Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / High on Oreos: Questions, Calls, and Lots of Sugar
Transcript
- 0:00Here the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56I have been weak, my friends, I am. I'm in the
- 1:00flesh today. Natalie and I try to eat pretty well, stay active,
- 1:06exercise moderate, but I've been craving lately. You ever just crave a food,
- 1:11random food, and you can't get it out of your head. I'm
- 1:15at the grocery store the other day and I'm trying to buy all the right
- 1:21stuff. Okay, we need connage cheese, and I need almond milk,
- 1:25and let's get some proteins over here, got to buy pecans, and let's
- 1:30do this and that. And I'm walking around an aisle and there it is
- 1:36and I can hear it speaking to me, a package of double stuff Oreo
- 1:45cookies. It's like destiny. It was fate, you know, the stars
- 1:52aligned, and the package actually spoke to me. The little plastic flap opened
- 1:57up and said, eat me right. I couldn't resist double stuff Oreos.
- 2:02I have the package here, just open it up, Just open it up
- 2:07and have a cookie. From time to time, somebody told me there's such
- 2:12a thing as triple stuff Oreo cookies. Where has that been all my life?
- 2:19Where do I find? Though it is triple stuff. I don't even
- 2:22know what the stuff is. It's like creamy filling, but it's not cream.
- 2:27I think it's just straight sugar. I don't care. It's delicious.
- 2:34Have you noticed people eat Oreo cookies in different ways? Like everyone's got their
- 2:38own method. Are you they just eat the cookie outright, person? Or
- 2:42do you pop it open and eat the outside first and then the cream?
- 2:47Do you twist right? I'm a twister, so you got to twist it
- 2:51so that it comes off cleanly, and then I eat the cream first and
- 2:55finish with the cookies. What's your method for the Oreo anyway? Just a
- 3:02window into my life, my indulgences. As I am in the flesh,
- 3:07I am acting out my carnal culinary desires today. Here's a little bunny trail
- 3:16I've been on. Let me tell you about this and we'll see if you
- 3:20can relate. Have you ever gotten what you would consider to be a bizarre
- 3:25or inflammatory text from somebody and you immediately started mashing out a reply. I
- 3:34don't know you could do paragraphs like you would write an email, because you
- 3:38have so much to say, And then you don't send just yet, and
- 3:43you reread it and you're like, no, that's not exactly how I want
- 3:47to say it. I can do this better. So you wipe it out,
- 3:51you delete the text, and you start again, and your partner is
- 3:54sitting next to you, going, what are you doing over there? I've
- 3:58got to reply to someone sent me this and I need to respond. So
- 4:03you're focused and you're typing with your thumbs and you spend another ten minutes,
- 4:10fifteen minutes massaging that reply and you almost hit send, and then you stop
- 4:15and go, I want to read it again. No, no, it's
- 4:18not gonna that's not I missed out. I missed this point and this is
- 4:26redundant. So you wipe that out, and you start again, and then
- 4:29you do it another time and another time, five times until you just either
- 4:32don't send it or you give up and decide it is what it is.
- 4:38I did this the other night. So another story about my religious mother,
- 4:43and I'll make this as short as I can. She ended up in the
- 4:47emergency room and she had some stomach pain, and so she ended up getting
- 4:54scoped at the hospital and they found ulcers in her stomach. I'm kind of
- 4:58serious, and so I call checked on her, trying to be a good
- 5:01son despite the difficulties that we've had and all the baggage. You know,
- 5:05she's eighty four and I'm reaching out in good faith. You're doing okay,
- 5:10You're just checking on you. Do you need me to bring buy some groceries
- 5:13or whatever? And she cannot help herself. And so as she's talking about
- 5:16how she was there in the waiting room waiting for the doctor. She should
- 5:21have had to wait for hours to get seen, but someone came right to
- 5:28her and said, the doctor will see you now, and she didn't have
- 5:33to wait very long in the emergency room. And she just knows it was
- 5:39because of Jesus. You're ahead of me. You are way ahead of me.
- 5:58Jesus in the emergency room before the doctor did what doctors do and knocked
- 6:04you out and dropped a scope down your esophagus and then prescribed twelve weeks of
- 6:11medications and diet changes. Because Jesus bumped somebody with a name tag and a
- 6:16white coat or scrubs over to your chair just a little bit early. I
- 6:21mean, what is the standard for divine intervention? I was tempted to say,
- 6:30in a strong field, that's the stupidest thing I've heard so far in
- 6:35twenty twenty three. But I didn't do it because I've been working on myself.
- 6:42I've been working on me. Well, I hope you're okay, let
- 6:45me know if you need anything, and I hung up. So the next
- 6:47night, I'm sitting up in bed with Natalie. It's about nine o'clock and
- 6:54I feel my phone vibrate. Oh look, oh, joy of Joyce.
- 6:58It's a text from my mother. And I immediately regretted unblocking her number.
- 7:09Why do I do this to myself? But it was, honestly, I
- 7:12found it. There was utility in seeing how she had said what she had
- 7:16said. And I'll tell you because I think it's a window into much of
- 7:19what we face when dealing with religious families, and it's an object lesson I
- 7:24think might be irrelevant to you. She said something weird and cryptic about how
- 7:30the Book of Malachi Malachi says something about how the atheist is going to face
- 7:39destruction. It was weird. I couldn't really make too much sense of it.
- 7:44But the final four words of the text from my mother are what struck
- 7:47me. She said, I am your mother just stuck it out there.
- 7:54It was just like it was its own paragraph kind of thing. So I
- 7:58sat down and started that process, typing out of paragraphs, and then I
- 8:03thought no, no, So I wiped it out and I started again,
- 8:07started again. I must have mashed it for an hour, and finally I
- 8:11just called her, Hey, Mom, I got your text. What exactly
- 8:16are you trying to say? Well, I know you say you're an atheist.
- 8:24Just like that, I know you've saying you're an atheist. Well,
- 8:31the Bible says here that the atheist is going to face destruction. My first
- 8:37inclination, of course, is to go thermonuclear. Natalie's waiting for it,
- 8:41She's five feet from me. But I tried out a little street epistemology,
- 8:46mostly for my own amusement and to see how it would play out, right,
- 8:50And so I said, well, can you help me understand what that
- 8:54looks like? If I'm going to be destroyed, what does that mean?
- 9:00Will I be annihilated in physical form? Or will I be cast off into
- 9:03the cosmos to live forever in darkness? Or is it temporary? I mean,
- 9:09what do you think destruction means for me? And I really felt like
- 9:16it was the first time she'd ever been asked to qualify it or consider it.
- 9:20It's one of those punch words, the sinner will be destroyed, But
- 9:26what does that really mean? And I could feel her working it out.
- 9:30Well, yeah, there, you won't be in heaven with Jesus. Okay,
- 9:39Well I get that. So I'm going to be destroyed, But what
- 9:43does that look like? She hemmed and hawed, And then I quoted that
- 9:46verse out of the New Testament, Depart from me, you who are cursed
- 9:50into a lake of everlasting fire. Mom. The New Testament says, I'm
- 9:54going to spend eternity burning and screaming and writhing in Great Paine. Do you
- 10:01hold to that verse out of the Bible. No, I think that that
- 10:07is wrong. I think that was a mistranslation. Okay, all right,
- 10:15you realize this is the translation used by the vast majority of the world's major
- 10:18religions, from the Southern Baptist to the Assembly of Gods, and they're preaching
- 10:24literal Hell. Well, I think that they have misunderstood what the author's originally
- 10:30intended. And that's just not theologically correct. It's the translation is wrong,
- 10:39all right, what's the right translation? Like? What translation? Got this
- 10:43right? Mom? Well, a lot of people like the new Schofield Reference
- 10:50Bible. My face gives it away. Natalie's looking at me, and I'm
- 10:56just like a lot of people. Hey, okay, Well, a lot
- 11:01of people say, Mom, how do you know that it's the Schofield Reference
- 11:07Bible that is more anchor? And where do you Well, you know,
- 11:11when you're a believer, the Holy Spirit guides you. But the Holy Spirit
- 11:16is guiding the Southern Baptist in the Assembly. I mean, they're all saved,
- 11:20so the Holy Spirit. And if I'm not a believer, I don't
- 11:26have the Holy Spirit. But I'm supposed to accept the claim of the Bible,
- 11:30but I need the Holy Spirit to understand the Bible, Well, how
- 11:33do I understand it to accept it? She's over there like totally tilt.
- 11:39I am not losing my mind. I have not raised my voice. I'm
- 11:43just sort of amused and asking questions. Hey, Mom, why do you
- 11:48think of billions of people are reading the wrong message that Jesus hasn't come down
- 11:52here to correct the record. You know, we got preachers behind the podiums
- 11:56all around the world. They've all got it wrong. Why do you think
- 12:00Jesus would allow everybody to get it wrong? The other side of the line,
- 12:07just a lot of hemming and hanging. I don't even remember what the
- 12:11non answer was, and then the final the big guns. How many times
- 12:16over the last how many ten years have I asked you not to do what
- 12:20you're doing, Not to interject in this way, No more naming and blaming
- 12:24and shaming, no more sermons. Right, We've been down this road and
- 12:28I drew a line, and you have crossed the line. How many times
- 12:31have you crossed it? And so I framed it like this, I said,
- 12:33either you don't understand what I'm saying, or you are purposefully disrespecting me.
- 12:43Which of those is true? Mum? And the response came back,
- 12:48well, i'm your mother, and there it is. The Book of Exodus
- 12:58commands honor your mother and father, or father and mother. I'm doing it
- 13:01from memory, but a lot of people don't know what the rest of that
- 13:05command is. It's honor your father and mother so that you may live a
- 13:11long life, which is a threat. The implication is if you don't honor
- 13:18your mother and father, God will kill you. Early then comes to question
- 13:24what does honor look like. The parent is training a child to act and
- 13:28behave and think and be a certain way, and if the child deviates at
- 13:35any age from that. The Bible and Biblical cultures tell a lot of cultures.
- 13:41Authoritarian cultures, high control cultures tell the parent, well, you're authorized
- 13:48to go stick your head in their windows, tell them they're wrong, and
- 13:52tell them how to live. Boundaries don't exist in that way. In fact,
- 13:56because they were burst from your loin, they remain under your authority for
- 14:03the rest of their lives. You've got the right to say and do whatever
- 14:07you want. And man, it's hard for people to overcome that after they've
- 14:11done it for decades of their lives. It's been pounded into them it's your
- 14:16mother. Oh, come on, it's your mother. You gotta put up
- 14:20with it. I've heard that a lot. Even my siblings know that mom's
- 14:24off base. They're like, well, you know, what's your mother?
- 14:26Yeah? And there's a deference there that I find alarming. At what point
- 14:31are you just being a coward or an enabler? Would they abide the stuff
- 14:39that mom says and does from a neighbor, a coworker, a total stranger,
- 14:46Hell no, But a parent is supposed to have some kind of a
- 14:50genetic get out of respect free card, And it's empowering. It's hard,
- 14:58but it's also empowering to say out loud, no, you don't get to
- 15:01play. You don't even have that card. Man. Once we understand that
- 15:07we have the right to say it, we have the right to say you
- 15:11don't have permission, it opens up the world for us. We are liberated.
- 15:18I just found that an interesting note an exercise based on that experience with
- 15:22my mother. Anyway, that's kind of what I've come off of and what's
- 15:28been on my mind lately. Today's broadcast, I would like to hear what
- 15:31is on your mind, whatever is happening in your world. Let's talk about
- 15:37that. Walter calling in from area code five O three. Are you there?
- 15:43Yeah? What is on your mind? My friend? What do you
- 15:46want to talk about? Oh? My goodness. Seth as a young child
- 15:50at a church across the street from my house. We weren't particularly religious,
- 15:56but I got sucked in because they had fun things to do and people to
- 15:58meet. And over time I realized that it was all a bunch of bullshit.
- 16:03And then by the time I got to college, I realized this,
- 16:07and I had a fun time telling people off about how dumb and stupid they
- 16:11were. And then I found your podcast and probably about twenty thirteen, twenty
- 16:18fourteen, when did you start? It was a long time ago, yeah,
- 16:22way back. Yeah, And then you taught me, well, you
- 16:26used to be all about it and the Christian podcasts are on the radio right
- 16:33And then after watching you, I realized that Christian people aren't bad people.
- 16:38You know. I kind of thought the idea it was more than the person,
- 16:42and I realized you're a nice person, and you went through all that
- 16:48stuff, and it made me realize that being militant toward people who believe it's
- 16:56just it's just a good way to lose friends. And you're not going to
- 17:00change anyone's minds. And I've kind of learned to live. You know,
- 17:03a lot of people do whatever they want as long as they don't push it
- 17:07on me. And that has been a great You tell me a great life
- 17:11lesson, and I fell on to it ever since. Are you very kind?
- 17:15I think I'd add the caveat that some religious people are good people,
- 17:18many religious people, But I take the spirit of what you're saying. I'm
- 17:25also not saying that we always have to play nice. I'm all about I
- 17:30hate the word balance because there's a false equivalence, sort of a baggage attached
- 17:36to that that I don't mean. But there are a lot of people who
- 17:38are just top heavy. All they do is rage and froth and scream and
- 17:42carry on. And so when I say, that's no way to live right,
- 17:47our existence on this planet, this finite existence, is short, and
- 17:51we need to be able to enjoy, breathe the air, feel the sun
- 17:56on our faces, you know, make memories, love, do those azing
- 18:00things. You know. To rage and froth and freak all the time is
- 18:03I think destructive really to ourselves. And if you say that, people are
- 18:07like, oh yeah, well, what about these horrible people? Aren't you
- 18:11angry about the injustice? And I'm like, no, no, no,
- 18:14I'm not saying we never have moments of anger, even rage about the injustices.
- 18:18I just think life is short. Anger can come in many forms.
- 18:23I think anger can be a great motivator. But I'm come to the point
- 18:29in my life we're running around with the two by four whacking people over the
- 18:33head and saying religious people are stupid and morons and brain defective or whatever.
- 18:38You know, that's not how we fix it. It's not how we change
- 18:41the world. And I just don't think it's a good way to live life.
- 18:45And I think that's fair. I'm glad that the message coming out of
- 18:48this broadcast, the temperature of this show has helped you in your own journey.
- 18:52That's a tremendous compliment to me, Walter, and I appreciate it.
- 18:55Man. I have a good one. See you bye. Susie at area
- 19:00code eight five zero. Are you there? Yes, I am. How
- 19:03are you doing, Seth? I'm so good or I'm well. I'm sorry.
- 19:07My English teachers just had a heart attack. I'm doing quite well.
- 19:11Thank you, Susie. Talk to me, what's on your mind today.
- 19:15You're just talking about your mom and how she's like still trying to get you
- 19:21back in. And it's like, once you pull the thread into atheism,
- 19:26it's hard to go back to make believe, you know. And I guess
- 19:32unless someone's cross that line. Just like when some people say on flight talk
- 19:37with Matt Dilloman, they go, well, I wasn't I was an atheist
- 19:38too, and now I'm a Christian. It's like, well, okay,
- 19:42that's a hard leap to make to me. I think too. It sounds
- 19:45like they're trying to build street cred. I was an atheist. I was
- 19:51out there, man, I was godless, and then Jesus revealed himself or
- 19:56then I discovered all the evidence for God. Now use it as kind of
- 20:00a business card when they enter a debate or conversation. And I'm fascinated by
- 20:07how few of those legitimate stories there are. I've known a few people they
- 20:12were religious and then they became an atheist, and then a few years later
- 20:17they went back into some kind of religion. And often with those people,
- 20:22it's because they missed the community and maybe they still harbored a fear of not
- 20:27living forever and there were other factors at play. Almost never did I see
- 20:33theology. It was always really more about community and belonging and kind of balming
- 20:38the mind and heart in this crazy world. But those stories even then were
- 20:42really rare. Almost always it's stories of people leaving the faiths and becoming an
- 20:48atheist. Has that been your experience? Yes? Or it's like young men
- 20:53they meet a girl and she goes to church and they just kind of go
- 20:57alone to be with the girl. Yeah, there's an ulterior motive there,
- 21:02yea social in grouping, community and tribes, tribalistic security. There's so much
- 21:08psychology behind why people gravitate to these types of groups. I'm sorry, Susy,
- 21:14go ahead, go ahead, what else you have? I was raised
- 21:17Southern Baptist, and my dad never went I think he was a deist.
- 21:21But my oldest brother he's atheist like I am, and he pretty much always
- 21:26has been. He was very skeptical even in Baptist Sunday school, and he
- 21:30would ask a lot of questions and make the Sunday school teacher mad. One
- 21:36thing he asked, does each planet have its own God? And the Sunday
- 21:41school teacher said no, oh, no, no, and then I found
- 21:47out years later when my mom would put a couple of dollars in the envelope
- 21:52for us to put in the play in church, my brother told her he
- 21:56was going to go sit in the back. He would actually walk down the
- 22:00street by an icy in a comic book with the money and read the comic
- 22:06book and then toss it in the woods and then be standing outside church.
- 22:11Oh, he was blessed in a whole different way, wasn't he. He
- 22:14cast his bread upon the waters and it returned to him as a beverage in
- 22:18a comic book. Yes. The part of the story that strikes me the
- 22:22most is my mother did the same thing. She would take a few bucks
- 22:26out of her purse and she would have us slide it in the envelope or
- 22:30just toss it in the offering plate. And in her mind, she was
- 22:34training us to give back. Right, we turn to the storehouse, what
- 22:37is the lord's which is the whole concept of tithing. Right, everything belongs
- 22:41to God, and so the ten percent that you tithe, you're actually returning
- 22:47to the storehouse what already belongs to the Father. But she was really programming
- 22:52into us this notion that monetary goods are resources financially and otherwise need to be
- 23:00brought to the church and hand it over in the hopes that when we got
- 23:03jobs and had careers and built the rest of our adult lives, we would
- 23:07continue the practice that had been programmed into us as young children. Fill the
- 23:12envelope, drop the checks, the dollars whatever in the plate, use your
- 23:17credit card, cast your bread out upon the water, and it shall be
- 23:22returned unto thee. And that training is often very effective. So it's a
- 23:26good point, Susie, thanks so much for calling. Appreciate you, Thank
- 23:30you all right, see you anybody else become acutely aware after leaving the church
- 23:37about how much of your currency you don't have to spend. And I'm not
- 23:42just talking about money, I meantime the currency of weekends, Sunday morning.
- 23:48And I know there are some people who wake up cheery, all too cheery
- 23:53and happy and spry, and they spring into action and they can't wait to
- 23:59go to church and they have a wonderful time and leave inspired. Yes I
- 24:03get it, but I was not that person, especially growing up, and
- 24:07we were forced you get up out of bed, it is time to go
- 24:11to church. We're gonna make nine am service. And back then it wasn't
- 24:15as much a come as you are experience. You can wear jeans and T
- 24:18shirts and even shorts like contemporary churches, they're so much different back then.
- 24:25No, you don't. You don't wear jeans. You don't wear shorts to
- 24:30church, not to be in the presence of the Lord. So it's slacks
- 24:36and a collared shirt, everything perfectly pressed, nice shiny shoes, the girls
- 24:41in dresses. We are going to church, and we would sit through the
- 24:48church and we would be waiting for the final benediction. And I don't know
- 24:56how much has changed attend church these days, but it used to be as
- 25:00the same template. You show up, We begin with a big song,
- 25:03there's an opening prayer, some announcements than you do, another song, maybe
- 25:08special music. There's an offering, more announcements, the pastor preaches, they
- 25:14have an altar call, and then at the very very very end, there's
- 25:17a final prayer. Lord, We thank you so much. As everyone goes
- 25:21off into their lives, we ask that you keep them safe as they spread
- 25:25your good word. Amen. Amen, And everybody stands up, and the
- 25:30people sitting in the congregation who have been ready to go for an hour and
- 25:34a half. It's like they've been freed from prison. Oh I'm good.
- 25:41Now I can go home and I can get in my grubbies and I can
- 25:47enjoy the rest of my day. Oh have you noticed what it's like to
- 25:52get your weekends back? Sunday morning? When I wake up, I worship
- 26:00my pillow. I just bow down. I'd bow back down and say,
- 26:04oh, yes, cool pillow. I will flip thee and I will lay
- 26:08my head into thee and we shall commune together. I will feel the spirit
- 26:15of the pillow in rapturing me above the neck. Can I get an amen?
- 26:22Oh, it's eight o'clock, eight thirty nine o'clock. Fine with me.
- 26:27I got nowhere to be. Oh that's lovely. My Sunday mornings have
- 26:33received salvation and liberation. Can I get an amen? Anybody else feel that
- 26:41the liberation? I don't know. I just went off. Let's hang out
- 26:45some more short break. I'll be right back after this. If you haven't
- 26:56checked out my second podcast, please do so. You can subscribe on all
- 27:00major podcast apps. True Stories with Seth Andrews five minute Vignette's True Crime,
- 27:08Celebrity Trivia weird news, fascinating history. You just never know what you're gonna
- 27:14get. Five minutes a show, three days a week. True Stories Podcast
- 27:19dot com area code three zero one, Ray, thanks for calling. Are
- 27:29you there? Yes, I am, Hi Seth. Thanks for colin what's
- 27:32on your mind? I was thinking about a time I was writing a Maryland
- 27:37bus last year, wait, last year, and I got my life fritened,
- 27:42and it was related to religion, atheism specifically. And what happened was
- 27:49I was sitting god into the bus, saying across from a guy who was
- 27:55disturbed, and he started asking questions about how God's been good to me,
- 28:00or if God has been good to me, and if I love God,
- 28:02etc. And he pressed it and eventually got to the point where he said
- 28:07concluded that I was an atheist, and then started to try to ask the
- 28:12usual questions why, and I'd just say no to all his assumptions. And
- 28:18then he said something about illegals on the bus and what I thought of him,
- 28:22and I said I don't care, but he heard something else and just
- 28:25accused me of being a racist and told the rest of the bus and then
- 28:30I said, Okay, I'm going to move to the back and got away
- 28:33from him. Then he pressed on. He just went on for about fifteen
- 28:37minutes, and then he got to escalate and he started threatening to f me
- 28:44up, and he knew people who had ake me up and asked me if
- 28:48I was white at that point, and I thought that was weird, and
- 28:52I had my phone bub and I won one. I was ready. The
- 28:55things got worse, and then he said I was going to die. I
- 28:59was going to to night. And then I wasn't sure what I should get
- 29:03off the bus, if you'd follow me or stay on the bus where there
- 29:06other people, or wasn't sure what to do. And after a while he
- 29:10finally got up his stop, and as he was getting ready to get off
- 29:15the bus, he said, do you want me to f you up?
- 29:18I said no, and then he said, well, you're going to die
- 29:19tonight. God's going to kill you. And when he said that, I
- 29:23knew it's going to be okay. But that made me think today and I
- 29:26was listening to you even though his religion kind of fed him off about me.
- 29:33I wonder maybe the fact is superstitioned about God and God being responsible for
- 29:37killing me, Maybe that prevent him from doing something much worse or at least
- 29:41trying to What do you mean by that? Do you feel like he was,
- 29:47you know, disadvantaged, he had something, he was troubled in some
- 29:48way, or do you think he was operating? Yes, okay, okay,
- 29:52I don't think he was thinking clearly, especially the way he jumped from
- 29:56your an atheist to your a racist. That was weird. And and yes,
- 30:00he was definitely disadvantaged, kind of like a thought. I mean,
- 30:03there was all kinds of stuff and the blender of his brain spilling out.
- 30:07But until today, it never occurred to me that maybe I was thinking,
- 30:11like, here's an example of religious thinking that's you know, triggered this whole
- 30:14thing, But I never thought about the other side. Maybe his religious superstitions
- 30:18prevent things from getting even worse. I don't know. Maybe it's two edges
- 30:22to the sword. If he had thought God wasn't going to do it,
- 30:26maybe he would have taken the matter into his own hands. Correct correct,
- 30:30Now, Maybe he wouldn't. The whole thing would have started, maybe with
- 30:33found some other reason. But yeah, maybe that stopped him from He certainly
- 30:38wasn't afraid to fight me, at least that's the way he sounded. But
- 30:42to take it to the next step to try and kill me. That's where
- 30:45his red line was. That's God's responsibility. Scary times. I'm glad you're
- 30:52safe. Ray, Glad it worked out, brother, Thanks me too,
- 30:56Thanks for sharing the story. We'll talk next time. Okay, I tell
- 31:02you that story about the comedian who said, whenever somebody wants to fight you
- 31:04and you don't think you want to fight or won't win, just take your
- 31:08pants off. Said that I've never forgotten that someone's gonna come kick your ass.
- 31:14First thing to do you just take off your pants, because nobody wants
- 31:17to fight anybody who takes off their pants. I tell that somebody like I
- 31:25am not a fighter. I'm not physical in that way. I've never been
- 31:29that dude. I've when I was in high school. Hell, when I
- 31:32was in junior high I was kind of a smart ass, smart mouth,
- 31:36snarky kid, and the truth is that I should have had my ass kicked
- 31:41on several occasions. It's the same thing that I do when I'm in a
- 31:48movie theater and I've paid full price for a ticket and somebody fires up a
- 31:55cell phone or won't stop talking during the movie, and when I leave which
- 32:00I am convinced that you sign a social contract when you go to the movies
- 32:06in a public place to follow the rules and don't spoil it. I will
- 32:10get out of my chair. Natalie's horrified. I will get out of my
- 32:14chair and I will go down and I will say, shut off your phone.
- 32:17I've waited for people at the end of the movie. I've been in
- 32:21the lobby and I've said, next time you want to talk for two straight
- 32:27hours, leave and go to the lobby. I did not spend twenty five
- 32:30bucks to listen to the sound of your voice. I will do that usually
- 32:35during the film. I have not yet had my ass kicked. It should
- 32:39have happened. Statistically, I'm a miracle. And that's what my wife says
- 32:46to me. One of these days, you're gonna get your ass whipped.
- 32:52Maybe, But if somebody comes at me, I'm just gonna should I just
- 32:55take off my pants. Nobody wants to fight somebody who tacks off their pants.
- 33:02I just heard that from I forget the name of the comedian. If
- 33:07anybody knows, put it in the put it in the comments. I've got
- 33:12seven to eight five. Who's this? Amos amos appreciate you. What's on
- 33:17your mind? Yes, I have this slightly a bit of I guess a
- 33:21traumatic event. Okay, it's not really slight. It's actually quite a traumatic
- 33:24event from my childhood. And I know that you're not like a psychologist or
- 33:28a therapist or anything, but there is one aspect of it I think you
- 33:30might be able to advise on. Growing up, I was Apostolic Pentecostal,
- 33:36and we had these family devotionals every night where I would play the piano and
- 33:40we would sing and my dad would reach from the Bible. And I got
- 33:45into a car accident and broke my leg at the age of eight, was
- 33:49in traction for three weeks. And when I came out of traction and was
- 33:53in a cast, my dad had been replacing my piano, playing with some
- 33:59other guide he had met, and he was coming to a long haired hippie
- 34:04guy who had like this truck and was a camper on it, and he
- 34:07would come by and he would play the guitar while he did the family devotionals.
- 34:10Well, I was back to playing the piano and we we did this
- 34:14for three or four nights, and then one night I woke up to the
- 34:20sound of my mom screaming, and she was screaming my name and not my
- 34:27dad's. She was screaming my name, and my dad was standing at the
- 34:30door just told me just stay there, just don't do anything. And we
- 34:37never saw that guy again because it took me up until several years to realize
- 34:42that what was happening was that man was raping my mother, and it just
- 34:47bothered me all the way to the day. I'm forty two years old now
- 34:51and it's still bothering me to this day, and I've talked with therapist about
- 34:55it and all that stuff because I can't see the get closure. I talked
- 34:59to my dad when I was I don't return twenty. I was about twenty
- 35:02years old when I brought it up again, and he denied that it had
- 35:06ever happened. My dad, to this day is a diehard Christian man and
- 35:10still tries to pray for me till it. Still tries to, you know,
- 35:15hopes that I'll open my eyes one day, but I can't seem to
- 35:20get closure from it. I don't know how to approach my dad, and
- 35:22I know that the best way to do this is not to come up to
- 35:25him and say, well, you're a Christian and throw that in his face.
- 35:29Why can't you admit to this? So that's the part I was hoping
- 35:32for advice from you. How would you get closure from your Apostolic, Pentecostal,
- 35:37diehard Christian father. But I wouldn't want to throw something in his face.
- 35:44You know. I've had conversations with psychologists and I've brought up the word
- 35:50closure, and the psychologist that I've been in dialogue with are not fans of
- 35:55that word, because in many ways, you don't get closure. I don't
- 36:00think there is closure with the knowledge that your mother was raped. I don't
- 36:05think that you necessarily even want to get past it. As far as the
- 36:10outrage that you feel and the fact that you see your father in a specific
- 36:15way, a very honest way, a very raw way. Sometimes I think
- 36:21we punish ourselves because while I haven't gotten past it, I don't have closure
- 36:25with the capital see that may be unrealistic. I'm not even sure it isn't.
- 36:30Maladaptive outrage is the appropriate response. I try to look at this from
- 36:37all perspectives, and I have not looked at it from that perspective before.
- 36:42I think you really didn't just help me. I never considered that closure might
- 36:45not Oh my goodness, well again you said it. I'm not the psychologist,
- 36:51but most of this stuff doesn't fit in a box, and there's this
- 36:54desire that we have to draw hard lines. I reached this moment in my
- 37:00life and it was done, and I had dealt with it, and it
- 37:06was complete. It is finished, you know, and I plant my flag
- 37:08and I move on. But I'm not convinced that life works like that.
- 37:14I'm not convinced that closure is, at least in the context that you mean,
- 37:20is a thing. I certainly not sure it's something that you should punish
- 37:23yourself for not attaining. Now that you put it that way, it kind
- 37:28of makes me realize maybe it wasn't really closure, but a desire to hold
- 37:32my dad accountable for not intervening when that man was doing that to my mother,
- 37:37which is a whole different right, because that has to do with him.
- 37:43Where closure you're speaking about closure in relation to you, but holding accountable
- 37:49that has more to do with him, you know. I think you may
- 37:52have to reframe your father in terms of who he is, what he has
- 37:57done, and if there's no intents or accountability or repentance for lack of a
- 38:02better word. You know that just is what it is. I wouldn't carry
- 38:07that on your shoulders. That's a burden you don't need. You are correct,
- 38:12and you've you opened. That's why I called you, because you're really
- 38:15good at opening people's minds a bit more, even when I didn't realize it
- 38:19was closed. Let's phrase it this way. I'm adding a perspective. I
- 38:22just threw another tool in the toolbox. You can take it, leave it.
- 38:25It may or may not even be a good Okay, all right,
- 38:29Well, is just a perspective. I really am desperate. These are such
- 38:35heavy, critical issues. I can't help but think that you might benefit by
- 38:40talking to somebody who is trained in this field, who really can speak professionally
- 38:45about you know, sexual assault, trauma to family, what it does to
- 38:51your mind and heart, and what you feel your responsibilities are moving forward.
- 38:55You know, that's a conversation I think you should pursue with somebody who is
- 39:00pedigreed, credentialed, and legit. Okay, thank you very much, sir,
- 39:05Thanks amos, you're good brother. We'll see him, all right.
- 39:09How often do we look at people and say I wish they would take responsibility
- 39:15I feel like if I wish to say this, maybe they'd see the light.
- 39:20I just want to hear them say the words I did it and I'm
- 39:23sorry. I hate the fact that they have success in their life, wearing
- 39:30a mask, living a facade, living a life when most people have no
- 39:34idea what they're really capable of. I get that, But how much responsibility
- 39:42can we take for the deeds that other people do or do not do.
- 39:46We might be able to sound the alarm to other people and say warning,
- 39:51danger, be careful, keep your eyes open, do some digging, right,
- 39:54background check Hello. There are many of us out here who have and
- 40:00legitimate concerns. I think that is important for the safety of other people.
- 40:05Right, If you've got someone who's done sexual assault in this context, they
- 40:07could be capable of it again, Yeah, I think that's valid as well,
- 40:13right, not libel or slander. But if you have a legitimate concern,
- 40:17I think you can go to some of the people involved and say there
- 40:21are some problems here. You need to be aware of what they are do
- 40:24with this information what you will, I would consider that due diligence, But
- 40:30changing other people who they are sometimes we carry that mantle, and I just
- 40:34think we just can't. It's a burden that we shouldn't have to carry.
- 40:37You know, people at some point are going to have to navigate their own
- 40:42lives and take responsibility for that. I've got area code four two five.
- 40:49Is it misca or misca meetsko a like meets company. Thank you, thank
- 40:54you very much for taking my call. So I'm along a lifetime eats in
- 41:00my thirties now, and I've spent decades studying other religions and philosophies. My
- 41:06idea is that by learning about religions, you actually learn about the cultures and
- 41:09people. I've been meaning to write a book that is to answer specifically Christian
- 41:17flavored questions through a scientific or an easiest point of view, in such that
- 41:23like, if a question is to be asked of a hard, diehard Christian,
- 41:28the only answer they would give is because God. If you can think
- 41:31of some of these questions types why we hear? Or the origin of universe,
- 41:37science, philosophy, stuff like that. So while writing this book,
- 41:43I've written down an outline, and I've collected the questions. I've written answers
- 41:47that are a coal for them, and I wanted to ask as a published
- 41:52author of topics related to atheism religion yourself. How did you approach writing books
- 42:00on the topic. Did you take it as a storytelling or did you want
- 42:02to do it like an essay. Do you have the knowledge to research the
- 42:07information to be able to write on these topics. Yeah, so that I'm
- 42:14pretty versus on a lot of scientific You could say I'm scientifically literates and these
- 42:21it would be questions that are related not just science, but some philosophy.
- 42:25And I'm not going to bite off more than they can shoe an inserting if
- 42:29I had to sum it up in a couple of sentences. And I know
- 42:31most people are not writing a book. I'm not trying to bore you to
- 42:34death here, but I think if you are expressing a personal story, you're
- 42:38taking that kind of personal journey, whether it's yours or somebody else's writing fiction
- 42:43or non fiction. That's more of a kinetic kind of writing. It's more
- 42:46about flow and momentum. Sometimes you're in the zone, you know, and
- 42:50the expressions just come out of you. And sometimes you start the journey and
- 42:53don't even know how it's going to end up. I've written ghost stories for
- 42:58the October podcast I've got a great beginning. I have no idea how it's
- 43:01going to end, and I'll just start writing the beginning and the character does
- 43:07this all of a sudden in my brain. That's great. So I've discovered
- 43:13the character while I'm telling the story. Well, how's it going to end?
- 43:16I don't know. Let's think about that, and then inspiration comes.
- 43:20I'm writing and discovering. But if I'm addressing specific things and sacred cows,
- 43:27we were talking about specific belief traditions, faith traditions, rituals, etc.
- 43:32I laid those out this chapter. This chapter, this chapter. I knew
- 43:37in advance how it would all frame out, and then I was able to
- 43:40go and fill in all the blanks. But I had a template in place.
- 43:45Fox News Christian a great example. I knew I was going to go
- 43:49after the origins of Fox News, and I was going to get into Magot
- 43:52culture and Christian nationalism. And I'd laid it out a template, and then
- 43:57I went back with heavy sourcing, lots of footnotes, lots of data to
- 44:02back up what I was writing about. Two very different kinds of storytelling.
- 44:07But I also think that data needs to be told in story form to be
- 44:14most effective. If you go after someone with a clinical textbook, you have
- 44:20not engaged them. But if you can tell the story of the specifics you're
- 44:25talking about, if you can engage all the senses, that really sucks him
- 44:30in. Sets the hook gets them leaning forward. And two last things,
- 44:36walk away from your work from time to time and then come back to it
- 44:38even days later. Get an objective look at it, and have a third
- 44:44set of eyes. I've got a trusted copy editor, professional in the language
- 44:51who can check me in, double check me. I mean, I'm confident
- 44:53as a storyteller, but I also know that I can always improve and I
- 44:58need an objective eye. And that's what Jessica Vineyard over at Red Letter Editing
- 45:02does for me. I don't know. Does that answer your question? It
- 45:07does. Thank you very much for your insights. Thanks so much for calling.
- 45:09Good luck with the project. Thanks luck. Jasmine at area code seven
- 45:15h four You there, Yeah, I'm here. Can you hear me?
- 45:19I can? What's on your mind? Oh? Yeah, So, my
- 45:22name's Jasmine and I was just calling to thank you for always putting out really
- 45:25entertaining programs. You know, even if the subject matter is dark, it's
- 45:30still a very compelling, and I don't know. I'm not very good with
- 45:34words, so I don't know, I don't have the right words. But
- 45:37yeah, yeah, it's always very good, very good stuff. I've been
- 45:40listening to you for maybe ten years at this point. I'll be thirty this
- 45:45year, and I started listening to you when I was like nineteen. Maybe
- 45:46I'm feeling that minute, Jasmine, I'm feeling old, you know, But
- 45:52I used to get what I used to get an FM radio is. I
- 45:54listened to you when I was a kid, and I'm always like, oh,
- 45:58oh my heart. You know, hey, it's not easy to come
- 46:02up with fresh content all the time, on the order of six hundred fifty
- 46:07plus shows, and knowing that there were so many options out there, and
- 46:10to hear someone say that the content still relates to me and I still enjoy
- 46:15it and it's still entertaining. That is a tremendous gift to me. To
- 46:21have someone notice that is hugely gratifying. Jasmine. That's so so sweet of
- 46:28you to say, so thank you. Oh you're very welcome. I'm glad
- 46:30I was able to make you feel a little a little good today. It's
- 46:34lovely. Yeah, just figure that I'm off work today and didn't have anything
- 46:37else to do. Something you enjoy your day. Go eat an Oreo cookie.
- 46:44You I have a wonderful day. To be safe. We'll see you
- 46:49later, okay, all right, all right? Thanks? Oh look,
- 46:53as I bring the show full circle, someone has sent me a couple of
- 46:59poems about Oreo cookies. By the way, they're getting one hello and advertisement
- 47:04on the show. You're welcome, Aria, Yeah, you're welcome. Let's
- 47:09see the Oreo life is like an Oreo cookie, past, present, future.
- 47:15The best part is in the middle. M That's profound cookie philosophy.
- 47:27Another one, Oreo cookies dunked in milk is greater than the finest of silk.
- 47:35Here's one called ode to an Oreo round. Tasty disc of rich,
- 47:39dark chocolate, bliss, creamy, filling, warm, and buttery, come
- 47:44to my lips. Another moment I won't miss. Free for me? How
- 47:49happy I would be? Some are smothered in milky chocolate, creamy white or
- 47:54lighter brown. Give me some for I can't wait. In that taste,
- 48:00I'd gladly drown. Oh, I can think of worse ways to go death.
- 48:12Buy chocolates and creamy feeling all right, I'm done. Thanks for indulging
- 48:16me. I'll see you back here next time. Take care. Follow the
- 48:20Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 48:25products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist
- 48:30pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log
- 48:36onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.