Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 16. What banks can - and can't - do when a relationship breaks down: Simon Birmingham uncut
Transcript
- 0:00Why is it that banks have said we need to do something about domestic and family violence and financial abuse?
- 0:06Because banks have recognised that joint accounts, financial instruments, loans, deposits, all of those things that become ever more entangled in relationships can be used as weapons and that in using them as weapons, that can be inflicting trauma in a whole manner of different ways.
- 0:25Yeah.
- 0:25This is where the complexity between sometimes what the law says in all of those joint circumstances versus what the circumstances actually are is a difficult point.
- 0:35So guidelines have been developed to try to help navigate a pathway for banks and for staff and institutions through those difficult sets of circumstances.
- 0:48I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 0:49I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:58This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:09So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:39Simon Birmingham, Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Banking Association, which is the peak body representing the nation's largest banks and many smaller and regional banks too, and also the custodian of the Banking Industry Code of Practice, which holds banks to a slightly higher standard than they would otherwise be held to.
- 1:57And a really good setting for consumers to understand what their rights are.
- 2:01A critical setting.
- 2:02It really does spell out a number of those rights.
- 2:05Everybody, of course, expects a legal framework and banks are subject to a very strong and stringent legal framework, lots of regulatory conditions.
- 2:16many regulators, but then also the industry applied code of practice, which spells out in many circumstances, the expectations on banks, the commitments that they are giving, but also reflect some of the legal realities they face when they come up against privacy laws or other things that mean that steps people think should be easy aren't always that easy to fulfil.
- 2:38Obviously, I come from this having worked inside banks and the code is a really important framework for how people in banks work and what our customers wanted from us.
- 2:50I really want to dive into parts of the code and give people practical tips of the kinds of things that they can expect from their banks.
- 2:59The reason we're doing this podcast is because I'm really concerned about financial abuse and I want to raise awareness of that as a problem.
- 3:07Okay.
- 3:08but also talk about what are the things you might do if you're starting to share your money, share your accounts to help protect you, protect your finances, that you could be thinking about at the start, and then also talk about what happens if the worst happens.
- 3:24So maybe we can dive into the code as a starting point.
- 3:27I know it's got some specific sections in it that talk about joint accounts and what consumers can expect of their banks when they're going to start having a joint account.
- 3:38Joint accounts, of course, by their very name and title, indicate what it is and people step into that.
- 3:46Always, usually, hopefully, thinking the best in terms of what they're signing onto and in doing so, thinking that there is a joint access and joint pathways and that is accurate.
- 3:58There are also, because it is joint,
- 4:01then legal provisions that apply in terms of what can or can't be done by individuals.
- 4:08And that's one of the challenges that exists clearly when you're talking about circumstances where things have gone wrong.
- 4:15And so the code does provide some steps there in regards to what banks can do.
- 4:23listening, understanding, advising, trying to find certain pathways, but also what they can't do in the sense that joint accounts are legally held as joint accounts.
- 4:35Each individual has rights under those joint accounts, and that means that there are many things that banks cannot do just because one person asks without necessarily seeking the authority of the other person, which is
- 4:50why very sensitive and careful conversations are needed when things do go wrong and somebody is seeking help in those circumstances.
- 4:57Yeah, I've been talking a lot recently about joint and several liability.
- 5:02People think I get very nerdy because I really like terms and conditions and I've spent far too long reading people's terms and conditions, but I don't think a lot of people really understand what that means.
- 5:14construct is in a contract that it means both people are on the hook for a loan 100%.
- 5:19A lot of people think they're getting a loan.
- 5:20It might be 50-50 or something.
- 5:23So that's been an interesting conversation to me about joint accounts.
- 5:26So you talked about that code says here's what banks can and can't do, say, if somebody wants to exit a joint account because relationships change and circumstances change, obviously,
- 5:39What does the code say about changing those joint arrangements?
- 5:45So you can't just walk in and say, I want to exit an account, take half the money with me, and I want you to do it without any engagement with the other person.
- 5:58It's unfortunately, in terms of those difficult circumstances, the case that those legal rights, those legal obligations create a set of circumstances where
- 6:08Banks need to go through certain steps to uphold their legal responsibilities.
- 6:14The code tries to provide the basis for them to make clear what those legal responsibilities are in terms of where they do need to get joint authority.
- 6:27But also, and especially when it then comes to the type of guidance that's provided to banks.
- 6:32how bank staff should actually engage with people to do that sensitively in a way that is trying to achieve the best possible outcome that can meet the reasonable needs and wants of somebody who's making a request while upholding those legal frameworks.
- 6:51I think that's a really important point because for many years the banks have had and the ABA has had guidelines for the industry on better practice.
- 7:01And in particular, when we're talking about the issue of financial abuse, it does talk about, well, how should a bank respond when somebody does disclose domestic or financial abuse?
- 7:13I'm really interested in intimate partner relationships.
- 7:17as opposed to elder financial abuse.
- 7:21What does the guidance say there?
- 7:23Because, yes, there might be a legal construct, but there are safety issues as well, for example.
- 7:28Yes.
- 7:29are safety issues and so in the guidelines expectations for banks in terms of the conversations that can be had in confidence in terms of protecting certain information that people may share in relation to localities and those things that are sensitive to obviously a circumstance of potential violence harassment threats or intimidation and so
- 7:53making sure that staff are aware, appropriately trained.
- 7:58And that really goes, of course, to how to engage with a bank.
- 8:02And not everybody's going to be able to have the right conversation with the right person the first time.
- 8:10And so...
- 8:11going into as best you can outline the circumstances and why you are trying to exit an account or change in arrangements and making sure that you're then asking who is the right person to talk to and getting the person on the end of the phone at the end of the chat line if you'd rather type a message and don't feel like talking to somebody or the teller across the counter making sure that they're understanding that you want to make sure you're speaking to somebody
- 8:40who understands, is trained, is skilled and is able to help you.
- 8:44Sometimes that will be the first person you talk to, but sometimes it will be a case that because of the complexity, it's better that a specialist gets involved.
- 8:54Why is it that banks have said, we need to do something about domestic and family violence and financial abuse?
- 9:01Because banks have recognised that joint accounts, financial instruments, loans, deposits, all of those things that become ever more entangled in relationships can be used as weapons.
- 9:16And that in using them as weapons, that can be inflicting trauma in a whole manner of different ways.
- 9:24And this is where the complexity between sometimes what...
- 9:28The law says in all of those joint circumstances versus what the circumstances actually are, is a difficult point.
- 9:36So guidelines have been developed to try to help navigate a pathway for banks and for staff and institutions through those difficult sets of circumstances.
- 9:46Tragically, we've seen
- 9:49Things like the weaponisation of messages on account transfers, as well as the threats around what people will or won't do with assets and finances that people have.
- 10:02So it can manifest itself in a whole range of ways, and it's recognising those circumstances and that when they present themselves to bank staff,
- 10:15It can be traumatic, of course, for the bank staff too in terms of how they then try to navigate a response where they can see or feel the trauma.
- 10:26They want to help, but they also have legal obligations and responsibilities that they have to manage.
- 10:32And so the guidelines are important really for those frontline staff too in how they can be best advised to most sensitively perform their jobs and to get the outcome.
- 10:44Yeah.
- 10:44Yeah.
- 10:46I ran one of these teams inside one of Australia's biggest banks.
- 10:51I do remember being really surprised and shocked, but also felt very privileged that people were willing to tell us about what was going on in their life.
- 11:03I didn't ever think working in a bank, someone would tell me so much or tell the team so much.
- 11:10There's been research that does show, though, that people are more likely to talk to a bank about financial abuse than they are to go to a specialist service.
- 11:19Because you've got to separate your money, you've got to start again and disentangle and maybe even set up safe accounts as you're thinking about that, too.
- 11:28I think it's a really critical but...
- 11:32hidden role that a bank might play to support somebody.
- 11:36Can you tell me what else might be in the guidance then for the kinds of support that people would receive?
- 11:44So bank staff can provide assistance and referral and both can be important.
- 11:50You just mentioned before the role of financial counsellors and others.
- 11:56And so if the bank is the first place people go,
- 12:00There's absolutely nothing wrong with that because one of our key messages in all conditions of hardship and difficulty is always to go and talk to your bank early about what can be done.
- 12:11But they may also suggest that you speak to a financial counsellor, get some other assistance about how all of the pieces of the puzzle can be brought together because your bank is there to provide information.
- 12:23advice around those bank products, not necessarily the totality of people's financial circumstances.
- 12:32Then of course there's the elements of how people engage and so the expectations on bank staff in terms of the way in which they are honest about what can and can't be done, that they
- 12:44are compassionate in the way they go about that, but also the options that they can present in terms of how people may be able to act within their rights to establish some of their own financial assets or products.
- 13:00The advice about how that can be done,
- 13:04course how existing credit arrangements or other things will impact on that and making sure that people understand perhaps the transition steps that that might be necessary and it can happen in all manner of circumstances we're focused on perhaps the hardest of circumstances being those of family and domestic violence and and abuse but equally
- 13:30older couples and circumstances where a credit card might be in the primary name of usually, historically, the man who also historically is more likely to pre-decease,
- 13:47having conversations about, well, what will that mean?
- 13:50How do we manage those finances?
- 13:54Far more easily done before you're bereaved or in those circumstances of separation, let alone in those hugely difficult circumstances at FDV, than of course at the worst possible time.
- 14:11I'm glad you raised that as an example.
- 14:14It's one that I talk about all the time, actually, because most people will know a widow where they've then been told, what do you mean I don't have a credit card anymore?
- 14:24I've been using this credit card for years.
- 14:26But actually it was their husbands.
- 14:29And I say it's widows and husbands because that's what you hear about.
- 14:33Yeah.
- 14:34the data does show that that's how it works.
- 14:37And they're really surprised by that and then maybe can't get another credit card later.
- 14:43It's an issue that I would really like banks to fix.
- 14:47And one day maybe there will be a product that allows people to do that.
- 14:50Who knows, I'm not asking you for product advice.
- 14:52I know we're not talking about that.
- 14:54Okay, I can't do the product advice, but I hope that there can be some pathways through there, responsible lending laws,
- 15:01make it tricky in some cases in terms of the assessment that then has to occur for a new applicant, where often then fixed incomes are quite low in the retirement phase, whereas these cards and credit cards and so on have been held
- 15:20since somebody was working and had a much better assessment potential against those lending criteria.
- 15:26So there are tricky things there, some of it regulatory, some of it banking practices.
- 15:31I hope we can work through it.
- 15:32It's sort of it's front of mind because to be perfectly honest, probably as we're sitting here right now, I think my mum is in the bank, having told me she was going to go in today.
- 15:44Stepfather, her husband in aged care, knowing it will come at some point.
- 15:50Yeah.
- 15:51And is in exactly that circumstance where the cards are all historically in his notes.
- 15:56Yeah, and it's why I'm doing this podcast too, to help people think about what are these circumstances, not necessarily about financial abuse because it could be someone is ill or they're sick or they pass.
- 16:14But also there's been a lot of work in banking about fraud and scams and detecting those and preventing those.
- 16:22And I think a lot of the safer design and the monitoring that banks do may also apply to financial abuse because the tactics are quite similar.
- 16:33Can you tell us a little bit about how banks are responding and the kinds of things that they're doing to educate and protect people from fraud and scams?
- 16:43As an industry, there's been a very rapid journey to scale up in response to scams in particular.
- 16:51And people are, I think, long accustomed to the traditional fraud, somebody stealing a credit card or stealing a credit card number and using it without your knowledge.
- 17:02And systems have been built to try to respond to that and longstanding practices surround it.
- 17:07Scams are slightly different because it's where you or I as the consumer have been entrapped, convinced to spend our own money on something that doesn't exist or that we aren't going to get a return for.
- 17:23Investment scams, romance scams, all of those other sorts of things or concert tickets and footy tickets that don't exist, the whole range.
- 17:32Yeah, or, you know, the scams I've fallen for.
- 17:35So, you know, paying to get stuff off the docks when you've been internet shopping, for example.
- 17:40Yeah.
- 17:41That's all – oh, that's right.
- 17:42The link that you just quickly go through because you're in a hurry and you want that product that you thought you'd ordered but, you know,
- 17:50Turns out it's a scam or you've been scammed on the delivery, a whole range of them.
- 17:55And so tragically, this has been escalating significantly.
- 17:59Industry's brought in the ScamSafe Accord, which has seen new technologies, things like confirmation of payee.
- 18:07Many people would now realize when they go to transfer money, there's actually a process where you check the name and the account numbers and they all match up and get a green tick and it matches.
- 18:17Happy days.
- 18:19Bermot can transfer the money to Fitz and everybody goes on happily.
- 18:22However, if you don't get the green tick, you know,
- 18:26go and check, check that actually that is the right account number because there are circumstances of people sending out fake invoices that are impersonating another business and misusing those names or the like, all of those sorts of things.
- 18:41So the new technologies that are customer facing, a lot of new technology and investment that is back of house as well in terms of being able to
- 18:53data match dubious transactions, and then stop ones from flowing through.
- 18:59And again, a little bit of patience sometimes required in consumer land.
- 19:03We all expect things to happen instantly nowadays.
- 19:07If your bank is holding up a transaction, if there is friction there, there's usually a very good reason why.
- 19:13And that reason is often because the bank thinks that you're being scammed and is checking itself or advising you to go back and check and make sure that this is a legitimate transaction.
- 19:27Soon, we will have the government's new scam prevention framework in place, which is a world-first ecosystem framework where banks are held to standards about the type of technologies and standards we should apply, but so too will telecommunications companies and digital platforms.
- 19:44Because what we really want to see is scams stop at the source so that Facebook isn't as proliferated with scam ads in the future and people aren't tripping over Google links that ensnare them.
- 19:55Because just as banks can detect bank accounts and try to stop those transfers, even better if people have the links taken down in the first place so they're not clicking on the dubious scam at the start.
- 20:06Yeah, I think there's so much in the way that there's an ecosystem response to scams that can apply to financial abuse too.
- 20:16And that friction you talked about, it's what I've talked about in all my Design to Disrupt papers, that if you've got someone with malicious intent, how do you make it much harder for them to cause harm?
- 20:28And the losses from scams actually...
- 20:32pale into insignificance when you look at the losses from financial abuse.
- 20:37And yet we haven't yet got an ecosystem response.
- 20:40I think various parts of different sectors are looking at it.
- 20:45But the safety element of it, I think, makes it much more complex for people to step into that space.
- 20:51Having said that, we're working together on an incredible initiative, which I'm really proud of, the Financial Safety Alliance,
- 20:59partnership between the Australian Banking Association, Customer Owned Banking Association, Australian Retail Credit Association and the Australian Finance Industry Association.
- 21:11Many associations.
- 21:12You've done very well.
- 21:13I was just looking for my notes to see if I could remember to name everybody else.
- 21:18I'm really delighted by it.
- 21:19Can you talk a little bit about what we're doing together there?
- 21:23So financial safety by design, all about trying to provide for that collection of associations, but far more importantly, are members who are banks and financial institutions that face directly into customers
- 21:42how do they think about when you're doing those products, those terms and conditions and how they operate, the design and construct of them in ways that can help to minimise the potential for financial abuse or best respond in circumstances where financial abuse occurs.
- 22:01And it's about, as we've talked through, the law, the code, the guidelines,
- 22:09It's about really saying, well, all of those things are critical to how a response environment occurs, and no doubt each will be strengthened over time.
- 22:20But ideally, when you are designing a bank account, when you are doing the terms and conditions for joint loans or for other financial instruments, they are designed in a way that can best minimise the potential for financial abuse to occur.
- 22:37It's been such an eye-opener for me to take a look at the ways that various products and services are being weaponised, but I've seen some incredible initiatives across banks and other sectors, actually, to try and minimise that harm with deliberately thinking about how could someone misuse this and...
- 22:58So stepping then into a consumer's shoes, what do you think the opportunity is for them to be looking for safer product design as well?
- 23:07And the way that they set themselves up, say, with a bank account, that may minimise the impact if something were to go wrong.
- 23:16It does go to the fact that there's a lot about financial products and bank accounts that is commoditized and where people just see everything as largely being the same and then consider the narrow things that matter to them.
- 23:35Of course, we all care about interest rates, fees and charges.
- 23:40Some will care more about...
- 23:43branch presence or a personal presence.
- 23:45Others are very happy with a totally digital only experience, but there are other things to contemplate as a customer as well and trying to understand the totality of the product and especially when you are taking that leap to go from managing your own finances into that joint account or joint financial arrangement.
- 24:08Just thinking that a little bit more carefully about how does this work?
- 24:13How is it applied?
- 24:15We understand because of that commoditisation, the importance of the guidelines, the code, because they are a common standard and you don't get to be a member of the ABA without adhering to code standards and practices.
- 24:29So we really seek to enforce and imply that.
- 24:32But there is that opportunity for people to think, to ask the questions, and to look carefully at some of those product design elements too.
- 24:41Yeah, and I would encourage lots of people to control F in their terms and conditions and look for the words financial abuse because Australia is the first country in the world to have made it really clear in their product terms for customers that if you misuse our products for financial abuse, there will be consequences.
- 25:03Banks are the biggest adopters of those terms.
- 25:06How do you think that that has come about and why are banks –
- 25:12so keen to support such an initiative, which of course I'm promoting because I'm very excited.
- 25:20That's well, and we are looking forward to seeing the end result of that work and then being able to work through that application of it.
- 25:31But I think, again, it comes back in very similar ways to the comments I made before about why banks hit the code, the importance of the guidelines, that...
- 25:42recognition and is emphasized again a dual recognition that there's a responsibility banks have.
- 25:51to their customers and to society generally, but also to their frontline staff and others to try to get these things right and to respond to increased awareness and knowledge.
- 26:04And the reality is the understanding of financial abuse and of course of family and domestic violence overall is far greater today than it was in years gone by.
- 26:19The expectation, therefore, that institutions like banks can and do respond in ways that are compassionate and sympathetic and effective is far greater as well.
- 26:32And so these sorts of tools to try to, again, get it right at the source, to borrow from the scams language I used before about stopping scams at the source, giving it the terms and conditions and the product design better,
- 26:47then you can harm minimise before you've actually got the problem.
- 26:52I've described it to people too and said, you can't get on a plane and joke about terrorism, or you can't go to the airport and joke about terrorism and expect to get on the plane.
- 27:01You can't go to a footy match and abuse the umpire and expect to stay at the game.
- 27:09Why should you expect you're allowed to misuse a bank product to cause harm to somebody else?
- 27:14So I'm really pleased at the number of banks that have adopted it and also actually more broadly.
- 27:20There's now more than 80 brands that have these terms and conditions in place and Australia is leading the world.
- 27:27So let's see how that goes.
- 27:29My final question, and I've been asking everybody, how would you complete this sentence before you say yes?
- 27:40I'll do two because I've been commenting on the way through about customers and staff.
- 27:47So to those working in banks and in frontline roles, before you say yes or say no, try to put yourself in the shoes of people in possibly the worst circumstances.
- 28:02Possibly worse circumstances, they might be telling you as well.
- 28:06And think about their position and make sure that the way you respond is as careful and considered as it can be and as helpful as it possibly can be.
- 28:19Before you say yes to customers and consumers, take the time to make sure you've looked at the products, thought about whether this is the right thing for you.
- 28:33Just that little bit of extra time in almost any part of the financial transaction is time well spent to keep yourself that bit safer.
- 28:43I love it.
- 28:44Thanks very much, Burmo.