Latest / Under Review: The Verification Project / James vs. Paul: Contradiction or Common Ground? | Under Review — Part 3 of 3
Transcript
- 0:11SPEAKER_00: Welcome back everyone.
- 0:12SPEAKER_00: This is Cody Clark, host and creator of Under Review, the Verification Project.
- 0:18SPEAKER_00: Today's episode is three of three Paul and Jesus Under Review.
- 0:24SPEAKER_00: And today on episode 7, part 303, we're going to start off with Paul versus the people who knew Jesus.
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: However, before we get into it again, we're going to recap what our hypothesis is and what we're working to figure out.
- 0:41SPEAKER_00: The hypothesis that we're putting under review is did Paul materially transform the religion taught by Jesus, shifting its center from Jesus, proclamation of the kingdom of God, toward a religion that was centered upon Jesus Himself, particularly his death, resurrection, and saving significance.
- 1:03SPEAKER_00: Again, I'll reiterate that.
- 1:04SPEAKER_00: Again, the hypothesis is essentially what we're saying, what we think happened, and we want to prove ourselves wrong.
- 1:10SPEAKER_00: So we're trying to go through and identify places that we can poke holes in the hypothesis and validate are we wrong or are we right?
- 1:18SPEAKER_00: And again, that hypothesis, one more time, is Paul materially transformed the religion taught by Jesus, shifting its center from Jesus, proclamation of the kingdom of God, toward a religion centered upon Jesus Himself, particularly his Jesus death, resurrection, and then saving grace, uh saving significance.
- 1:39SPEAKER_00: Alright, Paul versus the people who knew Jesus.
- 1:43SPEAKER_00: We ended with a pretty extraordinary fact.
- 1:46SPEAKER_00: Paul wasn't one of Jesus' original disciples.
- 1:48SPEAKER_00: He didn't follow Jesus through Galilee, he wasn't one of the twelve.
- 1:52SPEAKER_00: In fact, Paul tells us something considerably more uncomfortable, that he persecuted the Jesus movement.
- 2:00SPEAKER_00: Galatians says, For you have heard of my way of living in time past and the Jews' religion, how that beyond measure I persecuted the assembly of God and ravaged it.
- 2:15SPEAKER_00: Then something changes here, because Paul becomes convinced that God has revealed Jesus to him, and Paul begins preaching the person whose followers he had previously persecuted.
- 2:27SPEAKER_00: But here's our verification question.
- 2:29SPEAKER_00: Who authorized Paul to reinterpret Jesus?
- 2:33SPEAKER_00: Because if Paul is about to fundamentally transform Jesus' movement, we'd really like to know what the people who actually knew Jesus thought about him.
- 2:43SPEAKER_00: Fortunately, Paul tells us.
- 2:46SPEAKER_00: So Paul meets Peter and James, and Paul writes, Then after three years I went up to Jerusalem to visit Peter and stayed with him fifteen days, but of the other apostles I saw no one except James, the Lord's brother.
- 2:59SPEAKER_00: Galatians 1 verses 18 through 19.
- 3:03SPEAKER_00: So we're going to stop there because this is enormously important historically.
- 3:08SPEAKER_00: Paul personally knows Peter, and Paul personally knows James, the brother of Jesus.
- 3:15SPEAKER_00: I'm sure there's a lot of listeners out there who were not really aware that Jesus had brothers and sisters, but surprise.
- 3:23SPEAKER_00: Whatever else we say about Paul, he's not operating inside an entirely isolated religious ecosystem.
- 3:30SPEAKER_00: Think about what 15 days with Peter means.
- 3:33SPEAKER_00: We don't know what they discussed.
- 3:35SPEAKER_00: Paul doesn't give us any media minutes, so we shouldn't invent conversations.
- 3:40SPEAKER_00: But the idea that Paul developed his entire understanding of Jesus without meaningfully contact, uh without meaningful contact with the people who knew Jesus becomes increasingly difficult to maintain here.
- 3:52SPEAKER_00: Paul knew Peter, Paul knew James, and later he describes James and Peter and John as quote unquote those who are reputed to be pillars.
- 4:03SPEAKER_00: Galatians two verse nine.
- 4:06SPEAKER_00: So what happened when Paul's gospel was presented to them?
- 4:10SPEAKER_00: Paul says he returned to Jerusalem fourteen years later and laid before the leadership the gospel he was preaching among the Gentiles.
- 4:19SPEAKER_00: And then he tells us in Galatians two nine, when they perceived the grace that was given to me, James and Cephas and John gave to me and Barnabas the right hand of fellowship.
- 4:33SPEAKER_00: That's very difficult evidence for the strongest version of our hypothesis.
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: If Paul had invented a completely different religion, the people Paul identifies as leaders of the original Jerusalem movement apparently didn't simply throw them out.
- 4:48SPEAKER_00: According to Paul's own testimony, they recognized his Gentile mission.
- 4:53SPEAKER_00: But we don't want to overstate this because what happens next is a little bit messy or maybe a lot of it messy.
- 5:00SPEAKER_00: Galatians chapter two verse eleven But when Peter came to Antioch, I resisted him to his face because he stood condemned.
- 5:09SPEAKER_00: That's not exactly the harmonious stained glass version of early Christianity that many people envision.
- 5:16SPEAKER_00: Paul says Peter had been eating with Gentile believers, then people associated with James arrived, Peter withdrew, other Jewish believers followed, even Barnabas joined them, and Paul explodes.
- 5:29SPEAKER_00: Paul's complaint was essentially if Jewish and Gentile followers of Jesus are not or are one community, then why are you behaving as though Gentiles are religiously contaminated unless they live like Jews?
- 5:42SPEAKER_00: Paul says he confronted Peter publicly, and this matters because sometimes Christianity imagines the apostolic church as though everyone received a perfectly completed theological handbook on Easter morning.
- 5:57SPEAKER_00: And that's not what our earliest evidence looks like.
- 6:00SPEAKER_00: They're figuring things out, they're disagreeing, they're negotiating what Jesus' significance means in circumstances, Jesus' earthly ministry never directly confronted.
- 6:11SPEAKER_00: Most importantly, what happens when thousands of Gentiles begin worshiping Israel's Messiah?
- 6:18SPEAKER_00: Acts also describes a major Jerusalem meeting concerning Gentiles.
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: Acts 15 portrays apostles and elders debating whether Gentile believers need circumcision and observance of the law of Moses.
- 6:32SPEAKER_00: Peter argues against placing that burden upon Gentiles.
- 6:36SPEAKER_00: James gives a judgment, and the council sends requirements to Gentile believers without demanding full conversion to Judaism.
- 6:44SPEAKER_00: Now that sounds remarkably compatible with Paul's ultimate position, but there's a methodological methodological issue here.
- 6:52SPEAKER_00: Acts was written later than Paul's letters, and Galatians is Paul's own testimony.
- 6:58SPEAKER_00: The accounts can potentially be reconciled in several ways, but scholars debate exactly how the visits and events correspond.
- 7:05SPEAKER_00: So we shouldn't simply use Acts to smooth away everything uncomfortable in Galatians.
- 7:10SPEAKER_00: Historically, Galatians gives us something extraordinarily valuable.
- 7:14SPEAKER_00: Paul tells us himself that there was a real conflict inside the earliest Jesus movement.
- 7:21SPEAKER_00: What happens to our hypothesis?
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: Something interesting here.
- 7:25SPEAKER_00: The proposition Paul independently invented Christianity without meaningful connection to Jesus' original followers, has become substantially weaker.
- 7:35SPEAKER_00: Paul knew Peter, Paul knew James.
- 7:38SPEAKER_00: Paul met Jerusalem leadership, and according to Paul, they recognized his mission.
- 7:44SPEAKER_00: But Paul developed controversial conclusion about what Jesus meant for Gentiles.
- 7:50SPEAKER_00: That that statement there looks considerably stronger than before.
- 7:54SPEAKER_00: The dispute wasn't necessarily Jesus versus Paul.
- 7:58SPEAKER_00: It may have been at one point, but it also may have been what does Jesus mean now that Gentiles are entering this Jewish messianic movement?
- 8:09SPEAKER_00: That distinction matters enormously.
- 8:13SPEAKER_00: Did Paul turn Jesus into God?
- 8:15SPEAKER_00: Good question.
- 8:16SPEAKER_00: Now reach now we're going to reach one of the biggest claims in the entire debate here, and you've probably heard some version of this.
- 8:23SPEAKER_00: Jesus never claimed to be God.
- 8:26SPEAKER_00: Paul turned him into God.
- 8:28SPEAKER_00: If that's true, Paul didn't merely develop Jesus' teachings, he fundamentally changed the identity of the person at the center of the movement.
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: So let's test that out.
- 8:39SPEAKER_00: Paul's letters contain an extraordinarily elevated view of Jesus.
- 8:44SPEAKER_00: Philippians says, have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus, who, existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped.
- 8:55SPEAKER_00: Then Jesus empties himself, takes the form of a servant, becomes obedient to death, and then therefore God also highly exalted him and gave to him the name which is above every name, and ultimately that the name of Jesus every knee should bow.
- 9:13SPEAKER_00: That's Philippians chapter two verses five through ten.
- 9:17SPEAKER_00: This is what we call high Christology.
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: Jesus occupies an astonishing position, and Paul is writing this in the first century only decades after Jesus' death.
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: But now comes the critical question.
- 9:31SPEAKER_00: Did Paul write this material?
- 9:33SPEAKER_00: Or is Paul quoting something Christian was Paul quoting something Christians were already saying?
- 9:40SPEAKER_00: Philippians chapter two verses six through eleven often described as a hymn or a poetic passage.
- 9:47SPEAKER_00: Many scholars have argued that Paul is incorporating earlier Christian material here.
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: Others argue Paul himself may have composed it.
- 9:55SPEAKER_00: There's no manuscript sitting in a museum labeled Christian hymn written before Paul forty CE.
- 10:02SPEAKER_00: So we can't pretend the prepauline hypothesis is proven.
- 10:06SPEAKER_00: But here's what matters.
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: Even scholars who are questioning whether this is literally or pre-Pauline hymn recognizes that the Christology expressed here actually belongs extraordinarily early in Christian history.
- 10:19SPEAKER_00: And if Paul did inherit it, then the claim that Paul invented and exalted Jesus takes another serious hit, because Christians were apparently speaking about Jesus in astonishingly elevated terms before Paul put those words into Philippians.
- 10:36SPEAKER_00: And there's another detail.
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: In Philippians it says, Every knee will bow.
- 10:41SPEAKER_00: That language echoes Isaiah forty five.
- 10:43SPEAKER_00: And in Isaiah, the speaker is Israel's God.
- 10:46SPEAKER_00: Quote unquote, look to me and be saved, all the ends of the earth, for I am God and there is no other.
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: And then it says, To me, every knee will bow, every tongue will take an oath.
- 10:59SPEAKER_00: Isaiah chapter forty-five, verses twenty-two through twenty-three.
- 11:03SPEAKER_00: Paul applies that language within a passage centered upon Jesus, and that's pretty big, because whatever precise metaphysical framework Paul has in his mind, Jesus isn't merely a really important rabbi.
- 11:16SPEAKER_00: Paul places Jesus inside language associated with Israel's God.
- 11:22SPEAKER_00: Now, we have to equally be careful on the other side of this, because if we read John's Gospel, Jesus makes extraordinarily elevated statements where he says, I and the Father are one.
- 11:34SPEAKER_00: Before Abraham was born, I am.
- 11:37SPEAKER_00: But John is generally considered our latest canonical gospel.
- 11:41SPEAKER_00: So if we're investigating historical development, we shouldn't simply take John's most explicit Christological statements and automatically project them backward without analysis.
- 11:54SPEAKER_00: The synoptic traditions are more complicated than that.
- 11:57SPEAKER_00: Jesus forgives sins, claims authority over Sabbath, speaks as the Son of Man, he acts with extraordinary authority, he associates people's response to himself with final judgment, and tells followers to leave everything and follow him.
- 12:13SPEAKER_00: Those are quite significant.
- 12:15SPEAKER_00: But Jesus doesn't walk through Galilee delivering the Nicene Creed, that would be historically absurd.
- 12:22SPEAKER_00: So there's a genuine theological development between Jesus' ministry and Paul's letters.
- 12:28SPEAKER_00: And the question that belongs here is how early does the development begin?
- 12:33SPEAKER_00: And now we're going to reach what may be the single most damaging piece of evidence against the claim that Paul invented resurrection-centered Christianity.
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: Remember Corinthians chapter or 1 Corinthians chapter 15, where Paul wrote, For I derive to you first of all that which I also received.
- 12:53SPEAKER_00: Stop there, because those words matter.
- 12:56SPEAKER_00: Paul isn't presenting what followers as something excuse me, Paul isn't presenting what follows as something he personally invented.
- 13:05SPEAKER_00: He says he received it.
- 13:07SPEAKER_00: Then in first Corinthians chapter fifteen, verses three through five, that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised, and on the third day according to scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve.
- 13:23SPEAKER_00: End scripture.
- 13:25SPEAKER_00: Then Paul lists further appearances, and eventually, quote unquote, and last of all, he appeared to me also.
- 13:32SPEAKER_00: Paul places himself at the end of the appearance tradition.
- 13:36SPEAKER_00: Peter is already there, the twelve are already there, others are already there, and Paul comes in later.
- 13:41SPEAKER_00: And there's a reason why this matters, because scholars widely recognize that Paul's passing along the earlier tradition here.
- 13:49SPEAKER_00: Exactly how early the formulation took shape, that's debatable.
- 13:53SPEAKER_00: But it clearly precedes First Corinthians itself.
- 13:57SPEAKER_00: And Paul explicitly distinguishes between receiving the tradition and subsequently passing it on.
- 14:03SPEAKER_00: And this creates an enormous problem for the Paul invented the resurrection centered gospel.
- 14:08SPEAKER_00: Because no.
- 14:09SPEAKER_00: Paul himself tells us he inherited it.
- 14:12SPEAKER_00: No.
- 14:13SPEAKER_00: Does that prove Jesus physically rose from the dead?
- 14:16SPEAKER_00: That's a totally different historical and theological question.
- 14:20SPEAKER_00: The text proves that Paul's claims resurrection appearance and transmits a tradition that he says he received whether the resurrection really occurred is a separate investigation, and we don't want to confuse, quote unquote, early Christians believed X with quote, X therefore historically happened.
- 14:38SPEAKER_00: Those are different propositions, but for today's hypothesis, the first proposition is more than enough.
- 14:45SPEAKER_00: Belief in Jesus' death, resurrection, and appearance predates Paul for his formulation of 1 Corinthians.
- 14:53SPEAKER_00: So Paul cannot easily be the inventor of something he says he received from others.
- 14:59SPEAKER_00: So here's our first major falsification.
- 15:02SPEAKER_00: We're going to actually do what this show promises.
- 15:05SPEAKER_00: Let's try and kill our hypothesis right here.
- 15:08SPEAKER_00: Our strong version said Paul took a Jewish teacher and invented a religion centered upon that teacher's death and resurrection.
- 15:16SPEAKER_00: Our evidence is now fighting us here, because Paul's resurrection tradition came before him.
- 15:23SPEAKER_00: Again, just to reiterate, Paul knows Peter, Paul knows James.
- 15:27SPEAKER_00: Paul says Jesus appeared to Peter before appearing to him.
- 15:31SPEAKER_00: Paul identifies traditions he received, and Paul says Jerusalem leadership recognized his mission.
- 15:37SPEAKER_00: So if our hypothesis is Paul invented Christianity from scratch, it's in serious trouble.
- 15:43SPEAKER_00: Possibly fatal trouble.
- 15:46SPEAKER_00: But our narrower hypothesis survives still, because Paul materially developed the theological meaning of Jesus for a Gentile world, it's still very much alive.
- 15:57SPEAKER_00: Now let's return to something we mentioned a bit earlier.
- 16:00SPEAKER_00: Paul rarely narrates Jesus' life.
- 16:03SPEAKER_00: And why is that?
- 16:05SPEAKER_00: There are several possibilities here.
- 16:08SPEAKER_00: Maybe Paul didn't know much.
- 16:10SPEAKER_00: Maybe Paul's audiences already knew Jesus' traditions, making repetition unnecessary, borderline abrasive.
- 16:17SPEAKER_00: Maybe Paul's letters address specific community problems rather than attempting to write biographies.
- 16:23SPEAKER_00: Or maybe Paul's theological interest genuinely focuses overwhelmingly upon the crucified and risen Christ rather than Jesus' earthly ministry.
- 16:34SPEAKER_00: We can't simply choose whichever explanation helps our argument.
- 16:38SPEAKER_00: You could, but we don't do that.
- 16:39SPEAKER_00: But we can ask, what does Paul demonstrably know?
- 16:44SPEAKER_00: The Book of Romans describes Jesus as born of the offspring of David according to the flesh.
- 16:51SPEAKER_00: Romans chapter 1, verse 3, and then Galatians chapter 4, verse 4 says, God sent out his son born to a woman, born under the law.
- 17:01SPEAKER_00: So Paul understands Jesus as embedded within Israel.
- 17:05SPEAKER_00: First Corinthians refers to the brothers of the Lord, 1 Corinthians chapter 9, verse 5.
- 17:11SPEAKER_00: And Galatian explicitly identifies James, the Lord's brother in Galatians 1, verse 19.
- 17:18SPEAKER_00: So Paul's Jesus isn't merely a celestial being with no earthly family.
- 17:22SPEAKER_00: He's got parents, he's got siblings.
- 17:25SPEAKER_00: In 1 Corinthians chapter 7, Paul discusses divorce.
- 17:30SPEAKER_00: Then he makes an unusual distinction.
- 17:32SPEAKER_00: But to the married I command, not I, but the Lord, that the wife not leave her husband.
- 17:50SPEAKER_00: Paul appears capable of distinguishing between a teaching he attributes to Jesus and his own apostolytic judgment addressing a new situation.
- 17:59SPEAKER_00: And that's evidence that Paul knows at least some of Jesus' traditions.
- 18:04SPEAKER_00: And more importantly, he doesn't simply pretend every opinion he has came directly from Jesus.
- 18:11SPEAKER_00: Jesus taught about supporting missionaries.
- 18:14SPEAKER_00: First Corinthians 9 says, Even so the Lord ordained that those who proclaim the good news should live from the good news.
- 18:23SPEAKER_00: First Corinthians 14.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: Again, Paul appears to a teaching quote unquote of the Lord.
- 18:29SPEAKER_00: Compare that with gospel traditions about workers deserving support and another connection The Last Supper.
- 18:37SPEAKER_00: In first Corinthians chapter eleven, Paul says, For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, and recounts Jesus taking bread, this is my body which is for you.
- 18:48SPEAKER_00: Do this in memory of me.
- 18:51SPEAKER_00: Then the cup.
- 18:56SPEAKER_00: Whatever precisely the um from the Lord meant here, direct relevation, tradition ultimately traced to Jesus or Paul's formulation of an inherited material.
- 19:07SPEAKER_00: Paul knows a Last Supper tradition remarkably similar to what appears in the synoptic gospels, Matthew, Mark, and Luke.
- 19:14SPEAKER_00: And remember, 1 Corinthians predates the written gospel in their surviving forms, and that is historically important.
- 19:22SPEAKER_00: Scholars have also identified possible echoes between Paul's ethical teaching and sayings attributed to Jesus, like love your enemies, bless the persecutors, don't repay evil for evil, leave vengeance to God.
- 19:36SPEAKER_00: And Paul writes in Romans twelve, bless those who persecute you, bless and don't curse, and then repay no one evil for evil, and don't be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.
- 19:49SPEAKER_00: That's Romans chapter twelve, verse fourteen, verses seventeen and twenty-one.
- 19:54SPEAKER_00: But compare Jesus' teachings about enemies and retaliation in the gospel tradition.
- 19:59SPEAKER_00: Is Paul directly quoting Jesus?
- 20:02SPEAKER_00: He doesn't say so, and we shouldn't pretend that he does.
- 20:05SPEAKER_00: But the ethical resemblance is noteworthy.
- 20:08SPEAKER_00: So why does Paul say so little about Jesus' life?
- 20:13SPEAKER_00: Good question.
- 20:14SPEAKER_00: We're left with a generally interesting historical question about that, because Paul knows Jesus' traditions, he knows Jesus' family, he knows Peter and he knows James, he knows teachings that were attributed to Jesus, he knows Last Supper tradition, he knows crucifixion tradition, he knows resurrection tradition, yet he rarely tells stories about Jesus' ministry.
- 20:38SPEAKER_00: That suggests that Paul's silence cannot simply be translated.
- 20:42SPEAKER_00: Paul knew nothing about Jesus.
- 20:46SPEAKER_00: But neither should we present Paul sounds like the gospel writers because he doesn't.
- 20:52SPEAKER_00: Paul's center of gravity is completely different than the actual gospel writers were.
- 20:57SPEAKER_00: And that's really important for our hypothesis.
- 21:00SPEAKER_00: A verification checkpoint.
- 21:02SPEAKER_00: What has survived so far?
- 21:04SPEAKER_00: We're gonna stop the audit and review this um hypothesis.
- 21:08SPEAKER_00: Our claim Paul invented Jesus' resurrection.
- 21:12SPEAKER_00: The evidence strongly pushes against that.
- 21:14SPEAKER_00: Paul explicitly says he received the resurrection tradition.
- 21:18SPEAKER_00: The claim Paul had no meaningful connection to people who knew Jesus.
- 21:23SPEAKER_00: That fails because Paul knew Peter and James, Jesus' brother.
- 21:28SPEAKER_00: Claim Paul knew nothing about Jesus' teaching.
- 21:31SPEAKER_00: That's a bit too strong.
- 21:33SPEAKER_00: Paul explicitly appeals to teachings of the Lord and preserves last supper tradition so he absolutely knows about Jesus' teaching.
- 21:42SPEAKER_00: Claim Paul invented the idea that Jesus was extraordinarily exalted.
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: Much harder to establish than it initially appeared, Philippians 2 reflects extremely early high Christology, whether composed by Paul or incorporated from existing traditions, we don't know.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: Um So yeah, we can't really say one way or the other.
- 22:02SPEAKER_00: But we also need to consider this additional claim.
- 22:04SPEAKER_00: Paul dramatically expands the theological meaning of Jesus.
- 22:08SPEAKER_00: That one is still going to hold up pretty well because Paul constructs arguments about Adam and Christ, justification, participation in Christ, the Spirit, the body of Christ, Jew and Gentile unity, Israel and the nations, death and resurrection, the meaning of the cross.
- 22:25SPEAKER_00: Paul doesn't merely repeat sayings of Jesus, he theologizes Jesus.
- 22:31SPEAKER_00: And perhaps that's the distinction we've been looking for from the beginning.
- 22:35SPEAKER_00: Maybe the historical question isn't, did Paul invent Christianity?
- 22:39SPEAKER_00: Maybe the question should have been, did Paul become Christianity's first theologian?
- 22:45SPEAKER_00: Those aren't remotely the same claim.
- 22:47SPEAKER_00: One would be saying did he invent it?
- 22:49SPEAKER_00: And the other one would be, would he would he be the first theologian of that religion?
- 22:54SPEAKER_00: And before we can answer that, we've got one final test here, and our original hypothesis began with a contrast that Jesus preached the kingdom of God and Paul preached Jesus.
- 23:06SPEAKER_00: So let's go back and see whether that claim actually survives verification.
- 23:10SPEAKER_00: Because Paul talks about the kingdom too.
- 23:12SPEAKER_00: And when he put Jesus and when we put Jesus and Paul back inside their shared expectation that God was about to transform the world, the distance between them may shrink even more.
- 23:24SPEAKER_00: That's we're going to get into next.
- 23:28SPEAKER_00: Did Paul abandon the kingdom?
- 23:32SPEAKER_00: So we're going to return to where the investigation started.
- 23:35SPEAKER_00: Jesus announces in Mark chapter in Mark 1, chapter chapter 1, verse 15, the time is fulfilled and the kingdom of God is at hand.
- 23:45SPEAKER_00: Repent and believe in the good news.
- 23:48SPEAKER_00: Paul announces Christ crucified, Christ risen, justification, salvation, life in Christ, the Spirit.
- 23:56SPEAKER_00: At first glance, that looks like a major transformation.
- 23:59SPEAKER_00: Jesus preached the kingdom, Paul preached Jesus.
- 24:03SPEAKER_00: The observation has appeared in scholarship in different forms for generations.
- 24:08SPEAKER_00: But there's a problem here.
- 24:10SPEAKER_00: Paul talks about the kingdom too.
- 24:13SPEAKER_00: Paul's kingdom, um, and actually Paul warns the Corinthians in 1 Corinthians chapter 6, verse 9, or don't you know that the unrighteous will not inherit God's kingdom?
- 24:25SPEAKER_00: Galatians similarly warns those who practice such things will not inherit God's kingdom.
- 24:30SPEAKER_00: And Paul tells the Corinthians in chapter 15, verse 50, flesh and blood can't inherit God's kingdom.
- 24:37SPEAKER_00: So the kingdom hasn't totally disappeared here.
- 24:40SPEAKER_00: Paul expects it.
- 24:41SPEAKER_00: Paul teaches entrance into it.
- 24:43SPEAKER_00: Paul warns people they can fail to inherit it.
- 24:46SPEAKER_00: Something else has happened.
- 24:48SPEAKER_00: Jesus has moved to the center of Paul's explanation of how God's kingdom arrives until humanity participates in it.
- 24:56SPEAKER_00: That's different from simply replacing the kingdom altogether.
- 25:00SPEAKER_00: And there's another connection that we shouldn't uh shouldn't miss out on here.
- 25:04SPEAKER_00: Both Jesus and Paul operate inside an intensely um eschatological worldview, meaning they believe history is approaching some decisive intervention by God.
- 25:20SPEAKER_00: Jesus announces that God's kingdom has drawn near.
- 25:23SPEAKER_00: Paul tells the Thessalonians, for the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a shout.
- 25:29SPEAKER_00: First Thessalonians chapter four, verse sixteen.
- 25:31SPEAKER_00: And then Paul says in verse seventeen, then we who are alive, who are left, will be caught up together with them.
- 25:40SPEAKER_00: Notice Paul's language here, we who are alive.
- 25:43SPEAKER_00: Paul appears to consider it entirely possible that Christ's return could occur during his lifetime.
- 25:49SPEAKER_00: First Corinthians contains similar urgency in 1 Corinthians 7, verse 29, the time is short.
- 25:55SPEAKER_00: That matters because sometimes later Christianity makes Jesus and Paul sound like philosophers designing a religion intended to operate unchanged for thousands of years.
- 26:08SPEAKER_00: Historically, both appear to expect God to act soon.
- 26:12SPEAKER_00: Historian Paula Frederickson, I mentioned her earlier, is really useful right now.
- 26:17SPEAKER_00: Her reconstruction places Paul firmly inside Jewish apocalyptic expectation.
- 26:22SPEAKER_00: Paul's Gentile mission isn't necessarily evidence that he believes Judaism has failed and needs replacement.
- 26:29SPEAKER_00: It's actually quite the opposite.
- 26:31SPEAKER_00: Because the arrival of Gentiles worshiping Israel's God can itself function as evidence that Israel's prophetic expectations are reaching fulfillment.
- 26:41SPEAKER_00: Think about what he does or think about what this is going to do to the investigation.
- 26:45SPEAKER_00: Because Paul may not believe he's founding a new religion called Christianity, he may believe he's living at the climax of Israel's story.
- 26:53SPEAKER_00: Israel's Messiah has appeared, God raised him from the dead, the nations are turning toward Israel's God, and the kingdom is approaching.
- 27:02SPEAKER_00: From Paul's perspective, the clock is almost at midnight.
- 27:06SPEAKER_00: That's profoundly Jewish apocalyptic framework.
- 27:09SPEAKER_00: Jesus says, The kingdom is approaching, prepare yourself.
- 27:13SPEAKER_00: And then Paul says, Christ has been raised, the resurrection has begun, the Messiah will return, prepare yourself.
- 27:21SPEAKER_00: Those aren't identical messages, but they may belong to the same apocalyptic story.
- 27:28SPEAKER_00: For Paul, Jesus' resurrection becomes evidence that the coming age has already begun breaking into the present one.
- 27:36SPEAKER_00: Jesus announces the approaching kingdom.
- 27:39SPEAKER_00: Paul believes something decisive has happened.
- 27:42SPEAKER_00: Between Jesus' proclamation and Paul's mission, Jesus has been crucified, and Paul believes raised.
- 27:49SPEAKER_00: Of course Paul's message changes here.
- 27:51SPEAKER_00: The historical situation has changed, and that's a major challenge to our hypothesis.
- 27:57SPEAKER_00: Did Paul abandon Jesus' kingdom?
- 27:59SPEAKER_00: No.
- 28:00SPEAKER_00: At least that claim is too strong, because kingdom language remains in Paul's letters and books.
- 28:06SPEAKER_00: But did Paul recenter the story around Jesus' death and resurrection?
- 28:10SPEAKER_00: Without a doubt.
- 28:11SPEAKER_00: The question becomes whether that constitutes distortion, or is a theological interpretation of an event that Paul sincerely believes changed history.
- 28:22SPEAKER_00: Historical analysis can establish that development.
- 28:24SPEAKER_00: Theological judgment about whether Paul interpreted Jesus correctly is a different question altogether.
- 28:31SPEAKER_00: We've got to keep that distinction in mind when we talk about this, because we're approaching our conclusion here.
- 28:37SPEAKER_00: What did Paul actually develop?
- 28:40SPEAKER_00: It's a good question.
- 28:41SPEAKER_00: We've spent a lot of time attacking the proposition that Paul invented Christianity, but we shouldn't overcorrect it.
- 28:48SPEAKER_00: Paul's contribution is enormous, and if he didn't invent Christianity, Christianity without Paul would almost certainly look entirely different, and we're going to identify why.
- 28:59SPEAKER_00: Jesus teaches, Paul explains what Jesus means, that's a simplification, but an important one.
- 29:06SPEAKER_00: Paul asks, what does Jesus' death accomplish?
- 29:10SPEAKER_00: What does Jesus' resurrection mean for humanity?
- 29:12SPEAKER_00: How does Jesus relate to Adam?
- 29:15SPEAKER_00: What happens to sin?
- 29:16SPEAKER_00: What happens to death?
- 29:18SPEAKER_00: What happens to Torah?
- 29:19SPEAKER_00: How do Gentiles become members of God's people?
- 29:23SPEAKER_00: What does the Spirit do?
- 29:25SPEAKER_00: What does baptism mean?
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: What does Christian community mean?
- 29:29SPEAKER_00: Jesus doesn't leave us a systemic theology.
- 29:32SPEAKER_00: Paul begins to construct one.
- 29:35SPEAKER_00: And Romans five is a perfect example of Adam and Christ.
- 29:39SPEAKER_00: Paul creates a theological comparison here where Adam introduces sin and death.
- 29:44SPEAKER_00: Christ introduces righteousness and life.
- 29:46SPEAKER_00: And Paul writes in Romans chapter five, verse 19, for as through the one man's disobedience many were made sinners, even so through the obedience of the one, many will be made righteous.
- 30:01SPEAKER_00: That's not simply Paul repeating something Jesus said.
- 30:04SPEAKER_00: That's a theological construction.
- 30:06SPEAKER_00: Paul is interpreting Jesus through Genesis and Israel scriptures.
- 30:11SPEAKER_00: One of Paul's characteristic ideas is participating, quote unquote, in Christ.
- 30:16SPEAKER_00: People die with Christ, rise with Christ, live with Christ, become one body in Christ.
- 30:22SPEAKER_00: Paul isn't simply asking, do you agree with Jesus?
- 30:25SPEAKER_00: He's describing a transformed identity in which Paul believes particip um Paul believes that believers participate somehow in the Messiah's death and resurrection.
- 30:36SPEAKER_00: And that becomes enormously important for later Christian theology.
- 30:41SPEAKER_00: 1 Corinthians says, Now you are the body of Christ and members individually.
- 30:46SPEAKER_00: 1 Corinthians chapter 12, verse 27.
- 30:49SPEAKER_00: That's an extraordinarily metaphor, extraordinary metaphor.
- 30:52SPEAKER_00: The community isn't merely a club devoted to Jesus' teaching.
- 30:56SPEAKER_00: Paul describes believers collectively as quote unquote Christ's body.
- 31:01SPEAKER_00: Again, development, significant development.
- 31:05SPEAKER_00: And then we get into the Gentile inclusion, where perhaps Paul's greatest historical impact is practical rather than abstract.
- 31:13SPEAKER_00: Paul fights relentlessly for Gentiles to enter the Jesus movement without first becoming Jews themselves.
- 31:19SPEAKER_00: No circumcision requirement, no full Torah conversion.
- 31:24SPEAKER_00: That decision has consequences difficult to exaggerate because Christianity eventually becomes overwhelmingly Gentile.
- 31:32SPEAKER_00: And Paul didn't single-handedly cause that transformation.
- 31:35SPEAKER_00: Peter appears connected with Gentile inclusions in Acts.
- 31:38SPEAKER_00: The Jerusalem leadership ultimately recognizes Gentile mission and other missionaries existed.
- 31:45SPEAKER_00: But Paul becomes its most influential surviving theological advocate.
- 31:50SPEAKER_00: And once Gentiles dramatically outnumber Jews, the movement changes, language changes, culture changes, questions change, and eventually the relationship between Christianity and Judaism changes dramatically.
- 32:04SPEAKER_00: And not always peacefully, and often quite tragically.
- 32:09SPEAKER_00: Before given a verdict, we're gonna do something important.
- 32:13SPEAKER_00: Let's make the strongest case we can that Paul really did transform Jesus' religion.
- 32:20SPEAKER_00: No straw man, no easy version, here it is.
- 32:25SPEAKER_00: Jesus was a Jewish teacher operating within Israel.
- 32:29SPEAKER_00: He preached the kingdom of God, he taught Torah, he called people to repentance, he demanded radical ethics, he spoke constantly about wealth, mercy, forgiveness, enemies, justice, and behavior.
- 32:45SPEAKER_00: Paul enters later, Paul rarely quotes any of Jesus' teachings, and Paul tells us almost nothing about Jesus' ministry.
- 32:54SPEAKER_00: Instead, Paul's message centers upon Jesus' crucifixion, his resurrection, his lordship, faith, justification, participation in Christ, and salvation.
- 33:05SPEAKER_00: Paul also fights against requiring Gentiles to undergo circumcision and full Torah observance.
- 33:11SPEAKER_00: His mission becomes overwhelmingly Gentile.
- 33:14SPEAKER_00: His letters eventually become a huge portion of the Christian New Testament, and later Christian theology, especially Western Christianity, becomes deeply shaped by Paul's vocabulary and his arguments.
- 33:28SPEAKER_00: So one could reasonably argue even if Paul didn't invent Christianity, he helped transform a Jewish apocalyptic movement centered upon Jesus' announcement of God's kingdom into a trans ethnic religion centered upon the saving significance of Jesus himself.
- 33:48SPEAKER_00: That's the strongest version of the case.
- 33:51SPEAKER_00: And unlike Paul invented everything, this version deserves serious consideration.
- 33:57SPEAKER_00: But now let's attack it.
- 33:59SPEAKER_00: The first problem resurrection belief predates Paul's formulation of it.
- 34:12SPEAKER_00: He persecuted it.
- 34:13SPEAKER_00: You cannot persecute a movement you haven't invented yet.
- 34:16SPEAKER_00: Third, Paul knew leaders of the movement who knew Jesus.
- 34:21SPEAKER_00: He knew Peter, he knew James, and other Jerusalem leaders, and fourth, Paul's Gentile mission was ultimately recognized by Jerusalem leadership, at least according to Paul's own testimony.
- 34:33SPEAKER_00: Fifth, Paul knows Jesus' traditions, divorce divorce, missionary support, the Last Supper, Jesus' crucifixion, his family, Peter, James, resurrection appearances, and probably ethical traditions resembling teachings preserved in the Gospels.
- 34:50SPEAKER_00: Sixth, Paul still expects God's kingdom, he hasn't replaced it with an unrelated afterlife religion.
- 34:57SPEAKER_00: Seventh, Paul's worldview remains deeply Jewish.
- 35:01SPEAKER_00: Abraham, Adam, Moses, Torah, Israel, prophets, Messiah, resurrection, the nations turning toward Israel's God.
- 35:09SPEAKER_00: These aren't decorations around Paul's theology, they're its architecture.
- 35:14SPEAKER_00: And eighth, Paul believes something happened that Jesus pre-crucifixion teaching obviously could not yet explain retrospectively.
- 35:23SPEAKER_00: Jesus died, and Paul believes rose from the dead.
- 35:27SPEAKER_00: If you genuinely believe that happened, you would reinterpret everything around it as well.
- 35:32SPEAKER_00: The real historical divide here, and perhaps we finally found the mistake in the original question, was maybe the divide in line isn't Jesus versus Paul.
- 35:42SPEAKER_00: Maybe it's Jesus before Easter versus the Jesus movement after Easter.
- 35:47SPEAKER_00: That's a completely different historical question.
- 35:50SPEAKER_00: Because before Jesus' death, Jesus announces God's kingdom after his death, his followers become convinced he has been raised.
- 35:59SPEAKER_00: If that belief exists before Paul, then the transformation from Jesus proclaiming God's kingdom to Christians proclaiming Jesus cannot simply be blamed on Paul.
- 36:10SPEAKER_00: Something changed inside the Jesus movement before Paul became its missionary.
- 36:15SPEAKER_00: Paul then becomes the most influential surviving interpreter of that change.
- 36:20SPEAKER_00: That is much more historically precise.
- 36:24SPEAKER_00: The final part, our verdict, we're going to return to the hypothesis here.
- 36:28SPEAKER_00: Paul materially transformed the religion taught by Jesus, shifting its center from Jesus' proclamation of the kingdom toward a religion centered upon Jesus' death, resurrection, and surviving significance.
- 36:42SPEAKER_00: Excuse me, saving significance.
- 36:44SPEAKER_00: Does it survive?
- 36:46SPEAKER_00: Partially, but it needs significant revision.
- 36:50SPEAKER_00: And another and rather than issue one sweeping verdict, let's separate the claims here.
- 36:56SPEAKER_00: Claim one, Paul invented Christianity.
- 36:59SPEAKER_00: The evidence we've reviewed does not adequately support that claim.
- 37:03SPEAKER_00: A Jesus movement existed before Paul's conversion.
- 37:07SPEAKER_00: Paul persecuted it initially.
- 37:09SPEAKER_00: Belief in Jesus' resurrection predates Paul's surviving writings.
- 37:13SPEAKER_00: Paul says he inherited the traditions, and Paul interacted with Peter, James, and Jerusalem leadership.
- 37:19SPEAKER_00: Whatever Christianity becomes, its foundational movement does not begin with Paul.
- 37:24SPEAKER_00: Claim two, Paul invented belief in the risen or exalted Jesus.
- 37:29SPEAKER_00: Again, the evidence weighs against that formulation.
- 37:32SPEAKER_00: So the resurrection tradition Paul transmits in 1 Corinthians 15 is presented as something received, meaning Peter and others appear in the tradition in the tradition before Paul.
- 37:47SPEAKER_00: In very early Christian material reflects extraordinarily elevated beliefs about Jesus.
- 37:52SPEAKER_00: Exactly how early every element of the later Christology developed remains highly debated, but assigning the entire development to Paul is extremely difficult.
- 38:02SPEAKER_00: Claim three, Paul substantially developed the theological meaning of Jesus.
- 38:08SPEAKER_00: Yes, descriptively the evidence strongly supports substantial development, but be careful with what quote unquote developed means, because it doesn't automatically mean corrupted.
- 38:21SPEAKER_00: Paul constructs extensive theological arguments concerning Christ, Adam, sin, death, resurrection, justification, spirit, Torah, Israel, Gentiles, and participation in Christ.
- 38:34SPEAKER_00: The surviving teachings of Jesus do not contain an equivalent systematic framework.
- 38:41SPEAKER_00: Paul is doing theology about Jesus in a way Jesus' recorded teachings obviously do not.
- 38:48SPEAKER_00: Claim four, Paul helped transform a Jewish Jesus movement into a Gentile Christian movement.
- 38:54SPEAKER_00: Historically, Paul's mission is clearly an important part of that transformation, but Paul alone, but saying Paul alone caused it would go beyond our evidence.
- 39:05SPEAKER_00: Gentile inclusion was larger than Paul.
- 39:08SPEAKER_00: The Jerusalem Church confronted the issue, Peter appears in the tradition, other missionaries also existed in this space as well.
- 39:16SPEAKER_00: And historical developments continued long after Paul's death.
- 39:20SPEAKER_00: Paul is enormously influential though, but he is not the sole architect of it.
- 39:25SPEAKER_00: So what survives our original hypothesis?
- 39:28SPEAKER_00: Something more nuanced.
- 39:30SPEAKER_00: Paul didn't create Christianity from nothing.
- 39:33SPEAKER_00: He inherited a Jewish Jesus movement already proclaiming Jesus' resurrection and exaltic significance.
- 39:40SPEAKER_00: But Paul became one of the movement's most important theological interpreters, and his mission to Gentiles helped accelerate a transformation with enormous historical consequences.
- 39:51SPEAKER_00: So, Paul probably didn't invent Christianity, but Christianity without Paul would almost certainly have developed differently, and those statements can both be true.
- 40:03SPEAKER_00: History can't settle a lot of this.
- 40:07SPEAKER_00: And now that we need the one final boundary on this, the historical investigation that we can ask, what did Jesus probably teach?
- 40:15SPEAKER_00: What did Paul write?
- 40:17SPEAKER_00: Which tradition appears earlier?
- 40:19SPEAKER_00: Who interacted with whom?
- 40:21SPEAKER_00: How did the ideas develop?
- 40:23SPEAKER_00: But history alone cannot finally answer was Paul divinely inspired?
- 40:28SPEAKER_00: Did Jesus commission Paul through a revelation?
- 40:31SPEAKER_00: Did God raise Jesus from the dead?
- 40:33SPEAKER_00: Was Paul's interpretation of Jesus God's intended interpretation?
- 40:37SPEAKER_00: Those are all theological claims.
- 40:40SPEAKER_00: Historians can study the testimony, they can date text, they can compare traditions, they can evaluate explanations, but historical method cannot simply declare divine revelation true or false, using the same method we use to date Galatians.
- 40:55SPEAKER_00: That's where theology, philosophy, and personal beliefs enter the conversation.
- 41:00SPEAKER_00: And under review shouldn't pretend otherwise.
- 41:03SPEAKER_00: So let's conduct one last experiment.
- 41:06SPEAKER_00: Let's remove Paul.
- 41:08SPEAKER_00: Imagine Paul never converts.
- 41:10SPEAKER_00: No Romans, no Galatians, no Corinthians, no Philippians.
- 41:14SPEAKER_00: What remains?
- 41:16SPEAKER_00: Peter, James, the Jerusalem Church, belief that Jesus was Messiah, belief that Jesus had been raised, Jesus traditions, Jewish followers of Jesus, and eventually Gentile questions that somebody would have had to answer.
- 41:30SPEAKER_00: Christianity doesn't disappear, but would it become Christianity we recognize today?
- 41:36SPEAKER_00: That's a lot harder to say.
- 41:38SPEAKER_00: And maybe that's the most interesting conclusion of this entire investigation.
- 41:42SPEAKER_00: The question, did Paul invent Christianity, is probably too crude or too ignorant, if you will.
- 41:49SPEAKER_00: The better question is how much of Christianity's eventual shape exists because Paul became its most influential early theologian and missionary to the Gentiles?
- 42:01SPEAKER_00: And that is a question worth continuing to investigate.
- 42:05SPEAKER_00: Now it's your turn.
- 42:06SPEAKER_00: Don't trust this episode simply because I gave you citations, I gave you scripture, read the material, start with Mark, then read Galatians chapter 1 and 2, read 1 Corinthians 7, 1 Corinthians 11, 1 Corinthians 15, read Romans, read Philippians 2, then ask, does Paul sound like someone inventing a completely different religion?
- 42:27SPEAKER_00: Does he sound like someone who simply is repeating Jesus?
- 42:31SPEAKER_00: Or does the evidence suggest something more complicated?
- 42:35SPEAKER_00: And read scholars who disagree with each other.
- 42:38SPEAKER_00: Read Paul Frederickson, read Jimmy DG John or D.
- 42:42SPEAKER_00: G.
- 42:42SPEAKER_00: Gunn, read EP Sanders, read NT Wright, read scholars who see much greater discontinuity between Jesus and Paul.
- 42:51SPEAKER_00: Don't build your conclusion around one scholar and definitely don't build it around this podcast, because that's the whole purpose of the verification project.
- 43:00SPEAKER_00: We establish a hypothesis, we attack it, we try and prove ourselves wrong, and when the evidence forces us to modify our position, we modify it.
- 43:09SPEAKER_00: That's not losing the argument, that's the process working.
- 43:14SPEAKER_00: We started with did Paul change Christianity?
- 43:18SPEAKER_00: And somehow we ended up with another question.
- 43:20SPEAKER_00: If resurrection belief existed before Paul, if Peter and James were already landing, excuse me, leading communities devoted to Jesus, if Jesus' earliest followers were already trying to understand what his death and resurrection meant, then what did Christianity look like before Paul became Christianity's most influential theologian?
- 43:40SPEAKER_00: Who were those Christians?
- 43:42SPEAKER_00: And what did James believe?
- 43:43SPEAKER_00: What did Peter believe?
- 43:45SPEAKER_00: What did the Jerusalem church practice?
- 43:48SPEAKER_00: What happened to Jewish followers of Jesus after Paul's Gentile churches began expanding?
- 43:53SPEAKER_00: And perhaps most important or interestingly, was there ever one original Christianity at all?
- 44:00SPEAKER_00: And that is something I'm going to let you put under review.
- 44:04SPEAKER_00: Thanks again for joining me.
- 44:06SPEAKER_00: I'm Cody Clark, host and creator of Under Review, the Verification Project.