Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Hot Foxes, Clock Blocker & the Future of Product Testing
Transcript
- 0:00Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the Shiny New Object Podcast.
- 0:03My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:06we're the fastest way to make scale and test performance ads.
- 0:10And this podcast is about the future of data-driven marketing.
- 0:13And every week or so I have the pleasure and the privilege of
- 0:16interviewing one of our industry's leaders about the
- 0:18future of the data-driven marketing, and this week is no
- 0:20different. I'm on a call with Tracy Holland, who's founder of
- 0:24Goodwill Brands. So Tracy's a kind of unusual shape, a
- 0:28different kind of guest, and a brilliant set of call with us.
- 0:31So we look forward to this for a long time but Tracy, we've got
- 0:34to know each other a little bit, but some of the people watching
- 0:37this will have no idea who you are. So could you give us a bit
- 0:39of background?
- 0:40Tracy Holland: Sure. I'm a serial entrepreneur and started
- 0:44my love and passion for being an entrepreneur selling pies with
- 0:49my sister, door to door when I was 12. Moved into waiting
- 0:53tables, which is by far-
- 0:55Tom Ollerton: What kind of pies?
- 0:56Tracy Holland: Every pie. Pecan, chocolate...
- 1:00Tom Ollerton: Sweet pies?
- 1:01Tracy Holland: Yeah. Sweet pies.
- 1:02Tom Ollerton: Yeah. When you say pies, I'm from the north of
- 1:05England so I'm like potato, meat, gravy, do you know all
- 1:07that stuff?
- 1:08Tracy Holland: No, no. I'm talking like Thanksgiving Day
- 1:10pies.
- 1:11Tom Ollerton: Right. Okay.
- 1:12Tracy Holland: Best business.
- 1:13Tom Ollerton: Bizarre. So anyway, let's not fall out about
- 1:14what a pie is. Let’s move on...
- 1:17Tracy Holland: Moved to waiting tables as a teenager, which is
- 1:20one of the best ways to hone your entrepreneurial skills and
- 1:25learn how to connect with customers.
- 1:27Tom Ollerton: So pause on that, Tracy. Why is it a great way to
- 1:30hone your entrepreneurial skills?
- 1:32Tracy Holland: Because when you walk into your restaurant, they
- 1:35hand you a section, and that is your domain. They carry all the
- 1:40inventory. They hire all the labour. They produce all the
- 1:44product. Your job is to create the absolute best experience for
- 1:50your section and your customers. Sell them as much as you can
- 1:57while they're in your section. Provide the best, the most
- 2:00optimal experience possible and connect with them as someone
- 2:06that you are their right hand person. And the better the
- 2:10experience, the more they tip and the more cash you walk out
- 2:14the door with. And I loved learning how to utilise my
- 2:19skills by connecting with people in my section. Very lucrative
- 2:24for me.
- 2:25Tom Ollerton: Right. So what did you do after that?
- 2:27Tracy Holland: A series of businesses that had intellectual
- 2:30property at the foundation of each business. So scented nail
- 2:34polish company, built and sold a business where we were the first
- 2:38scented nail polish in the market. The first microfibre
- 2:41product that was ever utilised in beauty. And we did
- 2:45microfibre, which was a patented material for a long time, and
- 2:49then did spray-on silk hosiery. So hydrolysed silk hosiery that
- 2:55comes in a can. You spray it on your legs. It looks just like
- 2:58hose.
- 3:00Tom Ollerton: I don't know what you're talking about. But-
- 3:03Brilliant!
- 3:05Tracy Holland: And then a whole series!
- 3:07Tom Ollerton: I was not expecting to talk about spray-on
- 3:09tights, but here we are. And then, sorry, and then a whole
- 3:12series of?
- 3:13Tracy Holland: Just different, very special intellectually
- 3:16prop- intellectual property derived concepts in the consumer
- 3:20space where we would bring to retailers unique product. And
- 3:25then we would take celebrity talent or influencer talent and
- 3:29pair that with the product or the brand and then sell it
- 3:34through many of the mainstream retailers that you're familiar
- 3:38with around the world, like Costco and Sam's Club, Amazon,
- 3:41etc..
- 3:42Tom Ollerton: So that's your very interesting journey to how
- 3:45you got here. But you've done multiple businesses, you're a
- 3:48true serial entrepreneur, you've done it like upwards of three,
- 3:51four, five, six, seven times. Spray-on tights and all the rest
- 3:55of it. Scented nail polish. So in that career, what has been
- 4:00the best investment of your own time, your own energy or your
- 4:04own money?
- 4:05Tracy Holland: So I would say as an entrepreneur, connection to
- 4:10the customer, which is going back to waiting tables or going
- 4:14door to door and selling pies, right? In each of these
- 4:18businesses, and of course, what I will tell you is utilising
- 4:23this skill in these, this premise, which is networking and
- 4:27relationship building and connecting with your networking,
- 4:30keeping those relationships deep and connected and listening to
- 4:36what the needs are of your customer. Underpromising and
- 4:39overdelivering on results has been the single best investment
- 4:43in my career that I have made. And then hiring coaches to help
- 4:47me up level on how to be an internal leader and take my
- 4:52visionary skillset and communicate effectively to my
- 4:56team so that the people internally in my business can
- 5:00execute on the vision and that promise to my customer that I'm
- 5:05sitting across just like I was waiting tables or Costco or
- 5:08Sam's Club or Amazon or whoever it may be really listening to
- 5:12the problems that they have, hearing the issues and the pain
- 5:15points, and then underpromising and overdelivering results.
- 5:19Tom Ollerton: We're going to pull it back from what I said,
- 5:21"What is a great bit of advice?" And one that we... has been
- 5:25fairly common on this podcast. What is your best tip when it
- 5:28comes to data-driven marketing? So when it comes to the actual
- 5:33nuts and bolts of ones and zeroes, when it comes to ads,
- 5:36what do you find is the thing you find yourself sharing most
- 5:39often?
- 5:39Tracy Holland: Knowing the data and being able to test and learn
- 5:43iteratively, I mean, think about it. Every single product that I
- 5:47was most successful with was really a first to market
- 5:50concept. So there weren't trailblazers ahead of us. Nobody
- 5:55had done scented nail polish. Nobody had done spray-on
- 5:57hosiery. Nobody has done the iterative products that since
- 6:01then we have been first to market and developing. And it's
- 6:04because we can listen to what the customer is asking for.
- 6:07Develop the product uniquely and then test and learn. Looking at
- 6:12the data as to what's selling, what's not selling, and making
- 6:15sure we're making tweaks and upscaling the consumer and the
- 6:20retailers' knowledge on what is or is not working in real time.
- 6:25And what was, like, the old days of taking three months to get
- 6:30that information, I can do it on AB testing today on a livestream
- 6:34sell with 300, 500, 900 people in a room. I can livestream sell
- 6:41in real time, provide product to them, pull them into a
- 6:45community, have them share with the community, their experience
- 6:48with the product, and make real time tweaks and changes to the
- 6:53product or the positioning based on that data.
- 6:56Tom Ollerton: So you kind of stolen your own thunder here,
- 6:59Tracy, because at this point of the podcast, I'll be saying what
- 7:01is your shiny new object? And you've already told us, which is
- 7:05livestream selling. So livestream selling... It's
- 7:08fairly self-evident in my head, but specifically, what do you
- 7:11mean by livestream selling? And then let's get into it in a bit
- 7:15more detail and then going to testing and learning and how
- 7:19that actually works. But for someone who's never done a
- 7:21livestream sale. I've never participated in one. I've never
- 7:25done one. So help us understand what that is.
- 7:28Tracy Holland: Well, I think I can tell you what the nuts and
- 7:31bolts of it are. It's been around forever. I did it 20
- 7:35years ago on QVC, which is a channel that's live here in the
- 7:40United States, also Home Shopping. And in the old days,
- 7:42we would get on TV and we would show this product whether it's
- 7:46the spray-on hosiery or the scented nail polish or whatever
- 7:50it may be. And we would sell to an audience live on television.
- 7:54Today, fast forward, I can have a network, which I do, of 3,000
- 8:00women across the United States who are sitting in their house
- 8:04who can go on and livestream sell from their living room or
- 8:08their kitchen and talk about a product in real time with a link
- 8:13to a landing page that allows us to see how products are
- 8:18converting and what the consumer experiences in the moment.
- 8:21Tom Ollerton: I'm guessing this is TikTok and Instagram, or is
- 8:24this like your own dot com where this is happening?
- 8:27Tracy Holland: So we do Instagram, we do Facebook, we do
- 8:30Whatnot, we do QVC, we do TikTok. So it depends on where
- 8:36your audience is as to where you're resonating most. And so
- 8:40there's not a right or wrong answer. Each of them come with
- 8:44their own unique challenges or iterative things to consider.
- 8:49But the data, the ability to gain data and get immediate
- 8:53consumer feedback is alive and well and really an important
- 8:57aspect of, I think, product development and product
- 9:00pipeline.
- 9:01Tom Ollerton: So, could you talk about one product? Because it
- 9:03sounds a bit like to me, sorry if I've got this wrong, but like
- 9:06you're kind of sort of collapsing the funnel here, you
- 9:09go, "Hey, we've got spray-on hosiery." I've never heard of
- 9:12that. Oh, look, that's it working, right I'm going to buy
- 9:15it. You've gone all the way through in one step. Or are you
- 9:18using it to see if you should do for the R&D or if it's ready to
- 9:22sell to Amazon or Best Buy or whatever? Can you give me a
- 9:25story for one product and tell me how that works?
- 9:27Tracy Holland: Yeah. I mean, I would say this. All of us are
- 9:31familiar with the old days of walking into a retailer and
- 9:34having someone stand there and try something on your arm or
- 9:38give you something to try and eat or spray on to you. And that
- 9:43feedback in the old days was given to someone sitting on the
- 9:47selling floor and then hopefully you were able to extract from
- 9:51that person back to the head of marketing to try and understand
- 9:55what consumers were feeling about something. And so this is
- 10:00an old relic of another way, or I would say like an approach of
- 10:05how to do business. The beauty is with technology today, we
- 10:09have the ability to go right into someone's home and
- 10:13immediately give a community an opportunity to participate in
- 10:17product development. So there are a couple of ways in which we
- 10:20do that. On QVC, that's what I would call more like the store
- 10:24approach, right? Where you make something and there's a three,
- 10:28six, 12-month lead time from product development to be able
- 10:32to sell it on QVC, you have to go through regulatory, you have
- 10:35to go through packaging, you have to have the right barcode
- 10:39and label on the product so when it scans and gets to them that
- 10:43there is a process. But we've actually collapsed the funnel,
- 10:47all of us even bypassing the retailer and being able to go
- 10:51direct to consumers' homes and test something that may not even
- 10:55exist yet. It may be just in concept. And by the time we want
- 11:01to launch it, we could have ported all of our followers into
- 11:06a private community to say, "You're coming into the lab with
- 11:09us, you're coming into a product development secret club where
- 11:14you get to co-create this product with us."
- 11:17Tom Ollerton: Conceptually, I get it, but give me an example,
- 11:19like a recent example where that's worked so I can get my
- 11:23head around it.
- 11:24Tracy Holland: Sure. There's a brand that we own called Plant
- 11:26Apothecary. It's a ten year old brand. We started something
- 11:30called Plant Apothecary Labs, where we have a team of Ph.D.
- 11:36chemists and formulators in a private community on Facebook We
- 11:41go on to Instagram, we livestream sell, and we say,
- 11:44"Come join us In our private community. We're co-creating
- 11:47product together for women forty up. All your skincare issues,
- 11:52your ageing issues, your menopause issues, everything
- 11:56that you're facing, we want to hear about in this community."
- 11:59Tom Ollerton: Is this this guy? We've got the right screen?
- 12:01Okay, great.
- 12:02Tracy Holland: Yeah. And see all those women? That's a snapshot
- 12:07of some of the community.
- 12:09Tom Ollerton: The community, right. Nice. Okay. Cool.This is
- 12:13one of your sellers?
- 12:15Tracy Holland: Yup.
- 12:16Tom Ollerton: Okay. Sorry I cut you off there, but I just, I
- 12:18wanted to have a look at the brand.
- 12:19Tracy Holland: These are also community members. These are
- 12:21women that you're seeing who are giving real time feedback and
- 12:28telling us what is working, what is not. But there are also
- 12:32affiliates.
- 12:34Tom Ollerton: Got it. Got it. Brilliant. So you went to Plant
- 12:37Apothecary Labs, and you said right, "We're going to launch
- 12:40the Firm Believer Boost Serum." And then what happens? So what
- 12:45happens in the lab, as it were?
- 12:47Tracy Holland: We poll lab foxes and we choose 15-20 lab fox-
- 12:53Tom Ollerton: Hold on! What? What's a lab fox?
- 12:54Tracy Holland: We call them- It's a hot, foxy woman.
- 12:57Tom Ollerton: Ah, right! Okay.
- 12:59Tracy Holland: Who's 40 and up.
- 12:59Tom Ollerton: Thought you were testing it, testing on animals
- 13:01there for a minute, but, you know.
- 13:02Tracy Holland: No. No, we pull our hot, our hot members and we
- 13:08take 15 to 20. We send our first box where they get to just try
- 13:14it for two weeks and give before and after photos and talk to the
- 13:18private community about what their experience is. They get to
- 13:21say, "I like the fragrance. I don't like it. That irritated my
- 13:24skin. I want it to have this effect." And they all get to
- 13:28weigh in. And based on that feedback, we go back into the
- 13:31lab and make the changes. Then we do another 15 to 20 and have
- 13:36the next group try it. And then by the time we get it to the
- 13:40right place, we launch three to 500 units to the community to
- 13:47buy for a price that is less than what the market will pay
- 13:51when it's eventually. Right now we have an enzyme collection
- 13:56which uses papaya to remove the top layer of skin, and it has on
- 14:01the label, "No Name Yet." And that's literally what the
- 14:05product is called is No Name Yet because we don't have a name
- 14:08because we need to drop three to 500 sets to see if our community
- 14:16is resonating and what they believe the name for, for this
- 14:20product should be.
- 14:21Tom Ollerton: And what they, they- You say they crowdsource
- 14:22the name? Like people say this should be called cool serum,
- 14:26whatever. And then everyone says yay or nay?
- 14:28Tracy Holland: No. We pull names that we think are relevant. We
- 14:31pre-approve them through the trademark office to make sure
- 14:34they're available. And then we give them a group of names and
- 14:38let them select what they think is the best option.
- 14:41Tom Ollerton: Right. And how often does that community select
- 14:44the name that you think is going to work?
- 14:46Tracy Holland: They select the name that we choose. We have
- 14:49some great names. "Clock Blocker" is one of our, you
- 14:54know, so I'm on a Clock Blocker, right? It says what it does and
- 15:01how many of us have had a cock blocker or a Clock Blocker? We
- 15:06know-
- 15:07Tom Ollerton: It's not that kind of podcast, man, but I...
- 15:11Tracy Holland: But as a marketer, you understand?
- 15:14Tom Ollerton: Yeah. Yeah, of course. Okay, great. All right.
- 15:17So what's the downside to this? It all sounds too good to be
- 15:20true. You come up with a product, you seed it into the
- 15:23audience. 20 of these foxes try it then they come back, say, do
- 15:27this, reformulate, put it back out there, hasn't got a label,
- 15:30hasn't got a name. People come up with a name and then you
- 15:34launch. So where, when doesn't this work? What's the
- 15:37shortcoming?
- 15:38Tracy Holland: We haven't had a situation where it doesn't work.
- 15:40Now we run Meta ads against all the product that's available to
- 15:44the mainstream public. You were just on our website where all
- 15:47that product is now available to the world, but to the founding
- 15:52members and to the members in our private community, they are
- 15:56receiving between 20 to 30% discount on all product for
- 16:01life. So they're not only devotees of these products, but
- 16:08then they are also affiliates and they are reselling product
- 16:12to their, to their followers because they co-created it.
- 16:16Tom Ollerton: So how successful has this been like what's your
- 16:19biggest selling product? I know you're, you've cut out so many
- 16:23of those kind of QVC type costs. You just go in DTC, you go in
- 16:26direct, you just, you know, you pay for your lab and whatever
- 16:31and your Meta ads. But what's been the biggest hit here? Like
- 16:34how big does this get or does it not need to? It just needs to
- 16:38stay at a certain level and keep repeating it and it works.
- 16:42Tracy Holland: I mean, this is the business I came from, right?
- 16:46So the last business I built and sold, we had 11 brands and we
- 16:49did over 750 million in revenue over the course of the nine
- 16:54years in which I owned the company before I sold it. It
- 16:57gets as big as the flywheel gets, right? I think if you go
- 17:01back to what I said when we talked in the beginning about
- 17:05this is the premise of having your waiting years on your
- 17:09tables and having your station and providing the best absolute
- 17:14experience for each customer where they're really listened to
- 17:18and then they're part of co-creating and that feeling and
- 17:21that experience feels so personal and then they turn
- 17:25around and want to sell it to their friends and tell other
- 17:27people about it. This is as old as, you know, pre-Christ, right?
- 17:33Where people are sitting there sharing you know...
- 17:37Tom Ollerton: Pre-Christ!
- 17:39Tracy Holland: Pre-Christ, right? Sharing loaves of bread
- 17:41and telling each other what's working and what doesn't work
- 17:44and why they love something.
- 17:46Tom Ollerton: The very, very old school of marketing. Right.
- 17:48Yeah. Yeah, I, I totally agree with you. However, Tracy, we are
- 17:54out of time. So if someone wants to get in touch with you, where
- 17:58should they do it? And what should they say to get you to
- 18:00reply to them?
- 18:01Tracy Holland: Go to my my Instagram @tracy_m_holland. It's
- 18:05pretty straightforward. I reply to all my own, my DMs, everyone
- 18:09that DMs me. I reply and I'll connect with you there.
- 18:13Tom Ollerton: Tracy, thank you so much for your time.