Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Forensic Psychology Careers: Behavioral Health Jobs in Criminal Justice
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine showing up to a job every single day
- 0:02where your ability to feel deep empathy for other
- 0:05people is actually your greatest asset. It is
- 0:08the core tool you use to save lives, to seek
- 0:11justice, and to heal broken minds. But what if
- 0:14that exact same empathy is the very thing that
- 0:17is slowly, quietly destroying your own psychological
- 0:21well -being? Welcome to the Psychology undergrad.
- 0:24Yeah, welcome. I'm so excited for this study
- 0:26session. And hey, if you are listening right
- 0:29now, just consider yourself the third student
- 0:31in our study group. We are skipping the dry lecture
- 0:33hall today to really get into the weeds of how
- 0:36the human mind operates under some of most extreme
- 0:39pressures imaginable. It is a super heavy topic
- 0:42today, honestly. We are unpacking chapter 10,
- 0:44which explores this massive chaotic intersection
- 0:47where the behavioral health field just crashes
- 0:49headfirst into the criminal justice system. Go
- 0:51away. law enforcement, the courts, corrections,
- 0:54mental health facilities. And the reality is
- 0:57these systems do not run on gears and oil. They
- 1:00run on people. The psychology of those professionals
- 1:03completely dictates how our entire society functions
- 1:06on its worst days. So whether you are trying
- 1:09to figure out what major to declare or mapping
- 1:12out a future career or, I mean, you are just
- 1:15insanely curious about how we as a society handle
- 1:18human crisis, we are going to lay this whole
- 1:21web out for you. let's start right where the
- 1:23CEPHEM starts. With front lines. Exactly. Before
- 1:25anyone ever sees the inside of a courtroom or
- 1:28a psychiatric ward, they usually encounter a
- 1:30first responder on the street. Right, the initial
- 1:32point of contact. And traditionally, that almost
- 1:35always means law enforcement. So local police
- 1:38officers, sheriff's deputies, or even federal
- 1:40agents like the FBI. Yeah. To understand the
- 1:43psychology of this system, you really have to
- 1:44look at their day -to -day reality. I mean, they
- 1:47are juggling traffic stops, investigating crimes,
- 1:49doing just a mountain of paperwork. And increasingly,
- 1:52they are the primary responders to acute psychological
- 1:55crises. Which honestly makes the demographics
- 1:58of who's actually doing this job so crucial to
- 2:00think about. When we look at the data, who is
- 2:03stepping into these incredibly delicate mental
- 2:05health situations? The breakdown is heavily skewed.
- 2:08Over 80 % of police officers are male. Women
- 2:12make up only about 16 % of the force. Wow. Yeah.
- 2:15And racially, about 18 % are Latinx, 13 % are
- 2:18black, and only 7 % identify as LGBTQIA+. So
- 2:24you have a primarily... male, heavily armed workforce
- 2:28stepping into communities to handle individuals
- 2:31experiencing severe mental disorders. Right.
- 2:34And that brings up a profound moral tension.
- 2:36You have the individual moral burden placed on
- 2:39that officer who is carrying a lethal weapon
- 2:42into a highly distressed, unpredictable environment.
- 2:45Then you contrast that with society's broader
- 2:48moral obligation, which is to respond to illness
- 2:50with care and treatment rather than with force.
- 2:53We have basically treated crisis response like
- 2:55a Swiss Army knife. But for decades, society
- 2:58only ever pulled out the hammer. Oh, that's a
- 3:00good way to put it. Right. Like someone is having
- 3:02a mental health breakdown on a street corner.
- 3:05Call the armed police. A teenager is dealing
- 3:08with a severe substance abuse issue. Send the
- 3:11hammer. Now, we are finally realizing that maybe
- 3:14we need to... pull out the tweezers or the magnifying
- 3:18glass, depending on the situation. And that realization
- 3:21is driving a huge movement toward alternative
- 3:23responders. We are seeing models pop up where
- 3:26specialized units actually replace police for
- 3:29non -criminal mental health crises. Thank goodness.
- 3:32Yeah, some fire departments are even bringing
- 3:33sociologists and psychologists directly onto
- 3:36their response teams. I love the independent
- 3:38models, too, like the CAHOOTS program in Eugene,
- 3:41Oregon. I know. Yeah, they're great. They operate
- 3:43completely outside of the police and fire departments.
- 3:46If someone is pacing a bus stop, talking to themselves,
- 3:49and clearly in distress, but not committing a
- 3:51crime, Kahoot! sends a medic and a crisis worker.
- 3:54Right. They show up in a van with water, blankets,
- 3:57and de -escalation skills rather than handcuffs
- 3:59and a badge. Which makes so much more sense.
- 4:02But deciding who gets dispatched, you know, the
- 4:04hammer or the tweezers, falls on another crucial
- 4:07group. The 911 dispatchers. Yes. They are the
- 4:10true first responders. Over a crackling phone
- 4:13line, they have to make rapid fire psychological
- 4:16assessments just trying to figure out the exact
- 4:18nature of the crisis from a panicked caller.
- 4:21It's intense. OK, so let's follow a case through
- 4:23the system. Say the street interaction does end
- 4:26in an arrest. That person gets pulled out of
- 4:29the immediate chaos of the neighborhood and dropped
- 4:31right into the highly structured formal world
- 4:35of the legal system. The scales of justice. The
- 4:38psychological environment here shifts entirely
- 4:41because it is defined by an adversarial setup,
- 4:44two sides battling it out. On one side, you have
- 4:47prosecutors representing the government deciding
- 4:50what charges to file. On the other, you have
- 4:52criminal defense attorneys. Like public defenders
- 4:54or private lawyers. Exactly, whose entire job
- 4:57is to advocate for the accused. Just like with
- 4:59law enforcement, the demographics here are jarring.
- 5:02When you look across both prosecutors and defense
- 5:04attorneys, roughly 75 % are white, only about
- 5:075 % are black. And when you factor in that black
- 5:10people make up about 12 % of the overall US population,
- 5:15you start to see a significant disconnect. And
- 5:18that disconnect becomes even more pronounced
- 5:20when you look at the judges who preside over
- 5:23these adversarial battles. If we look at the
- 5:25ultimate authority on legal protections, the
- 5:29U .S. Supreme Court, the historical lack of representation
- 5:32is staggering. Out of the 116 people who have
- 5:36been appointed to that court historically, only
- 5:38eight. We're not white men. Only eight. Yeah,
- 5:41we are just now seeing certain milestones. Like
- 5:43Sonia Sotomayor becoming the first Latina justice.
- 5:46And notably, the only justice with a reported
- 5:49disability, type 1 diabetes. We also just recently
- 5:52saw Katanji Brown Jackson appointed as the first
- 5:54black woman on the court. OK, let me push back
- 5:56on this a little bit, or at least like play devil's
- 5:59advocate for our study session. Yeah, go for
- 6:00it. From a strictly psychological standpoint.
- 6:03How does a lack of diversity actually impact
- 6:06the moral fairness of the justice system? I mean,
- 6:09a law is a lot, right? But if the system completely
- 6:12lacks the lived experience of the populations,
- 6:15that it is actively judging and processing, doesn't
- 6:18it naturally suffer from a massive empathy deficit?
- 6:21That's a huge question. Right. Like, how can
- 6:24a judge be morally objective if they have no
- 6:27conceptual framework for the life of the person
- 6:29standing in front of them? Well, this is a debate
- 6:31The field of psychology studies very closely.
- 6:34Looking at it purely from an objective standpoint,
- 6:37based on the data we have, efforts to increase
- 6:39gender and racial diversity at higher legal levels
- 6:42offer the promise of increased fairness. The
- 6:45psychological consensus is that representation
- 6:48introduces varied lived experiences into legal
- 6:51interpretations. It theoretically broadens the
- 6:54system's capacity for contextual understanding.
- 6:57You aren't changing the law, but you are expanding
- 6:59the psychological lens through which the law
- 7:01is applied. That makes total sense. You just
- 7:03have more perspectives in the room. And I know
- 7:06there are alternative roles trying to help bridge
- 7:08that gap for everyday people who can't afford
- 7:11a massive legal team. Like paralegals? Yes. Oregon
- 7:15is actually pioneering a program to license paralegals
- 7:18for limited independent representation. Think
- 7:21of it kind of like a nurse practitioner in medicine.
- 7:24They can't do everything a doctor does, but they
- 7:26can handle specific cases, making legal help
- 7:28more accessible, even though it isn't applied
- 7:30to criminal law just yet. Access is a huge part
- 7:33of the puzzle. Now, what happens after the gavel
- 7:36falls? A judge hands down a sentence and we move
- 7:39further inside the machine. who is practically
- 7:42and morally responsible for taking care of these
- 7:45individuals. That brings us to corrections. You
- 7:48have correctional officers or COs who are overseeing
- 7:50safety inside prisons and jails, and this is
- 7:52way more complex than just locking doors and
- 7:55walking cell blocks. They have to pass intense
- 7:57psychological screenings just to get hired, and
- 7:59they require highly specific training to identify
- 8:02self -harm and suicide risks among inmates. Because
- 8:05legally, The state has taken away that person's
- 8:08freedom, which means the state is now entirely
- 8:10responsible for their physical and psychological
- 8:12care. Right. But the reality that often surprises
- 8:15people is that the vast majority of correctional
- 8:19supervision actually happens outside the prison
- 8:21walls, right, in the community. Yes. I actually
- 8:24use a mental shortcut for community supervision
- 8:27to keep it all straight. I call it the three
- 8:29P's. Oh, I love a good mnemonic. Let's hear it.
- 8:32OK. First, you have probation, which is supervision
- 8:35instead of going to prison. You stay in the community
- 8:37but have strict rules. Second is parole, which
- 8:41is post -prison. You served your time, you are
- 8:43out, but you are still being supervised. Got
- 8:46it. And the third is pretrial services. That
- 8:49is supervision while someone is out of custody,
- 8:52living at home, pending their actual trial. Probation,
- 8:55parole, pretrial. That is a perfect way to conceptualize
- 8:58it. And within those community systems, you have
- 9:00case managers. sometimes called correctional
- 9:02treatment specialists. They aren't guards. They're
- 9:05doing psychological and risk evaluations to create
- 9:08release plans. They figure out how to connect
- 9:11someone with education or substance use treatment
- 9:13so they don't re -offend. But we also have to
- 9:15look at the other side of the courtroom. What
- 9:17about the people who are harmed? The victim advocates.
- 9:20It is fascinating that nearly 90 % of victim
- 9:23advocates are women. That is a wild stat. Isn't
- 9:26it? Their entire job is to help victims navigate
- 9:30this sprawling, confusing legal system while
- 9:33simultaneously helping them cope with the acute
- 9:35trauma of the crime itself. And this role holds
- 9:38one of the most complex moral tensions in the
- 9:41entire system. Oh, for sure. On one hand, the
- 9:43advocate is deeply focused on the spiritual and
- 9:46psychological healing of a traumatized human
- 9:48being. They want to protect them from further
- 9:50harm. On the other hand, the advocate is often
- 9:53working for the government or the prosecutor's
- 9:55office, which has a very clinical, practical
- 9:57need to use that victim as a witness to secure
- 10:00a conviction. Wow. So you are constantly balancing
- 10:03the human need for healing against the state's
- 10:06need for a functional witness. That is an incredible
- 10:09psychological tightrope. It really is. Which
- 10:12brings us to the professionals whose primary,
- 10:15explicit job is the healing itself. Moving away
- 10:19from the punitive side, let's look at the behavioral
- 10:22health and medical careers embedded in this system.
- 10:25This world is heavily defined by a massive alphabet
- 10:28soup of certifications. So many acronyms. So
- 10:31many. Let's use Oregon as our baseline example
- 10:34from the text. You have the QMHA, the Qualified
- 10:37Mental Health Associate. You can get this without
- 10:40a bachelor's degree. And in the real world, this
- 10:42might look like doing skills training or helping
- 10:44a client learn to manage their daily schedule.
- 10:46Right. Then you have the QMHP, the Qualified
- 10:49Mental Health Professional. That requires a bachelor's
- 10:51and graduate work, and they are the ones usually
- 10:53doing the deep or therapeutic interventions.
- 10:56And for substance use, there is the Key DC, the
- 10:58Certified Alcohol and Drug Counselor. That is
- 11:01split into levels one, two, and three based entirely
- 11:04on education. Level one, I might just require
- 11:06some basic coursework while level three requires
- 11:08a full graduate degree. But I think the most
- 11:11fascinating role in this entire web is the peer
- 11:13support special. Oh, absolutely. These are professionals
- 11:16who bring their own actual lived experience with
- 11:19mental health or substance use recovery to the
- 11:22table. Groups like NAMI, the National Alliance
- 11:25on Mental Illness, provide specialized peer training
- 11:28with a massive focus on trauma -informed care
- 11:31and cultural humility. Their value cannot be
- 11:34overstated. A peer support specialist can sit
- 11:37across from someone in crisis and say, I have
- 11:39been exactly where you are in a way that a clinician
- 11:42with a textbook simply cannot. They build trust
- 11:45incredibly fast. Yeah, it's that shared lived
- 11:47experience. Right. Beyond peers, you also have
- 11:51master's level mental health counselors and social
- 11:53workers providing therapy, advocacy, and intensive
- 11:57case management. Then you step up to the doctoral
- 11:59level with psychologists, and it is really important
- 12:02to distinguish how they operate in this legal
- 12:04space. You have clinical psychologists who are
- 12:07focused on diagnosis and ongoing treatment for
- 12:09the individual. Right, the traditional role.
- 12:11Exactly. But then you have forensic psychologists.
- 12:13They are the ones working directly with the lawyers
- 12:15and the courts. They do the heavy assessments,
- 12:18like figuring out if a defendant is legally competent
- 12:21to stand trial or evaluating an insanity defense.
- 12:25To round out the healers, we have the medical
- 12:27careers, psychiatrists who are medical doctors,
- 12:30and PMHNPs, which are psychiatric mental health
- 12:33nurse practitioners. Think of the difference
- 12:35between these healers like this. Psychologists
- 12:38and counselors wear the talking and testing tool
- 12:41belt. They do the deep dive therapy, the behavioral
- 12:44assessments, the long conversations. Okay, I
- 12:46like that analogy. And psychiatrists and PMHMPs
- 12:49carry the prescription pad. While they certainly
- 12:52understand therapy, their primary function in
- 12:55this system is prescribing and managing psychiatric
- 12:57medications, like antipsychotics or mood stabilizers.
- 13:01And that medication management is absolutely
- 13:04vital, especially in overcrowded correctional
- 13:06environments where stabilizing an acute episode
- 13:09can be a matter of life and death. Very true.
- 13:11Now, we have mapped out the entire cast of characters.
- 13:15The cops, the lawyers, the CEOs, the advocates,
- 13:18the doctors. Let's pivot to the core psychology
- 13:21of this chapter. What happens to the human brain
- 13:23when you wake up and do these jobs every single
- 13:26day? Let's start with the things that keep people
- 13:27coming back, the psychological rewards. The text
- 13:30outlines compassion satisfaction. Oh, right.
- 13:34This is that profound, hard -earned emotional
- 13:37reward you get from genuinely helping someone
- 13:40else survive a terrible day. There is also vicarious
- 13:43resilience. This is the empowering, deeply moving
- 13:47feeling of watching someone else successfully
- 13:49overcome immense adversity. Seeing someone rebuild
- 13:52their life gives the professional hope. of that
- 13:56work is severe. Trauma is the currency of these
- 13:58systems. And we have to make a very clear distinction
- 14:00between direct trauma and indirect trauma. Direct
- 14:03trauma is exactly what it sounds like. An event
- 14:05that happens to you or violence that you witnessed
- 14:07firsthand, this can easily result in PTSD. The
- 14:10statistics on that are grim. Up to 19 % of police
- 14:13officers and up to 25 % of correctional officers
- 14:16experience indications of PTSD. What's really
- 14:19concerning about those numbers is the behavioral
- 14:21link. The data points out that officers conducted
- 14:24abusive behavior actually correlates with higher
- 14:27officer PTSD. It creates a terrifying vicious
- 14:30cycle. An officer experiences trauma, it goes
- 14:33untreated, they become hyper reactive or violent,
- 14:36which creates more trauma for the community they
- 14:38are policing and just deepens their own psychological
- 14:41wounds. Exactly. But the more insidious threat
- 14:44for many of these professionals is indirect trauma.
- 14:47These are terms people use interchangeably all
- 14:50the time, but clinically they're very different.
- 14:52Let's break down the four specific types. Okay,
- 14:55first is vicarious traumatization. This isn't
- 14:58just feeling sad, this is a fundamental structural
- 15:00negative shift in how you view the entire world.
- 15:03Right. The book gives a great example. A child
- 15:05abuse prosecutor who spends years reading horrific,
- 15:09unimaginable files. Eventually their brain rewires
- 15:13and they start believing that no child is ever
- 15:15safe anywhere, ever. The world is just a dangerous
- 15:18place. The second is compassion fatigue. This
- 15:21is a severe physical and emotional depletion.
- 15:25It leads to a complete loss of empathy. You become
- 15:27numb. It's awful. It isn't that you don't want
- 15:29to care about your client. It's that your emotional
- 15:32reservoir is entirely empty. You literally cannot
- 15:35bring yourself to care anymore. Third is secondary
- 15:38traumatic stress. This is fascinating because
- 15:41it mimics direct trauma. Just from hearing victims
- 15:44tell their stories all day, your brain reacts
- 15:47as if the trauma happened to you. You start exhibiting
- 15:50actual PTSD -like symptoms. Like hypervigilance,
- 15:54sudden panic, deep despair. Exactly, just from
- 15:57indirect exposure. And the fourth is burnout.
- 16:00Burnout involves exhaustion, cynicism, and depersonalization,
- 16:04like treating clients like numbers instead of
- 16:06people. But the key distinction is that burnout
- 16:09is specifically related to the workplace environment.
- 16:12Right, it's circumstantial. Yeah, it's about
- 16:14overwhelming caseloads, terrible bosses, and
- 16:17endless paperwork, not necessarily the traumatic
- 16:19stories themselves. Think about burnout like
- 16:21a depleted phone battery. You have been running
- 16:24way too many apps, the screen is too bright,
- 16:26and the phone is just exhausted. But if you unplug
- 16:28from that specific job, take a long vacation,
- 16:31or switch careers entirely, you can recharge
- 16:33and fix the phone. That's a great way to think
- 16:35about it. Mycarious traumatization, on the other
- 16:37hand, is like dropping the phone in water. It
- 16:40fundamentally shorts out the internal circuitry.
- 16:42It changes how the entire operating system works.
- 16:46And a week on a beach in Cancun is not going
- 16:48to fix the water damage. That is a perfect way
- 16:51to visualize it. Water damage changes the circuitry,
- 16:53just like vicarious trauma permanently alters
- 16:56your fundamental belief systems. And the text
- 16:58actually brings in a profound moral, even religious
- 17:02perspective on this dynamic. It quotes the Dalai
- 17:05Lama who said, if you want others to be happy,
- 17:08practice compassion. If you want to be happy,
- 17:11practice compassion. Which sounds incredibly
- 17:13beautiful on a bumper sticker, but when you apply
- 17:15it to the people working in the criminal justice
- 17:17system, it creates a terrifying moral paradox.
- 17:20The paradox of the helper. The exact quality
- 17:23that makes a victim advocate, a nurse, or a good
- 17:26police officer effective. Their empathy. Yes,
- 17:29their deep open -hearted empathy for other people
- 17:31is the very thing that makes them vulnerable
- 17:33to spiritual and psychological exhaustion. Their
- 17:36open heart is the door that allows the indirect
- 17:40trauma to get in. If they weren't empathetic,
- 17:42they wouldn't suffer compassion fatigue. But
- 17:44if they weren't empathetic, they would be completely
- 17:46useless at helping anyone heal. Man. So to synthesize
- 17:50everything we have covered in this deep dive
- 17:52study session. The intersection of criminal justice
- 17:55and behavioral health is this incredibly dense
- 17:58chaotic web. You have cops wielding the hammer
- 18:01and alternative responders bringing the tweezers.
- 18:04You have lawyers battling it out in a system
- 18:06struggling with diversity. You have CEOs guarding
- 18:09the facilities and case managers trying to keep
- 18:11people out of them. And you have a massive spectrum
- 18:14of healers trying to glue the pieces back together.
- 18:16Every single one of them is carrying an immense
- 18:19psychological burden just to keep the gears of
- 18:21society turning. exactly why this material matters
- 18:25so much to you, our listener and third study
- 18:27partner. Whether you are actively considering
- 18:29stepping into one of these career paths or you
- 18:32are simply a citizen voting on the policies,
- 18:34the budgets and the laws that shape these systems,
- 18:37you have to understand the human mind's capacity
- 18:39for both resilience and trauma. Absolutely. You
- 18:41cannot design a functional ethical justice system
- 18:44if you do not account for the psychological limits
- 18:47of the people who have to run it every day. So
- 18:50what does this all mean for us? I want to leave
- 18:52you with a final lingering thought to mull over
- 18:55before we meet up for our next study session.
- 18:58If our justice and mental health systems completely
- 19:01rely on the deep, open -hearted empathy of these
- 19:03frontline workers to function ethically, Yeah.
- 19:06But the daily reality of the work actively destroys
- 19:09that empathy through vicarious trauma, burnout,
- 19:11and compassion fatigue. Right. Are these systems
- 19:14actually sustainable in the long run? Or are
- 19:17they eventually destined to become cold, mechanical
- 19:19systems operating entirely without a moral compass?
- 19:22Something to think about. See you next time on
- 19:24The Psychology Undergrad.