Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Innovation vs. Legislation & The Part They Play
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] It is Friday after a really long and great week. Um, it's June 24th if you didn't know about it. Today we're gonna talk about the balance between innovation and legislation.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, it's the people I wanna know. [laughs] Need a catchy little rhyme for a Friday. I got the key. They stop and stare. Yeah, that's... Everybody's like, "Ooh, boy. I can't wait.
- 0:20We're talking about legislation on a Friday. Let's go" [laughs] Couple of light topics for your drive into work. I know everyone wakes up thinking about, "How can I think more deeply about legislation?"
- 0:30Actually, there's a big group- [laughs]... of people that wake up in the morning and they think, "How can I think more deeply about legislation?"
- 0:37And those are, happen to be very, very important people to the automotive industry. [laughs] They really are.
- 0:41You know, uh, i- if you listened to the podcast already from Thursday, you know that one of the primary things that NADA is actually doing is not trying to throw a massive conference every year.
- 0:53But they do a great job at that. They do a great job. [laughs] Not hosting 20 groups, and they do a great job at that. They do a great job at that, too.
- 1:00Actually, the thing that they're doing more often, that has more staff dedicated to it, is actually fighting on behalf and working on behalf of dealers and OEMs, and even the political landscape, to make sure that legislation is in place that protects the dealer, the OEM, and the consumer.
- 1:22It's, it's a really interesting thing that I think, and, and, and rightfully so, Mike said this yesterday, that they don't put on a pedestal, they don't shout from the rooftops because it does, it, it, it has to have a lot of people playing and working together.
- 1:36And it's that, like, ground game in the background, making sure that things are happening on a, on a regular basis to make sure just everything stays moving in the right direction. Yeah. No, it, there...
- 1:48I have to admit, coming to this and spending, you know, several days in the room with Mike Stanton and the Virginia Auto Dealer Association, and I'm sure most auto dealer associations, their primary role is legislation, right?
- 2:01Yeah. Even the state associations, right? The, at the state level, right? And then it feeds up in. And, and I have to admit that my balance has been calibrated between innovation and legislation.
- 2:13You and I get to roll with a lot of the most progressive thinkers in the business. Right. Right? And, and they're always looking over the horizon. They're trying new things. They're embracing new technologies.
- 2:22You got Brian Benstock traveling all over the world, trying to get, like, the, the tip of the spear, right? What's going on everywhere else. So very, very broadly thinking about the industry.
- 2:31So, it's easy for me to lean into the innovation side. Let's, let's do things differently. Let's make some trouble. And, but I know, I know the legislation's important. Yeah.
- 2:39And, and, and especially as marketers and as people that love technology- Oh, my gosh... and we're thinking blockchain and NFT and- We're on social media... you know, how can you do all of that? You know, creators.
- 2:50That, that's where we just, like, naturally move to. Right. Right? Break new ground. Yeah. How can we break new ground?
- 2:55And there's been a bit of conviction put in me this week that I've been out of balance on the legislation in- innovation, you know, pendulum, right? Yeah. It's been swinging too far to one side.
- 3:07And I need to come to a more moderate position because realizing that usually being in the room with the innovators, right, it's easy to downplay the, the legislative side of it. Yeah.
- 3:17Because, like, the consumers want change and all this, right? So it's easy to say, "Let's give them what they want."
- 3:22However, the balance on the other side, the legislative side and the people paying attention to that, can...
- 3:29I realize they can look at the innovators and be like, "Yo, y'all need to slow down for a second and realize there's gonna be no platform by which you can innovate on if it's pulled out from under us." Yeah.
- 3:38You know, I, as you're talking about that, I think about, you know, I have a six-year-old son. And when my six-year-old son gets to a park, his first thought is, "How do I get to the top of anything- [laughs]...
- 3:51and do something that nobody else is..." He's like, "Dad, I'm gonna slide down that slide way different than anybody has ever hit that slide in their life." [laughs] Watch this.
- 4:00"I'll probably do, like, a run jump spin dro-" You know. He's like, "Hold my chocolate milk" [laughs] And, and I'm like, I'm like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 4:06There's some guidelines to make sure- Yeah... that you don't get killed," right?
- 4:09[laughs] And tha- that's, that's kind of this, uh, that I'm, I'm seeing that in this, "Hey, we have to have kind of, like, the roadmap from just an ability to conduct business in order to even do those things, like to be in the metaverse," right?
- 4:27Yeah. Because there are legal things that have to happen to make sure we can conduct business well in the metaverse, right? Yeah.
- 4:33There are legal things that have to happen to make sure that DMVs can structure themselves so that we can do digital transactions. Across state lines. Right. Too.
- 4:43I mean, like you, you were just- We, we talked to some people from Dealertrack that were saying, like, "That is a major issue that we're trying to solve, but it's so hard because every state deals with it differently," right?
- 4:52You know, another, another element to that is, uh, I think... I don't know if it was Don Hall, um, or somebody that said, one of the days we were here, he said that, um, you know, auto dealers,
- 5:06like the Teslas, the Carvanas, they're not the disruptors. They're actually the new entrants- Yeah... to, to the business. The dis- That was Mike Shrep. Okay. Yeah. Mike Shrep.
- 5:16And the dealers have been the ones that have been literally disrupting and innovating this whole time, like, the last 100 years. Yeah.
- 5:23And, you know, spending time in Asheville where Henry Ford and Thomas Edison were hanging out, right? [laughs] Just, just... They, they weren't. They were innovating. Absolutely. Right?
- 5:32And so kind of repositioning that, saying the, the innovators have been retail auto dealers and how to provide the country with a reliable transportation network, um, reliable servicing of their vehicles.
- 5:45And, and basically the goal is the new entrants come in without any rules, right? Because it's new and it's fresh. He says, we... He was like, "We need them to just play by the same rules."
- 5:55And, and so that kind of recontextualized for me, too. Like, the legislation is saying, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. You should be regarded the same way. Your zoning should be put in the same place, right?
- 6:04We can't give you different rules that you can operate on because- Right... auto dealers are still bound by these legislative rules."So really protecting the boundaries of, like, the fair game. Yep. Almost.
- 6:14Well, and but the innovators would say sometimes understanding that, um, that there are rules that were in place because of one thing or another that might need to be shifted and changed. Yes. Right? Yes.
- 6:26And I think that that's what an innovator says. It says, "You know what?
- 6:29That rule was in place, and I see that there was good value in it at the time," and maybe that's, that's the piece or that's the one that has to be shifted or changed in order for us to progress. Yeah. Right?
- 6:40Because the c- r- really the consumer is driving the desire for something different. And- and that's- I think that's kind of the bow
- 6:48you can wrap on the whole conversation is that the consumer desire for something different, for a different way, for to be able to do it in the way they want it, how they want it, is actually what's steering the shift.
- 6:59Because people typically don't innovate things that nobody wants. Right. Right? The innovation is usually driven by consumer desire, consumer demand. Yep.
- 7:07So I think we could as an industry be very careful knowing that the stigma, knowing that people's perception of us as an industry, right?
- 7:16It's a generalization, yes, but still, the perception of retail auto dealers as being someone who's not for them, it's- it's... We- you and I had this conversation. If the general consumer was in the room- Mm...
- 7:29you know, while we were talking about legislation, the mentality would prob- their walk away would probably be, "See, this is part of the problem." [exhales] Right? And that's just true talk.
- 7:40That's- that's a hard pill to swallow. It is, but I think- I think it's real, right? And I don't think that's the intent, but I think that could easily be the perception.
- 7:47Because remember, consumer demand and consumer desire is what is driving the innovation, why the innovators are, or the new entrants, are popping up and have a place in the market, obviously, right?
- 7:59So- I- and, and I think-... we need to walk that fine line...
- 8:01like, we see it as our job, and we think that it's the- the job of the entire automotive industry to recontextualize that conversation in a story perspective to the consumer. Yeah. Right? Yes.
- 8:11And- and that's- that's the b- that's- that's the brand of auto, or that's the brand of any retail industry that has to be set, right?
- 8:23Like, you think about, you know, whenever you group an industry together, like the real estate industry or the auto industry or the mortgage lending industry or the whatever, you know, the housing industry. Yeah.
- 8:33There- there are- there's a brand that every industry carries that is more global and more, or more national, than the individual brands within it. Yeah. Right?
- 8:43And they're- they're always, you know, either working together or working to overcome the o- each other, right? Yeah. Like, I think of even realtors.
- 8:51And I know incredible realtors in Nashville that are- that are amazing, and there is also, there are other, like, global brands of the, quote-unquote, "realtor" that are trying to be shaken up, right?
- 9:04You think of Redfin and Zillow trying to go direct to consumer and- Yeah... and being that middleman because they're saying like- It's efficient, it's cheaper... "Don't deal with a realtor." Yeah.
- 9:12Uh, you know, 1%, right? But- but then you think about the- the- the local, and it's like, "No, I need my realtor to help me with- with- with this process."
- 9:21And so the- whenever a- a global brand is competing with a local brand, until you get alignment on that- That's a great example... right?
- 9:29You don't- you don't actually progress forward and m- and make it so that the consumer believes in the whole thing. We actually talked a- a little bit with Mike Stanton about that, you know?
- 9:37Man, that- that's such a great example because the global brand is more likely to say, "All the consumer wants is this." Right. "They want it cheaper and faster."
- 9:47And the local realtor's like, "All the consumer wants is to feel good about what they're doing because they're scared, 'cause they're about to buy a big thing and obligate themselves for 30 years." Yeah.
- 9:56And it's just the absolutist thinking on both of those is wrong. Yes. It's wrong. I have a- Bingo... another great example came to mind.
- 10:02Um, I have a, a good friend who owns, um, kind of a, a very forward-thinking collections agency, right? Do you think collections agencies have a bad rep? Oh, man. Yeah. [laughs] Right? Right?
- 10:12Like, those people are the worst of the worst. Why? Well, because you have predatory collections agencies. Yep.
- 10:17But actually his agency is thriving, and it's designed around being very empathetic and being very pleasant on the phone and being helpful because he said this. He goes, "Most people want to settle their debt.
- 10:28Most people want to do that." Wow. "There's just... it's just too hard to do it, and it's too aggressive."
- 10:32And it, you know, and so they're developing technology, and they're working on, you know, they have a whole legislative arm that they lobby for. And he gave me an example. He said, you know, I think it was N-
- 10:42N- it was in Vegas he was talking about? Nevada? Um, either way, he said they just passed a law because, um, a politician kind of like said, "Hey, collections agencies suck," right?
- 10:53And people rallied behind him with pitchforks, you know, and torches. Yeah, right. You know, "Let's, let's, uh, take 'em down." And now a hospital, say there's a hospital debt, they are unable to contact
- 11:06the people that have the debt. Meaning instead of going to a collections agency that, that can actually act as a mediator, now their only recourse is a lawsuit. S- No way.
- 11:18So now instead of going through, like, not having all these options taken away from them, which were done in the name of consumer protections, their only option is to just massively start filing, you know, like, lawsuits against these people.
- 11:31So they're gonna get... They're not even gonna get a call from may- maybe a nice friendly collections agency, "Hey, how can we settle this? How can we-" They're gonna get a legal call.
- 11:37They're gonna get a legal- That's unbelievable... they're gonna get a letter and a summons. Right. They're gonna get a letter and a summons. And who's gonna win in that battle? Yeah.
- 11:43And just think of what that does for the courts. It clogs the courts. Oh, wow. And so I think that's a great example- Yep...
- 11:48of like how legislation, because, you know, people think one thing, is actually really in their worst interest. Yep.
- 11:55And- So, so really what it is is it's contextualizing for the consumer why both working on the innovation, the actual consumer experience, the actual interaction on the ground floor, is just as important as working on how to protect them from- Yes...
- 12:10a legal standpoint. Yes.
- 12:12But you have to contextualize both stories, both on the ground level, the regional level, and the national level.So I guess a good question to ask on Friday, right, going into the weekend, um, you had a lot of things come at you this week, a lot of thoughts, right, a lot of things going on in your business, good things, bad things- Right...
- 12:26challenging things, et cetera. What side do you benchmark on? Do you lean toward the innovation side and know, like, "Oh, that's me. Yep, I'm always looking over the horizon and I don't pay attention to the legislation"?
- 12:37Or is your battle cry every morning when you wake up, like, "Let's legislate our way to success"? Whatever side it's on, right, very few people are gonna be balanced in the middle.
- 12:46Let's make this an opportunity to start to learn a little bit about the other side and move toward the middle, because the middle is honestly the only way retail automotive can win. And- Yep...
- 12:56we fully believe we can, right? We talk about this all the time. Like, there's no reason we shouldn't. It is our game to lose. Absolutely.
- 13:04And, and I would say, like, practical steps, if you're not involved in your dealer convention, whether you're, uh, you know, whether you're a salesperson or an owner,
- 13:13do that at the, at the local level, at the regional level, right?
- 13:17And also, if you're not, you know, paying attention to retail or, uh, retail automotive or outside of retail and looking at digital strategies and looking at NADA Digital Dealer, coming to ASOTU Con, if you're not both of those things and looking outside of your own business to understand what's happening nationally, then just press into something- Yes...
- 13:37more of that, because it will have you, help you have eyes further...
- 13:41You know, Liza said, like, we didn't have, uh, the, a, a vision for the future, that we were so dedicated every single month to the month-in, month-out grind of 30 days that we couldn't have our eyes up enough- Yes...
- 13:53to know what was coming.
- 13:54And so make sure you con- you know, take care of your business as it is right now, take care of your customers as they are right now, but have a vision for the future that is both innovative and legislative, that understands the whole scope of the consumer experience and takes care of the consumer.
- 14:08And vendors, you're not off the hook. Yeah. [laughs] Industry partners, you're not off the hook. If anything, we know that you lean innovation. Yep. Right?
- 14:16So you, we're imploring you to also be a part of the state associations. Without a doubt. Go out and spend some time with the folks that are legislative-minded, because you need them.
- 14:27You need to understand them so that you can better contextualize your product to what their need is. Yep. And they need you, and you need them, right?
- 14:35Like, this is, industry partners, it's easy to stand in the tower and build in the tech, and yes, maybe they don't understand what it is to run a dev team and be all over the country- Right...
- 14:44and, like, why an API matters [laughs] and all that. Maybe they don't understand that, but that's okay. This is, this is on you to understand them more. So- You ready? You ready? Yeah. I'm ready. I'm ready.
- 14:53OEM- Representatives Oh, my goodness... this doesn't get you off the hook either. Please, please, please. This says, this means get in the dealers and ask questions.
- 15:03Go to the, the, the state dealer associations and listen to what's happening. Ask the consumers alongside the dealers what they want, not segmented from that conversation.
- 15:13It literally takes all three of those parties collaborating together to serve the customer well, to solve the customer experience. Mm.
- 15:20And not just to solve the customer experience, but to make sure that they are protected when it comes to everything that, that it, that it takes to buy a car. So it takes literally all of us to make sure that we win.
- 15:32Yeah. So there you go. [upbeat music] Let's do a little thought on Friday. We're gonna be talking about a lot of this stuff at ASOTU Con, September 11th through 13th.
- 15:39If you haven't pre-registered, do it, asotucon.com, so we can continue the big, great collaboration. Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. And move the ride. Keep running. Keep running. Keep running.
- 15:57And move the ride.