Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 673. The Pee and Poop Episode: How Tracking Your Bowel Movements Can Save Your Life
Transcript
- 0:00With colon cancer, like that's one of those where just detected early, five-year survival rate at stage one when it's still local is like 91%.
- 0:06Yeah.
- 0:08But if you catch it late, your five-year survival rate by the time you get to stage four is 16%.
- 0:15So not too much better than a death sentence.
- 0:18And so time really is the difference between life and death.
- 0:22And it's, I think there's a very big part of our culture that is ashamed of our bodies.
- 0:30I just want to say thank you.
- 0:33The fact that you're here means that you have trusted me with something so valuable these days, your time.
- 0:40And I do not take that lightly at all.
- 0:42So if you're listening because you're exhausted, you're gaining weight for no reason, losing your hair, getting really frustrated, or you've been told that everything looks normal, when you know deep down something isn't right, I want you to know that I see you.
- 0:58I've been where you are.
- 0:59And that's exactly why I created this podcast.
- 1:02My mission is super simple to give you the information, the hope and the tools that I wish someone had given me years ago.
- 1:10So my goal is you get to stop wondering what's wrong with your body and finally start getting your life back.
- 1:18So if these episodes have helped you at all, would you do me one small favor?
- 1:23Take just a few seconds to follow the show, the little button in the upper corner, and then leave a review.
- 1:30Every follow and every review helps this podcast reach another person who's lying there awake at night wondering why they don't even recognize themselves anymore when they look in the mirror.
- 1:41Wondering what's happened to this amazing, energized, full of life person they used to be.
- 1:46You're helping them.
- 1:47And not only that...
- 1:49When you follow the show, you'll be notified about the hottest episodes everyone is listening to and everyone's downloading along with any bonus episodes I dropped throughout the month.
- 1:58Think of it as your insider pass.
- 2:01So thank you for letting me be part of your journey and thank you for your time.
- 2:05Now let's get into today's episode.
- 2:14So we track everything now.
- 2:16We track our steps and our sleep and our heart rate and our glucose and our calories and recovery.
- 2:22But there's one incredible, important variable to our health, which we talk about all the time, our gut.
- 2:29Everyone knows that...
- 2:31Immunity starts in your gut and bowel movement patterns can reflect back to us how our hydration is and our stress and our medication response.
- 2:41And yes, even fibroid function, but most people can't accurately remember how often they went.
- 2:46They don't remember what it looked like.
- 2:48They don't remember when normal bowel movements started to change for them.
- 2:54So today's guest decided to change that.
- 2:58Scott Hickel is the CEO and co-founder of Throne.
- 3:01And we're going to talk about this today.
- 3:03It's a device that clips directly under your toilet and uses AI to automatically track your stool consistency, bowel frequency, hydration, urinary flow, bathroom habits.
- 3:16And I'm just going to come right out and say this.
- 3:18Here's the story.
- 3:19I met Scott at an event in May.
- 3:22And I was so impressed with him and his product that I asked him to be on the show.
- 3:27This isn't a sponsored podcast.
- 3:29I'm not here to like, you know, give you an affiliate code for a product, blah, blah, blah.
- 3:33I am here to tell you about this very unique device where in the world of biohacking bullshit trackers, this one is actually one that's valuable.
- 3:45This is one that is going to help you to improve your product.
- 3:50habits, like your overall habits.
- 3:51And it might even tell you that, Hey, you know what, maybe there is a thyroid problem going on here because you haven't pooped in three days and that's not good, whether you remember it or not.
- 4:01So we, yeah, there, there's a health tracker for your toilet.
- 4:05It's, it's real.
- 4:07And again, before you think like, there's no way in hell I'm going to put a camera in my toilet.
- 4:12We're going to talk about that too.
- 4:14Because it's not a camera looking at your bum.
- 4:16It's looking at your poop.
- 4:17And it's looking at your pee.
- 4:19And it's analyzing it.
- 4:21So let's talk about going to the bathroom today, Scott.
- 4:27Welcome to the show.
- 4:31Dr. Horniman, that is my favorite introduction I've ever received.
- 4:34Thank you so much for having me.
- 4:37Well, you know, I mean, when we met, I was just, I was so impressed with you.
- 4:40I was impressed with your story, which you're going to tell.
- 4:45And I was impressed with the device because let's face it, there's nothing out there on the market like it.
- 4:52So this is really revolutionary.
- 4:54So we got to start with, because people are going to want to know, what is the origin story of this?
- 5:01What made you think I really have to start looking at,
- 5:05at people's bathroom movements to tie that back to their health.
- 5:12So I did not grow up thinking I was going to go into this line of work.
- 5:16Both my parents are doctors.
- 5:18So I actually wanted to grow up staying far away from healthcare because that was like their thing and they're very good at it and have big shoes to fill.
- 5:24So fast forward,
- 5:26I studied engineering undergrad and spent most of the last decade in tech.
- 5:29And some friends and I were talking one night about startups you would love to start, but wouldn't want your name associated with.
- 5:35And somebody pitched the idea of smart toilets.
- 5:37I was like, that's great.
- 5:38Clearly, you would name that company Throne.
- 5:40And stated that, right?
- 5:41Like it's like a perfect name.
- 5:43But then it became this like topic that keeps coming up over and over again.
- 5:46So two years after that, I called my mom and she's a geriatrician.
- 5:50So primary care physician for adults, you know, 65 and I. Yep.
- 5:54And asked her, mom, is there any medical utility to look at people's waste?
- 5:58And that was my first 45 minute masterclass in gut health.
- 6:02And the line she shared that I will never forget was, honey, I stopped moving my phone number to my patients years ago because they send me so many pictures of their poop.
- 6:11And...
- 6:13I walked away from that and she explained so much more to say, you know, when you age, your gut motility starts to slow down.
- 6:18And this is all speaking from her patient's perspective, but she's like, my patients are obsessed with their poop.
- 6:22It's, you know, chronic constipation is one of the number one reason that her patients end up in her office.
- 6:28And so I walked away from that and I was like, wow, you know, if this is something that A, is like...
- 6:34I guess the big takeaway for me were, number one, people intuitively appreciate that there's health information in their weight, which is why they're sending their photos to my mom, their doctor.
- 6:43And number two, it was so common that it changed the way my mom communicated with her patients as like a blank policy.
- 6:48And I went away from that and I was like, wow, it's crazy.
- 6:51Because to your point, we track everything else.
- 6:52We have 50 devices to choose from for every other corner of our health, but nothing giving us daily insights on our gut health, our urinary function, our hydration, our bathroom habits.
- 7:02And the more homework I did, I got deeper into it.
- 7:06I realized you had the opportunity not just to build a health tracker, but someday this will be able to save lives by looking for the earliest signs of colon cancer, bladder cancer, kidney cancer, your reader cancer.
- 7:16Basically, any cancer whose earliest sign is microscopic blood in your waist, be it stool or urine.
- 7:21And that is cumulatively like roughly 17% of U.S. cancers.
- 7:24That's one of the earliest signs.
- 7:26So one in six.
- 7:27So that's what got me into this.
- 7:28And once I realized that, it was like somebody has to do this.
- 7:31This is so important.
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:34Oh my gosh, it's so important.
- 7:35And now with the rise, you know, in our world, the functional medicine, let's say health and wellness world, the gut is talked about all the time, but it's talked about more from an internal standpoint, like what's your gut microbiome balance and the bacteria?
- 7:54And do you have a leaky gut where things pass through the
- 8:00ultimately comes out or doesn't as a reflection of our overall health status.
- 8:08That's absolutely right.
- 8:09The way I like to think about Throne and describe it to people is we are to a microbiome test what your whoop or your aura is to your blood test.
- 8:18So whoop and aura and Throne are devices that measure functional patterns in your health, right?
- 8:24Your hurt.
- 8:25your heartbeat or your respiratory rate, or in our case, your urine flow rate or your bowel movement, consistency and frequency and timing.
- 8:34That's all how your body's functioning.
- 8:36Whereas a blood test or microbiome tests are measuring the composition of different fluids, be it stool or blood.
- 8:44And it's all important, but
- 8:48It's crazy to me that there's nothing giving people an accurate roadmap of how their GI system and urinary systems are actually functioning day to day.
- 8:55But that's not to your point based on memory, which is notoriously terrible, like literally worse than a coin flip.
- 9:04Yeah, exactly.
- 9:05So go through, let's talk about Throne and let's talk about all the different things that it's looking at and measuring and giving us feedback on so people can actually know like what we're tracking and what we're seeing on the app too.
- 9:21Okay.
- 9:22So basically the device you mentioned here, I'm going to pick one up and demo it here.
- 9:28Oh, you got a full toilet.
- 9:29I love this.
- 9:30What a visual.
- 9:30You got to jump on YouTube if you're listening to this, because this is priceless.
- 9:35We have a toilet.
- 9:37Basically, it's a, as you mentioned, it's a camera that clips onto your toilet facing down.
- 9:41So you can see there, there's no way for it to look up.
- 9:43It's only looking down into the toilet bowl.
- 9:45And then we run a dozen different computer vision models that look for four different categories of health metrics.
- 9:51So the first is functional gut health patterns.
- 9:54So it's looking at stool color, volume, consistency, or form on the Bristol stool scale, which is hard, healthy, loose, or liquid.
- 10:01And then you have frequency, timing, or regularity.
- 10:05And then we look at hydration based on the color and cloudiness of your urine.
- 10:09And then we look at your bathroom habits.
- 10:10So that's how long it takes you to have your first movement.
- 10:13That's called time to first evacuation, which is a proxy for constipation or urgency.
- 10:17And then we also look at the total time you spend on the toilet, which is highly correlated to hemorrhoid risk.
- 10:21So we can send you a push notification and say, hey, I not want to spend so much time here, you know, stop doom scrolling.
- 10:27And then the last category is more a men's health thing, which is urinary flow rate.
- 10:31And so we can measure a man pee standing up.
- 10:34the acoustics of a strong stream or a weak stream mapped one-to-one to what's called instantaneous urinary flow rate.
- 10:40And then from that, the peak urinary flow rate is actually one of the number one, most important proxies of process.
- 10:46And so all of that happens in the app automatically.
- 10:49Every time you go to the bathroom, it uses your phone's Bluetooth to know this is me versus Dr. Horniman.
- 10:54And then you get a push notification a few minutes after you leave that says, here's your report card.
- 10:58Here's how hydrated you are.
- 10:59Here's how things are trending.
- 11:00And yeah, that's at a high level.
- 11:04Oh, that is, it's so simple, but yet it's so complex because it's looking at so many different factors.
- 11:10So the camera sees and then basically is sending a message back or using all AI-based software to give that user, and I've been using it so I can speak to it.
- 11:21There isn't a really freaking cool app that now you kind of get like obsessed with looking at.
- 11:26It's really neat.
- 11:27But it literally gives you that kind of feedback.
- 11:30And how it's helped me is,
- 11:32You know, I, oh, I have 100% right now.
- 11:35Look at that.
- 11:36I got 100% gut health.
- 11:38But where it helps me is if I think that I'm hydrated, and I hear this a lot from patients.
- 11:44I want to start with hydration.
- 11:46I think that I'm hydrated, but...
- 11:49maybe I'm really not drinking as much water.
- 11:52Maybe I only drank half of this and then filled it back up and I'm counting that as 20 ounces, but no, I only drank 10.
- 11:58And then that ad literally gives you that feedback on your hydration.
- 12:02So you can say, holy cow.
- 12:03Okay.
- 12:04I got to step it up a little bit today and maybe drink some more water.
- 12:09So that the hydration component is super cool.
- 12:13And yeah,
- 12:14It's important.
- 12:15I mean, if you're not drinking water, water and sleep are the basics, right?
- 12:20So if you're not drinking enough water, then it really doesn't matter how many supplements or biohacking things you do.
- 12:25You're not even hydrated.
- 12:26You're not even at point A to start on your health journey.
- 12:30So yes, it's funny you mentioned hydration.
- 12:33We build this thinking the gut health component would be the most compelling for people.
- 12:38And we do have a lot of users who have chronic digestive diseases who are tracking their gut health and wanting to see how does my body respond to this new diet or this new supplement or probiotic that I'm trying.
- 12:48But the thing that gets people to come back to the app, to your point, every single day, we hear, like you described, it's addictive.
- 12:54Yeah.
- 12:56your hydration score because it changes so much throughout the day based on your habits that day.
- 13:01And so if you are well hydrated, it shows up immediately.
- 13:04If you're poorly hydrated, it shows up immediately.
- 13:07And everyone wakes up dehydrated.
- 13:09So your score starts low every day.
- 13:11And then you get to see your score go up and to the right throughout the day.
- 13:14And who doesn't love seeing their numbers go up every day?
- 13:17Yes.
- 13:18Yes.
- 13:19And I'm only at 51% hydration today, so I do need to drink more.
- 13:22But you're right.
- 13:23And this tracking, so I did a podcast called Biohacking, Bullshit Biohacking, where I called out specific tools that might not be the best choice or even just the stress that comes along with...
- 13:39the trackables, the wearables, and you're always looking and looking.
- 13:43But this one isn't stressful.
- 13:45This one is just like, okay, I'll drink more water.
- 13:49So it's not like, oh my gosh, I didn't sleep well, so I must feel like garbage today.
- 13:55No, it's just like, okay, I'll drink more water.
- 13:57That's cool.
- 13:58So it's not a stressful tracker.
- 14:00It's funny.
- 14:01Somebody said something similar to us exactly about this.
- 14:04Basically, the way they described it was that
- 14:08Exactly what you're saying, where when you wake up and you check your recovery score or your sleep score and they're low, it really bum you out for the rest of the day.
- 14:19You feel like, oh, I'm not going to exercise this hard today, whatever.
- 14:22But gut health moved relatively slowly.
- 14:25You can't change your microbiome that's weak for months of effort.
- 14:29Whereas hydration moves so fast that there's always something you can change.
- 14:34And it's a very simple change.
- 14:36It's just drink more water.
- 14:38And it's actually quite empowering.
- 14:42I love that you feel the same because that is feedback that we've also heard.
- 14:46Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:47I mean, you really have to be careful with the devices out there and the trackables because they can make you crazy.
- 14:53I mean, they really can cause more stress, but this one doesn't.
- 14:57Now you talked about now let's move from pee to poop.
- 14:59Man, this is a fun conversation because you mentioned the Bristol stool scale and a lot of people don't know what that is.
- 15:07So can we break down poop and can we talk about like, what are we looking for?
- 15:11What's considered good, bad?
- 15:12What is this Bristol stool scale?
- 15:16So the Bristol stool scale was a chart that you see it often in doctor's office, particularly gastroenterologists or functional health practitioners.
- 15:24And it's often presented in like a watercolor fashion where Bristol one is like deer pellets almost, right?
- 15:32Like really hard, tiny little compact lumps.
- 15:35Bristol two is what happens when you bunch a bunch of those together.
- 15:39It's still difficult to pass.
- 15:40Bristol's three and four are the healthy ones, right?
- 15:43Like that's your ideal is a Bristol three or Bristol four, like smooth, maybe some cracks in it.
- 15:49Bristol five is when it starts to get mushy or loose.
- 15:52Bristol six and seven are mushy with some liquid and then seven is just all liquid.
- 15:58And this chart is used universally in the practice of gut health medicine to ask people how to...
- 16:06have your digestive patterns look.
- 16:08That combined with how often you're going is what we call our digestive pattern.
- 16:12And it's also highly correlated to how fast your digestive tract is moving.
- 16:17So it would be intuitive, right?
- 16:19When you have hard, compact, slow moving stools that all the water get pulled out of your colon, your gut transit is very slow.
- 16:26Whereas the opposite end of the spectrum, where it's mostly liquid, it's your body trying to expel something out of your body before it has a chance to fully digest or process because your body says, get this out of it.
- 16:39Right.
- 16:41Right.
- 16:41Okay.
- 16:42So, yeah.
- 16:43You know, obviously we can't control that necessarily.
- 16:47So or can we?
- 16:49So I guess the big question is, let's say Throne tells you that, you know, your poop score isn't that great.
- 16:56Are you also because I haven't had a bad poop score, so I don't know.
- 17:00Are you also telling people what they need to do to kind of change that?
- 17:07So that is such a big question.
- 17:11The short answer is not directly because there are so many just reasons.
- 17:19Yeah.
- 17:19A variety of reasons.
- 17:20Exactly.
- 17:21And so people don't like being told how they're doing nearly as much as they like being told, what do I do to fix it?
- 17:30And the problem is in order to tell you what to do to fix it, we need to know more about what your life looks like.
- 17:36So we built a feature called the gut health coach that you can say, basically, anytime you have a unhealthy bowel movement, that's not a Bristol three or four, then we prompt you and say, what changed in the last 24 hours?
- 17:49Was it, were you stressed?
- 17:50Yeah.
- 17:51Were you traveling?
- 17:52Was it something you ate?
- 17:54And then you can have a conversation with an AI and basically describe like, here's what my life looked like.
- 17:58You know, I had coffee on an empty stomach or I ate, you know, a pizza from a new pizza shop that I've never tried before.
- 18:04And I tried, you know, a gluten-free crust, whatever it is.
- 18:07And then over time, AI will start to extract all the tags.
- 18:12And so it'll tag all the ingredients.
- 18:14It'll tag the days you said you had bad sleep or acute stress.
- 18:17And over time, it compares the days you had any given tag.
- 18:20It's your baseline to be able to tell you these days that I like for me is stress.
- 18:25Like when I tag stress.
- 18:27Absolutely throws my gut.
- 18:29You know, the gut brain axis is very strong in my physiology.
- 18:33And I can see in my digestive health patterns, days that I'm stressed, I am far more likely to have loosened liquid bowel movements.
- 18:39That's just how my body works.
- 18:41And I did not literally, in the 30 years of my life before I started this company, I had no idea that's how my body worked.
- 18:47And then I started using this product that we built.
- 18:49And it's like night and day, for the last two and a half years, it has been true every time I fundraise, when I go home to the holidays, I'm relaxed and life is good.
- 18:58And I only see this because I have these patterns.
- 19:01Just to wrap it all up, we don't give you generic advice, but we do help you run the experiments on yourself to understand what are the actual things that drive my gut health.
- 19:10And you can try a new probiotic or a new supplement or a new diet or a new protocol and see, does that help or not?
- 19:17And if it doesn't, then move on to the next.
- 19:19Because that is so much of the challenge with people on gut health journeys is it's
- 19:25demotivating because you throw so many things at the wall and you don't have actual data to see, am I improving because it takes a week or two to even get to that point?
- 19:34And so we're giving you the tools to do that.
- 19:37So you need like a little Dr. Amy AI agent in there going, if you haven't pooped in a couple of days, check your thyroid and check all of these tests to make sure.
- 19:47Because that's one of the causes is at least we know that.
- 19:51So you had mentioned travel, which that's another I know that's going to be going through people's minds.
- 19:57Like, well, wait a minute.
- 19:58I'm not going to pass this with me when I try.
- 20:00I mean, you could like if you were going for a week or something, staying at an Airbnb, you could pack it.
- 20:06Just don't forget it on the toilet when you're packing up to leave because the next person is going to be like, what the hell is this camera?
- 20:11Oh, these people are freaks.
- 20:13But yeah.
- 20:14But the app lets you monitor your own bowel movements and keep going with it.
- 20:21So you can manually plug in your progress as you're traveling.
- 20:27And then you can kind of get back to it.
- 20:29So it links with your throne then at home to then pick up where you left off, essentially.
- 20:35Exactly.
- 20:35So what we allow you to do, again, going back to my mom's patients who were sending her pictures of their poop.
- 20:40Right.
- 20:41So many people keep pictures of their poop on their phones and they hate having those pictures in their camera roll.
- 20:47And so for those people...
- 20:49You can use the app to take the picture and it'll use our AI to analyze it.
- 20:52Or you can just use a slider and tell it, you know, Bristol 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7.
- 20:56Either way, you can log all of that in the app when you're on the go.
- 20:59You don't get nearly as rich of an analysis, but you do get the basics of your digestive pattern, which is the most important factor when we're correlating against all of the other things happening in your life.
- 21:12Okay.
- 21:12That's very cool.
- 21:13Now, how long, how can you tell people how long it takes thrown to really learn someone's personal baseline to, you know, to tie up with the recommendations?
- 21:26So, yeah, great question.
- 21:27So we need about one month of data to understand your baseline, and then you need to log any given factor five times to know how that factor moves against your baseline.
- 21:38Like stress for you.
- 21:39I see.
- 21:40Yeah.
- 21:40Yeah.
- 21:40Okay.
- 21:41So when you were talking about these changes in like the Bristol stool and our bowel movements, so that camera can really pick up microscopic changes.
- 21:54Does it pick up like undigested food, unusual colors, visible blood?
- 22:00And if it notices something concerning, what's it telling the user then about that?
- 22:04Great questions.
- 22:08Undigested food, not yet.
- 22:09Invisible blood, we are working on that one.
- 22:12Color, yes.
- 22:13We do have color in the app.
- 22:15And we are very careful because we are a wellness device, not a medical device.
- 22:21True.
- 22:21We can't make diagnoses.
- 22:23Yep.
- 22:23But we are very careful to give you an honest, candid presentation of the facts.
- 22:29And then from there, you can have conversations with your care providers as you deem fit.
- 22:34Ultimately, and this is something that FDA has...
- 22:37started to change their tune on a little bit or at least increase the scope of what wellness devices can do in january of this year they released a new update to the wellness guideline which basically differentiates what a wellness device like a looper aura can do relative to a medical device
- 22:51For the first time, wellness devices will be able to say, you should talk to a doctor.
- 22:56And so that's something nobody's doing that yet, but we are going to see how others start doing that before we do it.
- 23:02But that's what I'm very excited about because I think that's a very important end off is anytime we see something that's not right, we should be able to say this needs to be escalated to someone that's above our peak rate.
- 23:13Yeah, no, I love that.
- 23:14I mean, even just that knowledge alone is going to get people to take action and not ignore something that they may have otherwise ignored and put off.
- 23:22And then it gets worse.
- 23:23So actually, that leads me to my next question.
- 23:26Spouses.
- 23:27This one's for the ladies out there, because as we know, ladies tend to pay more attention to their own health and to their spouse's health.
- 23:37Guys are notorious for not really paying attention to their health.
- 23:40So I'm thinking, as you were talking about my husband, is there a way that I can also, do I put an app on his phone and can throne read both of us?
- 23:50Because I want to check his prostate because he won't go get a prostate check at all.
- 23:56So I want to check it.
- 23:58And now that you told me like, wow, this can detect microscopic blood in the urine or even just the urinary flow.
- 24:05Can we put our husband on the throne as well?
- 24:09100%, so you can have up to six members in a household use each device.
- 24:14And so, and the other nice thing is you can have multiple thrones in your home or one here at the home and one at your office and they all go up to your account seamlessly.
- 24:22So very, very cool.
- 24:26And so like I have two thrones here at our office, two thrones at my home.
- 24:30I use it.
- 24:31My girlfriend uses ours at home.
- 24:33And so it's all goes to your account privately.
- 24:35So your husband would have the app on his phone and you would have to look at his phone with him to see his data.
- 24:41Like we don't have a way for him to...
- 24:44I guess he could export that data or share it with you, but we don't have a way.
- 24:47Or you can log into his account on your phone, but we don't have a way to say, give my data to my spouse.
- 24:53Right.
- 24:54Right.
- 24:55But still, that's very cool because I was actually thinking about that.
- 24:57I'm like, oh, I always have to go into my bedroom bathroom that has the throne.
- 25:02But if I have to go pee in like the, you know, spare bathroom.
- 25:06So that's kind of cool that you can have.
- 25:09Multiple thrones to wherever you use it, use your toilet, and it all syncs together.
- 25:15That is very cool.
- 25:16Very cool.
- 25:18Yeah.
- 25:18And six users.
- 25:19I mean, come on.
- 25:20You can look at your kids then, too, and check their health all the way around.
- 25:25All the way around.
- 25:26For the whole family.
- 25:28For the whole family.
- 25:29I love it.
- 25:30So talk to me about different factors, just so people know, because I know they're going to go out and buy this.
- 25:36What factors can throw off going back to hydration?
- 25:39Like the hydration reading, like what about supplements, medication, the color of the toilet bowl?
- 25:47Like what if somebody is using one of those stupid blue cleaners?
- 25:50Great, great, great, great question.
- 25:52So this worked best with a standard white toilet without any of the blue toilet cleaners.
- 25:58because we're looking at the color and cloudiness of your urine in the toilet bowl.
- 26:02So if you have something like a toilet bowl cleaner, that's going to throw it off.
- 26:07If you have some toilets or like the black powder room toilets, or I've seen even like pink toilets, like super cute, but we are not at a place right now where it's going to work with that, particularly black, right?
- 26:19Like black is just no contrast, impossible to see.
- 26:22Yeah.
- 26:23And then if you are on vitamin B, I can throw it off.
- 26:27because it makes your pee very bright neon.
- 26:30And so we're working on updating the algorithm to account for that because intuitively, you know the difference between neon vitamin BP and like dehydrated dark amber.
- 26:42Yeah.
- 26:42Our model should be able to account for that, but we need more training to do that.
- 26:47Similarly, methylene blue.
- 26:48We've had several users write it and they have blue pee.
- 26:54Yes.
- 26:54And that's thrown off.
- 26:56Those are really the biggest ones though.
- 26:57Other than that, oh, and then the last one actually is menstrual blood will throw it off.
- 27:04Right.
- 27:05That is one that we're actively working on.
- 27:07So I mentioned we're working on the visible blood model
- 27:11One of the biggest reasons to do that is, A, obviously, it's an incredibly valuable thing to be able to track cycles passively based on menstrual blood, but also to be able to say this hydration reading might not be accurate because of this confounder.
- 27:25See, I love that you're always improving it.
- 27:27And this is more of a tech question then.
- 27:29So I have a throne.
- 27:31When you do all of these updates, does it automatically update with my app and the throne, or do I have to get a new throne?
- 27:40So great question.
- 27:41So all of the software updates go automatically out live.
- 27:44We're shipping updates every month.
- 27:46We're actually about to ship a very big one next week.
- 27:48I'm excited for you to try out.
- 27:50We will ship a new hardware version in a couple of years just to improve the capability of the sensors.
- 27:55And for that one, you would have to get new hardware, but if you have a thrown today, then you get the best discount we'll ever offer because we want obviously our existing users to have best latest greatest.
- 28:06Okay.
- 28:07That's very cool.
- 28:08Okay.
- 28:09Now, what about somebody running, I'm thinking of just personal experiments where people add fiber, maybe they do remove dairy or gluten, change meal timing, start a probiotic.
- 28:20And then can they actually use the data that they get from Throne to see how that particular behavioral change is changing their gut and their stool?
- 28:32Yes, that is one of my favorite cases is people running exactly those experiments.
- 28:38I had someone write in last week that he bought Throne because he was trying a low FODMAP diet with his nutritionist.
- 28:44And he wanted to see if that low FODMAP diet was helping his IBS.
- 28:49And he ended the email saying, and I'm excited to report it appears to be working.
- 28:53Like that is, that's it.
- 28:58We have made something that is helping someone see it works.
- 29:02black and white ink on their screen, but like my health is improving.
- 29:06I can see like month one versus month two.
- 29:09Like that's, you know, we similarly have users with like one of our users has Crohn's disease.
- 29:15And he showed that he was using a Crohn to track a new medication.
- 29:20He was put on a new biologic that his GI put him on.
- 29:22And you can see clear as day.
- 29:25He went from having two bowel movements a day to having like one a day.
- 29:29And they went through like, they went a lot loose and liquid to like regular healthy.
- 29:32He was like, this is amazing.
- 29:34You know, like my, my doctor's asking me to keep a journal of every time I go to the bathroom and I don't like that.
- 29:40And then even if I did do that, I'd bring a spreadsheet in and like, that's not easy to interpret.
- 29:45It's awesome.
- 29:46So that is exactly the use case that I think is so fun and compelling.
- 29:51Like the wearables use case is obviously like drinking alcohol and seeing how it impacts your sleep or your recovery, your HRV.
- 29:57But like nothing exists to do that for your gut health right now.
- 30:01Right.
- 30:02Right.
- 30:03Well, and then even the flip side.
- 30:04So with the uprise of GLPs and people using them.
- 30:08But inappropriately, instead of appropriately, we also see that constipation, that gastroparesis start.
- 30:16So if you are going to start on a GLP, this is perfect because you can actually start to see a trend if that GLP dose is too high and you're becoming constipated.
- 30:26And when I say, let me back up, because I know the listeners are going to go, I'm going to know when I'm constipated.
- 30:33Thanks, Dr. Amy.
- 30:34No, I'm not talking about that.
- 30:35I mean, just change.
- 30:36You don't, I couldn't tell you how many times I pooped in the last week.
- 30:41I have no idea.
- 30:42I don't even know how many times I went yesterday.
- 30:45So when you have something that's tracking that, then you can step back and go, just like the hydration, like I thought I was doing okay, but this pattern is definitely showing a slowdown that I didn't even realize was happening.
- 31:00So maybe I can adjust my dose a little bit here.
- 31:03That's exactly right.
- 31:04And just on the point of memory, there's been a lot of studies wrote about this.
- 31:10And two studies come to mind.
- 31:12The first, Dr. Satish Rao, who is one of the world-leading experts, most published researchers on constipation, did a study where he asked patients to keep a stool log of every time they go to the bathroom for a week.
- 31:24At the end of the week, he said, okay, without looking at that diary, how many times did you go to the bathroom?
- 31:29And then they compare their guess versus what they actually recorded and they agreed 30% of the time.
- 31:36So that's the first.
- 31:38And then another study asked patients to keep a stool log, but then they put a sensor inside the paper journal to actually keep track of how often they opened it.
- 31:50And then they asked, how often do you think you open this?
- 31:54And patients said 91% of the time I went to the bathroom, it was the average guess.
- 32:00In practice, it was 11%.
- 32:03Oh, damn.
- 32:05Okay.
- 32:06That's really bad memory.
- 32:09Yeah, exactly.
- 32:09But you think about like for something as second nature is going to the bathroom.
- 32:14Yeah.
- 32:15It's just you do it multiple times a day, every day.
- 32:19Sometimes you poop, sometimes you don't.
- 32:20But you're peeing at least on average four to eight times a day.
- 32:25And like, I don't know what I had for breakfast three days ago.
- 32:28And that to me is a far more memorable part of my day.
- 32:31Yeah.
- 32:32Yeah, exactly.
- 32:35So, okay, now we have to move on to accuracy and scientific validation because everybody's going to want to know.
- 32:42Well, I don't know if everybody is, but we're going to talk about it anyways because we're talking about AI, but your AI was trained on thousands of clinician-labeled images evaluated by five board-certified gastroenterologists.
- 32:55So what did human-level consistency actually mean in that validation process?
- 33:01Like the sensitivity, the specificity?
- 33:04specificity, other measures?
- 33:07Like, talk to me about that.
- 33:08Yeah, so Bristol's stool scale isn't measured on sensitivity and specificity because it's a subjective thing, right?
- 33:15Like, you might look at a bowel movement and say, that's loose.
- 33:17And somebody else looks at it and says, no, that's liquid.
- 33:20And for others, you might say, oh, that looks healthy.
- 33:22And then somebody else might say, oh, that looks hard or constant.
- 33:24And so the tool that they use to gauge Bristol stool scale is called interclass correlation coefficient.
- 33:32Basically, if I ask a group of five doctors to go through this list of 100 pictures of poop and assign them a score, one through seven, Bristol stool scale, how often are they going to agree with each other?
- 33:45And this is actually wild to me.
- 33:48Board certified gastroenterologists agree on average about 70% of the time.
- 33:55Okay.
- 33:55That's good.
- 33:57Good.
- 33:57And R&A is as accurate as gastroenterologists in the sense that it agrees with them as much as they agree with each other.
- 34:05And so we're publishing those results at a conference, one of the big gastroenterology conventions coming up here in October, which we're very excited about.
- 34:15Basically, that allows us to say in good faith, right?
- 34:17Like it's the equivalent of having a GI doctor look at your toilet every time in the bathroom.
- 34:22Like that's amazing.
- 34:23It's a horror.
- 34:25Oh, that's crazy.
- 34:26Yes.
- 34:27It's very exciting.
- 34:28Our hydration scores, we are working with a researcher out of Stanford who actually just wrapped up his fellowship at Stanford and is moving on to University of Nevada.
- 34:40But he's working on us to validate our hydration scores and our urinary flow rate metrics.
- 34:44So internally, we can't publish these results yet.
- 34:47We're still collecting the data.
- 34:48But internally, it looks like our hydration score is about 89% accurate.
- 34:52And the real opportunities for improvement are those confounders that we were talking about earlier, like vitamin B and different lighting conditions as well, because obviously it's very different when you're sitting down versus standing up and you have all the ambient light flooding into the toilet bowl.
- 35:05And then the thing I'm most excited about...
- 35:09is the prototype we have in the lab for microscopic blood detectives.
- 35:13So that's not in the hardware we have today.
- 35:16Yep.
- 35:16This is what we're working towards for the future smoke detector for colon cancer.
- 35:21But basically we have a device that images across infrared light, ultraviolet light, and visible light in five to nine different wavelengths.
- 35:30And then
- 35:31runs a bunch of different post-processing on the back end, and is 100,000 times more sensitive than the naked eye at identifying blood.
- 35:41And that's basically on par with the sensitivity of the standard of care fecal and mutal chemical test, which means that you can get equivalent results without having to collect a stool sample and send it off to a lab and wait a couple of weeks.
- 35:53It's just every time you go, you'll get the results, which is amazing because that means that you get...
- 36:00potentially life-saving intervention every time you go to the bathroom.
- 36:03Right.
- 36:04Patterns of bleeding as they emerge.
- 36:06And over time, that will give you way more insight into where the bleeding is coming from.
- 36:12Yeah, that's huge.
- 36:14And not everybody can afford a stool test.
- 36:16I mean, my God, they're like $500, $600 these days.
- 36:19So that's a lot for a one-moment-in-time data point versus an everyday, multiple-times-a-day data point that you can get continuously.
- 36:30I think that's a no-brainer.
- 36:32I appreciate that.
- 36:33So that's what we're building towards.
- 36:34We're not quite there yet.
- 36:35But to your point about pricing, it's one of the things we...
- 36:38are very proud of is how accessible we've made the product.
- 36:41It's $400 plus $6 a month.
- 36:43So it's like an Oura Ring.
- 36:44Yep.
- 36:45Exactly to your point.
- 36:45We wanted to make this something that pretty much anybody could afford if they needed one.
- 36:51and it's less than a stool test.
- 36:52And it's a one-time use and you can have six users.
- 36:55Like, I mean, let's talk about the affordability and practicality of this.
- 36:58I mean, it's right there.
- 36:59It's just kind of a no-brainer device.
- 37:03It really is.
- 37:04Now, you know, everybody talks about parasites, parasites, parasites.
- 37:08I'm going to assume that this does not detect parasites because they're too microscopic.
- 37:14Is that correct?
- 37:15Today, yes.
- 37:16There are some parasites that are not microscopic that I think could detect in the future.
- 37:22Yeah, right now we don't do parasites.
- 37:25And that is something that I, again, that's up there with like undigested in terms of like future opportunities for us to expand into and improve with software.
- 37:35Oh, yeah.
- 37:36And I think technology will continue to improve.
- 37:38I mean, we'll, you know, we'll get to the point where a camera can detect the difference between a little microscopic worm and a food particle.
- 37:46I mean, that's coming.
- 37:47We just need, you know, time and tech to catch up.
- 37:50But that's I would say that's in the near future for sure.
- 37:54So after seeing all of this, you've looked at the bathroom data, right?
- 38:00After seeing all this bathroom data, what has surprised you the most about what our bowel and urinary habits reveal about our overall health?
- 38:14So a few things.
- 38:16I have learned a lot getting into this line of work that I never, a lot of things I never even questioned.
- 38:23And so looking at our own data, one of my favorite findings is that people's clocks, like the rhythm of their bodies shifts later on weekends, which is intuitive.
- 38:37But like we can show it in the data.
- 38:39Like most people wake up and they have their first bowel movement either first thing in the morning when they wake up or maybe after their coffee within an hour or two of having woken up.
- 38:49And then that consistently gets moved back one to two hours on weekends, which is interesting.
- 38:54The mountain time zone in the United States has the healthiest bowel movements of any of our users.
- 38:59Okay.
- 39:01Which is, this is just pure speculation, but I have to assume it has to do with having a very healthy lifestyle.
- 39:09It's far more rural and a lot more mountains.
- 39:12And people go to Denver to spend their weekends hiking and exercising.
- 39:17Yeah.
- 39:18Yeah.
- 39:19And so that is, I think, an unintuitive, but amusing find.
- 39:24And then I think one of the other big things that's been really just changing how I view public health recently is this idea that embarrassment is a clinical risk factor.
- 39:38And I say that because there are studies, it's a causal chain where
- 39:43Embarrassment predicts how long it takes for someone to bring an issue to their healthcare team.
- 39:50And so much of healthcare, time is the leading factor for outcome.
- 39:59From the time you notice something to the time you act on it can totally change your outcomes, especially with something like cancer.
- 40:06Yep.
- 40:07Right.
- 40:08There's a study out of Denmark where they asked colorectal cancer patients what the first symptoms they noticed were.
- 40:16And the group of patients whose first symptom they noticed was blood, on average, waited longer than the other patients.
- 40:25Okay.
- 40:29With colon cancer, that's one of those where just detect it early.
- 40:33Five-year survival rate at stage one, when it's still local, is like 91% of blood.
- 40:38But if you catch it late, your five-year survival rate by the time you get to stage four is 16%.
- 40:44So not too much better than a death sentence.
- 40:47And so time really is the difference between life and death.
- 40:51And it's...
- 40:54I think there's a very big part of our culture that is ashamed of our bodies and has this taboo about having these candid and open conversations about gut health and urinary function and our waste and how they make us feel.
- 41:10That part of our mission is to make those conversations more human, more accessible, more open, more honest, so that people can get in and have the conversations they need to have with our healthcare teams earlier.
- 41:22Yeah.
- 41:23Yeah, that's very true.
- 41:25And that's crazy.
- 41:25You would think that blood would be the biggest factor where people go, you know, oh my gosh, I need to get this checked out.
- 41:33But that's interesting to hear that it produces embarrassment that holds people back instead.
- 41:38Yeah.
- 41:38It's anecdotally, at least of the study was the first I've seen confirmed that with a formal analysis, but anecdotally I've heard that story half a dozen times now, particularly from men who, because going back to your point about so often in American homes is a wife who is taking care of the family's health.
- 41:58Yeah.
- 41:59And there is this stereotype of a strong man who ignores health problems.
- 42:05Yep, yep.
- 42:06No, you're right.
- 42:07Now, when you put it like that, then it all makes sense.
- 42:09That's exactly right.
- 42:11And that's my husband.
- 42:12Exactly.
- 42:12That's why I'm going to have to track his pee to see if he has an alert frosty.
- 42:16Because, you know, otherwise he's not going to do it.
- 42:19He's not going to the doctor.
- 42:21So yeah, realistically, I mean...
- 42:23This is a fantastic intervention for those individuals, mostly men, who are too embarrassed to do something about their health.
- 42:32And like you said, I mean, colon cancer, prostate cancer, gut health that ties to the brain.
- 42:37I texted you, I was running late today because I was interviewing Dr. David Perlmutter talking about the gut-brain connection and Alzheimer's.
- 42:44So this has far-reaching effects into other areas of our health outside of just like, what's my poop look like?
- 42:52Like, no, this is telling you so much about your overall health profile.
- 42:57It's just incredible.
- 42:58That's why I wanted to have you on because I wanted to share this with my audience.
- 43:01So let's just say, you know, whether people purchase Throne or not, which I think they should.
- 43:07We already talked about the affordability and practicality.
- 43:09I mean, come on, it's six people on a device for $400.
- 43:12But what would you say is the one thing everybody should begin just starting to notice about their poop and their pee?
- 43:19Yes, this is a podcast about poop and pee.
- 43:21What should they start noticing about their poop and their pee tomorrow when they're looking in the toilet with their own eyes?
- 43:28So blood, the obvious one for both for P this one I learned in the last six months that it's really amazing to me.
- 43:37So one of the world's leading hydration researchers got named Dr. Stavros Kvoros out of the state university has published a whole body of literature studying how.
- 43:48hydration directly impacts metabolic health.
- 43:52And so there's dehydration, which people misuse the term, you know, myself, but dehydration really is like an acute medical state where you've lost 12 to 15% of your body weight in fluid loss.
- 44:04Like kidneys start to shut down and you should go to the hospital.
- 44:07But then there's under hydration, which is the thing that we've all heard 15 podcasts about where you lose 2% of your body mass and fluid weight.
- 44:15And that is like, you know, for someone who weighs 150 pounds, that's the equivalent of like two coffee cups.
- 44:19That's not very much.
- 44:21And in that case, that has direct impacts on your cognition, your memory, your focus, your stress.
- 44:29And the underappreciated thing is it increases your vasopressin levels or antidiuretic hormone
- 44:34anti-diuretic hormone decreases your glucose response.
- 44:39Or you, I guess you were, you perform worse on a glucose response test, but decreases your metabolic response and how I should probably phrase that.
- 44:47And.
- 44:49He goes on to say that, you know, you were talking about tracking how much water you drink.
- 44:53That is so much work for so many people to track how much water you're drinking.
- 44:56And it changes, too, based on how hot it is outside, how much exercise you're doing, what you're wearing.
- 45:02The suggestion is just track how often you pee and the color of your pee.
- 45:06And as long as you're peeing at least seven times a day and your pee is a three or less on, like, the color scale for pee,
- 45:15then you are 100% likely to be adequately hydrated.
- 45:19Like, there's a test with a sensitivity of 100%.
- 45:24And again, I don't think most people want to count how many times they're peaking a day, but something like Throne,
- 45:31What we see is going back to your feedback about how much it's helped you with your hydration habits.
- 45:36One of the number one things we see is people don't count how often they pee, but they do.
- 45:39If they get a hydration score, that's less than 50%.
- 45:42They think I'm going to drink some water.
- 45:44And so that's just one of the easiest, simplest things you can do to improve your health every single day.
- 45:51And like...
- 45:52depending on which study you look at, 50 to 75% of us are still walking around under hydrated and impairing our cognitive health, our mood, and our metabolic health without even realizing it.
- 46:06And I'm going to pull something out of what you just said, because I think it's important.
- 46:09I don't know if people picked up on it.
- 46:12When you are under hydrated, you...
- 46:16have an elevated glucose or blood sugar response, which then in turn we know will also create inflammation, will increase reverse T3 when we're talking about the thyroid, will impair T4 to T3 conversion, and will cause weight gain.
- 46:35So yes, just you not being hydrated enough and drinking water is free.
- 46:42It really takes no effort.
- 46:43It's not going to take a half an hour of like a, you know, sauna session.
- 46:48And that alone, your hydration status alone can help you in the battle of the bulge.
- 46:56Like you were talking and I'm making this connection in my mind going, holy shit, no pun intended, pun intended.
- 47:04This can literally help people to lose weight.
- 47:09My mind's blown.
- 47:11Yeah.
- 47:12Yeah.
- 47:13That's crazy.
- 47:15The link between hydration and metabolic health, and they tested this.
- 47:19They did this in a lab.
- 47:20What they did is they took people who had good hydration status and they injected them with antidiuretic hormone or vasopressin so they could causally infer.
- 47:32This is not a correlation.
- 47:33This is like a causal chain.
- 47:34Having higher levels of this hormone does impair your glucose response and it's
- 47:42Everybody is walking around just doing this naturally by just simply not drinking a water.
- 47:48Yeah.
- 47:50That is crazy.
- 47:51That is crazy.
- 47:51So we're going to leave it at that.
- 47:53Getting a throne can help you lose weight.
- 47:55I don't know if you can use that on Facebook for an ad.
- 47:58Probably not.
- 47:58But I'm just going to leave it at that because it's true.
- 48:02Because it's true.
- 48:02Maybe you can do that as an ad.
- 48:04I'm not sure.
- 48:05I'm not sure.
- 48:06But Scott, I'm just so impressed by you.
- 48:08I'm so impressed by this device.
- 48:10I really wanted to share it with my audience.
- 48:12I loved it.
- 48:13This all happened, just serendipity that, you know, your parents and talking about pictures of poop being sent to your mom.
- 48:21I mean, and then here we are and you're changing the world and you're changing people's health.
- 48:25So that's the most important part.
- 48:28So can you tell people where they can get themselves a throne?
- 48:32Yeah, so we are at throne science dot com.
- 48:35And I'll create a discount code as soon as we hop off here for any of your listeners.
- 48:40Should I just do it?
- 48:41Ornament?
- 48:42No, do Dr. Amy.
- 48:44We always use D-R-A-M-I-E.
- 48:45So there you go.
- 48:46There's your discount code, peeps.
- 48:47Dr. Amy.
- 48:48Yep.
- 48:50Beautiful.
- 48:50That's it.
- 48:51I love it.
- 48:52Well, it'd be under $400 with a discount code.
- 48:54So now it's really a no-brainer.
- 48:56So, Scott, thank you so much for coming on the Thyroid Fixer podcast.
- 48:59And thank you for creating Throne.
- 49:01It was a pleasure to meet you and get to know you.
- 49:04And then this interview has just really elevated my knowledge of bathroom habits.
- 49:12water, weight loss.
- 49:13You know, it's one of those things I know, but I haven't said in a long time.
- 49:16And when you said it, it's just like the bells went off.
- 49:19Ding, ding, ding.
- 49:20Oh my gosh, this is really something that we need to be talking about because the majority of my audience is looking to lose weight.
- 49:26I mean, they're menopausal females.
- 49:28This is just an issue.
- 49:29So thank you so much for coming on the show today and sharing all of this.
- 49:33I really appreciate you.
- 49:34Thank you for having me, Dr. Amy.
- 49:36Absolutely.
- 49:37The information shared on the Thyroid Fixer podcast is intended solely for informational and educational purposes.
- 49:43It is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
- 49:47Always consult with your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
- 49:54Thank you.
- 50:17Statements regarding dietary supplements or health-related products mentioned in this podcast have not been evaluated by the FDA.
- 50:24These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
- 50:28Some episodes of the Thyroid Fixer podcast may include sponsorships or affiliate links.
- 50:32The host may receive compensation for discussing or promoting certain products or services.
- 50:37Any such sponsorships or affiliations will be clearly disclosed during the episode.
- 50:42All opinions expressed are those of the host or guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of any sponsors.
- 50:48The inclusion of a product or service does not imply endorsement by any healthcare professional featured on this podcast.