Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP214: James & Paul's 2023 Ecommerce Platform & Technology Roundup
Transcript
- 0:02Happy New Year to everyone. Thanks for tuning back in in
- 0:042024 to the Replatform Podcast sponsored by Patchworks and
- 0:07hosted by me, James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:10We bring you interviews of industry thought leaders,
- 0:13C-Suite of tech companies and retailers.
- 0:15And also we do talking heads around like interesting topics
- 0:18in the industry where me and Paul ramble on about what we're
- 0:21seeing in the industry. All we ask in return is you tell
- 0:24other people about the podcast share or like our posts on
- 0:26LinkedIn and social media and if it's your first time listening,
- 0:29please do give us a rating wherever you are listening to
- 0:32the show. Thanks.
- 0:33We hope you enjoy today's episode.
- 0:35So we are doing our usual annual round up to doing the 2023
- 0:38e-commerce platform technology round up talking about what
- 0:41we've seen in the industry, things that got our attention
- 0:43last year, tech that that that's been trending etcetera.
- 0:48And I think the market context for this one is 2023 was
- 0:51definitely a more challenging year for e-commerce.
- 0:54Replatforming has slowed down and that inevitably has had an
- 0:58impact on the ancillary technologies that that normally
- 1:01go into replatforming projects or the third party apps and
- 1:04ecosystem. So the the year on year growth
- 1:08software e-commerce software revenue dropped from 20/22/20
- 1:122021-2022 and although growth has been a bit higher this year,
- 1:17it's still expected to be significantly lower than it was
- 1:19in 2021. So I think growth was about
- 1:222324% in 21, in 22 it was 11% and this year is expected to be
- 1:27around 16. And there's been lots of things
- 1:30impacting it. We've had high inflation,
- 1:32currency exchange issues, turbulent economies and that
- 1:35hasn't bottomed out yet. And you know we've got electoral
- 1:38uncertainty coming into next year as well in key markets like
- 1:41UK and US. So we're expecting that that
- 1:46turbulence to carry on a bit. But also one of the key things
- 1:49has been the continued growth of fiscal commerce, which we'll
- 1:51talk about in a minute and that's obviously had an impact
- 1:54on e-commerce growth in certain verticals and it's impacting
- 1:57budgets. So I think that's the key market
- 1:59context, but anything you want to add in terms of like the
- 2:02overall context for e-commerce this year, well last year's?
- 2:05No, not too. I think the only other one is
- 2:07that brands and retailers aren't performing as well as they were
- 2:11over the last couple of years obviously.
- 2:13And I think Q3 in particular was pretty tough, Q4 batter Q1 very
- 2:19good. And so I think that would be the
- 2:22only other thing where people just aren't, you know, I guess
- 2:27forecasting the growth that they were sending as much money.
- 2:31Yeah, exactly. I've definitely seen a slowdown
- 2:33in interest in in big CapEx projects because people are
- 2:36inevitably wanting to to push that and see what happens
- 2:40doubling down on like the operational side and trying to
- 2:43drive sales margin, profitability etcetera.
- 2:47So the when we were talking about this episode and we
- 2:50thought how do we structure, we're going to talk about a big
- 2:52trend, key platforms, third party apps and tech around it
- 2:58and then and then a section B to B towards the end.
- 3:01But the the big trend that you flagged so do you want to talk
- 3:03about first is about Omni channel being BAT and this
- 3:06there's an inevitability towards this because obviously the
- 3:08pandemic, sure store physical retail shut down.
- 3:12Then we've had a a slow return initially after we came out of
- 3:17lockdowns into 2022 and then in 2022 and 23, three it's really
- 3:22picked up and more people are back in store.
- 3:24And it doesn't mean e-commerce has shrunk, but it means the
- 3:26growth rate in e-commerce has been hit because because some of
- 3:28that spend patterns been switched back into physical
- 3:30environment. What, what, what have you seen
- 3:32across your client base, what you've seen in the wider market?
- 3:37Yeah, absolutely. Yes, I think Omni has become
- 3:41more of a focus again and also we work quite a lot of brands
- 3:44that have never done physical retail before.
- 3:46But now sit is a really interesting channel and I think
- 3:50part of that has definitely come for I think one is you know it
- 3:53can be a really good brand awareness channel like if you
- 3:55were fashion brand that's doing really well.
- 3:56Like we there are certain locations where you know that if
- 4:01you put physical store there you're going to reach you know a
- 4:04certain customer and that's going to really help you build
- 4:07your brand. But I think the interesting
- 4:09thing has recently is that the cost of opening stores has gone
- 4:14down where you know Ren has gone down.
- 4:18Obviously other costs around it has gone up, but the actual kind
- 4:21of you know rental agreements and things like that have gone
- 4:24down and then the cost of acquiring customers online has
- 4:28gone up. And I think, yeah, the other
- 4:30thing is one of the biggest trends for this year that we
- 4:32actually don't have in here, but we've kind of both hinted at a
- 4:35little bit with what we've written down is measurement and
- 4:38data. And I think particularly online
- 4:41and particularly with where the way the market is, a lot of
- 4:44people essentially wanting to spend less on top of funnel
- 4:48activity unless they can really measure the impact.
- 4:52And I think physical retail stores if done well are actually
- 4:56pretty measurable and you know, you know that you're going to
- 4:58track a certain level of new customers.
- 5:01And then think, yeah, as people are trying to kind of broaden
- 5:05what they're doing to like build brand awareness and decline in
- 5:09customers. I think physical retail has been
- 5:11really interested. And that's probably more
- 5:13specific to the types of brands that we're working with who are
- 5:16like fashion brands that are at a certain level, but have
- 5:20typically grown online and maybe via wholesale than via physical
- 5:25retail. Yeah, I think that's a really
- 5:26important element that wholesale one because they're the DTC
- 5:30brands, because the online growth is, is contracting and
- 5:36they're starting to see that actually you know to hit those
- 5:39big future growth numbers relying purely online is not
- 5:42going to achieve that. Therefore they're experimenting
- 5:44with different, different physical retail opportunities.
- 5:47So you've got the pop up stores which are popular, there's a lot
- 5:49of US brands have, they've done, I mean in the UK as well.
- 5:52But yeah, the wholesale bit I've seen is interesting because it's
- 5:55it's it's been embraced by small, medium and big business.
- 5:58So I've I've worked some SM ES where they've really pushed the
- 6:00whole channel whole. I can't speak the wholesale
- 6:03channel and interestingly they're they're starting to
- 6:05listen and talk about having people within their business
- 6:09whose role it is, is to manage those accounts and not just from
- 6:13the those wholesalers from the physical store selling point of
- 6:16view, but also from the e-commerce store point of view
- 6:19to maximize digital store revenue and digital store
- 6:22product visibility. So I I those roles have
- 6:26typically been the preserve of of like big consumer brands who
- 6:29for example big brands like Mars is working with online grocers.
- 6:33But actually now I'm seeing it in other areas like fashion
- 6:35beauty where people are starting to listen to think about having
- 6:38those expertise where previously selling online via wholesalers
- 6:42send them the product information, fulfil the orders.
- 6:45But there is no strategic ratio between the e-commerce teams.
- 6:49So yeah that's it's definitely interesting to see how that's
- 6:51going to go next year. I mean the predictions are that
- 6:53that that wholesale piece is only going to grow rapidly next
- 6:56year anyway. I think it is an inch.
- 7:00I mean again we didn't really touch on this, but that's kind
- 7:02of triggered me to think about some things that came up in our
- 7:05like review of Q4. And I think I think wholesale is
- 7:10at an interesting point, but it just differs at like different
- 7:14in different areas of the industry.
- 7:16So I think someone like Next are flying at the moment.
- 7:21Obviously they've just bought Fat Face and reworked together
- 7:23with, but they're also just doing lots of really smart stuff
- 7:28around multi brand. And actually so I believe
- 7:30they're going into premium early next year and a lot of our
- 7:34clients are already talking about it and they're
- 7:36propositioning it really well. Obviously people like far
- 7:38fetched and matches have been widely reported to not be doing
- 7:43particularly well. So there's a gap there.
- 7:45I think M&S are doing similar things as well and some of the
- 7:49other kind of retailers are starting to look at doing
- 7:52similar things. But I think the brat the
- 7:55retailers or the multi brand retailers like a sauce and a
- 7:59number of others at kind of that level shoe.
- 8:02Some of the other ones have been so aggressive or discounting
- 8:06recently. And I think one of the biggest
- 8:09things that I'm hoping next year, I think we'll see next
- 8:13year is some of those businesses will really struggle because
- 8:16it's a multi brand business. I just don't see how they can
- 8:19discount on that level and their margins are relatively low and
- 8:24acquiring a new customer for those businesses is like it just
- 8:27can't be profitable. So I think that'll be, we've
- 8:29obviously seen it with some multi brand retailers already,
- 8:33but I think that'll be, I think it'll be interesting to see how
- 8:37that goes and whether more big retailers will go under as well
- 8:42or at least face challenges. Yeah and I think that leads us
- 8:46nicely on to let's let's cover the B to B and wholesale bit
- 8:50because it this obviously links into the technology piece and AB
- 8:54to BA commerce growth has outpaced B to C and it
- 8:59definitely feels like the platforms have taken B to BA bit
- 9:03more seriously in terms of feature roll out.
- 9:07We've we've talked about the SAS world and big commerce have made
- 9:09real gains in B2B capability like they were they went
- 9:14significantly ahead of Shopify and that by by the acquisitions
- 9:18say bundle B2B as a wild back quotations.
- 9:21But they've they've ramped up the the the customer portal, the
- 9:24invoice portal. They've improved processes for
- 9:27like payment and settlement of multiple invoices, you know
- 9:31centralized purchase workflows, all the stuff that AB2B think
- 9:34lean and business needs and wants to see in a platform but
- 9:38through a modern interface. So it's not like you know really
- 9:41clunky old school green screen stuff.
- 9:43So they I know big commerce is is Newcastle acquisition in the
- 9:47B2B space has been really good this year.
- 9:48I'm working on a potential project with them at the moment
- 9:52and I still see that as a really strong offering.
- 9:54The the technology I think has has democratized this a bit
- 9:58because it's it's simpler for businesses with the B2B commerce
- 10:02on to launch sites and to manage that and have really good
- 10:06self-service and sales tool in as well.
- 10:10But the so then let's flip to the Shopify because I find this
- 10:14interesting and you can talk more about this.
- 10:17But Shopify have definitely sharpened their tools around B2B
- 10:22when they didn't look like it was a a key part of their
- 10:25strategy or road map, but they they've acquired fair the B2B
- 10:28marketplace, they've announced more features.
- 10:31Where where do you see, where do you see this from a tech point
- 10:34of view, where do you see Shopify being in like you know
- 10:36in 2024? Yes, I think Shopify invested in
- 10:41fair, which is interesting, but I think the biggest thing is
- 10:44more around how they're looking at targeting or growing their
- 10:51B2B market share. And I think they've similarly to
- 10:54how they approached international.
- 10:56I think for the last couple of years, they approached a company
- 10:58called Handshake. Yeah, sorry, acquired a company
- 11:01called Handshake a few years ago.
- 11:02No one really knew what's going on.
- 11:04Handshake became a wholesale marketplace or handshake.com
- 11:07became a wholesale marketplace. And then there wasn't really too
- 11:10much talked about it. And then I think that team has
- 11:13then gradually been merged into other teams.
- 11:16And then they've kind of built out the fundamentals of B to B
- 11:19in the core platform. But I think they've approached
- 11:21it in a similar way to international where they've kind
- 11:24of been working in the background to like retroactively
- 11:29build some of those beaches into their core platform.
- 11:34So things like price books, the you know, entity of a company,
- 11:39stuff like that, you know they've been working on.
- 11:42And I think now they've got to a point where their foundations
- 11:45are really strong within the core.
- 11:48But there's, you know, they've still got a lot of catching up
- 11:50to do around, you know, kind of building around that new
- 11:54ecosystem, you know, building out some of those kind of core
- 11:59functionalities to be at the same level as big commerce or
- 12:03you know, even Adobe, whoever else.
- 12:06But I do think they're, you know, they're releasing a lot of
- 12:08functionality very regularly. There's a lot coming next year
- 12:12that was announced at the Enterprise Summit in Ally and I
- 12:16think they are very they they want to be very aggressive in
- 12:21that market. But I think it'll be interesting
- 12:22because I think B2B is harder to shop 5, obviously well known for
- 12:27being exceptional at marketing and fairly strong at the
- 12:31commercial side. But I think B2B is slower.
- 12:35I think you know a lot of people working in B2B and manufacturer
- 12:38aren't going to like the big industry trade about said yeah I
- 12:42think it I think it will take longer for them to like really
- 12:45push a bit equally. You know if they go and win a
- 12:47few massive ones then they're definitely making progress.
- 12:51But yeah I think that I think they've still got a way to go
- 12:54until they're kind of you know really competing against some of
- 12:58the big platforms but equally it is pretty disparate.
- 13:00So it's it. Is and from a technology point
- 13:04of view there is so much choice now what for me the the, the big
- 13:08shift is there for SM ES. The SAS B2B products are mature
- 13:13and really nice and have really robust functionality at
- 13:16enterprise level. It often opens up a different
- 13:19discussion because you especially if you're in really
- 13:21complex industries like manufacturing or plant
- 13:24machinery, where you have really complicated sales cycles like
- 13:27huge configuration and real complexity around the product
- 13:30model and the pricing, then you often need greater degree of
- 13:33customization and deeper data models.
- 13:35And then you open up all the big enterprise players and there are
- 13:39many of them, whether that's a sales force, a Sprite, you name
- 13:43it, you keep going. But yeah, B2B definitely
- 13:47wholesale B2 BI think is going to just continue to grow.
- 13:49It actually is expected to grow quite sharply and continue to
- 13:52outpace B2C. So I think those those
- 13:54businesses out there who are brands wanting to sell to
- 13:58wholesale channels and want to improve automation and want to
- 14:01improve tooling, now's the time to go and look at the market.
- 14:04Because take a look at, you know if you are a BTC store on
- 14:08Shopify and you need a basic B2B wholesale channel, that's the
- 14:12path of least resistance. If you're not already on a
- 14:14platform like that, then you need to look at the likes of of
- 14:16big commerce as Shopify's. You know other platforms like
- 14:20Sentra headless out there which have B to B capability, a really
- 14:24lockdown which is going to give you the the, the fastest speed
- 14:27to market for a proof of concept store.
- 14:30You'd be surprised sometimes actually how cheaply and quickly
- 14:33you can, you can launch a basic storefront with a decent
- 14:36customer experience. So let's continue the platform
- 14:38thing. So let's talk about overall
- 14:39platform market because we've seen you know we spend a lot of
- 14:42time looking at platforms and doing re platforming projects
- 14:45and selecting technology. It definitely feels like let's
- 14:48do that the headline, let's get the elephant out of the room, it
- 14:51feels like it's been Shopify's year, Is that a good thing?
- 14:55Here's my question. So Shopify is from a marketing
- 14:59point of view they are smashed here, the way they are
- 15:01positioning the road map, how they're investing.
- 15:03You know what was it over 3000 developers, I think it's
- 15:05something like that. Their pace of change has gone up
- 15:07massively. We've talked about this before
- 15:10they've they've gone through and identified the key reasons
- 15:14people think Shopify is not suitable to bigger businesses
- 15:17and gone let's remove this gradually.
- 15:19They still got work to do around multi store.
- 15:21You know it's still not up there in in terms of like NACE
- 15:25capability in the ways like a sales force and Adobe might be.
- 15:28But they are getting through that quickly and it feels that
- 15:32now in a certain type of RFP that whereas it used to be which
- 15:37two or three platforms you look at.
- 15:38There are people starting with we should, is there any reason
- 15:41we shouldn't be on Shopify? And I think the mindset in
- 15:44especially in brands seems to have shifted.
- 15:47So do you, here's my question. Is it a good thing that Shopify
- 15:52is becoming so dominant or are we going to see the next that's
- 15:56yours? Yeah, I mean, I think it's
- 15:59really interesting. I didn't see the next sales, but
- 16:01I think Shopify is very different.
- 16:02Anyone that's ever been in the market, I don't think we've ever
- 16:06seen anyone with their market share in, you know, they've got
- 16:10over 3 million stores. I don't think we've seen anyone
- 16:13with their resources. So they've got 4000 developers
- 16:16of which 2000 to focus purely on R&D and I don't think we've seen
- 16:21anyone growing at the rate they're growing at.
- 16:24But what I do think will be interesting, it's where it leads
- 16:30because I see Shopify becoming like I think there'll be niches
- 16:34that Shopify won't be the market leader in nothing.
- 16:37They already are. And I think even if you look at
- 16:39you know for certain types of brands like right now a Centra
- 16:43might be functionally a better fit or you know in enterprise
- 16:47someone like a commas tools could functionally be a better
- 16:50fit. But I do think Shopify is
- 16:51becoming like a mainstream operating system to a certain
- 16:54extent. The thing that I think will be
- 16:57interesting into life. And I think the other thing is
- 17:00they're making a lot of quiet moves.
- 17:03You know, like you said about Fair before and Shopify
- 17:06Collective and you know they're improving POS, they're building
- 17:09more order management into the platform.
- 17:12It almost feels like they're you know, going like this and
- 17:15actually you know four years time in their world do they see
- 17:19a brand having an ERP or you know, they if they got a bigger
- 17:23share. And I I think there's a lot of
- 17:24question marks over that and my personally see it as I think
- 17:28it's interesting like I do think they are commoditizing and I
- 17:32think there's pros and cons to that.
- 17:34I think I like Shopify. I love what they've done for
- 17:37ecom. I think they've enabled a lot of
- 17:40brands to grow and build their experiences and everything else.
- 17:43But the only thing is they have made some fairly aggressive
- 17:46moves in the past, particularly around tech partners.
- 17:49You know they obviously in certain places the platform
- 17:52doesn't necessarily advocate choice and I think they are
- 17:57going to be very dominant. I personally, you know, I think
- 18:01a lot of people have seen Toby talk and kind of see his vision
- 18:05and I think I do think they'll commoditize a lot of stuff and
- 18:08they'll bring the barrier to entry down.
- 18:10You know, I think they'll go low code and then allow for
- 18:12complexity or even no code and then allow for complexity.
- 18:16But I think that it's a good thing, but there there's
- 18:21definitely risks with Shopify getting to a certain level of
- 18:26dominance and I think they will contract.
- 18:28They could feasibly control the ecosystem a little bit.
- 18:33And that is interesting. When I speak to you about this
- 18:36and other people, it's like a lot of people think Shopify are
- 18:39going to like increase their costs a lot in the future.
- 18:42Whereas I don't see it like that and I see it more.
- 18:44It's like it's almost like everyone's on Shopify.
- 18:47That's not where their income comes from.
- 18:49It's more they'll make more money through everything that
- 18:52needs to be active in the ecosystem.
- 18:54And yeah, I think it'd be. I guess, I guess because I
- 18:59because I always I do the dull side of projects, right.
- 19:01I look at all of the the operational, the the process
- 19:05within which the governance and the risk jobs and risk
- 19:08management's Professor Vegan. I in the back of my head I have
- 19:11this. We've seen it before where build
- 19:13an audience, monetize the audience, build an audience,
- 19:16monetize it. I know Shopify are going through
- 19:18that process of monetizing driving profitability out of
- 19:21payments and that obviously there there are cost
- 19:25implications to using payments and the benefits that gives you
- 19:28on their ecosystem rather than using a third party gateway.
- 19:31But I, I I would not be surprised if at some point they
- 19:36nudge up that that core platform license fee because they've got
- 19:40a long way to go that license fee before even with the work
- 19:44you have to do on Shopify to you know achieve some of the things
- 19:47that maybe you get natively out-of-the-box with like a
- 19:50Salesforce and Adobe. But the cost model is still
- 19:54significantly less. We've looked at it for like a
- 19:56300 impasse business and we know it's significantly less.
- 20:00So there's wriggle room for them to go.
- 20:02Do you know what? It's .24.
- 20:03It's it's .3%. So, yeah, I I, I know what you
- 20:07mean. Are you more closely connected
- 20:08and you don't see any talk of that, but I think businesses
- 20:11need to need to factor in. What if those costs go up when
- 20:15they're thinking about their cost model, because you just
- 20:16never know. Completely.
- 20:19And within the contracts there are, you know, they have room to
- 20:22do that. And I think they probably will
- 20:23do it at a time, but I don't think that'll be their big play.
- 20:26So, yeah, but I think it'll be more.
- 20:29Yeah, Pay to play and chop Life World and mice.
- 20:32It's funny isn't it because when we start this podcast in 2019, I
- 20:36was definitely, I was less in the Shopify camp than you and I
- 20:40thought Shopify is good but I saw it as a more basic platform
- 20:43and I thought it's got lots of potential, it's great for DC
- 20:45Brands. I've definitely changed my
- 20:47viewpoint. I think I mean Shopify is is
- 20:49strong in so many areas now. Although there's a lot still to
- 20:52not nuance in some of the the the like Omni channel, multi
- 20:55store processes. The only thing that I have an
- 20:58issue with is the way that I see the leadership in some of their
- 21:01social activity, especially on LinkedIn, where they are
- 21:05evangelical about Shopify, is best for everything.
- 21:08It's right for everyone. It's the cheapest for
- 21:09everything. And I'd I'd I'd like to see more
- 21:12nuance in that and less I get as a less evangelical attitude
- 21:17because I find that dangerous because it's not the right
- 21:19platform for every business. If it was you wouldn't need
- 21:22other platforms when you bloody well do.
- 21:23And choice is important and I think encouraging choice rather
- 21:26than shouting or shooting down alternatives is more positive
- 21:31for the industry. So that's my only bit caution
- 21:33around Shopify. But yeah overall their year very
- 21:36impressive road map and and and and future plans for enterprise
- 21:40next year Composable. Let's talk about about that
- 21:45because I think in 2022 the the amount of noise and PR around
- 21:50composable composable Mac Composable was huge.
- 21:54And you had and we know of a few projects which went down a fully
- 21:58composable route and burnt a lot of money at one which I think
- 22:01sacked off well over 1,000,000 Lbs before it pivoted an
- 22:04alternative tech. And I'm not denigrating
- 22:07Composable or Mac as the problem but evangelizing things and
- 22:12pushing things to businesses where they're not prepared for
- 22:14it isn't a good thing. So we've seen a slowdown in the
- 22:18number of new projects go down that full room and people.
- 22:21I I think I've seen people approaching composable is a
- 22:24strategy of I want a flexible platform where I can easily
- 22:27isolate and retire elements or I can integrate specialist third
- 22:30parties. But I don't need to build
- 22:33everything from scratch and create my own package business
- 22:37capabilities from a completely composable stack and and
- 22:40therefore build things that actually exist in in most
- 22:43platforms that I can just turn on.
- 22:45Are you seeing the same do you think do you think the the, the
- 22:49focus around composability and what I'm and who is right for is
- 22:53shifted? Yeah.
- 22:56So I think that I think we've got really similar beyond this.
- 23:00We obviously talk about all the time.
- 23:01I think that the fundamental process and you know thinking
- 23:06around composable by it's complete sense and I think the
- 23:09technologies that we're probably thinking of when we talk about
- 23:15maybe coming down market and they probably shouldn't have, I
- 23:19think have probably shot themselves in the foot a little
- 23:21bit because I think they're fundamentally good technology
- 23:24makes complete sense over here. But I think what's happened is
- 23:27where the market has been not struggling but just not been as
- 23:32you know strong as it was, they've just come down here.
- 23:35And then now you see these like you know enterprise solutions
- 23:38that are built purely for complexity targeting 1,000,000
- 23:42LB brands or. And I think that's been the
- 23:44problem and I think there's then been a number of failed projects
- 23:47that then led to some of those platforms not been seen as
- 23:50positively as they have in the past.
- 23:53I think the Mac alliance is really interesting.
- 23:55So that was a big part of the composable movement.
- 23:58I think 18 months ago, two years ago, even a year ago, I would go
- 24:03every CTO I spoke to just wanted to be involved in the Mac
- 24:06alliance and you know, wanted to learn more about Mac Alliance,
- 24:09wanted to invest their budget into the Mac Alliance.
- 24:12Whereas now every CTLI speak to, and this is really, really
- 24:16interesting, it's just talking about SAS and you know how will
- 24:20SAS benefits businesses in different areas.
- 24:24And I think you know a lot of the same principles around
- 24:26composable are still there, but I think people are looking to
- 24:30invest maybe in different areas than they might have been two
- 24:36years ago. I think you know complexity was
- 24:38like sort of knows you know the sensible make before.
- 24:41I might actually like building IP around being able to build
- 24:46you know and customize to your requirement.
- 24:49Now it feels like people are more looking to use solutions
- 24:54that do a higher percentage of the work and then invest in the
- 24:57areas that are going to grow your business or bring your new
- 24:59customers or whatever. Yeah, definitely this leads on
- 25:03to our next point which is the that integration layers are
- 25:06trending again not that they weren't never went out of
- 25:09fashion in terms of usefulness and projects, but I definitely
- 25:12felt a lot for a couple of years there were fewer my clients
- 25:15talking about it or or putting the time and effort into it.
- 25:17But actually now that specifically in the SME space
- 25:21that I work in, we're talking about businesses that that like
- 25:2510 million to to 50 million that because they want to get to a
- 25:30future state of compose ability. But they that you know they're
- 25:34not going to invest in something like a commerce source because
- 25:36it's just not right for them. They don't want to have that
- 25:38level of of of control and and complete and utter flexibility.
- 25:43But what they want to be able to do is put themselves in a
- 25:45position where in the future when they need to plug in a new
- 25:47system to e-commerce that they have that isolation of back end
- 25:51and from the the front end commerce piece and that they
- 25:55have that ability to do data transformation through that
- 25:57integration layer. So that they don't have that
- 25:58heavily customized commerce or you know God forbid do
- 26:01customization work in ERP which is always more expensive, time
- 26:05consuming and risky. So I've definitely seen that and
- 26:08you know I I the the bigger business I work with it seems to
- 26:11have been Siliga Mule Soft are the ones that every single
- 26:14project those are the two that are in there.
- 26:17But the SME space, I've seen Patchworks come back into a lot
- 26:21more conversations and we've had conversation about this in the
- 26:23past and we think that their last 12 months have been really
- 26:25stellar. I think Jim but since he's got
- 26:27it has made a massive difference.
- 26:29Their they shop and their focus on the road map.
- 26:32They've improved. Yeah, the the capabilities.
- 26:36I've added more connectors. They put that visual editor for
- 26:38creating data flow. So they're helping to create
- 26:40this low code no code ability. It's very rare that anything's
- 26:44no code but but yeah, it's just it feels like.
- 26:48It feels like more smaller businesses now are buying into
- 26:52the benefit of using an integration specialist like that
- 26:57rather than trying to just rely on out-of-the-box connectors and
- 27:01then a integration partner doing custom development.
- 27:04Are you seeing the same G thing? It's fair to say that integrate
- 27:07integration. Sexy again?
- 27:10I think it's definitely I mean yeah I think so like a lot of
- 27:14particularly like some of the bigger businesses I've worked
- 27:16with have definitely like you know invested budget in China
- 27:20lose 1 system to pass data around you know all of their
- 27:24systems or not one solution to pass data around all their
- 27:26systems. Yeah definitely I think I
- 27:28completely agree on the patch works piece.
- 27:31You know I think it's yeah crazy the impact or you you're
- 27:35assuming it's all gym but as had over there and you know they're
- 27:39doing a lot around partnerships a lot around position like I
- 27:43think they've yeah had a really solid year as well.
- 27:45I don't think you've got niche players.
- 27:47I think I mean that's just AI mean I completely agree with
- 27:49everything you said. The only other thing I'd say is
- 27:51like there's also a lot of like random small players in that
- 27:56market that charge an absolute fortune.
- 28:00But I think the the really interesting thing that I think
- 28:03around this space is like it'd just be interesting to see where
- 28:05it is in three years because I wonder, I wonder whether one I
- 28:11mean like we saw Shopify you know build out their connectors
- 28:15a couple of years ago NetSuite and that are like pre packaged
- 28:19connectors but like D365 naturally Manhattan, a few
- 28:24others and I think I don't think they've taken off.
- 28:27I've never known anyone to use them.
- 28:28It'd be interesting to see if and.
- 28:30There'd be a good. Reason.
- 28:33Yeah. Reason them like.
- 28:34Because because every time someone uses a default connector
- 28:38they realize that the 80% covers is is the easy stuff.
- 28:42Any custom data flows, any customer data like values that
- 28:47you need to pass or any transformation work then all of
- 28:50a sudden the connector doesn't work and then the cost to add on
- 28:54translation. Yeah, exactly.
- 28:57And I do think someone like some of the like integrated dot IO
- 29:01solutions, which is Siligo as well.
- 29:04Some of those aren't really built for like customization,
- 29:08stuff like that. But I think it'll be interesting
- 29:10in three years or so to see whether there is a lot of
- 29:14movement towards no code, because I think all of the front
- 29:18office solutions are just have invested in building like well
- 29:21documented, best in class AP is, but all of the back office
- 29:24system, every single one like still doesn't function in that
- 29:30way. So it'd be interesting to see
- 29:31how this means, because I think two years ago I probably would
- 29:34have expected that this area wouldn't have been as big, but
- 29:39it is. So yeah, yeah, interested to.
- 29:42See and and to be honest last year I wouldn't have expected in
- 29:4512 months time I'd be sitting there saying I'm really
- 29:47impressed with Patchworks and I don't mean this to call them out
- 29:50specific but I think they definitely had they dropped the
- 29:52ball on some of the the the way that they approached projects
- 29:55and the way that they handled like specs and documentation.
- 29:58But fact, I mean it's good, it's good that they've they're good
- 30:01that they fix that and that they're now back and the
- 30:03products stronger. And as we say in all elements of
- 30:07the e-commerce market, competition is good.
- 30:08And when when strong players drop off and it leaves only a
- 30:11few left, I think that can create a little bit of laziness,
- 30:15but it's easy to win business. So it's good to have healthy
- 30:18integration spark it. Now let's talk about the third.
- 30:24I learned we'll do the third party apps bit in a minute, but
- 30:28next thing is new platforms. So we've talked about a couple
- 30:31of these before and that is really interesting because you
- 30:34you look at Gardener's Quadrant, you look at Forrester's Wave and
- 30:37I think they're useful to keep an eye on what those big
- 30:41consultancies are rating and how they're moving around in their
- 30:43quadrants or their wave definitions.
- 30:45And it's it's really interesting to see proprietary platforms
- 30:50like THG Ingenuity in Gardener's Quadrant and they seem to be
- 30:55trying to to fix some of the concerns people had over the
- 30:58road map and the the operability of the platform.
- 31:00So again that's always used to know, but the big changes this
- 31:03year are two platforms we've had on the podcast.
- 31:07So number one is Sentra and #2 scale.
- 31:10So I know Sentra's done really well they they won Paul Smith
- 31:13which has launched B to B with with Ed and the team at Lime
- 31:18Sharp and B CS come in Q1 next year group and me and them.
- 31:22So they've they've got some big profile cards.
- 31:26What was impressed you about Sentra and why should I guess
- 31:30what UK businesses be looking at them as well?
- 31:35Yeah, so I really like. Centre, you know we've evaluated
- 31:39them quite a long time ago and I think they were really strong
- 31:43them, but they were very, very niche.
- 31:45Whereas now I think you know they've they've picked up some
- 31:48amazing brands like those ones are all massive wins in the UK,
- 31:51but they've also won like SAMSO and Denmark who are an amazing
- 31:55brand. And then they've got this like
- 31:57because there's so many people come into this market, you look
- 31:59at shop where like you say Spry could come into the UK market
- 32:03for B to CA while back like there's loads of others that
- 32:06kind of just come out of nowhere.
- 32:07But their portfolio particularly in fashion is insane.
- 32:11Like you know our legacy Santa Vista, there's so many of it and
- 32:14I think that one they've built a really good ecosystem of like
- 32:18creative focused agencies that have the engineering teams to
- 32:22work in the headless area. So I think that's really good.
- 32:28I think they've built a solid feature set specifically for
- 32:31fashion and I think now they they seem to be doubling down on
- 32:35the kind of water management and Omni side which they know their
- 32:39major confessors aren't strong in at the moment.
- 32:42So I've just been there a really solid platform for fashion I
- 32:45think and I've been said this to them before as well and I think
- 32:48you say the exact same thing. The thing that they need to do
- 32:53is you know a lot of brands aren't necessarily or they can
- 32:58be scared by headless and I think they need to essentially
- 33:04like address that head on. So they need to show the
- 33:07benefits of being headless. And you know how some of the
- 33:10brands that they're working with like the nudies and ascots and
- 33:14whoever else are benefiting as a result of having like more
- 33:18openness in the front end and the stack they've got.
- 33:23But overall, I think they're really solid actually.
- 33:26And I think they kind of sit really nicely in between the SAS
- 33:30players and the, you know, like best of breed or like you know,
- 33:34composable platforms. Yeah, definitely I'd.
- 33:39I really what what impresses me about them is the philosophy and
- 33:42attitude and they're very collaborative.
- 33:44And I I I love working with technology partners who are
- 33:49collaborative during the process of a build, even though an
- 33:51agency's doing the build and they are adding value and they
- 33:53are listening to the clients. And I guess one of the great
- 33:56advances centre have been focused purely on fashion and
- 34:00lifestyle is that there is commonality in terms of feature
- 34:03demand and they get that great ability when when when a couple
- 34:07of big customers say we really need this functionality maybe
- 34:10it's something to do with with Omni channel and stock
- 34:12visibility and ordering or maybe it's a merchandising they they
- 34:17are quite responsive in. OK.
- 34:19We'll put this into a road map and I think that's a that's a
- 34:21massive benefit if you're a potential customer looking at a
- 34:25vendor of how can you influence it because you can't do that so
- 34:28directly with with some of the bigger players like a sales
- 34:31source. Yes you have customer success
- 34:33teams. Yes you get to get feedback but
- 34:36unless you're one of the massive fish it's very hard to directly
- 34:38get something influenced so quickly in the road map.
- 34:40So I do like that the other platform that that I've been
- 34:45quite impressed by actually and and although it's a completely
- 34:49different proposition is scale. And the reason why I think it's
- 34:53worth for lagging and I know we did the episode but then some of
- 34:56you might have listened to the episode if not go and do have a
- 34:58listen to to the the founder story and to Rico Adlow's the
- 35:02the solution specialist like because they're interesting
- 35:04people and they're very knowledgeable, but they grew out
- 35:08of a 5 billion e-commerce retailer about you.
- 35:10So they are e-commerce people who've built a a proprietary
- 35:13technology, grown it to €5 billion business and now spun
- 35:18that tech out into a platform and now have hived that off into
- 35:21scale as a separate business running platform as a service.
- 35:24So all of the capability that Omni channel business needed
- 35:27including things like you know, the full Omni channel ordering
- 35:30and management into all, you know, order management end to
- 35:34end, it's got a, yeah, a, a PIM, not, not comparable to some of
- 35:38the marketing pins, but it's got decent solid PIM in it.
- 35:41It's got lots and lots of capability.
- 35:43And interestingly from a license point of view because it's
- 35:46charging 100 million plus businesses, it's .5% versus like
- 35:51a sales force which is typically around 1%.
- 35:54So it's got quite an interesting cost model on top of having
- 35:57loads and loads of features and I think it sets a specific type
- 36:00of business that wants something that a platform that provides a
- 36:04lot under the hood rather than bringing in lots of extra best
- 36:07of breed. So very different to to the
- 36:10satellite, Shopify's Bigcommerce which is all about apps and an
- 36:12interconnected ecosystem. This is more about lots of core
- 36:16functionality. So, yeah, I I have been
- 36:18impressed and I I also like their philosophical outlook and
- 36:22how they approach clients. I don't know what you've made us
- 36:25of scale this year. Yes, I haven't seen it as.
- 36:29Closely as you have. You know, I've obviously
- 36:32listened to the podcast and I've spoken to them a couple of
- 36:35times, but they seem impressive. The other thing that I've
- 36:38definitely noticed is that they're very well connected
- 36:41because, you know, a lot of people are talking about, yeah,
- 36:44very quickly. So I'm intrigued to hear more
- 36:47about them I think. And then the other one would
- 36:50probably be shop line, which will be interesting to see how
- 36:53they get on next year. So I think both of that, I've
- 36:56certainly only seen bits of that I want to do an episode with
- 36:59them, but they are massive in Asia, in certain Asian markets.
- 37:04So yeah, I'm quite intrigued to see how they kind of go to
- 37:07market next year, but they are picking up a few deals and I
- 37:10have started hearing about that more and more.
- 37:13Yeah, agreed. I'm I'm intrigued so and we
- 37:14obviously know so Steve back and and David who went across from
- 37:18big commerce they're they're they're smart guys and they know
- 37:21the industry inside out. So I'm intrigued on that GTM
- 37:24stuff as well. But I'm also intrigued to see
- 37:27how Shopify is it because at face value in terms of how it's
- 37:30positioned and marketed, it seems very, very similar and
- 37:32it's got its own payments etcetera.
- 37:33So I would, I'm really intrigued to get under the hood and see
- 37:36where the points of difference are and what type of business
- 37:38it's going for. And the other thing is yeah, as
- 37:42proprietary platforms because there are there, there's a
- 37:45couple of platforms out there where they they provide a
- 37:48platform and they provide the professional services and they
- 37:50build that probably don't get spoken about as much.
- 37:54But solidly going going along and acquiring not something
- 37:59that's the wrong way to do, but but less vocally going away into
- 38:02doing a really good job of maintaining their customers and
- 38:04acquiring new customers. And so like visual soft to get
- 38:07an honourable mention. But remarkable commerce is one
- 38:09that I see quite a bit of. I've been really impressed by
- 38:12Brad and the team over there are doing they, they really do know
- 38:16what their customers what when they focus their road map on it.
- 38:19So they've added some really cool stuff this year around
- 38:21trigger promotions. They've put a dam in as well for
- 38:23the CMS. They've done the Open AI
- 38:25integration. I know Open AI and you know
- 38:27ChatGPT stuff is table stakes now and platforms, but it's good
- 38:30to see these platforms that don't have such big development
- 38:33resources like some shop fire or big commerce putting this stuff
- 38:35in place for their clients. They've had marquee wins as well
- 38:39including hotter shoes and M and Co.
- 38:42So they're they're winning some really cool new clients as well
- 38:44as Main. They've got really good
- 38:45retention rate for existing. But what I love about it is
- 38:48they've got really interesting road map coming in 2024.
- 38:50So they're adding, they have a a really good like page builder
- 38:55CMS already in the platform native for those who don't want
- 38:59to invest in a specialist third party and they're adding
- 39:02personalisation in 2024. So I'm going to be keen to find
- 39:04out a bit more about what that means and what level of
- 39:06personalisation. But I think that's a really
- 39:07smart move. So you're really, really
- 39:09impressed at these platforms in the face of really stiff
- 39:11competition from businesses that obviously have deeper R&D
- 39:15marketing pockets are still doing really, really well and
- 39:18it's great to see that in the industry.
- 39:21So how about, sorry, but you're going to say something on that?
- 39:27Yeah, the last one I was. Going to add, I was just going
- 39:28to say commerce layer like I think given that they often go
- 39:36head to head with the, you know the commerce tools is and the
- 39:39other sort of the other ones, I think they've been winning some
- 39:41good brands and also they seem to be in a lot of the big tender
- 39:46processes. So I've been really impressed
- 39:47with that Rafa, I think was this year that was like the big one
- 39:51and we obviously have, we've had them on the podcast out of
- 39:54commerce layer. But yeah, I've just been quite
- 39:56impressed like I haven't actually seen loads of the
- 39:59platform, but I've been quite impressed with how they've been
- 40:01like chipping away at the market to be honest.
- 40:04I think they'll probably do fairly well in for certain types
- 40:08of businesses over the next year or two.
- 40:11Yeah, they and. From from when we look to them
- 40:13and the way that Felipe position is there, they've built a
- 40:18headless solution for engineers, right, for engineering teams.
- 40:22So if a business has its own in house resource and it wants to
- 40:26have greater control and it wants to drive a lot of
- 40:28development. It's a really well aligned
- 40:29platform. Yeah, interesting.
- 40:32Now let's do let's do our final bit which is like third apps,
- 40:35other functionality around the core platforms, what's hot,
- 40:38what's not and let's start with what hasn't been hot.
- 40:41And I'm delighted by this because it really wound me up in
- 40:4421 to 22 how obsessive people were talking about this Web 3
- 40:48and Metaverse, like how everyone's going to hang in the
- 40:51Metaverse, everyone's going to shop in the Metaverse.
- 40:52And I know there have been some successful brand collaborations.
- 40:57I know that that some of the big consumer brands and fashion
- 40:59brands have done some cool things.
- 41:02But but basically it it, it started off, I don't hear
- 41:06anybody and this is probably a reflection of the type of
- 41:09business I've worked with. But I don't hear anybody talking
- 41:11on any level about wanting to put any investment in this like
- 41:14are you still there is anyone in across your client base like?
- 41:19Not. I mean some areas of web free, I
- 41:22think some you know, web free technologies that were used in
- 41:25place in places, maybe some of the like the gaming stuff.
- 41:29But no, not at all. I mean I was really excited when
- 41:32it came about and like this kind of stuff people just looking to
- 41:36do because it was also new. But yeah, I think as some people
- 41:39predicted it has just kind of, yeah decent.
- 41:44Well, to be honest, I think we don't have any clients that are
- 41:47really, you know, looking like NFTS or some of the other areas
- 41:51that, yeah, people were looking up for.
- 41:56Yeah, exactly. I.
- 41:57I had a personal dislike of it simply because I work with a few
- 42:00businesses like brands who who hadn't got their basics right
- 42:03and we're willing to spend the money or fixing it for their
- 42:05customers and stuff that people really want.
- 42:07I better search better merchandise IT instead.
- 42:10We're quite happy to go and invest in some like absolutely
- 42:15bonkers NFT scheme, even though they had no idea whether their
- 42:18customers actually had the technology to.
- 42:21It's just I found that mental. So, so I'm not, I'm not
- 42:24denigrating it entirely, but I'm very glad that that the initial
- 42:27hype and the self-interest that was driving that hype has died
- 42:31away in a lot of e-commerce. The We talked.
- 42:36About live shopping About how it's I, I still think it's got
- 42:39real potential. I think I think if businesses
- 42:41look at it and understand it as an event management and
- 42:44marketing piece rather than just an e-commerce technology piece
- 42:47that they might they might be able to to to get some proper
- 42:50pilots working. So I've seen some good case
- 42:52studies over the years with with beauty and fashion where it's
- 42:54really driven good good sales volume and it's different
- 42:58encouraged people to shop wider across a product range by doing
- 43:02it. But it hasn't really gone
- 43:04anywhere. So I I'm going to go put my head
- 43:06out there and say I reckon maybe next year we'll see something in
- 43:10this, but I'm not. I'm not overly hopeful because
- 43:12I'm not hearing the chatter anymore about it.
- 43:16Yeah, I think, I mean. It's still massive in Asia and I
- 43:19think that's where a lot of it came from and I think you know
- 43:23TikTok still want to play on it as like, you know, a big part of
- 43:28their long term vision. But yeah, I think in order for
- 43:33it to become like the norm, like some of the bigger brands will
- 43:36need to, you know, focus on that.
- 43:39I think with drops and new launches and all of that, which.
- 43:42And I think that's the thing, like there's just not enough
- 43:45people doing it for it to become more mainstream.
- 43:48But I agree, it's got no potential.
- 43:52What I've always seen that's hot this year, loyalty has been the
- 43:55big one for amongst my clients and loyalty should always be
- 43:59important because we should be rewarding people for shopping
- 44:01and encouraging to. But I think what I've seen in
- 44:042023 is more businesses investing in specialist third
- 44:07party tech platforms. So that whether that's a yacht
- 44:11PO or you know, there are lots of different loyalties, there's
- 44:14smile, blue, yacht, PO, etcetera.
- 44:18But thinking beyond basic point swim prizes, which is for me,
- 44:22it's a very lazy form of loyalty is every time you spend you get
- 44:25some points, get a discount at the checkout.
- 44:28But given the fact that that retailers discount like crazy
- 44:32anyway, it kind of gets lost is OK you get an extra 5% off, but
- 44:36when you've been given 10% here, 15% oh you know buy 2, get one
- 44:41free, all this stuff. I find that just basic points
- 44:43doesn't really land and you've you don't seem to get such great
- 44:47redemption as I've said a lot Lord schemes where people have
- 44:49just got points and they're not using them because they're tuned
- 44:51out. The more of my clients are
- 44:53looking at tiers, how they reward people through behaviour
- 44:57to move up the tiers to get better perks.
- 44:59And the perks aren't just product based, they can be like
- 45:02free content, it can be events, it can be like you know
- 45:05anniversary gifts and but then the the big thing is people are
- 45:09now finally work or not. Not not obviously some were
- 45:13before, but more people are now realising that you've got to tie
- 45:15this in with other areas like reviews.
- 45:18If you want to take reviews seriously you've got to try and
- 45:20reward people for that positive behaviour.
- 45:23So looking at all that way, all the ways that customers define
- 45:27what what is valuable to them and then packed it, packing that
- 45:31into loyalty. I know loyalty was my big one.
- 45:35You said CDP, so do you want to talk about that?
- 45:39No. But I think these two kind of
- 45:42are a bit intertwined. So I think a lot of our clients
- 45:46are basically obviously retention is a massive focus at
- 45:50the minute. Oh, it has been, but it's even
- 45:51bigger than the minute. And then I think a lot of our
- 45:55clients are one of the number or one of the big things or one of
- 45:59the big objectives going into their road map is first party
- 46:03data. So I'd be there's different
- 46:05strands to that. So a lot of our clients have
- 46:08rolled out like membership and or VIP and they've tried to
- 46:13essentially get more people building accounts, more people
- 46:16giving them more data as part of an account build process or as
- 46:19part of it some level of process.
- 46:22And I think that together has been one major trend and I then
- 46:28think so essentially to capture more data And then I think that
- 46:33and more complex businesses wanting to invest in data has
- 46:38led to more people looking at CDPS.
- 46:39So we've definitely seen that as a trend.
- 46:43Clavio's new one has also put it on a lot of people's radars
- 46:46because there's a lower barrier to entry, a lot of people using
- 46:49Clavio and then you've obviously got other providers, you know,
- 46:53more specialist and maybe a bit more advanced.
- 46:56And then the only other one that I was also going to bring into
- 46:59that same groups thing was I think a lot of people are trying
- 47:05to plan for more changes around cookies and privacy.
- 47:11So things like you know if you look at Solomon in particular
- 47:15and how they proposition the account and it's like the base
- 47:18level of loyalty but realistic play.
- 47:20They want more data, one for personalisation and CRM but also
- 47:25for tracking purposes. So I think that's the other one
- 47:29that I would kind of like tie in together, but I think, yeah,
- 47:32those together are a massive trend at the moment.
- 47:37Yeah, yeah. Definitely.
- 47:41And the the other one that I would pull out is the Social
- 47:46Commerce and TikTok shop that seems to be in in especially in
- 47:50DC Brands. Everyone I don't work in in pay
- 47:53media, I know you guys do. That's the cool part of your
- 47:56agency side for everyone. I talk to TikTok shop is on
- 48:00people's minds and TikTok seem to be really doubling down this.
- 48:04I know like in the US they've got the partnership with Ship
- 48:06Bob to help businesses to be able to like use Ship Bob's
- 48:09fulfilment engine and network centres so they can you know DC
- 48:13brand. DC Brands can quickly launch on
- 48:14it and have all of their all the management done.
- 48:18I know you've talked about TikTok integration has been
- 48:20really important to a lot of your businesses.
- 48:22Have you seen, has this been consistent across all different
- 48:25industries or you've seen this focus in specific areas like
- 48:28fashion? So I haven't seen.
- 48:31Much around TikTok shop, I think a lot of our clients are still
- 48:36thinking about Instagram shopping as something that will
- 48:40get bigger and I think a lot of our clients used, but they do,
- 48:45they are taking TikTok very seriously for brand awareness
- 48:48and also as an advertising channel now.
- 48:52But I think it would just get bigger and bigger to be honest.
- 48:54And like Do Young in China, which is part of the same
- 48:58company in Asia, which part of the same pairing company.
- 49:01Like you know that's massive part of their strategy.
- 49:04And I think it will come to TikTok and our markets.
- 49:09But I think the other more interesting one will be
- 49:11Instagram. And like they recently removed
- 49:12the shop tab, which was surprising and a lot of our
- 49:15brands or at least one in particular really complained
- 49:18about that. But from what I understand
- 49:21that's still a big part of their plan.
- 49:23But I think it's like I feel like everyone knows this is
- 49:26going to get big, but they just don't know when that's kind of
- 49:28or at least everyone thinks this is going to get big.
- 49:31And I think TikTok seem to have more a plan then maybe Matt to
- 49:36do. But yeah, it's such an
- 49:38interesting area but I just haven't seen enough traction
- 49:43yet. But it's just a damn.
- 49:44Yeah, you assume it's going to be massive.
- 49:47I find it. Interesting because it's social
- 49:49is not my area. I deliberately moved out of it a
- 49:51while back because it's it's so nuanced and complex and you need
- 49:55to be on top of it day in, day out.
- 49:57And I'm a Luddite in my personal life.
- 49:59Haven't been on on. I still got Facebook for about 6
- 50:03years and I'm quite happy about that, right.
- 50:06So let let's stop there. Hopefully this has been useful
- 50:09for people. This is basically our our base
- 50:12download of what what we saw in 2023, what we thought was
- 50:15interesting, you know key technology trends fire in the
- 50:20comments. Wherever you've been reading or
- 50:22watching this, let us know what what else have you seen?
- 50:23What were your key technology takeouts from 2023?
- 50:26What do you think is going to really take off in 2024?
- 50:30Anything we've talked about you don't agree with, call us out on
- 50:33it. That's cool.
- 50:33We we we like listening. Then we're like having a debate
- 50:36and thanks for listening. Keep your ear open for your next
- 50:39episode and we look forward to you continue being a listener in
- 50:422024. Take care of him.
- 50:52For more information on this. Topic Head over to Re Platform
- 50:55dot FM for our audio podcasts to discuss a project or if you'd
- 50:59like to chat about any of the topics covered in this episode
- 51:01in more detail, please reach out to myself, James Gerd, or my Co
- 51:04host Paul Rogers via LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 51:06Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 51:08next episode.