Latest / Bloomberg Law / Blow to Red States Legal Coalitions
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: We just took back Texas.
- 0:16Speaker 3: When Texas turned blue on election night, the focus was
- 0:19Speaker 3: on the Democratic wins for governor in the U.S.
- 0:22Speaker 2: Senate.
- 0:23Speaker 3: Seemingly overlooked was a critical win for Democrats in the
- 0:27Speaker 3: state attorney general's office, a win that will punch a
- 0:31Speaker 3: Texas-sized hole in the coalition of Republican attorneys general. Democrat
- 0:37Speaker 3: Nathan Johnson will take over one of the largest attorney
- 0:41Speaker 3: general offices in the country, an office that for the
- 0:44Speaker 3: last three decades has been in Republican hands and leading
- 0:49Speaker 3: the red states in high-impact litigation. It's one of the
- 0:52Speaker 3: most powerful, important offices in all the country, and I
- 0:56Speaker 3: plan to use the responsibility well.
- 0:58Speaker 4: I meant to depoliticize.
- 0:59Speaker 5: I campaigned on depoliticizing the office... I will.
- 1:03Speaker 4: I will.
- 1:03Speaker 3: It's a less political office than a legislator.
- 1:06Speaker 1: But it's important that we maintain, and in this case,
- 1:10Speaker 1: rebuild the rule of law.
- 1:11Speaker 3: In all, five state attorney generals' offices flip from red
- 1:16Speaker 3: to blue. Georgia, Iowa, Kansas, Ohio, and Texas. As a result,
- 1:22Speaker 3: there'll be no Republican attorney general serving in any of
- 1:26Speaker 3: the southern border states. Joining me is Bloomberg Law reporter
- 1:30Speaker 3: Jacqueline Thompson. So Jacqueline, what was the biggest upheaval in
- 1:34Speaker 3: the flip from red to blue in state attorney generals' offices?
- 1:39Speaker 6: So I think the biggest change we saw was Texas.
- 1:42Speaker 6: The Texas attorney general, Ken Paxton, and before him, Greg Abbott,
- 1:47Speaker 6: they were.
- 1:48Speaker 4: Such conservative stalwarts.
- 1:50Speaker 6: And they ended up in a situation where they saw
- 1:53Speaker 6: the federal courts dramatically change during those 10 years. They
- 1:56Speaker 6: saw more conservative judges get placed there. We saw the
- 2:00Speaker 6: Fifth Circuit get dramatically more conservative, and they were able
- 2:04Speaker 6: to really use that to their advantage, whether that was
- 2:07Speaker 6: countering the Obama administration on immigration. We saw that play
- 2:11Speaker 6: out again with the Biden administration on immigration. And so
- 2:14Speaker 6: they were able to file cases challenging immigration policies in
- 2:20Speaker 6: venues that they viewed as favorable to them with conservative judges,
- 2:24Speaker 6: take those up to the conservative Fifth Circuit, and then
- 2:27Speaker 6: take that up eventually.
- 2:29Speaker 4: To a pretty conservative Supreme Court.
- 2:31Speaker 6: So you can see how that all plays out well
- 2:35Speaker 6: for the AG's office, but that only works really if
- 2:38Speaker 6: you have a Republican attorney general, right? So now we're
- 2:42Speaker 6: in a situation where all of the border states are
- 2:45Speaker 6: going to be led by Democratic AG's offices. And I
- 2:48Speaker 6: think those AG's are going to have to decide, you know,
- 2:51Speaker 6: where do we want to pick these fights? Do we
- 2:53Speaker 6: have to pick them in Texas? I don't think so.
- 2:56Speaker 6: I think if you have California and you have the
- 2:59Speaker 6: Ninth Circuit, that seems on its face to be, you know,
- 3:02Speaker 6: just an easier situation, even though the Ninth Circuit itself
- 3:06Speaker 6: has become more conservative over time.
- 3:08Speaker 3: Explain how the states, whether it's the blue states or
- 3:12Speaker 3: the red states, form coalitions to bring the big ticket
- 3:16Speaker 3: kind of lawsuits.
- 3:17Speaker 6: So multi-state coalitions are, you know, honestly a relatively new
- 3:22Speaker 6: phenomena over the last couple decades. But Texas is really
- 3:25Speaker 6: key in bringing those together and creating those. You know,
- 3:29Speaker 6: AGs get to know each other. There are groups. We
- 3:32Speaker 6: got RAGA on one side for the Republicans. We got
- 3:34Speaker 6: DAGA for the Democrats on the other. And that's a
- 3:37Speaker 6: way that attorneys general can speak to each other, can
- 3:41Speaker 6: collaborate on litigation. Make sure that, you know, as they
- 3:45Speaker 6: have a responsibility to taxpayers within their states, they're not
- 3:49Speaker 6: replicating litigation in other places if they don't need to.
- 3:53Speaker 6: It's especially important now that the Supreme Court has said
- 3:56Speaker 6: we don't really want universal injunctions anymore.
- 3:59Speaker 4: And that's not really something you can use.
- 4:01Speaker 6: So you want as many states as possible to be
- 4:04Speaker 6: part of a lawsuit so that your court ruling can
- 4:07Speaker 6: apply to as many parties as possible. So when you
- 4:11Speaker 6: have states instead of private groups filing lawsuits, it leads
- 4:15Speaker 6: to court decisions having a larger impact.
- 4:19Speaker 3: Also, the size of Texas's attorney general's office is second
- 4:24Speaker 3: only to California's, with more than 4,000 people, including more
- 4:29Speaker 3: than 750 attorneys and 17 dedicated full-time to the state
- 4:36Speaker 3: solicitor general's office. So if you now have a Democratic
- 4:40Speaker 3: coalition with Texas joining California and New York, that's huge,
- 4:47Speaker 3: isn't it? The resources available to them.
- 4:49Speaker 4: That's a lot of manpower.
- 4:51Speaker 6: But I think we also have to keep in mind,
- 4:53Speaker 6: we don't know how many of these people are going
- 4:55Speaker 6: to stick around. I'm sure a significant number of people will,
- 4:59Speaker 6: but those in the leadership positions in the Texas AG's office,
- 5:03Speaker 6: I just can't see them sticking around for a Democratic administration.
- 5:08Speaker 6: It's just not what's in line with their politics at the.
- 5:12Speaker 4: End of the day.
- 5:13Speaker 6: So if we have what is effectively a conservative public
- 5:17Speaker 6: interest litigation shop shutting its doors, You have a situation
- 5:21Speaker 6: where all those people are going to be going to
- 5:23Speaker 6: other places. We don't know if they'll end up in
- 5:25Speaker 6: other groups that could be attempting to replicate what Texas
- 5:28Speaker 6: did from the stance of a private entity. We don't
- 5:31Speaker 6: know if they'll go to other states to help other
- 5:33Speaker 6: Republican AGs that are still out there go.
- 5:36Speaker 4: Out and enact that conservative agenda.
- 5:39Speaker 6: But you're right, it is so much manpower that they
- 5:42Speaker 6: can really bring to the Democratic AG side now. Just
- 5:45Speaker 6: the big unknown is what exactly does that look like
- 5:49Speaker 6: and who's going to be left.
- 5:50Speaker 3: So is there any feel for where they might place
- 5:54Speaker 3: their resources, what they might target besides immigration, I assume?
- 6:00Speaker 4: We'll have to see.
- 6:01Speaker 6: Nathan Johnson said he's going to, as the new Democratic
- 6:04Speaker 6: Texas attorney general, review what the attorney general's office had
- 6:08Speaker 6: been doing previously, decide whether or not he wants.
- 6:11Speaker 4: To keep those cases.
- 6:13Speaker 6: He suggested there may be some partisanship in play in
- 6:16Speaker 6: some of the litigation cases. and that the office would
- 6:19Speaker 6: not continue to pursue those. So, you know, as we
- 6:22Speaker 6: see some cases drop, obviously new ones will come in.
- 6:25Speaker 6: I think antitrust is an area that's been pretty bipartisan
- 6:29Speaker 6: in terms of states saying, hey, yeah, we're interested in
- 6:32Speaker 6: taking a look at this. Texas has some pretty interesting
- 6:35Speaker 6: consumer protection laws on the book. So, you know, this
- 6:38Speaker 6: is an opportunity for them, especially as we've seen quite
- 6:41Speaker 6: a few businesses start to move to Texas and start
- 6:44Speaker 6: to incorporate and base their headquarters out of there. All
- 6:48Speaker 6: of Elon Musk's companies have effectively moved from California to Texas,
- 6:52Speaker 6: but now they no longer have the benefit of a
- 6:55Speaker 6: Republican attorney general and may face more scrutiny under a
- 6:58Speaker 6: Democratic one.
- 6:59Speaker 3: So as you said, the new Texas AG is probably
- 7:02Speaker 3: not going to want to file in federal court there
- 7:04Speaker 3: because they're so conservative, not only the circuit court, but
- 7:08Speaker 3: there are so many district court judges that are conservative.
- 7:11Speaker 3: I mean, would he fare better by filing in state
- 7:14Speaker 3: court in Texas?
- 7:16Speaker 6: I think a lot of people think that is the case.
- 7:19Speaker 6: Texas has a relatively new statewide appeals court. It's the
- 7:24Speaker 6: 15th Court of Appeals. It has three judges. And it
- 7:27Speaker 6: was set up a couple of years ago to start
- 7:29Speaker 6: hearing appeals that involve challenges to Texas agencies and anything
- 7:35Speaker 6: involving a Texas constitutional question. And that is now fully democratic.
- 7:41Speaker 6: So if you're looking at what your odds are, Why
- 7:43Speaker 6: would you go up to a situation where you could
- 7:46Speaker 6: be at the Fifth Circuit where you have a conservative
- 7:49Speaker 6: majority and a Republican appointed supermajority when you can go
- 7:53Speaker 6: up to the 15th Court of Appeals on the state
- 7:55Speaker 6: side and, you know, have potentially better odds there, especially
- 7:59Speaker 6: considering that the margins on the Supreme Court of Texas
- 8:02Speaker 6: have also been dramatically changed. We saw all four of
- 8:07Speaker 6: the Republican incumbents lose their races on Election Day. So
- 8:10Speaker 6: now it's a five to four court with that. Still
- 8:13Speaker 6: a Republican majority, but it's not as strong as one
- 8:17Speaker 6: as before. Now, the question is, you know, if there's
- 8:19Speaker 6: a federal interest, is a party going to say, hey,
- 8:22Speaker 6: we have to do this in federal court? And if
- 8:24Speaker 6: you're countering the Trump administration, you're probably going to have
- 8:27Speaker 6: to go to federal court. So the state courts will
- 8:30Speaker 6: work on the state side. But when it comes to
- 8:32Speaker 6: more federal actions or what other people want to do,
- 8:36Speaker 6: and if they want to take it to a federal
- 8:38Speaker 6: judge and the federal judge says, yes, I want this case.
- 8:41Speaker 6: You know, that's sort of the cards you've been dealt.
- 8:44Speaker 6: And we'll see with A.G. Johnson how he'll play them.
- 8:47Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 8:47Speaker 3: So, I mean, I guess that leads to perhaps the A.G.
- 8:51Speaker 3: 's in New York or California or other states filing
- 8:56Speaker 3: in federal court there and maybe Texas not taking the lead.
- 9:00Speaker 2: Right.
- 9:00Speaker 6: I mean, you can still be a leading state in
- 9:02Speaker 6: litigation without it being filed in your I think you
- 9:08Speaker 6: do have to join up with another state. I think
- 9:10Speaker 6: it's kind of difficult to say, hey, I'm Texas and
- 9:13Speaker 6: I'm filing my lawsuit in New York. I think a
- 9:15Speaker 6: judge would be like, Texas, go back to Texas. That
- 9:19Speaker 6: is where you belong. But if they work together, the
- 9:22Speaker 6: states work together and they're able to say, hey, New York,
- 9:25Speaker 6: you're the leading state on this.
- 9:27Speaker 4: California, you're the leading state in this. You end up
- 9:29Speaker 4: in a situation.
- 9:30Speaker 6: Where even, you know, Maryland, you have the Fourth Circuit.
- 9:33Speaker 6: That's not exactly a conservative court itself. So you have
- 9:37Speaker 6: a lot of situations where we could really play around
- 9:40Speaker 6: with venue and see how attorneys general take advantage of
- 9:43Speaker 6: those opportunities.
- 9:45Speaker 3: Which states are likely to step into the breach when
- 9:49Speaker 3: Texas leads? Because it's just played this dominant role.
- 9:54Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, I think all eyes are towards Florida
- 9:57Speaker 6: right now. Texas wasn't the only attorney. general that flipped
- 10:02Speaker 6: from Republican to Democrat. We saw that happen in Iowa,
- 10:05Speaker 6: which had been playing a leading role. We've seen it
- 10:07Speaker 6: in Ohio. They played a leading role. So now everyone's like, OK, Florida,
- 10:13Speaker 6: you have a situation where you still are Republican and
- 10:17Speaker 6: You're one of the few states that really held on
- 10:19Speaker 6: to your Republican statewide elections. You have the 11th Circuit
- 10:24Speaker 6: Court of Appeals there, which is a conservative majority court.
- 10:27Speaker 6: You have quite a few Trump appointees on there. You know,
- 10:30Speaker 6: you have real opportunities. We have a lot of Trump
- 10:33Speaker 6: appointees on the district court as well. Everyone still talks
- 10:36Speaker 6: about Aileen Cannon. Appointed during the first Trump administration, we
- 10:40Speaker 6: saw how important she became during the Biden administration. So
- 10:44Speaker 6: there's a lot of others. Kat Mizell, she's On the
- 10:47Speaker 6: middle district of Florida, she's seen as a rising star
- 10:50Speaker 6: in conservative circles. There's going to be a lot of
- 10:53Speaker 6: opportunities for the Florida attorney general to really make his
- 10:56Speaker 6: mark here.
- 10:57Speaker 3: Stay with me, Jacqueline. Coming up next on the Bloomberg
- 11:00Speaker 3: Law Show, I'll continue this conversation with Jacqueline Thompson. Should
- 11:04Speaker 3: corporations be on the lookout to settle cases in some
- 11:08Speaker 3: of these red states before Democrats take over? I'm June Grosso,
- 11:14Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:17Speaker 6: Peanuts.
- 11:18Speaker 1: That's not sending a message. That's not punishing a big
- 11:23Speaker 1: corporation that hurt our kids.
- 11:25Speaker 3: Florida Attorney General James Offmeyer was the only state AG
- 11:30Speaker 3: to reject the multi-billion dollar youth safety settlement with META.
- 11:35Speaker 1: That's unacceptable. We will not capitulate. We will not sell
- 11:39Speaker 1: out when it comes to our kids. They need to
- 11:42Speaker 1: take this seriously. If they're going to treat it like
- 11:44Speaker 1: a joke, like an insult, then they're going to have
- 11:46Speaker 1: to fight. We got the best dang legal team in
- 11:49Speaker 1: the country. We will see them in court.
- 11:51Speaker 3: And that legal team may be in court a lot more,
- 11:54Speaker 3: perhaps leading multi-state actions for Republicans now that Texas has
- 12:00Speaker 3: a Democratic attorney general. In fact, Uffmeyer has been the
- 12:03Speaker 3: second most active Republican top cop in pursuing big tech.
- 12:08Speaker 3: He's also taken on culture war issues like abortion and
- 12:12Speaker 3: parental rights and leveraged state anti-discrimination and antitrust law to
- 12:17Speaker 3: drag huge corporations into state court. I've been talking to
- 12:21Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law reporter Jacqueline Thompson. Jacqueline, I believe Florida is
- 12:26Speaker 3: fourth in the size of the offices of state attorneys general.
- 12:31Speaker 3: It has about 1,300 employees with 400 lawyers among them.
- 12:37Speaker 3: But that still pales in comparison to Texas's more than
- 12:42Speaker 3: 500 employees and 750 lawyers. So will Florida always have
- 12:48Speaker 3: to band with other states? How will they make up
- 12:51Speaker 3: for that loss of resources?
- 12:53Speaker 6: Well, there could be an interest in the part of
- 12:55Speaker 6: the Florida state government in saying, hey, let's put some more.
- 12:59Speaker 4: Money in the AG's office. Let's hire some of these people.
- 13:02Speaker 6: You know, that would be up to the legislators and
- 13:05Speaker 6: the governor to determine the budget and appropriations there. And
- 13:08Speaker 6: I won't pretend to be an expert on any of
- 13:10Speaker 6: that or any of those dynamics. But, you know, that's
- 13:13Speaker 6: one way to think about it. We could see maybe
- 13:16Speaker 6: groups setting up in Florida and saying, hey, yeah, we
- 13:19Speaker 6: want to file our lawsuits here. And even though it's
- 13:22Speaker 6: a little harder as a group to file a challenge,
- 13:25Speaker 6: especially on the federal side, to prove that you have standing,
- 13:28Speaker 6: that you've been injured, that you have an ability to
- 13:30Speaker 6: bring this lawsuit in the first place. You know, I
- 13:33Speaker 6: don't think that's ever foreclosed any group from doing so.
- 13:36Speaker 6: So there's going to be opportunities there as well. And yeah,
- 13:41Speaker 6: maybe they do want to band up more with other states.
- 13:43Speaker 6: And that goes back to those multi-state coalitions that we
- 13:46Speaker 6: talked about earlier and the importance in numbers.
- 13:50Speaker 3: Texas and Iowa have taken leading roles in litigation at
- 13:55Speaker 3: the Supreme Court. With those two states turning blue, what
- 13:59Speaker 3: state is likely to step into the Supreme Court role?
- 14:05Speaker 3: Besides Florida, are there other states?
- 14:07Speaker 6: It can depend on, you know, what attorney's general priorities
- 14:12Speaker 6: are in any of those states. I think the Eighth
- 14:14Speaker 6: Circuit is really interesting. That's become a very conservative federal
- 14:18Speaker 6: appeals court. We've seen new judges come on there during
- 14:22Speaker 6: the second Trump administration after a wave of appointees on
- 14:25Speaker 6: there during the first Trump administration. And, you know, they
- 14:28Speaker 6: could have quite a bit of say there. So AGs
- 14:31Speaker 6: within that jurisdiction might find themselves taking on more of
- 14:36Speaker 6: a leading role I mean, West Virginia is also another
- 14:39Speaker 6: Republican AG's office that's been quite prominent. And we could
- 14:43Speaker 6: see any of these states really start to take up
- 14:47Speaker 6: the mantle here. I do think it is a little
- 14:49Speaker 6: hard when you lose someone like Texas. That state has
- 14:53Speaker 6: just been really at the forefront of everything. I mean,
- 14:55Speaker 6: go back to the 2020 election. They were the ones
- 14:57Speaker 6: who filed that action before the Supreme Court that said, hey,
- 15:01Speaker 6: let's overturn the election results. And, you know, it sort
- 15:05Speaker 6: of prompted every other state to get in the mix,
- 15:07Speaker 6: whether with them or against them or partly with them,
- 15:10Speaker 6: partly against them.
- 15:12Speaker 4: You know, it forced everyone's hand. Everyone had to get involved.
- 15:15Speaker 3: What's the reaction to this blue wave of state AGs?
- 15:20Speaker 3: Have any liberal organizations or advocacy groups been commenting on
- 15:24Speaker 3: how this could be a positive change for them?
- 15:27Speaker 6: I mean, I don't think anyone said it explicitly, but
- 15:30Speaker 6: I think that's sort of, you know, the undercurrent here.
- 15:33Speaker 6: But I think a lot of it is a sort
- 15:36Speaker 6: of wait and see game. You know, this is just
- 15:39Speaker 6: four years. Will it be just four years? Will this be,
- 15:44Speaker 6: you know, a revolutionary change or will it be a
- 15:46Speaker 6: one-off blip? And then Texas will go back to doing
- 15:50Speaker 6: what it's always done. And it won't make that much
- 15:53Speaker 6: of a difference in the long run, but it may
- 15:55Speaker 6: make a big difference in the next four years.
- 15:58Speaker 3: Might corporations be scrambling to make deals before the shift
- 16:04Speaker 3: in power?
- 16:05Speaker 6: I mean, I think tech is always a big area. That's,
- 16:09Speaker 6: I think, definitely a space where they might want to
- 16:11Speaker 6: strike a deal. But it's not like the Republican attorneys
- 16:14Speaker 6: general have been easy on tech either. They brought big
- 16:17Speaker 6: cases against Meta and other social media giants. And so,
- 16:21Speaker 6: you know, maybe those aren't the ones that necessarily want
- 16:24Speaker 6: to strike a deal right now.
- 16:26Speaker 4: But Maybe more clients.
- 16:28Speaker 6: In areas where you think of a Republican attorney general
- 16:31Speaker 6: being a little friendlier, like let's talk about the oil
- 16:34Speaker 6: and gas industry that comes to mind. That's so big
- 16:37Speaker 6: in Texas. If you're dealing with any sort of litigation
- 16:41Speaker 6: right now involving the state, they probably want to assign
- 16:44Speaker 6: that sooner than later.
- 16:46Speaker 3: And though Texas's attorney general's office is in Democratic hands,
- 16:50Speaker 3: it's not going to be completely smooth sailing.
- 16:54Speaker 6: One of the most important things to remember is while
- 16:57Speaker 6: we had an AG change, we had the state courts change,
- 17:00Speaker 6: the federal courts have not changed.
- 17:03Speaker 4: And if anything, the Trump.
- 17:04Speaker 6: Administration is taking last minute efforts to try to fill
- 17:07Speaker 6: the remaining vacancies on the Texas federal courts during the
- 17:11Speaker 6: slain duck session in Senate. So, you know, you have
- 17:15Speaker 6: a situation where these groups are probably happy to, you know,
- 17:19Speaker 6: not be facing as much scrutiny from the attorney general
- 17:23Speaker 6: in Texas. But when it comes to vindicating rights and
- 17:26Speaker 6: figuring out your venue, if it's something that involves a
- 17:29Speaker 6: federal claim, you're still up against the same Texas federal
- 17:33Speaker 6: courts that you were before.
- 17:35Speaker 3: It's going to be interesting to watch these changes come
- 17:38Speaker 3: January 3rd. Thanks so much, Jacqueline. That's Bloomberg Law reporter
- 17:42Speaker 3: Jacqueline Thompson. The day after a bruising midterm election for
- 17:49Speaker 3: his Republican Party, President Trump's first event was at the
- 17:54Speaker 3: construction site of the future White House ballroom.
- 17:58Speaker 2: Very powerful ceiling.
- 17:59Speaker 4: It's drone-proof.
- 18:00Speaker 2: It's missile-proof.
- 18:02Speaker 4: It's bullet-proof.
- 18:03Speaker 2: The sidewalls, the glass is bullet-proof and drone-proof. There's no
- 18:08Speaker 2: drone can pierce it. There's no bullet can pierce it,
- 18:11Speaker 2: no matter how big the glass. When you see it,
- 18:14Speaker 2: you'll see it coming. It's starting to come now.
- 18:17Speaker 3: The next day, he signed a proclamation to prevent future
- 18:21Speaker 3: changes to the Oval Office and the Cabinet Room.
- 18:26Speaker 7: We're making it a national monument and it will not
- 18:30Speaker 7: be allowed to be touched by anybody, destroyed, ripped down
- 18:33Speaker 7: by stupid people in order to build something in a
- 18:38Speaker 7: slightly different shape.
- 18:40Speaker 3: So apparently Trump is continuing to concentrate on reshaping historic
- 18:46Speaker 3: landmarks in D.C., But will his projects, like building a
- 18:51Speaker 3: triumphal arch or renovating a community golf course in D.C.,
- 18:55Speaker 3: face new hurdles when Democrats take control of Congress next year?
- 19:01Speaker 3: Joining me is Bloomberg Law reporter Suzanne Moniak, who's been
- 19:04Speaker 3: covering all the action, and there's a lot of it,
- 19:07Speaker 3: in federal court over President Trump's D.C. renovations. So Democrats,
- 19:14Speaker 3: when they take control... They could file lawsuits against these projects.
- 19:19Speaker 3: There are already lawsuits against each of these projects. So
- 19:22Speaker 3: what difference would it make to have Congress file a lawsuit?
- 19:26Speaker 8: The reason it may be of interest for House Democrats
- 19:30Speaker 8: in Congress to file their own lawsuit is because of
- 19:33Speaker 8: challenges that some people have had in contesting some of
- 19:36Speaker 8: these projects in court, specifically as it relates to standing,
- 19:40Speaker 8: which is whether somebody has legal grounds to bring a lawsuit.
- 19:43Speaker 8: A lot of times we've been seeing some of these
- 19:45Speaker 8: suits filed by historic reservationists or sometimes even by just
- 19:48Speaker 8: residents who say that a monument they used to enjoy
- 19:52Speaker 8: visually is now being harmed. It's an eyesore or whatever
- 19:55Speaker 8: it may be, and that they've been aesthetically injured, essentially,
- 19:58Speaker 8: and that.
- 19:58Speaker 5: That's their basis for suing.
- 20:00Speaker 8: We saw success with that in the lower courts in D.C.,
- 20:02Speaker 8: particularly as it relates to the ballroom case. That would
- 20:05Speaker 8: be Trump's efforts to build a brand new White House
- 20:07Speaker 8: ballroom after demolishing the East Wing. But then once it
- 20:10Speaker 8: reached the Supreme Court, the justices found that likely those
- 20:13Speaker 8: historic preservationists and the professor that they had cited who
- 20:16Speaker 8: walked by the White House ballroom area didn't actually likely
- 20:19Speaker 8: have standing to sue. That's put maybe in jeopardy, perhaps,
- 20:23Speaker 8: a lot of the other cases that had advanced similar
- 20:25Speaker 8: arguments of standing. So perhaps House Democrats had come in
- 20:29Speaker 8: with their own perspective and own argument as it relates
- 20:31Speaker 8: to standing. just to give maybe another perspective, another type
- 20:35Speaker 8: of lawsuit that could be successful.
- 20:36Speaker 3: Who is paying for these projects? Because Trump always says
- 20:41Speaker 3: that it's private donations. But I mean, do we know
- 20:44Speaker 3: who's really paying the bills for the ballroom now, for
- 20:49Speaker 3: the arch, the golf course?
- 20:51Speaker 5: It's a good question.
- 20:53Speaker 8: The ballroom, Trump has said on multiple occasions, is being
- 20:55Speaker 8: funded by private donations. Of course, there are people with
- 21:00Speaker 8: taxpayer-paid salaries who are involved in working on it. And
- 21:03Speaker 8: so that may be one area in which if Congress
- 21:05Speaker 8: wants to sue about something, or if Congress wants to, say,
- 21:08Speaker 8: put in a prohibition in a spending bill, they could even,
- 21:11Speaker 8: you know, limit ballroom construction, even though it's ostensibly funded
- 21:15Speaker 8: with private funds, just by getting at the staffers involved.
- 21:18Speaker 8: Other projects may need, you know, federal appropriations. I think
- 21:22Speaker 8: we're going to see the administration try to do a
- 21:24Speaker 8: little bit of maneuvering where they look for authorizations for
- 21:27Speaker 8: maybe similar types of things, For example, the Kennedy Center
- 21:30Speaker 8: already has an authorization for repairs. Congress has already said, hey,
- 21:33Speaker 8: here's some money for you to make what we consider
- 21:35Speaker 8: to be necessary repairs for the center. Could he use
- 21:38Speaker 8: that money to do something a little bit different? I
- 21:40Speaker 8: think that sort of might be a question that we
- 21:43Speaker 8: see if we see this administration kind of trying to
- 21:45Speaker 8: divert funds from one thing to another. It's something we saw,
- 21:48Speaker 8: for example, with border wall construction under the first administration,
- 21:51Speaker 8: where they took funds from the Defense Department. It remarked
- 21:54Speaker 8: for other purposes and said, hey, we're going to use
- 21:56Speaker 8: it to build the wall. It's not something this administration
- 21:58Speaker 8: is afraid of doing and certainly would be something that'd
- 22:01Speaker 8: be ripe for legal challenges if and when it happens.
- 22:04Speaker 3: So they could tack language onto broader spending bills to
- 22:09Speaker 3: restrict funds from being used for these Trump projects. But
- 22:14Speaker 3: that would run into trouble when it reaches Trump's desk.
- 22:18Speaker 8: Of course, Democrats can try to add writers or other
- 22:21Speaker 8: provisions in a broader appropriations bill that says, hey, no
- 22:24Speaker 8: funds can be used toward creating a triumphal arch or
- 22:27Speaker 8: no funds can be used toward, say, staffers who might
- 22:29Speaker 8: be working on the ballroom construction project. But of course,
- 22:33Speaker 8: for a bill to become law, first must pass the Senate.
- 22:35Speaker 8: And in the Senate, there is a 60 vote threshold.
- 22:38Speaker 8: Democrats have a solid majority in the Senate, but it's
- 22:40Speaker 8: not going to be 60. So already that's a significant
- 22:43Speaker 8: hurdle into getting that language through the Senate. Maybe if
- 22:46Speaker 8: for argument's sake, they do get a handful of Republicans
- 22:49Speaker 8: who Don't see that as a deal breaker. They're willing
- 22:51Speaker 8: to move forward with the bill, perhaps for something like
- 22:54Speaker 8: the Kennedy Center, which was congressionally authorized. There's a lot
- 22:57Speaker 8: of bipartisan support for that performing arts venue here in D.C.
- 23:00Speaker 8: If it were to get through the Senate, of course,
- 23:02Speaker 8: then it lands on President Donald Trump's desk, which would
- 23:04Speaker 8: then beg the question, say, if it's a government funding bill,
- 23:08Speaker 8: is Trump willing to say shut down the government over
- 23:10Speaker 8: a provision that restricts funds for one of his projects?
- 23:13Speaker 5: Maybe, maybe not.
- 23:14Speaker 3: And are there any Democrats who've come out and said
- 23:17Speaker 3: that we want to stop these projects when we have
- 23:21Speaker 3: oversight power?
- 23:23Speaker 8: It's not something I've heard specifically from appropriations leaders, or
- 23:26Speaker 8: I should say those that we expect to be appropriations
- 23:28Speaker 8: leaders next Congress. But Representative Don Beyer, whose district would
- 23:32Speaker 8: be directly affected, has expressed concrete interest in interviews with
- 23:36Speaker 8: Bloomberg government in doing something about this. So I think
- 23:39Speaker 8: there certainly could be interest among the Democratic Party. I mean,
- 23:42Speaker 8: a number of Democrats have been very critical of of
- 23:44Speaker 8: these projects. And it does kind of get at a
- 23:46Speaker 8: broader democratic goal, which is to rein in this administration
- 23:49Speaker 8: and impose more accountability and really specifically to take back,
- 23:53Speaker 8: you know, the power of the purse. Congress is, you know,
- 23:55Speaker 8: supposed to be the one to control spending, not the
- 23:57Speaker 8: executive branch. But we have really seen the executive branch
- 24:00Speaker 8: really expand its power in this area. I could see
- 24:03Speaker 8: congressional Democrats, you know, wanting to take some of that back.
- 24:05Speaker 8: And maybe they would see these DC projects as sort of, well,
- 24:08Speaker 8: maybe not number one priority. I think affordability for them
- 24:11Speaker 8: is number one priority, but it's somewhat symbolic. if taxpayer
- 24:14Speaker 8: funds are being used for what they might see as
- 24:17Speaker 8: a monument to the president rather than something that, you know,
- 24:20Speaker 8: may help everyday Americans in their view.
- 24:22Speaker 3: Suzanne, tell us about other ways that Democrats can use
- 24:26Speaker 3: their oversight powers to control these Trump projects.
- 24:31Speaker 8: Law professors and other appropriations experts I spoke to told
- 24:34Speaker 8: me that one other way in could be through contractors.
- 24:37Speaker 8: In addition to appropriations and, you know, passing bills, maybe
- 24:40Speaker 8: trying to force difficult votes, even if the bill isn't
- 24:42Speaker 8: going to pass, Oversight is going to be a key
- 24:45Speaker 8: area we're going to see from this Democratic-controlled Congress. They
- 24:48Speaker 8: could theoretically subpoena a contractor. They can also try to
- 24:51Speaker 8: subpoena government officials. That's a tougher battle. A private contractor
- 24:55Speaker 8: may not feel like they're on quite as strong ground
- 24:57Speaker 8: to resist a subpoena the way top administration officials might.
- 25:00Speaker 8: So that might just be another opening for House Democrats
- 25:03Speaker 8: to try to, you know, conduct more oversight over how
- 25:05Speaker 8: these projects are being run and being funded.
- 25:08Speaker 3: Let's go through some of the projects that are ongoing.
- 25:12Speaker 3: The golf course. The federal judge overseeing the challenge to
- 25:17Speaker 3: Trump's plans for a community golf course in D.C. has
- 25:21Speaker 3: hired or tapped a former Justice Department official from Trump's
- 25:25Speaker 3: first term.
- 25:26Speaker 5: That's right. Judge Ana Reyes in D.C.
- 25:29Speaker 8: Is opening an ethics investigation into whether Justice Department lawyers
- 25:32Speaker 8: may have committed misconduct in proceedings over this community golf
- 25:37Speaker 8: course that Trump wants to transform into a championship-style golf course.
- 25:40Speaker 8: Gulf Course facility. Obviously, that's under challenge here, as many
- 25:43Speaker 8: of these projects are. The judge over the weekend announced
- 25:46Speaker 8: that she intends to tap Jessie Liu, who was a D.C.
- 25:49Speaker 6: U.S.
- 25:50Speaker 8: Attorney under the first Trump administration. She's not officially appointed yet.
- 25:54Speaker 8: The Justice Department has an opportunity to object to her appointment.
- 25:57Speaker 8: Our response from the government on that is due this
- 26:00Speaker 8: coming Friday. So it remains to be seen if the
- 26:02Speaker 8: government will object. I can't speculate too much on what
- 26:05Speaker 8: the judge might have been thinking. She didn't put out
- 26:07Speaker 8: a big order about it. But it does seem obvious, perhaps,
- 26:10Speaker 8: that it was maybe deliberate that she picked a lawyer
- 26:13Speaker 8: who has Republican ties to be the one to conduct
- 26:17Speaker 8: an investigation into the conduct of lawyers for this administration.
- 26:21Speaker 3: Next, the Kennedy Center. Where do the challenges there stand?
- 26:25Speaker 4: Is it open?
- 26:25Speaker 5: Is it closed?
- 26:27Speaker 3: Is it renovating? Is it not? Is the name the same?
- 26:29Speaker 5: It is closed. It is closed.
- 26:32Speaker 8: So that one's a little bit of a weird case
- 26:33Speaker 8: where it's almost closed under a different authority that is
- 26:37Speaker 8: being challenged. They've said that it's being closed on an
- 26:39Speaker 8: interim basis for safety reasons. And every so often that
- 26:43Speaker 8: closure has been getting renewed, renewed, renewed, separate from those
- 26:47Speaker 8: allegedly temporary closure that has been continuously renewed for weeks.
- 26:50Speaker 8: The board of trustees, which Trump chairs and has appointed
- 26:54Speaker 8: the members of, is wanting to close the facility longer
- 26:58Speaker 8: term for a two-year stretch for renovations.
- 27:01Speaker 5: All of these issues are under litigation right now.
- 27:04Speaker 8: The judge in that case, Judge Casey Cooper, also in D.C.,
- 27:06Speaker 8: has blocked the Trump-led board from adding Trump's name onto
- 27:10Speaker 8: the building, the Kennedy Center. But whether or not they
- 27:13Speaker 8: can close is still somewhat of a live issue. He
- 27:16Speaker 8: had blocked the first closure. They had initially voted months
- 27:18Speaker 8: ago to close the facility. The judge found that they
- 27:21Speaker 8: hadn't considered enough information in doing so. The board has
- 27:24Speaker 8: since now voted again on that two-year closure. The judge
- 27:27Speaker 8: is going to be considering whether to lift that part
- 27:29Speaker 8: of his order next week.
- 27:30Speaker 3: Is there any litigation still over the reflecting pool?
- 27:33Speaker 8: There is pending litigation over it, but the judge didn't
- 27:36Speaker 8: rule in that case before the old color was torn
- 27:40Speaker 8: out and new color was put in. So ultimately, the
- 27:42Speaker 8: request was, you know, essentially not responded to.
- 27:46Speaker 3: So now Trump's triumphal arch. There's a lot of litigation
- 27:51Speaker 3: surrounding it. So initially, Vietnam veterans and an architectural historian
- 27:56Speaker 3: file suit. But then on the last day of October,
- 27:59Speaker 3: the state of Virginia and D.C. sued to block it.
- 28:03Speaker 3: Tell us what their arguments were.
- 28:06Speaker 5: Attorneys General for D.C.
- 28:07Speaker 8: And Virginia, both Democrats, filed a suit, I guess, right
- 28:10Speaker 8: around a week before the date of earliest groundbreaking for this,
- 28:14Speaker 8: you know, triumphal arch that Trump wants to build. And
- 28:17Speaker 8: essentially they were arguing, you know, when we talked earlier
- 28:19Speaker 8: about standing in this issue of who can show that
- 28:21Speaker 8: they are harmed by a D.C.
- 28:23Speaker 5: Project, D.C.
- 28:24Speaker 8: And Virginia were able to bring in a different perspective
- 28:26Speaker 8: as a local government than others had brought in before.
- 28:29Speaker 8: They argued that essentially it would hurt residents of those,
- 28:33Speaker 8: you know, state and, of course, the district. They talked
- 28:35Speaker 8: about property values for people whose homes would be now
- 28:38Speaker 8: having a view of this colossal arch.
- 28:40Speaker 5: They talked about traffic.
- 28:41Speaker 8: The arch is targeted to be on Memorial Circle, which
- 28:44Speaker 8: is right around the entrance into D.C. from Virginia over
- 28:47Speaker 8: the bridge. For anyone who's done that commute before, you know,
- 28:49Speaker 8: it's a high traffic area already. The idea of closing
- 28:52Speaker 8: that for construction, the administration has talked about having construction
- 28:56Speaker 8: almost all day, every day for months and months. would
- 28:59Speaker 8: be a significant bottleneck and a key commuter path for
- 29:02Speaker 8: the city. So they'd raised harms like that. The other
- 29:05Speaker 8: harms had been raised in a different lawsuit by veterans
- 29:07Speaker 8: who'd wanted to be buried at the Arlington National Cemetery.
- 29:10Speaker 8: And they had talked about views being obstructed between the
- 29:13Speaker 8: monuments and that cemetery by the arch.
- 29:16Speaker 5: So that case is still pending, but put on.
- 29:18Speaker 8: Ice where the judge ruled was over the states. And
- 29:20Speaker 8: so I think that was an example where we saw
- 29:21Speaker 8: a new harm being brought that perhaps was stronger. The
- 29:25Speaker 8: judge didn't say Anything about the other case, just put
- 29:28Speaker 8: it on ice. But perhaps that was a stronger argument
- 29:30Speaker 8: of harm, and that's the one she decided to rule in.
- 29:32Speaker 3: How did the administration respond to the traffic concerns and
- 29:37Speaker 3: the residential property issues? value concerns?
- 29:42Speaker 8: The administration has really just kind of stood by its
- 29:44Speaker 8: authority to do this. For this ARCH, they have a
- 29:46Speaker 8: somewhat more unique argument than in other cases. They specifically
- 29:50Speaker 8: are looking to a 1925 law that authorized the construction
- 29:53Speaker 8: of two columns in that space.
- 29:56Speaker 5: The columns didn't end up getting built.
- 29:58Speaker 8: As you may recall, shortly after 1925, there was a
- 30:00Speaker 8: significant depression. It wasn't the time for our country to
- 30:03Speaker 8: be building big monuments.
- 30:04Speaker 5: It ended up never happening.
- 30:06Speaker 8: They've gone and revived that and have tried to argue
- 30:08Speaker 8: that that gives them the authorization to now build this
- 30:10Speaker 8: arch and that Congress.
- 30:11Speaker 5: Has, in fact, intended it to be built.
- 30:13Speaker 8: So while I don't know that the Justice Department can
- 30:15Speaker 8: necessarily argue that it won't create traffic, I think they
- 30:18Speaker 8: really just kind of stood by their authority to do it.
- 30:20Speaker 8: And they've basically argued that they would be more harmed
- 30:23Speaker 8: by not being able to do so because, you know,
- 30:25Speaker 8: they have this authority to do it. They've also argued
- 30:28Speaker 8: that it's like a national security need, which is something
- 30:30Speaker 8: the judge really didn't credit too much in her opinion,
- 30:33Speaker 8: just because that it was an argument that, you know,
- 30:35Speaker 8: was raised fairly late in the day in the case.
- 30:38Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 30:38Speaker 3: And she was dubious that the 1925 law could authorize
- 30:42Speaker 3: the arch. The sheer improbability that a 100-year-old statute would
- 30:47Speaker 3: contain authority unknown to every previous administration to erect a
- 30:52Speaker 3: 250-foot arch at a principal location in the nation's capital
- 30:56Speaker 3: indicates how far defendants must stretch to justify this project.
- 31:01Speaker 3: A pretty clear repudiation of that argument.
- 31:04Speaker 5: I would say so. Definitely wasn't moved.
- 31:06Speaker 8: It does seem like this was a situation where they
- 31:08Speaker 8: wanted to build the arch and they found the authorization, perhaps,
- 31:10Speaker 8: is what she's suggesting there, as opposed to, you know,
- 31:13Speaker 8: that genuinely that that's a strong argument.
- 31:15Speaker 3: I give credit to them, though, for finding that 1925 law.
- 31:19Speaker 3: So what about the argument that these monuments need congressional authorization?
- 31:24Speaker 3: Was that touched on? Because that seems to me like
- 31:26Speaker 3: the strongest.
- 31:28Speaker 8: Well, I think that's kind of what she's getting at
- 31:30Speaker 8: when she says that she doesn't see that law as
- 31:32Speaker 8: authorizing it. In this case, DOJ is saying, we have
- 31:34Speaker 8: congressional authorization. See, look at this law. And she's saying,
- 31:37Speaker 8: I don't think that is congressional authorization for what you're
- 31:39Speaker 8: trying to do, which is not two columns. It's a
- 31:42Speaker 8: giant arch, which is different than two columns and obstructs
- 31:46Speaker 8: more than two columns might. And of course, it was
- 31:48Speaker 8: from 100 years ago, perhaps, you know, not what she
- 31:51Speaker 8: considered to be active congressional authorization today.
- 31:54Speaker 3: I have to read her order because it's very comprehensive.
- 31:58Speaker 3: She barred the government from initiating making or otherwise effectuating
- 32:03Speaker 3: any construction, excavation, demolition, land disturbance, utility installation, or roadway
- 32:09Speaker 3: closure activity, or any other construction-related activity in connection with
- 32:15Speaker 3: the Arch. It sort of reflects the fact that D.C.
- 32:18Speaker 3: judges are concerned that the Trump administration will start construction
- 32:24Speaker 3: finding loopholes despite court orders. I mean, she tried to
- 32:28Speaker 3: cover every base.
- 32:29Speaker 8: It does seem that judges are incentivized to be as
- 32:32Speaker 8: specific as possible when putting down these orders. I mean,
- 32:35Speaker 8: we discussed the Gulf course case earlier, that was a
- 32:37Speaker 8: case where the judge hadn't put down a specific order,
- 32:40Speaker 8: but had just said to the government, hey, in good faith,
- 32:42Speaker 8: please don't do anything irreversible to this park while I'm
- 32:45Speaker 8: considering the challenge. We saw the government cut down 450
- 32:48Speaker 8: trees with 12 hours notice. And now there's been a
- 32:51Speaker 8: lot of heated exchanges in that case. And the government,
- 32:53Speaker 8: as we discussed earlier, is under an ethics inquiry for that.
- 32:56Speaker 8: So I mean, certainly, I wouldn't be surprised if Judge Tutkin,
- 32:59Speaker 8: who's the judge hearing that the case over the arch
- 33:01Speaker 8: is looking at what's happening to her colleagues and looking
- 33:04Speaker 8: at other cases in her courthouse and thinking, hey, it
- 33:06Speaker 8: might behoove me and the integrity of these proceedings to
- 33:10Speaker 8: be very precise.
- 33:11Speaker 5: About what I don't want to have happen while this
- 33:12Speaker 5: case is pending.
- 33:13Speaker 3: Yeah, she had said at one point that she was
- 33:15Speaker 3: afraid she was going to awaken and hear that there
- 33:17Speaker 3: were bulldozers at the site, which wouldn't be out of
- 33:20Speaker 3: the question. Why only a two-week restraining order? What happens
- 33:25Speaker 3: after that?
- 33:26Speaker 8: Well, we are expecting actually today at some point by
- 33:29Speaker 8: the end of Tuesday, November 10th, to see a preliminary
- 33:32Speaker 8: injunction request from D.C. and Virginia in this case, which
- 33:35Speaker 8: essentially is just a request to block arch construction for
- 33:39Speaker 8: the duration of the proceedings. So initially, it was a
- 33:42Speaker 8: two-week block because the administration was scheduled to break ground
- 33:45Speaker 8: as early as November 5th. So there needed to be
- 33:48Speaker 8: a quick order if something was going to happen, if
- 33:50Speaker 8: that was.
- 33:51Speaker 5: Going to be delayed.
- 33:52Speaker 8: So we saw that quick two-week order that expires at
- 33:54Speaker 8: the end of next week, around November 19th, 20th. So
- 33:57Speaker 8: we are expecting that preliminary injunction, I believe today is
- 34:00Speaker 8: when the plaintiffs had indicated that they plan to file that.
- 34:03Speaker 8: They're asking for a ruling before her temporary order expires.
- 34:07Speaker 3: And this arch is actually before two federal judges.
- 34:11Speaker 8: There's been a number of lawsuits filed about the arch.
- 34:14Speaker 8: I think I've mentioned one by veterans, one by D.C.
- 34:16Speaker 5: And Virginia.
- 34:17Speaker 8: There's a third lawsuit by Arlington County, which is, for
- 34:20Speaker 8: those not from the district, it's a county in Virginia
- 34:22Speaker 8: or just outside D.C., And that county has also sued
- 34:26Speaker 8: for the Arch, kind of bringing similar arguments that we're
- 34:28Speaker 8: seeing from the state of Virginia as it relates to
- 34:30Speaker 8: traffic and, you know, issues for its residents. That case
- 34:32Speaker 8: has not been filed in D.C. That case has been
- 34:34Speaker 8: filed in the Eastern District of Virginia. The judge in
- 34:36Speaker 8: that case, Judge Brinkema, is going to be having a
- 34:38Speaker 8: hearing on that on November 20th, right around when the D.C.
- 34:42Speaker 5: TRO is expiring.
- 34:43Speaker 8: So, you know, we're going to be expecting a lot
- 34:44Speaker 8: of action on the Arch really just before the Thanksgiving holiday.
- 34:48Speaker 5: We'll see how it plays out.
- 34:49Speaker 3: That'll keep you busy during the holiday, Suzanne. Thanks so
- 34:53Speaker 3: much for joining me. That's Bloomberg Law reporter Suzanne Moniak.
- 34:58Speaker 3: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember,
- 35:01Speaker 3: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 35:03Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 35:08Speaker 3: and at www.bloomberg.com slash podcast slash law. And remember to
- 35:14Speaker 3: tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at 10 p.m.
- 35:17Speaker 4: Wall Street time.
- 35:19Speaker 3: I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg.