Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Dr. Rajiv J. Shah - President at The Rockefeller Foundation | Why You Need To Make Big Bets
Transcript
- 0:00Today, my guest is Dr. Raj Shah Director at the Bill and Linda Gates Foundation,
- 0:05the 16th Administrator of USAID under President Barack Obama, now the President of the Rockefeller
- 0:12Foundation with a $20 billion fund leading the 110-year foundation globally.
- 0:20Welcome to Success Story. I'm your host, Scott Clary. The Success Story podcast is part of
- 0:26the HubSpot podcast network. For everyone listening, I just have to ask you a question. Do you want
- 0:30to know what separates the contenders from the pretenders, the A-list from the C-list,
- 0:35world champions from the world, not champions? It's pretty simple. The fourth quarter in sports,
- 0:42more importantly for a lot of the people listening here in business, finishing strong is key.
- 0:47Now, HubSpots, New Sales Hub is the software that you need for your sales and your sales team
- 0:54to win Q4. You could be a solo printer, you could own and run a larger business, regardless if
- 1:01you're selling anything to anyone, which I think a lot of the people who are listening to this are,
- 1:05you need to check out sales hub. So there is a new prospecting workspace, there's revamped
- 1:10deal management tools, there's smart sequencing, sales hub is loaded with everything you need to
- 1:16turn leads into prospects and then convert those prospects into customers. With sales hub,
- 1:21you have the right information at the right time to build better relationships, which means
- 1:26closing deals has never been easier. So this Q4 give yourself and your team the tools to win big
- 1:34with HubSpot Sales Hub. Learn more at HubSpot.com slash sales.
- 1:39You know what, I'm from suburban Detroit in Michigan, my parents are immigrants from India,
- 1:55and I grew up in a pretty typical Indian-American community in that time, and at that time,
- 2:02sort of our options if you were a hardworking kid where you could be an engineer or a doctor,
- 2:08and I actually wanted to do both, it didn't realize there was any other opportunity or option
- 2:13out there. And frankly, when I was a senior in high school, Nelson Mandela was released from prison,
- 2:22and of all places, he came to Detroit and he walked on the River Rouge auto plant and met with auto
- 2:29workers, my dad had worked at Ford for more than 30 years, and he ultimately gave an amazing
- 2:36speech, a Tiger Stadium, and I was a huge Tigers fan, but it was very Motown, Stevie Wonder was the
- 2:42opening act and Mandela spoke, and I was just watching on TV, but I was transformed, and I just
- 2:49thought what an amazing human being, what an amazing leader he brought tears to everyone's eyes
- 2:56with recounting his struggle and frankly thanking the people of Detroit for their support.
- 3:02And I kind of knew in that moment that I wanted to do something with my life that was more
- 3:08oriented around social change and social justice and impact for those who are left behind,
- 3:14but I had no idea what to do. So I went off to college and one thing led to another and I
- 3:19ultimately had the chance to have this type of career, but that was the moment when I realized
- 3:26that being a doctor or being an engineer in and of itself was probably not going to be my path
- 3:32long term. You know, I admire that because I think a lot of people have those altruistic goals.
- 3:38I think that the changing the world for the better is a thing that everybody wants to accomplish
- 3:44early on in their career, but you ended up in a spot where you could actually do it, and I think
- 3:49a lot of people find themselves aimless and find themselves lost. Maybe we don't have to go into
- 3:54everything you've done in your career because you've done a lot and we'll talk about your story
- 3:58and throughout this podcast and different pieces of it. But let's talk about some of those key
- 4:03things, some of those purposeful things that you did throughout your career that allowed you to
- 4:08eventually end up to where you're at now where you can actually invoke meaningful change at scale.
- 4:15Well, you know, so I went on from college and went on to medical school and as a training doctor
- 4:24to be, I was a highly distracted one. So I kept getting involved and I got involved in local
- 4:30political campaign for then Mayor Ed Rendell in Philadelphia. I kept taking the train down from
- 4:36Philly to D.C. to volunteer and engage in policy-making operations. And finally, I got a chance to
- 4:44join Al Gore's presidential campaign. And that was really a unique experience for me because I
- 4:50here I was like a college graduate and medical school almost graduate. And I went down there just
- 4:56as a volunteer and that experience changed my life because it introduced me to people who
- 5:02were like me, wanted to be involved in social impact and political activity. And even though we lost
- 5:08that campaign, some of us thought we wanted and I could sit here and make the argument that more
- 5:13people voted for Al Gore and Florida for sure. But when we lost that campaign, I was sort of
- 5:20searching around for what to do. And I landed at the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation right when
- 5:24Bill and Melinda were starting their major philanthropic initiatives. And really, I wrote
- 5:30the book Big Bets because of what I learned in those early days at the gates at the gates
- 5:35as hands, which was they wanted to do things that were going to make the make the world a better
- 5:40place. But they wanted to do it at massive scale. It wasn't enough to just say let's help some kids
- 5:46be healthier. It was how do we immunize every child on the planet to save child lives by the
- 5:51millions. And I feel like I learned a mindset and an approach in that setting that I was then able
- 5:58to apply and government and the Obama administration and now at the Rockefeller Foundation.
- 6:03You know, that's like that's like taking big Harry audacious goal to another level.
- 6:09Right. Really, it really is. And I think that I was listening to a couple different podcasts
- 6:14just to sort of prep for this. And I thought of I listened to Armchair X pod with with DAX and you
- 6:21were great on it. And one of the points that he brought up and I thought was so interesting was
- 6:25how effective Bill and Melinda Gates are at philanthropy because of their success in the business
- 6:32world. Maybe walk me through some lessons that you learned working with them in terms of just
- 6:38nonprofit efficacy. Because I think we've seen the opposite of the spectrum where we've seen
- 6:44nonprofits that are not effective. And they don't really change the world and really move the needle
- 6:51the way that we expect them to. And I think that sort of, you know, we start to lose faith when we
- 6:55give money and give money and give money and what and nothing really changes. So just walk me
- 7:00through that experience with with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Well, I think the first
- 7:05big lesson is if you're going to seek to create transformational change in the world, aim high.
- 7:12You know, the book is called big bets because these are big aspirational goals.
- 7:18And it's very easy when we try to quote unquote do good to think that doing good is good enough
- 7:24and therefore we get trapped in what I call the aspiration trap in the book, which is just all
- 7:29the cynicism is overwhelming and the problems are so big. So you say, okay, I'm going to do something
- 7:34small and modest and move on. Bill, Bill and Melinda took a very different point of view. I mean,
- 7:39they read a newspaper article about 400,000 kids dying every year of a disease called rotavirus
- 7:46and said, okay, all these kids are dying in poor countries from rotavirus.
- 7:50Almost nobody dies in the United States, yet all the vaccines are available. I'm going to be
- 7:56available in richer places, not in poor ones. Why why is it like that? What can we do to change
- 8:01the system so that vaccines are manufactured at a scale and a price point that make them accessible
- 8:07everywhere and what kind of investments are required to do that? So, you know, 20 plus years later,
- 8:13980 million kids vaccinated, 16 million lives saved. And it all started with Bill asking
- 8:20some pretty simple questions. In fact, the first chapter is called Ask a Simple Question because
- 8:24I know. We don't bring us together. But I see there's like a playbook bit. You sort of like
- 8:29reverse engineer here. And you know, but he would bring us all together and say, what is it
- 8:35cost to vaccinate a child? Yeah. And it be shocking. It took us like two years to answer that with
- 8:41discipline and with enough modeling to actually understand what was happening out there.
- 8:45And that was the basis for achieving those goals. Do you feel like, you know, you've worked in both
- 8:51private and public sector? Do you feel as though one should own more responsibility for changing
- 8:59the world? And I say that because it seems like what you can do in private sector with smart and
- 9:05vicious talent people can move the needle much quicker. And traditionally, I believe that we
- 9:11look to governments to solve a lot of these issues. And we feel that governments move slow. And
- 9:16they're not as efficient as some of these private sector individuals that technically, you know,
- 9:21they don't have to operate within the confines of bureaucracy, right? And you've seen this first hand.
- 9:26So whose responsibility is it? Who's doing a better job? What should we learn about working between
- 9:33the public and private sector? Because you have this unique experience of doing sort of both jobs.
- 9:38Well, I think the basic approach to making and executing big bets can be done in either. So
- 9:44finding fresh, innovative solutions to kind of seemingly sticky problems, building the kind of
- 9:49unlikely partnerships and alliances required to sustain them. And frankly, measuring results with
- 9:55discipline, you can do that in the public sector. And I have seen whether it was the Haiti earthquake
- 10:01response or fighting Ebola in West Africa or many other efforts. I've seen that you can bring
- 10:07that mindset to the public sector. The thing that private sector has that is so special is the
- 10:12capacity to innovate to take risks to go first to be bold. And for a lot of reasons, that's much,
- 10:20much harder to replicate in the public sector. The thing the public sector has that the private
- 10:24sector doesn't is scale scale and a mission to reach everybody with with whatever the policy
- 10:32purposes. So really big bets are best when you can marry the innovative capacity to take risks in
- 10:39the private sector with the scale, the resourcing and the sense of mission that you can develop in
- 10:46the public sector and then see it through with a rigor and discipline around measuring results that
- 10:51should exist in both. And that's when you get the real magic to happen.
- 10:57You mentioned this aspiration trap and I think that this is a, let's start there because this is
- 11:03sort of where this whole problem stems from. When you are, say an entrepreneur, a lot of entrepreneurs
- 11:09listen to this show and they're looking to build the next big thing and they want to do good in the
- 11:13world, but they're worrying about finding product market fit and making rent next month and
- 11:19they're going to listen to this and they go, yeah, I'm sure Bill Gates and the Rockefeller
- 11:23Foundation are able to change the world and they're able to make these big bets like, yeah,
- 11:27billions are at play here. It's not my reality. So I'm aspirational. I want to make the world
- 11:34a better place. I'm an entrepreneur. What are the lessons you're going to teach me? How do I
- 11:37avoid this aspiration, this aspiration trap? Well, I think it starts by being able to zoom in and
- 11:43zoom out. So great entrepreneurs can zoom out, see the forest for the trees, understand how their
- 11:50vision is going to affect change at massive scale, whether that's transforming an industry or
- 11:56building a new one or innovating technology that changes the way people live. But then to make it
- 12:02practical, real and to build the flywheel of progress, you have to zoom in tremendously in
- 12:08super detail oriented about as you point out, making payroll, delivering product, generating
- 12:14the next bit of revenue. And it's shocking. The same skill set is required in taking on big public
- 12:22sector or social sector efforts. You have to be able to kind of, I had teams at USAID that were
- 12:28leading and I was helping to lead the effort to overcome the earthquake crisis in Haiti
- 12:35right when it happened in 2010. And it was a massive tragedy. 250,000 people died very little
- 12:42visibility on the ground. You had to be able to kind of go all the way down to the ground and
- 12:45understand, okay, our women, is there enough lighting in a community to keep girls safe at night?
- 12:51Is there enough film micro? But then you had to zoom all the way out and it's okay, we got 56
- 12:57countries seeking to be part of this response. The whole thing might cost four billion dollars.
- 13:02How are we going to allocate resources? How are we going to move fast? How are we going to set
- 13:05a results framework that allows us to measure and respond to that whole cohort of actors that
- 13:11are going to be part of what was the largest civil military cooperative humanitarian response
- 13:16in history? So you just have to be able to do both. And I think that's a skill set for entrepreneurs.
- 13:21I think it's a skill set for people in charge of projects in government. I think it's a skill set
- 13:26for people in the social sector that really want to make change happen at scale.
- 13:31When you were thinking of compiling all your learnings and your knowledge into big bets,
- 13:38do you feel like it was knowledge that was based on retroactive responses or were you hoping to put
- 13:46this book out into the world in hopes of saying this is more of a proactive framework that I want you
- 13:51to take on? Well, I think a little bit of both when I did the book in part because when honestly,
- 13:58when I was a young kid kind of starting out in my career, I kind of knew I didn't want to be a
- 14:05practicing doctor. We had lost a presidential election. I found myself unemployed and I just
- 14:10had no idea what to do with myself. And I didn't believe in a million years you could have a career
- 14:16where you help Bill Gates deploy billions of dollars and save tens of millions of lives and then
- 14:20have a career where you work with President Obama and large global humanitarian and development
- 14:25priorities and then you run a really historically unique foundation that kind of created the movement
- 14:32of philanthropy before any of it existed. So I wanted readers to have confidence that in fact,
- 14:40there's a path here if you want to take it and there are set of tools and skills you can hone
- 14:46to be someone who has a successful career making change happen at scale if you kind of learn and
- 14:53apply these lessons. And I wrote it largely because I didn't have that when I was starting out and I
- 14:57thought it would be helpful to others. I also want to ask a tough question that's going to set the
- 15:03framework for how we can be effective as people that want to give back, that want to take big bets
- 15:10for people to take big bets or to even bet in institutions that can take on these challenges.
- 15:16There's a very important thing that I'd like you to speak on because I think I was looking back
- 15:21like three years ago you made a very good point how people don't trust institutions as much as
- 15:27they should. They don't trust governments and trust is a big thing because a lot of the issues
- 15:33that are big bets that are taken on by the Rockefeller Foundation, world governments, the Gates
- 15:39Foundation, these are things that should be nonpartisan. They are humanity improving initiatives.
- 15:46But for some reason there's a trust factor. There's discord there. So I don't think trust in
- 15:53institutions has gotten better since COVID. I'm pretty sure it's just gotten way worse.
- 15:57So how do we solve for this? Because right now I think trust is at an all-time low across the
- 16:04aisle with any group that you speak to. Yeah, trust is at an all-time low in almost any kind of
- 16:10institution. And so what I was hoping is that this big bet mindset gives people the capacity
- 16:18to trust others and to build trust and to be an optimist when it would be very, very easy to
- 16:24be cynical. It's very easy to say, well, government shuts down. It's not effective. It's not
- 16:30going to work. It takes more effort and you got to have a different kind of mindset to be able
- 16:36to say, hey, if we really want to tackle hunger at scale globally, we need food companies
- 16:42working together with humanitarian partners working together with governments at scale.
- 16:46And here's a playbook for how to bring that partnership together. One of the elements of
- 16:50building trust is reaching across the aisle and making your relationships really personal.
- 16:57And I write in the book about efforts we pursued after 2008 when there was a horrific food crisis
- 17:04around the world related to the financial collapse and the financial crisis.
- 17:09100 million people had pushed back into deep, deep hunger, kids eating mud cakes
- 17:14in very poor communities just to feel satiety. And we built a bipartisan coalition in the United
- 17:20States to pass something called the Global Food Security Act and move 100 million people out of
- 17:24hunger and poverty. And that happened because I had the good fortune of getting to know some really
- 17:32conservative Republican senators who on television didn't quite seem like they were going to be
- 17:38our partners and friends. But in private, when you got to know their families and you got to
- 17:43know their values and you got to know their faith and you got to know what they really cared about,
- 17:48they became real champions for fighting hunger, whether it was in Ethiopia or India or Indiana.
- 17:56And they held hands with progressive partners and made it happen at scale during a really tough
- 18:01political environment. And so I really think it's about building those personal relationships.
- 18:06And you can only have trust if you know people and you know their values. And to know their
- 18:10values, you have to talk about your own, you have to share what your vulnerabilities are and you
- 18:15have to be very real with people that sometimes you just met. I love that though. I think that's
- 18:20so important because I think that everyone being locked away and assuming that somebody's entire
- 18:26personality is their Twitter feed is it's a very dangerous game to play, right? And I think that
- 18:32I mean some of these, some of these ideas should not be partisan, should not be polarizing.
- 18:36And I think this is actually, you know, there's a few points. I think that trust is
- 18:41monumental. I think the way you build trust across the aisles is very important. Another point,
- 18:46it was literally your first point in this book, the ask a simple question, but there's a there's a
- 18:51there's a quote, a Bill Gates quote, and the barrier to change isn't too little caring. It's
- 18:57too much complexity. I think complexity causes confusion and confusion creates this trust. So
- 19:03talk to me about simplicity, simplifying these issues, educating on these issues that we can
- 19:08actually move the needle and stop worrying about the banter back and forth. Yeah, that's a great
- 19:15point. I think it's very easy for people to be put off by complexity. And it's super,
- 19:22how many times have you asked a question, well, why are so many people homeless? The answer is,
- 19:27well, it's very complex. Why do we allow 40% of American kids to grow up in child poverty? Well,
- 19:34that's that's super complex. You know, why? Why are there still droughts and famines that are
- 19:41actually killing people in large numbers when food is relatively abundant and pretty cheap.
- 19:48It's very complex. Complexity is a way to kind of keep people out and Bill actually told this great
- 19:53story once he was like, you know, Davos is something the world economic forum, all these leaders,
- 19:58private sector, public sector, go to the Swiss Alps and have this big conference. And he said,
- 20:02you know, you can go to Davos and sit and listen to a meeting about saving tens of millions of
- 20:09children's lives. And it can feel a little dry like everyone's using big words and it's all very
- 20:16technical and complex and very low energy. And then then you can go across the street where a software
- 20:23company is like launching a new game or a new piece of software and their lights and cameras and
- 20:29smoke and dancing and music. And it's very lively. And you're just like, why why do we try to tackle
- 20:36the toughest problems in the world with the language and a work style that is off-putting to
- 20:41so many people like we have to make this simple to bring people in. And I saw that over and over
- 20:46and we did the Haiti earthquake, you know, more than more American families contributed in some
- 20:51form to relief around the Haiti earthquake than watch the Super Bowl that year, which shows you
- 20:57how good American families are, how much they want to be on the side of right morally. And they
- 21:04did it because we created a text thread and you could text a small contribution very quickly,
- 21:08they did it because lots of our partners had other ways to be a part of the solution. Instead of
- 21:14saying, well, it's very complex, just just sit this one out. You got to reach out and give people
- 21:19and trust that people want to be on the side of right if you make it possible and you make it easy
- 21:23for them to do so. And I think the last question about trust in them will keep going, but I think
- 21:29this is also a very important question to address. When people think about big bets, it's just
- 21:34sentiment that I've heard echo repeatedly. It's like, well, we, especially in the US and I'm not
- 21:39even American, but let's pretend I am for a second. So say I'm an American and I'm always being
- 21:45told we have to help outside the country, outside the country, but to your point, there's homelessness,
- 21:50there's there's crime rates in certain cities that aren't great. I don't feel like the US is
- 21:54properly getting the TLC that it deserves. So for that individual that feels that way,
- 22:00how do you convince me to support big bets outside my country when at home, I feel like
- 22:05government isn't even taking care of me? Yeah, so both are quite necessary, but what we do in the
- 22:11context of global humanitarian and development efforts really amount to less than 1% of the
- 22:18federal budget. It's not a huge cost item, but it is often some of the most cost effective
- 22:25spending we've had. And on a bipartisan basis, when I write in the book about the effort to fight
- 22:33Ebola in 2014, the CDC was estimating in 2014 that there could be 1.6 million cases of Ebola
- 22:41that they would be all over the world, including throughout the United States. And President Obama
- 22:46on our team made I think a bold decision to say, you know what, instead of that outcome,
- 22:51we're going to send American troops, American humanitarian partners and global collaborators
- 22:56into three West African countries to fight the disease there. And when we made that decision,
- 23:02by the way, we didn't know what the solution was going to be. We didn't actually know how this
- 23:06particular variant could be beaten in the context of reducing contagion. We had to figure that out
- 23:12by experimenting on the ground in those countries in a very, very tough environment where people
- 23:18were literally bleeding to death in the streets. It was a hemorrhagic fever that was horrific,
- 23:23and I write about my own visits there during that time. But it's doable. And it was very cost
- 23:29effective at the end of the day and preventing a million plus cases from getting out of that
- 23:35region into Europe and the United States was well worth the cost of deployment. It's some of
- 23:40the most cost effective things we can do. I just want to take a second and thank the sponsor
- 23:45of today's episode HubSpot. Now, as you all know, the success story podcast is part of the HubSpot
- 23:50podcast network. There are incredible podcasts in this network. One of my favorites that you have
- 23:56to check out. If you don't know this podcast, you're kind of sleeping on it. The Gold Digger podcast
- 24:01hosted by Jenna Kutcher. This podcast has been around for a minute. Jenna is an OG in the podcast
- 24:08game. The Gold Digger podcast helps you discover your dream career with productivity tips,
- 24:12social strategies, business hacks, inspirational stories, interviews, and so much more. Please go
- 24:19check out the Gold Digger podcast hosted by Jenna Kutcher wherever you get your podcasts.
- 24:25I think that's very important. It's a very important message too. And I'm glad you sort of
- 24:29break it down because I think that that's lost on people. How effective some of these like,
- 24:33these big bets can really be it. It seems like it could be just so much bigger than,
- 24:37you know, the individual and it seems like it could be so expensive and time-consuming and
- 24:41resource-training, but really sometimes it's not and it's very important to sort of communicate that.
- 24:48One of the points that you mentioned and I didn't know if this was,
- 24:52it was pulled out of the book and when we were prepping, I was looking at some of the different
- 24:56points we could speak about and even you sent over some great points as well. But this was one
- 24:59I thought was interesting. The requirement to jump first, is that on an individual level,
- 25:05is that on a country level? Explain to me what jumping first means.
- 25:10Yeah, that's an on an individual level. You know, you mentioned you have a lot of entrepreneurs
- 25:15on this on the show and the listen. One thing I admire about entrepreneurship is it requires
- 25:21taking some risk, you know, having a vision going out there first and saying, hey folks, this could
- 25:26work and at a time when we had done a lot of the analysis around what it would take to vaccinate
- 25:32every child on the planet and change the structure of the global vaccine industry, one of the answers
- 25:37was we needed kind of fast early capital in order to build out the global supply base and do some
- 25:42long-term contracting and so to create that capital, we invented something called an immunization bond
- 25:49and to use a simple form for it. And we had all these partners, the UK, France,
- 25:55heads of state, chancellors of the ex-checker, which is effectively like a finance minister,
- 26:00Gordon Brown. But everyone, no one was willing to kind of go first. So I was as a young
- 26:08professional at the Gates Foundation, I sort of said once at one evening in a conference at a bar
- 26:14on the back of a cocktail napkin, we kind of drew out a financial structure and I said, well,
- 26:19the foundation could guarantee the securitization of this new bond and that guarantee kind of gave
- 26:28everybody confidence that, okay, this is going to work because an institution with billions of
- 26:33dollars is going to guarantee the debt issuance. And fast forward two years later, when we actually
- 26:39issued the debt, the guarantee wasn't even needed because the debt could stand on its own and
- 26:44was a credible financial instrument. But had we not jumped first to make that commitment,
- 26:49we never would have got to know whether the commitment was going to be drawn down on or not. And
- 26:54I of course made that commitment without anybody's permission to do so and gotten a little trouble
- 27:00for it. But it ultimately worked out. And the point I'm trying to make is if you want to be a
- 27:05leader in social change and creating change at scale, you have to use some of those entrepreneurial
- 27:12techniques of taking risks and jumping first to get others to go with you. I'll give you another
- 27:18one. If you're going to fail, well, you will fail. So you have to learn how to fail fast. I want
- 27:24to understand this in an entrepreneurial context. I also want to understand this in a you context
- 27:30because your career probably had so many points where very valid and positive syndrome manifested
- 27:37coming from a medical background, moving into these philanthropic organizations working with some
- 27:42of the most established, esteemed individuals in the world. When you jump into something is your
- 27:49mindset, I have to learn, I have to try, I have to fail. I'm assuming there is a portion of that,
- 27:54but it's also scary as hell for somebody to actually do versus you just teach over to that.
- 27:58Yeah, no, the mindset's definitely not I have to fail. It's kind of the opposite. In fact,
- 28:03the imposter syndrome makes you afraid of failing, right? So I remember once when I my very first
- 28:09national security council meeting was the day I was appointed the kind of global coordinator for
- 28:14the Haiti earthquake response. And we went that evening into the White House and sitting in the
- 28:18situation room across from Bob Gates and Mike Mull in the Secretary of Defense and the
- 28:23incredibly thoughtful and capable chairman of the Joint Chiefs. And you know,
- 28:2720 other people and and I had I had written out all the things we needed from the military in
- 28:33order to deploy these urban search and rescue rescue teams to go save lives in Port of Prince.
- 28:38And and I written it all on note cards and on the way over the White House, I'd smudge the edge
- 28:43of the note cards. So as I was reading my points, one of the things I said, well, we need these
- 28:48we need these C13s to get these urban search and rescue teams and their dogs into Port of
- 28:54Prince right away. And of course, I what I meant to say was C130s, which is the military cargo
- 28:59plane. As I said, C13, I didn't realize it until and then when it came out and I was like,
- 29:05should I correct myself? What do I do? I just rolled with it. Nobody said anything, thankfully.
- 29:10And we went on to have an amazing civil partnership. But you know, you make mistakes all the time.
- 29:17And so you give yourself you let yourself, I mean, you give yourself like the the psychological
- 29:22safety, you know, that there will be some failure. And then that's, but I think that's very
- 29:26important to that so far. There's one other thing I should say about that. Oops, let me
- 29:32there's one other thing I should say about that, which is I have a chapter in the book that's
- 29:36about failure. And it was a much bigger failure than just getting the terminology wrong about a
- 29:43cargo plane. It was as part of a big effort to bring power and electricity to Africa. We had
- 29:49pursued an effort to build out a large-scale hydropower dam, which would have provided electricity
- 29:55to 250 million people who didn't have it and effectively live constrained because of it. And it
- 30:01would have been the equivalent in terms of savings on fossil fuels of taking a third of the US
- 30:06auto fleet off the road. So it was a big deal. But I frankly pursued it aggressively without
- 30:13fundamentally understanding that the president of the DRC at the time, and even the chairman of
- 30:20the appropriate committee in the US Senate at the time, we're basically not going to be easily
- 30:27convinced to do this project with all the transparency and the ways we had to get it done. And so
- 30:34so, you know, as I was charging ahead doing this and issuing press releases and raising money and
- 30:39doing all the things with a large global team, the Senate passed a resolution that basically
- 30:44stopped us in our track. And the president of the host country did some things that did the same.
- 30:51And I woke up one day and read about it on the front page of the financial times. And so so,
- 30:56you know, what I learned from that is you do have to know who you're betting on when you make big
- 31:01bets. And I think that's true for folks in the private sector, public sector, really any project.
- 31:07And it sometimes you learn in the hard way that that's what you have to do on the front end.
- 31:12And sometimes sometimes you don't. How do you make those? So obviously, the decisions to invest in
- 31:20a certain initiative or whatnot, you probably get endless proposals like across your desk.
- 31:26So walk me even through that decision making process on deciding where to put the money and
- 31:31where to put time and the resources because yeah, that's right. All these great causes. I'm sure not
- 31:35too many causes are bad causes now, but there's their scale. There's there's, you know, feasibility.
- 31:41Then there's also the people that are sort of positioning this you and are going to be the people
- 31:44that are going to execute on it, right? Yeah, our basic criteria are things like impact, scale,
- 31:51leverage, you know, the single biggest investment the Rockefeller Foundation has made in 110 years
- 31:56of its existence. We made recently to create something called the global energy alliance for people
- 32:01and planet. And the goal literally is to reach a billion people across the planet who live without
- 32:06access to electricity with renewable electrification. And the reason we could go big in that setting is
- 32:12we have access to some really unique new technology that allows for solar grids and batteries
- 32:19to come together with AI and remote management and reduce the cost structure of providing
- 32:24electrification to rural communities that have never had access to electricity.
- 32:29The other reason we can do it is we know that it can largely be commercially viable. So if we put
- 32:34in this case, we raised about a billion and a half dollars from ourselves and other partners.
- 32:38If we put a billion and a half dollars in and take the risk out for more commercial investors,
- 32:45we can leverage that up to 10, 20, 30 billion dollars. And then you can really start to achieve
- 32:50impact at scale. So, you know, we actually just closed on a project in the eastern Congo,
- 32:56an area ravaged by war that I write about in the book because I met these kids there that just
- 33:01broke my heart. And they just had no opportunity. And we're breaking ground right now on building
- 33:07out solar infrastructure that's going to provide electricity to communities, help people start
- 33:11businesses and create jobs for the first time in decades. And it's going to transform their
- 33:16lives and their family's lives. That can happen because I think for every dollar we're putting into
- 33:21that project, we're getting $11 from private investors to come in behind us, even though we take
- 33:28the risk. And that's the kind of leverage we seek to deliver on when we take on these big
- 33:34scaled efforts. So, impact, results, leverage, those are the kinds of criteria we're focused on.
- 33:39And how do you, you know, just back to that people piece and that team piece, how do you build that
- 33:44right team to execute? And because, you know, you can't control, you can't control every single
- 33:49government in the world. You can't, you know, even in that one, one example in the DRC, like,
- 33:54it was just, it was frustrating and it probably, it probably was a foresight there, but you can't
- 33:58control everything. So, you can only control who you hire, who you directly work with. What's,
- 34:03what's the secret to finding these people that are going to execute on these, like, literally
- 34:07humanity impacting missions? It's not just revenue. It's people's lives, right?
- 34:12Yeah. You know, this is something probably I've evolved the most on during the course of my career.
- 34:17I mean, I used to look for people who are just super smart, super highly competent and say,
- 34:23I wanted to be surrounded by people who are the most smart, the most competent. But over time,
- 34:28I've realized that actually you need to find people that have that, but also have a sense of
- 34:34purpose and a sense of values that are pretty deeply grounded that come from somewhere where they
- 34:39can articulate their values, why they care about this mission, why they want to go the extra mile
- 34:44for doing things that actually lift up those who are vulnerable. And because you make sacrifices,
- 34:50frankly, when you, when you do this, and, and then I've always looked for people we call athletes,
- 34:57but I write one of the chapters of book is called Pivot, because I, I'm excited to be surrounded by
- 35:03a team at the Rockefeller Foundation that's willing to say, okay, we did, we did this, but now there's
- 35:07COVID, it's destroying our nation, we need to pivot and tackle that with real intention.
- 35:12So finding people who are agile, flexible, can pivot, that's the other element that we look for.
- 35:17Very smart. There's so much innovation, there's so much innovation in, in, in countries around
- 35:24the world, and we're constantly building new products and services and technologies that can
- 35:29make life better. Why do we have such an issue leveraging innovation to help other countries that
- 35:36are not as fortunate as ours? Yeah, well, first, I think we have to recognize that a lot of
- 35:42innovation is not really fundamentally improving quality of life, right? Yeah. In its most profound
- 35:49ways. I mean, we used to look back 20 years ago and say, you know, the, the world at that time
- 35:53spent six times more on developing the next erectile dysfunction product versus literally versus
- 36:01finding a vaccine to end AIDS, malaria, and TB combined. And you're like, okay, what's wrong,
- 36:06Karen? It's not that there's anything against Viagra, but we already had Viagra.
- 36:12Because market incentives are what they are, today's version of that would be a lot of our
- 36:17social media platforms are probably making us less healthy and less whole and less democratic as
- 36:23a society than, you know, than they could be. So, so there, there's that. And then frankly,
- 36:29there's the reality of the global macro economy. And right now is we're having this conversation.
- 36:34They're about 50 countries teetering on the edge of a debt crisis. And most private commercial
- 36:40investment flows are going from lower income countries to wealthier economies that are the
- 36:45beneficiaries right now of trillions of dollars of green economy subsidy investment. So,
- 36:51where would you rather build a battery plant? Yeah. In the United States or in a part of Africa where
- 36:58the currency just got devalued 40%. So, where I just happened to be there a few weeks ago,
- 37:03and that was the situation. So, so we, you know, there have been times in our history where leaders
- 37:08have come together after World War II, for example, and understood that it was both macro and micro
- 37:14effects. And they built institutions like the World Bank and the IMF and the United Nations
- 37:19to reshape how the global economy developed and how we'd prevent conflict at scale. And I've argued
- 37:27that we need that kind of a moment again when we have leaders who are willing come together and
- 37:31say, you know what, the challenges we face, climate change, massive hunger and dislocation,
- 37:361.2 billion climate refugees by 2050, they require a way of thinking about our global commons
- 37:44in a way that's fresher and more novel and more innovative. And I think we need to go through
- 37:48that now at a leadership level. You know, this is just very interesting because World War II
- 37:55really galvanized to your point. Quite a few nations and countries. You would think that you
- 38:02would think that an event like coronavirus, like COVID would also galvanize. It did, it seems like
- 38:10the exact opposite of galvanizing anybody. So, how do we, like, what happened here? Why can we not
- 38:16as a world get together and get on board with some of these initiatives? Why does it still feel like
- 38:22so, it feels like there's such an argument against basically what you just mentioned happened post
- 38:28World War II? Yeah. Well, you're right that COVID was so widespread that many of us hoped that it
- 38:35would change the consciousness, you know, that you'd understand that okay, we are all interconnected
- 38:41and that a disease that might emerge from China or part of Africa or a part of Latin America
- 38:47can wipe out millions of lives in the United States and vice versa. So, let's cooperate to tackle
- 38:53those problems in a more forward looking way. Honestly, I blame a lot of the lack of getting there
- 38:59to our politics and people like the book big bets is about global solutions that have we've
- 39:06demonstrated can work at scale and and I and right now our politics are pretty fragmented, which is
- 39:12why I want young people in particular to read the book and some of them at least if not just vote
- 39:18for the right candidates go into politics themselves and be part of reshaping the future because we
- 39:23we have had times in our past as you noted when we can when we have come together around a higher
- 39:30purpose and a higher calling and I've just seen it in communities across this country and across
- 39:36the world. I think people want to be part of solutions that are designed to produce gains for
- 39:42everybody in a way that's bigger than themselves. We are not fundamentally designed to be purely
- 39:48self interested in our entire lives. We just kind of beat it out of people over time in our own
- 39:54country. So, I want to I hope more people read the book and say okay, I can be part of the solution.
- 40:00And in your opinion with innovation, is there a red flag moment where innovation that is
- 40:06driven by the market is creating further gaps and further divides because there's sort of two
- 40:11views on this. I mean, globalization in terms of what happened post pandemic with
- 40:18everyone working from home and now you have a global marketplace of talent and you can
- 40:22hire people from different countries and you can afford them different opportunities. That's
- 40:26great, but then also with innovation. I mean, we look at some of the I don't think I don't know if
- 40:31people I have no idea. I don't want to sound like I know for sure, but I feel like, for example,
- 40:37the evolution of AI and some of the applications for business, I feel like it's being used more in
- 40:42the US than in other parts of the world. And that could just be totally me being naive. I have no
- 40:48idea, but maybe you go to these different countries. Do you see innovation in the US being a positive
- 40:54for other countries or a negative? Well, I think it's definitely a positive in the story of
- 41:00innovation has been one of invention creation somewhere in the world and then over time diffusion
- 41:07and it doesn't create a bigger imbalance. It creates a more positive. Well, no, so depending on
- 41:12depending on how it's embraced, it can actually create divides. If you look at the agricultural
- 41:18productivity improvements from the 1500s and the 1600s actually lowered the standard of living
- 41:23of many of the peasant producers because of the economic infrastructure and political infrastructure
- 41:28of medieval Europe, basically. But that's why it's so important that we come together in these
- 41:35collaborations that are public and private. When we reshape the global vaccine industry and
- 41:41focused on saving child lives, that was a collaboration that came together and we said, okay,
- 41:46let's actually make sure we're manufacturing 10, 50 times the scale of product at price points
- 41:52that are lower at volumes that are high so everyone can access them. Like that consciousness
- 41:57on the front end was the only thing that ultimately created that outcome on the back end.
- 42:03And I think by the way, we need to do exactly that now with the renewable energy revolution. We
- 42:08should be looking at how battery manufacturing can be global and be at high enough volumes that
- 42:14allow prices to be low and access to be ubiquitous. If you think about solar energy or just renewables
- 42:21in general, less than 1% of all renewable energy deployment on a global basis since its invention
- 42:27about 20 years ago has been in Africa, less than 1%. And about 60% of the world's energy poor people
- 42:36who don't have enough electricity to power their home and want appliance on an annual basis are in
- 42:42Africa. So to solve the markets alone are not going to solve those mismatches, which is why,
- 42:48you know, which is why I write about these big collaborations, big bets that bring together
- 42:52the public sector policy makers and private innovators to create change at scale. And I'll say one
- 42:58thing about that is I have found that the private companies that are part of these efforts actually
- 43:04love being a part of these efforts because most companies are populated by people who want to
- 43:10change the world at scale. They want to be a part of something that's big and important and
- 43:13meaningful. And I've seen it when we got Cargill to donate rice in the middle of a famine in
- 43:19the Port of Mogadishu. I've seen it when we got drug and vaccine companies to change their
- 43:24manufacturing and access IP policies. And I'm seeing it right now in our renewable energy
- 43:29partnerships where people, especially people who work in these companies, they want to be part of
- 43:34something special. And when you look at all the different initiatives that you are taking on and
- 43:40that you're trying to solve for, what is the biggest bet that is concerning, that is
- 43:47existential, that could really, really impact for the better or worse if we don't focus on it?
- 43:52Well, I think right now it is making sure we get the energy transformation or the energy transition
- 44:00to reach every part of the globe as quickly as possible. Just to put it in perspective,
- 44:06all of the talk of Paris commitments and climate targets and all that, it all leaves out one big
- 44:13piece of math and that is the emissions that come from developing economies over the next 20 or
- 44:1930 years. So we could be successful at changing emissions use in richer countries.
- 44:26If we could be more than successful at hitting our targets and we would still make our planet
- 44:31literally unlivable if we don't ensure that India and Brazil and South Africa and Nigeria and
- 44:38the DRC switch from diesel generation and heavy fuel oils and coal to renewable electricity. And
- 44:46right now, precious little is being done on that despite 10, 15 years of commitments and press releases
- 44:52and talk to do so, which is why our foundation is all in on making that renewable energy frontier
- 44:59a vehicle that lifts up everybody, not just those that live in wealthy economies.
- 45:04What do we have to do to fix that? Because this is now you're talking about, you're talking about
- 45:08imposing, not imposing, well, yeah, kind of imposing policy on a government that probably doesn't,
- 45:13you know, you know, without lack of a better word, doesn't give a shit the way that they should
- 45:18give a shit. Well, you know, it's interesting. If you if you go, because I spent so much time
- 45:22working with governments around the world on exactly this issue. And if you sit with Prime Minister
- 45:27Modi or you sit with President Ruto and Kenya, Modi's in India, you know, they actually understand
- 45:32that hey, solar power on 320 million Indian rooftops can create a second income stream for
- 45:39Indians farmers and can end poverty in our country while also reducing the need for coal and heavy
- 45:45fuel oil in the future. The challenge is attracting investment. The challenge is overcoming a reality
- 45:52that most of the subsidies are in the richer world. So right now, everyone's investing
- 45:57in the United States and Europe. And frankly, the challenge is making sure we have supply chains
- 46:02for these various products and commodities that are not entirely dependent on China and that are
- 46:06in fact much more distributed. So, you know, we need a globalization that actually allows for
- 46:11manufacturing of critical minerals and batteries and solar panels and equipment that's everywhere,
- 46:17not just in a few places. And we need some real transfers of public sector resources from wealthy
- 46:26economies to less wealthy economies so that everyone can access the energy future, not just a few.
- 46:33Do you see that being a reality? Do you have a playbook on RutoG?
- 46:38We have a playbook. There's a chapter in the book on exactly that task. And I would tell you,
- 46:43we are, it's slow work, but we are starting to succeed. I mean, when we launched the global
- 46:48energy alliance, we put $500 million in ourselves, raised a billion dollars from the Ikea Foundation,
- 46:53the Bezos Earth Fund. Thank you to both. And then we got another 10 billion from all of these
- 46:59multilateral development banks. That's about 11 billion. Today, we're in discussion with the next
- 47:04set of commercial banking partners to say, hey, you want to be part of this solution. And we're
- 47:09even designing, we're designing credits so that companies that need to buy carbon credits can do so
- 47:18by enabling these types of renewable energy projects like the one I described in the DRC.
- 47:23So it's possible to envision a future where a billion people move out of poverty because they
- 47:28have access to solar and wind and renewable energy. And it's possible to envision a future where
- 47:3475% of the world's emissions do not come from what we today call developing economies.
- 47:39But it depends on us making the decisions now and building the kinds of public private
- 47:43partnerships today. Have you figured out, have you figured out say, I'm very curious about the
- 47:49number that you would have to raise because you have that number. I know that you have that number.
- 47:53So what is that number that you have to raise and to to radically shift global warming and all
- 48:00and the, you know, the use of all these different types of fuel sources in these developing nations.
- 48:06What's that number? And then also what's the time frame that we could actually accomplish that
- 48:10and if you had that number? Okay, so there have been, you're right, we've done the math.
- 48:14There have been about six different analyses that all have the same answer. And that number is
- 48:19about $2 trillion a year for about 10 to 15 years. And that seems like such a massive
- 48:28amount of investment that it's impossible to imagine getting there. And then you realize,
- 48:33hey, wait a minute, that is 2% of the global economy. When America helped rebuild Western Europe
- 48:38after World War II, we committed about 2% of our economic GDP to the task of creating the
- 48:45Marshall line. So we've done it. We've done this before. And we did it before. And by the way,
- 48:49if we didn't do it, Western Europe wouldn't have been our stalwart partner in an Atlantic
- 48:54chartered partnership for decades that has maintained peace and prosperity. It's the same
- 48:59moment we can do it again. We just have to inspire people. It's possible. And by the way,
- 49:03if you think 2% of the global economy is a lot, which you should, you know, if you look at just
- 49:09the excess windfall profits earned by petro states in the last two years, because of two and a half
- 49:17years, because of very high oil prices, that's been about two and a half percent of the global economy.
- 49:22So if we had the capacity to, you know, tax, there has been a great proposal to tax that and
- 49:28transfer. But, you know, it's, it's out there. We just have to be more ambitious in what we seek
- 49:34to accomplish. And we have to be clear that this time, this is not just a humanitarian enterprise.
- 49:39Our planet's survival depends on our ability to get this right. I love that. Okay. Um, let's,
- 49:45let's uh, get some last closing thoughts from, from big bets. If you wanted to, you know,
- 49:52if you wanted to bring up one last lesson or one last thought or story that would be really,
- 49:56really impactful for the audience, what would that last lesson be?
- 50:01Well, we've talked a lot about big bets that are these big global initiatives. And one thing
- 50:05that I have found so inspiring is that it really anyone anywhere in any community can make a big
- 50:12bet and see it through. And when I first got started in this work, I spent a summer kind of
- 50:18interning basically with a doctor in Southern India, who was just going door to door looking for
- 50:23people with leprosy and finding, once he had eradicated leprosy from this, this sort of community
- 50:29and a rainforest, he realized what kids really needed was nutrition support. So he took these
- 50:34malnourished kids and helped help resuscitate them. And it was just amazing to watch. And what it
- 50:39taught me is that big bets are about big global things. And they're also about just in your local
- 50:44community, making a difference in any way you can. And, and I, I think that's an important part
- 50:50of the book. And I love the fact that I get to tell some of these stories because these folks
- 50:54bring so much inspiration. If people want to get the book, if I want to connect with you, see
- 51:01where you're, you know, see what you're working on, where, where should they go? The social,
- 51:05the website, I'm sure it's all over Amazon and wherever you get your books as well, but other places.
- 51:09Yeah, come, come to Rockfeller RockFound.org our website and join our big bet community. We're
- 51:16looking for people who want to be part of the solution. And, and we want to help you
- 51:20live out your aspirations to be a big better. So, so come join us.
- 51:25What does that mean? What's the big bet community? So if people actually want to get involved,
- 51:28what are they doing with you? Well, right now, we're just asking people to sign up and,
- 51:33and over time, we're going to have programs and outreach so that people can get trained and how
- 51:37to do this and people who are seeking jobs or internship experiences or connections to
- 51:44nonprofit organizations and others, we facilitate what we can so people feel like they're connected
- 51:50to getting a chance to express their values in this way. I love it. All right. Okay. Just to close
- 51:56this out, you've had an incredible career. I'm actually going to ask you two questions. The first
- 52:00question would be, if you could tell your 20-year-old self one thing after everything that you've done,
- 52:05what would that thing be? If I could tell my 20-year-old self, what would that one thing be?
- 52:14You know, honestly, it would be take a little time out to journal and to take pictures and to
- 52:22reflect on each day because it's going to be okay and these moments are the moments you'll
- 52:29look back on and cherish. I love that. And then again, incredible career, multiple seasons to your
- 52:35career, at this point in your life, both for the Rockefeller organization, for what you're working
- 52:41on, but also personally, what does success mean to you? You know, right now, success is really
- 52:47about helping others and sometimes that's, I have three wonderful kids and maybe I missed a little
- 52:55too much of their early childhood, so it's helping them be the best they can be and my parents
- 53:01a little older, it's helping them and my teammates here that I work with is just helping folks
- 53:08be their best self is super rewarding and I didn't fully appreciate that when I was younger,
- 53:14I think, in my career, so I get to spend more time thinking about that now.