Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / When Wiretaps Cross The Line
Transcript
- 0:13Adam Stirling: So that's the items on the defended today.
- 0:22Adam Stirling: And themselves applies to the lawyer here?
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately, yes.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: So this was a Supreme Court of Canada case that is an interesting fact pattern.
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: And it was a criminal charge brought against a lawyer who was alleged to have engaged in advice that would amount to obstruction of justice.
- 0:45Michael Mulligan: And so the background of it is that the police were conducting a drug investigation, drug trafficking investigation, not with respect to the lawyer, but apparently with respect to one of the lawyer's clients.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: And in the course of that drug investigation, the police were able to obtain wiretap authorization.
- 1:09Michael Mulligan: And as is not uncommon in Canada, when there is a wiretap authorized, where there's some reason to think that, for example, a person might be speaking to a lawyer on the phone, right, to getting legal advice, there was a condition put in the authorization that the judge made for the wiretap specifying that the wiretap was to be live monitored, so like not just record everything and we'll go through it later, but instead have a human being listening to the uh intercepted telephone communications.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: And one of the other conditions, which is also not uncommon, uh is a condition saying that look, when this person who's live monitoring and recording the uh phone calls, uh when they uh uh have any reason to believe that the person being spoken to is a lawyer, they are to stop listening and stop recording.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: Okay?
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: So that's what was in place.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: Now in this particular case, what happened is indeed there was a civilian police employee who was doing this live monitoring, um, and the civilian employee uh uh was uh listening to an intercepted phone call, and it became readily apparent that the person making the call was speaking to the lawyer who eventually became the subject matter of this case.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: But rather than discontinuing listening, the civilian police employee kept listening and kept recording, uh, and recorded a uh phone call that went on for some about just shy of seven minutes.
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: Now, during that phone call uh that was recorded and recorded in a way contrary to the terms of that order, the uh it was alleged that the lawyer uh told this person about uh a upcoming search or search that might be conducted, and it was alleged that the lawyer had said something to encourage the person to get rid of evidence that might be detected.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: Now, that's not proper, obviously, or maybe you should not obviously, that's not proper.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: A lawyer is not your partner in crime.
- 3:10Michael Mulligan: Your lawyer is there to give you legal advice, not tell you to do things that like hide evidence or uh uh do things of that sort.
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: That's not how it works.
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: Now, the there were two uh issues uh that arose at the original trial in this case that went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: The first issue was with respect to uh this interception which occurred contrary to the conditions that were imposed.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: And the first issue the issue there was uh while the crown acknowledged that this was a breach of the lawyer's privacy rights because there were the warrant specifically for the wiretap specifically said you cannot record these things, and as soon as it becomes clear the person speaking to a lawyer who's being the who is the subject of the investigation, you've got to stop listening and stop recording.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: And the police just didn't do that.
- 3:59Michael Mulligan: Uh and so on that basis, the uh judge had found at trial uh that that was a breach that was acknowledged and uh ruled that the uh recording, all of it, um, should be excluded on constitutional grounds, not be usable.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: Now, the Crown was appealing that, but the other very interesting issue that arose here is the issue of whether the lawyer has the ability to waive solicitor-client privilege to allow, in this case, the entire conversation to be used.
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: Because what was happening is that the the judge at the original trial concluded that the first two and a half minutes or so of this phone call, or two minutes and fifteen seconds, they concluded was not solicitor-client communication, but the remainder of the phone call was some four minutes and fifteen seconds.
- 4:52Michael Mulligan: So there are some things that were required.
- 4:53Michael Mulligan: The judge said, Well, that's not solicitor client.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: The crown can use that subject to that charter argument, but the rest of the call, no lawyer, you cannot use that.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: And here's the thing solicitor client privilege is a privilege that belongs to the client, not to the lawyer.
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: A lawyer can't waive that on behalf of their client, only the client can.
- 5:12Michael Mulligan: And here, the client wasn't waiving that.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: And so the other issue was for the lawyer saying, Look, I want the whole phone call to be played.
- 5:22Michael Mulligan: Uh, I want to be able to use the rest of it.
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: Presumably, it gave some context or some further description about what the person should or shouldn't do.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so the issue then arose, can the lawyer do that?
- 5:35Michael Mulligan: Uh, because the judge found that that was solicitor-client privileged communication.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: The person calling this lawyer was looking for legal advice.
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: That's what was being provided, and the lawyer wasn't allowed to use it.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: And so the other interesting advice the other interesting issue is all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada on what is what are the limits to solicitor-client privilege, and can the lawyer use it to defend in this case herself?
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: Now that's unclear.
- 6:01Michael Mulligan: Now, I should pause here just for a moment so listeners know, there are very few things which are there is privilege in, and many people don't appreciate that.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: Like in the criminal context, there is no privilege over things said to doctors, priests, in most cases, spouses any longer.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: That was amended a number of years ago.
- 6:19Michael Mulligan: Most special privilege, or much of it is now gone.
- 6:22Michael Mulligan: And so it's important for people to know, first of all, if you're saying something to a counselor, doctor, priest, or someone else, they could well be required to show up in court and testify about what you said to them.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: That is uh new news to a lot of people.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: Uh, and in fact, there was a uh murder case in Victoria a number of years ago now where there's a woman who went to law school a few years, uh I think a couple of few years uh after me.
- 6:47Michael Mulligan: Um she was charged with murdering her husband, uh, and in the course of the trial, her counselor decided to come forward and give evidence about how she said she wanted to kill her husband uh during the some counseling session, right?
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: And so all of those other sorts of professionals may be discreet, but there's nothing privileged there, and in some cases, listeners should know that there are obligations on some of those people affirmatively to go and report the person.
- 7:11Michael Mulligan: So, for example, in the case of doctors, uh which can include things like um psychologists or psychiatrists, um there can be a positive duty to report somebody with respect to things like child abuse.
- 7:24Michael Mulligan: And so, uh don't count on there being any privilege if you're doing any of those things.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: You could well be reported to the police.
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: Now, the law does take seriously solicitor-client privilege.
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: And here, the eventual issue that the Supreme Court of Canada dealt with was the issue of whether an exception called the innocence at stake exception applies to lawyers who want to be able to use something which was said to them in the course of a solicitor-client relationship, that's providing advice, to defend themselves in a criminal case.
- 7:56Michael Mulligan: And that concept of innocence at stake as an exception to uh uh otherwise an almost sacrosanct privilege, uh has been applied in another context, which is informer privilege, informant privilege.
- 8:10Michael Mulligan: Like you have somebody who's a confidential police informant, the law recognizes almost absolute privilege over that person's identity.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: But there's an exception to that, the exception being innocence at stake.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: And so if you could establish that look, I appreciate the person's a police informant, and if they're identified, you know, they could be killed or something for doing that.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: But let's say they are the eyewitness to what took place, and that eyewitness could be the key to establishing that the accused person is innocent.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: That is an exception uh to that form of privilege.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada found that that same principle of innocence at stake, in this case for the lawyer, can be an exception to solicitor client privilege.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: But to make sure that that's only uh uh used in cases where it's necessary, the Supreme Court of Canada set out there's a two-part test.
- 9:02Michael Mulligan: Like, first of all, uh the lawyer would have to show that the communication could raise a reasonable doubt about their guilt if they're charged with something.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: Um, and then if that satisfied at a second stage, then the judge would examine the communications themselves to determine whether in fact it would likely raise a reasonable doubt.
- 9:20Michael Mulligan: And only in that circumstance could it be allowed.
- 9:22Michael Mulligan: And so you can imagine other circumstances.
- 9:25Michael Mulligan: Let's say, for example, a client in the course of getting legal advice says something like, and I'm gonna frame you for the murder, or something of that sort, right?
- 9:33Michael Mulligan: You can well imagine how the lawyer might be like, well, hold on, I have now been framed for the murder.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: I'd really like that.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: I'd really like to be able to tell everyone about how the client said they were gonna frame me and then did.
- 9:44Michael Mulligan: And so now we have this authority from the Supreme Court of Canada saying that that uh does exist as an exception to solicitor client privilege.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: And here, on this case, both on that ground, which could have also applied, but uh the Supreme Court of Canada ultimately analyzed and focused on the reason why the judge, first of all, uh found the entire thing to be inadmissible on the basis that the police uh obtained this recording contrary to the order that was put in place at the time the wiretap was uh was authorized.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: And on that basis as well found that uh that breach was a very serious one, uh, given that it was a uh you know breach of a specific term of this wiretap authorization, um, and on a what's called a 24-2 analysis, like analyzing whether evidence which is obtained in an unconstitutional manner uh or in breach of a constitutional right should be excluded, found that this was a very serious breach, and when applying uh the sort of inquiry that has to be weighed up when deciding whether evidence would be admitted, including things like the seriousness of the state conduct, uh the nature of the charter right that was infringed, and the society's interest in adjudicating a case on a merits, on its merits, uh, on that basis uh as well, found that this statement was properly not admitted at all, not the first two minutes, none of it.
- 11:08Michael Mulligan: Um one of the interesting things that the Supreme Court of Canada commented on, and this could be an issue uh in cases in the future, is the Supreme Court of Canada commented on the fact that despite having engaged in this uh improper continuing to monitor and record this phone call with the lawyer, in addition to doing that, that the uh police, Crown, uh there was no indication of any reprimand or ameliorative efforts or anything done to prevent either to deal with the person who did that or to try to prevent that in the future.
- 11:39Michael Mulligan: And uh that was one of the factors which the Supreme Court of Canada pointed to as making it uh more serious that this breach occurred in contradiction of the terms of the wiretap uh authorization, and uh that nothing was done in terms of reprimand or to ameliorate uh the uh uh that sort of thing from occurring in the future.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: So very interesting case on the Supreme Court of Canada, uh, and uh it demonstrates both um just how careful uh courts are to preserve solicitor client privilege and the fact that that belongs to the client, not the lawyer.
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: The lawyer can't just choose to breach it, but it points out how there can be a narrow exception where it's necessary for the lawyer to establish they they are innocent uh in in order to uh uh uh use communication that would have otherwise been protected.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada on solicitor client privileged communication uh and when a lawyer might be able to use it to prove that they are in fact innocent.
- 12:35Adam Stirling: Fascinating.
- 12:35Adam Stirling: We'll continue with legally speaking right after this.
- 12:38Adam Stirling: All right, we're back on the air here at 70s.
- 12:41Adam Stirling: We continue legally speaking with Michael Mulligan for Mulligan Defense Lawyer.
- 12:55Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: Well, this is uh really interesting to know about, I think, because uh I think many people now are used to the idea that you could go and sue the provincial government.
- 13:05Michael Mulligan: Now, that was not always the case.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: Uh in fact, the default provision in common law jurisdictions is that the crown has immunity from being sued.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Um, and that changed in 1974, August 1st, 1974, as a result of an act called the Crown Proceedings Act, which is what authorizes you to sue the Crown.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: Now, uh this particular case is, as you indicated, it's a case involving a claim of sexual assault.
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and it was brought only a few years ago.
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: And first of all, listeners should know that there isn't a limitation period for a civil claim for sexual assault.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: And that is so because there could be a wide variety of reasons why a victim of a sexual assault may not be in a position to bring a claim in a prompt way as might be expected for other civil actions.
- 13:55Michael Mulligan: And so there's no time limit for doing that.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: So that wasn't a problem.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: But this particular person who was suing, his claim was based on an allegation that in 1972, when he was 16 or 17 years old, uh, he was in O'Calla prison.
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: Uh and his allegation was that two of the jail guards there sexually assaulted him, causing extreme negative, life-altering trauma and effects that he suffered ever since.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so he finally brought this claim.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: And the uh claim started along, and uh there was no uh initial objection brought uh to this claim, which dated from 1972, and indeed the uh council for the province of British Columbia conducted an examination for discovery of this fellow.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: An examination for discovery in the civil context requires a person to show up uh and uh conduct a uh uh answer questions about the uh claims all that went along, and there was no issue about uh the Crown Proceedings Act or 1972 or 1974 until after the examination for uh discovery concluded.
- 15:02Michael Mulligan: Now, what is at least alluded to in this decision is it may be that at the examination for discovery it was firmed up or made clear that this was from 1972.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: And so that then led to the uh province of British Columbia uh applying to amend its uh defense of this case to claim that to say that I'm terribly sorry, but uh your claim is from 1972.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: You can't sue the crown prior to 1974, you're out of luck.
- 15:31Michael Mulligan: Um and first of all, the fellow objected to that amendment saying, well, you know, I'm not agreeing to that.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: If you that was your position, why didn't you do that?
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: Why didn't you say that initially?
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: Why do you put me through this examination for discovery?
- 15:44Michael Mulligan: Uh and then the uh application was brought by the province to allow the amendment to add this defense saying we're immune, you can't sue us for what your jail guards are alleged to have done in 1972.
- 15:57Michael Mulligan: Uh and then so the uh man who was suing amended his claim to add a second cause of action, claiming that the province uh head and the lawyer acting for the province uh head on the province's behalf uh caused uh committed an additional uh tort uh by breaching what was an alleged duty of care to the plaintiff to ensure that during the course of the litigation they didn't cause unnecessary psychological trauma.
- 16:22Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the claim was unamended to say, look, uh uh you re-traumatized me by unnecessarily examining me about this sexual abuse I suffered in 1972, I now want to sue you for that.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and so this came to a head because the province of British Columbia brought an application to strike out this man's claim in the entirety, in its entirety, on the basis that there was no genuine need for a trial here because this was hopeless, it couldn't succeed.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and so in the course of deciding that, uh the judge hearing the case had to first of all determine was this claim uh barred, the actual claim against the provincial guards barred uh because of that uh crown immunity that existed prior to 1974.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: Uh and in that regard, the uh judge hearing it looked at some prior cases.
- 17:15Michael Mulligan: The BC Court of Appeal has uh previously considered the issue about whether the Crown Proceedings Act was like retrospective, like did it apply to did it allow you to sue for things before it came into effect?
- 17:26Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal on that ground has found previously, no, it didn't.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Uh and in fact, there's a case brought it was brought in BC uh brought by uh a group that had their children apprehended uh from them prior to the Crown Proceedings Act, where they were seeking to sue for the harm caused by it, um, and that was denied on the basis that it just came prior to 1974 as a Duke of Parents case.
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: Um, and that was a result of uh children being removed from their care in the 1950s, and the Court of Appeal found no, you're not allowed to sue for that.
- 18:00Michael Mulligan: You're just out of luck.
- 18:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh found that uh the claim was hopeless with respect to the province because it occurred prior to 1974.
- 18:09unknown: Wow.
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: And then the judge had to deal with this novel claim, saying that uh the province had re-traumatized him and that the province and the lawyer owed a duty of care to him.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: And on that ground, the judge analyzed whether that is could be a novel basis for a civil claim, but ultimately concluded that no, it couldn't, uh, on the basis that the lawyer defending somebody does not owe a duty of care to the opposing party when they're doing their their duty to defend the civil claim, including doing things like conducting examination for discovery.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: And so on that basis as well, the judge found that this claim had no hope.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: And the net result, regardless of whether this man was as a teenager abused, sexually abused by the two provincial jail guards, uh, he cannot proceed.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's uh the import of something occurring prior to the Crown Proceedings Act.
- 19:00Michael Mulligan: Uh, and uh important to know that uh the f the your uh ability to sue the province is a gift from the province uh brought in by legislation, and without that you'd be left in a position where you could not do that.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: So that's the uh latest in terms of uh the implication of Crown immunity uh and uh why that Crown Proceedings Act is the basis for being able to sue the province at all.
- 19:22Adam Stirling: Michael Mulgan with Mulgan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 19:27Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 19:28Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 19:29Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 19:30Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 19:30Adam Stirling: All right, quick break, back after this.