Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 6)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the alex Acosta interview with
- 0:09the OIG inspectors. Question do you recall that, and this
- 0:15is just do you recall that she periodically would give
- 0:19you in that early period of two thousand and six
- 0:21updates written updates? Answer? I don't. Question. Do you think
- 0:25that it was appropriate for a line USA to be
- 0:28shooting emails updating a case that was under investigation directly
- 0:32to you and your first assistant? Answer? It was unusual,
- 0:35and so did I think of Look, I can't reconstruct
- 0:39what I would have thought, but you know you're asking
- 0:41not just what did I know, but what I would
- 0:44have thought twelve years ago. But I can say, based
- 0:46on the general practice, it would have been unusual. And
- 0:49my best guess as to how I would have reacted
- 0:52would have been, Hey, redacted, this is unusual. Is the
- 0:55chain being fully informed? Our feathers being ruffled? Figure it out?
- 1:00Because you know you asked me early on to characterize
- 1:03redacted's qualities. I think one of the things that I
- 1:06have said is that you was very good at smoothing
- 1:08things over and sort of the interaction because he was respected,
- 1:13and so I might say, that's kind of unusual, go
- 1:16figure it out. Question, but you wouldn't necessarily jump on
- 1:19that chain yourself and be in direct communication. Answer. I
- 1:23tended not to question, would she have sent this to
- 1:27you something unusual if she thought that this was a
- 1:30case that you wanted to be involved in. Answer? Even
- 1:34in those I tried to be, as general matter fairly
- 1:36sensitive to the chain, because I had found that if
- 1:39you start jumping the chain too much, even if you
- 1:41become informed, managers feel, you know, out of the loop,
- 1:45and that's not conducive to sort of allowing them to
- 1:48do their job of supervising. It's a big enough office.
- 1:51You have to empower your folks to do their jobs. Question.
- 1:55So the concern on your part would not be that
- 1:57she was communicating directly to you, but that as long
- 2:00as all of the chain was informed as well. Answer. Yeah,
- 2:04I mean if you are redacted, or you know, if
- 2:06you're redacted, or you know, you don't want to talk
- 2:09to the line attorney before the line attorney talks to
- 2:12your boss, and so it's not just informed, but it's
- 2:14respecting your supervisor. And it's a difficult balance because often
- 2:19really good ausays are also the ones, you know that
- 2:22just want to get things done. Question did you have
- 2:25any reason to believe during this investigative phase that redacted
- 2:29was not pursuing this case, this investigation adequately, appropriately and fully?
- 2:34Answer No, I did not. Question did you feel that
- 2:40she did not have appropriate oversight? Answer not to my recollection.
- 2:44Question okay, did you feel that she had any resource problems?
- 2:49That is, did she have, as far as you know,
- 2:51sufficient resources available to pursue her investigation? Answer to my recollection. Yes,
- 2:57I noted her early. You know, I noted more recently
- 3:00the email where you know that was shared with me
- 3:03by redacted about resource concerns, and I would just note
- 3:07that I would allow the management chain to figure that out.
- 3:10Question all right, did you at any point consider, based
- 3:13on what you then knew, expanding the scope of the investigation.
- 3:17Did you ever suggest or propose that, instead of simply
- 3:20looking at Epstein's conduct in West Palm Beach this SIVI
- 3:23the girls, that the federal authorities could use their resources
- 3:27to look at other aspects of Epstein's activity. Answer, so,
- 3:31I think it's important to take a step back, and
- 3:33I was aware of any number of cases going on
- 3:36in the office, and based on what that stage of
- 3:39case was at, I would get more involved. For a time,
- 3:42it wasn't my practice to direct a ussays and how
- 3:45they should investigate or what the scope of a case
- 3:47investigation should be. The Miami office before I got there
- 3:51and after I left, had a reputation for knowing their stuff.
- 3:55It's a large office, it's got good people. I would
- 3:58assume that the aussays and their management would follow their
- 4:01natural leads question, all right, where you will wear that
- 4:04during this period? And by this period, I'm talking about
- 4:07the investigative period from the time that the case came
- 4:10in in mid two thousand and six up until May one,
- 4:14when Redacted put forth her prosecution memo and proposed indictment.
- 4:20During the sort of ten month period or almost a
- 4:23year where you will wear that, defense council for Epstein
- 4:26were reaching out or Redacted and Redacted to pitch their
- 4:29view of how the case should proceed. Answer. So I
- 4:33don't have a specific recollection of who reached out at
- 4:36what time. I would assume as a general matter that
- 4:39defense Council Defense Council were clearly involved before the case
- 4:42came to the office, and so I would assume that
- 4:45defense council would remain involved while the office was investigating.
- 4:50I say that not based on independent recollection. But why
- 4:53would they stop being involved? Question? And is it your
- 4:57experience as a US attorney that it was common or
- 5:00uncommon for defense counsel to approach the line prosecutor and
- 5:03supervisor to make whatever pitch they want with respect to
- 5:07a prosecution answer? Fairly common question, all right? And was
- 5:12it also common for those approaches to be entertained, in
- 5:15other words, for the line a USA and supervisor to
- 5:19meet with defense counsel And did you view that as appropriate? Answer?
- 5:25As a general matter, it was typical. It happened before
- 5:28I got there, and it's probably happening now. Question. And
- 5:31you view it as an appropriate part of the process,
- 5:34do you answer? I think a usays need to have
- 5:37discretion to meet with defense counsel, and defense counsel certainly
- 5:41should be able to present perspectives. Question. There's an outlook.
- 5:45This is Exhibit four, and this is something it's really
- 5:48sort of a point of information here. This is an
- 5:51outlook that shows you and redacted and redacted had a
- 5:55schedule a meeting with Roy Black. Roy Black a prominent attorney,
- 6:02a local criminal defense attorney at the time in the
- 6:04Miami area. This was a meeting scheduled in your office
- 6:07for the twenty third of February two thousand and seven.
- 6:10Do you have any he was he at the time
- 6:14was one of Epstein's attorneys. Do you have any idea
- 6:16whether that this meeting related to Epstein or some other case? Answer?
- 6:20I don't. I noticed that. I don't know whether it
- 6:24was this or another matter. Oh, I'm sure, mister Acosta,
- 6:26you have no idea? Are you guys hip to the bullshit? Yet?
- 6:30And again not even my own words. These people are
- 6:32sinking themselves with their own bullshit. Question but you have
- 6:38not particular recollection of a meeting with him on Epstein
- 6:41and the Epstein matter? Answer, I don't question at this time. Answer,
- 6:47And let me note I think most of the correspondents
- 6:50was from other attorneys and not him, And so yeah,
- 6:53another lie. There's a ton of emails from Roy Black
- 6:56and to Roy Black. Question all right, are you okay?
- 7:01Do you want to take a short break? Answer? Let's
- 7:05what time is it? Oh? Eleven? Question five minutes? Answer? Yeah,
- 7:09so they take a five minute break. Then they come
- 7:11back all right back on the record at eleven twelve.
- 7:15Having broken at eleven, mister Acosto, we're going to move
- 7:17on in the timeframe. I mentioned a moment ago May
- 7:20of two thousand and seven when redacted submitted her prosecution
- 7:24memo of more than eighty pages and her proposed indictment,
- 7:28her initial proposed indictment, which was more than fifty pages.
- 7:32She submitted that by transmittal memo to her entire chain redacted, redacted, redacted, redacted,
- 7:37and redacted, and you, was that a typical way for
- 7:41an indictment and proposed prosecution the memo to come? Answer
- 7:45to my recollection, it was not. And I don't recall
- 7:48that happening in other cases. I'm trying. I'm hesitating just
- 7:52because I'm trying to think through if there's I don't
- 7:55have any recollection of it happening in another case. Question,
- 7:59why do you think it happened in this case? And
- 8:01who caused it to happen? Answer? I don't know. I
- 8:05don't know. Question all right? All right, So when you
- 8:10before you saw it, I don't know if you even
- 8:11knew about it. By reference to Exhibit six. You learned
- 8:15essentially from redacted that the FBI was planning to do
- 8:18a press conference two weeks after that, and redacted told redacted,
- 8:22this office has not approved the indictment. Therefore, please do
- 8:26not commit us to anything in this time. Were you
- 8:28eventually in that email chain? And did it get to you?
- 8:31Apparently by blind carbon because there is no indication you
- 8:35actually get it. Answer right, question, but you advise Alicia Valley,
- 8:40who I think was your press person that redacted hasn't
- 8:45even finished recommendation to redacted, I e. We are a
- 8:48long way off. So did you have any idea why
- 8:50the FBI was planning a press conference on Epstein? Answer?
- 8:55I don't know. If I did, I don't recall if
- 8:57I did. Question how to was it for the FBI
- 9:01to plan a press conference on an indicted on a
- 9:03case that was being indicted at the time of an
- 9:06indictment or arrest without coordinating with you and your office?
- 9:11Answer under redacted, highly atypical question Was he the sack
- 9:15at the time? Answer? He was a sack. He was
- 9:18a sack. I know he was the sack at the
- 9:20time as of September, and I'm almost certain that he
- 9:23was a sack at the time. Question all right, and
- 9:26when you said that we are a long way off
- 9:29and redacted hasn't even finished a recommendation to redacted, do
- 9:33you know whether you had any idea what she was
- 9:35actually submitted in her prosecution memo and that she made
- 9:39a recommendation to redacted. Answer? I can't recollect, but I'll
- 9:43take my words as reflective of If I say she
- 9:47hasn't finished her recommendation, then I assume she hasn't finished
- 9:50her recommendation. Question does that mean, as you look at
- 9:55your own words, does that suggest to you that you
- 9:57were unaware as of that moment that she actually submitted
- 10:01her prosecution memo? Answer? That suggests that I would not
- 10:04have been aware that she submitted it, if you know,
- 10:07because it sounds like I'm saying she hasn't even submitted
- 10:10her memo. Question all right, Answer, we're a long way off,
- 10:15but again this is based on practice, not recollection. Question
- 10:19all right, and when you said that you're a long
- 10:21way off, did that reflect if you recall an assessment
- 10:24of the length of time to get a prosecution memo
- 10:28a recommendation, and an assessment of that or your expectation
- 10:32that even when you saw a prosecution memo and an indictment,
- 10:36it would be a long process before it was approved.
- 10:39Answer so I would assume, and again this is just
- 10:42based on speculating from the way that I write that,
- 10:44I'm thinking she hasn't submitted her recommendation to redacted, and
- 10:48redacted needs to review it. He may you know, he'd
- 10:52probably want to talk to her, say it needs to
- 10:55be scrubbed. You know, this could be this isn't happening
- 10:57next week, et cetera. Question all right, right, do you
- 11:00have any reason to believe that whatever that process is
- 11:03that you were describing would be any different, in particular
- 11:06measure in this case, from an ordinary complex case. Answer So,
- 11:11from my language, I would take it that it's the
- 11:13same process, but that there is a process and the
- 11:17process hasn't yet been followed. Question all right, okay, answer
- 11:23so it would be the typical process in a typical
- 11:25complex case. Question all right, and is it fair to
- 11:28characterize this as a relatively complex case given the legal issue? Answer?
- 11:35I think it is. Yes. All right, folks, We're going
- 11:37to wrap up right here, and in the next episode
- 11:39we're going to pick up where we left off. All
- 11:42of the information that goes with this episode can be
- 11:44found in the description box.