Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / Psychological Safety: Stop Guessing & Start Measuring To Supercharge Your Culture
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tons more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:47Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So, if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:11Okay then, have you ever bitten your tongue in a meeting knowing something needed to be said but stopping yourself because you didn't feel confident or that it was safe to do so?
- 1:23The possible reprisals of speaking out may not warrant speaking up.
- 1:29If that's happened to you, how many people in your team are also doing that right now and what are the implications of that?
- 1:39I mean, let's face it, workplaces talk about openness and trust and having a speak-up culture but how many of us genuinely feel safe to challenge, question or even admit a mistake without some element of fear, be that looking incompetent, ignorant, negative or you're just that destructive and difficult person in the room.
- 2:03Well, my guest today is Gary Keogh who's doing some frankly brilliant work in the field of psychological safety, helping some very well-known organizations stop guessing and start measuring what really drives high-performing, inclusive and resilient teams and cultures.
- 2:20So today, we're going to explore the real state of psychological safety at work where it's reported that two in five people still don't feel confident enough to speak up and also why many leaders think things are fine in their teams when they're not.
- 2:38We'll break down what psychological safety actually is and isn't, unpack the four domains associated with it and flip the narrative by spotlighting what good looks like instead of just focusing on what goes wrong.
- 2:51I hope you'll hear how some organizations are actively creating environments where feedback isn't feared but welcomed and Gary will also share the results he's seeing from his own powerful breakthrough sessions that help leaders finally connect culture with practical action.
- 3:08So, if you care about trust, team performance and creating a culture where people don't have to wear a mask to work, stick with us.
- 3:18This episode might just make you reassess just how safe and productive your own workplace really is.
- 3:25Gary, welcome to the show, my friend.
- 3:27Thank you very much, Andy.
- 3:28Great to be here.
- 3:29Super to have you, mate.
- 3:31I'm deadly excited to talk to you, not just on this topic in general but some of the specific brilliant work you're doing with clients and the results that you're getting on a topic that I think can at times get an eye roll or a side eye look from people when we mention psychological safety.
- 3:49So, I'm really looking forward to getting into that.
- 3:50Before we do, do me a favour, my friend.
- 3:52Just introduce yourself to the listeners.
- 3:54Tell us a little bit about you, what your background is and how come you've landed in this space about psychological safety.
- 4:02Thanks, Andy.
- 4:02I think this started for me maybe 15 years ago when I worked as a leadership coach myself.
- 4:08He said to me in our first session, he said, Gary, what's your purpose?
- 4:13I have to admit, I didn't really know what he meant.
- 4:16I was scrambling around for an answer and he said, come on, what lights you up?
- 4:19What motivates you?
- 4:20I said, to give my family choices.
- 4:23He went, mate, it's not that.
- 4:26I thought, wow, I thought that was quite a good answer.
- 4:30Anyway, long story short, I worked with him over a number of sessions and I wrote down four words that changed everything for me, unlock and ignite potential.
- 4:38It was a breakthrough moment for me because I realised my purpose was to do that with the brands I worked on, but more importantly, with the people that I worked with, my peers, my stakeholders and critically, my team.
- 4:51I worked in four fantastic companies, two FTSE 100 companies, two family-owned businesses.
- 4:58Unlock and ignite potential got personal because our daughter was diagnosed with dyslexia and we decided, my wife and me, to move three times in four years to get her into schools that specialise in dyslexia.
- 5:11Why?
- 5:12So we could unlock and ignite her potential.
- 5:15Then I went to a leader in the business I worked in, a fabulous organisation called William Grant and said, look, I'd love to train as a coach.
- 5:23I love coaching, mentoring, leadership, but I don't know if I'm any good at any of that.
- 5:26I've never had formal training.
- 5:28She said, what do you need?
- 5:29I said, I'd love to go to Henley and study coaching and behaviour change.
- 5:33So I did a master's there and that's where I specialised in psychological safety.
- 5:37Why?
- 5:38Because if you get it right, you unlock and ignite potential.
- 5:40What a beautiful rounding of that circle, right?
- 5:44As somebody who has struggled with their own purpose years ago, I totally empathise that.
- 5:50But when you find that thing, that core, I guess that anchor point for you, it's an amazing release because everything else falls into place and it's very easy to understand when you're doing things that are aligned to that purpose and feel right and good and useful and all the other stuff that you confused as being important and beneficial on the other side of it.
- 6:15I think it's a wonderful thing.
- 6:16I'm so pleased that I speak to somebody else who's found it and getting to live their best life now as a result of that.
- 6:22Psychological safety.
- 6:24I want you to set the burning platform for us as to why we're talking about this today.
- 6:29I mentioned in the intro that two out of five stat.
- 6:33But for you, why is it such an important thing to talk about right now?
- 6:40And that stat is scary, right?
- 6:42Two in five people on every team not speaking up.
- 6:46Let's be clear what that means.
- 6:47They're not saying anything.
- 6:49They're not being completely quiet, but they are pulling their punches and they are going on with the failing wisdom and maybe not challenging the status quo.
- 6:57And also let's get under the iceberg.
- 7:00There's reasons for it.
- 7:02This two in five people when their alarm clock goes off in the morning, they don't want to look intrusive, so they won't challenge the status quo.
- 7:10They don't get up in the morning to look ignorant, so they don't ask questions.
- 7:14They don't want to look incompetent, so they won't talk about mistakes.
- 7:17So there's some of the things that are getting in their way.
- 7:21And then overlay that other really important thing you mentioned in the intro, 70% of leaders overestimate how safe their teams feel to speak up.
- 7:31And why?
- 7:32Because leaders have rank, they have power, they have access to more data.
- 7:36And because they feel safe speaking up, they project that on their teams.
- 7:40And just think about the irony, Andy, of the leader sitting with their team and saying, do you feel safe to challenge me?
- 7:46What answer do they get?
- 7:48Everyone says, yeah, I feel great challenging you.
- 7:51No problem.
- 7:52And they walk out the room and they say, I've never challenged her on this.
- 7:56I'd never say that to him.
- 7:58Or they put in a WhatsApp group what they really think.
- 8:01So there's a barrier already before we even get anywhere.
- 8:05And you asked, why is it important?
- 8:07Well, if you have people speaking up, you get more diversity of thought.
- 8:11You get better informed decisions.
- 8:14You get greater innovation and creativity.
- 8:17If you don't have it, you have people feeling less engaged, demotivated, and absolutely not bringing their whole selves to work.
- 8:25I think that's so true.
- 8:26For me, it feels like one of the really strong enablers of that high trust, high challenge, high performance organization.
- 8:36The degree to which people feel like they can ask a question or show some vulnerability or disagree with something or have a confrontation allows, I guess, that fostering of trust, which means we can challenge the hell out of things.
- 8:53We can pick things apart, not take it personally, because we feel safe in the environment.
- 8:59It's OK to challenge these things or make a point or give a different opinion in these things.
- 9:05They are setting, I think, the foundations for a high performance culture.
- 9:11Do you agree with that?
- 9:13Yeah, exactly.
- 9:15And to build on what you just said, let's be clear on what psychological safety isn't as well.
- 9:22So it's not guaranteed applause for all your ideas.
- 9:25It's not a pass on the back, Gary, for everything you do all day long.
- 9:29It's not about people being agreeable and nice to each other.
- 9:32In fact, it can be exactly the opposite.
- 9:36And the guru in this space, Amy Evans, talks about creating a candid, energized place to work where people can speak up without fear of appraisal.
- 9:45And that means you get better contributions.
- 9:48And another thing is it's not long-winded conversations.
- 9:52Some people think, well, if we hear from everyone, we're going to be here all day.
- 9:57And a big learning for me was that awful moment when you're the leader of a team.
- 10:03And imagine you're in June, June or July, which we are now.
- 10:06And you're getting to the point where a project isn't going well.
- 10:10And you're six months into it.
- 10:12And you sit down with your team.
- 10:13And you go, yeah, it's not quite happening the way we expected it to do.
- 10:16And somebody on your team turns around and says, yeah, I could have told you that back in January.
- 10:21And I remember years ago, my reaction was, why didn't you bring that up sooner?
- 10:27And now, when I reflect on that, that was the wrong reaction.
- 10:32The right reaction would have been, what environment had I created so that person couldn't have brought that up sooner?
- 10:39I think that is a high-quality leadership paradox.
- 10:44Because I think the initial reaction to that sort of question is often the frustrated, well, why didn't you say?
- 10:50Just expecting that everybody's going to bring everything to you on their own bat.
- 10:56But I think that is an incredibly strong reflective question for leads to ask themselves.
- 11:00Actually, where have I failed here?
- 11:03What have I not provided you for you to feel like, yeah, this isn't going to work.
- 11:08Let me tell you why.
- 11:09You're not going to be seen as a neg ferret.
- 11:11You're not going to be seen as some sort of sod in the room.
- 11:14It's that candid space.
- 11:16I think this is what's fascinating about psychological safety.
- 11:19And maybe it's those two words that sound grandiose or something.
- 11:23I still feel it gets a bit of a bad rap.
- 11:26I think it's sort of like seen as something overly fluffy.
- 11:30I mean, fluffy is a word we use far too much on this podcast.
- 11:32But I think it's anything but that stuff.
- 11:35This is hard, tough stuff that really is about eliciting great performance, great diversity of thought, involvement, engagement, all these great things that if you wrote down the key words you want for a culture, that these are the things that enable that stuff, right?
- 11:51I think I have some sympathy for, I have some frustration and sympathy, right?
- 11:57Frustration that the words are being weaponized or misunderstood, but sympathy for the fact that while the concept has been around since the mid 1960s, the research into it didn't really start until the early 90s.
- 12:10And then there's been a generation of research that has associated and correlated psychological safety to high performance, greater innovation, higher motivation and engagement.
- 12:21But the first mainstream article on psychological safety wasn't until Charles Dunhigg wrote a piece in the New York Times in 2016 about a project that Google did called Project Aristotle, which was about what performance.
- 12:39And they concluded after looking at 180 teams, 250 characteristics, the most important element in the team was psychological safety, being able to speak out without fear of reprisal, without being worried something would be weaponized against you.
- 12:53But imagine if it's been in the mainstream since 2016, that's only nine years, nine, 10 years.
- 12:59And so if people have a skin deep understanding, then they might associate safety with, well, everyone's just going to agree and be nice to each other.
- 13:10And you're right, psychological might be a bit highbrow, potentially.
- 13:15Yeah, I think that's potentially why people kind of don't get it.
- 13:18There's a bit of Dunning-Kruger in there as well.
- 13:20I think you hear the headline and you assume you understand what it means.
- 13:24And therefore you think, I don't need that here.
- 13:26We haven't got time for that.
- 13:27We've got shit to do.
- 13:29And the reality is once you start looking under the skin of this stuff, it's absolutely foundational, fundamental to how teams, effective teams, high performing teams perform.
- 13:39Absolutely.
- 13:41Just so we bring everybody up to speed, Gary, I mentioned in the intro, the four domains associated with psychological safety.
- 13:50Do you want to just bring those to life for us just so we can get everybody understanding what we're really, really talking about here?
- 13:57Yes, exactly.
- 13:58And this is where it's important to point out that the concept is layered.
- 14:03And there are certain things that get in the way.
- 14:07So the four domains of psychological safety, one is willingness to help.
- 14:12And willingness to help is I feel confident that I can go and ask someone for help on my team and that help will be forthcoming.
- 14:19It's just a simple way of expressing that.
- 14:22And sometimes we don't ask for help, right?
- 14:23Because we think we should know the answer, especially if we're a leader.
- 14:27If I ask for help, that could impact my status and people think I look stupid.
- 14:33So willingness to help is one big area.
- 14:36Another area is inclusion.
- 14:38Do people genuinely feel like they belong in the team?
- 14:42Because guess what?
- 14:43When they feel like they belong and they're welcomed and their unique background or culture is accepted and respected, well, then they will speak up more.
- 14:51If they don't, they unlikely will.
- 14:55Another domain is the team's attitude to risk and failure.
- 14:59So how are mistakes handled around here?
- 15:02Do people get blamed for mistakes?
- 15:03Or do we use the insight from mistakes to get better and to learn and improve?
- 15:11And the other area is open conversations, open discussions.
- 15:16Do we genuinely say in meetings what needs to be said?
- 15:20Or are we pulling our punches or going along with the prevailing wisdom?
- 15:24And let me give you an example of that.
- 15:26You will have heard of fight or flight.
- 15:28So Walter Bradford Cannon, 1920s, American psychologist, came up with that based on us hunting for food in prehistoric, in caveman times, hunted by a saber-toothed tiger.
- 15:40The same thing can happen in meetings.
- 15:42You can have a stress response and lash out, which is fight, or you can flight and just withdraw and not say anything.
- 15:49But the other interesting build on that is the term fawn.
- 15:53Have you heard of that term?
- 15:54(Andy Goram: No, go on.
- 15:55Talk to me.)
- 15:56Okay.
- 15:56So fawn is when you just agree.
- 15:59So Andy, you and me are having a conversation in a meeting with the team, and you say, right, I think we should go in this direction.
- 16:06And me thorning is to be submissive and go, yeah, great idea.
- 16:10Let's do that.
- 16:11Well, actually, I don't agree at all.
- 16:13And I'm the person that says six months down the line, I could have said that we should have done that.
- 16:18So fight and flight are really well understood.
- 16:21Fawn is another one.
- 16:21We don't have open conversations.
- 16:23I disagree with you because actually it's easier to do, and there's no risk or cost to me in doing that.
- 16:29And I think that that risk to person shows up in, I guess, what people might commonly understand as things like imposter syndrome and all those different characteristics behind there.
- 16:40These are some things that will make us think twice about standing up, showing out for fear of that looking incompetent or ignorant of all the words we used in the intro.
- 16:52And to me, that's a very sad state of affairs because there's another horrible engagement stat that something like two thirds of the people who work in organization are just present.
- 17:03And when you understand why they're just present and when by present, I mean, they show up, but they don't give you all that they can give you.
- 17:11Another two thirds of the two thirds, which is dangerous stat territory, but feel that way because no one has ever asked them for that opinion.
- 17:22And then behind that, there's that fear of putting it forward.
- 17:25So that whole encouragement, that whole creating an environment that encourages and accepts different ideas and perspectives from other people, you know, that has to play better for us when we're talking about innovation, creativity, teamwork, you know, learning from mistakes.
- 17:43These are all fundamentally important, aren't they?
- 17:47.
- 17:48Massively, and I do think something else you were touching on there, Andy, is how much we get in our own way.
- 17:53And let me explain that with examples.
- 17:56So one breakthrough session I've ran with the team, this whole territory of willingness to help each other, which we can measure that and show where that is in a team in terms of a median score, but also the spread of perception.
- 18:13So the brilliant thing about measuring this is you illuminate how the whole team feels, but you do it anonymously and confidentially so no one knows who's answered it, which is important.
- 18:23But then you just ask a simple question.
- 18:25How does it play out in your team, like asking each other for help, as an example?
- 18:29And in one example, there was a great team, we'd worked together for a while, where one person in the team went forward and said, well, my role's quite technical.
- 18:39So two people in the team of seven understand my role.
- 18:42I can ask them to help, but they travel quite a lot.
- 18:44I can't really ask the other people in the team to help.
- 18:46So the reaction of the other people in the team was, we may not know the specific technicality of your role, but if you're struggling, please, please come and talk to us.
- 18:54And this person just her eyes widened and went, oh wow, I didn't know I could do that.
- 19:00And then the conversation moved on and a gentleman said to the leader in this breakthrough session, well, I know you've recently had a baby.
- 19:10You're not long in your role.
- 19:12I know you've got quite on your plate, so I don't really feel like I can come and ask you for help.
- 19:15And the reaction of the leader to his credit was to say, I know I'm quite introverted.
- 19:20I know that I can be quite head down when I'm working, but please, if you need help, you must come and interrupt me.
- 19:26And I really want to do that.
- 19:28I want you to understand that you can do that.
- 19:30And this gentleman was like, oh, okay, great.
- 19:33And then the third thing that happened was another colleague in the team, the same team, all in the space of a few minutes, gentleman went forward and said, well, I don't think I can ask other people for help because I feel I should know the answer.
- 19:43I feel it will be my own personal failing if I don't know the answer to this.
- 19:47And his whole team went back in their chairs and said, we think so much of you.
- 19:52We respect you so highly.
- 19:53We would never think anything negative about you.
- 19:56And I think sometimes the problem is Andy is we, we think we're mind readers.
- 20:00I think I can't bring this up with Andy now because he'll think I'm this or he'll think I'm that.
- 20:05And we think we're mind readers, but we're not.
- 20:08And all these invisible barriers that exist in teams just come tumbling down and people have conversations that they just haven't had.
- 20:16I think, I mean, we will probably get onto this,
- 20:19I think, when we start thinking about measurement, we make so many assumptions.
- 20:24As humans, we just love an assumption.
- 20:27It's our kind of default position.
- 20:28I reckon I know this what's going on here.
- 20:30I won't bother asking.
- 20:31I'll just plow on with my own gut.
- 20:34And sometimes that's right, but other times it's way, way, way off, but we do cause problems on both sides of the conversation.
- 20:41We definitely get in our own way and certainly get on our own heads, but what are we doing to other people by doing that at the same time?
- 20:47What are we not eliciting?
- 20:48What are we not empowering?
- 20:50What are we not releasing from inside people?
- 20:53This is why I find this topic so fascinating.
- 20:56If I think about what you've already said today.
- 20:58So we've established that psychological safety is about candor, not comfort, right?
- 21:04It's chuck the fluff stuff out the window.
- 21:06This is about saying what needs to be said.
- 21:10We've probably got similar values.
- 21:13One of mine being, I'm a kind person.
- 21:15I'm not a nice person.
- 21:17And that's not meant to sound Machiavellian.
- 21:19That is meant to sound like, I'm going to tell you what I think you need to know because I think it's the kind thing to do.
- 21:27It gives you an opportunity to see it.
- 21:28If it's a work-based thing, it gives you an opportunity to change and grow.
- 21:32Nice people may not tell you because they don't want to hurt your feelings.
- 21:35And I think this is definitely not what this is about.
- 21:37I think there's a danger associated with this silence that's going on around the table, right?
- 21:45We must be missing tricks.
- 21:46We must be missing opportunities.
- 21:48We're probably making some bad decisions.
- 21:51You said in your very first story, well, I could have told you that six months ago.
- 21:56That's six months' time wasted from silence.
- 22:00You know, who's got six months to waste in today's world?
- 22:04It just doesn't happen.
- 22:06And I think the thing that you've started to uncover for me here is, whilst we'll talk about psychological safety from an individual perspective, it has to be about having a collective condition right within a team.
- 22:20It's no good if one person, maybe it's that boss who thinks everybody else is okay, who feels confident and competent and okay to speak up.
- 22:28There may well be people in that team who individually feel confident and competent, but are still fearful of speaking up because of that environment.
- 22:37So it has to cover the collective, doesn't it?
- 22:40Yeah, it's a group phenomenon.
- 22:41You've absolutely hit the nail on the head.
- 22:43And I mean, there'll be people that do say, and I actually agree with them, they'll say you're only as psychologically safe in a team as how the person who has the least psychological safety feels.
- 22:58So you're dead right.
- 22:59This is a phenomenon that exists in a group.
- 23:04And because if you're talking about the difference between trust and psychological safety, trust tends to be a one-to-one phenomenon between two people, whereas psychological safety is how I feel in a group.
- 23:16And the other reason why it sometimes gets a bit complex is no one operates in the same group every day in their working life.
- 23:24They tend to move between different teams.
- 23:27So it might be, let's say their home team that they're on an organogram with, and they'll work in cross-functional teams throughout the course of the day.
- 23:34And that's another thing that happens.
- 23:36Psychological safety is temporal, and it will change in the different groups in which we mix as well.
- 23:43And I want to pick up on a word that you made.
- 23:46You brought up a really important word, comfort.
- 23:49And a recent post I did actually on the difference between nice and kind, which seems to get an awful lot of traction on LinkedIn, was a brilliant leader commented on there about, if you can create a safe environment, then people are more comfortable speaking up and giving people feedback.
- 24:06And actually, Amy Everson interjected and just kind of made us both aware that, you know what, it might never be comfortable being kind to people.
- 24:15It might never be comfortable giving people that feedback that will help them grow.
- 24:18You can still do it with care, but when you're kind to someone and you tell them something you think they need to hear, there is always a risk for you.
- 24:27And she just made that point, which I thought was great, around, do you know what, I took from it, if you wait to be comfortable, you may never say it.
- 24:36I love that.
- 24:37There's a very good old original model, I think it's by Byrne, that the sort of levels of communication, and it has a little triangle in it.
- 24:46And it talks about the levels of communication we go as we give more risk and we get more trust.
- 24:52And it starts at the bottom of all those kind of ritual things like, hey, Gary, how was your morning?
- 24:56Everything okay?
- 24:56Blah, blah, blah, all that kind of small talky stuff.
- 24:59And works through the pyramid up to the top where you're really kind of open and sharing and really getting into some deeper stuff, some deeper understanding.
- 25:08But at each level of that triangle, you are taking a greater personal risk in the payback of getting greater, more sustainable trust.
- 25:17And I think that to me is exactly what you're getting to there.
- 25:21Gosh, I mean, we could talk about so many things with this.
- 25:24What I do really want to get into is not all the negative stuff around this and what isn't happening.
- 25:31I think we've kind of nicely framed what we think it should be and where people need to act.
- 25:37I guess the thing I'd like to start getting to is, where are you seeing in the work you're doing great stuff happening?
- 25:45And I'm also, I don't know whether it will link into this or not, but something you just sort of said about, I'm fine in my team, but it's when I go and work in other teams that I've got a problem.
- 25:55This is, I think, a complex thing for organizations to get their head around.
- 25:59Where's the responsibility?
- 26:00Where's the accountability for creating that kind of matrix safety, if you like?
- 26:06So I think I've just thrown a lot of you in that sort of question, but if we start with that one, where do you think that responsibility lies and what are you seeing?
- 26:13And how does that knock onto where you're seeing organizations really lead on this stuff and make it work for them?
- 26:20I think I can link the two because you're raising a really important point and I'll throw some data as well at you, but essentially when you measure psychological safety, which is very, very simple to do, essentially people in teams break seven questions on a one to seven like that scale from strongly disagree to strongly agree.
- 26:43And you get a really clear report on how people feel across those four domains of psychological safety, which we talked about earlier.
- 26:51You see a roughly 9% drop in psychological safety between someone's home team and when they're in cross-functional teams.
- 27:01Why?
- 27:01Because we don't know people in cross-functional teams as well.
- 27:04We maybe aren't as connected with them and there's different disciplines in terms of maybe marketing, commercial, finance, supply chain, different levels of knowledge in the room as well.
- 27:15So that'll be a simplistic way of describing why that psychological safety fits.
- 27:21Let me link that with an organization that I think is doing things really well because a lot of stories around psychological safety are about disasters, whether that's the airlines and shuttles and they should never, they are really important stories, but there are not enough stories on identifying what happens when things go well.
- 27:40So one organization that I think has psychological safety in their DNA is Netflix because they adopt two simple principles.
- 27:48For every project, every work stream, they appoint an informed captain who must farm for dissent.
- 27:57Now informed captain means, the captain element means you make the call.
- 28:02So it's not the CEO, it's not necessarily the functional head, but you're empowered to make the call because you're the captain.
- 28:08The informed bit means your obligation is to farm for dissent.
- 28:13And what that means is someone comes up with an idea at Netflix and they go to content, they go to programming, they go to technology, they go to marketing, they go to sales, and they say, make this idea better or break this idea.
- 28:26And they are obligated to get the views of other people in the organization.
- 28:31So they're doing that in cross-functional teams, not just within their own work silo in one place.
- 28:38So an example, back in 2013, the prevailing wisdom in programming was to release episodes every week, drive intrigue, make us wait, to be continued, and trailer what's coming next.
- 28:51They released House of Cards, all nine episodes in one weekend in February, and gave control to consumers about when they watched it, how they watched it.
- 29:01That came from their philosophy of one person makes the call, but only after they've been around the organization and gone, what's the pros and cons of this?
- 29:10Help me make and break this idea.
- 29:11So informed captains who farm for dissent, I think it's a great model, it's in their DNA, and it's actually replicable.
- 29:20Other organizations could have their version of that.
- 29:23I think the interesting thing about that model is the informed captain making the call.
- 29:31Because there's an element of, well, hang on, I've asked everybody, or everybody's had a chance to say something, why haven't you taken my idea on board?
- 29:38And that can cause all sorts of conflict.
- 29:41But in an organization where it's like, hey, hey, hey, this is how we make decisions.
- 29:45It's down to this guy, he's going to talk to you, or she's going to talk to all of you.
- 29:50You have your chance to make or break this.
- 29:52At the end of the day, though, thank you for your contribution.
- 29:55It comes down to this person.
- 29:57Nothing personal about it, they're just informing and making a decision.
- 30:01That whole circle of understanding is so important, isn't it?
- 30:04Because that could cause all sorts of problems if that isn't well understood.
- 30:08Yeah, and it will also cause problems if the informed captain just dismisses people's ideas out of hand.
- 30:17And this comes down to tone now.
- 30:19So if you get someone's view, and you demonstrate appreciation for the risks they may have taken, for the contribution they've made, that's what we must do as leaders.
- 30:29It doesn't mean you have to agree with them.
- 30:31It doesn't mean that their idea is the one that gets adopted.
- 30:34And this is the bit that gets confusing, I think, at times on psychological safety.
- 30:38Like someone says, well, oh, you didn't agree with what I said, therefore I don't feel psychologically safe.
- 30:41That is to weaponize the concept in the wrong way.
- 30:45So when there's an understanding that psychological safety means that we are going to ensure that all the ideas are on the table, and we're going to be appreciative that people have taken the risk to do that, but then people also understand that we've chosen this route, and these are the reasons why, then that is creating a candid, energizing place to work.
- 31:06And leaders, they must start meetings not with, this is a safe place, because that just never works.
- 31:14People need to feel it.
- 31:19Exactly right.
- 31:21We've all been in those meetings, and you don't believe it.
- 31:23But if someone gives an idea, and you invite that participation, and you demonstrate appreciation, and you explain why you're going down a different route, guess what will happen next time?
- 31:34They'll come up with more ideas, and they'll make a contribution.
- 31:37If they dismiss that at hand, then you won't get more ideas.
- 31:41I think that's so important.
- 31:42I mean,
- 31:42I've talked about this sort of stuff, I think, when it comes to internal communication, because
- 31:46often when you're trying to influence, often emerging, or people who've been leaders for a
- 31:55long time, and are used to the way that they're doing things, and my way, or the highway, and
- 31:59you sort of say, you talk about this inclusive involvement, and asking people for ideas and
- 32:04opinions, and you get, well, yeah, but what if they're just crap?
- 32:07Well, then you tell them, but you're in a way that shows that you're listening to them, and thanking them for their input.
- 32:14But you're explaining why it's crap, not just saying it's crap, or doing it.
- 32:18What's even worse is ignoring the feedback, because then you'll never get anything.
- 32:24And that person may have a crap idea today, but tomorrow could absolutely unleash a huge revenue stream for you, or save you loads of money from profit, or really have a great connection for a customer that released something new, or have a great idea for a new product.
- 32:39If you shut them down in any of those ways, will you suppress any of that opportunity going forward?
- 32:46So I think this is where this topic, I come back to keep repeating myself, it's fundamental.
- 32:52I don't think it's a nice-to-have.
- 32:53I think it's kind of like absolutely front and center.
- 32:56If you want a high-performing organization, a high-performing team that is built on high trust, high challenge, you've got to look into this stuff, right?
- 33:07Because you can't just demand it.
- 33:09You've got to create it.
- 33:10You've got to curate it.
- 33:12.
- 33:13I totally agree. I think this is the foundation for high performance.
- 33:16And let me be really clear, I don't get any dictatorial leaders phoning me up going, Gary, I've got a command and control style.
- 33:25I did tell everyone what to do.
- 33:26Can you help me out?
- 33:27No one like that phones me up.
- 33:29I get people get in touch with me because they care about their culture, because they care about their people.
- 33:35And they might say something like, I don't feel like I'm quite getting out of the team what I need, or I need to empower people a bit more and get more ideas, more of a contribution.
- 33:46Something's not quite connecting in the right way.
- 33:49People who call me are ones that care about their people, and they want to create an environment where voices are heard, respected.
- 33:55And they also understand that we're not going to go with every idea someone comes up with.
- 33:58But if you don't go with your idea, we'll absolutely explain why.
- 34:03Yeah, I'm 100% with you there.
- 34:05I know you're doing a lot of work in the room with teams, running breakthrough sessions, sharing this data, doing, I guess, live polls, as well as surveys on this sort of stuff.
- 34:18What are some of the common aha moments that you've seen when you have this data in front of everybody in the team?
- 34:25What's going on?
- 34:27So I think the biggest aha moment is the way the survey results are shared.
- 34:34So the survey takes less than three minutes for anyone to fill in.
- 34:37So that's how long it takes you to find out how safe people feel.
- 34:40The big aha moment is when you share results in a room full of 100 people or a room full of nine people.
- 34:47It's demonstrating what the median score is, so the middle score of all the scores, whether it's nine or 100.
- 34:53And then you show the spread of perception in the team.
- 34:57I think that's the first aha moment that comes out, Andy, because someone could be sitting there going, well, I feel fine speaking up.
- 35:03But then they suddenly see that their colleagues don't.
- 35:07And so the first penny drop moment is people going, oh, wow, this is not just down to the leader.
- 35:12The leader plays an oversized role, let's be clear, in creating psychological safety.
- 35:16But it's down to everyone in the team, like, what am I doing that maybe is creating a situation where people can't raise things?
- 35:24So that would be the first penny drop moment.
- 35:27I think the data is the critical part because it's the colleagues' personal, it's their data.
- 35:35They've expressed what they feel.
- 35:38But it's the catalyst for the conversations that they're not having.
- 35:42And what do I mean by that?
- 35:43Teams spend a lot of time on strategy.
- 35:45They spend a lot of time on KPIs.
- 35:47They spend a lot of time on deliverables, as they absolutely should.
- 35:50And I've spent an awful lot of time on that in 27 years, working in four organizations, and they should.
- 35:56But they don't spend enough time on the interaction between the team members and how well that works or doesn't work.
- 36:03And frankly, you don't get the former, great strategy, great execution, achieving KPIs, without having a candid, energizing place to work, where connection is bringing out the best ideas, moving innovation forward, and making people feel truly engaged.
- 36:18So I'd say two big moments will be, one, okay, I know how I feel, but I didn't know how everyone else feels.
- 36:25So we're not mind readers, and we should forgive people for that.
- 36:29The second bit is, okay, what conversation does that drive?
- 36:32And how does that lead to the behavior change we can hold each other accountable to, and potentially even policy change as well?
- 36:39I bet you've seen and heard and been involved in some very interesting conversations with that data.
- 36:45I wonder if there's a meta thing going on here sometimes with the scores, where maybe the scores are in places because the team isn't feeling psychologically safe, but wants to project that because they don't feel psychologically safe enough to answer the question, honestly.
- 37:02But I guess even when you see those results, it might spark us some interesting conversations in the room, right?
- 37:07Are we really that good?
- 37:10Totally.
- 37:10I've also been in a situation where the opposite is true.
- 37:13So I've seen inflated scores where a team had a score of 90%, so top quartile benchmarks externally for asking for help in the team or willingness to help in the team.
- 37:25And they sat there and looked at the screen and said, oh, wow, that's generous.
- 37:28To which my response was, oh, that's interesting because it's your data.
- 37:32And they were pondering.
- 37:33And I said, how does it play out in your team?
- 37:35And then, interestingly, when they talked about it, the data was basically not aligned with the conversation.
- 37:43That's not important.
- 37:44The important thing is the conversation they then had to create an environment where it was more comfortable for people to ask each other for help.
- 37:52I think that's fabulous.
- 37:54I think these surveys, these questionnaires, they legitimize a conversation.
- 37:59They provoke a conversation.
- 38:02I'm with you, though.
- 38:03I think when I've ever done a similar thing with these questions, it's the scale.
- 38:08It's the look around the room when 10 out of 12 people are up the other end of the scoring scale.
- 38:15But over here, there's clearly a couple of people who aren't.
- 38:19Now, who's that?
- 38:21What's the problem?
- 38:22What's going on?
- 38:22We didn't see that.
- 38:24We didn't know that.
- 38:24We didn't appreciate that.
- 38:26What is going on?
- 38:28And it's often the bravery of those people who score, I guess, less highly that then provokes realism in the room about what's really going on.
- 38:37And like you say, then a decent conversation emerges from there.
- 38:40And at that point, I guess you can move forward as a team, right?
- 38:43Yeah, totally.
- 38:44Because you're then combining the quantitative data with the lived experience of the team.
- 38:49And look, the irony is not lost on me.
- 38:51You need psychological safety in those breakout sessions, right?
- 38:54Because you're trying to get under the iceberg.
- 38:57And who said what, again, is less important.
- 39:00What's important, or who scored what, rather, is less important.
- 39:03What's important is, how do you drag the people that have got the low scores up?
- 39:10What environment can you create to make sure that they actually are answering that differently next time?
- 39:14Because there's an opportunity to redo the survey in 3, 6, 12 months' time, however you feel.
- 39:19And this is why the spread of perception is important.
- 39:22Because you can see an average score of 86%, as an example.
- 39:26But you can see plenty of people would be scoring in the 50s.
- 39:31And if we get blinded by average scores, well then, we'll look at the number and just think everything's okay.
- 39:37Which is why it's important to combine quantitative data with the lived experience of people in the team.
- 39:43And that's where, I mean, forget what anyone else might say about the breakthrough sessions that I run.
- 39:48The consistent feedback I get at the end is, we've had conversations today that we never have had, and they will lead to better performance.
- 39:56And that's why I want to ask you, finally, there's all the heat of the moment in these breakthrough sessions about what the score says and what conversations you have.
- 40:05But it's what happens after that, right, is where things happen.
- 40:09What are some of the great shifts you've seen from these breakthrough sessions where we're sharing the data, having the conversations, and then things change?
- 40:17What have you seen?
- 40:19Yeah, and it's important in the breakthrough session that when you agree an action plan, what I tend to do is ensure that the leader and the leaders or people in the team take ownership of one of the four domains of psychological safety.
- 40:32So you reflect really clearly on the score, you bring it to life with lived experience, you talk about the behavior change you want to see, and then you've got people that are really checking in to see that happens.
- 40:43So it's critical in a breakthrough session, you don't just get a problem solution and then everyone's forgotten about it in three weeks' time.
- 40:50So you need an action plan that's going to be enduring and people calling out the behaviors that are reinforcing a safe environment, people can be candid, and call out behaviors when they're not doing that as well.
- 41:02And probably one of the most satisfying emails I got recently was from a board member who dropped me a note saying, just been to a board meeting of one organization that had done a breakthrough session back at Christmas time last year.
- 41:16And she was expressing how they're still implementing five, six months later, the change that they agreed to in a session we ran on the 18th of December.
- 41:25And actually, that's a bigger compliment than anything anyone says to you on the day about how good a workshop or a breakthrough session is.
- 41:33It's much more satisfying to hear actually, the actions that they defined, the behavior they wanted to change, the policy adjustments they want to create, so that they can speak candidly with each other are enduring, and they're still happening five, six months later.
- 41:49So the thing that also you're pointing to is, where's the accountability to make sure these behaviors are reinforced and pulled out, and teams collectively permitting to that over the long term?
- 42:02I love that.
- 42:03I mean, oh goodness, I think I say this at the end of every podcast episode.
- 42:07There's so much more I want to talk to you about.
- 42:10And I'm pretty sure this won't be our last conversation, recorded or not.
- 42:13But this is such a fascinating topic when you really start to get into the practicalities of it, and the conversations that happen, and the attitudes that change.
- 42:21I absolutely love it.
- 42:22But we are fast running out of time, Gary.
- 42:26So we've come to the part of the show I call Sticky Notes, which is my lazy attempt to summarize the takeouts from today's show by getting you to do it, and getting you to do it in a way that my little brain can cope with by giving me three pearls of wisdom that you reckon you could fit on three sticky notes.
- 42:41And then we'll whack those up on the Instagram channel when the episode goes live.
- 42:44So when we think about giving advice for organizations wanting to understand and move forward with this psychological safety concept, what three bits of advice would you leave behind today, Gary?
- 42:56I'd say, first of all, stop guessing and hypothesizing how safe your team is to speak up and measure it.
- 43:04It will cost you three minutes of your team's time.
- 43:07And then you'll go from hypothesizing to knowing.
- 43:11Then be open about what the dynamics are.
- 43:16So combine the lived experience with the data.
- 43:18And then commit to behavior change.
- 43:21That means people can voice their concerns, come up with great ideas that will absolutely add value going forward.
- 43:28And that will put you in a much, much better position.
- 43:33Three really, really simple sticky notes.
- 43:35And I desperately, desperately hope people take this topic far more seriously.
- 43:40If people want to find out a bit more about you, Gary, and where you are and these breakthrough sessions over this, where should they track you down, my friend?
- 43:50So LinkedIn, I'm on there.
- 43:53So just look, Gary Keogh, K-E-O-G-H on LinkedIn.
- 43:56There's not many of us, so hopefully I'll be up there.
- 43:59Also website, gkexeccoaching.com is another place to find me.
- 44:05And also through yourself, Andy. If someone wants to get in touch and get in touch that way, that's another way of doing it.
- 44:12Perfect.
- 44:12Love it.
- 44:13Gary, I have thoroughly enjoyed chatting to you today.
- 44:17I feel like we've done it some justice, but my God, like psychological safety itself, there's so much more to it.
- 44:22Thank you so much for coming on.
- 44:23I really appreciate your time.
- 44:25I appreciate yours.
- 44:26And let's do a sequel.
- 44:28Let's do it, mate.
- 44:29I look forward to that.
- 44:31You take care, buddy.
- 44:32Thank you.
- 44:33Okay, everybody, that was Gary Keogh.
- 44:35And if you'd like to find out anything more about the things that we've talked about in the show today, or track down Gary, please check out the show notes.
- 44:44So that concludes today's episode.
- 44:48I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting, and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 44:58If you have, please like, comment, and subscribe.
- 45:02It really helps.
- 45:04I'm Andy Goram, and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 45:09Until next time, thanks for listening.