Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / When the Future Feels Unfixable
Transcript
- 0:00Here the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth
- 0:46Andrews. I'll start the show with a little bit of a confashion. I
- 0:59guess confessions not really the word, but and maybe you can relate. I
- 1:06have just had a case of sadness lately. You ever feel just melancholy kind
- 1:15of modeling sad and you can't really pinpoint why. And I want to be
- 1:21careful here because you know, I really got to be careful. So there
- 1:26are many, I think legitimate instances where people who feel sad or depressed or
- 1:33overwhelmed about something and genuinely need support will reach out on whatever platform they can,
- 1:41often social media, and they're looking for someone to kind of lift them
- 1:47up. You know, Hey, we've all helped a friend through a difficult
- 1:49time. I think that's totally legitimate, so I'm not trying to in any
- 1:55way diminish that. But we also know people who are just still a little
- 2:00bit too performative, and it happens a little bit too often, so you
- 2:06log on. This is often known as vague booking, where they don't give
- 2:10any specific details, but it sounds very Shakespearean. You know. I wish
- 2:15certain people whom I will not name, would not be so toxic about issue
- 2:23X, which I will not detail, and then go talk about you behind
- 2:29your back to other people who I will not specify. Feeling sad, please
- 2:36send good vibes. Okay. Well, on the surface, okay, But
- 2:42when you see a lot of that stuff, it does two things, in
- 2:46my humble opinion. The first thing is you become the boy who cried wolf
- 2:50or the girl or whoever who cried wolf. Right, there's so much of
- 2:53it that people stop listening. It becomes a car alarm that people tune out
- 2:57and they're like, oh, well, that person happens to live at the
- 3:00intersection of mellow and drama, right, Melo drama And the second thing it
- 3:08does is I think it adds a burden to the lives of other people who
- 3:14are going through their own struggles, and we don't often think about it in
- 3:17that way. I've been working on it myself, where if you go and
- 3:23you take the weight on your shoulders, sometimes I think it helps to have
- 3:27that weight shared with loved ones, with people who care about you, But
- 3:31sometimes it also adds the burden to them in their already burdened lives, and
- 3:38I think we have to be a good steward of that. There's so many
- 3:40gears in this machine, and I worry someone's going to harvest SoundBite. They're
- 3:47going to quote mine and say that Seth doesn't care about people experiencing hardship who
- 3:53reach out for help and support. Hell, that's probably what I'm doing right
- 3:58now. If nothing else, I'm just venting expressing. But I've just been
- 4:00going through a moment of melancholy. It might have something to do with the
- 4:09change of the seasons. Do you feel that when you come out of wintertime
- 4:13and head into spring. Is spring fever a legitimate thing? And I've heard
- 4:17that like spring fever means that you feel more tired, you know your blood
- 4:21is thickened because of the cold weather, is what we've always heard, and
- 4:26it takes some time to navigate through that. I wake up, I've been
- 4:30waking up three in the morning. I just stare at the ceiling and I've
- 4:33just been overwhelmed at all of the craziness and the hate and the bigotry and
- 4:40the divisiveness and the problems. And I don't know why. You know,
- 4:44it's the difference, I think between reflection and rumination, because I think reflection
- 4:49is critical. We have to be able to reflect on the good and the
- 4:54bad. But then sometimes we slip into rumination. We're just wallowing, right,
- 5:00We're wallowing in it, and that becomes really problematic. And I struggle
- 5:04sometimes with that when I read the headlines and I see the actions of the
- 5:11theocrats and the zealots, and the Christian nationalist and the white supremacists and the
- 5:16people who so gleefully want to splinter us into these little tribes of bigotry,
- 5:23when the truth is, we could all do so much if we just saw
- 5:29the humanity in each other. I'm sitting across from some friends. I know
- 5:35there's some who would be like, well, why would you be friends with
- 5:38those people. But they are evangelical or at least casual Christian Republican conservative types.
- 5:44They go to church. I know more about the Bible than they do
- 5:47by far, but they are casual cultural Christians, and they vote are Republican
- 5:54across the board. And they were talking about something I think, and there
- 5:59may been a jab at the Libs or the liberals somewhere at the table,
- 6:04and I, in that moment, had a tremendous feeling of isolation and a
- 6:10loneness. I just look at them and I want the lightbulb of epiphany of
- 6:16humanity to go off in their heads. There are some people who get so
- 6:23mad at me when I talk about my values as a humanist and they're like,
- 6:27well, are you host of the thinking atheist show? Or are you
- 6:30host of the liberal show. It's all equally bad. It's all tainted.
- 6:39I'm just going to make a false equivalence claim and walk out the door and
- 6:44look down my nose from my superior perch at all the rest of you who
- 6:48are just sheepl Now you participate in the process because you think it matters.
- 6:55No. No, I am neither conservative nor liberal. I am I am
- 7:00outside it all, well, aren't you special? I think that's just a
- 7:06position of privilege or to cop out. Who in the world could look at
- 7:14the two main political forces held the two main cultural forces in the United States
- 7:19and decide that they're equal. Oh, you can do that. I'm sitting
- 7:26across from people I care about, and I wrestle with the fact that I
- 7:30love them, and I genuinely do, and I crave their friendship, and
- 7:34we have a lot that we really enjoy. And then I think the jab
- 7:41at the Democrats means you are what in opposition to so many of my values.
- 7:47You don't just think differently, but you may be working to defeat the
- 7:51very causes that I hold dear. Your party is working to co op the
- 7:58whole country to make it church theocracy, not democracy, and everybody who's not
- 8:05some flavor of christian becomes a second class citizen. That includes me. You're
- 8:11at war with LGBT people talk about second class citizens. They can be denied
- 8:18service based on your personal convictions, and you will find this the moral position
- 8:24as you treat humans as in some ways in human. You're part of a
- 8:31mechanism that treats the United States like it's better than the rest of the world,
- 8:37as if we have a monopoly on goodness and freedom. What we're better
- 8:41because we were born inside these subjectively drawn boarders. Fly the flag, handover
- 8:48heart, say the pledge. In fact, you are forced to say the
- 8:52pledge of allegiance in the name of freedom. I think children today should be
- 9:00wired to say a freedom oath. People say this without any sense of irony.
- 9:07Yeah, they must be mandated to say they love their country. This
- 9:11almost sounds like the Christian Bible commanded to love God. How do you command
- 9:18someone to experience and feel genuine love for someone or something else? How does
- 9:24that work? Exactly? My buddy Dave Warnock, who runs the Dying Out
- 9:31Loud websites, he continues to do what he does as an activist, knowing
- 9:37that his body is on the decline. He has already been planning his own
- 9:41exits, right, I mean he thinks in those terms. He says,
- 9:46I have a ls there is no cure. What will the final days of
- 9:50my life be? And the Republican Party believes that end of life decisions,
- 9:58Well, that's God's thing. Only God can decide. My father died of
- 10:03pulmonary fibrosis. The scar tissue in his lungs caused him to increasingly heave and
- 10:11gasp and heave and gasp, And so they bring in the oxygen machine,
- 10:16and when it can't keep up, they bring in a bigger oxygen machine,
- 10:22and when that machine can't keep up, they jack him up with morphine so
- 10:26at least he won't panic while he's writhing in his bed. This goes on
- 10:31four days. He finally gives out at two o'clock in the morning, and
- 10:35my family thanks Jesus that he died in the night as we prayed, as
- 10:43if he had just sort of peacefully gone to be with the Lord. There
- 10:48is no concept, there is no notion that my father had he wanted it,
- 10:54and I know he didn't because he was a devout Christian, But you
- 10:58know, he had the right to go with dignity. He knew there was
- 11:01no way out. Imagine if he had opened his mind and heart to the
- 11:03possibility that he could say goodbye at the moment of his choosing and he could
- 11:09peacefully fall asleep before his body turned into a suffocating, writhing nightmare. And
- 11:18who is standing against that right in the name of God. It's a political
- 11:22party, and it's not the liberals. It's not the Democrats, it's those
- 11:28bible banging ours who is in love with guns? Four hundred million guns in
- 11:37this country And when I say how many more guns do you need for us
- 11:41to be safe, they look at me and say, well, Seth is
- 11:46anti gun. Well that's an oversimplification because I do have a couple of firearms
- 11:50that I keep in a safe and occasionally target shoot. But my guns aren't
- 11:56part of my identity. It was John Stewart on his television show. He
- 12:03was doing an interview a few weeks back with Oklahoma State Senator Nathan Dom and
- 12:09Nathan Dom, is, you know, ringing the bell about the Second Amendments
- 12:13and how we need to deregulate access to guns in the name of protection and
- 12:18freedom. And John Stewart looks at him and says, well, at what
- 12:22point, you know, with four hundred more firearms than citizens in this country,
- 12:26at what point do we pass that bar? When do we become safe?
- 12:31Like? When did we get there? How many do you need?
- 12:35And the guy totally vapor locks, you know, I mean, I got
- 12:39people waving their guns in this town when they passed open carry in the state
- 12:46of Oklahoma. I shit you not. There was a guy who packed on
- 12:52a two gun holster, just like the Old West. He had a gun
- 12:56on each hip, and just to show how free he was, started walking
- 13:01around the courthouse buildings downtown. He has decided, I'm going to go show
- 13:07everybody how damn free I am. Here's madou guns. I'm gonna go walk
- 13:11around with my two barrels in full display and show everybody what freedom really is.
- 13:20Which party sees more of that insanity? I think it's the Republicans,
- 13:26don't you Who's dragging their bibles into school board meetings, who's trying to ban
- 13:33the books because God? Who's infecting secular city council meetings by insisting that the
- 13:43invocation slash prayers are all supposed to be Christian and nothing else. Who opposes
- 13:52climate change science and clean energy policies or even proposals, because wouldn't it be
- 13:58not used to build a better, cleaner, safer, less polluted world.
- 14:03I mean, even if you didn't believe that climate change was an increasing problem,
- 14:09just the notion that we would do better, that we would pollute less,
- 14:13that we would contaminate less, that we would pursue the cleanest and most
- 14:18efficient and most protective versions of what we do. I mean, how is
- 14:22that even controversial? And who's against it? It's over here one particular party
- 14:28talking about how it'll be a cold day in hell before I drive one of
- 14:31them liberal cars. Part of that conversation includes the proliferation, or the rise,
- 14:39at least of the electric vehicles. We can get into lithium battery technology
- 14:45and disposal and waste. These are necessary and interesting conversations, but the whole
- 14:50idea for them is black smoke coming out of the tailpipe of my truck is
- 14:56a symbol of freedom. They lean into the Old Testament's eye for an eye,
- 15:01versus to support the death penalty, which I've come to see as barbaric,
- 15:07inappropriately applied, usually against people of color and the poor, those who
- 15:13can't afford proper representation. We've seen so many instances of injustice reversals, new
- 15:20evidence came to light. And beyond all of that, how about the economics
- 15:24of it. It's actually more expensive to put somebody on death row than it
- 15:31is to imprison them for life. You would think the capitalists would see that
- 15:37and say, hm, that makes the latest dance no no, And you
- 15:41know which party wants to kill the killers. It's the Republicans. Do not
- 15:46tell me, it's not the Democrats on the Supreme Court that are planting their
- 15:52dominionist flags in the uteruses of one hundred and sixty six million women. You'd
- 16:03fold your arms all you want, and you can say, well, it's
- 16:07all equally bad, all you want. None of that makes what you say
- 16:11not bullshit. And here I am. I'm sitting at a table and Strawberry
- 16:17Red, Oklahoma, once again, fully aware that I'm alone, almost alone
- 16:23as far as my knowledge. I'm alone in my values and what I'm fighting
- 16:27for. And am I sitting at the table with people who are working against
- 16:32me? And how is that work? And do I draw the hard line?
- 16:34Do I end the friendship? Do I pound on the table and say
- 16:37what the hell is wrong with you people? Do I try to humanize my
- 16:41own value system, my own person and position in an attempt to try to
- 16:47bring their walls down so that we can have mind changing, opinion changing conversations
- 16:53about the things that matter. All I know is, at the end of
- 16:57the day, I leave and I just feel sad. I'm struck by how
- 17:06much energy, gleeful energy is position towards not sharing the world equally with other
- 17:14people, and often taking advantage of other people. How do we work the
- 17:19system? If somebody's smart enough to work the system, maybe the system deserves
- 17:25to be worked. And if you're taking advantage of well, you know,
- 17:30that's kind of your problem for being so vulnerable. And here's yet another reason
- 17:36why that is a sensitive nerve. I got a call from my CPA.
- 17:41It is tax season in the United States, and isn't that always a joy?
- 17:48Despite my occasional frustrations with the bureaucracy and inefficiency and waste that we have
- 17:55all seen our tax dollars go to, I think, most recently the one
- 17:59on my mind all the bank bailouts. Right, I get it. I'm
- 18:03part of a society. My taxes fund the support structure for that society,
- 18:11and I totally get that. So tax season comes around, I bite the
- 18:17bullets, I write the check, and I get a call from my CPA
- 18:22who says, well, I filed your taxes for twenty twenty two and those
- 18:26taxes were rejected by the Internal Revenue Service. Wait a minute, why did
- 18:33the IRS reject my taxes? Well, seth their record, say that you
- 18:40have already filed. Well, what's that about, Seth. You have been
- 18:45the victim of identity theft. By the way, I think this may be
- 18:49the first time in history that anybody has ever purposefully wanted to be me.
- 18:56So apparently this is a major majour, major problem, a scam that has
- 19:03been going on increasingly since twenty fifteen. Somebody steals your social right, your
- 19:11Social Security number, and they file taxes under your name, and they list
- 19:18a ton of dependence and those dependents bring about a tax credit which produces a
- 19:26refund check that that scammer receives at the false address that they put on the
- 19:33form, and then they go and launder the money through bitcoin. This is
- 19:40how it was explained to me, and the idea, I guess is is
- 19:45that it's untraceable. This is a billions of dollars scam that I was just
- 19:53made aware of because yeah, now it happened to me, and this is
- 20:00fun. Turns out that it'll be six to nine months before the IRS even
- 20:04opens the envelope containing my affidavit of identity theft and starts the case. So
- 20:11the whole time I'm waiting on them to investigate, I remain unprotected for twenty
- 20:15twenty three, meaning that the scammer might be able to do it again before
- 20:21anyone notices. And lo and behold, I end up on a hamster wheel
- 20:26that I may not get off of four years. So it's been that kind
- 20:33of month. I guess it's all first world problems when you look at it,
- 20:37but it's still frustrating, and I do I think, what if the
- 20:41people who spend all this time scamming other people and trying to grift and take
- 20:47advantage and work the system in these illegal and immoral ways, what if they
- 20:52committed themselves to doing it right, playing by their rules, building, constructing,
- 20:56helping, being good. Imagine what we might accomplish as a species,
- 21:04say goodbye to corruption and abuse and war, and we could all hold hands
- 21:11and advance and evolve as the human condition together. And of course you and
- 21:18I know that as long as there is an opportunity, as long as there
- 21:22is a scam, as long as there is easy money, and as long
- 21:26as there are awful people, that dream will always remain a dream. And
- 21:32I think it's just sad, and I sometimes feel overwhelmed by it. Do
- 21:34you ever feel overwhelmed? You wonder sometimes are there more bad people than good
- 21:41people? I don't think so, but I don't always feel so. And
- 21:45I have to be cognizant of the difference. Right, Instead of ruminating,
- 21:49I must objectively as best I can, reflect and be honest about what's really
- 21:56going on. I don't know. That's a little window into my life.
- 21:59I mean to burden you, but it's you know, some people I think
- 22:03are interested in what informs the attitude of the host, and that's kind of
- 22:10where I'm at. I'm interested in where you are at. My copywriter would
- 22:15kill me for saying that sentence in that way, like ending with the preposition
- 22:19where you are at? But I mean where you're at? Where are you
- 22:23at right now? As we'd go to the phones to find out? Six?
- 22:30One two? Hi? Who's this? Hi? This is Manuela,
- 22:33Manuela. Did I say it right? Yes? You did? Thank you
- 22:37so much for calling. What's on your mind? Well, forgive me a
- 22:41bit nervous. English is not my first language, so forgive you for any
- 22:44mistakes doing great. I'm from Europe and something that I noticed since I moved
- 22:51to the United States is how much Americans seem to hate children. For example,
- 22:56like you can't bring them public without people going like, k that thing
- 23:00shut up with literally saying the thing and complaining about people bringing their children in
- 23:08public, not like them going you know, climbing up the shelves and Walmart
- 23:12or something, just normal kids who are making noise and people are losing their
- 23:17little mind over it. And yeah, I was just wondering. For a
- 23:22country that's so much about family values, it sounds like they hate children a
- 23:26lot. Well, it's interesting. It has not been my experience. I
- 23:30don't have any kids of my own, but usually in my experience, unless
- 23:33they are unruly and banging around and screaming and carrying on, and somebody takes
- 23:37them into a movie theater or you know, something like the library, I
- 23:42haven't in my own life as an American scene that, but obviously it has
- 23:47been your experience, and I'm sorry that it has been. Yeah, it
- 23:52has literally people saying that you shouldn't bring children into a restaurant because they paid
- 23:56to eat their dinner in peace and quiet. And if that thing can shut
- 24:00up and leave it at home, well, I'm very sorry that that has
- 24:04happened to you. Just know that there are some people, even those who
- 24:07are child free like me, who you know, unless the kids banging my
- 24:12seat on an airplane are screaming in my ear somewhere. I mean, I'm
- 24:17easy, I'm good with it, so people like me exist, okay,
- 24:19man willa, Okay. I mean, I'll be the first to admit that
- 24:25there are some of us who do better and some who do not do better.
- 24:29When it comes to a lot of noise created by children, I'm yeah,
- 24:33I'm good, like I'm really fine. I think, you know,
- 24:37family should be able to go out and spend family time together. I do
- 24:41have a problem when unruly kids start to spoil the experience for other people.
- 24:47I don't think that's what my collar was necessarily talking about. I am child
- 24:52free, like I never had kids. Natalie's got a couple of grown children
- 24:56who are beautiful. They are my family and I love them with all my
- 25:00heart. But I myself never had that instinct, and in a highly religious
- 25:04family, it's race a lot of people's eyebrows. I was twenty two when
- 25:11I started my first marriage of eighteen years. I'm just a kid. I'm
- 25:15twenty two, But at that moment I had no desire to be a parent,
- 25:22and my then wife had no desire to be a parent. And we
- 25:26said, so, we're not interested in having kids, and everybody around this
- 25:30patted us on the head and said, oh, one day, one day,
- 25:34you're gonna wake up and you're just gonna want to have a little bundle
- 25:38of joy and you're gonna be ready to be a mother and father. Okay,
- 25:42well, if that day comes, we'll let you know. So a
- 25:48year passed, Oh one day, you're still young. Three years past,
- 25:53five years past, seven years passed, and I noticed that everybody around me
- 26:00started to get kind of quiet, and I felt it's nothing that they said.
- 26:06I felt this attitude that they thought I was just selfish. You're just
- 26:12all about yourself. Why don't you want to have kids? I mean,
- 26:17what is that about? You just want to come and go as you please.
- 26:19You're not interested in other people. And here's the fun one seth hate
- 26:23children. I'm sorry, I hate children. Where did that come from?
- 26:32So much of these attitudes, especially in religion, rooted in the Bible,
- 26:37be fruitful and multiply, you're supposed to go and have children, And there's
- 26:44this attitude that if you don't have kids, or something wrong with you.
- 26:48And I fielded that for a long, long time, and even now I
- 26:52sense it from some people who are just a little bit self conscious. I
- 26:56don't know, maybe they secretly envy the fact that somebody calls me at the
- 27:00last second because they need someone to fill in on a tennis match. I
- 27:04can just leave, all right, I'll be there in twenty two minutes.
- 27:10Hey, do you feel like going out tonight? Let's just leave and go
- 27:14do that. Would you like to spend a weekend with your brother in Kansas
- 27:18City. It's Friday afternoon. We could be there by nine. Let's grab
- 27:22the dogs, hop in the car. We got nothing else to do.
- 27:26That kind of freedom. I do wonder if some people, the self conscious
- 27:32people, maybe secretly envy that. But I'll admit there are certain joys in
- 27:37my life that I know I will never get. I'll never experience the birth
- 27:41of a baby in the delivery room. I'll never experience the joy of watching
- 27:45that child grow. I'll never be there for the first steps, the first
- 27:48day at school, being involved in sports or band or the arts or whatever,
- 27:56and being that parents in the audience cheering on my child, the graduation,
- 28:00seeing the child grow to become an adult and start a family of their
- 28:04own, and then grandchildren. I understand there are certain types of love,
- 28:10there are certain experiences, beautiful experiences that I myself will never get. But
- 28:18while other people lament that, for me, I simply want to look them
- 28:22in the eye and say it's okay. I've come to terms with it,
- 28:26because for me, the parental gene has just never been there. And I
- 28:30just don't think you have kids because you're supposed to, because the Bible tells
- 28:37you too, because mom and Dad want grandchildren, or because you're worried that
- 28:42person X is gonna think you're selfish, Like your expectations really should have no
- 28:51effect on whether or not I decide to bring a human being into the world
- 28:56and make a lifelong commitment to that person. I just I just never had
- 29:03it. Yeah, I just never got there. I don't hate kids.
- 29:07I'm not anti family, and I'm not one of those Americans that this caller
- 29:12experienced who thinks everything in public should be an adult's only experience. I mean,
- 29:18and you know, unless it's a rare designated spot, you know,
- 29:22if you're at Applebee's, I don't know. I'm just rambling. I've got
- 29:29nine one nine. Tell me your name? Donovan, Donovan what's on your
- 29:33mind? That's kind of wanted to talk a little bit about autism and assism
- 29:40because one of those things that I can discovered in my own discovery over the
- 29:44last year has been the autistic has an increased chance of being an atheist.
- 29:49Is it the filtering of emotion in different ways that someone autistic might experience has
- 29:57made them less susceptible to the be oeriential Personally from my own perspective of an
- 30:03autistic person myself, I think it's having a more analytical mind giving me the
- 30:08question even when I was raised as a Christian. Well, it's interesting.
- 30:14I don't know either way. It's highly possible that somebody who is more analytical
- 30:21will reject more to be experiential and add two plus two and come up with
- 30:27four. I mean, it's very possible, certainly. Yeah. Part of
- 30:30the reason why the kind of comes up to my mind as well as like
- 30:34both being autistic and being awesome asis kind of been an intersection that I've been
- 30:41trying to figure out on how they interact with each other because for both of
- 30:45them, or I'm normal passing to most people, So it makes me wonder,
- 30:52like, especially like with me taking on a social devience class of semester,
- 30:56like how does that affect my role in society? Are questions that are
- 31:00beyond me. Once again, I'm not an expert in mental health or autism.
- 31:07But what you've done is is I think you've given those of us who
- 31:11are listening to your story something to talk about, to be able to exchange
- 31:15ideas on the subject. And I would encourage our listeners to do so if
- 31:18maybe you've made that connection, or you have a mental health resource, or
- 31:22you you've done the homework on it's the common section is all yours, and
- 31:26we'll come back and review and see what you've come up with. I appreciate
- 31:30the call very much. Thanks for giving us something that you want to both
- 31:33today. All right, see your learning Emily at seven five seven Are you
- 31:40there? Yeah? Well, first I wanted to say thank you for talking
- 31:44about childless childlessness by choice. I think it's something that I'm really glad that
- 31:49we're finally talking about. So the reason that I called was I wanted to
- 31:56from your perspective, see does it ever change when someone or that feeling that
- 32:01you have inside when someone that you've known from the former you says, oh,
- 32:07I hear that you have a church problem or a God problem, and
- 32:10that you know that your family kind of have a distance. There this feeling
- 32:19of wanting to just have defensiveness kind of ever dissipate. Well, I think
- 32:25that's specific to you. You know, I can't tell you how you would
- 32:30feel about someone who is offering up a kind of I don't know a rationalization
- 32:36as to why you reject their faith. You must be the one to determine
- 32:40how you feel, what you feel, are those feelings valid? What do
- 32:45you do about those feelings? So I can't really speak to that. I
- 32:47do know that perceptions can change. I think relationships are always in a state
- 32:52of evolution or de evolution. And I think you know you've set your boundaries
- 32:59and decide how much you're willing to put up with and if someone's love is
- 33:02conditional, that's information you can use to make the decision. Okay, okay,
- 33:07thanks Emily, hang in there. I think Kevin at eight five zero
- 33:15high are you there? Seth good afternoon or a good morning, whatever it
- 33:20is in your neck of the whatever. I don't even have a clock in
- 33:22my office. Just what's on your mind? Brother? Well, first and
- 33:27foremost, I just wanted to pay a compliment and just tell you you're just
- 33:31such a pro my friend. You really are. Thank you. Yeah,
- 33:34I mean, you know, your heart and you're just how genuine you are
- 33:39comes across in spade and everything that you do, and I just wanted to
- 33:43give you a heads up on that on how I feel. No, thank
- 33:45you, man, I appreciate the kind words means a lot, and just
- 33:49in general, you know, I it's kind of an interesting experience to be
- 33:52talking to you because you're one of the guys that because I guess it is
- 33:55about three years now that I don't know if you call it deconversion or whatever,
- 34:00I claimed to be a Christian, and you know, I was driving
- 34:05I lived in a van for three and a half years, and I was
- 34:07driving down the road listening to you Tube and stumbled upon a Christopher Hitchens video
- 34:13I think it was he was debating Frank Turik, and I went into that,
- 34:16I think it was an hour and a half and I went into listening
- 34:19to that with a bias that the theist was going to kick the atheist ass.
- 34:23And at the end of it, I said, oh my gosh,
- 34:25I have a terrible problem on you know, I because I was always really
- 34:32uncomfortable with so much, so many of the components of faith and belief and
- 34:37all that. I mean, it just never made sense to me that I
- 34:39was taken care of and that there were so many people that, you know,
- 34:44their basic crime was being born in the wrong place, you know,
- 34:47and they were you know, kids starving to death. And here was this
- 34:52knucklehead like me being supposedly taken care of by something out there that loves me
- 34:57more than I could possibly imagine. When I really I didn't feel like I
- 35:00deserve it, you know, there was nothing special about me in that sense.
- 35:06So I became an atheist. You know, I prefer a nonbeliever,
- 35:08but I just you know, I just and my life has improved exponentially as
- 35:13a result. I was a happy guy before. I'm happier now because I
- 35:16feel like I'm being honest with myself and with the people around me. And
- 35:22it's guys like you that have helped me do that. Thank you man.
- 35:24Hey. By the way, if you want a lesson in daily madness,
- 35:30follow Frank Turk on Twitter. It's like a daily dose of empty calorie platitude
- 35:38nothingness. I mean, just illogic that comes out of his pages. I
- 35:44followed for a few days and I had to go and just unfollow and close
- 35:49my eyes and block my ears because the apologists to see them play that game
- 35:54of twister to excuse the inexcusable, and then they look down their noses at
- 36:00the rest of us as if they're supposed to be making sense. Frank Turk,
- 36:02no wonder, Christopher Hitchins kicked his ass right he was a minnow swimming
- 36:09among the sharks. Yeah, I, you know, I try to avoid
- 36:14a lot of conversations anymore. I just kind of debtail on what you've opened
- 36:17your live stream with being melancholy and whatnot, and you know, looking at
- 36:22the events of the world, and now talking about Twitter, I don't have
- 36:24any social media. I don't watch I know basically what's going on in the
- 36:30world, but not the details, you know. I honestly, I just
- 36:35feel like I, since I don't have any way to truly affect them on
- 36:38a macro level, I don't pay attention to them on that level. And
- 36:42I, you know, I still have basic struggles, but for the most
- 36:45part, I feel like that that's a better policy for me. Maybe it's
- 36:49a cop out, but man, I just can't pay attention. You know,
- 36:53well, I don't think. I don't think managing how much bullshit gets
- 36:59thrown in your face is the same as sticking your head in the sand.
- 37:01I would assume you're relatively informed about what's going on in the world. But
- 37:07I also think, you know, we can establish some filters to try to
- 37:10limit the madness. I think that's totally valid. Brother, You hit the
- 37:15nail on the head. You know, I do have a general sense of
- 37:17what's going on in the world. Part of the reason that I don't pay
- 37:21as much as the attention that I used to is because I'm proud to say
- 37:23I'm a former expert on everything. I mean, a decade ago, I
- 37:30could have told you what was going on in Ukraine and why Silicon Velly Bank
- 37:35crashed and all this other stuff. I don't know. I really don't know.
- 37:37You know. It's sort of like the same thing as being a non
- 37:40believer. How can you know so many of the things that people claim that
- 37:45they do. So, yeah, I just I just my own business.
- 37:50But I guess I'll just kind of try to end with this, and that's
- 37:52that. I'm also a member of Alcoholics Anonymous I've been an AA for a
- 37:57long time and having become a non believer, it's been interesting. It with
- 38:05a hyower model. Yeah, yeah, the higher power thing, and you
- 38:07know, people just invent their own god, and you know, mine does
- 38:10this, and then mine does that, and again kind of going back to
- 38:15my own personal journey. None of that ever made sense to me. And
- 38:19so when I was finally able to just be honest with myself and the rest
- 38:22of the people around me, it just felt better. You know, it
- 38:24just felt better. And you know, I use the idea put forth by
- 38:30Marcus Aurelius. If there are gods and they are just, then they won't
- 38:34care how devout that I've been. If there are gods and they are not
- 38:37just, well I don't want to worship them. And if there are no
- 38:39gods, well I have lived a good life and hopefully I'll be remembered for
- 38:44a little while by a few people. That's it. You speak wisdom,
- 38:47Kevin. I appreciate the kind words and the call hang in there to my
- 38:52brother. Hey, I wish I was going to be able to go to
- 38:53Phoenix, but I ain't got the cash. Bro. I got you,
- 38:57I got you the speech that I'm giving will eventually post online, probably closer
- 39:01to summertime, once I'm done with this. I hate to say after I'm
- 39:06done touring with it because I'm trying to sound like the Rolling Stones, which
- 39:08I'm not. But it will eventually go to YouTube, so you'll be able
- 39:14to see it soon. Okay, Yeah, all ranks, brother to you
- 39:17had a great day. It's funny. Yeah, he's right. Especially when
- 39:21I think you're in a fundamentalist culture, you have this weird confidence about how
- 39:25much you know. It's like I was a graduate with honors from Dunning Krueger.
- 39:30You. I mean, I was an expert on so much that I
- 39:35knew nothing about, and that I would be smug about all the answers that
- 39:38I had. And then you escape that culture and you start to look around
- 39:43and you start to know how much you don't know. And beyond that,
- 39:47the liberation of being able to say those words, and some cultures I don't
- 39:53know is considered an expression of weakness. How could you not know? You
- 40:00don't know? Well, you should know, I know, But the truth
- 40:05is it's the answers and times it's an honest answer. I don't know.
- 40:08How did the universe begin? Where did the first cell come from? Or
- 40:13whatever? I don't know. I have no idea. Of course, I'm
- 40:17thinking to myself, you don't know either. Sometimes I'll say that out loud.
- 40:24You can bang the Book of Genesis all you want. Trust me,
- 40:27you don't know how the universe started. You got a story, you got
- 40:30you gotta claim that needs to meet a burden to prove. But you I
- 40:34don't know, and neither do you. More of whatever it is you want
- 40:39to talk about in just a second, hang on. Thank you so much
- 40:51to all of my supporters on Patreon who get this show early and commercial free.
- 40:55But most importantly, they help me to do what I do. If
- 41:00I can be candid, I know that COVID the last few years have been
- 41:04kind of hard on people who have been supported by Patreon dollars, and I
- 41:09totally get it. I mean, the economy was in the tank, and
- 41:13everybody's job situation had changed, and they were scrounging for every penny, and
- 41:16so a lot of us saw many of our patrons have to go and take
- 41:21care of business in their own circles. But it does mean that some of
- 41:25us are trying to make up that lost ground. So if you enjoyed the
- 41:29show and you want to support it for I don't know one, four or
- 41:32five bucks a month or whatever. It does make a difference. It's huge
- 41:36for podcasters like me. You can go to Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews
- 41:44and thank you so much for your support. Joseph at two one five,
- 41:50thanks for waiting. Are you there? This is me, This is you.
- 41:53What's on your mind? Oh? Okay, well beliefs. Then I
- 41:58didn't hear you say my name? It's Joseph and Joselphia. Joseph. I'm
- 42:01glad I'm not the only one on the show today with a biblical names.
- 42:05That's refreshing. Yeah, I've thought about changing it. I've been in this
- 42:14journey at this point about four years. I initially, well, first of
- 42:20all, I'm gay, and I'm married to a man and his sister is
- 42:23gay and married to a woman. And I was going to a Catholic church
- 42:30seven days a week, serving at the altar. And the week before John
- 42:36and I got married, they had a service. All the readings were about
- 42:39marriage, and I said, what am I doing here? The Catholic Church
- 42:44does not accept me. They would never ever let me go in there and
- 42:47be married in a Catholic church. I said, why am I doing this?
- 42:53And so my first getting out of Christianity was deism and that didn't last
- 43:00long because you go on YouTube and the other videos that come up are atheist
- 43:05videos, and so I started listening to you in a few others and I
- 43:09said, this makes more sense to me. But the reason I called is
- 43:15my husband had some physical problems within the hospital, and of course his sister
- 43:21has to talk to me to find out how he's doing. She knows I
- 43:25do not believe. She is a very nominal, cafeteria Catholic. Well,
- 43:31I believe in God and you know that. So we just won't talk about
- 43:36that, okay. But she's also one hundred percent like some kind of raiky
- 43:43master, which I think is sort of odd compared to Catholicism. And we're
- 43:50talking about John's condition, and then we get on other subjects, and I
- 43:54said, you know, I've called our congressman and our senators to try and
- 44:00get them to propose a bill to change the motto of the United States back
- 44:06to the original motto E pure. But I can't say it epure. I
- 44:12can't say no, no, no, e pluribus unum. It means out
- 44:15of many, thank you. And yeah, it was the motto before in
- 44:20God We trust was added later on in like nineteen fifty six because of the
- 44:24Red scare. YEA. And she said, Joseph, I don't want to
- 44:29talk about that. I said, I'm not making fun of your religion or
- 44:32anything. I'm talking about the motto of the United States. She said,
- 44:36Joseph, I don't want to talk about that. If you keep talking about
- 44:38that, I'm going to hang up on you. And I said, okay.
- 44:44And it's like I'm talking about politics. I'm talking about the motto of
- 44:47the United States. And the biggest problem is I'm still an angry atheist.
- 44:52But you've caught me down a little bit. Oh I'm angry too, I
- 44:58trust me. I I was at a dinner table with a bunch of people
- 45:01the other night, this would just last week, and politics came up,
- 45:07and I'm having that whole cost benefit discussion, right do I really I did
- 45:12not come here to get into it about politics, but at the same time,
- 45:15it is important. And somebody said, well, you know, I
- 45:19really like Ron DeSantis for president in twenty twenty four, and I almost crawled
- 45:24out of my skin, climbed over the table and grabbed them by the throat.
- 45:30I didn't do it, but I had that inclination. So I get
- 45:35angry, just like you do when I think anger is the appropriate response.
- 45:39But as far as the sister is concerned, I mean, if she's not
- 45:43ramming her first, I've never heard Catholicism and raiki in the same room together.
- 45:49That's a that's a weird convergence of belief system. You know. I
- 45:52got the Catholic Church and raiky healing energies, chockris and shit like that.
- 45:58That's weird. Yeah, that's pretty weird. And she she asked me to
- 46:00tell John. She said, tell John, I'm sending reiki to him.
- 46:06She lives in guess where, Florida, and she hates the santis. We
- 46:12can agree on that. Okay, How do you send to someone? I
- 46:16thought raiki was a practice. I think you'd stand over someone and your hands.
- 46:21You believe you can send it long distance like or does AT and T
- 46:27charge extra for that? Do you need fiber Do you need fiber optics for
- 46:30raiki to go through the landline? I have questions about long distance raiki.
- 46:37Um. I'm sorry for that for your partner's troubles um anything I mean,
- 46:43okay, I mean I was gonna say, he's anything we can do,
- 46:45right, No, but she you know, and and I do because of
- 46:51you. I said to John, your sister Rose is praying for you and
- 46:55sending reiki to you. And I did it against my better judgment. I'd
- 47:02think it's silly, but I told him that, and he said, well,
- 47:07that's nice. But I just don't understand why she can't talk about the
- 47:13motto of the United States. Well she thinks it's somehow an attack against God
- 47:17or religion. Well, we're talking about a belief link to her identity,
- 47:22right. She lives in a confirmation bubble, and anything that disconfirms her pre
- 47:30established notions about the world, she's going to feel like this is a virus
- 47:34that's entering her healthy body and she has to inoculate herself. And why would
- 47:39she want to live in a world where her deeply held beliefs are challenged by
- 47:44those pesky data points and facts in the history of the United States. No,
- 47:49No, I don't even want to hear it. I've been in conversations
- 47:52with people and they will tell me outright, seth, I don't care what
- 47:55you say. I don't care what facts you present, I don't care what
- 48:00the evidence says. You will never change my mind. And I'm so struck
- 48:04by that because it's a proud declaration that you will never improve your perspective when
- 48:10you get better information. And that's the frustration you're feeling, right, Joseph,
- 48:15Yeah, it's like, I mean, I've had thoughts of, well,
- 48:19gee, I just don't even want to talk to her. But she's
- 48:22not strict. I mean, she's not like some fundamental as Catholic. She's
- 48:28a lesbian. I wouldn't sweat that. I wouldn't know the Catholic churches for
- 48:32your sanity's sake. I wouldn't spend too much time trying to change her mind.
- 48:37I think, you know, it's healthy for her to be not confronted,
- 48:43but to experience conflicting point of view, you know, a disagreeing perspective.
- 48:47We certainly don't want to feel like we're bubble wrapping ourselves to keep her
- 48:52comfortable, but changing her mind is that's probably a long game. I would
- 48:58focus more on you being true to you, taking care of your husband's you
- 49:04know, living your own values, and you know who knows. Maybe someday
- 49:07she'll actually, you know, maybe there'll be that how did how was that
- 49:12said? David McRaney called it the crack that lets in the light. Maybe
- 49:15one day that crack will sort of hit the verneer and she'll be able.
- 49:19Did I say verneer? Oh my god, that's a total Oklahoma, it
- 49:24snuck out. I said the word verner. I'm sorry. Anyway, we're
- 49:28hopefully one day she'll maybe tap you on the shoulder and you guys can have
- 49:31the conversation where she feels more safe. But I wouldn't beat yourself up because
- 49:36she's not going to bend. It's just I think it's the nature of the
- 49:37beast. Okay, Yeah, it's just frustrating because it was just a conversation.
- 49:43It wasn't I wasn't trying to affect her own belief system. I was
- 49:47talking about the country and the fact that Benjamin Franklin, Jefferson and Adams were
- 49:54commissioned to create a seal of the United States and the only thing that they
- 50:00came up with, and they came up with some weird ideas was eplurbusunum.
- 50:05It's stuck. Joseph I appreciate you and e pluribus unum. I'm sending that
- 50:12down the fiber optic right out of men. I'm sending the motto of the
- 50:15United States instead of raiki to you. That's more grounded and you'd be safe
- 50:21and take care of yourself. Okay, okay, thank you, see you
- 50:23later. I'm sending you raiki. I've never I've just never heard it phrase
- 50:28like that. I guess it's possible. I mean if like I was talking
- 50:30to Susan Gerbick on the The Grief Vampires podcast and they were talking about doing
- 50:37psychic readings on zoom. So I guess if you can read someone's you know
- 50:42they're psyche and talk to their dad's mother or grandmother or whoever, and you
- 50:47can do so on the internet, I suppose you know. But do you
- 50:51need I mean, can you do high speed? Do you need an ethernets?
- 50:54Can you do it over the standard phone lines? I mean, I
- 50:58have questions. I have questions about sending down the raiki. Let's see Chris
- 51:05at seven zero six. Are you there? I am, Thanks for calling.
- 51:08What do you want to talk about? You know, I'm pretty well
- 51:13into my journey of coming out of religion. I was raised in a very
- 51:17Southern Baptist sweating and spitting in the pulpit kind of church, and I've left
- 51:23home. I you know, I'm actual duty military, and I've just completely
- 51:29fallen out of kinds of stuff I was raised in. And as of now,
- 51:34my little sister, who still lives in that area, is the only
- 51:37one who really knows other than my wife. And I wanted to see if
- 51:43you had any nuggets of wisdom about how to handle bringing up to my parents,
- 51:49who are still very much religious. They've left kind of the more extreme
- 51:54version that we were in when I was younger. They're more and more that
- 52:00kind more progressive kind of first Aptist church now that still hold on to that
- 52:05very strongly. And my thoughts have been to not push the issue, let
- 52:12it come up naturally so that they don't feel too blindsided about it. But
- 52:16do you have any little pieces of wisdom? Oh, you're talking to somebody
- 52:22who has been bitching on the podcast for thirteen fourteen years about his own failures
- 52:29with his family. So but I can do this for you. I can't
- 52:34tell you the approach that will create a positive response from your mother and father.
- 52:39What I can do is to encourage you that whatever you do needs to
- 52:45not be about them as much as it is about you. I do think
- 52:52walking in with data points and trying to dissect the Bible and convince them,
- 52:58you know, to try to valid because I think we all want to do
- 53:00that. Here are the legitimate concerns I have about religion. Did you note
- 53:04that this is wrong and this is contradictory? And God said this, and
- 53:07he commanded rape in the Bible, and he wants the silence women, and
- 53:09there was genocide of a half a million people in blah blah. And so
- 53:13you go in and you're trying to be heard and saying, as a moral
- 53:16creature, as someone who wants to be about the truth, these are the
- 53:20reasons. And I think that's a temptation that many of us have. But
- 53:23I've become more and more convinced that this does not change minds and usually only
- 53:28creates problems, at least at the front end. I think you don't walk
- 53:34in with data points. I think you walk in and you say, look,
- 53:37I wanted to share with you that I have been on a journey and
- 53:40I have been navigating some questions and concerns about some things, and I have
- 53:47come to a position here that's you know, I'm not convinced. Right,
- 53:53this is language that is sort of softer, but I don't think it's weaker.
- 54:00I'm not convinced. I've got some real problems with this, and I
- 54:04just wanted you to know that I'm on this journey and that whatever is true,
- 54:07I'm making a commitment to you that that's what I want. And if
- 54:13God shows up, then I want to know that. You know, I
- 54:15think they're reassurance that life is a journey. You're taking your own on your
- 54:21own terms, and whatever is true, you want that to be a part
- 54:25of your journey as well. I would keep the first conversation short. Right
- 54:31short, you are going to they are going to throw the hooks out,
- 54:36They're going to want to suck you into a long form conversation. Then things
- 54:39are going to become frustrated, probably heated. Someone's going to leave, pissed
- 54:44off or whatever. I would try to avoid that at all costs. The
- 54:49first conversation is merely putting it on their radar in a soft way. This
- 54:53is my journey. Here's where I'm at. I just I don't want to
- 54:57talk through it at the moment, but I feel like I wanted you to
- 55:00know that I'm kind of here, and you know, let's we can talk
- 55:05more about it down the way, right. Then you'll let that sink in,
- 55:08and then the rest of those conversations I think can come afterward. But
- 55:14at the end of the day, your job will not be to convince them.
- 55:16Never walk in saying I'm going to fix them or convince them that I
- 55:22am right or that I have a point. We would love for that to
- 55:25happen, but I don't think that's the goal. The goal is for you
- 55:29to go in and say, this is my journey. I'm taking it on
- 55:31my terms. There are some boundaries I've established that I'm going to ask you
- 55:36to observe, and I commit to you that I want to live a truthful
- 55:39life. I think that's the goal. It's really more about you than it's
- 55:44about them. Does that answer your question? Yeah, yeah, it does,
- 55:47it does. I cannot reiterate this enough that first conversation. Trust me,
- 55:53you will go in and you'll want to make it ten minutes and they
- 55:58are going to want to suck you win to a ninety minute prayer meeting or
- 56:02a debate club. Do not take that bait right, skip out of that
- 56:08conversation, draw a hard line on that conversation, but that first one,
- 56:14keep it short, and that's my advice to you. Okay, thank you,
- 56:17And before I'll let you go, I actually found your channel a little
- 56:23later into my deconstruction and deconversion actually through the video you did with Forrest and
- 56:29Erica, who both of them were people that I learned a lot from very
- 56:35early on. People like them and Dapperdno and R and Raw. Apologies.
- 56:38So all of you guys doing what you do. It makes a big difference
- 56:43in a lot of people's lives and I'm very appreciative of it. Oh,
- 56:45it means a lot. And I'll pass the word on when I bump into
- 56:47those folks on the road. So good luck with your family, and you
- 56:52know, if something happens that is notable, feel free to call back give
- 56:55us the update. Okay, absolutely, thank you, all right, Well,
- 57:00see you later. I remember when I was having lunch with my sister
- 57:06and a friend of hers, both devoutly religious, and her friend said,
- 57:09well, can you tell me why you're no longer a Christian? This was
- 57:14years ago, before i'd evolved my own thinking and I just went to Genesis,
- 57:17chapter one, verse one, and I started, Did you know there
- 57:22are two conflicting versions of the Genesis story? Did you know that the geologic
- 57:27column totally disproves the biblical claim that there was a global flood? Did you
- 57:31know that there are four conflicting versions of the empty tomb story with Jesus,
- 57:37and that the Nativity story changes from book to book between Matthew and Luke.
- 57:42Did you know that the Jesus went to different places? After the sermon on
- 57:45the mountain, I was throwing all the data points, and you should have
- 57:50seen her face. She just glazed over and finally interrupted me, no,
- 57:54no, no, I ask you why you are no longer a Christian?
- 57:58Right? She wasn't hearing the data points. In fact, she doubled down
- 58:02and bristled, and it's like her skin got thicker to resist the facts that
- 58:07I was presenting. She was operating from a different frequency. And I wish
- 58:14I had used a different tactic with her. I wish I had used more
- 58:19of an introductory methods. I went back to the Bible, and I began
- 58:24to look at it more objectively, and I had some real concerns, and
- 58:30so I've been on this journey, and you know, I've come to the
- 58:34point now where I'm I'm just not convinced, and I'm still a good person
- 58:38and I'm a pursuer of truth. You know, I'm still the same guy
- 58:43you've always known. But for my part, I don't find this convincing.
- 58:49It's not right for me anyway, and I certainly respect the freedom of someone
- 58:53else to be religious, but I also you know, I'm not an opponent
- 58:58of religion. I'm simply an opponent to have religious privilege, people telling other
- 59:01people what to think, how to behave, what to do, who to
- 59:06be. I'm an opponent of that. But if you believe in God,
- 59:09you know, I wish you a truthful journey and an honest journey, and
- 59:14whatever's true, let's do that. I mean, I would have said something
- 59:16along those lines because I think it would have done a better job of keeping
- 59:22them off the defensive. Wasn't condescending, And I don't know. That's just
- 59:28my perspective, and I may be totally totally wrong. Terry at two four
- 59:36eights, are you there? I am here, Seth. Thanks for taking
- 59:39my call. Lo you are with us always, Terry, what's on your
- 59:44mind, Lo, I am with you. Well, you know, a
- 59:47week or so ago, I was watching some clips on the internet and I
- 59:52saw this guy named Sean McDowell. I don't know if you know of him.
- 59:55He's an apologist from Biola Universe, and he he was at a Christian
- 1:00:02university pretending to be an atheist and taking questions from the crowd. He didn't
- 1:00:08speak very long before he started digging questions and was actually had some good responses
- 1:00:15to the student's questions, and then admitted that he was not an atheist but
- 1:00:22was an apologist to a professor at Biola University. And if you've ever heard
- 1:00:28of him, and if you've ever seen his clips or wanted to debate him
- 1:00:32or anything like that, I've heard of Josh McDowell. I'm suspicious this may
- 1:00:37be Josh's son. A lot of these things are dynasties. It's almost like
- 1:00:43Jerry Folwell Junior and Franklin Graham, the son of Billy Graham. That would
- 1:00:47be my suspicion. More interestingly, i've heard you go out and you talk
- 1:00:53to either Christians or atheists under if not false pretenses. Is it's more of
- 1:01:00a lab experiment trying to expose how the atheists think and to somehow prove the
- 1:01:07facts of Christianity. I'm not too impressed by that kind of stuff. When
- 1:01:10you saw him playing the atheist that he sounded like the rest of us.
- 1:01:16He had a lot of the same points to make. But one of his
- 1:01:21that I thought was a little strange was when he was talking about whether the
- 1:01:25universe always existed or whether it had a beginning, and he went down the
- 1:01:30path of a multiverse and use that to justify that is why he thought that
- 1:01:37the universe always existed. It just seemed like a very odd tact to try
- 1:01:44to take, and that's why I started to question it at first. And
- 1:01:45then when he said he was an apologist, then it kind of all came
- 1:01:50together for me. But he was making some good points at a student's questions.
- 1:01:53It's funny, I'm not a cosmologist. Does a multiverse require that the
- 1:02:00universe had no beginning? I don't. I think that is maybe a non
- 1:02:05sequitor. I don't know. That doesn't really ring for me. I do
- 1:02:09hear the how did it all start? Or One of my favorites is when
- 1:02:14I'm talking about how the Genesis origin story for all of you know, the
- 1:02:21universe is totally unproven. In fact, it's been debunked. And they say,
- 1:02:24well, something started all of this, And I just look at him
- 1:02:30in the iron and say, ombous you and I agree, right, something
- 1:02:34happened. I mean, I think that's pretty basic, don't you. Yeah,
- 1:02:37I think I think so too, you know, And maybe a few
- 1:02:39of them should read Lawrence Cross's book Something from Nothing. I'm interested in the
- 1:02:45singularity, in measuring the universe as it expands, and then it's supposed to
- 1:02:50one day start contracting. And I read earlier that the Milky Way is going
- 1:02:54to collide with another galaxy in a certain measure of time, not in our
- 1:03:00lifetimes, not even in the immediate future, like millions of years. But
- 1:03:04they're saying that our galaxy is going to smash into another galaxy, and won't
- 1:03:07that be fun? All this is really really interesting. But beyond that,
- 1:03:13when someone says I'm a believer, but I'm either acting like an atheist or
- 1:03:16I'm representing the atheist or whatever, almost always they totally get it wrong.
- 1:03:22A great example is when they talk about the origins of the universe. Atheism
- 1:03:25doesn't make a claim about how the universe began. Atheism is simply a lack
- 1:03:31of belief in God. I am not convinced. I do not believe in
- 1:03:35a God. It doesn't say anything necessarily about anything else. And so the
- 1:03:38fact that he's walking in with questions about the origins of all things that,
- 1:03:44to me is not something that an atheist would necessarily lead with. Yes,
- 1:03:49as soon as he made the announcement that he was an apologist, I knew
- 1:03:52he was going to start going into his explanations of his playing an atheist response,
- 1:03:57and I just kind of hit stop. It just sounds like it sounds
- 1:04:00like he went to straw Man City, right. He just sets things up,
- 1:04:05and he misrepresents what's being unconvinced in God claims is, knocks him over,
- 1:04:12pats himself on the back, and then goes and makes a YouTube video
- 1:04:15about it. And this is a common apologist tactic out there. But you
- 1:04:18know, beyond all of that, the questions and answers, why would God
- 1:04:23entrust this guy Sean McDowell, Why wouldn't God come down and talk to the
- 1:04:27college students one on one? I don't get that exactly. That would have
- 1:04:32been a hell of a speech if that way, I'd be there for the
- 1:04:36tickets for that. Right, I'm an atheist. And if if Jesus olah
- 1:04:41thor Wotan whoever he wants to come down and be a god and I want
- 1:04:45to have that conversation, I'll buy. Right, I'll take you to cough.
- 1:04:49Let's do that. And that's one thing that many believers don't allow that
- 1:04:54atheists really do want is truth. And if there is a God, I
- 1:05:00would want to know that. And then the next questions are are you a
- 1:05:02good God, a bad God, a worthy God, a God worth following?
- 1:05:06You know, There's a whole other series of questions that come after that.
- 1:05:10But that's another example of the apologists doing apologetics things. Terry, thanks
- 1:05:15so much for Colin. Be safe out there, Okay, thanks, take
- 1:05:18care, soul. All right, we'll see you later. I wrote a
- 1:05:21chapter in my latest book, Christianity made Me talk like an idiot that gets
- 1:05:27into many of the apologists, just the pathetic ways that they represents the rest
- 1:05:33of us or try to defend the indefensible. And the apologist can't agree with
- 1:05:39each other on the basic stuff. You see, you know what I'm saying,
- 1:05:44And the whole concept is God looks down and says, hey, Sean
- 1:05:49McDowell, go defend me on you too. What is that if not arrogance?
- 1:06:00That's all I got today. I hope you have a wonderful week.
- 1:06:04I'm gonna go and start kind of nibble away and tweak the speech for American
- 1:06:10Atheist Convention in Phoenix. Scrap some coffee, pet the dogs, and I
- 1:06:15will see you back here next time. Take care. Follow The Thinking Atheist
- 1:06:19on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like
- 1:06:25mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and
- 1:06:30resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our
- 1:06:34website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.