Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / ERISA Disability Claims Demystified: What Every Practitioner Needs to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, welcome to ERISA Disability Claims Demystified,
- 0:07What Every Practitioner Needs to Know. I'm Stacey
- 0:10Monahan -Tucker, Chair of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:12Association's Insurance Law Section. I'm delighted
- 0:15to introduce today's speakers, Michelle L. Roberts,
- 0:19Brent Dorian -Brem, and me. Michelle Roberts
- 0:22is a principal at Roberts Disability Law and
- 0:24a nationally recognized ERISA litigation attorney.
- 0:27She's advocated for disabled individuals and
- 0:30employees since 2005. Her practice focuses on
- 0:33short and long -term disability claim benefits
- 0:35wrongfully denied by insurance companies. Michelle
- 0:38has been repeatedly recognized as a Northern
- 0:40California Super Lawyer and is widely regarded
- 0:42as a leader and authority in ERISA law. Brent
- 0:45Dorian Brem is a highly regarded attorney focusing
- 0:48on disability, life, AD &D, and long -term care
- 0:51insurance benefits. His career is dedicated to
- 0:54holding multi -billion dollar insurance companies
- 0:56accountable. Since 2006, he's resolved more than
- 1:00500 insurance disputes and has been repeatedly
- 1:03recognized by super lawyers, the recorder, and
- 1:05the Daily Journal for his excellence and impact
- 1:08in the field. Brent is also a frequent speaker
- 1:11on life insurance law and long -term disability
- 1:13claims and the process. I'm the founder of Monahan
- 1:17Tucker Law, and my career spanned over 25 years
- 1:20of disability insurance law, beginning at Jones
- 1:23Day, where I represented insurance companies
- 1:25in high value disability insurance disputes.
- 1:28After 20 years representing insurance companies,
- 1:31I changed sides and now bring that same expertise
- 1:33to advocate for the insurance. I've been recognized
- 1:36by best lawyers as one of the top attorneys in
- 1:38the field of insurance law, and I'm admitted
- 1:40to practice throughout the Ninth Circuit. And
- 1:43now we're going to get started on our presentation.
- 1:48Thank you, Stacey and Michelle. It's good to
- 1:50be with you today. So we're going to start. I'm
- 1:53starting with the outline and an overview, and
- 1:56then I will hand off to Stacey and Michelle for
- 1:59some some of the deeper dives. But we're going
- 2:02through four phases here. I'll be handling just
- 2:06kind of some throat clearing if you're completely
- 2:08unfamiliar with Arisa. how to identify an ERISA
- 2:12plan, some of the enforcement mechanisms. And
- 2:16of course, ERISA here, we haven't mentioned yet,
- 2:18but it's the Employee Retirement Income Security
- 2:21Act, E -R -I -S -A is the acronym, and we'll
- 2:25probably be calling it ERISA from here on out.
- 2:28Then we'll move on to some of the policy terms,
- 2:31especially here we're focusing on LTD policies.
- 2:36You'll see that ERISA is quite expansive in its
- 2:39breadth. But we are just trying to deal with
- 2:43one slice of it, which is LTV benefits. Some
- 2:47of those common terms will then move to some
- 2:51of the mechanics, how you actually might process
- 2:54one of these claims if you happen to come across
- 2:57one. And then in phase four, a couple just pointers
- 3:05that sometimes cross over with various different
- 3:09other fields of law to try and ensure that if
- 3:12you're representing a client who might have a
- 3:17LTD, or even other ERISA claims, that you're
- 3:21ensuring that those benefits are protected or
- 3:24not inadvertently rendered worthless by the actions
- 3:29that you might be doing in a typical case. So
- 3:32on the next slide, we have what is ERISA? So
- 3:39in this context, it is a statute that provides
- 3:43for the minimum standards for voluntarily established
- 3:47benefit plans for employees in private industry.
- 3:51So a lot of key terms there, right? It has to
- 3:55be voluntary. You get these benefit plans, the
- 3:59E in ERISA stands for employees, and it is largely
- 4:02private industry. The important key about ERISA
- 4:07is that it preempts state laws as they relate
- 4:10to any employee benefit plan. So it has one of
- 4:13the most expansive preemption clauses that we
- 4:18know in American legal jurisprudence. And so
- 4:24a lot of times people will get their hands on
- 4:27what they otherwise think would be a bad fake
- 4:30claim or some other type of law. And it's in
- 4:37fact an ERISA plan. So what does relates to mean?
- 4:40It means it has a connection with or reference
- 4:42to a plan. There are limits on this. It's not
- 4:46an endless series of events. It really is that
- 4:53it goes directly to it. But just as importantly,
- 4:58If we go to the next slide, we'll see that there
- 5:02are two kind of different global areas in ERISA.
- 5:08One is dealing with pension benefits or retirement
- 5:12benefits. You can see the litany of items there.
- 5:16And then on the other side are what are called
- 5:18welfare benefit plans. Most people, if you get
- 5:22your benefits through your employer, that's gonna
- 5:25be your health insurance, you see medical dental
- 5:27vision. disability here, we're going to be dealing
- 5:31with long -term disability, but it can be a variety
- 5:33of other aspects. And it's important here to
- 5:37pause that we look at, well, what is not an ERISA
- 5:45plan? So on the next slide, we see examples of
- 5:48that. It doesn't cover church plans. So if you
- 5:53get your benefits through church, that's not
- 5:56going to be ERISA unless they opt in. Like all
- 5:59things in the law, it's a, well, maybe type answer.
- 6:06You can also see that it's not plans that are
- 6:09maintained solely to comply with workers' compensation,
- 6:14unemployment, or other mandatory disability laws.
- 6:18It's not government plans, so that's federal,
- 6:21state, county, and even pseudo -governmental.
- 6:25We see this come up now and again with things
- 6:28like the Federal Reserve. That's going to be
- 6:31a pseudo -governmental entity where if you get
- 6:34your benefits through that, it is not an ERISA
- 6:38plan. Other things that are important. Social
- 6:44Security. That is not an ERISA plan. We discussed
- 6:48workers compensation, but state disability. In
- 6:51California, and I think it's four or five other
- 6:54states, there's mandatory disability insurance
- 6:59that covers all workers. That is not governed
- 7:02by ERISA, nor are individual insurance policies
- 7:06that you go out on your own as an individual.
- 7:09You get apply for, usually underwriting. That
- 7:14is not going to be ERISA either. There is, as
- 7:21we see here, another but on that exception, which
- 7:24is there can be known ERISA plans that you receive
- 7:29through your employer, but essentially it has
- 7:33to be that your employer just facilitates letting
- 7:37the insurer come to the captive audience of its
- 7:40employees. sell the insurance and then it helps
- 7:44administer the plan meaning collects premiums
- 7:47and might remit them. That's what's called a
- 7:50payroll practice. It's not particularly common
- 7:52but it generally can work if you ever see it
- 7:57in reverse where people will think it's an individual
- 8:01policy but it in fact is an ERISA policy because
- 8:06they received some sort of a group discount in
- 8:10this process. unless it's what we call ERISA
- 8:13file. So how do we form an ERISA plan? There
- 8:18are two ways. On the next slide, you can see
- 8:21there's the formal path, which is ERISA is a
- 8:24very comprehensive and reticulated statute. It
- 8:29says that all plans are supposed to be or must
- 8:32have a formal written instrument that establishes
- 8:35and maintains the plan. then there's a separate
- 8:39document, or they're supposed to be, called the
- 8:41summary plan description. This gives the common
- 8:46man or the lay person a way to digest, well,
- 8:52what exactly do these benefits provide? It is
- 8:56generally not the governing document. It is intended
- 9:00to provide information and not actually the terms
- 9:02of the plan. These documents will also tell you
- 9:06who the fiduciaries are and the funding source,
- 9:09which is typically a trust, general assets, or
- 9:13an insurance policy. And usually the distinction
- 9:17between whether it's an insured plan or a non
- 9:20-insured plan through something that's called
- 9:22the Deemer Clause is important if you start going
- 9:26down some of these paths because you might encounter
- 9:29different laws. because if it's an insured plan,
- 9:34getting a little deep in this, but then there
- 9:37can be insurance laws, state insurance laws,
- 9:40that are saved from the ERISA preemption. So
- 9:44ERISA, give it, take it away, all in one. You
- 9:49can also establish plans informally. So courts
- 9:54have recognized that if, individuals or employees
- 9:59are able to determine what the intended benefits
- 10:03are, who the intended beneficiaries are, the
- 10:07funding source, and how the plan is going to
- 10:09operate, you in fact have established, and when
- 10:12I say you, I mean an employer, an employer has
- 10:15established an ERISA plan even though it hasn't
- 10:19gone through what otherwise would be required
- 10:22for establishing such a plan. So now that we
- 10:28know the different types of plans that are out
- 10:31there, let's move to the types of ERISA claims.
- 10:34And specifically, we start to hone in here on
- 10:37LTD claims. So if you encounter a welfare benefit
- 10:44that is an LTD ERISA governed plan, and there
- 10:49happens to be a problem with this, well, what
- 10:52are... your causes of action or your remedies.
- 10:57And there are three that ERISA provides, or certainly
- 11:01most commonly. The first one's a denial of benefit
- 11:03claim. This is essentially a breach of contract
- 11:06claim. It's saying, hey, I was supposed to get
- 11:10these benefits. I'm entitled to them under the
- 11:12plan. You denied my claim. Now I'm bringing lawsuit
- 11:17to get those back. There's a breach of fiduciary
- 11:21duty claim. I'll touch on that in a bit. It doesn't
- 11:25come up nearly as often in LTD claims as it might
- 11:28in some other welfare benefit claims, and especially
- 11:32not as much as in the retirement benefit claims.
- 11:36And then there's civil penalties for the failure
- 11:39to provide plan documents. One thing that ERISA
- 11:42is about is ensuring that employees know exactly
- 11:48what benefits they have. And one way that ERISA
- 11:52did this is by allowing employees to ask their
- 11:56employer or the plan administrator for a copy
- 12:01of the plan documents. And that plan administrator
- 12:04has 30 days to provide a copy. And if they don't,
- 12:08they're subject to penalties for each day after
- 12:11the 30 days in which they fail to provide it.
- 12:14So let's start going through a bit more of those
- 12:16remedies a bit more closely. On the next slide,
- 12:19we can see what you can get out of each of these
- 12:23remedies and a bit about how you have to establish
- 12:28these claims. So I'll start from right to left
- 12:32from kind of least important to most important,
- 12:34the civil penalties. You can see it's $110 for
- 12:38each day after the information was due. That's
- 12:40a completely judicially discretionary award.
- 12:46So the judge looks at the factors and makes a
- 12:48decision whether you get zero to $110 a day for
- 12:53any financial violation. One thing I left off
- 12:57this slide is that a successful civil penalties
- 13:01claim can allow you to get attorney's fees, which
- 13:06as you see in the breach of fiduciary duty and
- 13:10the denial of benefit claims, is another place
- 13:13where ERISA departs from the standard of American
- 13:21jurisprudence, which is that it's a fee -shifting
- 13:24statute. If anybody on either side, meaning a
- 13:30defendant, a plaintiff, achieves some success
- 13:34on the merits, they're technically allowed to
- 13:37apply for or seek attorney's fees. We'll get
- 13:42into that a bit more later. But you can get that
- 13:47for breach of fiduciary duty. You can get it
- 13:49for the denial of a benefit claim and for civil
- 13:52penalties. In breach of fiduciary duty claims,
- 13:57this is a form of equitable relief. An interesting
- 14:03note here, as the slide says, the Supreme Court
- 14:07in 2011 in a case generally called Amara educated
- 14:12everybody that in fact equitable relief can end
- 14:16up with a war of monetary damages, where generally
- 14:22the law or most people before them had been thinking
- 14:26that equitable relief cannot be monetary, otherwise
- 14:31it would be sounding in a different remedial
- 14:35scheme. So you can get make whole relief. from
- 14:41a breach of video share duty claim. Now what
- 14:44you can't get, just like in a denial benefits
- 14:47claim or in a civil penalties claim, is consequential
- 14:51damages, punitive damages, emotional distress
- 14:55damages. All those things are not available in
- 14:59ERISA claims. Now on the proof side, Breach of
- 15:06fiduciary duties are a bit unsettled in, well,
- 15:09how do you prove a breach of fiduciary duty?
- 15:12Do you get to have discovery? So full federal
- 15:17discovery here, by the way, because it's, I failed
- 15:19to mention that ERISA is a federal statute. So
- 15:23it has a federal jurisdiction, federal question
- 15:27jurisdiction. So almost all of these cases are
- 15:30going to be in federal court. so the better rules
- 15:33of civil procedure apply. But breach of fiduciary
- 15:38duty claims, whether they might entitle you to
- 15:42a jury trial or even an actual judge trial with
- 15:45witnesses is a bit of an open question. We now
- 15:49move over to long -term disability claims and
- 15:51the denial benefits. There it's, back one slide,
- 15:56sorry. It's pretty well established. You're not
- 16:01going to get a jury trial. You're not going to
- 16:03get witnesses. You're going to get very limited
- 16:06discovery on top of the very limited damages
- 16:10that you can see. What you really can get out
- 16:14of a successful claim there is that you can get
- 16:17the benefits to the date of judgment. You're
- 16:20not going to be able to get future benefits or
- 16:23accelerated benefits on your disability claim.
- 16:28And if there's an open question, you might even
- 16:31end up just back with the administrator on what's
- 16:34called a renan, where for lack of a better term,
- 16:38you start over and they look at the mistake they
- 16:42made and fix it. And so with that, that's the
- 16:45remedies and proof. We'll now move into actually
- 16:48the nuts and bolts of a long -term disability
- 16:51plan and the claims. And I'm going to walk us
- 16:57through what a long -term disability plan looks
- 17:01like. Every long -term disability plan is different.
- 17:05There are insured plans, which are usually backed
- 17:08by an insurance policy, and there are self -funded
- 17:10plans where the employer funds its own plan.
- 17:15And so the plan essentially functions as an insurance
- 17:18policy. The very first thing you do if you have
- 17:21a disability claim that you're looking at, you
- 17:23have to review the plan documents. You get those
- 17:27documents from the plan administrator who is
- 17:31identified in the plan documents to usually the
- 17:35employer. The insurance company, if there's an
- 17:38insurance company involved and most claim, most
- 17:41employers have and insurer underwriting and ensuring
- 17:46the plan for them. The insurance company is not
- 17:50the legally required entity that has to provide
- 17:55the documents. The plan administrator is. So
- 17:58you can ask the insurance company to provide
- 18:01a copy of the plan or policy. If they don't,
- 18:05if they say, oh, that's not our job. Oh, that's.
- 18:08you need to talk to the plan administrator, they
- 18:10don't actually have any penalty for refusing
- 18:13to do so. Only the plan administrator can be
- 18:16held to penalties. So you need to ask the employer,
- 18:20you need to ask HR for a copy. If HR tells you
- 18:25that they are unable to provide one, you need
- 18:27to document that. Because under ERISA, after
- 18:3130 days of their refusal to provide a copy, penalties
- 18:35can accrue and those penalties can be up to $110
- 18:38a day if the judge chooses to enforce that. So
- 18:43that can be a substantial amount of money over
- 18:45the course of time if HR continues to insist
- 18:48that they don't have a copy. HR is required to
- 18:51have a copy. Another Option and this will not
- 18:55give you a copy of the plan, but it will let
- 18:58you know if a plan exists and has been designated
- 19:01as an ERISA plan. You can go to the Department
- 19:05of Labor site and look up the form 5500 5500
- 19:11for that employer that will list. all of the
- 19:16ERISA plans that the employer has filed with
- 19:19the Department of Labor and the IRS. If there
- 19:23is a plan listed for long -term disability, then
- 19:28you know that the long -term disability plan
- 19:31has been designated ERISA. It can be a quick
- 19:33and easy way to at least narrow down whether
- 19:37a plan is ERISA. Also, of note, filing a form
- 19:415500 does not automatically make it an ERISA
- 19:45plan if the employer does not comply with all
- 19:49the other requirements of an ERISA plan. But
- 19:51it is a good first step in determining whether
- 19:54or not the employer intended it to be treated
- 19:57as ERISA. So if there's ever any doubt, that
- 20:00is a good place to look initially. If we go down
- 20:04to the next slide, we're going to be talking
- 20:07about and the nuts and bolts of a policy. Every
- 20:12policy is different, but most of them have similar
- 20:15issues that are addressed. And because we can't
- 20:18talk about every policy in the world today, we're
- 20:20going to look at Google's long -term policy.
- 20:24This benefit plan, Google long -term benefits.
- 20:28Note that the certificate date here says January
- 20:301st, 2022. This is actually of interest because
- 20:35the policy that controls is the one that's in
- 20:40place on your last day of work, on the insured's
- 20:43last day of work. So if an insured became disabled
- 20:47in 2022, that's the policy that's going to control.
- 20:51Google has actually issued an updated one now
- 20:53in 2025. It has mostly the same slightly different
- 20:58terms. But if you have a client or you are an
- 21:02insured or you have an employee who became disabled
- 21:05in 2022, the newer plan does not control. It's
- 21:10the plan in place at the time of the disability
- 21:12and MetLife. will be very well aware of that
- 21:17if you try to argue anything differently. So
- 21:20it's important if you get a copy of the policy
- 21:22to make sure it is the one that controls for
- 21:25your client or your employee. And let's go down
- 21:29to the next slide. The very first thing we look
- 21:33at is who's eligible under this plan. There will
- 21:37be somewhere in the plan something that discusses
- 21:41eligibility requirements for Google's. You have
- 21:44to be in an eligible class of employee. For Google,
- 21:48that means you have to have been scheduled to
- 21:50work at least 20 more hours a week for at least
- 21:52five months during a calendar year. Not every
- 21:56employer has that requirement. They can all look
- 21:58very different. That's why it's important to
- 22:00look at this. And Google excludes people who
- 22:06are in a separate job agreement with the policyholder
- 22:09who are not eligible for insurance benefits.
- 22:12It excludes variable part -time employees. It
- 22:15doesn't cover interns and it doesn't cover independent
- 22:18contractors. And they are very clearly state,
- 22:21even if such persons are determined by a court
- 22:24regulatory body or agency to have been common
- 22:27law employees. Whether or not that last piece
- 22:30is going to be enforceable in a court of law
- 22:32remains to be seen. But that's certainly Google
- 22:37and MetLife's intention as stated in the policy.
- 22:40One thing that's important to remember is going
- 22:42through these policies. These policies are contracts.
- 22:46They are subject to interpretation by a court,
- 22:49and the language in the policy is not necessarily
- 22:53going to be upheld by a court. So it's important
- 22:56to know what the policy says, but it's also important
- 22:58to remember it's a contract. If it's not well
- 23:02written, if it goes against settled federal law
- 23:07under ERISA or potentially state law, depending
- 23:09on the issue, it might not be enforced. So something
- 23:13to keep in mind as you're reading through this.
- 23:16So first you determine is the insured or employee
- 23:19eligible. After you determine that, let's go
- 23:23to the next slide. Then we look at what's the
- 23:28benefit and what is the waiting period. Usually
- 23:31the monthly benefit is on average about 60 %
- 23:36of the pre -disability earnings. Now, pre -disability
- 23:41earnings is going to be a defined term and depending
- 23:43on who your employer is, it could encompass all
- 23:46sorts of things. It could be limited to your
- 23:50base salary alone. It could include bonuses.
- 23:53It could include bonuses that were paid in the
- 23:5612 months prior to... your disability, it could
- 24:01include an average of 24 months. It could include
- 24:04variable pay and overtime. It could include stock.
- 24:09There are policies that explicitly do not include
- 24:12stock. So looking at the definitions of these
- 24:16are where you need to go first to determine what
- 24:19you're dealing with. For this, the monthly benefit.
- 24:2260 % of the first $25 ,000 of your pre -disability
- 24:25earnings. That means that's going to be anybody
- 24:29earning up to $500 ,000 a year. And so the first
- 24:35$25 ,000, you get 60 % of the disability earnings
- 24:38up to $25 ,000. Oh, actually, I misinterpreted
- 24:42that. Sorry. It's up to $15 ,000. That means
- 24:45it's going to be people earning up to $350 ,000.
- 24:48After that, if you do earn $500 ,000, You're
- 24:52out of luck on that bit above that. So this is
- 24:55maximum monthly benefit of fifteen thousand minimum
- 24:58monthly benefit of a hundred dollars. So if you
- 25:02let's say your benefit should be four thousand
- 25:05dollars a month. You were earning ten thousand.
- 25:08You get 60 percent. Let's say you get six thousand
- 25:11and then let's say you have. offsets from Social
- 25:16Security, which under all of these policies,
- 25:19Social Security is considered an offset. So if
- 25:21you're disabled, the insurance company can require
- 25:24you to apply for Social Security. You apply for
- 25:27Social Security. It's approved. You get your
- 25:30benefit. And if you have children, that can go
- 25:33up to over $6 ,000 a month. So let's say your
- 25:37benefit is $6 ,000, but your Social Security
- 25:39is $6 ,500 a month, even though that would zero
- 25:44out your benefit under this, they would still
- 25:46have to pay you $100 a month under the minimum
- 25:48monthly benefit. It's an unusual circumstance.
- 25:51It doesn't come up a lot, but it certainly can
- 25:53come up. You also want to look at the elimination
- 25:56period. The elimination period is the greater
- 26:00of the short -term disability maximum benefit
- 26:03because we're looking at long -term disability
- 26:05here. So short -term disability is usually three
- 26:07to six months prior to that. There's usually
- 26:10a waiting period to get to long -term disability.
- 26:12most employers offer short -term disability to
- 26:15cover the gap, whether that's three months or
- 26:17six months. And this, because Google is based
- 26:21in California, also includes the California voluntary
- 26:27disability income coverage or VDI or 180 days.
- 26:34So basically, it's going to be 180 days. So you
- 26:41want to make sure that your claimant has been
- 26:44disabled for at least 180 days to be able to
- 26:47qualify for long -term disability benefits. And
- 26:50if we go to the next slide, as note, as I mentioned,
- 26:57what we're looking at right now is the 2022 Google
- 27:00policy. In 2025, people now get 65 % of their
- 27:06pre -disability earnings up to a maximum benefit
- 27:08of 20 ,000. And as I mentioned, it's important
- 27:12to look at the policy in place at the time you
- 27:15became disabled. While this change has been made
- 27:17in 2025, it's not going to apply to everybody
- 27:20who became disabled prior to this. So if you
- 27:23became disabled as a Google employee in 2024,
- 27:27you are out of luck on accessing these higher
- 27:31levels of benefits. You are still going to get
- 27:3460 % and it's still going to have a cap of 15
- 27:37,000. It's important to always understand that
- 27:40you have the copy of the policy in place at the
- 27:43time you became disabled. Let's go on to the
- 27:47next slide. As we discussed, pre -disability
- 27:52earnings is an important part of the definitions.
- 27:58According to Google's definition, it includes
- 28:01the benefit salary you were earning from the
- 28:03policy holder, which is Google, as of your last
- 28:06day of active work. If you were eligible for
- 28:10commissions, it'll be based on 100 % of your
- 28:13target earnings as determined by Google, by the
- 28:16policyholder. If you're a non -exempt employee,
- 28:19it's based on your annualized hourly rate as
- 28:21of your last active day of work. So if you started
- 28:24out the year making $30 an hour as a non -exempt
- 28:28employee and you got to raise up to $34 an hour
- 28:31three weeks before you became disabled, that
- 28:34$34 is going to be what it's calculated on. If
- 28:38you are a massage therapist, which apparently
- 28:40Google employs, your pre -disability earnings
- 28:43are based on the hourly rate from the massage
- 28:45pay rate. If there's an increase in your pre
- 28:49-disability earnings, it will be applied as of
- 28:52the effective date of the increase. So this is
- 28:57vague. This does not address whether or not bonuses
- 29:01are included. It does not address whether or
- 29:03not stock is included. and where language is
- 29:06vague, it is considered ambiguous. So I would
- 29:12argue that if it doesn't actively say bonuses
- 29:16are not included, that bonuses are included.
- 29:18It doesn't say that stock is not included. I
- 29:20would argue that stock is included. Google and
- 29:22MetLife might disagree. So these are the types
- 29:25of areas where it becomes confusing. But under
- 29:31Ninth Circuit law, If the policy is ambiguous,
- 29:34it should be interpreted in favor of the insured
- 29:37or employee because they did not have a role
- 29:41in drafting this. Let's go to the next page.
- 29:46And here we get into what should be included.
- 29:52It specifically states the term does not include
- 29:55tips, award, and bonuses. So now we know that.
- 29:58Does not include overtime pay. It does not include
- 30:02the grant, award, sale, conversion or exercise
- 30:04of shares or stock or stock options. And it does
- 30:08not include any deferred compensation arrangement
- 30:11or pension contributions. And it does not include
- 30:14anything else. So this is where the people drafting
- 30:20this for MetLife were careful and they put in
- 30:23the necessary language. There are many policies
- 30:26out there that do not have this language. And
- 30:29I can assure you that there has been copious
- 30:31amounts of litigation about the lack of these
- 30:36clarifications. So this is why it's important
- 30:40to look at the details of the language. The language
- 30:42controls. It's a contract. And if it's not in
- 30:45there, then it opens it up for ambiguity. So
- 30:48always make sure you know what is and is not
- 30:50covered. And let's go to the next slide. As we
- 30:57discussed, Ninth Circuit courts are clear. If
- 30:59the policy includes bonuses in the pre -disability
- 31:02earnings definition, and it doesn't explicitly
- 31:05exclude stock, stock awards received in the defined
- 31:10period before disability are considered pre -disability
- 31:13income. Some employers, like Amazon, include
- 31:16stock awards in pre -disability income. It says
- 31:18it right in the policy. Others, like Microsoft,
- 31:21are silent on it. They include bonuses, but they
- 31:24don't address stock one way or the other. These
- 31:27are the types of issues that crop up when you
- 31:30are addressing whether or not how much of the
- 31:35income is subject to that 60 % or 65%. Depending
- 31:40on who you are and how much of your pay is included
- 31:44in bonuses or stock, this can double somebody's
- 31:47income. So it is a significant issue and needs
- 31:50to be considered while reviewing any claim. If
- 31:54we go to the next Slide. Now we look at the maximum
- 32:00benefit period. How long does this go for? How
- 32:02long can your insured potentially be covered
- 32:06for? Most policies have adopted this language,
- 32:09which states the later of your normal retirement
- 32:11age, which is a defined term under Social Security,
- 32:15and it's usually age 67 for Social Security now.
- 32:18And unless you are very close to retirement already,
- 32:22for most people, it is now 67. Some policies
- 32:27will say age 65. Some could have an even shorter
- 32:31age cap. There's nothing in the law that requires
- 32:35it to go to age 65 or 67. It's a term that is
- 32:39selected by the employer and by the insurer.
- 32:44So you want to check to make sure you know what
- 32:47you're covered for. If we go to the next slide,
- 32:52we look at the What do you have to demonstrate
- 32:56to show that you're disabled? It's a defined
- 32:59term. For most policies, and certainly in this
- 33:02Google one here, for the first 24 months of long
- 33:07-term disability, you have to demonstrate that
- 33:09you're unable to perform the substantial and
- 33:12material acts necessary to pursue your usual
- 33:16occupation. And your usual occupation is not
- 33:20just your job. Insurance companies are very,
- 33:23very clear on this. So they will often argue
- 33:26that specific duties that your employer requires
- 33:30may not be specific duties that every employer
- 33:33requires. So it's important to be aware of that.
- 33:37If you were working as an accountant when you
- 33:40became disabled, you need to look at how the
- 33:43job of an accountant is performed in the general
- 33:48economy, not necessarily at your own individual
- 33:53employer. After 24 months, you have to be able
- 33:57to demonstrate at Google that you were unable
- 34:01to engage with reasonable continuity in any occupation
- 34:06in which you could be expected to perform in
- 34:08light of your age, education, training, experience,
- 34:12station in life, and physical and mental capacity.
- 34:15The inclusion of station and life here is not
- 34:18seen in every policy Station and life is often
- 34:21interpreted by courts to include To a certain
- 34:26extent consideration of how much money you are
- 34:28making Basically means that if you were a senior
- 34:31executive at Google after 24 months You cannot
- 34:34be expected to go get a job working at McDonald's
- 34:38serving fast food. There's a It's an undefined
- 34:42concept and it's not strictly limited to pay,
- 34:47but it is often tied to it by court analysis.
- 34:53Also, many policies do not include station in
- 34:58life. Many instead say you have to... If you're
- 35:03disabled, you cannot be able to do a job that
- 35:05makes at least 60 or potentially 80 % of your
- 35:08prior salary. That's another way that salary
- 35:10can come into play to, again, make sure that
- 35:14a white -collar employee is not expected to all
- 35:17of a sudden be doing menial sedentary work, like
- 35:21checking badges, for example, at a gate. policies
- 35:28have evolved over time to consider these issues.
- 35:32Also this policy has language that I like to
- 35:34see which states that you cannot be expected
- 35:37to travel more than a reasonable distance or
- 35:40travel time from your residence in light of the
- 35:43commuting practices of your community. That is
- 35:46a term subject to interpretation. So what is
- 35:49the reasonable commuting practice of your community?
- 35:52If you live in a small town, it might be 15 minutes.
- 35:55If you live in the San Francisco metro area,
- 35:59that could be two hours. So there's a lot of
- 36:03interpretation there. Also, you can't be expected
- 36:06to travel more than you traveled to work before
- 36:10coming disabled. And it needs to be a job that
- 36:14exists somewhere in your regional labor market.
- 36:17So if the job doesn't exist, they can't expect
- 36:19you to perform it, even if they have vocational
- 36:22experts who say you could be able to perform
- 36:24it. So if you worked for Google and you became
- 36:27disabled, these are additional issues that would
- 36:29need to be considered after the first 24 months.
- 36:33If we go to the next slide, we're looking at
- 36:37partial disability. You are entitled to benefits
- 36:41if you are able to work, but you can only work
- 36:44on a part time basis because of your disability.
- 36:48This particular policy defines partial disability
- 36:51as being unable to earn 80 % or more of your
- 36:54pre -disability earnings. And under this policy,
- 36:59if you're partially disabled for more than 24
- 37:02months, they'll adjust your pre -disability earnings
- 37:05only for the purpose of determining whether you
- 37:08are partially disabled and for calculating any
- 37:11return to work incentive. That is an amount that
- 37:15is deducted from what you're earning. Insurance
- 37:18companies want you to try to go back to work.
- 37:20So they claim in the policies to have incentives
- 37:25for you to return to work. Those incentives often
- 37:29allow you to make a certain amount of money without
- 37:31being penalized by it with the hope and intention
- 37:35that you will return to work. After a certain
- 37:39amount of time, that amount that you are able
- 37:42to earn will be deducted from your benefit so
- 37:47that the return to work incentive disappears
- 37:50over time. As it says annually thereafter, we
- 37:55will add an amount to your adjusted pre -disability
- 37:58earnings calculated by the method set forth above,
- 38:01but substituting your adjusted pre -disability
- 38:03earnings from the prior year. What this is really
- 38:06saying is that they will adjust your benefits
- 38:10each year depending on how much you're making.
- 38:13Also, in my own experience, While insurance companies
- 38:18claim that they want you to try to work part
- 38:20-time, in reality, what I at least frequently
- 38:23see is that when people attempt to make a claim
- 38:26for partial disability, insurance companies are
- 38:29very skeptical and ask why you cannot work 40
- 38:33hours a week if you're able to work 20 hours
- 38:35a week. So be aware that that can often... complicate
- 38:39a disability claim because it can be difficult
- 38:42to explain objectively why it is that an insured
- 38:47cannot regularly work 40 hours a week if they
- 38:50are able to work part -time. It can become a
- 38:55difficult and complicated question. But insurance
- 38:59policies do provide coverage for partial disability.
- 39:03And if we go to the next slide. When does the
- 39:07coverage terminate? It terminates if the group
- 39:10policy ends. It terminates if the last day of
- 39:15the calendar month when the insurance ends for
- 39:17your class. It terminates on the last day of
- 39:19the calendar month for which the last premium
- 39:21has been paid for you. It terminates on the last
- 39:24day of the calendar month when you cease to be
- 39:26an eligible class. It terminates on the last
- 39:30day of the calendar month when your employment
- 39:32ends. or the last day of the calendar month in
- 39:35which you retire. Termination of coverage does
- 39:39not mean termination of benefits. If you are
- 39:44on disability or in the process of making a disability
- 39:48claim, then you will still be able to obtain
- 39:56benefits. So be aware of that. People in HR are
- 40:00often confused about that. Let's go to the next
- 40:03slide. And we really just covered all of this.
- 40:12This is when disability payments end. End of
- 40:14the maximum benefit period, end of the date you
- 40:17are no longer disabled, the date you die, if
- 40:21you refuse to participate in a rehabilitation
- 40:24program that we require, if you refuse to have
- 40:27a medical exam, the... If your insurance ends,
- 40:33this says right here, your benefits will not
- 40:35be affected. So be aware of that. And I'm going
- 40:38to skip ahead because we are rapidly running
- 40:40out of time. So let's move ahead. Let's see,
- 40:44we've got temporary recovery. If you try to go
- 40:46back to work and you're able to work for a few
- 40:49months and then you're disabled again, you can
- 40:52make a recurrent claim that's based in the same
- 40:56disability that you had before. Let's look at
- 40:59the next slide. These are work incentives. As
- 41:05this says here, there's a limit on the work incentives
- 41:07for the first 24 months. We largely talked about
- 41:10work incentives already, so let's move to the
- 41:12next slide. Offsets. We talked about this already.
- 41:18Insurance companies are able to offset any additional
- 41:22benefits to which you are entitled from the government.
- 41:27People fight that a lot, but it's very clearly
- 41:30allowed under the contract and under federal
- 41:32law. Let's skip ahead to the next slide. This
- 41:36continues to talk about the different types of
- 41:39offsets. This includes sick pay, it includes
- 41:41any settlement if you were in a car accident
- 41:43or anything like that, or anything that you were
- 41:46earning from working part -time. Let's continue
- 41:50to the next slide. Limitations and exclusions.
- 41:54This is important. Many, most policies have a
- 41:5824 -month limitation for substance abuse and
- 42:04you only have coverage for a total of 24 months.
- 42:08If we go to the next slide. You'll see that that
- 42:12also applies to mental and nervous disorders.
- 42:15The Google policy actually provides 60 months,
- 42:18which is unusual. Most policies have a 24 -month
- 42:21limit. I know Microsoft recently increased theirs
- 42:24to 36 months, but 60 months is generous and unusual.
- 42:28So for substance abuse and mental and nervous
- 42:31disorders, that's very nice to see. They are
- 42:34allowed to terminate your benefits after that,
- 42:37even if you continue to remain disabled. Let's
- 42:40continue to the next slide. If you become disabled
- 42:45because you were in a war, because you participated
- 42:48in a riot, or you were committing a felony, they
- 42:50don't have to cover your benefits. Let's go to
- 42:53the next slide. Pre -existing exclusions. If
- 42:58you had been working for less than a year and
- 43:01you became disabled for something you were treating
- 43:03for in the three months prior to your coverage
- 43:06beginning, they can exclude you from having coverage.
- 43:11And treatment can be as simple as getting a refill
- 43:14on a medication or even having insurance companies
- 43:17argue that it includes having a prescription
- 43:20in place, even if you didn't pick up the refill.
- 43:23So it's important to realize in that three months,
- 43:25if you were receiving any type of treatment,
- 43:28even if it's for symptoms and the disability
- 43:31hasn't been diagnosed yet, the insurance company
- 43:34will argue that it's a preexisting limitation
- 43:36and that they don't have to cover it. Let's move
- 43:39to the next slide. And I believe Michelle is
- 43:42going to take over and talk about the ERISA regulation.
- 43:47Yes, thank you. So Brent gave like a good overview
- 43:51of Arissa and the law and remedies and Stacey
- 43:54went through sort of like the. common terms in
- 43:57a long -term disability policy. So I'm going
- 43:59to talk about the whole claims procedure and
- 44:02what you have to do to submit an effective appeal
- 44:05when it comes to long -term disability claims.
- 44:07So it's important to understand that employers
- 44:09do not have to provide these voluntary disability
- 44:12benefits. But if they do, they have to provide
- 44:16them consistent with the risks of implementing
- 44:18regulations. And it's. It's a very, it's a highly
- 44:23regulated area. And so there's rules that govern
- 44:27the initial claim for benefits and an appeal
- 44:30of an adverse determination. And the citations
- 44:32to the regulations are there. I'm not gonna keep
- 44:34repeating them as we go along. Next slide. Okay,
- 44:39so once a claim for benefits is submitted, claims
- 44:44administrator has to make a decision within 45
- 44:47days of receipt of the claim and i'm talking
- 44:49specifically here about disability claims there
- 44:52can be different dates when it comes to like
- 44:54other types of claims like pension or life insurance
- 44:56claims or health claims so if the administrator
- 45:00needs an extension of time because they don't
- 45:02have enough information or their special circumstances
- 45:05they can take up to two 30 day extensions so
- 45:08we're talking about a claims process that can
- 45:10take up to 105 days if there's any delay in getting
- 45:15the information to the claims administrator.
- 45:18If the administrator denies the claim, the claimant
- 45:24has 180 days to submit an appeal. And it sounds
- 45:30like a lot of time, but often it's not nearly
- 45:33enough time to put together an effective appeal
- 45:35because of all the things that I'm going to discuss
- 45:37in the subsequent slides. So once an appeal is
- 45:41submitted, the administrator has to make a decision
- 45:45within 45 days. Again, this is for disability
- 45:49benefit claims. It's a shorter window of time
- 45:51and they can take up to one 45 day extension.
- 45:53So there will be up to possibly 90 days. Next
- 45:59slide. Okay, so most policies will have a review
- 46:04procedure. Even if not, I suggest you go ahead
- 46:07and you submit an appeal within 180 days and
- 46:12if you need more time than that, get any extension
- 46:15request in writing. It's important that the appeal
- 46:19is on time because even being late by one day
- 46:22can cause your claim to just basically be tossed
- 46:26out. So next slide. I think that might be a duplicate
- 46:33slide. Next slide. OK, so I'm going to talk a
- 46:38little bit about the administrative record. It's
- 46:40basically everything that was submitted to the
- 46:42claims administrator during the claims and appeals
- 46:44process up until the time that the administrator
- 46:47issues a final determination. And this is important
- 46:50because, as Brent talked about, litigation the
- 46:53administrative record is basically the only thing
- 46:55that a judge is going to be looking at on the
- 46:58merits of the claim except in some certain certain
- 47:01circumstances regarding discovery and conflict
- 47:03of interest and all that. Next slide. Okay so
- 47:06I want to make sure we can get to talking about
- 47:08preparing a strong administrative appeal and
- 47:11so a lot of times when claims are denied the
- 47:13basis for the denial is that the insurance company
- 47:16just thinks that the person can work right and
- 47:18there can be a number of reasons why a claim
- 47:19gets denied but this is the Most often so you
- 47:23definitely want to get a copy of the claim file
- 47:26and you can get that by writing to usually the
- 47:28insurance company to ask for the complete. All
- 47:33of the documents that are relevant to the claim
- 47:35and in there you're going to see things like
- 47:37the reasons for the claim denial internal notes
- 47:39medical reviews vocational reviews sometimes
- 47:42surveillance reports and videos and you know
- 47:45anything that the administrator did in deciding
- 47:49the claim next slide. A lot of times people think,
- 47:54oh, I'll just write to the insurance company
- 47:56and say, I appeal, I disagree, and make some
- 47:59argument about why the decision is wrong. That
- 48:02is generally not enough to win an appeal. Because
- 48:06the court is going to be limited to the record,
- 48:09it is extremely important that any information
- 48:11that is out there that can support the claim
- 48:13be submitted during the appeal stage. Next slide.
- 48:19All right. i guess the types of evidence that
- 48:22we typically submit to support disability you
- 48:25know the first one is probably obvious medical
- 48:28records there you're going to see quote unquote
- 48:31you know objective evidence of disability things
- 48:34like you know current symptoms that are documented
- 48:36other medical conditions that might affect or
- 48:39lengthen the recovery period any. abnormalities,
- 48:45results from physical exams, observations that
- 48:48might be made by the treating provider during
- 48:50a visit, and diagnostic tests and their results.
- 48:53And sometimes for invisible disabilities, you're
- 48:55not going to have this type of evidence, but
- 48:57we definitely like to see medical records that
- 49:03include all of these things. Next slide. Other
- 49:09things that are available in the medical records
- 49:11or should be in there are the treatment plan
- 49:13medications and side effects or responses to
- 49:16those medications sometimes people can be disabled
- 49:18simply because of medication side effects and
- 49:21there's good case law on that. There you know
- 49:27a lot of times like doctors are not writing medical
- 49:29records for purposes of disability claims but
- 49:33we like to see. Discussion about. the claimant's
- 49:38level of functionality, what are the restrictions
- 49:40and limitations, and we usually will ask providers
- 49:45to include a statement as to how the employee's
- 49:49level of functioning impacts their ability to
- 49:51do their job, as well as their activities of
- 49:54daily living. Next slide. Other evidence that
- 49:59we submit, letters from medical providers to
- 50:02supplement what um, they might be documenting
- 50:05in medical records or to address, uh, rebuttal,
- 50:09I'm sorry, peer reviews or medical reviews obtained
- 50:12by the insurance company that are adverse to
- 50:15their claim, address any issues around surveillance.
- 50:18Like, okay, the insurance company saw the person
- 50:21going grocery shopping. Does this change your
- 50:22opinion about their workability? I like to get
- 50:25declarations, including from the claimant, friends,
- 50:27coworkers, anybody who can provide testimony
- 50:30because, again, they're not going to get on the
- 50:32stand and testify. So statements under penalty
- 50:35of perjury submitted during the appeals process
- 50:37is something that we use a lot. And then other
- 50:40types of exams that will objectively show restrictions
- 50:43and limitations, functional capacity evaluations,
- 50:46independent medical examinations. Sometimes there
- 50:48are tricky vocational issues that are an issue
- 50:51and we want a vocational expert to opine on that.
- 50:55Particularly for tricky conditions that might
- 50:59not be as well understood, medical literature.
- 51:03It's better to get that into the record versus
- 51:06trying to rely on citations when you're in court
- 51:09because court has to take judicial notice of
- 51:12that. But if it's in the record, it's easier
- 51:14to cite to. And then if a claimant has a positive
- 51:17social security claim, or if they have like a
- 51:19worker's comp file, getting records from those
- 51:22files would also provide supporting information.
- 51:26Next slide. All right. And then Brent will take
- 51:31us home with inadvertent waiver of a risk of
- 51:34claims. All right. So speaking of inadvertence,
- 51:39my webcam has decided to start to move around
- 51:41all over the place. Welcome to the world of better
- 51:44technology. So the biggest thing here that I
- 51:49want practitioners who don't operate in this
- 51:53field much is to think about, might my client
- 51:57have other benefits besides what I'm dealing
- 52:01with that might have an interaction or interplay
- 52:04with this? A lot of the slides we have here are
- 52:11focusing specifically on severance agreements.
- 52:15So if you're an unemployment attorney and you
- 52:21are settling an employment dispute, you absolutely
- 52:24need to be asking your client if they are on
- 52:28disability, if they have any... potential employee
- 52:33benefits that might, that they're still receiving
- 52:36a connection with this employer, because oftentimes
- 52:39severance plans are general releases. Not only
- 52:44are they general, but then if you look at the
- 52:46next slide, you'll, and even the next slide after
- 52:51this, you'll see that they include things like
- 52:57ERISA plans, insurers, administrators, And some
- 53:02courts will find that that will be a waiver of
- 53:06those claims, especially if your client is represented.
- 53:14Now, it has to be a knowing and voluntary waiver,
- 53:18so the bar is pretty high. But if you are representing
- 53:22somebody, it is hard to argue that Gosh, I didn't
- 53:27know I was waiving my disability claim when I
- 53:31settled my employment suit. If you're represented
- 53:35by a lawyer who should be telling you, hey, you
- 53:39know you are giving up these rights in exchange
- 53:44for the settlement agreement. Now, other places
- 53:47you might see this are personal injury clients.
- 53:52Some plans, and especially disability plans,
- 53:55will have offset provisions for loss of income
- 54:03that is attributable to the accident that caused
- 54:06the disability. So if you're in a PI case and
- 54:11you're making claims for lack of earning capacity,
- 54:17you want to know if, hey, maybe my client has
- 54:20insurance covering this. And if it's an ERISA
- 54:22plan, you want to be looking in there to be sure
- 54:25that what, if anything, does it say about this
- 54:30recovery being an offset? Because you might be
- 54:34able to shift things around in how you present
- 54:36the case or how you settle the case so that you
- 54:40aren't in effect robbing Peter to pay Paul. So
- 54:45getting money that gets paid by one party in
- 54:50your PI case only to have that client turn around
- 54:54and the insurance company has its handout asking
- 54:57for that exact same money. Of course, the client
- 55:01now has less of it because they paid you. That
- 55:05is not a phone call you want to be having with
- 55:08your client after you settle a PI case. Similarly,
- 55:13you see a bit of this in workers' compensation
- 55:16cases. where if sometimes ERISA plans will have
- 55:21offsets for specific elements of workers' compensation
- 55:24claims, sometimes only permanent, stationary,
- 55:28not medical, things like that. So you want to
- 55:32be aware of those things because to the extent
- 55:34you can resolve or push certain aspects of your
- 55:40case in a way that it doesn't result in a loss
- 55:44of benefits in another area, you need to be doing
- 55:49it. So it is very much if you're in any area
- 55:54of law that starts to touch on the wide range
- 55:58of these employee benefits, to retirement benefits,
- 56:02to disability, life insurance, health insurance,
- 56:06all those types of things. It'd be wise to ask
- 56:11your client, do you have any of these things?
- 56:14Do you have potential claims for them? Because
- 56:19you do need to be looking into these documents.
- 56:22And Stacey did a good job of pointing out some
- 56:24of those areas that you want to be looking at
- 56:27to see, how might resolution of my case impact
- 56:33my client in these other areas? So with that,
- 56:37you know, that's the end of our presentation.
- 56:39I don't know if we have a moment for questions,
- 56:42but if there are any, I'm sure we're happy to
- 56:45be with that. And otherwise I will turn it back
- 56:48over to Stacey to wrap this up. There were a
- 56:52couple of questions that I answered, but maybe.
- 56:55quickly helpful for other people? Can an employer
- 56:58terminate a partially disabled employee if there
- 57:01is cause to do so? Yes. Yes, you can if you demonstrate
- 57:05cause, whether or not that employee decides to
- 57:09look into if they have an ADA claim. separate
- 57:13issue not related to their insurance, but if
- 57:15they're receiving partial disability at the time
- 57:18their employment's terminated, they may continue
- 57:20to be eligible for disability. So you can terminate
- 57:24their employment, but that wouldn't remove their
- 57:26eligibility for ongoing benefits. There is no
- 57:32employee trigger for ERISA. any number of employees
- 57:37is subject to ERISA if there is an ERISA plan
- 57:40in place. It can be one, it can be a thousand.
- 57:42Doesn't matter. And the last question was whether
- 57:46or not a ADHD can be considered a diagnosis of
- 57:50disability. And as insurance companies love to
- 57:53explain, disability is based in symptoms, not
- 57:56the diagnosis. So what would matter in that situation
- 57:59is the symptoms that were demonstrated by the
- 58:03employee. And if those symptoms interfered with
- 58:06and made it impossible for them to do the duties
- 58:09of their occupation, or if it's after 24 months,
- 58:13any occupation. So it would be very... specific
- 58:17to the individual situation, as most of these
- 58:19are. There's never a clear yes or no answer.
- 58:23Everything in determining disability depends
- 58:25on that individual situation. Their job, their
- 58:28capabilities, their symptoms, it all comes together.
- 58:33Those are the questions that we had. And if you
- 58:35guys want to jump in and add anything else to
- 58:37that, please feel free. You did a great job.
- 58:43All right then, I think with that, we can conclude
- 58:46and please feel free to reach out to any of us.
- 58:49If you have additional questions, I'm sure all
- 58:51of us are happy to answer. We know it's a complicated
- 58:54area of law and it's coming up a lot with all
- 58:56of the layoffs that have been occurring over
- 58:58the past year. Thank you. Thank you.