Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / RUSSELL HEBETS DISCUSSES HIS LIFE AS A DEFENSE ATTORNEY1
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant, doctor Carlos. Welcome back everybody. Today,
- 0:26we have a great guest defense lawyer, Russell Hebits. That's h E B
- 0:29E t s. You can find them over at Hebits McCallen h E B
- 0:33T B E T S M double C A double L I N so hebitsmccallen
- 0:38dot com. Hebits McCallen dot com. Also, you're into the legal world,
- 0:43you can enjoy their podcast, Is This Legal. So I definitely recommend
- 0:46you head over there and check out that podcast. Before we get started,
- 0:50folks, we're gonna find out more about defending your rights and freedom. But
- 0:53before we do that, you know what to do. Share, subscribe,
- 0:55hit that like button. You know we like it. That's not waste any
- 0:57more time working to the show. Mister Hebits. Welcome sir, Thank you
- 1:00very much, pleasure to be here. Thank you for doing this. This
- 1:03is kind of interesting because we're kind of looking at we had a prosecutor on
- 1:07a few weeks ago to look at the world of a prosecutor, but also
- 1:11the psychology behind it, because there's a lot of things people don't know about
- 1:15a defense attorney. They kind of see them on TV. They kind of
- 1:19get that picture. First things first, what motivated you to become a defense
- 1:23attorney and maybe not a prosecutor or maybe you were. I don't know,
- 1:27I actually was. I started off as a prosecutor, was a d for
- 1:34roughly about a year. And I'll tell you my whole My guiding principle was
- 1:38I really liked legal defense. I like being in the court for more prosecution.
- 1:42I like criminal law. Okay, so if I were going to be,
- 1:47you know, a tax attorney, I wouldn't be a lawyer. If
- 1:49I was sitting in a room drafting contracts all day, I'd be doing something
- 1:53else right now. So I like being on my feet, being moving,
- 1:56making arguments, talking to juries. So I like it from both sides.
- 2:00However, you know, you kind kind of get thrown in the fire prosecution
- 2:05and get a lot of experience quickly. But for me, I really do
- 2:09enjoy the defense side better. Yeah. I know the prosecutors sometimes suffer a
- 2:15little bit more with politics of who to prosecute, who to go after and
- 2:17not go after? Is there any kind of politics in regards to the defense
- 2:22attorneys right now? There's really not. Now, if you're a public defender,
- 2:24there would be, But as long as you're a private defense, no,
- 2:29And that's one of the big pros for me with being defense rather than
- 2:32prosecution. Is exactly what you just said, which is it's not political.
- 2:38That's interesting, yeah, because I never really thought about it till I interviewed
- 2:42the other gentleman who was a prosecutor. That was kind of funny. So
- 2:45I know, we see that, I know some das we've had on here
- 2:46before, and that's that's a challenge. It's a reality in life, it
- 2:52is, And you can as a prosecutor, you can get some cases that
- 2:54you don't feel should be prosecuted. You feel like justice really does demand that
- 3:00this person gets either a better offer or even a dismissal. But if your
- 3:05higher ups say sorry, you're going forward, I mean you have your marching
- 3:09orders and you have to do it. That's not the same from defense.
- 3:13Now, we have our own separate set of issues, which is just dealing
- 3:16with the client. You know, I could have a client where I think
- 3:21that either the case should absolutely go to trial and the client doesn't want to,
- 3:25or vice versa. And so those are kind of the challenges we have,
- 3:31and it's much more in dealing with the client themselves, kind of assessing
- 3:38their needs and just dealing with that can be its own set of challenges,
- 3:43which can be significant. Sometimes, what is the biggest challenge for a client
- 3:50that you're defending. Is there something that keeps popping up or something you're really
- 3:53keep an eye out for anything in particular. No, it really varies.
- 3:59He's my case, so there's no It's not a cookie cutter, right,
- 4:02every every client is different. But the biggest thing is figuring out how to
- 4:06relate to those clients. You know, you can have You can have a
- 4:12client who comes in and they all have different priorities. Right. Some priorities
- 4:17might be, hey, I just want to be out of jail. Some
- 4:20may say, hey, you know I have You can have clients that say
- 4:25I absolutely did not do this hundred percent, and I want I want a
- 4:30full defense. And then you're looking at the police reports, the narratives,
- 4:34and it's just it just isn't there, you know, So it's you have
- 4:41to figure out how to get the client to the spot that is in their
- 4:45best interests while also keeping their priorities in mind. Well to keep I'm sure
- 4:50you have to keep this confidential. I think, I guess. But have
- 4:54you ever had a case where you looked at it and go, shit,
- 4:57this guy doesn't say, or this gal says, they're not innocent. Man,
- 5:00I really don't see, kind of like the fugitive the old TV show
- 5:02Majing Myself. But you're looking at that going, man, I don't know
- 5:04how you didn't do it. Yeah, So so it's tough and that that
- 5:09comes up, you know, it comes up fairly often, and ideally,
- 5:14as a defense attorney, you would hope that your client is one hundred percent
- 5:17honest with you, right, And my job, how I do it,
- 5:23how I view it. At least I take them at face value. Now,
- 5:26that doesn't mean you don't push back on them, and you know,
- 5:29so you can sit them down and say, listen, here's here's five witnesses
- 5:32who say different than you, or here's a video that shows different from what
- 5:38you just told me. But my job is to kind of either get them
- 5:44to come around and say, hey, listen, this isn't this isn't matching
- 5:48up. You want to go ahead and reassess what you told me before,
- 5:51because it's not making a lot of sense. Or if they're not if they're
- 5:56not saying that, if they're saying it's absolutely what they say is right despite
- 6:00all this evidence in their in their face that says opposite or contrary to that,
- 6:04then it's a matter of okay, well, let's let's say that your
- 6:10version is correct. Well, here's what's going to happen down the line is
- 6:14we're going to have this in front of a jury, and here's what the
- 6:16jury's gonna hear. And you know, if I really do believe that it
- 6:21is not a defensible case, I'll lay out the evidence and I'll say here's
- 6:26how this is going to come out. And in my opinion, you know,
- 6:29I don't care how good of a defense attorney I am, this is
- 6:33very difficult to win. And then at that point it becomes either we agree
- 6:40to, you know, cut the losses and take some sort of plea agreement,
- 6:44or there's times when you know you just have to fall on your sword
- 6:47and you do the best you can. But I'll tell you right now,
- 6:50even doing the best you can, I have had cases where I thought absolutely
- 6:55I was not going to win, like the facts were not stacked up correctly,
- 6:59and I went into trial, and I'm always gonna do my preparation and
- 7:03put put on the best case possible. But I've had cases where I lost
- 7:08or I won when I absolutely thought they were going to be losers. But
- 7:12the inverse is also true too, you know, I've I've lost cases where
- 7:15I thought for sure I had it. So juries are fickle people, fickle
- 7:20groups, and it's very difficult to really figure out what they're going to do
- 7:27on any given day or case. Is that one of the reasons I've forgot
- 7:30who I think his name was Fisher? He wrote a textbook up in Oh
- 7:34Camera because of Stanford or Not. You know you did in a while back
- 7:38ago, you wrote a textbook on plea bargaining and he was telling me that
- 7:43ninety five percent of people will plee out. Does that play a role about
- 7:46how fickle people can be on the jury and how unpredictable it could be?
- 7:50You know it can in that there's no sure thing, right, So from
- 7:56that perspective, it does play a role because you have to let your client
- 8:01know no matter how good a case looks you never know what will happen in
- 8:05trial, but I try not to. I try not to let that drive
- 8:11my recommendation to my clients as to whether they go to trial or not.
- 8:15You know, I'm looking at the facts. I'm looking at the evidence that
- 8:18the prosecution has against them, and then possible defenses. And you know,
- 8:24my assessment between as to whether it go to trial or not is how strong
- 8:28of a defense is it? So based on those things, I just tell
- 8:31you told you do we have a good defense. And then the other side
- 8:35of it is how good of a plea offer is it? Right? And
- 8:37you're weighing those two things. So the easy cases are if it's a really
- 8:43good plea offer. DA has given you a really good offer and the case
- 8:46is just garbage, right, we don't have good evidence, it does not
- 8:50look strong. That's an easy one. Conversely, if the DA says you
- 8:56could plead guilty to the highest charge and I'm going to ask jail at prison
- 9:01and we actually have a defense, well that's another easy one, right,
- 9:05because we could lose and do better than the DA is off right. So
- 9:11then there's a bunch of gray in between. But that's the assessment that is
- 9:13used to figure out whether or not you go to trial rolling the dice.
- 9:20Yeah, and a lot of it is how risk adverse is the client?
- 9:24Right? I mean you know that that definitely plays part. Yeah, definitely
- 9:28would right, man. Let me ask you this. We don't usually start
- 9:33this early with movies. Usually try to leave there for fun at the end.
- 9:37But since we're here, I kind of got and I kept popping in
- 9:39my head. I can't seem to shake them. What do you think about
- 9:43the realism like in movies like a few and again dating myself, but a
- 9:46few good Men, my cousin Vinnie Goes really pushed for the defense side.
- 9:50What do you think about those? Were they realistic or they only had little
- 9:54fragments of it? I think that the ones, the ones you mentioned,
- 10:00really especially my cousin video. I'm sorry, my cousin Vinny. That is
- 10:05really well done. From a courtroom perspective. You look at the objections in
- 10:11court, the rulings in court from an evidentiary standard, that is very,
- 10:20very realistic and very well done. You know, It's been a while since
- 10:24I've watched a few Good Men, but I would guess the same is true
- 10:28from a few good men. So there's I mean, obviously there's some that
- 10:33do a better job than others, but the ones you just mentioned, honestly,
- 10:37that's that's pretty accurate as to how it would work in an actual case.
- 10:41That makes me feel good because I usually when we get to talk a
- 10:43little bit about the legal system, and in my criminal psych class of I
- 10:48usually show clips of how he dismantled the witnesses of the prosecution side slowly but
- 10:54surely. Yep. Yeah, that that movie's really well done and very very
- 11:00true to life. Oh that's cool. I guess I have to ask you
- 11:03the question that I always get regards to defense attorneys with Raver have one on
- 11:07the show, Hey, can you ask them? You know, how can
- 11:09you live with yourself? As usually more extreme? But how do you reconcile?
- 11:13I guess I'll frame it better dealing with somebody you know is guilty of
- 11:18something horrendous, a murder, whatever it may be. How do you deal
- 11:22with that? Yeah, so you know you have to approach it from a
- 11:28place that doesn't come from judgment, right. My job is not to judge
- 11:31these people, right, because I truly believe bad things happen to good people.
- 11:37You know, I've been doing this for going on about twenty four years,
- 11:45both prosecution and defense, the vast majority of that as defense, and
- 11:50I think that there are very few people who, you know, what someone
- 11:54would call a truly evil person, right or you know, it's almost always
- 12:01just a person who just made a bad decision, made a bad choice.
- 12:05They're not a bad person. So you have to compartmentalize it, or at
- 12:09least I compartmentalize it, right, because no matter what they're charged with you,
- 12:15on one hand, you have that shouldn't define them, that one act
- 12:18or one day, That one charge shouldn't define their whole life. And I
- 12:24believe that, But you have to you have to be able to compartmentalize it.
- 12:33And you know, ultimately the justice system has to work and the cops
- 12:39have to be held responsible for doing a good, thorough, just legal investigation.
- 12:48Right. You have to have that presumption of innocence to have the system
- 12:52work, because if you start having it where well, you know someone you
- 12:58know and I'm using air quotes right now, you know someone's guilty. So
- 13:01therefore you know, you don't have to really prove it. Well, the
- 13:05next time, maybe it happens to someone who's innocent, right, So you
- 13:09have to have those safeguards in our society to you know, the system has
- 13:15to work and they have to. They have to do their job, just
- 13:18like I have to do my job as a defense attorney. You know,
- 13:20the prosecution has to do their job and the law enforcement has to do their
- 13:24job. And it does come up all the time. I mean, I'll
- 13:28tell you a quick story. Just recently. I have a daughter and she
- 13:31came up to me and she said, you know what, Dad, what
- 13:35if you know you had someone who was accused of a really bad crime and
- 13:39they told you they were guilty, and but they offered you a million dollars
- 13:43to represent them, would you still do it if you knew they were guilty?
- 13:50You know, I mean your a daughter. No, yeah, lesson,
- 13:52I think I would. That's my job. It's a system, man.
- 13:58I think you're absolutely right. You have to defend them. You have
- 14:01to. You have to. And you know, truly sometimes you get people
- 14:05who are truly innocent, and you know those you know, then makes you
- 14:11feel good, right when you can help those people and those do exist.
- 14:15You just look as far as the Innocence Project and how many Death Row inmates
- 14:18they've exonerated people get convicted even when they're innocent all the time. You make
- 14:26a great point. I forget who was it said that. I'm sure you
- 14:30heard it in law school too. It's better to can to let one yeah
- 14:35one guy, yeah let let yeah let. It's better to let ninety nine
- 14:39guilty people go free than one innocent person get convicted. There you go,
- 14:43thank you. I'm terrible. I just can't remember who said it either,
- 14:46but either way, yeah, I don't know. Yeah, I don't know
- 14:48who said it, but I mean I I agree with it, and that's
- 14:52how our justice system is built, and I think that's how it should be.
- 14:54I've like the other lawyers I guess and judges from around the world,
- 15:01and I found that to be a super interesting series as well. And if
- 15:07I was interesting because I look around, people say, oh, the justice
- 15:11system here is messed up, and it's like, well, if you compare
- 15:13it relatives, speaking from everything I've heard from other systems, ours is still
- 15:18the best. It's far from perfect, but it's still the best. I
- 15:20one hundred percent agree with that. It is far from perfect, but show
- 15:26me a better, better alternative. I haven't seen it, absolutely, and
- 15:30it's really hard. I mean, people think it's easy just because you see
- 15:33a camera video or something like that. I'm looking at the Alec Baldwin case
- 15:37and it's fascinating because you have a lot of different opinions about what should happen
- 15:41to him, and it's kind of messy. That case is fascinating. We've
- 15:46actually done a couple of podcasts on that. You mentioned my podcast earlier,
- 15:48but we've done a couple of podcasts on that, and I'm sure we'll do
- 15:52another one as his trial approaches. That's a fascinating case. I won't I
- 16:00won't spoil it. By the way, folks again can go to is This
- 16:03Legal podcast if you want to hear those and what their what their thoughts are
- 16:07on the Alec Baldwin case. Did you find Jesse small Let's casey fascinating?
- 16:11I thought that was a circus ride. But I don't know what do you
- 16:15think? So I didn't follow that one? Asked closely? So okay,
- 16:18yeah, so I don't. I don't have a well formed opinion on that
- 16:22one. No, no worry to me. It was just interesting, you
- 16:26know. I want to change the degree gears a little bit, or the
- 16:29direction into what I usually do is switch over to psychology for a second.
- 16:33I know you answer the question. Everybody always wants to know you tackle that
- 16:37one now the next question. But I don't think people ever ask or even
- 16:41think about. Is you guys and gals see a lot of things in the
- 16:47evidence room and discussing the cases, if it's a murder case or child abuse
- 16:52or sexual abuse, and you're exposed to a lot of things, just like
- 16:56the prosecutors are. And I'm sure that can sometimes be taxing and wearing on
- 17:03you. It is. It is the same thing applies to us as does
- 17:11to prosecutors, to kind of everyone else. You know, I've done.
- 17:17I've done first degree murder cases. I've done, you know, vehicular homicide
- 17:21cases. Those are some of the I'll tell you some of the most difficult
- 17:26cases. I won't say they are the most difficult case, but you know
- 17:30you have I here's I had a vehicular homicide case where a he was probably
- 17:37a fifty six year old man a single car accident, killed his wife in
- 17:44the accident, and he had a bunch of prior to you wise, and
- 17:48he was impaired at the time. And it is so difficult because what what
- 17:55do you do to that guy that he's not already doing himself. You know,
- 17:59his his wife of like thirty years I think was killed. He was
- 18:03responsible. So from that perspective, psychologically it's very tough. I'm dealing with
- 18:11family, like his family was supporting him but had lost their mother. Right,
- 18:17So very very taxing, difficult cases to handle. And then you also
- 18:22have things like crime scene photos, right, you know, murder cases,
- 18:29those can be very grizzly. I'll tell you a quick story. You know
- 18:34where I and my partner both used to be DA's in Colorado. What's the
- 18:40eighteenth judicial which encompasses a Rapo County where the Aurora Theater shooting James Holmes happened.
- 18:48And you know, we know I have my opinion about the political basis
- 18:56of that prosecution, but we know one of the paralegals or support staff with
- 19:03the DA's office who was tasked with helping to organize those crime scene photos.
- 19:10And you can imagine it doesn't get more ruesome than those crime scene photos.
- 19:17After that trial, she had to quit and she had to go into therapy
- 19:23because it was so traumatic just going through the evidence in that case. And
- 19:32that's that's the same for you know, anyone who's part of the case.
- 19:37Really, I mean, I'll tell you I no longer will accept child pornography
- 19:42cases. And it's because I don't want I just don't want to look at
- 19:47the evidence. I just it's it's something that I don't I don't have to
- 19:52deal with because I can choose my cases and I choose not to. And
- 19:56it's again for the same reason, like I'd rather do. Yeah, you
- 20:02know, it doesn't surprise man. No. Buddy of mine, his wife
- 20:04is a former FBI agent, and she was on the other line acting like
- 20:08the eleven or twelve year old right talking to them, and they had a
- 20:12five year old, and it was it was really messing her up. It
- 20:15was having a very difficult time with that. Yeah, yep, yep.
- 20:18It's it's traumatic. It is, and a lot of people don't don't see
- 20:22it. And that's why I wanted to kind of highlight it a little bit,
- 20:25because I don't think people realize some of the psychological trauma that can't happen.
- 20:29It was your story of the paralegal was right up that alley. People
- 20:32can't see that. Yeah, and you really do, like you have to
- 20:36be good at compartmentalizing, right, you have to be because otherwise you just
- 20:41wouldn't sleep at night. That's true too. What's the longest case you ever
- 20:45had? Now, curiosity, longest case I ever had. I just recently
- 20:51wrapped up what was an attempted murder case. But it was so long because
- 20:59there was competency issues with my client, so he was deemed incompetent early in
- 21:04the case and he sat in I mean there's a massive backlog at least in
- 21:08Colorado of compet restoration services. So he sat in custody for over a year
- 21:18and a half just waiting for competency restoration, just even to get into a
- 21:22program. So that case was probably two and a half years. Oh and
- 21:29that's without any appeals or anything, right, that's just kind of pending.
- 21:34So that's that's my longest. You know, if you talk to I don't
- 21:38really do a pellet work. If you talk to a pellet attorney's those can
- 21:42routinely last years. For me being a trial attorney. You know, Colorado
- 21:49tries to get people to try it. Well, there's a speedy trial statute.
- 21:52They have to get you to trial within six months of an entry of
- 21:56a not guilty fleeting. Interesting. That's interesting about the competency too, is
- 22:03I know some psychiatrists, psychologists, well, that's one of the tough ones
- 22:06for them, especially if it's going to be a well I don't know if
- 22:08Colorado has a death sentence or not, but that's usually one of those things
- 22:11that they kind of really feel bad about that we restore their competency to be
- 22:15told, hey, you're going to be executed here or not? Right?
- 22:18Right? Oh, yeah, no, I'm sure that's difficult, or or
- 22:22even you know, well life in prison. I mean, they're going to
- 22:26still be sitting in a deemed in a in a in a hou, in
- 22:30a home, or in a mental health hospital, right until until that happens.
- 22:34Right, what's your fastest case on the other side of it. Oh,
- 22:40I couldn't even name one. You know, cases, I mean,
- 22:42cases can go quick like there cases oh yeah, you know, if you
- 22:48like. I've had some cases where you know, there was really good,
- 22:55clear evidence that my client didn't do it, like Albi or something like that,
- 23:00where the police they just didn't do a good enough job investigating it.
- 23:04And then I have evidence showing that maybe they were in a different city at
- 23:10the time. And I have you know, GPS info and phone info and
- 23:12witnesses, and I just go in and as long as I have a reasonable
- 23:17DA who will look at it, case gets dismissed. Right then, right,
- 23:22So cases can go very quick. It's not typical, but they can.
- 23:26They can be you know, days, honestly, if you can get
- 23:30everything lined up quick enough. That's interesting to see. Which question I want
- 23:36to ask first, Well, I witness testimony when I talked to the prosecutor
- 23:42very unreliable but also very powerful. Do you think do you feel still just
- 23:47as powerful in regards to motivating the jury in one direction or another eye witness
- 23:52testimony? Yes, yet I'd agree with what that prosecutor said. I think
- 23:57it's pretty unreliable, but it's pretty powerful. You know. Jurors, they
- 24:06jurors are I put a lot of thought into juries because they're they're just such
- 24:11enigmas oftentimes, but for me, they make I believe they make a lot
- 24:17of their decision based on their heart, based on how they feel. Right.
- 24:23You know, there's been studies out there, and you would probably know
- 24:26this better than me, how bad people are at determining when other people are
- 24:30lying. Right, there's I mean, there's whole books written on how bad
- 24:34we are at telling someone's lying. But if you get someone up there who
- 24:38just makes a connection with the jury, they're they're far more likely to fall
- 24:45that way. And it's honestly for that reason, Like from this is from
- 24:49a psychological standpoint as well, like if I can, I I have come
- 24:56around in my career to the point where now I'm much more likely to put
- 25:00my client on the stand. You know, it's not universal, but I
- 25:06definitely that's my default because I think it helps for that exact reason. If
- 25:11you have a client who can present in an empathetic way, and you can
- 25:18just get a connection with a couple of jurors with with your client with a
- 25:22defendant, you're far more likely to get a good verdict. Well he is
- 25:26one, right, oh right, yeah, one to at least jam it
- 25:29up right? Was that twelve angry men? It's twelve angry men, right,
- 25:33And that's I think that's another one that that's how I think that that's
- 25:37how it goes, you know, I really do movie. Yeah, and
- 25:41I guess I don't know. You don't have to mention anything about the case,
- 25:45but I'm just curious you went to law school and assimming thirty years ago,
- 25:48twenty five years ago, so you were right around the days of O.
- 25:52J. Simpson's trial, and we know he just passed away. If
- 25:56you're did yesterday, I think, did you guys study that at all law
- 26:00school? Now? Yeah, we did not, so that one. Yeah,
- 26:04so that was when I was in undergrad so it would have been right
- 26:07before I went to law school, but we did not. We didn't.
- 26:12We didn't cover that. You know, it just depends on which what your
- 26:17how how much your professor is into current events. We talked in my criminal
- 26:22class, we talked a little bit about the Mike Tyson rape trial. And
- 26:29you know, it's been a while, you're making me go back, but
- 26:32I'll tell you my uh my, my law professor was under the firm belief
- 26:37that Mike Tyson's lawyers completely screwed that case up and that they did a terrible
- 26:42job. But I couldn't tell you exactly why he thought that. So so
- 26:48don't don't ask. I won't. I want to know, but I want
- 26:52to ask. That happens though. We've seen that a lot, and it's
- 26:56it's kind of a tricky situation because to one of the what if situations?
- 27:00Right, what if they had a good lawyer? Would it make a difference
- 27:03or not? Absolutely? Yeah, yeah, I was gonna say it is
- 27:07one of those what ifs. And you can see if someone like you can
- 27:11see, like I can look at a case and say I absolutely would have
- 27:14handled this differently and I feel like it would have been better. But that
- 27:18doesn't mean the person would have been acquitted, right, You can't say that.
- 27:22And yeah, it's really hard to be a it's easy to be a
- 27:26backseat driver, but it's hard to be because you don't know what could happen
- 27:30to you if you present it your way, then they ask you a different
- 27:32question that was thrown to them, and then all of a sudden we're heading
- 27:34in a different direction. Yeah, it's really tough. I don't like it.
- 27:37A lot of times when people say, oh my god, I don't
- 27:40know how they did that, it's like, well, you know, I
- 27:41guess you can maybe for future stuff not to do it. But yeah,
- 27:47it's it's tough. I mean, I agree with you, it's tough.
- 27:49There's there's some things that you know, if they're glaring, maybe you know
- 27:56you can you can have that opinion. Again, you can't make the ultimate
- 28:00call on whether that would have been dispositive to the outcome. But generally you're
- 28:06right because you never know what the what the defense knows. You don't know
- 28:10what was told to that attorney in confidence. You know, maybe it actually
- 28:15makes sense, and if you had all the information, maybe you would have
- 28:18made that same decision. So it is very tough to be a backseat driver.
- 28:25That leads me to an interesting question. I have a I don't say
- 28:27controversial opinion. It's not as popular, but I know the prosecutor. Honestly
- 28:33just can't remember what the prosecutor went on. I think he partially agreed with
- 28:37me, and I can't remember anymore. But the comedy just made we don't
- 28:41really know. This is one of the things I always tell the students,
- 28:44said, we don't really know what's going on between amberher and Johnny death,
- 28:48and you'll probably never know because they don't want to ever jeopardize whatever they had.
- 28:53The defense attorney's not going to tell you, and the prosecutor is not
- 28:56going to tell you everything either because they don't want to ruin their case.
- 29:00So I really just never really know. And my opinion, I always said
- 29:04certain cases like those should not be televised. That's my opinion. I just
- 29:08don't think. I think it causes so much division and there's so much backbiting
- 29:14in society. Oh he did it, How could you possibly not think he's
- 29:15guilty or not guilty? And I'm looking at that and going it causes so
- 29:19much dissent. Does it really have to be televised. I don't care about
- 29:23Judge Judy with somebody who has a loud barking dog, not a big deal.
- 29:29But other ones like the Written House, the OJ Simpson, all these
- 29:33other ones is kind of like whoa. I mean, I don't know,
- 29:36I don't know. I just your thoughts, and you can really happy to
- 29:38disagree with me. Just to me. It's's kind of interesting because I think
- 29:41it causes so many more problems. I mean, I hear where you're coming
- 29:45from, and I don't disagree with that like I think it is. Those
- 29:51cases can be very, very divisive. You know. The couple you just
- 29:56mentioned are great examples of that, right, Written House, everyone has an
- 30:00opinion one side or the other, you know, and then Amber Heard as
- 30:06well and Johnny Depp, same thing there, you know. I try to
- 30:10view them as objectively as possible. You know. Again, both of those
- 30:15are cases that we've talked about on our podcast and we try to kind of
- 30:18lay it out in a very non judgmental way. Right, So, I
- 30:26think there is an interest in society being able to have access to just see
- 30:37what's going on. You know, I don't know, I don't know where,
- 30:41I don't know what outweighs what right, because I agree with you that
- 30:44it is very divisive, it's not generally good for society. But honestly,
- 30:48there's there's a lot of things that aren't good for society that you know.
- 30:52There there's countervening sides to it, and I think people have a right to
- 30:59know what's going on in the legal system and to see for themselves what's being
- 31:03presented. So that's a tough one. Yeah, it is. And I
- 31:08also don't want to give a pass to the media because they'd like to stoke
- 31:11a lot of that stuff too. Sure, well, that's that's how they
- 31:15that's how they make money, that's how they get viewers. Yeah, and
- 31:19it really messes up the legal system for you guys and gals because it gives
- 31:23it a really weird skew, you know, and they're trying to present evidence
- 31:26and you're like, wait a minute, we don't know if this guy did
- 31:30it or not, and they make sometimes the defense look bad and make the
- 31:33prosecution look bad, and you just kind of like, what the hell you're
- 31:37doing. It's a whole different it's a whole different game when you have cases
- 31:41that have media publicity around it. It's a whole different thing, and it
- 31:45I think it's terrible exactly what you said. You know, the court of
- 31:49public like it gets put out there with the with the side. You know,
- 31:53if someone's writing an article, they're gonna have a side to take on
- 31:57it. And this is before or you know, before sometimes before even charges
- 32:04are filed. It happens, and it's very it's very frustrating from a from
- 32:09a defense standpoint when that happens. No, absolutely, you see it a
- 32:15lot. Yeah, So let me ask you this, which did should what's
- 32:21difficult cases? Is it a murder case, is it robberies? What is
- 32:25the most difficult one for you? Or do again? Does it depend on
- 32:28context and a lot of other vatables. It really does depend on context and
- 32:32what's going on inside the case. Like you can have you can have a
- 32:36first degree murder case that is relatively simple. You know, it's still going
- 32:42to be complex obviously, but you can have one that's not that's pretty straightforward
- 32:47that you can get. You can have a murder case that you could try
- 32:51in you know, five days in a week and start to finish, be
- 32:54done with it. And then you can have like I tell you, I've
- 32:59had them duy cases that are extremely complex, expert testimony, forensic toxicologists.
- 33:09So it really does just depend on the case. I don't think it falls
- 33:14along. I don't think you can say these charges are the most and then
- 33:17a little hierarchy. I don't think that's true. By the way, folks,
- 33:22again, we're talking to Russell Hebit EBITs, hebit's h E B E
- 33:25T S. You can find them over at hebit's McCallen and double C A,
- 33:30double L I N dot com. Hebit's McCallen over there, and you
- 33:34can also catch their podcast. Is this legal? But we're heading towards the
- 33:37tail end Russell, and it's really been an interesting conversation as we hear the
- 33:42different sides, and maybe one of these days we'll have a prosecutor and a
- 33:45defense attorney share both of their thoughts in the court system anything difficult or if
- 33:51fascinating for you, let me see, let me let me change that my
- 33:54backpedal. Has there been any big changes in the courtroom during trials over the
- 33:59last twenty years of your career or is it pretty much stayed the same.
- 34:06I would say that it has kind of slowly over the last twenty years been
- 34:13marching incrementally towards more significant generally more significant repercussions. Now you had you had
- 34:27some back pedaling at some point, and it kind of always ebbs and flows
- 34:31a little bit, and you have, I known, a lot of states
- 34:35have had you know, social justice reform legislation that's come in. But from
- 34:42my perspective, it has it has slowly, with some ebbs and flows,
- 34:50been more punitive as time has gone on. Now you get someone who goes
- 34:58back to you know, the eighties, nineties, that's probably not going to
- 35:00be true, right, It's probably probably had a pretty precipitous drop back then
- 35:06leading into two thousands. But I don't go back far enough to have seen
- 35:09that, So I think I see that a little bit. The one change
- 35:15that I'm seeing more now in more recent years that is really encouraging is that
- 35:20I'm seeing a lot more specialty courts, and by that I mean sobriety court,
- 35:27drug court, mental health court, veterans' courts. So these are specialty
- 35:31courts that are getting more and more funding more recently, and it is a
- 35:37great thing, great, great thing for the legal system because these courts focus
- 35:43on rehabilitation, and you know, just warehousing someone and then expecting them to
- 35:50come out in five or ten years and suddenly be a good citizen is unrealistic,
- 35:54you know, it's just unrealistic. You have to have programs that can
- 35:59get them to a spot where they can change their behavior. And these specialty
- 36:05courts really do a good job of it. They give you some like for
- 36:08example, Dui Court, it's much more intensive supervision. They have people coming
- 36:15in once a week to court to share how they've done that week. If
- 36:20they screw up, because they're almost expected to screw up because they're addicts,
- 36:25right, they don't get thrown in jail immediately, they get some other intervention,
- 36:32and the interventions step up and eventually they may get Okay, now you
- 36:37screwed up again, you get a weekend in jail. But it's all geared
- 36:43for not whereas with probation. You may say you screwed up, your probation
- 36:47is revoked. You had a year jail suspended based on you being compliant and
- 36:52you weren't. So sorry, go to jail for a year. These specialty
- 36:57courts really are working hard to get people rehabilitated, and they're having really good
- 37:01results. They're having really shown very good lower recidivism rates. Oh that's good.
- 37:08Havn't heard that. Colorado obviously operates a little different than we do.
- 37:10But that's interesting. We're gonna say, yeah, so I left you on
- 37:15a little positive note there, Doc. Yeah, and you made me think
- 37:19about a case that I saw a few weeks ago that kind of blew my
- 37:22mind a little bit. I don't know if you saw the one with the
- 37:24lady that stabbed her boyfriend. I think like a hundred times. But she
- 37:28was found not guilty because of psychosis due to CBD for marijuana. And I
- 37:35know Colorado has got a different legislation regards to marijuana. Has that been a
- 37:39player at all in any of your cases or not? Really, it's so
- 37:45tough to in Colorado's I mean, most places it's tough, but it's so
- 37:49tough in Colorado for not guilty by reason in sanity plea. Really yeah,
- 37:54very very tough to do that. I've I've taken one to trial on that,
- 38:00and you know, it was that was a murder case and it ended
- 38:04up being convicted a second degree murder instead of first. But still that's a
- 38:07significant conviction. But it's it's it's a very hard standard to meet right now
- 38:15in Colorado, and I think in most states, you know, you can
- 38:20have an impaired mental condition, you can have psychosis, but it still wouldn't
- 38:25rise to the legal definition of not guilty by reason of insanity. So for
- 38:31me, it's a very tough defense to make. I'm not familiar with the
- 38:37case you just referenced, so I'm not sure where it was case I think,
- 38:42yeah, so, but you know, to to kind of expand on
- 38:45that a little bit, I do think there's there's a lot of cases where
- 38:49you can show the inability to form the requisite mental state. Right, So
- 38:54if it calls for an intentional act, then you can have substances or maybe
- 39:00psychosis or something like that that you have an expert says, hey, that
- 39:06person wasn't capable of forming that mental state. That's a little different than the
- 39:09insanity plea and that that I've had more success with. Interesting. Yeah,
- 39:16but it's go ahead. Oh, I was gonna say it's a I'm sorry.
- 39:22I was gonna say it's interesting because you guys break it down in little
- 39:24parts too. When you're breaking down a case, and like you mentioned,
- 39:28maybe this part, this little mechanism isn't gonna We're not gonna look at this.
- 39:30We're not gonna make it in this little mechanism, but we can't make
- 39:32it in this part. Is that about right? That's about That's exactly right,
- 39:37That's exactly right. You know, you're as a defense attorney, I'm
- 39:39looking through the statute and saying what, what exactly do they have to prove?
- 39:45And you know, maybe there's seven elements to a crime and they can
- 39:49prove five of them, no problem. I just give it to them.
- 39:52Right. I'm not even gonna spend any time defending those because they have those.
- 39:57I'm gonna put all my effort into gating you know, whatever, whatever
- 40:01it is, right, is it causation, is it the mental state,
- 40:05whatever it might be. It's interesting. This was disputed by somebody I was
- 40:09talking to the other day at the judge a former judge, but it was
- 40:14told to me by the lawyer who defended OJ. So it's kind of interesting.
- 40:20You know, I guess take it as you will, folks, this
- 40:22is up to you. But when I talked to him, I didn't even
- 40:24get to interview him. We talked privately for about an hour or two and
- 40:28then we had some issues in scheduling and it just never happened. But he
- 40:32mentioned they didn't try to prove OJ innocent. He said that that's not going
- 40:37to fly with the jury. But we could do is prove that the cops
- 40:40were prejudiced and try to frame them. And I thought, well, that's
- 40:45a hell of an interesting way to do it, because it's really not people
- 40:50wouldn't think that way. It's like, at least non lawyers wouldn't take that
- 40:52way. And it was interesting. Kind of Okay, yeah, I guess
- 40:54second, see how that would work is your objective is just to win,
- 40:59So if you can win it, that's right, I'll win it. That's
- 41:00absolutely right. Like I mean, they did a the defense team for OJ.
- 41:07Whatever you may think about OJ, the defense team did a phenomenal job.
- 41:10They really did that, and I think that's exactly how you how you
- 41:15have to look at it, right, That's how you have to look because
- 41:17it is it is the prosecution's burden. Like you know, just coming full
- 41:22circle back to what we were saying at the top of the podcast, is
- 41:25it is their burden. In America, everyone is presumed innocent. Everyone is
- 41:30presumed innocent until proven guilty, and not just proven guilty, but proven guilty
- 41:34beyond a reasonable doubt. And that goes back to the whole You'd rather have
- 41:38ninety nine guilty people go free than one innocent person convicted. So it's a
- 41:43high standard and it's their burden. It's the government's burden, and they have
- 41:47to prove it and if they don't do it got to be not guilty the
- 41:52government. That's a whole different animal too. The Feds are They don't lose
- 41:55very often, that's for sure. Now they have really good cases. Pity,
- 42:01I don't know about that one. I'm getting out of that one,
- 42:05right, you know, it's interesting, Well I lost one train of thought,
- 42:09but I'll hijack to another one because this kind of leads to you,
- 42:15does we being able to wrap up? My daughter is my younger one.
- 42:17Is funny because she kind of I always say you're going to be an attorney
- 42:21when you grow up. She's always flipping things in arguments, and I'm kind
- 42:24of sitting there half the time, going it's too much work for a nine
- 42:27year old keeping up with her. And you know if her sister gets in
- 42:32trouble that she becomes the defense attorney and her sister does something she doesn't like,
- 42:37then she flips to the prosecution. It's just like, this is credible,
- 42:40but it's interesting. I guess my question to you, how has going
- 42:45to law school and practicing changed how you think as a person. I believe
- 42:53that law school changes anyone how how you think anyone goes to law school.
- 42:59In law school, you don't learn the law. You don't learn how to
- 43:01practice. You don't learn that stuff until you're studying for the bar. Really,
- 43:07in law school, in my opinion, you learn how to think like
- 43:12a lawyer. And it sticks with you, right, that's that it can't
- 43:17help abled in your personal life. So I do think it affects how you
- 43:25kind of view things and how you just process information. I think lawyers think
- 43:31in a very specific way, and it's it's learned. You know, it's
- 43:37learned, and that's that's what's taught in law school. You do a lot
- 43:39more critical thinking than people think. You can't present all of it, but
- 43:44you have to think critically on all angles to be able to make a good
- 43:47case. Right, that's absolutely right, that's absolutely right. Yeah. Yeah,
- 43:52that's the good thing. That's why I always liked law school, or
- 43:54at least having some of those tenants taught to students young in high school to
- 43:59learn how to able to look at both sides, right, right, Yeah,
- 44:02it's it's it's a yeah. If you can look at both sides,
- 44:06you're going to be better at whichever side you land on, you know,
- 44:08whatever side you have to argue. I guess my last question is kind of
- 44:13an interesting one about morality, as you were talking a little bit earlier and
- 44:17defending certain individuals or handling certain cases. A couple of years ago, I
- 44:22decided to do my own my own reading. I hate to say it's research,
- 44:25because it really is, and it's just reading about morality and evil.
- 44:30And I thought it was going to be a pretty easy read. I thought
- 44:32it was slam dunk, Evil's done, and it really wasn't. It became
- 44:37very subjective and relative, and I thought, this is kind of wild.
- 44:39And I remember talking to my students. I'll ask some questions and I'll say,
- 44:45hey, is every is any serial killer justified in doing what they do?
- 44:50Everybody goes really fast, no, no, no, So what about
- 44:52a serial killer who kills pedophiles? And then it's like, oh, all
- 44:58of a sudden, they backpedaled half of them. I thought, okay,
- 45:00interesting, so that's not pure evil for you. Well it depends. And
- 45:05it's like, okay, so the punisher you kind of agree with, and
- 45:08they're like, yeah, I guess so. And it was interesting. And
- 45:13then I threw one more at him, which was, if you have a
- 45:15thirty five year old male who sleeps with her fourteen year old student, no,
- 45:19it can't happen. Okay, twenty seven year old female teacher sleeps with
- 45:22a fifteen year old boy. What all of a sudden social media backpedals when
- 45:30fry the guy and praise the kid. And to me, it was kind
- 45:35of interesting to see how nuanced even evil can be your morality and stuff.
- 45:39I don't know if you have any takes on that at all. I mean,
- 45:43I agree, I think there is a lot of nuance. You know,
- 45:46Like I said before, I think the overwhelming majority of people who are
- 45:53charged with crimes are not evil, right, They really aren't there. They're
- 46:02people just like you and I, and they wound up in this position by
- 46:08bad luck, by bad decisions, by substance abuse, right by you know,
- 46:15sometimes mental health issues. But I absolutely agree with that it is,
- 46:22you know, there there's very, very, very few times. I mean,
- 46:27I can count on one hand the times when you know, I haven't
- 46:30been able to find at least some humanity right with with someone who I'm I'm
- 46:37talking to. And it's it's something where I think a lot of people just
- 46:46they don't have the experience and they are very quick to judge when if they
- 46:52had a chance to like sit down with this person, I think their whole
- 46:55perspective, I think their minds would be blown, right because as they'd see,
- 47:00this isn't the person I've made a character, They've made a caricature of
- 47:05whoever they're they've they're looking at and you know, it goes back to they're
- 47:09they're but they're but for the grace of God, go I right, And
- 47:14it can happen, you know, it can happen to good people. You
- 47:20know. It's but like I won't dwell on it. But one example of
- 47:23that is I've seen people who very late in life got into meth, right,
- 47:30and these are like fifty five year old you know, parents who just
- 47:37got into meth at that time and their life just spiraled down into the criminal
- 47:44justice system and they they lost everything. And it's they're not bad people,
- 47:50right, They went fifty five years being good members of society and then something
- 47:54happened and just like that. So that's my take on that. Maybe more
- 48:00than you want it, that's great. I think I was kind of reminded
- 48:05me of Clint Eastwood movie where he was like a mule at the very end
- 48:08of the movie, he's like seventy years old and he's taken the money.
- 48:10Oh can you do me a fever and drop this off? And then he
- 48:14kind of gets hooked on the money and he needed the money and okay,
- 48:17yeah, the guy who was pretty good I think for most of his life
- 48:20if I remember correctly. Yeah, it's not Grand Tarino. That was a
- 48:22different story either way. Fascinating stuff, folks. Again, it was Russell.
- 48:29Heabitch. You can find hibout Heabitt's McCallen. That's h. E.
- 48:31B. E. T. S. McCallen is M Double C A Double
- 48:35L I N dot com. You can also catch their podcast Is This Legal?
- 48:39I guess My last question is have you ever had anybody drop you in
- 48:43the middle of a case? I'm thinking of like Rodney. I think it
- 48:45was Rodney. I'll call the serial killer. I think a lot of psychopaths
- 48:49will tend to do I'll do it myself. I don't need you to do
- 48:51it and get a little bit more. I was superiority complex. Have you
- 48:54ever had any one of those? I was kind of curious. Never had
- 48:58that situation. I have very few times. I've had clients who dropped me,
- 49:05and it was mostly because they were looking for delay, right they were
- 49:09they're trying to delay their case. They're trying to delay the maybe the inevitable,
- 49:14and or you know, maybe they didn't like what I was telling them
- 49:17about their chances. Right, That could be that too, that could be
- 49:22But yeah, not often, but a handful of times, yes, thranks
- 49:27me have that one guy who defended himself and went up to the witness and
- 49:30said, what did the rapists sound like? And she said you yeah,
- 49:37For anyone out there listening, never never, never defend yourself. Please just
- 49:42don't do it. It's just such a such a terrible idea. Oh man,
- 49:46Yeah, any final words, Russell or No, I really I really
- 49:51enjoyed it. It was a fun conversation. Thank you for giving me the
- 49:53opportunity to hop on here. Thank you for you, thank you to you
- 49:57for coming on, thank you everybody for listening. Hey go check out habits
- 50:00McCallan dot com and the podcast is this legal? You know what to do?
- 50:04Share, subscribe, hit that like but you know, we like it
- 50:06and like heabit Russell said, please don't defend yourself.