Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP196: Heavenly Creatures
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, and I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes
- 0:17and Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. How
- 0:38are you today? I'm doing fantastic. I want to welcome everybody back to
- 0:42this week's episode of Crimes and Consequences. This is a story I didn't know
- 0:47about, and I don't think you know about. No, it's saying Parker.
- 0:51It's a New Zealand case. Yeah you don't. I didn't think they
- 0:54did bad things in news. I no. Apparently apparently crime is everywhere.
- 1:00Before I start, because this one's a doozy, I want to ask everybody
- 1:04hit whatever, but you got a hit to listen to us more. Just
- 1:08let people know you like us. I don't care how you do it.
- 1:11Just do it. Just talk to a friend. So I told you this
- 1:15is about Pauline Parker. She's born Pauline Reaper, Piper Yeah, and her
- 1:23friend Juliette Hume. So let me start with Pauline. Okay, okay,
- 1:29Pauline was born in New Zealand to her parents, Herbert and Hanora Reaper Pauline.
- 1:36She grew up in a blue collar, working class family, just this
- 1:38normal family. Her father was the owner of a fish market we did wholesale,
- 1:42and her mother ran a boarding house. Herbert her dad, he was
- 1:48known as a very gentle soul. He smoked his pipe, he was very
- 1:52small in stature, and he was just like a nice guy. Hanora,
- 1:56she was a loving wife and mother, like there's nothing wrong with them.
- 2:00The two had four children together and they had a common law marriage, so
- 2:06they weren't officially married. Yeah now like, at least in the state of
- 2:09Michigan, they don't allow that, but they had that, and I don't
- 2:13know how New Zealand works. But their oldest child was Wendy. In essence,
- 2:17she was what a good daughter would be back then. She didn't do
- 2:22anything wrong and they didn't really think she could do anything wrong. She was
- 2:25just like a good you know, she's a good kid. Yeah, just
- 2:29a little different than I was. Then there was Wendy's little sister, Pauline.
- 2:34She was a troublemaker of this very modest family and the family always worried
- 2:38since she was a little girl, like, what is she going to grow
- 2:43up to be? That's not good. That's not good. There wasn't a
- 2:46lot of information about her other two siblings, as they told you she was
- 2:51one of four, but it said that one child was considered okay to be
- 2:57a drooling imbecile. That's not what we would say this yeah, heart appropriate,
- 3:04that is yeah. And then I think this child had severe mental disabilities
- 3:07and ended up being locked away in a mental institution. But it's not all
- 3:12that clear. The youngest child died shortly after being born. The baby had
- 3:19a congenital heart problem and basically was I don't want to say born still born,
- 3:24still born, but was known to the family as the blue baby.
- 3:30Oh that is so sad. When Pauline was five years old, she got
- 3:35this bone infection she was diagnosed with enforced to spend months in the hospital over
- 3:42a three year span, and she had a lot of operations. I don't
- 3:46know exactly what the technical, scientific medical term for a bone infection was,
- 3:52but I do know that she spent a lot of time in the hospital,
- 3:54had a lot of operations. So why all these other kids were outside laughing
- 4:00and playing with friends. She was forced to spend all her time in a
- 4:05hospital bed. Wow, that had to suck as a kid and watch the
- 4:10kids from outside the window. She ended up walking with a limp for the
- 4:14rest of her life due to that condition. Now I'm gonna talk to you
- 4:17about Juliette Hume. Unlike Pauline, she was born in England to her parents,
- 4:24Henry and Hilda. She was born into a very intellectual family and she
- 4:29was the daughter of well known, highly celebrated physicist. His name was doctor
- 4:34Henry Rainsford Hume. He was one of four people who worked on developing the
- 4:40first British hydrogen bomb. Oh kind of like Appenheimer, Yes, right,
- 4:46she was thinking that, yeah, which eventually would be used during World War
- 4:49Two. The Hume family was considered wealthy, especially for those times. Her
- 4:55family moved to New Zealand in nineteen forty eight and Juliette was hospit realized in
- 5:00nineteen fifty three for tuberculosis. She was treated for four months and then discharged,
- 5:08but she would end up dealing with the effects of that her whole life.
- 5:11Juliet's father chose to relocate his family to christ Church, New Zealand after
- 5:18accepting a position as first Rector at Canbury University College. This position was sort
- 5:27of the president of the college, and he was ultimately responsible for running the
- 5:30whole college, the whole institute, like it's a big deal. That's why
- 5:34he moved. Juliet grew up in an entirely different world than Pauline did.
- 5:42She had horses, like I said, upper class family. Her mother was
- 5:47an aristocrat and immersed herself into the culture of other aristocrats to keep up appearances.
- 5:55We're talking way more high class in you and I exactly the kind of
- 6:00money. No, I'm not hanging out a country club. Nope, No
- 6:04going to balls everyone. When I was young, I was going to Kmart's
- 6:10kim close exactly together. Henry and Hilda raised their two children, Juliet and
- 6:15her brother Jonathan, in a sixteen bedroom stone mansion. Damn nice on tons
- 6:25of acres of land. Sixteen sixteen. Who cleans that house? Not missus,
- 6:30Hume, I'm sure of it. What the hell do you probably stay
- 6:35off? Like what the okay? I don't know, I'm not judging.
- 6:42Even though Juliette and Pauline were from very different backgrounds, they clicked as soon
- 6:47as they met one another. Besides their upbringings, the two girls were also
- 6:53opposite in their physical appearance. So Pauline, she was very small in stature.
- 6:58She stood five foot three inches tall, which is my height. It's
- 7:01not that small. I don't like I don't like being it's not small by
- 7:05four average. By four is average, which is a little tinier, dark
- 7:12hair, and a very very mean temper. Oh. Juliette was very tall
- 7:18for age. She was described as beautiful, had shoulder length, light brown
- 7:23hair. She was considered very pleasant, and she spoke with a British accent.
- 7:28Nice nice. Pauline was known to have very dark, very cold eyes
- 7:33because she's me yeah exactly. Some people described her as looking dead inside,
- 7:39and she was considered to look dumpy. Oh, but they quickly became friends
- 7:45like teenage girls do, I guess, well, she's I mean, think
- 7:48about it. Julietta is new and that's true. So they became friends quickly.
- 7:55After the human family located to christ Church. One of the things the
- 7:59two girls bonded over was their medical conditions, and that makes sense since they
- 8:03both have struggled with our health. They attended the same school, Christ Church
- 8:09Girls High School, and they quickly got to know each other. They usually
- 8:15hung out in Jim class. Oh I hated Jim class. I hated it.
- 8:20I hated it too. I hated it. I liked dodge a ball
- 8:22though, Yeah, dadge ball was fun. If you can dodge a wrench,
- 8:26you can dodge a ball. I don't think they played dodgeball in schools
- 8:30anymore. No, probably not. Anyway, since Juliet's father was a highly
- 8:35admired physicist, they could afford what most families couldn't as already you know told
- 8:39you. Pauline spent most of her time with Juliet at the Hume home,
- 8:43and one of the reasons was because Juliette had her own pony. Nice Nice.
- 8:48Did you ever see that Seinfeld episode which one where he talks about like
- 8:52who grows up with a pony? I saw all of them. The lady
- 8:56was like, I had a pony. Well, she get saw upset.
- 9:00I didn't have a back in Europe when she was a little girl. Yeah,
- 9:03okay, so she had a pony. Yeah. Pauline with her medical
- 9:05condition couldn't be is active, you know if she had this limp as other
- 9:11girl's rage, So she would ride Juliet's pony. And it made her feel
- 9:15about her. Yeah, on the pony, Pauline's limp, it didn't have
- 9:20any effect on her when she's on a saddle, right. And Pauline tried
- 9:24really hard to get her parents to allow her to keep a pony, and
- 9:30she really wanted to be part of the Horse and Pony club, but her
- 9:35parents were like, no, no, pony getting a pony. What her
- 9:39parents didn't know was that Pauline already had a pony. She did she kept
- 9:45a hidden away. I can't believe this. How do you hide a pony
- 9:48behind a padlock shed? And she had it for weeks. I don't know
- 9:52how she got the goddamn pony. I mean, like feeding it and just
- 9:56shoveling it shit, Like what is she doing with it? She's hiding a
- 9:58pony. I don't know. I don't I don't know. Man good for
- 10:05her, I guess I don't even know how she got a pony. Where
- 10:07did she get it from? Well? I do know Pauline had purchased the
- 10:11pony with the advice of Juliette, and nobody knows exactly where she got the
- 10:16money from. But I have a feeling Juliette gave it to her exactly.
- 10:20This type of sneakiness was common with Pauline. I mean that I feel like
- 10:26I know there was a pony there, but I might not. I don't
- 10:28know. She was known to sneak out of her house into boy's bedrooms during
- 10:35the middle of the night. I mean, oh, Pauline, you probably
- 10:37have before too. At least she wanted to. At least I wanted to.
- 10:43Regardless her parents, they knew how conniving their daughter was, which is
- 10:46why they became really worried when Pauline became so preoccupied with Juliet. Eventually,
- 10:54her parents did find out about the pony. Okay, but when they found
- 10:56out, they let her keep it since she'd already it's so long, Well,
- 11:01okay, you can, I mean, doesn't it take I don't know,
- 11:05then, That's what I'm saying. I mean, I've not a pony.
- 11:11I don't know the vet appointments from my tiny yorkist. I'm thinking like
- 11:16it's eating a lot and shitting a lot. I don't know anyway, the
- 11:20making doesn't a mcname sounds yeah, I don't know. Let's just go it's
- 11:24a small, tiny pony. I don't know pony would be cool. Yeah,
- 11:28all right, anyway, anyway, we're digressing. They knew that if
- 11:31they didn't let her keep the pony, she would metaphorically burn the house to
- 11:35the ground. She'd be passed, super passed, passed. They just didn't
- 11:39want to deal with it. Well, Pauline and Juliette's friendship seemed relatively innocent
- 11:46to the outside world. The girl's bond got the very dark very quickly.
- 11:52They had very intense imaginations. Let's just say. As they began to go
- 11:58closer and closer, they begin to create this makeup world called the Fourth World.
- 12:03Okay. They even invented a religion where they would appoint famous celebrities to
- 12:09be the saints of their religion. Did they list any of them? Okay,
- 12:15it was like Orson Wells, James Mason, and many other popular Yeah,
- 12:20some of the saints. I mean it was back in the day where
- 12:22Orson Wells, James Mason there, I don't know, randomly famous people we
- 12:28wouldn't know very much about now, but back in that time, if they're
- 12:31hot, I don't know. Many kids with wild imaginations have like imaginery friends.
- 12:37Okay, but they're getting a little bit old. Yeah, So that
- 12:41and they had entire backstories. They let their imagination run wild, and they
- 12:46get more and more immersed into this fantasy world. Juliette and paul even wrote
- 12:50stories that were set in the fourth world together, and that's okay. Yeah,
- 12:56they got nothing else going on, right, there's no Internet, a
- 13:01lot of time on their hands. They had the goal of becoming distinguished authors
- 13:05that would eventually get their stories published. Who knows. The friendship between Juliette
- 13:11and Pauline became more like an obsession with one another. And although many friends
- 13:16do become obsessed with each other and maybe even consider themselves soulmates or sisters,
- 13:22nothing compares to the ship that transpired between the brains of these two. These
- 13:28girls would become physically ill when they were apart. Okay, that's a little
- 13:33weird, strange. I mean, I love you today, but I don't.
- 13:37I don't. It hurts a little, but I don't get sick.
- 13:41I would compare their friendship to an addict, like going through withdrawals when they
- 13:46weren't around each other. Yeah, they were like drugs to each other.
- 13:50They became each other's entire world, and when they were together, they had
- 13:54that made up realm and they grew more and more distant from reality. So
- 14:00if they don't have each other, then they don't have that new reality and
- 14:05they're lost in the real world. Both sets of parents became very worried about
- 14:09their daughters, and since this case took place in the mid nineteen fifties,
- 14:13the parents were really more concerned that their daughters might be les. Oh okay,
- 14:20they were thinking, okay, that would be horrible, that would be
- 14:24a horrible existence. Right. Yeah. During that time in New Zealand,
- 14:28homosexuality was considered a sign of mental illness and it was actually punishable with a
- 14:35felony. Are you kidding? No? Wow. The girls were accused of
- 14:39being in the same sex relationship constantly, and we will circle around to this
- 14:46a little later. Their parents got concerned They're spending every day, all day
- 14:50just with each other like nobody else. And Pauline's parents were very worried since
- 14:56now Pauline's sixteen and she was doing very bad in school, like her grades
- 15:03dropped, and they thought it was because of Juliet. Pauline's father said his
- 15:07daughter kept him totally out of her life, which I mean, my fifteen
- 15:11year old Yeah, right, that's true. Some kids do do their parents
- 15:15are uncool. While she lived at home, she would go out of her
- 15:18way to blatantly ignore her parents, because teenagers are as right exactly. She
- 15:24and Julia apparently had better things to do, and they were always writing about
- 15:28their new fantasy world. Pauline's father wanted to spend time with his daughter so
- 15:33badly. I get it, I get it, But she don't care.
- 15:37You're uncool? Hurt was it Herbert? She don't care, Herbert, You're
- 15:41uncool, she's sixteen, Let it go. She did share the stories that
- 15:46she wrote, and he was excited for He just wanted to connect with her
- 15:50any possible way he could. This is like when my daughter talks abop,
- 15:54K pop. She knows like all the groups, she knows all their names,
- 15:58and she'll tell me all about it and which is cool, but I
- 16:03don't remember their names and yeah, okay, good, I don't want you
- 16:06to. She goes into it a lot. Was obsessed right now. Pauline
- 16:10once got so excited about what she was writing. She blurted out to him
- 16:14that she was writing an opera. Oh what an opera and it was really
- 16:21rare, and he was really happy because she was opening up to him.
- 16:25He was just looking for anything. No, you're writing an opera. Oh,
- 16:27that's awesome. Do you know music? Do you know? Do they
- 16:32even sing in English? I don't know. I'm being I don't know,
- 16:36uneducated here. All Pauline's parents wanted was to have a happy family in a
- 16:41happy home. They wanted their children, both their all their children to do
- 16:45wonderful things. At one point, Pauline's mother took her to me to psychologist
- 16:49though you still got that lesbian. Worried about his name with doctor Bennett,
- 16:56and she wanted Pauline to talk about her friends and ship with Juliet. Pauline's
- 17:02mother told the doctor that her daughter needed to leave the high school. She
- 17:04needed to get away from Juliet. I don't think Pauline feels that way,
- 17:10and she thought her daughter would do better if their friendship had some time apart.
- 17:15Pauline, to her mother's surprise, agreed, okay, what Yeah.
- 17:21One day, Juliet's father called the Parker household let him know that he was
- 17:26leaving New Zealand and he was going to take Juliet with him. She's out.
- 17:30Herbert and Hana were so happy to hear that Juliet's getting the funk out
- 17:34of chame. There was light at the end of the tunnel for them,
- 17:37But for Pauline this meant that her entire world was going to crumble the pieces.
- 17:44So even though she agreed shouldn't really, I don't think planet, I
- 17:48don't. Yeah, Mom, I'm not going to use my cell phone.
- 17:49Yeah kind of the thing. You can trust me. Yeah, I won't
- 17:53talk to no. So it's nineteen fifty four. Juliette's parents made the decision
- 18:00to get a divorce. Oh and even though this wasn't the reason behind this
- 18:03separation, Like the girl's relationship, it seemed to be a simple solution to
- 18:08end the obsessive relationship between Pauline and Juliet. It must be really bad.
- 18:14Yeah, just give you some background into the lives of Juliet's parents. During
- 18:18this time, Henry worked, as I told you, as the rector of
- 18:22Canterbury University College, christ Church, and soon after we got that position,
- 18:26another Englishman named Walter Andrew Bowman Perry arrived at christ Church, New Zealand.
- 18:33After the arrival of Walter, the relationship and marriage between Henry and Helda was
- 18:41never the same. Henry was making really good money as a rector of the
- 18:45university. And Walter was an engineer, he was a charmer, and he
- 18:49was actually in New Zealand for a just a prolonged business trip. Walter and
- 18:53Henry both were deeply into the studies of sociology, and Walter actually promise that
- 19:00he would work as a mediator and a marriage counselor for Henry and Hilda.
- 19:04Oh that's so nice, so nice to work with the two of them so
- 19:08closely. Walter was invited to move in. What, oh, they have
- 19:12sixteen bedrooms. They have sixteen bedrooms, Come on in and help us with
- 19:17our marriage. Sure, okay, a stranger, and he agreed at the
- 19:22beginning of his counseling, even though he I don't know that. I don't
- 19:25think he's a counselor. Henry, Hilda and Walter they were all close friends.
- 19:32They were all from England and it was nice to have someone that understood
- 19:36the culture right and all of that. So they have this fellow Englishmen living
- 19:41with them. So what I mean, what could possibly go wrong? What
- 19:44marriage is on the rocks and they've got a not marriage counselor counseling them and
- 19:49for the marriage. Living with them, I don't see any problems, but
- 19:52sure there's going to be a surprise. One day, Juliet decided that she
- 19:57was done horseback riding and she wanted to sell her horse. Walter heard that
- 20:03she wanted to sell her horse, and he offered to buy it from his
- 20:07new little friend, even though he's only on a business trip. I don't
- 20:10know. So Juliette walked in to talk to him about it. Later,
- 20:15okay, and yeah, she found her mom and Walter having sex in Oh
- 20:21shit, Juliet found them. My bad da gotta be Oh that's fine,
- 20:27A little bit hard. Yeah. Yeah. Apparently Henry found out and he
- 20:33resigned from his position so he could go back to England. He'd been asked
- 20:38for some time to go back to England, so he knew he had a
- 20:41job. They're working on atomic research, yeah, hydrogen. Henry was going
- 20:48to take Jonathan with him, and you know that's Juliet's father, Yeah,
- 20:53and leave Juliet with her mother. The air in England wasn't good for Juliet's
- 20:59lungs because remember she oh, she had tuberculosis. Yeah, especially in the
- 21:04winter months. The human family was also concerned with the fact that the daughter
- 21:08had become so close to Dumpy Parker Girl is now The two girls, Pauline
- 21:17and Juliette, were concerned over how their parents felt about their relationship because they
- 21:22fantasized in their novels or whatever you want to you, their writings or whatever,
- 21:27Yeah, that they're going to America. They idealized the American dream because
- 21:33they saw the movies and they wanted it for themselves. Everyone knew that those
- 21:37girls were determined to get their way anyway they could, and everybody knew,
- 21:42as I've said, their friendship was unhealthy. They just didn't know how right.
- 21:48On more than one occasion, Henry made calls to Herbert discussing the friendship,
- 21:53and they had a plan that would separate the girls before they had a
- 21:57chance to embarrass the family. Embarrass the family, so the dads are plotting
- 22:03to separate them. Hownry told juliet he had an idea of taking her and
- 22:07her brother to South Africa. Oh nice, I don't know what happened to
- 22:11England, maybe for a vacation or something for a vacation, but she could
- 22:15return without Jonathan to New Zealand to stay with her mother. If that's what
- 22:21she wanted. There's a lot of tension that was noticed between the forty six
- 22:25year old father and his fifteen year old daughter. Because she's only fifteen,
- 22:30the two had an unspoken understanding of the affair that was going on with Hill
- 22:34doing Walter. So apparently she didn't tell him, oh really, but somehow
- 22:38he knew and they just kind of that was that elephant. Yeah in the
- 22:44room. Hownry just knew his kids knew by the look in their eyes.
- 22:51And Juliette wasn't really good at hiding her emotions, and for mouth didn't say
- 22:53it, her face surely did. She probably was like when Walter came in
- 22:56the room, like, yeah, it's my guess. Regardless of the tension,
- 23:03neither one of them mentioned why any of this was happening to their family.
- 23:07Juliette reacted to her father's request to go to South Africa by saying,
- 23:11Pauline has to come with me. Okay, well that makes sense. Henry
- 23:17said, you know, Pauline tagging along, that's out of the question.
- 23:22That's not going to happen. But Juliette wasn't taking no for an answer.
- 23:26After this, Pauline and Juliette went to speak to Honora and she agreed wholeheartedly
- 23:33with Henry and said that it's just not Pauline is not going to South Africa.
- 23:37Oh maybe they were trying to convince her so that she could convince Henry.
- 23:42Honora's decision made the girls really angry, and their anger transformed into a
- 23:49plan to kill what Pauline's mother. Oh dang. The two discuss the plans
- 23:56and they were really enthusiastic. You would, honestly, you would have thought
- 24:00they were planning a surprise party. Pauline kept a diary and the contents would
- 24:06be heard as evidence when eventually there was a trial, and in it she
- 24:11didn't use real names. She didn't use her own name. Juliet was written
- 24:17under her pet name of Debra, and Pauline was referred to as Gina.
- 24:22Okay, oh, that's so sneaky and no one will ever figure it out
- 24:26right the code and wait till you hear clips of this diary. So now
- 24:30we're at June twenty second, nineteen fifty four. It's a gloomy winter day
- 24:34to send the outskirts of christ Church. Today was actually the first day of
- 24:38winter for New Zealand. Juliette and Pauline chose to invite Hanora out with them
- 24:45to Victoria Park and that is in a place called Cashmere Hills. Sounds lovely,
- 24:51you know. They stopped at a tea shot for a little bit.
- 24:53Let's get some tea. Yeah, and when they were done, they headed
- 24:56down a path further into the park. All three women were bundled up because
- 25:00his first day in winner, Juliette needed to get out the sights of Pauline
- 25:03and Hana to she the next stages of her plan. So she hurried around
- 25:07the bend in this path so no one could see her scattering the pebbles.
- 25:11I mean these rocks weren't that big. Yeah, I mean she has a
- 25:14whole bunch in her hands and not that bit. Pauline was unable to hurry
- 25:18ahead, would Juliet since she had to walk with that limp, so she
- 25:22stayed at her mom's side. But Pauline, like Juliet, was hiding something
- 25:29in her coat pocket. Half a brick. Oh shit, yeah. Juliet
- 25:34had brought the brick from her house three hours earlier and gave it to Pauline.
- 25:38After she was given this brick, which would be used as a murder
- 25:42weapon. Pauline placed the brick into the foot of winner her old socks.
- 25:48That way when she swung it. Oh, no, you know she could
- 25:52swing it. You could swing it right and bludgeon her mom. But before
- 25:57I tell you more, going to take a quick break. Juliette was still
- 26:04about sixty yards ahead of Pauline and Honora when a small pink pebble caught Honora's
- 26:11eye. Oh, so that's what she had, these pebbles. They were
- 26:14colorful. Yeah. Pauline played along and told her mom, Oh, look
- 26:18at how beautiful it is. When Honora bent down pick it up. Pauline
- 26:23was standing behind her mother. She pulled out the brick from her pocket in
- 26:27the sock, stood steadily, and swung a brick onto her mother's head.
- 26:33Oh. The brick crashed into Honora's head. She immediately fell to the ground
- 26:38and blood began pouring out of her head. But it was too late for
- 26:42Pauline to stop, so she just kept swinging and swinging and swinging over and
- 26:48over again, hitting her mom's head. Juliette sprinted back to them after the
- 26:55first blow and kneeled beside Pauline's mother from that position. She took the brick
- 27:00from Pauline and just started hitting Honora's head again and again and again. Together,
- 27:06Pauline and Juliet killed Honorah. That's terrible. Blood poured out of twenty
- 27:14four blows to her head and her face. It was destroyed. Oh no.
- 27:21Once they realized what actually happened, the two teen girls began to cry,
- 27:26oh, come on, uncontrollably, and they just looked at each other
- 27:30and that the woman they just killed in cold blood. They're watching as Honorah's
- 27:34blood is just trickling down her face down to the path. The plan wasn't
- 27:40complete, though. The girls had decided to make Honora's death look like an
- 27:45accident. Okay, sure she's been smashed in the face twenty four times,
- 27:49but if it loops accident. They were covered in blood as they ran four
- 27:53hundred yards back to where they had tea. When the two sobbing girls re
- 27:57entered the restaurant or tea shop, Pauline screened to the owner, it's mummy,
- 28:03like that accent I do. She wanted to say that her mother was
- 28:06in a terrible condition, and they both said, oh, I think she's
- 28:10dead. They tried to carry her, but she was just too heavy.
- 28:14Juliette blurted out, yes, it's her mother, as her voice was cracking
- 28:18through the tears. She just said, she's covered with blood. The shop
- 28:22owner asked where Honora was, and Pauline pointed down the path in the direction
- 28:29of where her mom's body was. As Pauline pointed, the shop owner her
- 28:33name was Agnes, Ritchie noticed that Pauline had blood splatter on her face.
- 28:37On her face, oh no, and Pauline could see the look in Agnes's
- 28:44eyes and said, please, don't make us go down there again. Pauline
- 28:48went on to explain that the three of them were coming back from wherever they
- 28:52were and her mother tripped on a plank of wood and hit her head.
- 28:59This is the this is the story, stupid. The police were called and
- 29:04other people showed up, and they saw Honora. It was obvious she'd been
- 29:10beaten to death, so Pauline had to improvise. She went on to explain
- 29:15that her mother just kept falling and kept banging her head and whacking her face
- 29:19on the ground as she fell. Come on, now, you fall on
- 29:23your face when you're sober, over and over and over over. I mean
- 29:27maybe once, yeah, maybe, but not over and over face and Juliet
- 29:34jumped in and tried to make pauline story, you know, more believable,
- 29:37saying I'll always remember her head banging. Agnes went ahead and she called her
- 29:45husband and she told the girls to use the SYNC to wash the blood off.
- 29:49Agnes remembered hearing Pauline and Juliette laughing hysterically as they watched off Honora's blood
- 29:56from them. Kenneth, who's Agnes's husband, He sprinted down the path and
- 30:02I think this is actually before the police came where Pauline had pointed to,
- 30:07and he found Honora, who was under a tall pine tree, laying on
- 30:10a bed of pine needles near the path. After seeing her kind of sprinted
- 30:15back to the shop to call the police. As I said, when the
- 30:18police and the ambulance arrived, it was like hello, Like she did not
- 30:22just fall. They ended up putting Pauline and Juliet in the police vehicle and
- 30:27Hanoor's body was taken away. A medical examiner actually counted a total of forty
- 30:33five separate wounds, so some of them weren't to the face and hut twenty
- 30:37four. Unfortunately, for the girls, No one bought there bullshit, bullshit,
- 30:45thank you, and they were charged with murder. After they were arrested.
- 30:48It didn't take long for these girls to confess and the trial took place
- 30:52three weeks later. That's fast, Maybe that's a prelimb. Ye Juliet told
- 30:57this detective detective that she gave the brick to Pauline and that she knew that
- 31:03she put in a sock. She claimed she didn't know what was going to
- 31:06happen with a brick in a sock. Yeah, oh no, I don't
- 31:10know what's going to happen, and that Pauline was going to use it to
- 31:14frighten her mother so she'd allow them to go to South Africa. Really,
- 31:18really, I got a brick here if you don't. She then said that
- 31:22she saw Pauline her mother, with a brick, and she took the brick
- 31:26and hit Hanra. Juliet said that as soon as she saw Pauline with a
- 31:32first strike against her mom, she knew they had no choice but to kill
- 31:36her. She ended the confession with the fact that she was just so terrified.
- 31:41Really. Pauline was the next one to be interrogated by investigators. She
- 31:45blurted out, I killed my mother. Well, there you go, all
- 31:51right, that didn't take long. She confessed that she'd made the decision to
- 31:55kill her a few days earlier. She told the Texas that she had no
- 31:57idea how many times she struck her mother, but it had been many,
- 32:00many times. While Pauline and Juliet were in custody, Juliet's father, Henry,
- 32:06left to go back to England to start his new job. Oh should
- 32:08he laughed? Do you laugh? Well, she's arrested and he took her
- 32:12brother Jonathan with him. Fuck you, I'm Audie. The funeral for Hanora
- 32:19took place, and Hanora was buried in christ Church Cemetery. The only parents
- 32:23left in the raa where Pauline's father, Herbert and Juliette's mother Hilda. While
- 32:30Herbert was falling apart, internally, Hilda she was calm, cool, collected.
- 32:35She had to keep up those appearances because I remember, she's an aristocrat,
- 32:38and she chose to do so with her new man, Walter Walter Fireside.
- 32:45Walter must be fabulous, It's all I have to say. I thought
- 32:49he was only staying there for a little while. What happened Herbert had to
- 32:52take the stand, and he only needed to speak on two things, the
- 32:57boy that Pauline was seeing and how was daughter and Juliet were in such good
- 33:01spirits on the day of his wife's murder, because remember she used to sneak
- 33:06into boys rooms. Yeah, and she was in really good spirits the day
- 33:09of her mom got murdered. So how could she have possibly murdered her when
- 33:14she was so happy? And she was so happy. This murder took New
- 33:16Zealand by storm, and you know, everybody was paying attention. It was
- 33:22a notorious event. The trial drew a very large crowd, but it was
- 33:28only crowded until the local rugby team's match started. That was the thing to
- 33:32do until rugby season. Rugby in this region of the world is like NFL
- 33:37in America's the equivalent to some people's religion. It's like soccer in Europe.
- 33:43Yeah, and everybody eats, sleeps and breeze rugby. So the case was
- 33:46huge for a time and then you know, rugby started. But there was
- 33:52one piece of evidence that was a focal point for the trial. Pauline's diary.
- 33:57Oh yeah, the contents of a diary, along with the medical evidence.
- 34:01I mean to me. Hello, it's all pretty clear. Were what
- 34:05was used to find out the pressing question were Julia and Pauline of sound mind.
- 34:13Nobody knew m Prosecutor thought they were completely rational and that they were just
- 34:19demented, and the motive for the murder was crystal clear to him. Prosecutor
- 34:23told the twelve jars, you look at them and you think they're just two
- 34:28teenage girls, but don't have any pity on them. As he described everything
- 34:32that happened, and then he presented the diary that was discovered in Pauline's bedroom.
- 34:38The jury was utterly astounded at the thoughts that were written down about these
- 34:45sixteen year old girls and what was in their head. Through the trial,
- 34:47the girls tried to chat quietly, but they always had somebody sit between them.
- 34:52They're like, hey, yeah, your hair looks good today. So
- 34:55I'm going to read you part of the some of the infamous lines of Pauline's
- 35:00diary that she wrote February thirteenth, nineteen fifty four. It's a Saturday,
- 35:05she said, quote, I felt depressed at the thought of the day.
- 35:07There seemed to be no possibility a mother relenting and allowing me to go.
- 35:12She's most unreasonable. I also overheard her making insulting remarks about Missus Hume while
- 35:19I was ringing this afternoon I was living. I'm very glad the Hume's sympathize
- 35:23with me, and it's nice to feel adults realize that what mother is?
- 35:28Why could not mother die? Dozens people are dying all the time, thousands,
- 35:31So why not mother and father too? Life is very hard, damn.
- 35:36She loved her dad in there too. Yeah. Then on April twenty
- 35:39eighth, this is a Wednesday, she wrote, Mother went out this afternoon,
- 35:42so Deborah and I bathed for some time. Yeah, and Deborah is
- 35:46Juliet and they used to bathe together. However, I felt thoroughly depressed afterwards,
- 35:52and even quite seriously considered suicide. Life seems so much not worth the
- 35:57living, and death was such an easy way out. Anger against mother boiled
- 36:00up inside me, as it was she who was one of the main obstacles
- 36:04in my path. Suddenly a means of ridding myself with this obstacle occurred to
- 36:08me. If she were to die, I spent the evening writing, and
- 36:13I managed to finish my chapter. The next day, she wrote, I
- 36:17did not tell Deborah slash Juliet of my plans for removing mother. I have
- 36:22made no definitive plans yet. I'm trying to think of some way. I
- 36:28do not want to go to too much trouble, but I wanted to appear
- 36:31either natural or accidental. Oh, her mom's death, yea yea. Lastly,
- 36:37in that day's excerpt, she spoke about how she thought of murdering her
- 36:39mother and it never upset her. She asked herself if she was peculiar feeling
- 36:45that way. Yes, Hudley, Pauline, and Juliet used the term moiter
- 36:51rather than murder than the diary was their code word. Yeah. I thought
- 36:54it was really clever. You know, no one will understand what moiter means.
- 36:59The next day, a diary passage was presented to the jury from June
- 37:02twenty one. It's a Monday, says quote. I rose late and helped
- 37:07mother vigorously this morning Debrah slash Julia ring, and we decided to use a
- 37:12rock in a stocking rather than a sandbag. We discussed the waiter fully.
- 37:17Oh. I feel very keyed up, as though I were planning a surprise
- 37:22party. And that was the day of the murder. Mother's fallen in with
- 37:28everything beautifully and the happy event is to take place tomorrow, the happy event.
- 37:32So next time I write in this diary, mother will be dead.
- 37:36How odd? Yeah? How pleasing? Wow. The next page is the
- 37:42next day and it's titled the day of the Happy Event. Wow, bitch,
- 37:47I'm writing a little of this up in the morning before the death.
- 37:52I feel very excited. And the night before Christmas, ish was last night.
- 37:57Oh, she was like giddy, like it's before Christmas. I did
- 38:00not have pleasant dreams though I am about to rise. What those psycho?
- 38:05Yeah? What the fuck is that? So that was all right to the
- 38:07jury. Then, you know, the defense is all trying to talk about
- 38:12how Pauline was bedridden as a child, and there were psych evaluations brought in.
- 38:19This doctor, doctor Medlicott, he came in and he testified. He
- 38:23spoke to both girls, and he testified that the diary what was given to
- 38:28him. Speaking to the girls and reading the diary, that's pretty much all
- 38:30he needed to give an assessment. He concluded that both girls thought they lived
- 38:35in a make believe world called the Fourth Realm, and that the higher power
- 38:37of God and those saints were more powerful than any human god, and that
- 38:45they had heightened powers. He concluded that both girls had a lot of arrogance,
- 38:51but Pauline did show some signs of remorse, but usually she only felt
- 38:55it when she was trying to sleep. Oh, she couldn't asleep a little
- 39:00ages, she said. Every time that she would try to fall asleep on
- 39:02her left side, her mother would appear on her right side. Okay,
- 39:08what the fuck is that? Both girls said, we're not crazy, we
- 39:10knew what we were doing, and that the rest of the world was out
- 39:14of their minds. Oh, okay, it's everybody else. That's everybody else.
- 39:19Pauline had also written in her diary how excited she and Juliette were about
- 39:22their next idea. They were going to figure out how much money typical sex
- 39:25worker made so they could join that field, because they wanted money, and
- 39:30they wanted to get money from men for sex and then. Doctor Medleycott also
- 39:36said that when Pauline did see a boy, she regularly visited This boy named
- 39:40Nicholas, it made Juliette jealous. Doctor Melicott answered that the girls were crazy
- 39:47and they suffered from a type of insanity in which individuals share the same delusion
- 39:52or false belief. Pauline's family doctor then took the stand, his name with
- 39:55doctor Bennett. He agreed that both girls had the same delusion beliefs. He
- 40:00also stated that both girls seemed to suffer from paranoia, and they were antisocial
- 40:05and very dangerous. Right they thought they were better than the human race.
- 40:09They didn't want any more nagging parents. Nobody does. And then doctor Bennett
- 40:15mentioned the fact that the girls bathed together, slept together, played dress up
- 40:19together, played make believed together, created a cemetery together, and even held
- 40:23a funeral for a dead mouse and buried the mouse with a cross headstone.
- 40:29Girls would ended up being examined four times and in the end it was determined
- 40:32they didn't have any mental defects. They knew what they were doing, then
- 40:36they knew what was wrong. They were above average intelligence, and it was
- 40:39concluded that girls were actually engaging in a homosexual relationship. When closing arguments came
- 40:45about, the girls were laughing as the jury returned with a verdict, the
- 40:51verdict of guilty, then they stopped laughing. They were sentenced to detention during
- 40:55Her Majesty's pleasure, a sentence for any convicted person under the age of eighteen
- 41:01years of age. I guess it's at their own discretion, pleasure's sentence.
- 41:06I don't know. They basically were to be imprisoned at the Yeah, the
- 41:09judge's discretion. I don't want to tell you how much the time they served,
- 41:14how much? Five years? Oh my god. But they weren't kept
- 41:17them same prison. While in separate prisons, they formed their own separate lives.
- 41:22They were forbidden to contact each other, so they drifted apart. Pauline
- 41:27eventually changed her name to Hilary Nathan and she lives in the UK a very
- 41:30private life. Her older sister, Wendy, has said that she does not
- 41:34have any contact with the outside world and she deeply regrets killing her mother.
- 41:39On the other hand, juliet lived out all of her dreams that she and
- 41:44Pauline had together. There was a movie called Heavenly Creatures and it was about
- 41:50these girls. The reporters were able to track Juliette down, and they were
- 41:53astounded to find out that she'd made quite a life for herself as the best
- 41:58selling author for murder mystery novels under the name Anne Perry. No I'm gonna
- 42:04have to read one of them. What she made murder mysteries the fuck is
- 42:09that she was asked about her pass with Pauline and she said that she doesn't
- 42:14dwell on the pass because she would end up tormenting herself, which really wouldn't
- 42:19help. Juliet passed away in April of this year at the age of eighty
- 42:22four. To this day, the murder of Honora Reaver is still considered to
- 42:27be the worst crime committed in Zealand's history. Damn, and that's our store.
- 42:31Wow, Teliah, that was crazy. Yeah teenagers, Yeah, man,
- 42:37I was a horrible teenager. Man. I didn't kill my mother though.
- 42:40No, I didn't either. Yeah, maybe wanted to but didn't know.
- 42:45So I want to thank you guys all for taking the time to listen
- 42:47to this episode of Crimes and Consequences. If you like this, you can
- 42:52hit the subscribe or follow button. You can also get unreleased episodes only for
- 42:58exclusive members at Pitton dot com. Slash T and T Crimes like Dynamite T
- 43:01and T Crimes, you can go to our website Crimes and Consequences dot com.
- 43:06And if you're listening on Apple, go ahead and just go to the
- 43:08Apple podcast and app and click subscribe. You get unreleased episode every week.
- 43:15You get all these episodes ad free and early and I gotta go Tan,
- 43:21Yeah, I know, we got a boogie all right. Well, thanks
- 43:22everyone. Until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye,