Latest / The Morning Rundown / Fed Reno Report, a Botched Execution, and Iran's Counterproposal
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I have to confess, I spilled coffee on my notes before
- 0:17[Maya] we started, so if I sound confused, that's why.
- 0:21[David] Wow, strong start, Maya.
- 0:23[Maya] Hey, it's the morning rundown.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya, that's David, and we've got a stacked one.
- 0:27[David] We do, and all of it comes back to one question, which
- 0:30[David] is who answers for it when the system fails?
- 0:33[Maya] Right?
- 0:34[Maya] That's wild, honestly.
- 0:35[David] And we'll keep it plain today.
- 0:37[David] No jargon, no shouting, just what the reports actually say.
- 0:41[Maya] Plain is my favorite flavor.
- 0:43[Maya] Also, my coffee's gone cold, so it's a stressful morning.
- 0:46[David] There's a report on the Fed's building project, there's a Tennessee execution
- 0:49[David] that did not go to plan, and there's Iran with a ceasefire
- 0:53[David] on the table.
- 0:53[Maya] Wait, those three are connected?
- 0:55[David] Loosely.
- 0:56[David] Somebody always ends up holding the bag, or somebody refuses to.
- 1:00[Maya] Huh.
- 1:01[Maya] Fine, I'll allow it.
- 1:02[Maya] Which one do we start with?
- 1:03[David] The Fed one.
- 1:04[David] The watchdog finally weighed in, and I wanna know what it actually
- 1:07[David] found.
- 1:08[Maya] Same.
- 1:08[Maya] Let's start with the Fed building fight.
- 1:11[Maya] Okay, so the inspector general's report landed, and the headline is a
- 1:15[Maya] split decision.
- 1:16[Maya] Big failures, no crime.
- 1:19[David] Right.
- 1:19[David] CNBC's writeup says the Fed's inspector general blamed management and oversight failures
- 1:24[David] for major cost overruns, and it found no grounds for a criminal
- 1:29[David] referral.
- 1:29[Maya] So nobody's going to jail over a very expensive building.
- 1:33[David] Nobody's going to jail.
- 1:35[David] The Washington Post had the same read, that the watchdog found overruns
- 1:39[David] but no evidence of criminal violations after the Justice Department had already
- 1:44[David] dropped its investigation earlier this year.
- 1:46[Maya] Wait, so the DOJ looked and walked away before the watchdog even
- 1:50[Maya] finished?
- 1:50[David] That's how the Post lays it out, yeah.
- 1:52[Maya] Okay, now the money, because this is the part that makes my
- 1:55[Maya] eye twitch.
- 1:56[David] CNBC reported the cost has nearly doubled since the 2020 estimates.
- 2:01[David] It's now budgeted about two point four billion dollars.
- 2:05[Maya] Billion with a B.
- 2:07[Maya] I once went over budget on a kitchen faucet, and I thought
- 2:10[Maya] that was a crisis.
- 2:11[David] And the report faulted the Fed board for not setting price caps
- 2:15[David] and with weak oversight.
- 2:16[David] That's the whole story, honestly.
- 2:18[Maya] Hang on.
- 2:19[Maya] What's a price cap in this case?
- 2:20[Maya] Like a ceiling?
- 2:22[David] Sort of.
- 2:23[David] Al Jazeera reported the report named the lack of a guaranteed maximum
- 2:27[David] price as a significant management shortcoming.
- 2:30[David] With one of those, the overruns land on the contractor.
- 2:33[Maya] So the contractor eats the extra cost.
- 2:36[David] Exactly.
- 2:37[David] Without it, the Fed eats it, which means whoever's paying the bills
- 2:40[David] just kept paying them.
- 2:41[Maya] Hmm, and I'll say it, from a taxpayer-minded angle, that's a failure
- 2:45[Maya] of stewardship.
- 2:46[Maya] You don't need a crime for that.
- 2:48[Maya] You sign a project that size with no cap, you've basically handed
- 2:52[Maya] over a blank check.
- 2:53[David] I'd agree, though the Fed isn't funded by appropriations the way an
- 2:57[David] agency is, so I'd be careful about calling it taxpayer money in
- 3:01[David] the usual sense.
- 3:02[Maya] Fair.
- 3:03[Maya] Still, it's public money in spirit.
- 3:05[Maya] Somebody should have been watching the meter.
- 3:07[David] Here's a wrinkle, though.
- 3:08[David] The White House had gone after the marble, the water features, a
- 3:11[David] garden terrace.
- 3:12[Maya] Right, the fancy stuff.
- 3:14[Maya] That was the whole pitch.
- 3:15[David] Al Jazeera says the report found those did not materially contribute to
- 3:19[David] the overruns.
- 3:20[Maya] Seriously?
- 3:21[Maya] So the stuff everybody could picture wasn't the problem.
- 3:24[David] Right.
- 3:25[David] The real culprit is boring.
- 3:27[David] No cap, thin oversight, which is less fun to put on a
- 3:30[David] cable chyron.
- 3:32[Maya] A missing contract clause.
- 3:34[Maya] Riveting television.
- 3:35[David] But we should be fair here.
- 3:36[David] The luxuries weren't the cost driver, and there's no criminal finding.
- 3:39[David] Those are both in the report, and they cut against some of
- 3:42[David] the loudest claims.
- 3:43[Maya] Totally.
- 3:44[Maya] And yet, the budget nearly doubled.
- 3:46[Maya] Both things can be true.
- 3:47[David] And that's the stewardship point.
- 3:49[David] A project can be free of crime and still badly run.
- 3:52[Maya] Right.
- 3:52[Maya] And a missing price cap is a kind of thing a board
- 3:54[Maya] decides.
- 3:55[Maya] It's a choice, not an accident.
- 3:57[Maya] That's the part I'd want somebody to answer for.
- 3:59[David] Which brings us to politics.
- 4:01[David] CNBC said Trump still said Powell should be forced to resign from
- 4:05[David] the Fed board.
- 4:06[Maya] Even after the report said no crime.
- 4:08[David] And CNN reported he said he'd ask Attorney General Todd Blanche to
- 4:12[David] review the report and decide what to do.
- 4:14[Maya] So the referral the watchdog didn't make might still get a second
- 4:18[Maya] look from the DOJ.
- 4:19[David] Possibly.
- 4:20[David] Meanwhile, CNN says Chair Warsh agreed with the findings and promised an
- 4:23[David] independent audit of the contractor.
- 4:26[Maya] An audit of the contractor.
- 4:28[Maya] That's the first thing in this whole saga that sounds like actual
- 4:31[Maya] follow-through.
- 4:32[David] It's a start.
- 4:32[David] Whether it finds anything is another matter.
- 4:34[Maya] What would you want that audit to answer if you were writing
- 4:37[Maya] the questions?
- 4:38[David] Mostly how the contractor's side of this played out.
- 4:41[David] But I'd note the reporting says the audit was promised, not what
- 4:43[David] its scope is.
- 4:45[David] So for now, it's a pledge, and a pledge is only worth
- 4:47[David] the follow-through.
- 4:48[Maya] And Powell's already out of the chair, right?
- 4:50[David] He finished his chair term on schedule, per CNBC's account of the
- 4:54[David] report, after a judge blocked the criminal probe.
- 4:57[Maya] So it ends in management failure and a lot of noise.
- 5:01[Maya] Okay, that's the sloppy one.
- 5:03[Maya] Accountability gets way more serious in our next story out of Tennessee.
- 5:06[David] Yeah, different weight entirely.
- 5:09[Maya] Christa Pike was the only woman on Tennessee's death row.
- 5:13[Maya] Her lawyer says she was taken to a hospital after an attempted
- 5:17[Maya] execution.
- 5:18[David] Attempted.
- 5:19[Maya] That's the word.
- 5:21[Maya] BBC reported her lawyer says she is being given life-saving measures after
- 5:25[Maya] two syringes of pentobarbital.
- 5:27[David] Two syringes.
- 5:29[David] Okay, and what's her condition now?
- 5:31[Maya] Unknown.
- 5:32[Maya] That's where the reporting sits right now, so we're not going to
- 5:34[Maya] guess.
- 5:35[Maya] This is a developing story, and it was reported on October first.
- 5:39[David] Let's make sure people know who she is, because the name may
- 5:42[David] not be familiar to everyone.
- 5:43[Maya] What the reporting we have says is that she was the only
- 5:46[Maya] woman on Tennessee's death row.
- 5:48[Maya] That's the detail that makes it stand out, and it's the one
- 5:51[Maya] we can stand behind.
- 5:52[Maya] We're sticking to what's in front of us and not filling in
- 5:55[Maya] the rest from memory.
- 5:56[David] Fair.
- 5:57[David] What did the people in the room say?
- 5:59[Maya] ABC News relayed what witnesses described.
- 6:02[Maya] Two rounds of pentobarbital were given, and she still appeared to be
- 6:05[Maya] breathing an hour later.
- 6:07[David] An hour?
- 6:08[Maya] An hour.
- 6:11[David] Hmm.
- 6:11[David] That's a long time in a room built for something that's supposed
- 6:14[David] to be over quickly.
- 6:16[David] I mean, I don't wanna say more than the witnesses did.
- 6:18[Maya] Right, and we shouldn't.
- 6:20[Maya] But there's a part of this that isn't just witness accounts.
- 6:22[Maya] Her lawyers pointed to concerns they had raised beforehand about getting access
- 6:26[Maya] to a vein and about degraded drugs.
- 6:29[David] So they flagged it before.
- 6:31[Maya] That's what ABC reports, yes.
- 6:33[Maya] What we don't know is whether either of those things played any
- 6:36[Maya] role in what happened.
- 6:38[Maya] The lawyers raised them, the witnesses described what they saw, and nobody
- 6:42[Maya] has connected the two yet.
- 6:43[David] And that's why a review matters, right?
- 6:45[David] Because right now, those are two separate threads.
- 6:48[Maya] Exactly.
- 6:49[Maya] A third-party review, by definition, is someone from outside looking at what
- 6:53[Maya] happened.
- 6:54[Maya] We haven't been told its scope, so I won't pretend to know
- 6:56[Maya] what it covers.
- 6:57[Maya] But the obvious questions are the ones the lawyers and witnesses already
- 7:01[Maya] put on the table.
- 7:02[Maya] What happened in that room, and whether the concerns raised beforehand got
- 7:06[Maya] a real look.
- 7:08[David] Which is exactly why the next part matters.
- 7:10[David] What did the governor do?
- 7:11[Maya] Governor Bill Lee ordered a third-party review, and he said the remaining
- 7:16[Maya] scheduled execution will not happen this year.
- 7:19[David] Okay, I'll say it plainly.
- 7:20[David] That's the right call, and it was quick.
- 7:22[Maya] Totally.
- 7:23[David] Look, where I come from, I'm supportive of the death penalty as
- 7:26[David] a lawful punishment for the worst crimes, but that support rests on
- 7:30[David] one idea.
- 7:32[David] The state carries it out the way the law says it must.
- 7:35[David] If the process doesn't work, you've lost the thing you were defending.
- 7:39[Maya] And critics land in the same place from the other direction.
- 7:42[Maya] They've been saying for years that the machinery doesn't work.
- 7:45[Maya] Either way, both sides want it to function as the law intends,
- 7:50[Maya] and a review by someone outside the system is how you find
- 7:53[Maya] out if it did.
- 7:54[David] Outside is the key word.
- 7:56[David] You don't want the same agency grading its own homework.
- 7:59[Maya] And there's the timing piece.
- 8:01[Maya] The governor said the remaining scheduled execution won't happen this year, so
- 8:05[Maya] there's a built-in pause.
- 8:07[David] Which means answers come first.
- 8:09[David] Nobody wants another one on the calendar while the first one is
- 8:12[David] still unexplained.
- 8:13[Maya] Mm.
- 8:13[Maya] We'll see what the review finds, and we'll keep an eye on
- 8:16[Maya] her condition as more gets reported.
- 8:18[David] Yeah.
- 8:19[David] Heavy one.
- 8:20[Maya] It is, and it's a process that failed on its own terms.
- 8:24[Maya] So let's turn to a negotiation where the two sides say they
- 8:27[Maya] largely agree and still can't close.
- 8:30[David] Iran.
- 8:31[David] Yeah.
- 8:31[David] That one's a puzzle.
- 8:33[Maya] Okay, Iran, and the headline on this one sounds like a contradiction,
- 8:37[Maya] so bear with me.
- 8:38[David] Go ahead.
- 8:38[David] I'm already confused.
- 8:40[Maya] CBS News live updates say Iranian state media is claiming the regime
- 8:44[Maya] received a full US response to its proposal.
- 8:47[Maya] That proposal is a ceasefire plus a phased reopening of the Strait
- 8:51[Maya] of Hormuz.
- 8:52[David] Wait, a response?
- 8:53[David] I thought Trump shot that plan down.
- 8:55[Maya] He did, publicly.
- 8:57[Maya] He rejected Iran's seven-day ceasefire plan.
- 9:00[David] So he said no, and then sent an answer anyway.
- 9:02[Maya] Right, and notice who's saying it.
- 9:04[Maya] That's Iranian state media, not exactly a neutral scorekeeper.
- 9:08[David] And the US response hasn't been made public.
- 9:10[Maya] Fair.
- 9:11[Maya] So what's the independent version?
- 9:13[Maya] A Yahoo News write-up says the counter proposal reached Iran through Qatari
- 9:17[Maya] mediators, and it says Reuters, citing a non-Iranian official, reported the two
- 9:23[Maya] sides largely agree on the steps.
- 9:25[David] Largely agree.
- 9:26[David] Okay, that's a big deal.
- 9:27[Maya] Totally.
- 9:28[Maya] They disagree on the order.
- 9:30[David] Of course.
- 9:31[David] The order, that's the whole thing.
- 9:33[Maya] I mean, come on, it sounds small, right?
- 9:35[David] It's not small.
- 9:36[David] Order is everything in a deal like this.
- 9:37[David] Who goes first?
- 9:38[David] Who reopens the strait first?
- 9:40[David] Whoever goes first is trusting the other guy.
- 9:42[Maya] And a phased reopening means in stages, not all at once, right?
- 9:46[David] Right, and that's the catch.
- 9:48[David] If it's phased, each stage has to be matched against something the
- 9:51[David] other side does.
- 9:52[David] Shuffle the order, and one side's exposed for a while.
- 9:54[David] We don't have the actual sequence either side proposed, so that's the
- 9:57[David] general logic, not the reading of the documents.
- 10:00[Maya] And there's more on Iran's list.
- 10:02[Maya] The same write-up says Iran also wants an end to the US
- 10:05[Maya] naval blockade.
- 10:06[David] Plus sanctions relief.
- 10:07[Maya] Plus the release of frozen funds.
- 10:10[David] Hmm.
- 10:10[David] That's not a ceasefire ask anymore.
- 10:12[David] That's a shopping list.
- 10:14[Maya] Yeah, a long one.
- 10:15[David] Back up on Qatar for a second.
- 10:16[David] Why does a message go through mediators at all?
- 10:19[Maya] Because a go-between lets two sides trade proposals without anyone having to
- 10:23[Maya] say yes out loud.
- 10:24[Maya] That's my read of how it generally works.
- 10:27[Maya] All we know from the reporting is that the counter proposal reached
- 10:30[Maya] Iran through Qatari mediators.
- 10:32[David] Here's where I land.
- 10:33[David] The public no and the private counteroffer are two different things.
- 10:36[David] Trump can say no on camera and still be talking through Qatar.
- 10:40[David] That's how a lot of negotiating works.
- 10:42[Maya] Sure, but does the public no do anything, or is it just
- 10:45[Maya] for show?
- 10:46[David] Maybe both.
- 10:47[David] Look, if the fight is over sequencing, then the US shouldn't hand
- 10:51[David] over leverage up front.
- 10:52[David] The blockade and the sanctions are the cards it holds.
- 10:55[David] You don't set those down before you've gotten something back.
- 10:58[Maya] Even if that slows things down?
- 11:00[David] Even then.
- 11:01[David] A deal where one side gives first and hopes is a bad
- 11:04[David] deal.
- 11:05[Maya] Does that make a deal impossible, though, if both sides hold that
- 11:08[Maya] line?
- 11:09[David] Not impossible.
- 11:10[David] It means the real work is finding a package where each step
- 11:13[David] is matched to a step from the other side, so nobody goes
- 11:16[David] first alone.
- 11:17[David] The reporting says they largely agree on the steps, which is a
- 11:20[David] hard part to get.
- 11:22[David] Whether the order can be settled is the open question.
- 11:24[Maya] Though Iran will say the exact same thing about the strait.
- 11:28[David] Oh, absolutely.
- 11:29[David] Both sides think the other should blink first.
- 11:31[David] That's the stalemate.
- 11:32[Maya] And the strait is why a lot of people outside the region
- 11:36[Maya] are watching.
- 11:37[Maya] Reopening it, even in phases, is a big piece of this.
- 11:41[David] Right.
- 11:42[David] But I'll be careful here.
- 11:43[David] The sources we have don't lay out how much traffic is involved
- 11:46[David] or how the phases would work, so I'm not going to put
- 11:48[David] numbers on it.
- 11:49[Maya] And honestly, nobody outside those rooms knows how it ends.
- 11:53[Maya] The US answer isn't public.
- 11:55[Maya] We're working off state media and one anonymous official.
- 11:59[David] Right.
- 11:59[David] So hold it loosely.
- 12:01[Maya] Hold it loosely.
- 12:02[Maya] Okay, that's the rundown on today's three.
- 12:04[Maya] Time to wrap it up.
- 12:06[Maya] Okay, so three stories, and not one of them ended with a
- 12:10[Maya] clean answer.
- 12:11[David] Nope.
- 12:12[David] A building that cost way more than planned, an execution that didn't
- 12:15[David] go to plan, and a negotiation where nobody wants to move first.
- 12:19[Maya] Different rooms, same question.
- 12:21[Maya] Who actually owns the outcome?
- 12:23[David] Right, and I'll say it.
- 12:25[David] Ownership is boring until something breaks, then everybody suddenly remembers they were
- 12:29[David] only responsible for one piece.
- 12:32[Maya] Every group project I ever did.
- 12:35[David] Totally.
- 12:36[David] Except these ones have taxpayers, a courtroom, and a strait attached.
- 12:40[Maya] Hmm, so maybe the thing to watch isn't the headline, it's who
- 12:44[Maya] signs their name to the follow-up.
- 12:46[David] The review, the audit, the next round of talks.
- 12:49[David] Somebody has to show their work.
- 12:51[Maya] And that's a fair test for everybody, whichever way you lean.
- 12:54[Maya] Say you'll do something, then let us see it done.
- 12:57[David] Right.
- 12:58[David] Pledges are easy.
- 12:59[David] Follow-through is the actual story.
- 13:01[Maya] And we'll be here to tell you if they do.
- 13:03[David] Go grab a coffee, Maya.
- 13:04[David] I'm already on our second.
- 13:06[Maya] Third, but who's counting?
- 13:08[Maya] Thanks for listening, everybody.
- 13:09[Maya] This was the Morning Rundown.