Latest / Film And Whiskey / Cinderella Man (2005) / Bulleit 95 Rye
Transcript
- 0:00In 2005, director Ron Howard and star Russell Crowe gave the
- 0:05world a feel good biopic about a Depression era boxer.
- 0:10In 2025, we try a whiskey that wants to be your number one with
- 0:15a bullet. That's a good one, dude.
- 0:19I. Like it?
- 0:21Thank you so much. That probably came out around
- 0:242005, right? I mean, we'll, we'll find out I
- 0:27guess, huh? Yeah, the film is Cinderella,
- 0:30man. The whiskey is Bullet Rye.
- 0:33And we'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:38podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:57podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:01glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:03I'm Brad G, the bulldog of Parma.
- 1:12Brad, today we are looking at the film Cinderella Man and can
- 1:16I just say as we set the stage here, I love this movie so much.
- 1:20Brad. I just freaking love this movie.
- 1:22What a great film. I feel like this is one of those
- 1:26movies that got like, lots of people have seen this movie, no
- 1:30one goes to bat for this movie. Like there is just no cultural
- 1:33footprint for this film. And I don't understand why,
- 1:36'cause it's just like to me it's just one of the best sports
- 1:40movies of this century or of any century.
- 1:42Brad Yeah. And it's weird because I, I'm
- 1:45100% with you, but it does have like a 8.1 on IMDb.
- 1:51That's like, that's a really good score.
- 1:53Maybe not quite top 150, but very close, like top 200 for
- 1:57sure. And yet I don't hear anybody
- 2:00ever talk about it. It it just doesn't do anything.
- 2:04And honestly, it's a minute ago I said what a great film.
- 2:07I'm like, I don't know if it's a great film.
- 2:09It's a great flick. Like this is a great flick, Bob.
- 2:13It is so entertaining. It is so much fun.
- 2:16It's got a little bit of overacting from everybody in the
- 2:20kind of way that makes you go like, yeah, they really liked
- 2:23pretending like they were in the Great Depression.
- 2:26That Bruce Mcgillis is just. Yeah, it's it's the best man.
- 2:32It's freaking fantastic dude. Now, OK, I think as we get into
- 2:36talking about Cinderella Man, first of all folks, welcome into
- 2:39film and whiskey. If this is your first time
- 2:41joining us, we talk about movies, we talk about whiskey.
- 2:44This season we've been going back and re watching all the
- 2:47movies from season #1 to try to get some better quality episodes
- 2:52out there into the world. We're a little over halfway
- 2:54through the season. I am highly enjoying it so far.
- 2:57Brad, this has been a lot of fun.
- 3:00I will say, like, I don't know that our opinion has changed
- 3:03about a ton of these movies. A couple of them we've come up a
- 3:06few points or down a few points, but I think what this proves is
- 3:10that we have had impeccable taste from the very beginning on
- 3:13film at whiskey. Absolutely, man, that that taste
- 3:17once given it, it's cemented in for all time.
- 3:21And honestly, dude, just going back to these movies, we had a
- 3:26heck of a season one, man. What like what a great line up
- 3:29of films. Yeah, I remember trying to like,
- 3:32I, I put these into like some sort of a randomizer 'cause I
- 3:35had a list of like what, what did we start with, like 150
- 3:38movies? Because when we started this
- 3:41podcast, ChatGPT was not a thing, 'cause now, 'cause tell
- 3:46me that if you had that exact same 250 movie list now, you
- 3:50wouldn't throw that in and be like, all right, ChatGPT, we're
- 3:54starting a podcast. What would be the most engaging
- 3:57first 32 movies to pick? No dude, we've been at this from
- 4:02the beginning. I put my blood We used Bob GPT
- 4:05to generate this list man and I. Tried though you just said like
- 4:09you use the randomizer. I did.
- 4:13Well, I mean, yes, but I I made the list and then I said put
- 4:16these in random order Internet. Yeah.
- 4:18So I tried to find like a good varied group of movies for our
- 4:21first season just in case. Like we didn't go any farther
- 4:24past that. And I'm really glad that I did
- 4:26stick a movie like Cinderella Man in here because again, this
- 4:29is not like it didn't win best picture.
- 4:31I think it was only nominated for one or two Oscars.
- 4:34But it's a crowd pleasing movie. And you have to have movies like
- 4:37that to break up sometimes the monotony of us watching like
- 4:41these high Oscari movies. Now, I will say, Brad, you've
- 4:45already mentioned that there's definitely some overacting in
- 4:48this movie. And I think that this movie is
- 4:50kind of the victim of that mid 2000s Oscar bait type movie.
- 4:56I also kind of wonder, I'm gonna talk about a movie that I don't
- 4:58think you've ever seen before, but The Walk Hard, the Dewey Cox
- 5:04story starring John C Reilly. Still have not seen it yet I I
- 5:08know that it. It's like it used to be more and
- 5:10more relevant as time goes on, you know?
- 5:12It was spoofing movies like Walk the Line, which also came out in
- 5:15O 5. And I think that now music
- 5:18biopics try so hard not to fall into like we're just remaking
- 5:23Dewey Cox, that they're trying to do different things.
- 5:26I kind of feel like this is the same like sports movies have,
- 5:30like they we haven't gotten like a Dewey Cox spoof movie, but I
- 5:34feel like now they don't want to follow this like paint by
- 5:37numbers kind of wrote thing. And I will say like it doesn't
- 5:42hit every beat you expect it to hit.
- 5:44It absolutely does. But sometimes I don't mind a
- 5:48formulaic movie. Like sometimes it's just nice to
- 5:51have a story where you can tell exactly where it's going to go
- 5:54and it still makes you feel incredible and you walk out of
- 5:57the theater like floating on air.
- 5:58And this is one of those movies. And it's also one of those
- 6:01movies where you can go to Wikipedia afterwards read about
- 6:03the life of the actual now what's what's Russell Crowe's
- 6:09name? James J Braddock, the Bulldog of
- 6:12Bergen. You can read about the actual
- 6:15James J Braddock. They pretty much nail it like
- 6:19story beat by story beat. They hit his life pretty well.
- 6:23And so to have an inspiring story that's not just created,
- 6:26that is an actual human being who live like it's nice, it
- 6:29feels good, it's inspiring, it's interesting.
- 6:33You, you get to see things that you don't really think about on
- 6:35a normal day-to-day basis. So I, I'm, I'm with you, man.
- 6:39I I really enjoyed coming back to Cinderella Man.
- 6:43Well, I think that's a great time for us to segue into our
- 6:46first segment of the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 6:49Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 6:53taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with this
- 6:56little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 6:59Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 7:02plot of the movie that he has just seen for at least the
- 7:06second time this season. Brad, have you revisited
- 7:09Cinderella Man in the interim between season 1 and now?
- 7:13No, like, like you said, I love this movie.
- 7:17I don't think about this movie. It's not something that comes up
- 7:19in my head. Unless for some reason, we're
- 7:22thinking about Renee Zellweger. And then, naturally.
- 7:25Sure. This movie pops into my.
- 7:27Head this This movie exists in one of those sub genres though
- 7:31which is like I should watch this movie more.
- 7:34Every time I see this movie I'm like I should this should be
- 7:36like a a holiday movie or something like I need to put
- 7:39this on once a year and enjoy the bulldog of Bergen once more.
- 7:45I'm trying to think, I don't know man.
- 7:46The for Boxing Day every year. The Bulldog of Bergen for
- 7:51boxing. Day there.
- 7:53There you go. That's perfect.
- 7:54All right, Brad, so you get one minute to break down the plot of
- 7:58the film Cinderella Man with full spoilers.
- 8:00Now, folks, this is a movie based on a true story which
- 8:03happened nearly 100 years ago. The movie is 20 years old.
- 8:06So if you don't want the movie spoiled for you, I mean, go
- 8:09watch it and then come back and listen to the rest of the
- 8:11episode. But we're going full spoilers
- 8:13here, Brad, so one minute on the clock and go.
- 8:17Cinderella Man is a film that follows the story of real life
- 8:21boxer James J Braddock, the Bulldog of Bergen as as we
- 8:26mentioned before, as he hits near the pinnacle of his career
- 8:31in the late 20s, has his entire career derailed by an injury on
- 8:36one hand, the Great Depression on the other, and he finds
- 8:39himself trying to scrape together a living for his
- 8:42family. Working as a longshoreman in the
- 8:44docks of New York. He eventually is given a chance
- 8:48at redemption by taking a crap fight where they just need a a
- 8:52warm body to fight a person who's on his way to the top.
- 8:56He ends up beating him, being reinstated into the the boxing
- 9:00ring, fights his way to the top, defeats Max Baer for the world
- 9:05champion and becomes champion of the world.
- 9:09I, I know that it would be anachronistic, but I kind of
- 9:11wish, I kind of wish that they played We Are the Champions at
- 9:15the end, because I, I just think that would have been incredible.
- 9:19If Tarantino made this movie, he would have done that.
- 9:22All right, Brad, I I have a lot of thoughts on the movie.
- 9:25Full disclosure Film and Whiskey Nation.
- 9:27Brad and I watched this movie almost two weeks ago thinking
- 9:30that we would get this episode recorded.
- 9:32And so now it just kind of lives in the memory in like in waves,
- 9:36you know what I mean? Like I'm just getting like vibes
- 9:38off this movie. It's kind of an abstract, like
- 9:41our avant-garde reality at this point.
- 9:45Which is kind of nice because sometimes like your immediate
- 9:48reactions could be a little like overstated.
- 9:51And now it's like I've been living with this movie in my
- 9:53head for two weeks. So whatever's still there must
- 9:55really have left an impression. And I, I think one of the things
- 9:59that I did through all the chaff, yes.
- 10:02And, and one of the things I want to talk about is Ron Howard
- 10:05comma filmmaker, which we do every time we have a Ron Howard
- 10:08movie on the podcast. And I think that it has been a
- 10:11career of ups and downs for sure.
- 10:13He's not regarded as like an auteur.
- 10:16And yet I do feel like he he typically tends to make movies
- 10:20about the same types of subjects.
- 10:22Like he very much lives in the Clint Eastwood and Steven
- 10:27Spielberg realm, where they are constantly making movies about
- 10:31competent men doing their job well.
- 10:34And I think Spielberg and Eastwood definitely have
- 10:37different intentions for what they're trying to say about
- 10:40America with those types of people.
- 10:42Ron Howard's definitely more on the Spielberg side of things.
- 10:46But I would say even more than Spielberg, Ron Howard tends to
- 10:50focus more on normal, everyday people accomplishing big things.
- 10:55Whereas Spielberg will make a movie about, like, Abraham
- 10:57Lincoln. Right?
- 10:58Like, typically Ron Howard's not that guy.
- 11:01Yeah. And I think that when I went
- 11:03back and watched it this time, a couple things.
- 11:07AI think Ron Howard is still a better film maker than he gets
- 11:09credit for. And BI was really impressed at
- 11:14how well they filmically captured the era.
- 11:19Like it didn't feel fake. And I don't know if it's just
- 11:22because we were still shooting on film in 2005 and not digital,
- 11:27but like when a Netflix movie comes out that's set in the
- 11:301930s now it just looks and feels like everyone's playing
- 11:33dress up. And this movie felt.
- 11:36It looks like an episode of Bridgerton or something.
- 11:39Yeah, dude, everything's just. Fake and overproduced, it felt
- 11:44realistically lived in and grimy and gritty, and I just really
- 11:48appreciated a movie that I didn't.
- 11:51I wasn't thinking about the set design or anything like that,
- 11:54but it was definitely an achievement in that area.
- 11:57Yeah, I mean, for me, I think about the the courtyard that
- 12:02they live in in New Jersey that like has a West Side Story, rear
- 12:09window kind of vibe, but it feels lived in and real.
- 12:13And like the scene where Zellweger is getting back home
- 12:19and the dude is there shutting off the electricity to her house
- 12:22and the little like spat that they get in where both of them
- 12:25are like incredibly desperate. They're she's trying to keep her
- 12:29kids alive. He's trying to make enough money
- 12:31to keep his kids alive. And they're at direct.
- 12:35I, I don't know, there's something about that scene that
- 12:37like the snow and the grime on the walls and the interaction
- 12:41that they have of like both of these people are in the same
- 12:45position and on the same team, and yet they're opposed to each
- 12:48other because of how desperate times are.
- 12:52And there's something about all that put together, the the
- 12:55visuals and the the way they interact with one another that
- 12:59makes it feel you feel the desperation of the era and it's
- 13:04just incredibly well done. Yeah, for sure.
- 13:08Now, I think part of that is the Thomas Newman score to this
- 13:13movie. And we just talked about Thomas
- 13:14Newman again two weeks ago in American Beauty.
- 13:17And I say all the time, every one of his soundtracks sounds
- 13:20the same, but there's like just slight little degrees of
- 13:23difference. And this, this definitely has
- 13:25more of like a Celtic 'cause he's Irish, you know.
- 13:28Yep. And, and I remember a couple
- 13:30years before this movie came out, he also did the score for a
- 13:33movie called Road to Perdition, which was Sam Mendes follow up
- 13:37to American Beauty. And that's a movie that's also
- 13:39set in the 1920s. I think that was set in Chicago,
- 13:42but following the Irish mob. And so there's a lot of
- 13:44similarities in those two soundtracks.
- 13:46But I think what the reason I wanted to talk about Ron Howard
- 13:51is that all of the pieces he's using, the cinematography, the
- 13:55set design, the way he's using the composer creates such an
- 14:00effective tone and mood for this movie.
- 14:04Where like we will talk about some of the things in the script
- 14:06that are a little hokey or things they could have tightened
- 14:08up. But he's creating such an
- 14:11environment filmically. I guess that like I, I can
- 14:16forgive a lot of what's going on in the script because the
- 14:19performances are really good and there's just this pervasive tone
- 14:24of, you said the best desperation.
- 14:25It's like people are desperate to survive in this movie.
- 14:29Then I found myself so often, like, on the verge of tears.
- 14:32Like, there's so many scenes that, like, I wasn't a full out
- 14:35cry, but it was like getting me choked up.
- 14:37Because it's just like parents trying to protect their kids, a
- 14:41guy trying to protect his family, people trying to protect
- 14:44their legacy and their reputation and their scrapping.
- 14:47And they're fighting and they don't know where the answers are
- 14:49gonna come from. And I just think that Ron
- 14:52Howard, for his part, does such a good job at capturing all of
- 14:55that. And I, I think part of it is
- 14:58like stage of life, like he was probably in his 30s when he,
- 15:03when this movie's going on, late 20s, early 30s, which happens to
- 15:06be where we're at in our life. And so I'm watching this movie
- 15:09going like, man, what would I do to keep my kids in the house and
- 15:14from having to go stay with, you know, an aunt or an uncle, Like
- 15:18how, how many shifts would I work?
- 15:20The, the scenes where she's taking off his boots because
- 15:24he's already asleep in the bed when he gets home.
- 15:26You're like, it just, it just reeks of that.
- 15:30I, I can't imagine the difficulties that they are
- 15:35facing. And, and Howard captures it all
- 15:38really, really well. And you're right, I, I think the
- 15:40performances do it. But even when you look at the
- 15:45boxing scenes, like the way the camera moves and follows Russell
- 15:51around the ring, I think does an excellent job of showcasing his
- 15:57determination and grit that has been purchased on the streets
- 16:02rather than like found in the ring.
- 16:06Yeah. And well, I spent a lot of this
- 16:08movie, I would, I would say I had to press pause around the
- 16:10halfway mark and I came back and and watch the rest of it later.
- 16:14And when I press pause, I was like, I don't think there's
- 16:18enough boxing in this boxing movie.
- 16:20Like he's he's barely been in the rent.
- 16:22Dude, I remember. A few times the.
- 16:24First time I saw this movie, I, I remember being bored by it.
- 16:27I like, I, I liked it, but I was like 15 or 16 and was like,
- 16:32yeah, that was kind of boring. I don't know.
- 16:33There wasn't enough like boxing. Well, and I think, OK, so like
- 16:38watching it now, I actually do think that that's a feature and
- 16:41not a bug of the movie. Like it's not a movie about
- 16:44boxing. Like boxing is a core component
- 16:47of the movie and it's a sports movie.
- 16:49And I'll talk about why I think it's such a great sports movie.
- 16:52But like you need all that build up to make those final couple
- 16:56fights matter. And even when they're kind of
- 16:59like breezing through some of those fights, the whole last
- 17:02half hour of this movie is the Max Baer fight.
- 17:04Like they put you in the ring literally for like 30 minutes at
- 17:08the end of the movie. It's incredible.
- 17:10It's so well edited, you don't even notice how much time that
- 17:13you spent there because they've done such a good job ramping up
- 17:16to it. And I think that that if they
- 17:19had front loaded it with the boxing stuff, it wouldn't have
- 17:23worked as well 'cause then it becomes like $1,000,000 baby,
- 17:25right? Like the reason $1,000,000 baby
- 17:27works is because it it like reverses this, it's all boxing.
- 17:31And then it's like, here's the rug pull.
- 17:33And now how do we grapple with the loss of that?
- 17:36Don't you mean this one? Don't you mean the plug pull
- 17:39Bob? The the the stool, the stool
- 17:43pull. Right.
- 17:47Yikes, Big old Yikes on $1,000,000 baby here, Brad.
- 17:51But yeah, I I think that the structure of this movie is done
- 17:55pretty well. I do think before we get into
- 17:57the performances, we should probably talk about like the
- 18:01things that didn't work, because I think that there are some
- 18:04things in the film that that just don't work for me.
- 18:07It's mostly script stuff. But I want to ask you first,
- 18:11what was the biggest detractor for you in the movie?
- 18:14I. It's got to be Renee Zellweger's
- 18:19overacting. Like everybody overacts in this
- 18:22movie. Renee Zellweger has a few
- 18:24moments where I'm like, you're nailing it.
- 18:27You're killing it. The conversation with the
- 18:29electrical guy, there's a few with between her and Russell
- 18:32Crowe. When they're at their darkest
- 18:34times, she nails it. It's when she's like happy and
- 18:37excited that I'm like, oh, like ROM com Renee Zellweger's coming
- 18:42through. And that just doesn't.
- 18:44I can't imagine ROM com Renee Zellweger in the 1930s
- 18:50Depression era. It's just doesn't vibe for me.
- 18:53Yeah, it's funny because I think the scenes where she's actually
- 18:56required to have, like, deep, real emotion, she she does nail.
- 19:00Yeah. Like the scene where she tells
- 19:01her kids, like, I've got to go outside for a minute and she
- 19:03just goes and like, weeps like, oh, it's so good.
- 19:06It's so heartbreaking. My wife has never been through
- 19:09what what she had been through in the Great Depression.
- 19:12I've seen my wife take a minute to go outside and cry.
- 19:15Yeah, man. For real, dude.
- 19:19And it's the scene for me, it's like the very early scene after
- 19:22he wins the fight. And they're trying to establish
- 19:24like the husband and wife rapport in the script.
- 19:28And so they're like, let's go sit outside and, and I'm going
- 19:31to be seductive and tell you what a great man you are and how
- 19:34how proud I am of you. And it's like, I don't need her
- 19:38to say all this out loud, to know that she supports her
- 19:40husband and loves him 'cause it just makes her like a tool of
- 19:44the script and a tool of the plot.
- 19:47And to have her, like, cradling his face 18 times in this movie
- 19:51and being like, you're the most important thing, you're doing so
- 19:54much for our family. It's like, it's just a little
- 19:57overkill. Yeah.
- 19:58And I don't really blame her for that.
- 20:00I blame the script for that. Yeah, and and this is like a
- 20:03perfect example of show don't tell.
- 20:05And and even there she could just look him dead in the eyes,
- 20:09give her a full 3 seconds of looking on him with like
- 20:13admiration and love. And then just a really quiet,
- 20:17I'm proud of you kiss him on the forehead.
- 20:19Done. It works like she, she still
- 20:22says the line. You're still telling some, but
- 20:25you get all of that without all this extra stuff that makes it.
- 20:30I think the big problem, Bob, is that it makes it feel unreal
- 20:33because I don't know any couple that interacts like that in
- 20:39private or in public. Like, it's just kind of a weird
- 20:42vibe, which makes it feel like she's just there to prop him up.
- 20:48And I think the rest of the script does such a great job of
- 20:51setting her up as her own independent, like, strong
- 20:54married woman who's pulling wood off of signs with her children
- 21:00to keep them warm in the winter. Like, she's a strong character,
- 21:03but it's moments like that that make it feel like she's just
- 21:06there to prop him up, which, yeah, she's clearly not, but.
- 21:11But she also is. Based on how the script.
- 21:13Got written now The funny thing is like the most egregious
- 21:17example of that is the scene where she calls him the bulldog
- 21:21of Bergen at the end of the movie because like they build it
- 21:24up that she's like, I'm not coming.
- 21:26I'm never going to come watch you fight, you know, so you know
- 21:29she's going to come, right? But then she like literally begs
- 21:32him, don't take this fight. And then they cut to him being
- 21:35like, see you later. I'm going to go take the fight.
- 21:37Like he's getting in a car and the script does not interrogate
- 21:42him at all for this decision. Like he's just like this stoic,
- 21:45like I'm a man, so I have to do it.
- 21:48And he goes and does it, which is a, a horrible thing to do
- 21:51'cause his wife is like, please, I don't want you to die.
- 21:53And he's like, dad, what fellas got to do what a fella's got to
- 21:56do? So he goes off to fight.
- 21:59And then lo and behold, she shows up in the in the locker
- 22:02room right before the fight and she gives this speech.
- 22:05That is the most unrealistic speech I have ever heard anybody
- 22:08give. And yet because of the heavy
- 22:12lifting that they've done throughout this movie to
- 22:15establish the stakes for everyone involved.
- 22:18When she looks at him and starts choking up and says, you're the
- 22:22bulldog of Bergen. And then she's like, and the
- 22:24champion of my heart. I'm like, I hate that line.
- 22:28And I'm still crying like I'm I'm 100% bought in on this.
- 22:32Do you? Do you want to know why, Bob?
- 22:34Because you want to be the champion of a woman's heart,
- 22:38that's why. Specifically, 1930s New Jersey
- 22:42Renee Zellweger. That's that's the ideal.
- 22:46Yo Bob Book. That bulldog of I love how every
- 22:51time we go dog gets more and more like mob boss Duh bulldog
- 22:57of burg. It's like it's almost turning
- 22:58into duh, bears. Like, duh, bears.
- 23:02Well, you're saying earlier that he gets in the cab.
- 23:04I'm like, I wish that instead of getting in the cab to go there,
- 23:07he gets in the cab. It fades and then it's like 20
- 23:10years later and him and her sitting in a car and he's he's
- 23:13looking at, he goes, I could have been a contender.
- 23:18And seen. Yeah, maybe that's the SNL
- 23:23version, who knows. Let's talk performances real
- 23:26quick before we go to break, Brad.
- 23:28So I do think top to bottom, the performances are pretty good and
- 23:32like the the issues that I have with them are all script
- 23:38related, dialogue related, right?
- 23:39So, you know, Russell Crowe's doing his version of a New
- 23:42Jersey guy and Renee Zellweger's doing her version of a New
- 23:45Jersey gal. The only person that seems like
- 23:48they actually feel like lived in is Paul Giamatti.
- 23:52Giamatti does get an Oscar nomination for this movie.
- 23:56I, I, it may have been the movie's only Oscar nomination.
- 23:58If not, it was like one of two. It's totally deserved.
- 24:03And he's coming off of Sideways, which was his big breakout
- 24:06starring role. He's kind of like riding high.
- 24:09We'll talk a bit about how this movie's Oscar chances got
- 24:12torpedoed by Russell Crowe. But Giamatti even revisiting
- 24:16this, it's like, This is why The Holdovers is such a perfect.
- 24:22Like, you can only get Paul Giamatti for that because I've
- 24:25already seen him do this tightrope walk of comedy,
- 24:30tragedy, outsized figure who is using his, you know, braggadocio
- 24:37as a way of covering for some real insecurity.
- 24:40And I just think he absolutely ties the whole movie together.
- 24:44Dude, when When he invites Renee Zellweger into their apartment
- 24:49and it's just completely barren. Like it, it kind of reminds me
- 24:53of charade when when Audrey Hepburn gets into her apartment
- 24:56and it's all gone and she's like, what the heck happened
- 25:00here? And and Renee walks in and just
- 25:02his matter of factness about like, well, I was trying to hide
- 25:07it, but here we are. Would you like some tea?
- 25:09And you're just like, I freaking love Paul Giamatti in this when
- 25:15he when he freaks out over Russell Crowe eating on an empty
- 25:18stomach. Which, by the way, the sound
- 25:20effect, Russell Crowe's empty stomach is the most overproduced
- 25:25sound effect in Hollywood history, and I love it.
- 25:29And his reaction is just like, what in the hell was that?
- 25:32Which, honestly, if I heard that sound coming out of a man's
- 25:36stomach, I would freak out, man. Just like, oh, this man has
- 25:40dysentery on the Oregon Trail. Like rough.
- 25:44But dude, I I'm going to go back to Russell Crowe for a second.
- 25:47I actually really liked Russell Crowe in this.
- 25:50I think he's like too. I think this is one of his
- 25:52better performances a because somehow he had to have like tape
- 25:57behind his ears to make them like more Irish looking and that
- 26:01had to be annoying and he still just nails it and.
- 26:06B That might have been the most racist thing you've said in the
- 26:08history of our podcast. I I don't know what to is that a
- 26:11fact or you just guessing that that's what Irish ears look
- 26:14like? I I'm Irish, it's OK.
- 26:18Brad, please answer my question. The other element of Crow's
- 26:24performance is so we'll use the the word of the day is desperate
- 26:30and that like it's the moment that he is looking at the at the
- 26:34bowl of hash, like bouncing, like I got a freaking heat and
- 26:38he just shoves his face in and starts eating.
- 26:42It's incredible. Like I feel every ounce of
- 26:45desperation he has in his soul in that moment.
- 26:48I I think Crow is just really, really good in this movie.
- 26:53I don't I don't care if the accent is not like accurate to
- 26:57New Jersey, like he's he's trying something.
- 27:00Whatever set that aside. I think he's better in this
- 27:03movie than he is in Gladiator, which won him an Oscar.
- 27:06And he's he's doing the like stoic man fighting in the ring
- 27:10for people's enjoyment thing again here.
- 27:12But Gladiator that is not a real person.
- 27:16Like, that's a man who is consumed by revenge and shows no
- 27:20emotion. And here he's a man who is like
- 27:22overcome with emotion all the time and has to be made low and
- 27:26reduced to nothing repeatedly. Like when he has when he goes to
- 27:31the boxing Commission with his hat in his hand to like get
- 27:34changed from them. It's it might be my favorite
- 27:37moment of both him and Giamatti in the movie because he's he's
- 27:42like crying. He's like choking back a SOB.
- 27:44And Giamatti does that voice crack when he's like, what in
- 27:48the hell do you have to be sorry about?
- 27:50And it's just like it. It's to watch a person get
- 27:54embarrassed like that and to understand that, like, this is
- 27:58not a unique situation to him. This is what it was like in the
- 28:01Great Depression for everybody. And that's why everybody liked
- 28:04this guy, because he had to go through exactly what we've all
- 28:08been through. I think Crow captures that
- 28:11perfectly, dude. It might be my favorite
- 28:12performance of his, honestly. And it's what makes it's moments
- 28:16like that that take him paying back his money to the government
- 28:20not feel cheesy like the to to know the depths of embarrassment
- 28:26that he goes through to do the things that he has to do to take
- 28:29care of his family. Also like talk about schmucks
- 28:34that Paul Giamatti has to cover the rest like this room full of
- 28:39millionaires and he goes up and GMI is like how much you
- 28:44missing? And he's like, I still I'm still
- 28:46missing like $19.00. What?
- 28:49You know what, though, I do think that him getting his
- 28:52license revoked is a really important plot point.
- 28:55And it's not just like piling on like, oh, this poor guy.
- 28:59Like they don't like him because they think that he was throwing
- 29:03fights and that he's like a washed up schmuck to your point.
- 29:07And so like, they're not incentivized even when he's down
- 29:09on his luck, they're like, I'm pissed off at you because you
- 29:12have like sullied the name of our sport.
- 29:14And I think that like having that extra bit of I not only
- 29:18have to financially get my family back, but I have to fight
- 29:22my way back into the good graces of the sport that I love it.
- 29:27I think it adds A component to the movie and it doesn't make it
- 29:30so like cheesy Oscar Beatty. It actually has a driving kind
- 29:34of like mechanism to the plot. Yeah, Now I know that we talked
- 29:38about our gripes earlier, Bob, but I was just curious how you
- 29:42feel about his friend on the docks that that helps him out
- 29:47from time to time. They they go to church together.
- 29:49How how you feeling about him? Sure.
- 29:52I think the character of Mike, first of all, I, I, I am
- 29:56assuming Mike was not a real person.
- 29:59And then this is like a composite character that they
- 30:01put, you know, he's a plot device character.
- 30:05It's, it's very much like there's multiple things I hate
- 30:09about Mike. And like, I think the first part
- 30:12that I hate about him is they make him like the Forrest Gump
- 30:15character in that, like, Mike being in Jim Braddock's life
- 30:21means that Jim Braddock will encounter all these famous
- 30:24historical things that we learned about in high school
- 30:26shanty. Towns, OH.
- 30:28They call it the Hooverville, the Hooverville.
- 30:31I guess I have to go to the Hooverville now and we're all.
- 30:34The Hoover it's. Like the Leonardo DiCaprio, like
- 30:39wow, the Hooverville. Beyond that, I think that like
- 30:43if you look historically, pre World War 2, like the idea of
- 30:48socialism and communism in America was it, it had more of a
- 30:54hold on people than I think sometimes we give credit to.
- 30:57It was a small minority of people, but it was like a
- 30:59growing political party in America, especially during the
- 31:02Depression when people were super desperate.
- 31:04And so they give Mike this like he's kind of like hinting at
- 31:09communism, but they won't go all the way.
- 31:12And they just kind of say like, we need to organize, we need to
- 31:14unionize and they make Jim Braddock be like, no, like FD Rs
- 31:20got us and, and Mike's like screw FDR organize, you know,
- 31:25like take the means of production and all this kind of
- 31:28stuff. And, and I what I hate about it
- 31:31is like, I don't even care if the movie wants to say communism
- 31:36is not the way and we believe in traditional American values.
- 31:40It's that like, they never actually give the time to like,
- 31:44meeting Mike at what he's trying to say and telling us why it's
- 31:48bad. And if you're not going to do
- 31:50that, then you're just setting up this weird straw man of like,
- 31:54communism bad, America good. And like, it just becomes Rocky
- 31:584 at that point. And it's not as fun as Rocky 4,
- 32:01you know, No. Dude, Rocky 4, if nothing else,
- 32:05is a very fun movie. Which which engages with
- 32:11communism at a deeper level than Cinderella Man does.
- 32:14It does. And honestly, I I feel like a
- 32:16lot of movies from the mid 2000s struggled with this, where the
- 32:21movie itself has nothing to do with the political worlds of
- 32:252005, let's say, and yet it feels the need to comment on it.
- 32:31So it brings in these politics and you're like Batman.
- 32:36The Dark Knight doesn't need a surveillance subplot in it.
- 32:41This does not need a anti communist subplot in it.
- 32:44It just feels like a lot of movies around this time are
- 32:47great and then they have 1 little squeaky wheel that was
- 32:51like maybe just should have been cut in pre production and yet it
- 32:55made it in and they filmed a few scenes and they're like well
- 32:58we're not going to cut this this guy out completely.
- 33:01So we're just giving me a few things.
- 33:03Part of me is like, if you only had the scene with Mike, the
- 33:08only scene with him was the one at the church, and you don't
- 33:11even know who he is. He's just a random guy that
- 33:14Russell Crowe tries to, like, keep from hitting his wife in
- 33:17public. That's all you need to know
- 33:19'cause it's telling you about Russell Crowe's character.
- 33:22You don't need to know anything about him.
- 33:24So I'm like, I, I think they could have used him well, but as
- 33:27it is, he's in the movie too much.
- 33:29And in one scene he's, you know, maybe going to hit his wife and
- 33:34you get to learn more about Russell.
- 33:36In another scene, he's Communist Mike.
- 33:38And then in the other scene, he's his buddy at the bar who's
- 33:41like, hey, everybody, shut up. This is my boy.
- 33:44He's on the radio. Well, that's the thing too is
- 33:47like they give him way too much screen time to not engage with
- 33:50any of his ideas. And so the way that they say
- 33:53ideas bad are like, we're going to also make him a wife beater.
- 33:57And so you know that communism is bad because the communist in
- 34:00the movie beats his wife and and.
- 34:02He and he dies and. Dies.
- 34:06It's it's like the the scene in Mean Girls.
- 34:09If you have sex, you will get chlamydia and you will die.
- 34:12If you support the Communist Party, you will get.
- 34:15B, You will get trampled by a horse in Central Park and you
- 34:19will die. And on that note, Brad, it's
- 34:21time to drink some rye whiskey. Let's go.
- 34:24Try this Bullet Rye, man. What do you say?
- 34:26Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 34:34checking out Bullet 95 Rye, perhaps the most confusingly
- 34:40named of all whiskey names. Brad.
- 34:43It's not like a super complicated finished in this age
- 34:47double twice in this thing. It's just Bullet 95 Rye, but
- 34:51it's called 95 rye because it's the 95.5 mash bill that MGP
- 34:57popularized. But it's not 95 proof, it's only
- 35:0090 proof. It's a 90 proof whiskey that's
- 35:03called 95 rye and that really pisses me off.
- 35:06Why can't you just do it at 95 proof and then it makes way more
- 35:10sense? Yeah, yeah.
- 35:12Do it at 95 proof or like if any whiskey ever has a number in the
- 35:19name, it's the proof across the board.
- 35:23This is the only one I've ever seen that doesn't do that, so
- 35:27that. Would be like having like Rebel
- 35:29100, but the 100 refers to the fact that it's 100% corn and
- 35:34it's only 80 proof. You know what I mean like it
- 35:36just doesn't make any sense Yep aside from that, listen, I do we
- 35:41care that this is an MGP product or originated as an MGP product.
- 35:45We do not. And Brad, you know, I don't want
- 35:47to immediately jump into the the nosing on this, but Bullet has
- 35:51become a major player in American whiskey.
- 35:54I'm sure most people here have tried either Bullet Bourbon or
- 35:58Bullet Rye at some point. So we're not going to give a ton
- 36:01of background on the company itself.
- 36:03But I just took my first nosing of this Brad, and it felt so
- 36:09familiar to me. And I think it's because in the
- 36:11early days of the podcast, when we hadn't tried much rye, most
- 36:15of the brands that we were trying, unbeknownst to us at the
- 36:18time, we're sourcing MGP rye. And so I smell this now and I'm
- 36:22like, oh man, this is what rye smells like, 'cause this is how
- 36:26I got trained on drinking rye. So like, I'm gonna give some
- 36:30very familiar nosing and tasting notes probably on this rye.
- 36:35But it's because like, this is how I learned what rye smelled
- 36:39and tasted like. Yeah, absolutely there.
- 36:42There is a lot going on here that feels like everything we
- 36:46had growing up in our in our journey with whiskey.
- 36:51And I will say I'm going to spoil a little bit where I'm
- 36:53going with this. I don't know if I enjoy it
- 36:56anymore, Bob. Oh, interesting.
- 36:59All right. Well, Brad, on that note, let's
- 37:01just go ahead and dive right in. I'll let you.
- 37:03You've already come in with a hot take, so I'll let you keep
- 37:06going with your nosing notes here.
- 37:08Yeah, I mean, this is a mint bomb.
- 37:12Like it. This is maybe the mintiest thing
- 37:15I have ever smelt in tasting whiskey there.
- 37:19There is so much just like overpowering toothpasty vibe
- 37:26going on here that I don't have any other notes on the nose I
- 37:30like. This is mint toothpaste through
- 37:32and through. Yeah, I think for me it's, it
- 37:37smells a little bit young, like I almost get a yeastiness to it
- 37:40that I wasn't expecting. It's definitely covered up by
- 37:43all that dill and mint for me. I do get almost a little bit of
- 37:46like a like pine needles on this it, it tips a little bit more,
- 37:52even more herbaceous than just saying mints.
- 37:54Like it's it's almost like woodsy.
- 37:56I like it a lot, but I do think that like some of those stronger
- 38:01notes we associate with a potent rye are kind of covering up for
- 38:04the fact that this might be a younger whiskey.
- 38:07I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 just because I like the scent
- 38:10here. Yeah, I, I give it a 6 1/2 out
- 38:13of 10. It's not like horrific or
- 38:14anything. It's just very overpoweringly
- 38:17minty for me. On the palate, it is.
- 38:21This is where the youth comes through.
- 38:22Bob This tastes like a very, very young rye.
- 38:27It's very effervescent. It kind of disappears somewhat
- 38:29quickly. The a lot of the dill and mint
- 38:32toothpaste kind of stick around. I don't really get a lot of
- 38:36other notes on this. Bob It's very minty.
- 38:40The rye spice kind of comes through, but not enough for me
- 38:43to get excited about it. Man, I, I turned on this pretty
- 38:47quickly. This is a non age stated
- 38:49product. So I mean, we're supposedly we
- 38:51know what the age of the youngest in the blend here is.
- 38:55This doesn't even drink like that, Brad.
- 38:56This drinks like 2 year, one year whiskey like it is very,
- 39:01very youthful, super grainy. I'm not I'm not enjoying this
- 39:06man. I'm just going to give it a 5
- 39:07out of 10 on the pallet here. Yeah, I I gave it a 5 1/2 on the
- 39:11pallet. I am not enjoying this.
- 39:14The finish is like the same. It gets a little bit ashy near
- 39:19the end. I think the youth starts to
- 39:21overpower everything else. I'm going to drop down to a 5
- 39:25out of 10 on the finish. I think the finish comes back up
- 39:29a bit, the youthfulness dissipates a bit.
- 39:31I am left with a nice sweet note here which I would expect from
- 39:35like a $20 rye like the finish on this if I could just remove
- 39:39it from the rest of the drinking experience.
- 39:41It's right in line with like this is a $2025 rye.
- 39:44So I'm I'm not going to Ding it based on the what I disliked
- 39:48before. I'll come back up to A7 out of
- 39:5110 on the finisher. I think balance wise I'll I'll
- 39:54give it a six out of 10. I like they know what they're
- 39:58doing. This is a consistent flavour
- 40:00experience throughout. I don't enjoy it enough to give
- 40:02it a good balance score, but you know, it is what it is.
- 40:07Yeah, I'll give it a six as well here, Brad and I will say we
- 40:10were just at Bullet a a few months ago and they did
- 40:13something really cool for us. They drilled into a barrel and
- 40:16they let us drink out of the barrel.
- 40:17I believe that was a rye that they've been aging on premise
- 40:21and we came home with little samples of that.
- 40:23It's, you know, obviously it's not being sold yet so we're not
- 40:25reviewing it, but I like a lot of what Bullet produces.
- 40:29I like Bullet bourbon. I think that they're well aged
- 40:32rye. They've got a 10 year rye.
- 40:33Yep, really good stuff. Yes, this particular product is
- 40:37not doing it for me, Brad. And when I look at MSRPI, think
- 40:43now this is from back in like 21 or 22, I'm I'm seeing a $40
- 40:47MSRPI. Don't think it's quite that
- 40:49expensive anymore. It is 20. $8 State of Ohio 28.
- 40:53OK, that's way better. Yeah, I still think you can get
- 40:56better Ryze than this. You know, you could get an old
- 40:59Overholt, the 86 or the 100 proof.
- 41:02You could get the Sazerac rye or the 100 proof rye of Sazerac for
- 41:06around the same price. So when you look at it against
- 41:10it's competitors, it Dings the value for me.
- 41:13I don't think it's overpriced like it's a fairly priced
- 41:16product. It's just not the best in it's
- 41:18class. So I'm just gonna give it a six
- 41:20out of 10 on value. Yeah, I everything you said is
- 41:24accurate. You can get.
- 41:25Other really good rise for right at or a lower price, so I'm
- 41:30going to give it a 5 out of 10 on value.
- 41:32Oof. Yeah, that's taking me to just a
- 41:3431 out of 50. Brad, where are you falling on
- 41:37this one? I'm sitting at a 28 out of 50.
- 41:41Yikes, that's your lowest score in a while, man.
- 41:44Yeah, I've, we've drank a lot of good whiskey, man.
- 41:46Even considering like, you know, season 1, we're going back and
- 41:49doing a bunch of old whiskies. I've overall enjoyed a lot of
- 41:53the whiskeys we've drank this season.
- 41:56Bullet 95 isn't quite doing it for me.
- 42:00Yeah, we're coming out to just a 59 out of 100 on this one or a
- 42:0329.5 out of 50 for reference. A 35 is where we typically start
- 42:09giving our like soft or or Hardy even recommendation.
- 42:13A-40 is a no brainer. So this is not approaching that
- 42:16for me. I would not recommend this one.
- 42:18I think if you really want to try a pour of it at the bar for
- 42:215 bucks, 6 bucks you can. But even at this price point, I
- 42:25just don't think there's really anything here to write home
- 42:28about Brad. No, no, go buy.
- 42:30Go buy yourself some of the Sazerac 100 and I think you'll
- 42:34have a good time. All right, man.
- 42:37Well, let's get back to talking about a movie that fared a lot
- 42:40better in our minds than this whiskey did in Cinderella.
- 42:42Man, what do you say the. Bulldog of Birkin.
- 42:48Let's get to it. All right, everybody, That was
- 42:54Bullet 95 Rye, A not good whiskey.
- 42:58Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 43:00We like Bullet. We just don't like that
- 43:02particular expression. Yeah, I know Bullet puts out a
- 43:05lot of great product. I I've I think I've realized
- 43:09Bob, I love rye so much that I I am more picky when it comes to
- 43:15rye. Like there there's even some
- 43:18like nicer and Ryze that I'm like I've I I feel like I'm a
- 43:22little more sensitive to what I really enjoy.
- 43:24And so something on this end, I'm kind of.
- 43:28Yeah. And we kind of said this in our
- 43:29review, too, but it's like, I don't know if it's just that
- 43:31like, I had rye mapped out for me by the early ryes we drank.
- 43:36And so my, my, like, wheelhouse of what I consider good is much
- 43:41narrower than it is with bourbon.
- 43:44Yeah. So maybe it's me 100%.
- 43:46It probably is you, Bob. I'm just.
- 43:49Slow. On that note, Brad, I'm going to
- 43:51see if I can redeem myself when it comes to our game for the
- 43:54day. 2 facts and a falsehood, Brad.
- 43:57Is going to try to stump you Bob.
- 44:03And what is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 44:07and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 44:10with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 44:14which is a complete lie. Brad, I am doing just incredibly
- 44:18poorly. This I like I've it's got to be
- 44:20like a 2 to one loss to win ratio for me right now.
- 44:25Yeah, it's hard. The the reason we don't know
- 44:27peek behind the curtain. We've filmed this season over
- 44:31quite a stretch of time, out of order, and so we don't actually
- 44:35know what the record is. We will tally it up by the end
- 44:37of the year. I would probably vibe with you,
- 44:41Bob, just as we are vibing on this movie.
- 44:43I think I would vibe with you and say I think I might be
- 44:47winning. Yeah, you have really hit your
- 44:48stride this season, man, with your lying.
- 44:51You've gotten so much better at lying, Brad.
- 44:53I'm clear for your family. That's all I'm saying.
- 44:56I'm. Bob, I don't know what you're
- 44:57talking about. I'm a terrible liar.
- 44:59Not good at it at all. Hit me with your two facts and a
- 45:02falsehood, my friend. All right fact #1 The prop money
- 45:06that is used when Braddock is counting out their last few
- 45:09dollars is not actually from the early 1930's.
- 45:13The design of the dollar bill used in the film is from a later
- 45:17period as it was changed in 1938.
- 45:19Under Secretary of the Treasury Henry Morgenthau.
- 45:22June fact #2 Max Baer, whose paternal grandfather was Jewish,
- 45:29boxed with a Star of David David embroidered on his trunks, which
- 45:33is visible on Baer's red trunks throughout his fight with Jimmy
- 45:37Braddock in the final fight scene.
- 45:38Faction #3 Art Binkowski The Box, a boxer in real life who
- 45:43played the role of Corn Griffin, didn't want to be knocked down
- 45:47during the Corn Griffin versus Jimmy Braddock fight scene.
- 45:50He'd never fallen in a real fight, and he didn't want his
- 45:53opponents to think it was either even remotely a possibility.
- 45:56I love that. Do you know, you know what's
- 46:00really funny is the Korn Griffin guy.
- 46:04I when I was watching the movie, I pulled up his IMDb because I
- 46:08was like, I couldn't tell if he looked familiar.
- 46:11He just looked like a boxer. I was like, that dude is perfect
- 46:14casting and I don't because it's been like 2 weeks now.
- 46:17He'd only made one other movie and he played a boxer in that
- 46:21movie too. So it was like the range on this
- 46:24guy, Art, Art Binkowski, Binkowski, Binkowski.
- 46:29He probably. Grew up just for.
- 46:30The sake of being able to talk about art, I'm going to say that
- 46:33number 3 is true. OK.
- 46:36And I think #2 is true too. If it's not true, then you did a
- 46:40darn good job of creating a a very innocuous sounding fact.
- 46:44So I'm pretty quickly, I'm just going to circle #1 I don't have
- 46:48any reasoning for that. I think that they all sounded
- 46:51pretty plausible today, Brad. So my chances are, you know, 33%
- 46:55here. We're going to go number one.
- 46:57I'm going to lock it in. Who the hell cares?
- 46:59Final answer. Bob, 33% of the time you're
- 47:03right every time. Did I get a?
- 47:06Job, you got it all right. Oh.
- 47:11Man, all right. Are you ready for a second game,
- 47:14Bob? Sure.
- 47:15This is a surprise. This is a surprise second game,
- 47:18OK. All right, Bob, I want you to, I
- 47:20want you to get into your imagination.
- 47:21I want you to think you're a world class boxer and you're
- 47:27you've trained, you're getting ready, you are coming up and
- 47:30coming. You're ready for the big fight.
- 47:32You're going to be the world champion of the world.
- 47:34What supporting actor do you want in your corner?
- 47:39Go, I mean, I've seen Paul Giamatti like you've, it's got
- 47:42to be Paul Giamatti. But if he's off the table, what
- 47:46supporting? What about?
- 47:47A A Meredith Burgess. Nah, I don't want him.
- 47:49Morgan Freeman. Clint Eastwood.
- 47:54You know, I wouldn't want Morgan Freeman.
- 47:56I might want Samuel L Jackson. Like I want a guy in my corner
- 48:00who's just cussing out the other guy.
- 48:02Like I need a hype man and a trainer.
- 48:05So hear me out. Samuel is a great choice.
- 48:09Joe Pesci, a tiny. A tiny man.
- 48:11We've seen that in Raging Bull. That did not end well for either
- 48:15of them. I, I, I personally would think I
- 48:18would pick Joe Pesci because like Samuel Jackson cussing you
- 48:22out is terrifying. Joe Pesci cussing you out, you
- 48:26think he will actually murder you?
- 48:29Like I I would be terrified if he was cussing me out, which is
- 48:33why I want him in my corner as a boxer.
- 48:36Now this is at least the 5th boxing movie we've done on the
- 48:40podcast. So to your point, let me turn
- 48:43this back around on you. Yeah, of the of the five that I
- 48:46can think of, I guess I'm not going to count on the Waterfront
- 48:50because he doesn't actually box in that movie.
- 48:51Yeah, we've done this. We've done Creed, we've done
- 48:55Rocky 4, we've done Raging Bull. We've done $1,000,000, baby.
- 48:59I can't think of any others off the top of my head.
- 49:01Have we done the original Rocky? No, not yet, Bob, what have?
- 49:05We been doing, we got to do it soon.
- 49:07Is this a film podcast? What are we?
- 49:10What's? Well, Rocky 4 is the most
- 49:11important of the bunch as we know Brad.
- 49:13That is a given. Of course he has a beard.
- 49:16Who is the best like sidekick trainer among the five?
- 49:22Oh man, there's something about Clint Eastwood, $1,000,000 baby.
- 49:25I'm a big fan of he he he's he's, he's gruff and does what
- 49:30it takes to get get her done, man.
- 49:35The thing is, we don't really see Giamatti train him at all.
- 49:42Like, you know, that's true. He seems more like a media guy.
- 49:46Honestly, I'm a promoter. Yeah, yeah.
- 49:48He's more of a promoter. I think I'd probably go with
- 49:51Barrett. Yeah, well, no, we didn't say
- 49:54Rocky. Who trains him in Rocky 4?
- 49:57I think he I think he is trained by his own beard in that movie.
- 50:01Like he just trains himself and then and then Adrian shows up in
- 50:05the corner at one point, right? I would say it's either that or
- 50:08does his his brother-in-law who's like having sex with a
- 50:11robot. Is he?
- 50:13Oh yeah, train him. Polly's gotta be.
- 50:15Maybe it was the robot. I don't want to know what kind
- 50:19of working out they're doing. I think with those five options,
- 50:22I am locking in Clint Eastwood as my trainer.
- 50:26There you go all right, I'll take it man Brad real quick.
- 50:30You know, we don't have to say too much more about this movie
- 50:33aside from like, I I think it's a great oscari Oscar bait movie.
- 50:37Like, sure, I wish that the Oscar bait movies made today
- 50:42felt like these ones did because these were just very much like a
- 50:46throwback to classic Hollywood by the numbers.
- 50:48But I felt awesome walking out of the theater.
- 50:51I wanna talk about this as a sports movie and why I think
- 50:54it's one of the best ones. And it's because watching this
- 50:59movie, you really get a sense of why sports are a metaphor for
- 51:07like, the struggle of life and why when a good sports story
- 51:12happens, we latch onto it. I think it's just like, it
- 51:15perfectly exemplifies why people feel the need to put their hopes
- 51:21and dreams on somebody else when they're going through a
- 51:24struggle. You know, when when Jim is in
- 51:27the back of that car pulling into the the Madison Square
- 51:30Garden bowl at the end of the movie and then recognize him and
- 51:34they're cheering for him. And then as he starts fighting
- 51:37Max Baer, how quickly the crowd turns in his favor and how badly
- 51:43everybody wants this for him. It's, you know, obviously they
- 51:47want Jim to succeed. And someone says it all.
- 51:50I think the priest says it at one point, like they they see
- 51:52themselves in him. It's made very explicit.
- 51:55It's not a subtle movie. And yet it's it's so perfectly
- 51:59encapsulates why sports matter. And I couldn't help thinking
- 52:05about the 2016 NBA Finals. And I like, I tell people all
- 52:11the time, like it. It is the stupidest thing that I
- 52:14say, and it's the most sincere. It was maybe the happiest day of
- 52:19my entire life when we won that championship.
- 52:21And like, people, you know, people are like, oh, the birth
- 52:25of your children. And I'm like, listen, I love my
- 52:27children more than I love that championship.
- 52:29The instant gratification of winning a championship is
- 52:33probably the happiest I've ever felt in one moment of life,
- 52:36like. And it's because I spent that
- 52:39whole day before game seven of that finals where the city of
- 52:44Cleveland, which had a long standing history of getting
- 52:47super close and losing and being shat on by the country, was
- 52:51right back in that position again.
- 52:52And it was still the closest we'd ever gotten.
- 52:56And I drove around the city of Akron, OH, where LeBron James is
- 52:59from, and there were signs out in front of churches that were
- 53:03like, we're all in this together, win or lose.
- 53:06I drove by Lebron's high School, and they had a viewing party
- 53:08there, and there was a liner on the block.
- 53:10And I just drove past and honked at people that I don't know.
- 53:13We were all cheering. And like, I got to go spend that
- 53:17game with my dad on Father's Day.
- 53:20And we won a championship for the first time since I've been
- 53:23alive. And he was a child and it was
- 53:25like it was so immediately like validating as a person who lived
- 53:32in Cleveland that like we matter again on the national stage.
- 53:37And it's so silly if you come from like, like if you're like a
- 53:40Yankees fan and you're used to winning, you don't understand
- 53:44this. Like, yeah, that too.
- 53:46When you're when you're like from a down and out hard working
- 53:50blue collar environment, sports matter because they are so
- 53:54validating to you as a person. And I don't know how else to
- 53:58explain it beyond that man. Dude I I sat on the couch of my
- 54:03best friend's house watching it with his family and when LeBron
- 54:08sinks that free throw they go down.
- 54:10Love is guarding staff and he misses the shot.
- 54:14As time runs out I watch my best friend's dad, who's I've known
- 54:18my entire life, fall to his knees weeping and I just hear
- 54:23him as he's crying going. I never thought I would see this
- 54:28day. He was literally born like 2
- 54:30weeks after the Browns championship in 64.
- 54:34And like he never thought that in his lifetime he would see a
- 54:38Cleveland championship. And we drove around town
- 54:41afterwards. People are just out walking the
- 54:44streets of Parma honking their horns, cheering and celebrating.
- 54:49Like it it is. It was such a unifying and
- 54:52beautiful moment for the city. I I still to this day, honestly,
- 54:57as you were talking about it, I was like, oh, I can't wait.
- 55:00I don't know who they're going to get to play LeBron like 30
- 55:02years from now, but I can't wait for like the draft day.
- 55:07But like of an actual championship, not of like, oh
- 55:11wow, we had a pretty decent draft go Browns.
- 55:14Like no, like, like we actually won a championship.
- 55:17This is incredible. Yeah, man.
- 55:21All right. I couldn't get us out of here
- 55:23without linking Jim Braddock to LeBron James somehow.
- 55:25But on that note, Brad, it is time for us to get into our
- 55:28final segment of the day, which we call Let's Make it a double.
- 55:32We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 55:35the film and Whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 55:38this one, even if it's struggling.
- 55:39It's the final segment of the day.
- 55:41Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 55:43part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 55:46to make the perfect double feature.
- 55:49Brad I was going to just go ahead and pair this up with
- 55:50Seabiscuit. I think I've I've paired like 5
- 55:53movies this season with Seabiscuit.
- 55:55It seems like that needs to be on the list for sometime soon.
- 55:58But that's another movie where it's like set during the
- 56:02depression, everyone puts their hopes and dreams on this ragtag
- 56:06horse and all the people surrounding it and feel
- 56:09validated At the end of the movie.
- 56:11I I thought of maybe I could do something more clever, but I
- 56:15really can't see this gets my pairing for this movie.
- 56:17I'm. Going to do something a little
- 56:18more clever, Bob. I was, I was thinking about
- 56:21staying in the realm of sports and if I did that, I would go
- 56:24with Rudy. I'm not going to stay in the
- 56:26realm of sports. I'm going to go with 2006, The
- 56:31Pursuit of Happiness. Now, if I remember correctly,
- 56:37you said you hate that movie at one point.
- 56:39Is that still true? I don't.
- 56:39Know if I don't know if hate, I did not enjoy it the one time
- 56:43that I watched it, but I do remember that feeling of
- 56:47desperation from Will Smith that he just nails it and so that was
- 56:54the. Keeping best performance.
- 56:56Yeah, I was like, oh, I remember Will Smith just oozing like, I
- 57:00have this son, I need to take care of him.
- 57:03I'm gonna do whatever it takes. And that's what really connected
- 57:06the pieces for me with Cinderella Man.
- 57:09Now 2005 is 1 of I think the best year movie years of this
- 57:13century. The Oscar list is pretty good
- 57:16but when you get down into the non oscari movies it's even
- 57:19better. But, you know, Russell Crowe
- 57:22famously had a huge temper and had a big temper tantrum when he
- 57:26was at a hotel in, I think, New York City.
- 57:28He threw a phone at the face of the the bellman or the at the
- 57:33desk and charged for assault. It was a huge scandal.
- 57:37For for you young people, I think it was like an actual
- 57:39phone that like had a cord and everything they.
- 57:42Brought like a hefty phone. Yes, and he whipped it at them.
- 57:46Yeah. And it happened right before
- 57:49this movie came out. This movie was a pretty much a
- 57:52flop at the box office, and it tanked all of its Oscar chances
- 57:55because it was such a big scandal.
- 57:58That's when Russell Crowe gets parodied on South Park for
- 58:01fighting around the world like it was a big deal.
- 58:03And it bums me out because I would have liked to have seen
- 58:06what kind of damage this could have done in the Oscar race.
- 58:09Remember, this is the year that Crash wins.
- 58:12Brokeback Mountain is another nominee.
- 58:14You've got Philip Seymour Hoffman wins the Oscar for
- 58:20Capote. You've got Joaquin Phoenix for
- 58:22Walk the Line hanging around in this year.
- 58:24It's good night and good luck. It's just it's a really, really
- 58:28good year for movies and it bums me out that that scandal cost
- 58:34this movie from competing in some of those categories.
- 58:36Do you know what happened, Bob? What's that?
- 58:39We didn't have thick Crow. If he was thick.
- 58:43If he was thick Crow, you think he would throw that phone?
- 58:47Thick Thick Crow doesn't care. He doesn't get angry.
- 58:50I don't know man, I feel like Thick Crow probably has even
- 58:54more power behind his throat now, like, because there's just
- 58:57so much more mass. Yeah, but it's like, it's like
- 58:59Mike Tyson when he's high and like not in fighting shape, he's
- 59:02just a happy go lucky dude. You, you take him off marijuana,
- 59:07get him training and get all his testosterone going.
- 59:09He's the most terrifying human ever to live.
- 59:12So like, you know, thick Crow, just he, he doesn't care.
- 59:14What does he have to care about? He's fat and happy and you know.
- 59:18I remember when I when I first took a distillery tour, it was
- 59:21at Woodford Reserve, and they were talking about how Russell
- 59:24Crowe had picked a barrel of Woodford.
- 59:26And that was back in the days before you could just like
- 59:28anyone could get barrels. And they had like a plaque of
- 59:31everyone who'd ever done it. And it was like Russell Crowe
- 59:33was on there. And then I saw Thick Crow.
- 59:35And I was like, that looks like a guy who would pay him a whole
- 59:37barrel of whiskey. Yeah, 100%, man.
- 59:41All right, dude, let's give this movie some final scores.
- 59:44I think objectively, this is somewhere between an 8 and a
- 59:46nine. It's like an 8.5 movie that I
- 59:49just really love and is more effective on me than its score
- 59:52would indicate. So I'm going to give this a nine
- 59:54out of 10. Brad, I love this movie.
- 59:57I I'm with you man. I love this movie.
- 59:59It is super fun. The the acting is overacted just
- 1:00:04enough to make you really like laugh at certain parts, cringe
- 1:00:07at certain parts. It it's such a fun feel good
- 1:00:11movie that has some rough edges. I'm going to just a little bit
- 1:00:15lower. I'm going to give it an 8.5.
- 1:00:18All right, so we're coming out to an average of an 8.75 out of
- 1:00:2210, but we'd like to hear from you.
- 1:00:24What do you think of Cinderella, Man?
- 1:00:25When was the last time you watched this movie?
- 1:00:27You can let us know on any of our social media accounts,
- 1:00:30Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film
- 1:00:35Whiskey. Or if you want to join the
- 1:00:37conversation, we are on Discord talking all things whiskey and
- 1:00:41film, so if you want to jump into that, you can find a link
- 1:00:43to our discord at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:00:46notes. We'll be back again next week
- 1:00:49revisiting one of our Season 1 masterpieces, but until then,
- 1:00:53I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:00:56And we'll see you next time.