Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Give Feedback That Actually Changes Behavior
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a moment every manager knows. You are sitting across from someone on your team, you have feedback to deliver, and you can already feel your stomach tightening. Luna: Yeah, and the worst part is you know the conversation matters, but you are not sure if the words you pick will actually land. Lucas: Right. And most of us default to one of two approaches. We either soften it so much that the other person does not hear the feedback at all, or we go the other way and just blurt it out and watch the relationship crack. Luna: There is a better way, I hope? Lucas: There is. And the research is pretty clear about what works. The Center for Creative Leadership ran a study a few years ago looking at what makes feedback actually change behavior. The single biggest factor was something they call 'behavioral specificity.' Luna: Define that. Lucas: It means you describe the exact behavior you observed, in concrete terms, without interpreting intent or adding judgment. So instead of saying 'you were dismissive in the meeting,' you say 'when Sarah was presenting the Q3 numbers, you interrupted her three times and said her projection was wrong without asking a follow-up question.' Luna: That is a big difference. One is an accusation, the other is a video replay. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is that the person cannot argue with the video replay. They were there. They know it happened. But if you say 'you were dismissive,' they can say 'I was not dismissive, I was just being direct.' Luna: So the specific language takes the defensiveness out of it. Lucas: It does. But here is the tricky part. You have to be specific with positive feedback too. A lot of managers think they are being nice by saying 'great job on the presentation,' but that is just as vague as a negative label. The person does not know what to repeat. Luna: So specific praise reinforces the right behaviors. Lucas: Exactly. There is a company that does this really well. At HubSpot, their marketing team has a practice they call 'feedback with evidence.' They require that every piece of feedback, positive or constructive, includes a timestamp and a quote or an action. When I heard about it, I thought it sounds bureaucratic, but the teams that do it report way fewer misunderstandings. Luna: Do you have an example from there? Lucas: I do. One team lead I spoke with told me about a junior content writer who kept submitting pieces with the same structural issue. The old way would have been 'your articles lack a clear narrative arc.' Instead, the lead said 'in your last three blog posts, the section after the intro starts with a new point rather than a transition. For example, in the post about attribution models, you wrote 'Let us talk about multi-touch' without connecting it to the problem you set up in the intro.' Luna: That is concrete. The writer can see exactly what to fix. Lucas: And the writer told me he actually appreciated it because he finally understood what 'narrative arc' meant in practice. And after two more pieces with the same feedback, the issue disappeared. Luna: What about the format of the conversation itself? Does it matter how you structure the feedback session? Lucas: It matters a lot. There is a simple framework called the two-by-two feedback matrix. You map feedback along two axes: behavior versus outcome, and positive versus negative. The idea is that you want most of your feedback to fall in the 'positive behavior' and 'positive outcome' quadrants, but you also need the 'negative behavior' quadrant when something is off. Luna: And the 'negative outcome' quadrant? Lucas: Avoid it. That is where you say 'the project failed because you messed up.' That is attribution, not feedback. You cannot change the past outcome. You can only change future behavior. Luna: So the matrix keeps you focused on what the person can actually do differently. Lucas: Right. And I think the most common mistake managers make is that they skip the 'positive outcome' quadrant entirely. They give corrective feedback, the person improves, and the manager says nothing. That is a missed opportunity to lock in the new behavior. Luna: I have definitely done that. Fixed the problem, moved on, never circled back. Lucas: And the research from the Center for Creative Leadership also found that the ratio of positive to corrective feedback matters. The ideal is about five to one. Not because you are artificially inflating praise, but because the corrective feedback lands better when the person knows you also see what they do well. Luna: Five positive interactions for every corrective one. That feels like a lot. Lucas: It does, until you realize that positive feedback can be as quick as 'hey, the way you handled that client question about scope creep was exactly right. You redirected to the contract without making them defensive.' That takes ten seconds. Luna: And it probably means the next time you need to correct something, they will actually listen. Lucas: Exactly. And speaking of listening — there is something else the best managers do. They ask a follow-up question after the feedback. Something like 'does that land with you?' or 'how does that fit with what you intended?' Luna: That gives the person a chance to process and respond, instead of just nodding and resenting. Lucas: And it gives you information. They might say 'I did not realize I was doing that because I was trying to speed things up.' And then you can work together on a solution. Luna: So the feedback becomes a dialogue, not a verdict. Lucas: That is the goal. And I would add one more thing. The worst feedback phrase in the English language is 'you always' or 'you never.' It is almost never literally true, and it immediately triggers a counterexample in the other person's mind. As soon as you say 'you always interrupt,' they are thinking 'what about last Tuesday when I waited for Jenna to finish?' Luna: And now the whole conversation is about the exception, not the pattern. Lucas: Exactly. So one concrete takeaway for anyone listening: before your next feedback conversation, write down the exact behavior you want to discuss. Use a specific time and place. Read it out loud to yourself. If it sounds like something a witness would say in court, you are on the right track. Luna: I love that image. A witness in court. Lucas: And a quick honest thing. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that is literally what funds making this many episodes. No ads, no sponsors — just people who find the show useful. Luna: Yeah, it is a small group, but it keeps us going. If the show has helped you think through a management decision, that is the only reason we are still here. Lucas: So if you ever wondered why there are no commercials, now you know. And back to feedback — I think the biggest shift for a new manager is moving from 'I need to tell them what they did wrong' to 'I need to help them see what they can do differently.' Luna: That is a reframe worth practicing. Lucas: And one last thing. If you give feedback and the person changes their behavior, do not forget to notice it. The next week, say 'I saw you let Sarah finish that whole explanation before responding. Thank you for that.' That simple sentence can undo months of resentment from previous bad feedback. Luna: Because you are showing that you pay attention to improvement. Lucas: Exactly. And that is what turns feedback from a dreaded conversation into a tool for actual growth.