Latest / MBA Training Data / Boeing component traceability: pay for the birth record
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Welcome back to Leaders Insights. Track Boeing's component data the way their regulators now
- 0:09Host: demand and why it matters this week. A single screw in an IKEA wardrobe comes in a labeled
- 0:14Host: bag with a part number and if it's missing you email them and get a replacement in a
- 0:18Host: week. A fastener holding together a 737 MAX has, until recently, had worse paperwork
- 0:25Host: than that flat pack bulb.
- 0:26Expert: And that's not a joke. That's a liability transfer. When a part goes into an aircraft
- 0:31Expert: without what the industry calls a birth record, the manufacturing history that says who made
- 0:36Expert: it, from which batch, on what machine. The regulator doesn't chase the tier 3 supplier
- 0:42Expert: who forged it. They land on the assembler. Boeing owns the defect the moment it can't
- 0:47Expert: prove otherwise.
- 0:48Host: So let's pull apart the actual thing they built. Boeing's traceability program. What's
- 0:53Host: the real artifact here? A system? A spreadsheet? What?
- 0:58Expert: It's a chain of custody stitched across roughly 12,000 suppliers. And the piece everyone points
- 1:03Expert: at is the digital genealogy record. One file per component that follows it from raw metal
- 1:09Expert: to installed part. On paper, elegant. In practice, three-quarters of the cost isn't
- 1:15Expert: the software. It's forcing a tier 3 machine shop in Wichita that still runs on paper
- 1:20Expert: travelers to emit clean structured data.
- 1:23Host: Where does that break?
- 1:24Expert: At the handoff, the part number Boeing expects. And the part number the supplier types are
- 1:30Expert: off by a character and the record orphans. Now you have a physical part with no valid
- 1:35Expert: genealogy. Multiply that by millions of line items and you get what DBT Labs, and I'll
- 1:42Expert: flag, they sell data pipeline tooling, so read their numbers as a sales deck until
- 1:46Expert: MIT Sloan confirms it. DBT calls the reconciliation tax, which they put around 30% of engineering
- 1:54Expert: hours spent just matching records that should have matched automatically.
- 1:58Host: You said read it as a sales deck. So what does the independent work actually show?
- 2:03Expert: MIT Sloan Management Review's manufacturing data studies put the honest figure lower on
- 2:08Expert: tooling and much higher on process. The bottleneck isn't the database. It's that nobody at
- 2:14Expert: the supplier is paid to care whether the record is clean because the penalty lands two
- 2:18Expert: tiers up. That's the part everyone gets wrong.
- 2:22Host: Spell that out. What's the consensus you think is dumb?
- 2:25Expert: The consensus is buy the traceability platform and you've solved traceability. No, you've
- 2:31Expert: bought a very expensive place to store your confusion. If the incentive structure means
- 2:36Expert: the supplier eats the cost of clean data, but the assembler eats the cost of dirty
- 2:41Expert: data, you've automated a lie with a nicer interface.
- 2:45Host: That's a strong claim. Back it.
- 2:47Expert: Boeing's own remediation timeline backs it. This wasn't a six-month software rollout.
- 2:53Expert: It's been a multi-year effort precisely because the hard part was contractual, rewriting
- 2:58Expert: supplier agreements so the tier three shop is paid for the record and penalized for
- 3:03Expert: a bad one. Once the money moved, the data got clean. Software didn't fix it. A clause
- 3:09Expert: fixed it.
- 3:10Host: Fine. But someone listening runs a mid-sized parts maker, not Boeing. What in this teardown
- 3:16Host: actually works that they should copy?
- 3:18Expert: The one genuinely good piece is the birth record as a single object, not a report you
- 3:23Expert: generate later. A record that's created the instant the part exists and travels with
- 3:28Expert: it. That's cheap to start, and it's the thing regulators now demand you produce
- 3:32Expert: on request within days, not months.
- 3:35Host: And what part of Boeing's approach should they absolutely not copy?
- 3:39Expert: The instinct to make it perfect across all 12,000 suppliers at once. Boeing had to, because
- 3:45Expert: a 737 is one system. A mid-sized shop doesn't. Start with the five parts that would sink
- 3:52Expert: you in a recall. Trace those end-to-end. Ignore the rest for now.
- 3:57Host: Last one. The cost of building this versus ignoring it. Give me the sentence.
- 4:02Expert: Building end-to-end traceability is a known painful number on a spreadsheet. Ignoring it
- 4:07Expert: is an unknown number that arrives the day a part fails, and you can't prove it wasn't
- 4:12Expert: yours. One you can budget. The other budgets you.
- 4:16Host: So the takeaway for a manufacturer this week? Pick your three most safety-critical parts
- 4:21Expert: and write the clause before you buy the software. Pay suppliers to deliver a clean birth record.
- 4:27Expert: Penalize them for a broken one. Get the incentive right, and the data follows for
- 4:31Expert: free.
- 4:32Host: This is for today's episode. Towards Data Science DDBT Labs, Vendor, Data Tooling, MIT Sloan
- 4:38Host: Management Review. Done. Want to know where you actually stand? Take the CDO self-assessment
- 4:44Host: at MBA-training.com.