Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Diplomacy with Byzantium: A Forgotten Alliance
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, when we think of Saladin, we usually picture him clashing with Crusaders on the battlefield—Hattin, Arsuf, the siege of Acre. But there's a whole other dimension to his strategy that doesn't get nearly enough attention: his diplomatic outreach to the Byzantine Empire. Luna: Wait—the Byzantines? I thought they were already deeply entangled with the Crusaders. Lucas: That's the thing—they were, but not always as allies. By the late 1180s, the Byzantine emperor Isaac II Angelos had a complicated relationship with the Franj. The Crusaders had repeatedly antagonized Byzantium, from the Norman invasions under Robert Guiscard to the outright sacking of Cyprus by Richard the Lionheart later on. So when Saladin won at Hattin in 1187, he saw an opportunity. Lucas: He sent envoys to Constantinople, proposing a kind of alliance against the Crusader states. The idea was to coordinate military efforts, perhaps even a joint attack, to weaken the Franj and secure Muslim control over Jerusalem—al-Quds, as he called it. Luna: What did Isaac think of that? He must have been wary. Lucas: Very wary. But also pragmatic. Isaac II had his own grievances. The Third Crusade was essentially a Western European enterprise, and the Byzantines had been sidelined. They still claimed authority over the Holy Land, but the Latins had elbowed them out. So Isaac saw potential in Saladin's offer. Luna: So what actually happened? Did they sign a treaty? Lucas: Not a formal treaty, but there was a significant diplomatic exchange. Saladin's envoy, a certain Husam al-Din, arrived in Constantinople with rich gifts and a proposal. According to the historian Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, who was a close confidant of Saladin, Isaac agreed to a form of cooperation. He promised to restrain any Crusader forces passing through Byzantine territory and even hinted at military support. Luna: But I recall that the Byzantines eventually made peace with the Crusaders too, didn't they? Lucas: Yes, and that's the tragedy of it. The alliance never fully materialized. Isaac II was playing both sides. He received Saladin's envoys warmly, but he also maintained communications with the Crusaders. Plus, internal Byzantine politics were a mess. Isaac was overthrown by his brother Alexios III Angelos in 1195, and after that, any chance of coordinated action evaporated. Lucas: Still, the correspondence between Saladin and Isaac reveals a lot. Saladin's letters, preserved by Baha ad-Din and also by the Byzantine chronicler Niketas Choniates, show a ruler trying to frame this as a natural alliance of powers who share a common enemy. Saladin even invoked the idea of the 'Rum'—the Byzantine Romans—as ancient rivals of the Franj. Luna: I love that you bring up Niketas Choniates. He's such a vivid source. Lucas: Absolutely. Choniates wrote about this in his 'History', and he's not exactly neutral—he's critical of Isaac for being too accommodating to the Latins. But he does record that Isaac was impressed by Saladin's gifts: a golden cross, relics, and even a piece of the True Cross, which the Byzantines revered. You can imagine the political theater. Luna: Wait—Saladin had a piece of the True Cross? How did he get that? Lucas: After Hattin, the Crusaders lost the relic that they had carried into battle. It was captured by Saladin's forces. He could have destroyed it, but instead he used it as a diplomatic chip. Sending it to Constantinople was a masterstroke—it signaled respect for Christian relics while also asserting his control over the Holy Land. Lucas: And it worked, for a time. Isaac even allowed the Greek Orthodox patriarch of Jerusalem, who had been exiled by the Latins, to return to the city under Saladin's protection. That was a huge gesture. The Orthodox Christians had been second-class citizens under the Crusader Kingdom, and Saladin's alliance with Byzantium helped him present himself as a liberator of all Christians, not just a Muslim conqueror. Luna: So was this a genuine attempt at a long-term alliance, or just short-term opportunism? Lucas: Probably both. Saladin was a pragmatist. He knew the Third Crusade was coming, and he needed to isolate the Franj diplomatically. An alliance with Byzantium would have pinned the Crusaders between two fronts. But it never reached that point. The Byzantines were too internally divided, and the Crusaders, especially under Richard, were too aggressive. Lucas: There's also the role of the Melkites—the Greek Orthodox Christians in the Levant. Saladin's policy toward them was generally tolerant, especially compared to the Latins. He restored many churches, including the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, to Orthodox control. That was partly to curry favor with Constantinople. Luna: So this diplomatic dance had real consequences on the ground for ordinary Christians. Lucas: Exactly. The ordinary Greek Orthodox Christians in Jerusalem saw a shift in their status. Under the Crusaders, they had been barred from the Holy Sepulchre. Saladin opened it to them again. That wasn't just theology—it was politics. He was sending a message to Byzantium: 'We can work together. The Franj are the common enemy.' Lucas: But ultimately, the alliance fizzled. When Richard the Lionheart arrived, he quickly made his own deal with Isaac—the Treaty of Messina in 1190—neutralizing any Byzantine threat. And after Isaac's deposition, the new emperor Alexios III was more pro-Latin. By 1192, Saladin had to negotiate directly with Richard, and the Byzantine card was off the table. Luna: So it's a story of what might have been—a Muslim-Byzantine coalition that could have reshaped the Crusades. Lucas: Exactly. It's one of history's fascinating 'what ifs'. Had Isaac stayed on the throne and coordinated with Saladin, the Third Crusade might have ended very differently. Instead, Richard secured the coast, and Saladin kept Jerusalem. The Byzantine alliance was a missed opportunity that tells us a lot about the intricate politics of the era. Luna: And it shows that Saladin wasn't just a warrior—he was a diplomat playing a much larger game. Lucas: Absolutely. He understood that military victory alone wasn't enough. You need allies, you need soft power, you need to manage perceptions. His outreach to Constantinople was a strategic vision that almost paid off.