Latest / Space Nuts: Astronomy Insights & Cosmic Discoveries / Distant Starlight & White Holes: Answering Your Cosmic Questions
Transcript
- 0:00Andrew Dunkley: Hi, there. Thanks for joining us on a Q and A
- 0:02edition of Space Nuts. And this is where
- 0:05we answer audience questions. And we've got a
- 0:08whole bunch today. We're going to talk about
- 0:10the light of a distant, uh, star
- 0:13or the lack of.
- 0:14And what happens when the star goes out and
- 0:17the light, you know, where does it go? Do we
- 0:19see it? Do we not? We'll tell you all about
- 0:21that. Um, black holes versus white
- 0:24holes. That's, uh, an old chestnut that comes
- 0:27up from time to time. Uh, the mass of the
- 0:30Earth is, um, something that
- 0:33somebody wants to know about. And we talked
- 0:35about black holes and white holes. What about
- 0:37neutrinos versus black holes? We'll answer
- 0:40all of that or not on this episode
- 0:42of space nuts.
- 0:44Professor Fred Watson: 15 seconds. Guidance is internal.
- 0:4710, 9. Ignition
- 0:49sequence start.
- 0:50Generic: Space nuts. 5, 4, 3. 2. 1. 2,
- 0:533, 4,
- 0:54Generic: 5, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. Space
- 0:57nuts. Astronauts report it feels good.
- 1:01Andrew Dunkley: Here again to try and solve all of that is
- 1:03Professor Fred Watson Watson, astronomer at
- 1:05Large. Hi, Fred Watson.
- 1:07Professor Fred Watson: Nice, um, to see you again. You, too,
- 1:09Fred Watson. Still at large as well.
- 1:11Andrew Dunkley: Yes, uh, I'm less large. I just. I've been
- 1:14losing weight lately, which isn't a bad
- 1:16thing. Isn't a bad thing.
- 1:18Professor Fred Watson: Okay,
- 1:19Andrew Dunkley: I'm back to manageable levels.
- 1:21Professor Fred Watson: Well, that's good. Well, congratulations on
- 1:23that.
- 1:23Andrew Dunkley: Thank you. Yeah, I think it's the first time
- 1:25in a decade I've been under 80 kilos.
- 1:29Professor Fred Watson: Um. Oh, that's, um. That's quite light.
- 1:32Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, for
- 1:32Professor Fred Watson: somebody your height.
- 1:34Andrew Dunkley: It's about right for my height. Okay.
- 1:37Professor Fred Watson: M.
- 1:38Andrew Dunkley: But, um, yeah, it's taken
- 1:41a while, but by design, slow and
- 1:44steady is the way to do it.
- 1:45Professor Fred Watson: That's a great thing.
- 1:45Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, I took my sweet time about it, that's
- 1:47for sure. All right,
- 1:50um, we've got some questions to deal with.
- 1:53Do you want to hear the first one?
- 1:55Professor Fred Watson: Um, I could say. Let me guess.
- 1:58But, um, I might hear it instead.
- 1:59Andrew Dunkley: All right, this comes from Billy.
- 2:02Billy Gerard: Professor Watson. Andrew. Billy
- 2:05Gerard here in New Jersey on the great
- 2:07old big old US Of A. Quick
- 2:10question. Let's just say, hypothetically, uh,
- 2:13we are looking at a star that's a billion
- 2:15light years away. And we're so. So
- 2:18theoretically, we're looking back in time a
- 2:19billion years. Now, hypothetically, let's
- 2:21just say that one day that star just
- 2:24goes out. It stops raining.
- 2:28Like, would we still see that star for,
- 2:31like. Like, does that light that's on its way
- 2:33to us keep coming? Like, would it take a
- 2:35billion years before we saw it go out?
- 2:38How does that work? Help me Understand that.
- 2:40By the way. Love you guys, Love you both,
- 2:42Love the podcast, love hearing you. And um,
- 2:45I, boy, I go all the way. I've been listening
- 2:47to you guys for a really long time. So I
- 2:48really appreciate the podcast and everything
- 2:50you do and thanks so much for uh, taking
- 2:53a call. Billy Gerard here in New, uh,
- 2:56Jersey, US of A.
- 2:59Andrew Dunkley: Thank you Billy. Uh, so lovely to hear from
- 3:01you and I'm glad you've been a long term
- 3:03listener and uh, glad you finally got through
- 3:05to us with a question. Uh, this, this sort of
- 3:08uh, is the same or similar to the question
- 3:11that we had recently. The hypothetical about
- 3:14the sun suddenly switching off and how much
- 3:17light we would see. Like if, if it switched
- 3:20off right now, we wouldn't see
- 3:22that happen for another eight and a bit
- 3:25minutes. Eight minutes, 20 seconds or
- 3:26something to that effect. It's the same for
- 3:29stars all over the universe, is it not?
- 3:32Professor Fred Watson: Yes it is,
- 3:33Andrew Dunkley: except that it'll be longer than 8 minutes
- 3:34and 20 seconds.
- 3:35Professor Fred Watson: That's right. So it's the same principle that
- 3:38light travels at uh, that
- 3:41rapid speed of 300,000 kilometres
- 3:44per second or in units that
- 3:48um, anybody in the USA will understand. One
- 3:51foot in a billionth of a second. Uh,
- 3:55so yeah, that's quite convenient actually
- 3:57that it's uh, a foot in a billionth of a
- 3:59second. Um, so yes, so
- 4:02that's exactly how it works. I mean
- 4:05there's always the analogue of um,
- 4:09sound when we
- 4:12listen to something, a noise made by
- 4:15something at a distance, for example, uh,
- 4:17lightning. And there was plenty of lightning
- 4:19around here last night, a huge flash.
- 4:21Andrew Dunkley: I've seen some of the footage.
- 4:23Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, uh, you get a flash, um,
- 4:26and then it takes, well, it takes
- 4:29sometimes minutes, several minutes for the
- 4:31uh, sorry, several seconds for the sound to
- 4:34reach you. Um, and so if you, you
- 4:37know, if the only way you knew about this
- 4:38thing was by the sound, uh, you'd be
- 4:41listening in the past as it were, because of
- 4:43that several seconds that it took. Uh,
- 4:46and it's true with uh, stars, whether they
- 4:48are as near as the sun is and you're
- 4:51exactly 8 minutes and 20 seconds is the light
- 4:54time from the sun to the earth. We wouldn't
- 4:56know anything about it until 8 minutes and 20
- 4:59seconds had gone by after the sun had managed
- 5:02to disappear or become extinct or ah,
- 5:05whatever. Um, and as we've spoken about
- 5:08before, gravity actually would work the same
- 5:10way because gravity, uh, also our
- 5:12gravitational waves also travel at the speed
- 5:15of light or the impulse of gravity.
- 5:17So yeah, uh, it's absolutely right, Billy,
- 5:20you're looking back in time and you're
- 5:22looking back in time sometimes a long way.
- 5:24Um, certainly, um,
- 5:27the most distant things that we can see,
- 5:30we're seeing them as they were when the
- 5:32universe was only about 300 million years
- 5:34old. So you're looking back Almost the whole
- 5:3613.8 billion year history of the universe,
- 5:38which is staggering really.
- 5:41Andrew Dunkley: It is. Uh, and just for the record, uh,
- 5:44the furthest star, ah, ever detected at
- 5:47this point in time is 12.9
- 5:50billion
- 5:52Professor Fred Watson: light
- 5:52Andrew Dunkley: years from Earth.
- 5:53Professor Fred Watson: That's right. So, um, um, that means,
- 5:56you know, it emitted its light when the
- 5:58universe was 900 million years old.
- 6:01Um, and I do remember reading about that, uh,
- 6:04some time ago, in fact, we probably covered
- 6:06it on space notes. And the only reason we
- 6:08could see a single star is because it's
- 6:11gravitationally lensed. It's being magnified
- 6:14by the gravitational distortion of
- 6:17a cluster of galaxies in front of it. So we
- 6:19can see an individual star at that distance.
- 6:22Andrew Dunkley: But I don't, I can't remember what the number
- 6:25Billy said was. 10 billion or
- 6:27Professor Fred Watson: one, uh,
- 6:28Andrew Dunkley: billion.
- 6:28Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, I think he said 10 billion.
- 6:30Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. So
- 6:30Professor Fred Watson: sorry. No, he said a billion. A billion.
- 6:32Andrew Dunkley: So if a star a billion light years away,
- 6:35Billy, just suddenly went out right now,
- 6:38you'd have to set your watch
- 6:41to go off in a billion years,
- 6:44basically, give or take because of
- 6:46gravitational lensing and other, other
- 6:48effects. Um, but it would take that
- 6:51long for you to see it go out.
- 6:54It's just hard to get your head around that
- 6:55sometimes, isn't it? Um,
- 6:58everything's finite, even light. I mean,
- 7:01there's a limit.
- 7:03Professor Fred Watson: I think what's almost more
- 7:05profound is that um, our ah, view of the
- 7:08universe doesn't matter. Whether you're
- 7:10talking about individual stars or
- 7:13galaxies or nebulae or whatever, we are
- 7:15always looking into the past. So,
- 7:18you know, when we look outwards, we're just
- 7:20looking further and further and further back
- 7:22in time. It's why we talk about space time,
- 7:25because space and time are so intimately
- 7:27related. Um, and
- 7:30that means because gravity also
- 7:33works on that speed limit, um,
- 7:37there's no point in really thinking about
- 7:39things in what we might think of as
- 7:41an absolute sense where you're looking at the
- 7:44universe from outside and seeing everything
- 7:45in it happening, uh, you know,
- 7:48simultaneously almost. Um, it's
- 7:51always, um, modified by our
- 7:53view. The fact that we are at the centre of
- 7:56an observing sphere. We're only
- 7:59an imaginary point and, you know, there's
- 8:01nothing significant about where we are. But
- 8:03it means that our whole sphere of
- 8:06observation has this time gradient
- 8:09across it Going back right to the Big Bang
- 8:11itself. Because we can still see the flash of
- 8:13the Big Bang in the cosmic radiation,
- 8:15Andrew Dunkley: cosmic
- 8:15Professor Fred Watson: background radiation.
- 8:16Andrew Dunkley: It's incredible. Uh, I was reading an
- 8:19article, uh, on the
- 8:22weekend, uh, about a scientist who was,
- 8:25um, quite prominent in the past. I can't
- 8:27think of his name right now, but, uh, he kind
- 8:29of got debunked or criticised or
- 8:32laughed at, whatever you like, for coming up
- 8:34with the theory that our existence
- 8:36is based purely on consciousness. That the
- 8:39universe and everything that's happening in
- 8:41it exists because we are
- 8:45sentient beings, that we are creating all of
- 8:48this. Um, it is so hard to.
- 8:52Professor Fred Watson: I think that's called the head. I think
- 8:54that's the strong anthropic principle.
- 8:57I
- 8:57Andrew Dunkley: think that's exactly what it was. Yes. Um,
- 9:00I can't remember why it came up. It was
- 9:02probably just one of those news feeds that
- 9:04pops up from time to time. But, uh, yeah,
- 9:06it's a fascinating theory. Um,
- 9:09there are those who believe you can
- 9:11manipulate that to your advantage, but I
- 9:14don't know if that's true or not. Um, there
- 9:16was a famous case of a woman who claimed, um,
- 9:19that she could and she won more
- 9:22prizes than anyone in history or something.
- 9:24Like there's some strange stories out there.
- 9:27Could just be coincidence. That's another
- 9:29theory as well. Thank you, Billy. Uh,
- 9:31awesome to hear from you in the lovely state
- 9:34of New Jersey. Our next question on
- 9:37Space nuts, Fred Watson, comes from Tristan,
- 9:40uh, and Simon. Simon's the dad, Tristan's
- 9:43his son. My 9 year old son Tristan. See, I
- 9:45was right. Uh, and I.
- 9:49My 9 year old son Tristan and I listen to
- 9:52your podcast on our, uh, daily drive to
- 9:54school. And he has a question among many.
- 9:57Tristan is interested in black holes and has
- 10:00heard about the theoretical idea of a white
- 10:03hole. His question is if black holes
- 10:05have extremely high gravity, are, uh, white
- 10:08holes the opposite? Thank you for keeping us
- 10:11entertained and curious during our long
- 10:14commute, Tristan and Simon.
- 10:17Thanks, uh, to both of you and, uh, hello,
- 10:19tr. All is well at school. I
- 10:22don't know if you like school or loathe it.
- 10:24Uh, I was not
- 10:27a very motivated student when I went
- 10:30to school. I think I did most of my learning
- 10:32when I got out, um, after they
- 10:35unlocked the doors. But anyway, um,
- 10:38Tristan's got a good question. We've had
- 10:40black hole, white hole questions a few times
- 10:42in the past. Uh, and it
- 10:45is probably logical to
- 10:47say that the theory is it would be quite the
- 10:50opposite. That's the reason it's called a
- 10:52white hole, I think, or they think
- 10:55it's white? I don't know, Fred Watson.
- 10:58Professor Fred Watson: We haven't
- 10:58Andrew Dunkley: found one yet.
- 10:59Professor Fred Watson: No, we haven't. Uh, so they are a
- 11:02theoretical entity,
- 11:05uh, and they are mathematically the
- 11:07opposite of a black hole, uh,
- 11:10in terms of some of the
- 11:13aspects, um,
- 11:16particularly in terms of something called
- 11:18time reversal. A, uh, comment
- 11:21that I've seen is if you played a video of a
- 11:23black hole backwards, it would look like a
- 11:25white hole. Um,
- 11:28that we. Yeah,
- 11:31we don't. To be honest, most physicists don't
- 11:34believe that they exist, uh,
- 11:36that, um, they're not real. But just
- 11:39going to the question that Tristan has posed,
- 11:42um, black holes of extremely high gravity
- 11:45are, uh, white holes the opposite? Uh, and
- 11:47the answer is, no, they're not.
- 11:52They still have a gravitational field because
- 11:55they've got mass. Uh,
- 11:58it's, you know, that doesn't go in the time
- 12:00reversal, doesn't affect that. But
- 12:03so the main thing is it doesn't have negative
- 12:06gravity, which is what you might think,
- 12:07because it's the opposite of a black hole in
- 12:09every other way. But it's not the.
- 12:12Not the fact that its mass becomes
- 12:15negative. It's the way
- 12:18space time behaves around it.
- 12:22Um, that's the crucial thing that makes
- 12:24it, uh, a white hole where it's trying to
- 12:27push everything outwards rather than pull
- 12:30everything inwards, which is what a black
- 12:31hole is doing. So it's all. Is a geometrical
- 12:34point. And I should just highlight here that
- 12:37the hall of Relativity is built on geometry.
- 12:40Uh, it's a geometrical theory.
- 12:42Um, Um, I did a talk on it a couple of
- 12:45weeks ago, and I actually took the equations
- 12:47out of it just because I didn't want to bore
- 12:49everybody to death. But the equations of
- 12:51relativity are basically geometry. In, uh,
- 12:53fact, in a sense, it's all Pythagoras's
- 12:55theorem, but it's very highly modified.
- 12:58Um, and so the geometry of the space time
- 13:00around the white hole is what makes
- 13:02everything want to get pushed out, rather
- 13:04than it having negative mass.
- 13:08Andrew Dunkley: Okay, yes, I understand. Um,
- 13:12I was just doing an AI Search on that very
- 13:15thing, and it says white holes are
- 13:16mathematically possible under Einstein's
- 13:18general theory of relativity, but physically
- 13:21unproven and unlikely to exist in our, uh,
- 13:23universe.
- 13:25Professor Fred Watson: I think I said something very similar to
- 13:26that. You
- 13:27Andrew Dunkley: did. I just wanted to
- 13:29compare to Einstein.
- 13:31Professor Fred Watson: M. Me and A.I. uh, were like that.
- 13:33Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, it's got its positives,
- 13:36but it's certainly getting some bad press
- 13:37too. Yeah, it
- 13:38Professor Fred Watson: is. Yes, it is indeed.
- 13:40Andrew Dunkley: Uh, I learned a new, um, online word.
- 13:42It's not A new word, but it's a new use
- 13:45for the word. It's. It's called slop. You
- 13:48know what slop means?
- 13:50Professor Fred Watson: Um, it's. Yes, it's the. The sort of.
- 13:54It's AI that's not got things quite right.
- 13:56Yeah, right.
- 13:58Andrew Dunkley: Sort of. It's. It's where an entire
- 14:00paper book article, whatever
- 14:03has been AI Generated absolutely no
- 14:06human creation in it at all.
- 14:09And unfortunately, it's starting to happen
- 14:11more and more and more. It's
- 14:14nasty stuff. Uh, and white holes are slop
- 14:17as well. No, we don't know that. Um, but
- 14:21we do know black holes
- 14:23exist. We don't know if white holes
- 14:26exist. They probably don't. But, uh, they
- 14:28would not be the exact opposite of a black
- 14:31hole is what we're saying.
- 14:32Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, that's right. In that regard. Um, it's
- 14:35what they do to space time that changes the.
- 14:37Basically changes
- 14:40the nature of the thing into something that's
- 14:42the opposite of a black hole. But. Great
- 14:45question, Tristan. And one, I'm absolutely
- 14:48delighted, um, you asked because it gave
- 14:51me a chance to think all that stuff through
- 14:53and bring back some memories of what I
- 14:55learned a few years ago.
- 14:56Andrew Dunkley: Very good. Uh, thanks, Tristan. Thanks,
- 14:59Simon. And keep, uh, the curiosity coming. We
- 15:02love hearing from, uh, the younger audience
- 15:04members here on Space Nuts. You're with
- 15:07Andrew Dunkley and Professor Fred Watson
- 15:09Watson.
- 15:11John F. Kennedy: I believe that this nation should commit
- 15:13itself to achieving the goal,
- 15:16before this decade is out, of landing a
- 15:19man on the moon and returning him safely to
- 15:21the Earth. Space Nuts,
- 15:24Andrew Dunkley: our, uh, next question, Fred Watson, is
- 15:27massive.
- 15:28Mike (from Hayward, California): Hey, Space Nuts, this is Mike in Hayward,
- 15:31California. Got a question for you about
- 15:34dark matter. Big surprise. So I've been
- 15:36thinking about dark, um, matter. And
- 15:39the way that you've described it on the
- 15:41podcast is it seems to
- 15:44be the solution to the problem that
- 15:47astronomers observe when they look at
- 15:49galaxies and they see the rate at
- 15:52which they're spinning doesn't quite line
- 15:55up with the mass that they can
- 15:57calculate of the galaxy that it seems like
- 16:00the stars should be flying off into space.
- 16:04Uh, except that they're not. So there must be
- 16:07more matter there that is causing
- 16:10a gravitational force to keep
- 16:12them in place. So I've been thinking
- 16:15about, um, are there other ways to
- 16:18measure this more locally? And I was
- 16:21thinking about the Earth. And we can make a
- 16:24direct, accurate measurement of the Earth's
- 16:27gravity, but we can't really make a direct
- 16:30measurement of the Earth's mass. Uh,
- 16:32so my question is, is the Earth's
- 16:35mass, uh, over overestimated?
- 16:39Because there's a component of the gravity
- 16:41that we feel that is attributable to dark
- 16:44matter and not all of it is
- 16:47baryonic matter. Anyway, hope that
- 16:49makes sense. Love your podcast. Can't wait to
- 16:52hear the answer. Thanks, guys.
- 16:54Andrew Dunkley: Thank you, Mike. Oh, you put a lot of thought
- 16:55into that. Um,
- 16:59uh, uh, um, it's a difficult question
- 17:01to get your head around. Um, so
- 17:04over to you, Fred Watson.
- 17:08Professor Fred Watson: I
- 17:08Andrew Dunkley: was going to paraphrase what he was asking,
- 17:10but it's just gone straight in one ear out
- 17:12the other,
- 17:13Professor Fred Watson: so. Yes, um, so,
- 17:17well, um, Mike's point
- 17:20was that we can measure gravity
- 17:23on Earth, uh, more accurately that
- 17:26we can than we can measure its mass. Um, I
- 17:28don't think that's true. The mass of the
- 17:30Earth is very well determined and it comes
- 17:33actually from space observations. You can
- 17:36just looking at the dynamics of the solar
- 17:38system, the way the planet moves in its orbit
- 17:41around the sun and the way it interacts with
- 17:42the other planets, we know it's mass to a
- 17:45very high accuracy. Um,
- 17:48and so that's
- 17:51not something we can compare.
- 17:55So we know its mass. The
- 17:58gravitational pull as, ah, a result of that,
- 18:00which we can also measure, uh, is
- 18:03completely consistent with its mass. So, um,
- 18:06I think what Mike is asking is if you measure
- 18:08the mass of the Earth and you measure its
- 18:10gravitational pull, uh, is there
- 18:14a component of that gravitational pull that's
- 18:16not due to the Earth, it's due to dark
- 18:18matter. Ah. And the answer
- 18:21is no, because
- 18:24we on Earth are immersed in a
- 18:26blob of dark matter, which certainly has
- 18:29gravitational pull, but it's going in
- 18:32all directions and so we don't feel
- 18:34its effect. It
- 18:37just cancels out. It's pulling in all
- 18:40directions because blobs of dark matter. Uh,
- 18:42uh,
- 18:46um. Did you hear that?
- 18:49Andrew Dunkley: That sounds like a dark matter.
- 18:51Professor Fred Watson: It was, it was, um, it was me,
- 18:54uh, tripping over a cable underneath my desk,
- 18:57which pulled all this stuff attached to it
- 19:00down onto the, oh, onto the floor.
- 19:04Andrew Dunkley: That's the good news. And I can still hear
- 19:06you.
- 19:06Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, no, it's all right. It's not done any
- 19:08harm. My table lamp is lying
- 19:11pointing awkwardly upwards rather than
- 19:13downwards like it's supposed to be. But
- 19:15everything will be fine. I'm not really
- 19:17worried about that. Um,
- 19:20so, um, yeah, so dark matter,
- 19:23basically what you can, you know, if you
- 19:26imagine the Earth, uh, there it is trundling
- 19:28around in its orbit, but it's
- 19:30immersed in a blob of dark matter which is
- 19:33probably much bigger than the whole galaxy.
- 19:36And so the density of
- 19:39that dark matter is effectively the same
- 19:42everywhere. As far as the Earth's concerned,
- 19:44Andrew Dunkley: uh,
- 19:44Professor Fred Watson: and so it's pulling in all directions. You
- 19:47can just take it completely out of the
- 19:49equations of motions of a planet.
- 19:52Andrew Dunkley: Okay, so would the dark matter be
- 19:55moving with the Earth and with the galaxy, or
- 19:57are we passing through it?
- 20:00Professor Fred Watson: Uh, um, there probably isn't a
- 20:03relative velocity between us and dark matter.
- 20:06Although there is an experiment
- 20:08that's being done in Gran Sasso in
- 20:11Italy that suggests that we are moving
- 20:14through dark matter because they think they
- 20:16see a different signature of
- 20:18certain. I think it's gamma radiation that
- 20:20they're picking up, uh, when the Earth is on
- 20:23one side of its orbit from when it's on the
- 20:25other side. Uh, but more or less,
- 20:28you can imagine that the blob of dark matter
- 20:30is rotating with the galaxy. That's
- 20:33very roughly.
- 20:34Andrew Dunkley: Okay, so what was the answer to Mike's
- 20:37question?
- 20:38Professor Fred Watson: No,
- 20:39Andrew Dunkley: no, I love it when
- 20:42it's that simple.
- 20:43Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, I can't remember what the question was.
- 20:45Let me just have a quick look to remind me.
- 20:48Uh, actually, no, it's an audio question,
- 20:51so I can't.
- 20:52Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, yeah. Um.
- 20:53Professor Fred Watson: Uh, but yes,
- 20:57I, uh, like the idea of, you know, taking.
- 21:01Measuring the Earth's gravity, measuring its
- 21:03mass, and from its mass you work out
- 21:06how much gravity it should have. Uh, and then
- 21:07you compare the two, the measurement of the
- 21:10gravity, with the theoretical prediction, but
- 21:12they're exactly the same. And that's because
- 21:14the dark matter's gravity cancels out,
- 21:17basically.
- 21:17Andrew Dunkley: Well, here's a test for you, Fred Watson.
- 21:20What is the mass of the Earth?
- 21:22Professor Fred Watson: Um, it's about. It's a few tons,
- 21:25isn't it? Um, it's
- 21:26Andrew Dunkley: a couple of kilogrammes.
- 21:28Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. The number, I think the sun's mass
- 21:31is 10 to
- 21:3327 kilogrammes. Is that
- 21:36right or is that tonnes? I can't remember,
- 21:38Andrew Dunkley: but
- 21:39Professor Fred Watson: it's a number with a, uh, lot of zeros
- 21:42after it.
- 21:42Andrew Dunkley: Yeah.
- 21:42Professor Fred Watson: What is the mass of the earth? You tell me.
- 21:44Andrew Dunkley: 5.9722 times 10 to the
- 21:4624th kilogrammes, or
- 21:495.97 sextillion kilogrammes.
- 21:53Professor Fred Watson: Yep.
- 21:53Andrew Dunkley: I don't know what that is in pounds. Sorry,
- 21:55America, I apologise.
- 21:58Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. What is it in dollars? That's the
- 22:00thing. That's
- 22:00Andrew Dunkley: a good question. I wonder if AI can
- 22:03answer that.
- 22:05Professor Fred Watson: Uh, what is the mass of the Earth in dollars?
- 22:07I bet it can.
- 22:09Andrew Dunkley: I'll do it in US dollars, because, you know,
- 22:11Australian dollars, it'll just say 10 bucks.
- 22:18Oh, dear. Yeah,
- 22:21I want to feel with a number.
- 22:24Professor Fred Watson: It might, uh. I think AI, uh. Is it
- 22:26Andrew Dunkley: did. 5 quadrillion US dollars.
- 22:29Professor Fred Watson: That's what it's
- 22:31Andrew Dunkley: worth.
- 22:31Professor Fred Watson: I thought
- 22:32Andrew Dunkley: Elon Musk had that much money
- 22:35Professor Fred Watson: anyway. There you go,
- 22:38Andrew Dunkley: M. Nobody
- 22:39Professor Fred Watson: can say we're not adequate with. No,
- 22:41Andrew Dunkley: very thorough when it comes to money.
- 22:44Well, some people are. I haven't got any. All
- 22:46right, thanks, Mike. Thanks for the question.
- 22:48Hope we adequately covered it for you.
- 22:52Suspect not, but anyway, we'll um, we might
- 22:54do a sequel. One day.
- 22:59Professor Fred Watson: Three, two, one.
- 23:02Space Nuts.
- 23:03Andrew Dunkley: Our final question on space nuts today,
- 23:05Fred Watson, comes from Eduardo, who is
- 23:08from Gran Canaria in the Canary Islands.
- 23:11Lovely. Um, we drove past there
- 23:14last year in a ship. We got to wave.
- 23:17We were supposed to stop there, but um, the
- 23:19schedule changed so we ended up um,
- 23:22at um, uh, Tenerife instead.
- 23:26Uh, so Eduardo, uh, asked do neutrinos
- 23:28interact with gravity at all? Do they get
- 23:30swallowed by black holes or do they just
- 23:32shoot through them like ordinary matter?
- 23:36Uh, light is massless, moves at the speed of
- 23:38light, and yet can't shoot through the Earth
- 23:40like neutrinos do, hardly interacting with
- 23:43matter at all. Although I imagine it would be
- 23:45hard even for neutrinos to shoot through a
- 23:48point of infinite density. I
- 23:51suppose that point, the so called
- 23:53singularity, is all the way, uh,
- 23:56down the gravity well of a black hole.
- 23:59Not all of the black hole volume from the
- 24:01event horizon to the
- 24:04singularity has infinite, uh, density,
- 24:07I guess. Or does it? What about
- 24:09spacetime itself? Bodies with huge mass and
- 24:12gravitational influence bend spacetime. They
- 24:15can also make an vibrate, generating
- 24:17gravitational waves if the interaction is
- 24:20strong enough, making space time somewhat of
- 24:22a material in nature. Could huge
- 24:25supermassive black holes feed on space time
- 24:28itself? Thanks for your answers, Eduardo.
- 24:31Thought provoking.
- 24:33Professor Fred Watson: It is, yeah. Um, I also
- 24:36have visited Gran Canaria,
- 24:40um, many times, um, usually
- 24:43on my way to La Palma where I used to observe
- 24:45a lot on the, um, William Herschel
- 24:47Telescope on the island of La Palma.
- 24:49Andrew Dunkley: Yeah,
- 24:50Professor Fred Watson: uh, it's a lovely part of the world. Uh,
- 24:53my last trip there was kind of
- 24:56disappointing because, um, Nani was supposed
- 24:59to come with me, but for reasons beyond our
- 25:01control she couldn't. So I ended up there on
- 25:03my own, doing a conference. Anyway, that's a
- 25:05long story. Um,
- 25:08um, okay, uh, so the
- 25:11basic question, uh, is let
- 25:14me just read the question. Do, in, do
- 25:16neutrinos interact with gravity at all?
- 25:20And the answer is yes. Um,
- 25:22because they've got a, um, non zero
- 25:25rest mass. Unlike a photon, which
- 25:28has zero rest mass. Um,
- 25:31a neutrino has a non zero rest
- 25:34mass but is Very, very small. But
- 25:37nevertheless, uh, that is enough to mean that
- 25:39it follows the curvature of space time.
- 25:42Exactly as defined by general relativity.
- 25:45So they do interact with grav.
- 25:48Um, and, you know,
- 25:51that's basically the crucial point about all
- 25:54this. Uh, if a neutrino
- 25:57crosses the event
- 26:01horizon of a black hole, uh,
- 26:04um, they do get swallowed, um,
- 26:08by a black hole. Uh,
- 26:11so it's the ones
- 26:14that are probably moving quickly enough that
- 26:17avoid being swallowed. But because they've
- 26:20got mass, and black holes love eating
- 26:22mass, that means they just basically get
- 26:25swallowed. Generally,
- 26:26Andrew Dunkley: they wouldn't get much out of a neutrino.
- 26:28Professor Fred Watson: No, that's not right. They're certainly not
- 26:31sustained by a neutrino in terms of
- 26:33sustenance. Um, so, yes,
- 26:36that's basically the question that, um,
- 26:39they do get swallowed. They don't. They don't
- 26:41just shoot through, uh,
- 26:43them, you know, like.
- 26:46Well, like nothing does really. And yet
- 26:49Andrew Dunkley: they can pass through Earth.
- 26:52Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, but that's because their mass and
- 26:55their, you know, their interact. If I can put
- 26:57it this way, their interactability with
- 26:59other, uh, subatomic particles is so
- 27:02low, they're weakly interacting. Very, very
- 27:04weakly interacting. So they just zoom through
- 27:07the Earth, Uh, uh, but they
- 27:09still have mass, um, but only a
- 27:12tiny amount. And so they will be sucked into
- 27:15a black hole.
- 27:17Andrew Dunkley: Uh, and that was the second part of his
- 27:18question. Ah. And the crux of that was,
- 27:22could a supermassive black hole feed on
- 27:24spacetime itself?
- 27:26Professor Fred Watson: Um, I don't think so, because
- 27:30space, ah, time is,
- 27:33you know, I mean, essentially
- 27:36Eduardo's suggesting that spacetime
- 27:39is material real in nature, but it's
- 27:42not. It's the medium, if I can put it that
- 27:44way. It's not a medium. It's just a framework
- 27:46within which everything else sits. Uh,
- 27:49so, um, a, uh, black hole feeding on m
- 27:51space time, I think, will be out of the
- 27:54question. There's plenty of other stuff
- 27:55within that space time for it to feed on,
- 27:57which is material in nature. Uh, uh, but
- 28:00not space time itself.
- 28:02Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. Okay, very good.
- 28:05I think we covered it.
- 28:07Professor Fred Watson: Um, I hope so.
- 28:11Andrew Dunkley: All right. Uh, thank you, Eduardo. Um, thanks
- 28:14for sending the question in. And a reminder.
- 28:16If you'd like to send us questions, please do
- 28:18just go to our website,
- 28:20spacenutspodcast.com or
- 28:22spacenuts IO. There's a little link at the
- 28:25top called AMA Ask Me Anything. You
- 28:28click on that and you can send us text or
- 28:30audio questions. Just, uh, fill in the
- 28:32blanks. Uh, if you've got a device, a smart
- 28:34device with a microphone, you're all Set.
- 28:36Just don't forget to tell us who you are and
- 28:38where you're from. We just like to know so we
- 28:40can spam you.
- 28:43I wish that was not true, but I have actually
- 28:46spammed a couple of people lately with, you
- 28:49know, some book that I was trying to flog.
- 28:52Yeah. Um, and thanks for those who have
- 28:55actually bought it. And even bigger thanks to
- 28:58those who've read it. I appreciate that.
- 29:00Um, because I've gone, um, I've gone Kindle
- 29:03plus on it, Fred Watson. And, uh, it gives
- 29:06me a report every day of how many pages have
- 29:08been read, which is fascinating because I
- 29:11get paid per page.
- 29:13Professor Fred Watson: Okay, that's interesting. Per page read.
- 29:15Andrew Dunkley: Yeah. So you get, you get, um,
- 29:18so many cents per page. I earned five cents
- 29:21yesterday after tax.
- 29:23That'll be one and a half cents.
- 29:26Professor Fred Watson: It's not, um, really comparable with the mass
- 29:29of the earth in dollars, is it? No,
- 29:30Andrew Dunkley: not really, no.
- 29:33Yeah, I never thought of it that way. But
- 29:35any, uh, it's just fun to do it. I
- 29:38enjoy writing and I enjoy the. I don't really
- 29:40enjoy the marketing side of things. That's
- 29:42not my jam.
- 29:45Professor Fred Watson: That's right.
- 29:47Andrew Dunkley: Anyway, uh, so, yes, keep those cards
- 29:50and letters coming in. Love to hear from you.
- 29:52And thank, uh, you, Fred Watson, as always,
- 29:55for answering those questions so thoroughly.
- 29:58Professor Fred Watson: Well, thank you, Andrew. Yeah, I am, um,
- 30:01glad you think they were thoroughly answered.
- 30:02That's all right. Um,
- 30:04Andrew Dunkley: or adequately.
- 30:07Professor Fred Watson: I'll. I'll take that one, thank you. Fair
- 30:09Andrew Dunkley: enough. We'll see. We'll see you soon,
- 30:10Fred Watson. Thank you. Yeah,
- 30:11Professor Fred Watson: uh, cheers for now. Bye.
- 30:12Bye.
- 30:12Andrew Dunkley: Professor Fred Watson Watson, astronomer at
- 30:14large, and thanks to Huw in this studio, uh,
- 30:17couldn't be with us today because he
- 30:18underestimated his mass and he's had to go to
- 30:21the gym. And from me, Andrew Dunkley,
- 30:24uh, we'll see you on the next episode of
- 30:25Space Nuts. Until then, bye Bye.
- 30:28Voice Over Guy: You've been listening to the Space Nuts
- 30:31podcast
- 30:31Professor Fred Watson: Missing Play do. Since
- 30:33Voice Over Guy: available at Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 30:36iHeartRadio or your favourite podcast
- 30:38player. You can also stream on
- 30:40demand@bytes.com.
- 30:42Voice Over Guy: this has been another quality podcast
- 30:44production from bytes.com.