Latest / AI in the UK / Keith Swain of Solveway on Whether the UK's AI Leadership Upskilling is Built to Last
Transcript
- 0:00All right, your luck. Listen up.
- 0:15Hello and welcome to AI in the UK.
- 0:18I'm Neil Footman. And I'm Matt Wilkinson.
- 0:21Professionally, we help organisations, leaders and
- 0:24individuals learn about and implement this.
- 0:26Big scary. Behemoth called AI.
- 0:30There's some amazing stuff going on with AI in the UK that
- 0:33doesn't always get the attention it deserves.
- 0:36With AI in the UK, we want to change that.
- 0:55Good morning, afternoon, evening, wherever you're
- 0:58listening from. And welcome to AI in the UK,
- 1:01which this time, for the first time ever, we are inviting a
- 1:06guest on to talk about his role in how AI is panning out here in
- 1:11the UK. So joining us is Keith Swain,
- 1:15managing director of Solveway Apprenticeships.
- 1:19So Solveway is one of the first providers approved to deliver
- 1:22the UK's AI Leadership apprenticeship units, the Level
- 1:265 modular training the government is pitching as the
- 1:29answer to the AI skills gap for managers and decision makers.
- 1:34So, Keith, first of all, welcome to the show.
- 1:37Thank you. Thanks for inviting me.
- 1:39And perhaps you could start just a little bit more detail about
- 1:42what Solvoy is and what you do. Yeah, sure.
- 1:45So, yeah, obviously my name is Keith Swain, MD here at Solvoy,
- 1:51Apprenticeship training provider who have been delivering
- 1:55apprenticeships since 2013, so a good few years now.
- 2:02We started off really as a tech company because that was my
- 2:05background in IT Technical Support.
- 2:09So that's kind of where we where we started.
- 2:12I used to work for a lot of big apprenticeship training
- 2:16providers around the country, consulting as curriculum
- 2:19development mainly, but kind of could see a bit of an angle on
- 2:24how we could improve the delivery of apprenticeships for,
- 2:27for UK employers. I saw a bit of a gap in the
- 2:30market and decided to, to open up our own apprenticeship
- 2:35training providers. So that's where we started.
- 2:38But since then we've kind of grown our provision a little bit
- 2:41into accountancy, which was a bit of a weird sidestep.
- 2:45But a lot of our customers that we were working with decided
- 2:49that, you know, or asked us whether we would deliver
- 2:53different apprenticeships to what we were currently
- 2:55delivering. And the accountants who come up,
- 2:57I knew a few accountants who trainers.
- 2:59So we we branched off into that area as well whilst maintaining
- 3:03our IT. And of course that naturally LED
- 3:05us on to things like data and now AI and yeah, being one of
- 3:10the first training providers in the UK to be give an
- 3:13authorisation to deliver the the level 5 AI units, which is quite
- 3:17exciting for us. Brilliant.
- 3:18Thank you. So Keith, for our listeners that
- 3:21have never sort of touched the levy system, what is an
- 3:24apprenticeship unit and how is it different from a full
- 3:27apprenticeship? And maybe a follow on to that,
- 3:29why is the government suddenly carving out sort of three
- 3:32separate 30 hour modules instead of 1 dedicated programme?
- 3:36Sure. So these where where they differ
- 3:41is employers have been asking the the government to to let
- 3:47them use their levy pot. So basically what the levy pot
- 3:51is, is any organisation who has a a wage bill in excess of
- 3:58£3,000,000 a year get taxed at source by HMRC of 0.5% of their
- 4:04annual salary and that money is taxed and ring fenced for
- 4:09apprenticeship delivery. Now apprenticeship delivery
- 4:12generally takes, you know, 12 plus months depending on what
- 4:16kind of programme people are on, they can take up to five years.
- 4:20Some of these programmes to be fair, but you know, the minimum
- 4:23is kind of 12 months, although that's just been reduced down to
- 4:26nine months. But yeah, the sort of the
- 4:27minimum tends to be around 12 months.
- 4:30But employers were saying, well, look, some of these, these
- 4:33courses are too long, right? The sort of stuff they want to
- 4:36teach their staff. They can't afford the staff to
- 4:40be out of the business for sort of nine months or 12 months
- 4:44plus. We, we want these shorter burst
- 4:48units. Can we have that?
- 4:51Can we use our levy pot to pay for those short units?
- 4:55So the government got together with employers and sort of
- 4:58worked out what that might that what, what that might look like.
- 5:03And hence the, the units were born and they literally were
- 5:09only released last month. So everyone's still trying to
- 5:12get their heads around them to be fair.
- 5:13But yeah, these are, are 30 hour units as opposed to units on a
- 5:19traditional apprenticeship which could last in excess of, you
- 5:22know, 350 hours in terms of the, the, the, the training.
- 5:26So that's the logic behind the apprenticeship units.
- 5:29Keith, what does your course look like?
- 5:31What? What is the emphasis and what
- 5:33are you saying Leaders need to do and learn to incorporate AI
- 5:38into their organisations? Yeah.
- 5:40So these courses aren't about learning AI in itself.
- 5:45So they're not, they're not a technical course in terms of
- 5:48we're not going to teach you, you know, anti gravity or
- 5:51whatever, you know, that type of thing.
- 5:53It's all around governance and how AI can be introduced into
- 5:58their business safely. It's about leaders
- 6:01understanding, which I think they do at the moment that
- 6:04everybody is using AI in the business.
- 6:07But what they're not sure on is how they're using AI in the
- 6:12business, you know, so what's the governance around it?
- 6:15So, you know, we, we all could paste a document into ChatGPT or
- 6:19Claude or whatever and say, you know, can you analyse this for
- 6:22me, please? And, and give me some
- 6:24information back. And what people are worried
- 6:26about is that sensitive information being, you know, out
- 6:31there now on, on the Internet, because we've just copied and
- 6:33pasted it out of a excel spreadsheet or whatever and
- 6:36asked somebody to do some data analysis on it.
- 6:39So it's, it's about business leaders understanding that we
- 6:43absolutely need to use AI in the, in the business, you know,
- 6:46they recognise that, but how can we use it safely and effectively
- 6:51and efficiently within the organisations?
- 6:53And that's the kind of stuff that that we that we'd be
- 6:56looking at with the with the level fives.
- 6:59And just a quick follow up to that man, I'll pass over.
- 7:01So I couldn't agree more. Clearly this is an element of it
- 7:04that they're they're deeply concerned with and it can be a
- 7:06big impediment. I would suggest also maybe does
- 7:10that and I understand that there'll be limited.
- 7:15So you've got a certain amount of time.
- 7:16So so trying to teach people all tools is not is, is.
- 7:19But is there an element of trying to instil a sense of
- 7:23personal change in leaders? Because I think that you can
- 7:27have you can have a sort of theoretical understanding of and
- 7:30quite clear understanding of the safety issues and how to address
- 7:32them. But in our experience, it very
- 7:35much depends on leaders using AI themselves.
- 7:38I think if they just stick with, it's a kind of Technical Support
- 7:42project that we have to deal with in a governance level.
- 7:44And don't get me wrong, governance is critical.
- 7:47Does does it also incorporate elements of that about
- 7:50persuading and showing leaders how to change themselves as a
- 7:52result of using AI? Yeah, it it.
- 7:55Is leaders, again, the leaders that we're talking to at least
- 7:59are using it almost every day, you know, but it is on a, on a
- 8:04very basic level in terms of, you know, help me reword this
- 8:08e-mail in, you know, in chat and, and that type of thing.
- 8:11So that that's where they're using it or, or getting a,
- 8:14getting a dashboard done quickly to help identify issues.
- 8:19So that's, that's where they, they are using it at a very
- 8:22basic level. So I think they can absolutely
- 8:24see the value. They know that they probably
- 8:28need to take it to the next step or people that are a little bit
- 8:31more savvy, you know, on the on the tech side of things or the
- 8:35development side of things. They, they are looking to them
- 8:38now to develop some good in house products because a lot of
- 8:44people are paying for products right now that kind of do half
- 8:50the job. And this is what some of the
- 8:51leaders are saying. You know, we're, we're paying
- 8:53for this product. It does this, we're paying for
- 8:54that product, it does that. And what we want to do is is to,
- 8:57to bring it all together and get the information out of that
- 9:00product and that product into what is effectively our own
- 9:03product that we can then, you know, do manipulate that data
- 9:07in, in, in whatever way we want. But how do we do that safely?
- 9:11What's the procurement process around that?
- 9:14You know, what's the best tools to use, who are the best people
- 9:18in the business to understand those tools?
- 9:21How and how do we farm that work out?
- 9:23So, so it is, it is a wider thing than just about
- 9:28understanding we need AI. It's the procurement process
- 9:33around that as well and how we transform that within the
- 9:35workforce. Fantastic.
- 9:37From September 26th, the government is withdrawing
- 9:41funding from sort of leadership and management apprenticeships
- 9:44because they've been can cited as sort of fancy CPD for over 20
- 9:49fives rather than a route, you know, an entry route into work
- 9:52for young people. And they've been, you know, they
- 9:54make quite a, a big splash about refocusing where the levy is
- 9:58going. At the same time, these AI
- 10:00leadership units seem to be explicitly CPD for over 25.
- 10:05Does that make sense? How, how, how have they
- 10:07positioned that to you? Well, I think they are to a
- 10:11degree because we're in the early stages.
- 10:14All the risk really with with these units are against the
- 10:18train provider. So these units can be withdrawn
- 10:21within 30 days notice. So that's that's the first
- 10:24thing. So normally you know you'd get
- 10:27at least six months for any delivery changes or anything
- 10:30that the government were going to withdraw.
- 10:32They've already said that there's a 30 day notice on
- 10:34withdrawing all of the apprenticeship units.
- 10:37So what that does tell me is if if too many people were using it
- 10:42and it was, it exploded and the levee pot was being used
- 10:45obviously to pay for these and that sacrificed their normal
- 10:49apprenticeships, then I would imagine these would be withdrawn
- 10:53quite quickly. But obviously the government
- 10:55wants to position themselves, you know, within Europe, within
- 11:00the world of being at the forefront of AI and pushing this
- 11:05sort of stuff out to their leaders.
- 11:07Is is the style of positioning themselves within that sort of
- 11:11scope OK? The so Keith the the
- 11:17apprenticeship standard was written at a certain moment in
- 11:20time and as we know AI is moving ahead spinning rate.
- 11:24It's it's impossible for anyone to keep up.
- 11:26You know, people working in the field like us, we can't keep up,
- 11:29never mind people who actually have day jobs to do.
- 11:31So how do you how do you plan to keep what you actually teach
- 11:35current? And I'm aware, like you said,
- 11:38it's not a technical course on the latest tools.
- 11:40Nonetheless, even with things like governance, the, the, the
- 11:45you get something. Well, the thing everyone's
- 11:48talking about the moment agentic, the rise of agents that
- 11:50has a profound have profound implications on governance and
- 11:55demote, you know, qualitatively different from governance
- 11:57around, say, AI chat bots. So how?
- 12:01How do you keep up? And who has the final say on the
- 12:05curriculum content? Is it you or or the employer or
- 12:09the awarding body? Well, there is no awarding body.
- 12:12OK. For, for these apprenticeship
- 12:15units. So there is a set criteria right
- 12:19now that we that we need to follow, you know, there's just
- 12:22knowledge and skills. There's about 20 criteria within
- 12:26those knowledge and skills that we need to follow.
- 12:29So that is set by skills England.
- 12:30So our job is to make sure that the end user, the client can
- 12:38evidence that they understand those knowledge and skills that
- 12:41have been laid down by Skills England.
- 12:43So in terms of things changing, and you're absolutely right, I
- 12:46mean, you wake up in the morning, there's something new,
- 12:48isn't there? You know, it's something better
- 12:50and all the rest of it. So we recognise things that do
- 12:53change, but from our point of view and what we'll be measured
- 12:56against is the fact that we've taught the knowledge and skills
- 13:00which are the requirement of the apprenticeship units.
- 13:03So, and I think they're so loose in the way that they've been
- 13:06written, but they kind of, you know, they will allow for the
- 13:10latest technologies that come through.
- 13:12You know, it'd be down to our guys to to make sure that we're
- 13:15keeping up with the latest trends and you know what's out
- 13:18there. And therefore we can impart that
- 13:20knowledge down on our our learners effectively might.
- 13:24Might might that be intentional? Do you think that they kept it
- 13:27intentionally because of the pace of change?
- 13:30I always do so and you know, anything, any work that you do
- 13:34with central government is always kind of loose and that
- 13:38they do that because if you ever go back to them and say, oh, you
- 13:43know, should we be doing this? And they'll say, well, is it on
- 13:48the, is it on the criteria? And you'll be like, well, it
- 13:52doesn't really say it's on the criteria.
- 13:54And that's, well, that's for you to kind of decide, you know,
- 13:58it's, and that's why they do leave this stuff quite loose.
- 14:01And actually, so one other follow up on that.
- 14:03So skills England must be a body you interact with quite
- 14:07frequently in the course of what you do.
- 14:08Keith, presumably is that. Fair to say, it's what's fair to
- 14:13say is I've had probably be about 5 meetings with Skills
- 14:16England in OK. Sort of, yeah.
- 14:19So just wonder, you know, I'm not we're not looking for him
- 14:21inflammatory, but just wonder how how well equipped you feel
- 14:25those bodies are for setting the course for these and set in the
- 14:30the curriculum and so on. So I'll go back to something we
- 14:33we cover on our show. We we talk about weekly
- 14:36developments, whatever has been going on.
- 14:37And there was this big push to upscale 10 million UK workers.
- 14:42That was, excuse me, a month or two ago.
- 14:45And that is a noble goal. I mean, we'd absolutely support
- 14:49that upscale as I'd say everybody upscale, everybody get
- 14:52everybody AI literate. But then the courses they came
- 14:55out with that I saw were really quite disappointing.
- 14:59They they were they were rather tick box.
- 15:02And you can imagine on the government side, the goal is big
- 15:07number. Say we're hitting it say say
- 15:09we're getting to this goal. The substance was rather less
- 15:11satisfactory. It was was an online course done
- 15:16it certificate boom. Can I use it?
- 15:18Who knows? You know, as you'll know, AI
- 15:21literacy is a bigger, more complicated thing than merely
- 15:25taking some Co pilot lessons. So I'm just wondering with you
- 15:29being on the been on the coalface of this, how much faith
- 15:32you have in government bodies to steer this in in a really
- 15:35productive direction? Yeah, I mean, any course that's
- 15:39released isn't really developed by Skills England themselves.
- 15:44You know, it is a collaborative process that they go through
- 15:47with employees. So that's that's the way that
- 15:51Skills England worked. So any course that is developed,
- 15:55any apprenticeship course that's developed and obviously the
- 15:57units as well will be in collaboration with what industry
- 16:02is looking for in a course. None of these were were
- 16:06developed in a silo by somebody at Skills England who really
- 16:10doesn't know anything about AI. You know, it's all done by a
- 16:13steering committee of employers. Now you could argue who those
- 16:18employers were and and whether you know, what was developed was
- 16:22just to satisfy the large multinationals, that's a
- 16:26different argument. But ultimately they can still
- 16:30satisfy what some of the SM, ES, medium sized enterprise
- 16:34organisations are looking to achieve in their businesses too.
- 16:38So yeah, it was done as a collaboration more so than just
- 16:41somebody doesn't know nothing about AII.
- 16:43Don't know if that helps that or not.
- 16:46Surely it leads nicely onto to our next question which is who
- 16:50are your typical employer partners?
- 16:52Are they large levy payers or SMEs using the Co investment
- 16:56route? You know, is that, you know, is
- 16:58the levy mechanism really directing money towards
- 17:02genuinely new sort of AI leadership skills or you know,
- 17:06our employees really just using it to rebadge existing training?
- 17:09So, so new this is the trouble, it's this is hot off the shelf,
- 17:13literally come out a couple of weeks ago.
- 17:16So people are still getting to grips with how the programme
- 17:21needs to be structured. Two weeks ago there was 1
- 17:25programme for AI leadership. Now there's three programmes,
- 17:30you know, so they changed it even in a matter of a couple of
- 17:34a week. So, you know, we're now just
- 17:36grappling with and the funding, the funding's only just been
- 17:40released. So, you know, builder, you know,
- 17:42I mean, these courses can be 160 hours, you know, but then when
- 17:47you look at the funding that the government has given for these
- 17:49courses, you can't build a course for 160 hours because the
- 17:52funding's not there for it. And then you look at the
- 17:55marketplace, what what are employers actually looking for?
- 18:00Are they looking for 160 hours? No, they're not.
- 18:03They're looking for courses that are short, sharp and have a
- 18:08strategic outcome at the end of that.
- 18:11And that's what employees are looking for in terms of solve
- 18:14way. We do work with large levy
- 18:17paying employees, but that's probably 20% of our business.
- 18:22The remainder of it is, you know, SMEs sort of 50 head count
- 18:28in terms of staff head count down to maybe about 10 is, is
- 18:33kind of that area that, that, that we work in.
- 18:36That's 80% of our, our business works in that sort of SME
- 18:40marketplace. We've had lots of enquiries
- 18:42about the about the units. Of course, we we are just
- 18:46starting to sign up those clients and but we're just again
- 18:50holding the programme as as we speak because it is that it's
- 18:53glad that we're. Getting this hot off the press
- 18:55then yeah. So, Keith, so about, about the,
- 18:59the, the leaders who are taking this course, I'm, I'm curious as
- 19:03to generally what kind of positions they hold frequently,
- 19:06you know, obviously, so consequential decisions for a
- 19:08company will be taken at a very senior level.
- 19:11I suppose a concern about AI application in general is that
- 19:15there can be, I saw temptation among senior leaders to delegate
- 19:20it in the belief that it's, it's kind of a tech support.
- 19:22I get it's different. It's, it's good, but it's a tech
- 19:25support project. So you director of IT or, or
- 19:29something like that, you take care of it, you write the
- 19:31policy, you decide the tools and then let everybody know.
- 19:34And, and, and he pressed the were AI capable.
- 19:38So I'm wondering, do you do you have that seniority of people
- 19:41coming on that this seems when you describe something as
- 19:43apprenticeships, I think it'll immediately conjure up images of
- 19:46young people taking it into the college.
- 19:48So an apprenticeship for a leader.
- 19:50Are these current leaders with with the authority to make
- 19:54changes in their companies or are they aspiring leaders who
- 19:57will get there eventually in it? And if the if it's the latter,
- 19:59what real influence and impact do you think they'll be able to
- 20:03have on the companies they're coming from?
- 20:04So I think. It's a mixture of both to be
- 20:06honest with you. From what we're seeing anyway,
- 20:09so first of all, they've they've got to be they 19 plus for for
- 20:15these apprenticeship units, they've got to be aged 19 plus
- 20:18they've already got to be in post.
- 20:20So it's not a new new job. So they've already got to be in
- 20:24post and. The.
- 20:26Apprenticeship itself or the apprenticeship unit itself has
- 20:29to contribute towards either, you know, making their job
- 20:34easier or better or be viewed that it could be used for the
- 20:38next step or next promotion. So that's kind of how the the
- 20:43government positioned people taking these apprenticeship
- 20:46units. So we are getting leaders in.
- 20:50We are getting sort of those heads of departments coming in.
- 20:54We've had a few enquiries actually from, from a competitor
- 20:57to be fair, who didn't get The Who, who, who wasn't allowed to
- 21:02deliver the apprenticeship unit. So they weren't, they weren't
- 21:04awarded that. So their massive training
- 21:07provider. So they've approached us for
- 21:09basically the heads of all of their departments for the actual
- 21:12unit. And then we've had enquiries,
- 21:15you know, from managers and team leaders that they can see that
- 21:18their team is the wild, Wild West out there when it comes to
- 21:24AI and the implement. Everyone's doing something with
- 21:26it, you know, so it's just team leaders recognising themselves
- 21:29that there's, there's a problem and governance and you know, the
- 21:33procurement side of it. Again, I, I said before, you
- 21:35know that some people are investing in the copilot, some
- 21:39people are using, you know, Gemini or Claude or whatever.
- 21:43So that you know, it's what, what are we going to use?
- 21:45Are we going to hang a hat on a particular model or are we going
- 21:48to try them all And you know how we can incorporate those into
- 21:52the business. So it really is quite diverse
- 21:54that we're finding things at the moment.
- 21:56But again, it is early days you raised.
- 21:58Raised an interesting sort of point there that you know, with
- 22:01it being early days and these being shall we say sort of solo
- 22:05units, that means that there must be no endpoint assessment
- 22:08involved. So how do you, and more
- 22:11importantly the employer paying for it actually now a leader can
- 22:14do anything different at the end of those 30 hours.
- 22:16You know, what's the, what's that sort of mechanism involved
- 22:19for, for grading? Yeah, yeah.
- 22:22So I think they, they do go for an assessment at the end of the
- 22:28process. But it's not, it's not by a
- 22:30third party endpoint assessment organisation as you mentioned.
- 22:34So the assessment is done by the train provider in collaboration
- 22:41with the employer. So the employer essentially
- 22:43needs to sign off that they are happy that the learner
- 22:48understands those knowledge and skills that I was previously
- 22:50talking about and that they're happy to sign off to say that,
- 22:55you know, that learner is capable in that area.
- 22:59And I mean, the way that we're designing the programme is, you
- 23:03know, especially around AI literacy and, you know, the
- 23:05landscape and the awareness of it and all of that kind of
- 23:08stuff. And the governance and
- 23:09procurement, we want our programmes to deliver something
- 23:14tangible at the end of those 30 hours.
- 23:17So you know, the policies, the procedures, the procurement
- 23:21processes, the workforce transformation and adoption and
- 23:27you know, all the management and the monitoring and all of that
- 23:29kind of stuff, we want them to to walk away with something
- 23:32tangible at the end of those 30 hours.
- 23:34So that's going to be the evidence of the learning that's
- 23:37taken place and something that they can bring back to the
- 23:41business that's tangible based on the training that they've
- 23:45had. And that would ultimately be
- 23:47that sign off at the end of the programme to say that they are
- 23:51confident and capable, meeting those criteria.
- 23:54Brilliant. Thank.
- 23:54You, Keith, as you've said. So early days and small sample
- 23:57size, I wonder if you're drawing any conclusions yet about where
- 24:02we are. That's a big question.
- 24:05Where we are is in in the UK in the SME sector in terms of AI
- 24:08adoption that that we we look at survey results frequently that
- 24:13the one that really just stunned us.
- 24:15It was released early in in the year by DSIT.
- 24:18You may may have seen it. They did, they did the field
- 24:20work last year and then released it early this year.
- 24:22But basically they were saying that and it was, it was a survey
- 24:25of 3 1/2 thousand UK companies ranging from very big to one or
- 24:29two man operations and it was weighted by sector and so on.
- 24:34But essentially they found that 50% of businesses responded.
- 24:38They couldn't see the relevance of AI to their business at all
- 24:41and only 16% at that time. And I stressed this was last
- 24:45year, but it was a very rigorous methodology to this study so
- 24:50that it was credible, but it was it was field work.
- 24:53Year ago, 16% said they were making official use of AI in
- 24:57some capacity, and that was clearly defined.
- 25:02In your experience so far, the leaders you've come into contact
- 25:05with, the people, what are you seeing?
- 25:07What sense are you getting of where where SM ES are in their
- 25:11AI adoption? Yeah, I.
- 25:13I would say today those stats would be flipped on their heads.
- 25:18I mean, I, I think the adoption is there.
- 25:21People are using it every day. Now, they may, may not be using
- 25:26it as fully as as they could do, but like I say, I think leaders,
- 25:32people on the shop floor, you know, they're all using it
- 25:35everyday as part of their, their, their everyday life, even
- 25:38just to correct emails. And I think that's kind of where
- 25:43we are at the moment. It's leaders understand the
- 25:46benefits or they can, they can see the benefits because they're
- 25:50using it kind of themselves. So they understand that it could
- 25:54really benefit the business, but they just don't have the
- 25:59internal resources to implement something better or stronger.
- 26:06And I think our argument is obviously we, we do the, I mean,
- 26:09we've been talking about the governance and the leadership
- 26:11side of things, you know, the transformation to lead it.
- 26:15But we also do the, the level 4, which is the, you know, the nuts
- 26:19and bolts of AI, you know, how to use AI, how to build your
- 26:22dashboards and to use clawed and all that kind of stuff
- 26:24effectively. So that's kind of the area that
- 26:27we are promoting as well within businesses.
- 26:31So let's get people using AI effectively, Let's stop them
- 26:35just using chat because there's so much more to AI than than
- 26:39just chat. So let's show you how you can
- 26:43use this stuff and what it can do for you.
- 26:45Let's solve, solve some real world business problems whilst
- 26:50also giving you the governance around it from your leadership
- 26:52team, You know, so that's kind of where we're positioned
- 26:55ourselves. So it's not just the leadership
- 26:57side of it. Is, is, is one thing.
- 26:59And obviously how to use AI and how to develop the tools and
- 27:04solve those business processes is, is key.
- 27:07And what we find is people within the organisations right
- 27:11now are the best people to tackle those problems because
- 27:15they're up against it everyday. They see what the problems are,
- 27:18they see what the challenges are.
- 27:20So those people are generally the best people to be able to
- 27:24fix those problems. And working with AI now, you
- 27:28know, they don't have to be coders and software developers
- 27:31and SAS development, you know, all of that kind of stuff is
- 27:33gone. And I think if you can be on a
- 27:35robust course for 12 months and can teach you how to use those
- 27:38products and solve some real world business problems for you
- 27:42whilst you're on that 12 month course, of course with the
- 27:45leadership governance bolted on as well, you've got a real
- 27:49robust AI development for businesses.
- 27:53I mean. I would certainly agree with
- 27:54that. I think certain those figures
- 27:56will be out of date to some extent, but I would think that
- 27:59they're not necessarily contradicting your experience.
- 28:02The emphasis was very much on official use, as they called it
- 28:07meaning and actually endorsed proper policies in place.
- 28:10Here's how we use it. Here's all that stuff.
- 28:13Yeah. And I still think that I would
- 28:17imagine most people now have used it at least, you know,
- 28:20sometimes. And many people use it all the
- 28:22time. But how are they using it?
- 28:24We're constantly coming up against this shadow AI thing,
- 28:27which is something that you must, you must talk about, given
- 28:30that if you don't have an official policy or if your
- 28:33policy is too restrictive, people just use it anyway and
- 28:35they'll use it in a way that is perhaps not safe or in line with
- 28:40the security of your business. So, yeah, but more of an
- 28:44observation really. I wonder whether that change or
- 28:46if you really do feel that companies have progressed a huge
- 28:50amount in terms of, quote, official or or proper use of AI.
- 28:55Yeah. So sorry, I, I probably
- 28:58misunderstood that question. I think it's, it's people are
- 29:03using it everyday inside of businesses, but obviously it's,
- 29:07it wouldn't be authorised or businesses, you know, haven't
- 29:10got those policies in place. Like we absolutely like you
- 29:13said. So now I do think lots of, you
- 29:16know, we're all using it everyday.
- 29:17But yeah, the policies and the procedures probably are not, are
- 29:20not in there to help with what people can actually do or can't
- 29:24do. So no, I think you're absolutely
- 29:25right with that. Oh yeah.
- 29:27Well. Yeah, it's certainly lagging I'd
- 29:28feel. Yeah, Thank you.
- 29:29One of the interesting. Things that we've seen recently
- 29:32is there's been a lot of talk about a lot of tasks in certain
- 29:35roles across accountancy, IT support operations, that a lot
- 29:39of those tasks that can be replaced by AI.
- 29:42When you're talking to people and training them, are they
- 29:44actually being trained to to get rid of their own jobs?
- 29:47How are the businesses that you're speaking to doing AI?
- 29:50Yeah, I'm not. Seeing we're not seeing that at
- 29:52the moment. It may come, but we're certainly
- 29:56not seeing it at the moment. We're not seeing this sort of
- 29:59human versus AI. We're kind of seeing that, you
- 30:02know, human working with AI type scenario that that's what that's
- 30:07what we're seeing. So it is absolutely right.
- 30:10You know, they're seeing the bottlenecks, they're seeing some
- 30:14of the problems where AI can assist and just alleviate some
- 30:18of those admin burdens really. So people could be doing some of
- 30:22the more sophisticated stuff that requires, you know, that
- 30:24human intervention, but certainly just, you know,
- 30:28mopping up some of this mundane stuff.
- 30:30But we certainly haven't seen that replacement of, you know,
- 30:34even lower level or entry level people coming into businesses.
- 30:37They still need those people. But AI just assists at this
- 30:40moment in time. That's really.
- 30:42Positive to hear. It's really interesting to sort
- 30:44of see that there's this maybe this disconnect between what the
- 30:47narrative is around job loss versus what you're seeing on the
- 30:50ground, which is it's good to hear that it's it's not hitting
- 30:54yet, at least not it's not. Hitting yet not.
- 30:57Not not from what we've seen. That's good to hear.
- 31:00That is really. Interesting, if I could ask a
- 31:02follow up on that. So, so your experience thus far
- 31:04Keith is certainly with SMEs that were still some way off
- 31:08actual displacement if, if it happens that's kind?
- 31:12Of that, that, that is what we're seeing because we're also
- 31:14seeing the June getting another plug.
- 31:17We, we also do a Level 3 AI course you see.
- 31:19So level 4 is going to be primarily aimed at people who
- 31:23are in the business and understand the problems of the
- 31:27business and therefore the best people to deal with it in terms
- 31:30of the AI. But we also do a Level 3 and
- 31:32we're going to be for people that are, you know, school
- 31:35leavers new to business, so therefore don't understand
- 31:39business processes right now. So, you know, we've got just as
- 31:42much call for the Level 3 as we do for the level 4.
- 31:46So that tells me that they, they, you know, businesses do
- 31:49want the young people coming in, you know, being taught on AI
- 31:53data, how to manipulate it and all of that kind of stuff.
- 31:56Yeah. From our experiences, it's
- 31:57still, you know, people aren't looking at it to replace
- 32:01personnel. It's, it's more to complement
- 32:04what they're doing. But, you know, who knows whether
- 32:07things change? Like we've already said, they've
- 32:08changed so quickly. So, you know, I could, I can see
- 32:12it changing, Yeah. But right now it's it's fine.
- 32:16Do. You think they might be doing
- 32:18that because so clearly, so you, you deal primarily with SMEs as
- 32:22do I. And.
- 32:25SMEs are going to be under different kinds of financial
- 32:28imperatives and leadership and structure and so on for publicly
- 32:31traded massive companies where they're under intense pressure
- 32:34from investors all the time to maintain margins and so on.
- 32:38Do you feel that there's more of a sense of responsibility to
- 32:43employees, that this is how they want to manage their companies
- 32:46more differently? They don't want it to be
- 32:48entirely down to the bottom line, or is it more is it, is it
- 32:52because they view this as the best way to increase their
- 32:56profitability and make themselves future proof is by
- 32:59bringing on young, young people to help them implement AI?
- 33:02You know what it's, it's just very interesting to hear this
- 33:04perspective that because the overwhelming narrative is either
- 33:08displaces jobs and or is particularly difficult for young
- 33:11people because the kinds of work that young people traditionally
- 33:16did when they joined companies, you know, sort of the quote,
- 33:18grunt work a lot, a lot of kind of research and, and admin and
- 33:22all that stuff where they learn the ropes is part of the work
- 33:25that's most at risk. What, what's, what's your view
- 33:28on why SM ES might be different? Or is it just we're just at a
- 33:31stage of development? I I think.
- 33:33It's where we are and that the timeline, you know, I, I, I
- 33:37think businesses are recognising that they have to use AI.
- 33:41You know, it's not a choice now, it's not a nice to have.
- 33:44It's, it's, you know, a requirement.
- 33:46And if they're not using it, you know, they know their
- 33:48competitors are going to be using it.
- 33:51So just some of them, it is just getting younger people in to the
- 33:55businesses because you know, there are certain age group
- 33:58within the organisation and therefore they need younger
- 34:01people to come through. And that's that's why they'll
- 34:04get the younger people in. But primarily the businesses
- 34:07that we talked to anyway, that they see AI as a tool to help
- 34:12solve problems a bit quicker than what they can do themselves
- 34:16right now. And it just makes them more
- 34:18efficient. It helps, of course, with the
- 34:20bottom line because we're not having to do all these admin
- 34:22burdens. But it still doesn't mean that
- 34:25we don't need that Junior Inn doing some of that grunt work,
- 34:29you know, even feeding it to the AI machine, you know, so because
- 34:33they're not quite sure about the automation and all of that sort
- 34:35of stuff. So there's still manual
- 34:37processes that are going on because, you know, a lot of
- 34:41businesses haven't had that exposure to the training that
- 34:43can open their eyes to some of the some of the things that are
- 34:47out there today. You know, they're still ChatGPT
- 34:50is, is the best way to, you know, answer a question or, or,
- 34:53or, or do a, you know, a basic process.
- 34:56So it could be just down to the fact that the training hasn't
- 35:00been done yet and and that's what's really being pushed now.
- 35:03And once, once we're at the other side of that, I think the
- 35:05landscape might be different looking at the other.
- 35:08Side of that sort of 12 months on from when we've got sort of
- 35:10the first cohorts having gone through this, what's the sort of
- 35:14things that we should be looking for to show that this approach,
- 35:16you know, as a country that this approach to training is, is
- 35:19being successful in terms of the.
- 35:21Units or just the? Yeah, I mean, obviously you've
- 35:24got 3 levels 3-4 and five. So hopefully organisations will
- 35:28be, you know, better skilled at, you know, at a variety of
- 35:32levels. What's the, you know, what
- 35:34should we be looking out for to sort of to say, hey, yeah, we're
- 35:37the UK is moving in the right direction thanks to this
- 35:39training. Yeah, that's.
- 35:41Kind of a, I don't know, it's my honest answer.
- 35:45I mean, obviously from our point of view and the government, you
- 35:49see are funding a lot of this training.
- 35:51So, so they're going to want to see some results, you know,
- 35:55based on what we're doing as, as the people that are delivering
- 35:57that training. But, you know, the assumption is
- 36:02that it's going to make the country more profitable, you
- 36:05know, position ourselves within the world's trade, you know, in
- 36:10a better mindset. So, you know, from, from the
- 36:13government's point of view, that's I guess the, the
- 36:15direction of travel. And I, I hear things around that
- 36:19the government is saying for every sort of pound that they
- 36:22invest in, in AI, you know, there's a sort of 3 LB return.
- 36:27So, you know, this is all about the money at the end of the day.
- 36:29And the more that we can get people and businesses using AI,
- 36:34then ultimately the more it comes back into the government's
- 36:38costs at the end of the day. Thank you.
- 36:40Thank you very much, Keith. I think we're we're drawing
- 36:44towards the end of our time together.
- 36:46That was really fascinating. I think we had a bunch of
- 36:49questions we couldn't get to the conversation took little turns
- 36:53here and there as well, which was really interesting that
- 36:55there was elements of what you're talking about that I
- 36:56hadn't really considered. So yeah, thanks for sparing your
- 37:00time and your and and giving us your candid opinions.
- 37:04No problem. I've enjoyed it, thanks for
- 37:06inviting me. And that's it for this week's
- 37:23episode of AI in the UK. If you found it useful.
- 37:27You can subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and we'd
- 37:31really appreciate a great rating or review it.
- 37:34Genuinely. Helps others find the show.
- 37:37You can also follow Neil's Footman and Matt Wilkinson on
- 37:40LinkedIn for links, notes and occasional extra content.
- 37:45Thanks for listening and we'll be back next week helping you.
- 37:49Make sense of AI as it lands here in the UK.
- 37:50AI in the UK. AI in the UK.
- 37:51AI in the UK.