Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 27: Iran Rejects US 15-Point Peace Plan, Issues 5 Counter-Demands Including Hormuz Sovereignty
Transcript
- 0:16The United States put a 15 point peace plan on the table.
- 0:20Iran called it maximalist and unreasonable.
- 0:24Then Iran put a 5 point counter plan on the table.
- 0:27The White House said Trump is prepared to unleash hell, and
- 0:31four separate polls now show that most Americans oppose this
- 0:34war. It is Thursday, March 26th,
- 0:382026, day 27 of Operation Epic Fury.
- 0:43The diplomatic window is narrowing, the bombs are still
- 0:46falling, and the distance between the two sides positions
- 0:50has never been more precisely documented or more starkly wide.
- 0:54This is episode 27 of Epic Fury, the US Iran War podcast.
- 0:59Let's get into it. Start with the substance of what
- 1:02was actually on the table this week, because the details of
- 1:05both Lans reveal more about where this conflict can and
- 1:09cannot go than any statement from any spokesperson.
- 1:12The 15 point United States proposal was transmitted to Iran
- 1:16through Pakistan and became public on Wednesday. 2 Pakistani
- 1:20officials and an Egyptian official involved in the
- 1:22mediation described its content broadly.
- 1:26The proposal includes sanctions relief for Iran, a rollback of
- 1:29Iran's nuclear program, including the decommissioning of
- 1:32three key facilities, Natanz, Isfahan and Ferdal.
- 1:36Limits on Iran's ballistic missile program, restricting it
- 1:39to self-defense use a cessation of Iranian support for its proxy
- 1:43network Hezbollah, the Houthis and Iran backed militias in
- 1:47Iraq, Iran's formal acknowledgement of Israel's
- 1:50right to exist, and the reopening of the Strait of
- 1:52Hormuz to all international shipping.
- 1:55In return, the United States would lift Iran's nuclear
- 1:58related sanctions, assist Iran in developing A civilian nuclear
- 2:01program including electricity generation at the Buscher plant,
- 2:05and remove the snapback mechanism that automatically
- 2:07reimposed international sanctions on Iran for non
- 2:10compliance. The proposal also reportedly
- 2:13included the possibility of a one month ceasefire during which
- 2:16both sides would negotiate the final details, similar to the
- 2:19structure used in the Gaza ceasefire agreement last year.
- 2:22The 15 point plan is in effect a demand that Iran accept the
- 2:26complete dismantlement of everything that has made it a
- 2:28regional power for the past four decades, its nuclear enrichment
- 2:32capability, its missile program, its proxy network, and its
- 2:35leverage over the straight. In exchange, it gets economic
- 2:39relief and a civilian nuclear program it already had before
- 2:42the war began. Before the war began, Iran was
- 2:46in nuclear negotiations with the United States.
- 2:49Those talks collapsed in part because Witkoff and the US team
- 2:52demanded 0 enrichment, something Iran had consistently said was a
- 2:56red line. Iran went to war with that
- 2:59position unresolved. 4 weeks later, the same 0 enrichment
- 3:03demand appears to be in the 15 point plan.
- 3:06The war has destroyed enormous amounts of Iranian
- 3:09infrastructure, killed over 1200 people inside Iran, and
- 3:13displaced millions. But the fundamental negotiating
- 3:16chasm that existed before February 28th appears to remain
- 3:20in place. Whether the military destruction
- 3:22has changed Iran's calculation sufficiently to accept what it
- 3:26rejected before the bombs fell is the central question of this
- 3:29entire diplomatic moment. Iran's response arrived within
- 3:33hours. It was called the proposal
- 3:35maximalist and unreasonable by an official who spoke on
- 3:38background. Iran then published its own 5
- 3:41point counteroffer through state broadcaster Press TV.
- 3:45Iran's conditions are as follows.
- 3:47A complete halt to aggression and assassinations by the United
- 3:51States and Israel. The establishment of concrete
- 3:54mechanisms to ensure the war is not reimposed on Iran.
- 3:58Guaranteed and clearly defined payment of war damages and
- 4:01reparations, a comprehensive end to the war across all fronts,
- 4:06including against Hezbollah and Lebanon and pro Iranian militias
- 4:09in Iraq, and international recognition and guarantees of
- 4:13Iran's sovereignty over the Strait of Hormuz, with that
- 4:16sovereignty framed as a guarantee for the implementation
- 4:19of any other commitments Iran makes.
- 4:21That last point deserves careful attention.
- 4:24Iran is not asking for the Strait to reopen under current
- 4:27arrangements. Iran is asking for international
- 4:30recognition that the Strait belongs to Iran, that Tehran's
- 4:34control over it is legally legitimate and permanently
- 4:36guaranteed. This is not a diplomatic opening
- 4:39position designed to be negotiated down.
- 4:42It is a demand to rewrite the foundational principles of
- 4:45International Maritime law that have governed global shipping
- 4:48for decades. The Strait of Hormuz is governed
- 4:51by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, which
- 4:54classifieds it as a Strait used for international navigation,
- 4:58through which all nations have transit passage rights that
- 5:00cannot be suspended. Iran is demanding that those
- 5:03rights be subordinated to Iranian sovereignty and Iranian
- 5:07permission. No American administration and
- 5:10no international legal community could accept that framing
- 5:13without fundamentally altering the architecture governing the
- 5:16transit of 20% of the world's oil supply.
- 5:20If the United States were to agree to this, it would be
- 5:22granting Iran a permanent veto over global energy flows that
- 5:25could be used as leverage in any future dispute, not just with
- 5:28Washington and Jerusalem, but with Riyadh, Beijing, Tokyo or
- 5:32anyone else whose tankers transit the Gulf.
- 5:35This demand alone makes the Iranian counteroffer
- 5:38structurally incompatible with any agreement the United States
- 5:41could publicly present as a victory.
- 5:44Foreign Minister Abbas Arcachi addressed the state of the
- 5:46negotiations directly on Wednesday, He said on state
- 5:50television. No negotiations have happened
- 5:52with the enemy until now, and we do not plan on any negotiations.
- 5:57He acknowledged that the United States is communicating through
- 6:00mediators, but he said an exchange of messages does not
- 6:03mean negotiations or dialogue. He said Iran is not seeking war
- 6:08and wants a permanent into the conflict, but on its own terms,
- 6:11with its own conditions met. He said the American shift
- 6:15toward talking represents Washington's acknowledgement of
- 6:17failure after previously demanding unconditional
- 6:21surrender. That framing is significant.
- 6:24Iran's public position is that the United States is coming to
- 6:27the table from a position of weakness, that Iran has absorbed
- 6:30nearly four weeks of the most intensive bombardment in Modern
- 6:33Warfare and is still standing, still firing, still setting
- 6:37terms. Whether that framing is accurate
- 6:39is a separate question from whether Iran believes it, and
- 6:43there is evidence it does. A senior Iranian official told a
- 6:47news outlet that Iran will end the war when it decides to do so
- 6:51and when its own conditions are met.
- 6:53Trump, speaking at a fundraising dinner in Washington on
- 6:55Wednesday evening, said Iran wants to make a deal so badly,
- 6:59but they're afraid to save for fear of being killed.
- 7:02He said the United States is talking to the right people.
- 7:06He said the deal is near. He said fake news was reporting
- 7:10that the United States was losing.
- 7:12He said We're decimating the other side.
- 7:15He maintained the posture of a victor in negotiations, even as
- 7:18Iran's foreign minister categorically denied any
- 7:21negotiations were taking place. The setting of the speech was
- 7:25itself worth noting the National Republican Congressional
- 7:28Committee's annual fundraising dinner.
- 7:31Trump was speaking to his political base, to Republican
- 7:34donors and operatives, in a room where projecting strength and
- 7:37imminent victory was not merely A strategic choice but a social
- 7:41expectation. The audience wanted to hear that
- 7:44the war was being won. Trump told them it was.
- 7:47Whether that message accurately reflected the state of
- 7:50negotiations or was calibrated for the room is a question only
- 7:54the participants know the answer to.
- 7:56White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt delivered the
- 7:59administration's most explicit threat since the power plant
- 8:03ultimatum. She said if Iran fails to accept
- 8:06the reality of the current moment, if they fail to
- 8:08understand that they have been defeated militarily and will
- 8:11continue to be, President Trump will ensure they are hit harder
- 8:15than they have ever been hit before.
- 8:17She added President Trump does not bluff and he is prepared to
- 8:20unleash hell. Iran should not miscalculate
- 8:23again. The gulf between Trump's
- 8:26optimism and Levitt threats reflects an administration that
- 8:29is simultaneously pursuing 2 contradictory postures.
- 8:33The president is projecting warmth and confidence about a
- 8:36deal. His press secretary is
- 8:38threatening the most severe military action of the entire
- 8:41conflict. The administration's internal
- 8:44diversity of message. Trump says deal near.
- 8:46Levitt says unleash hell. Hegseth says We negotiate with
- 8:50Bombs is either a deliberate good cop, bad cop strategy
- 8:53designed to pressure Iran into accepting terms, or it is
- 8:56evidence of a genuine internal disagreement about what comes
- 8:59next. Analysts and former officials
- 9:02are divided on which interpretation is correct.
- 9:05Both cannot be simultaneously true in the short run.
- 9:09One of them reflects the real policy.
- 9:12The question is which. Arachi's framing of the
- 9:14diplomatic moment is a sign of American failure is also worth
- 9:18examining on its own terms. He said Washington's shift
- 9:21toward talking represents an acknowledgement of failure after
- 9:25previously demanding unconditional surrender.
- 9:28That is a pointed reference to the fact that in the early days
- 9:31of this conflict, American officials spoke as if Iran would
- 9:34capitulate quickly. Hegseth said in the first week
- 9:37that the operation would achieve its goals swiftly.
- 9:40Trump's original four week timetable has now expired.
- 9:44Iran is still fighting. Its leadership structure is
- 9:48decapitated, but a successor government is in place.
- 9:51Its missile inventory is depleted, but it has fired more
- 9:54than 400 ballistic missiles at Israel and has not stopped.
- 9:58From Iran's perspective, surviving 4 weeks of this
- 10:01bombardment while still launching daily attacks and
- 10:03forcing the United States to send a peace plan through
- 10:05Pakistan is itself a form of victory.
- 10:08Regardless of what the physical destruction inside Iran looks
- 10:11like, the military picture on Wednesday provided little
- 10:15comfort to anyone hoping the diplomacy was producing a de
- 10:18facto reduction in violence. Israel launched another wide
- 10:21scale wave of strikes on Iran. Iran fired fresh barges at
- 10:26Israel with air raid sirens sounding across the country.
- 10:29Iranian missile and drone attacks continue to cross the
- 10:32Gulf. The UAE confirmed it was
- 10:34intercepting drones and missiles and told residents that sound
- 10:38they were hearing were air defenses, not impacts.
- 10:41Kuwait issued a similar message. Bahrain sounded sirens and told
- 10:45residents to shelter in place. Saudi Arabia's Eastern Province
- 10:49was attacked again with missiles targeting oil facilities
- 10:52including Rasta, Nura, Gawar and Ipkaic, the heart of the
- 10:56kingdom's oil production infrastructure.
- 10:58Iraq registered a formal diplomatic complaint with the
- 11:01United States on Wednesday. The Iraqi government said a
- 11:04strike hit near an Army Medical center, killing at least 7 Iraqi
- 11:08soldiers. It summoned the senior American
- 11:11diplomat in the country and described the strike as a breach
- 11:14of international law. Iraq's situation throughout this
- 11:17conflict has been uniquely difficult.
- 11:19It is a strategic partner of the United States while
- 11:22simultaneously hosting powerful Iran backed militias that are
- 11:25formally part of its own government forces.
- 11:28The killing of seven Iraqi soldiers in what appeared to be
- 11:31AUS or Israeli strike puts enormous pressure on Baghdad's
- 11:35ability to maintain its position of reluctant neutrality.
- 11:38Iraq has strategic interests pulling in opposite directions.
- 11:42It wants the Iranian threat to its government reduced but
- 11:45cannot be seen as a facilitator of strikes that kill its own
- 11:48soldiers and destabilize its territory.
- 11:51The formal complaint is Baghdad's way of managing that
- 11:54impossible position in public. Iran's parliament Speaker
- 11:57Galabaf posted on social media Wednesday that Iran had
- 12:01intelligence suggesting its enemies, with help from a
- 12:03regional country, are planning to occupy an Iranian island.
- 12:07He did not name the island or the regional country.
- 12:10The statement was widely read as a reference to the Karg Island
- 12:13blockade scenario that Washington has been openly
- 12:16discussing. If the United States were to
- 12:18move toward a blockade or occupation of Karg, through
- 12:21which 90% of Iran's oil exports flow, it would represent a
- 12:25fundamental escalation in the nature of the conflict, from
- 12:29aerial campaign to physical occupation of Iranian sovereign
- 12:32territory. The Gulf Cooperation Council
- 12:35nations publicly insisted this week that they must be
- 12:37represented in any peace talks, demanding guarantees on the free
- 12:41flow of energy and the cessation of Iranian missile threats.
- 12:45Their insistence on a seat at any negotiating table reflects
- 12:48how deeply the war has damaged their economies and their sense
- 12:51of security and how determined they are not to be excluded from
- 12:55any arrangement that shapes the post war Middle East.
- 12:57The polling picture inside the United States continued to shift
- 13:01against the war. An APRC poll conducted between
- 13:04March 19th and 23rd found 59% of Americans saying U.S. military
- 13:08action in Iran has gone too far, 26% saying it has been about
- 13:13right, and 13% saying it has not gone far enough.
- 13:17A Quinnipiac poll from the same period found 54% of registered
- 13:21voters opposed to the US military action.
- 13:24The Reuters in Ipsos poll from earlier this week found 61% of
- 13:28Americans disapproving. 4 separate polling organizations,
- 13:331 consistent finding. The American public by
- 13:36substantial majority believes this war has gone too far.
- 13:41These numbers have real political consequences.
- 13:44The House Armed Services Committee members said Wednesday
- 13:46they were unsatisfied with a classified briefing from Trump
- 13:50administration officials on the war, its objectives and its
- 13:53timeline, the latest sign that even within the Republican
- 13:56coalition, frustration is building.
- 13:58Members on both sides of the aisle said they left the
- 14:01briefing with more questions and answers.
- 14:03Democrats continued pushing for public testimony from Rubio and
- 14:07Hegseth before Congress. The war has now run for nearly
- 14:11four weeks without a single open congressional hearing.
- 14:15That absence of public accountability is itself
- 14:17becoming a political issue independent of the war's
- 14:20conduct. That polling is now influencing
- 14:23the war's economics in unexpected ways.
- 14:26The United States Postal Service announced Wednesday it will
- 14:28apply an 8% temporary fuel surcharge to its major domestic
- 14:32shipping products, including Priority Mail Express, Priority
- 14:36Mail and USPS Ground Advantage. The surcharge takes effect April
- 14:4026th and runs through January. USPS cited energy and fuel
- 14:45prices rising sharply since the war began as the reason.
- 14:49It is a small but concrete illustration of how the Hormuz
- 14:52closure is propagating through the entire American economy,
- 14:56down to the cost of sending a parcel across the country.
- 14:59The UN Secretary General, Antonio Guterres, said on
- 15:02Wednesday that the prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz
- 15:05is choking the movement of oil, gas and fertilizer at a critical
- 15:09moment in the global planting season.
- 15:11That last point, fertilizer, is not a detail.
- 15:15It is a global food security warning.
- 15:17The Straight is the primary transit route for fertilizer
- 15:20exports from Gulf producers. A sustained closure during the
- 15:24spring planting season means reduced fertilizer availability
- 15:27for farmers across Asia, Africa and Latin America.
- 15:31The consequences of that shortage will not appear in this
- 15:34spring's harvest. They will appear in autumn, and
- 15:37then again in next year's food prices in the most vulnerable
- 15:40countries in the world. Gutierrez has been calling for a
- 15:43ceasefire since the first day of this conflict.
- 15:46His fertilizer warning is a reminder that the human costs of
- 15:49this war extend far beyond the immediate military theater into
- 15:53food security, economic stability and the daily survival
- 15:56of populations who have no stake in the dispute between
- 15:59Washington, Jerusalem and Tehran.
- 16:02But who will pay for it regardless?
- 16:04China's Foreign Minister Wang He called his Iranian counterpart
- 16:07Arachi on Wednesday and said in terms made public that talking
- 16:11is always better than fighting. He urged all parties to seize
- 16:15every opportunity and window for peace and call for talks to
- 16:18begin as soon as possible. China's public position
- 16:22throughout this war has been 1 of condemnation of the American
- 16:25and Israeli strikes. Alongside calls for diplomacy.
- 16:29The combination positions Beijing as simultaneously
- 16:31backing Iran's narrative and calling for de escalation, A
- 16:35posture that gives China maximum influence over any eventual
- 16:38settlement without requiring it to take any military action or
- 16:42make any commitment that could damage its relationships with
- 16:44Washington. China receives roughly a third
- 16:47of its oil imports through the Strait of Hormuz.
- 16:50The war has been economically painful for Beijing in ways it
- 16:53is not publicly acknowledged. China's quiet diplomacy reflects
- 16:57the calculation that it benefits most from being seen as the
- 17:00responsible party that helped end the war, rather than as a
- 17:04participant on either side. As Day 27 ends, what is clear is
- 17:08that both sides have now publicly put their opening
- 17:11positions on the record. The distance between them is
- 17:14vast. the United States wants Iran to dismantle its nuclear
- 17:18program, abandoned its proxies, acknowledge Israel's existence
- 17:22and reopen the Strait. Iran wants reparations,
- 17:25sovereignty over the Strait and into all hostilities across
- 17:29every front, and guarantees against future attack.
- 17:32These are not opening positions that are edging toward each
- 17:35other. They are positions that, if
- 17:38maintained, make any deal impossible.
- 17:41Something fundamental will have to shift in the military
- 17:44situation, in domestic political calculations on one or both
- 17:47sides, or in the economic pain that the world is absorbing
- 17:51before these positions can be bridged.
- 17:53The structural problem with the diplomatic process right now is
- 17:57that neither side can afford to be seen to move first.
- 18:00For Trump, moving toward Iran's position even slightly would
- 18:04mean abandoning demands that he is framed publicly as non
- 18:07negotiable and that his base expect him to enforce.
- 18:11For Iran's leadership, any concession under active
- 18:14bombardment will be portrayed domestically and regionally as
- 18:17capitulation. Both sides have built their
- 18:20public postures in ways that make compromise extraordinarily
- 18:23difficult to sell to their own audiences.
- 18:26What mediators Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt and Oman are trying to do
- 18:30is find a sequencing that allows both sides to claim they never
- 18:33conceded anything while arriving at an outcome that ends the
- 18:37shooting and reopens the Strait. That is an extraordinarily
- 18:40delicate piece of diplomatic architecture to construct the
- 18:44Gaza ceasefire of last year, which the 15 point plan
- 18:47reportedly uses as a template, took months of painstaking
- 18:50negotiation to produce and still fell apart repeatedly before it
- 18:54held. The Iran situation is more
- 18:56complex, more geographically dispersed, involves more
- 19:00parties, and has higher economic stakes for the entire world.
- 19:04Mediators are reportedly pushing for in person talks in
- 19:07Islamabad, possibly as soon as Friday.
- 19:10If that meeting happens, if an Iranian official and an American
- 19:14representative sit in the same room in Pakistan, it would be
- 19:17the first direct contact of the war.
- 19:19It would not resolve the war, but it would change its
- 19:22trajectory in ways that cannot be predicted from the outside.
- 19:26History suggests that wars in through a combination of
- 19:29military exhaustion, economic pressure, and a specific moment
- 19:33when one or both sides conclude that the cost of continuing
- 19:36exceeds the cost of stopping. Whether day 27 is close to that
- 19:40moment, or whether the conflict has weeks or months still to run
- 19:44is something that only the decision makers in Washington,
- 19:46Jerusalem, and Tehran can assess.
- 19:49Whether Iran's government authorizes anyone to actually
- 19:51appear in Islamabad on Friday, and whether the person who
- 19:54appears has the authority to make any binding commitments are
- 19:58the two questions that will determine whether the five day
- 20:00window closes with something or collapses into the next military
- 20:04escalation. 3 days remain in the five day window.
- 20:08The bombs are still falling, the straight is still closed, the
- 20:12fertilizer is not moving, the cost to the global economy is
- 20:16still rising hundreds of millions of dollars every day,
- 20:20and neither side is yet willing to publicly say what it would
- 20:23actually accept in order to stop.
- 20:26This has been episode 27 of Epic Fury, the US Iran War Podcast.
- 20:31Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or YouTube to get every
- 20:35episode the moment it drops. Share this with someone trying
- 20:39to follow this story and we will be back very soon with the next
- 20:43update as this diplomatic window reaches its final hours.