pools are not really insurance, they are self-insurance. Japan has a Paris Agreement net zero fift twenty fifty goal and they're sticking to it. The best way of getting that done is to show up in person, face to face, a few times. So if you have some, yeah. contracted revenue, that's awesome. Copper pool, a developer locks up up to 35. We've even seen developers with 40%, you're paying, you know, 1% a year instead of 40% up front. No insurance company will ever cover you for a risk for 40 years. Banks do not lend money to anything that's not insured. speaker-1: Hey everyone, welcome to the next episode of CWN. You see, I'm alone. Only one face in the picture. Dan decided to leave us alone. Now he on short notice went to COP and the traffic is so bad in in Turkey that he's not making it. He planned to. But it's back to the roots. Me alone in the in the studio. But we still have two super interesting guests today. So first we're gonna talk about the Japanese way of thinking about CDR. We have Ambika from Idomitsu here. Idomitsu is super active in the car markets. They're not only investing straight into projects as a corporate venture fund, but they're also just announces that facility within Planet. They're also doing off takes and compliance markets. So that's super exciting. So we have Ambika here. We will talk about that and also what is different maybe from the Japanese way to the US way and the European way. And then the second part is around financing and insurance. So I think we've seen over the last couple of weeks that there's a lot of financing going on. But we've also seen more and more insurance things coming up. So we have Nandini from Carbon Pool over. They just placed this first insurance policy on Vera's durability pilot. And she will tell us a little bit about what this actually is about and what kind of role does insurance play and why buffer pools are not really helping buyers to cover their risks. And yeah, I'm super excited to get into it. Today we're gonna talk about. Something that is from my perspective super exciting from two different perspectives. So, on one hand, obviously what is super interesting is a company that is not the usual company, like your European or US company, and you already know how they interact with the CDR space. and the second one is a kind of theme that we've seen over the last couple of weeks, which is financing of of C DR projects and for that I have Ambika from Idimitsu with us and I'm super excited to see you again. in a new role since last we've seen, but I think the very first time we've seen each other was on that was that rooftop of the Salesforce building in in San Francisco. I think it was three or four years ago and a lot has happened since then. speaker-0: Agreed. Wow. I I I think of people in the carbon markets who have been around for more than one year are basically a veteran. There's so much that we've seen in just a few years. But yeah, it's been lovely to see your journey and really excited to tell you about what we're working on on our side. speaker-1: Amazing. And I think you've seen it all, right? No, you haven't been to a project developer, I I think, right? but you've been at a registry with Puro, you've been at Patch and now at Idomitsu. You have almost all the perspectives of carbon markets. So I wouldn't even say you're just a veteran. You're probably I don't know, the veteran expert of of carbon market after seeing it from all perspective, which I think that's the next level. speaker-0: The middle person. I'm constantly somewhere in the middle. I'm a sandwich sandwich operator. speaker-1: Somewhere always in between. But that's that's important, like building a bridges. And now you're building a bridge from the US to Japan. Maybe tell me a little bit like w what you're up to at Idomitsu, what is Idumitsu overall up to in in the C D R market? speaker-0: Well, coming from North America, it's been such a nice, nice experience because I'm working for a company that works within a compliance market. Japan has a Paris Agreement net zero fifty like twenty fifty goal, and they're sticking to it. And it's been slow progress, but it's been steady progress towards that. So Idamitsu is like any other Japanese corporate, we have a 2050 net zero goal. We also have pretty ambitious decarbonization goals for 2030 and 2035. And so a lot of our company across the company, there's all sorts of decarbonization efforts going on. With regard to carbon removal, we think of it the same way a lot of companies think of it, which is you know, let's prioritize reductions, but carbon removal is absolutely going to be something that we need to do. And we have a little bit of time to get to know. how carbon removal works and where we can operate and how we might be able to make money off of it and all of those little details. So on the corporate venture capital team, which is where I sit in Silicon Valley in California, we're taking a a long-term look at carbon removal. So five to 10 years years from now, what's going to be relevant for Idomitsu, what's going to be relevant for the market? And that's how we're plugging in. So we're investing usually equity positions into carbon removal companies and learning about the market that way so that slowly and steadily we can get more involved. speaker-1: But I I would still say, you said how other companies look at it, but I think your way, and maybe it's the Japanese way, but you will tell me about it, is a little bit different. Where a lot of the companies they're just interacting with the market by signing off takes, right? Signing off takes, and some even not off takes, some even just spot transactions. But you are looking at from a different perspective, right? You just said VC funding investment and learning from it. But then also there was a deaf facility that you just announced with Inplanet. And then I'm not sure if you also do off takes as well. I'm like there's there's a lot of different blocks here to that strategy, and I think that's not the the usual strategy. speaker-0: Fair enough. We do well, for our compliance obligations, we do have to purchase credits. we operate globally, and so in markets like Japan and Australia, we are purchasing credits. But and and there's a team focused on that. But when we think about the next generation of technologies, as you and I both know, these compliance markets are coming up to speed on high durability, carbon removal. You means who believes in high durability carbon removal and that we'll be able to play a role in that. And so that's where specifically we're learning and taking our time. whereas yes, there are some off takes but those are focused on our compliance targets at the moment. speaker-1: And and now you've s also I I just came up, you also seen almost three different cultures as well, right? Because Puro has been European company, Patch is a US company, your Japanese company. Yes. Can you maybe do like a small comparison? Like how d do these views on on on markets, ecosystem and so on differ? speaker-0: okay. So what comes up, okay, views on markets and ecosystems. I think the the truth is certainly that if you are operating in a country with a compliance market, you have a different sense of urgency, right? The time is now, policy is being developed and shaped now. So I think there's a different sense of speaker-1: Pull then push, right? speaker-0: exactly more pull than push. The time is now. There's more influence and actually a a little bit more of a sense of security. And so the very American way of doing things is to believe that we have to work harder, faster, make the market and push. Yeah. Yeah. Just or I don't yeah, in whatever sense in whatever direction we are providing the energy that the corporates need. Whereas in in Japan and Europe, there's a a lot more help from there's a lot more energy in general to draw. speaker-1: That's that's super interesting. And if you do you also if we then look f from the Japanese perspective, is there something else that you would say that is very, very unique to the Japanese thinking on CDR? Yeah. speaker-0: well, one thing that I've noticed is that like the Japanese way of business is very relationship driven. And that's not necessarily different from other markets, but it's it's just very codified into the way of work. And so if you are seeking an off take with a Japanese corporate, the best way of getting that done is to show up in person, face to face a few times. the The trust building is really pretty necessary. And there's a lot of a lot of reason for that. It's not just effort that you're putting towards this contract. It's an it's a partnership that you're creating that's gonna go both ways. So I can I can definitely say from my vantage point as a Japanese corporate, we do so much more beyond transactional deal structures. and that that type of partnership can only come from working really closely and trusting a partner. a lot. So I would say relationship building is a big unique thing that we don't see in other markets. speaker-1: That's wild because one thing I've I've realized really often and especially in European markets, it's obviously you have some well, you have like a in a corporate you on a buyer, you have some kind of champion that maybe is super interested in the topic and maybe goes to conferences and and so on and so forth. But then I would still say most of it is actually happening through procurement and they don't want to see you. Or like they don't care to see you. In the end, it's basically just the offer that you can make and the risks and the guarantees you can provide, the pricing and so on. So it's very interesting. Even we we have some some customers, I've never seen them in person. And it's it's really like one some of our big customers. I have never seen them. And basically, even when I'm there, I'm asking, like, hey. I'm around, should we go for coffee? And they're like, No, sorry, I have no time, or Hey, sorry, I'm not there, or too busy, or but hey, let's meet for a digital meeting next week or something like that. But really of that's that's not always the case, but I've seen that quite often in in Europe where it's I've never talked to someone. I at a certain point just get invited to an RFP and then I basically just have to hand in an offer that is really competitive. But it's not always around relationships. So that's very interesting. So very, very different to from that perspective. speaker-2: Yeah. speaker-0: I agree. The relationships are are true in every every region. But on on top of that, I would say diligence is of course a big thing on on the Japanese side of things as well. So anyone needs to be able to to jump through the regular hoops of quality and pricing. and those like Japanese corporates tend to dive into the details on that and are very they take their time to get to know all of the details and build that internal case and work through all of the corporate processes to to get everybody on board. It's a very consensus driven work culture. And so that does take longer. So I while in Europe you might be a little bit more transactional, a little bit less relationship based, you do get a deal done a little bit faster. speaker-1: that's that's interesting. But what I what I've seen is, and maybe you can correct me, the Japanese companies that are active in the CDR market, really often it's not RFP driven. It's more like relationship building and then due diligence and contracting and so on and so forth that maybe takes a long time, but hardly ever it's like an RFP and I get a lot of different offers in and then I decide who I want to work with. speaker-0: Yeah, that's a great that's a really great point and a piece of evidence that yeah, they're not gonna send out a call to the market. They're gonna send out a a call specifically to the the group, the person that they know. speaker-1: That's interesting. And I and I and I seen a lot of at conferences I also always see from Japanese corporates. They do their homework, right? I I realized like at one conference someone came up to me and and this person knew everything around about me. And is like, you're doing this and this and this. Very interesting on your biochar deal and I was like, okay, who are you? I I found that very interesting, but I think there's also a a thing, right? Whereas in in in Germany, at least I know, sometimes you send someone to a conference to learn things and to get into it. And then you come back with things that's over there is like a lot of pre work and then you go somewhere and that I found speaker-0: Definitely it. And I'd add that a lot of even though you might be meeting one person and interacting with one person and developing that relationship, often that person comes from a team of, you know, depending on the organization, like 20 other people who are constantly working on carbon markets day in and day out. So there's a lot of knowledge within that organization that gets filtered into one person. and that all happens behind the scenes. So it's a little bit tricky in that way. So if you're talking to, Mitsubishi, for example, there are over I think fifteen people working on CDR specifically. but that's hard to know sometimes. speaker-1: Wow, that that's a lot. Because yeah, again, I think it's different than a lot of the corporates, even on US side. Sometimes you literally even in a very big company, you only have one person working or two person working, people working in that department. And you will always know everyone. and then maybe there's procurement I think it's just a different structure of how it is, because you have one person working as a champion and then they just go to different departments and then they only draw them in when needed. well okay. And if we look at specific project types or pathways, is there something that is of specific interest? Because I've I've seen InPlanet is obviously enhanced rock weathering. It's quite new, but is there like any like specific perspective on what a methodology needs to be like, what a project needs to offer, is there regions, or is it really driven by the compli compliance perspective? how how do you look at it? speaker-0: Good question. And and increasingly I'm seeing this as I yeah, float around the market. There's there is definitely a regionality to the type of CDR that people want to buy or carbon credits that people want to buy. So in Japan, we're looking at an island nation that's very proud and and wants to stimulate domestic industry. So in like we see this in the JCM as it exists now, and we'll continue to see it. Whatever carbon credits can be done within can be created within Japan's borders are gonna take priority. so we're looking a lot at marine CDR technologies, for example, island nation. there's some forestry, but there's not a ton of biomass available on Japan as a, you know, as a country. And so direct air capture makes a lot of sense, BECS makes a lot of sense, but not so much biochar. Even ERW is a bit there aren't a ton of pasture fields within Japan to to apply that. So our connection to ERW is actually a bit more through a sense that there might be an Article Six connection. There's already a little bit of a connection between Brazil and Japan. but also Inamitsu plays in agriculture over broad abroad overseas. And so So that's our connection to ERW. But to speaker-1: It's l a little bit like a a long term view of what could get relevant and and what is maybe adjacent to to business field of Idomitsu. speaker-0: Right. Exactly. Yeah. speaker-1: Well. Okay. And I think what I was also interesting interested about is obviously that perspective on financing debts and so on. maybe I think the over the last couple of weeks there was quite some some headlines on debts and financing and so on. Obviously, Dan he knows a lot about it as a project developer. They got financing from the World Bank and so on. Here's an and traffic and and COP here short term decided to to go there. But if we look at the the debt side, like how how is your and also Idomitsu's perspective on debt and financing? I mean don't not sure if this was your first time dealing with that. it's obviously an important possible piece like but how do you think about it? speaker-0: Well, w the the original thought or the core belief is, you know, we've made an investment into our portfolio companies and we will do everything we can to support them. We are a strategic investor. And so that partnership, as we talked about before, is ex like very important to us. And as as you know, as CDR companies have established their technology, proof of concept is there, they're delivering. The next step that they need is to scale. their their projects. And so project level financing is extremely important at this point in the market. and we were approached by InPlanet or our had our had our relationship already and and we were talking about what they need and they were facing in Brazil a really high cost of capital, which is, you know Fair for maybe a generalist who doesn't know the ins and outs of of InPlanet, but we were familiar with the company. We knew that their technology had been proven and that like the volatility of the Brazilian market wasn't actually going to be as a like a big thing in in their investment or investing into them. And so we were really excited to be able to provide them capital at a lower cost. and help them scale to meet a very sure commitment, which was their big off take with a big creditworthy corporate. speaker-1: So but basically what what you're saying is that in order for you to feel comfortable about that, you also need an off tech on the other side. speaker-0: Yes. Yeah. So I mean, it's so much easier. well, let me take a step back. So in our process of getting this debt facility done, we went through our finance team at Idomitsu and they look at everything under the sun. We're an energy company. So they're looking at, you know, natural gas projects over here and rice methane projects over there. And so we needed to have a very clear financial reason for investing. So when we went to do that, we had to have yeah, a pretty strong case. and that meant that we needed revenue that implanted knew was gonna come through the door. Of course, there's always risk and there will always be risk. That's part of the game. but y you know, an option to buy or a soft commitment to buy, that's not really a great case. If you have some yeah. contracted revenue, that's awesome. We can do something with that. speaker-1: Fantastic. And if I'm now a a project developer, like what what is it that what else you're looking at at the moment? Like when does it make like or where do you say like this is something we're actually very excited about at the moment and we wanna get a little bit deeper into? speaker-2: Mm. speaker-0: meaning technology or anything? speaker-1: Yeah. I think I I think technology, I mean that obviously is is very exciting. But as mentioned, I think probably if you invest in a project and you're really convinced and they have an off take, then it's a win win for you. but that obviously you need to have invested in a company. So but if you then look about technology, like what what is it that you're currently very excited? speaker-2: Ooh. speaker-0: currently very excited about. it's it's all of the things that you know about, which is you know, we're looking for a technology that's actually venture worthy, right? We're looking for innovation on a venture capital team. it's hard to make a a case for a a technology that's already born out with a business model that's already born out. So we're looking for an innovation speaker-1: Imagine it's a biochar project and you're just gonna use a a new biochar a new kiln or a kiln that has been used for a lot and you it's just a logistic endeavor basically to deliver credit. speaker-0: Exactly, which is a great case for project finance. and and we're we're all for that as well. But I exactly. you know, biochar, some forestry projects, these are not venture related. so we're looking for for innovation. We're looking for as as we spoke, relevance to the the Japanese organization or the region as well as our organization. And and One thing that's really specific to us is that we're looking for a company or a technology where we can be relevant. Idomitsu can be a good partner. speaker-1: Okay. speaker-0: we know, for example, bioenergy. we know energy at large. And so VEX is looking like an exciting place for us. but we also know agriculture because we have some petro, petroleum-based fertilizers and and so on. the other technologies that are exciting. Are of course direct air capture is going to be very relevant to to an energy provider and and Japan. at the moment there's a lot going on in direct air capture. We're still learning a lot about the technology. And so that's an area where we're taking our time to get to know the space before we go too far in one direction. speaker-1: Yeah, it's I I I definitely see the same. I just had in the last episode I we were talking with the Rocky Mont Institute and they did that analysis on the different kind of pathways. And I I think one thing that also came out is that direct back catcher is definitely developing slower than expected. Right. And also the price forecast that we maybe all were dreaming about three years ago and we were like, hey, in 230 or 235, we're gonna get to a hundred dollar. I think that is at this point not working. But on the other hand, is we there's can still be innovation, right? Maybe there will be a new kind of direct catcher methodology and suddenly we're like, maybe we get to 50. I don't know. so I but it's it it's definitely not easy. Like we actually did a couple of and they're not announced yet but or not all of them one one is the the one with deep sky but we have another one way bigger. yeah I look quite a bit into it and it's definitely not easy. as for now to basically meet I think it's also the one where the Expectation from project developer and buyers are the furthest away on pricing. So there is this other study, I think or like it was a survey from CDR.fori, but then also BCG just brought out a new report where they interviewed 300 buyers, and we also had someone from BCG over recently. And both these surveys basically showed how like What are project developers asking for projects in the future and what are buyers expecting? And there's the biggest gap. Whereas mostly it's only off like five percent, ten percent, sometimes even c aligning quite a bit. I think with direct ad capture there was a massive gap. So I think we're still not at the spot where someone figured it out, so to say. that a buyer says, this is an attractive price. I'm I'm supporting that and not signing off takes and so on. But that also means that whenever there are hurdles it's interesting for for investments, right? If you solve it then can be a can be a good return. speaker-0: Definitely. yeah, to your point, we're we're really excited for that technology to be born out. It it isn't yet. And so yeah, wherever we can see see innovation, see development, we're yeah, we're happy to help. But it's been a slow, slow progress. speaker-1: So is there anything about the Japanese market that you haven't said yet? speaker-0: Well, the way that I like to think about it, and and perhaps this is a helpful framework, is Japan is prioritizing carbon credits made within its borders, and then Article Six countries. Article six countries tend to be right, there's there's a list. India is one of them, Indonesia is another. they tend to be in the global south and providing an entirely different regional. support to Japan than Japan has. So often agrarian countries. And then the third priority is you know, the global market. And so it's been really important to for us to invest not only in in something that's going to be relevant to Japan and and be useful onshore, but also then looking at the Article Six countries. And that's been an important distinction as we look at possible investments. speaker-1: Yeah. Fantastic. Thanks so much. to close it off, one last question. And first of all, obviously thank you for getting up so early for us. I know you're in in San Francisco. speaker-2: Anytime. speaker-1: It's seven AM and when when I actually checked the time just now and to check what what time is it actually, I was like, damn. some other time. Well, well. We we made it. but maybe to close off As we just as we started, you you being a veteran, where do you stand at the moment, like a how do you call it, barometer or something like that on your feeling on on CDR, right? Because you've been in the space for four years or so. Like there were ups and like four years ago when we met, then we were all like, This is gonna be the greatest thing ever. I then it went down again. now for me at least this year somehow felt good, even though maybe I'm also just really good at not looking at any bad headlines anymore, not just focusing on the good. But where do you stand right now on on your C D R barometer? speaker-0: I think like you, I'm as excited about it as ever, but in different ways. Right. I think we've made a lot of progress technologically. I mean, two, three years ago, if we were talking about biochar, we were all very hesitant, maybe it'll work. We're not sure. And now it's just it's out there, it's fully fledged, it makes so much sense. speaker-2: I would speaker-1: Asking questions anymore, right? Everyone is like, yeah, that's Balcha. speaker-0: Exactly. And and as there should be. and and and I'm seeing that conversation also be a part like biochar is a part of a lot of other industries that were previously not talking about biochar. I mean steel, concrete, just anyone who has biomass sitting around is thinking about biochar these days, which which is great. I think so I'm I'm excited as ever, I think that there I mean, we knew that this was gonna happen. It happens with any hype hype cycle. There's a little bit of a a lull where we all have to put our heads down and get the technology to scale and build the market infrastructure. I think everyone's still excited. Everyone has the right ideas and knows what the market needs. so it's just a matter of having that marathon mindset now. Rather than the let's all pile on in this exciting new thing. It's time to yeah, put our heads down and slog through. speaker-1: Which sometimes is tough if you're VC, but you're a corporate VC, maybe it's little bit different. but I I can just say, I mean, obviously I'm talking to a lot of VCs always, and San Francisco even more so and our investors are mostly from there. they obviously have a different mindset. so I'm I'm very curious and we've seen that with some companies that have been VC funded, it's quite tough. to align that kind of marathon mindset with the kind of returns that maybe a a VC wants to see. But because then that's actually where I think a corporate VC can be so valuable for for companies that's that need to raise money. So I I appreciate what you're doing and I think it's super valuable. Thanks so much for coming over. speaker-0: Course. Thanks. And I'll I'll simply add that what I like about corporate VC is we're looking at how does this technology get applied and how can we be helpful. so so we're really looking through like we want to use this technology tomorrow if we can. let's get that done as opposed to here's some money, we're gonna be hands-off and hope that you make it happen in the next couple of years. speaker-1: Fantastic. Thanks so much for coming. speaker-0: Thanks so much, Adrienne. I really appreciate it. And thanks for the the podcast. It's been so wonderful. speaker-1: No pleasure. I hope you enjoy your first coffee or second. speaker-2: Thank you. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: So now we're gonna talk about a topic that also followed us a lot over the last weeks. We talked about financing, but we also talked a lot about insurance because this is one of the building blocks in order to get the market up. And I'm super excited to have Nandini from Carbon Pool with us. It just announced this insurance policy under Vera's durability pilot, which I'm super excited to talk about in a minute. But Nandini, welcome. I'm excited to have you. Maybe you can tell us a little bit like how did you end up in this not it wouldn't I I was about to say mess, but how did you end up in in carbon markets? Tell us a little bit about it and then we can maybe talk about the durability part. speaker-0: Yeah, sure. Adrian, thank you very much for having me. how did I end up in the carbon markets? It's a good question. I started my career as a real estate lawyer, so I've certainly departed from the from the original track a multiple times already. I was at Allianz for thirteen years doing various things, insurance related and My former boss at Alliance left in twenty twenty-two and he phoned me up and he said, Hey, I have this idea. I said, Well, tell me about it. And he said, I think really that the carbon markets are, you know, the biggest and most important uninsured opportunity that exists today. And I thought, I don't even know what a carbon credit is, so let's start there. but once he explained the proposition to me, I got it. And honestly. There was nothing that anybody else could offer me that was more compelling than the ability to use this financial instrument that I knew quite well to help scale investment and carbon removal and avoided avoided carbon emission. You know, we all live in a in a planet that is experiencing an incredible crisis that is, you know, that's probably even an understatement. But to be able to use my professional skills and energies to do that. was s so compelling that I that I left Alliance and officially joined Carbon Pool early in twenty twenty three. speaker-1: It's actually wild, right? That we think about the carbon market a couple of years ago and insurance was not a topic. Like it was I mean, maybe people talked about it, but it's there was no serious insurance pilots going on and so on and so on. I I think pretty wild, right? Because we knew all at least we knew the forecast, right? We all the papers that came out from McKinsey, BCG and so on. We know in two thirty it will be this, then two forty it will be this. Actually I like at least from an entrepreneur perspective, it's interesting that it took quite some time until insurance came into the picture. speaker-0: Yes. Yeah. I actually th that is correct. And I agree that there seems to have been a real sea change between when we started out end of twenty twenty two to now that the dis the difference is is substantial. when I joined, people didn't weren't familiar with insurance solutions, people were asking insurance to cover for things that insurance typically doesn't cover for. people just there wasn't insurance capacity really available in the space. And my big revelation over the last couple of years is that insurance startups like ours are a really important go-between between the carbon market and as large established insurance players. Right. So all of us in the carbon markets, whether it's RTO or Kita or Carbon Pool. Are working with large capacity providers, large insurance companies. But we are the ones who explain the market to those insurance providers, and we are the ones who explain the risks and explain how insurance can play in those markets. And I think without that translation, the amount of work and time and effort it takes to get to know the carbon markets and to understand the niches in which insurance products can play. A role today, that effort is is hard for a big balance sheet insurer to justify. But if they do it using someone like us as kind of an intermediary or an underwriting partner, then they they don't have they can they can stick their toe in the water without having to invest all the time and effort up front in learning how how insurance can play in the space. speaker-1: I talked to a lot of insurance companies, the big ones, and I probably at least can say that I mean you talked way more to these kind of companies, but I I I have the same feeling, right? So what I mean by the same feeling is that everyone is excited about it, the opportunities it brings, but as these corporates work, they don't have the kind of I was I wouldn't say innovation budget, but that kind of budget to now basically get the complete expert in the market and now can set up I don't know twenty, thirty people to figure out and and you don't know the timelines, right? You don't know how the market evolves and so on. Yeah. So it's it's more like a a startup job, so to say. Yeah. than than it is a a a corporate job. speaker-0: Yes, that's right. That's right. Go. speaker-1: But yeah, let's let's talk about the exciting news you had recently. You've just placed the first insurance policy under Vera's durability pol pilot. Yes in in plain words, like what does that policy do and how did you get there? Like I'm I'm I was really excited when I read it and then I was like immediately, we have to we have to get Nandini on the show. So I'm I'm super excited to dig in a little bit. speaker-0: Yes, let's dig in. So one of the th the opportunities that was what first caught our attention when we as carbon pools started was in fact buffer pools. Because we thought, well, a pool, what's a pool? Is it an insur it's an insurance vehicle? effectively it was set up as promising s something like an insurance cover. So when you issue credits, you put some credits aside in the buffer pool and those credits are supposed to cover you in the event of of of certain events happening in the future that reverse your carbon credits. And I thought to myself, okay, let me find out what how these actually operate. How do they work? How are the contributions size? What risks do they cover? How much coverage do they offer? And as we're ready speaker-1: He asked more questions than most buyers. speaker-0: Yeah, I yeah, exactly. Well I came at right. So I came at it with a very insurance mindset, which is what is this thing that seems to be insurance? And what we quickly discovered is actually buffer pools are not really insurance, they are self-insurance. Effectively, they require a developer to put aside some credits. And if the developer suffers a loss, not only if if those those credits are used first to to compensate for the loss, but if there aren't enough and the central pool maintained by the registry, if that has to kick in. Then at the next issuance, the developer has to backfill those credits. the registries are all slightly different in how they operate, but that's basically how they operate. also, they promise to cover a reversal for a very long time. And no insurance company, no insurance company will ever cover you for a risk for 40 years. It just doesn't work. And the reason is simply because risk profiles change. And every year or every two years, an insurance company will remodel the risk or re-underwrite the risk because they want to know how the risk has changed. So there were a couple of things that set off alarm bells is maybe too strong a word, but I just thought this doesn't it it smells like insurance, but it's really not insurance. So on the back of that, we we started to have conversations with registries, with standards standard setters like ICBCM. and in particular we had a long and deep sustained conversation with Vera. And Vera, I think, was quite open to the idea of of other ways to mitigate reversal risk. And I think one of the the underlying themes there was that this c buffer pool costs a developer a lot of money, right? So the buffer pool, a developer locks up to 35. We've even seen developers with 40% contributions of their credits into a project. And that is an enormous amount of foregone, foregone revenue. Whereas if you take an insurance premium and you split it out over 20, 30, 40 years, you're paying, 1% a year instead of 40% up front. and for when you pay 40% up front, you're not even sure it's gonna cover the whole, the the entirety of your loss. So long story short, we had a long conversation with Vera about it. And on the back of that, Vera launched a d this thing called the durability pilot last December. And in short, what it does is it allows developers of AFOLU projects, so afforestation, other land use projects. To instead of putting credits into the buffer pool to purchase an insurance policy to cover those credits against a reversal. And it is with a cash payout. It's not like the buffer pool in the sense that there are no credits that be are being struck. But once the developer receives a cash payout, they take that and they go and they buy credits to compensate for the reversal. That's the long and short of how it works. speaker-1: Okay. And now now looking at that, I think as you mentioned the buffer pool, it's it's interesting from from a first perspective that in the past, I think also a lot of companies interacting and buying carbon credits, they were like, Yeah, but I have the buffer pool. I'm like I'm yeah there's no risk. I'm like I'm I'm at the buffer pool. But on one hand, as you just mentioned, they're not Completely secure because for instance, we've seen with I I think there was a wildfires in in California, for instance, on the buffer pool impact. But also on the other hand, so they're not fully secured, but on the other hand, also for the project developers, it's really inefficient tooling and makes a life of like I know that project developers they're always complaining about the buffer pool. Yes, it's it's painful for them. But so basically. With insurance we can solve both things. We on one hand actually can yeah, cover the risk fully. And on the other hand, we can also make a project developer's life or even the success of a project developer surviving or bringing more credits to the market, maybe even at a at a at a lower price, also happening. So basically there's no downside or is there speaker-0: Yeah, look, that's a that's a good question. There is no downside. I think there is only upside, but I think there are still unanswered questions. So I think we have to be very clear that right now the carbon markets require, registry buffer pools are supposed to cover permanence for 40 years. In no other market is the producer of a product liable for the performance of that product for 40 years. So that's not even that's not a reasonable expectation, but it's the expectation. Right. So, when you buy a car from BMV, they don't they don't guarantee it for 40 years. They guarantee it for maybe two, right? And then after that, it's your liability. So, in in our view, I think the buyer is the right person to make maintain the rever to pay for the mitigation of reversal risk over the long term. But right now, let's face it, that's not the market that we have. You know, we don't have a market where buyers are really voluntarily voluntarily paying for income. speaker-2: I can tell speaker-1: you but I I I talk to a lot of buyers obviously and always when I'm like hey and I we pitched it. I I I talked to a lot of them and asked especially two years ago when insurance products came up I was like hey look how how how do you look at at the risk and would you pay more if that risk would be covered? And a lot of them literally said but there's a buffer pool. Yeah. and that was mostly the answer, or that there was not enough education on the risk element of carbon credits in general. So it's not again. speaker-0: Yeah. So I I think one pretty important message is that if a buyer is concerned about integrity of the credits and permanence, it is not sensible to rely on the buffer pool because the buffer pool is an untested mechanism. There's no statistics about how the buffer pool works. And I can tell you as an insurance professional. That the buffer pool, no matter what its size, is not correctly sized. And the reason I can tell you that is because the way that buffer pool contributions are calculated is not the way an insurance, any insurance company in the world would price the risk. And we've seen, as you mentioned, wild virus in California and the effect on the car buffer pool, or, certain projects, I don't need to name names, that were found not to have been fraudulent, that would take down half of a registry. Buffer pool. So I think people who think, who say that they are really concerned about credit integrity and, who put developers through a really rigorous, really involved due diligence process, they must understand that what if they rely on the buffer pool, they are certainly not guaranteeing any kind of integrity. And the other thing that people don't really realize about how the buffer pool works, you know, is that When a an a reversal occurs, the way it is compensated for is that any credit in the buffer pool can be struck to compensate for the reverse credit. So that means if you are a buyer who has placed a lot of value on getting an an afford a certain kind of afforestation credit, when there is a reversal, if the buffer pool has the credits to compensate, then they will take any credit. They will take a red credit, they will take a cook stove credit. They will take a soil soil carbon cron, they'll take whatever they have, right? So that's that's one important point. And I think the other important point is the following. This is how the market has evolved in the last couple of years. I think if you if anybody thinks that buffer pools are a mechanism that they can rely on in the same way that they can rely on insurance, that's a mistake. Because the truth of the matter is now that the registries have really become aware of the risks associated with maintaining a buffer pool and how big it needs to be to cover whatever kinds of risks. I think what they are realizing is, we need to start increasing contributions. We need to start testing to see whether these buffer pools have enough assets to cover their liabilities. And I will tell you that what the what is gonna probably what they're gonna find is that those buffer pools are not sufficient. So I think people who say to me but the buffer pool. I first of all I say to them, look, nobody's ever tested a buffer pool. So I'm not really sure what it can do. I'm pretty sure that it can't do all the things that it promises to do. But if you think that, the buffer pool is one static contribution and that is never gonna change over time, I think the mentality around buffer pools and how they should be run is completely changing. So I don't think that's it. If I were a buyer, and by the way, many of the buyers, as are institutional players, they don't they will know what insurance is. They know how insurance operates. They know that a regulator is watching to make sure that we that that we price the risk correctly and that we're setting aside enough enough capital to cover that risk. That is not the case with a buffer pool. And by the way, like I I must sound like I'm jumping up and down on the grave of buffer pools, but but really what I think is important to to to understand is that. We are witnessing an evolution in lots of ways in the carbon markets, right? credit integrity and MRV and product project design and methodologies and all that stuff. Lots of stuff has evolved for the better. And buffer pools were I I have to laud the registries. They put them in place when there was nothing else. Like where was the insurance industry 20 years ago when people were doing this? It was nowhere to be found. So good for them for having come up with a mechanism. But now, as part of the natural evolution of the market to more to prov professionalism and to attracting capital at scale, banks do not lend money to anything that is not insured. right? They don't they're not gonna lend you money for your house or, you know, they're not gonna lend somebody money to build a building if there's no insurance. And that is what we're seeing in this space as well. So this is just part of the natural evolution of the of the markets. And I have to say, I'm I'm glad that we're able to for now work alongside of the registries and the registry buffer pools. But eventually in an ideal world, I would say, the buffer pools should probably go away. speaker-1: And I I think as you just said on the financing perspective, as we see more and more financing and debts and so on coming into the market, we also I at least from outside perspective, it feels like there's more and more insurance coming, as you just mentioned, because they look at they just look at it as any other thing that they finance and they're like probably look at it and say like, Hey, but why is there no financing? We exactly that doesn't make sense. we're not doing this in any other space. So that is that is obviously super interesting. But if we then look in insurance is obviously a big term. What is the main thing that we insure? speaker-0: The main thing that we insure in the carbon markets? speaker-1: Do you mean speaker-0: Yeah. Well, look, I think there are some that there are lots of different risks in the carbon markets, but the ones that I think are the ones that are most insurable, because you know, in order for a risk to be insurable, it has to meet certain criteria, right? Typically it needs to be accidental. Not always, but that's how you avoid moral hazard, right? You don't want you don't want to reward somebody for bad behavior. It should really be things that are out when something occurs that is outside of your control, and that something is something that you can measure. So we can measure the damage, and therefore know how much to pay you, and therefore know how much to charge you for the possibility that you'll incur that damage. That those are sort of the key characteristics of insurability. So what's insurable in the carbon markets? I would say, generally speaking, that delivery risk is very insurable. I would say that reversal risk is very insurable. I would say different kinds of risks, like natural risk. So we at Carbon Pool are very focused on natural risk because we feel like that is the the risk that is easiest to understand and model really at a at an extremely granular level. And I think Given that we're all insurance old insurance people here, we we know that if you don't understand the risk, you lose your shirt, right? So it's really important that you understand the risk. And we are very clear about what we insure and what we don't insure. But there are other risks, political risk, for example. There are carriers who will insure you against political risk. There are some carriers who will insure against sort of credit risk, like what if a developer goes bankrupt or something like that? speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: In my, you know, in my personal view. I think I used to be an MA lawyer and I did a lot of MA deals as head of MA for Allianz in Africa. And I view buying a buying into a carbon project, buying carbon credits as a kind of it's similar to buying a company, right? You have lots of different ways that you can mitigate risk. You can mitigate risk through contract. So you can have contractual provisions, but you need to have a good counterparty standing behind it. You can mitigate risk through the use of insurance. And you can accept some risk once you've done a a reasonable amount of due diligence. And I think that's the way that that buyers also need to approach the exercise of deciding to buy carbon credits from a project, right? There should be a sort of panoply options that you can use to decide how I will mitigate the risks of this project. That doesn't include saying to the developer, hey, listen. Go and buy an insurance policy that covers everything but the kitchen sink, because if the developer can find that policy, it will be extraordinately expensive. Right. So that's why, it is you have to be sensible about what kind of risks you're asking them to cover. The reason also one of the reasons we're also focused on natural risk is insurance is very good at covering for things like catastrophic loss, earthquake, wildfire, you know, tornado or something. That's that that's where insurance plays plays a role. It can also play a role, though, as I said, in things like delivery risk because of, you know, a credit issue, the developer runs out of money. It will be expensive to insure that, but it can, it can, it can work there. but the reason, one of the reasons we really, really focused on reversal risk is because right now it's a space where there's a lot of demand. Any project that wants to issue credits has to either insure or put credits in the buffer. And second of all, many of our developer clients say to us, Look, I can manage the political risk. I'm financed. I I can manage the the credit risk. But what I can't manage is the risk of a wildfire. And that's where insurance plays best. speaker-1: Interesting. The last question I actually have, because this is something I can't wrap my head around, is obviously now we talked a lot about nature and depending on how long a project goes, maybe 40, 200 years or whatever. But how how do we think about reversal risk on these very permanent projects that maybe said, hey, we store carbon for 10,000 years? Like I'm always wondering how does Someone from the insurance space looks at these I would say, claims or at these kind of promises and because at a certain point maybe SBTI says, okay, you're only allowed to use these, but do they then need to prove that everything is stored for the next ten thousand years? And how how does insurance look at that? speaker-0: Yeah, it's a it's a good question. I think there are in a way there are two parts to that question. So there are those projects that purport to store carbon for ten thousand years or something like that, probably they have a negligible risk of reversal for for from natural causes. Once it's been stored underground, what is gonna disturb it? I mean, and also It calcifies depending on the technology. What are the risks of reversal? They're not zero, but they're extremely low, which actually makes insurance for that those things extremely affordable. I think the second thing is it is absurd to talk about timescales of 10,000 years or 50, even 50 years, because let's face it, neither you nor I, nor any of these Project developers or standards bodies are going to be around in 50 years to see whether this credit remains permanent. This is why insurance companies also don't insure on those kinds of timescales. We should talk about increments that are realistic: one year, two years, three years, maybe five years, maybe 10 years, right? And that's where we as an as a startup, I think, can bridge that gap between insurers who wouldn't usually touch a 10-year risk. We can say, listen. We've ri we've done the model modeling. We think the risk is acceptable, and maybe we can convince our partners to do 10 years. But I think the bottom line is we need to think about this on a rolling basis. We need to think about this in increments of one or five or 10 years. The carbon market in that way is no different than any other market, which is to say, if you want financing and if you want insurance, you have to talk in terms, you have to talk in realistic time frames. You can't talk in those. Those kinds of time frames where nobody's gonna be around. And literally, I did have a a pretty senior person from the carbon market say to me, Isn't it true that buffer pools are better at managing risk for the long time scales that permanence requires? But are better than insurance because no insurance company will send and sell you a contract for 40 years. And my answer to him was, Show me. You know, please show me. Any evidence that any buffer pool has been around for 40 years and has covered the risk. A, it's not happened yet. B, obviously insurance companies don't write contracts for 40 years, but there's a reason for that, right? Because bearing risk for that long and having the capital to cover claims for that long would be so expensive that nobody does it for that long, right? So I think if we want this market to be a professional investable market, we have to start talking in realistic terms and realistic time frames. Otherwise, we're never going to scale. And that's one of the things that I think is very encouraging about the buffer pool pilot. I think people are, we don't nobody knows the answer yet about who's going to be paying for permanence for 40 years. But I think what people are realizing is A, it's not the registry's job to manage an insurance pool. B, it's too expensive for developers to Pay all of this money up front and be liable for the risk for 40 years and see, you know what, let's not let the the perfect, be the enemy of the good. Let's start already with the insurance solutions that are available today. Let's work in increments that the insurance company can ensure can ensure, the insurance industry can ensure. And then, let's figure it out as we go along. And I think that's a that's a very promising start. speaker-1: I think for me the big realization was because I not coming from I'm I'm a typical German engineer. I have no clue about insurance and finances and so on. And I and it maybe sounds very very stupid, but I think like four years when I first thought about insurance and I I talked to you and the likes. And people told me insurers only think about a couple of years into the future. And they don't think about 10 year frames, even or 20 year frames, and so on. And I like, I didn't even know. because I li I literally had that carbon that buffer pool perspective and I was like, Yeah, but how should they then do forty years? And I think for me the big realization and change was like That no market works like that. And we know how market works and they're working on other time frames, especially for insurance. And we shouldn't reinvent the wheel here. We should see what works. And that for me was a big change. where I was like, okay. Wow, I didn't know. And now it feels stupid even talking about it. No, But think that just means like a lot of people probably look at it the same way. And I think this is something That at least for me unlocked the understanding of the the building blocks for carbon market. speaker-0: And I think one really important point about that, the the point that you identify is insurance companies are required by regulation to to cover 99.5% of the outcomes that can occur across their portfolio, right? And in order to do that, insurance companies collect a premium for you from you and they put a little bit of a aside to cover the expected loss. But they have to put their own shareholders' capital at risk under that. They have to provide an extra buffer to cat what happens if there's a worst case loss scenario across the portfolio. They need to be prepared to respond to that. And the thing is that in order to do that for a time scale of 40 years, you must imagine that the shareholders who are putting their money at risk, they want a return. And the longer that money is exposed to a risk that changes over time. the more expensive it becomes. Insurance companies, though, unlike the buffer pool, an insurance company can't say to you, hey Adrian, I paid your claim. Guess what? You've got to pay me back now. They can't say that to you, right? Their job is to pay the claim. And they also can't say to the regulator, Oops, sorry, I wrote a policy that was too long. I don't have enough money for this. This is what regulators sit on them every quarter and look at their books and look at their capital to make sure that they are able to To provide the certainty that insurance provides to us as a society. This is why we allow insurance companies to insure our most important risks, like our lives, our health, our homes, you know, our assets. This is why insurance companies are allowed to do that because they're watched very carefully to make sure that they can. And the thing is when people say to me, look, the buffer pool can, I'm like, you know what? No, it can't. The buffer pull just can't. I know that it can't, because nobody's doing, nobody's really doing the math. And nobody's, they're not putting aside that extra buffer that I'm required to put aside. Right. And so this is why that time seal question, you know, when you compare at somebody who is required to deliver an outcome by a by a regulator to somebody who's making a promise that does is not substantiated, those two things are not comparable. speaker-1: Exciting. I I I think it's very exciting and I'm excited to also see that we're getting somewhere. I think obviously we're always sad about I think especially short-term development. But then if we look at the longer time frame and we see like four years ago there there was no talk about insurance at all, and now we see these pilots and we see first insurance is also on the bigger scale coming out. Then I'm like, okay. probably in five years. most of maybe there are no buffer pools anymore, I don't know. but I'm excited and about the future and and insurance plays and that so thanks so much Andini for coming over. It was a pleasure to talk about all things insurance. speaker-0: Yes, my pleasure, Adrian. Thank you for having me. speaker-1: Thanks so much. Have a good one. Bye. speaker-2: Yeah, too. Bye bye. speaker-1: If you've loved this episode, please, please, please hit the subscribe button. The more followers we have, the more guests we can get, and the more coverage we will be able to provide. So thank you so much for your support.