Latest / Stories and a Cup / Finding Strength Through Fear: A Mother's Story
Transcript
- Speaker 1: All right, thank you, Hidayah. And I have Shamael with me here today. Shamael, good morning. How are you? Speaker 2: Good morning. are you? Thank you for having me today. Speaker 1: Yeah, so Shamael, tell me that people don't know about you. When did you come to the United States? Speaker 2: So actually I moved to the United States in 2018. I first moved to New York. We stayed there for two full years and then we decided that we're going to end our chapter there and move to Texas to open a new chapter. And we've been in Texas now for like five years, five and a half years. Speaker 1: Nice. So you've been in Texas for five and a half years and two years in New York City. So New York City, you came to New York City, like guess seven and a half years ago, were you living ⁓ in North America all your life or was this like the first encounter? Speaker 2: No, I actually was born and raised in Egypt and I got married in Egypt. I had my son and I moved to the States when I was like maybe 22, 23 years old. So this was my first encounter moving to America and living abroad. I used to visit though, yeah, but it my first time. ⁓ Speaker 1: So how was the, like tell me, so how was it like starting to live in America versus visiting? Speaker 2: Yeah, so no, living in America is completely different than visiting. So when you visit, come as, you know, like a tourist, you see all the beautiful things, only the bright side of living here. And you actually have this thought of, wow, if I moved to live here, this would be amazing. I would have all these nice ⁓ bright side of the United States that everybody sees, right? But then when you actually come and move here and you encounter like the day to day lives, you started to see like the negative sides along with the positive sides. But yeah, it's completely different. Especially in New York City, I used to visit before and the city captured me honestly, like all the lights, the city that never sleeps, the promises. ⁓ I New York City when I visited but then when I want to live there, ⁓ No, it's different. It's completely different living there versus visiting. It has a lot of positives though, but there were a of negatives that I didn't touch when I used to visit. Speaker 1: Yeah, so before we dive into your experience in New York City, I'm curious, your life in Egypt, what did that look like? living in Egypt, growing up there, ⁓ lot of us, I ⁓ you know, come from like sheltered backgrounds in Egypt, like Egypt is very segregated, as you know, like there's lots of experience you can have there. Speaker 2: Yeah, so living in Egypt was completely different from my experience living here because it's pretty luxurious, right? So you have everybody to do everything for you. So ⁓ you have somebody to put the gas for you. You have somebody to come and take out the garbage, somebody to clean the house. It's like there is help everywhere plus living along or near your family is also ⁓ pretty different from being here even if you're surrounded with like friends. ⁓ Living in Egypt, was much easier than living here. ⁓ But living the States kind of makes you grow up, right? So you learn a lot of experiences and a lot of skills that you might not have the chance ⁓ to learn Egypt. Also, you kind of meet ⁓ different people in Egypt, you're in a bubble, right? In a circle where the same people you know, like come from the same background, the same culture. They speak the same language, but then you come here and it's very diverse. You meet a lot of people with different backgrounds. This makes you learn and gain a lot of skills. living in Egypt is very easy, but living in the States kind of makes you more ⁓ self-aware, stronger, and resilient. Speaker 1: Yeah, for sure. You reminded me of something I saw online and someone was saying something around the lines of you literally pack like a 23 kilogram bag and just move. But the unpacking is not just physical unpacking. Do agree? mean, like you said, you started growing up, you realize how resilient you are. didn't really feel that before. So tell me something that you experienced in New York City that really made you grow. Speaker 2: Okay, so Living in Egypt. I was living in a bubble. Okay, I moved to the New York City and as I told you I was so optimistic and I was so caught up in the idea of New York City the energy the promise and the excitement but ⁓ Two weeks after we arrived I took my son for a walk on the beach and it was a really beautiful day sunny calm and peaceful and I Like I remember feeling so optimistic like life was opening up in front of me And ⁓ then it started to shift when I noticed a man standing on the beach with like this huge Rottweiler dog. And the dog was unleashed, okay, in an area where dogs weren't allowed. And the man said something to me in a language that I didn't recognize and no warning, he just let his dog run straight towards us. And no, how literally the dog just stopped inches from our feet. I remember I froze and my son was terrified. I was holding him, trying to protect him and calm him and also trying to understand what's happening. You know, like when this happens, your brain kind of completely shut down. And ⁓ then seconds later, the man called the dog bag and you know, as if it was like a game for him, he was testing us and the dog just walked back to him. I remember walking toward the man and asking him in like a shaking voice, why would you do that? So he looked at me and in the most extreme mocking tone he said, well, if you want to live in America, you just need to teach your son how to respect animals. And honestly, the comment made no sense for me. I love animals. My son love animals. And this line struck me because we talk a lot about teaching children respect, right? But what about respecting adults and respecting other human beings? But he just mumbled in something and he walked away. And also, Noha just wanted to say something. This is not the only thing that shook me at the time. He did something big. He weaponized his dog to terrify a mother and her toddler. But what actually shook me the most was the passive indifference and silence of everybody watching. Like the beach was full of people. Everybody saw what happened. Nobody said a word and nobody intervened in any way, you know, like as if they're watching a movie. So I walked away shaken. My phone was dead. So I actually didn't have anybody to talk to. So I was shaken and not only scared, like I felt disoriented. I was new to the country. ⁓ I didn't the law. I didn't know what protection I had to the point that I thought maybe I don't have any protection at all. And at that night, I didn't sleep well. You know, like when night hits and you just replay everything over and over in your head, like thinking of all the things you wish that you have said and done. And then I realized that ⁓ silence does not stop behaviors like this, right? Silence feeds behavior like this. So this man definitely did the same thing to another person who went silent. So that's why he did it again and again and again. So I decided I'm gonna break that cycle, right? So two weeks later, I saw him again. So I was parking my car at night when I noticed him walking his dog. And this time I decided I would not stay silent. I will just be courageous, brave. I got out of my car and I walked toward him. So what he did is that he lifted his leash as if he was about to release the dog again. So I walked closer and asked him, why are you doing this? You know how I went with the intention of talking to him in a way that maybe he experienced a bad thing with another person. So that's why he's acting this way. And I was like intending to tell him, like having a bad experience with one person does not dictate that you should react in this way with like this whole population. OK, so I was really having a good intention just to talking to him calmly. So he looked at me and he said like. ⁓ you're a Muslim. I can smell a Muslim from 20 feet away. Go back to your country. And I was like, okay, so first of all, I'm five feet away from you. Show me what you can do, okay? And second, the day you go back to your country is the same day I'm going to go back to mine. We're all different, right? Speaker 1: and we all are rooted from different areas for sure. Speaker 2: Exactly, exactly. So we just learned how to live with each other, respect our differences. But then he just mumbled again and he walked away. This time I decided I'm going to call 911. OK, and the police came and I spoke to the police. They were like, you know, that old talk of, we hope you're going to be OK. You don't worry. We're going to talk to him. And they actually went and spoke to him and I didn't see him again for about a month until my husband and I, we ⁓ went on a short vacation and returned. ⁓ And we went back, we decided that we want to go grocery shopping. Okay, so we walked outside and we found a large trash bag dumped on my husband's car. And the bag had been cut open, okay, and trash was scattered everywhere. So in my mind, I knew immediately who it was. I was just 100 % positive it was that neighbor. And we called the police again. one officer came. So they were two officers. One of them tried to minimize it. They said, ⁓ we cannot do anything about it. There is no physical harm, no injury, nothing we can charge him with. ⁓ And plus, he said, you cannot just accuse him. There is no evidence that he did that. ⁓ The other officer was really helpful and he was trying to help as much as he can and he took it seriously. So he said that if your neighbor does have a camera, because we didn't have one at the time, ⁓ we can ⁓ check the camera. And ⁓ it turns out that the neighbor is really best friends with the other neighbor family and they were resisting ⁓ for the footage to be reviewed. But then after a while, they got the police officers inside and When the police officers came out, they showed us like the footage. So it's like this, the man walking his dog, holding the trash bag. He saw our car. He just casually threw the trash bag on the car and he cut it open and dumped it on the car. Okay. So when I saw that video, I got furious. Like, why do you feel entitled to do that? Right. And the officers then started to explain our options to us. We wanted to do like the extreme course of flow with him. So they gave us a lot of options. The first one was you can just let it go and live peacefully with him. And we were like, no, this is a hard no for us. And then they said, okay, so you can move forward legally. We have two options, either having the man pay a fine to the city. And that's it. For me, it's also like a no. And then the other thing is just like moving forward with a legal course of action. Okay, so this wouldn't be a personal retaliation. It's going to be the city of New York versus him. And when we knew that this would stay on his record, something that's permanent and it would follow him for his lifetime, we chose that course of action. And honestly, you know, like after that, everything changed surprisingly. So every time the man saw me, he crossed the street, he turned his back, he avoided me completely and his behavior stopped. Like also my neighbor who turned out to be like best friends with his family, she had like that kind of hidden racism, like the look away racism and the weird looks racism. This completely stopped. And later on when I spoke, with another Muslim neighbors in the area. I learned something that shook me even more. They told me that when they first moved to this neighborhood, like ages ago, they received an anonymous letter in their mailbox. And the letter said that the writer had lived in the neighborhood his entire life and that it used to be clean and that he was afraid their presence would draw on it. So they never knew who sent this letter. ⁓ They called 911 at the time and they said, well, it's anonymous. We can't do anything about it. Until I shared my story with them and without hesitation, they said, well, it's definitely him. This is when I understood, you know, like I was not an isolated incident. It was a pattern. It was a pattern that he used to make with every Muslim he saw. And I know that patterns survive in silence, right? Silence feeds such patterns and it escalates. At the time, I didn't feel victorious because I like won over him or anything. I felt victorious because I broke the silence. And I felt victorious because what he did, he did what he did to hurt us, right? To intimidate us and to make us feel afraid and out of place. But in the end, it followed him. It stayed on his record. It changed the way he moved through the world, right? He changed his streets when he saw me. And the fear didn't live with us. It just kind of lived with him and haunted him. And I believe that until this moment, he remembers us every time he tries to like take a loan or have a credit check or something like that. And ⁓ I came to the conclusion that harmful action and racism It doesn't target other people. It haunts the people that carry them. Hate haunts the people that carry it, right? They follow those people. The hate shape their life in a way they cannot escape because for every action there is a consequence. And now he's living the consequence for the action he did to me, right? So he hurted himself more. And I decided to share this story not only because I felt as a victim at the time, so because someone who learned that breaking silence is powerful and because when you speak up, you don't just protect yourself, right? You protect the next person. I believe when he sees another Muslim woman or Muslim man, he wouldn't do that. So I was just happy that I stopped the cycle. And this was my first encounter to anything that I had to stand up for myself by myself in the States. I never encountered anything like that in Egypt, right? Because in Egypt, you have a lot of people to protect you. You don't have to stand up for yourself and something like that. So that's why I decided to share that story. The cycle has to stop. And I really advise anyone who just ⁓ encounters something like this to not remain silent. Speak up for yourself. Educate yourself about your rights, about the law. And everybody will just stay in their shape, right? Speaker 1: Yeah, absolutely. Shimael, ⁓ you mentioned something during your story with this man. At the very beginning, the first attack at the beach, you said something that probably will strike a lot of people when you said, like watching a movie, people were looking like they're watching a movie, not reacting. Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, yeah, this this was striking for me. Because, ⁓ you know, where we come from, ⁓ like in Egypt, since we were talking about the difference in ⁓ experience between living in Egypt and here, people wouldn't have that reaction, you know, like people would interfere, they would defend you, they would they would stand up for you. But no, this didn't happen. They're just they were so passive and indifference, you know. Speaker 1: Yeah, I'm sure a lot of people will absolutely relate to that. do you think if someone had stood up for you at that instant at the beach, would that have changed the course of the action that came after that? Speaker 2: It would have made me feel much safer. It would have made me like that feeling that I walked away with from the beach was really, was really bad. You know, I felt so alone. I wouldn't have felt that. I'm not sure if it would have changed. It would have changed the action of the man because this is the pattern. Okay. So this is calculated. He wants to be intimidating for Muslims. He hates Muslims. He might have had a bad experience with them. So I feel hate does not stop with having an external person interfere in an argument, right? It might have just escalated things. So ⁓ I'm not sure if it would have changed his own behavior, but it would have definitely changed the way I felt about it. Speaker 1: Absolutely. And then when you mentioned that you tried to come in peace after and talk to him, assuming that maybe he had a bad experience for whatever reason, ⁓ that was also ⁓ pushed back. He said you lifted his leash and tried to intimidate you again. ⁓ And then that's when you had to involve the police because at that moment it probably felt very scary and very unsafe. Speaker 2: Exactly, because I had the intention that I would talk to him calmly, like understand why he's saying that maybe if he has a misconception, I can correct it. But like when they say hate you blind, he wouldn't even listen. ⁓ He wouldn't even take a back. So having a neighbor that hates you that much without any reason that is racist doesn't usually end well until you just break this cycle, right? So this is when I decided that I'm going to, yeah, I'm going to call 911 and I'm going to have like higher authority interfere in this. Because at that time I felt really unsafe. So here's my neighbor, he knows where I live, has been in this neighborhood for ages and He's like best friends with most of the neighbors who were actually kind of having this ⁓ stereotype about Muslims and Islam. So I felt, no, I felt in danger actually. Speaker 1: And ⁓ Shemail, something else that you said that I really want to highlight is that pattern survives in silence. So you really felt the ownership of breaking that silence and ⁓ putting in action and making sure that the police follows up. And then from there, that's when the behavior completely stopped. if anyone is experiencing anything remotely similar, and I hope not. knowing that when you action it and you make sure you action it in a safe way, that you also could come out with a good outcome where someone is going to stop bullying essentially someone else. Speaker 2: Exactly. Yeah. So it's not only that I was defending myself, Noha, it was I'm defending myself and other people because ⁓ for him, I'm representing that whole population of Muslims, right, from his own perspective. So I felt like if I didn't stand up for myself, so I'm not protecting myself and I'm not protecting the coming person. ⁓ And ⁓ like if he his dog to us, why would he not do anything else that is more dangerous? Like he doesn't mind having physical harm. Cause at that time the dog might have. ⁓ made any physical harm either to me or my son. So I felt the responsibility that this person needs to know that it's not okay to terrify a person no matter what his religion was or what his beliefs was. And when I took that action and I made sure the police follows up, the behavior stopped from him and all the other neighbors, right? So he was the only one who was violent. He was the only one who was loud. Other neighbors were like looking at you, you know, that kind of hidden racism, right? So, so everybody stopped. So they actually stopped when they know you understand themselves. But when they are confronted by the contrary of what they think about, they kind of stop. Right. Speaker 1: Absolutely, absolutely. And that's a very important point. ⁓ as a minority myself, I certainly understand where you come from. You do feel the pressure of having to be almost like a gold standard continuously. certainly, even if you're not, even if you're just acting normal, there's certainly people that just have hate inside them and certainly express it in different ways. Speaker 2: Yes, exactly. And it's unexplained hate, know, like you don't have a reason for it. Speaker 1: Yeah. Yes, absolutely. I've also had that chance come my way visiting New York. Speaker 2: Yeah. ⁓ Speaker 1: Yeah, so thank you Shamal for sharing your story and it sounds like ⁓ you went from optimistic feeling when you came seven and a half years ago. You experienced this, ⁓ you took a course of action that corrected the behavior and then you moved to Texas where it sounds like ⁓ inshallah you're on the optimistic path again. Speaker 2: Yes, optimistic or grounded path, know? Not blindly optimistic. Yeah, it's really... It's always good to know how to get back to ground. Speaker 1: Absolutely, Well, thank you so much for sharing your story with us. appreciate your time. And I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day. Speaker 2: Thank you. You too. Thank you so much for having me.