Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E042: Entering a New Paradigm with Mitch Kochman
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record and securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on RAMPS. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met At on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation
- 1:10as we prepare for the Bitcoin having and the next wave of
- 1:13global adoption of this nascent and growing asset class.
- 1:16We are having all annual maintenance fees for clients
- 1:19that secure their wealth before the next Bitcoin epoch.
- 1:23What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:27we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 1:31ever assembled in the history of Governors 1970?
- 1:374. 198792972000 and whatever we want to.
- 1:41Call this. It's all just the same.
- 1:43Thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:46I say when we sell, hey, OK. So I'm behind.
- 1:51I say when we sell. Gentlemen, are you choosing
- 1:57Rich? Every day.
- 2:01I'm I'm starting to I'm starting to question my whole Bitcoin
- 2:04maxi thing because you know, NFT Nick is making some really good
- 2:08points. He's on a boat.
- 2:10He's on a boat. He's got a penthouse in New
- 2:12York. I don't know, Drake.
- 2:14Drake seems to be picking up the signal.
- 2:19Posting sailor comments on his on his story, that's pretty big.
- 2:24He's got like, I think, 200 million followers on Instagram.
- 2:29Wow, that's insane. 7X what I thought.
- 2:31I thought it was like 30 million.
- 2:33I think it's in the, I think it's in the nine figures.
- 2:36So the figure what did he post exactly?
- 2:38He posted a Michael Saylor clip of what?
- 2:42It was him on CNBC. Yeah, basically breaking down
- 2:45why like MSTR from like a higher beta or whatever like from a
- 2:49trading and all the things is is he's breaking down why somebody
- 2:52would hold MSTR versus like spot, yeah.
- 2:55So, so that would sort of suggest that like Drake has a
- 2:58big MSTR position then, which is a wild world to live in.
- 3:04Potentially. I mean, he's got a lot of money.
- 3:06He's probably diversified. Yeah, good for him.
- 3:10Good to have Drake on on Team Bitcoin.
- 3:13It's I'm fine to not have NFT Nick on Team Bitcoin that that
- 3:17one we can we can miss out on. So David Garland, he's an NBA
- 3:22star, was was in a a Satoshi T-shirt showing up to warmups
- 3:27last week. So definitely, definitely
- 3:29getting, getting some of that bull market buzz back.
- 3:32We're not seeing. The.
- 3:36MSTR thing's funny because, you know, everybody probably has
- 3:38their friends that are, you know, aping in or family or
- 3:41wives their 401 KS. But I was talking with, and I'm
- 3:45sure, and I'm only saying this, 'cause I saw his public on
- 3:47Twitter is a rock star was joking around how he, he has a
- 3:51position or had one. And it was because he was
- 3:54hanging out with like, Preston and these guys in Madera, and
- 3:56they're like, telling him about it.
- 3:58And so he's like, screw it. And he's like, it's just a joke,
- 4:00'cause I was just talking. He's like, it's all Ponzi.
- 4:02He's just like, laughing on this call because it's just like
- 4:04ripping, outpacing. He's like, Bitcoin goes like
- 4:07this and MSTR just goes like this.
- 4:09He's like, I don't even know why.
- 4:10He's like, it's all just like a joke.
- 4:11And then a couple of hours later I looked on Twitter.
- 4:13He's like, guys, the Volatility's too much.
- 4:15I'm stopping out my position. Like, good luck.
- 4:17And I guess there's a thing accrue at 2121 Crew, 'cause it's
- 4:20trading like 1600 a share. He's like, you guys can deal
- 4:24with this, but I guess that's like, it's just been this trade
- 4:26that everybody knew. I'm just and we're just, I don't
- 4:30know, I'm not in it. I'm just sitting on my little
- 4:31poor bitcoins. It's fascinating watching it
- 4:34play out because I mean you think about and where I don't
- 4:38know how much of it is, you know, I'd say buzz and retail
- 4:41buzz pumping up and and destroying shorts versus the
- 4:44actual valuation. But they're so levered up in
- 4:48that treasury. And like I'm starting to learn
- 4:52more the side of you know, this is just the impact of being so
- 4:55levered up on Bitcoin and what happens when all that bitcoins
- 4:58in the green. You know, there's a, there's a
- 5:02chance, not financial advice that this is, you know, just
- 5:05just how this looks moving forward.
- 5:07Well, that I saw an interesting thread comparing Micro
- 5:11Strategy's Bitcoin acquisition strategy to the Hunt brothers in
- 5:15the 80s where they tried to corner the silver market.
- 5:19Made me question like, is this something we should be worried
- 5:21about as an industry, like is micro strategy.
- 5:25I think at one point the Hunt brothers had something I don't
- 5:27think Sailor and Micro Strategy will like ever get to this
- 5:30percentage. But I think at one point in the
- 5:3180s they just, they were doing the micro strategy thing where
- 5:35they were taking out cheap debt, buying a bunch of silver.
- 5:37I think they acquired something like 80% of the physical silver
- 5:41on the market at the time. And then they got to a point
- 5:44where they're levered too much and they were forced to
- 5:46liquidate by the government crash the price of or silver
- 5:52from I think like 18 to $2.00. I think you wonder though if
- 5:57like if they had had it, if they were trying to corner the market
- 6:01on an asset that had increasing scarcity and like was early
- 6:04stage in its adoption and it was you know still a small asset in
- 6:08the global scheme of things. Maybe it would have worked but
- 6:12it it doesn't work for silver where you where you can also
- 6:16ramp up production of the asset by mining more too.
- 6:20So, so maybe like that playbook, Playbook does work with a better
- 6:25asset. And of course Sailor will never
- 6:27get to 80%. He's at 1% now of all the
- 6:31Bitcoin. And it is kind of a fun thing to
- 6:32think about, like how many entities, how many companies or
- 6:37or nation states will ever get to 1% of all the Bitcoin because
- 6:41it's a lot more than 100 who should be interested in
- 6:45accumulating Bitcoin and will at some point.
- 6:49And obviously they can't, you know, you can't have even 100
- 6:54entities accumulate 1% of the Bitcoin.
- 6:56There'll be a much, much smaller number and obviously the price
- 6:59has to go up in order to prevent that from, you know, from being
- 7:04possible really. Yeah.
- 7:06And and I think there's actually I was reading about it and it
- 7:09was kind of like instinctually I think it has to do with similar
- 7:13as oil like commodities that have infrastructure baked in
- 7:17along with all the different bureaucracy tied in is what like
- 7:19kills trying to corner and tie like peg doll or peg nominal
- 7:24amounts to the underlying into it.
- 7:28They were like sued and there was like regulation.
- 7:30There's all these things happening but there's none of
- 7:31that that exists in Bitcoin. So like, the government can do
- 7:33something to sailor, but like if you're just sitting in your Abu
- 7:36Dhabi or Saudi Arabia, like they can do as much they can buy as
- 7:39much Bitcoin as they want. To Jesse's point, like, it's
- 7:41just a reflexive market. There's no like Central Point
- 7:44where you can go like shut it off or don't like buy anymore.
- 7:47Right. Or make more of it.
- 7:49Yeah, that's the, I mean the other side of the coin is this
- 7:53just a full on speculative attack on the dollar cause news
- 7:56this week MicroStrategy did another convertible note
- 8:00oversubscribed over $800 million at a 65 BIP interest rate due in
- 8:0620-30 I believe. And so we're just doing the math
- 8:10on Bitcoin's average CAGR over what's that a six year period?
- 8:17I mean it seems pretty pretty wise.
- 8:20Financial more than 1%, yeah. It's this happened.
- 8:26I had Pierre Richard on TFTC last week to talk about
- 8:30Elizabeth Warren's attack on the Bitcoin mining industry.
- 8:32But that's one thing we harken back to the first episode of
- 8:36TFTC that we ever recorded. The 1st guest ever had on TFTC
- 8:40was Pierre and go back to October 2017 and he says it
- 8:45pretty explicitly like at some point one of these companies
- 8:47gonna start borrowing money to just buy Bitcoin.
- 8:49And lo and behold, three years later micro strategy set out on
- 8:53that path and has accumulated 1% of the total supply.
- 8:58Will, Will Cole talks about this a lot, right?
- 9:00I don't know if it's Switzerland, but it's some like
- 9:02European. Country.
- 9:03Switzerland, right? They like print money from the
- 9:06central bank to buy equities like in this like U.S. equity
- 9:09like so it's just a matter of time.
- 9:12Yeah, yeah, it's happening first first the last trade episode or
- 9:19recording above the previous all time high.
- 9:21How's it feel, gentlemen? Mitch, what was that you were
- 9:26saying before we started? It's it's quiet.
- 9:30It is quiet. It's the quietest all time high,
- 9:33you know, at least I I've seen, you know being in the market
- 9:36since since 2017. I'm definitely getting getting
- 9:41some of the text from, you know, from people that we've been
- 9:45begging to you know, buy Bitcoin during during the bear markets.
- 9:48But I'd say you know as far as the IT being commonplace and you
- 9:55know you see it on CNBC, but I'd say friends, family, I I think
- 10:00largely are blissfully unaware of the appreciation we've been
- 10:03seeing. Yeah, I was.
- 10:07I was commenting before that it it feels like we're entering a
- 10:14new era for Bitcoin of like we're we're leaving behind the
- 10:17the time when an average person could stack a whole Bitcoin, you
- 10:24know, 'cause $70,000 per Bitcoin.
- 10:26That's that's out of reach for most people, I would say.
- 10:31And it it's kind of interesting how quiet it is and how the vast
- 10:37majority of people simply have yet to realize that they missed
- 10:42an opportunity. But I think I think that's you
- 10:46know people will look back on people will look back on 70,000
- 10:50as cheap which is the the alarming thing about where we're
- 10:53at right now. Because you know every time
- 10:56we've gone through a long bear market and then slowly
- 10:59approached the previous all time high.
- 11:02You know when you reach that all time high again it feels like
- 11:05wow we've we've made it back. We're as high as Bitcoin ever
- 11:09goes because you know, you have this four year memory of here's
- 11:15the range that Bitcoin can possibly go to and and we're at
- 11:17the top end of that. And then a year later because of
- 11:21the halving that comes and the supply scarcity that plays out,
- 11:25suddenly the price is like 5X higher than it than it was at
- 11:30that, you know at that moment when prior all time high was met
- 11:33and exceeded finally. So, you know, I think we're at
- 11:37that point again where like 70,000 is going to look like
- 11:4120,000 did four years ago, which is to say like a year later
- 11:47it'll it'll it'll seem cheap based on where we're going.
- 11:52And it's just so it's like a kind of sad moment in many ways,
- 11:56because I don't know about you guys, but I feel like I
- 12:00succeeded in getting some of my friends and family to acquire a
- 12:06meaningful position of Bitcoin, but for the most part they
- 12:10didn't listen. Most most of my network still
- 12:13doesn't have a meaningful position of Bitcoin and and I
- 12:18doubt that they will get to whole coiner status now.
- 12:24Yeah, it's gonna be hard for many people we're sitting at.
- 12:27I think we just dropped sitting around like $70,500.
- 12:33That's more than the median income in the United States
- 12:36right now. So I think for your average
- 12:39person, and as this thing runs, it's gonna get harder and harder
- 12:43to stack sets. I think, I think the beauty of
- 12:47that though is like it goes back to positioning in the unit bias
- 12:50like end of the day anybody can preserve their wealth, right.
- 12:52So we have to figure out what is new messaging of like.
- 12:55It's not necessarily an investment.
- 12:56It's literally just protecting yourself and making sure you can
- 12:59stack and then think about your future and retain the purchasing
- 13:03power so you can have some hope to build something.
- 13:05Because I got caught with this, like with somebody bagging
- 13:07groceries, I asked, like, randomly about Bitcoin.
- 13:09It's like, oh, yeah, that thing's too far from me.
- 13:11And I like, got caught because I was like, shit, like you're not
- 13:12gonna buy a whole Bitcoin. But like, there's actually a lot
- 13:14more. There is obvious value to the
- 13:16underlying, but it's like more nuanced than, hey, buy this, you
- 13:19know, as a percentage of your net worth, it's low.
- 13:21Like think about this because you can actually, you know,
- 13:24preserve your purchasing power and think about the future in a
- 13:26positive light then versus just being stuck on like throwing
- 13:29dollars in a club to make it rain.
- 13:32So I think we just got to figure out that and then the unit buys
- 13:34probably comes in at some point, right where we switched Sats or
- 13:37something to help. Yeah, I I do like the the meme
- 13:44that's been going around lately of Bitcoin is only zero point
- 13:50zero $1 million or less. 0.07, sorry, 0.07 million dollars,
- 13:59that's a good way to reframe it because that's where we're
- 14:01heading. And yeah at some point it it
- 14:05probably we probably switched to sats as as like what people talk
- 14:09about. But because, you know, when when
- 14:11Bitcoin is fluctuating between 456,000 and you know, 482,000 in
- 14:20a day, those numbers become so large that it's hard to like
- 14:25make sense of them or or they they feel it's like talking
- 14:29about Berkshire Hathaway stock prices.
- 14:31It's just not salient. And so maybe we switch to SAT
- 14:36SAT's, the standard. And I'll go first, we almost
- 14:40actually have to switch to SAT's because probably in parallel, if
- 14:43there's going to be technological component to
- 14:46Bitcoin being used in anything like consumer applications, it's
- 14:50going to be in SAT's. So it's just going to be a
- 14:52synonymous thing with Bitcoin and you need it to be like the
- 14:55same standard because if you have one over here with like
- 14:57decimal places, you know the other one over here with
- 15:00thousands, like I think there ends up being a a standard
- 15:03that's established and it's probably SAT's, right?
- 15:08Yeah, I'd say. Probably.
- 15:08But we need the meaningful appreciation for for it to not
- 15:12be absurd numbers that we're we're still dealing with there.
- 15:15You know, to buy, you know, burger with 1000 stats, you
- 15:19know, is a little bit tougher. But if we get that price
- 15:21appreciation they they it will be easier numbers to to transact
- 15:26with. But I do think those bear.
- 15:28Probably the cycle, probably the cycle that that that you know we
- 15:34as a community do need to figure out you know what what that unit
- 15:37basis is is going. Right.
- 15:38That'll probably be a big conversation in the next bear
- 15:41market. As it stands right now, one kook
- 15:46buck $1.00 is worth 14115 sets, so at some point this year most
- 15:53likely will fall below 1000 SATS per dollar.
- 15:57I think that's when you get into a really interesting pair, yeah.
- 16:01It's like, all right. Another related thing that I was
- 16:05thinking about this morning is I've been thinking about, you
- 16:10know, the the the layup for Bitcoin is to match gold.
- 16:13It's just such a clear path to do that as a minimum, and in my
- 16:19head that has been like 400, five, $100,000 per Bitcoin to
- 16:24match gold. But gold is appreciating too
- 16:27right now and with the inflation that we're inevitably going to
- 16:30see over the next few years, we probably are at parity with
- 16:36gold, around $1,1,000,000 per Bitcoin.
- 16:40All that, all that that would mean is, you know, $21 trillion
- 16:43asset class. Gold right now is like a 1415
- 16:46trillion dollar asset class. So gold would just have to grow
- 16:49a little bit and Bitcoin grow a lot.
- 16:52But that would be that would be quite something that if if we're
- 16:56at parity with gold at that price point and that's just the
- 17:01beginning for what Bitcoin will eventually do that that's that's
- 17:04the minimum. So yeah, I think, I think
- 17:08thinking about that this morning sort of made me realize how how
- 17:13likely $1,000,000 per Bitcoin really is.
- 17:17Because by the time that that's you know in the cards, gold will
- 17:22be at that total valuation anyway, and it'll just mean
- 17:25matching the pet rock. If you're if you're setting
- 17:30setting gold as you know the the bar that we're going for here I
- 17:34read this week that ETF inflows just in the last two months were
- 17:39five times or were larger than than the last five years of gold
- 17:44ETF inflows. So that that acceleration is
- 17:49certainly happening and I think we we we might end up there as I
- 17:55said gold's appreciating but I think as more people wake up to
- 17:58you know in the we see the game theory occur on on the Bitcoin
- 18:02side. I think you might see some flows
- 18:03out of gold and you know, might speed up sort of Bitcoin taken
- 18:07over in that race. Yeah, a a related bit of math
- 18:10there. It's it's, I saw something on
- 18:13Twitter a week or two ago about, you know, there's like $500
- 18:18million of of net inflows on average for the ETFs recently
- 18:23every trading day. And obviously we're about to
- 18:27enter an era where we're mining 450 Bitcoin per day and so, so
- 18:35long as there's that so so long as assuming that there's from
- 18:39all other demand sources net 0 inflows.
- 18:45So, so not negative, but not positive and the ETFs continue
- 18:49at $500 million a day. For price equilibrium to re
- 18:56establish in that in the new block reward era, price will
- 19:00have to go to $1,000,000 per Bitcoin.
- 19:04And obviously there's a lot of assumptions in there that won't
- 19:06remain true, but that's how close, that's how massive the
- 19:11ETF inflows are and how that bumps up against the increasing
- 19:16scarcity that's coming and puts suddenly $1,000,000 per Bitcoin
- 19:21like in our sights. I don't think it happens this
- 19:24cycle, but like it suddenly becomes like possible.
- 19:28I I I've got a op-ed coming out this week but the the premise of
- 19:33of it is is largely you know what you would describe here is
- 19:37we're we're seeing supply demand dynamics that we we haven't
- 19:42really seen in you know in previous Bitcoin cycles there's
- 19:46we're at all time high pre having and we're you know the
- 19:52the dynamics that are are are playing out we've got different
- 19:55buyers here than we've ever seen in Bitcoin stable buyer larger
- 20:00buyers coming in that don't have retail behaviors and I think
- 20:04it's misguided comparing you know at the risk of this time
- 20:08it's different comparing you know previous cycles to this one
- 20:13just because the the the game has has totally changed you know
- 20:18you've got anyone from you know your fidelities and black rocks
- 20:21putting Bitcoin in you know all in or you know total total funds
- 20:25that you know they're giving Bitcoin an allocation to.
- 20:28To obviously CE OS and board members are seeing you know
- 20:32what's going on at micro strategy and that stock price
- 20:35appreciation looking there and they've got you know incentive
- 20:40structures that are aligned to stock price increases like there
- 20:43will be domino stuff all here there's just different buyers
- 20:47and you know with with very very different behaviors and I think
- 20:50if we're we're looking at past cycles to try to try to get
- 20:53price predictions here you know for better or worse I I think
- 20:56you know those people are are gonna look pretty silly when
- 21:00when we're all said and done here.
- 21:03Yeah, I think things are gonna get weird when you saw.
- 21:08Last. Week we mentioned the fact that
- 21:12the Arizona State treasury wrote an official letter saying hey,
- 21:16we want to make it so that our retirement systems can buy these
- 21:20Bitcoin ETFs. This morning we saw the Patience
- 21:24capital which is I believe $15 billion in AUM is amending their
- 21:30prospectus to enable them to have the ability to allocate up
- 21:34to 15% of one of their funds into the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 21:38Their founder is a student of Bill Miller's who is a prominent
- 21:44bitcoiner from the Tradfi world, and I was talking to my neighbor
- 21:48last night is wealth manager at Morgan Stanley.
- 21:51We've been talking a lot about the ETFs and their impact and he
- 21:54was explaining to me last night that it's far exceeded his
- 21:58expectations up to this point just due to his knowledge of how
- 22:03slow these institutional investors move.
- 22:06And we were talking about the Arizona State treasury and a
- 22:09couple of their funds that are beginning to amend their
- 22:12prospectuses to enable access to Bitcoin ETS specifically.
- 22:17And like it really hasn't even started yet in terms of
- 22:21institutional inflows that that we can, that we can expect in
- 22:27the future. It's gonna take time 6 to 9
- 22:29months for a lot of this to happen.
- 22:31So think about. What you said there with the 15%
- 22:34which is the, you know right now I think Fidelity, you know
- 22:39they're with a more aggressive fund I think was at was at 3%
- 22:41and might have been a little higher.
- 22:43But all these you know asset managers are are all competing
- 22:48against each other to show the best returns and you're going to
- 22:52see that number increase and increase as you know number goes
- 22:56up to you know be most attractive to the most clients.
- 23:00And it's it's that game theory again, if largely they're going
- 23:05to be competing against each other and it's just going to
- 23:07drive more liquidity to the asset class, once again, it's
- 23:11going to get weird. Yeah, we'll see.
- 23:19I I mean I don't know about you guys but I'm like I'm I'm
- 23:22incredulous. I I after so long of like
- 23:26believing that this this asset is you know worth a million, $10
- 23:30million and it's finally starting to get appropriately
- 23:35repriced just just beginning to I definitely have some like
- 23:40emotional inertia of like I I kind of can't believe it's
- 23:43finally happening or finally beginning and yeah been pinching
- 23:49myself a little bit lately and and despite the fact that like I
- 23:52don't think I could really have done much more in terms of
- 23:54stacking. I also feel like, man, the
- 23:59window of opportunity closed, maybe I should have done more.
- 24:04Yeah, you all have that FOMO. I should have been stacking
- 24:08more. I should have been making more
- 24:09money. But it is what it is.
- 24:12These ridiculous price pumps are reminders, like I gotta work
- 24:15harder, gotta cut my cost where where they can be cut to make
- 24:19sure that I'm saving as much Bitcoin as possible.
- 24:21And I was explaining it to my neighbor last night.
- 24:23He was talking about how he got one of his friends in the
- 24:27Bitcoin they bought like $1000 at $65,000 Bitcoin.
- 24:32And that was like one point 5 million Sats, I think.
- 24:38And I explained to him, I was like, if every person on the
- 24:41world were to adopt Bitcoin, you'd divide 8,21,000,000 by 8
- 24:45billion. Like the average person's only
- 24:47gonna get 230,000 Sats if it were evenly distributed, which
- 24:53we know it's not. MicroStrategy has 1%, Satoshi
- 24:57has a million coins. You're gonna get sovereign
- 25:00wealth funds that scoop up hundreds of thousands like.
- 25:04So thinking, thinking of that #230,000 sets, if it's evenly
- 25:07distributed among 8 billion people, if you're above that,
- 25:11you're you're doing well. And it's a small amount of money
- 25:13right now still, even with the price bumping part of.
- 25:18What I found was fun about the show and talking with folks is I
- 25:22think it's what made all In a good pot is there's people like
- 25:24doing stuff in the real world every day.
- 25:26And so you get to bring it every week and like have the
- 25:28conversations behind the scenes without naming the names in
- 25:31front. And one of the conversations I
- 25:33had yesterday was about like, there's this level of of it's
- 25:37not intensity but like in the bowl that you naturally feel and
- 25:43the word's gonna escape me. But it's effectively like it's
- 25:46not really responsibility, but it's just different when the
- 25:49stakes are at $70,000 and you're kind of like now you may be
- 25:53suggesting point, you're pinching yourself as you're
- 25:55like, OK, you built it for this and now you have to the the way
- 25:58we like and they were joking around, it's like you're driving
- 26:00on the highway at well, you know, very fast speed and
- 26:02there's like a Brinks truck in front of you and there's $100
- 26:05bills flying out. Now you have to start picking
- 26:06them up and you only have X amount of time.
- 26:08And so like the the the the game and the the the game and the
- 26:14stakes start to increase as the price appreciates.
- 26:17And so there's a different level of responsibility and things at
- 26:23play versus when it's $25,000 and nobody's looking at it.
- 26:27And I think there's like this natural like uncomfortability or
- 26:30or friction that's like starting to be felt by individuals that
- 26:34are working in this space. I don't know if anybody feels
- 26:37like that here, but I personally have in this individual I was
- 26:39talking to you that that works for one of the larger like
- 26:42ETPETF providers was in a similar boat.
- 26:44And I think that's kind of what also Jesse was alluding to is
- 26:46like, OK, now you're here and it's like this is what you've
- 26:49been waiting for. Now there's like, what do you
- 26:51actually do to capitalize? I I've.
- 26:54Seen the behavior change from I'd say let's first start with
- 26:58the the existing Bitcoin platforms that I work with and
- 27:01the I'd say all through the bear it was figuring out how do we
- 27:06build new products and there was that you know anything from you
- 27:10know what we bought with on ramp to Swan Vault and and you know
- 27:15the work I did with Swan it was all product creation and that
- 27:21conversation with the existing platforms has totally changed
- 27:23and it's now how do we how do we number one like we there was a
- 27:30lot of shoring down on the infrastructure and you've got
- 27:35you know a lot of I'd say some of the miners out there looking
- 27:38for 2nd and 3rd custodians you know to spread risk now that the
- 27:42the asset price has gone up but it's it's figuring out you know
- 27:47we're faces you know with the the the new fee market as you
- 27:51know the demand comes in you know more people are are you
- 27:56using and moving moving asset. We've got you know all the you
- 27:59know the BRC 20s and ordinals taking up clogging up manpoles
- 28:03which you know comes and goes. But these platforms do need to
- 28:06respond and be able to handle withdrawals in that environment
- 28:11and a lot of them offer free withdrawals which gets
- 28:14expensive. You know we need to be able to
- 28:16do send too many transactions. You know Biko just released
- 28:20replaced by fee where if you got a transaction clogged in the mem
- 28:23pool you can if you put a setting on that transaction you
- 28:28can you can then flip it you know with the new transaction
- 28:30with a higher fee to to ensure it gets processed.
- 28:33It's a lot of changes like that where really how do we, how do
- 28:39we handle the all the new demand, that's the new demand,
- 28:42the new price appreciation which obviously very different than
- 28:46than releasing new products. Yeah.
- 28:50Yeah. I hope you were building in the
- 28:51bear market. Anybody running a company out
- 28:53there because the the wave is coming and I think we're better
- 28:59positioned from an industry standpoint to take on this wave
- 29:02outside of Coinbase, which is obviously not as bad.
- 29:06I'll test it as it as it should be at this point, 12 years into
- 29:10its existence, to to handle an influx of users, but outside of
- 29:15Coinbase, it does seem like the infrastructure is more robust
- 29:19than ever, I'd say. On the custodian side, I'd say
- 29:24trading side liquidity, I think that's pretty short down.
- 29:30My concerns compared to the last cycle are are in the banking
- 29:33side and the you know obviously you've got banks upside down you
- 29:40know because of because of treasuries and as a as an
- 29:44industry they we are you know pretty underbanked and a lot of
- 29:48you know you've got smaller banks you know supporting you
- 29:51know a lot of a lot of on ramps here and you know BICCO we've
- 29:56got a network of I think like 6 to 8 banks supporting our
- 29:59infrastructure. I'm hoping you know a lot of a
- 30:02lot of the the exchanges out there do have that the the sort
- 30:05of rail so they don't need to shut down trading, you know
- 30:07should you know bank or or cascaded banks go under.
- 30:12So that's that's where my fears are.
- 30:13It's it's all on Fiat right now. But you know, I think slowly the
- 30:21some of the the banks are in like all larger banks are
- 30:24warming up and and hopefully there's change there.
- 30:27You mentioned that prescient that you mentioned that today
- 30:32the latest CPI print came in above expectations.
- 30:36These banks are obviously under stress.
- 30:37We had to have that private consortium led by Steve Mnuchin
- 30:41to come in and save New York Community Bank Court last week.
- 30:45But it was a billion dollar capital injection there.
- 30:49Deposits are way bigger than that and you imagine their
- 30:52liabilities are too. And so with inflation staying
- 30:56relatively elevated, it'll be very interesting to see what the
- 31:00Fed does, particularly with the context that a lot of these
- 31:04banks are under a lot of stress. We have BTFP being being
- 31:09discontinued later this month and what are they going to do?
- 31:15How? How do you like that, that
- 31:17headline that snuck in there though like Steve Mnuchin comes
- 31:20in to save New York Bank Corp You know like the the reality of
- 31:26that. I don't.
- 31:27I don't know the details. I don't know if how much of the
- 31:30details are known. But for sure, that is a
- 31:32sweetheart deal where Steve Mnuchin and his gang will make
- 31:36out like bandits. And I have a feeling it'll be
- 31:39subsidized by taxpayers. Yes.
- 31:42Eventually it definitely will be.
- 31:45I am. I'm looking for a headline I saw
- 31:48Jesse, did you see this something having to do with
- 31:50banks and their treasury reserves?
- 31:54I have not been paying as close attention to that as I was a
- 31:58year ago. Let me find.
- 31:59This headline, I'll send it to Logan to pull up well, Marty's.
- 32:02Looking it up Mitch, I'd be curious to the extent you know
- 32:05what you can share you reference infrastructure, it's public bit
- 32:11go supports ETFSA few, I don't know the exact number maybe you
- 32:14can clarify that. But then also just like from an
- 32:17infrastructure perspective, you mentioned the banks, but also
- 32:19think about like custody where we have Coinbase, we have bit go
- 32:23is the I think two big players cracking I think came out last
- 32:26week that they want to get more in the institutional space when
- 32:29it comes to custody. Like how do you guys think about
- 32:32that in like any, I don't know if it's like rumblings, but
- 32:35concerns or questions from clients about like that seems
- 32:38like another kind of just like area of the market that doesn't
- 32:42have a lot of options. Yeah I I I would say we
- 32:47definitely lost quite a few custodians I I want to be
- 32:52careful about about you know commenting publicly about about
- 32:55competition and and you know I'd say the and the competitors that
- 33:01that we are typically up against there are some good ones out
- 33:03there. But I think one of the things
- 33:08I've enjoyed particularly about the ETF is how the the
- 33:13bitcoiners on Twitter will will hammer you know any any
- 33:17custodian that that isn't using you know current the Bitcoin
- 33:21wallet tech and it's important because of the we're improving
- 33:27the you know the the protocol for a reason and you know if
- 33:30you've got you know you know Cyberhorn that's attacking you
- 33:36for for for using old wallet tech there's there's there's
- 33:39there's reasons to you know to upgrade and you can't get away
- 33:43with it anymore. So I I do think you know the the
- 33:50case I I referenced Coinbase in particular I think they did make
- 33:53some some changes at least in the in the short term.
- 33:58But I I think in general you know there there's gonna be more
- 34:04pressure to you know to be on you know latest technology but
- 34:09I'll be I I, I dodging a bit I there, there obviously you know
- 34:13in the custodial landscape there, there are pressures on
- 34:15other custodians out there right now and I think we're there will
- 34:24there's still some fallout to take place.
- 34:26I think you know it's not like a funds are in trouble sort of way
- 34:29but you know M&A and you know that sort of behavior.
- 34:34Yeah, and. And I think the core roads kind
- 34:37of driving is like, we have all these ETFs, what is it, 11?
- 34:39And there's really like 2 custodians that handle it.
- 34:42And thinking through like, what does that look like even from
- 34:44just a pure marketability perspective, right, Because
- 34:48these ETFs are switching around or thinking about how do they
- 34:51differentiate? I think it came out today, Van
- 34:52Acker yesterday that they're like waiving all fees, which is
- 34:55like always should smell like in its place.
- 34:57Like, I like, I think Jan's a great guy and they're doing
- 35:00great stuff. But it's like when nobody
- 35:01charges you for anything, like there's no such thing as a free
- 35:03lunch. Somebody has to pay somewhere
- 35:05for everything all the time like this, like, and so like that
- 35:09should always raise pause. And it's almost like the
- 35:11opposite is a false signal of like if you're not charging like
- 35:14what's happening and getting deeper and then you start
- 35:16looking at like custody and all the things associated.
- 35:18So I think that's just, it's an interesting premise in itself,
- 35:23yeah, I think. You know.
- 35:27The you know. We probably have the large
- 35:28players that that will be a part of this cycle.
- 35:31I think when Sev 21 gets repealed, which is more of a
- 35:36matter when not. If you know you'll have some M&A
- 35:40from you know existing providers, you'll have some Chad
- 35:44Fi participants you know enter the space and it will have you
- 35:49know some massive balance sheets start to get into this into this
- 35:52business would you when? Do you forecast that like not,
- 35:55You don't think you have direct, like do you think that's like a
- 35:58free 2026 or like? Because that's very interesting
- 36:01from the bank's perspective. Seeing what's happening.
- 36:03And wanting to get a piece, yeah.
- 36:06And obviously they do. I would I would be surprised and
- 36:12obviously it's going to be, it's going to be pretty political but
- 36:16I I 2026 I think would be you know reasonable hopefully and
- 36:21maybe that's addressed in you know the the crypto regulation
- 36:25that we've seen you know discussed you know that they
- 36:28said they were tabling to 2024 that you know is that going to
- 36:32happen in an election year. I think it's going to it's
- 36:35necessary but it it might take another I I'd say a year or two.
- 36:41It's pretty funny how this. All got politicized.
- 36:43Like if Trump wins, everybody moves to Florida and Texas.
- 36:47If Trump loses, we're all going to the UAE.
- 36:51Because like Trump was talking about this past week, right?
- 36:53He's like, yeah, it's cool. Like everybody uses it.
- 36:55And then I think this morning it's like Biden's gonna put a
- 36:5830% tax on minors or something. Like headline, Yeah.
- 37:02I guess we could talk about that.
- 37:03So the 2025, the general administration projections for
- 37:1120/20/25 revenue from the Biden administration came out this
- 37:16week. And within that 236 page report
- 37:20on page 72, they lay out an excise tax on Bitcoin miners of
- 37:2630%. They're going to tax their
- 37:28electricity consumption so they'll have their electricity
- 37:31costs and then if Biden's administration gets their way,
- 37:35they'll have a 30% excise tax on those electricity purchases.
- 37:40And this is actually a resurgence of something they've
- 37:43they've proposed this in the past, I believe, in the
- 37:45beginning of last year, in the middle of last year.
- 37:48And it actually ties very tightly with the EIA survey that
- 37:54got next in court a couple of weeks ago.
- 37:58That survey now makes a lot more sense, it seems like.
- 38:02The Biden. Administration wanted to put
- 38:04this excise tax on the industry and to make sure they were
- 38:08generating as much tax revenue as possible, they sent the EIA
- 38:12out with a survey to basically identify all these mining, all
- 38:17these mining operations, how much electricity they were
- 38:19consuming so that they could accurately tax them with the
- 38:22they just wanted. To know more about the industry.
- 38:25That's all Marty. They weren't trying to figure
- 38:27out exactly what their tax base is and how much to squeeze out
- 38:30of people when the time comes take.
- 38:32Off your tinfoil hats, yeah. And I would I I mentioned that I
- 38:38recorded with Pierre last week. If you're listening to this, I
- 38:41highly recommend you go listen to that episode if you want to
- 38:43understand more about this particular confrontation between
- 38:47the Bitcoin mining industry and the Department of Energy.
- 38:50The Basically the government is coming to this problem with the
- 38:57pretextual from a pretextual basis where they're basically
- 39:01assuming that Bitcoin mining is bad for energy grids, bad for
- 39:04the environment, and bad for electricity pricing.
- 39:06But there's plenty of publicly available data that proves the
- 39:10exact opposite is true. Bitcoin mining consumes wasted
- 39:15energy, it makes grids more stable, more reliable, and it's
- 39:20good for the environment 'cause it soaks up excess emissions in
- 39:24the form of methane with off grid mining.
- 39:27And so even though the BIND administration is putting this,
- 39:33proposing this excise tax of 30% on the mining industry, I I
- 39:38don't think it's gonna pass. I think actors like ERCOT and
- 39:43the TVA are very clued in onto how Bitcoin mining operations
- 39:48work and what they provide to their individual grid systems
- 39:52that they'll stand up and say, hey, if you levy this excise
- 39:55tax, you're essentially taking out one of our most dynamic.
- 40:00And reliable demand sources and we need those to to run our
- 40:06grids in a stable and reliable fashion.
- 40:10This, this ties. Into the politics thing.
- 40:12That whole quote of you may not care about war, but war will
- 40:14eventually care about you. It's like we may not care about
- 40:16politics, don't speak personally, but it's going to
- 40:18care about us. And it's like command.
- 40:19I was talking to Lee and I know Pierre was involved.
- 40:22It's like at the end of the day, people have to maneuver and
- 40:24wield the right influential power to get these things
- 40:26across. Because if we don't, that's how
- 40:28they will end up happening with the TVA and these other
- 40:31participants not actually speaking up.
- 40:34So yeah, it's it's huge what TBC has participated.
- 40:38I know again, Pierre was involved in, I think Riot was
- 40:40involved, right? Yeah, it was.
- 40:42Riot and the Texas Blockchain Council?
- 40:45That's not a joke. To see the US government like,
- 40:48yeah, it's not huge. Like so the US government had to
- 40:51back off and and settle out of courts and now they have to go
- 40:54through this whole commenting process.
- 40:58The the the whole justification for the emergency order was
- 41:03completely bunk. They literally broke the law by
- 41:08by like the the amount of days that people had to respond to
- 41:11the survey was like off like outside the letter of the law.
- 41:14They they're claiming that, like, this data isn't available.
- 41:18But riots and other participants have responded to letters from
- 41:22Elizabeth Warren over the last two years asking for this data.
- 41:25They gave it to her. She obviously didn't read it or
- 41:28acknowledge it. And then they don't have any
- 41:32justification for this outside of they don't like Bitcoin.
- 41:36So like the the whole reason they're doing this is not
- 41:39because they truly believe that Bitcoin mining's bad for the
- 41:41environment, bad for grids, bad for electricity pricing for
- 41:45residential consumers. They don't like Bitcoin 'cause
- 41:48they can't control it. And the Elizabeth Warrens of the
- 41:52world are really pushing for a CBDC and Bitcoin and the Bitcoin
- 41:57mining industry are in the way of of facilitating that
- 42:00transition to a central bank digital currency.
- 42:02And so they're gonna ignore reality and just try to brute
- 42:07force all this regulation and excessive taxes through the
- 42:12market. I highly recommend anybody go.
- 42:15I I read it last night. The 2025 general Administration
- 42:20revenue projections. Just search.
- 42:22Just control F excise. It's insane how many excise
- 42:26taxes there are. Like Bitcoin mining was just one
- 42:28industry they want to levy an excise tax on.
- 42:30Like the government has completely lost control of their
- 42:34spending and they're really clamping down and and trying to
- 42:37tax the shit out of everything. But not to be confused.
- 42:40With Pierre's tweet, because that was not real.
- 42:43I was on a call the the day and somebody sided and I was like, I
- 42:46looked at it. I was like, this doesn't look
- 42:47official. The big Bitcoin in like, right
- 42:49next to the US government logo. Yeah, he.
- 42:52He clarified that yes, I made these charts based off of the
- 42:58assumptions the government was making, but it.
- 43:02It's pretty amazing to think about.
- 43:05Like, Can you imagine if if the government had tried to levy an
- 43:10excise tax for Internet traffic for like Yahoo or Google or
- 43:16Amazon in the early days, You know, like what would, what
- 43:19would have happened? Like it's pretty obvious to
- 43:21think about it from from that thought problem perspective.
- 43:26But like those companies would have set up shop in a different
- 43:29jurisdiction. You know, they wouldn't, we
- 43:32wouldn't have Google or Amazon in the US.
- 43:35They'd be Canadian or they'd be you know Auk based company or
- 43:41something. And and the the reason the US
- 43:44won with the Internet and became the home, the global home of
- 43:48Internet development and Internet companies is because we
- 43:52had like loose guide rails for allowing innovation to blossom
- 43:57before stepping in with detrimental regulation and and
- 44:03taxes. So you know, I hope that the
- 44:07truth prevails here, Marty. And I think it's to Michael's
- 44:10point it's like it's thanks to Texas Blockchain Castle Council
- 44:14and and Riot and folks like that that are putting in the fight
- 44:20and to to surface the truth about how Bitcoin mining is
- 44:24actually good. And so long as a rule of law
- 44:28prevails and you know the the the people in decision making
- 44:34places in the court system follow the rule of law and are
- 44:38interested in the truth rather than corruption, then I think we
- 44:44win this fight. But it you know it has to be
- 44:46fought. No, it's a very.
- 44:48Good point. It's.
- 44:50It's. I think that was one of my
- 44:52biggest worries. When the EIA survey first came
- 44:54out, I wrote a newsletter about it was like, do not respond to
- 44:57this, like we have to fight back.
- 44:58And I was very happy to see that Riot in the Texas Blockchain
- 45:01Council stepped up because that is the biggest threat to Bitcoin
- 45:05and always has been is complacency and apathy.
- 45:09And I do think because of the nature of the federal government
- 45:14and how overarching it has become, many individuals think
- 45:17it's not even worth an effort to try to push back.
- 45:19But I think Riot and the Texas Blockchain Council just proved
- 45:23that like, no like that. There is a rule of law.
- 45:25There are judges like Jesse mentioned that Will we'll follow
- 45:30the rule of law and all you have to do is take some effort and
- 45:34and push back and say no, you're not doing this to us.
- 45:37And in this case, the law prevailed, the truth prevailed,
- 45:41and that's the other thing. We have the truth on our side.
- 45:43We have the data, we have economic flourishing happening
- 45:48in areas where where Bitcoin miners enter an economy.
- 45:51And that's another thing on top of all, well, the truth in that
- 45:56regard we have to really lean into is the the truth of the
- 45:59matter. That if Elizabeth Warren and the
- 46:02Biden administration get their way in pushing the Bitcoin
- 46:05mining industry out of the country, it's really not gonna
- 46:09do anything to Bitcoin. It's gonna hurt American
- 46:11citizens and you can eventually try to shovel in the CBDC, but
- 46:17life finds a way. Americans will find a way to get
- 46:21access and use Bitcoin because it is better money and your CBDC
- 46:25is destined to fail. And so that is the proposition
- 46:30you have to put forward to the people pushing against the
- 46:32industry is like, hey, this is happening whether you like it or
- 46:35not. If it doesn't happen here, it's
- 46:37going to happen somewhere else and eventually it will come back
- 46:40here because Bitcoin is the best money.
- 46:42And so do you want to shoot yourself in the foot and have
- 46:45the American economy miss out on the proliferation of this
- 46:49incredible technology for the next decade, 2 decades, a
- 46:52generation, whatever it may be? Or do you want to accept reality
- 46:56and let Americans prosper from this reality and actually
- 47:00innovate and lead in terms of Bitcoin?
- 47:05What I don't understand here is and 1st thank you to you know to
- 47:10Riot and and everybody who who helped push against this and
- 47:15grateful for you guys in Texas blockchain council too.
- 47:18But the the political calculus involved and it's you know for
- 47:22for the last several years of the, you know, we've got 20%,
- 47:26you know, it's it that number's I'm sure higher as we've been
- 47:29picking up you know, people but 20% of Americans out of that
- 47:33whole crypto at this point you've got more onboarding to,
- 47:36you know, you know via the ETF as liquidity pours into this
- 47:40ecosystem. And you know that the
- 47:43demographics for for those holders, it's going to skew
- 47:46younger. It's going to skew towards more
- 47:48towards the, you know, more the left and you know the the
- 47:51Democratic base. I don't understand, you know how
- 47:56you know who's running the numbers here that this is going
- 47:59to be politically favorable for them.
- 48:00Because I think you've got the majority of people who might be
- 48:03even pro this probably not listening, probably voting, you
- 48:06know in in that direction anyway and you're just losing
- 48:11meaningful number of of your voter base when you know margins
- 48:15are are razor thin, you know and we're in 2020 and probably will
- 48:19be in 2024. It's just it doesn't make sense
- 48:23to me. Yeah.
- 48:28I already said it very diplomatically.
- 48:29It was nice, but it was just like, it's just like has to be
- 48:32said. It's like it's pretty sick.
- 48:34Like what Jesse was referencing. It's like you're going to
- 48:35stifle, it's like a double whammy.
- 48:37You stifle the innovation and then you just harm people like
- 48:39because people literally work at these places like in town.
- 48:42It's like it literally worked. And you're like, Oh yeah, we're
- 48:44just going to like kill you on inflation.
- 48:45We're going to kill you on all these things and we're going to
- 48:47take away your job well and. There's a negative externality
- 48:52ripple effect here. Yes, you target the Bitcoin
- 48:55mining industry, but if you're successful in pushing them out,
- 48:58like it doesn't only affect the Bitcoin mining industry.
- 49:01Think about the electrical infrastructure that's being
- 49:04built to supply electricity to these Bitcoin miners.
- 49:08I mean, you're talking about a lot of heavy construction jobs,
- 49:12a lot of electrical engineering jobs, a lot of jobs within ERCOT
- 49:18On the pricing side of things like this is not confined to
- 49:22people that plug in and operate ASICS.
- 49:25Like there's a very interconnected industry growing
- 49:29around just the the production of Bitcoin via Bitcoin mining.
- 49:33It's not only going to affect Bitcoin or something like
- 49:37gigawatts worth of capacity in line.
- 49:40And ERCOT is working hard to get the construction teams and
- 49:44electrical engineers in place to build out that infrastructure.
- 49:47If you were to levy this excise tax, all that would be rendered
- 49:50moot overnight and you'd have to fire a bunch of people that are
- 49:54outside of the Bitcoin mining industry.
- 49:57Yeah, you know, I. Think about Texas and freedom
- 50:00loving. You know another place?
- 50:01It's pretty. Freedom loving is the City of
- 50:03Brotherly Love, Delphia. Yeah, we gotta give.
- 50:08You guys, a huge shout out with the launch of branches.
- 50:11I swear probably 40% of like inbound last week was from
- 50:14individuals living in Philadelphia interested in
- 50:17getting involved, meeting the team participating help it out,
- 50:21which is really cool to see and it was people from across the
- 50:24spectrum, people that are stacking Sats to executives at
- 50:27companies. So we got our John friends and
- 50:30and Jackson who lives in Philly along with our advisor working
- 50:33on some special stuff for I think the April meet up and then
- 50:36maybe some stuff this summer. Yeah, I mean, despite what many
- 50:41will say about Philadelphia, that spirit of freedom that was
- 50:45imbued in the city during the American Revolution still exist.
- 50:48It's a little faint. It's a faint flame, but it can
- 50:51be. It can be harnessed and it could
- 50:55grow. Marty, would you say New England
- 50:58or Philadelphia cares more about freedom and patriotism?
- 51:05Philadelphia. I see.
- 51:08I had to throw out the Philly props because, you know, we kind
- 51:11of we rag on it a lot. You see the pictures of the
- 51:13zombies on Twitter, so there's a lot to rag.
- 51:15On There's a lot to rag on. We got we got to be objective
- 51:18about the state, the city and what's going on.
- 51:21But I have hope that that flame again, that flame exists in the
- 51:25bellies of of many Philadelphians.
- 51:28Maybe not at all. But many.
- 51:29We we joke with Jackson. Because he goes to Dubai, We're
- 51:31always like, he's never going to come back.
- 51:33You go from the streets of Philadelphia to Dubai, you know,
- 51:35like, what am I doing? Another Philly song on the
- 51:38streets of Philadelphia. Yeah, we'll see.
- 51:44We're going to save Philly. Philly's going to save itself.
- 51:46It's a it's a very hardened population.
- 51:51Well, that's the. That's the positive threat of
- 51:52what we just talked about TBC. It's like not who.
- 51:56It's not you then who step up. You form, you go to the John,
- 51:59you become part of the industry, you saving them a better form of
- 52:01money and you have a fighting chance to fix stuff.
- 52:05Yeah, yeah. I don't think the buying, I
- 52:09don't think this excise tax is going to get through.
- 52:13States will stand up. And even if it does get through,
- 52:15I could see states like Texas and Tennessee being like, yeah,
- 52:18you don't have to pay that. If the federal government comes
- 52:19and tries to shut it down, we'll we'll protect you.
- 52:24That's interesting. Angle you're.
- 52:27Not going to get those. Moonshine, moonshine, Moonshine.
- 52:30Miners down in down in Texas. People to seriously consider
- 52:34it's just like, what are you doing with this tax money?
- 52:36You're gonna tax me 30%? And then what do we Let's look
- 52:40at the national debt. Let's look at your revenues,
- 52:42Let's look at the interest expense on that debt.
- 52:44Let's look at the result of you issuing this debt, taking that
- 52:47money in and then allocating it. Is it really, really producing a
- 52:51good outcome? Like, no.
- 52:53Like, I think as American citizens, we need to begin
- 52:55seriously thinking about, like, what are we getting for our tax
- 52:58dollars? Why do we even need to pay
- 52:59taxes? You can print the money.
- 53:01Is this a big humiliation ritual?
- 53:03I think. A big I think.
- 53:05Buchelli had, I think. Didn't Buchelli have a a talk
- 53:09about it? He did, yeah.
- 53:10At CPAC, he was basically he he basically gave him the playbook.
- 53:14He's like you. You pay taxes.
- 53:16It's a humiliation ritual. They can just print the money.
- 53:18This is why inflation's going crazy and they're gonna have to
- 53:21print a lot more money. I mean, again, CPI is high.
- 53:24Jesse, I'm interested to get your thoughts.
- 53:25And then Logan pull up the tweet.
- 53:27I found what's going on in the treasury market.
- 53:31So they're they're changing the like what it can be defined.
- 53:37They're changing the leverage calculations within Basel 3 and
- 53:41taking treasuries out of the necessary assets that you need
- 53:46to count in this leverage calculation.
- 53:48So this is essentially creating an opportunity for limitless,
- 53:52limitless purchasers of treasuries as future issuance
- 53:56begins to surge because they've got to roll over a bunch of
- 53:59debts and then begin paying off the interest they've already
- 54:02accrued. So you basically have the cap
- 54:06coming off of the treasury market.
- 54:08Like it seems like they're tapping out.
- 54:10They're like we need as much liquidity as we can get.
- 54:13All right, banks, you don't need to factor these into your
- 54:16leverage calculations anymore. Go buy as much as you want
- 54:18'cause we need you to. It it's it's more than a full
- 54:22time job just to keep up with how the goal posts are are
- 54:25quietly moved because you know there's there's that there's
- 54:30this latest thing there's the fact that banks are have been on
- 54:34AA0 reserve requirement you know fractional reserve banking
- 54:39model. So nobody had no.
- 54:41Reserve banking, yeah. No reserve banking model.
- 54:46You know they change, they keep changing the money supply
- 54:48calculation. They they changed the
- 54:50methodology for it from that the M2 to M2 SL which which inserted
- 54:56a few ways that they can adjust it without publicly changing you
- 55:03know how it's calculated it'll just show up as at slightly
- 55:07different numbers over time and at first it was the same and and
- 55:11they will have will have the ability to pull these levers
- 55:13over time to manipulate what they have to show in terms of
- 55:18the money supply numbers that they are obligated to report.
- 55:22And three examples are just endless supply of like goal post
- 55:27shifting stuff, you know and like BTFP and all the other
- 55:31acronyms that they're managing to put out to have off balance
- 55:35sheet expansion of you know of central bank balance sheets.
- 55:41Sounds like Aetherium when you're describing the inflation,
- 55:46it's like how it's really that, right?
- 55:48It's just like security after through sufficient.
- 55:50Complexity. Yeah.
- 55:53I mean. This is far beyond sufficient
- 55:56complexity. This is.
- 55:58A. Rube Goldberg machine that would
- 56:00make Rude Goldberg blush The the US financial system and the
- 56:04banking system it's. The best we've got.
- 56:08What was it like? Was it Egypt that just like,
- 56:10completely? Was it Egypt Debugged.
- 56:13Yeah, it, it manipulated interest rates and they had a
- 56:1650% devaluation overnight and what can?
- 56:19Go wrong here when you're incentivizing bankers to then go
- 56:23buy treasuries again, and then you know if inflation does go up
- 56:29and you do have to raise rates. You're gonna have.
- 56:32Underwater banks again, we're just rinse and repeat what we
- 56:35just went through. Well, that's the.
- 56:37Big question right now it's because inflation is still going
- 56:41up with rates high. They've signalled that they want
- 56:43to lower rates and now like this seems, which is interesting too
- 56:49because it's Basil 3, which is international reserve laws.
- 56:54So it seems like the global banking system's like, ah, fuck,
- 56:57like we kind of do something here And like, So what happens,
- 57:00like you do, you take this out of leverage ratio so you can
- 57:03actually like for right now like buying a bunch of treasuries
- 57:08like adds to that ratio. After this gets passed, it's
- 57:11like, all right, you essentially had what we deemed as high
- 57:15leverage yesterday, not as high leverage anymore.
- 57:17And so you just sort of shove it under the radar and let people
- 57:21shovel into this, Mitch, to your point.
- 57:23What's gonna happen is they're gonna just like flood the market
- 57:30with liquidity and Dr. asset prices up.
- 57:32And it seems like a Hail Mary to by the Fed and the international
- 57:36bankers to like be like we just need to get these asset prices
- 57:39up so people think they're rich And I don't see how this ends
- 57:44well at all. I was just laughing because,
- 57:48like, none of this stuff should be controversial or like Tinfoil
- 57:51Hattie. And it is because it's just
- 57:53numbers. And I was thinking about like
- 57:55all in. I was like, those guys are
- 57:56smart. They should talk about it.
- 57:57And if you go down the list of those guys, like one of them
- 57:59knows it but can't say it because he made his money in the
- 58:01world. So he has to play the game.
- 58:02And then you start going around and some of them know it all the
- 58:04way back to, like, you go to that archetype that's like, Oh
- 58:06no, everything's fine. It can never blow up.
- 58:09And that's just how we, like, look at the world.
- 58:11It's like some people know, but they're like, I made the money
- 58:13here. It'll all get figured out.
- 58:14And then you go back and it's like, you know, it's to somebody
- 58:16else. And they're like, oh, yeah, this
- 58:18is like, this is crazy. Like, how could the government
- 58:20and the dollar and all the things that, you know, people
- 58:22talk about with the integrity of it ever happened?
- 58:26And there's just not like an earn.
- 58:27I don't know, just like working through like, this is not that
- 58:30hard to understand, that it's not sustainable.
- 58:32For some reason, if somebody listened to this, it was not
- 58:35initiated into like Bitcoin or understanding that there's some
- 58:38value around it would think that what Marty or we just talked
- 58:41about the past 3 minutes or 5 minutes is absolutely insane.
- 58:46Yeah, and there's not a lot to talk about this either.
- 58:48So this is like one of those. Things.
- 58:51No, I mean even from like, like the Wall Street Journal, like,
- 58:54like, all in guys. Like they'll touch that third
- 58:56rail every once in a while, even though I want to consider it a
- 58:58third rail. But they'll go where other
- 59:02people won't. Like the fact that they're not
- 59:03talking about it, nobody else is.
- 59:05It's this guy, the the Fed guy. Like like hey guys, did you
- 59:08notice this is going on and? I mean, I I put out a, you know,
- 59:14a national debt article about a year ago and and they pulled it
- 59:19up on the All In podcast, the charts from it.
- 59:22And Chamath said this is a nothing, this doesn't matter.
- 59:28This is fine. This is fine.
- 59:30We're actually going to go issue 100 year bonds.
- 59:32That's what we should do, yeah. I mean his his point of view is
- 59:41I, you know I think, I think it's easy it's easy to like tell
- 59:44yourself that oh this is a a cherry picking of data and like
- 59:48oh if you look at this on a like a GDP adjusted basis it's it's
- 59:53all, it's all fine, we're still, you know we're still growing but
- 59:57then you show that chart and you you show the fact that debt to
- 1:00:01GDP is now 130%. And and Lynn Alden has done some
- 1:00:07great work on how when you get above 100% that tends to be kind
- 1:00:11of the death spiral where like countries don't get out of that
- 1:00:14they don't they don't dig out of that hole they that eventually
- 1:00:19is a one way train to a a soft default usually on through
- 1:00:26through inflation of defaulting on the debts and even that I
- 1:00:33think from Chamas point of view is like well that's fine because
- 1:00:37we're still the the best country and people are going to want our
- 1:00:40debt. That was really his.
- 1:00:41His take is people want our debt.
- 1:00:43People are are hungry for our debt, hungrier now than ever
- 1:00:46which is in my opinion pretty myopic because yeah, it's the
- 1:00:51as, as I guess as Greg Foss likes to say, it's the US dollar
- 1:00:56is the the the best looking horse at the glue factory.
- 1:00:59It's you know it's stronger than the competition.
- 1:01:05But none of them are good because they're all Fiat based
- 1:01:07and they all have enjoyed several decades of running up
- 1:01:11debts that that nobody's has any intention of ever paying, and
- 1:01:17the bill is going to come due eventually.
- 1:01:20And meanwhile, simultaneously, there are scarce assets like
- 1:01:25gold or Bitcoin that can be the escape valve for people trying
- 1:01:31to save who want to not have their savings inflated away
- 1:01:36right from under them. And you know, for some reason
- 1:01:41Chamath doesn't see those that that set of facts laid out and
- 1:01:48connect the dots to to show that, oh, we're at the end of a
- 1:01:51long term debt cycle. And the fact that the US is the
- 1:01:55most attractive debt issuer on the global stage today doesn't
- 1:02:01mean that our national finances will be fine.
- 1:02:05Thanks for tuning. In If you're interested in
- 1:02:07exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 1:02:10about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 1:02:14allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:02:18We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey, so
- 1:02:21just give. Credit to Chamath he he's very
- 1:02:23smart. I think he does know when you go
- 1:02:25around the list. I think for sure he knows.
- 1:02:27I think Sachs potentially the problem is it's the whole thing
- 1:02:31show me incentives. I'll show you the outcome.
- 1:02:33And the reality is all of our incentives and we're talking a
- 1:02:35book that we believe to be true and our businesses around it.
- 1:02:38So we could talk about it. At the end of the day he has
- 1:02:40investors. He has a bunch of businesses.
- 1:02:42So we can't talk about these things because they're just like
- 1:02:44completely not kosher from a number of respects.
- 1:02:47Be in the proofs in the pudding. Like it's like he's carried
- 1:02:51Bitcoin since what, 2012, 2014, whatever.
- 1:02:53He like ceded GBTC, like he called it schmuck insurance.
- 1:02:56Smuck insurance from what? Like you know the the dollar.
- 1:02:59So I think he knows what's your point, Jesse?
- 1:03:01Like they anchor around this whole idea that it's OK because
- 1:03:06we are the world reserve currency and so we'll get out of
- 1:03:09it. And there's some some truth to
- 1:03:10that. But I'm pretty convinced like
- 1:03:12him and SACS have an idea. The other side of it is like the
- 1:03:15other side of just the general populace.
- 1:03:17That's like this is all I'm saying.
- 1:03:18It can't happen because they're just like haven't even dug deep
- 1:03:21enough. Forget about Bitcoin just to
- 1:03:23know about like the structure of the US government, its fiscal
- 1:03:25situation. Yeah.
- 1:03:31Like, he's brilliant. Like, I can't imagine.
- 1:03:32Like Chamoth. He's like probably smarter than
- 1:03:34all of us. Like, come on, like, I don't
- 1:03:35think he doesn't. It's like you don't think so
- 1:03:38yourself. So short, Michael, But you don't
- 1:03:41say like I don't. I don't think he doesn't
- 1:03:42understand the fiscal situation or it's untenable and like it's
- 1:03:45because it's just numbers. I think he literally has to play
- 1:03:47a game of being a billionaire and like not getting kicked out
- 1:03:50of the group for saying the things out loud that we're
- 1:03:52saying because we're our incentives are aligned to be OK
- 1:03:54with it, so. So I'll give, I'll give him
- 1:03:57benefit of the doubt in a different way that I think
- 1:04:00explains it. I think he has an incredible
- 1:04:02belief in American exceptionalism and and
- 1:04:06productivity through technology. And I think that that is his
- 1:04:11North Star and that he thinks that that solves everything long
- 1:04:14term. And I I think that that's like a
- 1:04:18very noble point of view and I think it's a commendable like
- 1:04:23very American point of view of like we solve this by through
- 1:04:27capitalism and I think that that you know it's the it's
- 1:04:32ultimately the yuppie elite mentality of like the world is
- 1:04:37great. I have faith in in our
- 1:04:39institutions of capitalism and and the financial system and we
- 1:04:45solve this by doing what we've what we've always done because
- 1:04:49America's great and I. So I think that like, like
- 1:04:52that's the trap that he falls into, is having too much
- 1:04:54confidence in American exceptionalism and productivity
- 1:04:58through technology and generally.
- 1:05:00Like these people are right until they're not.
- 1:05:02Like, you know, it's it's not like, you know, the
- 1:05:05conversations that we're having are are new, you know, yes, you
- 1:05:09know Bitcoin is still, you know, 15 years old.
- 1:05:12But you know the gold bugs were out there saying the same things
- 1:05:15for decades. It's just you know, it's a
- 1:05:17tipping point and are we at that tipping point now I I think
- 1:05:22we're getting there. I think you know bitcoin's the
- 1:05:24exit valve. We have the rails to you know
- 1:05:27even through the through the ETF for all this liquidity to to to
- 1:05:31use that exit valve. When Alden said ETF and and our
- 1:05:35eyes was as an you know an API integration you know to to bring
- 1:05:40liquidity to the you know from traditional finance to the you
- 1:05:44know to the to the to Bitcoin. I think all the stage is set and
- 1:05:48we're just we're just sort of sitting here watching are we at
- 1:05:51that tipping point Jesse have, have.
- 1:05:53You seen this? They haven't told some authors a
- 1:05:54new sheriff in town. I don't know if anybody can see
- 1:05:57it. Logan, should you pull it up?
- 1:06:04There. You think it's here?
- 1:06:06Boy, that's that's funny. That's in the Wall Street
- 1:06:10Journal. I love it.
- 1:06:12Yeah, well, that. I mean this and this also ties
- 1:06:15into like the game theory of Bitcoin.
- 1:06:16At some point, yes, they have to play the game now and posture a
- 1:06:20certain way, but at some point there's an inflection point
- 1:06:24where it flips. And again, if you're an early
- 1:06:27adopter, an early advocate of Bitcoin over the traditional
- 1:06:33debt based financial system, you're going to benefit
- 1:06:35massively. And so there will be a point at
- 1:06:37some point, I believe in the next five years between now and
- 1:06:422030, where these types, the Chamas of the world, are
- 1:06:46basically making a calculation in their mind.
- 1:06:49Like, yes, I've I've had to posture this way for this amount
- 1:06:52of time. But it seems like the the right
- 1:06:54bet to make now is to posture the other way.
- 1:06:57Like it's all fucked. We need to get on Bitcoin.
- 1:06:59And then you you make that transition, you get on like
- 1:07:01Elizabeth Warren. 'S bags are very heavy right
- 1:07:03now, basically, yeah. I'll give Chamath a.
- 1:07:05Little bit credit he when in 20 was it 2020 one or 20/22 to
- 1:07:1320/20/22 when you know the the inflation prints were out there
- 1:07:17and you know there was the signal that you know we were we
- 1:07:20were headed for a downturn sorry it was 20/21/22.
- 1:07:26He he was trying to signal to you know American population
- 1:07:30that you know this you've been you've been children of you know
- 1:07:36a 0% interest rate environment and you know you've got to I
- 1:07:39remember that it it impacted me hearing and hearing his words
- 1:07:42you got to look you know be able to look at your family and and
- 1:07:45know what you're holding and and be confident in that.
- 1:07:47And you know, sure he pushed a lot of specs and invested a lot
- 1:07:51of those companies, but at the same time he did exit and he was
- 1:07:55trying to sound, you know the the, the warning signs that that
- 1:07:57was coming. Yeah, and.
- 1:08:01And the other thing I'll say about Chamath is that, So his,
- 1:08:05his Bitcoin story is pretty remarkable to me.
- 1:08:08There's some article I think in like Vice or something from a
- 1:08:12decade ago about about him getting into Bitcoin.
- 1:08:16And he, he got into Bitcoin because he was on a private jet
- 1:08:20flight from the Bay Area to Vegas with Wensis Caesaris, who
- 1:08:27is the patient zero of Bitcoin in in Silicon Valley.
- 1:08:31And so he got just a A1 on one orange Pilling from like, you
- 1:08:36know, the legendary Bitcoiner who I think probably spun it as
- 1:08:41like this is early digital gold. You have a chance to, you know,
- 1:08:44bet on this new technology and you're going to want to have a
- 1:08:49slice of it and Chamath put, you know, bought a bunch of it just
- 1:08:53as like a tech bet, I think. And so he's been unbelievably
- 1:08:57right and has a huge Bitcoin position and has held on to it,
- 1:09:01to his credit. And I think that that.
- 1:09:05Creates. This sort of phenomenon that you
- 1:09:08often see with like the OG bitcoiners is a lot of them
- 1:09:12don't actually understand Bitcoin, but they were early and
- 1:09:15they were right enough to buy some and to hold it.
- 1:09:18And so in their mind, they're extremely confident that they
- 1:09:21they get it, 'cause obviously they get it.
- 1:09:24They they were early, they bought it, they held it, they
- 1:09:27know everything. But you know the reality of it
- 1:09:30is you can be right for the wrong reasons.
- 1:09:32Like the the the Winklevi twins, their whole thesis is Bitcoin is
- 1:09:37digital gold. And so they bought some when it
- 1:09:40was like $11.00 and they were going to hold on to it until it
- 1:09:45becomes digital gold. And that was enough, like that
- 1:09:48was enough for them to make a billion dollars because they've
- 1:09:51been holding on watching that thesis play out while not
- 1:09:56understanding that Bitcoin is turning into much more than
- 1:09:58digital cult. And I think the same story is
- 1:10:01true with with Chamath and and I think that kind of plants the
- 1:10:05seed of like being very wrong about the the current state of
- 1:10:11Bitcoin and where Bitcoin is headed because you were so right
- 1:10:14in the past that it doesn't matter.
- 1:10:15You don't have to pay attention anymore.
- 1:10:19Yeah, you're going to be forced to pay attention and really dig
- 1:10:24into what's going on here. What's happening, what else?
- 1:10:29What else caught your eyes in in the news this week.
- 1:10:37You're on mute watching the. Watching volatility come back to
- 1:10:39Bitcoin Right behind you, Marty. I know.
- 1:10:42Was a. Was a 71 not long ago.
- 1:10:46We're at 69. Five now, yeah.
- 1:10:49The having it's kind of strange. It's surreal, like the price
- 1:10:53action pre halving. Yeah, we'll.
- 1:10:56See. Who knows?
- 1:10:57Are we above or below previous all time highs?
- 1:11:02Is this a fake out? I guess we passed the previous
- 1:11:07all time high with authority this week.
- 1:11:08We're now still above it right now sitting at like 69500,
- 1:11:13barely above it. But what are the dynamics?
- 1:11:15Typically when we pass the all time high, it's usually like up
- 1:11:19and to the right and you don't say hello to it ever again.
- 1:11:23But outside of 2017 when we went below that but.
- 1:11:28For for that matter, it usually does take a couple weeks to
- 1:11:32decisively breakthrough like the the prior all time high.
- 1:11:36There's usually a pattern of like getting above it, dipping
- 1:11:39back below and then, you know, takes a while to eat through
- 1:11:43that. Everything's a little different
- 1:11:45now, though because of the scale of like net inflows from the
- 1:11:49ETFs, like $500 million of demand a day.
- 1:11:53You know, the the 10X, what we're mining every day in
- 1:11:56Bitcoin demand, eating through available for sale supply.
- 1:12:01Again, I think that, you know, one of the major misconceptions
- 1:12:03that that people fall into is thinking, oh, there's 21 million
- 1:12:06Bitcoin. So what's the, what's the big
- 1:12:08deal with 10,000 Bitcoin being gobbled up per day by the ETFs?
- 1:12:14The truth is there's there's not 21 million Bitcoin available for
- 1:12:17sale at these prices. There's, I don't know, 500,100
- 1:12:23thousand. Like, obviously there's there's
- 1:12:28different nodes of supply as you work up the price chart because
- 1:12:32people become willing sellers as they hit their magic number or
- 1:12:36they start to scale out or whatever reasons.
- 1:12:39But you know 10,000 Bitcoin a day is is a huge percentage of
- 1:12:47of what is available to be purchased at any price point.
- 1:12:55And that again that's a much bigger delta versus what we see
- 1:13:01after the halving where the halving creates like a 2X
- 1:13:03imbalance and and right now we have a 10X imbalance before the
- 1:13:06halving has even come. If if we're, if we're in dealing
- 1:13:11with the same scale of inflows, you know 10,000 Bitcoin per day
- 1:13:15on average at the halving, then it's suddenly a 20X imbalance.
- 1:13:20So in the we're in the past we've been stuck at prior all
- 1:13:24time highs for two weeks because we were dealing with a 2X
- 1:13:28imbalance and that took some time to eat through things.
- 1:13:31I I think it makes sense for us to eat through much faster when
- 1:13:36we're dealing with a 10X imbalance.
- 1:13:39So I I continue to think like it's still up or sideways only
- 1:13:45so long as ETF demand remains where it is.
- 1:13:47Like I like I don't think this is like a a a summer 2019
- 1:13:53scenario like Barty has been scarred by where we pump off the
- 1:13:58bottom and and rip until there's euphoria and then and then you
- 1:14:03know dip for the next several months.
- 1:14:05But I think this is real and sustained.
- 1:14:08Yeah, I think. I think it's like truly a like
- 1:14:10global asset in the sense it's always been global but the
- 1:14:13global liquidity pools opening up like today it was like
- 1:14:16Thailand's SEC approved and then London Stock Exchange or
- 1:14:19approving Etns. So like all of these different
- 1:14:24vehicles or star or countries starting to have want the
- 1:14:27capital to accrue to their country or like we talked about
- 1:14:31the Hong Kong ETF and so like what would change is the main
- 1:14:34question for it to go in the opposite direction because it
- 1:14:37just looks like a one way trade which is.
- 1:14:40Why on on Jesse's point of you know how we normally perform at
- 1:14:44an all time high. You know obviously we did have
- 1:14:47the leverage wipeout you know the you know the first time that
- 1:14:49we you know we we touched on on 69 K again a week or so ago
- 1:14:55feels like a lifetime ago. The I just I'm really careful
- 1:15:02about comparing what's going on right now to to what we've seen
- 1:15:05before because I think in general like you know mistakes
- 1:15:10can be made and you know you think you know something and and
- 1:15:13you know you get you get rugged one one thing I've noticed that
- 1:15:18to pivot for a second and I'm interested for my for Marty's
- 1:15:21take on it is you know in the the equities market I've
- 1:15:25definitely seen a divergent in the the the Bitcoin correlated
- 1:15:30stocks and you know you've got you know your micro strategies
- 1:15:33you know mooning you've got your coin bases up and you've got
- 1:15:38that side of the fence. But I think going whether it's
- 1:15:41going into the halving or some of the other, you know, whether
- 1:15:45it's sovereigns coming into the space or you know a lot a lot a
- 1:15:49lot of heavier money. But your your public miners have
- 1:15:52not been performing the same way and you know have had a lot of
- 1:15:56downward pressure on on their prices and some of that was pre
- 1:15:59ETF. But it it seems to be happening
- 1:16:01again Marty, how do you think that that that affects things
- 1:16:06you know coming out of that having the miner's ability to
- 1:16:09raise money, you know going into the, you know this new cycle and
- 1:16:14then you know post having environment?
- 1:16:17Yeah, I don't want to talk my own book, but that's part of the
- 1:16:23reason we announce and the proposed merger between Cathedra
- 1:16:26and Kunz laden last week. I think up until this point of
- 1:16:31Bitcoin's history outside of micro strategy, retail investor
- 1:16:35didn't really have proxy exposure to Bitcoin outside of
- 1:16:39Bitcoin mining stocks. So historically, Bitcoin mining
- 1:16:42stocks have been that equity of choice or basket of equities of
- 1:16:48choice for retail investors to get indirect exposure to
- 1:16:53Bitcoin. And historically, up until this
- 1:16:56year, I would say the mining stocks had a very simple
- 1:17:00strategy that was tried and true, which is go out, raise a
- 1:17:04bunch of money via debt or inequity offering to the market
- 1:17:08and then buy a bunch of ASICS, increase your hash rate under
- 1:17:11management that you're able to publicize, and then the market
- 1:17:15will reward you by pushing your stock price higher.
- 1:17:19I don't think that is going to work moving forward.
- 1:17:22I think analyst especially and even retail investors to a
- 1:17:25certain extent have begin to better understand these mining
- 1:17:29businesses. And yes, you can go raise money,
- 1:17:31buy a bunch of ASICS, make that announcement and have a larger
- 1:17:35hash rate under management as a company.
- 1:17:37But is it profitable and is it actually returning your initial
- 1:17:43investment of capital in a timely amount of time?
- 1:17:47And it I think it's proving over time that it's not the best
- 1:17:53strategy to just APE and a six increase your hash rate that
- 1:17:56does not lead to the best profit margins and return of
- 1:18:01shareholder equity in the long run.
- 1:18:04So I think moving forward, I'm, I'm not, this is not to say that
- 1:18:08mining stocks are dead. It's to say that they really
- 1:18:10have to begin to focus on revenues and profitability and
- 1:18:13margin much more smartly. And so I think what we're going
- 1:18:17to see moving forward is the separation of the strategy of
- 1:18:21just raise money, accumulate ASICS, announce it to companies
- 1:18:26that are really focused on return on invested capital, high
- 1:18:31margins and optionality in terms of revenue streams.
- 1:18:35So companies engaged in demand response programs that have
- 1:18:40additional revenue from participating in that will
- 1:18:42probably fare well. Those that get Direct Energy
- 1:18:45exposure have the optionality to either mine with Bitcoin or like
- 1:18:51360 mining is out of the Commons.
- 1:18:53They have the ability to mine Bitcoin or sell natural gas to
- 1:18:56market at any given point in time.
- 1:18:58So that revenue optionality being able to go for the revenue
- 1:19:03stream that is going to produce the most revenue.
- 1:19:06Natural gases are high, natural gas prices are high.
- 1:19:08It's like, yeah, I'll sell natural gas back to the market
- 1:19:11over mine Bitcoin that'll make my company more profitable in
- 1:19:13the long run. At Cathedra with this proposed
- 1:19:15merger that this sort of the idea that we went with is how do
- 1:19:20we diversify our revenue streams.
- 1:19:22And with Congress laden, we are able to do that by building
- 1:19:27infrastructure, hosting infrastructure very cheaply
- 1:19:31since we can build it so cheaply.
- 1:19:32Since Congress laden can build it cheaply, you get a quicker
- 1:19:36return on your initial invested capital, which leads to higher
- 1:19:42profit margin in the long run. So Long story short, I think the
- 1:19:46tried and true strategy of raising money, buying ASICS,
- 1:19:50announcing it, stock price goes up.
- 1:19:52I don't think that's the game anymore.
- 1:19:54I think the market now that it has optionality in terms of
- 1:19:58indirect Bitcoin exposure via the ETFs and.
- 1:20:01Stocks like micro strategy, it's really going to force the mining
- 1:20:04industry to to not be lazy with that strategy and actually run
- 1:20:09good businesses moving forward that focus on margin, return on
- 1:20:13invested capital and growth that is manageable you think over.
- 1:20:19The long run, this is probably a good thing for Bitcoin and that
- 1:20:21there's not, you know I'd say I'm sure there will always be a
- 1:20:26responsibility here, but you know over leveraged miners and
- 1:20:29the incentive to to over leverage, you know and caused
- 1:20:34some of the issues that we saw in the last cycle.
- 1:20:36Yes, I. Think this is the market's
- 1:20:39natural forces? Like basically forcing miners to
- 1:20:42be more risk averse with their companies?
- 1:20:47I don't. Know mining anywhere near Marty,
- 1:20:50but like what you just described sounds like this ends up in a
- 1:20:53barbell approach where anybody that looks like Riot looks like
- 1:20:56a sovereign that has access to you know, money, printer and
- 1:21:00energy at 0 cost and then the other side of the barbell which
- 1:21:04is smaller, more modular. Is that correct?
- 1:21:07Like where this all ends up trending.
- 1:21:09I think so, yes, and I think. Just based on what you described
- 1:21:16right. Because like Riot and all these
- 1:21:17are were proxies to get exposure.
- 1:21:19So that's how you could get capital markets.
- 1:21:20But if nobody's gonna address. Why I pause here?
- 1:21:23It's like, 'cause I don't know if it's like barbell, 'cause I
- 1:21:26think it's gonna be like a spectrum of different business
- 1:21:28models, right? Like you can have the demand
- 1:21:32response side of things, the revenue from pure prop mining
- 1:21:37and then revenue from selling electricity back to the grid.
- 1:21:40What we're doing, it's like a different strategy Cathedra
- 1:21:42where it's like we get prop mining revenue with the
- 1:21:45optionality to participate and increase revenues when bitcoins
- 1:21:49in a massive bull run, but we also get that steady revenue
- 1:21:52stream of the hosting and infrastructure fees that we get
- 1:21:56for building out Rackspace and I mean barbell in.
- 1:22:00This sense, like what you're describing a cathedral, is
- 1:22:01probably like 1100, if not more than Riot.
- 1:22:05And so you end up with these like two sides of strategies
- 1:22:07that make up the majority of hash rate.
- 1:22:08But there's no at. All that's.
- 1:22:10What I was going to. Say is like because I don't
- 1:22:14think necessarily, I think it'll there'll be like a wide
- 1:22:16spectrum. I don't think it'll be like
- 1:22:17Barbell where it's like you're either on this end or that end.
- 1:22:20I think there will be a pretty diverse mix of business models
- 1:22:25between those two size of participants.
- 1:22:30Where like you think about it for Cathedra, its proposed
- 1:22:34merger goes through like we have that steady revenue stream.
- 1:22:38And because the return on investment vested capital is
- 1:22:43very short in terms of the capital outlay we do to build
- 1:22:46the infrastructure versus the revenues that pay back that
- 1:22:49infrastructure from the hosting fees like that's what Kunz
- 1:22:52Laden's done up to this point is achieved pretty good scale
- 1:22:56within two years just reinvest those cash flows to build out
- 1:22:58more infrastructure. And so you I think that actually
- 1:23:02like it's a much more efficient way to grow a business.
- 1:23:04It's just to use operating cash flow to funneled back into
- 1:23:09reinvestment of the company and expansion of infrastructure.
- 1:23:12So I think it's again thinking creatively like a new way to
- 1:23:17actually build a mining company to scale without having to
- 1:23:22dilute shareholders massively or go into insane amounts of debt.
- 1:23:27Obviously there will be a mixture of all three of those
- 1:23:29things, investing cash flow, raising money via the public
- 1:23:34markets when the opportunity presents itself and it's is
- 1:23:38advantageous. And then a mixture of debt,
- 1:23:42which would probably be the the smallest portion, I imagine
- 1:23:47would be the smallest portion because we know due to the
- 1:23:51variability of revenue from prop mining doesn't make sense to go
- 1:23:55into insane amounts of debt. The world's changing.
- 1:24:03It is for the better it's. It's good.
- 1:24:07I mean, it's just a maturation of, oh, the mining industry
- 1:24:11again, like the, it was very easy between 2017 and 2023.
- 1:24:19It's probably up until this year to just be like, Yep, we're
- 1:24:22raising money, price, Bitcoin's up, We're gonna issue a bunch of
- 1:24:25shares, we're gonna take in a bunch of cash, buy a bunch of
- 1:24:28ASICS, add it to our PRS, and the companies were rewarded for
- 1:24:33that during the bull market. But they overextended
- 1:24:36themselves, bought too many A6, weren't able to plug them in
- 1:24:39quickly enough, and then during the bear markets like a shit.
- 1:24:41This actually isn't that great of a business.
- 1:24:49Hope that answered your. Question, Mitch.
- 1:24:51It did. I I've learned a a remarkable
- 1:24:54amount on the mining industry from you in you know TFTC over
- 1:24:57the last couple months. So I appreciate it.
- 1:25:01These are just my thoughts. I'm sure there are many in the
- 1:25:03mining industry that will have different, but that's what like
- 1:25:06Michael, to your point about the barbell, I mean that's what Fred
- 1:25:09Teal is really pushing right now.
- 1:25:12Like a lot of the big box miners are saying, if you don't have 10
- 1:25:15XA hash of hash right under management before the halving,
- 1:25:18you're not going to have a business, which I don't think is
- 1:25:21true for everybody. Certainly there are many cases
- 1:25:24where that would be true, but I don't think people are actually
- 1:25:26thinking about this creatively and thinking really smartly
- 1:25:29about their actual cash flows and how they're creating
- 1:25:32optionality for those cash flows.
- 1:25:34I don't think they will succumb to go under after the having
- 1:25:40because they don't have 10 XA hash.
- 1:25:42I think there's a lot of posturing from the big box
- 1:25:44miners trying to project like, yeah, if you're not a big box
- 1:25:47miner like us, you're not going to survive and basically trying
- 1:25:49to convince potential shareholders to invest in them
- 1:25:52over smaller upstarts sounds. Like, we need to get Tom and
- 1:25:57Drew on the pod at some point, yeah.
- 1:25:59Definitely. I got I got I.
- 1:26:01Got one more for us on A, it's a totally, totally other angle,
- 1:26:06but you guys see Jamie Dimon this morning saying that he'll
- 1:26:10defend your right to smoke cigarettes and help defend your
- 1:26:12right to buy Bitcoin. And are are we in the midst of
- 1:26:15of one of the, I guess the the the bigger pivots in in Bitcoin
- 1:26:21industry? Yeah, obviously Larry Fink was a
- 1:26:24big one for us. But you know Larry Fink wasn't
- 1:26:27as vocally, vocally against us. But this, this seems like a a
- 1:26:32slight turn, you know, starting to form from Jaime here.
- 1:26:36You know what? Life?
- 1:26:37Was better before the smoking ban.
- 1:26:38So it's nice to see he's gonna defend their right to to smoke
- 1:26:42cigarettes. Yeah.
- 1:26:43Yeah. I mean, it's the slow.
- 1:26:46I mean, think about it. He's the CEO of the largest bank
- 1:26:50in the world. I believe.
- 1:26:51Is JP more the largest bank in the world or just in the US?
- 1:26:54Probably the world. Hideous.
- 1:26:55The world, I would imagine. The world.
- 1:26:58I think. He's he has to back step and
- 1:27:02readjust his priors if Bitcoin is gonna have massive success
- 1:27:05like you don't get your job if you if you're fighting against
- 1:27:09if you Peter Schiff your way towards $1,000,000, I don't
- 1:27:12think that's gonna look good for him I.
- 1:27:15Don't think the 3rd, 4th and 5th order effects of what the ETF
- 1:27:18being announced were not contemplated and known before
- 1:27:23being announced IE the banks like remember Marty we had you
- 1:27:26had a call one one March Chris morning we were in California
- 1:27:31and there was things happening. I think this is like this ETF
- 1:27:34thing was once it's there, it's like all lights go, like banks
- 1:27:38are here that you know what Mitch was talking about.
- 1:27:41They're going to roll back the requirements like custody.
- 1:27:44Like it's just, it's just. It's going to take some.
- 1:27:47Steps. And what that means is very high
- 1:27:50Bitcoin. And then that means that banks
- 1:27:52have to participate and they have to get fees and that whole
- 1:27:55game and you just had to take out a couple of CZS and a couple
- 1:27:58you know little little slap Brian Armstrong on the hand of
- 1:28:01your mind now. But you look like you're you're
- 1:28:03independent just get it all locked and and loaded and you're
- 1:28:07it's, you know like you said things are gonna get weird I
- 1:28:10think like the things that are gonna happen at least like the
- 1:28:14the perceived like oh like now it's gonna get weird.
- 1:28:16It's like, I don't think it's like that.
- 1:28:18They knew the demand before, like we know this, that people,
- 1:28:22institutional investors were interested in BlackRock to
- 1:28:25BlackRock to get exposure to Bitcoin, but they were
- 1:28:27apprehensive because of the market structure.
- 1:28:30So they knew who was going to come in before it was launched,
- 1:28:33right. And so that's why we don't hear
- 1:28:36like from retail because the retail's not buying Bitcoin
- 1:28:39right now. I mean some is, some are, but
- 1:28:42just point of like a lot of this stuff that's going to happen and
- 1:28:45I don't think it's just like going to like surprise a bunch
- 1:28:47of people including banks, the, the.
- 1:28:49Fascinating thing from my like vantage point of Bitco is so
- 1:28:55you've got all you know the banking sector and traditional
- 1:28:58finance starting to wake up to the space starting to build
- 1:29:02their own infrastructure starting to you know if SAP 2121
- 1:29:05gets rid of repealed they'll start doing some of the things
- 1:29:07that bitco does right now the same time your platforms you
- 1:29:12know anyone from you know your your Bitcoin exchanges to the on
- 1:29:15ramps of the world your you've got to stay one step ahead to
- 1:29:20differentiate and obviously you know pushing the the narrative
- 1:29:23of of actually owning your Bitcoin and I'm I am of the camp
- 1:29:26that one day you will be able to withdraw you know your Bitcoin
- 1:29:29from an ETF but it's just a question mark down the road but
- 1:29:34the the same time you've got to keep innovating and staying you
- 1:29:38know those couple steps ahead of the ETF.
- 1:29:40So how do you do it. It's whether it's the multi
- 1:29:41institution custody being you know being an absolutely
- 1:29:44differentiated product and and you know better than you know
- 1:29:47how the the ETFs are are custodied you know to you know
- 1:29:52be building you know products and withdrawals on on on
- 1:29:55lightning which you know even if ETFs were able.
- 1:29:57I think it'll be politically popular not for a couple years
- 1:30:01but you know obviously you you've got the you know the
- 1:30:03chance of obviously the fears that everybody has that the US
- 1:30:06government can go knock on Black Rock store and take your
- 1:30:08Bitcoin. But the same time I I do think
- 1:30:12it will be politically popular to you know to withdraw to you
- 1:30:15know and the black rocks and fidelities of the world are
- 1:30:19going to want to open that up because you know maybe the the
- 1:30:22fees should you know that much higher to actually withdraw
- 1:30:24Bitcoin. There will be money in this and
- 1:30:27I think money is going to drive you know that you know that that
- 1:30:29behavior and I know that's that's not exactly a popular
- 1:30:32point but I I do think you know it's more likely than not that
- 1:30:37you know this sort of closed loop does open up.
- 1:30:41But I I think largely I'm excited for the the innovation
- 1:30:45that takes place to you know that bad, you know rebels
- 1:30:50against you know the the the the traditional you know finance
- 1:30:54route to getting your Bitcoin. And I think we're always just
- 1:30:57starting to see that. Yeah, again.
- 1:31:03It's gonna take time, My neighbor last night.
- 1:31:06It's gonna take nine months, Then it comes in and then we get
- 1:31:09the sovereigns coming in too. The the meeting between was that
- 1:31:13UAE Prince and Bukaylee. Very interesting.
- 1:31:16Very interesting. Wonder what they talked about?
- 1:31:19Very deliberate Twitter post with just from from Bukaylee
- 1:31:24with just the eyeballs looking and that was it in a video and
- 1:31:29that that that's saying something, yeah.
- 1:31:33Here's how you suppose the record.
- 1:31:35We got Saber on yachts with Bezos.
- 1:31:38Oh yeah, I forgot about. That Did you see that, Morty?
- 1:31:43I did. Yeah.
- 1:31:46It. And you know, like I was
- 1:31:48thinking about that recently, that if you're Bezos, you
- 1:31:51probably don't respect a ton of people.
- 1:31:55Anybody. Just generally.
- 1:31:59But you, your peer group is like minds who understood the
- 1:32:06Internet early and and then did heroic things to build a
- 1:32:10business and and make a fortune in that space.
- 1:32:15And Sailor is in that small group.
- 1:32:18So it's Bezos has got to respect Sailor's vision and what he says
- 1:32:24is important. So you know that puts a little
- 1:32:27more weight behind it when you, when you think about it that
- 1:32:29way. Yeah.
- 1:32:32We're. Getting in the Bezos circle.
- 1:32:37I mean, they've been around for a while and what he's.
- 1:32:39Just been market selling billions of dollars in my in
- 1:32:43Amazon stock like I wonder what he what he what is he buying 8
- 1:32:46billion. Dollars worth, I believe well.
- 1:32:49And everyone was watching that thinking it was a top signal for
- 1:32:51the market and it potentially could have been because you know
- 1:32:55they they the, you know a lot of the, you know, the tech execs
- 1:32:58were doing that in 21. You know, Elon was doing it too,
- 1:33:01and perhaps he's doing it, you know, not as a, you know, market
- 1:33:06top signal, but as a, you know, exit valve signal, yeah.
- 1:33:14Jeff you're very well off, man. You've got billions of dollars.
- 1:33:18You've built an empire. It would it would be terrible to
- 1:33:22see you end up poor because you get caught in this.
- 1:33:24They'd. Probably be welcoming here and
- 1:33:27see Jeff if you if. You want to come talk?
- 1:33:36It's just exciting. I don't know.
- 1:33:38We. We.
- 1:33:38Have a pretty full calendar on this podcast.
- 1:33:40I don't think we can fit Jeff Bezos in.
- 1:33:42Yeah, you know what? Maybe next or?
- 1:33:43Sailor. Or Sailor.
- 1:33:44I don't think we can hear him talk about, you know, MSTR
- 1:33:48ripping. If you cancel me next time for
- 1:33:51for Sailor or or Jeff Bezos, yeah, I'll give you that.
- 1:33:55We have a we're. Gonna need the we're gonna need
- 1:33:58we got like the yin and Yang because I I think sailor you
- 1:34:01know is is favorable to Jesse and his charts and his leverage
- 1:34:06them in some of his discussions but then our our good buddy
- 1:34:08Marty and him have a little bit of a contentious relationship
- 1:34:11since the the my contentious it's not.
- 1:34:13Contentious, but I've only had Michael Saylor on TFTC once, and
- 1:34:17it was in 2020-2021, and we basically fought the whole
- 1:34:22episode because he was pushing ESDI was telling him like it was
- 1:34:25deep. 2020, it was COVID, I remember, because it was
- 1:34:27literally like everybody's locked down.
- 1:34:29And it was 2020. One, because he didn't get into
- 1:34:31Bitcoin until 2020. Oh yeah, 21 and then with
- 1:34:35Feinstein, right? Yeah.
- 1:34:37And they yeah, I got, I got attacked.
- 1:34:40I love, I love all, everybody involved.
- 1:34:42But we had we had a gentleman's disagreement.
- 1:34:44He was saying like, just eat the burger Marty.
- 1:34:46Like ESG is good. Like we're ESG.
- 1:34:48And I was like, oh, she's terrible.
- 1:34:50I don't want to be associated with all.
- 1:34:52And for what it's worth, I mean Michael Saylor's Bitcoin buying
- 1:34:54strategy been validated over the years.
- 1:34:57I think my comments on that podcast have been validated.
- 1:35:00Yes. She's complete horseshit and the
- 1:35:02market is running away from it. You don't say it's not a
- 1:35:05currency. He says it's also not a
- 1:35:06currency. So you got to like, look what
- 1:35:08they do and then look what they say.
- 1:35:09And you got to like, take them with grains of salt.
- 1:35:11You can't. You know he doesn't think
- 1:35:12bitcoin's money. I I think he does.
- 1:35:16I think he's, I think he's well. No, I mean.
- 1:35:18It's obvious I'm. I'm joking.
- 1:35:19Like, he knows it's money. He can't say.
- 1:35:21He can't say it publicly. Like he literally can't say
- 1:35:23yeah, and again going back to. What we're saying like Chamath
- 1:35:25and then like had the balls say it, we're in control.
- 1:35:28We're not in there with them. They're in there with us.
- 1:35:30Sack up. ESG is bad.
- 1:35:33Bitcoin's gonna be money. There's nothing you can do about
- 1:35:35it. Get used to it.
- 1:35:38We're gonna win. That's.
- 1:35:39True we we. Straddle the the we straddle the
- 1:35:41line here on some of that stuff. But that is actually like pure
- 1:35:45alpha, like there's conversation.
- 1:35:47I mean, that was a bad trade for anybody that was buying anything
- 1:35:51ESG related. That was not a good trade, even
- 1:35:54though 24 months ago they would have called you like, you know,
- 1:35:57a crazy person. Why don't you care about the
- 1:35:58guy? The environment, Marty?
- 1:36:00I want you to care about equality.
- 1:36:04I do. That's the thing.
- 1:36:05ESG I I read it like it's I sent this tweet out yesterday.
- 1:36:09It was hilarious that over the last five years people have been
- 1:36:12calling Bitcoin a Tulip bubble craze, while one of the biggest
- 1:36:16Tulip bubble crazes was actually inflating in front of them.
- 1:36:18And it was ESG which told you that it was a wise investment
- 1:36:22strategy to neglect reliable energy infrastructure and target
- 1:36:27diversity quotas. Like that's that's how you're
- 1:36:29going to get a return on your money.
- 1:36:31Just decommission all the reliable energy that got us here
- 1:36:34and just make sure your board's constructed to people who do not
- 1:36:37have merit. But check off some boxes, we're
- 1:36:39going to win. Got Marty treated right at the
- 1:36:46end Here they're. They're in here with us.
- 1:36:48We're not in there with them. I'm not going to be apologetic.
- 1:36:50Bitcoin is taking over the world.
- 1:36:52We're going to consume more energy.
- 1:36:53It's going to be used as money. The government is overspending.
- 1:36:56They're wasting our money. I do not respect them at all.
- 1:37:00Bitcoin gives us the tool to just give them the big little
- 1:37:03finger and say this is a you're. Completely.
- 1:37:05Right. You're completely right, Martin.
- 1:37:07But I'm glad that staler is taking the Bitcoin's just
- 1:37:11property. Don't worry about it.
- 1:37:12It's the meeting. It's meeting people there.
- 1:37:15No, no, but it is. It is the meeting the people
- 1:37:17where they're at. Because like, it goes back to if
- 1:37:19Sailor told everybody that, like, then you wouldn't have the
- 1:37:21next. Yeah, you wouldn't get bases.
- 1:37:23On board you wanna? Get bases.
- 1:37:24But we're going back real quick. Just as a funny anecdote,
- 1:37:27there's like. Assumption.
- 1:37:31The world is. Looking for high tea?
- 1:37:33The world is looking for alpha and you just basically say the
- 1:37:37government is messing up everything.
- 1:37:39Bitcoin's here to fix it. Like, if you don't believe it,
- 1:37:42have fun staying poor. We're going to the moon.
- 1:37:44You get part this. Is at the end, so hopefully like
- 1:37:47either we we don't have to club move it.
- 1:37:48Most people won't make it to the IS.
- 1:37:51There's this anecdote and it's great.
- 1:37:54I don't know if you guys feel it, but I I talked to my like
- 1:37:56wife in laws about you know like things going good and you bring
- 1:38:00up all the stuff and I get so excited and and all they say and
- 1:38:02this and they say is maybe they like say maybe or they're just
- 1:38:09very like even keel like you just explain it.
- 1:38:11And in 2021 or whenever this all this stuff started on ramp.
- 1:38:15I brought up all this, all this stuff ETFs and my mother-in-law
- 1:38:19goes, you know, just have a question.
- 1:38:21Could you ever go work for BlackRock or like Fidelity?
- 1:38:24If it doesn't all workout like she meant in the most, like
- 1:38:27compassionate way. It's like maybe this doesn't
- 1:38:28work. Can you go work there right now?
- 1:38:29All I could think of is like what you're saying, right?
- 1:38:31It's like they'll never let us work there.
- 1:38:33They'll. Just like they'll just like
- 1:38:38never let us work. I mean, obviously we'll never,
- 1:38:40but we never think anybody. Wants we never want.
- 1:38:42It's a funny thing. It's.
- 1:38:43Like, it just pulled the clip. They're like, yeah, you know,
- 1:38:46Marty just, like literally went on a monologue about how we're
- 1:38:49all like, it's like, no, we can't, we can't go work at
- 1:38:52BlackRock. Raise your tea levels.
- 1:38:54Gentlemen, come on. We have the truth on our side.
- 1:38:59The truth prevails, I mean. You know, there is a
- 1:39:02objectively, I think, lower tea levels across, you know, all
- 1:39:05populations in the world. So I think that these are just
- 1:39:07acts, yes? I do have to run here.
- 1:39:11I got somebody hopping in this room in 5 minutes.
- 1:39:14Gentlemen, Mitch, we all have to.
- 1:39:16Run before we get cancelled, we're.
- 1:39:18Not gonna get cancelled. That's the thing we can't be,
- 1:39:20Can't be fearful. This is a buttoned.
- 1:39:22Up crowd. Marty, we're we're speaking to.
- 1:39:25We're meeting anybody. Anybody listening?
- 1:39:27Is still here. Loosen your buttons up a little
- 1:39:30bit. Live a little.
- 1:39:32It's gonna be fun winning. Winning is fun.
- 1:39:34It's gonna be incredibly fun. We're gonna have a lot of fun.
- 1:39:37And also. Stay humble, stay humble and.
- 1:39:40Send us notes. It was nice to get all the
- 1:39:41emails from branches. If you're interested in getting
- 1:39:43involved in anything we do or working in the space like, we
- 1:39:46appreciate it. So send us a note, we'll we'll
- 1:39:48respond and get you in touch with the right people.
- 1:39:51Do that. We'll be back next week to read
- 1:39:53your notes. Enjoy it.