Latest / CreepsMcPasta Creepypasta Radio / "He only eats the best of us" Creepypasta
Transcript
- 0:02I worked as a social worker for twelve years out on the East Coast.
- 0:07I saw children who were mistreated, women that were abused, and plenty of
- 0:11others that had mental health problems, bad judgment or worse luck. So many
- 0:18people suffering, and you get invested and try to help and then have to
- 0:22leave it at the job so it doesn't eat you alive when you go.
- 0:27And for the most part, I was good at compartmentalizing that stuff. But
- 0:33then five months before I quit and moved across the country, I met a
- 0:38young traumatized woman and everything changed. Her name was Hattie McGovern and she was
- 0:49a college student who had been attacked the night before as she crossed through a
- 0:53park and the way to a neighborhood. When I saw her, she was
- 0:57on the first day of three days of observation. She had injuries, sure,
- 1:03but there were largely cuts and abrasions to a scalp, and what she
- 1:07was saying didn't entirely make sense. When we were alone and I was finished
- 1:14telling her about the government services she might benefit from, I asked her if
- 1:19she wanted to talk about what happened. I'd heard enough from the nurse outside
- 1:23to know it would be wild, but I had no idea of the details
- 1:29until she began to speak in a soft, hoarse voice. She said she'd
- 1:37been halfway through the park, walking at a fast pace because she planned on
- 1:42taking a shower and then heading back out to meet some friends, and was
- 1:46running behind when she realized an older man was walking next to her, well
- 1:53not next to her, she said, about fifty feet away, traveling across
- 1:57the grass, stepping over hedges and sidewalks without slowing or even looking at where
- 2:02he was going. Instead, he was just keeping pace with her, step
- 2:07for step and staring at her with a wide smile that made him look like
- 2:13a skull between his pale skin and his bald head. This freaked her out,
- 2:19of course, and she began walking faster. She didn't run, she
- 2:23said, because she felt like it was kind of like running from a bear.
- 2:29You shouldn't show weakness or fear, but just get away before things went
- 2:32from weird to bad. So she turned to look to where she was going
- 2:38and to see if she saw any people closer than her apartment complex ad block
- 2:42away. There was none, and when she looked back to where the man
- 2:46had been, he was gone. That when she felt the hand plunging into
- 2:53a long blonde hair and pulling her to the ground. Known he was going
- 3:00to be something about her hair. Her injuries, other than a bruise on
- 3:05her throat and a couple of other scrapes, were all on her head,
- 3:09dozens of oozing places where the strange board man had held her down and roughly
- 3:15cut off all her hair with a straight razor. Crying softly, she showed
- 3:21me a picture of her the week before, long curly hair the color of
- 3:25summer honey framed her. Then smiling face. I passed her that didn't know
- 3:31what was about to happen. The version of her before me looked ten years
- 3:38older and broken in some fundamental way. Sniffing back tears, she said that
- 3:45when the men yanked her to the ground, the breath went out of her,
- 3:50but she immediately started trying to get up and get away. That he
- 3:53had grabbed her by the throat and held her back down, but just for
- 3:58a moment, just long enough that he could spit in her face. Hattie
- 4:05said it made no sense, but after he did that, she couldn't move
- 4:11anymore, not at all. The girl told me the doctors had tried to
- 4:15say it was shock or fear, but she said that was nonsense. She
- 4:21was paralyzed by the thick, foul smelling wad he'd spat onto her face,
- 4:28and even him producing the straight razor from a hidden pocket didn't get a move
- 4:32in again. Beyond the hammering of a heart. He never said anything,
- 4:40just smiled as he began gripping handfuls of her hair and scraping them off a
- 4:45scalp. I asked her if it hurt, and she gave me a warchy
- 4:49laugh. She said that sure it did, but that wasn't the worst part.
- 4:58He was feeling so violated and having a part of her taken away,
- 5:01even more than the fear of what he might do to her after the feeling
- 5:06had been the worst. When he had rolled her over to her stomach to
- 5:11cut the rest of her hair off, she felt the first tingles of movements
- 5:15starting to come back, not enough to really move, but some small,
- 5:20stirring twitches. She decided to wait, let it come back more, and
- 5:27then tried to run when the opportunity came or he was distracted, not that
- 5:32she was just sitting and waiting for him to do whatever he wanted. Every
- 5:36moment she was tensed to try and fight if she saw the blade coming for
- 5:42her neck, or if he tried to take her clothes off. She just
- 5:46knew that she couldn't really move or fight yet, and she wanted him to
- 5:50either go slow or just stop and leave her alone. He chose the latter.
- 5:58When he had cut off the last of her hair, he scooped up
- 6:01the pile next to her head and walked a few feet away out of a
- 6:05line of sight. She heard some kind of gasping, choking sound then,
- 6:12and while it took all her strength, she managed to turn her head slightly
- 6:16to see what he was doing. He was eating her hair, all of
- 6:25it. Golden fistfuls were crammed in one after the other as he chewed and
- 6:30gasped and choked and swallowed. The sound was disgusting, but seeing it was
- 6:36worse. She said, it scared her worse than before, though she couldn't
- 6:43have said why. And it was then, as she lay frozen and horrified,
- 6:48that the man suddenly let out a gasping groan and toppled over under the
- 6:54grass. He lay there, twitching for what felt like a minute or two,
- 7:00and though from her angle she couldn't see his face. She felt like
- 7:04he was either having a seizure or choking to death. She hoped for the
- 7:10latter, but didn't dare rely on that. Forcing her limbs to move,
- 7:16she got to her hands and knees and started to crawl out of the street.
- 7:23Everything felt weird and slow, but she started making progress, periodically looking
- 7:29back to see if the man was still out. First time, still down
- 7:34and twitching. Second time he was sitting up and staring at her. It
- 7:46was at this point that she started shaking and crying harder. So after waiting
- 7:51a couple of minutes, I asked the question to prompt her. Did he
- 7:57come for her again? No, she said. They looked at each other,
- 8:05He gave her another smile, and she started crawling faster or screaming her
- 8:11head off. The guy was jogging down the other side of the street and
- 8:16came over to help. When she looked back the next time, her attacker
- 8:22was gone. Thank god, I said, and she nodded in mute agreement.
- 8:30But I could tell there was something more. When I asked, she
- 8:35paused a long time before shaking her head. You'll just think I'm a crazy
- 8:41liar, like they do. I had to reassure her that I wouldn't think
- 8:46any such thing several times before she finally told me the rest when he sat
- 8:54up. When I saw him that last time, he wasn't bald anymore.
- 9:01He had long, curly hair, blonde hair just like mine. He ate
- 9:09my hair and stole it from me. Over the next couple of months,
- 9:18I checked on her case. Hattie had moved back to Wisconsin to be with
- 9:24her family, and while her physical wounds were healing well enough, she still
- 9:28had emotional issues she was working through from the attack. When I called her
- 9:33mental health counselor at a new college, she tried to talk very broadly and
- 9:39not give me any details, But toward the end of the conversation she did
- 9:45let one slip. The poor dear, it's so strange how her hair won't
- 9:52grow back. It was another month and a half before I saw the graffiti.
- 10:01I normally took a bus home to just two blocks from my work,
- 10:05but one day my normal bus line was delayed due to an accident, so
- 10:09I had the choice of paying for a taxi or walking further to a different
- 10:13stop. I picked the latter, and while the neighborhood I traveled through didn't
- 10:18seem especially rough or dangerous. It was more run down than the places I
- 10:24worked or lived, more closed businesses and unkent blots and graffiti scattered along the
- 10:30walls here and there. It was, when I was nearing the bus stop
- 10:35that I had to walk under an overpass bridge that I had colorful drawings and
- 10:39sayings, insults and boasts. Yet among that riot of lines and squiggles,
- 10:48one thing stood apart, as though none of the rest wanted to be close
- 10:52to this single line, written in simple letters of dark red, he I
- 11:00only eat the best of us. A year earlier, I would have laughed
- 11:07at the line, wondering if it was a social commentary or a line from
- 11:11a movie. But walking through that patch of shadows, as the words burned
- 11:18down at me from above, my mind immediately went a hattie, and I
- 11:22walked faster until I reached my stop. When I reached it, I looked
- 11:28back, and that's when I saw him, a thin, pale man with
- 11:37long, flowing blonde hair. I might have let out a little scream right
- 11:45then, I don't remember. I do recall turning back to the street,
- 11:50thinking I needed to call a taxi or get someone's attention. When I saw
- 11:54the bus turning the corner, A blocked down and I nearly cried and really
- 12:01running to meet it. I jumped on as soon as the doors opened,
- 12:05and when I looked back, I saw no sign of the man anywhere.
- 12:11Heart pounding, I scanned my pass and took a seat in the middle of
- 12:16the bus. It was only half full, but the comfort of being around
- 12:20other people, even total strangers, was undeniable. I felt like a gazelle
- 12:28hiding in the herd from a stalking lion. The dramatic flare of the thought
- 12:33made me laugh. Wasn't I overreacting? Had I really seen the man?
- 12:39Or had I just imagined it because I was tired and taking a strange route
- 12:43that made me uneasy. Glancing at my phone, I guessed my nearest stop
- 12:50to home would be about twenty minutes away. After a moment's debate, I
- 12:56set my phone alarm for fifteen in case I dozed off, though that seemed
- 13:01unlikely given the panic I had felt a few moments before. I might not
- 13:07ever sleep. I woke up to words being spoken right next to my ear.
- 13:16Few have lovely eyes. I jumped to my seat and started to turn
- 13:22round when I froze. The evening had fully come on by now, and
- 13:28the windows of the bus were all black with the growing night outside. In
- 13:33the reflection of the window closest to me, I could not only see myself,
- 13:37but who had spoken to me. It was the old blond man,
- 13:43leaning against my ear like a whispering lover. In the reflection, my terrified
- 13:50gaze found his milky eyes hanging like infected moons above his sickly sickle smile.
- 13:58He held me with that look for a moment before rasping out the words again,
- 14:03you have lovely eyes. My fear broke the spell this time, and
- 14:11I jumped out of my seat and rushed to the front, yelling for the
- 14:15driver to let me out. Let me out now, goddamn it. Looking
- 14:18surprised and irritated, he pulled at the curb, even as my phone alarm
- 14:24went off. I was just two blocks away now, and I wasn't above
- 14:28running the entire way, so that's exactly what I did. I jumped off
- 14:35the bus as the doors opened, pulling off my heels and running barefoot down
- 14:39the sidewalk for two blocks to my building. I never looked back the entire
- 14:45time. And it wasn't until I was behind my door and the dead bolt
- 14:50was thrown that I took a breath or dared to look back out through the
- 14:54peep hole. I saw no sign of anyone out there, and when I
- 15:01went to my windows to look for any sign of the old man following me,
- 15:05I found none. Good it was maybe a coincidence, but even if
- 15:11it was Hattie guy, he couldn't have followed me all the way home,
- 15:16not with how fast I was. There was a knock at the door,
- 15:22stifling another scream. I crept back to the door, not wanting to betray
- 15:26that I was home. Looking back through the peep hole, I saw nothing.
- 15:33Maybe he had been a mistake and the person had realized they had the
- 15:37wrong door and went on. I waited for a couple of minutes, watching
- 15:41and listening for someone, and there was nothing. It wasn't until I turned
- 15:48to go into the living room that a new knock returned, this one more
- 15:52rhythmic and familiar. Knock knock, kN knock, knock, knock knock.
- 16:02I gave a shudder as I realized I recognized what that was. Shaven a
- 16:07haircut, two bits, biting my lip, I went back to the door
- 16:12and stared out again through the hole. There was still no one out there
- 16:18that I could see, not that I was about to open the door to
- 16:22fully check. What if they were just standing to the side waiting for me
- 16:26to crack the door. I debated calling the police, but I wasn't sure
- 16:33what to tell them, or if they'd even come for something so small,
- 16:37so instead I called the building's handyman. George told him I thought a creepy
- 16:42guy might have followed me into the building, and now someone kept knocking on
- 16:47my door. I asked him, did he mind coming up and just see
- 16:52if he saw anything. He sounded sleepy and irritated initially, but when he
- 16:57heard the fear of my voice, he said he'd be right there. Less
- 17:03than five minutes later, there was a new knock on the door, for
- 17:07this time who was quickly followed by George's voice, Miss Castillo. There's no
- 17:14one out here. Now. I'm going to double check the other doors,
- 17:18but I think you're okay. Someone did leave you something out here, though
- 17:25I unlocked the door and opened it part way left something what. George pushed
- 17:32the items through the crack and handed it to me. There that's for you.
- 17:37I guess. I think you're okay, but you be careful. Okay,
- 17:42there are some bad things out there. I noticed that he said things
- 17:48instead of people, but I let it pass. George, it's something wrong.
- 17:57He looked a little paler as he forced a smile and shook his head,
- 18:03never raising his eyes to me. No, I think everything is okay.
- 18:07Just keep your door locked, okay, and let me know if you
- 18:12have any more trouble. I gotta get back downstairs. I thought about reminding
- 18:21him to check the other floors, but then he was gone, shutting the
- 18:26door back and locking it. I decided it didn't matter. I had a
- 18:30feeling he wasn't going anywhere except down to his own apartment to turn his own
- 18:36dead bolt. That feeling only grew when I turned on the lights and looked
- 18:41more closely at what had been left for me. Maybe it had been a
- 18:48mocking threat or a warning, but I knew what it felt like a promise.
- 18:59So the next day I gave my notice and move most my stuff into
- 19:03an extended stay hotel. Three weeks later, I was driving a moving truck
- 19:08across the country to my new home. The first thing I set out in
- 19:14my new house was the gift I got that night. I hate looking at
- 19:19it, but I need to see it, be reminded of it, like
- 19:26a head or heart full of scars, or the red letter scrawled underneath a
- 19:30bridge. It warns me to never let my guard down, to never assume
- 19:37that the darkness has nothing but empty fear waiting for me in its depths.
- 19:42Even now, I can see it on my mantle, gleaming a dull gray.
- 19:48I think it's made of pewter, and it feels very heavy and old.
- 19:53The few times I've been able to make myself touch it, not that
- 19:59I need to any more, I still see it when I close my eyes.
- 20:03A thick handled metal spoon with a deep round bowl. The tabors to
- 20:10a sharp edge on the outer rim, not by initial design, but by
- 20:17use of wet stone or a grinder. It's more of a razor, now,
- 20:22hard and cold and bitingly thin, shaped for cutting and digging. And
- 20:29I know, without checking that if some one were to stick it into my
- 20:33eye socket, they could sliced through the lid and scoop out my eyeball like
- 20:37a bit of over ripe melon. My hands are shaking as I tell you
- 20:44this. I can't quite look at the mantle any longer, so I look
- 20:48out the window instead. It's not dark yet, but the shadows are growing
- 20:56fatter with each passing morsel of the day. I force myself to keep looking
- 21:02into the deepening twilight, and some nights I even tell myself, I'm not
- 21:07still afraid. But the whisper in my heart is en of bravery or strength,
- 21:15is the dreadful double thrum of the gazelle's heart looking out into the darkness,
- 21:22not looking out of courage, but out of terror and necessity and weak
- 21:29trembling. Hope, hope that when we look out into the darkness, nothing
- 21:37looks back or is drawing near